Agenda - 07/10/1995 CITY OF WOODBURN
270 MONTGOMERY STREET * ** ° WOODBURN, OREGON
AGENDA
WOODBURN CITY COUNCIL
JULY 10, 1995 - 7:00 P.M.
A. Council minutes of June 26, 1995 regular and executive meeting.
B. Planning Commission minutes of June 22, 1995.
APPOINTMENTS:
A. C. Bakken, to the Woodburn Cable Television Advisory Board
to a term expiring December 31, 1995.
3A
3B
ANNOUNCEMENTS:
JULY 19, 1995 AT 7:00 P.M. Joint informational workshop:
Cable Television Advisory Board and Woodburn Cable Access TV (WCAT)
at James Street Fire Station.
JULY 20, 1995 AT NOON. Woodburn Transportation TaSk Force meeting
Woodburn Public Library -
JULY 24, 1995 AT 7:00 p.m. Public Hearing before the City Council:
Appeal of Planning Commission action on SPR 95-10, LaPointe Texaco,
at Woodburn City Hall.
PROCLAMATIONS
A. Chamber of Commerce
B. Other Committees
(This allows public to Introduce items for Council consideration
not already scheduled on the agenda.)
~ NO PUBLIC HEARINGS WERE SCHEDULED ON THIS DATE.
Page I - Council Agenda, July 10, 1995
Se
A. Council Bill No. 1646 - Ordinance amending the Woodburn Comprehensive
Plan Map and changing the zoning designation on four parcel of property
located between Hardcastle and Mill street between Corby and Front Streets.
(Woodburn Fertilizer) 10A
o
B. Council Bill No. 1647 - Resolution approving final draft of the Wastewater
Facilities Plan. 10B
Council Bill No. 1648 - Resolution entering into an agreement with the city
of Salem for use of the Salem Senior by the RSVP program, 10C
D. Insurance coverage recommendations for fiscal year 1995-96.
10D
E. Contract award: Library parking lot.
IOE
F. Tentative agreement pertaining to Rugged Manufacturing property 10F
at 192 Young.
14. _ :..'...._'_,..~..~
A, Subdivision 94-04 - Six lot subdivision on "A" Street,
A, Donation from French Prairie KiWanis to Woodburn Public Library,
B. Revocation of Business Registration,
C, City Hall HVAC system update.
D. Transportation Task Force update,
E, Building Activity Report for the month of June 1995,
16. - :' =.,.'....." ~.' ; · '"..<.
14A
15A
15B
15C
15D
Page 2 - Council Agenda, July 10, 1995
3A
TAPE
READING
0001
0003
00~3
0034
OO5O
0062
COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
June 26, 1995
DATE. COUNCIL CHAMBERS, CITY HALLt CITY OF WOODBURNt COUNTY
OF MARION, STATE OF ORE~ON, JUNE 26, 1995.
CONVENED. The Council met in regular session at 7:00 p.m.
withMayor Kirksey presiding.
ROLL
Mayor' Kirksey Present
Councilor Chadwick Present
Councilor Figley Present
Councilor Hagenauer Present
Councilor Jennings Present
Councilor Pugh Present
Councilor Sifuentez Present
Staff Present:
City Administrator Childs, City Attorney Shields, Public Works
Director Tiwari, Community Development Director Goeckritz,
Police Chief Wright, Park Director Holly, Library Director
Sprauer, 9-1-1 Communications Manager Wolf, Public Works
Manager Rohman, City Recorder Tennant
MINUTES.
JENNINGS/FIGLEY .... approve the Council regular and executive
session minutes of June 12, 1995; and accept the Planning
Commission minutes of June 8, 1995. The motion passed
unanimously.
Administrator Childs requested that the Council designate a
representative to the NORCOM Board and this item be included
under General Business item 10(H). It was the consensus of
the Council that this item be added to the agenda.
~uWNOUN~(~NT~.
The Woodburn Transportation Task Force will hold a Open House
on Thursday, June 29th, 4:00 pm to 8:00 pm at the PGE
Building.
Mayor Kirksey reminded the public of the following July 4th
activities in Woodburn: the Chuckwagon Breakfast (6:00 am to
11:00 am), Old Fashioned city Picnic (12:00 noon to 6:00 pm),
Pre-Fireworks Show and entertainment (6:00 pm to 10:00 pm),
and Fireworks Display (10:00 pm).
WOODBURN CONEB~CK C~MPAIGN REPORT.
Councilor Figley stated that volunteers are still needed for
the July 4th celebration to be held at the High School
athletic field. She encouraged interested persons to call
Page i - Council Meeting Minutes, June 26, 1995
3A
TAPE
READING
0173
0283
0310
0331
COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
June 26, 1995
City Hall and/or attend the Comeback Campaign's meeting on
Tuesday, June 27th, 6:00 p.m., at City Hall.
Councilor Jennings also advised the public that plans are
being made for a VJ Day Program on August 12th in honor of the
50year end of World War II. He stated that more information
on this program will be made available in July.
PUBLIC ~ING - 1994-95 SUPPLEMENTAL BUDGET.
Mayor KirkSey declared the public hearing open at 7:08 p.m..
Administrator Childs stated that the purpose of the proposed
supplemental budget is to properly reflect unforeseen
appropriations to be spent during fiscal year 1994-95. He
outlined the budgetary revenues and appropriations being
proposed in the Library Fund, Cable TV Franchise Fund, and
City Hall Construction Fund.
No one in the audience spoke either for or against the
proposed 1994-95 supplemental budget.
Mayor Kirksey declared the hearing closed at 7:13 p.m..
COUNCIL BILL 1641 - ORDI1TANCE ~DOPTING A SUPPLEMENTAL BUDGET
FOR FIBCAL ~EAR 1994-95.
Council Bill 1641 was introduced by Councilor Hagenauer.
Recorder Tennant read the two readings of the bill by title
only since there were no objections from the Council. On roll
call vote for final passage, the bill passed unanimously.
Mayor Kirksey declared Council Bill 1641 duly passed with the
emergency clause.
COUNCIL BILL 1642 - RESOLUTION aUTHORIZING TRANSFER OF
OPERATING CONTINGENCY aPpROPRIaTIONS DURING FISCAL YF2%R 1994-
95.
Council Bill 1642 was introduced by Councilor Hagenauer. The
bill was read by title only since there were no objections
from the Council. On roll call vote for final passage,
Council Bill 1642 passed unanimously. Mayor Kirksey declared
the bill duly passed.
COUNCIL BILL 1643 - RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING TRANSFER OF
aPPROPRIaTIONS ~ITHIN a FUND DURING FIBCaL YF~/t 1994-95.
Councilor.Hagenauer introduced Council Bill 1643. Recorder
Tennant read the bill in full since there were no objections
from the Council. On roll call vote for final passage, the
bill passed unanimously. Mayor Kirksey declared Council Bill
1643 duly passed.
Page 2 - Council Meeting Minutes, June 26, 1995
3A
COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
June 26, 1995
TAPE
READING
0353
COUNCIL BIlL 1644 - ORDINANCE ADOPTING A BUDGET FOR FISCAL
YE]iR 1995-96m MAKING ~DPROPRIATIONS, ]%ND LEVYING TAXES,
Council Bill 1644 was introduced by Councilor Hagenauer.
Recorder Tennant read the two readings of the bill by title
only since there were no objections from the Council. On roll
call for final passage, the bill passed unanimously. Mayor
Kirksey declared Council Bill 1644 duly passed with the
emergency clause.
0384
COUNCIL BILL 1645 - RNSOLUTION AUTHORIZING CONTRACTUAL
SERVICES AGREemeNT WITH N. ROBERT SHIELDS. CITY ATTORNEY.
Council Bill 1645 was introduced by Councilor Hagenauer. The
bill was read by title only since there were no objections
from the Council.
Administrator Childs stated that there was an error in the
main text of the agreement, Section 4, and that the correct
rate per hour is $50.00. Additionally, a memo was included in
the packet from Attorney Shields declaring a conflict of
interest on this issue.
Councilor Jennings stated that future budgets should consider
paying the.City Attorney at a similar hourly rate as that paid
to our Judge and Labor Consultant.
On roll call vote for final passage, the bill passed
unanimously. Mayor Kirksey declared Council Bill 1645 duly
passed.
0454
ACCEPTANCE OF PUBLIC'RIGHT-OF-FAY - BROWN STREET.
Staff recommended the acceptance of a right-of-way easements
for roadway purposes from Nancy Bocchi and Fay Zimmer which is
being conveyed to the City in conjunction with the Steklov
Subdivision (developer Pete Cam).
JENNINGS/FIGLEY... accept the two easements from Nancy Bocchi
and Fay Zimmer as recommended. The motion passed unanimously.
046~
REQUEST FOR STB_~T CLOSURE AND USE OF SOUND ]~(PLIFICATION
EQUIPmeNT FOR NORTH SIXTH STREET JULY 4TH BLOCK PARTY.
Residents in the North Sixth Street area requested a street
closure in the vicinity of High and Fir streets and the use of
sound amplification equipment for a 4th of July Block Party.
Police Chief Wright recommended the approval of the partial
street closure and the use of sound amplification equipment
for this event.
JENNINGS/PUGH... approve the recommendation of Chief Wright
with the proviso that the sound amplification begin no earlier
than 10:00 am and end by 9:00 pm. The motion passed
unanimously.
0483
DESIGNATION OF NORCOM (9-1-1) BOARD MEMBER.
Administrator Childs stated that the City needs to appoint a
Councilor and staff member to the Board.
Page 3 - Council Meeting Minutes, June 26, 1995
COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
June 26, 1995
TAPE
READING
HAGENAUER/JENNINGS .... recommend the appointment of Councilor
Jennings to the NORCOM Board. The motion passed unanimously.
JENNINGS/FIGLEY .... appoint Administrator Childs or his
designee to also serve on the NORCOM Board. Following a brief
discussion on who would be appointed as designee,
Administrator Childs stated that he wanted to have some
flexibility on the designee issue but it would most probably
be Chief Wright.
The motion passed unanimously.
0555
~L~TMS FOR THE MONTH OF NAY 1995.
SIFUENTEZ/FIGLEY .... approve voucher checks ~27241 - ~27632
issued during the month of May 1995. The motion passed
unanimously.
O57O
Preston Tack, 2197 Camilla Way, and Gilbert Flaugher, 1352
Astor Way, presented a letter to the Council regarding future
consultant fees for preparation of plan documents relating to
the new Wastewater Facility. Mr. Tack stated that, as
members of the Wastewater Advisory Committee, they are well
aware of the amount of time and money spent as of this date
to prepare the Wastewater Facilities Plan and they strongly
feel that a competitive bidding process should occur to obtain
firm price proposals in the preparation of bid documents for
the construction of a new facility.
Mayor Kirksey expressed her gratitude to Mr. Tack and Mr.
Flaugher for their research and overall work while on this
committee.
Councilor Jennings stated that staff will review the contents
of their letter and report back to the Council at a later
date.
O8OO
SITE pLAN REVIEW ~95-11 -- WOODBURN pUBLIC LIBRARy PARKING
LOT.
The site plan was included in the agenda packet for Council
review. No comments were made by the Council on this issue.
0810
BT~FF REPORTB.
A) OGA Well Development -- Director Tiwari stated that the
Oregon Golf Association (OGA) is proposing to drill a well on
their property located outside of the city limits for
irrigation purposes. The proposed irrigation well would Be
drilled through to the 3rd aquifer strata which is in the same
strata as the City's water supply. He explained the different
levels of strata and the need to eliminate the risk factor of
contaminating the City's water supply since the City does not
currently pre-treat its water. Currently, the City has. a
long-term goal in place which involves abandonment of water
wells within the city limits to help protect our water supply.
Permits for wells are issued by the State and the State has
Page 4 - Council Meeting Minutes, June 26, 1995
TAPE
READING
1422
1451
COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
June 26, 1995
legal authority on water issues. He stated that the OGA golf
course is an asset to the community, however, he strongly
feels that there is sufficient water supply within the 1st
aquifer strata to meet the irrigation needs of the golf course
without drilling down to the 3rd aquifer.
Councilor Jennings expressed his opinion that water
contamination is not that likely and since the well is being
drilled within the County, the City should not be so concerned
over the issue. He cited the possibility of farmers within
the County surrounding the Woodburn area who also may have
drilled to the 3rd aquifer in the past.
Councilor Pugh referred to the letter from OGA Attorney David
Weiner to the city and he felt that the OGA and City should
come to some agreement on this issue since both have some
responsibilities to work toward the common good of the
community.
Mayor Kirksey questioned if the City would have any legal
rights to maintain its water supply for its residents if OGA
does drill through to the 3rd aquifer strata and their well
ultimately becomes a source of contamination.
Director Tiwari reiterated that there is plenty of water of
available and, in time of a drought, the community would have
priority for water over the golf course. He is not implying
that OGA would pollute the water source but risk increases as
the drill goes through each aquifer level.
Administrator Childs stated that the staff is not suggesting
that anyone is in a position to contaminate the water source
and there is little risk to the consumer. The staff's major
concern relates to the potential multi-million dollar source
of water treatment alternatives that would become necessary if
the water eventually becomes contaminated.
B) city Hall HVAC System Replacement Update -- Public Works
Manager Rohman advised the Council that no firm start date has
been set. The contractor is working with the roof repair
contractor to set a specific date since the roof repair needs
to be done in concert with the replacement of the HVAC units.
C) Liability/Property Insurance for Fiscal Year 1995-96 --
Insurance quotes from four companies have been received and,
after a review of those quotes, it has been determined that
the liability and auto physical damage insurance coverage will
be renewed with City/County Insurance Services (CIS) who had
submitted the lowest quote for this insurance. In regards to
property insurance, the quotes contained different levels and
deductibles for earthquake insurance which is now a mandate as
part of our propertycoverage after receiving FEMAmonies from
the 1993 earthquake. Staff will make a recommendation On
which company to contract with at the next regular meeting.
Page 5 - Council Meeting Minutes, June 26, 1995
TAPE
READING
1500
1585
3A
COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
June 26, 1995
ADMINIBTRATOR'S REPORT.
Administrator Childs stated that the city's annual
Equipment/Surplus auction was held on Saturday, June 24th. He
commended the Police Department, in particular part-time
evidence clerk Ms. Timmons, on having the items well-packaged
and well-marked for sale to the public.
Healso distributed copies of a Police Department press
release to the Council regarding the recent conclusion of an
undercover drug investigation at La Linda's, 293 N. Front
Street, on Saturday, June 24th.
Councilor Chadwick stated that. several streets within the
Senior Estates are showing signs of weeds growing through the
cracks. She suggested that something be done about this
problem now to stop the deterioration of the street.
Mayor Kirksey also encouraged the citizens and businessmen
within the community to help with this situation even it is to
contact the Public Works department to find out what they can
do to keep the weeds down.
Councilor Pugh stated that improvements need to be made at
Burlingham Park and he requested staff to follow-up on the
suggestions made earlier by residents who live in the area.
Councilor Figley stated that she hoped to see a large turnout
at the July 4th celebration.
Councilor Jennings stated that he would like to tour the new
swimming pool facility. In regards to LaLinda's, he
questioned if the city could revoke their business license
based on the recent outcome of the drug investigation.
Administrator Childs stated that staff will need to research
that question and report back to the Council.
Councilor Hagenauer stated that the lot on Hardcastle
continues to have high grass which is a reoccurring problem
involving this absentee landowner.
Community Development Director Goeckritz stated that he will
have the Code Enforcement officer check out this property
later this week.
Councilor Sifuentez questioned the opening date for the new
aquatic center.
Park Director Holly stated that they hope to open the facility
by September 1st. A Pool Manager has been hired and will
begin work on July. 10th. The new manager currently works in
California and hasbeen involved in year-round pool operations
for approximately 20 years. She was raised in the Salem area
and her mother still resides in Salem.
Page 6 - Council Meeting Minutes, June 26, 1995
3A
TAPE
READING
2175
2183
COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
June 26, 1995
Mayor Kirksey stated that consideration should be given to
assessing fines to property owners who do not remove graffiti
in a timely manner and/or revoking their business license.
She also stated that concerns have been raised regarding
transient businesses and further research needs to be done on
this issue.
She advised the Council that she will be giving Code
Enforcement another list of locations where graffiti has been
placed on property for an extended period of time.
Additionally, she expressed her opinion that tenants should be
made responsible for absentee landlords.
Councilor Chadwick questioned what the law is regarding how
late people can play loud music outside and what can the
neighbors do about it.
Chief Wright stated that it is generally around 7:00 p.m.,
however, it can be anytime when adjoining residents are
offended. The resident(s) must sign the complaint and the
Police Officers are a tool the resident(s) can use to initiate
the.complaint process and assist in the prosecution of the
complaint. In regards to a barking dog complaint, the
resident offended by the barking dog must also be the
complainant and, as with noise complaints, the officer will
issue the citation and assist in the prosecution of the
complaint.
Mayor Kirksey stated that she had recently assisted the Police
Department by getting the license number of a large truck that
had parked in a lane of traffic on Highway 99E in order to go
into the 7-11 Store. The trucking firm will get a parking
citation mailed to them. She encouraged residents to get
involved.
~xBcvTIV~ SESSION.
JENNINGS/FIGLEY .... adjourn to executive session under the
authority of ORS 192.660(1)(H) to consult with legal counsel
concerning the legal rights and duties of a public body with
regard to current litigation or litigation likely to be filed.
The motion passed unanimously.
The meeting adjourned to executive session at 8:11 p.m. and
reconvened at 8:50 p.m..
No action was taken by the Council following the executive
session.
Mayor Kirksey reminded the Council that there is a vacancy on
the Cable TV Advisory Board and she enlisted their assistance
in trying to find an individual for this position to be
appointed at the July 10th meeting.
Page 7 - Council Meeting Minutes, June 26, 1995
COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
June 26, 1995
TAPE
READING
2219
ADJOURNMENT.
JENNINGS/FIGLEY .... adjourn the meeting.
unanimously.
The meeting adjourned at 8:53 p.m..
The motion passed
3A
APPROVED
NANCY A. KIRKSEY, MAYOR
ATTEST
Mary Tennant, Recorder
City. of Woodburn, Oregon
Page 8 - Council Meeting Minutes, June 26, 1995
Executive Session
COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
June 26, 1995
3A
DATE. CONFERENCE ROOM, CITY HALL, CITY OF WOODBURN, COUNTY OF
MARION, STATE OF OREGON, JUNE 26, 1995.
CONVENED. The Council met in executive session at 8:15 p.m. with Mayor Kirksey
presiding.
ROLL CALL.
Mayor Kirksey Present
Councilor Chadwick Present
Councilor Figley Present
Councilor Hagenauer Present
Councilor Jennings Present
Councilor Pugh Present
Councilor Sifuentez Present
Staff Present: City Administrator Childs, City Attorney Shields, Scott Spence, City
Recorder Tennant
Press: Shelby Case, Woodburn Independent
The executive session was held under the authority of ORS 192.660(1)(h) to consult
with counsel Concerning the legal rights and duties of a public body with regard to
current litigation or litigation likely to be filed.
Mayor Kirksey reminded the Councilors, staff, and press that information discussed in
executive session is not to be discussed with the public.
Attorney Shields and Administrator Childs provided the Council with updates on the
following legal issues:
1) Mar-Dene Corp. v. City of Woodburn
2) City of Woodburn v. Salud Medical Center, Inc.
3) threatened litigation by North Willamette Telecom, Inc.
ADJOURNMENT.
The executive session adjourned at 8:46 p.m..
APPROVED
NANCY A. KIRKSEY, MAYOR
ATTEST
Mary Tennant, Recorder
City of Woodburn, Oregon
Page I - Executive Session, Council Meeting Minutes, June 26, 1995
3R
MINUTES
WOODBURN PLANNING COMMISSION
JUNE 22 1995
1)
2)
3)
4)
5)
6)
ROLL:
Chairperson
Vice Chairperson
Commissioner
Commissioner
Commissioner
Commissioner
Commissioner
Commissioner
Commissioner
Mrs. Warzynski Present
Mrs. Bjelland Present
Mrs. Henkes Absent
Mrs. Schultz Present
Mrs. Davis Absent
Mr. Atkinson Absent
Mr. Palmer Present
Mr. Will Present
Mr. Frawley Present
Staff Present:
Steve Goeckritz, Community Development Director
Teresa Engeldinger, City Planner
MINUTES:
The Planning Commission minutes of the May 25, 1995 meeting were accepted
as printed.
The Planning Commission minutes of June 8, 1995 were accepted as printed.
INTRODUCTION OF NEW PLANNING COMMISSION MEMBERS:
Commissioner Bjelland and Chairperson Warzynski welcomed the new
Commissioners.
BUSINESS FROM THE AUDIENCE:
None
COMMUNICATIONS:
None
PUBLIC HEARING:
A. Subdivision 94-04 - J. McCaulley
Staff read the statement necessary to open the public hearing. The nature of
the application is approval of a six lot subdivision. Staff read the Approval
3B
Criteria, the Raise it or Waive it Rule and the Right to Have the Record Remain
Open.
Staff stated that the applicant is proposing to create six lots which puts the
property into the category of a subdivision. There are existing homes that are
around these parcels. These lots will be served by private driveways. These
lots exceed the minimum of 6,000 sq. ft.
Commissioner Schultz asked if this land had already been annexed into the city.
Staff answered yes.
Staff further stated that this area is currently unimproved. This proposal will
be a plus for this area with the street improvements being made and the
infrastructure being laid.
Chairperson Warzynski asked if that portion of Payne Street would be built at
Public Works engineering standards.
Staff answered yes. The developer is responsible for extending Payne Street
to the end of their subdivision. Payne Street will eventually be improved all the
way to Brown Street as development occurs.
Commissioner Will asked if this would include sidewalks when the street is
improved and if "A" Street would be extended all the way down to Bradley?
Staff answered yes.
There was some further discussion regarding the driveway accesses to these
lots.
Commissioner Frawley asked if these homes would be stick built or
manufactured homes?
Staff answered that under the law the developer has the opportunity to chose
what type of housing he wishes to build.
The applicant, J. McCaulley, 1555 N. Jansen St., Portland, OR 97217. He
stated that they have anticipated building stick built homes. They felt that
stick built homes would look best in the neighborhood.
Chairperson Warzynski asked if there were any questions from the Commission
for the applicant. There were none. There was no one in the audience to
PCM6-?.2.95
SG:bw
2
7)
speak for or against this project. She closed the public hearing.
Commissioner Palmer stated that he felt that this would be a good addition to
the area.
Commissioner Bjelland felt that this would be a nice improvement to the area.
Commissioner Palmer made the motion to approve Subdivision 94-04 with the
conditions outlined in the staff report.
Commissioner Will seconded the motion.
A vote was taken and the motion passed.
J. McCaulley told the Commission that he wished to thank Teresa. He stated
he had processed many landuse applications in the US and in Europe and he
found Teresa to be the most professional competent planner he had dealt with.
REPORTS:
A. Site Plan Review//95-11 Library Parking Lot
Staff stated that administrative approval was given for the parking lot for the
library. It will increase the amount of parking around city hall and the library.
Staff needed only acknowledgement from the Commission.
Commissioner Palmer asked if this parking was for employees or patrons.
Staff answered both.
Commissioner Will asked if 50 spaces were required and only 20 were being
provided, if someone else were to build a building somewhere else could this
same criteria apply that they build another parking lot.
Staff answered that the existing parking around city hall and the library would
be counted in that number of required spaces.
Chairperson Warzynski asked if there was a bike stand.
Staff answered that part of the Transportation Rule requires bike parking and
the city complies with this rule.
B. Bicycles:
3B
~'CM;-Z2.SS 3
,SG:bw
3B
8)
9)
Staff has put in a request to the Police Department for the usage of one of their
bikes until the Planning Department can afford to buy a bike for usage by city
staff who will be utilizing the bike for site visitation, planning errands, such as
post office, newspaper office, printing shops, office supply store, public notice
posting and various other activities.
C. Workshop - Draft Transportation Plan
This workshop will be held on June 29, 1995 at City Hall. Staff wants the
Commission to feel comfortable when going over this material. The Planning
COmmission will be making a recommendation to the City Council regarding this
plan in the near future.
D. Building Activity - May, 1995
E. Code Enforcement Activity - May, 199§
F. Name/Address of all Planning Commission members
Staff stated that a ethics information packet for Planning Commission members
use will be given out at a future meeting. The new members and anyone else
who wishes to go will be sent to the next Planning Commission training
seminar.
BUSINESS FROM THE COMMISSION:
None
ADJOURNMENT:
There being no further business the Planning Commission meeting adjourned.
PCM6-22.95
SG:bw
4
10A
COUNCIL BILL NO. 1646
ORDINANCE NO.
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING THE WOODBURN COMPREHENSIVE PLAN MAP AND
CHANGING THE ZONING DESIGNATION ON FOUR PARCELS OF PROPERTY
LOCATED BETWEEN HARDCASTLE AVENUE AND MILL STREET BETWEEN CORBY
STREET AND FRONT STREET AND DECLARING AN EMERGENCY.
WHEREAS, the Woodburn Comprehensive Plan and Zoning Map have
established certain land uses within the City of Woodburn's Urban Growth Boundary,
and
WHEREAS, the Woodburn Planning Commission has previously considered
various land use decisions involving the parcels described herein; and
WHEREAS, the land use decisions involving a Site Plan Review and two
variance requests were not appealed to the City Council under Section 11.050(b) and
13.120(a), respectively, of the Woodburn Zoning Ordinance; and
WHEREAS, The City Council did not "call up" the Site Plan Review or Variance
requests pursuant to Sections 11.050 and 13.070, respectively, of the Woodburn
Zoning Ordinance; and
WHEREAS, The City Council, after a public hearing, must now take action on
the application regarding the recommendation of the Planning Commission on the land
use decisions involving a Woodburn Comprehensive Plan Map Amendment and a
change in the zoning designation; NOW, THEREFORE,
THE CITY OF WOODBURN ORDAINS AS FOLLOWS:
Section 1. Parcel I of the subject property is described as follows:
Tax Lot 2300, Map 6-1 WO7DD
Section 2. As to Parcel 1, the Woodburn Comprehensive Plan Map is hereby
amended from Residential Less Than 12 Units Per Acre to Industrial.
Section 3. As to Parcel 1, the Woodburn Zoning Map is hereby amended from
Residential Single Family (RS) to Light Industrial (IL).
Page I -
COUNCIL BILL NO. 1646
ORDINANCE NO.
IOA
Section 4. Parcel 2 of the subject property is described as follows:
Tax Lot 2200, Map 5-1 WO7DD
Section 5. As to Parcel 2, the Woodburn Comprehensive Plan Map is hereby
amended from Residential Less Than 12 Units Per Acre to Industrial.
Section 6. As to Parcel 2, the Woodburn Zoning Map is hereby amended from
Residential Single Family (RS) to Light Industrial (IL).
Section 7. Parcel 3 of the subject property is described as follows:
Tax Lot 10300, Map 5-1 WO7DD
Section 8. As to Parcel 3, the Woodburn Comprehensive Plan Map is hereby
amended from Residential Greater Than 12 Units Per Acre to Industrial.
Section 9. As to Parcel 3, the Woodburn Zoning Map is hereby amended from
Residential Single Family (RS) to Light Industrial (IL).
Section 10. Parcel 4 of the subject property is described as follows:
Tax Lot 10700, Map 5-1 WO7DC
Section 11. As to Parcel 4, the Woodburn Comprehensive Plan Map is hereby
amended from Residential Greater Than 12 Units Per Acre to Industrial.
Section 12. As to Parcel 4, the Woodburn Zoning Map is hereby amended from
Residential Single Family (RS) to Light Industrial (IL).
Section 13. That the amendments to the Woodburn Comprehensive Plan Map
and Woodburn Zoning Map on Parcels 1, 2, 3, and 4, as described above, are based
upon the Findings attached hereto as Exhibit "A" and incorporated herein.
Section 14. That approval of the application on the subject property is
conditioned upon the applicant meeting all conditions on the Site Plan Review and
Variance applications previously approved by the Planning Commission.
Section 15. This ordinance being necessary for the immediate preservation
of the public peace, health and safety, and emergency is declared to exist and this
Page 2 - COUNCIL BILL NO. 1646
ORDINANCE NO.
IOA
ordinance shall take effect immediately upon passage by the Council and approval by
the Mayor.
APPROVED:
Passed by the Council
Submitted to the Mayor
Approved by the Mayor
Filed in the Office of the Recorder
ATI'EST'
Mary Tennant, City Recorder
City of Woodburn, Oregon
Nancy A. Kirksey, Mayor
Page 3-
COUNCIL BILL NO. 1646
ORDINANCE NO.
10A
FINDINGS
Council Bill No. 1646
Exhibit "A", Page 1 of 11
Compliance with Goals, Policies and Elements of the Comprehensive Plan:
Sections 1 and 2 of Chapter Xlll of the Woodburn Comprehensive Plan require
that any change comply with goals, policies and various elements of the
comprehensive plan that are applicable to the quasi-judicial application. This
criteria encompasses Sections 1 and 2 of Article Xiii and because of the
similarities in issues, will be dealt with under one heading.
113dustrial Land Use Policies - Comprehensive Plan Article IX, Section C
relates to industrial land use policies in the City. Several of these
policies are directly applicable to this application. Policy C-1 provides
that the City will maintain a sufficiently large enough industrial land base
to provide for industrial growth in the City to accommodate the
residential growth expected. Policy C-2 provides that industrial land
should be located near areas where there is easy access to major
transportation routes. Policy C-3 recognizes that industrial land needs
good flat areas that are free from flooding dangers.
As indicated in the inventory of available industrial land, the City is
essentially out of vacant available industrial lands. While there are a few
small sized isolated tracts scattered throughout the City, there is only a
single large tract remaining for which an industry the size of Woodburn
Fertilizer could consider. That parcel (Davidson Farms) is committed
historically to a campus type industrial park.
The addition of this industrial land is adjacent to existing industrial lands,
and (for the most part) is owned by Woodburn Fertilizer. While this
application does not involve a large land area (the total land mass of the
4 parcels which is being changed by this application is approximately 1
acre) it does allow Woodburn Fertilizer to grow and expand. See
Attachment I.
The growth can take place at their current location without the huge
expense of relocation, and without disturbing the composition and mix
of the area· The applicant's have existed in this area for generations
without significant impact on the area, and this application will allow
that situation to continue.
Woodburn Fertilizer is located adjacent to the railroad tracks, and at the
corner of Front and Hardcastle which provides transportation access.
Such access is imPortant for an industry that supplies and services local
1-A
2)
2-A
3)
IOA
Council Bill No. 1646
Exhibit "A", Page 2 of 11
well as easy access to the seed cleaner and warehouse are important to
this business and the customers it serves. Few if any other locations in
the city combine the rail and truck traffic accessibility that the current sit
provides.
A large section of Parcel No. 2 is steep leading down to the swale
located to the north of the parcel. This area can not be used for
industrial purposes because of the terrain and the flooding that occurs
in the swale. Therefore, even the industrial based land currently
designated for Woodburn Fertilizer is not all useable. By allowing this
application, expansion can take place on contiguous lands to replace the
industrial land that is lost to natural features.
Conclusion: The applicant's request complies with the Industrial Land
Goal and Policies relating to industrial lands.
Housinq Goals and P01icie8 - This section of the plan describes the need
for the City of Woodburn to provide enough inventory of land to meet
current and projected housing needs through the year 2008.
Fortunately, the comprehensive plan had the foresight to include an
abundance of residential lands in the plan inventory to accommodate
such minor and technical changes as are involved here.
At page 32 of the WCP, it is noted that~there exist 837 acres of
SURPLUS residential lands in this community. Such a surplus indicates
that there is enough land to meet all of the housing needs of the
community and still to have lands left over to convert to other uses that
have demonstrated need for that land. While the amount of land is
small, about 1 acre total, it is important land because of its unique
location adjacent to existing industry.
Conclusion; The Housing Policies would not be detrimentally affected
because the city has surplus residential lands.
Public Service Goals and Policies - This section of the comprehensive
plan generally sets forth the goal of the City of Woodburn to provide
adequate public services to develop lands in the City. Public services
include sewer, water and storm drainage. See specifically goals H-i and
Policies H-l, H-5 and H-6. These policies also provide that where
possible, development should carry the brunt of the cost of extension of
these services.
These policies are carried out by this application. The only improvement
that will be generated by this application is one three-sided storage
2
3-A
4-A
IOA
Council Bill No. 1646
Exhibit "A", Page 3 of 11
building. With this Iow impact change, there will be no impact
whatsoever on the sewer system, water system or storm drainage
system in the area. With this application, the city can enhance one of
its strongest industries with no impact on public services.
Conclusion: Public services are available at the site.
Transoortation Goals and Policies - This section of the comprehensive
plan deals with the transportation needs and desires of the City of
Woodburn. Since this application does not involve any new activity or
business, there will be no impact on the transportation system of the
community.
No new traffic will be generated as a result of this approval. The mix of
traffic will also remain the same.
Hardcastle is an arterial connecting the downtown area with both the
east and west portions of the city. In addition, Front Street provides
north to south access for this area. Finally, the railroad parallels Front
Street providing additional transportation facilities for industrial users.
There is a good transportation system in place serving the area. This
application will not increase traffic, therefore approval will not adversely
impact transportation.
Conclusion: There will be no additional impact on the transportation
system. The expanded land area will be used for parking.
Zoning Ordinance
In this determination,the community as a whole must be looked
at to see if there is a "public need". Within the UGB, two
questions must be answered. The first is "What is the current
inventory of industrial lands in the City?" A parcel by parcel
analysis must be done to determine how much vacant industrial
land is available in the City; what sizes the parcels are; and where
they are located. This data must then be compared against
current market trends which establish demand for existing
industrial land, and the need for more industrial land into the
future through the planning period.
The industrial lands inventory for the City of Woodburn shows
very few acres of available industrial land remain. With
approximately 6 years left for growth within the planning period,
3
IOA.
Council Bill No. 1646
Exhibit "A", Page 4 of 11
approximately 6 years left for growth within the planning period,
the current industrial land base is clearly not sufficient to meet
demand. Industrial land has been consumed in this City much
faster than what was originally anticipated. Just in the past few
years, well over 100 acres of industrial land has been purchased
and developed or committed to development through the site.
planning process.
The applicant has done a detailed study of all lands inside the
Woodburn UGB to determine the extent of lands currently
available to meet the high demand for industrial lands. This study
shows that there are only 22 parcels remaining inside the entire
UGB, that carry the industrial land classification. The
characteristics of these 22 parcels are described in the Industrial
Lands Inventory data sheet of the staff report.~
This study included all lands designated as "industrial" in the
Woodburn Comprehensive Plan. Many of the parcels are not
available to meet the current or future needs of the city for one
reason or another. However, all WCP industrially designated
parcels were included to show the best picture possible of
available lands in the city.
Of the 22 parcels at least one is known to be undevelopable
because of terrain and flooding. This is Inventory Parcel I, which
is the swale owned by this applicant. Two other parcels have
severe developmental limitations, and may either by undevelopable
or too costly to develop. These are Inventory Parcels 6 (water
problems) and 14 (access problems). These three total 17.25
acres and thereby reduce the 203.48 remaining inventory of
industrial land to 186.23 acres.
From this total must be subtracted inventoried lands that are
already committed to industrial growth by way of expansion of
existing operations onto adjacent lands owned by that same
business. Three of the parcels fit this category. Inventory Parcels
7, 8 and 10 are committed to expansion, and comprise a total of
12.92 acres. This further reduces the available inventory of
industrial lands to 173.31.
Seven of the inventory parcels are presently not properly zoned to
The detailed study is incorporated in the staff report and consists of 21 pages of narrative and 34 pages
of maps, pictures and cherts.
5-A
10A
'Council Bill No. 1646
Exhibit "A", Page 5 of 11
ever be available to meet the industrial demand. Parcel 19 is
zoned for Interchange District (ID) use. This parcel, because of its
location in the southwest quadrant of the freeway interchange, is
best suited to a commercial use associated with the freeway, and
probably should not have been designated industrial, the other
four and portion of another are zoned for Urban Transition Farm
(UTF) and are located outside the city limits. These parcels may
at some time become available, but several things must happen
first.
The UTF parcels will require a zone change, site plan approval and
annexation. These may or may not be approved depending upon
the proposal and its impacts. It is sufficient to identify that none
of these parcels are currently available to meet the existing
demand and need for industrial land of this city.
The three parcels that are generally accepted to not be industrial
lands (Inventory Parcels 3, 4a and 19) comprise 14.66 total acres.
Taking this total from the remaining acreage leaves only 158.65
acres of industrial land in the city. IF we then take away the total
UTF acreage of 33.24 that is not currently available that leaves
only 125.41 acres of industrial land.
To get even a better picture of the true nature of industrial land
availability in the city, one must factor in Inventory Parcel 20
(Davidson Farms) which is 68.38 acres. However, this parcel is
to be sold in large tracks.
If the entire acreage of Inventory Parcel 20 is removed, there
remains only 57.03 acres left. If only the area that will be
occupied by the transportation facility is removed, the remaining
inventory of industrial land is still only 113.41 acres of land.
The 113.41 acres of industrial land left, from an initial inventory
of 55.6.71, leaves only 20%. Industrial land has exceeded its
need projections to the extent that 80% of the projected lands
were used in only 35% of the allotted time.
Conclusion: The city's land use inventory for Industrial lands is in
deficit.
B. This Land Best Suites the Public Need:
Land' proposed to be added to the inventory must be
5
5-B
10A
Council Bill No. 1646
Exhibit "A", Page 6 of 11
considered the land best suited to meet the public need
found in the above-referenced criteria. This is probably the
easiest of all the criteria in this application to meet. Since
the purpose of this application is to provide expansion area
for existing business only those properties that are adjacent
to the existing industry are even possible to use or
consider.
In the case of Parcel 2, it will be used for equipment
storage in association with an existing load out facility on
the industrially zoned portion of the parcel. On Parcels 3
and 4 the use is for parking, storage and access roadway.
These uses are by necessity site-specific, and must occur
on certain lands that are adjacent to existing operations.
It is fairly obvious that it is impossible to use a site across
town to provide access across existing property on this side
of town. It is equally impossible to use a site even several
blocks away for parking. Finally, pure common sense says
that all storage and load out areas associated with a
particular part of business must be located together and not
on two different sites blocks, or even miles away.
For these reasons, and not to mention the fact that 3 of the
4 subject properties are already owned by the adjacent
existing industry, the subject parcels are the best suited to
at least partially fill the public need for more industrial land
in the City of Woodburn.
Conclusion: The land lies adjacent to existing industrial property
and is a logical extension of an existing use.
C. The Land Cannot Be Suitably Used As Is:
The last criteria that must be addressed in any change to
the Comprehensive Plan is a determination that the land
being converted cannot be reasonably or suitably used as
it is presently designated.
While it is clear that the parcels involved here could have
houses built or kept on them, the key element to this
consideration is the "suitability" standard. In other words
it is not enough that a house could be placed on the
property. After all with today's engineering, and
6
5-C
IOA
Council Bill No. 1646
Exhibit "A", Page 7 of 11
technology, houses can be built almost anywhere. The real
standard is whether or not the land, given the
characteristics of the area, is suitable to place a house.
As to the three Woodburn Fertilizer properties, they are so
integrated into the business operation at this time that
placing houses on that land makes no sense, either
economical sense or practical sense. For example, Parcel
2, is split zoned with an existing industrial use ongoing.
That parcel is not suitable for anything except expansion of
the existing industrial use. The majority of Parcel 3 and
almost all of Parcel 4 consist of existing access road to
allow ease of movement of Woodburn Fertilizer cars, trucks
and customers between Mill Street and Hardcastle as well
as in and around their own facilities.
Parcel I is enclave, and for that reason alone should not be
considered suitable for anything other than industrial use.
All four of the parcels involved here are not SUITABLE for
residential use, but are ideal for industrial use. This criteria
is satisfied by this application.
Conclusion: The parcels are already utilized as parking and
storage areas the zone and comprehensive plan amendment bring
this land into compliance with the existing use.
D. Compliance With Zone Code Criteria:
In addition to the approval criteria stated in the
comprehensive plan, §16.080(a) of the Woodburn Zone
Code requires either a finding that he original plan was in
error, or that the community has changed since the original
plan was adopted.
The Woodburn community has changed significantly since
the UGB was originally drawn in the early 1980's. In the
last 14 years, the growth Woodburn has experienced is far
greater than either the 1981 or 1989 projections. This
rapid growth has outstripped the City's ability to provide
industrial areas to meet current need, let alone through the
planning period in year 2008.
7
IOA
Council Bill No. 1646
Exhibit "A", Page 8 of 11
5-D
Conclusion: This application satisfies all of the requirements of
the Woodburn Zone Code.
6. Statewide Goals and Guidelines
This application satisfies and complies with all Statewide Goals and
Guidelines. The following discussion addresses each applicable goal
individually.
Goal I - Citizen Involvement - This goal seeks to ensure that the public
will be involved in all aspects of land use planning in the city. Two
public hearings and an extended open record and notice period are
provided in this case. Goal I is satisfied.
Goal 2 - Planning - This is the goal that sets up the planning process, and
is used currently and primarily as the "exceptions" mechanism when a
local jurisdiction wishes to avoid compliance with any of the Statewide
Goals and Guidelines. No exception is involved in this case, and the
Goal is not applicable.
Goal 3 - Farm Land - The subject properties are not farm land. The land
is inside the UGB and the city limits and is committed to non resource
development. The Goal is not applicable.
Goal 4 - Forest Lands - The subject properties are not forest land. The
land is inside the UGB and the city limits and is committed to non
resource development. This Goal is not applicable.
Goal 5 - Open spaces, scenic and historic areas and natural resources -
The subject properties are not identified as being in the inventory of open
space, scenic, historic or natural resource areas of the City therefore this
Goal is not applicable, As previously mentioned however, a large part
of the northern section of Parcel 2 slopes down into a swale and is
undevelopable, This land will remain in open spaces and in its natural
state and condition, With this area preserved, and the lack of inclusion
in any city resource inventory, the subject properties and the change
being requested here comply with this Goal,
Goal 6 - Air, water and land resources oualitv - Goal 6 strives to maintain
and improve the quality of the air, water and land resources in the State
of Oregon. This proposed project does not disturb or crate problems
with the environmental quality of the state.
8
,10A Council Bill No. 1646
Exhibit "A", Page 9 of 11
This application has no real impact on the air, water and land resources.
There is no air pollution generated by this use. The only improvement
being built as a result of this application is a storage building that will not
cause any environmental problems at all. In fact the only impact at all
will be on storm water, and the building will be constructed to
adequately control and discharge that run-off. The Goal is complied
with.
Goal 7 - Areas sub!ect to netural disasters and h~z~rd~ - Goal 7 seeks to
protect life and property from natural disasters and hazards. There are
no identified natural disasters or hazards on the subject property. The
subject property is not located in an identified landslide or earthquake
zone. None of the property is located within an identified flood plain.
This Goal is complied with.
Goal 8 - Recreational needs - This goal was created to insure that the
recreational needs of the people were taken care of in the siting of
necessary recreational facilities. This project does not involve the siting
of any recreational facilities, nor does it involve the removal of any land
that could be used for recreational purposes. This Goal is complied with.
Goal 9 - Economy of the state - Goal 9 strives to diversify and improve
the economy of the state. This proposal does diversify and improve the
economy of northern Marion County by allowing the needed expansion
of a vital industrial in the community. Without expansion, the business
would not be able to serve the continued and growing needs of its
customers. Service is a big part of the competition in the seed and
fertilizer business. Being able to grow with market demands is critical
in business survival. This Goal is complied with.
Goal 10 - Housing - The housing goal is meant to provide for the housing
needs of the citizens of the state of Oregon. This project does not
involve the removal of any existing housing. As discussed above the
vacant lands are not reasonably suited to residential use in the first
place. Woodburn continues to maintain a large surplus of residential
lands, both Iow and high density. This surplus allows minor adjustments
in the WCP to move residential lands into needed industrial lands on a
case by case basis without adversely affecting the housing inventory in
the city. This Goal is complied with.
Goal 11 - Public facilities and services - This goal is meant to provide a
plan for the development of property in a timely, orderly and efficient
arrangement of public facilities and services. The applicant's proposal
complies with this goal because no public facilities or services will be
9
6-A
, 10A
Council Bill No. 1646
Exhibit "A", Page 10 of 11
necessary, nor will any additional pressure for public facilities be created
by this project.
Woodburn Fertilizer, Inc. has already contributed significantly to the
placement of infrastructure and streets in this area. Within the last year,
the applicant built at its own considerable expense, a complete overhaul
of Railroad Avenue including somewhere near 1,500 feet of new
pavement and sidewalks on one full side of the new street. This
improvement cost in excess of $300,000.00 This Goal is complied with.
Goal 12 - Transoortation - This goal is meant to provide and encourage
the safe, convenient and economical transportation within the state of
Oregon. This project meets and complies with this goal, as no new
traffic will be generated by this proposal.
Goal 13 - Energy Conservation - The purpose of this goal is to conserve
energy in the state of Oregon. This proposal does not involve the
expenditure of any energy resources whatsoever and, therefore,
complies with the goal.
The applicant's proposal does not require significant construction or use
of energy other than gasoline for vehicles to come and go, which
undoubtedly would be expended in any event since no new traffic will
be generated because of this application. The subject property is not
located on any sources of geothermal or other energy resources so that
the utilization of the property for industrial purposes would not deprive
the citizens of the state of Oregon of any energy resources.
Because the project does not expend a significant amount of energy, nor
does it deprive the people of a significant resource, it, therefore,
complies with goal 13.
Goal 14 - Urbanization - This Goal is meant to provide for an orderly and
efficient transition from rural to urban land uses. This Goal is not
applicable here, as we do not have a conversion of rural land to urban
type uses. The parcels involved here are already committed and being
put to urban uses. This Goal is complied with.
Conclusion: The applicant's request meets all relevant statewide goals.
SG:bw
10
Bill No. 1646
HARDCASTLE
8 S 80~E'Y DLC 47
24-OO
lOB
MEMO
TO:
FROM:
SUBJECT:
City Council through the City Administrator
Scott Burlingham, Chairman, Wastewater Advisor~Committee~_~'~
Frank Tiwari, Public Works Director . I
Final Draft Approval of Wastewater Facilities-Plan
DATE: July 6, 1995
RECOMMENDATION: Ratify the attached resolution that officially approves the draft
Facilities Plan for Wastewater and directs staff to forward it to the Department of
Environmental Quality (DEQ).
BACKGROUND: The facilities planning process started a number of years ago, but the
process speeded up after the appointment of the Wastewater Advisory Committee in July
of 1993.
The Advisory Committee held approximately twenty-five meetings with planners, engineers,
business people, industrial customers, and general public. Workshops and open houses were
held to keep the public and the governing body informed. The Advisory Committee has
recommended that the city council approve the recommended final draft of the facilities plan
and forward it to the Department of Environmental Quality (DEQ).
It should be noted that the ordinance setting rate structure will be brought to the council at
a later date after attached resolution has been approved. The rate modification document
will contain minimum plus volume charges.for residential customers instead of the flat rate
currently being used.
It has been an extensive, exhaustive process to reach the stage when a recommendation for
approval of the draft facilities plan could be made to the governing body without hesitation.
Resolution approval is recommended.
GST:Ig
F [NALT,&,/. CC
, lOB
COUNCIL BILL NO. 1647
RESOLUTION NO.
A RESOLUTION APPROVING THE FINAL DRAFT OF WASTEWATER FACILITIES PLAN
AND DIRECTING STAFF TO FORWARD IT TO THE DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL
QUALITY.
WHEREAS, the City of Woodburn must comply with the stipulated final order of
the Department of Environmental Quality, upgrade and replace components of the
treatment plant nearing its design life, and plan for expansion to accommodate projected
growth, and
WHEREAS, in the interest of public involvement, the city governing body
appointed a Wastewater Advisory Committee to analyze the complexities and
recommend the most suitable treatment alternative supported by a fair rate structure
acceptable to the community, and
WHEREAS, the Wastewater Advisory Committee held approximately twenty-five
meetings with planners, engineers, regulatory groups, Woodburn residents, business and
industrial representatives, and other interested parties and all these meetings were open
to the public, and
WHEREAS, the Wastewater Advisory Committee appointed a volunteer
information person who kept the public informed of the calendar of events and the
decisions of the committee, and
WHEREAS, the Wastewater Advisory Committee held two open houses, one to
receive public input on the preferred treatment alternative and the second to receive
input on rate structure for funding the improvements, and
WHEREAS, residents were provided with the opportunity to interact with the
members of the Advisory Committee, engineers and economist from Oregon's largest
environmental consulting firm and well qualified technical city staff in the meetings,
workshops and especially in the open houses.
WHEREAS, the City Council attended workshops related to the projected growth,
the treatment alternatives, and the funding needed to support the plan, and
WHEREAS, in the regular meeting of June 18, 1995 the City Council held the
final official public hearing to receive public input on the entire facilities plan, a copy of
which had been provided to the members of the city council and another copy has been,
and is presently, kept in the Public Works office for public review, and
WHEREAS, on the basis of the Wastewater Advisory Committee
recommendation, input from the public, information from the consultants and regUlatory
agencies and on the evaluation made by individual members of the council, the City
Council finds the final draft of the facilities plan acceptable, NOW, THEREFORE,
Page I - COUNCIL BILL NO.
RESOLUTION NO.
~JAL6OVT
10B
THE CITY OF WOODBURN RESOLVES AS FOLLOWS:
Section 1. The City Council hereby approves the final draft of the Wastewater
Facilities Plan as recommended by the Wastewater Advisory Committee. The facilities
plan in its entirety includes Volume I (Treatment), Volume II (Collection System), and
Volume III (Rates and System Development Charges).
· . Section 2. That the City Council intends to implement the rates that will produce
the needed amount of revenue projected in Volume III of the facilities plan, and the
implementation of these rates through the regular billing cycle for residential, commercial
and industrial customers is intended to start in November, 1995.
Section 3. Public Works staff is hereby directed to bring to the city council an
ordinance for the implementation of rate modification as recommended by the
Wastewater Advisory Committee that uses the fair share philosophy without subsidies
between residential, commercial and industrial users and includes the minimum plus
volume charge for the residential users.
Section 4. Public Works staff is hereby directed to officially forward the final
draft copies of the council approved facilities plan to the Department of Environmental
Quality.
City Attorney
Date
Passed by the Council
Submitted to the Mayor
Approved by the Mayor
Filed in the Office of the Recorder
APPROVED:
Nancy Kirksey, Mayor
ATTEST:
Mary Tennant, City Recorder
City of Woodburn, OregOn
Page 2 - COUNCIL BILL NO.
RESOLUTION NO.
~UAL~0V"r
10C
TO:
FROM:
SUBJ.:
DATE:
.MEMO
Mayor and City Council
Chris Childs, City Administrator ~.~/
Facility Use Aqreement - Salem Senior Center
July 6, 1995
RECOMMENDATION: Approve accompanying Council Bill (Resolution) entering into
agreement for use by RSVP program of office space located in the Salem Senior
Center.
BACKGROUNI~; For a number of years a small office in the Salem Senior Center
has been provided to the Marion County RSVP program, which is administered by the
City of Woodburn, for use as a satellite center. From this office, volunteer jobsites
and placements in the Salem area can be monitored and supported, and program
materials stored.
This agreement will be in force for one year, expiring June 30, 1996. You may
recall a similar agreement which the Council approved in May, 1995 that
"retroactively" served the same purpose for Fiscal Year 1994-95.
Staff recommends approval of this Resolution/Agreement.
10C
COUNCIL BILL NO. 1648
RESOLUTION NO.
A RESOLUTION ENTERING INTO AN AGREEMENT WITH THE CITY OF SALEM FOR
USE OF THE SALEM SENIOR CENTER BY THE RETIRED SENIOR VOLUNTEER
PROGRAM.
WHEREAS, the city of Salem operates the Salem Senior Center; and
WHEREAS, the city of Woodburn administers the Retired Senior Volunteer
Program (RSVP) through the Federal Action Program; and
WHEREAS, the city of Salem has agreed to use of the Salem Senior Center for
RSVP activities, pursuant to the terms of a written agreement; NOW, THEREFORE,
THE CITY OF WOODBURN RESOLVES AS FOLLOWS:
Section 1. That the city of Woodburn enter into an agreement with the city of
Salem for the use of the Salem Senior Center for RSVP program activities, a copy of
said agreement which is attached hereto and, by this reference, incorporated herein.
Section 2. That the Mayor and RSVP Director are authorized to sign said
agreement on behalf of the city of Woodburn.
APPROVED:
Passed by the Council
Submitted to the Mayor
Approved by the Mayor
Filed in the Office of the Recorder
ATTEST:
Mary Tennant, City Recorder
City of Woodburn, Oregon
NANCY A. KIRKSEY, MAYOR
Page I -
COUNCIL BILL NO. 1648
RESOLUTION NO.
SALEM SENIOR CENTER USE AGREEMENT 10C
This Agreement is made between the City of Salem, an Oregon Municipal
Corporation (CITY) and the Retired and Senior Volunteer Program (RSVP), (User)
administered through the Federal Action Program and whose subsidiary agent is the
City of Woodburn.
Be it known that the USER is a branch of the US Action Program. As such, its
mission is to provide meaningful participation in their communities to the retired
population through outreach to the community by placing seniors in nonprofit, nursing,
governmental facilities, or other community agencies as volunteers. Volunteer
opportunities for seniors in Salem, Oregon, include but are not limited to: The State
Capitol, Marion County and City of Salem offices, Salem Hospital, Life Une, Arts
Commission, Migrant Workers Project, Golden Clowns, Knitters Circle, Boys & Girls
Club, Salem/Keizer Schools, nursing and care homes, Literacy Council, Mano a
Mano, Salem Outreach Shelter, Women's Crisis Services.
IN CONSIDERATION of the mutual obligations and benefits herein set forth,
the parties agree as follows:
1. CITY OBLIGATIONS
1.1
CITY shall provide Room 24 in its Salem Senior Center for the USER and
space for activities up to 20 hours. When Room 24 is not in use by
RSVP, the Senior Center may schedule it for other uses, e. g., tax and
personal counseling. USER is entitled to use the Classroom or
Auditorium when space is requested by RSVP and can be
accommodated in the Senior Center's Facility Use Schedule. USER may
use the photocopy machine.
1.2
CITY shall allow the use of facilities and equipment at the Salem Senior
Center for the uses specified in Section 1.1. Such use is subject to all
generally applicable policies and procedures that the CITY may adopt
and amend from time to time.
1.3
CITY shall provide building supervision during the hours of USER use of
the Salem Senior facility. 'Building supervision" means opening and
closing the building, turning on and off lighting and HVAC systems, and
providing access to special equipment approved for USER's use. CITY's
staff shall have no obligation to supervise the conduct of the RSVP
Coordinator or volunteer participants in the program. Such staff may
take any actions they deem appropriate to prevent misuse of or damage
to the City's property. They may also act to stop conduct that violates
any law, ordinance, or established Salem Senior Center use and conduct
policies.
1.4
1.5,
1.6
1.7
1.8
1.9
1.10
CITY shall schedule the Salem Senior Center and coordinate programs
and uses at the facility. CITY's staff shall perform this obligation using
their sole discretion within the framework of the annually approved
Facility Use Schedule. CITY's goal is to assure access to and use of the
Salem Senior Center by the broadest possible range of groups, activities,
and interests to serve Salem's senior community. No single group or
organization shall be given any preferred or preemptive status in
scheduling use of the Salem Senior Center facilities, equipment and
space.
CITY shall assure USER timely, periodic opportunity for communicating
complaints, requests, suggestions, and comments relating to the Salem
Senior Center and its operation.
CITY shall provide at no cost, limited access to a telephone for local and
toll-free calls by USER's staff for purposes related to USER's programs
and activities under this Agreement. CITY is not obligated to provide toll
call access.
A CITY staff person shall serve as a liaison to USER to assist in
coordinating and facilitating USER's use of the Center and minimize
conflict with other Center users.
CITY shall provide USER timely information about Senior Center policies
and operations that affect USER's activities at the Salem Senior Center.
CITY shall publicize USER activities where appropriate in the sole
discretion of CITY's Senior Center Director.
CITY may provide co-sponsorship, partial funding, or both for certain
special activities at the Salem Senior Center as may be separately agreed
upon between the parties. Availability of City funds depends on budget
authorization. Planning for such events must start enough before the
CITY's budget review process to allow their consideration.
lOC
USER OBLIGATIONS
2.1
All USER activities shall be open to all persons age 55 and older
regardless of the person's race, gender, ethnic background, national
origin, or disability.
2.2
USER shall be solely responsible for recruiting and, if necessary,
providing mileage compensation for persons to carry out all of its
activities.
2.3
USER, its officers, directors, staff, and volunteers will cooperate fully with
the CITY officers and staff of the Salem Senior Center. USER will follow
all rules, regulations, and policies established for the Salem Senior
Center. USER will assure that its representatives and patrons follow
such policies in activities, programs, and meetings conducted or
sponsored by USER.
2.4 10C
2.5
2.6
2.7
USER shall be solely responsible for obtaining all required licenses,
permits, and registrations necessary for the lawful conduct of its affairs,
programs, events, and activities.
Should USER require special equipment or fixtures that would also
benefit and be shared by CITY, the parties shall, by separate agreement,
provide for acquisition, reimbursement, and ownership of such.
USER will provide information regarding USER for publication in Salem
Senior Center Update newsletter as space is available.
USER agrees to co-sponsor the annual Volunteer Recognition with a
contribution of $400 annually.
INSURANCE AND INDEMNITY
3.1
USER provides for supplemental car insurance for those RSVP members
who maintain their own insurance and are in the process of using a
personal car in the delivery of USER duty.
3.2
USER agrees to indemnify the City of Salem, its officers, employees, and
agents from all claims, demands, suits and legal actions including
appeals arising out of or in connection with User's activities under this
Agreement.
3.3
"Indemnify," as used herein, means to indemnify, defend, and save
harmless.
Q
MISCELLANEOUS
4.1
This Agreement represents the complete understanding of the parties
concerning the subject matter hereof. All prior agreement,
representations, and negotiations, written and oral, relating to the subject
matter of this' Agreement are hereby repudiated and set aside.
4.2
This Agreement may be amended only by written instrument executed
with the same formalities as the Agreement itself.
4.3
In the event any term of this Agreement shall be held invalid or
unenforceable, the parties declare that any such holding would not affect
their willingness to enter into all other terms hereof, and such holding
shall not affect the validity and enforceability of the remainder of this
Agreement.
4.4
Failure of either party to object to an event of default, breach, or
inadequate performance by the other shall not constitute a waiver of the
offended party's dght to object to future events, whether of the same or
different nature. No provision of this Agreement shall be held waived or
modified by a party's past failure to assert its rights to full and faithful
performance.
4.5
4.6
This Agreement shall take effect as of July 1, 1995 through June 30,
1996 unless sooner terminated as provided in Section 4.6.
Notwithstanding Section 4.5, either party may terminate this Agreement:
4.6.1
In the event of a continuing material breach by the other, provided
that the offended party has given the other not less than 30 days
written notice to cure the breach and the other party does not
effectively cure the breach within that time. The remedy of
termination as provided herein shall be in addition to and not in
lieu of any other remedy available at law or equity.
4.6.2 Without cause by giving not less than 30 days prior written notice.
10C
IN WITNESS WHEREOF the parties have caused this Agreement to be signed
in their respective names by their duly authorized representatives as of the dates set
forth below.
CITY OF SALEM, OREGON
RETIRED AND SENIOR
VOLUNTEER PROGRAM
By: By:,
City of Salem, City Manager
Date:, Date:
City of Woodburn, Mayor
Approved as to form:
City Attorney
RSVP Coordinator
Marion County RSVP
Date:
IOD
TO:
MEMO
Mayor and City Council
FROM: Chris Childs, City Administrator ~
SUBJ.: Insurance Coveraqe Recommendations
July 5, 1995
DATE:
I have reviewed the accompanying recommendations made by our City Recorder
and insurance Agent of Record concerning the various areas of insurance coverage for
Fiscal Year 1995-96, As a matter of reasonableness and good business, I concur with
their recommendation,
As in past years, however, I am declaring that I have a potential conflict of
interest regarding this issue, in that my wife is an employee of City County Insurance
Services, one of the vendors that is being considered for our insurance needs.
IOD
MEHO TO:
THROUGH
FROM
DATE
SUBJECT
MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL
CITY ADMINISTIUkTOR CHILDS
CITY RECORDER TENNANT ~'~-
July 3v 1995
INSURANCE COVERAGES FOR FISCAL YEAR 1995-96
RECOMMENDATION: Council authorize, by motion, a change in the
property insurance carrier from Chubb Insurance to Zurich Insurance
effective July 1, 1995.
BACKGROUND: Insurance quotes were solicited by our Insurance Agent
of Record, 'Chuck Huggins (Huggins Insurance), and the results of
those quotes are briefly summarized below.
Property Insurance --- Three companies submitted quotations for
property insurance only. Each company had similar deductibles for
property loss, however, earthquake coverage varied with each
company along with the deductible amount each company required. As
you will recall, the City received FEMAgrant funds for repairs and
reconstruction projects resulting from the 1993 earthquake
(approximately $500,000). Under the FEMA program, the City is
required to carry earthquake insurance on property which received
FEMAmonies. Quotes from the insurance companies included coverage
limits from $1.5 million to $5 million, however, the deductibles
ranged from 5% of building loss and/or contents loss to $1.25
million.
Over the last two years, the City has secured their property
insurance through Chubb Insurance. Again this year, Chubb
Insurance submitted the lowestquote ($22,212), however, they would
only provide $1.5 million in earthquake coverage with a $175,000
deductible. Considering the value of the new aquatic center alone,
Chuck Huggins and I felt that the $1.5 million limit was too low
and either a separate earthquake insurance policy should be
purchased (approximately $10,000) or another quote from one of the
other two companies be accepted.
The CIS property coverage ($30,563) provided $5 million in
earthquake coverage, however, the deductible was 5% of botal
property (approximately $1.25 million) rather than 5% of building
and/or content loss. This deductible is excessively high and we
are not in any such financial position to absorb that much of a
deductible if a major earthquake occurred. We also felt that the
CIS deductible should be similar to what is quoted by other
carriers i.e. a flat deductible amount or a percentage of actual
loss. Mr. Huggins will be discussing the deductible issuewith
other agents who do business with CIS to see if they can get CIS to
change their calculations in determining the deductible amount. It
, , IOD
Page 2 - Insurance Memo
July 3, 1995
should be noted that the City currently has an $8,145 credit with
CIS for prior years net income distribution. We can hold this
credit for one more year, therefore, it is hoped that the property
coverage limits and premium quotes for next year are such that we
can take advantage of the credit in fiscal year 1996-97.
Lastly, Zurich provided us with a quote of $29,689 which includes
$3.5 million earthquake coverage with a 5% deductible of building
value and/or 5% contents value. This coverage seems to offer us
the best protection att his time with a minimal deductible program.
For example, under this program, a $500,000 loss would result in a
$25,000 deductible which is far less than the $175,000 deductible
of Chubb Insurance or the $1.25 million of CIS Insurance.
Based on his review ofthese insurance coverages, Chuck Huggins is
also recommending that the City change insurance carriers from
Chubb Insurance to Zurich.
General Liability/Auto Liability/Auto Ph2sicaX Damage---
Proposals for this specific insurance coverage were received from
CIS Insurance ($82,122) and Northland ($88,840). We have advised
CIS that we will continue our coverage with them for fiscal year
1995-96. No action is necessary on the part of the Council to
authorize the continuation 'of this coverage.
Workers' Compensation Insuranae ---
We have secured our Workers' Compensation coverage through CIS for
many years and our rates have remained fairly stable even though
payroll costs have increased. In fiscal year 1994-95, our
experience modification factor was 102% while in 1995-96 we will be
seeing a decrease to 98%.
' ' IOE
TO:
FROM:
SUB. CT:
DATE:
City Council through City Administrator f~ A (~ ,
Frank Tiwari, P.E., Public Works Director
Contract award for City Library Parking Lot/Street Improvements Project
July 6, 1995
REcoMMENDATION:
That Woodbum City Council award the contract to low bidder, Bob's Backhoe, in the amount of
$38,301.24 for the construction of the city library parking lot and street improvements.
NOTE: $27,700 is specifically budgeted for this project in the General Fund Non-Department
are~ Because of certain basic street improvement aspects of this project, $7,915 will be paid
from Public Works Street Improvement budget. The balance, approx. $2687, will be paid
from the Library Endowment Fund.
BACKGROUND:
The Engineering Division properly advertised and received four legal bids for the above named
project. The bids were publicly opened and read at city hall on Thursday, June 29, 1995 at 11:O0 am.
The bid results are as follows, including the engineer's estimate:
Engineer's Estimate:
Bob's Backhoe:
North Santiam Paving:
Morse Bros. Co.:
Kerr Contractors:
$30,882.50
$55,065.69
$57,964.25
$59,367.O0
$67,655.O0
We are expedenc~g high bid prices for concrete work this season, which is the moin reason for the
difference in the bid price and the engineer's estimate.
The lowest bid of $55,065.69 was received from Bob's Backhoe and is not within ten (10) percent
of the engineers estimate, therefore, we recommend the elimination of the new sidewalks located
on the east side .of the parking lot behind the stirrup factory. All other sidewalks are planned to be
constructed as designed. The other item_~ red concrete paving bricks, decorative tree grate, tree
removal and removaYreinstallation of existing sign has been renegotiated and modified. With these
deletions and modifications, contract approval is recommended for the amount of $38,301.24.
c:~lmmcyroje~ts~95001028~o*mawrd.~pd
1OF
M EM.O
TO:
FROM:
SUBJECT:
City Council through City Administrator
Publie Works Program Manager~~'//~'~'-'-'~-
Tentative Agreement regarding Rugged Manufacturing Property at 192
Young Street
DATE: July 6, 1995
RECOMMENDATION:
Approve by motion the terms, as outlined in this memo, of a tentative agreement for
the removal and replacement of asphalt as part of removal of an underground storage
tank and sharing of costs for a boundary survey associated with the Rugged
Manufacturing property at 192 Young Street.
BACKGROUND:
Two items involving the city concerning the Rugged Manufacturing property require
council concurrence.
The first involves a underground gasoline tank in city right of way in front of the
Rugged Manufacturing property, This tank was decommissioned in the 1960's. it is
my understanding that it must be removed as part of the proposed sale of this
property. The tank is in city right of way and it is in the best interest of the city that
it be removed, The Rugged Manufacturing property owners will remove the tank and
conduct all required testing, The property owner would be responsible for any
cleanup that would be required. Since the tank is in city right of way and it is in the
city's interest to have it removed the removal and replacement of the asphalt over the
tank by city street department forces is an appropriate city share of the removal
project.
When the burned out Rugged Manufacturing building was removed a storage shed on
city property, directly to the south, lost one wall which it shared with the Rugged
Manufacturing building', Since it is unclear where the property line actually is between
the Rugged Manufacturing and city property, the boundary needs to be established
before decisions can be made on the disposition of the city building. It is estimated
that the cost of determining the boundary line will be $500.00. It is proposed that
the city share this cost equally with the Rugged Manufacturing property since the city
has an equal interest in an accurate delineation of the property line,
C:\Randy~Memos~Rugmanuf.pty'.bw
14A
MEMO
TO:
Mayor and
Administrator
City Council
through City
FROM:
Planning Commission
SUBJECT:
Subdivision 94-04, 6 Lots on "A" Street
DATE:
July 6, 1995
At their hearing of June 22, 1995 the Woodburn Planning
Commission approved, with conditions, Subdivision 94-04
located on the east side of "A" Street.
Attached is a brief description of that proposal with an area and
plat maps.
One of the most important aspects of this proposal is that "A"
Street will be improved from Payne to Bradley. Also Payne
Street will be improved up to the east property line of Lot #6.
The Council has two options:
1) You may call this proposal up for a public hearing
or
2) Choose not to review this subdivision
C:\steve~memos\subdiv94.04:bw
14A
STAFF REPORT
Subdivision #94-04
II
III
IV
APPLICANT:
J. McCaulley
1555 N. Jantzen Street
Portland, OR 97217
OWNER:
Callaham and Callaham a Washington Corporation
10804 NE Highway 99
Vancouver, WA 98686
NATURE OF THE APPLICATION:
The applicant is requesting preliminary approval of a 6 lot subdivision.
RELEVANT FACTS:
The proposed subdivision is located along A street, north of Bradley Street and south
of Payne Street, an unimproved dedicated right of way. The property can be
identified specifically on Marion County Assessors May as Tax Lot 4100 Township
5 South, Range I West, Section 18CA and TL 8400 Township 5 South, Range 1
West, Section 18BD.
The subject property is zoned RS, single family residential.
Properties surrounding the proposed subdivision are Zoned Residential Single Family.
The proposal includes 2 existing lots each containing one Single Family Residence.
The applicant indicated that the average lot size will be 7,461 sq. ft. to 8,108 sq. ft.
All lots with exception of the two existing dwellings will be served by private roads.
FINDINGS:
1. The applicant is requesting preliminary approval of a 6 lot subdivision.
2. The subject property is zoned appropriately for single family development.
3. The new lots' will access a private street.
4. The applicant has met the goals and policies of the Comprehensive Plan.
The applicant has submitted the necessary documents as required by the
Subdivision Ordinance for preliminary approval of a subdivision.
C:\steve\staffrpt\subdiv94.04
~r,~O0
!
!
!
14A
WOODBURN PUBLIC LIBRARY
280 GARFIELD STREET
WOODBURN, OREGON 97071-4698
503-982-525215263 OR FAX: 503-982-5258
15A
MEMORANDUM
TO:
FROM:
DATE:
RE:
MAYOR & CITY COUNCIL THROUGH
CHRIS CHILDS, CITY ADMINISTRATOR~
MNDA SPRAUER, LIBRARY DIRECTOR
July 6, 1995
DONATION FROM FRENCH PRAIRIE KIWANIS
On June 28, 1995, Ron Monnier and Don Eubanks presented a check for $1,000 to
Gloda Predeek, President of the Woodbum Public Library Board.
This money was collected from the community by the French Praide KJwanias following
the untimely death of Alan Hamilton as a college fund for his sons if necessary. When the time
ardved to close out the account, Mr. Hamilton's widow, Lynda, since he was a supporter of the
library, asked that the money be given to the library.
At the regular monthly meeting of the Woodburn Public Library Board, the members
voted to direct the money be spent on an item to benefit the community as a whole. They then
voted to apply this money be applied toward the purchase of a reader board to be placed so that
special library activities may be announced to the citizens. I hope to be able to have this
purchase in place by fall.
15B
MEMO
TO:
FROM:
SUBJ.:
DATE:
Mayor and City Council
Chris Childs, City Administrator
Revo¢e~;i0n of Business Reqistration
July 3, 1995
At the June 26, 199§ Council meeting, a question was posed regarding the
City's ability to revoke the Business "License" (Registration) of LaLinda's, located at
293 Front Street, as a result of closure of the establishment by the Oregon Liquor
Control Commission (OLCC).
Our Business Registration ordinance does contain a section which allows for
revocation, based on the City Administrator's determination that "... a business
activity ... is violating this ordinance, other City ordinances, or State or Federal law
...[emphasis added]".
In this instance, the OLCC issued an "immediate closure order" containing some
27 allegations of violation of OLCC rules. LaLinda's will be afforded due process and
appropriate opportunity for hearing before the OLCC. Only after that process is
completed, and a final determination of any wrongdoing made, would the City
Administrator be in a position to pursue revocation of the establishment's business
registration under the ordinance.
.... 15C
MEMO
TO:
FROM:
SUBJECT:
DATE:
City Council through City Administrator
~..~ ~--~
Public Works Program Manager ~/~¢-¢_.~---
City Hall HVAC Update
July 5, 1995
The replacement of heating, ventilation and air conditioning (HVAC) units for city hall
is now scheduled to begin on July 17, 1995. The delay was a result of a scheduling
backlog for the roofing company who is replacing the city hall roof. In order to get
the best quality replacement of both the HVAC units and the roof it was essential that
the HVAC replacement and roof replacement be coordinated.
There should be no interruptions of city hall services. There could be some minor
traffic disruptions and some temporary parking changes around city hall during the 7
to 10 days the work will take.
C:\Randy~Memos~HVACup.dte:b w
· · 15D
MEMO
TO:
FROM:
City Council through City Administrator
Public Works Program Manager
SUBJECT: Transportation Task Force Update
DATE: July 6, 1995
The last public open house on the Woodburn Transportation Plan was held on June
29, 1995. A newsletter outlining the plan was sent to all Woodburn residents prior
to this open house. The next Transportation Task Force meeting will be held on July
20, 1995 at noon in the Library meeting room.
The Council will also be provided with Technical Memorandum #5 of the
transportation plan work program at the July 10, 1995 council meeting. This
memorandum summarizes the results of an access management analysis for portions
of Highway 214 and Highway 99E. The memorandum also includes background
information on Oregon Highway Plan Access Management Policies and a review of
techniques and standards for implementing access management policies.
The next product of this project will be a draft Transportation System Plan for the
city. This will be the basis for a public hearing before the Planning Commission which
is currently planned for August, 1995. It is anticipated, at this time, that a public
hearing on the plan will be held by council in September, 1995. This draft
Transportation System Plan should be available near the end of July, 1995 and will
be given to council for their review when it is received.
C:~Randy~Memos~TTFUPDA.TE:b w
MEMO
TO:
FROM:
SUBJECT:
DATE:'
Community Development Director
Bob Arzoian, Building Inspector
Building Activity for JUNE, 1995
July 5, 1995
15E
New Resi~ Value
Multi Family
Res. Add Sc Alts
Industrial
Commercial Value
Signs, Fences, Drways
Mobile Homes
JUNE 1993 JUNE 1994
No. Dollar Amt No. Dollar Amt
I $120,000 8 $ 987,348
0 0 0 0
13 91,647 11 68,400
2 20,747 0 0
2 330,000 2 18,128
10 21,094 7 6,915
1 55,000 0 0
29 $638,488
28 $1,080,791
J-UN~ 1~)5
No. Dollar Amt
4 609,781
0 0
9 50,810
I 150,000
I 38,000
11 53,690
3 140,700
29 $1,042,981
July 1-June 30 Fiscal
Year-to-Date
~10~478~419
Robert Arzoian
Building Official
RS:bw
B LDACT 06. ~5