09-26-2011 Presentation: 99E Updatelighwa
r,
Highway
Highway 99E Corridor Plan Project Schedule
HIG HWAY 99E CORRIDOR PLAN OCTOBER— JANUARY—� APRIL— JULY— OCTOBER— JANUARY —
DECEMBER MARCH JUNE SEPTEMBER DECEMBER MARCH
PROCESS 2010 2011 2011 2011 2011 2012
Stakeholder and Agency Involvement
Project Vision / Goals / Guiding
Principles -72d
Existing Conditions Assessment / is
Opportunities & Constraints in the
Corridor
Draft Corridor Design Concepts You Are Here
Evaluation of Corridor Design
Concepts & Draft Implementation
Steps -
Prepare Corridor Plan,
Implementation Report
Prepare Ordinances and Corridor Plan
Adoption
otiot " WQODBUR
Incorporated 1889
Highwa 99E
�.
Corridor`Plan��
"Narrowing the Alternatives"
Extend Existing
Improvements
Minimize Impacts
Young Street Node
/ Main Street
Main Street
Neighborhood
Enhanced Corridor
Limited
Improvements
Mixed Use Village
� QODBUR,NJ
Incorporated 1 889
Highwa 99E
Corridor`Plan
The Highway 99E Corridor - 4 Segments
1. Industrial /rural
2. Commercial, larger
parcels, more recent
development
3. Commercial, smaller
parcels, older
development
4. Industrial/ rural /future
multi - family
a f CORRIDOR SEGMENTS
Y �g y ° �" "" 1.North Corridor
k
_ _�
W �
- - ,,,�✓
`
2.North Central Corridor
Corridor`Plane�
S
3. South Central Corridor
>
�..�.
"rracgT
4. South Corridor
his
1
;- ' . 7
_
/.�
E __r
.
/1z
r
—
---- - - --
r
I
f
LEGEND
r
r /
,soar
uroan cmwm Baum
�¢
6 `�
y
Ivrroa,ael
r Raikoaa
[j rirmary swnruea
City of Woodburn
Highway 99E C... Plan
Corridor Segments
W 4ODSURN
-,
�". Incorporated 1889
Highwa 99E
Corridor`Plane�
w
>
�..�.
"rracgT
m –�
his
Concept 1
wa
S
] f.
3
ra, I
r
LEGEND
5lanes, bike lane; curb -tight
sidewalks
5lanes sub- standard, bike
lanes, curb- tight sidewalks
3 lanes, wide shoulder,
cnrb - tight Sidewalks
e ■ no change to existing
zoning
Gateway feature
11 #�}II Corridor Segmefinte
nt
—END
Limited Improvements
1 0
Concept 2
z i t °
3
4
s
3
» I r -
LEGEND
5lanes, bike lanes, curb -tight
tid —alks
5lanes, bike lanes, buffered
sidewalks
r— 3 lanes, wide shoulders,
buffered sidewalks
Young Street Corridor to
Downtown
■ no change to existing
zoning
■ modify zoning to"Mixed Use
Village "Commercial
Gateway Feature
11 ®II Corridor5egment
te.—
Mixed Use Village
:r QODBUR,
__ Incorporated 1 889
1 0
Highwa 99E"..:
6
Corridor "Plano y�
4
' A '.V 2,d •. w
WOOdDSQ7�]�T
Common Elements
• No medians
• Young Street gateway
• Undergrounding utilities
• City access management standards
• Intersection improvements for pedestrian safety
Crossing improvements at signals
Curb bump -outs on side streets that have parking
• Mid -block pedestrian crossings
• Bike /pedestrian access connections from stub streets
-,
W QODBUR N
+� 1 Picorporated 1 889
Highwa 99E
Corridor`Plan
Concept I
Limited Improvements
-� ODBURN
Highway 9
, Corridor PI
e: ,
w , + � w , woeecrwEres
6 musnn,riw
«wwmrnue �' �
y
eE
wry
o
w�
" " avr
3
LEGEND
City Limits
tallp(g
Urb Gm ' M.d.q
(Pmpo
r} R.kb
�� Piimary S'adY Area
City of Woodburn
Highway 99E Corridor Pian
Limited Improvements
AUGUST2011
Aibs
o
0.5 n
u
dda
2 d '
d
d
d
. .................
g
LEGEND
3
1
5 lanes, bike lanes, curb -tight
sidewalks
5 lanes sub - standard, bike
lanes, curb -tight sidewalks
3 lanes, wide shoulder,
curb -tight sidewalks
'
d "
no change to existing
■
— -.�
zoning
i
Gateway feature
/
II (D II Corridor Segment
LEGEND
City Limits
tallp(g
Urb Gm ' M.d.q
(Pmpo
r} R.kb
�� Piimary S'adY Area
City of Woodburn
Highway 99E Corridor Pian
Limited Improvements
AUGUST2011
Aibs
o
0.5 n
Highwa 99E
N Corridor "Plan 4..
y .... . . . . . .
�, Incorporated 1889
Highway 99E ?'
Corridor "Plan`
71
1 ncor 1889 Fll �
- r4
W
QODBUR,�T
Incorporated A88q
Highwa 99E"..:
6
Corridor "Plan
4
' A '.V 2,d •� w
Example
Development
Parking in front
Landscape strip
W QODBURN
- lrrcor1, orateA f889
Highwa WE
,Corridor "Plan 4��� y�
Example
Development
Parking to the side
Landscaping in front
Iighway 99E'.
QODBUR,
Corridor " Plan 4
1 ncor�norated 1889 _ _ _ _ ��"
0
Example
Development
Parking to the side
Landscaping in front
w • - 0103
IT ........
'T
Highway 99LE
QODBUR
Qpr
,ridqiPlan
Example
Development
Landscaping
Parking in front
-� W ,
+� Incorporated 1 88q
Highwa 99E"..:
6
,Corridor Plan .�`
LAND USE
Concept 1: Limited Improvements
-� W
.QODBURN
4 4L
I n c o r p o r a t e d 188
Highway QQE
E l
C orridor n
Land Use &Urban Design Implementation
Modifications to Development Standards (Corridor -Wide)
• Apply City's access management guidelines
Minimizing access points
Shared access with adjacent sites
Connections to abutting parking lots
Taking access from abutting street with lowest functional class
• Require pedestrian walkways from sidewalk to primary building
entrance
• Require trees between areas used for parking and sidewalk
• Require bike /pedestrian accessways from adjacent stub streets
to Highway 99E upon redevelopment
W
ooDBUR,�J
...
1 ncor rated 1889
Highwa 99E
Corrido T1an
Land Use &Urban Design Implementation
Streetscape Enhancements and Public Investments
• Highway -style lighting
• I nsta I I gateway arch over Young Street
• Create Local Improvement District or other mechanism to fund
undergrounding of utilities
• Create a storefront improvement program
• Consider non - conforming sign amortization program
Highwa 99E
-
WQODBUR Corridor`Plan �
1 ncor 1889 = '�� _� NGOD] "UR
TRANSPORTATION
Concept 1: Limited Improvements
Highwa 99E ?'
. ° -_ 1 ,, o oD U Corridor "Plan Q4�
.�
�""'" Incorporated 1889
Segment 1: No Change
Existing ROWin
5' s„ 6' 12' 12' 14' 12' 12' 6' S" 5' Segment1 is
ewalkm Bike Travel Lane Travel Lane Two -Way Left Travel Lane Travel Lane Bike E2 Sidewalk approximately 90
Lane Turn Lane Lane
Paved Width = 74'
Tntal Width = AS'
Segment 2: No Change
Existing ROW in
5' s„ 6' 12' 12' 14' 12' 6" Segment2is
12' 6' 5' approximately 85'
malkm Bike Travel Lane Travel Lane Two -Way Left Travel Lane Travel Lane Bike m Sidewalk
Lane Turn Lane Lane
Paved Width = 74'
Total Width = 85'
Segment 3: 5 Lane, Sub - Standard Within Existing ROW (80 ft)
5' 6" 5' 12' 11' 13' 11' 12' 5' 6" 5'
Sidewalk' Bike Travel Lane Travel Lane Two -Way Left Travel Lane Travel Lane Bike SidewA
Lane Turn Lane Lane
Paved Width = 69'
Minimum Right -of -Way Width = 82'
Existing ROW in
Segment 3 is
approximately 80'
Segment 4: 3 Lane, Curb Tight Sidewalks
Existing ROW in
6' 6" 8' 12 4 14' 12' 8' 6„ 6' Segment 4 is
Sidewalk'' Shoulder Travel Lane Two Left Travel Lane Shoulder TSidewalk approximately 80'
Turn Lane
U
Paved Width = 54'
Minimum Right -of -Way Width = 69'*
* One foot of right -of -way outside each sidewalk is
needed for operational purposes.
CLEVELAND /YOUNG INTERSECTION CONCEPTS - STREET CLOSURES WITHOUT STREET VACATION 1 200
WQODBURN
Incorporated 1889
Highwa 99E"..:
CpaidoiFidn
City of Woodburn
Highway 99E Corridor Plan
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES
Concept 1: Limited Improvements
, 4 1 .wooaaBVZ�,�T
��". Incorporated l88q
Highwa 99E
Corridor`Plane�
m —� �isrracgT
Pros
• Minimal impact to existing
businesses
• Lower construction cost
• Lower maintenance costs for
the city
• New development standards
could be met with modest
site improvements
• Potentially easier process for
ODOT to improve highway
Cons
• Reduced incentive for new
businesses to locate in area
• Requires design exception
from ODOT
• Narrower bike lane provides
less protection for cyclists
• No street trees to shade or
buffer sidewalk
• Limited opportunities to add
pedestrian amenities without
obstructing sidewalk
W OODBUR,�J
1 ncor rated 1889
Highwa 99E
Corrido Tlan
Concept 2
Mixed Use Village
WOODBUR
N
I n c o r p o r a t e d 1 8 8 9
Highway QQE
Corridor n
L ..................
1Axamx BE M
S�
INI
d
' 4i
Me
4
l g
3
17 1
----------- ...... ............
I
2
A/
P
LEGEND
5 lanes, bike lanes, curb-tight
sidewalks
5 lanes, bike lanes, buffered
sidewalks
3 lanes, wide shoulders,
buffered sidewalks
4[mm■
Young Street Corridorto
Downtown
no change to existing
zoning
■
modify zoning to "Mixed Use
VillageCommercial
Gateway Feature
11011
Corridor Segment
LEGEND
teslots
uroen
(P.w.d)
Cl
City of Woo&, AUGUST2011
Highway 99E
Miles
Mixed Use Village 110
Highwa 99E
N Corridor "Plan 4..
y .... . . . . . .
�, Incorporated 1889
TQODBU_RN
i 7 .. Irrcor1, orateA f889
Highwa 99E
Corridor "Plan
X
�
4 r
�FJOddD�Q7Z8�.
4
�
-• �r'
QODBURN
.�. Incorporated 1889
Highway 316,
Corridor Plan
Example
Development
Mixed Use building in
Wood Village, OR
-� .QODSUR,
+� Incorporated 1 88q
Highwa 99E"..:
6
,Corridor Plan .�`
LAND USE
Concept 2: Mixed Use Village
L.WQODBUR
I n c o r p o r a t e d d 1 8 8 9 N
Highway QQE fie.:
Co rridor Plan
Land Use &Urban Design Implementation
Modifications to Development Standards (Corridor -Wide)
• Apply City's access management guidelines
Minimizing access points
Shared access with adjacent sites
Connections to abutting parking lots
Taking access from abutting street with lowest functional class
• Require pedestrian walkways from sidewalk to primary
building entrance
• Require bike /pedestrian accessways from adjacent stub
streets to Highway 99E upon redevelopment
W ooDBUR,�J
1 ncor rated 1889
Highwa 99E
Corrido T1an
Land Use &Urban Design Implementation
Modifications to Development Standards (Within Segment 3 Only)
• New "Mixed Use Village" — allowed land uses would be more similar to
the downtown zone (DDC) than the General Commercial zone (CG)
• Setbacks: reduce minimum front setbacks from 15' to 0', and establish
maximum front setback (for example, 10')
• Establish building frontage requirement
• Require primary entrance oriented to sidewalk
• Prohibit parking between the front of the building and the street
• Strengthen architectural design guidelines
• Prohibit pole signs (free- standing signs over 8 feet high)
��- WQODBURN
+� 1 incorporated 1 889
Highwa 99E
Corridor`Pht
Land Use &Urban Design Implementation
Streetscape Enhancements and Public Investments
• Pedestrian amenities
• Add highway -style lighting to strategic locations in Segments 1, 2, and 4
• Install gateway arch over Young Street
• Install special paving at the Young Street / Highway 99E intersection in
Segment 3
• Create Local Improvement District or other mechanism to fund
undergrounding of utilities
• Storefront improvement program
• Consider non - conforming sign amortization program
• Expand and modify existing Urban Renewal Area (URA) or establish new
URA to include Segment 3 "Mixed Use Village"
• Assemble and consolidate small parcels for redevelopment
• Identify public /private partnership catalyst project
Highwa 99E
-
WQODBUR Corridor`Plan �
+� 1 ncor 1 88q
TRANSPORTATION
Concept 2: Mixed Use Village
Highwa 99E ?'
OD BUR Corridoi ?lan
Segment 1: No Change
' Existing ROW in
6 " 6' 12' 12' 14' 12' 12' 6' 6" 5' Segment1 is
Bike Travel Lane Travel Lane Two -Way Left Travel Lane Travel Lane Bike m Sidewalk approximately 90'
Lane Turn Lane Lane
Paved Width = 74'
Total Width = 85'
Segment 2: No Change
ExistingROWin
6' 12' 12' 14' 12' 12' 6' 6„ 5' Segment 2is
Bike Travel Lane Travel Lane Two -Way Left Travel Lane Travel Lane Bike Sidewal approximately 85
Lane Turn Lane Lane
Paved Width = 74'
Total Width = 85'
Segment 3: 5 Lane, Buffered Sidewalksr�
Existing ROWin
6' s„ 6' 12' 12' 14' 12' 6" Segment 3is
andscape Bike Travel Lane Travel Lane Two -Way Left Travel Lane Trave�Lane Bike m Landscape Sidewalk approximately 80'
Buffer E2 Lane Turn Lane Lane Buffer
U
Paved Width = 74'
Minimum Riaht- of -Wav Width =101'*
6' 1 6' ° 8' 12' 14' 12' 8' ° 6' 6'
Sidewalk Landscape Shoulder Travel Lane Two -Way Left Travel Lane Shoulder Landscape Sidewalk
Buffer = Turn Lane = Buffer
U U
Paved Width = 54'
Minimum Right -of -Way Width = 81'
* One foot of fight -of -way outside each sidewalk is
needed for operational purposes.
Existing ROW in
Segment 4 is
approximately 80'
w; }
Segment 4: 3 Lane, Buffered Sidewalks
CLEVELAND ! YOUNG INTERSECTION CONCEPTS - STREET CLOSURES WITH STREET VACATION
.��� • b
R E G 0 N
Highwa 99E
6
Corridoi ?ldn 4
HiUn waV 9y� C;or <<��� Plan
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES
Concept 2: Mixed Use Village
-ten
W4oaaSU,
+� Incorporated 1 889
Highwa 99E
CorridorPlali "M
m —� �isrracgT
Pros
• Improves corridor aesthetics
• Easier for large vehicles to
navigate full -size lanes
• Full -width bike lane safer for
cyclists
• No design exceptions required
from ODOT
• Street trees buffer & shade
sidewalk
• More pedestrian - friendly
development
• Enhances connection to
downtown
Cons
• Greater impacts to existing
businesses in Segment 3
• Higher construction costs
• Higher maintenance costs for
City
• Potentially harder process for
ODOT to improve highway
• Increased development
potential in Segment 3 would
increase traffic somewhat
• Intersection improvement
would be needed at Young St.
• Mixed Use Village could fill a
similar niche to downtown
47�
�J`TOODBURN
i ✓ .�, „
1 incorporated 1 889
Highwa 99E
Corridoi ?lan
LEGEND
Zoaing Distd&s
RS- Single Family Residential
RM- Medium D—ly Re dM rtial
CA- kbinmerdal Office JJ
CG - C.Mn rG91 Goneml
IL- Light Industrial
� j PISP - Publ'o and Semi - Public
j I Uiban Grwrth Boundary
Clty Limds
HIr Railroad Highway 99E & Lincoln, Woodburn
toe P� ,n.l Fu Migtmey (Retail: Goodwill. Meets current city
Right -of -way standards far parking, setbacks, etc.)
Development Examples
❑ Lat Lines Landscaping
■Building � Pafking/OriveWays
S'T
1-
z rn LAUREL AVE
4 r CO
m Shallowest depth of CG
- zoning ( -100 R from
future ROW at
narrowest)
r
ti�sT I
r
NE MLK Jr & Fremont, Portland (Mixed
Use: retail, office, townhomes. Less
parking than required in Woodburn.) _
GEORGE ST
e �F
�F<
R NO
/ Sr
SILVERTON AVE
uj
NW Cornell & Gallatin, Hillsboro (Retail. Suburban parking ratios but ¢ SE Belmont &
setbacks less than required by Woodburn.) W 42nd, Portland
-- w (Mixed Use: retail8
Y o condos, tuck -under
parking. Less
parking than
a required
Woodburn.)
f
City of Woocf'.. June 2011
Highway 99E Corridor Plan
0 100 200
Young Street/ 99E Gateway Area Redevelopment Potential � Feet
Vision Statement
Highway 99E is a vibrant, safe and
sustainable business district easily
accessible to shoppers traveling by
car, bike or on foot. The corridor is
aesthetically pleasing and provides
opportunities
Corridor Aesthetics
The Corridor Plan provides
guidance and
recommendations on how
the visual appearance of the
Highway 99E Corridor can
be improved overtime
through land use, design
and streetscape strategies
and enhancement
Economic Development:
The physical environment and
viability of businesses along the
Highway 99E Corridor is supported
and enhanced by the Corridor Plan
recommendations. The project
recommendations facilitate the
revitalization of the corridor as a
viable, safe, and sustainable business
district
Pedestrian / Bicycle Access & Safety
Recommended improvements in the Highway
99E Corridor include pedestrian / bicycle
enhancements that improve safety, reduce
potential conflicts, and provide an improved
physical environment for these activities.
Community
Outreach Comments
Traveling display boards Young Street gateway entrance
— Library Favor of the mixed use zone
— Long Brothers Lumber Landscaping.
Nine surveys were received Filling in and improving the
— Seven out of nine empty lots
preferred Concept 2 Concept 2 was not right
— Two of nine rejected both Community not support
concepts (one said to leave Concept 2
99E as it is, and the other Many challenges to Concept 2
felt the concepts were too Like the gateway sign
boring)
• What will the community
— The majority of the surveys support?
centered on wanting the
corridor to become more
green/landscape-oriented
Citizen Advisory
Committee Comments
• Young Street gateway entrance
Bruce Crane chose Concept 2
Favor of the mixed use zone
Dick Jennings chose Concept 2
Landscaping.
Sam Brentano chose Concept 1
Filling in and improving the
David Paradis chose Concept 1
empty lots
Ruby Wolfer chose Concept 1
Concept 2 was not right
Janice Webb chose Concept 1
Eric Morris chose Concept 2
• Community might not support
Concept 2
Gerald Curtis chose Concept L.
Darcy Ruef did not choose a
• Many challenges to Concept 2
concept
Like the gateway sign
The CAC was unable to come to a
What will the community
consensus, since neither concept
support?
was supported whole - heartedly
Planning
Commission
Ellsworth -Concept 2
Corning -Concept 2
Grigorieff -Concept 1
Chair Jennings - Concept 2
Commissioners Corning,
Jennings and Ellsworth
preferred Concept 2, and
Commissioner Grigorieff
was in favor of Concept 1.
Comments
• Unwilling to shortchange
the ultimate vision
• Like the "green" aspect, as
well as thesafety - Concept
2
• Liked Concept 2, but
thought Concept 1 more
feasible
• Who was paying for
Concept 2?
• Need to achieve some goals
in the foreseeable future
Highway 99E Corridor Plan
*Council Comments
•Concept 1
*Concept 2
City Council consensus on proceeding
with Concept 2