Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Agenda - 06/27/2005
CITY OF WOODBURN CITY COUNCIL AGENDA JUNE 27, 2005- 7:00 P.M. KATHRYN FIGLEY, MAYOR WALTER NICHOLS, COUNCILOR WARD 1 RICHARD BJELLAND, COUNCILOR WARD [I PETER MCCALLUM, COUNCILOR WARD ttt JAMES Cox, COUNCILOR WARD IV FRANK LONERGAN, COUNCILOR WARD V ELIDA SIFUENTEZ, COUNCILOR WARD Vi CITY HALL COUNCIL CHAMBERS - 270 MONTGOMERY STREET CALL TO ORDER AND FLAG SALUTE ROLL CALL ANNOUNCEMENTS AND APPOINTMENTS Announcements: A. In observance of Independence Day, City Hall and the Library wilt be closed Monday, July 4, 2005. The Aquatic Center will be open from 1:00 p.m. fo 4:00 p.m. with $1 swim. Bo Independence Day Celebration - July 4th · 6:00 - 10:30 a.m. - a Chuck Wagon Breakfast will be served at Legion Park; · 1:30 p.m.- decorations and organization for the Youth Parade, which will begin at 2:00 p.m. at Settlemier Park and end at Centennial Park; · Activities at Centennial Park include: 3:00 - 8:00 p.m. - youth games and activities 3:00- 10:00 p.m.- DJ and food concessions 4:00- 5:00 p.m.- Dance Dance Dance 5:00 ~ 6:00 p.m.- Americana Band 6:00- 7:30 p.m.- Joni Harms 7:30 - 10 p.m. - Americana Band 10 p.m. (approximately) Fireworks A free shuttle bus will be available from City Hall parking lots to and from Centennial Park Music in the Park presents J.T. & the Tourists on July 5, 2005 at 7:00 p.m. Drums of Fire will be held at Woodburn High School on July 6, 2005 at 7:00 p.m. a[ (5o3) 98o-e-485." June 27, 2005 Council Agenda Page i A public hearing on the Boones Fern/LID will be held on July ] 1, 2005 at 7:00 p.m. ODOT wilt be holding a public hearing on the I-5 interchange environmental assessment on July 21,2005, from 4:30-7:30 p.m., at the Woodview Church of God (1530 Mt. Hood Avenue) Appointments: None. PROCLAMATIONS/PRESENTATIONS Proclamations: A. Honoring Harriet Gorman's 52 Years of Service e Presentations: B. Gary Lawhead, MacLaren Superintendent, will make their Annual Presentation to the Aware Food Bank C. Boones Ferry, Settlemier, Hwy. 214 Intersection Update- City/ODOT staff COMMITTEE REPORTS Chamber of Commerce Woodburn Downtown Association COMMUNICATIONS None. BUSINESS FROM THE PUBLIC - This allows the public to introduce items /:or Council consideration not already scheduled on the agenda. CONSENT AGENDA - Items listed on the consent agenda are considered routine and may be enacted by one motion. Any item may be removed for discussion at the request of a Council member. Woodburn City Council minutes of June 13, 2005, regular and executive sessions Recornmended Action: Approve the minutes. 2 June 27, 2005 Council Agenda Page ii B. Police Department Statistics- May 2005 Recommended Action: Receive the report. C. ODOT Highway 99E Preservation and Safety Project Recommended Action: Receive the report. D. Removal of Two Street Trees at 378 Montgomery Street Recommended Action: Receive the report. TABLED BUSINESS 16 23 ¸25 None. 10. PUBLIC HEARINGS 11. ke Appeal of Design Review Case File No. 05-01 and Variance Case File No. 05-05 located at 1475 Mt. Hood Avenue Recommended Action: Concur with the Planning Commission's decision of approval of Design Review Case File No. 05-01 and Variance Case File No. 05-05, or modify the Planning Commission's decision, and instruct staff to prepare an ordinance to substantiate its decision. Be Public Hearing Related to Sale of Community Center Property Recommended Action: (1) Reject the Offer of $185,000 submitted by Mark Nyman for 491 N. 3rd Street (the former Woodburn Community Center) because the City has received an offer of higher amount for sale of the property; (2) conduct the public hearing required by ORS 221.725 on the proposed sale of 491 N. 3rd Street to Deborah Higginbotham for a purchase price of $200,000; and (3) after completing the public hearing, accept the offer of $200,000 submitted by Deborah Higginbotham for 491 N. 3rd Street and direct staff to prepare a resolution documenting the sale of the property. GENERAL BUSINESS -Members of the public wishing to comment on items of general business must complete and submit a speaker's card to the City Recorder prior to commencing this portion of the Council's agenda. Comment time may be limited by Mayoral prerogative. Council Bill 2573- Ordinance adopting a supplemental budget for Fiscal Year 2004-05 and declaring an emergency Recommended Action: Adopt the ordinance. 28 31 82 June 27, 2005 Council Agenda Page B. 86 12. 13. 14. 15. Council Bill 2574 - Ordinance adopting a budget for fiscal year 2005-2006, making appropriations, levying taxes, and declaring an emergency Recommended Action: Adopt the ordinance. Council Bill 2575 - Resolution entering into an agreement with the City of Lake Oswego, Oregon for police range use and training services and authorizing the Police Chief to sign said agreement Recommended Action: Adopt the resolution. Council Bill 2576 - Resolution certifying the eligibility of the City of Woodburn to receive state-shared revenues during fiscal year 2005-06 Recommended Action: Adopt the resolution. Ee Council Bill 2577 - Resolution declaring the City's election to receive state revenues during fiscal year 2005-06 Recommended Action: Adopt the resolution. Traffic Grant Enforcement Program and Agreement Recommended Action: Authorize the City Administrator to sign an Agreement with Marion County for administration of a traffic grant once final language has been agreed upon. Ge Liability, Auto, Property, and Worker's Compensation Insurance for Fiscal Year 2005-06 Recommended Action: Item will be presented at the meeting. NEW BUSINESS PLANNING COMMISSION OR ADMINISTRATIVE LAND USE ACTIONS - These are Planning Commission or Administrative Land Use actions that may be called up by the City Council. None. CITY ADMINISTRATOR'S REPORT Ae Status of Police Facility MAYOR AND COUNCIL REPORTS 97 105 107 109 110 June 27, 2005 Council Agenda Page iv 16. EXECUTIVE SESSION To consult with counsel concerning the legal rights and duties of a public body with regard to current litigation or litigation likely to be filed pursuant to ORS 192.660 (1)(h). To consider records that are exempt by law from public inspection pursuant to ORS ] 92.660 (1)(f). To conduct deliberations with persons designated by the governing body to carry on labor negotiations pursuant to ORS ] 92.660(1)(d). 17. ADJOURNMENT June 27, 2005 Council Agenda Page v PR OCI. AMA TION HONORING HARRIET GOP, LAM'S 52 YF_ RS OF SEP-:qICE WHEREAS, Harriet Gorman received degrees from Marylhurst University and the University of Oregon, and began her career as a music teacher with the Woodburn School District in 1952; and WHEREAS, Harriet began her work as a choir director for St. Luke's Church in 1953; and WHEi~diAS, for the following 52 years, Harriet has served St. Luke's and the greater Woodburn community as a singer, musician, choir director, and teacher, while raising a family and making other contributions as a community member; and WHEREAS, Harriet's talents have enhanced worship, enriched celebrations, and eased grief for thousands of Woodburn area residents during her long and distinguished career; and WHEREAS, Harriet Gorman is retiring from her position at St. Luke's Church; NOW THEP,~FORE, I, Kathryn Figley, Mayor of the City of Woodburn, proclaim Harriet Gorman's 52 years of service to our community to be deserving of citywide recognition and congratulate her on her retirement. The songs in her voice, her fingers, and her heart have enriched us all. City of IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand and caused the seal o Cit~ of ,odburn to be affixed this 15th day of June 2005. ' Ma~ 8A COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES JUNE 13,2005 TAPE RE~M31NG 0001 DATE. COUNCIL CHAMBERS, CITY HALL, CITY OF WOODBURN, COUNTY OF MARION, STATE OF OREGON, JUNE 13, 2005. CONVENED. The meeting convened at 7:00 p.m. with Mayor Figley presiding. 0015 ROLL CALL. Mayor Figley Present Councilor Bj elland Present Councilor Cox Present Councilor Lonergan Present Councilor McCallum Present Councilor Nichols Present Councilor Sifuentez Present Staff Present: City Administrator Brown, City Attorney Shields, Public Works Director Tiwari, Public Works Manager Rohman, Asst. City Engineer Torgeson, Police Chief Russell, Community Development Director Mulder, Finance Director Gillespie, Park & Recreation Director Westrick, Management Analyst Smith, Senior Planner Zwerdling, Associate Planner Pike-Salas, Associate Planner Richling, City Recorder Tennant 0054 ANNOUNCEMENTS. A) Relay for Life event will begin on Friday~ June 24th at 6:00 p.m. and conclude on Saturday, June 25th at 12:00 noon. The event will be held at Woodburn High School and proceeds will benefit the American Cancer Society. Mayor Figley stated that the City is a platinum sponsor which was paid for through individual donations from City elected officials and senior management staff. B) Public Hearing will be held before the City Council on Design Review Case File No. 05-01 and Variance Case File No. 05-05 on June 27, 2005, 7:00 p.m., in the Council Chambers. C) July 4th Independence Day Celebration: Scheduled events are as follows: Chuckwagon Breakfast - 6:00 am until 10:30 am Youth Parade beginning at Settlemier Park - 2:00 pm Centennial Park Activities include: Youth games; Disc Jockey; Food concessions; Dance, Dance, Dance performance; performances by the Americana Band and Joni Harms; and Fireworks. D) Independence Day Closures: In observance of Independence Day, City Hall and the Library will be closed on Monday, July 4th . The Aquatic Center will be open on July 4th from 1:00 pm until 4:00 prn. Page 1 - Council Meeting Minutes, June 13, 2005 2 COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES JUNE 13,2005 TAPE READING 0243 PROCLAMATION: TADASHI NAGAI, HONORARY CITIZEN OF 0420 WOODBURN. Mayor Figley stated that Foreign Exchange student Tadashi Nagai graduated from Woodburn High School in 1961 and, over the years, has served in Japan's Foreign Service. Currently, his diplornatic assignment is at the Consulate in Portland because of his fond memories of Oregon. She is issued a proclamation naming Tadashi Nagai an Honorary Citizen of Woodburn. She also stated that she would be attending a reception for Mr. Nagai since he will soon be returning to Japan and she will present a framed copy of the proclamation along with Woodburn Bulldog memorabilia. PRESENTATION: WATER ISSUE (May 25 - 27, 2005). Administrator Brown stated fhat the purpose of this report is to provide information on what happened, the staff's response, what staff learned from this experience, what is now being done with the water system, and policy issues. He stated that water quality is highly regulated at the federal and state level and the protocols followed are dictated by the regulations of those agencies. This includes water sampling, testing of samples, and notices sent out to the public based on test results. He stated that tests are done weekly and state regulations require 20 different sites within the distribution system in addition to the City wells. The City actually tests 25 sites in addition to the wells on a monthly basis. The tests are done for indicator organisms one of which is for coliform bacteria. This bacteria is carried in the air and soil and, if found in water, is usually a reason for additional testing. One of the additional tests then run is for fecal coliform which is a sub-group of E-coli. There are a number of different strains of E-coli most of which are not disease causing agents but they do indicate the presence of fecal matter someplace. The protocol followed is a re-test and if there is no more coliform in the next testing, a notice would then be sent out to all residents within 30 days to inform them of the positive coliform test. However, following an E-coli positive test, if the second test still shows either coliform or e-coli, then it becomes a Tier I violation and a Boil Water advisory is required. He reviewed the chronology of the event beginning with the test samples taken on Monday, May 23~d, and the notification by the lab on May 24th that a positive e-coli test result was from the Parr Road reservoir and a positive coliform test result at the Country Club Road reservoir. As required, additional samples were taken at the reservoir sites and on Wednesday, May 25th, the lab notified the City that the samples taken tested positive for total coliform only. Staff proceeded to notify the public of the boil water advisory, began an aggressive flushing program, worked with State Drinking Water Program technicians on the notices and additional sampling, and the County Health Department who provided information specifically for food service providers. He stated that the City may never kmow what caused the positive samples because of the extensive amount of flushing that was done to clem' the system. It was noted that public notification included the media (television, newspaper, radio), City website, Chamber of Commerce, and School District. It was decided not to do door-to-door notification since there was Page 2 - Council Meeting Minutes, June 13, 2005 3 TAPE R_EADFNG COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES JUNE 13,2005 concern that there might be general panic if residents were told that the water was contaminated when in fact staff was fairly certain that there was not a high level of contamination in the system. Additionally, the City did not have the resources to go door-to-door and it was felt that utilizing the mass media spread the word faster. The City was given a 24-hour period of time to make the notifications but it took staff about 4 hours to get the information out to the businesses and public. On Thursday, May 26~h, three of twelve tests came back as positive for total coliform so flushing continued. Re- tests were done on Thursday and on Friday morning, the City was notified that the samples were negative and staff then went through the reverse process to notify the businesses and public that it was safe to drink and the boil water advisory was lifted. He stated that staff learned from this incident other means of notifying residents through sources such as Senior Estates and Neighborhood Watch cornmanders. Daily group meetings were also held with staff and representatives from the School District, Fire Department, Chamber, and 9-1-1 Dispatch. Staff also met on June 2nd to analyze what could have been done differently in the event this type of situation may arise in the future. He stated that system engineers will try to find out what did happen since the problem areas were at the reservoir sites. Vents on the reservoirs have been modified to prevent bird droppings from getting into the exhaust ductwork and seals have been checked to make sure that they are tight. Administrator Brown stated that it is anticipated that the new system will be operational within the next 60 days. Even though staff acted quickly to notify the public, he reviewed lessons learned by staff in this type of emergency situation. Lastly, he stated that the City does not chlorinate the water and staff will be researching methods to disinfect the water and to circulate water within the reservoirs. Councilor Bjelland questioned if the lab could hold a sample for a longer period of time in order to identify the type of e-coli. Administrator Brown stated that the City does not have the control over lab tests whereas the State may have the ability to have the lab do further testing. Tom Charboneau, State Drinking Water Program representative, stated that staff did an excellent job and took the lead in this matter. He reiterated that the City may never know what caused the problem. The City has never chlorinated the water and he suggested that the City consider some type of disinfection process. He stated that the City followed all protocol to get the information out to the public. Councilor McCallum questioned if the City will be required to do additional testing beyond what is already being done by the City. Mr. Charboneau stated that the City will continue to do the testing as before because the number of samples is based on the size of the City. The sampling sites used by the City provides very good coverage of the main line water system. Councilor McCallum also questioned if business closures were voluntary or required. Administrator Brown stated that it was his understanding that a limited number of businesses did close, however, they did so because it -,vas too difficult for them to operate under the conditions that were imposed. In regards to reports of illness connected to this Page 3 - Council Meeting Minutes, June 13, 2005 COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES JUNE 13,2005 TAUPE READ1NG situation, Administrator Brown stated that Public Works did check with the County Health Department and, as of Thursday, May 26th, there were no reported cases of illness. Councilor Cox stated that any e-coli would generate the steps taken to notify the public, however, most strains of e-coli are harmless. Mr. Charboneau stated that the second positive e-coli sample, even if it is a harmless strain, triggers the notification process to the public. If a disinfection process is installed, there may still be a possibility of getting a positive e-coli test result, however, the potential is greatly reduced. The main system is very tight but the reservoirs have a large standing water supply where bacteria could grow but chlorine residual would kill the bacteria in most cases. Councilor McCallum stated that he had heard that there were some individuals who came into the City to take advantage of the situation by selling bottled water and giving out rnisinformation. Administrator Brown stated that the Ordinance Officers did not locate those individuals. Councilor McCallum expressed his appreciation to all City staff for their work in dealing with this situation. He also mentioned that the Water Quality Report for 2004 also provided information about the bad things that can be in water at anytime including bottled water. Mayor Figley requested that more information on means of disinfection, related costs, and its ability to be initiated with the City's new system be provided to the Council for discussion. She also praised Public Works Manager Rohman and Water Department staff for going the extra effort to provide information to the public and in getting the situation quickly resolved. Councilor Bjelland read an excerpt fi'om the staff report stating that the City would obtain the services of an independent consultant with expertise in bacterial contamination to inspect and evaluate the reservoirs and distribution system. He reminded the public that the City wants to explore everything so that if there is any chance to identify what caused the contamination or come up with recommendations with ways to minimize the potential of it recurring. 3500 CHAMBER OF COMMERCE REPORT. Nick Harville, Chamber of Commerce Executive Director, provided the Council with a packet of information which included statistics and a profile of travelers that come to Marion County. The Woodburn Company Stores, along with other attractions in the surrounding area, has turned Woodbum into a tourist destination and the Chamber is working to capitalize on this tourism to market the Woodburn area. The Chamber Board has expanded the area for which they represent and have adopted the Hubbard Business Economic Development Group. Additionally, the Chamber was instrumental in creating the North Willamette Tourism Alliance which includes 12 communities in the surrounding area. Later this summer, a new Visitor's Center will be located at the Woodbum Company Stores and this is a partnership between Oregon Travel Information Page 4 - Council Meeting Minutes, June 13, 2005 COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES JUNE 13,2005 T3~PE ¢~ADING Council, Woodbum Company Stores, and the Woodburn Area Chamber of Commerce. The Chamber will be operating both Visitor's Centers until the lease at the present location expires. He also stated that the Salem Convention Visitor Association will be dissolving as of June 30, 2005 and now the tourism alliance has become even more important because it will be the method to promote the tourism within the County outside of Salem. 4313 WOODBURN SCHOOL DISTRACT REPORT. Walt Blomberg, Superintendent of Woodburn Schools, stated that there were 257 students graduating from high school last week which was Woodburn's largest graduating class at Woodbum. There were 143 scholorships totaling $1.3 million, 17 students achieved the Certificate of Initial Mastery issued by the State, 23 students were part of the National Honor Society, and 39 students graduated with an Oregon Honor's diploma. It is anticipated that this year there will be 3 times more students completing the full international baccalaureate diploma which is one of the most rigorous programs available to students in high school. Heritage Elementary School was shown on Public Broadcasting System regarding this school's tri-lingual educational program. At Washington School, there is a new mosaic in the foyer that illustrates diversity and unity within our community. Lastly, the School District continues to grow and planning will soon begin to address space needs. A Facilities Planning Team will be put together in August to work on this project and persons interested in being a part of this team are asked to contact the District Office. Councilor McCallum stated that the Woodburn School District is being noted for its successes with their students, however, Superintendent Blomberg will be a featured presenter at a state-wide conference in August to share information on how to succeed while working with limited resources. 4926 CONSENT AGENDA. A) approve the Council minutes of May 23, 2005; B) accept the Planning Commission minutes of May 12, 2005; C) receive the Building Activity report for May 2005; D) receive the Planning Tracking Sheet dated June 6, 2005; and E) receive the report on Claims for May 2005. MCCALLUM/NICHOLS... consent agenda be adopted as presented. The motion passed unanimously. 5030 PUBLIC HEARING: SUPPLEMENTAL BUDGET FOR FISCAL YEAR 2004-05. Mayor Figley declared the public hearing open at 8:13 p.m.. Finance Director Gillespie outlined proposed changes in the current budget to adjust revenues and appropriations within the General Fund and the General Fund Capital Improvement Fund. Within the General Fund, grant funds were received for police Page 5 - Council Meeting Minutes, June 13, 2005 6 COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES JUNE 13,2005 TAPE READING overtime, increased recreation fee revenue will be used to fund additions to the Teen Program, and operating contingency will be reduced to pay for additional Periodic Review consulting services and for the purchase of some amenities in the Downtown Plaza. The proposed budget adjustments will increase the General Fund revenues by $34,282 and operating contingency will be reduced by $31,000. The General CIP Fund revenue will increase by $71,000 and the Downtown Plaza appropriation will increase by a like amount to pay for contract change orders and the plaza amenities. No one in the audience commented on the proposed supplemental budget. Mayor Figley closed the public hearing at 8:17 p.m.. COX/SIFUENTEZ... authorize staff to draft a budget ordinance reflecting approval of a supplemental budget as presented in the staff report. The motion passed unanimously. 5555 PUBLIC HEARING: CITY BUDGET FOR FISCAL YEAR 2005-06. Mayor Figley declared the public hearing open at 8:19 p.m. on the 2005-06 City budget which includes State Revenue Sharing funds. Finance Director Gillespie briefly reviewed the 2005-06 budget as recommended by the Budget Committee. He stated that the budget financial summary was published in the newspaper on June 8, 2005. Staff has proposed changes to the recommended budget in the Water Fund ($16,000 for chemicals), General CIP Fund ($32,500 for Centennial Park Ballfield #3), and multiple Public Works construction projects since these projects wilt not be completed until after July 1, 2005. He also stated that staff will be returning in July 2005 with a Supplemental Budget request for Council consideration of additional funding of construction projects related to the Greenview Pump station and the Industrial Pump station since the outstanding contractor payments for these two projects exceed the amount that a budget can increase over the Budget Committee's recommendation. Councilor Cox questioned the amount that will be carried forward for the two pump stations. It was noted that the Greenview Pump station will require a supplemental budget of $124,300 and the Industrial Pump station will require $165,000. Beginning fund balance will be used as the revenue source for these expenditures. No one in the audience spoke either for or against the proposed 2005-06 budget. Mayor Figley declared the public hearing closed at 8:28 p.m.. BJELLAND/MCCALLUM .... authorize staff to draft a budget ordinance based on the Budget Committee's recommendation including allowable budget adjustments that do not change the tax levy requirement as presented in the attached memo. The motion passed unanimously. Page 6 - Council Meeting Minutes, June 13, 2005 7 COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES JUNE 13,2005 TAPE READFNG 6792 Tape 2 0010 APPEAL OF DESIGN REVIEW CASE FILE NO. 05-01 AND VALANCE CASE FILE NO. 05-05 (1475 MT. HOOD AVENUE). Mayor Figley stated that it was her understanding that the applicant's attorney has requested that the public hearing be continued on these matters until the next regular Council meeting. Mayor Figley declared the public hearing open at 8:29 p.m.. COX/SIFUENTEZ .... continue the public hearing fbr Design Review Case File No. 05- 01 and Variance Case File No. 05-05 to the City Council meeting of June 27, 2005. The motion passed unanimously. PEPdODIC REVIEW DELIBERATIONS. Mayor Figley stated that City Attorney Shields provided a memo to the Council just prior to this meeting regarding staff recommendation to reopen the record for the submission of written materials to accept testimony to comply with the new version of Goal 14. City Attorney Shields stated that the LCDC had adopted a new Goal 14, however, the new version of the Goal has not yet been filed with the Secretary of State. He reviewed his recommendation which would relate to 1) changes made by the City to the Periodic Review Tasks~ 2) City's incorporation of the new Goal 14 into the findings, and 3) respond to any written testimony received by the Council on June 13, 2005 submitted after April 20, 2005. Until the new Goall4 is in effect, it would be premature for the City to proceed with final adoption of an amendment to the urban growth boundary. Greg Winterowd, Winterbrook Planning, stated that LCDC's new version of the Goal was adopted about 6 weeks ago but as of today it still has not been filed with the Secretary of State. The new version has some substarttial advantages to the City and it is critical to adopt findings that would be applicable to the Goal in effect at the time of the adoption. Attorney Shields also stated that he had City Council Speaker Cards submitted by Attorneys Brian Moore and Roger Alfred xvho would like to orally address the City Council if an opportunity is given. He advised the Council that oral testimony would require re-notice of the hearing thereby giving all interested persons an opportunity to give testimony. Mayor Figley stated that there is a trade-off in that the City wants to be fair and there has been ample opportunity for oral testimony and then a generous period for additional written testimony. In reviewing the City Attorney's recommendation, she felt that limiting additional testimony to written testimony under the parameters he has outlined would be acceptable whereas she would strongly urge the Council not to reopen the hearing for oral testimony unless there is a subject that the Council feels it is vitally important. Councilor McCallum stated that he could accept Attorney Shields recommendation to reopen the record for limited written testimony. Councilor Cox stated that he agreed in general with the written testimony within a limited time frame but the record should not be opened for oral testimony. He stated that there Page 7 - Council Meeting Minutes, June 13, 2005 8 COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES JUNE 13,2005 TAPE I~ADING were some new twists with the new version of the goal and it is a very important matter to a lot of people financially and to the public. He stated that the Council may choose to consult with staff or consultants to help interpret those new submissions but that is not going to give rise to a new realm of opening the matter up for new testimony of those who do not agree with the City's staff or consultants. He also questioned the meaning of "changes made by the city to the Periodic Review work tasks". It was noted that the intent is to accept testimony that relates to staff's new recommended changes since the Council's last hearing. COX/BJELLAND... re-open the record on Legislative Amendment 05-01 to receive the following documents that were submitted and received by the City after the April 20, 2005 deadline: 1) Petition from Daniel Orsborne received April 22, 2005; 2) letter from the Serres Family received May 5, 2005; 3) letter from Richard Stein received May 23, 2005; 4) letter from Roger Alfred received May 23, 2005; 5) packet of materials from Richard Stein received June 2, 2005; and 6) letter from Roger Alfred received June 13, 2005; and to re-open the record in this matter to allow written responses to any of the matters that were just mentioned as being received and to relate to the City's incorporation of new Goal 14 into its findings; and to changes made in staff recommendations to the materials originally presented to the Council at the beginning of the public hearing; and the date for the submission of all of the above mentioned written materials is close of business on June 27, 2005. Following a brief discussion on the content of the motion, the Council unanimously passed the motion. 1440 Community Development Director Mulder highlighted on the map the staff's recommended changes to the Periodic Review amendment package and Urban Gro~vth Boundary expansion proposal that was presented at the public hearing. Urban Growth Boundary changes are as follows: 1) area that was originally proposed located west of Butteville Road in the southwest area of the proposed expansion area be relocated to the eastside of I-5 south of the current proposed urban growth boundary; and 2) remove the portion of the OGA golf course which primarily relates to an issue regarding Class I soils. Greg Winterowd, Project Consultant, stated that the OGA golf course area was originally included since it was part of a planned development approved years ago by the City. However, the City will face a challenge in getting this area approved since the area has Class I and H soils. He stated that the new Goal 14 rule would give the City the ability to include land based on special characteristics and an argument could be made that this land is good for high-end housing which is why it should be included. If the City elected to include the area in its final adoption, then the City could be a test case before LCDC. He reminded the Cotmcil that Class II soils are only supposed to be brought into the UGB if it is necessary to cross over Class II soils in order to get to Class III soils. He could see no reason to extend the UGB to include only Class II soils when there ~vere no Class III soils to get to beyond the Class II soils. Page 8 - Council Meeting Minutes, June 13, 2005 TAPE READING COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES JUNE 13,2005 2658 2953 Councilor Cox questioned if the developer who is now required to put in the emergency access road be required to put in a full road if the UGB expansion is implemented as outlined on the map. Director Mulder stated that the developer would be required to put in a full road if it came into the urban growth boundary. He stated that another map change involved the change of a designation of an exception area located in the northeast comer of the proposed UGB expansion since it was an original mapping error. In the downtown area, the original proposal was to change zoning from commercial office but the proposal is now to keep the zoning as it is now. A change was also made to the boundary line for the Interchange Management Area Overlay thereby excluding residential area and coinciding more with commercial areas since those are the areas the overlay regulates. He also stated that the triangular piece at the south end of the Winco property is actually a part of the Winco property therefore it should not be included in the Southwest Industrial Overlay or within the Interchange Management Area. Director Mulder summarized the information that has been provided to the Council which includes all written testimony; copies of Council minutes; responses from Consultant Winterowd and staff on various comments; draft response letter to DLCD and the Marion County comments; response from Public Works Department to Serres Family comments; recommended revisions (attachment F) to the proposed amendment package which includes revisions to the Comprehensive Goals and Policies, the Woodbum Development Ordinance, and Public Facilities Plan; map of recommended revisions; draft Urban Growth Boundary Coordination agreement with the County; and a Citizen Involvement report that will be updated before final adoption. Greg Winterowd discussed the new Goal 14 language that would control hoxv urban growth boundaries are amended. The new language specifically states that (1) it is a 20- year population forecast, (2) that the UGB justification report does not need to be in all of the findings as part of the Comprehensive Plan, (3) that a formal exceptions process does not need to be followed, and (4) it includes language that when determining need local government may specify characteristics such as parcel size, topography, or proximity (to roads, interchanges) necessary for land to be suitable for an identified need. He stated that the changes in the Goal would be advantageous to the City since the new Goal is better written, and it puts ever~hing into one place. It is also his belief that the Commission will be interpreting this Goal for the very first time in the City's case and there is positive staff report for what is being recommended. Councilor Bjelland stated that Goal 14 has been in place for 30 years and it did not anticipate all of the situations that have arisen in the land use arena over that period of time. The new Goal takes into account decisions made through the Court system or have been adopted by LCDC in addressing the land use issues that have come before them. He felt that it would be wise for the City to move fopa, ard once the new Goat 14 is effective since it is a key element in the City's Economic Opportunities Analysis program. Mr. Winterowd entered into the record the Goal 14 adopted language dated April 28, Page 9 - Council Meeting Minutes, June 13, 2005 10 COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES JUNE 13,2005 TAPE READFNG 4100 2005, a photograph which is already in the record but blown up to a readable scale, and a memorandum dated April 14, 2004 which identifies soil types and what crops are grown with those soil types. Councilor McCallum questioned the status of the School District request. Mr. Winterowd expressed his opinion that it is hard to find affordable sites for schools and the School District had some good reasons for buying the land that they did. After reviewing the law and the objections from 1000 Friends, he felt compelled that the Council recommend that this property not be included at this time. He stated that the land need on the public side had been increased based on a recommendation from the School District. However, the land chosen by the School District is on Class II soils at the edge of the growth boundary and part of a much larger cluster area of Class II soils between the UGB and the Pudding River. He felt that it was a target for an appeal and did not feel that the City had enough information to defend inclusion of the land. He also was glad to here that the School Superintendent had informed the Council that they would be working with a Facilities Planning Team to address future facilities needs of the district. He reminded the Council that this process has been worked on since 2000 and if the UGB is amended now there is 15-year supply of land rather than a 20-year supply but the City is bound by the 20-year population projection that has been coordinated with Marion County. He stated that there will most likely be a need to amend the growth boundary for school and residential lands soon after this UGB expansion is approved. He reiterated that all of the projections that have been done are based on 15 years away rather than 20 years. Councilor Cox requested additional detail about the changes that were made in the Interchange Management Overlay relating to the scope of how it would work. Director Mulder stated that staff continues to refine the proposed ordinance and addressing comments as far as having a minimum threshold for a type of development that would trigger compliance with the ordinance. A lot of the amendments related to putting the draft ordinance into the format of the City's current ordinances. Substantive changes included establishing a 20 peak hour vehicle trip minimum and amendments to the tables of the properties that would be subject to the ordinance. The minimum threshold amendment would address the concerns expressed by the Real Estate group. To be subject to the ordinance, parcels would need to be at least one (1) acre in size. Councilor Cox stated that the Interchange Management Overlay Area is a way of striving for a portion of Woodbur-n to have concurrency in that development would not occur until infrastructure is available to serve the property. Within our City, the limiting factor has been and will continue to be traffic growth. He has been thinking about having some concurrency requirement for the City as a whole and he would tike to get some response from staff on this issue. Director Mulder stated that the concurrency issue would be coming forward to the Focus Group as part of the Woodburn Development Ordinance updates. Mr. Winterowd stated that every concurrency ordinance he has seen has a safety valve in Page 10 - Council Meeting Minutes, June 13, 2005 11 COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES JUNE 13,2005 TAPE READff4G that a developer could go ahead with a proposal provided that they have an assured means of fixing problem within a period of time and then be a part of a solution to the problem. The intent is to give ODOT some assurance that the City will not overburden the interchange and will work with the property owners to make sure that they pay their fair share. ODOT and the City will also contribute money for road irnprovements so that over time there will be an interchange that will work, and then the City will make sure that the capacity is not used up sooner than expected. The numbers in the document are based on a level of development that is in the proposed plan. Administrator Brown stated that the Council would next discuss this issue in July since June 27, 2005 is the deadline for submission of written testimony. 5016 Mayor Figley recessed the meeting at 9:42 p.m. and recorwened at 9:47 p.m.. 5042 HERMANSON POND DEED RESTRICTIONS. Mayor Figley stated that there was nothing in the document that is inconsistent with the development of the park as a wetland. Councilor Cox stated that the restrictions were reasonable, however, he has learned through the years that problems arise with f~ature interest in property and deed restrictions. These restrictions may be acceptable now but they could create problems years into the future. The State legislature had adopted a statute a few years ago to limit the bad effects of some of those future interests but did not know if it applied to public land. He expressed his hesitation to put in restrictions that would be permanent and never have the fight to remove. He would like to have the deed restrictions either limited to a period of years or that those restrictions would not be removed or modified without the consent of one of the agencies mentioned in the staff report. Director Westrick stated that the Department of State Lands (DSL) permit is required to perform the work which includes deepening and expanding Hermanson pond, removing and abating noxious non-native plant materials, and restoring natural native habitat. He did not feel that DSL would object to adding on the stipulation that restrictions could be lifted with DSL's consent. City Attorney Shields stated that he also had some concern regarding the permanency of the restrictions and was willing to work on drafting a legal document that is acceptable to the Council. Director Westrick stated that project documents can still be prepared in anticipation of the permits and he will work with the two state agencies who will be funding these improvements. BJELLAND/COX... authorize the City Administrator on behalf of the City to record a document containing restrictive covenants noted in the staff report against the City owned property located at Hermanson Pond with the addition that a waiver or a removal of that deed restriction through a DSL waiver be included. The motion passed unanimously. Page 11 - Council Meeting Minutes, June 13, 2005 12 COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES JUNE 13,2005 TAPE READff4G 5868 Tape 3 0272 MID-WILLAMETTE COMMUNITY ACTION AGENCY. Councilor Bjelland stated that he was recently approached by an individual who was interested in serving on the Board of Directors of the Mid-Willamette Valley Community Action Agency. This Agency is a partner with a non-profit agency that receives federal and state funding for a multitude of purposes such as Head Start program, poverty related programs, community service programs. The Agency's constitution requires representation from various sources one of which is elected officials. He stated that Woodburn could request representation on the Board of Directors and then designate an official representative to serve on the Board. He recomrnended that Jenne Arana be designated as the elected official representative who, up until a couple of months ago, was Administrator of the Community Services Division for Oregon Housing and Comrnunity Services Department. She is a resident of Keizer, however, she does have a strong interest as an Administrator for the Community Services division. She also helped to set up the Family Referral Agency in Woodburn through the Community Action Agency, is very knowledgble about the programs, and would be an advocate for our community. He stated that the Community Action Agency Director is desirous of having someone serve on the Board that would represent the North Marion County area since representation in the past has been primarily Polk County and the City of Salem. Discussion was held in regards to the need to have a representative on the Board and in designating a representative to the Board that is not a resident of the City or from within the North Marion County area. MCCALLUM/COX... nominate Councilor Lonergan to serve on the Mid-Willamette Valley Community Action Agency Board of Directors. The motion passed unanimously. Councilor Lonergan designated Jenne Arana as his representative on the Board. PLANNING COMMISSION OR ADMINISTRATIVE LAND USE ACTIONS. A) Planning Commission approval of Conditional Use 05-01 and Design Review 05-02: Woodbum Police Facility (1060 Mt. Hood Avenue) B) Planning Commission approval of Design Review 04-10, Variance 04-34, Variance 04-35, Variance 05-08, and Property Line Adjustment 05-04: Cascade Park (950 North Cascade Drive) C) Community Development Director's approval of Partition 05-02: Boones Crossing PUD No action was taken by the Council to call these applications up for review. 0345 MAYOR AND COUNCIL REPORTS. Councilor McCallum expressed his appreciation for the support extended to this year's Relay for Life event to be held on June 24-25, 2005. There are over 700 individuals scheduled to participate and he reminded the public that Safeway is providing dinner at $4.00 per plate with all funds going to the Relay, the Luminary ceremony' is scheduled for 10:00 pm. On Saturday beginning at 7:00 am, Team Woodburn (City Attorney Shields Page 12 - Council Meeting Minutes, June 13, 2005 13 COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES JUNE 13,2005 TAPE READING and Public Works Manager Rohman) will be running a mini-marathon, and the Mayor's lap will begin at 11:30 am. Mayor Figley also congratulated the High School Graduating Class of 2005. 0472 EXECUTIVE SESSION. Mayor Figley entertained a motion to adjourn to executive session under the authority of ORS 192.660(1)(h) and ORS 192.660(1)(f). It was noted that no discussion would be held regarding labor negotiations. MCCALLUM/NICHOLS... adjourn to executive session under the statutory authority cited by the Mayor. The motion passed unanimously. The meeting adjourned to executive session at 10:14 p.m. and reconvened at 10:45 p.m.. 0500 Mayor Figley stated that the Council took no action while in executive session and no action is necessary in open session. NICHOLS/SIFUENTEZ .... meeting be adjourned. The motion passed unanimously. The meeting adjourned at 10:46 p.m.. APPROVED KATHRYN FIGLEY, MAYOR ATTEST Mary Tennant, Recorder City of Woodburn, Oregon Page 13 - Council Meeting Minutes, June 13, 2005 14 Executive Session COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES June 13, 2005 DATE. CONFERENCE ROOM, CITY HALL, CITY OF WOODBUR2'/, COUNTY OF MARION, STATE OF OREGON, JUNE 13, 2005. CONVENED. The Council met in executive session at 10:16 p.m. with Mayor Figley presiding. ROLL CALL. Mayor Figley Present Councilor Bj elland Present Councilor Cox Present Councilor Lonergan Present Councilor McCallum Present Councilor Nichols Present Councilor Sifuentez Present Staff Present: City Administrator Brown, City Attorney Shields, City Recorder Tennant Mayor Figley reminded the Councilors and staff that information discussed in executive session is not to be discussed with the public. The executive session was called under the following statutory, authority: 1) To consult with counsel concerning the legal rights and duties of a public body with regard to current litigation or litigation likely to be filed pursuant to ORS 192.660(1)(h); and 2) To consider records that are exempt by law from public inspection pursuant to ORS 192.660(1)(f). ADJOUPd',IMENT. The executive session adjourned at 10:44 p.m.. APPROVED KATHRYN FIGLEY, MAYOR ATTEST Map/Tennant, Recorder City of Woodbum, Oregon Page 1 - Executive Session, Council Meeting Minutes, June 13, 2005 15 e laior?oraeed ~859 813 June 24, 2005 TO: Mayor and City Council through City Administrator FROM: Scott Russell, Chief of Pdice ~t~'~ Su~ECTi POlice Department Statistics - May 200S RECOMMENDATION: Receive the Report BACKGROUND: The a~ached report lists year to date reported offenses and arrests displayed by month. DISCUSSION: The statistics have been gathered The Previous comparison purposes. from the Police Departments Records year's statistics are also displayed for FINANCIAL IMPACT: None Agenda Item Review: City Admini,' City Attorney __ Finance __ 16 PL6860 TIME: 12:52:37 MONTHLY CRIMINAL OFFENSES FOR JANUARY THRU MAY 2005 SCOTTRU ORI#: 0R0240500 WPD RESULTS FOR ALL OFFENSES CHARGE DESCRIPTION JAN FEB MAR APR MAY TOTAL AGGP, AVATED ASSAULT ............................................................................................ i 3 2 4 3 13 AGGRAVATED N'~JRDER ~N INIAL ORDINANCES ~SON ASSAULT SIMPLE ATTEMPTED MURDER BOMB THREAT BRIBERY BURGLARY - BUSINESS BURGLARY - OTHER STRUCTURE BURGLARY - RESIDENCE CHILD ADBANDOMENT CHILD NEGLECT CITY ORDINANCE CRIME DAMAGE-NO VANDALISM OR ARSON CURFEW CUSTODIAL INTERFERENCE CUSTODY - DETOX CUSTODY - MATERIAL WITNESS CUSTODY - MENTAL CUSTODY - PROTECITVE DISORDERLY CONDUCT DOCUMENTATION DRINKING IN PUBLIC DRIVING UNDER INFLUENCE DRL~S LAW VIOLATIONS DRUG PARAPHERNALIA DWS/REVOKED - FELONY DWS/REVOKED-MISDEMEANOR ELUDE EMBEZZLEMENT ESCAPE FROM YOUR CUSTODY EXTORTION/BLACKMAIL FAIL TO DISPLAY OPERATORS LICENSE FAMILY-OTHER FORCIBLE RAPE FORGERY/COUNTERFEITING FRAUD - ACCOUNT CLOSED CHECK FRAUD - BY DECEPTION/FALSE PRETENSES FRAUD - CREDIT CARD/AUTOMATIC TELLER MACHINE FRAUD - IMPERSONATION FRAUD - NO ACCOUNT - CHECK FRAUD - NOT SUFFICIENT FUNDS CHECK FRAUD - OF SERVICES/FALSE PRETENSES FRAUD - WELFARE FRAUD - WIRE FRAUD-OTHER F~ITIVE ARREST FOR ANOTHER AGENCY FURN I SH I NG GAMBL tNG - BOOKMAKING GAMBLING - GAMES GAMBLING - ILLEGAL DEVISES/MACHINES 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 10 9 11 32 1 0 0 I 1 3 20 11 I8 16 15 80 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 7 5 4 i 6 23 2 I 4 2 10 19 14 5 12 11 15 57 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 I 1 2 i 5 2 2 12 34 23 24 21 17 119 0 0 0 3 2 5 0 0 0 I 0 1 I 5 I 3 2 12 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 3 4 0 0 0 0 i 1 3 i 2 4 8 18 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 I 1 4 9 8 6 13 40 6 10 7 13 12 48 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 I 2 2 4 9 18 0 2 4 3 i 10 0 0 0 1 I 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 4 I 3 1 4 13 0 0 i 0 I 2 0 3 0 0 2 5 4 6 8 10 3 31 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 2 0 i 5 0 0 0 0 1 1 i 4 2 3 i tl 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 I 0 3 1 1 6 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 32 29 28 34 43 166 i 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1'1 DATE: 6/21/2005 PAGE PL6860 TIME: 12:52:37 MONTHLY CRIMINAL OFFENSES FOR JANUARY THRU MAY 2005 SCOTTRU ORI#: 0R0240500 WPD RESULTS FOR ALL OFFENSES CHARGE DESCRIPTION JAN FEB MAR APR MAY TOTAL G~NMBLtNG - ILLEGAL PAY OFF ................................................................................. 0 0 0 0 0 0 G~NqBLING - NUMBERS A~D LOTTERY G~NMBLING - OTHER CARBAGE LITTERING HIT AND RUN FELONY HIT AND RUN-MISDEMEANOR ILLEGAL ALIEN - INS HOLD ILLEGAL ESTABLISHMENT ILLEGAL LIQUOR-MAKE.SELL,POSSESS IMPORTING LIQIJOR INTIMIDATION /OTHER CRIMINAL THREAT JUSTIFIABLE HOMICIDE KIDNAP - FOR ADDITIONAL CRIMINAL PURPOSE KIDNAP - FOR PJ~SOM KIDNAP - HI-JACK.TERRORIST KIDIN~NP - HOSTAGE/SHIELD OR REMOVAL/DELAY WITNESS LICENSING ORDINANCES LIQUOR LAW-OTHER LIQUOR LICENSE VIOLATIONS MINOR IN POSSESSION MINOR ON PREMISES MISCELLANEOUS MOTOR VEHICLE THEFT NEGLIGENT HOMICIDE - TRAFFIC NEGLIGENT MANSLAUGHTER NON CRIMINAL DOMESTIC DISTURBANCE NON SUPPORT OTHER PARENTAL RESPONCIBILITY ORDINANCES (SVP) PROPERTY - FOUND LOST MISLAID PROPERTY RECOVER FOR OTHER AGENCY PROSTITUTION - COMPEL PROSTITUTION - ENGAGE IN PROSTITUTION - OTHER PROSTITUTION - PROMOTE PUBLIC HEALTH AND SAFETY ORDINANCES RECKLESS DRIVING ROBBERY - BANK ROBBERY - BUSINESS ROBBERY - CAR JACKING ROBBERY - CONV.STORE ROBBERY - HIGHWAY ROBBERY - OTHER ROBBERY - RESIDENCE ROBBERY - SERVICE STATION RUNAWAY SEX CRIME - CONTRIBUTE TO SEX DELINQUENCY SEX CRIME - EXPOSER SEX CRIME - FORCIBLE SODOMY SEX CRIME - INCEST SEX CRIME - MOLEST (PHYSICAL) SEX CRIME - NON FORCE SODOMY 0 0 0 1 14 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 2 0 6 34 0 0 0 0 9 0 23 0 0 0 0 0 13 0 0 2 1 0 0 1 1 0 7 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 0 5 36 0 0 0 0 13 0 14 0 0 0 0 0 12 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 10 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 4 2 0 1 4 12 6 13 53 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 5 2 12 0 0 0 0 I 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 i i 2 9 0 0 0 0 3 6 5 25 13 6 10 99 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 i 3 12 3 10 47 0 0 0 0 21 24 25 107 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ~ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 6 10 99 140 i 2 2 5 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 4 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 I 0 2 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 6 10 8 41 1 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 0 0 1 0 2 1 4 0 0 0 1 18 DATE: 6/21/2005 PAGE PL6860 TIME: 12:52:37 MONTHLY CRIMINAL OFFENSES FOR JANUARY THRU MAY 2005 SCOTTRU ORI#: 0R0240500 WPD RESULTS FOR ALL OFFENSES CHARGE DESCRIPTION JAN FEB MAR APR MAY TOTAL SEX CRIME - NON-FORCE RAPE 0 4 0 0 1 ..... SEX CRIME - OBSCENE PHONE CALL SEX CRIME - OTHER SEX CRIME - PEEPING SEX CRIME - PORNOGRAPHY/OBSCENE MATERIAL SEX CRIME - SEXUAL ASSAULT WITH AN OBJECT STALKER STOLEN PROPERTY - RECEIVING,BUYING,POSSESSING SUICIDE THEFT - BICYCLE THEFT - BUILDING THEFT - COIN OP MACHINE THEFT - FROM MOTOR VEHICLE THEFT - MOTOR VEHICLE PARTS/ACCESSORIES THEFT - OTHER THEFT - PICKPOCKET THEFT - PURSE SNATCH THEFT - SHOPLIFT TRAFFIC ORDINANCES TRAFFIC VIOLATIONS TRESPASS UNKNOWN VANDALISM VEHICLE RECOVERD FOR OTHER AGENCY WARRANT ARREST FOR OUR AGENCY WEAPON - CARRY CONCEALED WEAPON - EX FELON IN POSSESSION WEAPON - OTHER WEAPON - POSSESS ILLEGAL WEAPON - SHOOTING IN PROHIBITED AREA WILLFUL MURDER ZONING ORDINANCE 0 t 0 0 0 I 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 I 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 I 5 0 I 0 7 0 i 0 0 0 1 3 1 i 2 5 12 2 3 3 4 2 14 0 0 I 0 0 1 43 38 34 36 22 173 3 0 3 i 0 7 15 12 24 13 23 87 0 0 0 0 i 1 2 0 i 0 0 3 14 4 9 9 15 51 0 2 i 0 0 3 21 15 9 6 9 60 4 7 4 9 6 30 0 0 0 0 0 0 56 43 46 37 37 219 6 11 4 4 0 25 2 I I 1 0 5 I i I 0 1 4 i I 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 0 2 1 6 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 i 3 I 3 5 13 TOTAL: 431 387 377 363 500 2058 2005 TOTAL' 431 387 377 363 500 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2058 2004 TOTAL: 541 543 575 495 495 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2649 2003 TOTAL: 520 360 437 459 567 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2343 19 .............. ~: u:w. PAGE DATE: 6/21/2005 PL6850 TIME: 12:52:17 MONTHLY ARRESTS BY OFFENSE FOR JANUARY THRU MAY 2005 SCOTTRU ORI~: 0R0240500 WPD RESULTS FOR ALL CH4RGES CHARGE DESCRIPTION JAN FEB MAR APR MAY TOTAL AGGRAVATED ASSAULT 1 2 3 2 1 9 AGNSRAVATED MURDER 0 0 NttMAL ORDINANCES 0 1 ARSON 0 1 ASSAULT SIMPLE 14 9 ATTEMPTED MURDER 0 0 BOMB THREAT 0 0 BURGLARY - BUSINESS 0 0 BURGLARY - OTHER STRUCTURE 0 0 BURGLARY - RESIDENCE 0 4 CHILD ADBANDOMENT 0 0 CHILD NEGLECT 0 0 CITY ORDINANCE 0 0 CRIME DAMAGE-NO VANDALISM OR ARSON 0 1 CURFEW 0 0 CUSTODIAL INTERFERENCE 0 0 CUSTODY - DETOX I 7 CUSTODY - MENTAL 0 0 CUSTODY - PROTECITVE 0 0 DISORDERLY CONDUCT 4 2 DOCUMENTATION 0 0 DRINKING IN PUBLIC 0 0 DRIVING UNDER INFLUENCE 4 9 DRUG LAW VIOLATIONS 5 9 DRUG PARAPHERNALIA 0 0 DWS/REVOKED - FELONY 0 0 DWS/REVOKED-MISDEMEANOR I 2 ELUDE 0 1 EMBEZZLEMENT 0 0 ESCAPE FROM YOUR CUSTODY 0 0 EXTORTION/BLACKMAIL 0 0 FAIL TO DISPLAY OPERATORS LICENSE 4 1 FAMILY-OTHER 0 0 FORCIBLE RAPE 0 0 FORGERY/COUNTERFEITING i 0 FRAUD - ACCOUNT CLOSED CHECK 0 0 FRAUD - BY DECEPTION/FALSE PRETENSES 0 0 FRAUD - CREDIT CARD/AUTOMATIC TELLER MACHINE 0 0 FRAUD - IMPERSONATION 3 3 FRAUD - NOT SUFFICIENT FUNDS CHECK 0 0 FRAUD - OF SERVICES/FALSE PRETENSES 0 0 FPAUD-OTHER 0 0 FUGITIVE ARREST FOR ANOTHER AGENCY 34 28 FURNISHING 1 0 GAMBLING - GAMES 0 0 GAMBLING - OTHER 0 0 GARBAGE LITTERING 0 1 HIT AND RUN FELONY 0 0 HIT AND RUN-MISDEMEANOR 2 1 ILLEGAL ALIEN - INS HOLD 0 0 INTIMIDATION /OTHER CRIMINAL THREAT 0 1 KIDNAP - FOR ADOiTIONAL CRIMINAL PURPOSE 0 0 0 0 0 10 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 2 0 0 1 12 15 60 0 0 0 0 0 0 t 0 3 4 I 0 0 1 0 6 0 10 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 2 0 0 0 0 4 4 2 11 0 4 3 7 0 0 0 0 i 3 2 14 0 1 1 2 0 0 I 1 i 9 11 27 0 0 0 0 0 0 i 1 8 6 13 40 7 13 17 51 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 4 9 19 4 3 0 8 0 0 0 0 0 I 0 1 0 0 0 0 2 1 3 11 0 0 0 0 0 i 0 1 I 9 2 13 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 6 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 27 39 47 175 0 0 i 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 2 4 1 0 0 ! 2 2 3 t0 0 0 0 0 1 8 1 11 0 0 0 0 20 DATE: 6/21/2005 TIME: 12:52:17 ORI#: 0R0240500 WPD MONTHLY ARRESTS BY OFFENSE FOR JANUARY THRU MAY 2005 RESULTS FOR ALL CHARGES PL6850 SCOTTRU CHARGE DESCRIPTION JAN FEB KIDNAP - FOR P~SOM KIDNAP - HI-JACK.TERRORIST KIDNAP - HOSTAGE/SHIELD OR REMOVAL/DELAY WITNESS LICENSING ORDINANCES LIQUOR LAW-OTHER MINOR IN POSSESSION MINOR ON PREMISES MISCELLANEOUS ~TOR VEHICLE THEFT NEGLIGENT HOMICIDE - TRAFFIC NEGLIGENT MANSLAUGHTER NON CRIMINAL DOMESTIC DISTURBANCE NON SUPPORT OTHER PROPERTY - FOUND LOST MISLAID PROPERTY RECOVER FOR OTHER AGENCY PROSTITUTION - COMPEL PROSTITUTION - ENGAGE IN PROSTITUTION - PROMOTE PUBLIC HEALTH AND SAFETY ORDINANCES RECKLESS DRIVING ROBBERY - BANK ROBBERY - BUSINESS ROBBERY - CAR JACKING ROBBERY - CONV.STORE ROBBERY - HIG~AY ROBBERY - OTHER ROBBERY - RESIDENCE ROBBERY - SERVICE STATION RUNAWAY SEX CRIME SEX CRIME SEX CRIME SEX CRIME SEX CRIME SEX CRIME SEX CRIME SEX CRIME SEX CRIME SEX CRIME SEX CRIME STALKER - CONTRIBUTE TO SEX DELINQUENCY - EXPOSER - FORCIBLE SODOMY - INCEST - MOLEST (PHYSICAL) - NON FORCE SODOMY - NON-FORCE RAPE - OBSCENE PHONE CALL - OTHER - PORNOGRAPHY/OBSCENE MATERIAL - SEXUAL ASSAULT WITH AN OBJECT STOLEN PROPERTY - RECEIVING.BUYING,POSSESSING SUICIDE THEFT - BICYCLE THEFT - BUILDING THEFT - COIN OP MACHINE THEFT - FROM MOTOR VEHICLE THEFT - MOTOR VEHICLE PARTS/ACCESSORIES THEFT - OTHER THEFT - PICKPOCKET THEFT - PURSE SNATCH MAR APR MAY TOTAL 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 8 5 0 0 0 3 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5 6 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 I 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 t 7 0 0 0 0 0 t 0 0 0 3 0 0 1 i 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 4 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 2 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 i 0 16 12 9 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 2 2 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 t 0 0 t 0 0 t 0 0 1 1 0 t 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 I 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ! 2 3 0 0 0 i3 4 1 0 0 0 4 3 6 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 19 0 3 7 0 0 0 1 48 0 0 0 0 0 0 6 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 4 1 1 2 1 I 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 10 0 0 7 0 21 0 15 0 i 21 DATE: 6/21/2005 PL6850 TIME: 12:52:17 MONTHLY ARRESTS BY OFFENSE FOR JANUARY THRU MAY 2005 SCOTTRU ORI#: 0R0240500 WPD RESULTS FOR ALL CHARGES CHARGE DESCRIPTION JAN FEB MAR APR MAY TOTAL THEFT - SHOPLIFT TRAFFIC ORDINANCES TRAFFIC VIOLATIONS TRESPASS VANDALISM VEHICLE RECOVERD FOR OTHER AGENCY WARPJ~NT ARREST FOR OUR AGENCY WEAPON - CARRY CONCEALED WE~ON - EX FELON IN POSSESSION WEAPON - POSSESS ILLEGAL WEAPON - SHOOTING IN PROHIBITED AREA WILLFUL MURDER ZONING ORDINANCE 2005 TOTAL: 2004 TOTAL: 2003 TOTAL: 14 3 7 10 15 49 0 0 0 0 0 0 16 14 12 25 46 i13 2 t0 5 14 4 35 1 t t 12 2 17 0 1 0 3 0 4 I 1 1 t 0 4 i 1 1 0 1 4 0 2 0 0 0 2 0 2 0 2 3 7 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 129 148 144 234 238 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 893 208 194 218 195 196 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1011 202 148 164 190 221 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 925 June 22, 2005 TO: FROM: SUBJECT: Honorable Mayor and City Council through Ci' Administrator Public Works Program Manager ODOT Highway 99E Preservation and Safety Project iNI~OR/~ATION: ODOT is beginning their four-phase process to complete engineering work for a project called the "OR99E: Aurora to Salem Pavement and Safety Improvements Project." The first phase, Project Definition and Concept Design, is just beginning. The project is currently projected for bidding in June 2007. The project is currently within budget but there is significant definition to complete on pavement preservation limits and the safety project portion of the project. The pavement preservation overlay portion of the project includes all of Highway 99E through Woodburn. The safety improvements portion of the project includes work on three specific projects within the Woodburn city limits. The first safety project goal will be to provide effective solutions to high crash history on OR99E from Mt. Jefferson Avenue to James Street. This area was identified as a safety concern in the 200] OR99E Corridor Safety Report. The OR99E Corridor Safety Report recommended pedestrian refuge islands similar to the island at the high school as one of the potential solutions. Pedestrian islands will potentially create conflicts with left turn movements. Other solutions will be evaluated as well as part of concept design. The second safety project goal for the project is to provide effective solutions to high crash history at the intersection of OR99E and Young Street. The project will also improve intersection geometry for truck turning and replace the existing traffic signal. Trucks tov,,ing manufactured homes generally do not use this intersection but instead use Silverton Road to the south and make the turn onto 99E where they often cross the centerline in order to complete the northbound turn. Trucks that use the Young intersection often have to move out of the designated travel lane to make the turn and negotiate the intersection afa much lower speed than at a properly designed intersection. Within the boundaries of the proposed improvements are numerous accesses and two city Agenda Item Review: City Administrat( City Attorney_ Finance Honorable Mayor and City Council June 22, 2005 Page 2 streets, George Street and Birdseye Avenue, which are close to the intersection and must be addressed in the conceptual design. There will have to be some right of way purchased for this intersection improvement. The third project would be to make illumination improvements at the intersections of Lincoln, Hardcastle and Aztec Streets. The better illumination will address pedestrian crossing safety at these intersections. The lack of illumination at these intersections was a deficiency that was identified as a safety concern in the 2001 OR99E Corridor Safety Report. ODOT will also be looking at relieving congestion and improving safety throughout the project through implementation of an access management strategy. The section of OR99E between Lincoln Street and the south city limits has too many access points which tend to cause safety and congestion problems. These deficiencies are outlined in specific detail in the City's Transportation System Plan. The specific scope of the access management strategy for this project has not been defined and how much of the highway segment will be evaluated is not known. Another goal that ODOT has with this project is to provide a context sensitive project supported by local agencies and other stakeholders. With the proposed project scope in the Woodburn city limits ODOT realizes that a significant public involvement with the City and other stakeholders including business interests along the highway will be required to develop a concept design that is acceptable to the community. To accomplish this goal ODOT has contracted with a public involvement consultant to assist in appropriately engaging the City and other stakeholders in the development of alternative solutions and selection of a concept design. The ODOT design consultant has begun alternative solution development and the public involvement consultant has been selected and is beginning work on developing stakeholder involvement plans, that include some door-to-door business outreach and smaller stakeholder meetings with businesses and affected property owners, tt is anticipated that the development of alternative concepts by ODOT will be sufficiently advanced to allow ODOT to make a presentation and receive comment from City Council in August 2005. 8I) June 22, 2005 TO: FROM: SUBJECT: Honorable Mayor and City Council throu City Administrator Public Works Program Manager Removal of Two Street Trees at 378 Montgomery Street INFORMATION: Unless directed otherwise by Council, City staff will approve removal of two frees at 378 Montgomery Street. The trees are street trees and eligible for the cost sharing policy for street tree maintenance in the right of way. BACKGROUND: The City received a request from the property owner at 378 Montgomery Street requesting approval for removal of two street trees. The two maple trees are located in the Montgomery Street right of way. The property owner obtained the attached evaluation and removal quote from J & J Stump and Tree Removal that indicated the trees posed a safety risk and should be removed. The City required an evaluation and recommendation from a certified arborist. On April 26, 2005 a certified arborist from Northwest Tree Specialists in the attached report confirmed that the two trees were in a heavy state of decline and should be removed. The arborist indicated in the report the deteriorated condition of the trees had been created by heavy overhead utility line clearance pruning and verbally indicated that maple trees are particularly susceptible to the damage that he observed as a result of utility tine pruning. Both trees have large branches that extend out over the street and could pose a public safety hazard due to the condition of the trees. DISCUSSION: The City has a cost sharing policy that shares the cost of extensive maintenance and removal of street trees. The maximum city contribution for one property is based on a formula and is limited to $500. FINANCIAL IMPACT: The City costs of the removal share will be from budgeted funds in the tree maintenance object in the Street Division budget. Agenda Item Review: City City Attorney Northwest Tree Specialists 818 SW 3rd Avenue Suite 294 Portland, OR 97204 503-380-6688 T(): I)ATI'~: q ASSIGNMENT: '--~~C ~-~Ac~T~ OF 'T~Q_O <~a~LVC_~__ OIlS ERVATION S :_.,% CONCI.USIONS: X RECOMMENI)ATIONS:_~_ I rcv,,r March. ( ,,nsulting Arhorist 26 PH 503-585-2443 ~ .~J. ULJA ~JUO SALEM. OR 97304 aHOPOSAt SUBMITTED TO NAME~''~"'Xv~ ADDnESS ...... 5o3 - WOIiK TO B( PFRI (')RM~ '~ Al I AIlCHt I [; ('~ T We hereby propose I0 furnish Ilia matonals and pedofm lhe labor necessary lot lhe complehon of ............. All matedal t~ guaranteed to be as specified, and the above work to be pedormed in accordance with the drawings and specifications submitted for above work, and completed in a substantial workmanlike manner for the sum of _ Dollars ($ ................. ) with payments lo be made as follows: Nc)I(; This propr)s;d may ho wJlhdrawn I)y t1'; d nM ;~¢:(;r;l)lO¢l w,lhm ACCEPTANCE OF PROPOSAL above p.cos, Spocifl¢sl~ons and coft, dll~ons ,~lrO salislaclory ;md ;ire hr:fo.h¥ ;iccqfled Yo~ ;irc, ;i i herbitol 10 dr) Ih~; work '.pooflod Paymenls will ho rn;ido ils oulhned .lbovc~ PROPOSAL. 27 e IOA June 27, 2005 TO: FROM: SUBJECT: Honorable Mayor and City Council through City Administrator Jim Mutder, Director of Community Development ~ Appeal of Design Review Case File No. 05-01 and Variance Case File No. 05-05 located at 1475 Mt. Hood Avenue. RECOMMENDATION: In regard to this proposal, the City Council has the following options: Concur with the Planning Commission's decision of approval of Design Review Case File No. 05-01 and Variance Case File No. 05-05. (2) Modify the Planning Commission's decision. It is recommended that the City Council instruct staff to prepare an ordinance to substantiate its decision. BACKGROUND: On May t2, 2005, the Planning Commission adopted a final order approving the applicant's request for administrative design review to retrofit and upgrade the building fac~ade and site elements at the existing structure located at 1475 Mt. Hood Avenue for use as an outpatient health service and wellness center (Design Review Case File No. 05-01), and variance to allow 43 existing parking spaces to remain in the required front yard setback (Variance Case File No. 05- 05). As a part of the Planning Commission's approval of Design Review 05-01 and Variance 05-05, a condition of approval required the applicant to provide a driveway cross-connection between the subject property and the properties to the east aligned with the driveway cross-access easement provided in Partition Case File No. 04-05 in compliance with the driveway cross-connection provisions of Section 3.104.03.A.3 of the Woodburn Development Ordinance and Section 9.4.2 of the Woodburn Transportation System Plan. On May 25, 2005, the appellant filed an appeal of the Planning Commission's decision to approve Design Review 05-01 9nd Variance 05-05. The appellant Agenda item Review: City Administrato City Attorney_ Finance~ 28 Honorable Mayor and City Council June 27, 2005 Page 2 requests removal of the condition of approval to provide a driveway cross- connection between the subject property and the properties to the east aligned with the driveway cross-access easement provided in Partition Case File No. 04-05. This public hearing is to consider that appeal and has been noticed as a de novo hearing, which allows new evidence and testimony to be presented by any party. The Planning Commission's final order is attached. Pages 15-19 and page 34 of the find order specifically address the condition requiring the cross-access easement. DISCUSSION: None. FINANCIAL IMPACT: There is no financial impact associated with the recommended action. Attachments: Exhibit A: Planning Commission Final Order, dated 5/] 2/05 Exhibit B: Planning Commission 4/28/05 Staff Report Exhibit C: Applicant's Testimony Submitted 4/28/05 Exhibit D: Planning Commission 4/28/05 Minutes Exhibit E: Notice of intent to Appeal, dated 5/25/05 Exhibit F: Aerial Photo Showing Potential Cross-Connection The attachments for Item IOA are not included in the agenda packet. The entire document has been given to the City Council and is available for review by the public in the City Recorder's office, in the City Administrator's office, and at the reference desk of the Woodburn Public Library. IN THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF WOODBURN, OREGON DESIGN REVIEW 05-01 VARIANCE 05-05 WELLSPRING HEALTH CENTER ) ) ) ) ) FINAL ORDER WHEREAS, a request was made by Matthew Spicer, the applicant, and Webstar V. LLC, the property owner, for administrative design review approval to retrofit and upgrade the building fa(;ade and site elements at the existing structure located at 1475 Mt. Hood Avenue for use as an outpatient health service and wellness center, and variance approval to allow 43 existing parking spaces to remain in the required front yard setback, and; WHEREAS, the Planning Commission reviewed the matter at their meeting of April 28, 2005, and; WHEREAS, the Planning Commission considered the written and oral testimony presented by staff, the applicant, and other interested persons, and; WHEREAS, the Planning Commission closed the hearing, and; WHEREAS, the Planning Commission moved to approve Design Review Case File No. 05-01 and Variance Case File No. 05-05 and instructed staff to prepare findings and conclusions. NOW, THEREFORE, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED BY THE COMMISSION: The Planning Commission approves Design Review Case File No. 05-01 and Variance Case File No. 05-05 based on the findings and conclusions contained in Exhibit "A", and subject to the conditions of approval contained' in Exhibit "B', which are attached hereto and by reference incorporated herein and which the Planning Commission finds reasonable. Approved: Claudio Lima, Chairperson Date Exhibit "A" EXHIBIT "A" FINDINGS & CONCLUSIONS II. III. DESIGN REVIEW 05-01 VARIANCE 05-05 APPLICANT INFORMATION Applicant: Matthew Spicer 333 NW 5u~ Avenue Portland, OR 97209 Property Owner: Webstar V. LLC Attn: Robert Engle 610 Glatt Circle Woodbum, OR 97071 Application Deemed Complete: 120-Day Rule Deadline: March 9, 2005 July 7, 2005 NATURE OF APPLICATION: The applicant requests administrative (Type II) design review approval to retrofit and upgrade the building fac,.ade and site elements at the existing structure located at 1475 Mt, Hood Avenue for use as an outpatient health service and wellness center, and variance approval to allow 43 existing parking spaces to remain in the required front yard setback. The applicant also proposes to remove the existing 3,565 square foot Garden Shop on the eastern building frontage and add a 960 square foot covered walk and 1,128 square foot drive-through canopy in its place, and to create two interior garden atriums (1,728 and 2,720 square feet respectively). RELEVANT FACTS: The site is approximately 7.05-acres in area and can be identified specifically on Marion County Assessor's Maps as Township 5 South, Range 1 West, Section 08B, Tax Lot # 2800. The site is currently developed as a big box retail center (formerly K-Mart) with existing structures, off street parking and landscaping. The property is zoned Commercial General (CG) and designated Commercial on the Comprehensive Plan Map. Properties to the north, northeast and northwest are zoned Industrial Park (IP) and designated Industrial on the Comprehensive Plan Map. Properties located to the south (across Mt. Hood Avenue) are zoned CG and Single-Family Residential (RS) and designated Commercial and Residential Less Than 12 Units per Acre on the Comprehensive Plan Map. Properties to the east and west are zoned CG and designated Commercial on the Comprehensive Plan Map. The industrial properties to the north, northeast and northwest are used as a manufactured home storage site, truck chassis manufacturing facility and self- DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page I IV. storage business respectively. Properties to the south (across Mt. Hood Avenue) are currently occupied by a house of worship and an integrated business center. The commemial properties to the east are developed as an implement rental service and a Washington Mutual Bank. The commercial properties to the west are vacant and the location of a Pizza Hut Restaurant. No significant wetlands are located on the subject property, and the site is located outside of the 500- year floodplain. Previous land use decisions exist for the site. On November 28, 1990, the Woodbum City Council approved Ordinance No. 2050 allowing a Comprehensive Plan Map Amendment and Zone Map Amendment from Industrial Park (IP) to Commercial General (CG) (Zone Map Amendment Case File No. 90-03, Comprehensive Map Amendment Case File No. 90-01) to allow for the development of a commercial retail center (Site Plan Review Case File No. 90- 10) on Parcel 2 resulting from Partition Case File No. 90-04. The existing structure on the subject site was constructed as Phase 1 of a 2-phase commercial retail development. Phase 2, a proposed row of retail shops abutting the west side of the Phase 1 structure, was never developed. RELEVANT APPROVAL CRITERIA: Desian Review 05-01: WOODBURN DEVELOPMENT ORDINANCE Section 2.106 Commercial General (CG) Section 3.101 Section 3.102 Section 3.103 Section 3.104 Section 3.105 Section 3.106 Section 3.107 Section 3.1t0 Section 5.t 02.02 Variance 05-05: Street Standards Utilities and Easements Setback, Open Space and Lot Standards, Generally Access Off Streets Parking and Loading Landscaping Standards Architectural Design Guidelines and Standards Signs Design Review for All Structures LESS THAN 1000 Sq. Ft. WOODBURN DEVELOPMENT ORDINANCE Section 5.103.11 Variance V. FINDINGS: Deslan Review 05-01: WOODBURN DEVELOPMENT ORDINANCI= DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 2 Section 2.106 Commercial General (CG) Section 2.106.01 Permitted Uses The following uses, when developed under the applicable development standards of the WDO, are permitted in the CG zone: M. Health Care and Social Services Ambulatory health services (621) EXCEPT ambulance service. (62191) FINDING: The applicant has indicated that the structure will be used for ambulatory health services. Ambulatory health services are outright permitted in the CG zone. This approval criterion is met. 2.106.05 Dimensional Standards The following dimensional standards shall be the minimum requirements for all development in the CG zone. A. Lot Standards. Lots in a CG zone shall comply with the applicable standards of Table 2.1.10. I TABLE 2.1.10 Lot Standards for Uses in a CG Zone In the CG zone the lot area for a non-residential use shall be adequate to contain all structures within the required setbacks. There shall be no minimum width or depth. FINDING: Compliance with setbacks and lot standards is addressed later in this report. B. Building Height. The maximum height of buildings shall not exceed 70 feet, EXCEPT chimneys, spires, domes, flag poles and other features not used for human habitation (EXCEPT telecommunication facilities), shall not exceed 100 feet. FINDING: According to the submitted elevation plan, the maximum height of the proposed parapet atop the existing structure is 29 feet, which meets the 70-foot maximum height allowed for buildings in the CG zone. This approval criterion is met. DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 3 C. Setback and Buffer Improvement Standards. 1. Front Yard Setback and Setback Abutting a Street: a. Dimensions: 1) The minimum setback abutting a street shall be 15 feet plus any Special Setback, Section 3.103.05. 2) The maximum yard abutting a street shall be 150 feet. FINDING: The subject property abuts Mt. Hood Avenue on its southern frontage. Mt. Hood Avenue is classified as a Major Arterial in the Woodbum Transportation System Plan (TSP). The special setback for a major arterial is 50 feet from the centedine of the street plus the required 15-foot setback adjacent to the street, which totals 65 feet from the centerline of Mt. Hood Avenue. The proposed addition to the farrade of the existing structure is located approximately 313 feet from centerline of Mt. Hood Avenue, which meets the 65-foot special setback from Mt. Hood Avenue. The depth of the existing yard abutting Mt. Hood Avenue is approximately 282 feet, which exceeds the 150-foot maximum yard depth for a yard abutting a street. The existing yard depth is nonconforming and subject to Section 1.104. Section 1.104.04.A states that "...Any expansion or addition to buildings or structures with nonconforming height, setback, density or lot coverage shall not make the development more nonconforming." The current proposal does not increase the depth of the yard abutting Mt. Hood Avenue and does not make the development more nonconforming. These criteria are met. b. Off Street Parking and Maneuvering: 1) Off street parking and storage shall be prohibited within a required front yard or special setback. 2) The distance between the sidewalk on a public street and a loading dock shall be sized to preclude vehicles using the dock from projecting over the sidewalk FINDING: The submitted site plan shows 43 existing parking spaces on the subject site located within the §§-foot special setback from the centerline of Mt. Hood Avenue. The applicant has submitted a vadance request to allow the existing 43 parking spaces to be located within the 65-foot special setback from the centedine of Mt. Hood Avenue. This variance request is discussed later in this report. No parking spaces are located in the required 5-foot intedor yard setbacks. The applicant is proposing to stripe 33 parking spaces and 4 loading stalls on the existing asphalted areas to the rear and sides of the existing DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 4 structure that am not located in the required 5 foot interior yard setback or 65 foot special setback. em Clear Vision Area: Fences, walls, landscaping and signs shall be subject to clear vision area standards, Section 3.103. FINDING: The submitted site plan does not show any of the above-mentioned items located in the 10-foot clear vision areas abutting the ddveway entrance. This criterion is met. d. Vehicular Access. Permitted in conformance with Section 3.104. FINDING: Vehicular Access is discussed in Section 3.104 of this report. 2. Interior Side and Rear Yard Setbacks. ae Development in a CG zone shall be subject to the setback and buffer requirements of Table 2.1.11. (Table on following page) DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 5 TABLE 2.1.11 Interior Yard and Buffer Standards for CG Zones Abutting Property Landscaping Wall Interior Setback RS, RIS, or RM There is no buffer Solid bdck or 10 ft. zone yard landscaping architectural wall requirement for an with anti-graffiti interior yard surface, no less abutting a buffer than 6 feet or wall. greater than 7 feet in height. CO, CG, DDC, There is no buffer Altemative A: Altemative A: P/SP, IP or IL zone yard landscaping requirement for an Wall requirements 5 ft. interior yard shall be determined abutting a buffer in conjunction with wall. the applicable Design Review process. Altemative B: Altemative B: Zero setback abutting a building No wall required, wall. FINDING: The adjacent properties to the east and west are zoned Commercial General (CG) and the properties to the north are zoned Industrial Park (IP), requiring a 5-foot interior yard setback or O-foot setback abutting a building wall along the north, east and west property lines. The structure is located a minimum of 58 feet from the north property line, 53 feet from the east property line and 42 feet from the north property line. The proposed covered walkway and drive- through canopy on the eastern building fac~ade are located 53 feet and 82 feet from the east property line respectively. The structure has a O-foot setback where the exterior building wall is located along the central portion of the west property line. These setbacks meet the minimum required 5-foot interior yard setback and O-foot setback abutting a building wall along the north, east and west property lines. A wall is not necessary on the north, east and west property lines of the subject site because the abutting commercial and industrial uses are compatible with the proposed ambulatory health center. An existing chain link fence and proposed Roundleaf laurustinus (Viburnum tinus l~obustum') hedge will abut the north property line. Roundleaf laurustinus grows to a height of 6 to 12 feet and will effectively obscure visibility of the site from the adjacent industrial uses to the north. A hedge of Green Island Holly (Ilex crenata "Green Island") is proposed along the northeast property line. Green Island Holly grows to a height of 2 feet, which will not effectively screen the site from the adjacent industrial use to the DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 6 northeast. As a condition of approval, the applicant shall submit a revised landscaping plan showing a Roundleaf laurustinus hedge along the northeast property line to screen the site from the abutting industrial use to the northeast. This criterion will be met. be The minimum building setback from a private access easement shall be 5 feet. FINDING: No private access easements are shown on the submitted site plan. This approval criterion is met. c. Off street parking. Maneuvering and storage: Off street parking and storage shall be prohibited within a required setback. FINDING: The submitted site plan shows 43 existing parking spaces on the subject site located within the 65-foot special setback from the cent, dine of Mt. Hood Avenue. The applicant has submitted a variance request to allow the existing 43 parking spaces to be located within the 65-foot special setback from the centedine of Mt. Hood Avenue. This variance request is discussed later in this report. Section 2.106.06 Development Standards NI development in the CG zone shall comply with the applicable provisions of the WDO. The following standards specifically apply to uses in the CG zone. A. Off Street Parking. Off street parking shall be subject to the standards of Section 2.106.05 and Section 3.105. FINDING: Compliance with off street parking requirements is discussed in Section 3,105 of this report. B. Setbacks and Lots, Generally. Setbacks and lots shall be subject to Section 3.103. FINDING: Compliance with Section 3.103 is discussed later in this report. C. Architectural Design Guidelines. DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 7 All primary buildings and structures, EXCEPT those described in Section 2.106.05. C. 1, shall be subject to the architectural guidelines of Section 3.107.06. FINDING: Compliance with architectural design guidelines is discussed later in this report. E. Landscaping and Sidewalks. The street frontage of a subject property shall be Improved with either property line sidewalks and street trees or curb line sidewalks. The Improvement shall be determined at the time of subdivision, PUD or design review as applicable. Sidewalks and trees shall be Installed by the property owner to the standards of Section 3.101 and 3.106. The subject property shall be landscaped to the standards of Section 3.106. FINDING: Compliance with Section 3.101 and Section 3.106 is discussed later in this report. Common refuse collection facilities shall be screened on all sides by an architectural block wall and solid gate, both with an anti-graffiti surface, a minimum of six feet and a maximum of seven feet in height. FINDING: The submitted site plan shows the proposed common refuse collection facility in the northwest comer of the site to be surrounded by a 6-foot 10-inch tall combination scored and split-face CMU block wall with a slatted chain link gate, which does not meet the requirement for a common refuse collection facility with a solid metal gate. As a condition of approval, the applicant shall submit a revised elevation of the proposed trash enclosure showing a solid metal gate prior to building permit issuance. This criterion will be met. F. Property Disposition. All uses shall be established and conducted on lots of record, as defined by Section 1.102 and developed to the public facility and access standards of Sections 3.101, 3.102 and 3.104. FINDING: The proposed development will take place on a legal lot of record located at 1475 Mt. Hood Avenue in Woodbum. The property can be identified specifically on Madon County Assessor's Maps as Township 5 South, Range 1 West, Section 08B, Tax Lot # 2800. This approval criterion is met. DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 8 Section 3.101 Street Standards Section 3.101.02 General Provisions The access or driveway, for each lot shall be connected to the existing public street system in compliance with Section 3.104. FINDING: Compliance with Section 3.104 is discussed later in this report. No access permit shall be issued unless the internal street(s), boundary street(s) and abutting street(s) are constructed pursuant to Section 3.101.02. C, UNLESS or until the applicant has obtained an exception as provided in this section. FINDING: Mt. Hood Avenue is a State Highway under the jurisdiction of the Oregon Department of Transportation (ODOT), and a referral has been sent to ODOT regarding this proposal. ODOT's Region 2 Representative has indicated that "...based on the plans available, [ODOT has] determined that no amended approach permit is necessary for the existing signalized intersection...' This criterion is met. Section 3.102 Utilities and Easements Section 3.102.01 Water, Sanitary Sewer and Storm Drainage Facilities Municipal water, sanitary sewer and storm drainage facilities shall be Installed to applicable Public Works Department and state standards. FINDING: According to Public Works Department comments, water service is currently being provided by an existing City maintained water main traversing through the site. Waste water service is provided by the existing private sanitary sewer main extended through the site and connected to the existing public sanitary sewer at Mt Hood Avenue. A grease trap will be required to be installed on the sanitary service, either as a central unit or in each kitchen or food preparation area. Storm water runoff from the site is currently being provided from the on-site private system, discharging to a city maintained system on Progress Way. Any additional required public municipal water, sanitary sewer and storm infrastructure will be subject to the requirements of the Public Works Department and the WDO. These requirements will be met. Section 3.102.04 Easements A. Municipal Infrastructure Easements. The Public Works Department shall require dedication of specific easements for the construction and maintenance of municipal water, DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 9 sewerage and storm drainage facilities located on private property. Easements shall be required in accordance with the Public Works Department standards. FINDING: According to Public Works Department comments, the existing fire hydrant identified on the utility plan to be relocated shall nquire a utility easement to be provided to the City for the relocated hydrant if it is not relocated within the existing easement currently conveyed to the City. Any additional required municipal infrastructure easement dedications required by future development w/Ii be subject to the requirements of the Public Works Department and the WDO. B. Public Utility Easements (PUE). Five foot wide public utility easements (i.e., easements for natural gas lines and for electric and telecommunications wire or cable service) shall be dedicated along each lot line abutting a public street. At the time of tentative approval, utilities may request dedication of a public utility easement within a reciprocal access easement or centered along specified rear lot line in those zones where zero setback is not permitted. FINDING: Any required public municipal water, sanitary sewer and storm drainage utility easement dedications required by future development will be subject to the requirements of the Public Works Department and the WDO. C. Creeks and Watercourse Maintenance Easements. FINDING: There are no creeks or watercourses on the subject property for which maintenance easements will be required. This approval criterion is met. Section 3.103 Setbacks, Open Space and Lot Standards, Generally Section3.103.03 Setbacks, Setback Area and Required Open Space, Generally. B. Setbacks to be Unobstructed. A setback is the minimum required yard between a structure and a lot line, whether or not additional open space is actually provided between the structure and the lot line. Every setback area shall be open and unobstructed by buildings or structures from the ground to the sky EXCEPT as may otherwise be permitted in this Sect/on and Sections 2.201 and 2.202, Accessory Uses and Structures. DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 10 FINDING: The abutting properties to the north, east and west are zoned Industrial Park (IP) and Commercial General (CG), requiring a 5-foot interior yard setback or O-foot setback abutting a building wall according to Table 2.1.11. The existing structure is located a minimum of 58 feet from the north property line, 53 feet from the east property line and 42 feet from the northwestern property line. The proposed covered walkway and drive-through canopy on the eastern building facade are located 53 feet and 82 feet from the east property line respectively. The structure has a O-foot setback where the exterior building wall is located along the central portion of the west property line. These setbacks meet the minimum required 5-foot interior yard setback and O-foot setback abutting a building wall along the north, east and west property lines. This criterion is met. Section 3.103.05 Special Street Setbacks B. Setback Requirements. Required setbacks adjacent to a street shall be in addition to the special setbacks required in this Section. The special setback distances shall be measured at right angles to the center line of the original street fight of way. C. Special Provisions. Buildings, structures and paved surfaces shall not be located within the special setbacks EXCEPT as specifically provided for in the I/l/DO. Any portion of a building or structure lawfully established within a special street setback pfior to date of WDO shall be considered a nonconforming structure. D. Special Setback Standards. Special setback standards by street classification are established in Table 3.1.1. The special setback standards shall be applied to streets within the City of Woodbum as functionally classified in the Woodburn Transportation System Plan. (Table on following page) DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 11 TABLE 3.1.1 Special Setback Standards by Street Classification WTSP Functional Classification Special Setback from Center Line Major Arterial 50 feet Minor Arterial 37 feet Service Collector 37 feet Access Street with Parking or Golf Carts 35 feet Access Street with Bike Lanes 30 feet FINDING: The project site abuts Mt. Hood Avenue, classified as Major Arterial in the Woodbum Transportation System Plan (TSP), on its southern frontage. The required front yard setback for the subject site is a total of 65 feet (50 foot special setback plus 15 foot front yard setback) from the centerline of Mt. Hood Avenue. The proposed addition to the fac~ade of the existing structure is located approximately 323 feet from the centedine of Mt. Hood Avenue, which meets the 65-foot combined front yard and special setback for a structure abutting a Major Arterial in the CG zone. This criterion is met. Section 3.103.06. No Parking or Storage in Setbacks Adjacent to a Street Parking and storage shall be prohibited within a required setback adjacent to a street, EXCEPT for parking in driveways. FINDING: The submitted site plan shows 43 existing parking spaces on the subject site located within the 65-foot special setback from the centerline of Mt. Hood Avenue. The applicant has submitted a variance request to allow the existing 43 parking spaces to be located within the 65-foot special setback from the centerline of Mt. Hood Avenue. This variance request is discussed later in this report. Section 3.103.10 Vision Clearance Area A. Generally. A vision clearance area is an area at the intersection of two streets, a street and a driveway or a street and an alley in which visual obstructions are limited for safety purposes. B. Street-Driveway Intersection. A vision clearance area at the intersection of a street and a driveway shall be the area delineated as follows: A line extending ten feet from the Intersection along the street right of way. DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 12 o A line extending ten feet from the intersection along the side of the driveway. A third line that creates a triangular vision clearance area by connecting the ends of the lines described in Section 3.103.'i0.B. 1. and 2. E. Prohibited Development. A vision clearance area shall contain no plants, fence, wall, structure, or temporary or permanent obstruction exceeding 30 inches in height [measured from the top of the curb or, where no curb exists, from the established street centsrline grade], EXCEPT as follows: Trees, provided branches and foliage are removed to a height of 7 feet above grade; 2. Telephone, power and cable television poles; Telephone and utility boxes less than ten Inches at the widest dimension; and 4. Traffic control signs and devices. FINDING: The submitted site plan does not show any of the above-mentioned items located in the 10-foot clear vision areas abutting the driveway entrance. This criterion is met. Section 3.104. Access Section 3.104.0t Applicability A. Street Access Required. Every lot shall have direct access to an abutting public street or to a public street by an irrevocable access easement. FINDING: The subject property has existing access onto Mt. Hood Avenue via a 42-foot wide 2-way signalized ddveway entrance. The site also has existing access to Progress Way to the west via a reciprocal access agreement with the property to the west. This criterion is met. B. Access to City Streets, Permit Required. DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 13 A Traffic Impact Analysis (TIA) may be required by the Public Works Director prior to the approval of a City access or street construction permit when the Director estimates a development proposal may generate either 100 or more additional, peak hour trips, or 1,000 or more additional daily trips, within ten years of a development application. A TIA shall evaluate the traffic Impacts projected of a development proposal and the estimated effectiveness of potential traffic Impact mitigation measures. The methodology for a TIA shall be consistent with Public Works Department guidelines. FINDING: The Woodbum Transportation Manager indicated that the proposal would not require a TIA because the proposed development is not anticipated to generate 100 or more additional, peak hour trips, or 1,000 or more additional daily trips, within ten years of the development application. This approval criterion is met. 3. Administration of City access permit standards and guidelines Type II and III Applications. Development subject to one of the following Type II and III applications: 1) Type II Design Review, Section 5.102.02; shall be subject to the access standards and guidelines specified in this Section EXCEPT when the subject property is bound by the requirements of a precedent land use decision that has not been modified by a subsequent land use decision. FINDING: The current proposal is subject to administrative (Type II) Design Review and will be required to meet the requirements of Section 3.104. Section 3.104.02 Driveway and Drive-Through Measurements and Dimensions A. Driveways Crossing a Setback. The portion of a driveway crossing a setback shall be perpendicular to the setback lines. FINDING: The proposed site plan shows the driveways crossing a setback to be perpendicular to those setbacks. This approval criterion is met. B. Driveway Width. DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 14 Driveway width shall be determined by measurement at the property line. Drive-Through Dimensions and Configuration. 1. Minimum Lane Width. 12 feet. w Minimum Lane Length. 50 feet, unobstructed by lateral vehicular access. Precluded lateral vehicular access shall include the access/maneuvering area for off street parking and overlap onto public street right of way. The unobstructed length shall be measured from the drive up window or stop line, whichever is greater. 3. Turn Radius. 25 feet. m By-Pass Lane. A development providing a drive-through for passenger loading and/or unloading or for drive-up services shall include a by-pass lane to a site exist. FINDING: The applicant proposes to remove the existing 3,565 square foot Garden Shop on the eastern building frontage and add a 960 square foot covered walk and 1,128 square foot Urgent Care drive-through canopy in its place. The submitted site plan shows a 22-foot wide driveway beneath the canopy with a minimum lane length of 50 feet unobstructed by lateral vehicle access. This does not meet the standard for a 12-foot wide drive-through lane and 12-foot bypass lane (24-foot combined width). As a condition of approval, the applicant shall submit a revised site plan demonstrating compliance with the drive-through and bypass lane width requirements pertaining to the proposed Urgent Care patient drop-off area prior to issuance of a building permit. This criterion will be met. Section 3.104.03 Driveway Access Guidelines, Type II and III Applications Guidelines for the Number and Location of Driveways, Type II and Type III Applications. 2. Joint/Shared Access. Medium density residential, commercial, industrial uses and other development subject to Type II or III Design Review located on the same lot, or on abutting lots, that abut a Major Arterial, Minor Arterial, or Service Collector should be designed to share access to those major streets... DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 15 Shared/Joint Access Agreements. Shared and/or joint access agreements sewing properties under separate ownership shall be subject to legal documentation, to the satisfaction of the City Attorney, establishing permanent use of the access. The agreement shall be recorded with the County Recorder and filed with the Community Development Director. 3. Cross Connections. Similar, and/or compatible, uses on abutting lots should have interconnected on-site access and parking facilities. Such shared facilities sewing properties under separate ownership shall be subject to legal documentation, to the satisfaction of the City Attorney, establishing permanent use of the access. The agreement shall be recorded with the County Recorder and filed with the Community Development Director. FINDING: The property abuts Mt. Hood Avenue to the south. Mt. Hood Avenue is classified as a Major ^rteriai on the Woodbum Transportation System Plan (TSP). Commercial uses abut the subject property to the west (a Pizza Hut restaurant, bank and. undeveloped parcel zoned CC) and east (a bank and undeveloped parcel zoned CC). The Woodbum Transportation System Plan (TSP) provides access management policies and guidelines for Highways 214, 219 and 99E that are implemented by Sect/on 3.104.03 of the WDO. As a means of controlling vehicle access to accommodate future traffic volumes on Highway 214 and Highways 219 and 99E, Sect/on 9.4.2 of the TSP states that, '...From an operational perspective, the City of Woodbum and ODOT could (where appropriate) consider...purchasing right -of-way and closing driveways...[andlor]...installing median barriers and driveway access controls...' Sect/on 9.4.2 continues, "Crossover easements should .be provided on all compatible parcels (topography, access and land use) to facilitate future access between adjoining parcels...' The subject property and the abutting parcels to the east and west are relatively fiat and devoid of significant topographical features. The subject property and the abutting parcels to the east and west also have existing access onto Mt. Hood Ave. The proposed use of the subject property as an ambulatory health center is similar to existing uses on abutting properties to the east and west. Accordingly, the provision for providing a driveway cross-connection applies to the subject parcel and the abutting parcels to the east and west. In implementing the policies of the TSP, the WDO provides that commercial uses on adjoining properties abutting a major arterial should share driveway accesses to the major arterial. The subject property has existing access onto Mt. Hood DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 16 Avenue via a 42-foot wide 2-way signalized driveway entrance. The abutting parcels to the east and west have accesses to Mt. Hood Ave. The subject property has a shared access agreement with the property to the west. The property owner intends to modify the provisions of this shared access easement in conjunction with this proposal. A draft of the modification has been provided to staff. The modification continues to provide shared access, cross-connections and parking between the subject parcel and the parcel to the west. Therefore, the above provisions are satisfied relative to the abutting property to the west. Concerning the abutting properties to the east, a condition of approval of the original development of the subject property (as K-Mart under Site Plan Review Case File No. 90-10) required a driveway cross-connection on the east edge of the property. That connection was not constructed because the owner was unable to reach an agreement with the property to the east. The property to the east was partitioned on November 17, 2004, Partition Case File No. 04-05. In the partition approval, the Community Development Director required a 24-foot wide easement running east/west along the boundary created by the partition from the partition plat's ddveway west to the subject property's boundary line to provide for future connection of the accesses. The applicant has not provided a shared access agreement between the subject property and the properties to the east. This criterion can be satisfied by a condition of approval. The WDO also provides that abutting lots should have interconnected on-site access and parking facilities. This provision applies when abutting uses are either similar or compatible. The subject property is zoned CG, as are the abutting properties to the east and west. Similar uses are listed as outright permitted uses in the CG zone. The proposed use on the subject property, an ambulatory health center, is a permitted use in the CG zone. The abutting property to the west contains a Pizza Hut restaurant and a vacant commercial site. The abutting property to the east contains a bank fronting Mt. Hood Avenue and a vacant commercial site. These uses are similar to the proposed use on the subject site. Consequently, the provision for interconnected on-site access and parking facilities applies to the subject parcel and the abutting parcels to the west and east. The subject site has access to Mt. Hood Avenue via a signalized driveway entrance and the abutting properties to the east and west have access onto Mt. Hood Avenue via un-signalized driveway entrances. As mentioned previously, the subject property has existing driveway cross-connections via a shared access agreement with the property to the west. As traffic volumes on Mt. Hood Avenue increase and access management measures are implemented, driveway cross-connections between the subject property and abutting properties to the east and west will form a critical link between the abutting properties and the signalized driveway entrance on the subject site. The ability of the City to successfully employ access management to accommodate future traffic volumes along Highway 214 in accordance with Section 9.4.2 of the TSP as implemented DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 17 by Section 3.14.03.3 of the WDO requires the establishment of a dri~/eway cross-connection between the subject property and the commercial properties to the east. Establishment of a ddveway cross-connection on the eastem margin of the subject property in alignment with the 24-foot wide access easement provided across the properties to the east in Partition Case File No. 04-05 would provide the necessary vehicle cross-connection between the subject property and the properties to the east. The site plan does not show interconnected on-site access to the property to the east nor has the applicant provided documents to demonstrate the access and parking will be interconnected with the property to the east. This criterion can be satisfied by a condition of approval. The applicant provided written testimony asserting that the establishment of a cross-connection between the subject property and the properties to the east will be detrimental to vehicular safety on the subject site. The applicant states that ambulances will also be transporting patients to the proposed Urgent Care facility. The applicant identified the 90-degree driveway tum at the southeast comer of the ambulatory health center as the location of the proposed cross- connection and as a site where the potential for collision between vehicles accessing the site from the "retail and restaurant" uses to the east and vehicles accessing the Urgent Care facility from Highway 214 is "extremely high." The property abutting the subject site to the east (north of the existing Washington Mutual Bank) is currently vacant and no development is proposed at this time. Therefore, the establishment of a driveway cross-connection between the subject property and the properties to the east will have no immediate impact on vehicular safety on the subject property. An ambulance service, a Conditional Use in the CG zone, is not proposed in conjunction with this proposal. Further, it is the policy of ambulance services to deliver patients to full service emergency rooms rather than providing transportation to local Urgent Care facilities. Consequently, ambulance services arriving at the proposed Urgent Care facility will be providing non-emergency patient transportation services. It is expected that future vehicular traffic accessing the site from the property to the east will have a negligible impact on traffic generated by the proposed development. In addition, the 24-foot wide cross-access easement provided in Partition Case File No. 04-05 is located approximately 55 feet south of the proposed east/west drive aisle abutting the south side of the proposed ambulatory health center. Thus, the driveway cross-connection will have a 55-foot offset from the east/west ddve aisle abutting the south side of the ambulatory health center. This 55-foot offset will reduce the speed of future vehicular traffic using the cross-connection, thereby reducing the potential for collisions between vehicles accessing the site from the east and vehicles accessing the site from Highway 214. The cross- connection will allow users of the subject site to access businesses on adjacent properties without using Highway 214 where traffic volumes, congestion, rates of speed and the risk of collision are greater than in an off street parking area. The DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 18 applicant can further reduce traffiq.cellision potential within the off street parking area by installing traffic calming devices. The Woodbum Fire District and Oregon Department of Transportation state that they support the creation of a ddveway cross-connection between the subject property and the properties to the east in conjunction with this proposal. Development of this cross-connection will require the. elimination of several off street parking spaces. These displaced parking spaces can be relocated and provided elsewhere on the subject site. As a condition of approval, the applicant shall submit a revised site plan showing a driveway cross-connection with the properties to the east aligned with the 24-foot wide driveway cross-access easement provided in Partition Case File No. 04-05. Any parking spaces eliminated by creation of the cross-connection shall be replaced on-site. The shared and/or joint access agreement shall be subject to legal documentation, to the satisfaction of the City Attorney, establishing permanent use of the access prior to building permit issuance. The agreement shall be recorded with the County Recorder and filed with the Community Development Director. B. Driveway Spacing Guidelines, Type II and III Applications. The minimum separation of a driveway from: a) the special setback of a parallel major street, b) the right of way of a parallel local street, or c) from another driveway should be as follows. 1. Major Arterial Street: 300 feet; EXCEPT where pre-existing conditions preclude such separation the separation should be maximized. FINDING: Site access onto Mt. Hood Avenue is existing and no new accesses onto a public street are proposed. The driveway access onto Mt. Hood Avenue is located approximately 378 feet from the nearest driveway entrance to the east and approximately 525 feet from the nearest driveway entrance to the west, which meets the 300-foot minimum separation for driveway entrances accessing a Major Arterial. This criterion is met. Section 3.104.05 Driveway Dimension and Improvement Standards, Type I, II and III Applications. E. Commercial and Industrial Use. 1. Paved Two-way Driveway Width. With a turn lane: Throat width 36 feet minimum, 40 feet maximum. ("No Parking" restrictions shall be posted by the owner.) DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 19 FINDING: The submitted site plan shows the existing 42-foot wide driveway access onto Mt. Hood Avenue incorporating a turn lane. Mt. Hood Avenue is a state highway under the jurisdiction of the Oregon Department of Transportation (ODOT). Thus, a City access permit is not required and the City's access standards are not applicable to the existing driveway access. A referral has been sent to ODOT regarding this proposal. ODOT's Region 2 Representative commented that '...based on the plans available, [ODOT has] determined that no amended approach permit is necessary for the existing signalized intersection..." Throat length of a driveway, extending from the closest off street Parking or loading space to the outside edge of right of way for a: Major street connection: 50 feet minimum, with greater Improvement as may be required by a TIA. FINDING: The site plan shows off street parking located outside the 50-foot throat depth within the existing driveway access onto Mt. Hood Avenue. This criterion is met. Section 3.105 Off Street Parking and Loading Section 3.105.01 Applicability The provisions of this Section shall apply to the following types of development: B. Expansion or Change of Use. Any additional parking and/or loading required by the WDO to accommodate a change in use, or expansion of an existing use shall be subject to the following. Applications subject to Type II Design Review, Section 5.102.02, where the change or expansion increases the required area for parking, loading or landscaping by 25 percent or more, shall conform to all parking, loading and landscaping to the standards of the WDO. Parking, loading and landscaping required for changes or expansion of less than 25 percent shall be limited to those necessary to conform with the increment of change or expansion. FINDING: The applicant proposes to reduce the floor area of the existing structure by approximately 9% and the parking ratio for both the prior (retail sales) and proposed (ambulatory health services) site uses is the same (1 parking space per 250 square feet of gross floor area [sfgfa]). Because the DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 20 change in use does not increase the required number of parking spaces, improvements to parking and loading shall be limited to those necessary to conform with the increment of change. The applicant proposes to upgrade landscaping in buffer yards in the southern, eastern and northern portions of the site. Compliance with landscaping standards is discussed later in this report. Section 3.105.02 General Provisions for Off Street Parking and Loading E. Off Street Vehicle Parking Requirements. Off street vehicle parking spaces shall be provided in amounts not less than those set forth in Table 3.1.2. FINDING: The proposed ambulatory health center will require 338 parking spaces: I space per 250 square feet of gross floor area (84,607 sfgfa) for ambulatory health services. The submitted site plan shows a total of 338 spaces provided. This criterion is met. The number of disabled person vehicle parking spaces shall be provided to the standards of the state Building Code and applicable federal standards. The number of disabled person vehicle parking spaces shall be included as part of total required vehicle parking spaces. FINDING: Eight disabled person vehicle parking spaces are required per the Uniform Building Code for a parking lot containing 300 through 400 spaces. The applicant is proposing nine disabled vehicle parking spaces to meet this requirement. G. Off Street Loading Requirements. Off street loading spaces shall comply with the dimensional standards and amounts not less than those set forth in Table 3.1.3. The off street loading facilities shall be on the same lot, or site, as the use or structure they are Intended to serve.. Required loading spaces and required parking spaces shall be separate and distinct. FINDING: The 84,607 square foot building is required to have four loading spaces with a minimum 12-foot width, 30-foot depth and unobstructed vertical clearance of 14 feet. The submitted site plan shows four separate and distinct loading spaces and one passenger loading area. A 17-foot wide, 30-foot long loading space abuts the north side of the building. A 12-foot wide, 30-foot long loading space abuts the west side of the building. Two 12-foot wide, 30-foot long DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 21 loading spaces abut the truck docks located at the northeast corner of the building. A curved passenger loading area a maximum 20 feet wide and 130 feet long abuts the building to the south. The proposed loading spaces meet the 12- foot width and 30-foot length standards of Table 3.1.3. The submitted site plan shows bicycle racks located in the loading zone abutting the north side of the structure. As a condition of approval, the applicant shall submit a revised site plan showing bicycle racks relocated from the loading zone abutting the north side of the structure to within 50 feet of the main entrance on the south side of the existing building prior to building permit issuance. This criterion will be met. He On-site Vehicle Parking and Loading Area Improvement Requirements. Bumper Guards and Wheel Barriers. All vehicle parking spaces, EXCEPT those for single family and duplex dwellings, shall be constructed with bumper guards or wheel barriers that prevent vehicles from damaging structures or projecting over walkways, access ways or abutting property or rights of way. FINDING: The submitted site plan shows the 41 spaces abutting the proposed structure to be constructed with wheel barriers to prevent vehicles from damaging the structure or projecting over a walkway. This criterion is met. Size of Vehicular Parking Spaces and Maneuvering Areas within Off Street Parking Areas. Off street vehicle parking spaces and maneuvering areas, EXCEPT those for single family and duplex dwellings and those for disabled persons, within off street parking areas shall be designed in compliance with Table 3.1.4. Three or more off street parking spaces provided subject to Table 3.1.4 shall be designed so that no backing or maneuvering within a public street right of way is required. FINDING: The applicant proposes to relocate the 32 off street parking spaces on the north side of the structure to face toward the south and directly abut the structure. In addition, the submitted site plan shows the 9 disabled person parking spaces to be added as new spaces abutting the structure to the east and southwest. The disabled parking spaces are not subject to Table 3.1.4. The 32 realigned spaces to the north of the structure are standard parking spaces designed at a 90-degree angle with a minimum stall width of 9-feet, stall depth of 19 feet, and 2-way aisle width of 24 feet. These proposed dimensions meet the 9-foot stall width, 19-foot stall depth, and 24-foot 2-way aisle width requirements in Table 3.1.4. This approval criterion is met. DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 22 bm Off street parking for disabled persons shall be designed to the standards of the state Building Code and applicable federal standards. FINDING: The applicant is proposing 9 disabled person parking spaces. Compliance with the State and Federal design standards will be reviewed when the building permit is submitted. This criterion will be met. Directional Marking. EXCEPT for vehicle parking areas for single family and duplex dwellings, off street parking and maneuvering areas shall have directional markings and signs to control vehicle movement. FINDING: The submitted site plan shows 1-way and 2-way arrows on the pavement surface at the entrance and exit of 1-way and 2-way drive aisles. This criterion is met. Space Marking. EXCEPT for vehicle parking areas for single family and duplex dwellings, off street parking spaces shall be delineated by double parallel lines on each side of a space. The total width of the lines shall delineate a separation of 2 feet. FINDING: The submitted site plan indicates that all off street parking spaces will be re-striped with double parallel lines 2 feet in width that delineate each space. This approval criterion has been met. am Outdoor Lighting. EXCEPT for vehicle parking areas for single family and duplex dwellings, all outdoor lighting shall be designed so as not to shine or reflect into any adjacent residentially zoned or used property, and shall not cast a glare onto moving vehicles on any public street. FINDING: The submitted lighting plan shows outdoor lighting designed so as not to shine or reflect into the residentially zoned properties to the south and not to cast a glare onto moving vehicles on any public street. This approval criterion is met. Landscaping. EXCEPT for vehicle parking spaces for single family and duplex dwellings, all parking areas shall be landscaped to the standards of Section 3.106. FINDING: The applicant proposes to upgrade landscaping throughout the entire site. Compliance with landscaping requirements is discussed in Section 3.106 of this report. DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 23 10. On-site Bicycle Parking Requirements. All uses required to provide 10 or more off street parking spaces shall provide a bicycle rack within 50 feet of the main entrance. The number of required rack spaces shall be one plus one per ten vehicle parking spaces, with a maximum of 20 rack spaces. FINDING: The required off street parking for the site is 338 parking spaces, requiring 35, or a maximum of 20, bicycle rack spaces within 50 feet of the main entrance. The submitted site plan shows bicycle racks located with 50 feet of the primary and secondary pedestrian entrances. The applicant states that 20 bicycle parking spaces will be provided on the subject site. The submitted site plan shows bicycle racks located in the loading zone abutting the north side of the structure. As a condition of approval, the applicant shall submit a revised site plan showing bicycle racks relocated from the loading zone abutting the north side of the structure to within 50 feet of the main entrance on the south side of the existing building prior to building permit issuance. This criterion will be met. Section 3.106 Landscaping Standards Section 3.106.01 Applicability The provisions of this section shall apply: To the site area of the development, where the cumulative effect of additions to structures and/or parking areas Increases the total area covered by structure and parking by 50 percent or more than existed at the date of the WDO adoption. FINDING: The cumulative effect of the addition of 9 off street parking spaces and minor structural alterations does not increase the total area covered by building and parking by 50 percent. The applicant is proposing to upgrade landscaping for much of the site, which requires compliance with the requirements of Section 3.106 where new landscaping is proposed. Section 3.106.02 General Requirements A. Landscaping and Irrigation Plans Required. Building plans for all uses subject to landscaping requirements shall be accompanied by landscaping and irrigation plans to City standards. FINDING: The applicant has submitted a landscaping plan and as-built irrigation plan detailing irrigation for the southern portion of the site in conjunction with this proposal. A condition of approval requires the applicant to submit a final irrigation DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 24 plan showing irrigation for proposed landscaping elements abutting the north and northeast property lines to be reviewed and approved by the Community Development Department prior to issuance of the building permit, B. Irrigation. All required landscaped areas shall be permanently irrigated unless a planting plan without irrigation is submitted by a licensed landscape architect or a licensed nursery person demonstrating that the proposed landscaping will thrive without irrigation. FINDING: The applicant is proposing to irrigate the new landscaping. A condition of approval requires the applicant to submit a final irrigation plan showing irrigation for proposed landscaping elements abutting the north and northeast property lines to be reviewed and approved by the Community Development Department prior to issuance of the building permit. E. Maintenance. The property owner shall be responsible for maintaining all landscaping in good condition so as to present a healthy and orderly appearance. Unhealthy and dead plants shall be removed and replaced in conformance with the original landscape plan. FINDING: This requirement is a condition of approval for all landscaping located on the subject site. Section 3.106.03 Landscaping Standards A. Streetscape. Street Trees. Within the public street right of way abutting a development, or within an ally right of way in the DDC zone, street trees shall be planted to City standards prior to occupancy. Acceptable Types of Trees. See Section 6.103 for a description of acceptable and unacceptable trees for this purpose, classified by size and species. Tree Density. Trees shall be planted to the following intervals within the right of way, subject to Clear Vision Area standards, Section 3.103.10 and Section 6.103: 1) Four (4) small trees per 100 feet of street frontage; DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 25 2) Three (3) medium trees per 100 feet of street frontage; or 3) Two (2) large trees per 100 feet of street frontage. FINDING: The subject site has 537 feet of frontage abutting Mt Hood Avenue and currently incorporates 10 Red Maples (Acer rubrum), classified as a "large tree" according to Section 6.103. This meets the requirement for 2 large trees per 100 feet of street frontage. The applicant proposes to use the existing street trees to fulfill the above requirement. This criterion is met. 2. Front Yard and Yard Abutting a Street. b. Landscaping Design and Density in CO and CG zones. 1) All yards abutting a street, Including off street parking and circulation areas shall be landscaped to a density of one (1) plant unit (PU) per 20 sq. ft. FINDING: The submitted landscaping plan shows the yard abutting Mt. Hood Avenue to be landscaped at densities ranging between1.64 and 1.8 PUl20 sq. ft. This cfitedon is met. 2) Ail parking areas abutting a street shall provide a 42 inch vertical visual screen from the abutting street grade. Acceptable design techniques to provide the screening Include plant materials; berms; freestanding, architectural walls with anti-graffiti finish, depressed grade for the parking area. Ail screening shall comply with the clear vision standards, Section 3.103.10. FINDING: The existing landscape strip abutting Mt. Hood Avenue along the south property line incorporates a 24-inch high berm feature. The submitted landscaping plan shows a hedge of Green Island Holly (Ilex crenata "Green Island") to be planted atop the existing 24-inch berm. Green Island Holly grows to a height of 2 feet (24-inches) and is classified as a 'small" or "medium" shrub according Table 3.1.5, The combined 48-inch screen height (24-inch berm and 24-inch hedge) meets the requirement for a 42-inch vertical screen between Mt. Hood Avenue and the off street parking area located on the subject property. This criterion is met. B. Buffer Yards. All buffer yards shall be landscaped at the rate of one (1) plant unit PU per 20 sq. ft. EXCEPT for interior buffer yards abutting a wall DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 26 which are paved and which may be used for parking or site access and vehicular circulation. FINDING: The applicant proposes to upgrade landscape elements in the north, northeast, east, south and southwest buffer yards. According to the submitted landscaping plan, planting densities in these buffer yards range between 1.21 PUl20 sq. ft. and 1.41 PUl20 sq. ft. This criterion is met. C. Off Street Parking Areas. All unpaved land within the off street parking area, and within 20 feet of the paved edge of off street parking and/or circulation improvements, shall be landscaped in the following proportions: am RM, CO and CG zones: Landscaped area(s) equivalent to 20% of the paved surface area for off street parking and circulation. FINDING: According to the submitted landscaping plan, the existing and proposed landscaping will cover an equivalent of 24.6% of all paved areas. This approval criterion is met. e The density of landscaping required in and adjacent to off street parking and circulation facilities, EXCLUDING required trees, shall be one (1) plant unit per 20 square feet. FINDING: The submitted landscaping plan shows yards to be landscaped at densities ranging between 1.07 PUl20 square feet and 4.9 PUl20 square feet excluding required trees where landscaping is proposed abutting off street parking and circulation facilities to the north, south and east of the existing structure. This criterion is met. Trees, Section 6.103, shall be planted within and abutting off street parking facilities in a pattern that is in roughly proportion to the distribution of the parking spaces, at the following densities: a, 1 small tree per 5 parking spaces; b. 1 medium tree per 10 parking spaces; or c. 1 large tree per 14 parking spaces. FINDING: Required parking for the site is 338 spaces, necessitating the planting of 68 small trees, 34 medium trees, 24 large trees, or some combination thereof. DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 27 The applicant proposes to plant 46 large trees abutting the off street parking area including 30 Village Green Zelkova (Zelkova serrata 'Village Green') and 16 True Shade Honeylocust (Gleditsia triacanthos 'True Shade') abutting off street parking and cimulation areas to meet the requirement of I large tree per 14 parking spaces. In addition, 16 existing Sycamore Maples (Acer platanoides), classified as a large tree in Section 6.103, will be retained on the property abutting off street parking to the south, southwest and east. This criterion is met. 3.106.05 Planting Standards A. Distribution of Plant Materials. The required number of plant units shall be met by a combination of plant materials listed in Table 3.1.5, so that eighty (80) percent of the area to be landscaped is covered within three years. Required plant units need not be allocated uniformly through out specified landscaping areas, but may be grouped for visual effect. FINDING: A condition of approval is that all shrubs and ground cover shall be of a size upon installation so as to attain 80% of ground coverage within 3 years. B. Ground Cover. Landscaped areas that are not covered by plant materials shall be covered by a layer of bark mulch or decorative rock, EXCLUDING ordinary crushed gravel, a minimum of 2 Inches in depth. FINDING: The applicant has indicated that all landscape areas not covered by plant materials will be covered by a 2-inch layer of bark mulch. This criterion is met. C. Curbs. A six-inch concrete curb shall be provided between a landscaped area and a parking area or access way. FINDING: The submitted site plan shows a 6-inch concrete curb between the parking spaces,, landscaped areas and circulation areas on the site. This approval criterion is met. Section 3.107 Architectural Design Guidelines and Standards Section 3.107.06 Guidelines and Standards for Structures in RS, R1S, RM, CO, CG and PISP Zones Non-Residential A. Applicability. DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 28 The following design guidelines shall be applicable to all non- residential structures and buildings in the RS, R1S, RM, CO, CG and P zones. FINDING: The proposed office building is a non-residential structure proposed within the CG' zone, and is subject to the architectural design guidelines of Section 3.107.06. B. Architectural Design Guidelines. 1. Mass & Bulk Articulation Guidelines. ae Building facades visible from streets and public parking areas should be articulated in order to avoid the appearance of box41ke structures with unbroken wall surfaces. The appearance of exterior walls should be enhanced by incorporating three dimensional design features, including the following: 1) Public doorways and/or passage ways through the building. 2) Wall offsets and/or projections. 3) Variation in building materials and/or textures. 4) Arcades, awnings, canopies and/or porches. FINDING: The southem facade of the existing structure is visible from Mt Hood Avenue and the abutting public parking area. The existing building features a painted split-face CMU fac~ade with a smooth CMU accent band and metal roofing system adjacent to the primary pedestrian entrance. The applicant proposes to break-up the existing box-like southern building face with the addition of a curved entrance fac~ade bisected by a glass and wood canopy feature above the primary pedestrian entrance and proposed individual tenant space entrances. The submitted floor plan shows the entrance fac~ade to be offset from the structural building walls by 10 to 24 feet. The applicant states the intent of this design is to create "...transitional indoor/outdoor spaces..." The parapet of the proposed curved entrance fagade will rise 6 feet above the existing roofline and provide 3-dimensionality to the currently fiat southern building wall. The submitted elevation and floor plans show the glass and wood entrance canopy to be set below and extending laterally outward 22 to 26 feet from the plane of the proposed curved entrance fa(;ade and the existing CMU DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 29 structural wall. The proposed curved facade will feature stucco with stone wainscot while the entrance canopy will be composed of glazing and exposed wood structure. In addition, the applicant proposes decorative fountain features and stone "garden" walls along the southern building fac~ade. This proposed variation in building materials will effectively minimize the current predominant CMU wall surfaces, This criterion is met. 2. Materials and Textures Guidelines. Building exteriors should exhibit finishes and textures that reduce the visual monotony of bulky structures and large structural spaces; enhance visual interest of wall surfaces and harmonize with the structural design. bm The appearance of exterior surfaces should be enhanced by Incorporating the following: 1) At least 30% of the wall surface abutting a street should be glass. 2) All walls visible from a street or public parking area should be surfaced with wood, brick, stone, designer block, or stucco or with siding that has the appearance of wood lap siding. 3) The use of plain concrete, plain concrete block, corrugated metal, plywood, T-tll and sheet composite siding as exterior finish materials for walls visible from a street or parking area should be avoided. 4) The color of at least 90 percent of the wall, roof and awning surface visible from a street or public parking area should be an "earth tone" color containing 10 parts or more of brown or a "tinted" color containing t0 parts or more white. Fluorescent, "day-glo," or any similar bright color should not be used on the building exterior. FINDING: The proposed curved facxade structure and existing building walls, comprising the bulk of the wall area visible from a public street or parking area, will feature stucco with stone accents and painted existing CMU wall surfaces. In addition, a glass and wood canopy is proposed above the primary pedestrian entrance and a decorative fountain feature with stone "garden" walls will be located at the southeast corner of the building facade. This proposed variation in building materials will effectively vary and minimize the current predominant CMU DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 30 wall surface. Proposed coloration of the primary wall surfaces, entrance canopy, covered walk, cap flashing and storefront system, comprising the bulk of the visible area, incorporates colors including "Earth Red", "Taupe-Cream", "White", "Aluminum' and natural wood tones. The shades "Earth Red", "Taupe-Cream", "White", "Aluminum' and natural wood coloration may all be considered "earth tones' and "Tinted tones' in accordance with the above requirement. The proposed colors and materials are represented on the colored building elevation and materials sample board submitted in conjunction with this application. The submitted elevations show the wall surface of the proposed ambulatory health center to be comprised of 21% glass abutting Mt Hood Avenue, which does not meet the guideline of 30% glazing for a wall surface facing a street. The south fac~ade of the existing structure currently incorporates 8% glazing. The proposed curved entry incorporates a parapet rising 6 feet above the plane of the existing roofline, which significantly increases the vertical wall area of the southem building facxade. The proposed parapet breaks up the current flat roofline and will be used to screen roof-mounted equipment. It is not feasible to incorporate additional windows in the proposed curved entry. In addition, the existing CMU building shell forming the southern building far,.ade is a structural wall, which currently has minimal window area. The applicant proposes to significantly increase the percentage of window area incorporated in the wall surface facing Mt. Hood Avenue from 8% to 21% while taking into account the architectural utility of the curved entry parapet and the existing structural wall. This approval criterion is met. 3. Multi-planed Roof Guidelines. The roof line at the top of a structure should establish a distinctive top to the building. bm The roof line should not be fiat or hold the same roof line over extended distances. Rather the roof line should Incorporate variations, such as: 1) Offsets and/or jogs in the plane of the roof. FINDING: The proposed curved entry feature will establish a distinctive "top' to the existing fiat roofline. The submitted elevations show a 6-foot offset in the primary roofline. These approval criteria are met. Roof Mounted Equipment Guidelines. All roof mounted equipment, EXCEPT solar collectors, should be screened from view from streets abutting the building site by: Locating roof mounted equipment below the highest vertical element of the building; or DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 31 Screening roof top equipment using materials of the same character as the structure's basic materials. FINDING: The submitted elevations do not show any roof-mounted equipment atop the proposed structure. The applicant has indicated that the 6-foot curved entry parapet will be used to screen roof-mounted equipment. This criterion will be met. Weather Protection Guidelines. All building faces abutting a street or a public parking area should provide weather protection for pedestrians. Features to provide this protection should include: ae A continuous walkway at least 8 feet wide along the face of the building utilizing a roof overhang, arcade, awnings and/or canopies. Awnings and canopies that incorporate the following design features: 1) Angled or curved surfaces facing a street or parking area. 2) A covering of canvas, treated canvas, awning fabric, or matte finish vinyl. 3) A constant color and pattern scheme for all buildings within the same development. 4) No internal back lighting. FINDING: The site plan shows a continuous walkway abutting south and east building frontages that varies between 8 feet and 30 feet in width. The submitted floor plan shows the primary pedestrian entrance on the southern fa(;ade to provide weather protection via a minimum 24-foot, maximum 26-foot wide wood and glass entry canopy. The proposed pedestrian entrance and Urgent Care drop-off on the eastern building facade feature a 9§0 square foot covered walk and 1,128 square foot drive-up canopy respectively. These approval criteria are met. Em Landscaping and Screening Guidelines. The landscaping required by the standards of the WDO should be augmented to address site specific visual Impacts of abutting uses and the visual character of the surrounding area. DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 32 FINDING: Landscaping is proposed abutting the southern, eastern and southwestern building frontages. A Roundleaf laurustinus (Viburnum tinus Robustum') hedge is proposed abutting the north property line. Roundleaf laurustinus may grow to a height of 6 to 12 feet and will effectively obscure visibility of the site from the adjacent industrial uses. A hedge of Green Island Holly (Ilex crenata "Green Island") is proposed along the northeast property line. A condition of approval requires the applicant to replace the lower growing Green Island Holly with Roundleaf laurustinus along the northeast property line to screen the site from the abutting industrial use to the northeast. This criterion will be met. Design Character Guidelines. Standardized or characteristic "corporate" and "franchise" design elements Should be refined to reduce domination of the visual environment by corporate Icons. FINDING: Excluding proposed signage, the submitted site and elevation plans do not show any proposed "corporate" or "franchise" icons on the subject site. This criterion is met. Buffer Wall. A solid brick or architectural wall with anti-graffiti surface, no less than 6 feet or greater than 7 feet in height: ao Should be constructed on the perimeter property line of non-residential development to mitigate adverse visual, noise and/or light Impacts on the abutting use when no comparable buffer exista, and Shall be constructed where the standards of the underlying zone require such a wall for a non-residential use in, or abutting, a RS, RlS, or RM zoning district. FINDING: Per Table 2.1.11., there exists no buffer yard landscaping requirement along the northern, eastern and western perimeter of the subject property as the abutting lots are zoned CG and IP. A wall is not necessary on the north, east and west property lines of the subject site because the abutting commercial and industrial uses are compatible with the proposed commercial-institutional use. A proposed Roundleaf laurustinus (Viburnum tinus ~obustum') hedge will abut the north property line to obscure visibility of the site from the adjacent industrial uses. This approval criterion is met. Sidewalk Location and .Street Trees. Sidewalks should be located at the property line along streets with street trees, Section 3.106. DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 33 FINDING: The submitted site and landscaping plans show existing curb line sidewalk and street trees abutting Mt. Hood Avenue. Compliance with street tree standards is discussed in Section 3.~08.03.A.~. of this report. 10. Solar Access Protection. Obstruction of existing solar collectors on abutting properties by site development should be mitigated. FINDING: The proposed building will not obstruct solar collectors located on abutting properties. This approval criterion is met. C. Site and Building Access Guidelines. Access to and from the site and circulation within the site should separate facilities for cars, trucks and transit from those for bicycles and pedestrians. Site access in compliance with Section 3.104 should be augmented by the following considerations: a. Vehicle Access. Vehicle access points should be identified by accentuated landscaped areas, by entrance throats designed to control access from abutting parking and by monument type entrance signs. 2) New parking lots abutting major streets should connect internally with the parking lots of abutting commercial uses or land zoned for commercial use. FINDING: The submitted landscaping plan shows accent landscaping provided at the existing ddveway entrance onto Mt. Hood Avenue and the driveway cross- connection with the property to the west. The property abuts Mt. Hood Avenue, classified as a major arterial on the Woodbum TSP, on the north. Commercial uses abut the subject property to the west (a Pizza Hut restaurant, bank and undeveloped parcel zoned CG) and east (a bank and undeveloped parcel zoned CG). The abutting parcels to the east and west have accesses to Mt. Hood Ave and the subject property has an existing shared access agreement with the property to the west. A condition of approval requires the applicant to submit a revised site plan showing a driveway cross-connection with the properties to the east aligned with the 24-foot wide driveway cross-access easement provided in Partition Case File No. 04-05. Compliance with WDO cross-connection standards is discussed in Section 3.104.03.A.3 of this report. b. Pedestrian Access and Circulation. DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 34 1) The buildings should be linked to the sidewalks on abutting streets by internal pedestrian ways. Such pedestrian ways should be either raised or delineated by distinctive pavers. FINDING: The site plan shows proposed pedestrian access to the proposed from the south via a 4-foot wide walkway abutting the east margin of the primary driveway entrance. Where pedestrian ways cross internal drive aisles, they are shown on the site plan to be delineated with pavers. In addition, distinctive pavers delineate the passenger loading area to the south of the structure. The site plan does not show this proposed pedestrian walkway as connecting to the existing curb line sidewalk abutting Mt. Hood Avenue. As a condition of approval, the applicant shall submit a revised site plan to the Community Development 'Department for review and approval showing the proposed 4-foot wide pedestrian walkway abutting the east margin of the primary driveway entrance as connecting to the existing curb line sidewalk abutting Mt. Hood Avenue prior to building permit issuance. This criterion will be met. 2) Parking areas should be designed in multiples of no more than 50 spaces separated by landscaped buffers or raised pedestrian ways in order to minimize negative visual Impacts associated with expansive parking. FINDING: The proposed parking area incorporates multiples of 50 or more parking spaces that are not separated by landscaped areas. The off street parking area is existing, and is not being expanded. The applicant proposes to make incremental improvements proportional to the proposed change in use including the addition of landscape islands and resurfacing and re-striping of parking spaces. The applicant will not be required to realign the existing off street parking area to separate multiples of 50 parking spaces with landscape buffers in conjunction with this proposal. This criterion is met. D. Building Location Guidelines. Within the prescribed setbacks, building location and orientation should compliment abutting uses and development patterns. FINDING: Compliance of the building location within the required setbacks is discussed eadier in this report Section 2.106.05. C. The proposed changes to the existing building facade incorporate architectural elements, materials and coloration complementary to nearby residential developments. This criterion is met. E. Parking Location Guidelines. DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 35 Off street parking between the architectural front of a building and the setback line abutting a street should be limited to a depth of not more than 130 feet. FINDING: The depth of the off street parking area abutting Mt. Hood Avenue is approximately 280 feet, which exceeds the 130-foot off street parking area depth guideline. The site was developed prior to the July 1, 2002 effective date of the WDO and the off street parking area is not being expanded. The applicant proposes to make incremental improvements proportional to the proposed change in use including the addition of landscape islands and resurfacing and re- striping of parking spaces. The applicant is not required to realign the existing off street area to meet the 130-foot off street parking area depth guideline in conjunction with this proposal. These criteria are met. F. Design Standards. Outdoor Storage Standards. Outdoor storage, when permitted, shaft be screened from the view of abutting streets by a solid brick or architectural block wall not less than 6, nor more than ? feet in height. 2. Outdoor Lighting Standards. All outdoor lighting shaft be designed so that: a. Parking areas are evenly illuminated at ground level at one foot candle; b. Entrance and loading areas are illuminated at ground level of two foot candles; c. Illumination does not shine or reflect into any adjacent residentially zoned or used property; d. Lighting does not cast a glare onto moving vehicles on any public street. FINDING: Outdoor storage is not proposed on the subject site. The applicant has submitted a lighting plan showing photometric values within the primary off street parking and pedestrian entrance areas to the south of the structure. The lighting plan shows photometric values ranging between 1.0 and 1.6-foot candles near the primary pedestrian entrance, which does not meet the required illumination level of 2-foot candles at pedestrian entrances. Photometric values within the off street parking area range between 1.0 and 9.0 foot candles, which meets the required illumination level of 1-foot candle within an off street parking area. A condition of approval requires the applicant to submit a revised lighting plan to DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 36 the Community Development Department for review and approval prior to building permit issuance showing compliance with Section 3.107.06.P.2 in all off street parking, loading and pedestrian entrance areas. This approval criterion will be met. Section 3.110 Signs Section 3.110.04 Sign Permit Required A sign permit is required to erect, replace, construct, relocate, or alter a sign, unless such sign or action is exempt under Section 3.110.11... FINDING: The submitted site plan shows three wall signs on the southern building fac,.ade and one canopy sign. These signs are subject to sign permit approval in accordance with the applicable criteria of Section 3.110. Section 3.110.t 6 Permitted Signs - Commercial General District (CG) Signs in the CG district shall be subject to the following provisions and all other applicable provisions of Section 3.1fO of the WDO. A. Pole Signs. 2. Complex. Cm A pole sign on a street with 300 lineal feet or more but less than 600 lineal feet of frontage shall not exceed 18 feet in height and 75 square feet in area. FINDING: The subject site is proposed as a complex and has an existing 537 lineal feet of street frontage. An existing pole sign is located on the subject site measuring approximately 32 feet in height and 100 square feet in area, which does not meet the requirement for a maximum 18-foot tall 75 square foot pole sign at a complex in the CG zone with a street frontage between 300 and 600 lineal feet. This sign is nonconforming and is therefore subject to Section 3.1 fO. 20, discussed later in this report. C. Wall Signs. Wall signs are permitted on a primary building frontage. Such signs shall not cover more than six percent of the building wall on a single tenant building or each tenant's leased wall on a multiple tenant building and shall not exceed a maximum area of 200 square feet. However, a minimum sign area of 20 square' feet shall be permitted for each single tenant building or tenant DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 37 in a multiple tenant building. Only one building wall shall be designated as the primary building frontage. FINDING: The modified primary building frontage will have a wall area of 10,051 square feet, 6 percent of which is 603 square feet. The submitted elevation plan shows three proposed wall signs on the primary building frontage; one 135 square foot wall sign in the upper center of the curved entrance wall, one 36 square foot wall sign at the west end of the southern building fa~de, and one 14 square foot sign on the window of a proposed tenant space adjacent to the pdmary pedestrian entrance. The combined square footage of these proposed wall signs is 186 square feet, which meets the maximum 200 square foot area allowed for wall signs on a pdmary building frontage. As a condition of approval, all proposed signage shall be subject to the applicable provisions of Sect/on 3.110. This criterion will be met. e Wall signs are permitted on canopies. Such signs shall be limited to no more than two sides of the canopy and shall not cover more than 15 percent of a canopy face or 50 square feet, whichever is less. FINDING: The submitted elevation plan shows a canopy sign located on the south face of the proposed drive-thru canopy on the east side of the structure. The wall area of the south face of the proposed canopy is 156 square feet, 15 percent of which is 23.4 square feet. The proposed canopy sign is approximately 46 square feet in area, which does not meet the maximum 15 percent (23.4 square foot) allowed area for a canopy sign. As a condition of approval, all proposed signage shall be subject to the applicable provisions of Section 3.110. This criterion will be met. Section 3.110.20 Nonconforming Signs. Nonconforming permanent signs shall comply with the provisions of Section 3.110 when one or more of the following happens: The use of the premises upon which the sign is located changes. In a complex, if the use of an individual tenant space changes, only signs attached to such tenant space shall be required to comply with Sect/on 3.110. A Type II Design Review or Type III Conditional Use or Design Review land use application is approved for the premises on which the sign is located. In a complex, if an Individual tenant space is the subject of a Type II Design Review or Type III Conditional Use or Design Review land use application, only signs attached to such tenant space shall be required to comply with the provisions of Section 3.110. DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 38 FINDING: An existing pole sign is located adjacent to the southern driveway entrance on the subject site. This pole sign measures approximately 32 feet in height and 100 square feet in area, which does not meet the requirement for a maximum 18-foot tall 75 square foot pole sign at a complex in the CG zone with a street frontage between 300 and 600 lineal feet. The applicant proposes a change in use from retail to ambulatory health services, and has submitted a Type II Design Review land use application to retrofit and upgrade the building facr3de and site elements. The applicant is therefore required to bring the nonconforming pole sign into conformance with the applicable criteria of Sect/on 3.110. As a condition of approval, the applicant shall submit plans to bring the existing nonconforming pole sign into compliance with the applicable provisions of Sect/on 3.110 prior to issuance of a building permit. Section 5.102.02 Design Review for All Structures LESS THAN t 000 Sq. Ft. Criteria. The applicable guidelines and standards of Sect/on 3.1 shall apply and other applicable sections of the WDO. FINDING: The compliance of the applicant's proposal with the applicable standards and guidelines of the WDO is discussed throughout this report. This approval criterion is met. Variance 05-05: The applicant is requesting a variance to allow for 43 parking spaces to remain in the 65-foot special setback .abutting Mt. Hood Avenue. WOODBURN DEVELOPMENT ORDINANCE Section 5.103.11 Variance Criteria. A determination of whether the criteria set forth are satisfied necessarily involves the balancing of competing and conflicting interest. The factors that are listed to be considered are not criteria and are not intended to be an exclusive list. The factors to be considered are used as a guide in deliberations on the application. FINDING: Sufficient justification to approve Variance 05-05 has been provided based on the analysis of the following considerations: The variance is necessary to prevent unne~:essary hardship relating to the land or structure which would cause the property to be unbuildable by application of the WDO. Factors to consider in determining whether hardship exists, include: DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 39 Physical circumstances over which the applicant has no control related to the piece of property involved that distinguish it from other land in the zone, including but not limited to lot size, shape, and topography. bJ Whether reasonable use similar to other properties can be made of the property without the variance. Whether the hardship was created by the person requesting the variance. FINDING: The applicant states the following: "The variance is necessary to allow existing non-conforming parking to remain in the required...front...yard setback. Elimination of the 43 parking spaces within the front setback is undesirable from an operational standpoint. The existing non-conforming parking areas [SIC] is a condition created prior to the property purchase by Webstar V, LLC.' The combined front yard and special setback for the site is 65 feet (50-foot special setback and 15-foot required front yard setback) abutting Mt. Hood Avenue and the submitted site plan shows 43 existing parking spaces currently located in the 15-foot front yard setback. The 43 non-conforming parking spaces are existing and the applicant is not required to meet all off street parking and loading standards in conjunction with this Type II Design Review because the proposed change in use does not increase the required parking for the site by 25% or more. The 43 non-conforming parking spaces cannot be provided elsewhere on the site and the removal of 43 parking spaces is not proportional to the impact of the change in use of the existing structure from a retail center to an ambulatory health services center, which have the same parking requirement. Mt. Hood Avenue is a state highway under the jurisdiction of the Oregon Department of Transportation (ODOT). Comments received from ODOT regarding this proposal do not require the applicant to provide improvements to the existing Mt. Hood Avenue right of way in conjunction with this proposal. The applicant has shown on the submitted site and landscaping plans that the required street improvement of Mt. Hood Avenue, including curb line sidewalks, landscape strip and street trees are currently provided within the existing right of way abutting the southern property line. This hardship was not created by the person requesting the variance. e Development consistent with the request will not be materially injurious to adjacent properties. Factors to be considered in determining whether development consistent with the variance is materially injurious Include but are not limited to: DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 40 Physical impacts such development will have because of the variance, such as visual, noise, traffic and drainage, erosion and landslide hazards. Incremental Impacts occurring as a result of the proposed variance. FINDING: The applicant states: 'The existing non-conforming parking areas are currently screened, and will be further screened by proposed landscape materials along the property line on Mt. Hood Avenue. No changes in this design or way the existing parking areas are used are contemplated." Mt. Hood Avenue is a state highway under the jurisdiction of the Oregon Department of Transportation (ODOT) and comments received from ODOT regarding this proposal do not require the applicant to provide improvements to the existing Mt. Hood Avenue right of way in conjunction with this proposal. The existing landscape strip abutting Mt. Hood Avenue along the south property line incorporates a 24-inch high berm feature and the applicant has submitted a landscaping plan showing a hedge of Green Island Holly (Ilex crenata "Green Island") to be planted atop the existing 24-inch berm. Green Island Holly grows to a height of 2 feet in height and the combined 48-inch screen height (24-inch berm and 24-inch hedge) meets the off street parking screening requirement of Section 3.106.03.A.2.b. 2). No physical or incremental impacts will result from the granting of this variance. Existing physical and natural systems, such as but not limited to traffic, drainage, dramatic land forms or parks will not be adversely affected because of the variance. FINDING: The site is currently developed as a retail center with existing structures, off street parking and landscaping. Traffic, drainage, landforms and natural systems will not be adversely affected by granting this variance. e The variance is the minimum deviation necessary to make reasonable economic use of the property; FINDING: The applicant indicates that allowing the 43 existing off street parking spaces to remain in the 65-foot special setback abutting Mt. Hood Avenue is the minimum deviation necessary to make reasonable economic use of the property. The 43 non-conforming parking spaces are existing and cannot be provided elsewhere on the site. The applicant is not required to meet all off street parking and loading standards in conjunction with this Type II Design Review because the proposed change in use does not increase the required parking for the site by 25% or more. Removal of 43 parking spaces is not proportional to the impact of DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 41 VI. the change in use of the existing structure from a retail center to an ambulatory health services center, which have the same parking requirement. The applicant has shown on the submitted site and landscaping plans that the required street improvement of Mt. Hood Avenue, including curb line sidewalks, landscape strip and street trees are currently provided within the existing right of way abutting the southern property line. 5. The variance does not conflict with the Woodbum Comprehensive Plan. FINDING: The Woodbum Development Ordinance and Transportation System Plan implement the goals and policies in the Woodbum Comprehensive Plan (WCP). WCP Sect/on IX Goals and Policies states, '...Architectural design of commercial areas should be attractive with...enough landscaping to reduce the visual impact of large expanses of asphalt parking areas.' The applicant requests variance approval to allow the 43 existing off street parking spaces located in the 65-foot combined special and required front yard abutting Mt. Hood Avenue to remain. The proposed 24-inch hedge of Green Island Holly (Ilex crenata "Green Island") to be planted atop the existing 24-inch berm separating the off street parking area from Mt. Hood Avenue will effectively mitigate any visual impact associated with granting of this variance. The proposed development does not conflict with the policies of the WCP. CONCLUSION: Based on the information in this report, the information provided by the applicant and the applicable review criteria, findings required to approve Design Review 05-01 and Variance 05-05 can be made. DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 42 EXHIBIT "B" CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT: Design Review 05'0t: 1. The proposed development shall be in substantial conformance with the attached preliminary plans provided in Exhibit "A" (Site Plan [Sheet A1.1], Floor Plan [Sheet A2.1], Building Elevations [Sheet A3.1], Grading/Utility Plan [Sheet C1 and Lighting Plan [Sheet El.0] date stamped. April 8, 2005; Landscaping Plan [Sheets L2.1 and 'L2.2] and Materials Plan [Sheets L1.1 and L1.2] date stamped April 20, 2005; and Colored Elevation and Materials Sample Board date stamped February 1, 2005); except as herein 'modified by these conditions of approval. The property owner/applicant shall submit to the Community Development Department a signed "Acceptance of Conditions" agreeing to all conditions of approval prior to the issuance of building permits for the project. This approval shall expire within the time period specified by City ordinance (currently one year from the date of the final decision). Expiration of a final decision shall require a new application. The applicant shall request building permit occupancy review by the Community Development Department a minimum of seven days pdor to the issuance of final occupancy. Any conditions attached to this design review approval shall be conditions on the issuance of a building permit unless otherwise stated. A violation of the conditions shall be considered a violation of the Woodbum Development Ordinance. Prior to building permit issuance, the applicant shall submit a revised site plan to the Community Development Department for review and approval showing the following modifications: ao The drive-through and bypass lane pertaining to the proposed Urgent Care patient drop-off area shall be modified to comply with WDO Section 3.104.02.D. The proposed 4-foot wide pedestrian walkway abutting the east margin of the primary driveway entrance shall be modified to connect to the existing curb line sidewalk abutting Mt. Hood Avenue. DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 43 A driveway cross-connection shall be provided with the properties to the east aligned with the 24-foot wide driveway cross-access easement provided in Partition Case File No. 04-05, Any parking spaces eliminated by creation of the cross-connection shall be replaced on-site. Bicycle racks shall be relocated from the loading zone abutting the north side of the structure to within 50 feet of the main entrance on the south side of the existing building. Prior to building permit issuance, the applicant shall submit a final irrigation plan to the Community Development Department for review and approval. 8. All shrubs and ground cover shall be of a size upon installation so as to attain 80% of ground coverage within 3 years. m Prior to issuance of a building permit, the applicant shall submit an elevation plan of the proposed common refuse collection facility with a solid metal gate to the Community Development Department for review and approval. 10. Prior to issuance of a building permit, the applicant shall submit a final lighting plan to the Community Development Department for review and approval showing compliance with Sect/on 3.107.06.F.2 in all off street parking, loading and pedestrian entrance areas. 11. Prior to issuance of a building permit, the applicant shall submit a revised landscaping plan showing a Roundleaf laurustinus hedge along the northeast property line to the Community Development Department for review and approval. 12.The property owner shall be responsible for maintaining all landscaping in good condition so as to present a healthy and orderly appearance. Unhealthy and dead plants shall be removed and replaced in conformance with the approved landscaping plan, 13. Placement of all signage shall be subject to the standards of Sect/on 3.110. 14. Prior to building occupancy, the applicant shall bring the existing nonconforming pole sign into compliance with the applicable provisions of Sect/on 3.110. 15. Prior to building permit issuance, proposed shared access easement agreements shall be submitted to the Community Development DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 44 Department for review and approval subject to legal documentation to the satisfaction of the City Attorney. Said agreements shall be recorded with the County Recorder. Variance 05-05: 6.This variance approval allows parking spaces abutting the south property line to remain in the special setback from the centerline of Mt. Hood Avenue and required front yard setback as shown on Exhibit 'A" (Site plan [Sheet A1.1 date stamped April 8, 2005]). This variance shall not apply to any subsequent development of the subject property. PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT: GENERAL CONDITIONS: 17.The applicant, not the City, is responsible for obtaining permits from any state and/or federal agencies, which may require approval and/or permit. 18. AII work within the public rights-of-way or public facilities within public easement shall require plan approval and permit issuance from the Public Works Department. 19. System Development fees shall be reviewed for the change and increase of use. If appropriate, additional fees shall be paid at the time of building permit issuance. SANITARY SEWER: 20.A Grease trap will be required to be installed on the sanitary service, either as a central unit or in each kitchen/food preparation area. Contact Marion County Plumbing Department for permit and installation requirements at (503) 588-5147. WATER: 21.The current level of backflow protection, double detector check device, on the fire sprinkler service and reduced pressure device on domestic service is adequate for the proposed use. The landscape irrigation meter shall be upgraded with double detector check backfiow device at the meter. Contact Larry Arendt, City of Woodbum Cross Connection Inspector, for installation requirements at 503-982-5283. 22.The relocation of the existing fire hydrant as identified on the plan shall be relocated by the property owner/applicant in accordance with city standards and specifications. A utility easement shall be provided to the DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 45 city for the relocated hydrant if it is not within the existing easement currently conveyed to the City. DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 46 U. AI Ili, Jl( --I~" II. III. CITY OF WOODBURN, OREGON PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT April 28, 2005 DESIGN REVIEW 05-01 VARIANCE 05-05 APPLICANT INFORMATION Applicant: Matthew Spicer 333 NW 5th Avenue Portland, OR 97209 Property Owner: Webstar V. LLC Attn: Robert Engle 610 Glatt Circle Woodburn, OR 97071 Application Deemed Complete: 120-Day Rule Deadline: March 9, 2005 July 7, 2005 NATURE OF APPLICATION: The applicant requests administrative (Type II) design review approval to retrofit and upgrade the building fac~ade and site elements at the existing structure located at 1475 Mt. Hood Avenue for use as an outpatient health service and wellness center, and variance approval to allow 43 existing parking spaces to remain in the required front yard setback. The applicant also proposes to remove the existing 3,565 square foot Garden Shop on the eastern building frontage and add a 960 square foot covered walk and 1,128 square foot drive-through canopy in its place, and to create two interior garden atdums (1,728 and 2,720 square feet respectively). RELEVANT FACTS: The site is approximately 7.05-acres in area and can be identified specifically on Madon County Assessor's Maps as Township 5 South, Range 1 West, Section 08B, Tax Lot # 2800. The site is currently developed as a big box retail center (formerly K-Mart) with existing structures, off street parking and landscaping. The property is zoned Commercial General (CG) and designated Commercial on the Comprehensive Plan Map. Properties to the north, northeast and northwest are zoned Industrial Park (IP) and designated Industrial on the Comprehensive Plan Map. Properties located to the south (across Mt. Hood Avenue) are zoned CG and Single-Family Residential (RS) and designated Commercial and Residential Less Than 12 Units per Acre on the Comprehensive Plan Map. Properties to the east and west are zoned CG and designated Commercial on the Comprehensive Plan Map. The industrial properties to the north, northeast and northwest are used as a DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page I IV. manufactured home storage site, truck chassis manufacturing facility and self- storage business respectively. Properties to the south (across Mt. Hood Avenue) are currently occupied by a house of worship and an integrated business center. The commercial properties to the east are developed as an implement rental service and a Washington Mutual Bank. The commercial properties to the west are vacant and the location of a Pizza Hut Restaurant. No significant wetlands are located on the subject property, and the site is located outside of the 500- year floodplain. Previous land use decisions exist for the site. On November 28, 1990, the Woodbum City Council approved Ordinance No. 2050 allowing a Comprehensive Plan Map Amendment and Zone Map Amendment from Industrial Park (IP) to Commercial General (CG) (Zone Map Amendment Case File No. 90-03, Comprehensive Map Amendment Case File No. 90-01) to allow for the development of a commercial retail center (Site Plan Review Case File No. 90- 10) on Parcel 2 resulting from Partition Case File No. 90-04. The existing structure on the subject site was constructed as Phase I of a 2-phase commercial retail development. Phase 2, a proposed row of retail shops abutting the west side of the Phase 1 structure, was never developed. RELEVANT APPROVAL CRITERIA: Design Review 05-01: WOODBURN DEVELOPMENT ORDINANCE Section 2.106 Commercial General (CG) Section 3.10t Section 3.102 Section 3.103 Section 3.104 Section 3.105 Section 3.106 Section 3.107 Section 3.110 Section 5.102.02 Variance 05-05: Street Standards Utilities and Easements Setback, Open Space and Lot Standards, Generally Access Off Streets Parking and Loading Landscaping Standards Architectural Design Guidelines and Standards Signs Design Review for All Structures LESS THAN 1000 Sq. Ft. WOODBURN DEVELOPMENT ORDINANCE Section 5.103.11 Variance V. ANALYSIS Design Review 05-01: DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 2 WOODBURN DEVELOPMENT ORDINANCE Section 2.106 Commercial General (CG) Section 2.106.01 Permitted Uses The following uses, when developed under the applicable development standards of the WDO, are permitted in the CG zone: M. Health Care and Social Services 1. Ambulatory health services (62t) EXCEPT ambulance service. (62191) STAFF COMMENT: The applicant has indicated that the structure will be used for ambulatory health services. Ambulatory health services are outright permitted in the CG zone. This approval criterion is met. 2.106.05 Dimensional Standards The following dimensional standards shall be the minimum requirements for all development in the CG zone. A. Lot Standards. Lots in a CG zone shall comply with the applicable standards of Table 2.1.10. TABLE 2.1.10 Lot Standards for Uses in a CG Zone In the CG zone the lot area for a non-residential use shall be adequate to contain all structures within the required setbacks. There shall be no minimum width or depth. STAFF COMMENT: Compliance with setbacks and lot standards is addressed later in this report. B. Building Height. The maximum height of buildings shall not exceed 70 feet, EXCEPT chimneys, spires, domes, flag poles and other features not used for human habitation (EXCEPT telecommunication facilities), shall not exceed 100 feet. STAFF COMMENT: According to the submitted elevation plan, the maximum height of the proposed parapet atop the existing structure is 29 feet, which meets DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 3 the 70-foot maximum height allowed for buildings in the CG zone. This approval criterion is met. C. Setback and Buffer Improvement Standards. 1. Front Yard Setback and Setback Abutting a Street: a. Dimensions: 1) The minimum setback abutting a street shall be 15 feet plus any Special Setback, Section 3.103.05. 2) The maximum yard abutting a street shall be 150 feet. STAFF COMMENT: The subject property abuts Mt. Hood Avenue on its southern frontage. Mt. Hood Avenue is classified as a Major Arterial in the Woodbum Transportation System Plan (TSP). The special setback for a major arterial is 50 feet from the centerline of the street plus the required 15-foot setback adjacent to the street, which totals 65 feet from the centerline of Mt. Hood Avenue. The proposed addition to the fac,.ade of the existing structure is located approximately 313 feet from centerline of Mt. Hood Avenue, which meets the 65-foot special setback from Mt. Hood Avenue. The depth of the existing yard abutting Mt. Hood Avenue is approximately 282 feet, which exceeds the 150-foot maximum yard depth for a yard abutting a street. The existing yard depth is nonconforming and subject to Section 1.104. Section 1.104.04.A states that "...Any expansion or addition to buildings or structures with nonconforming height, setback, density or lot coverage shall not make the development more nonconforming." The current proposal does not increase the depth of the yard abutting Mt. Hood Avenue and does not make the development more nonconforming. These criteria are met. b. Off Street Parking and Maneuvering: 1) Off street parking and storage shall be prohibited within a required front yard or special setback. 2) The distance between the sidewalk on a public street and a loading dock shall be sized to preclude vehicles using the dock from projecting over the sidewalk STAFF COMMENT: The submitted site plan shows 43 existing parking spaces on the subject site located within the 65-foot special setback from the centerline of Mt. Hood Avenue. The applicant has submitted a variance request to allow the existing 43 parking spaces to be located within the 65-foot special setback from the centerline of Mt. Hood Avenue. This variance request is discussed later in this report. No parking spaces are located in the required 5-foot interior yard DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 4 setbacks. The applicant is proposing to stripe 33 parking spaces and 4 loading stalls on the existing asphalted areas to the rear and sides of the existing structure that are not located in the required 5 foot interior yard setback or 65 foot special setback. Clear Vision Area: Fences, walls, landscaping and signs shall be subject to clear vision area standards, Section 3.103.10. STAFF COMMENT: The submitted site plan does not show any of the above- mentioned items located in the 10-foot clear vision areas abutting the driveway entrance. This criterion is met. d. Vehicular Access. Permitted in conformance with Section 3.104. STAFF COMMENT: Vehicular Access is discussed in Section 3.104 of this report. 2. Interior Side and Rear Yard Setbacks. Development in a CG zone shall be subject to the setback and buffer requirements of Table 2.1.11. (Table on following page) DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 5 TABLE 2.1.11 Interior Yard and Buffer Standards for CG Zones Abutting Property Landscaping Wall Interior Setback RS, R1 S, or RM There is no buffer Solid brick or 10 ft. zone yard landscaping architectural wall requirement for an with anti-graffiti intedor yard surface, no less abutting a buffer than 6 feet or wall. greater than 7 feet in height. CO, CG, DDC, There is no buffer Alternative A: Alternative A: P/SP, IP or IL zone yard landscaping requirement for an Wall requirements 5 ff. intedor yard shall be determined abutting a buffer in conjunction with wall. the applicable Design Review process. - ....................... Alternative B: Alternative B: Zero setback abutting a building No wall required, wall. STAFF COMMENT: The adjacent properties to the east and west are zoned Commercial General (CG) and the properties to the north are zoned Industrial Park (IP), requiring a 5-foot interior yard setback or O-foot setback abutting a building wall along the north, east and west property lines. The structure is located a minimum of 58 feet from the north property line, 53 feet from the east property line and 42 feet from the north property line. The proposed covered walkway and drive-through canopy on the eastern building fa(;ade are located 53 feet and 82 feet from the east property line respectively. The structure has a 0- foot setback where the exterior building wall is located along the central portion of the west property line. These setbacks meet the minimum required 5-foot interior yard setback and O-foot setback abutting a building wall along the north, east and west property lines. A wall is not necessary on the north, east and west property lines of the subject site because the abutting commercial and industrial uses are compatible with the proposed ambulatory heath center. An existing chain link fence and proposed P, oundleaf laurustinus (Viburnum tinus l~obustum') hedge will abut the north property line. Roundleaf laurustinus grows to a height of 6 to 12 feet and will effectively obscure visibility of the site from the adjacent industrial uses to the north. A hedge of Green Island Holly (Ilex crenata "Green Island") is proposed along the northeast property line. Green Island Holly grows to a height of 2 feet, which will not effectively screen the site from the DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 6 adjacent industrial use to the northeast. As a condition of approval, the applicant shall submit a revised landscaping plan showing a Roundleaf laurustinus hedge along the northeast property line to screen the site from the abutting industrial use to the northeast. This cdtedon will be met. b. The minimum building setback from a private access easement shall be 5 feet. STAFF COMMENT: No private access easements are shown on the submitted site plan. This approval criterion is met. c. Off street parking. Maneuvering and storage: Off street parking and storage shall be prohibited within a required setback. STAFF COMMENT: The submitted site plan shows 43 existing parking spaces on the subject site located within the 65-foot special setback from the centerline of Mt. Hood Avenue. The applicant has submitted a variance request to allow the existing 43 parking spaces to be located within the 65-foot special setback from the centedine of Mt. Hood Avenue. This vadance request is discussed later in this report. Section 2.106.06 Development Standards All development in the CG zone shall comply with the applicable provisions of the WDO. The following standards specifically apply to uses in the CG zone. A. Off Street Parking. Off street parking shall be subject to the standards of Section 2.106.05 and Section 3.105. STAFF COMMENT: Compliance with off street parking requirements is discussed in Section 3.105 of this report. B. Setbacks and Lots, Generally. Setbacks and lots shall be subject to ~ecflon 3.103. STAFF COMMENT: Compliance with Section 3.103 is discussed later in this report. C. Architectural Design Guidelines. DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 7 All primary buildings and structures, EXCEPT those described in Section 2.106.05. C. 1, shall be subject to the architectural guidelines of Section 3.107.06. STAFF COMMENT: Compliance with architectural design guidelines is discussed later in this report. E. Landscaping and Sidewalks. The street frontage of a subject property shall be improved with either property line sidewalks and street trees or curb line sidewalks. The improvement shall be determined at the time of subdivision, PUD or design review as applicable. Sidewalks and trees shall be installed by the property owner to the standards of Section 3.101 and 3.106. The subject property shall be landscaped to the standards of Section 3.106. STAFF COMMENT: Compliance with Section 3.101 and Section 3.106 is discussed later in this report. Common refuse collection facilities shall be screened on all sides by an architectural block wall and solid gate, both with an anti-graffiti surface, a minimum of six feet and a maximum of seven feet in height. STAFF COMMENT: The submitted site plan shows the proposed common refuse collection facility in the northwest corner of the site to be surrounded by a 6-foot 10-inch tall combination scored and split-face CMU block wall with a slatted chain link gate, which does not meet the requirement for a common refuse collection facility with a solid metal gate. As a condition of approval, the applicant shall submit a revised elevation of the proposed trash enclosure showing a solid metal gate prior to building permit issuance. This criterion will be met. F. Property Disposition. All uses shall be established and conducted on lots of record, as defined by Section 1.102 and developed to the public facility and access standards of Sections 3.101, 3.102 and 3.104. STAFF COMMENT: The proposed development will take place on a legal lot of record located at 1475 Mt. Hood Avenue in Woodburn. The property can be identified specifically on Madon County Assessor's Maps as Township 5 South, Range 1 West, Section 08B, Tax Lot # 2800. This approval criterion is met. DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 8 Section 3.101 Street Standards Section 3.101.02 General Provisions A. The access or driveway, for each lot shall be connected to the existing public street system in compliance with Section 3.104. STAFF COMMENT: Compliance with Sect/on 3.104 is discussed later in this report. No access permit shall be issued unless the internal street(s), boundary street(s) and abutting street(s) are constructed pursuant to Section 3.10f.02. C, UNLESS or until the applicant has obtained an exception as provided in this section. STAFF COMMENT: Mt. Hood Avenue is a State Highway under the jurisdiction of the Oregon Department of Transportation (ODOT), and a referral has been sent to ODOT regarding this proposal. ODOT's Region 2 Representative has indicated that "...based on the plans available, [ODOT has] determined that no amended approach permit is necessary for the existing signalized intersection..." This criterion is met. Section 3.102 Utilities and Easements Section 3.102.01 Water, Sanitary Sewer and Storm Drainage Facilities Municipal water, sanitary sewer and storm drainage facilities shall be installed to applicable Public Works Department and state standards. STAFF COMMENT: According to Public Works Department comments, water service is currently being provided by an existing City maintained water main traversing through the site. Waste water service is provided by the existing private sanitary sewer main extended through the site and connected to the existing public sanitary sewer at Mt Hood Avenue. A grease trap will be required to be installed on the sanitary service, either as a central unit or in each kitchen or food preparation area. Storm water runoff from the site is currently being provided from the on-site private system, discharging to a city maintained system on Progress Way. Any additional required public municipal water, sanitary sewer and storm infrastructure will be subject to the requirements of the Public Works Department and the WDO. These requirements will be met. Section 3.102.04 Easements A. Municipal Infrastructure Easements. DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 9 The Public Works Department shall require dedication of specific easements for the construction and maintenance of municipal water, sewerage and storm drainage facilities located on private property. Easements shall be required in accordance with the Public Works Department standards. STAFF COMMENT: According to Public Works Department comments, the existing fire hydrant identified on the utility plan to be relocated shall require a utility easement to be provided to the City for the relocated hydrant if it is not relocated within the existing easement currently conveyed to the City. Any additional required municipal infrastructure easement dedications required by future development will be subject to the requirements of the Public Works Department and the WDO. B. Public Utility Easements (PUE). Five foot wide public utility easements (i.e., easements for natural gas lines and for electric and telecommunications wire or cable service) shall be dedicated along each lot line abutting a public street. At the time of tentative approval, utilities may request dedication of a public utility easement within a reciprocal access easement or centered along specified rear lot line in those zones where zero setback is not permitted. STAFF COMMENT: Any required public municipal water, sanitary sewer and storm drainage utility easement dedications required by future development will be subject to the requirements of the Public Works Department and the WDO. C. Creeks and Watercourse Maintenance Easements. STAFF COMMENT: There are property for which maintenance criterion is met. no creeks or watercourses on the subject easements will be required. This approval Section 3.103 Setbacks, Open Space and Lot Standards, Generally Section 3.103.03 Generally. Setbacks, Setback Area and Required Open Space, B. Setbacks to be Unobstructed. A setback is the minimum required yard between a structure and a lot line, whether or not additional open space is actually provided between the structure and the lot line. Every setback area shall be open and unobstructed by buildings or structures from the ground to DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 10 the sky EXCEPT as may otherwise be permitted in this Section and Sections 2.201 and 2.202, Accessory Uses and Structures. STAFF COMMENT: The abutting properties to the north, east and west are zoned Industrial Park (IP) and Commercial General (CG), requiring a 5-foot interior yard setback or O-foot setback abutting a building wall according to Table 2.1.1'/. The existing structure is located a minimum of 58 feet from the north property line, 53 feet from the east property line and 42 feet from the northwestern property line. The proposed covered walkway and drive-through canopy on the eastern building fa(;ade are located 53 feet and 82 feet from the east property line respectively. The structure has a O-foot setback where the exterior building wall is located along the central portion of the west property line. These setbacks meet the minimum required 5-foot interior yard setback and 0- foot setback abutting a building wall along the north, east and west property lines. This cdtedon is met. Section 3.103.05 Special Street Setbacks B. Setback Requirements. Required setbacks adjacent to a street shall be in addition to the special setbacks required in this Section. The special setback distances shall be measured at right angles to the center line of the original street right of way. C. Special Provisions. Buildings, structures and paved surfaces shall not be located within the special setbacks EXCEPT as specifically provided for in the WDO. Any portion of a building or structure lawfully established within a special street setback prior to date of WDO shall be considered a nonconforming structure. D. Special Setback Standards. Special setback standards by street classification are established in Table 3.1.1. The special setback standards shall be applied to streets within the City of Woodburn as functionally classified in the Woodburn Transportation System Plan. (Table on following page) DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 11 TABLE 3.1.1 Special Setback Standards by Street Classification WI'SP Functional Classification Special Setback from Center Line Major Arterial 50 feet Minor Arterial 37 feet Service Collector 37 feet Access Street with Parking or Golf Carts 35 feet Access Street with Bike Lanes 30 feet STAFF COMMENT: The project site abuts Mt. Hood Avenue, classified as Major Arterial in the Woodbum Transportation System Plan (TSP), on its southern frontage. The required front yard setback for the subject site is a total of 65 feet (50 foot special setback plus 15 foot front yard setback) from the centeriine of Mt. Hood Avenue. The proposed addition to the fa(~ade of the existing structure is located approximately 323 feet from the centerline of Mt. Hood Avenue, which meets the 65-foot combined front yard and special setback for a structure abutting a Major Arterial in the CG zone. This criterion is met. Section 3.103.06. No Parking or Storage in Setbacks Adjacent to a Street Parking and storage shall be prohibited within a required setback adjacent to a street, EXCEPT for parking in driveways. STAFF COMMENT: The submitted site plan shows 43 existing parking spaces on the subject site located within the 65-foot special setback from the centerline of Mt. Hood Avenue. The applicant has submitted a variance request to allow the existing 43 parking spaces to be located within the 65-foot special setback from the centerline of Mt. Hood Avenue. This variance request is discussed later in this report. Section 3.103.10 Vision Clearance Area A. Generally. A vision clearance area is an area at the intersection of two streets, a street and a driveway or a street and an alley in which visual obstructions are limited for safety purposes. B. Street-Driveway Intersection. A vision clearance area at the intersection of a street and a driveway shall be the area delineated as follows: A line extending ten feet from the intersection along the street right of way. DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 12 m A line extending ten feet from the intersection along the side of the driveway. A third line that creates a triangular vision clearance area by connecting the ends of the lines described in Section 3.103.10.B.I. and 2. E. Prohibited Development. A vision clearance area shall contain no plants, fence, wall, structure, or temporary or permanent obstruction exceeding 30 inches in height [measured from the top of the curb or, where no curb exists, from the established street centerline grade], EXCEPT as follows: Trees, provided branches and foliage are removed to a height of 7 feet above grade; 2. Telephone, power and cable television poles; Telephone and utility boxes less than ten inches at the widest dimension; and 4. Traffic control signs and devices. STAFF COMMENT: The submitted site plan does not show any of the above- mentioned items located in the 10-foot clear vision areas abutting the ddveway entrance. This criterion is met. Section 3.104. Access Section 3.104.01 Applicability A. Street Access Required. Every lot shall have direct access to an abutting public street or to a public street by an irrevocable access easement. STAFF COMMENT: The subject property has existing access onto Mt. Hood Avenue via a 42.foot wide 2-way signalized driveway entrance, The site also has existing access to Progress Way to the west via a reciprocal access agreement with the property to the west. This criterion is met. B. Access to City Streets, Permit Required. DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 13 A Traffic Impact Analysis (TIA) may be required by the Public Works Director prior to the approval of a City access or street construction permit when the Director estimates a development proposal may generate either 100 or more additional, peak hour trips, or 1,000 or more additional daily trips, within ten years of a development application. A TIA shall evaluate the traffic impacts projected of a development proposal and the estimated effectiveness of potential traffic impact mitigation measures. The methodology for a TIA shall be consistent with Public Works Department guidelines. STAFF COMMENT: The Woodbum Transportation Manager indicated that the proposal would not require a TIA because the proposed development is not anticipated to generate 100 or more additional, peak hour trips, or 1,000 or more additional daily trips, within ten years of the development application. This approval criterion is met. 3. Administration of City access permit standards and guidelines bm Type II and III Applications. Development subject to one of the following Type II and III applications: 1) Type II Design Review, Section 5.102.02; shall be subject to the access standards and guidelines specified in this Section EXCEPT when the subject property is bound by the requirements of a precedent land use decision that has not been modified by a subsequent land use decision. STAFF COMMENT: The current proposal is subject to administrative (Type II) Design Review and will be required to meet the requirements of Section 3.104. Section 3.104.02 Driveway and Drive-Through Measurements and Dimensions A. Driveways Crossing a Setback. The portion of a driveway crossing a setback shall be perpendicular to the setback lines. STAFF COMMENT: The proposed site plan shows the driveways crossing a setback to be perpendicular to those setbacks. This approval criterion is met. B. Driveway Width. DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 14 Driveway width shall be determined by measurement at the property line. C. Drive-Through Dimensions and Configuration. 1. Minimum Lane Width. 12 feet. m Minimum Lane Length. 50 feet, unobstructed by lateral vehicular access. Precluded lateral vehicular access shall include the access/maneuvering area for off street parking and overlap onto public street right of way. The unobstructed length shall be measured from the drive up window or stop line, whichever is greater. 3. Turn Radius. 25 feet. By-Pass Lane. A development providing a drive'through for passenger loading and/or unloading or for drive-up services shall include a by-pass lane to a site exist. STAFF COMMENT: The applicant proposes to remove the existing 3,565 square foot Garden Shop on the eastern building frontage and add a 960 square foot covered walk and 1,128 square foot Urgent Care drive-through canopy in its place. The submitted site plan shows a 22-foot wide driveway beneath the canopy with a minimum lane length of 50 feet unobstructed by lateral vehicle access. This does not meet the standard for a 12-foot wide drive-through lane and 12-foot bypass lane (24-foot combined width). As a condition of approval, the applicant shall submit a revised site plan demonstrating compliance with the drive-through and bypass lane width requirements pertaining to the proposed Urgent Care patient drop-off area prior to issuance of a building permit. This criterion will be met. Section 3.104.03 Driveway Access Guidelines, Type II and III Applications Guidelines for the Number and Location of Driveways, Type II and Type III Applications. 2. Joint/Shared Access. Medium density residential, commercial, industrial uses and other development subject to Type II or III Design Review located on the same lot, or on abutting lots, that abut a Major Arterial, Minor Arterial, or Service Collector should be designed to share access to those major streets... DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 15 dm Shared/Joint Access Agreements. Shared and/or joint access agreements serving properties under separate ownership shall be subject to legal documentation, to the satisfaction of the City Attorney, establishing permanent use of the access. The agreement shall be recorded with the County Recorder and filed with the Community Development Director. 3. Cross Connections. Similar, and/or compatible, uses on abutting lots should have interconnected on-site access and parking facilities. Such shared facilities serving properties under separate ownership shall be subject to legal documentation, to the satisfaction of the City Attorney, establishing permanent use of the access. The agreement shall be recorded with the County Recorder and filed with the Community Development Director. STAFF COMMENT: The property abuts Mt. Hood Avenue on the north. Mt. Hood Avenue is classified as a major artedal on the Woodburn TSP. Commercial uses abut the subject property to the west (a Pizza Hut restaurant, bank and undeveloped parcel zoned CG) and east (a bank and undeveloped parcel zoned CG). The WDO provides that commercial uses on adjoining properties that abut a major arterial should share driveway accesses to the major arterial. The subject property has existing access onto Mt. Hood Avenue via a 42-foot wide 2-way signalized driveway entrance. The abutting parcels to the east and west have accesses to Mt. Hood Ave. The subject property has a shared access agreement with the property to the west. The property owner intends to modify the provisions of this shared access easement in conjunction with this proposal. A draft of the modification has been provided to the staff. The modification continues to provide shared access, cross connections and parking between the subject parcel and the parcel to the west. Therefore, the above provisions are satisfied relative to the abutting property to the west. Concerning the abutting properties to the east, a condition of approval of the original development of the subject property (as K-Mart under Site Plan Review Case File No. 91-10) required an access connection on the east edge of the property. That connection was not constructed because the owner was unable to reach agreement with the property to the east. The property to the east was partitioned on November 17, 2004, Partition Case File No. 04-05. In the partition approval, the Community Development Director required a 24-foot easement running east/west along the boundary created by the Partition from the partition plat's driveway west to the subject property's boundary line to provide for future DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 16 connection of the accesses. The applicant has not provided a shared access agreement. This criterion can be satisfied by a condition of approval. The WDO also provides that abutting lots should have interconnected on-site access and parking facilities. This provision applies when abutting uses are either similar or compatible. The subject property is zoned CG, as are the abutting properties to the east and west. Similar uses are listed as outright permitted uses in the zone, and may include allowed uses within the zone. The proposed use on the subject property, an ambulatory heath center, is a permitted use in the commercial zone. The abutting property to the west contains a Pizza Hut restaurant and a vacant commercial site. The abutting property to the east contains a bank fronting Mt. Hood Avenue and a vacant commercial site. These uses are similar. Consequently, the provision for interconnected on-site access and parking facilities applies to the subject parcel and the abutting parcels to the west and east. The proposed modified shared access and parking agreement between the subject property owner and the owner of the abutting property to the west covers interconnection of access and shared parking. The requirement is satisfied with respect to the property to the west. The site plan does not show interconnected on-site access to the property to the east nor has the applicant provided documents to demonstrate the access and parking will be interconnected with the property to the east. This criterion can be satisfied by a condition of approval. The Woodbum Fire District and Oregon Department of Transportation state that they support the creation of a driveway cross-connection between the subject property and the property to the east in conjunction with this proposal. Development of this cross-connection will require the elimination of several off street parking spaces. These displaced parking spaces can be relocated and provided elsewhere on the subject site. As a condition of approval, the applicant shall submit a revised site plan showing a driveway cross-connection with the properties to the east aligned with the 24- foot wide driveway cross-access easement provided in Partition Case File No. 04-05. Any parking spaces eliminated by creation of the cross-connection shall be replaced on-site. The shared and/or joint access agreement shall be subject to legal documentation, to the satisfaction of the City Attorney, establishing permanent use of the access prior to building permit issuance. The agreement shall be recorded with the County Recorder and filed with the Community Development Director. B. Driveway Spacing Guidelines, Type II and III Applications. DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 17 The minimum separation of a driveway from: a) the special setback of a parallel major street, b) the right of way of a parallel local street, or c) from another driveway should be as follows. 1. Major Arterial Street: 300 feet; EXCEPT where pre-existing conditions preclude such separation the separation should be maximized. STAFF COMMENT: Site access onto Mt. Hood Avenue is existing and no new accesses onto a public street are proposed. The driveway access onto Mt. Hood Avenue is located approximately 378 feet from the nearest driveway entrance to the east and approximately 525 feet from the nearest driveway entrance to the west, which meets the 300-foot minimum separation for driveway entrances accessing a Major Arterial. This criterion is met. Section 3.104.05 Driveway Dimension and Improvement Standards, Type I, II and III Applications. E. Commercial and Industrial Use. 1. Paved Two-way Driveway Width. With a turn lane: Throat width 36 feet minimum, 40 feet maximum. ("No Parking" restrictions shall be posted by the owner.) STAFF COMMENT: The submitted site plan shows the existing 42-foot wide driveway access onto Mt. Hood Avenue incorporating a turn lane. Mt. Hood Avenue is a state highway under the jurisdiction of the Oregon Department of Transportation (ODOT). Thus, a City access permit is not required and the City's access standards are not applicable to the existing driveway access. A referral has been sent to ODOT regarding this proposal. ODOT's Region 2 Representative commented that "...based on the plans available, [ODOT has] determined that no amended approach permit is necessary for the existing signalized intersection..." Throat length of a driveway, extending from the closest off street parking or loading space to the outside edge of right of way for a: Major street connection: 50 feet minimum, with greater improvement as may be required by a TIA. DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 18 STAFF COMMENT: The site plan shows off street parking located outside the 50-foot throat depth within the existing driveway access onto Mt. Hood Avenue. This criterion is met. Section 3.105 Off Street Parking and Loading Section 3.105.0'l Applicability The provisions of this Section shall apply to the following types of development: B. Expansion or Change of Use. Any additional parking and/or loading required by the WDO to accommodate a change in use, or expansion of an existing use shall be subject to the following. Applications subject to Type II Design Review, Section 5.102.02, where the change or expansion increases the required area for parking, loading or landscaping by 25 percent or more, shall conform to all parking, loading and landscaping to the standards of the WDO. Parking, loading and landscaping required for changes or expansion of less than 25 percent shall be limited to those necessary to conform with the increment of change or expansion. STAFF COMMENT: The applicant proposes to reduce the floor area of the existing structure by approximately 9% and the parking ratio for both the prior (retail sales) and proposed (ambulatory health services) site uses is the same (1 parking space per 250 square feet of gross floor area [sfgfa]). Because the change in use does not increase the required number of parking spaces, improvements to parking and loading shall be limited to those necessary to conform with the increment of change. The appliCant proposes to upgrade landscaping in buffer yards in the southern, eastern and northern portions of the site. Compliance with landscaping standards is discussed later in this report. Section 3.105.02 General Provisions for Off Street Parking and Loading E. Off Street Vehicle Parking Requirements. Off street vehicle parking spaces shall be provided in amounts not less than those set forth in Table 3.1.2. STAFF COMMENT: The proposed ambulatory health center will require 338 parking spaces: I space per 250 square feet of gross floor area (84,607 sfgfa) for DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 19 ambulatory health services. The submitted site plan shows a total of 338 spaces provided. 'l'his criterion is met. The number of disabled person vehicle parking spaces shall be provided to the standards of the state Building Code and applicable federal standards. The number of disabled person vehicle parking spaces shall be included as part of total required vehicle parking spaces. STAFF COMMENT: Eight disabled person vehicle parking spaces are required per the Uniform Building Code for a parking lot containing 300 through 400 spaces. The applicant is proposing nine disabled vehicle parking spaces to meet this requirement. G. Off Street Loading Requirements. Off street loading spaces shall comply with the dimensional standards and amounts not less than those set forth in Table 3.1.3. m The off street loading facilities shall be on the same lot, or site, as the use or structure they are intended to serve. Required loading spaces and required parking spaces shall be separate and distinct. STAFF COMMENT: The 84,607 square foot building is required loading spaces with a minimum 12-foot width, 30-foot depth and vertical clearance of 14 feet. The submitted site plan shows four to have four unobstructed · separate and distinct loading spaces and one passenger loading area. A 17-foot wide, 30-foot long loading space abuts the north side of the building. A 12-foot wide, 30-foot long loading space abuts the west side of the building. Two 12-foot wide, 30-foot long loading spaces abut the truck docks located at the northeast corner of the building. A curved passenger loading area a maximum 20 feet wide and 130 feet long abuts the building to the south. The proposed loading spaces meet the 12- foot width and 30-foot length standards of Table 3.1.3. The submitted site plan shows bicycle racks located in the loading zone abutting the north side of the structure. As a condition of approval, the applicant shall submit a revised site plan showing bicycle racks relocated from the loading zone abutting the north side of the structure to within 50 feet of the main entrance on the south side of the existing building prior to building permit issuance. This criterion will be met. He On-site Vehicle Parking and Loading Area Improvement Requirements. Bumper Guards and Wheel Barriers. All vehicle parking spaces, EXCEPT those for single family and duplex dwellings, DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 20 shall be constructed with bumper guards or wheel barriers that prevent vehicles from damaging structures or projecting over walkways, access ways or abutting property or rights of way. STAFF COMMENT: The submitted site plan shows the 41 spaces abutting the proposed structure to be constructed with wheel barriers to prevent vehicles from damaging the structure or projecting over a walkway. This criterion is met. Size of Vehicular Parking Spaces and Maneuvering Areas within Off Street Parking Areas. Off street vehicle parking spaces and maneuvering areas, EXCEPT those for single family and duplex dwellings and those for disabled persons, within off street parking areas shall be designed in compliance with Table 3. f.4. Three or more off street parking spaces provided subject to Table 3. t.4 shall be designed so that no backing or maneuvering within a public street right of way is required. STAFF COMMENT: The applicant proposes to relocate the 32 off street parking spaces on the north side of the structure to face toward the south and directly abut the structure. In addition, the submitted site plan shows the 9 disabled person parking spaces to be added as new spaces abutting the structure to the east and southwest. The disabled parking spaces are not subject to Table 3.1.4. The 32 realigned spaces to the north of the structure are standard parking spaces designed at a 90-degree angle with a minimum stall width of 9-feet, stall depth of 19 feet, and 2-way aisle width of 24 feet. These proposed dimensions meet the 9-foot stall width, 19-foot stall depth, and 24-foot 2-way aisle width requirements in Table 3.1.4. This approval criterion is met. bm Off street parking for disabled persons shall be designed to the standards of the state Building Code and applicable federal standards. STAFF COMMENT: The applicant is proposing 9 disabled person parking spaces. Compliance with the State and Federal design standards will be reviewed when the building permit is submitted. This criterion will be met. Directional Marking. EXCEPT for vehicle parking areas for single family and duplex dwellings, off street parking and maneuvering areas shall have directional markings and signs to control vehicle movement. DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 21 STAFF COMMENT: The submitted site plan shows 1-way and 2-way arrows on the pavement surface at the entrance and exit of 1-way and 2-way drive aisles. This criterion is met. Space Marking. EXCEPT for vehicle parking areas for single family and duplex dwellings, off street parking spaces shall be delineated by double parallel lines on each side of a space. The total width of the lines shall delineate a separation of 2 feet. STAFF COMMENT: The submitted site plan indicates that all off street parking spaces will be re-striped with double parallel lines 2 feet in width that delineate each space. This approval criterion has been met. Outdoor Lighting. EXCEPT for vehicle parking areas for single family and duplex dwellings, all outdoor lighting shall be designed so as not to shine or reflect into any adjacent residentially zoned or used property, and shall not cast a glare onto moving vehicles on any public street. STAFF COMMENT: The submitted lighting plan shows outdoor lighting designed so as not to shine or reflect into the residentially zoned properties to the south and not to cast a glare onto moving vehicles on any public street. This approval criterion is met. Landscaping. EXCEPT for vehicle parking spaces for single family and duplex dwellings, all parking areas shall be landscaped to the standards of Section 3.106. STAFF COMMENT: The applicant proposes to upgrade landscaping throughout the entire site. Compliance with landscaping requirements is discussed in Section 3.106 of this report. 10. On-site Bicycle Parking Requirements. All uses required to provide 10 or more off street parking spaces shall provide a bicycle rack within 50 feet of the main entrance. The number of required rack spaces shall be one plus one per ten vehicle parking spaces, with a maximum of 20 rack spaces. STAFF COMMENT: The required off street parking for the site is 338 parking spaces, requiring 35, or a maximum of 20, bicycle rack spaces within 50 feet of the main entrance. The submitted site plan shows bicycle racks located with 50 feet of the primary and secondary pedestrian entrances. The applicant states that 20 bicycle parking spaces will be provided on the subject site. The submitted site plan shows bicycle racks located in the loading zone abutting the north side of the structure. As a condition of approval, the applicant shall submit a revised site DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 22 plan showing bicycle racks relocated from the loading zone abutting the north side of the structure to within 50 feet of the main entrance on the south side of the existing building prior to building permit issuance. This criterion will be met. Section 3.106 Landscaping Standards Section 3.106.01 Applicability The provisions of this section shall apply: To the site area of the development, where the cumulative effect of additions to structures and/or parking areas increases the total area covered by structure and parking by 50 percent or more than existed at the date of the WDO adoption. STAFF COMMENT: The cumulative effect of the addition of 9 off street parking spaces and minor structural alterations does not increase the total area covered by building and parking by 50 percent. The applicant is proposing to upgrade landscaping for much of the site, which requires compliance with the requirements of Section 3/106 where new landscaping is proposed. Section 3.106.02 General Requirements A. Landscaping and Irrigation Plans Required. Building plans for ail uses subject to landscaping requirements shall be accompanied by landscaping and irrigation plans to City standards. STAFF COMMENT: The applicant has submitted a landscaping plan and as-built irrigation plan detailing irrigation for the southern portion of the site in conjunction with this proposal. A condition of approval requires the applicant to submit a final irrigation plan showing irrigation for proposed landscaping elements abutting the north and northeast property lines to be reviewed and approved by the Community Development Department prior to issuance of the building permit. B. Irrigation. All required landscaped areas shall be permanently irrigated unless a planting plan without irrigation is submitted by a licensed landscape architect or a licensed nursery person demonstrating that the proposed landscaping will thrive without irrigation. STAFF COMMENT: The applicant is proposing to irrigate the new landscaping. A condition of approval requires the applicant to submit a final irrigation plan showing irrigation for proposed landscaping elements abutting the north and DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 23 northeast property lines to be reviewed and approved by the Community Development Department prior to issuance of the building permit. E. Maintenance. The property owner shall be responsible for maintaining all landscaping in good condition so as to present a healthy and orderly appearance. Unhealthy and dead plants shall be removed and replaced in conformance with the original landscape plan. STAFF COMMENT: This requirement is a condition of approval for all landscaping located on the subject site. Section 3.106.03 Landscaping Standards A. Streetscape. Street Trees. Within the public street right of way abutting a development, or within an ally right of way in the DDC zone, street trees shall be planted to City standards prior to occupancy. Acceptable Types of Trees. See Section 6.103 for a description of acceptable and unacceptable trees for this purpose, classified by size and species. Tree Density. Trees shall be planted to the following intervals within the right of way, subject to Clear Vision Area standards, Section 3.103.10 and Section 6.103: 1) Four (4) small trees per 100 feet of street frontage; 2) Three (3) medium trees per 100 feet of street frontage; or 3) Two (2) large trees per 100 feet of street frontage. STAFF COMMENT: The subject site has 537 feet of frontage abutting Mt Hood Avenue and currently incorporates 10 Red Maples (Acer rubrum), classified as a "large tree" according to Section 6.103. This meets the requirement for 2 large trees per 100 feet of street frontage. The applicant proposes to use the existing street trees to fulfill the above requirement. This criterion is met. 2. Front Yard and Yard Abutting a Street. b. Landscaping Design and Density in CO and CG zones. DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 24 1) All yards abutting a street, including off street parking and circulation areas shall be landscaped to a density of one (1) plant unit (PU) per 20 sq. ft. STAFF COMMENT: The submitted landscaping plan shows the yard abutting Mt. Hood Avenue to be landscaped at densities ranging between1.64 and 1.8 PUl20 sq. ft. This criterion is met. 2) All parking areas abutting a street shall provide a 42 inch vertical visual screen from the abutting street grade. Acceptable design techniques to provide the screening include plant materials; berms; freestanding, architectural walls with anti-graffiti finish, depressed grade for the parking area. All screening shall comply with the clear vision standards, Section 3.103.10. STAFF COMMENT: The existing landscape strip abutting Mt. Hood Avenue along the south property line incorporates a 24-inch high berm feature. The submitted landscaping plan shows a hedge of Green Island Holly (Ilex crenata "Green Island") to be planted atop the existing 24-inch berm. Green Island Holly grows to a height of 2 feet (24-inches) and is classified as a "small" or "medium" shrub according Table 3.1,5. The combined 48-inch screen height (24-inch berm and 24-inch hedge) meets the requirement for a 42-inch vertical screen between Mt. Hood Avenue and the off street parking area located on the subject property. This criterion is met. B. Buffer Yards. All buffer yards shall be landscaped at the rate of one (1) plant unit PU per 20 sq. ft. EXCEPT for interior buffer yards abutting a wall which are paved and which may be used for parking or site access and vehicular circulation. STAFF COMMENT: The applicant proposes to upgrade landscape elements in the north, northeast, east, south and southwest buffer yards. According to the submitted landscaping plan, planting densities in these buffer yards range between 1.21 PU/20 sq. ft. and 1.41 PU/20 sq. ft. This criterion is met. C. Off Street Parking Areas. All unpaved land within the off street parking area, and within 20 feet of the paved edge of off street parking and/or circulation improvements, shall be landscaped in the following proportions: DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 25 RM, CO and CG zones: Landscaped area(s) equivalent to 20% of the paved surface area for off street parking and circulation. STAFF COMMENT: According to the submitted landscaping plan, the existing and proposed landscaping will cover an equivalent of 24.6% of all paved areas. This approval criterion is met. o The density of landscaping required in and adjacent to off street parking and circulation facilities, EXCLUDING required trees, shall be one (1) plant unit per 20 square feet. STAFF COMMENT: The submitted landscaping plan shows yards to be landscaped at densities ranging between 1.07 PUl20 square feet and 4.9 PUl20 square feet excluding required trees where landscaping is proposed abutting off street parking and circulation facilities to the north, south and east of the existing structure. This criterion is met. Trees, Section 6.103, shall be planted within and abutting off street parking facilities in a pattern that is in roughly proportion to the distribution of the parking spaces, at the following densities: a. 1 small tree per 5 parking spaces; b. I medium tree per 10 parking spaces; or c. 1 large tree per 14 parking spaces. STAFF COMMENT: Required parking for the site is 338 spaces, necessitating the planting of 68 small trees, 34 medium trees, 24 large trees, or some combination thereof. The applicant proposes to plant 46 large trees abutting the off street parking area including 30 Village Green Zelkova (Zelkova serrata 'Village Green') and 16 True Shade Honeylocust (Gleditsia triacanthos 'True Shade') abutting off street parking and circulation areas to meet the requirement of I large tree per 14 parking spaces. In addition, 16 existing Sycamore Maples (Acerplatanoides), classified as a large tree in Section 6.103, will be retained on the property abutting off street parking to the south, southwest and east. This criterion is met. 3.106.05 Planting Standards A. Distribution of Plant Materials. The required number of plant units shall be met by a combination of plant materials listed in Table 3.1.5, so that eighty (80) percent of the DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 26 area to be landscaped is covered within three years. Required plant units need not be allocated uniformly through out specified landscaping areas, but may be grouped for visual effect. STAFF COMMENT: A condition of approval is that all shrubs and ground cover shall be of a size upon installation so as to attain 80% of ground coverage within 3 years. B. Ground Cover. Landscaped areas that are not covered by plant materials shall be covered by a layer of bark mulch or decorative rock, EXCLUDING ordinary crushed gravel, a minimum of 2 inches in depth. STAFF COMMENT: The applicant has indicated that all landscape areas not covered by plant materials will be covered by a 2-inch layer of bark mulch. This criterion is met. C. Curbs. A six-inch concrete curb shall be provided between a landscaped area and a parking area or access way. STAFF COMMENT: The submitted site plan shows a 6-inch concrete curb between the parking spaces, landscaped areas and circulation areas on the site. This approval criterion is met. Section 3.107 Architectural Design Guidelines and Standards Section 3.107.06 Guidelines and Standards for Structures in RS, R1 S, RM, CO, CG and PISP Zones Non-Residential A. Applicability. The following design guidelines shall be applicable to all non- residential structures and buildings in the RS, R1S, RM, CO, CG and P zones. STAFF COMMENT: The proposed office building is a non-residential structure proposed within the CG zone, and is subject to the architectural design guidelines of Section 3.107.06. B. Architectural Design Guidelines. 1. Mass & Bulk Articulation Guidelines. DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 27 Building facades visible from streets and public parking areas should be articulated in order to avoid the appearance of box-like structures with unbroken wall surfaces. The appearance of exterior walls should be enhanced by incorporating three dimensional design features, including the following: 1) Public doorways and/or passage ways through the building. 2) Wall offsets and/or projections. 3) Variation in building materials and/or textures. 4) Arcades, awnings, canopies and/or porches. STAFF COMMENT: The southern facade of the existing structure is visible from Mt Hood Avenue and the abutting public parking area. The existing building features a painted split-face CMU facade with a smooth CMU accent band and metal roofing system adjacent to the primary pedestrian entrance. The applicant proposes to break-up the existing box-like southern building face with the addition of a curved entrance facade bisected by a glass and wood canopy feature above the primary pedestrian entrance and proposed individual tenant space entrances. The submitted floor plan shows the entrance fa(;ade to be offset from the structural building walls by 10 to 24 feet. The applicant states the intent of this design is to create "...transitional indoor/outdoor spaces..." The parapet of the proposed curved entrance fac~ade will rise 6 feet above the existing roofline and provide 3-dimensionality to the currently fiat southern building wall. The submitted elevation and floor plans show the glass and wood entrance canopy to be set below and extending laterally outward 22 to 26 feet from the plane of the proposed curved entrance fa(~ade and the existing CMU structural wall. The proposed curved fac,,ade will feature stucco with stone wainscot while the entrance canopy will be composed of glazing and exposed wood structure. In addition, the applicant proposes decorative fountain features and stone "garden" walls along the southern building fa~}ade. This proposed variation in building materials will effectively minimize the current predominant CMU wall surfaces. This criterion is met. 2. Materials and Textures Guidelines. Building exteriors should exhibit finishes and textures that reduce the visual monotony of bulky structures and large structural spaces; enhance visual interest of wall surfaces and harmonize with the structural design. DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 28 The appearance of exterior surfaces should be enhanced by incorporating the following: 1) At least 30% of the wall surface abutting a street should be glass. 2) All walls visible from a street or public parking area should be surfaced with wood, brick, stone, designer block, or stucco or with siding that has the appearance of wood lap siding. 3) The use of plain concrete, plain concrete block, corrugated metal, plywood, T-111 and sheet composite siding as exterior finish materials for walls visible from a street or parking area should be avoided. 4) The color of at least 90 percent of the wall, roof and awning surface visible from a street or public parking area should be an "earth tone" color containing 10 parts or more of brown or a "tinted" color containing 10 parts or more white. Fluorescent, "day-glo," or any similar bright color should not be used on the building exterior. STAFF COMMENT: The proposed curved fa(;ade structure and existing building walls, comprising the bulk of the wall area visible from a public street or parking area, will feature stucco with stone accents and painted existing CMU wall surfaces. In addition, a glass and wood canopy is proposed above the primary pedestrian entrance and a decorative fountain feature with stone "garden" walls will be located at the southeast corner of the building fa(~ade. This proposed variation in building materials will effectively vary and minimize the current predominant CMU wall surface. Proposed coloration of the primary wall surfaces, entrance canopy, covered walk, cap flashing and storefront system, comprising the bulk of the visible area, incorporates colors including "Earth Red", "Taupe- Cream", "Wh/te", "Aluminum" and natural wood tones. The shades "Earth Red", 'Taupe-Cream", "White", "Aluminum" and natural wood coloration may all be considered "earth tones" and "Tinted tones" in accordance with the above requirement. The proposed colors and materials are represented on the colored building elevation and materials sample board submitted in conjunction with this application. The submitted elevations show the wall surface of .the proposed ambulatory health center to be comprised of 21% glass abutting Mt Hood Avenue, which does not meet the guideline of 30% glazing for a wall surface facing a street. The south fa~:ade of the existing structure currently incorporates 8% glazing. The DP, 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 29 proposed curved entry incorporates a parapet rising 6 feet above the plane of the existing roofline, which significantly increases the vertical wall area of the southern building fac,,ade. The proposed parapet breaks up the current fiat roofline and will be used to screen roof-mounted equipment. It is not feasible to incorporate additional windows in the proposed curved entry. In addition, the existing CMU building shell forming the southern building facade is a structural wall, which currently has minimal window area. The applicant proposes to significantly increase the percentage of window area incorporated in the wall surface facing Mt. Hood Avenue from 8% to 21% while taking into account the architectural utility of the curved entry parapet and the existing structural wall. This approval criterion is met. 3. Multi-planed Roof Guidelines. ae The roof line at the top of a structure should establish a distinctive top to the building. The roof line should not be fiat or hold the same roof line over extended distances. Rather the roof line should incorporate variations, such as: 1) Offsets and/or jogs in the plane of the roof. STAFF COMMENT: The proposed curved entry feature will establish a distinctive "top" to the existing fiat roofline. The submitted elevations show a 6- foot offset in the primary roofline. These approval criteria are met. m Roof Mounted Equipment Guidelines. All roof mounted equipment, EXCEPT solar collectors, should be screened from view from streets abutting the building site by: Locating roof mounted equipment below the highest vertical element of the building; or Screening roof top equipment using materials of the same character as the structure's basic materials. STAFF COMMENT: The submitted elevations do not show any roof-mounted equipment atop the proposed structure. The applicant has indicated that the 6- foot curved entry parapet will be used to screen roof-mounted equipment. This criterion will be met. Weather Protection Guidelines. All building faces abutting a street or a public parking area should provide weather protection for pedestrians. Features to provide this protection should include: DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 30 am A continuous walkway at least 8 feet wide along the face of the building utilizing a roof overhang, arcade, awnings and/or canopies. Awnings and canopies that incorporate the following design features: 1) Angled or curved surfaces facing a street or parking ' area. 2) A covering of canvas, treated canvas, awning fabric, or matte finish vinyl. 3) A constant color and pattern scheme for all buildings within the same development. 4) No internal back lighting. STAFF COMMENT: The site plan shows a continuous walkway abutting south and east building frontages that varies between 8 feet and 30 feet in width. The submitted floor plan shows the primary pedestrian entrance on the southern fa(;ade to provide weather protection via a minimum 24-foot, maximum 26-foot wide wood and glass entry canopy. The proposed pedestrian entrance and Urgent Care drop-off on the eastern building fa(;ade feature a 960 square foot covered walk and 1,128 square foot drive-up canopy respectively. These approval criteria are met. Landscaping and Screening Guidelines. The landscaping required by the standards of the WDO should be augmented to address site specific visual impacts of abutting uses and the visual character of the surrounding area. STAFF COMMENT: Landscaping is proposed abutting the southern, eastern and southwestern building frontages. A Roundleaf laurustinus (Viburnum tinus ~obustum') hedge is proposed abutting the north property line. Roundleaf laurustinus may grow to a height of 6 to 12 feet and will effectively obscure visibility of the site from the adjacent industrial uses. A hedge of Green Island Holly (Ilex crenata "Green Island") is proposed along the northeast property line. A condition of approval requires the applicant to replace the lower growing Green Island Holly with Roundleaf laurustinus along the northeast property line to screen the site from the abutting industrial use to the northeast. This criterion will be met. Design Character Guidelines. Standardized or characteristic "corporate" and "franchise" design elements should be DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 31 refined to reduce domination of the visual environment by corporate icons. STAFF COMMENT: Excluding proposed signage, the submitted site and elevation plans do not show any proposed "corporate" or '~=ranchise" icons on the subject site. This criterion is met. Buffer Wall. A solid brick or architectural wall with anti-graffiti surface, no less than 6 feet or greater than 7 feet in height: ae Should be constructed on the perimeter property line of non-residential development to mitigate adverse visual, noise and/or light impacts on the abutting use when no comparable buffer exists, and Shall be constructed where the standards of the underlying zone require such a wall for a non-residential use in, or abutting, a RS, RlS, or RM zoning district. STAFF COMMENT: Per Table 2.1.'/1., there exists no buffer yard landscaping requirement along the northern, eastern and western perimeter of the subject property as the abutting lots are zoned CG and IP. A wall is not necessary on the north, east and west property lines of the subject site because the abutting commemial and industrial uses are compatible with the proposed commercial- institutional use. A proposed Roundleaf laurustinus (Viburnum tinus 1~,obustum') hedge will abut the north property line to obscure visibility of the site from the adjacent industrial uses. This approval criterion is met. Sidewalk Location and Street Trees. Sidewalks should be located at the property line along streets with street trees, Section 3. STAFF COMMENT: The submitted site and landscaping plans show existing curb line sidewalk and street trees abutting Mt. Hood Avenue. Compliance with street tree standards is discussed in Section 3.'106.03.A.1. of this report. 10. Solar Access Protection. Obstruction of existing solar collectors on abutting properties by site development should be mitigated. STAFF COMMENT: The proposed building will not obstruct solar collectors located on abutting properties. This approval criterion is met. C. Site and Building Access Guidelines. DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 32 Access to and from the site and circulation within the site should separate facilities for cars, trucks and transit from those for bicycles and pedestrians. Site access in compliance with Section 3.104 should be augmented by the following considerations: a. Vehicle Access. 1) Vehicle access points should be identified by accentuated landscaped areas, by entrance throats designed to control access from abutting parking and by monument type entrance signs. 2) New parking lots abutting major streets should connect internally with the parking lots of abutting commercial uses or land zoned for commercial use. STAFF COMMENT: The submitted landscaping plan shows accent landscaping provided at the existing driveway entrance onto Mt. Hood Avenue and the driveway cross-connection with the property to the west. The property abuts Mt. Hood Avenue, classified as a major arterial on the Woodburn TSP, on the north. Commercial uses abut the subject property to the west (a Pizza Hut restaurant, bank and undeveloped parcel zoned CG) and east (a bank and undeveloped parcel zoned CG). The abutting parcels to the east and west have accesses to Mt. Hood Ave and the subject property has an existing shared access agreement with the property to the west. A condition of approval requires the applicant to submit a revised site plan showing a driveway cross-connection with the properties to the east aligned with the 24-foot wide driveway cross-access easement provided in Partition Case File No. 04-05. Compliance with WDO cross-connection standards is discussed in Section 3.104.03.A.3 of this report. b. Pedestrian Access and Circulation. 1) The buildings should be linked to the sidewalks on abutting streets by internal pedestrian ways. Such pedestrian ways should be either raised or delineated by distinctive pavers. STAFF COMMENT: The site plan shows proposed pedestrian access to the proposed from the south via a 4-foot wide walkway abutting the east margin of the primary driveway entrance. Where pedestrian ways cross internal ddve aisles, they are shown on the site plan to be delineated with pavers. In addition, distinctive pavers delineate the passenger loading area to the south of the structure. The site plan does not show this proposed pedestrian walkway as connecting to the existing curb line sidewalk abutting Mt. Hood Avenue. As a DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 33 condition of approval, the applicant shall submit a revised site plan to the Community Development Department for review and approval showing the proposed 4-foot wide pedestrian walkway abutting the east margin of the primary ddveway entrance as connecting to the existing curb line sidewalk abutting Mt. Hood Avenue pdor to building permit issuance. This criterion will be met. 2) Parking areas should be designed in multiples of no more than 50 spaces separated by landscaped buffers or raised pedestrian ways in order to minimize negative visual impacts associated with expansive parking. STAFF COMMENT: The proposed parking area incorporates multiples of 50 or more parking spaces that are not separated by landscaped areas. The off street parking area is existing, and is not being expanded. The applicant proposes to make incremental improvements proportional to the proposed change in use including the addition of landscape islands and resurfacing and re-striping of parking spaces. The applicant will not be required to realign the existing off street parking area to separate multiples of 50 parking spaces with landscape buffers in conjunction with this proposal. This criterion is met. D. Building Location Guidelines. Within the prescribed setbacks, building location and orientation should compliment abutting uses and development patterns. STAFF COMMENT: Compliance of the building location within the required setbacks is discussed earlier in this report Section 2. f06.05. C. The proposed changes to the existing building facade incorporate architectural elements, materials and coloration complementary to nearby residential developments. This criterion is met. E. Parking Location Guidelines. Off street parking between the architectural front of a building and the setback line abutting a street should be limited to a depth of not more than 130 feet. STAFF COMMENT: The depth of the off street parking area abutting Mt. Hood Avenue is approximately 280 feet, which exceeds the 130-foot off street parking area depth guideline. The site was developed prior to the July 1, 2002 effective date of the WDO and the off street parking area is not being expanded. The applicant proposes to make incremental improvements proportional to the proposed change in use including the addition of landscape islands and resurfacing and re-striping of parking spaces. The applicant is not required to DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 34 realign the existing off street area to meet the 130-foot off street parking area depth guideline in conjunction with this proposal. These criteria are met. F. Design Standards. Outdoor Storage Standards. Outdoor storage, when permitted, shall be screened from the view of abutting streets by a solid brick or architectural block wall not less than 6, nor more than 7 feet in height. Outdoor Lighting Standards. All outdoor lighting shall be designed so that: a. Parking areas are evenly illuminated at ground level at one foot candle; ' b. Entrance and loading areas are illuminated at ground level of two foot candles; c. Illumination does not shine or reflect into any adjacent residentially zoned or used property; d. Lighting does not cast a glare onto moving vehicles on any public street. STAFF COMMENT: Outdoor storage is not proposed on the subject site. The applicant has submitted a lighting plan showing photometric values within the primary off street parking and pedestrian entrance areas to the south of the structure. The lighting plan shows photometric values ranging between 1.0 and 1.6-foot candles near the primary pedestrian entrance, which does not meet the required illumination level of 2-foot candles at pedestrian entrances. Photometric values within the off street parking area range between 1.0 and 9.0 foot candles, which meets the required illumination level of 1-foot candle within an off street parking area. A condition of approval requires the applicant to submit a revised lighting plan to the Community Development Department for review and approval prior to building permit issuance showing compliance with Section 3.107.06.F.2 in all off street parking, loading and pedestrian entrance areas. This approval criterion will be met. Section 3.110 Signs Section 3.110.04 Sign Permit Required A sign permit is required to erect, replace, construct, relocate, or alter a sign, unless such sign or action is exempt under Section 3.110.11... DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 35 STAFF COMMENT: The submitted site plan shows three wall signs on the southern building fa(;ade and one canopy sign. These signs are subject to sign permit approval in accordance with the applicable criteria of Section 3.110. Section 3.110.16 Permitted Signs - Commercial General District (CG) Signs in the CG district shall be subject to the following provisions and all other applicable provisions of Section 3.110 of the WDO. A. Pole Signs. 2. Complex. em A pole sign on a street with 300 lineal feet or more but less than 600 lineal feet of frontage shall not exceed 18 feet in height and 75 square feet in area. STAFF COMMENT: The subject site is proposed as a complex and has an existing 537 lineal feet of street frontage. An existing pole sign is located on the subject site measuring approximately 32 feet in height and 100 square feet in area, which does not meet the requirement for a maximum 18-foot tall 75 square foot pole sign at a complex in the CG zone with a street frontage between 300 and 600 lineal feet. This sign is nonconforming and is therefore subject to Section 3.110.20, discussed later in this report. C. Wall Signs. 1. Wall signs are permitted on a primary building frontage. Such signs shall not cover more than six percent of the building wall on a single tenant building or each tenant's leased wall on a multiple tenant building and shall not exceed a maximum area of 200 square feet. However, a minimum sign area of 20 square feet shall be permitted for each single tenant building or tenant in a multiple tenant building. Only one building wall shall be designated as the primary building frontage. STAFF COMMENT: The modified primary building frontage will have a wall area of 10,051 square feet, § percent of which is 603 square feet. The submitted elevation plan shows three proposed wall signs on the primary building frontage; one 135 square foot wall sign in the upper center of the curved entrance wall, one 36 square foot wall sign at the west end of the southern building fa(;ade, and one 14 square foot sign on the window of a proposed tenant space adjacent to the primary pedestrian entrance. The combined square footage of these proposed wall signs is 186 square feet, which meets the maximum 200 square foot area allowed for wall signs on a primary building frontage. As a condition of DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 36 approval, all proposed signage shall be subject to the applicable provisions of Section 3,110. This criterion will be met. Wall signs are permitted on canopies. Such signs shall be limited to no more than two sides of the canopy and shall not cover more than 15 percent of a canopy face or 50 square feet, whichever is less. STAFF COMMENT: The submitted elevation plan shows a canopy sign located on the south face of the proposed drive-thru canopy on the east side of the structure. The wall area of the south face of the proposed canopy is 156 square feet, 15 percent of which is 23.4 square feet. The proposed canopy sign is approximately 46 square feet in area, which does not meet the maximum 15 percent (23.4 square foot) allowed area for a canopy sign. As a condition of approval, all proposed signage shall be subject to the applicable provisions of Sect/on 3.110. This criterion will be met. Section 3.110.20 Nonconforming Signs. B= Nonconforming permanent signs shall comply with the provisions of Section 3.110 when one or more of the following happens: The use of the premises upon which the sign is located changes. In a complex, if the use of an individual tenant space changes, only signs attached to such tenant space shall be required to comply with Section 3.110. A Type II Design Review or Type III Conditional Use or Design Review land use application is approved for the premises on which the sign is located. In a complex, if an individual tenant space is the subject of a Type II Design Review or Type III Conditional Use or Design Review land use application, only signs attached to such tenant space shall be required to comply with the provisions of Sect/on 3.110. STAFF COMMENT: An existing pole sign is located adjacent to the southern driveway entrance on the subject site. This pole sign measures approximately 32 feet in height and 100 square feet in area, which does not meet the requirement for a maximum 18-foot tall 75 square foot pole sign at a complex in the CG zone with a street frontage between 300 and 600 lineal feet. The applicant proposes a change in use from retail to ambulatory health services, and has submitted a Type II Design Review land use application to retrofit and upgrade the building fa~:ade and site elements. The applicant is therefore required to bring the nonconforming pole sign into conformance with the applicable criteda of Section 3.110. As a condition of approval, the applicant shall submit plans to bring the DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 37 existing nonconforming pole sign into compliance with the applicable provisions of Section 3,110 prior to issuance of a building permit. Section 5.102.02 Design Review for All Structures LESS THAN 1000 Sq. Ft. Criteria. The applicable guidelines and standards of Section 3.1 shall apply and other applicable sections of the WDO. STAFF COMMENT: The compliance of the applicant's proposal with the applicable standards and guidelines of the WDO is discussed throughout this report. This approval criterion is met. Variance 05-05: The applicant is requesting a vadance to allow for 43 parking spaces to remain in the 65-foot special setback abutting Mt. Hood Avenue. WOODBURN DEVELOPMENT ORDINANCE Section 5.103.11 Variance Criteria. A determination of whether the criteria set forth are satisfied necessarily involves the balancing of competing and conflicting interest. The factors that are listed to be considered are not criteria and are not intended to be an exclusive list. The factors to be considered are used as a guide in deliberations on the application. STAFF COMMENT: Sufficient justification to approve Variance 05-05 has been provided based on the analysis of the following considerations: The variance is necessary to prevent unnecessary hardship relating to the land or structure which would cause the property to be unbuildable by application of the WDO. Factors to consider in determining whether hardship exists, include: am Physical circumstances over which the applicant has no control related to the piece of property involved that distinguish it from other land in the zone, including but not limited to lot size, shape, and topography. Whether reasonable use similar to other properties can be made of the property without the variance. Whether the hardship was created by the person requesting the variance. DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 38 STAFF COMMENT: The applicant states the following: "The vadance is necessary to allow existing non-conforming parking to remain in the required...front...yard setback. Elimination of the 43 parking spaces within the front setback is undesirable from an operational standpoint. The existing non-conforming parking areas [SIC] is a condition created prior to the property purchase by Webstar V, LLC." The combined front yard and special setback for the site is 65 feet (50-foot special setback and 15-foot required front yard setback) abutting Mt. Hood Avenue and the submitted site plan shows 43 existing parking spaces currently located in the 15-foot front yard setback. The 43 non-conforming parking spaces are existing and the applicant is not required to meet all off street parking and loading standards in conjunction with this Type II Design Review because the proposed change in use does not increase the required parking for the site by 25% or more. The 43 non-conforming parking spaces cannot be provided elsewhere on the site and the removal of 43 parking spaces is not proportional to the impact of the change in use of the existing structure from a retail center to an ambulatory health services center, which have the same parking requirement. Mt. Hood Avenue is a state highway under the jurisdiction of the Oregon Department of Transportation (ODOT). Comments received from ODOT regarding this proposal do not require the applicant to provide improvements to the existing Mt. Hood Avenue dght of way in conjunction with this proposal. The applicant has shown on the submitted site and landscaping plans that the required street improvement of Mt. Hood Avenue, including curb line sidewalks, landscape strip and street trees are currently provided within the existing dght of way abutting the southern property line. This hardship was not created by the person requesting the variance. e Development consistent with the request will not be materially injurious to adjacent properties. Factors to be considered in determining whether development consistent with the variance is materially injurious include but are not limited to: Physical impacts such development will have because of the variance, such as visual, noise, traffic and drainage, erosion and landslide hazards. b. Incremental impacts occurring as a result of the proposed variance. STAFF COMMENT: The applicant states: "The existing non-conforming parking areas are currently screened, and will be further screened by proposed landscape materials along the DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 39 property line on Mt. Hood Avenue. No changes in this design or way the existing parking areas are used are contemplated." Mt. Hood Avenue is a state highway under the jurisdiction of the Oregon Department of Transportation (ODOT) and comments received from ODOT regarding this proposal do not require the applicant to provide improvements to the existing Mt. Hood Avenue dght of way in conjunction with this proposal. The existing landscape strip abutting Mt. Hood Avenue along the south property line incorporates a 24-inch high berm feature and the applicant has submitted a landscaping plan showing a hedge of Green Island Holly (Ilex crenata "Green Island") to be planted atop the existing 24-inch berm. Green Island Holly grows to a height of 2 feet in height and the combined 48-inch screen height (24-inch berm and 24-inch hedge) meets the off street parking screening requirement of Section 3,106.03,A,2.b. 2). No physical or incremental impacts will result from the granting of this variance. g Existing physical and natural systems, such as but not limited to traffic, drainage, dramatic land forms or parks will not be adversely affected because of the variance. STAFF COMMENT: The site is currently developed as a retail center with existing structures, off street parking and landscaping. Traffic, drainage, landforms and natural systems will not be adversely affected by granting this variance. The variance is the minimum deviation necessary to make reasonable economic use of the property; STAFF COMMENT: The applicant indicates that allowing the 43 existing off street parking spaces to remain in the 65-foot special setback abutting Mt. Hood Avenue is the minimum deviation nece.ssary to make reasonable economic use of the property. The 43 non-conforming parking spaces are existing and cannot be provided elsewhere on the site. The applicant is not required to meet all off street parking and loading standards in conjunction with this Type II Design Review because the proposed change in use does not increase the required parking for the site by 25% or more. Removal of 43 parking spaces is not proportional to the impact of the change in use of the existing structure from a retail center to an ambulatory health services center, which have the same parking requirement. The applicant has shown on the submitted site and landscaping plans that the required street improvement of Mt. Hood Avenue, including curb line sidewalks, landscape strip and street trees are currently provided within the existing right of way abutting the southern property line. w The variance does not conflict with the Woodburn Comprehensive Plan. DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 40 IV. STAFF COMMENT: The Woodburn Development Ordinance and Transportation System Plan implement the goals and policies in the Woodburn Comprehensive Plan (WCP). WCP Section IX Goals and Policies states, "...Architectural design of commercial areas should be attractive with...enough landscaping to reduce the visual impact of large expanses of asphalt parking areas." The applicant requests variance approval to allow the 43 existing off street parking spaces located in the 65-foot combined special and required front yard abutting Mt. Hood Avenue to remain. The proposed 24-inch hedge of Green Island Holly (Ilex crenata "Green Island") to be planted atop the existing 24-inch berm separating the off street parking area from Mt. Hood Avenue will effectively mitigate any visual impact associated with granting of this variance. The proposed development does not conflict with the policies of the WCP. CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION: Based on the information in this report, the information provided by the applicant and the applicable review criteria, findings required to approve Design Review 05-01 and Vadance 05-05 can be made. Therefore, staff recommends approval of Design Review 05-01 and Variance 05-05 subject to the following conditions of approval: CONTITIONS OF APPROVAL COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT: Design Review 05-01: The proposed development shall be in substantial conformance with the attached preliminary plans provided in Exhibit "A" (Site Plan [Sheet A1.1], Floor Plan [Sheet A2.1], Building Elevations [Sheet A3.1], Grading/Utility Plan [Sheet C1 and Lighting Plan [Sheet El.0] date stamped April 8, 2005; Landscaping Plan [Sheets L2.1 and L2.2] and Materials Plan [Sheets L1.1 and L1.2] date stamped April 20, 2005; and Colored Elevation and Materials Sample Board date stamped February 1, 2005); except as herein modified by these conditions of approval. The property owner/applicant shall submit to the Community Development Department a signed "Acceptance of Conditions" agreeing to all conditions of approval prior to the issuance of building permits for the project. This approval shall expire within the time period specified by City ordinance (currently one year from the date of the final decision). Expiration of a final decision shall require a new application. DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 41 o go The applicant shall request building permit occupancy review by the Community Development Department a minimum of seven days prior to the issuance of final occupancy. Any conditions attached to this design review approval shall be conditions on the issuance of a building permit unless otherwise stated. A violation of the conditions shall be considered a violation of the Woodbum Development Ordinance. Prior to building permit issuance, the applicant shall submit a revised site plan to the Community Development Department for review and approval showing the following modifications: The drive-through and bypass lane pertaining to the proposed Urgent Care patient drop-off area shall be modified to comply with WDO Section 3. I04.02.D. The proposed 4-foot wide pedestrian walkway abutting the east margin of the primary driveway entrance shall be modified to connect to the existing curb line sidewalk abutting Mt. Hood Avenue. Co A driveway cross-connection shall be provided with the properties to the east aligned with the 24-foot wide driveway cross-access easement provided in Partition Case File No. 04-05. Any parking spaces eliminated by creation of the cross-connection shall be replaced on-site. Bicycle racks shall be relocated from the loading zone abutting the north side of the structure to within 50 feet of the main entrance on the south side of the existing building. Pdor to building permit issuance, the applicant shall submit a final irrigation plan to the Community Development Department for review and approval. All shrubs and ground cover shall be of a size upon installation so as to attain 80% of ground coverage within 3 years. Pdor to issuance of a building permit, the applicant shall submit an elevation plan of the proposed common refuse collection facility with a solid metal gate to the Community Development Department for review and approval. 10. Pdor to issuance of a building permit, the applicant shall submit a final lighting plan to the Community Development Department for review and DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 42 approval showing compliance with Section 3.107.06.F. 2 in all off street parking, loading and pedestrian entrance areas. 11. Prior to issuance of a building permit, the applicant shall submit a revised landscaping plan showing a Roundleaf laurustinus hedge along the northeast property line to the Community Development Department for review and approval. 12.The property owner shall be responsible for maintaining all landscaping in good condition so as to present a healthy and orderly appearance. Unhealthy and dead plants shall be removed and replaced in conformance with the approved landscaping plan. 13. Placement of all signage shall be subject to the standards of Section 3.110. 14. Pdor to building occupancy, the applicant shall bring the existing nonconforming pole sign into compliance with the applicable provisions of Section 3.110. 15. Prior to building permit issuance, proposed shared access easement agreements shall be submitted to the Community Development Department for review and approval subject to legal documentation to the satisfaction of the City Attorney. Said agreements shall be recorded with the County Recorder. Variance 05..05: 16. This variance approval allows parking spaces abutting the south property line to remain in the special setback from the centerline of Mt. Hood Avenue and required front yard setback as shown on Exhibit "A" (Site plan [Sheet A1.1 date stamped April 8, 2005]). This variance shall not apply to any subsequent development of the subject property. PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT: GENERAL CONDITIONS: 17.The applicant, not the City, is responsible for obtaining permits from any state and/or federal agencies, which may require approval and/or permit. 18.AII work within the public rights-of-way or public facilities within public easement shall require plan approval and permit issuance from the Public Works Department. DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 43 19. System Development fees shall be reviewed for the change and increase of use. If appropriate, additional fees shall be paid at the time of building permit issuance. SANITARY SEWER: 20.A Grease trap will be required to be installed on the sanitary service, either as a central unit or in each kitchen/food preparation area. Contact Marion County Plumbing Department for permit and installation requirements at (503) 588-5147. WATER: 21 .The current level of backflow protection, double detector check device, on the fire sprinkler service and reduced pressure device on domestic service is adequate for the proposed use. The landscape irrigation meter shall be upgraded with double detector check backflow device at the meter. Contact Larry Arendt, City of Woodburn Cross Connection Inspector, for installation requirements at 503-982-5283. 22. The relocation of the existing fire hydrant as identified on the plan shall be relocated by the property owner/applicant in accordance with city standards and specifications. A utility easement shall be provided to the city for the relocated hydrant if it is not within the existing easement currently conveyed to the City. VII. ATTACHMENTS: Exhibit "A" Exhibit "B" Attachment "A" Attachment "B" Attachment "C" Attachment "D" Site Plan [Sheet A1.1], Floor Plan [Sheet A2.1], Building Elevations [Sheet A3.1], Grading/Utility Plan [Sheet C1 and Lighting Plan [Sheet El.0] date stamped April 8, 2005; Landscaping Plan [Sheets L2.1 and L2.2] and Materials Plan [Sheets L1.1 and L1.2] date stamped April 20, 2005; and Colored Elevation and Materials Sample Board date stamped February 1, 2005 Design Review and Variance Applications Zoning Map Comprehensive Plan Map Public Works Department Comments Oregon Department of Transportation Comments DR 05-01, VAR 05-05 Page 44 II , I I _ I Il! i~J I ,I ili,ljjjj I [[! 1-1 -- 1.! I,I I I I I I ! ! CITY OF WOODBURN Community Development Department Related Files:~q~'J~ Date Received'aL///~ ~- Fees ~eiv~:~ ~ ~.~:)~ o/ 270 Montgomery Street · Woodburn, Oregon 9707! Phone: 503-982-5246 · Fax: 503-982-5244 · Website Address: www.ci.woodburn.or.~EE~ 0 ] 2005 UNIFORM APPI./CATION ;e eral %nformation )reject location Property owner ~ailing Telephone & Fax No. (r~) E-mail Addre~ (z~rec=~ c=~nteea) I Comprehen~ive Plan Zone Map De~ignetion nation W00DBURN COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPT. Applicant Hailing Addres~ Telephone & Fax No. E-mail Addr,,~_- (ae-,~ A_~w Map & Tax ~ No. Description of the proposal (~ =krona,ecru) ~.l~TJ~' :eq uested Review 1 c3 ACCESS PERM[T TO CITY STREET 2 r~ ANNEXATION 3 m APPEAL TO CITY COUNCIL 4 ~ COMP. PLAN MAP CHANGE S [3 CONDIT[ONAL USE 7~~IGN REVIEW 13 D FORMAL INTERPRETAT[ON OF THE WDO 14 o MDP PREUMINARY APPROVAL 15 r~ MDP FINAL PLAN APPROVAL 16 o MODI~CAI'ZON OF CONDITIONS 17 r~ PARTLTION PREI TM[NARY APPROVAL 18 r~ PARTIT/ON fiNAL PLAT APPROVAL 19 n PHASING PLAN 8 [] EXCrd~O~ TO ST. ROW & ;~PROV~HmT REQ. 20 r~ PUD PREUMINARY PLAN APPROVAL 9 [] EXTENSION FOR A DEV. DECL51ON 21 [] PUD DESIGN PLAN fiNAL APPROVAL 10 E3 FE~ & FR~. STANDING WALL PRE-CONST REV. 22 [] PUD FINAL PLAN APPROVAL 11 [] GRADING PERMIT [2 n H~STOeJC Oe AeC~. S~N~R. ~i~ r.s~r=caqc cu 23 [] LLA & CONSOliDATION OF LOTS 24 r~ RS ARCH. STANDARDS SUBD[V. kpplicant Certification cc~ec~ M ~.=) 25 r~ REVOC~T~Oa C~ PREWOUStY Ae~VEO F~e. Nrr 26 ~ ~OD PE~ 27 ~ SPE~ USE ~ A CU 28 ~ ~B. ~UMZNARY ~OVAL 29 D SUB. ~N~ P~T ~PROVAL 30 ~ ~~ r~. ~ ~ ~, ~ 31 ~ ~M~RY ~R PERM~ 32 ~ ~ R~OV~ PERM~ 33 o VA~ ~ ~ ZONING AD~U~M~T 35 ~ ZONE C~GE 36 o OTHER: % hereby declare that as applicant for this proposal, % have familiarized myself with the relevant provisions of the City of Woodbum Development Ordinance; and % hm~ reed the foregoing mppllc]tlon and know the contents of the application to be tree to the best of my knowledge (if applicant is not same ms property .o~mer, own. er s.hal. I a....u~, ze applica?t to rep.ruent h~lher~etmLe~t in the above referenced application by signing below). (~or/~ ~s~ W<~o M a~a Jol~te d~ Owner (~r~, ge/due'm) IJ ]P_ I~_ <~4~J~[~/~ L C. [ '"~_ _fl~'~ '( ( ~Applicant (F~ma d~ .~tante) Y~~ C L A R K ~ K J 0 S MEMORANDUM Page 1 Project Wellspring Medical Center 1475 Mount Hood Avenue Woodbum, OR 07071 Date January 31, 2005 Revised March 22, 2005 Project # 04048 Subject Distribution Woodbum Development Guidelines Findings of Conformance with Approval Criteria Type II Design Review Issues - for expansion adding less than 10% gross floor area~ Findings are listed below in italics. 2,1 2.106 2.106.01 ITEM LA_ND USE ZONING Commercial General (CG) Permitted Uses The proposed project does not change the permitted use. Eo Retail Use~ Tbe p~posed food and beverage stores, and tbe proposed health and personal care stores are permitted uses. M. Health Care and Social Services Proposed ambulatory health services are permitted uses. P. Other Services Proposed personal care services are permitted uses. 2.106.05 A Dimensional Standards Lot Standards. The lot area is adequate for accommodating the structures within the required setbacks. B Building Height. The building height is 35', well within the maximum 70' requirement C Setback and Buffer Improvement Standards. The proposed building design meets the WDO standards for Front Yard Setback and Setback Abutting a Street, and Interior Side and Rear Yard Setbacks, as described below in the findings for Section 3.1 Development Guidelines and Standards. 2.106.06 Development Standards A Off Street Parking. C L A R K // K J O S MEMORANDUM Page 2 B C D E F The re-striping and curb re-alignments for extsting parking stalls and travel lanes, along with the proposed new parking and drive lanes conform to the requirements of Sections 2.106. 06 and Section 3.105 as described below in the findings for Section 3.1 Development Guidelines and Standards. Setbacks and Lots, Generally. The proposed design meets the WDO standards for Front Yard Setback and Setback Abutting a Street, and Interior Side and Rear Yard Setbacks, as described below in the findings for Section 3.1 Development Guidelines and Standards. Architectural Design Guidelines. The proposed design meets the WDO standards Architectural Design Guidelines and Open Space Standards, as described below in the findings for Section 3.1 Development Guidelines and Standards. Signs. 1. Proposed stgnage will be in conformance with the recently amended Woodburn Sign Ordinance as described in the findings for Section 3.1 Development Guidelines and Standards (to be submitted for separate design approval process). Landscaping and Sidewalks. 2. The provisions of the Landscaping Standards section do not apply to the entire site since the area increase of the proposed building and parking area expansion is only 50% more than existed on the date of the WDO adoption. 3. The proposed landscape improvements will meet requirements of WDO Sections 3.103.10, 3.106 and 3.107.06, as described below in the findings for Section 3.1 Development Guidelines and Standards. 4. Plans include the provision of a concrete block wall enclosure with solid gates around the refuse collection containers to be located against the northwest corner of the building. Property Disposition. The proposed uses will be established and conducted on lots of record as required. Development of site improvements will comply with City of Woodburn public facility and access standards as required. 3.101 3.101.02 A DEVELOPMENT GUIDELINES AND STANDARDS Street Standards General Provisions The existing driveway for the lot connected to Mt. Hood Avenue is designed to comply with Section 3.104. No modifications are proposed. C L A R K ~ K J O S MEMORANDUM Page 3 B C D E G H 3.101.03 A Access permit requirements relative to construction of intemal street(s) boundary street(s) and abutting street(s). Do not apply - no modifications are proposed. Design and Construction Standards. No modifications are proposed. Street Right of Way and Improvement Standards for Development. No modifications proposed. Private Streets. No private streets are proposed. Termination of Streets, Bikeways and/or Pedestrian Ways. No modifications are proposed. Block Standards. No modifications are proposed. Street Names. Does not apply. Right of Way Landscaping and Street Trees. See "Development Standards" for the subject zoning district, Section 2.1. Improvements to the street frontage of the property along Mt. Hood Avenue include the installation of new ornamental shrub beds. Shrub beds will meet requirements described in WDO Section 3.106.03. Existing street trees be retained to meet requirements per WDO Section 3.106.03. Sidewalks. No modifications are proposed to sidewalks located in the right of way line. Ri?.ht of Way and Improvement Sta.clards (Figure 6.9) Street right of way and improvements. No right of way improvements are proposed. 3.102 3.102.01 3.102.02 Utilities and Easements Water. Sanitary_ Sewer and Storm Drainage Facilities Municipal water, sanitary sewer and storm drainage facilities will be installed to applicable Public works Department and state standards as required. Underground Utilities All permanent utility service to development shall be underground EXCEPT where overhead high-voltage electric facilities exist and for partitioned lots are C L A R K // K J O S MEMORANDUM Page 4 3.102.03 A 3.102.04 A B C currently served by overhead wires or cables. Outdoor Li_mhting Public Streets. No modification to public street lighting is proposed. Easements Easements exist on site for various municipal services. Municipal Infrastructure Easements. The Public works Department shall require dedication of specific easements for the construction and maintenance of municipal water, sewerage and storm drainage facilities located on private property shall be required in accordance with the Public Works Department standards. Public Utility Easements OaUE). Fire, foot wide public utility easements (i.e., easements for natural gas lines and for electric and telecommunications wire or cable service) shall be dedicated along each lot line abutting a public street. At the time of tentative approval, utilities may request dedication of a public utility easement within a reciprocal access easement or centered along specified rear lot line in those zones where zero setback is not permitted. Creek~ and Watercourse Maintenance Easements. Does not apply. 3.103 3.103.O1 Setback, Open Space and Lot Standards, Generally Setback. Open Space. Generally The project design complies with setback and open space requirements with the exception of setback requirements for existing paved parking areas. An application for a variance will be ftled to allow existing paved parking areas to remain within the front and side setback areas on the lot. 3.103.02 Lot Coverage. Generally The lot is zoned Commercial General (CG), and is adequately sized to contain the structure within the required setbacks. No minimum width or depth is stipulated in the WDO. 3.103.03 Setbacks. Setback Area and Required Open Space. Generally Existing off street parking spaces fall within the required 15' Front Yard Set Back measured from the 5~foot Special Setback for a major arterial. The existing "front yard' abutting Mt. Hood Avenue is 304' and will be reduced by C L A R K // K J 0 S MEMORANDUM Page 5 3.103.04 3.103.05 3.103.06 3.103.07 3.103.08 3.103.09 3.103.10 B approximately 24' with the proposed entrance facade addition. Existing relationships between the building and paved areas relative to Interior Side and Rear Yard Setbacks are as follows: A portion of the west side of the existing building is located on the west property line. Existing off street parking areas along the south property line fall within the required 15-foot setback. Existing off street maneuvering areas along the northeast and northwest corners of the property fall within the required 5-foot setbacks. An application for variance will be filed as noted above. Separation of Lot or Setback The lot is not being separated in ownership. Setback areas and required open spaces are not being separated from the lot. Special Street Setback The off street parktng, maneuvering and storage areas meet the 50-foot Special Setback requirement for major arterials. No Parking or Storage in Setback~ Adjacent to a Street Existing off street parking spaces along Mt. Hood Avenue are located within the required 15' setback adjacent to a street. An application for variance will be filed as noted above. Projections into the Setback Adjacent to a Street No portion of the building projects into the setback adjacent to a street. Projections in the Interior Side Yard Setback No portion of the building projects into the interior side yard setback. Projections in the Interior IZe~__r Yard Setback No portion of the building projects into the interior rear yard setback. Vision Clearance Area, Street-Driveway Intersection The existing design of the driveway intersection at Mt. Hood Avenue meets the required vision clearance area dimensional requirements stipulated by the WDO. All adjacent landscape areas and site walls will comply wttb WDO Standards Section 3.103. I0. 3.104 3.104.01 Access The lot bas an existing driveway access from Mt. Hood Avenue, and through an access easement to Progress Way, to the west. No Traffic Impact Analysis is anticipated, since no change in use on the lot within the CG zone is C L A R K // K J O S MEMORANDUM Page 6 3.104.02 3.104.03 3.104.05 contemplated. Driveway and Drive-Through Measurements and Dimensions The existing 42' driveway width complies with WDO minimum width requirements. (12' lane width - 36/40feet w/ turning lane w/ "No Parking" restrictions / 50' lane length / 30' radius of curb flare). Driveway Access Guidelines. Type II and III Applications No driveway improvements are proposed. Driveway DimeosJon and Improvement Standards. Type I. H and HI No driveway improvements are proposed. 3.105 3.105.01 3.105.02 A Off Street Parking and Loading Applicability The proposed improvements meet parking, loading and landscaping requirements required by the WDO. General Provisions for Off Street Parkinz and Loadine Reduction of Parking and Loading Spaces Prohibited. The number of parking spaces meets the required ratios as follows: Parking Ratio Ambulatory Health Services l. O / 250 sfg]'a Required Proposed 338 339 B C D The number of loading spaces meets the required 4.0 / 82,000+ sfgfa as follows: Total Loading Spaces Loading Ratio Required Proposed 4 4 Ownership of Parking. The land for off street parking is owned by the owner of the building served by the parking area. Fractional Measurements. See calculations in Item 3.105. 02.A above. Location of Off Street Parking. Off street parktng spaces are on the same lot as the building served, and therefore is located in the same use zone. E Off Street Vehicle Parking Requirements. C L A R K // K J 0 S MEMORANDUM Page 7 F G H See calculations in Item 3.105.02.A above. The total number of parktng spaces includes 2 van~accesstble and 8 required dtsabled person vehicle parking spaces. No parking spaces are located within the public right-of-way. All parking spaces are intended for customers and employees only. Compact Vehicle Parking. The proposed design incorporates tbe existing parking stall configurations which meet standard stall dtmensions per WDO Section 3.105.02, Table 3.1.4. No compact vehicle parking spaces are planned. Off Street Loading Requirements. Two existing off street loading spaces are located at the nortbeast corner of the building and will be distinctly marked. A third loading space is located along the north side of the building. ?be fourth required loading space is located near the northwest corner of the building. On-Site Vehicle Parking and Loading Area Improvement Requirements. The proposed improvements to the existing parking area will meet surfacing, drainage, wheel barrier, parking space and maneuvering area, directional marking, space marking, access, outdoor lighting and landscaping standards set forth in the WIX). Twenty on-site bicycle parking rack spaces Cone plus one/ten vebtcle parktng spaces, with a max. 20 twenty rack spaces) will be provided near main building entrances per WDO Section 3.105.02.H. Joint Use vehicle Parking. No parking areas are planned for joint use as loading areas. The required loading areas are separate and distinctly marked as described above. 3.106 3.106.01 Landscaping Standards Proposed landscaping at areas of construction impact will comply with WDO standards as required. The primary areas of impact include · 12,83 7 sq. ft. area including the property's street frontage at Mt. Hood Ave. and landscaping at the entrance driveway. · 7,463 sq. ft. entrance plaza planting beds at the south and east face of the building. · 7,969 sq. ft. within tntertorparktng islands · Approx. 7'wide planting strip at the eastpertmeter of property. · Approx. 15'wide planting strip at the north perimeter of property. · Approx. 11 'wide planting strip at the southeastpertmeter ofproperty. The provisions of the Landscaping Standards section do not apply to the entire site since the area increase of the proposed building and parking area C L A R K // K J O S MEMORANDUM Page 8 expansion is only 50% more than existed on the date of the WDO adoption. 3.106.02 Coeneral Re(]_uirements The proposed landscape improvements will meet requtrements for plants, irrigation, plant materials, installation of plant materials and irrigation system, and maintenance set forth in the WDO. All planttng areas will be permanently irrigated. See enclosed drawings L 1.1 Conceptual Landscape Site Plan and L2.1 Conceptual Planting Plan. 3.106.03 A Streetscape. Existing street trees will be retained along Mt. Hood Avenue to meet requirements of Section 3.106.03.4. All streetscape planting will meet densities per WDO standards and planttng abutting Mt. Hood Avenue wtll provtde a 42" vertical screen for adjacent parked cars. B Buffer Yards. All planting will meet densities per WDO standards. C Off Street Parking Areas. All planting will meet denstties per WDO standards. Landscape areas, inclusive of surrounding multi, purpose landscaping, will meet the 20% minimum equivalency wtth paved areas. Tree planting in tbe prlmary parking area will exceed requirements per Section 3.106. 03 (1 large tree per 14 parking spaces). D Common Areas. All planting will meet densities per WDO standards. E Yards. All planting will meet densities per WDO standards. 3.106.04 Consenration of Significant Trees No Significant Trees as defined by WDO standards exist on the property. 3.106.05 Planting Standards The proposed landscape improvements will meet requirements for plant material distribution, ground cover and curbs set forth in the WDO. See enclosed drawing L2.1 Conceptual Planting Plan. 3.107 3.107.06 A ArchitecULral Design Guidelines and Standards Guidelines and Standards for Non-Residential Structures in RS. R1 S. RM. CO. CG and P/SP. Applicability. The design guidelines for the proposed building improvements apply in the CG zone. B Architectural Design Guidelines. The objective is to transform the former K-Mart windowless "box" into a warm inviting health center that adds to and enhances the community. The C: L A R K // K J O S MEMORANDUM Page 9 proposed curving facade of the building expansion creates transitional indoor / outdoor spaces tied to various *tenant~ spaces The new main entrance features a curving glass entrance canopy. The new curving wall is . predominantly earth- red stucco with stone accents. New window openings are puncbed into the existing masonry wall structure. The proposed landscape setting at the entrance lobby structure will be enhanced with new plantings, speclalty pavtng and open walkways. Low stone ~garden' walls and a small reflective water feature form an inviting courtyard near the entrance canopy. The roofltne of the curved entrance facade rises above the existing masonry structure. The curved glass entrance canopy roof with exposed wood structure is set at a lower plane to provide weather protection and presents a more human scale to customers and staff. Roof mounted equipment is located behind roof parapets, out of site, on the existing structure. All other mechanical equipment is either screened or located inside the building. The building character is defined by the use of natural materials, colorful stone tiles, and earth tone colors that are appropriate for the proposed landscaped setting. Stgnage ts planned for the low garden wall near the car drop~ff area at the entrance canopy. Buffer walls are not planned for this expansion project and are not required for a CG zone abutting IP and CG zones. Sidewalk improvements and additional street trees are not planned along Mt. Hood Avenue for tbis project. Tbe existing streetscape will he enhanced wtth the addition of new ornamental shrub plantings. Solar access protection of any solar devices on abutting properties is not impacted by any of tbe planned development for this project. C Site and Building Access Guidelines. Vehicular access to and from the site will be enhanced with the addition of new landscaping and a new monument sign at the driveway area. All on-site parking lots are connected internally. Pedestrian access to and from the site will be enhanced by a new accessible walk along the east side of the entrance drive, which will connect the property to the existing sidewalk and bus stop on Mt. Hood Avenue. Pathways delineated by decorative paving mark the pedestrian patbs to the building entrance. The primary parking area is designed with landscaped buffers between every 15 spaces at most. D Building Location Guidelines. The proposed expansion to the south side of the existing building is well within the required setbacks. C L A R K // K J O S MEMORANDUM Page 10 E F 3.110 3.110.16 Parking Location Guidelines. Existing off street parktng areas located between the front of the building and the abutting streets occupy a "depth~ of approximately 280feet. Design Standards. Outdoor Storage: NA Outdoor fighting levels are designed as follows: Existtng parking areas 1-12fc (Ifc minimum req'd) average Entrance and Loading 5 fc (2 fc minimum req'd) average Illumination does not impact abutting properties (zoned IP and CG). Lighting does not cast a glare onto vehicles on Mt. Hood Avenue. Signs Permitted Signs-Commercial General. To be submitted for separate design approval process. End of Memo By Matthew Spicer C L A R K // K J 0 S MEMORANDUM P~el Project Wellspring Medical Center Date 1475 Mount Hood Avenue Woodburn, OR 07071 January 31, 2005 Project # 04048 Subject Distribution Woodbum Development Guidelines Findings of Conformance with Approval Criteria REC'D FEB 0 1 WOODBUBN COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPT. Type II Design Review Issues - for expansion adding less than 10% gross floor area_ Findings are listed below in italics. 2,1 2.106 2.106.01 ITEM LAND USE ZONING Commercial General (CG) Permitted Uses The proposed project does not change tbe permttted use. Retail Uses The proposed food and beverage stores, and the proposed health and personal care stores are permitted uses. M. Health Care and Social Services Proposed ambulatory health services are permitted uses. P. Other Services Proposed personal care services are permitted uses. 2.106.05 A Dimensional Standard~ Lot Standards. The lot area is adequate for accommodating the structures within the required setbacks. B Building Height. The building height is 35; well within the maximum 70' requirement. C Setback and Buffer Improvement Standards. The proposed building design meets the WDO standards for Front Yard Setback and Setback Abutting a Street, and Interior Side and Rear Yard Setbacks, as described below in the findings for Section 3.1 Development Guidelines and Standards. 2.106.06 Development Standards A Off Street Parking. C L A R K // K J O S MEMORANDUM Page 2 B C D E The re.striping and curb re-alignments for existtng parktng stalls and travel lanes, along with the proposed new parking and drive lanes conform to the requirements of Sections 2.106.06 and Section 3.105 as described below in the findings for Section 3.1 Development Guidelines and Standards. Setbacks and Lots, Generally. The proposed design meets the wDo standards for Front Yard Setback and Setback Abutting a Street, and Interior Side and Rear Yard Setbacks, as described below in the findings for Section 3.1 Development Guidelines and Standards. Architectural Design Guidelines. The proposed design meets the WDO standards Arcbttectural Design Guidelines and Open Space Standards, as described below in the findings for Section 3.1 Development Guidelines and Standards. Signs. 1. Proposed stgnage will be in conformance with the recently amended Woodburn Sign Ordinance as described in the findings for Section 3.1 Development Guidelines and Standards (to he submitted for separate design approval process). lmndscaping and Sidewalks. 2. The provisions of the Landscaping Standards section do not apply to the entire site since the area increase of the proposed building and parking area expansion is only 50% more than existed on the date of the WIX) adoption. 3. The proposed landscape improvements will meet requirements of WDO Sections 3.103.10, 3.106 and 3.10Z06, as described below in the findings for Section 3.1 Development Guidelines and Standards. 4. Plans include the provision of a concrete block wall enclosure with solid gates around the refuse collection containers to be located against the northwest corner of the building. F Property Disposition. The proposed uses will be established and conducted on lots of record as required. Development of site improvements will comply with City of Woodburn public facility and access standards as required. 3.1 3.101 3.101.02 A DEVELOPMENT GUIDELINES AND STANDARDS Street Standards General Provisions The existing driveway for the lot connected to Mt. Hood Avenue is designed to comply with Section 3.104. No modifications are proposed. C L A R K // K J 0 S MEMORANDUM Page 3 B C D Access permit requirements relative to construction of internal street(s) boundary street(s) and abutting street(s). Do not apply - no modifications are proposed. Design and Construction Standards. No modifications are proposed. Street Right of Way and Improvement Standards for Development. No modifications proposed. E Private Streets. No private streets are proposed. F Termination of Streets, Bikeways and/or Pedestrian Ways. No modifications are proposed. G Block Standards. No modifications are proposed. H 3.101.03 A Street Names. Does not apply. Right of Way Landscaping and Street Trees. See 'Developmem Standards~ for the subject zoning district, Section 2.1. Improvements to the street frontage of the property along Mt. Hood Avenue include the installation of new ornamental shrub beds. Shrub beds will meet requirements described in WDO Section 3.106. 03. Existing street trees be retained to meet requirements per WDO Section 3.106.03. Sidewalks. No modifications are proposed to sidewalks located in the right of way line. gi?ht of Way and Improvement Standards (Figure 6.9) Street right of way and improvements. No right of way improvements are proposed. 3.102 3.102.01 3.102.02 IJt, ilities and Easements Water. Sanitary_ Sewer and Storm Drainaee Facilities Municipal water, sanitary sewer and storm drainage facilities will be installed to applicable Public works Department and state standards as required. Undereround Utilities All permanent utility service to development shall be underground EXCEPT where overhead high-voltage electric facilities exist and for parttttoned lots are C L A R K // K J O S MEMORANDUM Page 4 3.102.03 A 3.102.04 A B C currently served by overhead wires or cables. OT]t0oor Lighting Public Streets. No modification to public street lighting is proposed. Easements Easements exist on site for various municipal services. Municipal Infrastructure Easements. Tbe Public works Department shall require dedication of specific easements for the construction and maintenance of municipal water, sewerage and storm drainage facilities located on private property shall be required in accordance with the Public Works Department standards. Public Utility Easements (PUE). Five-foot wtde publtc utility easements (i.e., easements for natural gas lines and for electric and telecommunications wire or cable service) shall be dedicated along each lot line abutting a public street. At the time of tentative approval, utilities may request dedtcaelon of a public utility easement within a reciprocal access easement or centered along specified rear lot line in those zones where zero setback is not permitted. Creeks and Watercourse Maintenance Easements. Does not apply. 3.103 3.103.01 Setback, Open Space and Lot Standards, Generally Setback. Ope_ n Space. Generally The project design complies with setback and open space requirements with the exception of setback requirements for existing paved parking areas. An application for a variance will be filed to allow existing paved parking areas to remain within the front and side setback areas on the lot. 3.103.02 Lot Coverage. Generally The lot is zoned Commercial General (CG), and is adequately sized to contain the structure within the required setbacks. No minimum width or depth is stipulated in the WDO. 3.103.03 Setbacks. Setback Area and Required Open Space. Generally Existing off street parking spaces fall within the required 15' Front Yard Set Back measured from the 50-foot Special Setback for a major arterial. The existing "front yard' abutting Mt. Hood Avenue is 304' and will be reduced by C L A R K // K J O S MEMORANDUM Page 5 3.103.04 3.103.05 3.103.06 3.103.07 3.103.08 3.103.09 3.103.10 B approximately 24' with the proposed entrance facade addition. Existing relationships between the building and paved areas relative to Interior Side and Rear Yard Setbacks are as follows: A portion of the west side of the existing building is located on the west property line. Existing off street parktng areas along the south property line fall within the required 15-foot setback. Existing off street maneuvering areas along the northeast and northwest comers of the property fall within the required 5-foot setbacks. An application for variance will be filed as noted above. Separation of Lot or Setback Areas The lot is not being separated in ownership. Setback areas and required open spaces are not being separated from the lot. Special Street Setback The off street parktng, maneuvering and storage areas meet the 5Ofoot Special Setback requirement for major arterials. No parkin_o or Storage in Setbacks Adjacent to a Street Existing off street parking spaces along Mt. Hood Avenue are located within the required 15' setback adjacent to a street. An application for variance will be filed as noted above. Projections into the Setback Ad}acent to a Street No portion of the building projects into the setback adjacent to a street. Projections in the Interior Side Yard Setback No portion of the building projects into the interior side yard setback. Projections in the Interior Rear Yard Setback No portion of the building projects into the interior rear yard setback. Vision Clearance Area Street-Driveway Intersection The existing design of the driveway intersection at Mt. Hood Avenue meets the required vision clearance area dimensional requirements stipulated by the WDO. All adjacent landscape areas and site walls will comply with WDO Standards Section 3.103.10. 3.104 3.104.01 Access Applicability. The lot bas an existing driveway access from Mt. Hood Avenue, and through an access easement to Progress Way, to the west. lVo Traffic Impact Analysis is anticipated, since no change in use on the lot within the CG zone is C L A R K // K J 0 S MEMORANDUM Page 6 3.104.02 3.104.03 3.104.05 conte~nplated. Driveway and Drive-Throu?-h Measurements and Dimensions The existing 42' driveway width complies with WDO minimum width requirements. (12' lane width - 36/40feet w/ turning lane w/ "No Parking" restrictions / 50' lane length / 30' radius of curb flare). Driveway Access Guidelines. Type H and III Applications No driveway improvements are proposed. Driveway Dimension and Improvement Standards. T_ _vpe I. H and In No driveway improvements are proposed. 3.105 3.105.01 3.105.02 A Off Street Parking and Loading Tbe proposed improvements meet parking, loading and landscaping requirements required by the WDO. General Provisions for Off Street Parking and Loading Reduction of Parking and Loading Spaces Prohibited. The number of parking spaces meets the required ratios as follows: Parking Ratio Required Ambulatory Health Services 1.0 / 250 sfgfa 184 Administrative & Support 1.0/350 sfgfa 41 Storage 1.0 / 900 sfgfa 7 Health Care Stores 1.0 / 250 sfg[a 16 Food & Drinking Place 10 + 1.0 / 200 sfgfa 28 Propo~d Total Parking Spaces 276 331 B C The number of loading spaces meets the required 4.0 / 82,000+ sfgfa as follows: Total Loading Spaces Loading Ratio Required Proposed 4 4 Ownership of Parking. The land for off street parktng is owned by the oumer of the building served by the parktng area. Fractional Measurements. See calculations in Item 3.105.02.A above. C L A R K // K J 0 S MEMORANDUM Page 7 D E F G H Location of Off Street Parking. Off street parktng spaces are on the same lot as the building served, and therefore is located in the same use zone. Off Street Vehicle Parking Requirements. See calculations in Item 3.105.02.A above. The total number of parking spaces includes 2 van~accessible and 8 required disabled person vehicle parking spaces. No parking spaces are located within the public right-of-way. All parking spaces are intended for customers and employees only. Compact Vehicle Parking. The proposed design incorporates the existing parking stall configurations which meet standard stall dtrnenstons per WDO Section 3.105.02, Table 3.1.4. No compact vehicle parking spaces are planned. Off Street Loading Requirements. Two existing off street loading spaces are located at the northeast corner of the building and will be distinctly marked. A third loading space is located along the north side of the building. The fourth required loading space is located near the northwest corner of the building. On-Site Vehicle Parking and Loading Area Improvement Requirements. The proposed improvements to the existing parking area will meet surfacing, drainage, wheel barrier, parking space and maneuvering area, directional marking, space marking, access, outdoor lighting and landscaping standards set forth in the WDO. Twenty on-site bicycle parking rack spaces (one plus one/ten vehicle parking spaces, with a max. 20 twenty rack spaces) will be provided near main building entrances per WDO Section 3.105.02.H. Joint use Vehicle Parking. No parking areas are planned for jotnt use as loading areas. The required loading areas are separate and distinctly marked as described above. 3.106 3.106.01 Landscaping Standards Applicability. Proposed landscaping at areas of construction impact will comply with WDO standards as required. The primary areas of impact include · 12,837 sq. ft. area including the property's street frontage at Mt. Hood Ave. and landscaping at the entrance driveway. · 7,463 sq. jrt. entrance plaza planting beds at the south and east face of the building. · 7,969 sq. ft. within tnteriorparking islands · Approx. 7'wtdeplanting strip at the eastperimeter ofproperty. C L A R K ~ K J O S MEMORANDUM Page 8 3.106.02 3.106.03 A · Approx. 15'wide planting strip at the north perimeter of property. ' Approx. 11'wide planting strip at the southeast perimeter of property. The provistons of the Landscaping Standards section do not apply to the entire site since the area increase of the proposed building and parking area expansion is only 50% more than existed on the date of the WDO adoption. General Requiremellt$ The proposed landscape improvements will meet requirements for plants, irrigation, plant materials, installation of plant materials and irrigation system, and maintenance set forth in the WDO. All planting areas will be permanently irrigated. See enclosed drawings L I.I Conceptual Landscape Site Plan and L2.1 Conceptual Planting Plan. Landscape Standar~ Streetscape. F_zctsttng street trees will be retained along Mt. Hood Avenue to meet requirements of Section 3.106.03.A. AH streetscape planting will meet densities per WDO standards and planttng abutting Mt. Hood Avenue will provide a 42" vertical screen for adjacent parked cars. B Buffer Yards. All planting will meet densities per WDO standards. C Off Street Parking Areas. All planttng will meet denstttes per WDO standards. Landscape areas, inclusive of surrounding multiq~urpose landscaping, will meet the 20% minimum equivalency wlth paved areas. Tree planting in the prlmary parking area will exceed requirements per Section 3.106. 03 (1 large tree per 14 parking spaces). D Common Areas. All planting will meet densities per WDO standards. E Yards. All planting will meet denstties per WDO standards. 3.106.04 ~5.106.05 3.107 3.107.06 A Conservation of Significant Trees No Significant Trees as defined by WDO standards exist on the property. Planting Standards The proposed landscape improvements will meet requirements for plant material distribution, ground cooer and curbs set forth in the WDO. See enclosed drawing L2.1 Conceptual Planting Plan. Architectural Design Guidelines and Standards Guidelines and Standards for Non-Residential Structures in RS. R1S. RM. (~O. CG and P/SP. Applicability. The design guidelines for the proposed building improvements apply in the CG zone. C L A R K // K J 0 S MEMORANDUM Page 9 B Architectural Design Guidelines. The objective is to transform the former K-Mart windowless "box" into a warm inviting health center that adds to and enhances the community. The proposed curving facade of the building expansion creates transitional indoor / outdoor spaces tied to various "tenant" spaces. The new main entrance features a curving glass entrance canopy. The new curving wall is predominantly earth- red stucco with stone accents. New window openings are punched into the existing masonry wall structure. The proposed landscape setting at the entrance lobby structure will be enhanced with new plantings, speclalty pavtng and open walkways. Low stone "garden~ walls and a small reflective water feature form an inviting courtyard near the entrance canopy. The roofline of the curved entrance facade rises above the e~isttng masonry structure. The curved glass entrance canopy roof with exposed wood structure is set at a lower plane to provide weather protection and presents a more human scale to customers and staff. Roof mounted equipment is located behind roof parapets, out of site, on the existing structure. All other mechanical equipment is either screened or located inside the building. The buiMtng character is defined by the use of natural materials, colorful stone tiles, and earth tone colors that are appropriate for the proposed landscaped setting. Stgnage is planned for the low garden wall near the car dropoff area at the entrance canopy. Buffer walls are not planned for this expansion project and are not required for a CG zone abutting IP and CG zones. Sidewalk improvements and additional street trees are not planned along Mt. Hood Avenue for this project. The existing streetscape will be enhanced with the addition of new ornamental slyrub plantings. Solar access protection of any solar devices on abutting properties is not impacted by any of the planned development for this project C Site and Building Access Guidelines. Vehicular access to and from the site will be enhanced with the addition of new landscaping and a new monument sign at the driveway area. All on-site parking lots are connected internally. Pedestrian access to and from the site will be enhanced by a new accessible walk along the east side of the entrance drive, which will connect the property to the existing sidewalk and bus stop on Mt. Hood Avenue. Pathways delineated by decorative paving mark the pedestrian paths to the building entrance. The prtmary parking area is designed with landscaped buffers between every 15 spaces at most. C L A R K // K J O S MEMORANDUM Page 10 D Building Location Guidelines. The proposed expansion to the south side of the existing building is well within the required setbacks. E Parking Location Guidelines. Existing off street parking areas located between the front of the building and the abutting streets occupy a "depth~ of approximately 280feet. Design Standards. Outdoor Storage: NA Outdoor lighting levels are designed as follows: Existing parking areas 1-12fc (I fc minimum req'd) average Entrance and Loading 5lc (2 fc minimum req'd) average Illumination does not impact abutting properties (zoned IP and CG). Lighting does not cast a glare onto vehicles on Mt. Hood Avenue. 3.110 3.110.16 Signs Permitted Signs-Commercial General. To be submitted for separate design approval process. End of Memo By Matthew Spicer L IIY OF WOODBURN Commun~ Development Department 270 Montgomery Street · Woodbum, Oregon 97071 Related files: Re ,e: Phone: 503-982-5246 · Fax: S03~J82-S244 · Website Address: www.ci.woodbum.or~;(B 0 1 2005 General InformaUon Project location Pmlmrt~ owner Mailing ~mm UNIFORM APPLICATION (AP:rc4acw WOODBURN COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPT. Telephone & Fax No. ('r~) Telephm~ IL Fax No. ('re) Comprehendve Plan .alii ~Dedjination ~ ~ Acreage "~" ~' I Requested Review 1 [] ACCESS PERMLq' TO CZTY STREET 2 o ANNEXKI'ZON 3 o APPEAL TO CITY COLINC/L 4 o COMP. PLAN MAP CHANGE 5 o CONDTI'IONAL USE 6 0 7 o DESZGN 80 ecamo~*To ~. 13 o FORMAL ]NTERPRE~ATION OF THE WDO 14 o MDP PRE~M]NARY APPROVAL tS o MDP fiNAL PLAN APPROVAL 16 o MOOZficA'r/ON OF CONDI'I/ONS 17 o PART/TION PREU~INARY APPROVAL 18 o PAR'TTr[~ fiNAL PLAT APPROVAL 19 o I~.t~SING ~ 20 o PUD PREL/MINARY PLAN APPROVAL 25 o RemCA'n0a o~ menouscY AmeOve:) PBU~]'T 26 o SWOO PERMIT 27 o SPEOAL USE AS A CU 28 o SUB. PREUJ4INARY APPROVAL 29 o SUB. la,,NAL PLAT APPROVAL 30 o ma:omumckTma PAaLTW, Static USeASAC~ 31 o 'TEMPORARY OUTDOOR PERM1'1' 32 o TREE REMOVAL PERHrr Applicant Certification _ , ~n m app~m mm~ CITY OF WOODBURN VARIANCE CRITERIA rovide a written response in the spaces provided below to show how the proposed variance complies with each of the ~llowing criteria. Attach additional pages if necessary. :riteria. A determination of whether the criteria set forth are satisfied necessarily involves the balancing of competing nd conflicting interest. The factors that are listed to be considered are not criteria and are not intended to be an xclusive list. The factors to be considered are used as a guide in deliberations on the application. The variance is necessary to prevent unnecessary hardship relating to the land or structure which would cause the property to be unbuildable by application of the WDO. Factors to consider in determining whether hardship exists, include: a. Physical circumstances over which the applicant has no control related to the piece of property involved that distinguish it from other land in the zone, including but not limited to lot size, shape, topography. b. Whether reasonable use similar to other properties can be made of the property without the variance. c. Whether the hardship was created by the person requesting the variance. Development consistent with the request will not be materially injurious to adjacent properties. Factors to be considered in determining whether development consistent with the variance materially injurious include but are no limited to: a. Physical impacts such development will have because of the variance, such as visual, noise, traffic and drainag~ erosion and landslide hazards. b. Incremental impacts occurring as a result of the proposed variance. Existing physical and natural systems, such as but not limited to ~raffic, drainage, dramatic land forms or parks will not be adversely affected because of the variance. The variance is the minimum deviation necessary to make reasonable economic use of the property; The variance does not conflict with the Woodburn Comprehensive Plan. h\Communlty Development~Plannlng~3rm~\WDO AppllcaUon~Type IIIWAR AppllcaUon.wpd ~ATUTORYW~RANTYD~D Wd~lm V. U.C I10 GIIII Ckl:~ Reel ~age 2348 60 ~ iNSU~ COMPANY, AH ILUNOIS CORPORATION, Gnntor, convis ~cl Mumm, m WEBSTAR V, L1.C, AN OREGON UMITED LIABILITY COMPANY, AS TO AN UNOIVIDED 85% INTEREST AND BERRYMAN GFIOUP II LLC, AN OREGON UMITED LIABILITY COMPANY, AS TO AN UNDIVIDED 15% 1N'TERE6T. Gr~l~. ihe Iolmdng dmat~ rml pmpe~ Iree of m, wu'TdxancM em~t aa aPecmcdy mt loflh h~r~k~ M~aMmcl Iff M,m~km Cctv'P/. Oreom, to wi: m~Am~m m ~ J~ov~ ,__~__ ~TO nCrmU~E ~ uurm ON L~V,~U~ AOrta' F~Mm O. · rite IlUe (~miidmlian Io~ Ids conv~/mvm k S2,4~O,QQQ~I. A ~,~ of whk:h i~ b~k~ i~d by m ~ ~ _--~:',-mmda~' pumu~l to m IRC Wwjn~ IR. Hi, Vice Presid~l of ~ IrmJmnce Company, an Illinois coq~ora~)n, on ~ d 14A~CIA ],m TICOR TITLE iNSURANCE COMPANY PAGE 1 S'IAITJ lO#1' W MUUi~' L'~mO fC~M) REEL:2348 PAGE: 60 July 19, 2004, 10:58 am. CONTROL#: 118814 S~te of Oregon County of Marion I hereby certify that the attached instrument was received and duly recorded by me in Marion County FEE: $ 31.00 PHIL MILES CHIEF DEPUTY CO. CLERK THIS IS NOT AN INVOICE. VICINITY. MAP LEGAL DESCRIPTION Parcel 2 of Partition Plat No. 91-38, recorded April 24, 1991 in Reel 848, Page 444, Film Records for Marion County, Oregon described as follows: Beginning at a point on the North line of Lot 3, Block 1, Walilale Home Tracts as said subdivision is platted and recorded in Volume 5, Page 64, Book of Town Plats for Marion County, Oregon, situated in Township 5 South, Range I West of the Willamette Meridian in Marion County, Oregon, which point marks the Northwest comer of that tract of land conveyed to Don-Susie Enterprises, Inc. by deed recorded in Reel 358, Page 668, Deed Records, which point bears North 89° 38' 30" West 267.02 feet from the Northeast comer of said Lot 3; thence South I° 51' 45" West along the West line of said Don-Susie tract and the Southerly extension thereof a distance of 485.91 feet to an iron rod on the Northerly right of way line of Mt. Hood Avenue; thence North 88° 05' 00" West along said right of way line, a distance of 53§.92 feet to an iron rod on the East line of Lot 5, Block 1 of said subdivision; thence North 1° 51' 17" East along said East line, 264.00 feet; thence South 88~ 05' 00" East 56.62 feet; thence North 1° 55' 00" East 149.96 feet; thence North 88° 05' 00" West 47.00 feet; thence North 1~ 55' 00" East 57.51 feet to a point on the North line of Lot 4 of said Block 1; thence North 1 ° 55' 00" East 130.03 feet; thence South 88~ 05' 00" East 408.73 feet to a point on the Northeasterly boundary line of that tract of land conveyed to Morgan Drive Away, Inc. by deed recorded in Reel 60, Page 716, Deed Records; thence South 48° 44' 38" East, along said boundary line, 181.56 feet to the Southeast comer thereof; thence North 89~ 38' 30' West along the South line of said tract, 22.03 feet to the point of beginning. Together with an easement of ingress and egress 30 feet in width as set forth on the Partitioning Plat No. 90-104, recorded December 28, 1990 in Reel 823, Page 279, Film Records, Marion County, Oregon. C L A R K ~ K J TRANSMITTAL ,A, OREC,DS ,A, FEB 0 ] 200§ Project Jason Richling City of Woodbum Planning Department Wellspring Medical Center Date February Fax Number Phone Number # of Pages (including transm#taO Project # 04048 Sent by [] mail [] courier [] UPS [] FedEx [-I facsimile [] e-mail [] Hand Delivered 1 1 1 15 Date 01/31/05 01/31/O5 01/31/05 07/13/04 11/24/O4 01/31/O5 O1/31/05 O1/31/O5 01/31/05 01/31/05 11/09/04 01/31/O5 01/31/O5 01/31/O5 Description Type II Design Review Application Form and Application Fee Variance Application Form and Application Fee Project Description (with project areas listed) Statutory Warranty Deed and Legal Description Assessor's Map / Notification Area (with certification from preparer of the notification list, that the address labels reflect the required ownership and address data as contained in the current property tax rolls) Notification List on adhesive labels Location Map Findings of Conformance with Approval Criteria 8.5xl 1 copies of drawings listed below Drawing Al.1 -Site Plan Drawing A2.1 -Floor Plan Drawing A3.1 -Building Elevations Site Survey Drawing C1 - Preliminary Site Grading/Utility Plan Drawing L1.1 - Materials Plan - South Drawing L1.2 - Materials Plan - North By Matthew Spicer This transmittal contains confidential information and is intended for the use of the recipient named above. If you have received this document in error, please destroy it and notify us at 503/224-4848. CLARK/KJOS ARCHITECTS, LLC C L A R K // K J O S TRANSMITTAL 15 01/31/O5 15 01/31/O5 15 01/31/O5 1 11/23/O4 1 12/05/O4 Drawing L2.1 - Planting Plan - South Drawing L2.2 - Planting Plan - North Drawing El.0 -Site Lighting Plan Parker Fire Protection water flow information MFIA Consulting Engineers water flow review comments Cc: Robert Engle - Webstar V, LLC Shawn Whalen - Silverton Hospital By Matthew Spicer This transmittal contains confidential information and is intended for thc usc of thc recipient named above. If you have received this document in error, please destroy it and notify us at 503/224-4848. CLARK/KJOS ARCHITECTS, LLC Taxlot(s): '051w08b 02800' Owner Name: WEBSTAR V LLC & Situs Address: 1475 MT HOOD AV Zip Code: 97071,WOODBURN Land Use Zone: Schools: Woodburn Fire District: WOODBURN This map was produced from data stored in the Marion County Assessor Oeogrephic database. This deta is maintained by the Assessor to =upport ita activities. The Aaaeasor is not responsible for any map errors, possible misuse, or misinterpretations. capture radius = 250' scale 1" = 326' .+ This is to certify that this is a true and correct copy of the record now on file in the Assessor's Office. Doug Ebner, Marion County AssessO~ to'~ -::'3 04 O~):OOa Par. kef Fire (503)663-229? P' z ~ REC'D ~ Parker Fire Protection, Inc. OR. CCB No. 124300 WA. CCB No. PARKF. FPO: ~IOP FEB 0 1 ?.005 WOODBURN COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPT. TO: Triplett Wellman 1717 M£ Jefferson Ave. Woodburn, Oregon 970'/1 Old K-Mart Water Flows Woodbnrn, Oregon Ken Tdple~ November 23, 2004 Please find attached Wato~ Flow i~o at site. To confirm I also flowed the hydrant # 536 wit~ the same t suRs ~s number 538 Static Pressure: 56 psi Residual Pressure: 53 psi Pitot Pressure: 21 psi Total Flow (~ 20 PSI = 2946,7 GPM if additional information is needed please contact mo. ~~ou, 30205 S.E. Kelso Rd, · Boring OR 97009 .~03.663.6278 * fax: 503,663,729~ ' emall: pidire(~gte.net .23 04 09:00a Parke~ FLON TEST SUMMARY REPORT pagel ,OCATION:Old K-Mart Newburg Hwy Woodburn Oregon DATH: Nov 23 TIME: S ~dq Static Hydrant Number: Elevation: ~37 ~00 Flowi$ g Hydrant Number: )levation: Dist. Between Hydrants: 500 Diameter of Main: Outlet Diameter: Static pressure: Pitot Reading: Plow at 20 psi: 2946.7 2.50 in 56.00 ps/ 21.00 psi Numbs: flowing: 1 Resi~al pressure: Flow: GRAPH: ]'SI ................................................................ :.00 8O 60 50 40 30 20 lO /Normal Pressure-No Flow-S6.00 psi S /Test Flow-769.2 gpm-S3.O0 psi \\\\~ .... Avail. Flow · 20 psi-2946.7 gpm * 600 900 1200 1500 1800 2~00 2400 2700 3000 PLOW {GPM) NOTES: (1) Flowing hydrant is assumed to be on a circulatLng main or downstream of the pressure test hydrant on a c~ad-end system. (2) Flow analysis assumes a gravity flow system wJ=h no distribution pumps and having no demand, other than the tel: flow. (3) Diatance between hydrants, elevations & main CLamecer are for information only. 536 500 0.90 53. O0 p~i 769.2 140~ .~30~ 09:OOa Parker Fire Inc. (503)GG3-7297 p.3 FLOW TEST SUMMARY REPORT page2 A E o~orma1 Pressure-No Plow-S6.00 psi P 0.R _ E U lO.O __ 10.0 _ 0.0 ~'~o.Test Flow-769.2 gpm-53.00 psi Avail. Flow ~ 20 p~ i-29%6.7 ~pmO 2400 2700 3000 600 900 1200 1500 1800 2100 FLOW (GPM) I~o~ 23 O~ 08:OO& Parker F~re Inc. (503)GG3-7297 P.e Newberg OD' ~0 M INC. CONSULTING ENGINEERS 2007 SE Ash Street Portland, OR 97214 Date: 12/5/2004 To: Matthew Spicer Company: __ Project: Woodbum Wellness Comments/Description Fax (503) 234-0677 Phone (503) 234-0548 From: John van Bladeren Fax Number: Cc: # Of Pages Including Cover Sheet Mail Follow-up Copy: Yes [--1 No [~] Mathew, we have examined the attached study by Parker fire protection and based upon the following: 1. The new occupancy will be light hazard without any storage 2. The building has an existing fire sprinkler system in it which in all likely hood was ordinary storage. (Therefore greater fare flow required) It would be our opinion that the water service would be adequate. Regards Jvb 'MENT DATE: IUE STATION: 2/01/2005 CITY HALL Finance Department 270 Montgomery St. Woodburn, OR 97071 (503) 982-5215 RECEIPT NO.: CASHIER: 050043127 SUZANNEYB Plan Fees Plan Fees WEBSTAR V, LLC 1475 MT HOOD AVE WEBSTAR V, LLC 968. 1,769.0 RECEIVED FROM: CHECK 1035 2,737 00 TOTAL · AMOUNT: DESIGN REVIEW 05-01, VARIANCE 05-05 ZONING MAP AVENUE RS r"l Subject site.shp Text Street Names ,streams Railroad t~nes Neighborhood Conservation District ~=1 City Lim~s r='l L,,kban Growth Boundary ~ Assessors T~xto~s Zoning Plan CO IL E~ NON~ i~.;* P~sP ~s RS 0.02 0 0.02 0.04 Miles DESIGN REVIEW 05-01, VARIANCE 05-05 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN MAP MI' HOOO I"'1 Subject si~e.shp Text Street Names Railroad lines Neighborhood Conservation D~bict ~ U~oan Growth Boundary ~ ~aaor'$ Taxlots Comprehensive Plan ~ INDUSTRIAL ~ NONE ma OPEN SPACE AND P^R~ ~ PUBL~, USE ~ RESIDENTIAL (<12 UNITS/ACRE) ~ RESIDENTIAL (>12 UNITS/ACRE) 0.02 0 0.02 0.04 Miles DESIGN REVIEW Design Review 05-01 PUBLIC WORKS GENERAL CONDITIONS: Final plans shall conform to the construction plan review procedures and standards. The applicant, not the city is responsible for obtaining permits from any state and/or federal agencies, which may require approval and/or permit. All work within the public rights-of-way or public facilities within public easement shall require plan approval and permit issuance from the Public Works Department. System Development fees shall be reviewed for the change and increase of use, if appropriate, additional fees shall be paid at the time of building permit issuance. STREET AND DRAINAGE: The Oregon Department of Transportation (ODOT) in accordance with OAR 734- 051 regulates the boundary and connecting street, Mt Hood Avenue (State Highway 214). The primary access currently to the site is a signalized intersection, ODOT may require the applicant obtain a modified access permit. Interconnected on-site access agreement/easement be shall be provided for review and approval by the city prior to building permits being issued. No additional impervious surface is being created with the development. Strom water runoff from the site is currently being provided from the on-site private system, discharging to a city maintained system on Progress Way. SANITARY SEWER: Waste Water service can and is being provided by the existing private sanitary sewer main extended through the site and connecting to the existing public sanitary sewer at Mt Hood Avenue. A Grease trap will be required to be installed on the sanitary service, either as a central unit or in each kitchen/food preparation area. Contact Marion County Plumbing Department for permit and installation requirements, (503)588-5147. WATER: The current level of backflow protection, double detector check device, on the and fire sprinkler service and reduced pressure device on domestic service is adequate for the proposed use. The landscape irrigation meter shall be upgraded with double detector check backflow device at the meter. Contact Larry Arendt, City of Woodburn cross connection inspector for installation requirements at 503-982-5283. Water service and fire protection is currently being provided by an existing city maintained water main traversing through the site. The existing fire hydrant identified on the plan to be relocated shall be done by the property owner/applicant in accordance with city standards and specifications. Utility easement shall be provided to the city for the relocated hydrant if it is not within the existing easement currently conveyed to the city. Fire protection requirements shall comply with the State Fire Code and Woodbum Fire Districts Standards. PROJECT REFERRAL Woodburn Community Development Department 270-M~ntgomerY Street 'Woodbum, OR 97071 (503) 982-5246 DATE: March 10, 2005 TO: _ Project Applicant __ Marion County _X_ Woodbum Fire District (Paul Ivemon) Wooclburn School District D.$.L. D,L,C,D, _X_ Engineering Department (Randy Scott) ~ Other _X_ ODOT (Dan Fricke/Don Jordan) Parks Department (Randy Westdck) __ Woodbum Police Department Street Division Water Divlelon Wastewater Division _X_ Building Department (Steve Krleg) PROJECT: Deelan Revle.w...0.5.-01, Var!ance 05-05: Request for administrative (Type I!) design review approval to retrofit and upgrade fac~ade and site elements of the existing (former K-Mart) building at 1475 Mt. Hood Avenue for use as an outpatient health services and wellness center, and variance approval to allow existing parking to remain in required front and interior yard setbacks. The property is identified specifically on Marion County Assessor Map T5S, R1W, Section 08B, Tax Lot~ 2800. A facilities meeting has been scheduled to take place on Monday, March 21, 2005 at 10:00 em in the Conference Room. If you are unable to attend, please retum written comments to the Woodbum Community Development office by 5:00 pm on March 18, 200.5.. Please contact Jason Richling at (503)' 980-2431 if you have any questions. Thank you for your assistance. r'XIIILIIL CITY OF WOODBURN, OREGON PLANNING COMMISSION APPLICANT/PROPERTY OWNER'S RESPONSE TO DESIGN REVIEW 05-01, VARIANCE 0505 STAFF REPORT April 28, 2005 SUMMARY OF RESPONSE Applicant, Clark/Kjos Architects, LLC, Tenant, Silverton Hospital, and Property Owner, Webstar V, LLC do not agree with condition of approval 6c requiring cross connections between the WellSpring property and the property to the east and request that such condition be removed aa a requirement of completion of the project. DISCUSSION This is a Type H Administrative Design Review Application for the WellSpring Medical Center 1475 Mt. Hood Avenue, Woodburn, Oregon. Webstar V, LLC, the property owner and Silverton Hospital are proposing to develop an Outpatient Health Service and Wellness Center in an existing 90,000 square foot building on 7.05 acres of land on Mt. Hood Avenue. The completed facility and health service program will be operated and managed completely under the direction and control of Silverton Hospital. Applicant, Matthew Spicer, is an architect employed by ClarkdKjos Architects. Clark/Kjos has designed and facilitated multiple medical facilities for Silverton Hospital including the Silverton Hospital Family Birth Center in Silvertorb the Woodbum Family Clinic and the Tukwila Center for Health and Medicine both located in Northwood Office Park. Property owner Webstar V, LLC, is the developer of the subject parcel solely and expressly for the use of Silverton Hospital as designed by Clark/Kjos Architects. Clark/Kjos and Webstar received the Staff Report on April 22, 2005. This written response is intended to address the condition of approval 6c and the supporting staff comments on pages 16, 17 and 33 of the staff report. Applicant, Silverton Hospital and Webstar V are not in agreement with conditional of approval 6c and request that this condition be removed as a requirement of the completed project. Our reasons for this request are as follows: Page I of 3-APPLICANT/PROPERTY OWNER'S RESPONSE TO DESIGN REVIEW 05-01, VARIANCE 05-05 A cross connection on the east of the WellSpring Development will create a hazard and danger to ambulance traffic and to patients and their drivers accessing and leaving the WellSpring Urgent Care Center on the southeast corner of the complex. e The current and proposed uses within both developments to the east of the WellSpring building are neither similar to nor compatible with the Urgent Care facility. ARGUMENT: Section 3.104.03 of the Woodbum Development Ordinance entitled "Driveway Access Guidelines, Type II and HI Applicationsn does not require vehicular cross access between all adjoining properties facing arterial or collector streets. The ordinance encourages cross connections for vehicular access if, and only if, uses on the adjoining lots are "similar and/or compatible, uses". The ordinance clearly states that abutting lots "should" have interconnected on-site access and parking facilities. The ordinance does not state that abutting lots "shall" or "must" have interconnected on-site access. Obviously, staff and the Planning Commission are expected to use discretion to determine whether or not cross connections are in the best interest of the users of the abutting lots. If a cross connection would result in a likelihood of personal injury or property damage to the users of either or both of the adjoining lots, then the cross connection should not be required. Mark Wolf is the owner and developer of the parcel on the east of the WellSpring property designated as parcel I on the attached diagrams labeled aa Exhibits Al, A2 and A3. Parcel I lies north of the existing Washington Mutual Bank parcel, which is designated as parcel 2. A twenty-four foot access easement between parcel 1 and 2 dead ends at the WellSpring property on the west but opens a cross connection between parcel 1 and the Mid-Valley Plaza to the east. The opening of a cross connection between Mark Wolf's parcel 1, north of Washington Mutual and the WellSpring facility would allow traffic from ten separate retail units proposed on parcel 1 and traffic from multiple separate retail units in the Mid-Valley Plaza to utilize the stoplight to access Mt. Hood Avenue in front of the WellSpring building. Although we do not know the exact uses that will be made of the ten retail units in parcel I north Washington Mutual, we do know that the east end of Mid-Valley Plaza will serve as a sports bar, a community meeting facility and a restaurant, all of which would undoubtedly prefer to use the stoplight in front of WellSpring for access to highway 214 during times of busy daily traffic on 214. The Urgent Care portion of the WellSpring Medical Center will contain Page 2 of 3-APPLICANT/PROPERTY OWNER'S RESPONSE TO DESIGN REVIEW 05-01, VARIANCE 05-05 approximately 10,000 square feet. Diagrams evidencing the location of the Urgent Care Center, the interior of the Urgent Care Center and the exterior access to the Urgent Care Center are attached hereto labeled ~ Exhibits BI, B2 and B3. The Urgent Care Center will be open and will be taking Urgent Care patients during the day and evening hour~ and the sports bar and the restaurants will be open and generating traffic during the day and evening hours. It is expected that ambulances will be accessing the Urgent Care facility either to bring people to the facility or to take people from the facility to more intensive emergency department or hospital care. It is expected that concerned and fearful patients and/or their drivers will be accessing th~ Urgent Care facility from the stoplight on 214, will be turning fight (east) at the WellSpring building and will then be turning leR (north) to the Urgent Care entrance at the location which would be the point of the cross connection with Mark Wolf's property to the east if condition of approval 6c is not removed. The likelihood of collisions between vehicles coming from the easterly retail and restaurant uses with vehicles accessing the Urgent Care Center would be extremely high. Ndther of the parcels to the east need additional access to the WellSpring property for reasonable ingress and egress. A forty foot north-south existing access easement serving Mark Wolf's parcel 1 is located on the east side of Washington Mutual Bank. Four accesses to highway 214 and 99E are located within Mid-Valley Plaza. The convenience afforded to the customers of parcel 1 and Mid-Valley Plaza to ~ the stoplight in front of the WellSpring facility does not jtmtify the hazardous and dangerous condition likely to result in personal injury and property damage if the cross access is required. The consideration of the Planning Commission to our position will be greatly appreciated. ROBERT L. l~qOLE, On behalf of Webstar V, LLC Silverton Hospital and CI-'~ "' - ' ' -'ark/Kjos Architects Page 3 of 3-APPLICANT/PROPERTY OWNER'S RESPONSE TO DESIGN REVIEW 05-0 !, VARIANCE 05-05 ! j I ,SITE PLAN II II BUll. DING SECTION WELLSPRING MEDICAL CENTER In Cooperation with Silverton Hospital C L A R K // K J 0 l~lt'$ URGENT URGENT CARE CENTER 1/16 = 1'-0" WELLSPRING CENTER FOR HEALTH In Cooperation with Silverton Hospital CLARKil BERRYMAN PATRIClA RERRYMAN ROBERT ENGLE CAROLYN ~GL~ MARVIN SHELBY WEBSTAR L.L.C. NORTHWOOD Olll~IC~ PARK - Ii0 GI,AT[ CIRCLE WOODBURN, OREGON 97071 TELEPHONE: (~) FAX: ($0~) 981-01~ CAROL SHELBY KINNgTH TRIPLIT! GgNR W~LI,MA~ DENI~ L DAIASKY JANL~T L. DALISK'Y May 25, 2005 Planning Department City of Woodburn 270 Montgomery Woodburn, OR 97071 Re: Webstar V, LLC-Notice of lntent to Appeal Enclo,~l-i.s our application for the Notice of Intent to Appeal, together with our check for $1,394.00 tn payment of the filing fee. Thank you. i Yours truly, RLE:ss Ends OF WOODBURN File Number: 2]~"-d/j Mailing Address: C /n Rv/~/'? L ,C~',r~ /e . ~ /~ G/Ct/lll"_ ,rrl~ : /d ~J, bq l'['(, /),g . ~'"//J q ! a Daytime Phone Number Cx,~'~$) 9~/-'g)/C~' , . [] Statement o[ how thc ~gpeliant has standing to ~ppcal: ,4~a~!la n/s ~a ~e' ~ /a,,,~h~, a_.~ '-/4,,, z~r,,.,~,.,'~; ~,,~,,_,- C. ''~ ,o,.-,,~,",'-, ; [3 A statement of the grounds for the appeal: ~ T?,q ¢ N£h $ ?& ?£1'n~nTT Filing Fee: $1,594.00. STATEMENT TO WOODBURN CITY COUNCIL IN SUPPORT OF APPEAL OF DESIGN REVIEW 05-01 AND VARIANCE 05-05 MAY 2 5 2005 WOOg3U~f,! E?,'~t.O; ~r,. '!;;f Appellants have carefully planned and designed access requirements and constraints to their 90,000 square foot Outpatient Health Service and Wellness Center to alleviate congestion and minimize hazards to pedestrians and vehicles utilizing the Center's services and particularly the Center's Urgent Care Clinic. Woodburn City staff and three of five Planning Commission members wish to inject a flow of traffic into this carefully considered design which will disrupt safety and place ail those using the Center, and particularly the Urgent Care Clinic, at risk. The City staff and Planning Commission have supported their insistence on a cross connection on the provisions of Section 3.104.03 of the Woodbum Development Code. That provision states as follows: "Similar, and/or compatible, uses on abutting lots should have interconnected on-site access and parking facilities." As additional support, staff cites the Woodbum Transportation System Plan (WTS) in Section 9.4.2. This section, provides in part "*** crossover easements should be provided on all compatible parcels (topography, access and land use) to facilitate future access between adjoining parcels.***" Appellant asks the Woodburn City Council to particularly note that the language in Section 3.104.03 of the Woodburn Development Ordinance and in Section 9.4.2 of the Woodburn Transportation System Plan is not mandatory. The word "should" is used in both sections. Both sections state that the cross connection should only be required on parcels that will have similar and compatible uses. Appellant is now before the City Council, on appeal, only because a 10,000 square foot Urgent Care Center will be located on the Southeast comer of this 90,000 square foot building. If emergency care services for the Woodburn community were not planned in this building, at this location, the existence or non existence of cross connection to the East would be irrelevant to the appellant. Silverton Hospital deems this to be an extremely important issue to the safety and proper utilization of this Urgent Care facility which, for reasons that the appellant does not understand, are not recognized and apparent tO either City staff or the majority of the Woodbum Planning Commission. Page 1 of 3 - NOTICE OF INTENT TO APPEAL Notwithstanding the fact that no application has currently been filed, a 10-unit retail center is planned by Mark Wolf on his parcel to the East. This retail center is neither similar nor compatible with an Urgent Care Center. See Exhibits A-l, A-2 and A-3. Vehicles using the drive-thru from the Washington Mutual Bank to the East attempting to access the stoplight through the Urgent Care parking lot cannot be classified as coming from a use which is similar or compatible with the Urgent Care Center. Vehicles which could potentially travel from Shaft's Restaurant, from the community meeting center or from the sports bar on the West end of Mid-Valley Plaza cannot be classified as coming from uses which are similar or compatible with the Urgency Care Center. The aforesaid vehicles utilizing the requested cross connection would travel through the Urgent Care parking lot where people are parking their vehicles and walking to the Urgent Care Center. See Exhibit B-2. Vehicles utilizing the requested cross connection would enter the fully landscaped ingress and egress road to access the stoplight on 214 by traveling through the passage way for vehicles entering the emergency drop off area on the East side of the Urgent Care Clinic. The dsk to pedestrians and the drivers of vehicles seeking emergency services at Urgent Care is too great. This dsk is not only existent during normal and regular daytime hours but potentially during all hours of the night as well. The Urgent Care Clinic will be open during evening and nighttime hours. Vehicles utilizing the bank's ATM drive-thru, Shaft's Restaurant and the sports bar will all potentially choose to use this cross connection during the same nighttime hours. The unfortunate error in the staff argument, adopted by majority of the Planning Commission, in the findings set forth on Pages 16-19 of the Notice of Decision is to define the terms "similar and/or compatible" in the framework of uses allowed in the commercial general zone. Woodbum Development Ordinance and the Woodburn Transportation System Plan, in using the term "compatible" must mean uses that do not conflict with one another and uses that do not create a risk of personal injury and property damage as a result of the cross connection. Whether or not the Urgency Care Clinic and a restaurant, bank, retail center and sports bar are all allowed in the commercial general zone has very little to do with whether those uses are compatible for purposes of cross connections. It should be no surprise to the City Council that Silverton Hospital would not consider the investment of time, effort and dollars to develop a 90,000 square foot Outpatient Health Service and Wellness Center without careful analysis of projected user and traffic volumes for this facility. Silverton Hospital projects 109,000 visits to this facility in the first year of its existence, increasing to 143,000 visits in the fifth year. This project does not include staff that will be using the back parking area that will not access the facility through the front driveway. Staff will access the facility from the West connection to Progress Way. All of the projected visits specified herein would be utilizing the entry and exit from the stoplight on Mt. Hood Avenue (214). Page 2 of 3 - NOTICE OF INTENT TO APPEAL That figure in the fit~th year translates to almost 400 vehicles per day entering the facility through the stoplight entrance. A substantial and material number of those will be Urgent Care patients whose minds will be focused on injury, sickness and obtaining immediate relief from the crisis that each patient will be experiencing. The hospital and the developer will manage this project's traffic and pedestrian usage through planned lighting, walkways and architecturally designed ways of travel. We cannot manage, to this extent, the safety of our users if additional traffic is generated through an inadvisable cross connection. Although there may be an argument of convenience to users of the retail center, the bank, the restaurant, the community center and the sports bar to be able to exit through a stoplight, that is only for their "convenience" and not "necessity." Ample means of ingress and egress on to highway 214 exists for these other facilities without funneling their traffic through our Urgency Center parking lot and driveways. ReSpectfully s~bmitted, . ENGLE & SCHMIDTMAN / ! / Page 3 of 3 - NOTICE OF INTENT TO APPEAL SITE Pt.~N ( C C ¢ I WELLSPRING MEDICAL CENTER In Cooperation with Silverton Hospital ¢ L A R K // K J O IlIF. AW 1 URGENT URGENT CARE CENTER 1116 = 1'-0" WELLSPRING CENTER FOR HEALTH In Cooperation with Silverton Hospital...,..,.,'"' =AYMENT DATE: rENUE STATION: 5/25/2oo5 CITY HALL 270 Montgomery St. Woodburn, OR 97071 (503) 982-5215 RECEIPT NO.: CASHIER: 050066737 SUZANNEYB RECEIVED FROM: WEBSTAR V LLC 1,594.00 CHECK 1055 1,594.00 TOTAL AMOUNT: CLARKE BERRYMAN PATRICLA BERRYMAN ROBERT ENGLg CAROLYN ENGLg MARVIN SHELBY W SU'A NORTIDVOOD OVFICE PARK- 610 GLATT CIRCLE WOODBURN, OREGON 97071 TELEPHONE: (~d)3) 981-015~ FAX: (503) 981-0158 CAROL SH]~LBY KENNETH TlUI'LETI GENg V/gLLMAN DF. NIB J. DALLSK'Y JANL~ L. DAIASICY May25,2005 Planning Department City of Woodburn 270 Montgomery Woodbum, OR 97071 MAY ~ 5 ~005 L'.;':VELO':L .:;,; I' Re: Webstar V, LLC-Notice of lntent to Appeal Encloged-[S our application for the Notice of Intern to Appeal, together with our check for $1,~4.00 tn payment of the filing fee. Thank you.) Yours truly, RLE:ss Encls CITY OF WOODBURN ~,,,,.,,,,I ,.., NOT[CE OF INTENT TO APPEAL File Number: .73~d~-d/j O,Y-O,5- cl Date of Decision: O..5'//,g/t9 -~"- Mailing Address: C? ,~,~he,,/- L ~-/~lc.. /oi~ Gkt//C, rrl~../;_ ~o-/~t, ~,m. ,o,~ qqa o I Daytime Phone Number. ~63) c/X/. ~/~5" . Statement of how thc appellant has standing to appeal: - ! ! ! - [] A statement of the grounds for the appeal: i iii Filing Fee: $1di94.00. -vA,. REC'O .',A" STATEMENT TO WOODBURN CITY COUNCIL IN SUPPORT OF APPEAL OF DESIGN REVIEW 05-01 AND VARIANCE 05-05 MAY 2 5 2005 WOO,.33U~,! E:.U,,'Et.O: :",. 'L :f D E? f. Appellants have carefully planned and designed access requirements and constraints to their 90,000 square foot Outpatient Health Service and Wellness Center to alleviate congestion and minimize hazards to pedestrians and vehicles utilizing the Center's services and particularly the Center's Urgent Care Clinic. Woodburn City staff and three of five Planning Commission members wish to inject a flow of traffic into this carefully considered design which will disrupt safety and place all those using the Center, and particularly the Urgent Care Clinic, at risk. The City staff and Planning Commission have supported their insistence on a cross connection on the provisions of Section 3.104.03 of the Woodbum Development Code. That provision states as follows: "Similar, and/or compatible, uses on abutting lots should have interconnected on-site access and parking facilities." As additional support, staff cites the Woodbum Transportation System Plan (WTS) in Section 9.4.2. This section, provides in part "*** crossover easements should be provided on all compatible parcels (topography, access and land use) to facilitate future access between adjoining parcels.***" Appellant asks the Woodburn City Council to particularly note that the language in Section 3.104.03 of the Woodburn Development Ordinance and in Section 9.4.2 of the Woodburn Transportation System Plan is not mandatory. The word "should" is used in both sections. Both sections state that the cross connection should only be required on parcels that will have similar and compatible uses. Appellant is now before the City Council, on appeal, only because a 10,000 square foot Urgent Care Center will be located on the Southeast comer of this 90,000 square foot building. If emergency care services for the Woodbum community were not planned in this building, at this location, the existence or non existence of cross connection to the East would be irrelevant to the appellant. Silverton Hospital deems this to be an extremely important issue to the safety and proper utilization of this Urgent Care facility which, for reasons that the appellant does not understand, are not recognized and apparent tO either City staffor the majority of the Woodbum Planning Commission. Page 1 of 3 - NOTICE OF INTENT TO APPEAL Notwithstanding the fact that no application has currently been filed, a 10-unit retail center is planned by Mark Wolf on his parcel to the East. This retail center is neither similar nor compatible with an Urgent Care Center. See Exhibits A-1, A-2 and A-3. Vehicles using the drive-thru from the Washington Mutual Bank to the East attempting to access the stoplight through the Urgent Care parking lot cannot be classified as coming from a use which is similar or compatible with the Urgent Care Center. Vehicles which could potentially travel from Shaft's Restaurant, from the community meeting center or from the sports bar on the West end of Mid-Valley Plaza cannot be classified as coming from uses which are similar or compatible with the Urgency Care Center. The aforesaid vehicles utilizing the requested cross connection would travel through the Urgent Care parking lot where people are parking their vehicles and walking to the Urgent Care Center. See Exhibit B-2. Vehicles utilizing the requested cross connection would enter the fully landscaped ingress and egress road to access the stoplight on 214 by traveling through the passage way for vehicles entering the emergency drop off area on the East side of the Urgent Care Clinic. The risk to pedestrians and the drivers of vehicles seeking emergency services at Urgent Care is too great. This risk is not only existent during normal and regular daytime hours but potentially during all hours of the night as well. The Urgent Care Clinic will be open during evening and nighttime hours. Vehicles utilizing the bank's ATM drive-thru, Shaft's Restaurant and the sports bar will all potentially choose to use this cross connection during the same nighttime hours. The unfortunate error in the staff argument, adopted by majority of the Planning Commission, in the findings set forth on Pages 16-19 of the Notice of Decision is to del'me the terms "similar and/or compatible" in the framework of uses allowed in the commercial general zone. Woodbum Development Ordinance and the Woodbum Transportation System Plan, in using the term "compatible" must mean uses that do not conflict with one another and uses that do not create a risk of personal injury and property damage as a result of the cross connection. Whether or not the Urgency Care Clinic and a restaurant, bank, retail center and sports bar are ail allowed in the commercial general zone has very little to do with whether those uses are compatible for purposes of cross connections. It should be no surprise to the City Council that Silverton Hospital would not consider the investment of time, effort and dollars to develop a 90,000 square foot Outpatient Health Service and Wellness Center without careful analysis of projected user and traffic volumes for this facility. Silverton Hospital projects 109,000 visits to this facility in the first year of its existence, increasing to 143,000 visits in the fifth year. This project does not include staff that will be using the back parking area that will not access the facility through the front driveway. Staff will access the facility from the West connection to Progress Way. All of the projected visits specified herein would be utilizing the entry and exit from the stoplight on Mt. Hood Avenue (214). Page 2 of 3 - NOTICE OF INTENT TO APPEAL That figure in the fifth year translates to almost 400 vehicles per day entering the facility through the stoplight entrance. A substantial and material number of those will be Urgent Care patients whose minds will be focused on injury, sickness and obtaining immediate relief from the crisis that each patient will be experiencing. The hospital and the developer will manage this project's traffic and pedestrian usage through planned lighting, walkways and architecturally designed ways of travel. We cannot manage, to this extent, the safety of our users if additional traffic is generated through an inadvisable cross connection. Although there may be an argument of convenience to users of the retail center, the bank, the restaurant, the community center and the sports bar to be able to exit through a stoplight, that is only for their "convenience" and not "necessity." Ample means of ingress and egress on to highway 214 exists for these other facilities without funneling their traffic through our Urgency Center parking lot and driveways. ReSpectfully scbmitted, , ENGLE & SCHlVIID~ Page 3 of 3 - NOTICE OF INTENT TO APPEAL .11 SITE PI. AN i I UNASSIGNED UNASSI~4EO WELLSPRING MEDICAL CENTER In Cooperation with Silverton Hospital c L A R K // K J o s 't MI~mCAL. CENTER [_ UR~'T '1 I ' URGENT CARE CENTER 1/16 = 1'-0" WELLSPRING CENTER FOR HEALTH In Cooperation with Silverton Hospital =AYMENT DATE: rENUE STATION: 5/25/ oo5 CITY HALL 270 Montgomery St. Woodburn, OR 97071 (503) 982-5215 RECEIPT NO,: CASHIER: 050066737 SUZANNEYB RECEIVED FROM: WEBSTAR V LLC 1,594.00 CHECK 1055 1,594.00 TOTAL AMOUNT: WOODBURN PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES April 28, 2005 CONVENED The Planning Commission met in a regular session at 7:00 p.m. in City Hall Council Chambers with Chairperson Lima presiding. ROLL CALL Chairperson Lima P Vice Chairperson Bandelow P Commissioner Vancil P Commissioner Grigorleff A Commissioner Hutchison P Commissioner Jennings P Staff Present: Jim Mulder, Community Development Director Jason Richling, Associate Planner Chairperson Lima provided an opening for Public Hearing. MINUTES A. Woodburn Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of April 14,2005 Vi--ce Chairperson Bandelow moved to approve the minutes as drafted. Commissioner Vancil seconded the motion, which unanimously carried. BUSINESS FROM THE AUDIENCE None COMMUNICATIONS A__~. Woodburn City Council Meeting Minutes of March 28, 2004 PUBLIC HEARING A_,. Design Review 05-01 and Variance 05-05, reauest to change use and renovate the old K- Mad building to a medical facility at t475 Mt. Hood Ave., Matthew Soicer. applicant, EX-PARTE CONTACTS Commissioner Jennin_~s reported he and Bob Engle have been friends for a very long time. However, he did not feel there was any bearing in the way he would vote to support or not support the project. Chairperson Lima indicated he is familiar with the facility and met Mr. Engle at previous Planning Commission meetings. Vice Chairperson Bandelow commented all the Commissioners are probably familiar with the property and Mr. Engle. Staff read the applicable ORS Statement and provided a presentation as reflected in the Staff Report. Staff recommended approval of Design Review 05-01 and Variance 05-05 based on the information in the report, the information provided by the applicant and the applicable review criteria subject to the conditions of approval listed in the Staff Report. Commissioner Jennings indicated he spoke with Staff about concerns he had regarding the easement. He stated there is an easement requirement that was placed on Washington Mutual Bank. Commissioner Jennings further commented there used to be an opening by the Washington Mutual Bank where you Page 1 of 8 Planning Commission Meeting - April 28, 2005 could go right in to that piece of property but apparently the easement has changed from where he thought it was. He inquired what is the easement requirement and do we have any knowledge of what might go in the bare piece of property? Additionally, he asked whether there is an easement in front of the Washington Mutual Bank? Staff replied there has been possible talk of a proposed retail center in the future to go in the bare piece of property. He indicated there is no easement in front of the Washington Mutual Bank. However, the only cross access easement that exists is between the newly created parcels. The property line runs just about in the middle of the two parcels. Commissioner Jennin§s stated it appeared that there was an easement requirement in front of the Washington Mutual drive-thru. Staff said when speaking with Commissioner Jennings last week he believed the easement was further South than it actually is on the partition plat. He commented how it looks on the map compared to how it looks on the ground are two different things. Vice Chairperson Bandelow reported Washington Mutual did open that side at one point. Moreover, the personnel at the bank informed her that the owners of the K-Mart property, at that point, forced them to close it. Staff stated that could be because there is no reciprocal easement that we are aware of. Commissioner Vancil remarked from reviewing the material, he was not clear as to the percentage of the building that will not be developed. Staff responded he believed the entire structure is to be used for the ambulatory health center but there were a few segments of the floor plan that have not been pinned down to precisely what they will be. Commissioner Hutchison asked if the connection to the East was not feasible with K-Mart based upon the property owner not agreeing to it, has it been approached in this case? Additionally, it seemed to him a hindrance to have the connection right up to an unpaved area because it would decrease their paved area very quickly if trucks are being brought through there. Commissioner Hutchison inquired why are we having the applicant put a brand new driveway in to an unfinished area that is practically a field? Secondly, if the person does not agree to that, will it waived? Staff answered they are in position now to make it happen. He stated this is how cross connections are done and how access management is accomplished by doing exactly what has been done in this case. It is the policy of the City to accomplish this as it is clear in the code that you are to do cross connections whenever feasible. The only exception to that would be if the uses or zones were incompatible with each other where you would not want to have a cross connection. However, you definitely want to accomplish cross connection in a commemial zone especially when you are on essentially one of the busiest streets in the City. Staff indicated they are planning for the future and there will be no physical cross connection when this development goes forward and all we can expect from this applicant is that they do their portion. He further reported the easement was required from the adjacent property owner when they partitioned so that there is something to connect up to as far as the easement. There will be no physical connection there until the property is developed and therefore, cars will not be able to drive across that. He also stated the other owner has already agreed by granting the easement and they cannot renege on that. At this point, only the City can allow that to be removed. Staff clarified that Washington Mutual will not be required to do their portion of the improvement. TESTIMONY BY THE APPLICANT Bob Engle, Webstar V. LLC, 610 Glatt Circle, Woodburn, OR 97071 explained a development group called Webstar, which he is a member of, bought the K-Mart building and property solely for the purpose of the use and benefit of Silverton Hospital. He introduced Michael Frasier as the Director for Woodburn Page 2 of 8 Planning Commission Meeting - April 28, 2005 Services for Silverton Hospital and indicated Matthew Spicer, Clark/Kjos Architects, LLC is the architect working for Silverton Hospital in the design of the building. However, Matt Ottinger is present tonight on behalf of Clark/Kjos Architects because Mr. Spicer could not be here tonight. Mr. Engle also introduced Ken and Gene Triplett, Triplett Welllman, Inc., as the contractors who will do the renovation of the building and they also happen to be members of the Webstar Group. Mr. Engle indicated he wanted to get the additional information to the Commission last week and apologized for having distributed it tonight but Staff indicated to him that if he sent it to the Commissioners prior to the hearing it might have been considered as a pre-hearing contact. He also stated he did not have the Staff Report until Friday and Monday was the first opportunity he had to know for sure what he was going to do. Mr. Engle commented they are in agreement with every condition contained in the Staff Report with the exception of the condition for a cross connection. Silverton Hospital, the architects and the property owners consider that condition a recipe for disaster because the uses are not consistent. He pointed out he did not hear from Staff nor did he read in the Staff report why they need the cross connection at this point in time. Mr. Engle referred to Exhibit A-1 and A-2 and stated as it now stands, the reciprocal easement that Staff indicated is in place between what is going to be called Mid-Valley Plaza, Mid-Valley Bank, the sports bar and the entire shopping center is going to have access back and forth to Mr. Wolf's commercial development. Their concerns are with the night use of the sports bar, the restaurant and an urgent care clinic and it not being a consistent use. He also made reference to his memo to the Commission and pointed out the cross connection is not a requirement. It is discretionary for the City to say if it works out, if you have consistency of use, if you have similarity of use, there is not going to be a conflict, then a cross connection would be a good thing. Mr. Engle further remarked the properties would have plenty of exits out on to the major arterials and therefore, the cross connection that will be there will provide more than adequate access for this particular piece of property. He discussed the reasons why they do not want the cross connection in to their property. The owners of the Progress Way property still own it and there were CC&R's in place at the time the properties were planned and in fact still are, that require cross connections and access for the K-Mart property out to Progress Way. He said they want to keep it that way so that access is there because there is no conflict with their use on anything that might go on that property. In closing, Mr. Engle requested that the Commission ask themselves what is the need for the cross connection between the two properties that offsets the potential danger with traffic, drivers and stress conditions going in and out of the urgent clinic at all hours of the day and night? Mr. Engle further reported there would be an aesthetic center, which would include plastic surgery and would have a separate entrance for people that may not want to go through the front entrance for confidentiality issues. Commissioner Bandelow inquired why is the urgent care on that side and not the other? Matt Ottin.qer, Clark/Kios Architect~. stated he was part of the planning and design committee that came up with the layout before the Commission tonight. He reported they do not have the space on the other side of the building because it is very narrow and it is also where all the utilities come in and was prohibitively expensive to relocate. Additionally, he mentioned they are trying to limit the amount of automobile traffic that people will have to negotiate. People going to the center should already be aware of the fact that there are other patients. However, someone coming from a sports bar or other retail outlets may not be aware that they are about to encounter a compromised person walking in front of them. Michael Frasier, Director of Woodburn Operations for Silverton Hospital reported he is responsible for all of the activities of Silverton Hospital in the Woodburn area as well as with some clinic facilities in the · Silverton area. Chairperson Lima commented it appeared that Mr. Engle was picking on a particular individual about the sports bar and the restaurant when he failed to mention that there is another restaurant there that could also benefit from the cross connection. He further remarked he is aware that a sports bar could no longer serve alcoholic products if you are intoxicated because then the owner will be fined and probably lose their liquor license. Secondly, he requested clarification regarding the confidentiality issue concerning a private entryway for plastic surgery patients. Page 3 of 8 Planning Commission Meeting - April 28, 2005 Michael Frasier stated hospitals and health care operations are bound by the HEPA and are obliged to provide a certain level of privacy to their patients, if they so desire. He clarified that is not the sole purpose of having the separate entryway. Vice Chairperson Bandelow interjected she could guarantee that most men or women who are going to have plastic surgery done in the town in which they live will want to enter and leave by a back door. She felt the applicants' statements were absolutely correct and it is one of the things that most of the clinics advertise and she understood the need for a back door. Bob Engle further remarked the confidentiality issue was really not the issue; the issue is that you've got more traffic going around that area. Vice Chairperson Bandelow asked if the applicant's fear would be alleviated if the joining of the properties were further to the South and with perhaps a little reconfiguration out front on the entrance to the applicant's property? Michael Frasier provided the history of the original planning considerations as they looked at the site. He described the building as being a big box sitting on an additional rwe acres of black top, which has less of an ideal environmental situation than they would like to see. Ideally, in a building of that size they would have three public entryways into the building. This presented a real challenge to them just because of the size of the building and as a result they ended up with two of the entryways in the front and Eastside and the placement of the urgent care center was due to the ability to access it. He explained the back area would be a storage area and the employee entrance would be towards the very back. Mr. Frasier reported they would have about 100 employees that work there, 50 of which would be newly created jobs in the area. Additionally, by expanding the urgent care center hours to 8 hours a day 7 days a week from just evening hours, they are currently seeing between 8,000-9,000 patients visits a year. They anticipate that it would be very reasonable to see 15,000-16,000 patient visits a year because the urgent care center will become a higher level urgent care center than it has been with a lot more space, more access to lab and radiographic facilities. It has been Mr. Frasier's experience in previously developed urgent care facilities to see about 19,000 patient visits. He indicated they recognize that will draw from beyond the city limits of Woodburn as well because of all the space and the array of services they want to develop. Mr. Frasier mentioned they are aware of the tight band as you come in the entryway and they assume there would probably be about two ambulance trips a day in and out of the facility. Moreover, truck traffic would be coming in to support the services that are there as well as the employee traffic to the back, which they cannot work around and would have to be aware of that. He expressed concerns with the access and the additional traffic going through the main parking area for the urgent care center trying to come out and complete the loop all the way through to the other side while there is pedestrian traffic. Additionally, he reported they worked extensively with the landscape architects in trying to make the space as green as possible and trying to make it look more than 5 acres of blacktop. Nonetheless, they would need every bit of parking for a significant part of the day and he expressed concerns in that they would be giving up parking spaces and saw themselves with conflicting values. Vice Chairperson Bandelow commented there are some significant advantages to having the crOss connection. Commissioner Jennings interjected the easement will come in to that property because it has already been partitioned and the easement cannot be moved. Chairperson Lima asked Mr. Frasier when would construction start if the project moves forward? Bob Engle answered they hope to begin doing something in September and to complete the project by late next year. Chairperson Lima also inquired whether the urgent care center would be the main business? Page 4 of 8 Planning Commission Meeting - April 28, 2005 Michael Frasier replied the urgent center would be an anchor tenant to other key programs. He described the aesthetic center as being beyond aesthetics and would include dermatology, plastic surgery as well as reconstructive surgery. In addition, there are plans for primary care service through the integrated medicine department. Mr. Frasier pointed out they are a charitable non-profitable organization and see all patients regardless of ability to pay, which is carried through all of their operations. He stated other development and clinical services at other sites would be tied in with the new facility. Bob Engle commented he would like to hear, at some point in time during Commission discussion, why the Commission feel that in the face of all the other entrances and exits that the other properties have that it is so important to have a cross connection vice Chairperson Bandelow expressed concerns with what we are going to be looking at five years from now when someone comes back before the Commission and they have to revisit the issue because there are no connections there. TESTIMONY BY PROPONENTS None TESTIMONY BY OPPONENTS None DISCUSSION Chairperson Lima closed the public hearing and opened up for discussion among the Commissioners. Discussion was started by Chairperson Lima asking Staff about the easement and the possibilities of being relocated to a different area and how much of an impact it would have on the proposed parking areas? Staff referred to the aerial overhead and explained why cross connections are required and why it is a City policy to provide that. It is a policy of the existing Transportation Plan as well as the draft Transportation Plan that is currently being considered by the Council to provide cross connection. Additionally, it is also a policy of the Oregon Department of Transportation through the City's Transportation Plan that we provide for a cross connection for access management. Staff indicated it is obvious you want to address the conflicts of turning movements from driveways on to the highway whenever you have a very busy highway or arterial. He made reference to the applicant's statement regarding conflicts that could be created on site and stated those don't even compare to conflicts and the potential hazards crossing the highway. Having unneeded turning movements across the highway are potentially much more hazardous as they are obviously higher speed and could create much more of a danger to life than conflicts within a parking lot where the speeds are going to be much lower. Moreover, on private property the applicant could put all sorts of traffic calming devices they want to really slow down the traffic and mitigate any potential hazard in the parking lot. Staff said he did not see hazards within the parking lot as an issue. He hoped the Commission would understand that this partition came in before this development plan did. They try to plan for the future and in the best way that makes the most sense to where it hopefully would work in the future for cross connection. Staff further explained it was not feasible to make the access straight across as the parking is tight for the proposed development and doing that would remove at least 15-20 parking spaces. Providing a cross connection would not provide a thoroughfare and we were sensitive to the applicant's concerns about everyone coming through their site. Commissioner Jennings commented the present signals make a break in traffic and he felt there is no danger unless you are not paying attention to what you are doing. He questioned what are the similarities between a retail development, a pizza parlor, a bank and whatever else is out there to a medical facility? There is no relationship to the word "similar', except for zoning and he could not support the easement. Commissioner Vancil pointed out it is a difficult intersection to get out off and will become twice as difficult when you add ten more retail spaces. There isn't enough traffic control on Highway 214 and he could not Page 5 of 8 Planning Commission Meeting - April 28, 2005 imagine allowing the development before the Commission tonight or future development without getting more people coming out at the light because there is more traffic than is safe now. Commissioner Hutchison stated somebody bleeding profusely needing to get in to the urgent center might be coming through within the 2-3 hour rush and he believed the risk of injuring somebody that needs urgent care is something we need to consider. In addition to the current restaurants in the area it is possible that another restaurant facility would go in that could also serve adult beverages and we are giving a thoroughfare to an easier access through a facility that caters to helping people. Chairperson Lima asked whether the condition of access could be modified at this point? Staff replied there needs to be a reasonable expectation that the condition could be accomplished to apply it as a condition, otherwise it would probably be inappropriate to make it a condition. Commissioner Vancil pointed out any way you cut it up you've got the 3 acres of land and we are talking about a space that is approximately 30-40 ft. wide and 100 ft. long that is either going across some place. Is having the road part of the applicant's site plan or is it part of the modifications that were made by Staff to accommodate the easement? Staff clarified the parking lot configuration decision was made with the partition when the easement was established, which provided the only means of providing connection. The design of the parking lot was the applicant's design. Additionally, he indicated the applicant has shown where that easement is but has not shown the physical connection in that area. Staff's recommended condition is that the applicant modify the site plan in that area to actually provide a physical connection, which would entail the loss of three or so parking spaces. Vice Chairperson Bandelow referred to Mr. Engle's question regarding why we think it is important to have the connection. She stated part of it is that very often the Commission has to come back and revisit decisions they've made 2-4 years ago that no longer work as other things change in the City and as traffic worsens. To have a connection all the way across allows flexibility for development for everything. She felt you could safely enter and exit the area because you can wait long enough and make a left or right turn anywhere. However, that is not happening because people are shooting across from Bi-Mart into Shari's at a frightening rate. She thought the access would allow those who would like to be safe as we go in and out a way to do that as we go through the various businesses. Although the interior atrium and the building fa(;ade are fantastic, she felt we should find a way to make the easement work in order to provide some protection to the urgent care center. Commissioner Vancil stated he was in favor of the application with the access and believed we should keep the access; leave it up to the planners and the applicants to figure out how the configuration will be on site. Commissioner Jennings interjected medical facilities sell a service, whereas a pizza parlor or retail developments sell product, which he considers as commercial. Additionally, he stated he could not support creating a thoroughfare clear from Highway 99E to Progress Way. Chairperson Lima asked if the Washington Mutual Bank could provide a jog to get to the easement? Staff answered the connection would not be made until the vacant property is developed or the bank does something that would trigger them to make that improvement. Therefore, whoever comes first would improve the easement across its full length even if part of the easement is on their neighbors property. He further explained it becomes practically impossible to make that type of thing happen if you do not obtain these types of easements. Staff referred to Vice Chairperson Bandelow's comment regarding looking towards the future and providing for this cross access. He mentioned traffic volume will only get heavier on the highway and it may not be that far in the future where ODOT may install a median down the middle of the highway just like has been done North and South of the intersection on Highway 99. Page 6 of 8 Planning Commission Meeting - April 28, 2005 There would be no option for left turns out of the driveways once the median is in. Commissioner Jenninqs remarked having looked at the improvement plan for Highway 214, which includes a 5-lane highway with no median down the middle of it, he felt we should not try to be convinced that somebody would put a median in when they have absolutely no idea in the world what will happen. Additionally, he thought we could not base a decision on something that he guarantees will never happen. He mentioned Mark Wolf has partitioned the property and has indicated as well as has spoken with Staff that he is going to put in a 10-unit retail center. Commissioner Jennings further stated he is living in the real world and knows what the developer is going to do. Therefore, he has to put that information in context and make his decision based upon what he knows is going to happen to that property even though there is no plan submitted to the City today. Vice Chairperson Bandelow further added highway traffic in the real world is going to get greater and there will be more controls on it and we need to have access for all of the businesses along there. Commissioner Vancil interjected the plan when the light was put in was to provide access to all the businesses. Commissioner Jennin~s commented Commissioner Vancil's statement was incorrect, as the plan for an easement to the east was not requested on paper. Chairperson Lima pointed out the fact of the matter is the easement is granted and is required by City ordinance. Commissioner Hutchison questioned whether it is based on the connection or is just suggested and not actually required? Staff responded it is intended to be somewhat flexible depending on the situation. Vice Chairperson Bandelow moved to approve Design Review 05-01 and Variance 05-05 and instructed Staff return with facts and findings, which includes all of the conditions as stated in the Staff Report. Commissioner Vancil seconded the motion. Motion carried with Commissioner Hutchison and Commissioner Jennings voting No. Commissioner Hutchison stated for the record that he felt the project is a benefit to Woodburn in many ways however, he really regrets the access issue. ITEMS FOR ACTION None DISCUSSION ITEMS None REPORTS None BUSINESS FROM THE COMMISSION Chairperson Lima announced the Woodburn Flower Basket Program is currently soliciting donations and he commented the Commissioners have contributed in the past as a group. Commissioner Jennings interjected he refused to ask people at the bench to donate to any program back when he was Mayor. He indicated he supports the program on his own and he recommended the Commission support the program as individuals and not as a Commission. Planning Commission Meeting - April 28, 2005 Page 7 of 8 Commissioner Vancil agreed with Commissioner Jennings. ADJOURNMENT Vice Chairperson Bandelow moved to adjourn the meeting. Commissioner Jennin,qs seconded the motion, which carried unanimously. Meeting adjourned at 8:50 pm. APPROVED CLAUDIO LIMA, CHAIRPERSON DATE A'I-rEST , Jim~ cor n city o Jer, nity Development Director Noodburn, Oregon 12-05- Date Planning Commission Meeting - April 28, 2005 Page 8 of 8 UA I.l.lO LU LU O lOB June 27,2005 TO: FROM: SUBJECT: Honorable Mayor and City Council John C. Brown, City Administrator Public Hearing Related to Sale of Community Center Property RECOMMENDATION: It is recommended the City Council: Reject the Offer of $185,000 submitted by Mark Nyman for 491 N. 3rd Street (the former Woodburn Community Center) because the City has received an offer of higher amount for sale of the property. Conduct the public hearing required by ORS 221.725 on the proposed sale of 491 N. 3rd Street to Deborah Higginbotham for a purchase price of $200,000; and After completing the public hearing, accept the offer of $200,000 submitted by Deborah Higginbotham for 491 N. 3rd Street and direct staff to prepare a resolution documenting the sale of the property. BACKGROUND: In June 2003, the City Council authorized the closure and sale of the former Community Center at 491 N. 3rd Street. The Building was taken out of City service due to its deteriorated condition, disproportionately high costs of renovation, and because City space needs have outgrown the site's capacity. The Council intends to dedicate the proceeds of the sate of various parcels of surplus property, including the Community Center, to help support the cost of a new community center. The City attempted to sell the property for over a year, but was not successful. A number of inquiries were received during that period, including one offer that did not meet the City's needs and which was allowed to expire. Last year, the City listed the property with Hallmark Realty, which has shown the property several times, and has forwarded three offers to purchase Agenda Item Review: City 31 City Attorney_ Finan~ Honorable Mayor and City Council June 27, 2005 Page 2 the property. One of those offers was withdrawn; two of those offers are presented with this report. (Attachments 1 and 2). City property must be sold consistent with ORS 221.725 (Attachment 3). The section requires a city council, when it considers it necessary or convenient to sell real property, to publish a notice of the proposed sale in a newspaper of general circulation in the city and hold a public hearing concerning the sale, prior to the sale. The notice must be published at least once in the week prior to the public hearing and must state the time and place of the public hearing, a description of the property to be sold, the proposed uses for the property and the reasons why the city council considers it necessary or convenient to sell the property. The nature and general terms of the proposed sale, including an appraisal or other evidence of the market value of the property, must be fully disclosed at the public hearing, and residents must be given an opportunity to present written or oral testimony. As i indicated in my May 23rd staff report, an offer to purchase the Community Center was received, which prompted the public hearing that was convened on May 23, 2005. Notice of the hearing was published in the Woodburn Independent on May 18, 2005 (Attachment 4). The hearing was opened on May 23rd, but was continued to June 27, 2005, because the period allowed the prospective buyer to complete his due diligence was extended to June 18th. That period has passed, and in the meanwhile, a second purchase offer was received. DISCUSSION: As indicated previously, the need for sale of the Community Center property is based on the City Council's determination that the building is in deteriorated condition, is too expensive to renovate, and is too small to serve the needs of the community. With respect to value, the property was appraised in September 2001. The appraiser valued the property at $395,000, on the basis of Cost and Sales Comparison valuation approaches. The pertinent portions of the appraisal are included as Attachment 5. A full copy of the appraisal is available for inspection in the City Offices. City staff viewed the 2001 valuation as high; it exceeded an earlier in-house estimate by more than 100 percent. Evidence that the estimate was too high came during the City's attempts to sell the property. The only offer made during that period was $160,000. That offer was rejected as too tow, and because of other terms proposed by the prospective buyer. Hallmark realty provided further evidence that the appraised value was Honorable Mayor and City Council June 27, 2005 Page 3 too high. Hallmark valued the property, based on their experience with comparable sales, at approximately $200,000. The property was listed at $200,000, with the requirement that prospective uses will be consistent with those allowed in a Commercial-Office zone. The property is currently zoned Commercial-General, but is targeted in the Comprehensive Plan update for rezoning to Commercial-Office. The rezone is intended to limit the number, and reduce the intensity, of allowable uses on the site to minimize impacts on the surrounding residential neighborhood. A rezone to residential use is not recommended, because of the size and configuration of the community center, and the nature of its past uses. Other City conditions include the requirement that the sale is subject to City Council approval, and the provisions of ORS 221.725. Two purchase offers are presented for your consideration. April 2005 by Mark Nyman. The second, in June Higginbotham. The first was made in 2005 by Deborah Mr. Nyman offered the City $150,000 for the property, cash at closing from the proceeds of a 1031 exchange, with a 60 day escrow period. Included with his offer was the previously mentioned due diligence period and a requirement that the City meet with him as to the potential use of property. It is Mr. Nyman's intention to rent or lease the property, and his interest is in the uses that would be allowed by the City in a commercial office zone. The City's counter to his offer was for $185,000, which took into account the limitations placed on Mr. Nyman, in adhering to Commercial Office, as opposed to Commercial General zoning. This counter also placed restrictions on the hours of operation of activities to take place in the building, limiting them to 10 pm, with exceptions made for occasional late-night church services, if any. Mr. Nyman accepted the City's counter offer. City planning staff met and talked with Mr. Nyman in May 2005, but was not able to provide sufficient specificity to satisfy him regarding his intended use of the building. This owed, in part, to a lack of specificity on his part as to what he intends to do with the building. This prompted the extension of the due diligence period to June 18th, with a closing date of July 3rd, 2005. On May 19th, 2005 Mr. Nyman provided a list of proposed uses (Attachment 6). On June 2nd, the City responded to Mr. Nyman's inquiry (Attachment 7), and indicated that commercial kitchen space, a day care facility, church, office space, and a gymnasium/fitness center for dance lessons and exercise lessons are allowed uses in the CO zone. The due diligence period expired on June 18, 2005. Mr. Nyman has not indicated whether he is satisfied with the City's response to his inquiries. Correspondence from his real estate broker suggests he Honorable Mayor and City Council June 27, 2005 Page 4 is not. Mr. Nyman indicated, however, on June 23rd that he is willing to go forward with the transaction pursuant to his offer. The proposal from Deborah Higginbotham was received earlier this month, as a back-up offer fo tar. Nyman's. Ms. Higginbofham offered $200,000, contingent on receipt of an SBA loan and City approval of her use of the building as a dance studio. This offer proposes a six-week closing period following the date that if is placed, if if is placed, in first position. I accepted this back-up offer on June 13, 2005. Ms. Higginbofham currently operates the Willamette Ballet. Ms. Higginbofham's proposed use appears consistent with uses allowed in the CO zone, related to Gymnasiums and fitness facilities (as did Mr. Nyman's proposed use of the building for a similar purpose). The City's counter offer provides that the transaction is conditioned on City approval of her proposed use, and her acceptance of any conditions the City may place on if. I have discussed your prerogative as the City Council, with respect to these offers, with the City Attorney. As both offers are conditioned on your approval, you have discretion as to which offer you accept. It is Mr. Nyman's position that you should accept his offer, as it was placed before Ms. Higginbotham's. It is staff's recommendation that you deny Mr. Nyman's offer, because you have received, and may accept, a higher offer. The Council also has that prerogative throughout the public hearing process, with respect to a more attractive offer that might be made by another party as part of their testimony at the hearing. It is staff's belief that the public benefit derived from a higher selling price justifies this action. It is staff's further recommendation that, after you deny Mr. Nyman's offer, you conduct the public hearing on the proposed sale of 491 N 3rd Street to Deborah Higginbotham required by ORS 221.725, and then accept the offer submitted by Ms. Higginbotham. FINANCIAL IMPACT: The recommended action will net the City approximately $188,000 for the former Community Center property, after paying brokerage fees. This money will be placed in reserve, to be used to buy or construct new community facility space. JCB Attachments 1 through 7 34 ATTACHMENT 1 qJ~ ADDENDUM TO REAL EST'ATE SALE AGREEMENT TNS iS ~n Addemtum ~o; areal Estat~ Sa~e Agaaement ["]Seller*s Counter Offer [~Suyer's Counter Offer Re: Rcat Estat~ Sale A~reemen~ No. Dated.__ __ Acldcndum No ..... ._A ..... 5etie~ ..... - . C__I. TY OF WOOD, URN .... SELLER ~D BUY~ HEREBY AGREE THE FOLLO~ S~LL BE A PART ~ 3HE R~E ESTATE SALE ~7~ze R OF ~er Sigm~ure Date_ Setl~r St~nal~e Date ._ 2,3 .35 SELLER'S COUNTER OFFER Re: Real Estate Sale Agreement No. Un-number Dated 4-10-2005 Seller:. City of Woodburn Buyer:. Mark Nyman The real property described as: 491 N. 3rd Street, Woodbum, OR Lots 5, 6 & 7 Block 7 C Addition City of Woodburn Seller agrees to sell ~ real and personal property specified in Buyer's offer on the terms aqd conditions in Buyers offer, except to be Buyer is aware that the City. will restict the use of the property to conform to a Commercial 10 Office use. Transaction is subject to Buyer's satisfaction within 30 days of mutual acceptance that Buyer is able and willing to comply with said use. Buyer is also aware that there will be a restriction of time hours Which shall not be later than 10 PM with exception 'fo'r ocCassionat ..... 13 house and is aware that 3. Transaction is governed and City Council apt: to be on or before AGREEMENT TO SELL: and ~ublic hearing requirements and herein agrees to the 18 of $1"1:~00 for professional real eslate services rendered in this t~ansection. Seller autho~es Listing Firm to order a prelin~nary ~ title report and title insurance at Seller's expense and further authori~__as escrow to pay out of the cash proceeds of sale lhe expenses ~ or before closing, Seller is a U.S. citizen unless otherwise stated herein (See FIRPTA clause in Real Estate Sale Agreement). z; SELLER ACK~aZ)WLEDGES RECEIPT OF A COMPLETELY FILLED IN COPY OF BUYER'S OFFER AND SELLER'S COUNTER z~ OFFIER~ WHICH SFI i FR HAS FULLY REAJ3 AND UNDERSTANDS. Seller ackr~ that Seller has nat received or relied on any ~, statement made by any reel e~ta[e licensee which is not heroin expressed. In the event Buyer fails to complete the sale as herein one) [] First to the listing Firm, to the extent of the agreed commission just as if the transaction had been consummated, with residue to Seller;, or [] 100% Seller Geller $ignal~m ~ , A.M.__P.M. AGF~£M£1~,rl' TO PURCHASE: [] Buyer ~jec~ Seller'S coun~r ofl~:. OR [] Buyer rn~kes the ~f~ched count, er offer. Buyer ,~gr~b~re [~e... , A.M.__P.M. Buyer Signature ~ A.M. , .P.M. SEt I FR'S ACKNOWLEDGMENT: and unde~s[ands. Seller Signature Date , __A.M.__P.M. Setler Signature Date . . , A.M. P.M. RECEIPT OF EARNEST MONEY (Use only if earnest money provided in Buyer's offer is changed by Seller's counter offer). Selrmg F'm-n ~ receipt of earnest nx~-~y from Buyer NOT previous¥ receipted for in the sum of $ evidenced byE]cash, []check, I-Ipromissory note payable on or before ,which Selbg Frm agreesto hax~ as provided inthe Agreement. Selling Licensee's signature Listing Lic,~--qsee , , David..,..J' Christoff Selling Ucensee Phiilip Higgins OregOn Real Estate Forms, LLC. a ~ subsidia~/of the Eugene, Portland Metropolitan and Oregon Associations of REALTORS~ OREF 0{~ 07/02 SELLERS COUt~t'ER OFFER Pffnted Using Pr~'essional Compu~r Forms Co. On-Line Focm, s Software (408) 947-2'107, v. 7102 36 37 ~u~ o=q u;~,,,rz~ ~o10-05 12:0~ PA~ 3 COMMERCIAL ASSOCIATION OF REALTORS~I OREGON/$W WASHINGTON PURCHASE A, ND SALE AGREEMENT AND ~ECEIPT FOR EARNEST MO~EY (O~egon Commerci~ AGENCY AC~OWLEDG~N~ Buyec s~a~l e~ecu~ th~ A~k~uwledgm~t C~rent wi~ ~4. execution of t~e Ag;eement ~a A~e~me~t or an~ ~fms con~n~d therein. p~mu~t t~ the ~em~ts of O~e~ ~minl~tra~iva Ral~ (O~R 863-01~Z15). ~o~n ~nd ~tl~ ac~owledg~ having rK~ve~ the Or~oa Re~! ~ Agenoy 0t~tosum PampN~, and b~ fa} Licensee) is ~e age~t of {~4e~ One): ~ BuYer e~lusiv~; ~ellm exclusively; bo~ S~let Ind Buyer ('D~$e6 Limited ~(~gent n~e) ~ el ~ALLeARK PRO,PERTIES_ {firm) L~cena~) la the agen~ of (chec~ one): ~ BuYer tx~usi~y: ~ Sei~e~ e~usNely: if the ~a~l of the ~me real ~tate firm appears in bo~ Paragraphs fa) and {b) above, Buyer and ~elter a~nowiedge that a prTncipel broker of ~at feel esmte firm shall become the Limited Agent for ~ auye~ and ~tlef, aG mo~e 4ally sat rerth i~ ~e Disclosed Limited Agency kgreemente ~at have heefl reviewed ~d stoned by Buyer. Seit~ ~nd the named real estate ticensee(e). % Buyer; (.print} (aiNu) Buyer. (priRtl ......... (sin Seller: (print} Seitac (print) ~(sign) iGED Da[e: Date: Dote: pURcHASE AND SALE AGREEI~E~IT AND RECEIPT FOR EAR~EST MONEY Dated: ~ , ('Seller'} BETWEEN: C_LTrY oF' WOODBURN I AN1DfOR SELLER O RECORO~ AddresS: AND: ~ ('Buyer') Address: ._-.--. ~uyer offe~ to buy 9pd acqui~ from Sel~r fi) the ~ai p~pe~ and afl improvements thereon commonty known ss ~OODBURX COMMUNITY CENTER aed located at ~9t N 3RD STREET in 1 d 13 ~0 ]FJ~d :8 I~I:BY..S£OS; ~g :~ia 38 the City of ~ County of MARION. Oregon legally described on ~ attached hereto and incorporated herein bl reference 'Prop~'~ ~d [~he~ box If applic~le ~. (il) all of S.lte~s tight, ~e ~d i~ere~t ~n and tO ce~ifl tease(s) by which the Pmpe~y is demis~ n de~rtbad on ~ att~h~ a~ ~n~o~ted ~e~in ~y ~lufenca "Leases'l. U no legal de~lpflon is attache, Buyer and Setter wilt a~h a legal de~riptiofl upo~ receipt and ma~nibie apparel b~ ~oth p~ of t~ Pfelimi~ Commi~ent or, applicable, ~e Survey. ~ p~l~ ~sidemtio~ f~ ~o assignment Of tho Lead(s) to B~yer. ~ the Closing (as defln~ ~ ~ta~ Z hereo~ Buyer sbelt assume ~t et ~ obiigation~ of the substa~alty in the form of ~ ettached hereto (the 'Assign~nr). T~ occupancy of 'Tenafl~es'. P~OCE~O& OFA tOa~ EXCHANGE. 1 .t. Earn~$~ Money 0e~it. Upo~ execution of this Aomement, Buyer shall ~eliver to the Esc~ow H~l~er as defined in heroin, ~r the account of Buyer $~ as earnest money (the 'Earnest ~aey'} in the fo~ of ~ cash or ~ che~k ~ ~ pmmlase~ note (~ "Note'). If t~e Earnest Moaey is in the form of a ~heck bet~ held ~-~p~lt~ by the ~ Listiag Se~ling Fi~m, it s~all be eeposite4 no ta~r ~an 5 PM P~ific ~me three days after execu~on of the A~eement by Buge~ a~d Seller in 1be ~ Listing ~ SeUin9 Firm's Clients' Trust Account U ~ the Es~ow [aa ~emina~er defi~ed). If the Eames~ Money is ~n ~he form o{ Note, it shall be &ue ae~ p~able no tater than 5 P~ Pa~flc Time one day ~ a~ execuiion of this Agreement by Bayer and Seller or ~ after satistact~n or ~vet bl Buyer of OLher:~ if the Note is not r~eem~ and paid in fui~ when due, th~ (11 ~e NOte shall delivered ~d endorsed to Setter (if not ~re~y tn Seller's ~sesslon), (ii) SeUer may the Earaest Money from Buyer, either pursuant to an a~Uon on the Note ~ a~ a~ion on Agreement, and (iii) Sell~ sh~l have no fu~er obligations unde~ t~is Agreement. The 35 perchase and sale of ~e Pro~y shall be accom~ished through an escrow (~e "Escrow'~ ' h Seller has established or will es~blish with FIRS[ AME~CAN TITLE CO (the 'Titte 36 w~ .... ~ ..a *he Ea~t Mosey s~ail be Oeposil~ with ~TIIIe Company or ~ Other: Prope~y at CleatS- Any interest eam~ on t~ Earnest Money s~ali ~ conaidarad to be of ~he Earnest Mone~. The Eareest ~ne~ shall be returned to Buyer ~n t~ event an~ condiUon to Buyer's obligation to purchase the Propel shall fail ~ ~ satt~led or waived t~ugh ac fault of Bayer, 4~ 2. Cop~t~eqs to Purcha~. auye~s e~llgatton to pura~aSe the Proper~ ~oeditioned on t~e followiag: ~ noee or ~ BuyeCs approval of ~e resuR~ et (i) t~a insgectton descdb~ in Section 3 below and (ll) the do~meflt review d~cflbed tn Section an~ (iii) (descttbe ~Y other ~n~i~ofl)SUgJECT TO PuRChASER ~E~tNG W CiTY O~ ~o ~c~ 39 ........ , ~ oo,~ u~uz; ,,~#-IU-O~ 12:07; PAGE 5t12 ~. If for a~y mason in 5uyer's sole disoretion. Buyer has not given wdtte~ 'waiver of the~ con~l~o~s, or st~ted In wCUng that the~e condhJo~ h~e haan satisfied, by written notice 9tven to ~ller wi~in ~ days after ~e dellve~ o~ a fully execut~ Agr~ment to ~uyer a~d Seller, this Agreement shall be deem~ automad~flY te~mina~d, the Earnest ~oney s,~I be prompt~ re~m~ to Buyer, ~d ~areaffer, except as specificity provided to the contra~ herein, neith~ pa~ sh~! hays ~y fu~e[ rigM o~ remedy hero. nde. 3. ~oe~f tnsoectl~ Setter shall permit Buyer and i~ agent, at ~uyer's sale expense and hot, ~ enter t~e ~pe~y at reasonable times a~e re~on~bie prior no~ce to Seller and af~ pdo~ no~e to the ten~ of the Property ~ reqair~ by ~e tenants' leas~, if ~ny, to ~nduct ~ny and all i~peGt~ns, tests, and surveys concerning the structurN comdition of t~ imPlYemea~. ~lt m~6~.l, ete~ic~[ and plumbing systems. ~azardoue materials, peet lnfaststion, sNIs ~ondiflons, wallace, Ame~cans with Oi~bi~tl~ A~ ~mptianea, and all o~er m~s affec~ng t~ sui~ilL~ of ~e Pfope~y for B=yer's intende~ use ~d/or o~erwise reasonably related lo t~e p~mhase of the P~pe~y including ~e ~onomic feasibility of such pumhase. Bayer sh~l indemnify, hold harmleSS, and defe~ Seller from ail liens, co5~, and axings, inGludifl9 reasonable attorneys' fe~ and expeds' fees, ads~g from 0r relaUng to 9uyedsent~ aa snd i~pec~on of ~e Property. This ~greemen/ m t~demni~, hold he. lees, and defend S~lef sh~l survive closing of any lamination of thim Agmemen~ 92 4. Sptle?s Doormen.. Within ~ d~ys after ~e ExeCution D~e, Belier shatl Z3 deliver to Bayer, at 6u~e~a address s~wn h~ow, legible and complete copies of the followifl9 ~ documents and otha~ item r~ating to ~e o~ne~bi~, oper~on, and maintea~e o1 the ~S Prope~, to ~e extent now in axis~nce and ~ the ext. nt s~h Items are ~ithin Sellers ~ CApTIAL tMP~OVE~E~TS COM~ETE~ WlI~ p~T 2& MOH~HS,, LI~T O~ AHY HESC ZZ PROV E BY R OCU A IF ANY. 30 5. TiUe insurance. WiAtn [ days after the Ex.uriah nam, ~iler shall open the 3t Escrow with [he Title Company a~ ~iiver to Buyer a preliminary title mpo~ ~om ~he TiU~ 3Z Company (the 'Preliminary CommiSsAr'}. showin~ the s~atus of SelieCs title ~o ~e Prope~, ~ ~ogethef with complete and legible copies of ali documents shown therein as exceptions to ~4 title ('Ex~eptiQns'}. Buyer shell have 5 days a~er receipt of a Gopy of the Preliminary ~5 Commi~ent and Ex,options wi~in which~o give ~otlce in wrlU~ to Seller of any objection to 36 suc~ tide ~r to an~ liens or encumb~ces a~ec~ng the Pmpe~. Wi~in ~days afar the date ;~ of such nott~e from Buyer, Seller shall give Buyer wrt~en noUce of whether it ~ wiili~9 and ~s able To removl the ob~md-~ ~ceptlons. Within 5 days alter the ~ate of such notice )9 from Seller, 6uye~ shall eMct whm~er to (i) purcha~ t~e Properly ~ubje~ to those ob~ec~d- ~ tO ExGe~iQns whic~ Seller is n~ willing or able t~ remove or (ti) terminate this Agreement. ~l On or before ~e Closing ~ate (defined below), SeLler shall remove mt Ex~eptio~s to which +2 Buyer obj~ and which Seller agrees SelTe~ is willing and able to remove. Ali remaining Exceptions set forth in the PTetiminary Commitment a~d agreed tO by Buyer shall be deemed Seller to Buyer ~ "PermiBed ExcepSo~ · The ttUe ~surance polt~ ~ ~ delivered by 4~ al Closing shall conmi~ no Exceptions other than the Permi~ed ~cepUons, any Exceptions ~ caused by Buyer and the usual preprinted Excep~ons cad. ned iff an o~eCs s~ndard ALTA 47 form title ins~ranGe pot~GT. ~~/ 40 1 5 ? Il 21 2~ 2'7 ~9 30 31 6. ~: Notwithstanding an¥1~hing to the contrary ~ntained in Chis Agreement. in the e~e~ Buye~ fails to deposit the Earnest Mone~ Deposit in Esc~ow stfl~ly as no fauR of Buyer, to close the sale of ~e Prope~Y, Buyer shal be a~tled to pumue any ~emed[es available at law o~ in equitY, [~ctudi~ wffb~t limitation, the remedy of s~ecltic pedorma~ca, tn no event shail 9uy~ be entitt~ to punitive or co~seq~ential damages, if any, resulting ~om Seller's failure to ~1o~ the sale ot ~e PrepaY. ~ e~ the Execute Date {~ Closing Oats ~T ~. au er and Selt~ ag~ t~ ~le et ~e PrOperty shall ~ ~n the Escrow. The sa{ sh~ be d~med closed when the d~umen~6) ~onweylng flue to ~e PTope~ is recorded and ~e P~ha~ Price [increased or deleted, ~ the caae may be. by the ~et emount of credi~ and debits ~ Seller's a~ou~t at Closing made by ~a ESCROW ~O~d~[ Seller shaft ~epOSlt w~k t~ Title Company ail documents and funds required to close the t~s~flon io accordance with the terms of this Agr~menL AI Closing, Seller shall ~eliver a cerfiflcat~n i~ a form approved by Buyer th~ ~lier ~ ~[ a '~eiSn 'person" as suchtetmis define6 i~ the Internal Re.hue Code and the T~asu~ Regulations promul~ted under ~e ln~nsl Re.hue C~e. ~ Seller ia a foreiOn pe~n a~d this transactioP Is ~t othe~ise exempt from FT~A regulations, the Title ~mpany shaft be instructed by the paffies to withhold and pay the amount required by !~ to the tntemal Revenue Service. At Closing, Seller shatl convey fee Simpie tiUe ~ the Property [¢ Buyer by ~ statutory warranty d~d or ~ (~e 'Deed'} If this Agreeme~ provides for the ~a~eyance by Seller of a vendee'a interest In tbs PrO~ffy by a uo~m~ of sate, Salter shst~ depustt ~[~ the T~e Comply (or othe~ m6tually acceptable escrow) the executed and aGknowtedged Dead, together with wfi~en [ns~d~to~ to deiiv~ su~ da~ W Buyer u~n payment in fall of the purcha~ price. At Ciosi~g, Seller shNi pal ~r and deliver to Buyer a standard AL~A ~orm owner's po[i~ M title insuraece (the "POlTGy'} in the amount ef the ~ Purchase PriGs insuring tee sim~le title ~ ~e Prope~ [n ~uyer s~t o~iy to the Permitted 3~ E[cepfiofls a~d the standa~ preprinted excepkions coe~ine~ in the Poticy. 37 6. Closinfl COsts; ptemte~. ~lter shatt pay t~ premium for the Policy. 3S and Buyer sha~i ea~ pa~ efta'hal or the escrow f~ Gh~9ed by the Tltla Company. any 3~ excise ~x, and way trsflsfet ~. ReM ~opa~ t~es for the tax yea[ ~a which the ~aflsaGfiOn ~ Ts G~SeO, ~sesaments {if a pe~mi~d ExcepSon}. persoflai properly ta~s. re~ and ot~er 4] Lessee char~es 8~siflg from ex.ting Tenancies paid ~or the mofl~ of Closing, i~te[est on 4z assumed obligations, an~ utilities cheil be pro~d as of ~e Closi~ Oats. Prepaid rems, 43 security ~epo~, a~d ether Gnearned refund~ie deposits regarding ~e Tenant.s shall ~ be assigned and delivered to 6uyer at Closing. ~ Seller ~ Buyer ~ NIh shall be ~5 responsible for payment of ail tares, i~terest, and pe~Gties, if any, upon removal of the ~ p~er~ f~m any speclel assessment or program, ZEZTsLgEss t~6 :~O ~00~18[/t~0 41 2 4 :party, s~b~ect to the Tenancies existing be entitled to exclusi~ie possession o! the as of the CIoeioO Date, ~ on the Closing Date or 10. ~ Setter represents that, m the best o! Seller's knowledge no written notices of violation of any laws, codes, without speciflo inquiry, Seller has recsivect of any such toanY repair or cortest. Risk of toss or dam MADE HO REPRESENTATIONS TO ANY P~RTY EEGAROING THE CONOI~ION OF THE PROPERS, T~E OPERATIONS ON OR iNCOME FROM THE PROPERTY, THE OR WHETHER THE pRo~RTY OR THE UgE THEreOF COMPLIES WiTH ~WS. Except tot Sellers mpresentat~ns set ~rth in This s~tiofl 10, 6dyer shall acqaira the Pro~Y 'as with ali faui~ ~nd buyer shaft ~iy off the tesut~ of its own inspection and investigation in of Seller's right to retain ~e ~amest Money ~ of C~stn~, that itl of The Sailor's representations ~nd warranties stated in this Agreement are m~[efiaity true and co~a~t on the 1t. ~ This sale ineL~es the tonguing personal ~ or ~ the personal propaffy located off ann used in connection ~ith the Prope~Y and owned ~Y Setter ~bic~ Seller s~[! itemize in a sefl~le. Salter shall deli~er to Buyer such owned by Seller on or in ~e Property to Buyer by executing and d~i~eriag ~ Buyer al Closing through Escro~ a Bill of S~e substanfieit~ in ~he fo~ of ~ at. chad hereto and 3o inco~omte~ herekn b~ ~ference (the 'BiLl o~ 31 32 33 12, Notkca~. Unless othe~ise specified, any notice requited or pe~itted ~ or related to, tbis Agreement must be in writing and signed ~I the pa~? m be bound. Any l~ notice will be deemed delivereO (~) when pemonall~ ~liveted of delivered by facsimite ~6 tmnsmkssio~ (with ele~ronic ~nflrmation of deli~ery), or (ii) on the d~y foito~in9 deiNery 31 ot the no,ce by re~utabla overnight ~.rier, or (iii) ~ree (3) days after mailing in tbs ~l malts, postage prepad, b~ the ~pticabte pa~y iff a~ arena, to the address ot ~e other 3e shown Iff this Agr~ment, unt~ that day is a Sa~reay, ~unday, or regal holiday, tn which ~ event it will be deem~ delivered on the next following ~usiness day. if the deadline under a~ this Agreement for delivery of a notice or payment is a SatardaY, Sunday. or teGa[ holiday. ~ such last day witl be deemed extended to the next follo~in~ bosiness 43 Ass' est Buyer ~ may not assign ~ m~ assign ~ may a~ei~n, onty if ~5 the assi~oee i5 afl eflttt~ gonad a~d contmtle~ by Buyer [may tot assign, if no box ~ checked) thio Agreem~t or ~uyer's ~g~f~ under this Ag~emeflt without Sailor's prior written 41 consent. If S~lef's ~nsent is requi~ tot assig~eflL such consent may be withhet4 Seite~s reasonable discretion. 42 ' e . s~tt, action, arl~itration, or other l~roceeding of Cod~, is insttt~te~, ac the serv~es of an afforney are re~ined, to i~terprM or enforce any prevision of Ibis Agreeme~ or ~i~ resp~ to any ~tspute ~lMtng ;a ~is Agreement, ~mvatling p~f shatt be entifl~ to m~ovir from t~e iosi~ P~ ~S attorneys', p~l~els', accOua~ts', a~d other e~s' lees ~nd all e~e~ f~a, cos~, a~ ex~nses a~tualty and reasonably neoe~a~ tn c0anec0on therewith (t~e *;ees"~. In the ~e~t of suit, action, arbitration, or othlr ~mceedi~g, the amount ~ Fees 5h~! be de.reined ~Y the ~udge or a~itr~tor, sh~i In=lode ~[ cos~ an~ expanses ~ncu~d o~ ~ appe~ or re,taw, and shall be in addition t~ ail other ~tS prOv~ad by la~. 15. Stat~to~ ~nd ~se ~i~taima~ THE PROPERTY DESCRIBED IN THIS iNSTR~EHT MA~ NOT BE WiTHin A FIRE PROTECTION DIS~RIC~ PROTECTING S~RUCTURES. THE PROPER~ IS SUBJECT TO L~D USE ~WS ~O REGULATIONS. WHICH, IN FARM &~O FORES~ ZONES, MAY NOT AUTHORIZE CONSTRUCtiON OR OF A RESIDENCE AND W~IC~ L[M1T LAWSUITS AGAINST FAR~ING Off FOREST p~CTICES AS DEFINED IN ORS 30.938 tN ALL ZONES. BEFORE StGNIHG OR ACCEPTING THiS iNSTRUMENt, THE PERSON ACQUIRING FEE TITLE TO T~E P~OPER~ SHOULD CHECK WlTH THE APPROPRIATE CI~ OR COUNTY PLANNING 0SPARTAN1 TO VERIF~ APPROVED USES AND THE EXISTENCE OF FIRE pRO~CTION FOR STRUCTURES. 16. Caut~na~ NOtice About Liens. UNDER CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES, A PERSON W~0 PEREORMS CONSTRUCTION-RELATED ACTIVITIES MAY C~iM A LiEN UPON REAL PROPERTY AFTER A SALE TO THE PURCHASEA FOR A ~RA~SACTION OR AC~iVI~ THAT OCCURRED BEFORE THE SALE. A VALID C~IM MAY aE ASSERTED AGAINST THE PROPERTY ~HAT YO~ AR~ PURCHASING EVE~ IF THE CIRCUMSTANCES THAT GI~E RISE TO THAT C~iM HAPPENED ~EFORE YOUR PURCHASE OF THE ]~ P~OPERTY. THIS INCLUDES, ~UT IS NOT LIMITED ~O, ~IRCUMSTANCES WHERE THE ze OWNER OF T~E PROPERTY CON~ACTED WITH A PERSOH OR 9USINESS TO PROVIDE ~0 LABOR. MATERIAL, EQUIPMENT OR SERVICES TO T~E PROPER~ AND HAS NOT PAiD 3t T~E PERSONS OR BflSI~ESS IN 17. ~. Time ~s of ~he essence of this Agreement. The facsimile trans~issio~ of a~Y signed document including ~is Agreement, in a===~dan=e ~h Paragraph 12. shall ~ ~a ~ame as delivery of an original At t~e request =f either ~arty, the paAy delivering a duptiGate original document T~is Agreement may be executed in ~o or more countesses, each of whic~ shall ~ons[itute an original and ali of w~ich together shall constitute 0aa an~ the same AgreemeaL This Ag~eamenl contains t~a entire agreement and 4o understanding of the ~adies with res~t to the sublet maker ef this Agreemeet supersedes all ~fior and ~ntempo~an~us agreements betw~n them with rasper thereto. Without limi~ag the provisions of Sa~tiO~ 13 of this Agreement, ~is ~r~ment shall be binaing upon an6 shall inure to the ~aneflt of the padi~ and thor raspe~ve successom assians. The person signing ~is Agreement an behaf of auye~ an~ the person signing this Agreement on behalt of Sailer each represent, co~aaants and warrants ~at such p~son has full right end adtbority to enter inffi this Agreement and ~ bin~ ~e pa~V for ~hom s=ch 47 pe~o~ signs this Ag[cement to the terms a~d provisions of this Agreement This Agreement shall not be recorded unless t~e pa~i~ otherwise e9ree- 4g 4.3 SENT BY: ; 503 554 9202; APR-IQ-05 14:20; PAGE 8 50~55+ 9203; APR-10-06 attac~ad to thi~eement and tnGorporated within t~is Agreemeat: 'Tim~ fol ~ccegm~c~. Seller AAS anttl 5:~0 ~.m. Pacitts Time on ~11~,, to o~. AcceP~n~ is not eff~ve un~l a copy of 19. accept this signed an~ ~ate~ ~I Seller is aGtuatty r~eived by Buyer. sflatt expire and the Ea~est Mo~ay shai be ~mmpfl? re~nd~ 'to Buyer a~d thereafter, neither parW s~ail have anl f~her rtgh[ of remedy ~aa~ the e~er. ~~ ~y axe=uriah of this Agreement, ~atlel agrees m .w, .,- - r - ~Ot~l amount computed acoordanoe wi~ g) the 6.~ng agreement or other ~mmission agreement dated agrees to pay a commission of ~ ~ pement [~) of the purchase pri~e or (i~ Closing o[ (ii) the d~a Buyer waives ~1 condi[~as preceder ~ Ctostn~ as set ~ In this the Escrom Holder to deliver to Stoker ~e real esta~ ~ommission on ~e Ct~iag Date or upon ~etler's breac~ of ~is Agreement, w~iGhever ~um flint, if t~e Earnest Money is fodeited an~ retained by Seller in ~cord~ce with this Agreement. in addition to any o~ rights the Bm~ar may Rave, the Brok~ s~all be entitled to the laser of (A) fi~ percent (50%1 of the Ear~s[ Money or (B~the commission agreed t~ above, an~ Seller hereby assigns such amount to me Broker. 2i. ~. The Execution Date is ~e later of the ~o datea shaw~ Beneath the p~rties' signatures below. ~9 22. Ga~e~in~ ~ew. This Agreement is made and execu~d under, and in all 3o respite shall b~ governed and construea b~ the taws of the State of O~egan. ;~ CONSULT YOUR ATTORNEY. THIS DOCUMENT HAB BE~ PREPAREO FOR SUBMISSION ~3 TO YOUR kTTORNEY FOR REVIEW 'AND APPROVAL PRIOR TO SIGNING, NO ~4 R~PRESENIATION OR RECOMMENDATION IS ~OE BY T~E COMMERCIAL ASSOCIATION IS OF REALTORS~ OREGONISW WASHINGTON OR BY THE REAL ESTATE LICENSEES ~6 iNVOLVED WITH THiS DOCUMENT AS TO THE LEGAL SUFFICIENCY OR TAX ~7 CONSEQUENCES OF THIS DOCUMENT. 3~ 3~ THIS FORM 8HOUL0 NOT BE MOOtFtED WITHOUT ~HOWING SUCH MODIFICA~tONS aY ~ REOLINING, iNSERTIO~ ~RK8, OR ADDENDA ...... Execution Date ' Time of Execution ~ o _ Office Phone ~~ .~.., ~t~ ~dress 7d13 ,:1-4 8~N1~ ~y| ~ OU~ ~4 ~U~ APH-1U-U: 14|2t~ PA~E ~ 12:10; Z[I) ............. ~o7 ~ o~ Signature ..... EXi. IIBIT A LEGAL DE$CI~IPTIO# Of: PROPERTY 45 20 21 46 ATTACHMENT SELLER'S COUNTER OFFER I The Oregon Real Estate Agency has reviewed tiffs form for compliance with the applicable provisions in ORS.696 and finds that 2 it complies with ~ pr~isions. 3 4 Re: Reat Estate Sale Agreement No. /'~"¢~ *' Dated6-9-2(X~ 5 Buyer: Deborah I-liRginbotham 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 2O 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 3O 31 32 33 Seller: City of Woodburn The real property described as: 491 N 3RD ST Woodburn OR 97071 Seller agrees to sell the real and personal property specified in Buyer's offer on the terms and conditions in Buyer's offer, except as modified below: 1. Train is a back-up offer subject to release or cance,lation,.,~,Present primary offer.. 2. Transaction is ,q~,~erned by ORS 221,72S arm is sub~ect to public notice and public llearin~l requ~ents and City Council aDDr~! a~ is aware that this may delay closin¢l and herein aflraes to clo~in.q date beinfl on or before Au~lust 317 200~. 3. Transaction is su~ to City approval of Buyer's apl31ication ~ ~ ~ 13r_o~ as a dance studio a~nd___Bu~, er'~ ~oval of any Cit~ co~itions, For additional provisions, see Addendum. AGREEMENT TO SELL: All provisions of this offer (or counter offer(s), where applicable) not otherwise modified, are approved and accepted by Seller. Time is of the essence of this counter offer. This counter offer shall automatically expire on Date June t67 200~ , a.m.6;00 p.m., if not accepted within that time. However, Seller may withdraw this counter offer any time prior to written acceptance. This counter offer may be accepted by Buyer only in writing. If Buyer accepts Seller's counter offer, Seller agrees to pay to the Selling Firm, or if this is a co-op transaction, the Listing Firm, the sum of $t2~000.00 for professional real estate services rendered in this transaction. Seller authorizes Listing Firm to order a preliminary title report and title insurance at Sellers expense and f~Jrther authorizes escrow to pay out of the cash proceeds of sale the expenses of furnishing title insurance, Sellers recording fees, Seller's closing costs and any encumbrance on the property payable by Seller on or before closing. Seller is a U.S. citizen unless otherwise stated herein (See FIRPTA clause in Real Estate Sale Agreement). SELLER ACKNOWLEDGES RECEIPT OF A COMPLETELY FILLED IN COPY OF BUYER'S OFFER AND SELLER'S COUNTER OFFER, WHICH SELLER HAS FULLY READ AND UNDERSTANDS. Seller acknowledges that Seller has not r~eived or relied on any statement made by any real estate licensee which is not herein expressed. In the event Buyer fails to complete the sale as herein provided, the earnest money shall be distributed as follows after deduction of any title insurance and escrow cancellation charges: (check one) I'-I First to the Listing Firm, to the extent of the agreed commission just as if the transaction had been consummated, with residue to Seller; or [] Seller Sigl Date __a.m. ~.~.m. Seller Signature ~'~. ~ ~/'/~ ~- /.~2/7'-~~/ Date . , __a.m. , p.m. 36 37 AGREEMENT TO PURCHASE: 38 ~ Buyer accepts Seller's counter offer. 39 /ri Buyer rejects Seller's counter offer: OR ri Buyer makes the attached counter offer. 41 Buyer Signature ~~(, Date=_ 42 Buyer Signature Date . 43 44 SELLER'S ACKNOWLJE~NT: 45 Seller acknowledges receipt of copies of Buyer's offer and of Seller's counter offer bearing Buyer's signature, which Seller has fully read 46 and understands. 46 Seller Signature Date. _ __a.m. __ _p.m. 49 Seller Signature Date .......... a.m. , p.m. 5O 51 52 53 54 55 56 RECEIPT OF EARNEST MONEY (Use only if earnest money provided in Buyer's offer is changed by Sellers counter offer). Selling Firm ac. knowledges receipt of earnest money from Buyer NOT previously receipted for in the sum of $. ri by cash, ri check, [] promissory note payable on or before . , which Selling Firm agrees provided in the Agreement. Selling Licensee's signature evidenced to handle as 57 58 Listing Licensee David Christoff Selling Licensee Victor Morris 59 Listing Firm Broker's Initials/Date ~/~ / ~'-/~-~"~ ~ Selling Firm Broker's Initials/Date © 2005 Oregon Real Estate Forms, LLc 0'~/05 No portion may be reproduced without express permission of Oregon I~eal ~tate Forms, LLC OREF 003 iSale Agreement FINAL AGENCY ACKNOWLEDGMENT Both Buyer and Setler acknowledge having received the Oregon Real Estate Agency Disclosure Pamphlet, and hereby acknowledge and consent to the following agency, relationships in this transaction: (1) ~',]~.L'~27* ~'V[()~r~q'~ (Name of Selling Licensee) of '..*1~1..~ ~ ~/.l~-~.,' (Name of Real Estate Firm) is the agent of (check one):~e Buyer exclusively. QThe Seller exclusively ("Seller Agency"). Q Both the Buyer and the Seller ("Disclosed Limited Agency"). '"' ' '; ¢ i-' _ . Y** t - (Name of Real Estate Firm) (2)__ \~:til( (~'t%TO ¢6 (Name of Listing Licensee) of is the agent of (check one): ::ji~.The Seller exclusively. Q Both the Buyer and the Seller ("Disclosed Limited Agency"). (3) If both parties are each represented by one or more Licensees in the same Real Estate Firm, and the Licensees are supervised by the same principal broker in that Real Estate Firm, Buyer and Seller acknowledge that said principal broker shall become the disclosed limited agent for both Buyer and Seller as more fully explained in the Disclosed Limited Agency Agreements that have been reviewed and signed by Buyer, Seller and Licensee(s). Buyer shall sign this acknowledgment at the time of signing this Agreement before submission to Seller. Seller shall sign this acknowledgment at the time this Agreement is first submitted to Seller, even if this Agreement will be rejected or a counter offer will be made. Seller's signature to this Final Agency Acknowledgment shall not constitute acceptance of the Agreement or any terms therein. Buyer __ Print Print Seller Print Date Date 9 10 !2 13 14 ~5 16 17 This Agreement is intended to be a legal and binding contract. If it is not understood, seek competent legal advice before signing. 1. DEFINITIONS: All references in this A~ to 'lJcensee" and "Firm" shall refer to Seller's and Buyers real estate agents licensed in ff~ State of Oregon and the respective real estate companies with which they are affiliated. The Licensee(s) and Rrm(s) ~ in the F~'~al Agency Ad,-.nowtedgment Section above are not parties to this Agreement, except as may be applicable in Sections 35, 36, 37, 41 and 44, below. Unless otherwise provided herein: (1) Time calculated in days after the date Seller and Buyer have signed this Agreement shall start on the first full business day after the date that the last party has signed accepting th~s Agreement, induding counteroffer(s), if appl~; (2) written notices required or permitted under this Agreement to be delivered to Seller or Buyer may be delivered to their res~ Licensee with the same effect as if delivered to that Seller or Buyer; (3) a't)~siness day" shall mean and include Monday through Friday; exit recognized legal holidays as enumerated in ORS 187.010 and 187.020. DESCRIPTION: Buyer (print n~me(s)) ~'~)~.-¢-( /L¢ [~.-( ,4¢~.~ (~ 2. PRICE/PROPERTY offers to purchase from Seller (print name(s)) '~'t""~ :,~¢~ -~i~. ~, ~,:,-_'~.ct¢I,~ the following described real property (hereinafter"the Property") situated in the State of Oregon, County of ~¢.z,t ¢%c ~*'? , and commonly known or identified as (insert street address, c ty, zip code, tax identification nut~ber, and/or lot-block description, etc.). (Seller and Buyer agree that if it is not provided herein, a complete legal description as provided by the title insurance company in accordance with Section 4, below, shall, where necessary, be used for purposes of tegat identification and conveyance of title) for the purchase price (in U.S. currency) of ...................................................... A $ on the following terms: Earnest money herein receipted for ................. B $_ ~ ,, ~ {-~ ~ on as additional earnest money, the sum of ....... C $ at or before closing, the balance of down payment .............................. D $ at closing and upon delivery of Q DEED Q CONTRACT the sum of (Lines B, C, D and E should equal Line A)._.. ...................... E $ Payable as follows (Describe details of any loan(s) to be obtained): '~'~'~i¢~ [o&~, '+ h~"~¢'.i For additional details, see Addendum 3. BUYER REPRESENTATION 1 LOAN CONTINGENCY: As of the date of signing this Agreement, Buyer has sufficient funds available to close this transaction in accordance with the terms proposed herein, and is not relying on any contingent source of funds (e.g. from loans, gifts, sale or cIosing of property, 401K disbursements, etc.), unless otherwise disclosed in this Agreement. !F A NBc*4 LOAN tS REQUIRED, THIS TRANSACTION IS SUBJECTTO BUYER AND PROPERTY QUAUFYtNG FOR THE LOAN AND THE LENDER'S APPRAISAL BEING NOT LESS THAN THE PURCHASE PRICE. This contingency is soteiy for BuyeFs benefit and may be waked by Buyer n wr~ng. Buyer agrees ~o make wntten loan application not later than / ~ [~,~siness days (three (3) if ngt fiiied in), after the date Seiter ~qd Buyer have signed this Agreement, and thereafter compete necessa~ry papers, and exert best efforts, including peyment of ail application, appraisal and processing fees, in order to prccure the ban. Buyer authorizes tender to provide non-confiderd'Jai informaticn to Usting ar~ Selling Ucensees regarding status of the !oan. ~f Property ~ ',ocated in a designated ficod zone, Buyer acknowledges that flood insu~nce may be ,~equired as a condiC.~on of the new ban. Buyer is encouraged to promptly veri.~ the ~¢ailabi~ity and cost of prcperty/casua~ insurance that wilt be secured for the Properb: 4..,%-'~,?- ~NSURANCE: Uniess otheP,vise provided herein, this transaction is subject to Buyer's review and approval of a preiiminap/t~tle report and the ~ecorded covenants, conditions and restrictions ('~e report and CC&Rs") showing the condition of '~tte to the Property. (if not fully understood, Buyer should immediately co,tact the dtle insurance company for fu~her nformation or seek competent ',egst advice. Neither the L[sting ;'~or Belting L;ceceeee sro quaiified to ~d%,ise on specific !egal o~ tit~e issues). Upon execution of this AGreement by Se!ter a,nd Buyer, Se(',er wiiL at Seilers sole expense, promptty orCer the report and ~ Oregon Real Estate Forms, LLC 01/05 ~ --¢ - ¢-~- OREF 001-1 Buyer nitials'~jZ'~ / Date REAL ESTATE SALE AGREEMENT - Page i of 7 ! Seller Ini NOTE: Filt in preprinted number from Page l [SateAgreement# i,~'~ ~ ~ .~ .~" t ..... I CC&Rs from an Oregon title insurance company and furnish them to Buyer. Upon receipt of the report and CC&Rs, Buyer shall have business days (five (5) if not filled in) within which to notify Seller, in writing, of any matters disclosed in the report and CC&Rs which is/are unacceptable to Buyer ('~e objections'~. Buyer's failure to timely object, in wdting, to any matters disck)sed in the report and/or CC&Rs shall constitute acceptance of the report and/or CC&Rs. Provided, however, Buyer's failure to timely object shall not relieve Seller of the dut~ to convey marketable title pursuant to Section 6 below. If, within business days (f~Je (5) if not filled in) folk)wing receipt of the objections, if any, Seller fails to remove or correct the matters identified in the objections, or does not give wdtten assurances reasonably satisfactory to Buyer that they wilt be removed or corrected pdor to the closing date, all earnest money shall be promptly refunded to Buyer and this transaction shall be terminated. This contingency is solely for Buyer's benefit and may be waived by E~Jyer in writing. Within thirty (30) days after closing, Setler shall furnish to Buyer an owner's standard form policy of title insurance insudng marketable title in the Property to Buyer in the amount of the purchase price, free and clear of the objections and all other title exceptions agreed to be removed as part of this transaction. 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 62 63 64 65 For additional provisions, see Addendum 6. DEED: Seller shati convey marketable title to the Properb! by statutory warranty deed (or good and sufficient personal representative or trustee's deed, where applicable) free and clear of all liens of record, except property taxes which are a lien but not yet payable, zoning ordinances, building and use restrictions, reservations in Federal patents, easements of record which affect the Property, covenants, conditions and restrictions of record and those matters accepted by Buyer pursuant to Section 4 above. 7. FIXTURES: All fixtures, including remote controls and essential related equipment, are to be left upon the Property. Fixtures shall include but not be limited to: Built-in appliances; attached floor coverings; drapery rods and curtain rods; window and door screens; storm doors and windows; system fixtures (irrigation, plumbing, ventilating, cooling and heating); water heaters; attached electric lights and bathroom fixtures; light bulbs; fluorescent lamps; window blinds; awnings; fences; alt planted shrubs, plants and trees; EXCEPT: I'~ ~ ~-.X(Z~.,~"~e~ _,; 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 PERSONAL PROPERTY: The following personal property, in "AS-IS" condition and at no stated value is included: 76 77 9. ALARM SYSTEM: Q NONE Q OWNED Q LEASED. If leased, Buyer Q will ::l will not assume the lease at closing. Approximate monthly lease payment is $ 10, SELLER REPRESENTATIONS: (1) The above dwelling is connected to (check all that apply): ~[~a public sewer system; Q an on-site sewage system; ~a public water system; ~ a private well. (2) At the earlier of possession or closing date, the dwelling will have one or more operating smoke alarms or smoke detectors as ~equired by ~aw. (See, http//www, sfm.state.or, us) (3) Seller has no knowledge of any hazardous substances on the Property other than substances (if any) contained in appliances and equipment. Buyer acknowledges that asbestos commoner exists in ~nsulation, ceilings, floor coverings and other areas in residential housing and may e×ist in the Property. (4) Seller knows of no material structural defects. (5) All electrical wiring, heating, cooling, plumbing and irrigation equipment and systems and the balance of the P~perty, including the yard, will be in substantially its present condition at the time Buyer is entitled ~o possession. {6) Seller has no notice of any {iens to be assessed against the Property. (~ Seller has no notice from any 9ovemmental agency of any viol~ticn ~f ~aw relating to the Properbt. (8) Seller is not a"foreiGn person" under the Foreign investment in Real Property Tax .Act ("FIRPTA") as defined in Section 25 below. (9) Seller agrees to promptly notify Buyer if, prior to closing, Se!~er receives actual notice of any went or condition which could :esult in making any previously disclosed material Information relating to the Property substantially misleading or incorrect. These ;epresentations are based upon Seller's actual knowledge. Seller has made no investigations. Exceptions to items (1) thrcugh (9) are: 78 79 80 81 82 84 85 86 87 88 90 91 9~ Buyer acknowledges that the above ;*epresentations are not warranties regsrdinG ~he condition of the Property and are ~ot a substitute 'for, nor in lieu of, Buyer's own responsibility to conduct a thorough and complete independent investigation, including the use of professionals, where app¢opriate, ~egarding all material matters bearing on the condition of the Property, its value and its suitability for 9uyer's intended use. Neither the Listing nor Selling L[censees shall be responsible for conducting shy inspection or investigation of any aspects of the Property. 11. "AS-iS": Except for Setler's express written agreements and written representations contained herein, and Seller's Property Disclosure, if any, 9uyer is purchasing the Property "AS-kS," in its present condition and with all defects apparent or not apparent. This provision shall not be construed to limit Buyer's right to implied new home warranties, if any, that may otherwise exist under Oregon law. © Oregon Real Estate Forms, LLC 0t/05 OREF 001-2 No portion may be reproduced, altered or modified without express written consent of~C~gon Reai Estate Forms, LLC REAL ESTATE SALE AGREEMENT - Page 2 of 7 Buyer ,n~t~ats Date NOTE: Fill in preprinted number from Page t [Sate Agreement # ~ -~ ~ i .~ ~ / 12. PRIVATE WELL: If applicable, Seller represents that the pdvate water well located on or serving the Property has provided an adequate supply of water throughout the year for household use. To the best of Setter's knowledge, the water is fit for human consumption and the continued use of the welt and water is authorized by and complies with the laws of the State of Oregon and appropriate governmental agencies. No other representation is made concerning the water supply and well except as expressly stated in this Agreement. If the well provides water for domestic purposes, upon Seller's acceptance of Buyer's offer, Seller, at Seller's expense, will have the welt tested for nitrates and total coliform bacteria and for such other matters as are required by the Oregon Health Division. Upon receipt, Seller shall promptly submit the test results to the Oregon Health Division and Buyer. At Buyer's expense, Buyer may h~ve the well water tested for quantity or quality by a qualified tester, and obtain a written report of such test(s), showing the deficiencies (if any) n the welt and the standards required to correct the deficiencies, all within __ business days (seven (7) if not fitted in ) after the date Seller and Buyer have signed this Agreement. If the written report of any test made by Seller or Buyer shows a substantial deficiency in quantity or quality of the water, Buyer may terminate this transaction by delivering written notice of termination, together with a copy of the test report, to Seller or the Listing Licensee within twenty-four (24) hours after the receipt by Buyer of the written test report unless, within twenty-four (24) hours after delivery of notice of termination, Seller agrees in wdting to correct the deficiencies shown on the report. Any report obtained by Buyer wilt show what deficiencies, if any, are substantial. In the event any wells located upon the Property are not currentJy registered with the applicable governmental agency, Seller agrees to assist Buyer, at Buyer's sole expense, in registering them. The preceding sentence shall survive closing of this transaction. For additional welt provisions see Addendum 13. INSPECTIONS: Buyer understands that it is advisable to have a complete inspection of the Property by qualified professional(s), relating to such matters as structural condition, soil condition/compaction, stability, environmental issues, survey, zoning, operating systems, and suitability for the Buyer's intended purpose. Neither the Listing nor Selling Licensees are qualified to conduct such inspections and shall not be responsible to do so. For further details, Buyer is encouraged to review the Buyer's Advisory at http://www, oregonrealtors.org or at http://www, rea.state.or, us. PROFESSIONAL INSPECTIONS: At Buyer's expense, Buyer may have the Property and all elements and systems thereof inspected by one or more professionals of Buyer's choice. Provided, however, Buyer must specifically identify in this Agreement any desired inspections which may include testing or removal of any portion of the Property. Buyer understands that Buyer is responsible for the restoration of the Property following any inspection(s)/test(s) performed by Buyer or on Buyer's behalf. Buyer shall have __ business days (ten (10) if not filled in), after the date Seller and Buyer have signed this Agreement, (hereinafter '~he Inspection Period") in which to negotiate with Seller regarding any matters disclosed in any inspection report. However, during the Inspection Period, Seller shall not be required to modify any terms of this Agreement already reached with Buyer. Unless a written and signed modification is reached, at any time during the Inspection Period, Buyer may notify Sailer or Listing Licensee, in writing, of Buyer's unconditional disapproval of the Property based on any inspection report(s), in which case, all earnest money deposits shall be promptly refunded and this transaction shall be terminated. Buyer shall promptly provide a copy of all reports to Seller, only if requested by Seller. If Buyer fails to provide Seller or Listing Licensee with written unconditional disapproval of any inspection report(s) by Midnight of the final day of the inspection Period, Buyer shall be deemed to have accepted the condition of the Property. SEE ATTACHED ADDENDUM REGARDING ALTERNATIVE INSPECTION PROCEDURES. BUYER'S WAIVER OF ~NSPECTION CONTINGENCY: Buyer acknowledges that Buyer has been given an opportunity to have the Property fully inspected. Buyer represents to Seller and all Licensees and Firms that Buyer is fully satisfied with the condition of the Property and all elements and systems thereof and elects to waive the right to have any inspections performed as a contingency to the closing of this transaction. Buyer's election to waive the right of inspection is solely Buyer's decision and at Buyer's own risk. Oregon Reat Estate Forms, LLC 01J05 OREF 001-3 No portion may be :eproduced, &tered, or mod fled without express wr tten consent o~li~gon Reai Estate Forms, LLC REAL =~ ~:'~, c SALE AGREEMENT - Page 3 of 7 14. LEAD-BASED PAINT INSPECTION: If the Property was constructed before 1978, a Lead-Based Paint Disclosure Addendum (hereinafter "the Disclosure Addendum") shall be signed by Seller, Buyer and Listing and Selling Licensees, and made a part of this Sale Agreement. After reading the section below, Buyer should check the accompanying box if Buyer intends to conduct a risk assessment or inspection. Buyer shall have _ 1[ ~ catendar days (ten (10) if not filled in), hereinafter referred to as "the Lead-Based Paint Inspection Period;' within which to conduct said assessment or inspection. The Lead-Based Paint ~nspection Period shall commence when Buyer signs the Disclosure Addendum. During the Lead-Based Paint Inspection Period, Buyer shall i~ot become obligated under this Sate Agreement. Buyer may, in writing, unconditionally cancel this transaction during the Lead-Based Paint Inspection Period and receive a prompt return of ali earnest money deposits. Buyer understands that the failure to give timely written notice of cancellation shall constitute acceptance of the condition of the Property as it relates to the rice of lead paint or lead-based paint hazards. 15. ESCROW: This transaction shall be cio~ed "Escrow"), a neutral escrow ioca[ed in the State of Oregon. Costs of Escrow shall be shared equally between Seiler and Buyer, unless Buyer is financing through Federal VA, n which case Sailer shall pay all Escrow costs. ~'8 CLOSING' TIIVIE S OF THE ESSENCE. ,-Clos ng sba( occur on ~ date mutuaily agreed upon by Selter and Buyer, but n ~o event ater tha~ cor~tract is ?ecot'ded end runts ~r~ avattabla to Sel~er. Seller a~d Bu*jer acknowledge that for closing to occur by the C~cei;*,g Oeadli~e, ;t may be necessary to axecute documents ~nd deposit funds in Escrow prior to that date. / Date 102 103 104 ~05 I06 107 I08 109 12O 121 122 123 124 12~ t2( 12( 13~ ~3 !3 13 13 13 17. POSSESSION: Seller shall remove all personal property (including trash and debris) that is not a part of this transaction and deliver possession of the Property to Buyer (check one): '~¢..by 5:00 p.m. on the closing date; Q by a.m./p.m. ~ days after the closing date; 154 '21 by __ a.m./p.m, on the __ day of . if a tenant is currently in possession of the Property (check one): ~ Buyer wilt accept tenant at the closing date; ~21 Seller shall have full responsibility for removal of tenant prior to closing date. 156 18. PRORATIONS: Prorates for rents, current year's taxes, interest on assumed obligations, and other prepaid expenses attributable to the Property shall be as of: (check one onty) ~ the closing date; ~ate Buyer is entitled to possession; or ~ 19. SELLER POSSESSION AFTER CLOSING: In the event that Seller and Buyer have agreed that Seller will deliver possession after the closing date, Seller shall pay as consideration $ { ~ (.) _ per day for each day after closing that Seller remains in possession of the Property. Such 160 payment shall be made by Seller through Escrow at the time of closing and no landlord-tenant relationship shall be created thereby, so long as Seller's possession does not exceed 90 days after the date of closing. See attached Addendum if applicable. 162 20. UTILITIES: Seller shall pay all utitity bills accrued to date Buyer is entitled to possession: Buyer shatl pay Seller for heating fuel then on premises, 163 at Seller's supplier's rate on the possession date. Payment shall be handled between Buyer and Setler outside of Escrow. t64 21. INSURANCE: Seller shall keep the Property fully insured until closing. 22. ESCROW DEPOSIT: Escrow is hereby instructed by Seller and Buyer as follows: (1) Upon your receipt of a copy of this Agreement marked "rejected" by Seller or upon Listing Firm's written advice that the offer is "rejected" by Seller, you are to refund att earnest money to Buyer. (2) Upon your 167 receipt of a copy of this Agreement signed by Seller and Buyer, set up an escrow account and proceed with closing in accordance with the terms of this Agreement. If you determine that the transaction cannot be closed for any reason (whether or not there is then a dispute between Seller and Buyer), t69 subject only to Section 37 below, you are to hold ali earnest money deposits until you receive written instructions from Seller and Buyer as to disposition of such deposits. ~7~ 23. EARNEST MONEY PAYMENT/REFUND: If (1) Seller does not approve this Agreement; or (2) Seller approves this Agreement but fails to furnish marketable ~ 72 title; or (3) Seller fails to complete this transaction in accordance w th th s Agreement, or perform any other act as herein provided; or (4) any condition which !73 Buyer has made an express contingency in this Agreement (and has not been otherwise waived) fails through no fault of Buyer, then alt earnest money shall i74 be promptly refunded to Buyer. However, acceptance by Buyer of the refund shall not constitute a waiver of other legal remedies available to Buyer~ if Seller ~,75 signs this Agreement and title is marketable; and (1) Buyer has misrepresented Buyer's financial status; or (2) Buyer's bank does not pay, when presented, any check given as earnest money; or (3) Buyer fails to redeem, when due, any note given as earnest money; or (4) Buyer fails to complete this transaction in accordance with this Agreement, or perform any other act as herein provided, then all earnest money paid or agreed to be paid shall be paid to Seller either as 78 liquidated damages or as otherwise allowed under Oregon law, and this transaction shall be terminated. ~t is the intention ofthe parties Nat Setler's sole remedy 79 again, st Buyer for 3uyer's failure to close this transaction shall be timited to ~e amount of earnest money paid or agreed to be paid herein. 80 24. BINDING EFFECT/CONSENT: This Agreement is binding upon the heirs, personal representatives, successors and assigns of Buyer and Sei!er. However, Buyer's rights under this Agreement or in the ProperW are not assignable without prior written consent of Seller. 82 25. FOREIGN D~VESTMENT tN F~EAL PROPERTY TAX ACT: The Foreign Investment in Real Proper~y Tax Act ("FtRPTA") requires every person who purchases neat property located within the United States from o"foreign person" to deduct and withhold from the Seller's proceeds ten percent (10%) of the 9ross sales price, with certain exceptions, and to pay the amount withheld to the internal Revenue Service. A "foreign pemon" includes a ~cn~ ~.~ resident atien individual, foreign corporation, Ioreign partnership, foreign trust and foreign estate. Setler and Buyer ~gree to execute and deiiver, as appropriate, any instrument, affidavit or statement, and to perform any acts reasonable or necessary to carry out the provisions of FiRPTA. if Setter s 18' a foreign person as defined by FIRPTA, Seller and Buyer instruct Escrow to take all necessary steps to comply therewith. 26. APPROVED USES: THE PROPERTY DESCRIBED ~N THiS iNSTRUMENT MAY NOT BE WITHIN A FiRE PROTECT!ON DiSTRiCT PROTECTING 8 STRUCTURES. THE PROPERTY iS oUBJ:~,, TO LAND USE ~AVVS AND REGULATIONS, WHICH. iN FARM OR FOREST ZONES, MAY NOT ,~UTHCRIZE CONSTRUCTION OR SITING OF A RESIDENCE AND WHICH LIMIT LAWSUtTS AGAINST FARMING OR FOREST PRACTICES AS DEFINED;NORS 30.930 tN ALL ZONES. BEFORE SiGNiNG OR ACC~-PT,NG THIS ~NSTRUMEN i, ~ HE PERSON ACQUIRING FEE T1TLETO THE PROPERTY SHOULD CHECK WITH THE APPROPRIATE C~TY OR COUNTY PLANNING DEPARTMENT TO VERIFY APPROVED USES AND EXISTENCE OF FRE PROTECTION FOR STRUCTURES. [F THE PROPERTY DESCRJBED N THIS. ~TRUMEN t ~ ~UB.cEC ~ , O SPECIAL ASSESSMENT UNDER ORS 358.505, ORS 358.515 REQUIRES NOTIFiCATiON TO THE STATE HISTORIC PRESERVATION OFFICER OF SALE OR TRANSFER OF THIS PROPERTY. 27. iRC 1031 E%CHANGE: ':n the event Seller or Buyer elects to complete an ',RC !031 exchange in this transaction, the other party agrees to cooperate with them, and the accommodator;' ff any, in a manner necessary to compiete he exchange, so cng as it will not delay the close of escrow or cause additional expense or iiability to tP~e cooperating party. Unless otherwise provided herein, this provision shall not become a contingency to the closing of this transaction. 2.8. LEVY OF ADDITIONAL PROPERTY TAXES: The Property: (check one) D is ~ s not speciaily assessed for proper~ taxes ,e.g. ~arm forest or other) in a way which may resuit n evy of additicr~at taxes n the future, if t is speciaiiy ~ssessed, Seiler represents that the Property is current as to ncome or other conditions required o creserve s deferred ~:ax status.., ~ as a result of Buyer's. actions or the ciosing of tbs transaction, the Property 2~ ~cD Oregon Reai Estate Forms, LLC 01/05 ~ ~.' _ ,¢~ ~ ORFF 001-4 Date No per on *nay be reproduced aitered, or modif ed without express wr tten ccnse~t c~gon Reai Estate Forms~ LLC NOTE: Fill in preprinted number from Page I t Sale Agreement # t~ ~ *,E.~ ,/ '~ ~ f either is disqualified from special use assessment or loses its deferred property tax status, unless otherwise specifically provided in this Agreement, Buyer shall be responsible for and shall pay when due, any deferred and/or additional taxes and interest which may be levied against the Property and shall hold Seller completely harmless therefrom. However, if as a result of the Seller's actions prior to closing, the Property either is disqualified from its entitlement to special use assessment or loses its deferred property tax status, Seller shall be responsible for and shall pay at or before closing alt deferred and/or additional taxes and interest which may be levied against the Property and shall hold Buyer completely harmless therefrom. 29. ADDITIONAL LAND SALE CONTRACT/TRUST DEED/MORTGAGE PROVISIONS: If this transaction is to include a fand sale contract, trust deed or mortgage to be carried back by Seller, Buyer and Seller shall agree upon the terms and conditions of such document not later than __ business days (ten (10) if not filled in) after the date Seller and Buyer have signed this Agreement. Upon failure to reach such agreement within said time period, this transaction shall be terminated, and alt earnest money shall be promptly refunded to Buyer. 30. DISPUTE RESOLUTION BETWEEN SELLER AND BUYER: Setler and Buyer agree that alt claims, controversies and disputes between them, including those for rescission (hereinafter collectively referred to as "Claims'), relating directly or indirectly to this transaction, shall be resolved in accordance with the procedures set forth herein, which shall expressly survive closing or earlier termination of this Agreement. Provided, however, the following matters shall not constitute Claims: (1) any proceeding to collect, interpret or enforce any mortgage, trust deed, land sate contract or recorded construction lien; or (2) a forcible entry and detainer action (eviction). The filing in court for the issuance of any provisional process or similar remedy described in the Oregon or Federal Rules of Civil Procedure shall not constitute a waiver of the right or dully to utilize the dispute resolution procedures specified herein. 31. SMALL CLAIMS BETWEEN SELLER AND BUYER: Notwithstanding the following provisions, Seller and Buyer agree that alt Claims between them that are within the jurisdiction of the Small Claims Court shall be brought and decided there, in lieu of mediation, arbitration or litigation in any other forum. 32. MEDIATION BETWEEN SELLER AND BUYER: if Seller or Buyer were represented in this transaction by a Licensee whose principal broker is a member of the National Association of REALTORS®, all Claims between Seller and Buyer shall be submitted to mediation in accordance with the procedures of the Home Seller/Home Buyer Dispute Resolution System of the National Association of REALTORS®, or other organization-adopted mediation program (collec- tively "The System"). Provided, however, if the Licensee's principal broker is not a member of the National Association of REALTORS®, or the System is not available through the principal broker's Association of REALTORS~, then all Claims shall be submitted to mediation pursuant to: (t) the special mediation program administered by Arbitration Service of Portland for the mediation of Claims in those geographic areas where the System is not available through the principal broker's Association of REALTORS®, or (2) any other impartial private mediator(s) or program(s) providing such service in the county where the Property is located, as selected by the party first filing for mediation. 33. ARBITRATION BETWEEN SELLER AND BUYER: All Claims between Seller and Buyer that have not been resolved by mediation, or otherwise, shall be submitted to final and binding private arbitration in accordance with Oregon Laws. Filing for arbitration shall be treated the same as filing in court for purposes of meeting any applicable statutes of limitation or for purposes of filing a tis pendens. Seller or Buyer may file Claims with Arbitration Service of Portland ("ASP'~ or, alternatively, with any other professional arbitration service that has existing rules of arbitration, provided that the selected alternative service also uses arbitrators who are in good standing with the Oregon State Bar, with expertise in real estate faw and who can conduct the hearing in the county where the Property is located. The arbitration service in which the CIaim is first flied shall handle the case to its conclusion. BY CONSENTING TO THIS PROVISION YOU ARE AG REEING THAT DISPUTES ARISING UNDER THIS AGREEMENT SHALL BE HEARD AND DECIDED BY ONE OR MORE NEUTRAL ARBITRATORS AND YOU ARE GIVING UP THE RIGHTTO HAVE THE MATTER TRIED BY A JUDGE OR JURY. THE RIGHT TO APPEAL AN ARBITRATION DECISION IS LIMITED UNDER OREGON LAW. 34. ATTORNEY FEES tN CLAIMS BETWEEN SELLER AND BUYER: The prevailing party in any suit, action or arbitration (excluding those Claims filed in Small Claims CouP) between Seller and Buyer shall be entitled to recovery of all reasonable attorney fees, and costs and disbursements as defined in ORCP 68 (including all filing and mediator fees paid in mediation). Provided, however, if a mediation service was available to the Seller or Buyer when the Claim arose, the prevailing party shall not be entitled to any award of attorney fees untess it is established to the satisfaction of the arbitrator(s) or judge that the prevailing party offered or agreed in writing to participate in mediation prior to, or promptly upon, the filing in arbitration or court. 35. SMALL CLAIMS COURT AND ARBITRATION: Alt claims, controversies or disputes relating to this transaction in which a Licensee or Firm identified in the F~nat Agency Acknowledgment Section above, s named as a party, shall be resolved exclusively as follows: (1) If within the jurisdictional limit of Small Claims Court, the matter shall be brought and decided there, in Iieu of arbitration or itigation in any other forum. (2) Att other claims, controversies or disputes involving such Licensee or Firm shall be resolved through final and binding arbitration using the arbitration selection process described in Section 33, above. This Section 35 shall be in tieu of litigation involving such Licensee or Firm [n any other forum. Such Licensee or Firm may voluntarily participate in formal or informai mediation at any time, but shall not be required to do so under this Section 35~ This Section 35 shall not apply to those matters in which: dP Oregon Real Estate Forms, LLC 0t/05 OREF 001-5 Buyer initials / Date No portion may be reproduced, aitered, or modified without express written consent o~f~gon Real Estate Forms, LLC REAL ESTATE SALE AGREEMENT - Page 5 of 7 203 204 205 2o6 207 2o8 209 210 21~ 212 213 2t4 215 2!6 217 218 219 220 221 222 223 224 225 226 227 228 23( 23- 23~ 23: 23. 23 23 23 2.~ 2/ 2z 2~ 2, 2. 2 2 2 2 2 2 (a) The claim, controversy or dispute is exclusively between Realtors® and is otherwise required to be resolved under the Professional Standards Arbitration provisions of the National ,&~sociation of REALTORS4B; (b) The Licensee or Firm has agreed to participate in altemalJve dispute resolution under a pdor written listing, service or fee agreement with the Seller or Buyer, or (c) The Licensee or Firm is the Seller or Buyer in this trarksaction (in which case, Sections 30-34 shall appty).This Section 35 shall expressly surVrve dosing or earlier termination of this Agreement. As to any claim, corCaz~erey or dispute in which such Licensee or Firm is named as a party, this Section 35 shall, where applicable, be in lieu of, replace and supercede the aitemab~e dispute resolution and attorney fee provisions of Sectkm'~s 20-34 above. 251 252 253 254 255 256 36. RECEIPT FOR EARNEST MONEY: The undersigned Selling Firm acknowledges receipt of earnest money (which Selling Firm agrees to handle as 257 provided below) from Buyer in the sum of $ ! j ~ 0 (~") evidenced by (check one) Q CASH Q CHECK ~'.PROMISSORY NOTE payable on 258 or before. 37. ~RNEST ~ONEY INSTBUC~ONS: Buyer instructs the undersigned Selling Firm to handle the earnest money as follows (check ~ that apply): 26o Q Hold any earnest money that is in the form of a check undeposited pending mutuaf~acceptance of this Agreement and all agreed-upon 261 counter offers, after which time deposit it as provided herein within three (3) banking day~Deposit it in the Selling Firm's client trust account, and 262 thereafter/or Q Deposit with Escrow. ~, Deposit any earnest money funds redeemed under a promissory note with 263 SELLING LICENSEE AND SE~ING FIRM SHALL HAVE NO FURTHER LIABILI~ WITH RESPECT TO EARNEST MONEY WHICH THE PARTIES HAVE 265 AU~ORIZED TO BE TRANSFERRED TO A THIRD PA~¢. . 266 Selling Firm 2~O_~t~¢~ 9,*~.. Selling Licensee Signature ~,~(~'~ i7'~1~¢-, 267 B~nch Office Address ¢[ ~7 ~ Phone FAX 269 38. PROPERTY DISOLOSMRE LAW: Buyer acknowledges that unless this transaction is othe~ise exempted, Oregon taw provides that Buyer has a 270 right to revoke Buyer's offer by giving Seller written notice thereof (a) within five (5) business days after Seller's delivery of Seller's Proper~ Disclosure 27~ Statement ("the Statement"), or (b) at any time before closing (as defined in the Oregon Administrative Rules) if Buyer does not receive the Statement 272 from Seller before closing. Buyer may waive the right of revocation if done so in writing. 273 Seller authorizes the Listing Firm to ~eceive Buyer's notice of revocation, if any, on Seller's behalf. 274 39. COUNTERPARTS/DELIVERY: This Agreement may be signed in multiple counterparts with the same effect as if all parties signed the same document. 275 Delivery of a legible photocopy, tetefax, carbon or carbonless copy of a signed original of this Agreement shall be treated the same as delivery of the original. 276 40. AGREEMENTTO PURCHASE: Buyer acknowledges receipt of a completely filled in copy of this Agreement which Buyer has fully read and understands. Buyer acknowledges that Buyer has not received or relied upon any oral or written stateme~3ts, made by Seller or any Licensees, which are not expressly contained in this Agreement. Neither Seller nor any Licensees warrant the square footage of any structure or the size of any land being purchased. If square footage or land size is a material consideration, all structures and land should be measured by Buyer prior to signing, or should be made an express contingency in this Agreement. Deed or contract shall be prepared in the name of I'~ ~"'/~1:~ t~-/,¢- Pt¢ ~,/~E'/.-////-~.~ 4~ ~./¢/z~/[,'1, This offer shall automatically expire on (insert date) ~//~ ! 2-6'~; ,~-- at % a,~+~("the Offer Deadline"), if not accepted within that time. Buyer may withdraw this offer any time prior to Seller's acceptance before the Offer Deadline. If Seller accepts this offer after the Offer Deadline, it shall not be binding upon Buyer unless accepted by Buyer in writing within __ business days (two (2) if not filled in) thereafter by so indicating at Section 43 below. This offer may be accepted by Seller only in writing. Buyer Buyer Date p.m. ~ Address Z7/'b ~ ~--'~//1'~ ~-' F / ~1~-'-~/-~ ~'" /'c)¢ ~) J~ 7'~ M/2~/4~//--.~-~ Phone Home.,~_~' ~-~¢~_.-/./'2-~- Work ~-~E'_,~ Work Fax a.m. a.m. Zip 277 278 279 280 281 282 283 28,~ 28~ 28( 28; 28~ 28~ 29~ 29 29 29 This offer was submitted to Seller for signature on the __ By day of. at a.m. p.m. 29 (Licensee presenting offer). 29 LINES WITH THIS SYMBOL ~ REQUIRE A SIGNATURE OF BUYER AND/OR SELLER AND DATE © Oregon Peat Estate Forms. LLC 01/05 OREF 001-6 No port on may be reproduced a tered or mod fled without express written consent of ~'a'~on Rea Estate Forms, LLC REAL ESTATE SALE AGREEMENT- Page 6 of 7 i Seher NOTE: Fill in preprinted number from Page 1 1 Sale Agreement 41. AGREEMENTTO SELL/PAY COMMISSION: Seller accepts this offer. At the time of closing, Seller agrees to pay in U.S. dollars to the Selling Firm or, if this is a co-op transaction, to the Listing Firm, the sum of $ for professional real estate services rendered in this transaction. Seller authorizes Listing Firm to order a preliminary title report and title insurance at Seller's expense and further authorizes Escrow to pay out of the cash proceeds of sate the expenses of furnishing title insurance, Seller's recording fees, Seller's closing costs and any encumbrances on the Property payable by Seller on or before closing. Seller is a U.S. citizen unless otherwise stated herein. Seller acknowledges receipt of a completely filled in copy of this Agreement, which Seller has fully read and understands. Setler acknowledges that Seller has not received or relied upon any oral or written statements of Buyer or any Licensee(s) which are not expressly contained in this Agreement. In the event Buyer fails to complete this transaction as provided herein, att earnest money shall be distributed as follows after deduction of any title insurance and escrow cancellation charges: (check one) '~i First to the Listing Firm to the extent of the agreed commission just as if the transaction had been closed, with residue to Seller, ~ or. 296 297 298 299 3O0 301 302 3O3 304 3O5 Seller Date . a.m. p.m.S,- Seller Date a.m. p.m.4~,,. Address Zip Phone Home Work Work Fax 3O6 307 3O8 309 42. REJECTION/COUNTER OFFER: SELECT ONE: Seller Seller Address Phone Home the above offer, but makes the attached counter offer; ;~1 Seller rejects Buyer's offer without a counter offer. Date a.m. p.m.S.., ~ ~' ~'/'~..~~ Date a.m. p.m.S,, Zip Work Work Fax 310 311 312 31~ 314 31.~ 43. BUYER'S ACKNOWLEDGMENT: Buyer acknowledges receipt of a coPY of Selleds written response to this Agreement. If Seller's response is an acceptance of Buyer's offer that occurred after the Offer Deadline identified at Section 40 above, Buyer (select only one) ,Q agrees Q does not agree to be bound thereby_ (The failure to check either box shall constitute rejection of Seller's acceptance after the Offer Deadline.) Buyer Date Buyer Date , · a.m. p.m.~-,. 31( 31; 3!~ 31~, 32( 44. CO-OP TRANSACTION: Setling Firm Listing Firm Selling Firm to receive: (select one) Listing Firm Main Office Address Listing Firm Branch Office Address Listing Firm Principal Broker Initials/Date __ Selling Licensee Listing Licensee % of purchase price or $_ Phone Phone g Firm PrincipalBrokerlnitials/Date__ Fax Fax 32 32: 32: 32 32 32 32 LINES WITH THIS SYMBOL 4"' REQUIRE A SIGNATURE OF BUYER AND/OR SELLER AND DATE © Oregon Rea~ Estate Forms, LLC 01/05 OREF 001-7 No portion may be reproduced, altered, or modified without express written consent of i~j-j~on Reat Estate Forms. LLC REAL ESTATE SALE AGREEMENT - Page 7 of 7 Buyer(s) Seller(s) I Sale Agreement # PROMISSORY NOTE FOR EARNEST MONEY Property Address 70'7 i Buyer(s): jointly and severally promise Real Estate Firm: Seller(s): (select only one payee): the sum of $ ...... 1~, 0 00 1) 2) 3) 4) 5) 6) Upon redemption of this promissory note, funds shall be made payable to This Note is due and payable (select only one due date): i~i ~ .~ days after mutual acceptance of the Real Estate Sale Agreement; c~.~,,O( ~ ~j ¢..~-. ~ on or before , If this Note is not paid when due, Buyer(s) shall pay interest at the rate of ten percent (10%) per annum on the unpaid balance from the due date until it is paid in full. BUYER(S) UNDERSTAND(S) THAT TIME IS OF THE ESSENCE, AND THAT THE FAILURE TO PAY THIS NOTE WHEN DUE, MAY CONSTITUTE A DEFAULT UNDER THE REAL ESTATE SALE AGREEMENT WITH SELLER. If Real Estate Firm is named as the payee of this Note, and Note is not paid when due, Buyer(s) hereby consent(s) to Real Estate Firm assigning and transferring it to Seller(s) for all purposes including collection. This Note is hereby incorporated into and made a part of the Real Estate Sale Agreement between Seller(s) and Buyer(s). In the event of any dispute between said parties, the mediation, arbitration and attorney fee provisions therein shall expressly apply. If payment is not made on or before the due date, Buyer(s) understand that Principal Broker is instructed by Seller(s) to promptly assign and transfer this Note to Seller(s), without recourse, and for all purposes, including collection. It is expressly understood and agreed that neither Principal Broker nor Principal Broker's Firm, its owners, officers or directors, licensees, employees or representatives shall have any duty (fiduciary or otherwise), responsibility or liability to Seller(s) to enforce collection of the Note, nor for any fees or costs associated therewith. Buyer Date .(., Seller Date Date LINES WITH THIS SYMBOL ~' REQUIRE A SIGNATURE & DATE © Oregon Real Estate Forms, LLC 01/04 OREF 060 No portion may be reproduced without express permission of Oregon Real Estate I~s, LLC !~incipal Broker's l lnitials & Date ATTACHMENT 221.725 Sale of city real property; publication of notice; public hearing. (1) Except as provided in ORS 221.727, when a city council considers it necessary or convenient to sell real property or any interest therein, the city council shall publish a notice of the proposed sale in a newspaper of general circulation in the city, and shall hold a public hearing concerning the sale prior to the sale. (2) The notice required by subsection (1) of this section shall be published at least once during the week prior to the public hearing required under this section. The notice shall state the tirne and place of the public hearing, a description of the property or interest to be sold, the proposed uses for the property and the reasons why the city council considers it necessary or convenient to sell the property. Proof of publication of the notice may be made or provided by ORS 193.070. (3) Not earlier than five days after publication of the notice, the public hearing concerning the sale shall be held at the time and place stated in the notice. Nothing in this section prevents a city council from holding the hearing at any regular or special meeting of the city council as part of its regular agenda. (4) The nature of the proposed sale and the general terms thereof, including an appraisal or other evidence of the market value of the property, shall be fully disclosed by the city council at the public hearing. Any resident of the city shall be given an opportunity to present written or oral testimony at the hearing. (5) As used in this section and ORS 22 !.727, "sale" includes a lease-option agreement under which the lessee has the right to buy the leased real property in accordance with the terms specified in the agreement. [1983 c.216 §1] Note: 221.725 and 221.727 were enacted into law by the Legislative Assembly but were not added to or made a part of ORS chapter 221 or any series therein by legislative action. See Preface to Oregon Revised Statutes for further explanation. 221.727 Alternative procedure for sale of city real property; public notice and hearing. Notwithstanding ORS 221.725, a city council may adopt, after public notice and hearing, a procedure for the sale of individual parcels of a class of city-owned real properties, or any interest therein, under a single program established within the city for the sale of that class of properties. The city may thereafter sell any parcel under that adopted procedure in lieu of the procedure under ORS 221.725. [1983 c.216 §2] Note: See note under 221.725. ATTACHMENT Affidavit of Publication tet; ~bli~hed! i STATE OF OREGON, County of Marion SS. I, Les Reitan, being first duly sworn, depose and say I am Publisher Woodbum Independent, a newspaper of general circulation as defined by ORS 193.010, and 193.020 printed and published at Woodbum in the aforesaid county and state, that Public Hearing Notice Sale of City Real Property, a printed copy of which is hereto annexed, was published in the entire issue of said newspaper for the following issues: May 18, 2005. Subscribed and sworn to before me t?fis 18th day of May, 2005 Notary Public for Oregon (My Commission Expires 9/12/07) NO. 371289 ___(,.0 ATTACHMENT LAND VALUATION As cited in the Highest and Best Use Analysis, the subject is a 15,000 SF CO-zoned site located in an established neighborhood in central Woodburn. A search for commercial land market data revealed five comparables that are considered suitable for this appraisal assignment. This data specifically consists of three sales occurring between January 1998 and April 2000 as well as two current listings. The comparables are located in Woodburn, Silverton and Stayton, range in size from 4,998 and 53,143 SF and indicate unit prices between $4.23 and $10.80/SF. In estimating the land value of the subject parcel, consideration is given to property rights conveyed, financing, conditions of sale, market conditions (time of sale), location, terrain, utility availability, parcel size, configuration, presence of offsite improvements, and zoning. The appropriate unit of comparison is the price per SF. These comparables are depicted in the table on the following page. In the Addenda of this report are photographs of each comparable and a Land Sales Map. No adjustment for property rights is necessary. All transactions convey a similar fee simple estate as the subject's interest being appraised. The three sales involved cash to seller financing and no cash equivalency adjustment is warranted for these transactions. Regarding conditions of sale, all transactions are arm's length with no evidence of duress by either party. The three sales occurred between January 1998 and April 2000. Arraying the market data by date of sale reveals no discernable time trend. Market conditions for commercial land in these communities have been relatively stable during the time span between these sales as well as the subject's valuation date. Overall, no time adjustment is appropriate. Items 4 and 5 are listings. These listings require a downward adjustment for listing status given the likelihood that a sale price less than the listing price will be negotiated. Regarding utility availability, the subject and all of the comparables are similar in having available municipal utilities. However, the sewer extension required for Sale 1 requires upward adjustment. While the five commercial comparables have a variety of commercial zones designated by their respective communities, no adjustment for the specific zoning designations are appropriate for comparison with the subject's CO-zoned site area. The subject site has offsite improvements in place (curb, gutter and sidewalk). Sales 2 through 5 have similar offsite improvements, but Sale 1 is a retail pad lacking these improvements. Given that Sale 1 is a pad with a usable site area smaller than its entire parcel size, coupled with a significant amount of land area encumbered for common area parking and access, an upward adjustment for site characteristics is required. The subject has a level terrain with no unusable land area. Item 4 requires an upward terrain adjustment because the rear of the parcel slopes downward to a creek and provides no utility for commercial use. The remaining comparables have similar terrain characteristics as the subject. 26 W/l/lam E. Adams, MA/ 58 LAND VALUATION (Cont.) CASH PRICE/ SITE UNIT SALE LOCATION SALE DATE SiZE (SF) PRICE COMMENTS I Mt. Jefferson Avenue $225,000 53,143 SF $4.23/SF Level parcel, at grade, located in Woodburn Cash to Seller retail center with portion of site 5S-1W-8DB: 1501 (1/98) used for common area parking and Doc. No.: 1468-247 access, utilitarian configuration, no offsites, utilities available but sewer extension required, located in commercial area with good access from two nearby highways, zoned CG. Subsequently developed with store. 2 69t Setflemier Avenue $54,000 4,998 SF $10.80/SF Level parcel located along Woodburn Cash to Seller thoroughfare in mixed commercial 5S-1W-7CA:3500 (11/98) and residential area, offsites in Doc. No.: 1541-48 place, utilitarian configuration, utilities available, zoned CO. Subsequently developed with a residence. 3 WIS 1st Street between $150,000 21,780 SF $6.89/SF Level parcel along three roads, Lewis and Jersey Streets Cash to Seller offsites along two roads, located in Silverton (4/00) downtown area in commercial 6S-1W-35CB: 3800 district, all utilities available, Doc. No.: 1686-273 utilitarian configuration, zoned C3. Old parking lot pdor to sale. City purchased parcel for development of paved parking lot. 4 SEC 1st & Water Streets $129,900 30,310 SF $4.29/SF Gentle terrain near road frontage, Stayton Listing then downslope to creek at 9S-1W-10DC:14100,14200 (9/01) parcel's rear, irregular shape, Doc. No.: n/a utilities available, offsites in place, portion developed as used car lot, balance is native vegetation, located in mixed commercial and light industrial area, zoned CG. 5 SIS Locust Street $36,000 7,670 SF $4.69/SF Level parcel, offsites in place, Stayton Listing utilities available, utilitarian shape, 9S-1W-9DA: 900 (9/01) located along collector street in Doc. No.: n/a mixed residential and commercial area, zoned CG. W/1//am E. Adams, MAI ,59 27 LAND VALUATION (Cont.) The subject and all the comparables have similar utilitarian configurations. When arrayed by Parcel size, the highest unit price ($10.80/SF) is generated by the smallest parcel (Sale 2). The size differential requires an upward size adjustment. The remaining comparables indicate a relatively narrow price range between $4.23 and $6.89/SF. While the largest parcel (Sale 1) generated the lowest unit price ($4.23/SF), the unit price is influenced by the parcel's pad status and the price being estimated on a total site area rather than on the unknown usable area. No size adjustments are necessary for Sales 3 through 5. Regarding Iocational attributes, Sales 4 and 5 are inferior to the subject and require upward adjustment. Sales 1 and 2 have superior Iocational attributes and require downward adjustment. Sale 3 has a similar location in a downtown environment as the subject and requires no location adjustment. The following paragraphs discuss each comparable and identify the factors warranting adjustment for comparison with the subject. Sale 1 is the January 1998 sale of a 53,143 SF retail pad located adjacent to Bi-Mart near Mt. Hood Highway and Highway 99 in northeast Woodburn. The sale price of $225,000 is equivalent to $4.23/SF based on the total site area. By comparison with the subject, Sale I is similar in property rights and terrain, with no adjustments needed for financing, conditions of sale, time of sale and zoning. While a downward adjustment is necessary for Sale l's superior Iocational attributes, this adjustment is outweighed by upward adjustments for inferior utilities, offs/res, and its pad status. Overall, this sale suggests that the subject's land value is greater than $4.23/SF. Sale 2 involves a 4,998 SF CO-zoned parcel located on the west side of Settlemier Avenue in Woodburn that sold in November 1998 for $10.80/SF. By comparison with the subject, Sale 2 is similar in property rights, utilities, zoning, offsite improvements and terrain. No adjustments are needed for financing, conditions of sale, or time of sale. A downward adjustment is necessary for Sale 2's size differential and its location along a thoroughfare. As such, this sale suggests that the subject's land value is less than $10.80/SF. Sale 3 is a 21,780 SF parcel located on the west side of 1st Street between Jersey and Lewis Streets in downtown Silverton. This parcel sold in April 2000 for $6.89/SF. By comparison with the subject, Sale 3 is similar in property rights, utilities, terrain, offsite improvements and location in downtown environs. No adjustment is needed for financing, conditions of sale, time of sale, parcel size, or zoning. With no factors warranting adjustment, Sale 3 suggests that the subject's land value is similar to $6.89/SF. Item 4 is a 30,310 SF parcel located at the southeast corner of Ist and Water Streets in Stayton that is currently listed for sale at $129,900 or $4.29/SF. By comparison with the subject, Item 4 is similar in property rights, utilities and offsite improvements. No adjustment is needed for differences in zoning or parcel size. While a downward adjustment is warranted for listing status, this adjustment is outweighed by upward adjustments for item 4's inferior terrain and Iocationai attributes. Overall, this listing suggests that the subject's land value is greater than $4.29/SF. W/l/lam E. Adams, MA/ 60 28 LAND VALUATION (Cont.) item 5 is a current listing of a 7,670 SF parcel located on Locust Street in Stayton in a mixed residential and commercial area. The asking price is equivalent to $4.69/SF. By comparison with the subject, item 5 is similar in property rights, utilities, offsite improvements and terrain. No adjustment is needed for zoning or the size differential. While a downward adjustment is warranted for listing status, this adjustment is outweighed by an upward location adjustment. Overall, Item 5 suggests that the subject's land value is greater than $4.69/SF. The five commercial land comparables indicate unadjusted unit prices between $4.23 and $t0.80/SF. After considering differences between this data and the subject site, Sale 2 suggests a land value less than $10.80/SF, Sale 3 suggests a value similar to $6.89/SF, and the remaining comparables suggest a land value greater than $4.23, $4.29 and $4.69/SF. In consideration of the preceding analysis and the subject's attributes, the subject's land value is estimated to be $7.00/SF or $105,000 in total. William E. Adams, MAI 61 29 COST APPROACH In this approach to value, the replacement cost new of the improvements is estimated and depreciation from all causes is deducted. The result is added to the underlying land value for an indication of market value for the improved property. In estimating the direct costs for the subject's building and site improvements, the Marshall Valuation Service's published cost manual is used. Site improvement costs are based on costs suggested by Marshall as well as costs incurred for other area projects. Given the age of the subject property, no historical cost data is available. Please reference the improvement description discussion for details of the subject's building and site improvements. Based on the cost data obtained for this analysis, the direct construction cost of the subject's building is estimated to be $530,000 or $55.04/SF based on 9,630 SF of building area. The direct cost of the subject's site improvements is estimated to be $18,757 with a breakdown of this cost shown below. The total direct construction cost for the subject property is therefore $548,757. Landscaping $10,053 Asphalt Paving 6,288 Concrete Paving and Waikways 1,687 Flagpole 529 Parking Lot Striping 100 Display Sign 100 Total $18,757 Indirect or soft costs must also be estimated and added to the direct construction costs. These items include loan fees and construction loan interest, system development charges, professional fees, real estate taxes and insurance during construction, closing and marketing costs, and other miscellaneous expenses. These costs typically range between 7 and 12 percent of total direct costs, with costs being at the higher end of the range for projects located in communities imposing significant system development charges. For the subject, these indirect costs are estimated to total 7 percent of direct costs, or $38,413 in total. The subject's direct and indirect cost estimate is $587,170. The developer of a property is usually entitled to an entrepreneurial profit. This profit is the developer's reward or incentive for undertaking the project and represents the difference between the property's market value and all direct and indirect costs. The amount of entrepreneurial profit required by an investor or developer is a reflection of the amount of risk associated with undertaking a project such as the subjeCt and the opportunity cost of holding alternative investments of similar risk. If developing the property today, it is unlikely that a developer would take on such a project without the anticipation of profit. Developers anticipate profit rates within a range of 10 to 15 percent, depending on the quality of the project and the anticipated income stream (if an income producing property). William E. Adams, MAI 62 30 COST APPROACH (Cont.) For the subject, an entrepreneurial profit rate of 10 percent is considered reasonable. Applied to the subject's direct and indirect costs, this rate results in a profit estimate of $58,717 and a replacement cost new estimate of $645,887. Depreciation is the loss in value from the replacement cost of a property's improvements resulting from physical deterioration, functional obsolescence or external (economic) obsolescence. For this appraisal assignment, depreciation is estimated using the breakdown method and the market depreciation method. The breakdown method separately itemizes the various forms of depreciation. Physical curable deterioration covers minor cosmetic and physical items (deferred maintenance) a prudent purchaser woUld repair or replace on purchase. As cited earlier in this report, deferred maintenance is present in the building. The cost of this work is estimated to be $500 and cover general cleanup, replace soiled ceiling tiles, clean the roof (north face), install molding around some entry doors, and do some minor painting. Physical incurable deterioration identifies normal wear and tear in the improvements and their various components. This form of deterioration is calculated using the modified age-life basis. The subject building has witnessed upgrading and renovation since originally constructed. The current owner has replaced certain short-lived items and performs periodic maintenance on the building and site improvements: Given these factors, the building's effective age is younger than its actual (or physical) age. An effective age of 25 years is estimated for the subject, its economic life is estimated to be 35 years. Using the modified age-life basis, the subject's physical incurable deterioration is estimated to be 55 percent of the subject's replacement cost new less deferred maintenance. This results in a physical incurable deterioration estimate of $354,963. Functional obsolescence is the loss in value due to poor workmanship or design. It is caused by elements within the subject. The subject property is functional in terms of site utilization and design. The building is neither superadequate nor deficient for its current use or many alternative uses. The building's layout is suitable for continued municipal use, a meeting hall, or a church. The lack of an elevator to the upper floor precludes its use by certain governmental entities, although alternative uses are suitable for the property "as is". The property includes both on-site and curbside parking and the land to building ratio is within market parameters and the comparables used for this report's Sales Comparison Approach. Overall, the subject does not suffer functional obsolescence. External (or economic) obsolescence is the loss in value from factors outside the subject. The subject's neighborhood does not contain any characteristics or businesses that would adversely impact the subject's marketability or value. Regarding economic factors, no adverse market conditions are evident with regard to uses suitable for the subject property. The market data provides evidence of continued demand for sUch property in the Willamette Valley and there does not exist an oversupply of similar property currently being marketed for sale. The subject would be expected to witness good demand if marketed for sale. Overall, these factors suggest that the subject does not suffer external or economic obsolescence. William E. Adams, MA/ 63 31 COST APPROACH (Cont.) Using the breakdown method, the subject suffers from both physical curable and physical incurable deterioration, with the total depreciation estimate being $355,463. This figure is equivalent to 55 percent of the subject's replacement cost new. An alternative method to derive accrued depreciation is the market depreciation method. This method calculates the replacement cost new of each comparable used in the Sales Comparison Approach and then compares this figure with each comparable's improvement value. The improvement value is the difference between each comparable's sale price and land value. The market depreciation estimate of these four sales is indicated as follows: Improvement Replacement Market Sale Value Cost New Depreciation 1 $175,000 $365,571 52% 2 95,000 321,798 70% 3 432,000 836,154 48% 4 264,000 501,934 48% The preceding sales contain buildings that were originally constructed between 36 and 75 years ago, with these structures being subsequently upgraded. Sale 2 suggests the highest depreciation rate, yet this rate is influenced by the building being an under-improvement for the site and the parcel located along commercial highway frontage. The remaining sales suggest a relatively narrow value range between 48 and 52 percent. Using the breakdown method, the subject's depreciation estimate is $355,463 or 55 percent of the subject's replacement 'cost new. This estimate is within the range established by the market depreciation method, and only slightly higher than the range estimated using Sales 1, 3 and 4. Overall, the market depreciation method supports the depreciation estimate using the breakdown method. As such, the $355,463 depreciation estimate using the breakdown method is used for this analysis. Deducting the $355,463 of accrued depreciation from the subject's replacement cost new estimate results in a depreciated replacement cost of $290,424. Adding the subject's $105,000 land value results in a total property value of $395,424, rounded to $395,000 as of the September 4, 2001 valuation date. William E. Adams, MA/ 64 32 COST APPROACH (Cont.) The subject's value as suggested by the Cost Approach is summarized as follows: REPLACEMENT COST NEW Direct Construction Costs: Building Improvements Site & Landscaping Improvements $530,000 18,757 Total Direct Costs Add Indirect Costs (7%) $548,757 38,41.3 Subtotal Add Entrepreneurial Profit (10%) Replacement Cost New $587,170 58,717 LESS DEPRECIATION Physical Curable Deterioration Physical Incurable Deterioration Functional Obsolescence External Obsolescence Total Depreciation $ $ $ $ 5OO 354,963 0 0 DEPRECIATED REPLACEMENT COST ADD LAND VALUE VALUE USING THE COST APPROACH (Rounded) $645,887 355,463 $290,424 105,000 $395,424 $395,000 William E. Adams, MAI 65 33 SALES COMPARISON APPROACH A search for improved market data suitable for comparison with the subject resulted in four comparables. These comparables represent a meeting hall, two former fraternal buildings, and a church. The buyers acquired the properties for multiple reasons including continuation of a church use as well as conversion to a church, a meeting facility, and a municipal use. It is noted that all four comparables were purchased for owner occupancy. These properties are located in Silverton, Keizer and Corvallis, and contain building sizes ranging from 4,368 and 13,020 SF. These comparables include three sales occurring between August 1999 and August 2000, as well as one pending escrow which commenced in September 2001. The unit prices range between $33.65 and $43.09/SF on an overall basis, with the improvement allocations being between $21.75 and $37.42/SF. Two unit of comparisons are used for this analysis; the overall price per square foot and the improvement allocation. The latter unit of comparison estimates a contributory value for the subject's improvements. To this value is added the previously-estimated land value in order to derive a total property value estimate. In this analysis, consideration is given to property rights conveyed, financing terms, conditions of sale, market conditions (time of sale), and differences in location and physical characteristics. Physical characteristics include building size, quality, condition, parcel size, land to building ratios, interior configuration, and site improvements. The subject's interest being appraised is the fee simple estate. The four comparables a/so conveyed a similar fee simple estate; therefore no adjustment for property rights is warranted. All four comparables involved cash or cash to seller financing. As such, no cash equivalency adjustment is warranted. With regard to conditions of sale, none of the transactions involved parties under duress. Sale 2 involves the Corvallis Eagles facility. According to the confirming party, the Corvallis Eagles Lodge was having financing problems and the facility was taken over by the Albany Eagles Lodge. The property was listed for sale and the resulting price does not suggest that a conditions of sale adjustment is appropriate. The three sales occurred between August 1999 and August 2000, with the pending escrow being negotiated in September 2001. Arraying this data by date reveals no discernable time trend. These sales are located throughout the Willamette Valley and subject to varying Iocational influences. The subject and these facilities are considered special-use properties with value dependent upon many variables. Lacking suitable data to perform matched-pair analysis for the purpose of isolating an adjustment for market conditions, a review of the market conditions for these comparables suggest that no time adjustment is warranted. The four comparables used for this analysis are summarized in the table on the following page. An Improved Sales Map and photographs of each comparable are found in the Addenda of this appraisal report. W/l/lam E. Adams, MA/ 66 34 SALES COMPARISON APPROACH (Cont.) Date I BId.q. Size Sale Location Financing Sale Pricet Land Size Comments 1 209 Mill Street 8/99 $210,000 5,624 SF 2-story wood frame building, built in 1926 Silverton Cash to $37.34/SF ovrl 4,520 SF and subsequently remodeled, dated 6S-1W-35BC:3100 Seller $31.12/SF imps design but average quality and condition, Doc. #: 1627-449 includes kitchen. Located in residential and commercial area along local street. Site includes small gravel parking lot and minimal landscaping. Site zoned RI. Buyer converted to a meeting hall. 2 2700 3rd Street SW 12299 $225,000 4,368 SF Former Eagles Lodge. 1-story wood Corvallis Cash to $33.651SF ovrl * 13,100 SF * frame structure built in 1965 and 12S-5W-11CB: 2100 Seller $21.75/SF imps subsequently expanded, below-average Doc. #: 277534-99 quality and condition commensurate with age, has kitchen but no basement, large site with small parking area. Located along highway in mixed-use area. Site zoned LC. · Represents supporting land and overall pdce excluding excess land. Buyer using facility for a church. 3 122 SW 5~ Street 8/00 $561,000 13,020 SF Former Moose Lodge in downtown Corvallis Cash $43.09/SF ovrl 10,758 SF Corvallis next to city hall. 2-story masonry 11S-5W-35CD: 5400 $33.18/SF imps structure built in 1949 and subsequently Doc. #: 287862-00 remodeled, average quality and condition commensurate with age, has kitchen, finished basement and mezzanine, small paved parking lot. Site zoned CB. Bought by City of Corvallis for assemblage with ... adjacent city-owned property. 4 4855 NE Bailey Road 9/01 $299,000 7,056 SF Open Gate Church facility, 1-story wood- Keizer (Pending) $42.38/SF ovrl 14,523 SF frame building, built in 1957 and 7S-3W-2BD: 3300 Cash to $37.42/SF imps subsequently remodeled, average Doc. #: n/a Seller quality, good condition, has kitchen but no basement, good on-site paved parking. Located in residential neighborhood. Site zoned RS. Being purchased for continued church use. SUBJECT 9,630 SF Woodbum Community Center, 2-story 491 North Third Street 15,000 SF wood frame building, dated design but Woodburn average quality and condition, has 5S-1W-7CD: 10900 and kitchen but no basement, adequate 11000 parking, located in mixed residential and commercial area. Land to building ratio is 1.6:1. Site zoned CO. William E. Adams, MAI 6'7 35 SALES COMPARISON APPROACH (Cont.) The following paragraphs discuss each comparable and identify the factors warranting adjustment for comparison with the subject. Sale 1 is a 5,624 SF building located near Silverton's downtown that sold in August 1999 for $210,000. This price is equivalent to $37.34/SF overall or $31.12/SF on an improvement allocation basis. This facility was purchased for use as a meeting hall and card shop. The building was constructed in 1926 and subsequently remodeled. By comparison with the subject, Sale 1 is similar in property rights, building quality, and condition. No adjustments are necessary for financing, conditions of sale, market conditions, or building size. Upward adjustments are needed for Sale l's inferior Iocational attributes, site improvements and lower land to building ratio. Overall, Sale 1 suggests that the subject's value is greater than $37.34/SF overall or $31.12/SF on an improvement allocation basis. Sale 2 is the former Eagles Lodge in Corvallis that sold in December 1999 for $225,000. This property included excess land suitable for separate development. The sale price exclusive of the excess land value is equivalent to $33.65/SF overall or $21.75/SF on an improvement allocation basis. This facility was purchased for use as a church and was vacated by the Eagles over one year prior. The 4,368 SF building was constructed in 1965 and subsequently remodeled. By comparison with the subject, Sale 2 is similar in property rights and site improvements, with no adjustment necessary for financing, conditions of sale, market conditions, or building size. Upward adjustments are warranted for Sale 2's inferior building quality and condition. On an overall unit of comparison basis, a downward adjustment is necessary for differences in land to building ratios (using Sale 2's supporting site area). Overall, Sale 2 suggests that the subject's value is greater than $33.65/SF overall or $21.75/SF on an improvement allocation basis. Sale 3 is the former Moose Lodge in downtown Corvallis that sold in August 2000 for $561,000. The price is equivalent to $43.09/SF overall or an improvement allocation of $33.18/SF. This 13,020 SF building included a finished basement and mezzanine, with the interior configured for a fraternal organization. The building was originally constructed in 1949 and subsequently remodeled. The City of Corvallis purchased this property to assemble with adjacent city-owned property. By comparison with the subject, Sale 3 is similar in property rights, building condition, and site improvements. No adjustments are needed for financing, conditions of sale, market conditions, or building size. Downward adjustments are needed for Sale 3's slightly superior building quality. On an overall unit of comparison, an upward adjustment is necessary for Sale 3's smaller land to building ratio. Despite this upward adjustment, Sale 3 suggests that the subject's value is slightly less than $43.09/SF overall and $33.18/SF on an improvement allocation basis. Sale 4 is a 7,056 SF church facility located in Keizer that is currently in escrow for $299,000. This price is equivalent to $42.38/SF overall or $37.42/SF on an improvement allocation basis. The buyer intends to continue operating the facility as a church. The building was constructed in 1957 and subsequently remodeled. By comparison with the subject, Sale 4 is similar in property rights, building quality, and site improvements. No adjustment is needed for financing, conditions of sale, market conditions, building size or land to building ratio. A slight downward adjustment is warranted for Sale 4's superior condition. Overall, Sale 4 suggests that the subject's value is slightly less than $42.38/SF overall or $37.42/SF on an improvement allocation basis. William E. Adams, MAI 68 36 SALES COMPARISON APPROACH (Cont.) The four comparables used for this analysis indicate overall prices between $33.65 and $43.09/SF, with the improvement allocations being between $21.75 and $37.42/SF. After considering the differences between this data and the subject, Sales 1 and 2 suggest overall values greater than $33.65 and $37.34/SF while Sales 3 and 4 suggest values slightly less than $42.38 and $43.09/SF. Based on the subject's attributes and the preceding market analysis, the subject's value is estimated to be $40.00/SF on an overall unit of comparison. Based on 9,630 SF of building area within the subject, this value is equivalent to $385,200, rounded to $385,000. Using the improvement allocation unit of comparison, Sales I and 2 suggest a value greater than $21.75 and $31.12/SF while Sales 3 and 4 suggest values slightly less than $33.18 and $37.42/SF. Based on this data, the contributory value of the subject's improvements is estimated to be $32/SF or $308,160 in total based on 9,630 SF of building area. Adding the subject's land value of $105,000 to this improvement allocation suggests a total property value or $413,160, rounded to $413,000. William E. Adams, MAI 69 37 RECONCILIATION In the valuation of the subject property, the Cost and Sales Comparison Approaches are used. The Income Approach was deemed inappropriate due to the lack of available rental data. The values suggested by these approaches are shown as follows. Cost Approach $395,000 Sales Comparison Approach: Overall Unit of Comparison Improvement Allocation Method $385,000 $413,000 The Cost Approach estimates the subject's market value to be $395,000. This approach quantified accrued depreciation using two methods. In the Sales Comparison Approach, two units of comparison are employed. Using the overall value unit of comparison, the subject's value is estimated to be $385,000. Using the improvement allocation unit of comparison, the subject's value is estimated to be $413,000. Adequate data was available to reliably use these approaches and generally equal weight is given to each of the value indications. In consideration of the values suggested by the approaches, the subject's attributes, and current market conditions, the "As Is" market value of the subject's fee simple estate as of the September 4, 2001 valuation date is estimated to be: THREE HUNDRED NINETY FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS .... $395,000 The preceding estimate is not dependent upon any extraordinary assumptions or hypothetical conditions. William E. Adams, MAI 38 ATTACHMENT 6 Quadrant Investments LLC P.O. Box 749 - Aurora, Or. 97002-0749 Phone: $03-678-1122 Fax: 503-678-1132 May 19, 2005 City of Woodburn ARm dohn Brown Re: Property Address 491 N 3ra Street, Woodburn, OR I am considering purchasing the City of Woodburn's property at the above noted address. My decision on buying this property (also known as the old Woodburn Community Center) will be based upon the type of commercial use that will be allowed. The types of businesses/activities that I am considering leasing to are listed below: · Commercial Kitchen space to caterers and/or small businesses who want to make their own food product to sell 6ommercially · Gymnasium for Dance lessons, Exercise sessions (i.e. Jazzercise), Wedding Receptions, Special Events, Business/Dinner meetings, Dances, etc. Day Care facility Church to hold services and/or special events · Office space upstairs for small start-up companies or businesses We want to provide affordable commercial space to start-up companies that cannot afford the higher rents. Eventuafly, maybe some of these smaller companies could tllrn into something much larger and be great for the community. Before 1 make my final decision on the purchase of this facility, I wffi need to know what uses are approved. Please provide response. Sincerely, Mark Nyman 71 sAng(IO0~ EEIIBLg£O~ E£:IO S00E/BE/S0 ODBU Incorporated 1889 June 2,2005 Mr. Mark Nyman Quadrant Investments LLC P.O. Box 749 Aurora, OR 97002-0749 RE: Property Address 491 N. 3rd Street, Woodburn, OR Dear Mr. Nyman: This responds to your May 19, 2005 letter requesting information regarding uses permitted in the City's former Community Center located at 491 N. 3rd Street. Pursuant to our sales agreement related to the Community Center, uses at the location must be consistent with those allowable under Commercial Office (CO) zoning. Uses are permitted in the CO zone pursuant to Section 2.105 of the Woodburn Development Ordinance (WDO). Planning Staff compared the uses delineated in your letter to allowed uses in the CO zone. The results of this comparison are listed below: 5/19/2005 Letter Reference Section 2.105 Reference Commercial Kitchen Space Gymnasium (Fitness Center) Day Care Facility Church Office Space Reception Hall for Wedding Receptions, Special Events, Business Meetings/Dinners, Dances 2.105.01.K.3 2.105.01.J.2 2.105.01 2.105.01 .L.6 Industry specific references Use not allowed in the CO zone Note: Uses allowed in the City's CO zone are not limited to those listed above. A full list of uses allowed in the CO zone is available in WDO Section 2.105 (attached). Staff calculated the required parking for the existing structure according to its prior function as a Community Center. The structure incorporates approximately 3,712 square feet of meeting room space and 3,696 square feet of office space, Office of the City Administrator 270 Montgomerv Street . Wocdburn, Oregon 97071 ?h, 503~98L )~l;~ · Fax 503~9824243 Mr. Mark Nyman June 2, 2005 Page 2. requiring 117 parking spaces (Meeting Room = 1 space per 35 square feet, Office Space = I space per 350 square feet). Please be advised that any change in use that increases the required parking for this property in excess of the previous Community Center use (117 required parking spaces) will be subject to Design Review pursuant to WDO Section 5.102.02.A.2. All proposed uses will be reviewed by the Community Development Department and Public Works Department on a case-by-case basis to ensure compliance with the applicable criteria of the WDO, State Building Code and applicable facilities development standards. A detailed floor plan delineating specific uses and square footages will also be required prior to issuance of business licenses for any proposed uses. We look forward to concluding the sales transaction on the Community Center property. If you have any further questions regarding development of this property, please contact Mr. Jason Richling in the Community Development Department at (503) 980-5246. Sincerely, John C. Brown City Administrator JCB/jr Attachments: WDO Section 2.105 cc: Mr. David Christoff, Hallmark Properties 73 2.105 Commercial Office (CO) 2.105.01 Permitted Uses The following uses, when developed under the applicable development standards of the WDO, are permitted in the CO zone. A. Residential 1. One dwelling unit in conjunction with a commercial use. B. Transnortation & Warehousinl~ l. Postal service. (491) C. Information Radio & TV studios & offices EXCEPT antennae or towers. (5131) Cable networks. (5132) Telecommunications (5133) EXCEPT telecommunication facilities subject to Section 2.204.03. Information & data processing. (514) D. Finance & Insurance Finance and insurance (52) EXCEPT pawn shops (522298) & check' cashing, pay day loan and cash transfer establishments [other than banks] as a predominant, ancillary, or required supporting use. E. Real Estate & Rental & Leasino Real estate. (531) Rental & leasing, without outdoor display or storage (532) F. professional, Scientific & Technical Services 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. Legal services. (5411) Accounting. (5412) Architects and engineers. (5413) Specialized design services (5414) INCLUDING interior design services. Computer system design. (5415) Management consulting. (5416) Advertising. (5418) Other professional services (5419), EXCEPT veterinary sewice (541940) not contained in a building. Section 2.105.01 Woodburn Development Ordinance [WDO] Page 2.1-29 duly 1. 2002 74 Administrative & Support Services 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. Administrative and facilities support services. (5611 and 5612) Employment services. (5613) Business support services INCLUDFNG copy shops. (5614) Travel and tour agencies. (5615) Investigation and security services. (5616) Services to buildings and dwellings (5617), offices only. Other support services. (56199) Educational Service Business schools. (6114) Technical and trade schools. (6115) Health Care & Social Services Ambulatory health services (621) EXCEPT ambulance service. (62191) Social assistance (624) INCLUDING child day care services. Arts,. Entertainment & Recreation Museums and historic sites (712) EXCEPT zoos. (712130) Fitness and recreation sports centers. (71391) Accommodation & Food Service Hotels (EXCEPT casino hotels) and motels. (72111) Bed and breakfast inns. (721191) Food service and drinking places (722) EXCEPT food contractors (7231) and mobile food service. Other Services 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Personal care services (8121) INCLUDING barber shops and beauty salons. Funeral homes. (812210) Photo f'mishing. (81292) Parking lots and garages (81293) EXCEPT extended vehicle storage. (4939190) Ail Other Personal Services (81299) INCLUDING bail bonding and consumer buying services. Religious, eivie, professional and sim~Llar organizations. (813) M. Public Administration Section 2.105.03 Woodburn Development Ordinance {WDO] Page 2.1-30 July 1, 2002 1. Public Administration (92) INCLUDENG government offices, courts a_nd fire protection. N. Streets & Utilities 1. Rights of way and easements and the improvements therein for streets, water, sanitary sewer, gas, oil, electric and communication lines and for storm water facilities and for pump stations. 2.105.02 Special Permitted Uses The following uses, when developed under the applicable development standards of the WDO including the special development standards of Section 2.203, are permitted in the CO zone. A. A~ricultural practices without livestock subject to Section 2.203.02. B. Delivery services subject to Section 2.203.08. C. Facilities during construction subject to Section 2.203.10. 2.105.03 Conditional Uses The following uses may be permitted in the CO zone subject to the applicable development standards of the WDO and to the conditions of conditional use approval: A. Ambulance service. (62191) B. Multiple family dwelling units, iNCLUDI'NG apartment houses. C. Assisted living facilities. (62331) D. Nursing care facilities. (6231) E. Rooming and boarding house. (7213) F. Group home or group care facilities. G. Government and public utility buildings and structures EXCEPT uses permitted in Section 2.105. Ol and telecommunications facilities subject to Section 2.204.03. 2.105.04 Accessory Uses The following uses are permitted as accessory uses subject to Sections 2.202 and 2.203. Section 2.105.05 Woodburn Development Ordinance [F/DOJ Page 2.1-31 Jttly 1, 2002 76 A. Fence or free standing wall. 2.105.05 Dimensional Standards The following dimensional standards shall be the minimum requirements for all development in the CO zone. A. Lot Standards. Lots in a CO zone shall comply with the applicable standards of Table 2.1.8. TABLE 2.1.8 Lot Standards for Uses in a CO Zone A. In an CO zone the lot area for a non-residential use shall be adequate to contain all structures within the required setbacks. There shall be no minimum width or depth. B. In a CO zone, residential use shall be subject to the lot standards of Table 2.1.5. B. Building Height. The maximum height of buildings shall not exceed 35 feet, EXCEPT chimneys, spires, domes, flag poles and other features not used for human habitation (EXCEPT telecommunication facilities), shall not exceed 70 feet. C. Setback and Buffer Improvement Standards. 1. Front yard Setback and Setback Abutting a Street: a. Dimensions: t) The minimum setback abutting a street shall be 15 feet plus any Special Setback, Section 3.103.05. [Section 2.105.05.C. 1 .a.2 repealed by Ordinance No.. 2383, § 13, passed March 16, 2005.] b. Off Street Parking and Maneuvering: 1) Off street parking, maneuvering and storage shall be prohibited within a required setback EXCEPT for parking, maneuvering and storage adjacent to a wall. [Section 2.105.05.C.l.b.1 as amended by Ordinance No. 2383, §14, passed March 16, 2005.] 2) The entrance to a garage shall be set back a minimum of 20 Section 2.105.05.C Woodburn Development Ordinance [g/DO] Page 2.1-32 ,lttly 1, 2002 77 feet from the closest edge of a shared driveway and 20 feet from a street fight of way line. Clear Vision Area: Fences, walls, landscaping and signs shall be subject to clear vision area standards, Section 3.103. I0. d. Vehicular Access: Permitted in conformance with Section 3.104. Interior Side and Rear Yard Setbacks. Development in an CO zone, EXCEPT conditional uses permitted by Section 2.105.03. A~ through E., shall be subject to the setback and buffer requirements of Table 2.1.9. Conditional uses permitted by Section 2.105.03. A. through E. shall be subject to the setback and buffer requirements of Table 2. L 7. TABLE 2.1.9 Interior Yard and Buffer Standards for Non-Residential Uses in CO Zones Abutting Property Landscaping Wall Interior Setback RS, RIS or Pm, l, zone All interior yards shall be Solid brick or architectural 10 ft. fully landscaped subject to wall with anti-graffiti Section 3.106. surface, no less than 6 feet or greatex than 7 feet in height. DDC, CG, IP or IL zone All interior yards shall be Wall requirements shall be 15 fully landscaped subject to determined in conjunction Section 3.106. with the applicable Design Review process. P/SP or CO zone All interior yards shall be No wall required. 10 ft. fully landscaped subject to Section 3.106. b. The building setback from a private acces: easement shall be a minimum of 5 feet. c. Off Street Parking, Maneuvering and Storage: 1) Off street parking and storage shall be prohibited within a required setback EXCEPT for parking maneuvering and storage adjacent to a wall. [Section 2.105.05.C.2.c. 1 as amended by Ordinance No. 2383, §15, passed March 16, 2005.1 2) The entrance to a garage shall be set back a minimum of 20 feet from the closest edge of a shared driveway and 20 feet from a street right of way line. Section 2.105.06 Woodburn Development Ordinance [WDO] Page 2.1-33 July 1. 2002 78 2.105.06 Section 2.105.06 Woodburn Developrnent Ordinance [WDO] 3) The distance between the sidewalk on a public street and a loading dock shall be sized to preclude vehicles using the dock from projecting over the sidewalk. d. Clear Vision Area: Fences, walls, landscaping and signs shall be subject to clear vision area standards, Section 3.103.10. e. Vehicular Access: Permitted in conformance with Woodburn Access Management Ordinance and Section 3.104. Bevelopment Standards All development in the CO zone shall comply with the applicable provisions of the WOO. The following standards specifically apply to uses in the CO zone. A. Off Street Parking. Offstreet parking shall be subject to the standards of Section 2.105.05 and Section 3.105. B. Setbacks and Lots, Generally. Setbacks and lots shall be subject to Section 3.103. C. Architectural Design Guidelines and Open Space Standards. 1. Multiple density residential buildings shall be subject to the design standards or guidelines of Section 3.10 7. 05. 2. All primary buildings and structures, other than those noted in Section 2.105. 05. C. 1. shall be subject to the architectural guidelines of Section 3.107.06. D. Signs. Signs shall be subject to Section 3.110. [Section 2.105.06D as mended by Ordinance No. 2359, §6, passed March 22, 2004.] E. Residential Density. The density and number of medium density residential units permitted in a CO zone shall be subject to the requirements of Table 2.1.5. F. Landscaping and Sidewalks. 1. The street frontage of a subject property shall be improved with either Page 2.1-34 duly I, 2002 79 propeWj line sidewalks and street trees or curb line sidewalks. The improvement shall be determined at the time of subdivision, PUD or design review as applicable. Sidewalks and trees shall be installed by the property owner to the standards of Section 3.101 and 3.106. The subject property shall be landscaped to the standards of Section 3.106 and 3.107. 03. Common refuse collection facilities shall be screened on all sides by an arch_itectural block wall and solid gate, both with an anti-graffiti surface, a minimum of six feet and a maximum of seven feet in height. Property Disposition. All uses shall be established and conducted on lots of record, as defined by Section 1.102 and developed to the public facility and access standards of Sections 3.101, 3.102 and 3.104. New lots of record shall be subject to the following standards and procedures: a. Partitions, Section 3.108; b. Subdivisions, Section 3.108; or c. Planned Unit Development Section 3.109. Alteration of the property lines of existing lots of record shall be subject to the applicable following standards and procedures: Property Line Adjustment, Section 5.101.07. Replatting, Section 3.108. Vacation, applicable Oregon Revised Statutes. Section 2.105.06 t~oodburn Development Ordinance Page 2.1-35 July 1, 2002 80 Section 2.105.06 kgoodbttrn Development Ordinance [??DO] Page 2.1-36 duly l, 2002 81 11A June 21,2005 TO: FROM: SUBJECT: Mayor and City Council through,,.Cflity Administrator Ben Gillespie, Finance Director.~~.. 2004-05 SiJpplemental Budget RECOMMENDATION: Council adopt the attached ordinance for a supplemental appropriation BACKGROUND: At its June 13, 2005 meeting the Council conducted a hearing to consider budget amendments to the General Fund and the General CIP Fund. At the conclusion of the hearing the Council directed staff to return an ordinance increasing the General Fund budget by $34,282 and increasing the General CIP Fund budget by $71,000. The General CIP total included $16,000 for Plaza amenities that was added to the proposal after the budget hearing was noticed. The notice did not include that amount. Adding the $16,000 to the General CIP budget would increase that fund's budget by more than 10%, Oregon budget law does not allow the Council to approved budget increases greater than 10% unless they have been noticed. Consequently the $16,000 has not been included in the attached ordinance. This will not slow progress on the Plaza, because it turns out the amenities could not be delivered until after June 30. Because the delivery date is in the next fiscal year, the accounting rules require that they be charged against the 2005- 06 budget. FINANCIAL IMPACT: The proposed revision increases revenue in the General Fund by $34,282. Appropriations are increased by $49,282, and Contingencies are decreased $15,000, leaving the Contingencies balance at $748,120, which is 8.6% of the expenditure budget. Agenda item Review: City City Attorney __ Finance__ 82 Mayor and City Council June 21,2005' Page 2 In the General CIP Fund expenses are increased by $55,000, and Reimbursement from the Urban Renewal Agency is increased by a like amount, leaving Fund Balance in that fund unchanged. COUNCIL BILL NO. ORA)INANCE NO. AN ORDINANCE ADOPTING A SUPPLEMENTAL BUDGET FOR FISCAL YEAR 2004-05 AND DECLA~NG AN EMERGENCY. WHEP~AS, Oregon State Statute 294.480 allows for the adoption of a supplemental budget during a fiscal year to meet changes in financial planning, and WHEREAS, the Notice of Supplernental Budget Hearing and Financial Summary was published in the Woodbum Independent on June 8, 2005 as required under State budget law; and WHEPd~AS, the City Council held a public hearing on June 13, 2005 to give citizens an opportunity to comment on the proposed 2004-2005 supplemental budget, now, therefore, THE CITY OF WOODBURN ORDAINS AS FOLLOWS: Section 1. That the supplemental budget for fiscal year 2004-2005 is hereby adopted as set forth below. Section 2. That fiscal year 2004-2005 appropriations are adjusted as follows: Revenues Appropriations GENERAL FUND: Revenue Adjustments: Grant - State (Police) Recreation Fees Total General Fund Revenue Adjustments Appropriation Adjustments: Police Department: Personnel Services Parks - Leisure Services: Personnel Services Materials & Services Planning Division: Materials & Services Operating Contingency Total General Fund Appropriation Adjustrnents $19,282 15,000 $ 34,282 $19,282 10,000 5,000 15,000 (15,000) ~4,282 Page 1 - Council Bill No. Ordinance No. 84 GENERAL CIP FUND: Revenue Adjustment: Reimbursement Total General CIP Fund Revenue Adjustment Appropriation Adjustment: Capital Outlay Total General CIP Fund Appropriation Adjustment $ 55,000 $ 55,000 $ 55,000 $ 55,000 Section 3. That if any clause, sentence, paragraph, section or portion of this ordinance for any reason shall be adjudged invalid by a court of competent jurisdiction, such judgment shall be confined in its operation to the clause, sentence, paragraph, section or portion of this ordinance directly involved in the controversy in which such judgment is rendered. Section 4. This ordinance being necessary for the public peace, health and safety, an emergency is declared to exist in that appropriation adjustments are necessary to meet estimated expenditures during the 2004-05 fiscal year which concludes on June 30, 2005 and this ordinance shall take effect immediately upon passage by the Council and approval by the Mayor. Approved as to Form: City Attorney Date APPROVED IC~THRY'N FIGLEY, MAYOR Passed by the Council Submitted to the Mayor Approved by the Mayor Filed in the Office of the Recorder ATTEST: Mary Tennant, Recorder City of Woodburn, Oregon Page 2 - Council Bill No. Ordinance No. 85 11B June 20, 2005 TO: FROM: SUBJECT: Mayor and City Council through City Administrator Ben Gillespie, Finance Director i~J~ Adoption of City's 2005-06 Budget RECOMMENDATION: Council adopt the attached ordinance setting the City of Woodburn's budget for 2005-06 BACKGROUND & Discussion: On May 21, 2005, the Budget Committee concluded their hearing on the City's 2005-06 budget and unanimously recommended that the budget document be forwarded to the City Council for the next phase of the budget process. As required by Oregon Budget Law, the City Council conducted a public hearing on June 13, 2005 to consider a City budget totaling $50,830,520. The Council made three changes to the Budget Committee's recommendation: Water Treatment Plant Chemicals Donation for Centennial Park Carry forward PW construction contracts TOTAL $16,000 32,500 382,000 $430,500 The attached ordinance, which includes those changes, totals $51,261,020. The Council also considered the Budget Committee's recommendation to impose the full property tax rate allowed by law ($6.0534 per $1,000 of value) and to levy $683,550 for bonded debt, which is excluded from the statutory limitation. The attached ordinance reflects those amounts. Agenda Item Review: City Administrat ity Attorney 86 Finance~ Mayor and City Council June 20, 2005 Page 2 FINANCIAL IMPACT: The attached ordinance is consistent with the budget policies adopted by the Budget Committee in January 2005. COUNCIL BILL NO. OP~INANCENO. AN ORDINANCE ADOPTING A BUDGET FOR FISCAL YEAR 2005-2006, MAKING APPROPRIATIONS, LEVYING TAXES, AND DECLARING AN EMERGENCY. THE CITY OF WOODBURN ORDAINS AS FOLLOWS: Section 1. That the budget for fiscal year 2005-2006 is hereby adopted as set forth below. Section 2. That taxes provided for in the adopted budget are imposed at the rate of $6.0534 per $1,000 of assessed value for operations and in the amount of $683,550 for bonds; and that these taxes are hereby imposed and categorized for tax year 2005-2006 upon the assessed value of all taxable property within the City. General Excluded from Government the Limitation Tax Rate - General Govt. Operations $ 6.0534/$1,000 Bonded Debt $ 683,550 Section 3. That the budget amounts for fiscal year 2005-2006, and for the purposes shown below, are hereby appropriated as follows: GENERAL FUND --- City Council and Mayor City Administrator's Office City Recorder's Office City Attorney's Office Finance Department Municipal Court Non-Departmental - Interfund Transfer - Interfund Transfer ~ Interfund Transfer - Interfund Transfer - Interfund Transfer - Interfund Transfer - Interfund Transfer - Police Department Library Leisure Services Swimming Pool Parks Administration Planning Parks Maintenance Operating Contingency Materials & Services Transit Fund R.S.V.P. Street Fund General CIP Fund Information Services Fund Building Maintenance Fund Equipment Replacement Fund $ 30,279 309,530 52,169 153,176 190,640 120,886 126,700 27,507 42,137 280,000 115,550 26,050 6,615 11,185 4,119,190 1,047,223 377,636 550,425 232,322 499,326 466,953 916,149 TOTAL GENEPokL FUNT) APPROPRIATIONS Page 1 - COUNCIL BILL NO. ORDINANCE NO. 88 $ 9,701,648 GENERAL OPERATING R~SERVE FUND --- Operating Contingency $100,000 TOTAL GENERAL OPERATING RESERVE FUND TRANSIT SYSTEM FUND -- City Transit System Dial-a-Ride Program Interfund Transfer - Information Serv. Fund Operating Contingency 136,027 151,742 145 2,982 TOTAL TRANSIT SYSTEM FI. YND APPROPRLATIONS BUILDING FUND -- Personnel Services Materials & Services Interfund Transfer - Information Serv. Fund Operating Contingency $ 274,371 49,888 100 279,443 TOTAL BUILDING FUND APPROPRIATIONS SEARCH AND SEIZURE FUND --- Materials & Services Operating Contingency !3,000 900 TOTAL SEARCH & SEIZURE FUq',ID APPROPRIATIONS STATE REVENUE SHAPdNG FUND --- Materials & Services Capital Outlay Interfund Transfer - Street Fund Debt Service Operating Contingency $ 9,000 147,000 20,000 47,043 28,672 TOTAL STATE REVENUE SHA_RANG FUND APPROPRIATIONS HOUSING PdgHABILITATION FUND -- Personal Services Operating Contingency $ 9,015 451,150 TOTAL HOUSING REHAA3ILITATION FUq'4D APPROPRIATIONS $ 100,000 $ 290,896 $ 603,802 $ 13,900 $ 251,715 $ 460,t65 Page 2 - COUNCIL BILL NO. ORDINANCE NO. 89 RETIRED SENIOR VOLUNTEER PROGRAM FUND --- Personal Services Materials & Services $ 91,542 10,97~ TOTAL R.S.V.P. FLINT) APPROPRIATIONS CABLE FRANCHISE MANAGEMENT FUND --- Personal Services Materials & Services Operating Contingency $ 3,215 15,600 1,916 TOTAL CABLE FRANCHISE MANAGEMENT FUqNT) APPROPPdATIONS STPAg, ET FUND --- Street Repair & Maintenance Street Cleaning Street Administration Interfund Transfer - Information Serv. Fund Interfund Transfer - Tech. & Envir. Serv. Fd Interfund Transfer - Equipment Replacement Fund Operating Contingency $1,007,192 91,684 168,901 33O 228,000 45,000 132,795 TOTAL STREET FUND APPROPRIATIONS CITY GAS TAX FUND --- Materials & Services Capital Outlay' Operating Contingency 7,000 364,621 10,117 TOTAL CITY GAS TAX FUND APPROPRIATIONS BONDED DEBT FUND --- Personnel Services Debt Service - Principal Debt Service - Interest Operating Contingency $ 1,607 281,000 368,000 79,393 TOTAL BONDED DEBT FUND APPROPRIATIONS BANCROFT BOND FUND Operating Contingency $ 5,700 TOTAL BANCROFT BOND FUqqD APPROPRIATIONS 102,5t7 20,731 1,673,902 381,738 730,000 5,700 Page 3 - COUNCIL BILL NO. ORDFNANCE NO. 90 ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT REVOLVING LOAN FUND --- Materials & Services Capital Outlay Debt Service Operating Contingency 20,000 150,000 34,757 54,826 TOTAL ECON. DEVLP REV LOAN FU-ND APPROPRIATIONS POLICE CONSTRUCTION FUND: Personnel Services Materials & Services Capital Outlay $ 4,822 474,000 6,222,178 TOTAL POLICE CONST. FUND APPROPRIATIONS GENERAL FUND CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT FUND --- Capital Outlay Operating Contingency $ 371,050 72,491 TOTAL GENERAL FUND CAPITAL IMPRV. FUq'4D APPROPRIATIONS SPECIAL ASSESSMENT FUND --- Materials & Services Capital Outlay Operating Contingency 56,000 293,500 232,500 TOTAL SPECIAL ASSESSMENT FUND APPROPRJATIONS STREET/STORM CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT FUND --- Materials & Services Capital Outlay Operating Contingency $ 492,400 2,237,700 321,621 TOTAL STREET/STORM DRAIN C.I.F. APPROPRIATIONS PARI4~ CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT FUND --- Materials & Services Capital Outlay Operating Contingency 65,000 120,000 758,000 TOTAL PARKS CAPITAL 1MPRV. FLq',ID APPROPRIATIONS $ 259,583 $ 6,70t,000 $ 443,541 $ 582,000 $ 3,051,721 $ 943,000 Page 4 - COUNCIL BILL NO. ORDINANCE NO. 91 TRANSPORTATION IMPACT FEE FUND --- Materials & Services Capital Outlay Operating Contingency $ 300,000 557,100 2,764,15.6 TOTAL TRCANSPORTATION 1MPACT FEE FUND APPROPRIATIONS $ 3,621,256 STORM WATER SYSTEM DEVELOPMENT FUND --- Materials & Services Capital Outlay Operating Contingency 80,400 471,500 208,969 TOTAL STORM WATER SYS DEVLP. FUND APPROPRIATIONS $ 760,869 PUBLIC WORKS FACILITY EXPANSION/CONST. FUND --- Capital Outlay Operating Contingency $ 25,876 4,991. TOTAL PUBLIC WORKS FACILITY CONST. FUND APPROPRIATIONS $ 30,867 SEWER CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT FUND --- Capital Outlay Debt Service Operating Contingency 26,000 29,102 60,987 TOTAL SEWER CAPITAL ~PRV FUND APPROPRIATIONS $ 116,089 WASTEWATER TREATMENT CONSTRUCTION FUND --- Design Engineering Construction Engineering Construction Right of Way Debt Service Operating Contingency 51,100 58,566 291,500 8,780 1,780,551 35,280 TOTAL WWPT CONST. FUND APPROPRIATIONS $ 2,225,777 WATER WELL/DISTRIB. CONSTRUCTION FUND -- Design Engineering Construction Engineering Construction Debt Service Operating Contingency $ 40,000 73,332 836,3O0 870,000 1,689,624 TOTAL WATER SYSTEM CONST. FUqqD APPROPRIATIONS $ 3,509,256 Page 5 - COLFNCIL BILL NO. ORDINANCE NO. 02 WATER FUND --- Water Supply Meter Reading/Accounting Water Administration Interfund Transfer - Information Serv. Fund Interfund Transfer - Tech. & Envir. Serv. Fd Interfund Transfer - Equipment Replacement Fund Operating Contingency TOTAL WATER FUND APPROPRIATIONS $1,171,227 210,272 72,371 975 298,000 35,000 188,95~ $ t,976,804 SEWER FUND - Wastewater Treatment Plant Operations Wastewater Pre-Treatment Wastewater Maintenance Wastewater Lab POTW Administration Sewer Line Maintenance Sewer Administration Interfund Transfer ~ Tech. & Envir. Serv. Fd InterlS. tnd Transfer - Information Serv. Fund Interfund Transfer - Water Fund Interfund Transfer - Equipment Replacement Fund Operating Contingency $ 834,789 71,124 258,742 75,836 650 222,706 289,266 298,000 1,530 70,000 70,000 29,700 TOTAL WASTEWATER TREATMENT PLANT FUND APPROPRIATIONS WATER SYSTEM DEVELOPMENT TRUST FUND --- Materials & Services Capital Outlay Debt Service Operating Contingency $ 41,400 166,000 460,000 210,243 TOTAL WATER SYSTEM DEVLP. TRUST FIfND APPROPRIATIONS SEWER SYSTEM DEVELOPMENT TRUST FUND --- Materials & Services Debt Service Operating Contingency 15,000 593,518 26,325 TOTAL SEWER SYSTEM DEVELP. TRUST FL2qD APPROPPAATIONS $2,222,343 $ 877,643 $ 634,843 Page 6 - COUNCIL BILL NO. ORDFNANCE NO. 93 INFOP~ATION SERVICES (IS) FUND --- Personal Services Materials & Services Capital Outlay Operating Contingency $ 212,589 145,700 48,500 23,478 TOTAL II--WORMATION SERVICES FUNT) APPROPRIATIONS CENTRAL STORES WORKING CAPITAL FUND --- Materials & Services Operating Contingency $ 15,000 13,000 TOTAL CENTRAL STORES WORKING CAP. FUND APPROPRIATIONS 430,267 28,000 SELF-INSURANCE FUND --- Personal Services Materials & Services Operating Contingency 20,335 539,850 82,955 TOTAL SELF-INSURANCE FUND APPROPRIATIONS $ 643,140 TECHNICAL & ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES FUND --- Public Works Administration Engineering Division Central Garage Interfund Transfer - Information Serv. Fund Operating Contingency $194,890 796,841 95,924 470 34,807 TOTAL TECH. & ENVIRONMENTAL SERV. FUND APPROPRIATIONS $ 1,122,932 BUILDING MAINTENANCE FUND --- Personal Services Materials & Services Operating Contingency $ 240,225 292,969 15,315 TOTAL BUILDING MAINTENANCE FLD, ID $ 548,509 EQUIPMENT REPLACEMENT FUND --- Water Equipment Replacement - Cap. Outlay Sewer Equipment Replacement - Cap. Outlay Maintenance Equip. Replacement - Cap. Outlay Transit Equipment Replacement - Cap. Outlay Parks Maintenance Equip. Replacement - Cap. Outlay $ t50,654 104,109 108,256 51,373 18,493 TOTAL EQUIPMENT REPLACEMENT FUND APPROPI~JATIONS $ 432,885 Page 7 - COUNCIL BILL NO. OP. DINANCE NO. 94 LIBRARY ENDOWMENT FUND -- Operating Contingency $ 24,000 TOTAL LIBRARY ENDOWMENT FUq'qD APPROPPAATIONS MUSEUM ENDOWMENT FUND --- Operating Contingency $ 10,00Q TOTAL MUSEUM ENDOWMENT FUND APPROPRIATIONS TOTAL APPROP~ATIONS -- ALL FUNDS UNAPPROPPAATED RAgQUIPdEMENTS: General Fund: Reserve for PERS General Fund Operating Reserve Fund: Unappropriated Balance Transit Fund: Reserve for PERS Building Fund: Reserve for PERS Reserve for Equipment Federal Program Fund: Reserve for PERS Street Fund: Reserve for PERS General Fund Capital Improvement Fund: Fund Balance Reserve - Police Fund Balance Reserve - Building Transportation Impact Fee Fund: Reserve for Future Capacity Storm Water System Development Fund: Reserve for Future Capacity Wastewater Treatment Construction: Reserve for Future Capacity Water System Development Trust Fund: Reserve for Future Capacity Sewer System Development Trust Fund: Reserve for DEQ Loan Water Fund: Reserve for PERS Wastewater (Server) Fund: Reserve for PERS 418,000 116,000 12,696 14,553 6,200 3,567 33,196 10,000 15,000 2,264,156 208,970 1,112,554 210,242 1,112,554 44,276 68,999 $ 24,000 $ 10,000 $45,533,039 Page 8 - COtYNCIL BILL NO. ORDINANCE NO. 05 Technical & Environmental Services Fund: Reserve for PERS Building Maintenance Fund: Reserve for PERS 64,470 12,548 TOTAL UNAPPROPI~AATED REQUIREMENTS -- ALL FUNDS $ 5,727,981 TOTAL 2005-2006 CITY BUDGET $51,261,020 Section 4. That the City Recorder shall certify the tax rate and tax levy to the County Clerk and County Assessor of Marion County, Oregon, made thereby and shall file with the Department of Revenue and the Division of Audits of the Secretary of State, State of Oregon, a true copy of the budget as finally adopted in accordance with the provisions of the Local Budget Laws of the State of Oregon. Section 5. That if any clause, sentence, paragraph, section or portion of this ordinance for any reason shall be adjudged invalid by a corox of competent jurisdiction, such judgment shall be confined in its operation to the clause, sentence, paragraph, section or portion of this ordinance directly involved in the controversy in which such judgment is rendered. Section 6. This ordinance being necessary for the public peace, health and safety, in that a budget for fiscal year 2005-2006 needs to be adopted by July 1, 2005 in order to continue City services, an emergency is declared to exist and this ordinance shall take effect immediately upon passage by the Council and approval by the Mayor. Approved as to Form: City Attorney Date APPROVED KATHRYN FIGLEY, MAYOR Passed by the Council Submitted to the Mayor Approved by the Mayor Filed in the Office of the Recorder ATTEST Mary Tennant, Recorder City of Woodburn, Oregon Page 9 - COL~qCIL BILL NO. ORDffqANCE NO. 96 e 11C June 20, 2005 TO: FROM: SUBJECT: Mayor and City Council through City Administrator Scott D. Russell, Chief of Police( "'"" Intergovernmental Agreement for Police Trainin.q RECOMMENDATION: It is recommended the City Council pass the attached resolution authorizing the Police Chief to sign an agreement with the City of Lake Oswego for police range use and training services. BACKGROUND: The City of Lake Oswego Police Department has built a reputation as a regional leader in providing cutting edge law enforcement training. The Woodburn Police Department has partnered with Lake Oswego Police and participated in their training on several occasions. These partnerships have allowed us to obtain training and utilize training equipment that we would not otherwise have been able to obtain. Lake Oswego Police have expressed a desire to continue and formalize this training arrangement as they wish to utilize the Woodburn Police Firing Range for training. DISCUSSION: One of the challenges of modern police management is seeing to the maintenance of officer's perishable skills through ongoing training. Many of the critical skills that officers must possess, to be safe and to reduce civil liabilities, perish if they are not utilized regularly. These critical skills (shooting, pursuit driving, ground fighting, responding to an active shooter, etc) are thankfully not needed on a regular basis in the City of Woodburn. However, when a skill is needed the courts and the public expect that our officers will possess the required skill and be competent in using it. This requires continuous and rigorous training on not just new topics but, retraining and maintenance of the basic skill sets. Agenda Item Review: City 97 City Attorney __ Fine Mayor and City Council June 20, 2005 Page 2 The Oregon Department of Public Safety Standards and Training now requires each officer to complete a number of hours of in service training in specific areas every year in order to maintain their certification. The Woodburn Police Department has worked diligently to train our own staff as instructors and subject matter experts and vce have numerous certified police instructors on various topics within our department. However, with the many varied fields that must be covered, some outside instructors and classes must be used each year. The cost of such training continues to escalate and includes; training equipment, instructor fees, travel, per diem, and loss in work time. The proposed mutually beneficial agreement would assist us in obtaining regular, quality, realistic police training on numerous critical subjects that we would otherwise have to pay a great deal for, and/or travel a great distance for, or in many cases just do without. Lake Oswego Police will benefit from the use of our police range and have accepted the attached ORS 190 agreement, which was drafted to assure proper safety, and liability measures are followed in order to provide for a safe and efficient training facility for all those involved in the training and the public as well. FINANCIAL IMPACT: This limited increase in range use will not measurably increase range costs or maintenance needs. The agreement calls for an ongoing review and any unforeseen increased costs would be negotiated when identified. Reciprocal training could reduce future training needs and associated budget increases. COUNCIL BILL NO. RESOLUTION NO. A RESOLUTION ENTERING INTO AN AGREEMENT WITH THE CITY OF LAKE OSWEGO, OREGON FOR POLICE RANGE USE AND TRAINING SERVICES AND AUTHORIZING THE POLICE CHIEF TO SIGN SAID AGREEMENT. WHEREAS, by the authority granted in ORS Chapter 190, incorporated cities may enter into agreements with each other for the performance of any of the functions and activities that they have the legal authority to perform; and WHEREAS, under said authority, the City of Woodburn and the City of Lake Oswego desire to enter into this Agreement for police range use and training services; NOW, THEREFORE, THE CITY OF WOODBURN RESOLVES AS FOLLOWS: Section 1. That the City of Woodburn enter into an Agreement with the City of Lake Oswego. Section 2. That a copy of said Agreement is affixed to this Resolution as Attachment "A" and is by this reference incorporated herein. Section 3. That the Police Chief of the City of Woodburn is hereby authorized to sign said Agreement on behalf of the City. A p pro v e d as t o f or m: ~"'"'-7J~'"~ ~//,/.~z'~ City Attorney Date Approved: Kathryn Figiey, Mayor Passed by the Council Submitted to the Mayor Approved by the Mayor Filed in the Office of the Recorder ATTEST: Mary Tennant City Recorder City of Woodburn, Oregon Page 1 - Council Bill No. Resolution No. 99 AGREEMENT Police Firearms Range Usage ATTACHMEt~I' J~' Page l ..... of ~' i- This Agreement is made and entered into between the City of Woodburn, an Oregon municipal corporation (hereinafter "Woodburn") and the City of Lake Oswego, an Oregon municipal corporation (hereinafter "Lake Oswego") under the authority of ORS Chapter 190. RECITALS: Pursuant to ORS Chapter 190, incorporated cities may enter into agreements with each other for the performance of any of the functions and activities that they have the legal authority to perform. Under said authority, Woodburn and Lake Oswego desire to enter into this Agreement. Lake Oswego police officers will benefit by the use of the Woodburn Police Firearms Range ("the Range"). Woodburn police officers will benefit by attending training conducted by the Lake Oswego Police Department. As used herein, "Woodburn Police Chief" means the Police Chief of the City of Woodburn or another person in the Woodburn Police Department designated by the Police Chief. WITNESSETH: In consideration of the mutual covenants contained herein, the parties agree as follows: 1. TERM The term of this Agreement is perpetual and it shall run from its execution by both parties until terminated subject to the provisions contained herein. The parties shall periodically review this Agreement and may modify it by addendum as they mutually agree. 2. USE OF THE RANGE BY LAKE OSWEGO ko Woodburn shall allow all sworn members of the Lake Oswego Police Department to use the Range subject to the terms of this Agreement. Bo Range usage by Lake Oswego shall be subject to availability and is not guaranteed. In order to avoid scheduling conflicts, the first of each month a Lake Oswego Rangemaster shall communicate with the Woodburn Police Firearms Training Sergeant and they shall mutually agree to a Range schedule for the upcoming month. Agreement - Police Firearms Range Usage Page 1 100 ATTACHMENT Page ,~_ of Woodburn shall maintain the Range and shall be the sole entity authorized to modify or alter the Range in any way. Lake Oswego shall supply and bear the cost of all necessary supplies or equipment for Lake Oswego shoots or training, including all necessary ammunition and weapons. Lake Oswego shall keep the Range clean and in good repair during its use of the Range. Lake Oswego shall be responsible for any damage to the Range caused by its act or neglect, other than as the result of normal usage. All Range and safety rules set forth in Woodburn Police Department Policy 13.14 (attached hereto as Exhibit "A" and incorporated herein) shall be applied to all members of the Lake Oswego Police Department when using the Range. Said policy shall be enforced by a Lake Oswego Rangemaster who shall be present on each occasion when Lake Oswego police officers use the Range. The normal hours of Range use by the Lake Oswego Police Department shall be Monday through Saturday, 0800 hours to 1900 hours. The use of the Range by the Lake Oswego Police Department at any time other than the normal hours must be approved in writing by the Woodburn Police Chief. This Agreement authorizes only sworn Lake Oswego police officers to use the Range subject to the provisions contained herein. This Agreement does not authorize any other persons to use the Range as guests of the Lake Oswego Police Department. The only weapons authorized for discharge at the Range shall be handguns of the type normally used by law enforcement agencies, police patrol rifles of the 9 mm or .223 caliber variety, and police shotguns. No discharge or explosives, chemical agents, or distraction type devices shall be allowed at the Range. USE OF RANGE FOR POLICE TRAINING CLASSES Pursuant to this Agreement, Lake Oswego shall be allowed by Woodburn to use the Range to conduct police training classes. A proposal to conduct a police Range training class shall be submitted by Lake Oswego to the Woodburn Police Chief at least 60 days prior to the date of the proposed training. Agreement- Police Firearms Range Usage Page 2 101 All police Range training class proposals shall be in writing and in a form satisfactory to the Woodburn Police Chief. Within 14 days after receiving a police Range training class proposal from Lake Oswego, the Woodburn Police Chief shall act to approve, disapprove, or modify the proposal. Alt decisions by the Woodburn Police Chief on Range training class proposals are final and not subject to review. Subject to the approval of the Woodburn Police Chief, certified police officers not employed by Woodburn or Lake Oswego may participate in police Range training classes. When certified police officers not employed by Woodburn or Lake Oswego participate in police Range training classes, Lake Oswego shall ensure that each police officer executes a Liability Waiver and Assumption of Risk document in a form acceptable to Woodburn. Each time Lake Oswego conducts a police Range training class, two (2) Woodburn police officers shall be allowed to participate in the class without paying the class registration fee. CONSIDERATION In consideration for use of the Range, Lake Oswego shall pay Woodburn a Three Hundred Dollar ($300.00) annual fee for Range maintenance. In addition to this annual fee, Lake Oswego shall provide to Woodburn 80 hours of annual in- service police training by Oregon Department of Public Safety Standards and Training (DPSST) certified instructors. ANNUAL TRAINING SCHEDULE The schedule and specific subjects of the annual training provided by Lake Oswego to Woodburn shall be agreed to and approved by the Woodburn Police Chief and the Lake Oswego Police Chief. RESPONSIBILITY FOR EMPLOYEES Lake Oswego shall be exclusively responsible for the protection of its employees and agents and shall provide adequate safety provisions and supervision for its employees and agents who utilize the Range. Woodburn shall have no responsibility or obligation with respect to the safety or supervision of these Lake Oswego employees or agents. Agreement- Police Firearms Range Usage Page 3 102 10. 11. A~rTAC INSURANCE Lake Oswego shall provide and maintain a certificate of insurance naming the City of Woodburn as an additional insured regarding incidents arising from the Lake Oswego use of the Range. insurance coverage shall include liability and workers compensation and all costs of insurance shall be paid by Lake Oswego. The minimum liability coverage maintained by Lake Oswego for use the Range shall be $1,000,000. ASSUMPTION OF RISK To the extent it may under the constitution and laws of Oregon, Lake Oswego agrees to assume the risk for the use of the Range and shall not seek damages against Woodburn for the use of the Range pursuant to this Agreement. iNDEMNIFICATION To the extent it may under the constitution and laws of Oregon, Lake Oswego shall indemnify, defend, and save Woodburn harmless from any and all claims arising out of the acts, errors or omissions of Lake Oswego occurring in the course of its use of the Range pursuant to this Agreement, provided, however, that the liability of Lake Oswego pursuant to this section shall not exceed the limits provided under ORS 30.270.. TERMINATION This Agreement may be terminated by mutual consent of both parities or by either party upon thirty (30) days notice. This termination must be in writing and delivered by certified mail or in person. Any such termination of this Agreement shall be without prejudice to any obligations or liabilities or either party already accrued prior to such termination. NOTICES All notices required under this Agreement shall be delivered by facsimile, personal delivery, or mail and shall be addressed to the following persons: Scott D. Russell Chief of Police City of Woodburn 270 Montgomery Street Woodburn, OR 97071 Daniel Duncan Chief of Police City of Lake Oswego 380 A Avenue Lake Oswego, OR 97034 Agreement- Police Firearms Range Usage Page 4 103 12. 13. GOVERNING LAW ATTACHMEN'T ~,, Page __~._ of ~ The law of the State of Oregon shall govern the validity of this Agreement, its interpretation and performance, and any other claims related to it. SEVERABILITY If any of the provisions contained in this Agreement are held for any reason to be invalid, illegal, or unenforceable in any respect, such invalidity, illegality, or unenforceability will not affect any other provision, and this Agreement shall be construed as if such invalid, illegal, or unenforceable provision had never been contained herein. 14. ENTIRE AGREEMENT This Agreement constitutes the entire Agreement and supercedes all prior written or oral understandings, and may be changed only by a written amendment to this Agreement, which is executed by both parties. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have caused this Agreement to be executed by their respective authorized officers or representatives. CITY OF WOODBURN CITY OF LAKE OSWEGO By: By: Scott D. Russell, Chief of Police Date: Date: Daniel Duncan, Chief of Police Agreement- Police Firearms Range Usage Page 5 104. 11D June 14, 2005 TO: FROM: SUBJECT: Mayor and City Council through City Administrator Mary Tennant, City Recorder Eligibility to Receive State Shared Revenues in Fiscal Year 2005-06 RECOMMENDATION: Council adopt the attached resolution declaring the City's eligibility to receive state shared revenues during fiscal year 2005-06. BACKGROUND: Annually the City is required under state statute to adopt a Resolution declaring the City's eligibility to receive State revenues derived from various sources such as gas tax, liquor tax, and cigarette tax. This resolution must be filed with the Department of Administrative Services by July 31,2005 in order to receive funds allocated by the legislature during fiscal year 2005-06. DISCUSSION: The 2005-06 proposed budget will reflect projected revenues from these state shared revenues for various operational purposes within the General Fund and Street Fund. The estimated per capita distribution is as follows: State Gas Tax Revenue $49.00 per capita Liquor Tax $ 8.99 per capita Cigarette Tax $1.78 per capital FINANCIAL IMPACT: During fiscal year 2005-06, the City anticipates receiving $1,181,520 in state shared revenues. Agenda Item Review: City 105 City Attorney Finance COUNCIL BILL NO. RESOLUTION NO. A RESOLUTION CERTIFYING THE ELIGIBILITY OF THE CITY OF WOODBUR2N TO PdgCEIVE STATE-SHARED REVENUES DURANG FISCAL YEAR 2005-06. WHEREAS, Oregon Revised Statutes 221.760 provides that the officer responsible for disbursing funds to cities under ORS 323.455,366.785 to 366.820 and 471.805 shall, in the case of a city located within a county having rnore than 100,000 habitants according to the most recent federal decennial census, disburse such Bands only if the City provides four or more of the following services: (1) Police protection, (2) Fire protection, (3) Street construction, maintenance, and lighting, (4) Sanitary sewer, (5) Storm sewers, (6) Planning, zoning, and subdivision control, and (7) one or more utility services, and WHEREAS, City officials recognize the desirability of assisting the state officer responsible for determining the eligibility of cities to receive such funds in accordance with ORS 221.760, now, therefore, THE CITY OF WOODBURN RESOLVES AS FOLLOWS: Section 1. That the City of Woodburn hereby certifies that it provides the following four or more services enumerated in ORS 221.760: (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) Police protection; Street construction, maintenance, and lighting; Sanitary sewers; Storm sewers; Planning, zoning, and subdivision control; and One Utility service. Approved as to Form: City Attorney Date APPROVED KATHRYN FIGLEY, MAYOR Passed by the Council Submitted to the Mayor Approved by the Mayor Filed in the Office of the Recorder ATTEST Mary Tennant, City Recorder City of Woodburn, Oregon Page 1 - Council Bill No. Resolution No. 106 11E June 14, 2005 TO: FROM: SUBJECT: Mayor and City Council through City Administrator Mary Tennant, City Recorder [,.,~'E' State Revenue Sharing Funds for Fiscal Year 2005-06 RECOMMENDATION: Council adopt the attached resolution declaring City's election to receive State Revenue Sharing funds in fiscal year 2005-06. BACKGROUND: Annually the City is required under State Statute to adopt a resolution declaring the City's election to receive State Revenue Sharing funds. This resolution must be filed with the State Dept. of Administrative Services before July 31, 2005 in order to receive the funds allocated by the legislature during fiscal year 2005-06. DISCUSSION: In order to receive State Revenue Sharing funds, the statute requires the City to hold public hearings before the Budget Committee and the City Council for the purpose of giving the public an opportunity to comment on proposed uses of the funds. The hearing before the Budget Committee was held on May 21,2005 and the hearing before the City Council was held on June 13, 2005. FINANCIAl. IMPACT: During fiscal year 2005-06, the City anticipates receiving $150,000 in State Revenue Sharing funds. Agenda Item Review: City Administra City Attorney Finance~ 107 COUNCIL BILL NO. RA~SOLUTION NO. AN RESOLUTION DECLARING THE CITY'S ELECTION TO RECEIVE STATE RA~VENUES DUPING FISCAL YEAR 2005-06. Whereas, ORS 221.770 requires cities to pass a resolution annually declaring their election to receive state revenue sharing, now, therefore, THE CITY OF WOODBURN RESOLVES AS FOLLOWS: Section 1. Pursuant to ORS 221.770, the City hereby elects to receive state revenues for fiscal year 2005-2006. Approved as to Form City Attorney Date APPROVED KATHRYN FIGLEY, MAYOR Passed by the Council Submitted to the Mayor Approved by the Mayor Filed in the Office of the Recorder ATTEST Mary Tennant, Recorder City of Woodbum, Oregon Page 1 - Council Bill No. Resolution No. 108 e 11F June 20, 2005 TO: Mayor and City Council through City Administrator FROM: Scott D. Russell, Chief of Police SUBJECT: Traffic Grant Enforcement Proflram and A.qreement RECOMMENDATION: City Council authorize the City Administrator to sign an Agreement with Marion County for administration of a traffic grant once final language has been agreed upon. BACKGROUND: In June 2005 the Woodburn Police Department was advised that the Marion County Sheriff's Office was awarded an Oregon Department of Transportation Traffic Grant to provide enhanced traffic enforcement as part of a multi-agency effort. This effort must include assistance from local police agencies that may share in the grant as a pass through for an amount of up to $5000.00. DISCUSSION: Officers will utilize this overtime to work in concert with other local officers, and sheriff's deputies, on traffic enforcement operations in the area to reduce traffic accidents and injuries. Operations are slated to coincide with major civic events and holidays when extreme traffic problems occur. The City and Marion Count,/are working to finalize a minor portion of the agreement language. All grant moneys must be expended prior to September 30, 2005. Since time is of the essence we request authority to allow the City Administrator to sign the agreement once final language has been completed. FINANCIAL IMPACT: $5,000 will be added to Police Department Overtime budget and offset by this grant. An in kind match of 20% (or $1,000) is required, and matching overtime will be spent from the Police Department Overtime Budget. Agenda Item Review: City 109 City Attorney Fin( Incorporated June 27, 2005 TO: FROM: SUBJECT: Mayor and City Council through City Administrator Mary Tennant, City Recorder Liability, Auto, Property, and Workers' Compensation Insurance for Fiscal Year 2005-06 RECOMMENDATION: It is recommended that the Council authorize the City Administrator to execute liability, auto, property, and workers' compensation insurance contracts with City County Insurance Services (ClS) for fiscal year 2005-06. BACKGROUND: Annually, the City's Agent of Record, Huggins Insurance Services, solicits quotes from potential insurance companies to insure competitive pricing on the City's liability, auto, property, and workers' compensation insurance needs. DISCUSSION: Public entity liability insurance continues to be a difficult market in which to secure coverage with the two primary carriers being CIS and Argonaut Insurance. Argonaut insurance is in their second year of writing insurance in Oregon and coverage differences such as high deductibles, premium increases, and coverage restrictions were of high concern to our Agent in providing an insurance package that would be cost effective and yet best serve the insurance needs of the City. As a result, CIS was the only company submitting a proposal for fiscal year 2005- 06. Attached is a letter from our Agent of Record recommending that the City continue to secure liability, auto, property, and workers' compensation insurance through CIS. Also attached is a summary report of the CIS proposal for these insurance coverages. It should be noted that the proposal was based on asset values as of June 2005 and additional premiums will be assessed during the year as new property and buildings are acquired by the City. Agenda Item Review: City Administrator__ City Attorney __ Finance __ Mayor and City Council June 24, 2004 Page 2 · In regards to Workers' Compensation coverage, the City was provided with options for a guaranteed cost plan and a retrospective plan. Currently the City is under a retrospective plan which could provide the City with some substantial premium savings if losses are below $90,000. Due to the lateness in receiving the CIS quote, staff will be analyzing options before a selection is made on the plan type. FINANCIAL IMPACT: For fiscal year 2005-06, the estimated premium for liability, auto, and property insurance is .$218,762.65 which is a 6.7% increase over the estimated premium for 2004-05. In comparing the retrospective plan, the initial premium contribution increase for workers' compensation insurance is approximately 13.96% due to payroll classification rate increases, the City's experience modification rate, and salary projections within the 2005-06 budget. 11G June 24, 2005 TO: FROM: SUBJECT: Mayor and City Council through City Administrator Mary Tennant, City Recorder Liability, Auto, Property, and Worker's Compensation Insurance for Fiscal Year 2005-06 At the time of printing the agenda materials, this item was still in draft form. A memo will be distributed to the Council at their June 27, 2005 meeting. Agenda Item Review: City Adrr City At:orney Finance 110