04-12-2010 Item 10A: Staff Presentation
Fifth Street
Improvement Project
Public Safety
Transportation Connectivity
Providing Alternate Routes
Fifth Street Project
This project is identified in the City’s
?
most recent 2005 Transportation
System Plan (TSP) update as one of
several projects that make up the
preferred alternative to address the
City’s long-term transportation goals.
Fifth Street Project
Specific Goals of the Project Are:
?
–Upgrade 5th Street to access street
standards (including connection to Hwy
214).
–Signalize the intersection of Meridian
Drive/5th Street/Oregon 214.
Fifth Street Project
Project Objectives
?
1.Enhance public safety
2.Provide greater connectivity (more
alternate routes)
3.Reduce traffic congestion at key
locations such as on nearby Hwy 214
and SettlemierAvenue
4.Provide crucial north/south access
street
Fifth Street Project
Objectives continued
?
5.Eliminate or reduce need for local traffic
to travel east/west on OR 214 to move
about the city
6.Obtain a fully signalized intersection at
OR 214/Meridian/Fifth
7.Provide sidewalks, additional parking,
street lighting, landscaping, and
drainage improvements
Fifth Street Project
Existing Conditions
?
–Fifth Street is barricaded 400 feet south
of intersection with OR 214
–Street north of the barricade was
improved with the construction of the
Nuevo Amanecermulti-family housing
–Street north of the barricade is 40 feet
wide with 6 feet wide sidewalks
Fifth Street Project
Existing Conditions
?
–Street south of the barricade is
unimproved and varies in width from 17
to 23 feet
–Street south of the barricade does not
have any sidewalks or paved parking
–Pavement condition is poor
Fifth Street Project
Design Criteria
?
–City standards for a Local Access Street
are generally followed
–A design exception will be required to
adjust the standard cross section fit
within the available right of way
–Street proposed is to consist of two travel
lanes, on street parking, and curb tight
sidewalks
Fifth Street Project
Project Delivery Process
?
–Confirm project is needed and viable
–Involve public
–Prepare Design Acceptance Package for
Council approval alternative selected and
authorization to proceed
–If approved, complete final design,
prepare bid documents, and construct
Fifth Street Project
Public Involvement Process
?
–Conducted 3 Open Houses
Seventh Day Adventist Church
?
St. Luke’s Church
?
Nuevo Amanecer
?
–Invited Open House attendees to sign-up
for participation in a Citizen Advisory
Committee
Fifth Street Project
Public Involvement Process
?
–20 Citizens volunteered to participate in a Citizen
Advisory Committee
–Citizens desiring to participate were primarily
those citizens opposed to the project
–Difficult to identify citizen participants who were
either neutral or in favor of the project to
participate
–18 of the 20 Committee members participated
and only 17 contributed a final recommendation
Fifth Street Project
Public Involvement Process
?
–The Citizen Advisory Committee was
chartered to advise the Project Delivery
Team on alternative assessment and
design consideration
–The No Build option was considered as an
alterative
Fifth Street Project
Public Involvement Process
?
–The No Build alternative was favored by a
majority of the Citizen Advisory
Committee (10 of 17 members)
–Alternative 1, which is to construct Fifth
Street as a two-way access street
between OR 214 and Harrison is the staff
recommended alternative
Fifth Street Project
Public Involvement Process
?
–The public involvement process is
summarized as an appendix to the Design
Delivery Package
–Benefits of the public involvement
process are the Project Delivery Team
received good insight on assessing
alternatives
Fifth Street Project
Public Involvement Process
?
–Why did the Citizen Advisory Committee
majority reject the staff preferred
alternative and favor No Build?
Desire to continue to live on a dead end
?
street versus a through access street
Fear that a through access street would
?
deteriorate the academic environment of St.
Luke’s Elementary School
Fifth Street Project
Alternatives Analysis
?
–7 of 17 CAC members preferred Alternatives 1 or
2 (Fifth Street Improvements)
–Alternative 1 addresses other design
considerations identified by the Citizen Advisory
Committee more effectively than the No Build
alternative
–There was no engineering solution to address
the preference of committee members to live on
a dead end street or to preserve the current
academic environment of St. Luke’s School.
Fifth Street Project
Design Acceptance Package
?
Recommendations
–Two way traffic on Fifth Street
–On-street parking on both sides of the
street
–Curb tight sidewalks on both sides of the
street
–Narrow cross section where possible to
minimize impact on residences
Fifth Street Project
Design Acceptance Package
?
–Other alternatives considered
No Build
?
One-way couplet that would have included
?
one-way traffic on Fifth and Third Streets and
included extending Yew Street from Third to
Fifth
Fifth Street Project
Design Acceptance Package
?
Recommendations
–Based upon current traffic counts with the
opening of Fifth Street, warrants for a signalized
intersection at OR 214/Meridian/Fifth have been
met
–An application for approval of a signalized
intersection has been submitted by Public Works
to ODOT and is pending review and approval
Fifth Street Project
Delivery Schedule
?
–April 2010 –Council Approve Design
Acceptance Package
–April 2010 to September 2010 –Complete
design and prepare Plans, Specifications,
and Engineer’s Estimate
–October 2010 to December 2010 -ODOT
Review contract documents
Fifth Street Project
Project Delivery Schedule
?
–January 2011 –Advertise for bid
–March 2011 –Award contract for
construction
–April 2011 –Start construction on north
end of project limits
–August 2011 –Construction complete
near St. Luke’s School
–November 2011 –Project complete
Fifth Street Project
Estimated total project cost
?
–$2.5 million
Fifth Street Project
Public Safety Project Endorsements
?
–Woodburn Fire District
–Regional Emergency Medical Services
–Woodburn Police Department
–ODOT Bicycle and Pedestrian Program
Fifth Street Project
Conclusion
?
–Fifth Street project is a viable and needed
project
–Fifth Street project is strongly opposed by
residents of Fifth Street and St. Luke’s
Parish
–Fifth Street project will enhance
connectivity and public safety for our
community