02-22-2010 Presentation: Hendryx-LA 2009-02
~~.
-~
`' ,~~,'
~_ _- u ~ , -~`~`
_~. ~. ~:
,. ~~
4 °W
r _ - _t~~v. ~.P:
-.~ ~ 4 ~
0 ~ T.
t.e t~ ~.
__ _ ~
~ ~ t
9 :. M x.11 - r -_ ~ -s' ~ ~.~r _
tea, { s;~.~` ~4 ... v-- _ _ -,,_., S ,~..
F ~ Y ~ _ __ _ ~. ,.~
~~ a ~ - 'a'
r ~ ~~:~ _ _ _-=_ -~•
F ~ # . , fie' ~ + -_ 1 -~ I
y1 fir,. _ _ _ --- .'ilr~~ t "
_~ ~`.
~. _ ~~,
f _ ~_'~ _
__~_~, 'fir
y.
~,+ -
r - ... ~ ~ v 3~~
Leaislative Amendment ~~
. ~~
t
~°
r~
F'~
~.
1
~t~!
i
_ ~ '._
°~ 4" a^~~
z^' - ,: mar,
A ti - ~ ~ ,o II
_yj f5 I
- - - __--
-_-
_-- ---
Signs in the right-of-way in the Retirement
~~.
. _~
Legislative Amendment 2009-02
• On October 26, 2009 the City Council initiated the
proposed text amendment
` -.~-
• Planning Commission public hearing December 17, 2009
-Unanimously disapproved the ordinance
• City Council public hearing January 11, 2010
+'f~y.A
- Referred the ordinance to the Sign Focus Group '~
•Unanimous support within the R1 S zone
•Minor modifications (setback) ~ '^ ~ "~
Tom, .# _ Tf _ ~ y ~~iy l1
• City Council consideration of revised ordinance .
22, 2010 -- y
~_ ~ ~_ .
Dui uai y
J ~~,
~ u
m~
y~2
a• ~ a~ ~ . - a ~~ r i~ a - .~ i ~" ' i`-= i" ' ,.1'f" 1 ~ ~~ ~ 11 i~M1~4
^..1!~ ~'. IP
u g ~ ., , ~ 1
~ ~ i . ~ is a r. l
_ _ _ [ ~ ~
- Y I ~
W t
i
~° *"~.
~ ~~
n
~ - T 1 ~ .,R ~` . ~ . ,.
+~- r _ ~ m
- - r ~ ~~ ~
~~rl
~ J ~- ~ Ar ~- '1
~ . i a, ~ ~V
_.~T
'-~ ~ .-~
;~~
r ~
.,
_ Y
I ~i
l • ~ [
1
e ~ i ~ e ~
- - F~ la
~Il l - __ ^
u
~ - S ~'
r~
• ~ ~ lit ~ If
_ r ~ ~,
_ ~~ y ' '~+, ~~ ~ - ~~
. ~.
~ ~~
.,~ ,+-
~ ~ ~ 1
n ~ ~ ~y
~- ., .
` , . ~ ~. ~
... '_ ~ i
~. ~.. ~
_ ~ ~ .~ _ _ .. _ , ~ IW
4 ~ ~ ~
~` ~ r
~~
- _ ~~~ ~~ ar ~~
,~ iq
_.~~' _. rF- ...
~ r r1d„ "~, 1 u ~.
;,.
i
w
'~ - i .r 9
'- I
i i
a
d
~ ~ Y~
~~nn _ i
_ r i _$, ~ i 1 i 1 u yN... _.
I _ - _ II ~ _ '1 ~' _ i. i.
! u~ ~ ~~ 1 I ~ ~ 1 R
~ i ' !~"' r ~ _ ~
1 ~ '~ - '~ ~ a.. 4
^ •u yl'
i M a
~ i
i
I
.:
~ - a^ ~ T~
,~; ~~ 1w-
~ ~ ~, ~
f.7'
u -~
^ l - i
~. l R f - .
~i p 1 I~~ ~ 1
- ~ ~~
L _ 1 ~ I - _ y
^ L ~ i li ~ i
~ .I ' 1 ~ _ ~ ' ~ ~_ J ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ it
- R ~, W - -,
^ ~~~ ^
_ _ ~f1
V
1
3 - II ~ t
r
i ~ :~ ~ - - J ~ _ '~- Ei R~ a §# i rri it - _ ~~~
• ~ '~
I^
__ ~ €
•~ t 1' ~ iii a ~. .~.. '_:i _. I !~ ~ F ~ 1 `_ V ~~. _
$ 1 ~i - .; II ~ -
g ,,
'~1 L _ ~ ,v
L
,~ ~ -~
.~
_, 1-~ ~ 11 ~- as ~ _ = n„
~~ b -. ~~
- ~ ..
.•
~~
-.
_i. "'° -
1: ~ ~
__ ~ ~
_ _ _
~~.~ a~ _ ~ ~~ r _ ~ ~ - i~
~. ~ r
_- e a
~,
i • - • .~
a_.. n 1~ _q, ~~-~~ t ~ -a: is
i i
u
;~
^
a
' ,
l i `~' ~ ~ ~ psi ,. ; - ~ ' ~ ~*a~~ ,
a
~~ i ,,~ ~
,. ~ ~, . ,~ i E -
V i R' n
.YID Ili " & y._ .__ w - - .~ o u ! _
~ C
~~~, . ,
W
_ ~ ~~+~
i i _
1 ~" d
k' b'. a r_ r '~~
r.
II
_ _ ~ Y- ~ _ _ ii - l
i i.~~ ^_It r N -_ _ - i y - .-
-~ ~ i I
,.~ ~ d~~ m
~. ` i ~ ,~
^ i - ~`
r- ~ ~ ° ~
II "a`,~ , .. ,
'.
.. a
- ri - ~~y 1 F ~ ~ ~ '1
~.'~ . ' , < ~ ~I ,
a• ~ a~ ~ . - a ~~ r i~ a - .~ i ~" ' i`-= i" ' ,.1'f" 1 ~ i~ ~ 11 i~M1~4
^..1!~ ~'. IP
u g ~ ., , ~ 1
~ ~ i . ~ is a i. l
_ _ _ [ ~ ~
- - Y I ~
W t
i
i ::a ~ -° ~ _ _ - ~ ,R F iii ~i
1 ~'"~ ~ '~
~° *"~.
~ ~~
i
1 - T 1~ ..W JF a` . ,i
+~- r _ ~ m
- - r ~ ~~ ~
~~rl
~ J ~- ~ Ar ~- '1
~ . i a, ~ ~V
_.~T
'-~ ~ .-~
;~~
r ~
.,
_ Y
I ~i
l • ~ [
1
i ~ i ~ e ~
- - - F~ la
~Il l - __ ^
u
~ - S ~'
V y-i - ~~ 1 i E ~
r~
• ~ ~ lit ~ If
_ r ~ ~,
_ ~~ y ' '~+i ~~ ~ -
. ~.
~ ~~
.,~ ,+-
~ ~ ~ 1
~- ., .
n i ~ ~y
` , . ~ ~. ~
... ~_ ~ i
~. ~.. ~
_ ~ ~ .~ _ _ .. , ~ IW
4 ~ ~ ~
~` ~ r
~~
- _ ~~~ ~~ ar ~~
,~ iq
_.~'' _. rF- ...
' . 9 'J ~ ` ~i ~ d~'I
~ r r1d„ "~, 1 u ~.
i • ,~ IY s 1... ~, ~ R ~1~
;,.
i ~,
w
'~ - i it 9
'- I
i i
a
d
~ ~ Y~
~~nn _ i
_ r i _$, ~ i 1 i 1 u yN... _.
n M io rrIJ V iiY ~. ~~, .,
~ - - _ - _ II ~ _ '1 ~' _ - i. i-
i ~ l~ ~ LR'.~ -
! u~ E ~~ 1 I ~ ~ 1 R yiY
L"' '.1 ~ ~ _ "~' ~Q i i
~ i ' !~"' r ~ _ ~
_ 1 ~ '~- - I~a~ a 4
^ •u yl'
i M a
~ i
i
I
.:
~ - a^ ~ T~
,~; ~~ 1w-
~ ~ ~, ~
f.7'
u -~
^ l - i
~. l R f - .
- ~ ~~
~i p 1 .~" ~ 1
L 1 ~ I - _ y
^ L ~ i li ~ i
~ .I i E - ~ ' ~ ~_ J ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ it
^ ~~~ ^
_ _ ~f1
V
1
3 - II ~ i
r
i ~ :~ ~ - - J ~ _ '~- ii R~ a §# i rri it - _ ~~~
• ~ '~
^
__ ~ _ €. _ ,
_ •~ i 1' ~ iii a ~. _ - I !~ ~ F _ ~ 1 E_ Li ~ ~. _
,y~ •_ -
$ 1 ~I a+ a: ~ - II
'~1 L ,v
--
w ~ ~.
~.. w ~ i ,
,.. , ,~~ r
_ ~ ,
ii - ~
~ _~~ ~ - ~L _
i u
m~ _- _
r; _ ' ' I it
r
..
' ~ s1 ~ e s ,' ~T _ ~ min i ~ ~. -
_ i
` ~ i W
_ ~ ~ ~ ~ ^'
i • i
qt~
3 a-" ° o ~_ p " 'T'.'-~E -~ ~ci -r: as
4^ ~~m
1 1 ~ ~~ ~
^ - R ~ ~.R i. 1 In 1 ' u
~.
_ ~, _ _ -
i
- ~ ~ ~,.
~_ ,
a
~~ i ,, ~~ ~
r V i R' n
~7 ~a 'r ' ~' 1 ~ i „ ~ . ~ ~A rim 1
.YID Ili " & y. _ ° _ " - - .~ o u
~ C
~~~, . ,
W
_ ~ ~~+~
i i _
- - 1 ~" d
k' b'. a r_ r '~~
r.
II
_ _ ~ Y- ~ _ - ii - l
i i.~~ ^_It f N - -_ _ - i y - .-
-~ i I
,.~ ~ d~~ m
~. ` i ~ i~
^ i - ~`
r- ~ ~ ° ~
II "a`,~ , .. ,
'.
.. a
- ri - ~~y 1 F ~ ~ ~ '1
~.'~ . ' , < ~ ~I ,
~,
"~ ~
~, 1
-'~-- 1..
1 4 y
i ~ -
ij1 4 ~~
i ~~
/_/f ~ /, ~ ~1.~
_k ',~
I
S,
'~
e~
~ .~_
I ~_
Compliant sign on
private property
Noncompliant sign
~% in the right-of-way
~;~ t.
Current language
3.110.11
Exemptions.
The following are exempt from application, permit and
fee requirements of Section 3.110, but are subject to
other applicable portions of Section 3.110 and the City
Code and may require building and electrical permits:
G. Lawn signs and A-frame signs in residential zones
provided that not more than two such signs are
located on a lot or parcel and the total area for all
such signs does not exceed eight square feet. Such
signs shall not exceed six feet in height and shall
not be placed in the public right of way or vision
clearance areas.
Proposed language
3.110.11
Exemptions.
The following are exempt from application, permit and fee
requirements of Section 3.110, but are subject to other applicable
portions of Section 3.110 and the City Code and may require
building and electrical permits:
G. Lawn signs and A-frame signs in residential RS, RSN, RM, and RMN
zones provided that not more than two such signs are located on
a lot or parcel and the total area for all such signs does not
exceed eight square feet. Such signs shall not exceed 5~x seven
feet in height and shall not be placed in the public right-of-way or
vision clearance areas.
Proposed language
3.110.11 Exemptions.
H. Lawn signs and A-frame signs in the R1S zone provided that:
1. The signs are established by the property owner or
propel'tV owner's agent,
2. Not more than two such signs are located on a lot or in the
public right-of-way abutting the lot.
3. The total area for all such signs does not exceed eight
square feet,
4. Lawn signs shall not exceed seven feet in height,
5. A-frame signs shall not exceed three feet in height,
6. Signs shall not be placed in vision clearance areas
(Section 3.103.10) or in adjacent rights-of-way,
7. Signs shall not be on or overhanging a travel or on-street parking
lane,
8. Signs shall not be on or overhanging a sidewalk, and
9. No portion of a sign shall be less than 3 feet from the back of a
curb.
^ ~ ~'
u g ~ ., , ~ '
~ ~ . ^ ~ I
- E ~ 1
W
i .
_ .~i ~. -
®.~ ~ ~ i i _ _ - ~. ..
~ ~ Iii
a ~ T
'~
r ~
-ET ~~
_ ~i.' ~
. I
~.i - -
~ ~ -
-. r
.:
~ ~ -~ ~ _ _ i
- ~~ ~ r ~ ~a
i` '
~.
ii
ra
~~ ~~ ~ i Vl
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~' ~' ~L ® ~: ~ ' -
~_ ., .
n
~.~
~ ,~
.. -.
` ,, ~.
_ E
~.
~ 9
_ ! ~ ~~ ~u
~ - - ,~ ~~
- f ~-
W Il ~ + ~ l~ ~ ~ _ W
.I I
~E ~
'~ - E .a 9
-~ ~ - ~ ~.
•_ I
1 = 1 i
~I'
' u n ~ .0
~ -
n l
! ~ ~~ ~I~ ~ ~ I ~~ ~ 1 III
f 1
~ I~ ~
w I ~ ~I r
~ J~ ~ -
.n
.n
a. -
II ~ ~
~, -,
p n i ~
_ l ~ r ~
L ' I I I _
^ - ~. ®.. _
_ - ^ r`~~7 y~Ai
' -
F ~ ~ _,
~~ ~ ~ _
--
as ~
_ - ~ E ~ ~-
I ~a - ~I
-~ ~_ ~~
..
~ ~ E~ w
r
If ~
L ~ f T
r V
I l ~i ~ . - it _ .. a n,,,
I ~ I ~' il._ III I.. ' ~ ~ ._ - ~ - '~ -
- ~ ~ '•€ ~ - w ; ~ _ - .~ ° 9. r z is - - - - w
- - ~ _
a,
'~ I E
s~ E~ ~ ;~ „!~ ~
r
F ~" ~ a
_ u
_ '
z _
n ~~
^
- _ _
;~
E(
I
-_ n M ~~ -
. ~:
~ ~ io ~~
i
li ^ ~ _ ~~a. ~ d ..
T~ ~ ! _ _ -
. ~ ~ - -~ - .~ ._ __..._ _ - :. .n
~ '~ u. a -
Itl ~ e ~ .~'
~ _
- T
ai a u -
R i ~
_~i 1 j , a y ~_ ~ ~ v
i. ~ 1f _ _ _
- - ~- - _rG ii i a
e
_ _
.- ~ 9 ~_
r i ~ ,r,£
_ ~ c. L _ - ~~ ns
~ _ ~
- it __ ~ - fln.
Y - ~ ~_ I.
u
a ` 1. - - -. - - _ ~
u~ % Y ~ I a
1
6~i n i
i ~ G~
~ e a n~ u - ..
Ali ~ E~ ~ - G: =a,
P i l ~ II C' ~ ~ ~~ i _ 'u i
. ~ ~ '~ ~
~~ ~ . LL
The Vision Clearance Area does
not extend into the right-of-way.
Street Centerline
Street/Curb
Clearance Area
The ordinance prohibits signs
in vision clearance areas or in
adjacent rights-of-way.
Street Centerline
Street/Curb
Clearance Area
ta. -
_ti `~
_ _
-- ~ ~.
- ax ~.
t ~ ~ ~ •.
~ A,~ F, }per- .ip e- _ _ _ ~ ~ ~.4
"~
- ~'-~ .~
..- .. .. _ ~ _ -,. ., _ .. ..n _
~~`
_ -~
~ ~
.yam ,~ ~~,
k _ s a
~~
~p ~ ~~
,9 ~r y ~.~ ~ y _
' F
s ~ ti i _ _ _ ~
~,_a_-
._
- .~ _
.- ~ _ ~~ - c _ ~pr ~
d'
r.~
- -
t+~4~ - ~
w
i {
~ r:
e~..a
_ _
~~, ~ _ _ ~
~. - - ~'
4
- ~ r v -`~
~~ ' 1' ~ -
Jy i ~y
T... .~ ~ _ _.-. _ i. ~ ..
. .; r i
r 1, ~ ° ~ ._., - ~ ~a 5.. ~ '~- ~~ j
- ,
~ ~ ~ ~}
rt ~,
~ i ~ l ~.
:'~; ,, 4. f i _ -..mot `~~' -d ~'~•S .~+; f '~ ~
1 _ d ~. ,.
,,
r ~`
r.. ~
_ ~.
,. ~ ~ ~' , e , -..
a . ~~
4 ~ ~,
k
- mr
Y
•.
_ -- ~ ~ ~
' ~ ..
~ ~, M1
'~_. ~~
~L a- -n ~ 4
~ ~
a Fe
A ' r ,
C f _ _ _.-' - ~ ~ -'
}
1 .. i~' _~~ ~ ~' ~ is ~. ,. _ ~" ~ ,~ i ~ ,: ''F
~ ; .. ~ -~
-- ~ __ d ~ . :ofd
_ .~ a a ' ,
~~1'~ ~~ !_ - _ - ~ ~ ~ ~~Y is T ~ 'L S.
- ~, ,~
,..~4 ,
.~,,. _ ., ti ~- --
f , ' ~' a, N ~, ~
,~ 0 r r .. ,
~ ~ •~,R~ ~~ t~
'n ~ p
,i
r .,
'~
r ..
'
~ ..I. f .. n.~w r
~ . P I ,~~ .
8 9 ,..:ry
~q ,
~M ~ *d, t
.j 7
;. ,
~ ----° r -
- _. P .,. - ~ i4 , _ ,. r
"E~"~'T r 'i~ ~
H fir, kk y~ ~Ni {~, ~~ ~~-~- ~ a. -_ •~...1 °31.~ _ +' r ~"
._ ,
.. '4 a
t . ~ ,~`
~ T F' a.,
~ke' "
~ 4
s' F
i!- ^~, ~
~ _ _
'. \ ?t
i
_. _ ....s-_ . -
,'
^~
Sign Focus Group
The focus group received the proposed amendment favorably.
One suggestion (made after the amendment was sent to
DLCD) was to add a provision that signs not project over
the curb or sidewalk.
Current language
3.110.12 Prohibited signs
The following signs and advertising devices are
prohibited:
G. A sign in public right of ways except awning,
projecting, wall, and suspended signs projecting
over a public right of way in conformity with Section
3.110, or unless specifically exempt under
Section 3.110.11.