Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
July 14, 2026 Agenda
K ERGAN, YOR CITY OF WOODBURN FRAN,COUNCILORWARD1 ORLANDO BRAVO,COUNCILOR WARD 1 MARK WILK,COUNCILOR WARD II CITY COUNCIL AGENDA JEN CANTU,COUNCILOR WARD III SHARON SCHAUB,COUNCILOR WARD IV AMENDED MARY BETH CORNWELL,COUNCILOR WARD V ALMA GRIJALVA,COUNCILOR WARD VI JULY 14, 2026 - 6:00 P.M. LIBRARY SQUARE -280 GARFIELD Si 1. CALL TO ORDER AND FLAG SALUTE 2. ROLL CALL 3. ANNOUNCEMENTS AND APPOINTMENTS Announcements: A. Woodburn Fiesta Mexicana - We hope you join us at Legion Park on August 21-23. -Event Features: • 60+ vendors featuring authentic Mexican cuisine, artisan vendors, informational booths and more. • On Saturday, our much-anticipated parade highlighting the amazing Woodburn community. • Performances such as live music, dancing, cultural celebrations and more on the main stage. • Additional entertainment such as soccer & pickleball tournaments, Lucha Libre wrestling, and carnival rides. - Cost • Friday: Free all day • Saturday &Sunday: Free until 5:00 pm. There will be a $5 entry fee after 5 pm for those 10 and older. Appointments: None. 5. PROCLAMATIONS/PRESENTATIONS Proclamations: None. Presentations: A. Nancy Kirksey Award B. Mary Tennant Award This facility is ADA accessible. If you need special accommodation, please contact the City Recorder at 503-980- 6318 at least 24 hours prior to this meeting. **Habra interpretes disponibles para aquellas personas que no hablan Ingles, previo acuerdo. Comuniquese al (503) 980-2485.** July 14, 2026 Council Agenda Page i C. Recognition and Thanks to John Reinhardt D. Recognition and Thanks to David Piper E. All-America City Award F. Working Dogs Oregon 6. COMMUNICATIONS None. 7. BUSINESS FROM THE PUBLIC - This allows the public to introduce items for Council consideration not already scheduled on the agenda. 8. CONSENT AGENDA -Items listed on the consent agenda are considered routine and may be adopted by one motion. Any item may be removed for discussion at the request of a Council member. A. Woodburn City Council minutes of June 22, 2026 1 Recommended Action: Approve the minutes. B. Election Results - May 19, 2026, Primary Election 6 Recommended Action: Accept the Certified Results from Marion County. C. New Development Activity for June 2026 8 Recommended Action: Receive the report. 9. TABLED BUSINESS None. 10. PUBLIC HEARINGS None. 11. GENERAL BUSINESS - Members of the public wishing to comment on items of general business must complete and submit a speaker's card to the City Recorder prior to commencing this portion of the Council's agenda. Comment time may be limited by Mayoral prerogative. A. Council Bill No. 3307 - An Ordinance Amending Ordinance No. 2464 9 (Regulation of Taxicabs; Taxicab Drivers; Taxicab Companies), Modifying the Requirements for the Issuance of a Taxicab Driver Permit and Declaring an Emergency Recommended Action: Adopt an Ordinance amending Ordinance 2464 (Taxicab Regulation), thereby modifying the requirements for the issuance of a July 14, 2026 Council Agenda Page ii taxicab driver permit by reducing the lookback period for a prior suspension of driving privileges from ten (10) years to five (5) years. B. Final Decision of an appeal of the Planning Commission approval of 30 the WinCo Grocery Store (DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, VAR 25-06) PUBLIC TESTIMONY ON THIS AGENDA ITEM IS CLOSED. NO PUBLIC COMMENTS WILL BE RECEIVED. Recommended Action: Adopt the Final Decision approving the consolidated application package which includes a Design Review, Property Line Adjustment, Street Adjustment and Variances (3) to allow for the development of a WinCo Grocery Store located on Stacy Allison Way, south of Center Street, and authorizing the Mayor to sign the Final Decision document. 12. PLANNING COMMISSION OR ADMINISTRATIVE LAND USE ACTIONS - These are Planning Commission or Administrative Land Use actions that may be called up by the City Council. None. 13. CITY MANAGER'S REPORT 14. MAYOR AND COUNCIL REPORTS 15. EXECUTIVE SESSION None. 16. ADJOURNMENT July 14, 2026 Council Agenda Page iii COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES JUNE 22, 2026 DATE COUNCIL CHAMBERS, CITY HALL, CITY OF WOODBURN, COUNTY OF MARION, STATE OF OREGON, JUNE 22, 2026 CONVENED The meeting convened at 7:01 p.m. with Mayor Lonergan presiding. ROLL CALL Mayor Lonergan Present Councilor Cantu Present Councilor Cornwell Present Councilor Schaub Present Councilor Bravo Absent Councilor Grijalva Absent Councilor Wilk Present Staff Present: City Manager Derickson, City Attorney Granum, Assistant City Manager Row, Special Projects Director Wakeley, Police Chief Millican, Finance Director Turley, Community Services Director Cuomo, Public Affairs and Communications Manager Guerrero, Economic Development Director Johnk, Deputy Police Chief Shadrin, Lieutenant Nic Wilson, Sergeant Hershberger, Lieutenant Stewart, Community Relations Manager Herrera, Law Clerk Krueger, City Recorder Pierson ANNOUNCEMENTS Councilor Cantu made the following announcements: • The Woodburn School District Summer Meals Program will provide free meals for children ages 1-18 from June 22 through July 17, with both dine-in and grab-and-go meal locations available. • City Hall will be closed on Friday, July 3, in observance of Independence Day. The Library and Transit Services will be closed on Saturday, July 4. • The French Prairie Kiwanis Chuckwagon Breakfast will be held on July 4 from 7:00 a.m. to 10:00 a.m. at Legion Park, featuring an all-you-can-eat breakfast. Children ages 12 and under eat free. • The City's Independence Day Celebration will take place on July 4 from 5:30 p.m. to 10:30 p.m. at Centennial Park, featuring food vendors, live music, family activities, games, and a fireworks display. • The next City Council meeting will be held in conjunction with the Community Barbecue on Tuesday, July 14, at 6:00 p.m. at the Library, coinciding with Music in the Park. • The 10th Annual Community Connection Day and Kids Fest will be held on Saturday, August 1, from 10:00 a.m. to 2:00 p.m. at Legion Park, featuring family activities, entertainment, community resources, emergency vehicle displays, giveaways, and free backpacks and snacks while supplies last. PROCLAMATIONS: 43rd Annual National Night Out- Councilor Cornwell read a proclamation designating August 4, 2026, as the 43rd Annual National Night Out in the City of Woodburn. Page 1 - Council Meeting Minutes, June 22, 2026 1 COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES JUNE 22, 2026 Honoring The 250th Anniversary of the United States of America -Mayor Lonergan read a proclamation declaring the year 2026 as America's 250th Commemorative Year in the City of Woodburn and encouraged all residents to join in observances, celebrations, service projects, and moments of reflection that honor our nation's history, celebrate our present, and inspire our future. SWEARING-IN CEREMONY Police Chief Millican provided the Oath of Office to newly promoted Lieutenant Nic Wilson. Mayor Lonergan called for a 15-minute recess. BUSINESS FROM THE PUBLIC Jaime Rodriguez,Woodburn,requested that the City review parking and traffic management at St.Luke's Cemetery during high-attendance holidays to improve accessibility for seniors, individuals with disabilities, and other visitors paying their respects. He also submitted a letter for the record outlining his request. CONSENT AGENDA Before reading the consent agenda items, the City Recorder announced that Item G, Election Results, was being removed from the agenda because the County was providing a corrected version. A. Woodburn City Council minutes of June 8, 2026 B. Building Activity for May 2026 C. Traffic enforcement report—March through May 2026 D. Monthly Financial Report E. Ola Crab liquor license application F. Liquor License Application for La Casa De Los Machetes LLC. H. Utility Assistance Program Agreement—Funding for FY26-27 Motion: Schaub/Cornwell... approve the consent agenda as presented. The Motion passed with the following vote: Councilors Cantu, Schaub, Cornwell, and Wilk voting"aye." [4-0] PUBLIC HEARINGS Taxicab Application Appeal, Martha Monroy Mayor Lonergan declared the hearing open at 7:38 p.m. for the purpose of hearing public input on the Taxicab Application Appeal, Martha Monroy. Mayor Lonergan asked if there were any declarations from the Council. There were none. Finance Director Turley and Deputy Police Chief Shadrin presented a staff report, explaining that although the taxi license application had previously been approved in 2023, a subsequent review during renewal of her application identified a driver's license suspension within the 10-year look-back period required by the current taxi ordinance. As a result, staff determined the renewal application had to be denied. Staff noted that the ordinance contains an inconsistency, as other serious driving offenses have a five-year look-back period and recommended amending the ordinance to make it consistent. Page 2 - Council Meeting Minutes, June 22, 2026 2 COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES JUNE 22, 2026 City Attorney Granum advised that the current denial was consistent with the existing ordinance and recommended that the license not be reinstated until the ordinance could be amended to address the inconsistency and reduce potential liability to the City. Ms. Monroy was given the opportunity to address Council and chose to rely on her written appeal,which was entered into the official record. Mayor Lonergan asked if any member of the public wished to speak in support or in opposition. Michelle Underwood, Salem, spoke in support of Ms. Monroy, requesting consideration of a temporary or provisional license due to the financial hardship caused by the denial. Mayor Lonergan closed the hearing at 7:56 p.m. Councilors discussed the appeal, the current ordinance requirements, potential ordinance amendments, and options for addressing the matter moving forward. City Attorney Granum noted that an emergency provision could be added to the ordinance to allow the changes to take effect immediately and that, as long as the application submitted met the remaining requirements of the ordinance, the license could be issued the day after Council approved the ordinance. Councilors expressed support for this approach. Motion: Schaub/Wilk... affirm the denial of the taxi license renewal application for Martha Monroy and direct staff to prepare a final decision with findings to be signed by the Mayor. The Motion passed with the following vote: Councilors Cantu, Schaub, Cornwell, and Wilk voting"aye." [4-0] Motion: Schaub/Wilk... direct staff to prepare modifications of the taxi ordinance in line with the council's discussion to be brought at the next city council meeting. The Motion passed with the following vote: Councilors Cantu, Schaub, Cornwell, and Wilk voting"aye." [4-0] COUNCIL BILL NO. 3306 - A RESOLUTION ESTABLISHING COUNCIL OBJECTIVES & BENCHMARKS FOR ANY FUTURE AMENDMENT OF THE WOODBURN URBAN GROWTH BOUNDARY PURSUANT TO HOUSE BILL 4035 (2026) Schaub introduced Council Bill No. 3306. City Recorder Pierson read the bill by title only since there were no objections. City Manager Derickson provided a staff report. City Attorney Granum noted that a revised resolution has been placed in front of Council and reviewed the revisions made to the resolution. She noted that the language was updated to clarify the document is a policy directive establishing Council's objectives for future UGB expansion applications under the House Bill. She added that additional revisions clarify the affordable housing language to establish Council's expectations regarding the incorporation and dispersal of affordable housing throughout a development site. On roll call vote for final passage, the bill passed unanimously with: Councilors Cantu, Schaub, Cornwell, and Wilk voting"aye." [4-0] Page 3 - Council Meeting Minutes, June 22, 2026 3 COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES JUNE 22, 2026 Mayor Lonergan declared Council Bill No. 3306 duly passed. AWARD OF CONTRACT FOR ON-CALL CCTV SEWER INSPECTION SERVICES Public Works Director Stultz provided a staff report. Motion: Schaub/Cantu... Award the contract for On-Call CCTV Sewer Inspection Services to the highest ranked proposer, Pacific Int-R-Tek. The Motion passed with the following vote: Councilors Cantu, Schaub, Cornwell, and Wilk voting"aye." [4-0] LEASING SPECIALISTS, LLC. CONTRACT AWARD Deputy Police Chief Shadrin provided a staff report. Motion: Schaub/Cornwell... award a police vehicle contract in the amount of 301,793.21(Total estimated contract price over the next four years) to Leasing Specialists, LLC., with an additional contingency of$30,000 authorized to account for increases in the final outfitting costs and financing of the vehicles and authorize the signing of a contract with AXON Enterprise, Inc, to add Fleet 3 dash cams to be included in the vehicle outfitting contract lease and authorize the City Manager or their designee to sign the vehicle lease agreement with Leasing Specialists, LLC., and AXON Enterprise, Inc Fleet 3 dash cam contract. The Motion passed with the following vote: Councilors Cantu, Schaub, Cornwell, and Wilk voting"aye." [4-0] COUNCIL BRIEFING OF STAFF APPROVAL OF A TYPE II DESIGN REVIEW AND STREET ADJUSTMENT APPLICATION PACKAGE FOR "LINCOLN STREET APARTMENTS" AT 1283 E LINCOLN STREET (DR 24-07 & SA 24-06) The Council declined to call this item up. CITY MANAGER'S REPORT The City Manager reported the following: • 36 participants took part in the Front Street Dessert Walk on Friday. • New student artwork is on display at the Bungalow Theater and Museum. • Staff is preparing a "Be Responsible with Fireworks" public information campaign as part of the Good Neighbor program to encourage the safe and responsible use of legal fireworks, proper disposal and extinguishment of fireworks, and fire prevention awareness during the holiday celebrations. MAYOR AND COUNCIL REPORTS Mayor Lonergan questioned whether Council wants to take another look at possibly banning fireworks or having restrictions. He also noted that the dessert walk was a very well thought out event. Councilor Schaub gave a shout out to public works for the paving on the streets and wished everyone a Page 4 - Council Meeting Minutes, June 22, 2026 4 COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES JUNE 22, 2026 safe Fourth of July. Councilor Cornwell announced that Fiesta Mexicana will be held August 21-23, and she hopes to have the Fiesta Court visit an upcoming Council meeting. She added that the book sale was well attended and shared that the food bank mural is being installed. City Manager Derickson noted that The University of Oregon will no longer sponsor Fiesta. However, Western Oregon University has stepped in as a chief sponsor. Councilor Cantu reported that she and 20 others would represent the City at the All-America City Awards in Denver and wished everyone a safe Fourth of July and to act responsible. Councilor Wilk noted that he would like to look at possible restrictions on fireworks at some point. He also expressed excitement about Woodburn's All-America City nomination and appreciated the City's statement recognizing the mural's significance and the contributions of farm workers. ADJOURNMENT Motion: Cornwell/Schaub... move to adjourn. The Motion passed with the following vote: Councilors Cornwell, Cantu, Schaub, and Wilk voting"aye." [4-0] Mayor Lonergan adjourned the meeting at 8:35 p.m. APPROVED FRANK LONERGAN, MAYOR ATTEST Heather Pierson, City Recorder City of Woodburn, Oregon Page 5 - Council Meeting Minutes, June 22, 2026 5 /ii - /rr' /p a�r�i r Marion County, Oregon %//r / r a atll�/k �f lsr q r � / � dril i r�i�r�N�r�i�irrl/pf�,/�/ %r/�/i/�//�/�////` d / / / � /j/�(////✓,i/G%//irrri%/%i!//rj Gubernatorial Primary Election I. I � j �3 '{//���/YY ��/f�'%i////I 11/ /I/�j//i//�/'�/irlf%/�/i/�//�//ice%( r/rr✓� / i r //F,ri /�� / �r�/r/�r�/%kY�f��i�@trr�,/(% f�a�r � ��r( U��///✓//////r. /Oi l/i r / �i"r, 5/19/2026 Page 1 24-522 - City of Woodburn - Non Partisan Precincts Voters i Counted Total Percent Ballots ;Registered Percent 7 7 100,00% 4,796 15,474 30.99% Choice Party Vote by Mail Total YES 1,690 36.34% 1,690 36.34% NO 2,960 63.66% 2,960 63.66% Cast Votes: 4,650 100.00% 4,650 100.00% Undervotes: 141 141 Overvotes: 5 5 *** End of report*** I certify that the votes recorded on this abstract correctly summarize the tally of votes cast at the May 19, 2026 Primary Iection. JV4fl '° ' June 11 2026 e / wh gnatu e-6K ounty Clerk Date of Abstract Bill Bur ess 6 Marion County,Oregon Gubernatorial Primary Election r 5/19/2026 4 if 24-522-City of Woodburn-NonPartisan U 9 V is > D O b 0 _ > Z Z N o O E Precinct Z U D o >o I 11 815 220 307 527 22 0 549 549 2,328 23.58% 825 141 270 411 6 1 418 418 1,858 22.50% 835 235 439 674 20 0 694 694 2,169 32.00% 837 7 12 19 1 0 20 20 48 41.67% 845 424 928 1,352 49 3 1,404 1,404 3,033 46.29% 855 493 754 1,247 30 1 1,278 1,278 3,993 32.01% 865 170 250 420 13 0 433 433 2,045 21.17% Totals 1,690 2,960 4,650 141 5 4,796 4,796 15,474 30.99% certify that the votes recorded on this abstract �a, i rods correctly summarize the tally of votes cast at the : I/ ' May 19, 2026 Prima lection. �� ' June 11, 2026 µ p flt dig -turd f Co- my Clerk Date of Abstract Bill Bur ess 7 City of Woodburn New Development Activity June-'26 New Single Family New Total Home Residential Building Commercial Building Housing Month Permits Permits Permit Valuation Permit Valuation Total Permit Valuation Units June'20 53 18 $ 3,830,226 $ 4,063,834 $ 8,070,529 18 June'21 90 29 $ 7,407,870 $ 2,783,366 $ 10,378,952 53 June'22 80 7 $ 2,430,429 $ 8,723,439 $ 11,697,379 91 June'23 118 10 $ 2,369,945 $ 2,670,653 $ 9,060,450 10 June'24 95 22 $ 6,815,553 $11,398,860 $ 19,307,915 22 June'25 54 11 $ 3,667,550 $ 354,620 $ 4,318,273 11 June'26 68 20 $ 7,120,337 $ 8,079,221 $ 15,881,747 65 Fiscal Year Totals(July'25-June'26) 2019-2020 447 56 $ 13,358,341 $ 38,754,214 $ 56,098,631 56 2020-2021 745 207 $ 53,528,913 $ 23,136,728 $ 83,281,553 327 2021-2022 937 241 $ 72,548,523 $ 506,799,260 $ 604,623,350 665 2022-2023 903 68 $ 23,759,732 $ 87,408,784 $ 123,082,344 410 2023-2024 835 129 $ 44,181,553 $ 76,819,590 $ 128,047,536 475 2024-2025 893 317 $ 109,160,267 $ 65,518,023 $ 181,093,055 496 2025-2026 755 250 $ 77,135,020 $ 47,121,777 $ 130,784,842 276 *Mechanical,demolition,alarm,and sprinkler permits not included in this report. July-June New Housing Units 500 475 X496 �4"1I.G 4010 12w7 200 '7.7'6 200 C7 I U 20191 2020 202D-2021 22V2Ji 2:2122 202..2-2023 271i'.�3..::7)2q 22025 2U2202 July June Total Permits 1.{VI:VI7 X37 903 3lI:VI7 .35 800 74 755 l;l 2YJ1212YJ ..020-2021 2:021•2022 2022-2023 2(12:9-2'014 2024.2)25 202Yi-2G...2.I 8 WWODBURN In orarn reA 188 ______ A July 14, 2026 TO: Honorable Mayor and City Council through City Manager FROM: Tony Turley, Finance Director Andy Shadrin, Deputy Chief of Police SUBJECT: An Ordinance Amending Ordinance 2464 (Regulation of Taxicabs; Taxicab Drivers; Taxicab Companies), modifying the requirements for the issuance of a taxicab driver permit RECOMMENDATION: Adopt an Ordinance amending Ordinance 2464 (Taxicab Regulation), thereby modifying the requirements for the issuance of a taxicab driver permit by reducing the lookback period for a prior suspension of driving privileges from ten (10) years to five (5) years. BACKGROUND: In 2010, the Council adopted Ordinance 2464, establishing the regulations for taxicabs, taxicab drivers, and taxicab companies. Under Ordinance 2464, Section 9, the City set out a taxicab driver permit application and screening process. More specifically under that subsection E(6), the Ordinance included certain applicant driver-history preclusions, including that a taxicab driver permit could not be issued if the applicant's driving privileges were suspended or revoked due to a driving-related incident in any jurisdiction in the ten (10) years preceding the filing of the driver's initial application. The provisions of Section 9 of the Ordinance, regulating driver application and screening procedures, has not been reviewed or updated since the original adoption of the Ordinance. When taxi drivers submit a permit application to the City, the applications are accepted and processed first through the Finance Department and then the police department completes a driving history search through the Law Enforcement Data System (LEDS). Agenda Item Review: City Manager_x City Attorney_x_ Finance_x_ 9 Honorable Mayor and City Council July 14, 2026 Page 2 Recently, the City processed and denied the renewal for a driver's permit when it was discovered that the driver had a prior license suspension that would have made them ineligible for their initial permit under Section 9, subsection E(6). When the City then informed Applicant that their permit could not be renewed, the Applicant subsequently filed an appeal on June 4, 2026, and was heard in front of City Council on June 22, 2026. At the June 22, 2026, City Council hearing, Staff acknowledged that it had approved the subject Applicant's initial permit in error, but due to restrictions under the current Ordinance, it was still required to deny the permit renewal. Staff informed City Council that it may overturn the Finance Director's decision; however, staff recommended against such action because of the plain language reading of the ordinance and the potential liability risks toward the City in making an individualized waiver. Instead, staff recommended that City Council consider directing staff to modify provisions of the ordinance to align the driver history standards with a consistent 5-year lookback period DISCUSSION: The City Council directed staff to amend the provisions of the ordinance to modify the lookback period for driver suspensions, from ten (10) years to five (5) years. City Council, wishing to help the Applicant quickly, also directed staff to prepare the ordinance amendment with an emergency provision which will allow for the approval of the Applicant's permit immediately following ordinance passage. The proposed amendment is intended to create greater consistency for the permitting requirements within the ordinance itself and will allow for the Applicant to be eligible for a taxicab driver permit. Staff recommends the following modification to the Taxicab Regulation Ordinance (shown in bold underline below): Section 9. Taxicab Driver Permits Required - Application Process & Requirements. E. Age, Criminal History, Driving History and Insurability Requirements. Applicants for Taxicab Permit may not be issued a permit if any of the following conditions exist: . . 4. During the 5-year period preceding the submission of the application, the applicant has: 10 Honorable Mayor and City Council July 14, 2026 Page 3 a. Been convicted of any traffic crime, including but not limited to: Driving under the Influence of Intoxicants, Reckless Driving, Attempt to Elude a Police Officer, or Failure to Perform the Duties of a Driver; b. Been convicted of misdemeanor theft; or c. Had driving privileges suspended or revoked by any governing jurisdiction as a result of a driving-related incident. FINANCIAL IMPACT: No financial impact is anticipated from City Council's decision. Attachment: • Ordinance No. 2464- Taxicab Regulation (Redline) 11 COUNCIL BILL NO. 2816 ORDINANCE NO. 2464 AN ORDINANCE PROVIDING FOR THE REGULATION OF TAXICABS; TAXICAB DRIVERS; TAXICAB COMPANIES; AND SETTING AN EFFECTIVE DATE WHEREAS, the Woodburn Charter provides that the City shall have all powers which the constitutions, statutes, and laws of the United States and of Oregon expressly or impliedly grant; and WHEREAS, the above referenced grant of power has been interpreted as affording the City all legislative power under the home rule provisions of the Oregon Constitution; and WHEREAS, it is the purpose of this Ordinance to require that those persons operating taxicabs do so in a safe, fair and efficient manner; and WHEREAS, the taxicab industry constitutes an important part of the City's transportation system, and transportation so fundamentally impacts the well- being of the City's citizens that some regulation is necessary to ensure that the public safety is protected, the public need provided for, and the public convenience promoted; and WHEREAS, the provisions contained herein should be applied and enforced in such a manner as to require the taxicab industry to regulate itself, under City supervision, to promote innovation and adaption to changing needs, and respond to economics of the marketplace, so long as the public interest is served, NOW, THEREFORE, THE CITY OF WOODBURN ORDAINS AS FOLLOWS: Section 1. Definitions A. Certified Mechanic. A mechanic who meets all the following criteria: 1 . Does not own, lease or drive a Taxicab; 2. Has no financial interest in any Taxicab Company operating within the State of Oregon; 3. Has received ASE (Automotive Service Excellence) A Series (Automobile/Light Truck Certification) master certification; and PAGE 1 - COUNCIL BILL NO. 2816 ORDINANCE NO. 2464 12 4. Is not employed by any Taxicab Company. B. City Recorder. The City of Woodburn City Recorder or designee. C. Driver. Any person operating Taxicabs as a Driver for any Taxicab Company regardless of whether the vehicles so operated are owned by the company, leased, or owned by individual members of the company. D. Finance Director. The City of Woodburn Finance Director or designee. E. Flat Rate. A rate that remains constant regardless of the distance traveled or the time involved. F. Operate. To drive a Taxicab, to use a Taxicab in the conduct of business, to receive money from the use of a Taxicab, or cause or allow another person to do the same. G. Person. Any individual, partnership, trust, estate, corporation, or other form of business organization recognized by Oregon law. H. Police Chief. The City of Woodburn Chief of Police or designee. I. Taxicab. Any motor vehicle used for transportation for hire where the destination and route traveled may be controlled by a passenger and the fare is calculated on the basis of any combination of an initial fee, distance traveled, waiting time, or a flat fee except for an accessible vehicle, ambulance, limousine, medical transport vehicle, shuttle or tour bus. For purposes of this section, the following definitions shall apply: a) "Accessible vehicle" means any motor vehicle constructed and equipped for the non-emergency transportation of persons in wheelchairs, persons using other mobility aids, or with other mobility impairments. b) "Ambulance" means any motor vehicle constructed and equipped for the emergency transportation of persons because of or in connection with their illness, injury or disability. c) "Limousine" means any luxury class motor vehicle that is operated for hire on a reserved, hourly basis. d) "Medical transport vehicle" means any motor vehicle constructed and equipped for the non-emergency transportation of persons in connection with their illness, injury or disability. e) "Shuttle" means any motor vehicle for hire that transports passengers between predetermined destinations (e.g., motels and airports), at fixed rates, and on a fixed schedule. PAGE 2 - COUNCIL BILL NO. 2816 ORDINANCE NO. 2464 13 f) "Tour bus" means a motor vehicle accepting individual passengers for a fare for sightseeing or guided tours, making occasional stops at certain points of interest and returning the passengers to the point of origin. J. Taxicab Company. Any person that operates Taxicabs other than only as a Driver that either has its primary place of business within the city limits, or regularly conducts business within the City, regardless of whether the vehicles so operated are owned by the company, leased, or owned by individual members of the company. K. Taxicab Company Permit. A permit issued under this Ordinance to operate a Taxicab Company. L. Taxicab Driver Permit. A permit issued by the City that the Driver is authorized to operate a Taxicab under this Ordinance. M. Translink Provider. A business or company that has been approved as a provider of transportation services by the federal government by meeting federal standards and receipt of a certificate evidencing such compliance. N. Taximeter. A mechanical or electronic device which calculates and displays a fare based on an initial fee, distance traveled, waiting time, or any combination thereof. Section 2. Taxicab Company Permit Required - Exemptions A. No Person shall operate any Taxicab Company in the City of Woodburn without possessing, in addition to any license required by any other law, a valid Taxicab Company Permit issued pursuant to this Ordinance. A Taxicab Company Permit may not be sold, assigned, mortgaged or otherwise transferred. B. Exemptions to Taxicab Company Permit Requirement. 1 . Public Transportation provided and funded in whole or in part by public organizations shall be exempt from the permit requirements of this Ordinance. 2. Certified Translink Providers that show proof of such certification to the City. PAGE 3 - COUNCIL BILL NO. 2816 ORDINANCE NO. 2464 14 Section 3. Taxicab Company Permit Applications - Issuance A. Application Requirements. An applicant for a Taxicab Company Permit must submit to the Finance Director: 1 . Proof of registration with the Secretary of State for any corporate, LLC or LLP entity; 2. Proof of registration with the Secretary of State for any assumed business name, along with a listing of the registrant of such; 3. The business name, business address and residence address and telephone numbers of the applicant; 4. A list of any misdemeanor or felony convictions of the owner(s) and officers of the Taxicab Company; 5. The name of the person who will be responsible for and who will oversee the day-to-day operations of the Taxicab Company; 6. The make, type, year of manufacture, VIN number, and seating capacity of each vehicle that will be operated as a Taxicab under the Taxicab Company Permit; 7. A description of the proposed color scheme, name, monogram or insignia that will be used on the Taxicabs; 8. A nonrefundable application fee in the amount of $120. B. Insurance Certificate. No Taxicab Company Permit will be issued unless the Taxicab Company provides to the Finance Director a Certificate of Insurance indicating that the insurance requirements of Section 8 of this Ordinance have been satisfied. C. Inspection Certificate. No Taxicab Company Permit will be issued unless the Taxicab Company provides to the Finance Director an Inspection Certificate from a Certified Mechanic as provided in Section 7 of this Ordinance. D. Issuance of Permit. The Finance Director will issue a Taxicab Company Permit upon finding that the applicant has met the requirements of this Ordinance. E. External display of permit. Each Taxicab operated by a Taxicab Company shall prominently display on the exterior of the Taxicab a sticker issued by the City indicating that the permit requirements of this Ordinance have been met. PAGE 4 - COUNCIL BILL NO. 2816 ORDINANCE NO. 2464 15 Section 4. Annual Taxicab Company Permit Renewal. Taxicab Company Permits shall be renewed upon submission of an annual permit fee in the amount of $100. Section 5. Equipment Every Taxicab is to be equipped with the following: A. Except for a Taxicab charging a flat rate, a Taximeter that meets the requirements of this Ordinance. B. A Taxicab charging a flat rate must be equipped with a sign that states "Flat Rate" and specifies the rate. C. A top light identifying it as a Taxicab. D. The company name and telephone number where service can be requested displayed on the exterior of the Taxicab. E. A cell phone or taxi radio dispatching calls for service. F. A current copy of the Taxicab Company Permit with the approved vehicle's Vehicle Identification Number (VIN). G. A notice providing information necessary to file a complaint under this Ordinance. Section 6. Taximeter Requirements. A. Every Taxicab, except for a Taxicab charging a Flat Rate, must be equipped with a Taximeter in accurate operating condition, with a lighted face that can easily be read at all times by the passenger. B. Every Taximeter must be inspected by a certified taximeter installer and certified at installation, at change in rate, and within 1 year of the last inspection. A certificate of inspection must be issued by a qualified Taximeter repair service upon each inspection. A copy of the certificate of inspection must remain in the Taxicab. C. Certificates of inspection must include: 1 . The identifying number of the Taximeter; PAGE 5 - COUNCIL BILL NO. 2816 ORDINANCE NO. 2464 16 2. The make, model and license number of the Taxicab in which the Taximeter is installed; 3. The name of the Taxicab Company; 4. The date of inspection; 5. A statement that the Taximeter has been inspected and approved and that its readings are accurate; and 6. The signature of the individual making the certification. D. A Taxicab Company must keep on file copies of all certificates of inspection of Taximeters. E. Taximeters must operate within the following limits of accuracy: Plus or minus 50 feet in 1 mile and 1 second in 1 minute of waiting time. F. Certificates of inspection may be examined by the City at any time during normal business hours. G. All Taximeters must be approved by the National Type Evaluation Program (NTEP) as evidenced by a "Certificate of Conformance" issued by an authorized inspector. All Taximeters must have an active NTEP Certificate of Conformance number. Section 7. Inspection and Maintenance of Taxicabs A. Prior to the issuance of a Taxicab Company Permit, and annually thereafter, each Taxicab shall be examined and inspected by either a Certified Mechanic and shall be found to be in safe operating condition. B. Every Taxicab must have proof of its annual inspection in the vehicle. Proof of the inspection shall be submitted to the Finance Director on an annual basis. Section 8. Taxicab Insurance Requirements. A. Coverages and Limits: All Taxicab Company Permit holders must obtain, comply with, and maintain the minimum levels of insurance coverage outlined below during the entire term that the Taxicab Company Permit is valid: 1 . Commercial Business Insurance_Taxicab Company Permit holders must secure and maintain a Commercial General Liability policy reflecting limits PAGE 6 - COUNCIL BILL NO. 2816 ORDINANCE NO. 2464 17 of no less than $1,000,000 per Occurrence and $2,000,000 Aggregate for covered claims arising out of, but not limited to, Bodily Injury, Property Damage, Personal Injury, and Contractual Liability in the course of the policy holder's work under the Taxicab Company Permit. 2. Vehicle Insurance. All Taxicab Company Permit holders, regardless of whether the company holds title to a vehicle or not, must provide the City with a copy of a valid Commercial Auto Liability policy reflecting a Combined Single Limit of not less than $500,000 per occurrence for claims arising out of, but not limited to, bodily injury and property damage incurred in the course of the vehicle's use as a Taxicab. The Commercial Auto Liability policy must comply with the mandatory laws of the State of Oregon and/or other applicable governing bodies. 3. Worker's Compensation and Employers Liability Insurance. The Taxicab Company Permit holder must secure and maintain a Workers Compensation and Employers Liability policy where required by state law. 4. The Commercial General Liability and Commercial Auto Liability coverage must name the City and its officers, agents and employees as additional insureds as respects to claims, in the course of the policy holder's work as a Taxicab Company. 5. The insurance limits are subject to statutory changes as to maximum limits of liability imposed on municipalities of the State of Oregon during the permit's term. 6. The insurance policy must allow for written notice to the Finance Director 30 days before any policy is canceled, will expire, or be reduced in coverage. Section 9. Taxicab Driver Permits Required - Application Process & Requirements. A. Permit Required. No person may drive a Taxicab that regularly conducts business in the City without a Taxicab Driver Permit issued under this Ordinance. B. Application Documents Required. Applicants for a Taxicab Driver Permit must submit to the Finance Director the items listed below. The failure to submit any of the items listed will result in a denial of the permit: 1 . A completed application on a form approved by the Finance Director; PAGE 7 - COUNCIL BILL NO. 2816 ORDINANCE NO. 2464 18 2. A copy of the applicant's current driver's license; 3. A copy of the applicant's non-Oregon driving record for any year in which the applicant was not a resident of Oregon during the last 10 years, regardless of the jurisdiction; and 4. A copy of the applicant's criminal history; and 5. A set of the applicant's fingerprints; and 6. If necessary, any information that reasonably relates to the application or is a clarification of information provided to the Finance Director. C. Photographs. Applicants will be photographed by the City upon submittal of the Taxicab Driver Permit application. The photograph then becomes a part of the applicant's submittal package. D. Fees Required. Applicants must submit a nonrefundable application fee in the amount of $105. E. Age, Criminal History, Driving History and Insurability Requirements. Applicants for a Taxicab Permit may not be issued a permit if any of the following conditions exist: 1 . The applicant has been convicted of any felony in the 10 years preceding the submission of the application; 2. The applicant has been convicted of any misdemeanor involving assault, sex crimes, drugs, prostitution or weapons in the 10 years preceding the submission of the application; 3. The applicant has a felony conviction involving physical harm or attempted physical harm to a person, regardless of when the conviction occurred; 4. During the 5-year period preceding the submission of the application, the applicant a. traffic crime, including but not limited to: Driving under the Influence of Intoxicants, Reckless Driving, Attempt to Elude a Police Officer, or Failure to Perform the Duties of a Driver; Ef b. Ili , r�� c ( ir�� iic � ���' ir mr�isdemeanor theft;. PAGE 8 - COUNCIL BILL NO. 2816 ORDINANCE NO. 2464 19 ( rrfiiiR f�) r.� « l 11.11 w5577-.. iFeGf sir IhGF� f V SeFiG �s 1F:: 11f ,... f� f q:.ii. �� ( s ww .:�,.sa 11 1: � `, ��. s •�':i\4 �I IF)Fjvfleg s...`Is ar ;.su ,'F a)&(Je( ...� r � ,.V()ke ,��y ��y �: v a�ir:lfir�I J�::JFiiS4G14G GI s iFeil k)f f ( f G (JFfs4� ..iY'e fe(J iii GkJ&r f.®.. p. The applicant has more than three traffic violations of any kind within the previous 12 months from the date of the application; 1f� 'm. The applicant does not have at least 2 years' worth of continuous driving experience in a United States jurisdiction immediately prior to the date of the application's submission; . The applicant is less than 21 years old; or 1 u. The applicant is unable to obtain car insurance for any reason. Section 10. Issuance of Taxicab Driver Permit; Term; Replacements. A. After an application for a Taxicab Driver Permit is submitted, the Police Chief will provide to the Finance Director a written investigation based upon the requirements of this Ordinance. B. Issuance and Fees. If an applicant submits the required documents and otherwise satisfies all conditions and requirements of this Ordinance, the Finance Director will issue a Taxicab Driver Permit. PAGE 9 - COUNCIL BILL NO. 2816 ORDINANCE NO. 2464 20 C. Permit Requirements: A Taxicab Driver Permit must: 1 . Contain the permit number, permit expiration date, the driver's name and the driver's photograph; 2. Be posted in a prominent place within the Taxicab; and 3. Be inside the vehicle and available for inspection by any customer, passenger, police officer or designated City employee. D. Term. A Taxicab Driver Permit is valid for a period of 12 months from the date of issuance and must be renewed upon expiration. E. Replacements. If a driver's permit is lost, damaged or stolen, the Finance Director will issue a replacement permit for a fee in the amount of $25. Section 11. Taxicab Driver Permit Renewals; Consequences of Failure to Renew. A. Taxicab Driver Permits must be renewed every 12 months from the date of issuance. B. The following information and the renewal fee must be submitted to the Finance Director no less than 30 days prior to the renewal date: 1 . Updated file information if any information in the original application has changed; 2. Payment of the renewal fee of $55. C. A Taxicab Driver Permit will not be renewed if the driver fails to satisfy any condition that would have been grounds to deny the initial permit, including any criminal activity or driving crimes/violations. D. If a driver fails to timely pay the permit renewal fee or timely provide the renewal information required by this Ordinance, the Taxicab Driver Permit expires and becomes void. A voided Taxicab Driver Permit requires the former permittee to file an initial permit application and pay all necessary fees required by this Ordinance to obtain a valid Taxicab Driver Permit. Section 12. Operating Regulations of Taxicab Companies and Drivers A. Taxicab Companies. A Taxicab Company shall not: PAGE 10 - COUNCIL BILL NO. 2816 ORDINANCE NO. 2464 21 1 . Allow any Taxicab to be driven that has not been inspected and properly permitted, or 2. Allow a person to operate a Taxicab that does not have a valid Taxicab Driver Permit issued pursuant to this Ordinance. B. Drivers. A Driver shall not: 1 . Transport a passenger to his destination by any other than the most direct route, unless requested to do so by the passenger; 2. Fail to give a correct receipt upon payment of the correct fare if requested to do so by the passenger; 3. Permit additional persons to occupy or ride in the Taxicab without consent of the original passenger; 4. Unreasonably refuse to transport to a requested destination any passenger who requests services and is able to demonstrate the ability and willingness to pay the fare; 5. Charge a fare higher than the posted rates, or try to defraud a passenger in any way by manipulating devices to cause a registration to be made of a greater distance or more time; or 6. Operate a Taxicab in violation of any Oregon law. Section 13. Suspension or Revocation A. Any Permit under this Ordinance may be suspended or revoked by the Finance Director if after a reasonable investigation one or more of the following conditions exist: 1 . The Taxicab Company ceases to operate any Taxicab for a period of 15 consecutive days without obtaining permission for the cessation of such operation from the City. 2. The Taxicab Company and/or Driver fails to operate the Taxicab in accordance with the provisions of this Ordinance. 3. The Taxicab Company and/or Driver fails to pay any of the fees or payments required to be paid by the provisions of this Ordinance. PAGE 11 - COUNCIL BILL NO. 2816 ORDINANCE NO. 2464 22 4. The suspension or revocation is necessary to protect the public health, safety, and welfare. 5. The revocation or suspension is otherwise authorized by Ordinances of the city. B. Any suspension or revocation pursuant to this section shall be in writing, setting forth the reasons therefore and the right of appeal pursuant to this Ordinance. C. Except as provided below, any suspension or revocation shall be effective 10 days after mailing a copy thereof by first class United States mail addressed to the Taxicab Company and/or Driver at the business or residence address shown on the Permit application or renewal. D. Notwithstanding subsection (C) of this section, a suspension or revocation may be made effective immediately if the City finds reasonable grounds to believe that: 1 . A person holding a Taxicab Driver's Permit is not covered by liability insurance as required by this Ordinance, 2. A vehicle being operated as a Taxicab is not covered by liability insurance required by this Ordinance, or 3. Continued operation by the Taxicab Company or Taxicab Driver would cause, or is likely to cause, imminent danger to the public health, safety, or welfare. Section 14. Surrender of Certificate or Permit Any Permit suspended or revoked by the City shall be surrendered to the Finance Director and the operation of any Taxicab covered by said permit shall cease. Section 15. Rates A. Except for a Taxicab charging a Flat Rate, the rates to be charged to passengers are to be based on the factors of mileage from the point of origin to the point of destination by the most direct route, the time involved, and the number of passengers. No Taxicab may charge any fees or rates other than those that are posted. B. A clear and complete summary of a Taxicab Company's rate schedule shall be posted in a conspicuous place in the passenger compartment of every PAGE 12 - COUNCIL BILL NO. 2816 ORDINANCE NO. 2464 23 Taxicab. Every Taxicab Company shall provide the Finance Director with a copy this summary prior to posting them in the Taxicabs. C. Except for a Taxicab charging a Flat Rate, a summary of the meter rate in a form approved by the Finance Director shall be placed in a manner to be visible from the outside of every Taxicab. Section 16. Complaints A. Every Taxicab shall have posted in a prominent place within the passenger compartment a notice entitled "Complaints" providing the information necessary to file a complaint with the City and/or the Taxicab Company under this Ordinance. B. Every Taxicab Company shall maintain an Annual Log of all complaints it receives either in writing or by telephone. Each Annual Log shall be kept by the Taxicab Company for a period of five years and shall be available to the City upon request. Section 17. Appeals and Writ of Review A. Any Person aggrieved by a decision of the Finance Director under this Ordinance may appeal such action to the City Council by filing a written Notice of Appeal, accompanied by an appeal fee of $65 with the City Recorder within 10 days of the Finance Director's decision. B. Within 10 days of receiving the Notice of Appeal, the City Recorder will: 1 . Set a time for the appeal to be heard by the City Council; 2. Place the hearing of the appeal upon the Council agenda; and 3. Notify the aggrieved Person and the Finance Director of the time set no less than 10 days prior to that time. C. The aggrieved Person may appear personally, via a company representative, and/or by counsel and present such facts and arguments as may tend to support the appeal. D. The Finance Director will provide the City Council with a staff report outlining the decision and the reasons therefore. PAGE 13 - COUNCIL BILL NO. 2816 ORDINANCE NO. 2464 24 E. The City Council will uphold the Finance Director's decision, reverse it, or modify it with any conditions that the City Council deems appropriate. The City Council's final decision shall be in written and supported by findings. F. All final decisions by the City Council under this Ordinance shall be subject only to Writ of Review in the Marion County Circuit Court pursuant to ORS Chapter 34. Section 18. Violation - Penalty A. In addition to, and not in lieu of any other enforcement mechanisms, a violation of any provision of this Ordinance constitutes a Class 1 Civil Infraction and may be processed according to the procedures contained in the Woodburn Civil Infraction ordinance. B. Each day that a violation of this Ordinance is committed or permitted to continue shall constitute a separate Civil Infraction. C. The remedies provided for in this Section are cumulative and not mutually exclusive. Section 19. Severability. The sections and subsections of this Ordinance are severable. The invalidity of any section or subsection shall not affect the validity of the remaining sections and subsections. Section 20. Savings. The repeal of any ordinance by this Ordinance shall not preclude any action against any person who violated the ordinance prior to the effective date of this Ordinance. Section 21. Effective Date. This Ordinance is effective on October 1 , 2010. Approved as to form: City Attorney Date APPROVED: Mayor Passed by the Council: Submitted to the Mayor: Approved by the Mayor: Filed in the Office of the Recorder: PAGE 14 - COUNCIL BILL NO. 2816 ORDINANCE NO. 2464 25 ATTEST City Recorder City of Woodburn PAGE 15 - COUNCIL BILL NO. 2816 ORDINANCE NO. 2464 26 COUNCIL BILL NO. 3307 ORDINANCE NO. 2649 AN ORDINANCE AMENDING ORDINANCE NO. 2464 (REGULATION OF TAXICABS; TAXICAB DRIVERS; TAXICAB COMPANIES), MODIFYING THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE ISSUANCE OF A TAXICAB DRIVER PERMIT AND DECLARING AN EMERGENCY WHEREAS, on March 24, 2010, the Woodburn City Council adopted Ordinance 2464 establishing and providing for the regulation of taxicabs; taxicab drivers; and taxicab companies; and WHEREAS, Section 9 of the Ordinance specifies requirements for taxicab driver permitting, including an application and screening process; and WHEREAS, Section 9 (E)(6), required the City to deny issuing a Taxicab Permit if "[d]uring the 10-year period preceding the filing of the initial application, the applicant's driving privileges were suspended or revoked by any governing jurisdiction as a result of a driving-related incident"; and WHEREAS, the City Council has determined that a lookback period of five (5) years in lieu of ten (10) years is a more reasonable period of time, which also better aligns with the lookback period of other driver penalties within the current permitting requirements; and WHEREAS, regarding the lookback period for an applicant's prior suspension of driving privileges, a five (5) year lookback period is also more consistent with comparable cities to the City of Woodburn; NOW, THEREFORE, THE CITY OF WOODBURN ORDAINS AS FOLLOWS: Section 1. Section 9 (E) of Ordinance 2464 is amended to read as follows: Section 9. Taxicab Driver Permits Required - Application Process & Requirements. E. Age, Criminal History, Driving History and Insurability Requirements. Applicants for a Taxicab Permit may not be issued a permit if any of the following conditions exist: Page 1 Council Bill No. 3307 Ordinance No. 2649 27 4. During the 5-year period preceding the submission of the application, the applicant has: a. Been convicted of any traffic crime, including but not limited to: Driving under the Influence of Intoxicants, Reckless Driving, Attempt to Elude a Police Officer, or Failure to Perform the Duties of a Driver; b. Been convicted of misdemeanor theft; c. Had driving privileges suspended or revoked by any governing jurisdiction as a result of a driving-related incident; or d. Had greater than 10 traffic infractions as defined in ORS 801 .557; greater than five serious traffic violations as defined in ORS 801 .477; greater than five motor vehicle accidents that are required to be reported to the Oregon Department of Motor Vehicles pursuant to ORS 811 .720; or, greater than five of any combination of serious traffic violations or motor vehicle accidents as provided above. 5. The applicant has more than three traffic violations of any kind within the previous 12 months from the date of the application; 6. The applicant does not have at least 2 years' worth of continuous driving experience in a United States jurisdiction immediately prior to the date of the application's submission; 7. The applicant is less than 21 years old; or 8. The applicant is unable to obtain car insurance for any reason. Section 2. Emergency Clause. This ordinance being necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health, and safety because it is in the City's best interest to adopt reasonable regulations that allow taxicab drivers to receive their permits and local taxicab businesses to actually operate, an emergency is declared to exist and this ordinance shall take effect immediately upon passage by the Council and approval by the Mayor. Approved as to form: City Attorney Date Page 2 Council Bill No. 3307 Ordinance No. 2649 28 Approved: Frank Lonergan, Mayor Passed by the Council Submitted to the Mayor Approved by the Mayor Filed in the Office of the Recorder ATTEST: Heather Pierson, City Recorder City of Woodburn, Oregon Page 3 Council Bill No. 3307 Ordinance No. 2649 29 C WUN In cn r 1e armed 18 ' July 10, 2026 To: Honorable Mayor and City Council Through: Scott Derickson, City Manager From: Chris Kerr, Community Development Director <;t_:; Subject: Final Decision of an appeal of the Planning Commission approval of the WinCo Grocery Store (DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, VAR 25-06) Recommendation: Adopt the Final Decision approving the consolidated application package which includes a Design Review, Property Line Adjustment, Street Adjustment and Variances (3) to allow for the development of a WinCo Grocery Store located on Stacy Allison Way, south of Center Street, and authorizing the Mayor to sign the Final Decision document. Background: On June 8th, the City Council held a duly noticed public hearing and voted (unanimously) to tentatively approve with conditions the WinCo Grocery Store development and directed staff to return with a Final Decision with associated Findings for consideration and adoption. Attachment: 1 . City Council Final Decision Agenda Item Review: City Managerx City Attorney x Finance X 30 �, �� ✓,ei,�� �P C ors�,�,„3 � w Incur � ur47ry WooDBuRN 18'89 Final Decision City Council (Appeal) File number(s): DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal Project name: WinCo Grocery Store Date of decision: June 8, 2026 Applicant: Ryan Barnett, b.hills architecture, P.C. Property Owner: Capital Development Company Appellant: Protect Our Valley Alliance(POVA)c/o Attorney Andrew Mulkey Site location: 052W12C002100&052W12C002200;Generally located south of Center St.west of Evergreen Rd. Contents I. Introduction& Procedural History.....................................................................................................................2 II. General Facts .....................................................................................................................................................4 Ill. City Council Analysis and Findings.....................................................................................................................8 IV. City Council Supplemental Analysis and Findings....................................................................................... 65 V. Conditions of Approval.................................................................................................................................... 80 VI. Decision........................................................................................................................................................... 85 VII. Appeals............................................................................................................................................................ 85 VIII. Testifiers.......................................................................................................................................................... 86 IX. Exhibits............................................................................................................................................................ 89 DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 1 31 I. Introduction & Procedural History Proposal: The request is for a consolidated application package consisting of a Design Review, Property Line Adjustment, Street Adjustment and Variances (3). The Winco development site is approximately 10.6 acres. It is within the Commercial General (CG) zoning district. The proposal is for an 84,073 square foot retail grocery store to be open seven (7) days a week. Approval Criteria:The applicable approval criteria for the consolidated applications is as follows:Woodburn Development Ordinance (WDO) 2.03, 2.05, 2.06, 3.01, 3.02, 3.03, 3.04, 3.05, 3.06, 3.07, 3.10, 3.11,4.01, 4.02, 5.01.08, 5.03.02, 5.03.03, &5.03.12. Procedural History: • Woodburn Planning Commission Public Hearing: The Planning Commission held a public hearing on March 12, 2026. During the hearing, five people testified in favor of the project, stating that the project would bring much needed affordable groceries, eliminate the need to travel to WinCo in Tigard or Salem and generate new jobs. Proponents also mentioned that Woodburn's economy would benefit by having visitors and residents spend money in Woodburn, and the savings would increase their purchasing power. Opponents raised concerns about increased traffic, construction noises, diminishing property values and potential light and noise encroachment from the WinCo signs and the proposed bus stop. Additionally, staff received 34 written comments in favor of the project and 11 against it.The applicant also presented a social media post by WinCo that obtained 427 comments,the overwhelming majority in favor of the proposal. Based on the volume of testimony received, the applicant requested to keep the record open for 28 days until April 9 and the Planning Commission unanimously granted the extension. In accordance with ORS 197.797(6)(c) and (e), from April 10 to April 16 all parties had an opportunity to respond to any new evidence submitted during the 28- day open record period.Then from April 17 to April 23, the applicant had 7 days to provide final argument. On April 21, a procedural objection was raised by a group known as the Protect Our Valley Alliance("POVA"). The applicant submitted a response to the objection on April 23. At their April 23, 2026, Planning Commission meeting, after closure of the record, review and discussion of the procedural objection, the Commission did not find any procedural issues and proceeded with their deliberation.The Commission considered all oral and written arguments presented; including those submitted by both an opposition attorney/engineer as well as the applicant's attorney/engineer. The Commission deliberated and unanimously approved (6-0) the application package.The approval included the Design Review,the Property Line Adjustment, the three Variance requests, and Street Adjustment,with the conditions recommended by staff through the staff report published on March 5, as well as adding a new Finding reflecting the Planning Commission's conclusion that no procedural error occurred, and including two additional conditions. A comprehensive list of individuals who testified at the Planning Commission hearing can be found in Section VIII of this Final Decision.The Final Decision of the Planning DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 2 32 Commission was signed by Planning Commission Chair Lisa Ellsworth on April 23, 2026, and mailed on April 29, 2026. • Appeal: Type III decisions rendered by the Planning Commission are appealable to the City Council.The City Council's decision is the City's final decision maker. The Appellant, Protect our Valley Alliance and members ("POVA"; c/o Andrew Mulkey),filed a timely appeal by submitting a Notice of Intent to Appeal,which included each of the elements required by WDO 4.02.01.B.2., including a statement of the grounds for the appeal. Generally,the grounds included procedural errors, inadequate findings, and objections to the approved traffic analysis. • City Council Hearing: Notice of the Public hearing before the City Council on appeal of a land use decision by the Planning Commission was mailed on May 19, 2026, to all parties who signed in or participated before the close of the record of the Planning Commission Hearing. The City Council held a public hearing on the appeal on June 8, 2026. The meeting was held in person at Woodburn City Hall, 270 Montgomery Street, Woodburn, Oregon. The hearing was simultaneously held virtually. Per WDO 4.01.15,the City Council conducted the public hearing pertaining to the Type III quasi-judicial hearing procedure, proceeding in the following general order: (i) staff report; (ii) applicant's presentation; (iii)testimony in favor of the application; (iv)testimony in opposition to the application (with appellant permitted to testify and present its argument first); (v) rebuttal by the applicant; (vi) record closes; and (v) deliberation and decision. While the WDO standard for appeal hearing notices provides that the notice shall include the following statement, "the appeal hearing is confined to the issues raised in the notice of appeal" (WDO 4.02.01.C.7); the Council interprets that provision to be limited in application to the notice itself and not to any restriction on evidence that may be admitted during the appeal hearing. Furthermore, per WDO 4.01.16.E.2-3,the City Council did not limit the appeal hearing to an "on-the-record" hearing, but rather conducted a de novo hearing, permitting the applicant and other parties an opportunity to "present testimony, arguments, and evidence on applicable criteria," and permitting the discussion of issues beyond those raised in the notice of appeal. City Council heard testimony from the Applicant,Appellant, and then from numerous individuals. The table in Section VIII of this Final Decision lists those who provided testimony to City Council. The Applicant was also provided an opportunity for rebuttal. Following the testimony and closure of the record, a motion was made to (i) Affirm the Planning Commission's approval with all conditions;and (ii) directing Staff to prepare a final land use decision for consideration at the next available council meeting. The motion was seconded. A vote was taken and City Council voted 6-0 passing the motion. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 3 33 At their July 14, 2026, meeting, the City Council considered the final land use decision with findings and approved it unanimously. II. General Facts Applications The project site includes two vacant properties near the 1-5 interchange, south of Center Street and west of Evergreen Road, and totals approximately 10.6 acres.The site is within the Commercial General (CG) zoning district with an IMA overlay.The proposal was for an 84,073 square foot retail grocery store. �, JI SSw f )i un � C1��4F.f7�i4 Project Site (outlined in red) DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 4 34 S,rncrs MLLASON WAY iitiiitiii u . W1,NC O EC.NODS S 1 ORE. PS Y w r r k Y Ni 0 fllhft NRD Illustrative Site Plan The front of the building faces west towards 1-5. Access will be from two driveways on Stacy Allison Way, one on Evergreen Rd. and another through a future, currently undeveloped lot along Center St. Parking spaces for 504 vehicles will wrap around the west and south side of the building.Trucks will enter through the southernmost driveway on Stacy Allison Way. A truck dock is proposed on the south side of the building with loading bay doors facing the freeway to minimize any impacts of trucks on the adjacent residential properties. An existing block wall at the Cascade Meadow Apartments and 30-foot-high trees screen this development from the apartment complex to the south. Several public improvements are proposed to alleviate traffic concerns and to promote pedestrian/transit users. To facilitate pedestrian access, wide walkways are provided from Stacy Allison Way and Evergreen Rd to the building entrance. The applicant will also build a pedestrian crossing at the intersection of Evergreen Rd and Oxford Dr featuring a rectangular rapid flashing beacon (RRFB). The developer will install a bus stop shelter on Evergreen Rd to serve a recently implemented bus route. In accordance with the adopted Transportation System Plan, the City will also be using the fees paid by the applicant to complete the design and construction of new traffic signals at both Evergreen Rd & Stacy Allison and Evergreen Rd & Hayes St; additionally, a roundabout will be completed at the intersection of Evergreen Rd and Harvard St. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 5 35 Front Elevation Rendering The applicant also submitted variance applications, which is the process for applicants to request to deviate from certain code provisions. In this case, the applicant is requesting to deviate from three requirements in the WDO summarized below(these are discussed in greater detail in the attached Analyses and Findings): 1. Reducing the number of Electric Vehicle (EV) parking spaces: The WDO requires 5 percent of the required parking stalls to be minimum Level 2 EV charging spaces, which for this project would be 17 EV stalls.The applicant requested to reduce this requirement to provide eight Level 3 chargers.To support this, the applicant included a letter from Tesla stating that Level 3 chargers are 20x faster than Level 2 chargers and can be used by all EV brands. The applicant indicated that eight EV stalls would meet the charging demand for this site. 2. Increasing Allowable Signage Area on Front Elevation: Adherence to the WDO would allow 300 square feet of signage on the front elevation.The request was to increase the front elevation signage by 153 square feet to 453 square feet.The applicant states that this extra sign allowance would ensure the sign is visible and recognizable from I-5 and Stacy Allison Way. 3. Increasing parking area light pole height:The WDO limits parking light poles to 14.5 feet above grade.The applicant proposed 24.5-foot-tall light fixtures, stating that taller pole height results in fewer light poles needed,which in turn frees up space for customer parking. Staff supported this variance with the compromise that light poles in the southwest of the property will meet the 14.5 feet height requirement to reduce light encroachment into adjacent residential properties.The applicant has agreed to this and modified their plans accordingly. The applicant also submitted a Street Adjustment application, which is the process for applicants to request modified street improvement requirements for abutting street rights-of- way.The applicant's request was to provide a street cross-section consistent with the recent approval to the south along Stacy Allison Way. This modified cross-section was previously supported by the Council. The land use application master case file number is Conditional Use CU 24-02, and the corollary case file numbers are Design Review DR 24-02, Street Adjustment SA 24-01, & Phasing Plan PP 24-01. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 6 36 The subject property is lots 11 and 12 of the Town Center at Woodburn Plat.These are both legal lots of record. Land Use&Zoning Comprehensive Plan Land Use Commercial Designation Zoning District Commercial General (CG) Overlay Districts Interchange Management Area (IMA) Overlay District Existing Use Vacant—with minimal street improvements For context,the subject property and adjacent zoning are illustrated and tabulated on the following page. � 1 fff ✓ a�. i� " f n r µ'rd � G its Zoning map excerpt Cardinal Adjacent Zoning and use Direction North Commercial General (CG)—Vacant East Residential Medium Nodal (RMN)—Evergreen Rd./Single family homes South CG & RMN—partially vacant and apartment buildings West Stacey Allison Way/ 1-5 Section references throughout this staff report are to the Woodburn Development Ordinance DO . DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 7 37 Ill. City Council Analysis and Findings The City Council adopts the Planning Commission findings with minor modifications and updates and as supplemented herein.The original Planning Commission findings may be found in Exhibit A. 2.03 Commercial Zones A.The City of Woodburn is divided into the following commercial zones: 2.The Commercial General (CG) zone is the community's primary commercial area, providing for businesses requiring extensive land intensive outdoor storage and display of merchandise, equipment, or inventory. B.Approval Types(Table 2.03A) 3. Permitted Uses(P)are allowed outright, subject to the general development standards of this Ordinance. Uses Allowed in Commercial Zones Table 2,03A Use Zone Accessory Uses(A) Conditional Uses(CU) Permitted Uses(P) DDC CG CO MUV NINIC S ecial Permitted Uses CS) Specific Conditional) Uses SCCU B Commercial)Retail and Services, 3 Bakerliies, delicatessens, grocery and convenience stores P P P P 1. Not alllowed in the Gateway Overlay District 2. Onlly allowed in the Gateway Overpay District 3. Allowed outright if not wuithdin 200 feet of residentially zoned properties 4. Wiithdin a, building, no outdoor storage or repalir S. All outdoor storage and diisipllay sha)))ll be enclosed by a seven foot masonry wall, 6. Existing uses are allowed as'a permitted use, new uses are not allowed in the MUV 7. Drive-throughs are not allowed 8. Chid care ffaciillliity for 13 or more chillldren,,group home for six or more persons 9. Except allowed as a permitted use in the Gateway Overlay District and prohibited in the interchange Management Area Overlay District (Amended by Ordinance 2573, passed June 24, 20^19) Findings: The proposed supermarket is permitted outright as a "Grocery" store within the CG zone. The store will not have a drive-through. It has been reviewed (traffic, parking, landscaping, etc.) to meet the standards of the proposed use which is permitted outright in the CG zone; subject to a Design Review approval. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 8 38 C. Development Standards(Tables 2.03C) Commercial General (CG) -Site Development Standardls,Table 2.03C Lot Area, Minimum (square feet) JNo miiairnu;uir m Lot Width, Mrruiurnurn (feet) No miirurnum Lot Depth, Miruinrnmurn (feet) No miirunium Street Fironta e, Minimum (feet) JNo miinaimumr Front Setback and Setback Abutting a Street, Minimum (feet) 51. Side or Rear Setback, Abutting RS, R1S, or IRM1 zone 10 M1linir ruunn (feet) AbuttingCO', CG, 10-10-C, N NNC, P/,SP, IP, SW'11R, or. 0 or 5 4,s IL zone Setback to a Private Access Easement, Minimum (feet) 1 Lot Coverage, Maximum I of 5peclhed2 Town house 12 Child care facillity+, group home, or 12 Minimum nursing hone Triplex, Stand-allone 12 Residential Density c ua slle�xdevelopment t I In mixed uuse devello pment No minimum (units per net acre) mulltiiilplle- fa.mnilly dwelling Rov-r house 24 Child care facillity, group home, or 32 Maximum nursing hone Triplex, Stand-allane 32 quadlpllex, In mixed use devellopment 32 multi P'1 e- rn i ly dwelling Priinrary or Outside Gateway Subarea 70^ Building Height, accessory Western Gateway ulkbarea 50 Maximum (feet) structure Eastern Gateway subarea 40 Features not used for habitation 100 DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 9 39 L, Measured from the Street V"idenling Setback (Section 3 03,.02), if any 2, Lot coverage is limited by setbacks, off-street parking, and landscaping requirements. 3. Only allowed in the Gateviay Overlay 10= strlct 4. A house of.viorslliip,shall be set back at leaist 2.0 feet from a property line abutting a residential l zone or use. a,. A building may be constructed at the property line, oir shall be set back at least five feet. Findings: The site plan demonstrates the proposed building will meet or exceed the minimum front, side, and rear setbacks.There is no maximum lot coverage. No residential dwellings are proposed therefore the density standards do not apply. A setback in excess of 10-feet is proposed adjacent to the RMN - Nodal Medium Density Residential zone (Cascade Meadow Apartments)to the south. The allowable building height is 70-feet and the proposed building height is 42-feet. No residential is proposed. The Development Standards of the CG zone are met. 2.05 Overlay Districts 2.05.01 Interchange Management Area Overlay District A. Purpose The purpose of the Interchange Management Area Overlay District(IMA) is to preserve the long-term capacity of the 1-5/Highway 214 Interchange. Preserving the capacity of the interchange is essential for the City's future. Continued access to I-5 is critical for existing businesses and for attracting new businesses and development to the community. The IMA complements the provisions of the Southwest Industrial Reserve (SWIR)Zoning District by ensuring that industrial land is retained for the development envisioned in the Woodburn Comprehensive Plan.The IMA also ensures that needed industrial, commercial and residential lands within the IMA are protected from incompatible development generating excessive vehicle trips. The vehicle trip budget(Table 2.05A)identifies by parcel the maximum amount of peak hour trips for each parcel within the IMA and is intended to be high enough to accommodate peak hour trips anticipated by the Woodburn Comprehensive Plan and the Transportation Systems Plan (TSP), but low enough to restrict unplanned vehicle trips that could adversely affect the I- 5/Hwy 214 Interchange. B. Applicability The provisions of this Section apply to all Type II—V land use applications that propose to allow development that will generate more than 20 peak hour vehicle trips(based on the latest Institute of Transportation Engineers Trip Generation Manual) on parcels identified in Table 2.05A.The provisions of Section 2.05.02F apply to all properties within the boundary of DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 10 40 the IMA. C. Vehicle Trip Budgets This Section establishes a total peak hour trip generation budget for planned employment (commercial and industrial) land uses within the IMA. 1. The IMA vehicle trip budget is allocated to parcels identified in Table 2.05A on a first- developed, first-served basis. 2. Parcel budgets are based on 11 peak hour trips per developed industrial acre, and 33 peak hour trips per developed commercial acre. 3. The parcel budget for each parcel will be reduced in proportion to actual peak hour vehicle trips generated by new development on any portion of the parcel. 4. The City may allow development that exceeds the parcel budget for any parcel in accordance with this Section. c ii 1.. Site Figure 2.05B — Interchange Management Area Boundary and Subareas DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 11 41 ehiclle Trip Budget by Paircelll (Parcel Budget)Tabllle 2,05A Subarea Assessor"s Tax.Lot Comprehensive Plan Buildable Aches Maximum Peak Hour Number Designationi eh idle Trips 52W12C 02100 2W12C 02200,,,,,, 1,3 NK .� .........� ........: .................'rommerciall 52W13 01600 5 165 ) 2W14 02300 5 198 D. Administration This Section delineates responsibilities of the City and ODOT to monitor and evaluate vehicle trip generation impacts on the I-5 interchange from development approved under this Section. TIA: In addition to Section 3.04.05, the following applies: A Transportation Impact Analysis(TIA)is required for all land use applications subject to the provisions of this Section. The TIA must meet City and ODOT administrative rule (OAR Chapter 734, Division 51) requirements and shall include an evaluation and recommendation of feasible Transportation Demand Management(TDM) measures that will minimize peak hour vehicle trips generated by the proposed development. 1. For a land use application subject to the provisions of this Section: a. The City shall not deem the land use application complete unless it includes a TIA prepared in accordance with TIA Requirements; b. The City shall provide written notification to ODOT when the application is deemed complete.This notice shall include an invitation to ODOT to participate in the City's review process; c. ODOT shall have at least 20 days to provide written comments to the City, measured from the date the completion notice was mailed. If ODOT does not provide written comments during this 20-day period,the City's decision may be issued without consideration of ODOT comments. 2. The details of City and ODOT monitoring and coordination responsibilities are found in the Woodburn—ODOT Intergovernmental Agreement(IGA). a. The City shall be responsible for maintaining a current ledger documenting the cumulative peak hour trip generation impact from development approved under this Section, compared with the IMA trip budget. b. The City may adjust the ledger based on actual development and employment data, subject to review and concurrence by ODOT. c. The City will provide written notification to ODOT when land use applications approved under this Section, combined with approved building permits, result in traffic generation estimates that exceed 33%and 67%of the IMA trip budget. 3. This Section recognizes that vehicle trip allocations may become scarce towards the end of the planning period, as the I-5 Interchange nears capacity.The following rules apply to allocations DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 12 42 of vehicle trips against the IMA trip budget: a. Vehicle trip allocations are vested at the time of design review approval. b. Vehicle trips shall not be allocated based solely on approval of a comprehensive plan amendment or zone change, unless consolidated with a subdivision or design review application. c. Vesting of vehicle trip allocations shall expire at the same time as the development decision expires. E. Allowed Uses Uses allowed in the underlying zoning district are allowed, subject to other applicable provisions of the Woodburn Development Ordinance and this Section. F. Comprehensive Plan and Zoning Map Amendments 1. The provisions of this Section (2.05.02.F) apply to all Comprehensive Plan Map amendments within the IMA. This Section does not apply to Zoning Map amendments that result in conformance with the applicable Comprehensive Plan Map designation, such as Zoning Map amendments that occur when land is annexed to the City. 2. Applications for Comprehensive Plan Map amendments and for Zoning Map amendments shall determine whether the proposed change will significantly affect a collector or arterial transportation facility. 3. To ensure that the remaining capacity of the I-5 Interchange is reserved for targeted employment opportunities and needed housing,this section imposes the following prohibitions on Comprehensive Plan Map amendments within the IMA: a. Comprehensive Plan Map amendments that will increase the net commercial land area within the IMA shall be prohibited. b. Comprehensive Plan Map amendments that allow land uses that will generate traffic in excess of the IMA trip budget shall be prohibited. G. Interchange Capacity Preservation Standards Land use applications subject to the provisions of this Section shall comply with the following: 1. Peak hour vehicle trips generated by the proposed development shall not exceed the maximum peak hour vehicle trips specified in Table 2.05A for the subject parcel, except: a. Development may be allowed to exceed the maximum, if the development will contribute substantially to the economic objectives found in the Comprehensive Plan. b. Residential development on a parcel zoned Commercial shall be allowed to exceed the maximum. Transportation Demand Management(TDM) measures shall be required to minimize peak hour vehicle trips and shall be subject to annual review by the City. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 13 43 Finding: A This proposal is for Type III review that will generate more than 20 peak hour vehicle trips for a property in the City's IMA Overlay District. The proposed development site occupies part of the northeast portion of Subarea K of the IMA District. A TIA was provided meeting all ODOT, OAR 737, Division 51 and City requirements (see ODOT correspondence). City Staff and applicant worked together to determine TDM measures to minimize peak hour vehicle trips for the development. These are included in Condition of Approval 14. Staff provided the required notices when the application was deemed complete (as well as at the time of submittal) and 20 days prior to the public hearing. ODOT provided comments to the City and applicant on the TIA, which was been revised to their satisfaction. Based on the ODOT approved TIA, no additional traffic mitigations were warranted. Although ODOT agreed that no additional traffic mitigations were required for approval of the proposed development, they nevertheless recommended, but did not require, adding traffic signals at eastbound (from Evergreen) and southbound (from 214) movements, to address future (2040) mobility standard issues at the intersection for 214 and Evergreen. These recommendations have been memorialized in Condition of Approval #14 in Section IV and are further discussed in the supplemental findings attached to this final decision and incorporated by reference herein. The applicant is proposing a number of TDM measures that will facilitate transit usage as well as pedestrian and cycling opportunities for employees and visitors. These are tailored to working directly with the future tenants and enhancing the City's transit system in this area. These include: i. An information board for employees that shows the city transit schedule ii. Potential employee rewards for use of transit and/or bike/walk iii. Identify a TDM manager on site,who will be a point of contact for City staff iv. Potential carpool-only parking spaces v. Providing employees with bus passes vi. Periodic updates to the posted information, based on feedback from City staff or changes to travel options. vii. An annual report referencing how the TDM measures and targets are met viii. Installation of a bus stop shelter on Evergreen Rd to serve a future bus route ix. Construction of a pedestrian crossing with a flashing beacon at the intersection of Evergreen Rd and Oxford St DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 14 44 um u111uu111vu1ul�lmuullllll Iglu 1I111i1111u111u11u11u11uvuvuvul111111111uuvuu11uW111uwIu1lvululuvulmuluWuluvuuvumuW111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111vu1 mlmuluW11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111u111111111111111111111111111111111111111vuvulullu11111vuu1u 111 muum ii/�����JlJyyyyyyyyyy➢➢Y i U� lu II hlll�lllllll I I Iluuu�ulmlyJ�ylYyJ����mlmlmy���UWl�uuul�luu�uuluuu�uuuuu�uuu�uuu�uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuum gl I I luuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuiuuuullm�lu�u�um ml I m II 1° rj I �l �;�//°/J/ / % �/// //r� a r//riy'�yir/%///©�/ifr✓/„"� i f � 4 m�liuuuu uuuuu(ufi���R 1111 uudl�OflVmfi �11f1 I11ou001 VIf�1Vu 11 miill11111mliGimllllmV@d1 111�aIdulnl11 111m 1mIIhIlVlllll ll� � lu �Y Approximate location of PROPOPSED FLASHING RRFB crossing (looking west from eastside of Evergreen St., with Oxford St. on the left.) DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 15 45 With the proposed conditions of approval related to those TDM requirements, this criterion can be met. See Section 3.04.05 for a detailed review of the TIA The proposed development is expected to generate 511 new peak hour trips and encumbers two lots. Pursuant to the table 2.05A,these two lots have a maximum peak"allocation" of 429 peak hour trips. Pursuant to 2.05.02G.2(a) a development may exceed the allocated parcel budget if the development will contribute substantially to the economic objectives found in the Comprehensive Plan. In their TIA, the applicant provided the following justification for exceeding the parcel peak hour trip allotment: "While the proposed development does exceed the 429 peak hour trips allocated per Table 2.05A, this should be allowed per 2.05(G)because the project will contribute substantially to the economic objectives found in the Woodburn Comprehensive Plan as outlined below. Part F of the Comprehensive Plan states in part, "The third large area of commercial development in the City is the 1-5 Interchange. This contains one small shopping center, a large retail use (WalMart), a premium outlet mall, restaurants, and other highway related uses. In general, commercial uses in West Woodburn, which is the west side of the freeway, should be limited to highway related interchange type uses, while on the east side, a more general commercial nature should be encouraged. Land available for development located west and southwest of Evergreen Road should be developed as a large commercial retail node when Woodburn's population makes it economically feasible.Access management in the 1-5 interchange area is extremely important because the traffic capacity limit of the improved interchange in turn limits commercial growth in West Woodburn. This issue is addressed further in the 2019 Woodburn Transportation System Plan."The Plan anticipates and promotes different types of commercial uses on either side of 1-5. The proposed project is for general commercial retail on the east side of the freeway, which is specifically encouraged at this location. It is not a highway-related interchange use (e.g. regional mall, gas station).Allowing the parcel budget to be exceeded is necessary to allow this development to occur. Without this allowance, the site will remain vacant and the city's goals of having general commercial/retail uses in the commercial area east of 1-5 will not be realized. In addition, the City of Woodburn Economic Opportunities Analysis(EOA) adopted by the city in January 2024 indicates that Woodburn faces a deficit of 107 gross Commercial acres, and 273 gross Industrial acres,for a total employment land deficit of 380 gross acres. The 2025 Urban Growth Boundary(UGB) expansion into the Urban Reserve Area (URA)did not address any of this commercial land need as the 237 URA acres are strictly zoned Southwest Industrial Reserve. The proposed project contributes to the following adopted economic need and goal of the City of Woodburn as concluded in the EOA: • The EOA concludes that "The projected 20-year need for Commercial land trails the supply significantly, with an estimated 65 acres of commercial land remaining to meet a projected need for 171 gross acres."It goes on to state "The largest remaining contiguous development sites in Woodburn are under 20 acres in size, with most being five acres or less. In addition, roughly one third of the remaining buildable land is found in partially vacant parcels where the decision to add further development is subject to the desires of current property owners and/or tenants. The DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 16 46 land for large-lot industrial or large commercial employers is very limited."The proposed project makes use of one such vacant parcel to provide a needed and desirable large commercial employer." City Council concurs with the above analysis and justification. Additional findings on compliance with WDO 2.05A and WDO 2.05.02G.2(a) can be found in the supplemental findings which are attached to this document and incorporated by reference herein. With the imposition of Condition of Approval 14, the provisions of this Section are met. 2.06 Accessory Structures 2.06.02 Fences and Walls A. Location and Height Abutting a Street in Residential Zones 1. The height shall comply with the vision clearance area standards,Section 3.03.06. 2. The height shall not exceed 42 inches(3%feet) above the ground elevation under the fence or wall located at the lot line abutting the street. 3. The height may increase one foot for each 6 feet of setback from the lot line abutting the street. Fences may increase to their maximum height(7 ft)when flush with the house or garage. 4. For corner lots, one frontage shall not exceed the standards in#2 above.The alternative frontages are treated as interior lot line(s), allowing fencing in excess of 42 inches up to, and equal with, the house frontage.The remaining frontage shall not exceed the 42 inch limitation. 5. For through lots, abutting streets and/or alleys on two opposite frontages,the rear frontage opposite the front is be treated as an interior lot line, allowing a maximum height of 7 ft. 6. Fences and free-standing walls may be constructed in the Street Widening Setback, provided the property owner agrees to removal at such time as street improvements are made; however,free-standing walls within this setback also require Public Works Director written authorization. B. Height in Yards Not Abutting a Street 1. In residential zones,the maximum height of a fence or wall other than for corner and/or through lots, shall be seven feet, relative to the ground elevation under the fence or wall. C. Height in Non-Residential Zones 1. In commercial, industrial, or public zones,the maximum height of a fence or wall located in a yard abutting a street shall be 6 feet, relative to the ground elevation under the fence or wall. Fence height may increase to 9 feet once flush with the building face, or 20 feet from street right-of-way. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 17 47 2. Fences and walls may be constructed in the Street Widening Setback provided the property owner agrees to removal at such time as street improvements are made. D. Fence Materials 1. Materials: Fences and walls shall be constructed of any materials commonly used in the construction of fences and walls, such as wood, stone, rock, or brick, or other durable materials. 2. Coating and slats: Chain link fences are acceptable as long as the fence is coated and includes slats made of vinyl,wood or other durable material. Chain link fence in a residential zone, except where part of refuse and recycling collection facility gates, is exempt from the slats requirement. Slats may not be required when visibility into features such as open space, natural areas, parks and similar areas is needed to assure visual security, or into on-site areas in industrial zones that require visual surveillance. 3. Industrial: For manufacturing, assembly,fabricating, processing, packing, storage and wholesale and distribution activities which are the principle use of a building in industrial districts,the preceding standards apply when visible from, and within 20 feet of, a public street. Prohibition: A fence constructed of materials that could cause bodily harm, including, but not limited to, those conveying electric current, barbed wire, razor wire, spikes and broken glass, is prohibited2.06.02 Fences and Walls Finding: The fencing and walls included with the site plan appear to meet all of the fencing requirements of the WDO. The proposed project includes coated chain link fencing with vinyl slats in the following three locations: 1. A 42-inch-high fence at the southwest side of the Truck Dock for fall protection along the top of the dock retaining wall. 2. A 72-inch-high (6-feet) fence at the Covered Deck on the southwest side of the building connected to the Truck Dock to provide security and screening.This fence is flush with the building face. 3. A 42-inch-high fence along the southeast and northeast sides of the Compactor Dock also for fall protection.These fences are all well over 20-feet from the street rights-of-way and the proposed heights and materials are allowed per WDO 2.06.02.The Generator Enclosure walls are 12- feet, 6-inches high and are attached to the building. These walls as well as the Covered Deck roof structure meet the requirements of WDO 2.06.03 as accessory structures. See the Architectural Site Plan for locations of the proposed fencing, Generator Enclosure and Covered Deck. .\ Any new fencing is reviewed separately via a Fence Permit, City Council adds Condition of Approval 3 to obtain a Fence Permit for any new fencing. 3.01 Streets, Greenways&Other Off-Street Bicycle/Pedestrian Corridors, and Bus Transit DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 18 48 3.01.01 Applicability A. Right-of-way standards apply to all public streets and public alleys. B. Improvement standards apply to all public and private streets, public alleys, sidewalks, landscape strips, and on and off-street public bicycle pedestrian corridors.Standards do not exclude conformance with the public works construction code that the Public Works Department administers. C.The Woodburn Transportation System Plan (TSP) designates the functional class of major thoroughfares and local streets. D.This applies to all development as Section 1.02 defines, and is not limited to partitions, subdivisions, multi-family, commercial or industrial construction, or establishment of a manufactured dwelling or recreational vehicle park; however, a lesser set of standards applies to infill residential development of 4 or fewer dwellings and where no land division or Planned Unit Development is applicable, including construction of a single-family dwelling or placement of a manufactured dwelling on an infill lot.See Section 3.01.03C.2. 3.01.02 General Provisions A. No development shall be approved, or access permit issued, unless the internal streets, boundary streets and connecting streets are constructed to at least the minimum standards set forth in this Section, or are required to be so constructed as a condition of approval. C. Materials and construction shall comply with specifications of the City of Woodburn. D.The standards of this Section may be modified, subject to approval of a Street Adjustment, Planned Unit Development,Zoning Adjustment, or Variance. Other sections restrict where and how these application types apply. E. When all public improvements are due:The construction of all public improvements, their passing City inspections, and acceptance by the City are due no later than by either 5.01.06B in the context of land division final plat application to the City or by building permit issuance, except if(1)the developer applies to the City through the Public Works Department for deferral and (2)the City Administrator or designee issues a document approving and describing a bond or performance guarantee pursuant to Section 4.02.08. Administration of bonding and performance guarantees for improvements that are public defaults to the Public Works Department, and the department shall notify the Community Development Director of deferral applications and any approvals and conditions of approval. F. Fees in-lieu: Per Section 4.02.12. 3.01.03 Improvements Required for Development A. With development,the Internal, Boundary,and Connecting streets shall be constructed to at least the minimum standards set forth below. C. Boundary Streets 1.The minimum improvements for a Boundary Street may be termed "half-street" improvements and shall be as follows, except per subsection 2: a. One paved 11-foot travel lane in each direction, even though this results in required improvements being slightly more than half-street by exceeding what the applicable cross section figure would require for a half-street; DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 19 49 b. On-street parking on the side of the street abutting the development, if the required cross section includes on-street parking; c. Curb on the side of the street abutting the development; d. Drainage facilities on the side of the street abutting the development; e. Landscape strip with street trees and lawn grass on the side of the street abutting the development; and f.Sidewalk on the side of the street abutting the development. G. ADA: The minimum standards of this Section 3.01 apply to development such that implementation includes constructing new or upgrading existing public improvements to be ADA-compliant. K. Signage:A developer shall remove prohibited signage that Section 3.10.08R identifies. 3.01.04 Street Cross-Sections A.These standards are based on the functional classification of each street as shown in the Woodburn TSP.The street right-of-way and improvement standards minimize the amount of pavement and right- of-way required for each street classification, consistent with the operational needs of each facility, including requirements for pedestrians, bicycles, and public facilities. B.All public streets under the jurisdiction of the City of Woodburn shall comply with the cross- sections depicted in this Section, unless the developer obtains approval of Street Adjustment, modification through Planned Unit Development, Zoning Adjustment, or Variance as the WDO allows them to be applicable. 1. For local residential streets, the standard cross section is Figure 3.01G.Another among local cross section figures, or a custom cross section, may apply through Street Adjustment or Planned Unit Development. Landscape or planter strips shall have area remaining after street tree plantings landscaped with lawn grass or, if the Public Works Director in writing allows, a species of groundcover. Cobblestones,gravel, pebbles, and rocks are prohibited. Bark dust, mulch, or wood chips are permissible only within the immediate vicinity of a street tree trunk.The developer shall install landscape strip irrigation, and shall provide temporary irrigation during construction, per the public works construction code. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 20 50 re i,ml 'ralrw q m;N,I✓/(4G" ;l„ Io;r 12,1 19,mw CW,11 h:, ',II,4vi 0, 111,,04 h, (Um!„ 'x+d,,) rdr�l°„a1.'°T" af,ill A°rfw sm,t'k Io%9i Lm"wPg mNLAwfb! 9A (,A 4, %;wrt, !°r reff I Figure 3.01C +JU( Cfl_ANI'. AV 1 , � r,�• ru S TSP: Fi ure 3 Roadway Plan elements (Note: R43 is a requirement to make upgrades to Stacey Allison consistent with the future truckway. R35- R37 are intersection improvements that are funded in the city's Urban Redevelopment Area and which the City has already started design & engineering.) Findings: The proposal is a commercial development therefore the provisions within 3.01 are applicable.The proposed project fronts both Stacey Allison Way and Evergreen Road. Note that no improvements are DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 21 51 justified along Center Street at this time since that will remain undeveloped. When future development occurs on the northern property, all street frontage improvements along that frontage will be required at that time. Evergreen Road is a minor arterial street therefore improvements must match WDO Figure 3.01C. A new 6-foot-wide sidewalk is proposed to allow for a 6-foot-wide planter strip with new landscaping to meet WDO 3.01.03C.1.e, 3.01.04 and 3.06.03A.This will bring the Evergreen frontage improvements up to the requirements shown in Figure 3.01C. As directed by City staff(and consistent with the City's Council's previous determination), Stacey Allison Way frontage improvements include a new 6-foot-wide detached sidewalk and 5-foot planter strip to match the modified cross-section that was approved for the Allison Way Apartments Phase 1. OFF-SITE TYPICAL SECTION: APPROVED TYPICAL SECTION STACY ALLISON WAY PHASE I IOT TO SC'ALEUI ow car ... .. . . .. . .. ROW �.... .... r,Mr �WFP c r «ri -- --- —II P i „ ., t�4�d ANNfPlNt1 1M' NNlrtlA,l 141M�D d 1 �f NAM^�;�Frd'WrYtK N Xk,°u i ga6F7,47 r � OF 8177Yf4'7' �7I MSU0"v OAdl MI SMAINN W4ff fAaIUY AAYkifRINNYfB'dl7'M 7MPAM E%A7- An additional 5 foot ROW is required along Stacy Allison;which is indicated on the Plan. No additional ROW dedication is required along Evergreen or Center St. at this time. ADA compliant sidewalk curb ramps will be installed at all driveway access points from the subject site onto Stacey Allison and Evergreen. 3.01.05 Street Layout B.Termination of Streets and Off-Street Bicycle/Pedestrian Facilities 3. Continuity of Off-Street Bicycle/Pedestrian Facilities Public bikeway and pedestrian facilities, other than those incorporated in a street right-of-way, shall either: a. Provide for a continuous system,with each segment originating and terminating with a connection to a public street, a public alley, a shared rear lane, a greenway, a public park, or to a designated activity center; or b. Provide stubbed facilities to not preclude subsection (a.) and that may extend beyond the limits of DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 22 52 an approved development,when such a public facility has been required by the decision-maker. C. Block Standards 1. Block length shall not be less than 200 feet and not more than 600 feet, except where street location is precluded by any of the following; b. Blocks adjacent to arterial streets, limited-access highways, collectors or railroads; 2. In any block that is longer than 600 feet, as measured from the right-of-way line of the street to the right-of-way line of the adjacent street, a bikeway/pedestrian facility shall be required through and near the middle of the block. 3. On any block longer than 1,200 feet, corridors per Section 3.01.07 and 3.01.08 may be required through the block at 600 foot intervals. 4. In a proposed development including partition and subdivision, or where redevelopment potential exists and a street connection is not proposed, one or more off-street bicycle/pedestrian facilities may be required as partition or subdivision connection paths or shortcut paths to connect a cul-de-sac or other public street to other public streets,to other bicycle/pedestrian facilities, or to adjoining land to allow for future connections. Finding: The distance along Stacey Allison between Hooper Street to the south and Center Street to the north is more than 2,000 feet.Additional public streets between Hooper and Center are not feasible given the existing development.The proposed project includes 717 feet of property frontage along Stacey Allison. An ADA compliant bikeway/pedestrian sidewalk is proposed along the south property line to provide a pedestrian connection roughly mid-block from Stacey Allison to Evergreen. An additional ADA compliant pedestrian pathway is proposed roughly 420 feet further north to connect Stacey Allison to the main entrance and front walkway of the building. This pedestrian route will continue around the northeast side of the building and connect to Evergreen. See Condition of Approval 7. 3.01.09 Bus Transit Improvements A. Purpose: The purpose of this section is to provide for apparent, attractive, and dignified regional and City bus transit facilities, to improve service, especially to include and be equitable toward Woodburn residents who cannot or do not own private vehicles or drive,to extend the reach of those walking and cycling,to implement Woodburn Comprehensive Plan policies,to implement the Transportation System Plan (TSP), to implement the Transit Plan Update that supplements the TSP, to guide City capital improvement projects, and to have developers improve bus transit stops that have few or no improvements.The provision of bus transit improvements is guided also by the Highway 99E Corridor Plan and other WDO sections. B.Applicability: The standards apply along a frontage for which development causes street improvements and either where a bus stop exists that lacks conforming improvements or the City has adopted a long-range transit plan identifying a new bus stop. The standards apply also to off-site bus DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 23 53 stop improvements where and as conditioned. D. Improvements: Per the Director. E. Fees in-lieu: Per Section 4.02.12. Finding: Considering the adopted Transit Development Plan, approved by City Council via Resolution No. 2213 on June 12, 2023, the preferred service plan illustrates the Highway 214 Express route within a quarter of a mile from the subject property. The City recently implemented the preferred public transit service plan outlined in the Transit Development Plan. The plan identifies a new route ("B") running along Evergreen Road which aligns perfectly with a new bus stop shelter for southbound buses along the proposed project frontage. The City is expected to start operation this new route on May 1st of this year. .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. II T.n,i , r,m,ryn POan PREE'E �J EI 'SEIRVICE ,. Fi"rgure 58 (Preferred Fixed Route Service Plan Overview Preferred Scenario BaSGC)caau input from the TOP'Steewring Rawtoctte9 th(cmmunity survey results,ind Cpmmi us' rou condlucted In Spanish,a ^^^^.Route e B the f C Preferred Service Pllan wwas'developed that' "'r Includes modif ed versions of the conceptual ...., ......,., ,i rroute�s dewtlKa ed un thm Serv6ce S'reroarVos ,;^ ?� •' - presanted above. vva The Pneterfed Service Plan includes three routes:•�i„ va ...f�Fi d v v R e fo us offethis route s topdovide thehmost dQ�ct 10 odlburn. Dir � f dm II-ock "`*" ©�, rout ng passible w h le also serving these r rsor haw'"w,rvw C]... w % nwra r rte,, "nr T m w4 Edr of i flw.ncMay_ _ destinations'. a i O z d P + _ •Route B—Local.This route provides service to the major F uu a f u { destinations do the cormmundy ass'well as tc several t � tie, r '` _ residentlel nelghhorhaads Chat sae nap servssd by Raups A. lua v I wf 0 •Route C—Highway 214 Express Thee mevu rroufe r r i r „� rou esfn ay 214 and opeerat 4setwaer nndar er than oths rades oadier end Mter than alher players In tIl'le CDmml}]111t'tP sand connect to regional transit serviices =. _..... rrn,���� o-, More detain about.the three route's included in the Preferred Service Plan a,re provided belown. sr,�f.imitd; q i<fatf p c o,;arp .. uoue.r�r o it,uvrrtd„w dsciru,V corrrrry NnrK i'a fl Cnty Half Q N 49 b�., O e'?MiJ<<+.'nral yWa n l�A�'s �SMIIWo Imo} Consistent with that plan as well as the applicant's requirements under the IMA provisions related to reducing vehicular trips,the applicant will install a bus stop shelter consistent with the City's transit and public works standards. Pursuant to the C above, the applicant is conditioned to provide an easement over the transit shelter as well. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 24 54 3.02 Utilities and Easements 3.02.01 Public Utility Easements&Public Access Easements A.The Director shall require dedication of specific easements for the construction and maintenance of municipal water, sewerage and storm drainage facilities located on private property. B.Streetside: A streetside public utility easement(PUE)shall be dedicated along each lot line abutting a public street at minimum width 5 feet. Partial exemption for townhouse corner lot: Where such lot is 18 to less than 20 feet wide, along the longer frontage, streetside PUE minimum width shall be 3 feet; or,where the lot is narrower than 18 feet,the longer side frontage is exempt from streetside PUE. C. Off-street: The presumptive minimum width of an off-street PUE shall be 16 feet, and the Public Works Director in writing may establish a different width as a standard. D. City& public access: The minimum width of a public access easement along either a bicycle/pedestrian corridor or sidewalk overlap of property,where the easement serves instead of dedication of either land or ROW to the City, shall be per Section 3.01.07C. E. As a condition of approval for development, including property line adjustments, partitions, subdivisions, design reviews, Planned Unit Developments(PUDs),Street Adjustments,Zoning Adjustments, or Variances, the Director may require dedication of additional public easements, including off-street public utility easements and other easement types such as those that grant access termed any of bicycle/pedestrian access, cross access, ingress/egress, public access, or shared access, as well as those that identify, memorialize, and reserve future street corridors in place of ROW dedication. F. Streetside PUE maximum width: 2.Standards: Exempting any lot or tract subject to Figure 3.018"Major Arterial",the following standards are applicable to a lot or tract with: a. No alley or shared rear lane: 8 feet streetside. Nothing in this section precludes a streetside PUE from variable width where necessary such as to expand around public fire hydrants. Findings: A The applicant will be conditioned (Public Works Condition 3) on dedicating a 5-foot ROW along Stacey Allison as well as a 5 foot PUE along all street frontages. This is based on the recommendations of both PGE and the city's Public Works Dept. 3.02.03 Street Lighting A. Public Streets: DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 25 55 Public streets abutting a development shall be illuminated with street lights installed to the standards of the City and the electric utility. A developer shall provide documentation to the attention of the Public Works Director indicating that any needed illumination complies with the standards. A developer is to refer to Illuminating Engineering Society(IES)of North America Recommended Practice 8, Roadway Lighting(RP-8) or other source as the public works construction code specifies. Finding: . City Council adds Public Works Condition 6 to either provide documentation that existing street lighting meets the requirement, or, if it doesn't, install new lighting to meet this requirement. 3.02.04 Underground Utilities C. Off-street: All permanent utility service to and within a development shall be underground, except where overhead high-voltage (35,000 volts or more)electric facilities exist. Finding: Regarding subsection C., site plans illustrate underground utility connections for the proposed building. 3.03 Setbacks and Open Space Finding: As analyzed for 2.03, the development complies with setback requirements. Site plans demonstrate the proposal complies with setbacks, projections, and vision clearance area standards. 3.04 Vehicular&Bicycle/Pedestrian Access 3.04.01 Applicability and Permit A.Street Access Every lot and tract shall have minimum access per subsection 1. or 2.: 1. Direct access to an abutting public street, alley, or shared rear lane; or 2. Access to a public street by means of a public access easement and private maintenance agreement to the satisfaction of the Director, revocable only with the concurrence of the Director, and that is recorded.The easement shall contain text that pursuant to Woodburn Development Ordinance DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 26 56 (WDO)3.04.03B.3,the public shared access(ingress and egress) right of this easement is revocable only with the written concurrence of the Community Development Director. 3.04.03 Access Management: Driveway Guidelines and Standards B. Number of Driveways 3. For nonresidential uses,the number of driveways should be minimized based on overall site design, including consideration of: a.The function classification of abutting streets; b.The on-site access pattern, including parking and circulation,joint access, turnarounds and building orientation; c.The access needs of the use in terms of volume, intensity and duration characteristics of trip generation. 4. Unused driveways shall be closed. 5. For all development and uses,the number of driveways shall be further limited through access management per subsections C& D below. C.Joint Access 3. Every joint driveway or access between separate lots shall be per the same means as in Section 3.04.01A.2. 4. Standards: a. Easement: Per Section 3.04.01A.2 and minimum width 20 feet. b. Improvements:The easement and the drive aisle or aisles it follows shall align along centerline. Each shared access drive aisle shall extend to the property line with no terminating curb and no fixed barrier mounted to the drive aisle.The drive aisle minimum width is 20 feet if without side curbs and 21 feet inclusive of side curbs. D. Access management: 2. Commercial: Any development within a commercial zoning district that Section 2.03A lists shall grant shared access to adjacent lots and tracts partly or wholly within any of the same districts. An alley or shared rear lane may substitute for meeting this standard if the alley provides equivalent public access. Zoning Adjustment is permissible. E. Interconnected Parking Facilities 1. All uses on a lot shall have common or interconnected off-street parking and circulation facilities. 2. Similar or compatible uses on abutting lots shall have interconnected access and parking facilities. Access Requirements Table 3.04A DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 27 57 1 to 4 Dwellings, 5 or More Dwelling or Commercial or Living Units or Living Units,School, or Industrial Use 6 6 Individual Lots House of Worship 1-way 8 minimum 10 minimum 10 minimum 20 maximum 20 maximum Paved Width 20 minimum Commercial/Mixed- of Driveway 2-way 14 minimum 24 maximum* Use: 3,4,7,8 (feet) 7 16 maximum *(Add 6 ft maximum if 20 minimum a turn pocket is added) 24 maximum* *(Add 12 ft maximum if a turn pocket is added) Industrial: 22 minimum 36 maximum* *(Add 8' if a turn pocket is added) Manufactured 10 minimum n/a n/a Dwelling Park Major Arterial, Commercial: Minor Arterial, n/a 36 minimum 36 minimum; Throat Service Collector I.ndustrial:, Length (feet) 50 minimum Access or Local n/a 18 minimum 18 minimum Street Corner Access or Local 30 minimum 30 minimum 30 minimum Clearance Street (feet) Guidelines 1 Service Collector 50 minimum 50 minimum 50 minimum (See Figure Minor Arterial 245 minimum 245 minimum 245 minimum 3.04B) Major Arterial 300 minimum 300 minimum 300 minimum Driveway on the 22 minimum 50 minimum 50 minimum Driveway same parcel Separation Access or Local none none none Guidelines Street 1,2 (feet) Service Collector 50 minimum 50 minimum 50 minimum (See Figure 3.04B) Minor Arterial 245 minimum 245 minimum 245 minimum Major arterial 300 minimum 300 minimum 300 minimum Access to a Major or Minor Required Required Required Arterial DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 28 58 Turnarounds Required if the 9 driveway length to Requirements' Access to any the lot located Requirements per the per the other street furthest from the Woodburn Fire District Woodburn Fire street exceeds 150 District feet 1. The separation should be maximized. 2. Driveways on abutting lots need not be separated from each other, and may be combined into a single shared driveway. 3. Driveways over 40 feet long and serving one dwelling unit may have a paved surface minimum 8 feet wide. 4. Notwithstanding the widths listed in this table,the minimum clearance around a fire hydrant shall be provided (See Figure 3.04D). 5. Throat length is measured from the closest off-street parking or loading space to the right-of-way. A throat applies only at entrances(See Figure 3.05B). 6. Maximum of 4 individual lots can be served from single shared driveway(See Figure 3.04A) except where and as Section 3.04.03D.3"Flag Lots"supersedes. 7. It is permissible that the Oregon Fire Code (OFC) as administered by the independent Woodburn Fire District may cause driveway widths to exceed minimums and maximums. It is a developer's responsibility to comply with the OFC. 8. Width measurement excludes throat side curbing, if any. 9. Refer to OFC Appendix D, Figure D103.1. Findings: As a minor arterial street, only one driveway access is allowed along Evergreen Road pursuant to WDO 3.04.03B.3.The driveway is proposed to be roughly 150 feet from the existing driveway into the Cascade Meadow Apartments to the south. The 245-foot separation shown in Table 3.04A is a guideline rather than a required standard. Staff can support this driveway location. The Applicant is proposing this driveway location to allow easier(less circuitous)vehicle access into the site as well as more direct fire access to the Fire Department Connection (FDC)which will be located southwest of the building. Per the project Traffic Impact Analysis (TIA),traffic volumes at the Hooper Street/Evergreen Road intersection just south of the Oxford intersection are exceptionally low during peak hours. Hooper serves a similar function to Oxford and therefore would also have low traffic volumes at the intersection with Evergreen.The apartment access may be slightly busier than the Oxford intersection but traffic from both would be minimally impacted by the new, proposed access point to Evergreen. All driveways meet the width requirements of Table 3.04A, except for the northern driveway on Stacy Allison, which needs to be modified in the final engineering drawings. This is addressed through Condition of Approval 10. The two driveways accessing Stacey Allison are separated by more than 400 feet, meeting the minimum DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 29 59 separation distance required by Table 3.04A.To meet 3.04.03D.2 and 3.04.03C.4, a driveway will be installed to connect the subject property to the commercial properties and Center Street to the north. As indicated on the Architectural Site Plan, a future driveway will connect to commercial properties to the south. 3.04.05 Traffic Impact Analysis B.A transportation study known as a transportation impact analysis(TIA)is required for any of the following: 1. Comprehensive Plan Map Change or Zone Change or rezoning that is quasi-judicial, excepting upon annexation designation of zoning consistent with the Comprehensive Plan. 2. A development would increase vehicle trip generation by 50 peak hour trips or more or 500 average daily trips(ADT) or more. 3. A development would raise the volume-to-capacity(V/C) ratio of an intersection to 0.96 or more during the PM peak hour. 4. Operational or safety concerns documented by the City or an agency with jurisdiction, such as ODOT or the County, and submitted no earlier than a pre-application conference and no later than as written testimony entered into the record before the City makes a land use decision. 5. A development involves or affects streets and intersections documented by ODOT as having a high crash rate, having a high injury rate of persons walking or cycling, having any cyclist and pedestrian deaths, or that partly or wholly pass through school zones that ODOT recognizes. 6. Where ODOT has jurisdiction and ORS or OAR, including OAR 734-051, compels the agency to require. A developer shall submit a traffic impact letter or memo when the City or an agency with jurisdiction does not require a TIA.A development within the Downtown Development and Conservation (DDC) zoning district is exempt from TIA submittal. Finding: The applicant provided a traffic impact analysis from a registered professional engineer and which has been reviewed and deemed in conformance with all of the above requirements by City Staff, the City's contract traffic engineer, as well as ODOT.The analysis indicates that all 16 intersections included in the study will operate within the identified standards with the exception of three intersections along Evergreen Rd., specifically: • Stacy Allison Way/Evergreen Rd. • Hayes Street/Evergreen Rd. • Harvard Drive/Evergreen Rd. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 30 60 These three intersections are projected to exceed there operating standards even without this project being approved. The City had identified these projects in the recently adopted TSP for updates and the engineering work has already begun on designing new signal improvements at Stacy Allison/Evergreen and Hayes and Evergreen. Harvard/Evergreen is being designed with roundabout. Construction on these important public projects is expected to be underway later this year. The TIA includes an analysis of these intersections after these improvements are completed (and the store is open) and it indicates that all three will operate within the mobility standards. The cost of these three projects is expected to be approximately the same as the transportation SDC's that will be collected at time of building permit issuance. Owing to the impacts this project will have on these intersections, and the desire to have development pay its "own way"to the greatest degree possible, staff anticipates using all of the transportation SDC's collected for the project to go paying for these three nearby intersections. Additional findings on compliance with WDO 3.04.05 can be found in the supplemental findings which are attached to this document and incorporated by reference herein. 3.04.06 Bicycle/Pedestrian Access between Sidewalk and Building Entrances B. Wide walkway: Excluding residential development other than multiple-family dwellings, 1 wide walkway minimum or with each of two frontages for sites of two or more frontages. Where a development includes or abuts a public off-street bicycle/pedestrian facility, a wide walkway shall also connect to the facility. Minimum width 8 feet,ADA-compliant, and not gated. Gating is allowed only if the development driveway throat or throats are gated. C. Walkway: Minimum 1 per frontage except where a wide walkway supersedes. Minimum width 6 feet and may have stairs. For residential development of other than multiple-family dwellings, each lot shall have a walkway minimum 2 feet wide of minimum length such that it connects sidewalk with an entrance to each and every dwelling on a given lot. The walkway shall not overlap a driveway, and where a walkway is flush with a driveway, it shall either(1) be raised minimum 3 inches, have curbing which may be mountable, and be minimum 3 feet and 3 inches wide, or(2) be dyed, patterned, stamped or otherwise treated or of a different paving material than the driveway to visually distinguish it from the adjacent driveway. D. Walkway and wide walkway crossings: A development with crossings of drive aisles shall have one or more crossings made visually distinct from adjacent vehicular pavement and minimum width equal to that of the walkway. 1. Wide walkways: Minimum width 8 ft each. Every crossing along a wide walkway shall be either an extension of wide walkway poured concrete at the same grade as adjacent vehicular area or in the form of a speed table, also known as a raised walkway crossing, minimum 4 inches high and with vehicular side ramps maximum slope ten percent and with striped warning triangles. ADA-compliant transitions or ramps shall be minimum 5 feet wide. For multiple-family dwelling development,the speed table option shall be a requirement. 2. Walkways: Where there are walkways and any of them cross drive aisles, all of the crossings along minimum 1 walkway shall be either an extension of walkway poured DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 31 61 concrete at the same grade as adjacent vehicular area and same width as the walkway or in the form of a speed table, also known as a raised walkway crossing, minimum 4 inches high. A developer shall stripe remaining walkway crossings with any of hatch or ladder pattern or three or more bars perpendicular to the crossing. 3. See Section 3.05.02N regarding crossings within multiple-aisle parking areas. Finding: The proposal is new commercial development therefore the provisions apply.The plans illustrate a six-foot-wide public sidewalk connection along the south side of the property between Stacey Allison and Evergreen Rd. Separately,wide walkways eight feet in width meeting WDO 3.04.06 are proposed from the building to both Stacey Allison Way and Evergreen Road. Where these wide walkways cross drive aisles, they will be poured concrete to provide visual cues further delineating the walking space from the vehicular drives.These walkways also connect to the privately owned on-site bicycle parking. The walkways will be ADA compliant and not gated. 3.05 Off-Street Parking and Loading 3.05.01 Applicability 3.05.02 General Provisions A.All required parking and loading spaces shall be retained and maintained in accordance with the standards of the WDO. B.The land for off-street parking and loading areas shall either be: 1. Owned in fee title by the owner of the structure or site being served by the parking area, or D. Location 4. In non-residential districts, off-street parking and storage shall be prohibited within a setback adjacent to a street, except if screened per Section 3.06.05B. Vehicle parking within the public right- of-way shall not be eligible for fulfilling any required off-street parking requirement. E. Setback 1. In commercial and industrial zones,the parking, loading, and circulation areas shall be set back from a street a minimum of five feet. 2. Parking, loading, and circulation areas shall be set back from a property line a minimum of five feet, excepting any of(a)interior lot lines of lots in a development that have the same owner or that have outbuildings as part of a complex of buildings sited amid parking, such as in an office or industrial park or strip mall, (b)a shared access and use agreement between or among landowners per Section 3.04, and (c)shared access in the specific context of residential development of other than multiple-family dwellings. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 32 62 F. All vehicle parking and loading areas shall be paved to the standards of this ordinance(Section 3.04.04), except that in the IP, IL,SWIR, and P/SP zones, storage areas used for equipment that may damage pavement may be stored on a gravel-surface storage area. A gravel storage area shall be constructed to a minimum of surfacing of:six inches of one inch minus to three inch minus gravel. If three inch minus is used,the top two inches shall be one inch minus. The property owner shall maintain a gravel storage area to ensure continued drainage and dust control.A paved access apron to any paved access road is required, regardless of the storage area surface. G. All vehicle parking, loading, and storage areas shall be graded and provide storm drainage facilities approved by the Director. H. All parking spaces, except those for residential development other than multiple-family dwellings, shall be constructed with concrete or rubber bumper guards or wheel barriers maximum 4 inches high that prevent vehicles from damaging structures, projecting over walkways so as to leave less than 4.5 feet of unobstructed passage, or projecting over wide walkways, abutting properties, or rights-of-way. I. Maneuvering areas shall be designed in compliance with this Section (Table 3.05B). Off-street parking areas shall be designed so that no backing or maneuvering within a public right-of-way is required.These provisions do not apply to dwellings other than multiple-family. J. All uses required to provide 20 or more off-street parking spaces shall have directional markings or signs to control vehicle movement, and any dead-end drive aisle 50 feet or longer shall have an MUTCD-compliant"no outlet" sign. K. Except for dwellings other than multiple-family, off-street parking spaces shall be delineated by double parallel lines on each side of a space, except a side adjacent to any of curb or ADA parking accessible aisle.The total width of the lines shall delineate a separation of two feet. The lines shall be four inches wide(See Figure 3.05C). L. Parking area lighting for all developments shall conform to Chapter 3.11. M. Required parking spaces shall be available for parking of operable vehicles of residents, customers, patrons and employees and shall not be used for the storage of vehicles or materials or for the parking of fleet vehicles, except for those fleet vehicles: 1. Driven by an employee to the site each work day from home, or 2. Stored during periods other than normal business hours. N. Walkway crossings: Parking areas with multiple aisles shall have minimum 1 walkway or wide walkway that passes through the parking area to the aisle farthest from the building. Each walkway crossing shall conform to Section 3.04.06D. 3.05.03 Off-Street Parking A. Number of Required Off-Street Parking Spaces 1. Off-street vehicle parking spaces shall be provided in amounts not less than those set forth in this Section (Table 3.05A). 2. Off-street vehicle parking spaces shall not exceed two times the amount required in this Section (Table 3.05A). DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 33 63 B.ADA:Accessible parking shall be provided in amounts not less than those that ORS 447.233 requires.The number of accessible spaces shall be included as part of total required vehicle parking spaces. C. A maximum of 20 percent of the required vehicle parking spaces may be satisfied by compact vehicle parking spaces. D. Off-street vehicle parking spaces and drive aisles shall not be smaller than specified in this Section (Table 3.05C). E. A developer shall provide off-street bicycle parking per the minimums and standards in Tables 3.05D&G and the additional standards in Section 3.05.06. Off-Street Parking Ratio Standards Table 3.05A Use 1,2 Parking Ratio-spaces per activity unit or square feet of gross floor area 7. General retail sales(such as food and beverages, clothing, sporting goods, health and personal care 1/250 square feet items, and motor vehicle parts) 1.The Director may authorize parking for any use not specifically listed in this table.The applicant shall submit an analysis that identifies the parking needs, and a description of how the proposed use is similar to other uses permitted in the zone.The Director may require additional information, as needed, to document the parking needs of the proposed use. 2.There is no required parking ratio for non-residential uses and residential units above first floor commercial uses in the DDC zone (See Section 3.07.07.C.12). 3. See Tables 3.05C& E for minimum carpool/vanpool and electric vehicle parking and Table 3.05D for minimum bicycle parking. 4. In compliance with OAR 660-046-0220(2)(e). Parking Space and Drive Aisle Dimensions Table 3.058 Curb Stripe Stall to Drive Aisle Width Parking Type of Space Stall Width Length Length Curb (feet) Angle (feet) feet (feet) (feet)) ( ) 1-way 2-way A B C D E F G Standard 9.0 9,0 18.0 18.0 24.0 90° Compact 7.5 7.5 15.0 15.0 22.0 (Perpend- 24.0 icular) Car Accessible Aisle 6.0 6.0 18.0 18.0 24.0 Van Accessible Aisle 8.0 8.0 18.0 18.0 DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 34 64 Parking Space and Drive Aisle Dimensions Table 3.05B Curb Stripe Stall to Drive Aisle Width Parking Stall Width Type of Space Length Length Curb (feet) Angle (feet) feet (feet) (feet)) ( ) 1-way 2-way A B C D E F G 1. A parking space other than compact may occupy up to 1.5 feet of a landscaped area or walkway as measured from face of curb. Compact may occupy up to six inches.At least 4.5 feet clear width of a walkway must be maintained. 2. Space width is measured from the midpoint of the double stripe. 3. Curb or wheel stops shall be utilized to prevent vehicles from encroaching on abutting properties, rights-of-way, or wide walkways. 4. The access aisle must be located on the passenger side of the parking space, except that two adjacent parking spaces may share a common access aisle. 5. Where the angle of parking stalls differ across a drive aisle,the greater drive aisle width shall be provided. 6. In the context of residential development of other than multiple-family dwellings, parking space minimum dimensions shall be 8 feet wide by 18 feet long, including within a carport or garage. See also Section 3.05.03F.1. 7. The Oregon Fire Code(OFC) as administered by the independent Woodburn Fire District may cause drive aisle widths to exceed the minimum and maximums in this table. 8. Zoning Adjustment permissible. Findings: Pursuant to WDO 3.05.02D.1, off-street vehicle parking is proposed on the same lot as the proposed building. Per Table 3.05A, a minimum of 336 off-street parking stalls must be provided as part of the proposed development.The number of stalls proposed (i.e., 504 stalls) exceeds that required by Table 3.05A, however, is less than double that required in order to stay under the limit imposed by WDO 3.05.03A.2. As required by WDO 3.05.02D.4 and 3.05.02E, no parking is proposed within the setbacks, and all parking and circulation areas are setback a minimum of 5-feet from boundary streets as well as interior property lines. All parking and circulation areas are paved, graded, and include storm drainage facilities in compliance with WDO 3.05.02F and G. Concrete curbs, wheel stops and steel pipe bumpers are proposed as necessary to meet the requirements of 3.05.02H. Stall width and length, accessible aisles and drive aisles meet or exceed the minimum dimensions shown in Table 3.05B and are in compliance with WDO 3.05.021. Directional markings and double stall delineation lines are proposed pursuant to 3.05.02J and K. A wide walkway meeting WDO 3.04.06D is proposed to pass through the parking area and extend all the DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 35 65 way to Stacey Allison way to meet 3.05.02NThe proposal is a new commercial office building totaling 14,052 square feet. Pursuant to Table 3.05A row 12, the minimum parking requirement for the proposal is 40 stalls. Site plans illustrate 41 new parking stalls proposed, 7 of which are compact size and the remainder are standard size. Parking stalls and drive aisles are noted to conform with the dimension requirements in Table 3.05B. Bicycle parking is analyzed further under Section 3.05.06. City Council adds Condition of Approval 11a to memorialize the accessible parking requirement. Carpool/Vanpool Parking Table 3.05C Development or Use Description Stall Minimum Number or Percent 1. Non-residential Zero to 19 total minimum required off- n/a development within street parking spaces commercial zoning 20 to 33 total 1 stall districts 34 to 65 total 2 stalls 66 or more total 2 stalls or 3%,whichever is greater 1. Standard applies even if the site is not zoned P/SP. 2. See Section 3.05.03H for carpool/vanpool (C/V) development standards. H. Carpool/vanpool (C/V) stalls shall meet the following standards: 1. Convenient locations: The distance from a stall, in whole or in part, shall be maximum 50 feet to a building perimeter walkway or,where there is no perimeter walkway, a building main or staff-only entrance. 2.Striping: Stripe each stall in lettering 1 ft high min "CARPOOL/VANPOOL" or similar. 3. Signage: Post at each stall a wall-mounted or pole-mounted sign for"Carpool/Vanpool"or similar. Each sign 1% by 1 foot minimum with top of a posted sign between 5%and 7 feet high max above vehicular grade. Findings: The proposal is a new commercial office building within the Commercial Office zone. As analyzed for Table 3.05A, the minimum parking requirement for the proposal is 40 stalls.The carpool/vanpool parking requirement is therefore 2 stalls. Plans illustrate 2 carpool/vanpool parking stalls provided. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 36 66 .\City Council adds Condition of Approval 11b to memorialize the striping and signage requirements for carpool/vanpool parking. Electric Vehicle Parking Table 3.05E Development or Use Description Stall Minimum Number or Percent 2. Non-residential Zero to 19 total minimum required spaces n/a development within 20 to 39 total 2 stalls commercial zoning 40 or more total 2 stalls,or 5%of tote districts minimum required spaces, whichever is'greater 1. Standard applies even if the site is not zoned P/SP. 2. The Director may authorize EV parking for any use that the Development or Use column does not clearly include. 3. See Section 3.05.031 below for EV development standards. 4. Administrative note: As of January 2022, electrical permitting remains through the County instead of the City by agreement between the City and County. 1. Electric vehicle(EV)includes both electric vehicle and plug-in hybrid vehicle,and EV parking stalls shall meet the following standards: 1. Convenient locations: The distance from a stall, in whole or in part, shall be maximum 50 feet to a building perimeter walkway or,where there is no walkway, a building main or staff-only entrance. 2. Charging level: minimum Level 2 (240 volt alternating current [AC] charging), or faster charging. 3.Striping: Stripe each stall in lettering 1 ft high min "ELECTRIC VEHICLE CHARGING"or similar and stencil of an EV image or logo. 4. Signage: Post at each stall a wall-mounted or pole-mounted sign for"Electric Vehicle Charging"or similar and include an EV image or logo. Each sign 1% by 1 foot minimum with top of a posted sign between 5%and 7 feet high max above vehicular grade. 5. Management/operations: The landowner or property manager shall keep EV stalls available for EVs and plug-in hybrid vehicles and keep conventional gasoline vehicles from parking in them, and in the context of multiple-family dwelling development: a. Priority users shall be tenants, and guests/visitors would be secondary. b. May charge EV stall users for the costs of charging an EV through a charging station, but shall not (1)charge users for either simply parking an EV or plug-in hybrid vehicle in an EV stall or for leaving DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 37 67 such a vehicle parked without actively charging, and (2) shall charge to recoup costs to the landowner or property manager and not generate profit for the landowner or property manager. (This does not preclude the landowner or property manager contracting with a for-profit company to manage EV charging stations). c. Shall not charge any fee that discriminates among particular EV parking stalls based on the perception of some stalls being more convenient or otherwise desirable than others. It is anticipated but not required that the layout would be that each charging station would serve a pair of stalls. Findings: The proposal is a new retail building within the CG zone. The minimum electric vehicle charging stall requirement is to provide 17 (Level 2) EV stalls. The plans propose eight Type 3 Tesla chargers; hence the need for a variance.The variance criteria are outlined in Section 5.03.12 of the WDO and reviewed later in this report. .\ Regardless of the result of the variance request, City Council adds Condition of Approval 11c to memorialize the charging level, striping, and signage requirements. 3.05.04 Off-Street Loading& Unloading A.Standard: Loading and unloading for all multiple-family dwelling and non-residential development shall not encroach within the ROW of a street with a functional class designation higher than local. B.Administration:The Director may require a developer to submit a site plan sheet or sheets illustrating where and how loading and unloading would occur such that a development would meet subsection A above. Finding: The site plan demonstrates that no loading will encroach into street right-of-way. 3.05.05 Shared Parking Finding: The applicant's narrative states no shared parking is proposed therefore the provisions do not apply. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 38 68 Off-Street Bicycle Parking Table 3.05D IIIIIIII Development or Use Description Stall Minimum Number, Percent, or Ratio 2. Non-residential Whichever of the two rates it,greater: development within (1)2 stalls or 15%of total minimum commercial zoning required parking spaces,whichever is districts greater;or (2)2 stalls or equal to 0.6/1,000 square feet GFA,whichever is greater. 1. Standard applies even if the site is not zoned P/SP. 2. Each modular classroom counts as a classroom. 3. The Director may authorize off-street bicycle parking for any use that the Development or Use column does not clearly include. 4. See Section 3.05.06 for bicycle parking development standards. 3.05.06 Bicycle Parking Standards B.Applicability:Applies to total minimum required bicycle parking per Table 3.05D and any excess. C. Standards: Developers shall install parking in lockers or racks that meet the following: 1. Surface:The area devoted to bicycle parking shall be paved if outdoors or otherwise hard surfaced if enclosed or indoors. Outdoor pavement shall be asphalt, bricks, cobblestone rectangular pavers, concrete pavers, poured concrete, structurally supported fiber cement or wood planking, or combination. 2. Facility:Where bicycle parking is provided with racks, they shall meet the following: a.The rack shall be designed so that the bicycle frame and one wheel can be locked to a rigid portion of the rack with a U-shaped shackle lock,when both wheels are left on the bicycle; b. If the rack is a horizontal rack, it shall support the bicycle at two points, including the frame; and c.The rack must be securely anchored with tamper-resistant hardware. 3. Dimensions: Bicycle parking spaces, aisles and clearances shall be per Table 3.05G,which Figures 3.05E, F, &G illustrate. 4. Signage: If bicycle parking is not visible from sidewalk,wide walkway, or the main entrance of the building(s), a developer must install a permanent sign, minimum 1 by 1.5 feet, at the main entrance of each primary building indicating the location of bicycle parking. Figure 3.05H illustrates examples. 5. Proximity:A developer shall construct or install bicycle parking within maximum 50 feet of the main entrance and per Figures 3.05J-L. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 39 69 6. Covered/sheltered:A developer shall cover or shelter from precipitation among the total required bicycle parking minimum 50 percent of any and all parking that is outdoors. 7. Multiple-family dwellings: In multiple-family dwelling development where buildings have no elevators, some of the bicycle parking that a developer may provide in stairwells and patio and balcony outdoor closets may count towards the total minimum required bicycle parking stalls. Specifically, all stall facilities in stairwells and patio outdoor closets may count,while 50 percent of stall facilities in balcony outdoor closets may count. A developer may provide a stall in an indoor closet or alcove of a dwelling if the space meets the minimum dimensions per Table 3.05G and includes a hook or rack meets the locking standards of above subsection 2 and is foldable or retractable. All patio physical separations from common area shall have a gate minimum 2 feet,4 inches wide. 8. Plan review:The developer or contractor shall submit the following information with applications for any of land use or building permit review: a. Location;where not obvious, access route(s)to; and number of bicycle parking stalls; b. Notated dimensions of all stalls, aisles, maneuvering areas, and clearances;and c. If applicable, information adequate to illustrate the racks and stalls that meet a particular set of standards. Bicycle Parking Stall Minimum Dimensions Table 3.05G ................................................................................................................ z' l \ 6' , Dimension Conventional Alternative(feet)2 Horizontal 1 Horizontal as Wall- Vertical or Wall-Mounted 1,4,5 (feet) Attached 3 Length 6 6 3 ft,4 inches Width 2 2 1 ft, 5 inches Height 3 ft,4 inches 3 ft,4 inches 6 Maneuvering width 7 5 5 5 Clearance 0.5 8 1 9 n/a 1. See Figure 3.05E. 2.The purpose of alternatives primarily is to allow multiple-family dwelling developments to include more easily a number of stalls through any of communal storage rooms and sheds and on building, freestanding, and trash and recycling enclosure walls. 3. See Figure 3.05F. 4. See Figure 3.05G. 5. Vertical or wall-mounted maximums: a. Where the total minimum required bicycle parking is fewer than 4 stalls,vertical and wall- mounted stalls are prohibited. b.Where the total minimum required bicycle parking is 4 or more stalls, of the subtotal that is DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 40 70 outside a building, maximum 50 percent may be vertical stalls. 6. See Figure 3.05H. 7. Sidewalk:Where a bicycle parking stall is adjacent to a sidewalk, off-street bicycle/pedestrian facility,walkway, or access way,the maneuvering area may overlap it. 8. Measured to stall length or width boundary. 9. Measured to centerline of outermost bar of facility. Main ientrance iLandsca piir a ' '` � III w a h port-terry Less — r•° STREET Figure 3.05J—Bicycle Parking Proximity: One Building, One Entrance Finding: The proposal is for a new 84,073 SF retail use within the Commercial General zone. As analyzed for Table 3.05A, the minimum parking bike parking requirement is 50 stalls. All stalls are provided on a paved surface and of the 50 stalls provided, 66%are covered. The plans illustrate 50 spaces meeting all of the size and signage location requirements; however, it may not be apparent that the requirement to have bike parking within 50 feet of the entrance (per 3.05J) is being met. Therefore,the City Council has made an interpretation that pursuant to the Figure, not all of the required bike stalls must be within 50 feet of the door. City Council interprets this Figure to indicate that short term parking spaces need to be within 50 feet of an entrance. The proposed plans provide DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 41 71 for 12 spaces within the 50 of the entry,the remaining are under a shelter approximately 100'feet away. It is the Director's interpretation that this meets the letter, and intent, of the provided within 50 feet of the entrance as is required per 3.05.06. 3.06 Landscaping 3.06.01 Applicability The provisions of this Section shall apply: A.To the site area for all new or expanded multiple-family dwelling and non-residential development, parking and storage areas for equipment, materials and vehicles. 3.06.02 General Requirements A. Building plans for all uses subject to landscaping requirements shall be accompanied by landscaping and irrigation plans. B.All required landscaped areas shall be irrigated unless it is documented that the proposed landscaping does not require irrigation. C. All shrubs and ground cover shall be of a size upon installation so as to attain 80%of ground coverage within 3 years. D. Installation of plant materials and irrigation specified in an approved landscaping plan shall occur at the time of development and shall be a condition of final occupancy.Should site conditions make installation impractical, an acceptable performance guarantee may be approved, subject the requirements of this Ordinance(Section 4.02.08). E.The property owner shall be responsible for maintaining all landscaping,fences, and walls in good condition, so as to present a healthy and orderly appearance. Unhealthy and dead plants shall be removed and replaced, in conformance with the original landscape plan. F.The required number of plant units shall be met by a combination of plant materials listed in this Ordinance (Table 3.06B). G. Required plant units need not be allocated uniformly throughout specified landscaping areas, but may be grouped for visual effect. H. Landscaped areas that are not covered by plant materials shall be covered by a layer of bark mulch or decorative rock, a minimum of two inches in depth. I. A minimum 4 inch high and wide concrete curb shall be provided between landscaped areas and parking and circulation areas. J. Plant materials shall be appropriate to the climate and environment of Woodburn. Inclusion of plants identified in"Suggested Plant Lists for Required Landscaping", published by the Portland Bureau of Development Services, can be used to meet this standard. A landscape architect, certified arborist or nursery person may also attest to plant appropriateness. 3.06.03 Landscaping Standards A.Street Trees DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 42 72 The purpose of the street tree provisions is to get and preserve street trees, to shade those walking and provide them psychological protection from passing vehicles,to calm those driving,to help spatially define streets through canopy,to absorb stormwater and pollutants,to reduce the urban heat island effect, and to raise value of adjacent property. Within the public street right-of-way abutting a development, street trees shall be planted to City standards, prior to final occupancy or earlier if conditioned. 1. A number of trees equal to one tree per every 30 feet of street frontage within a block face, shall be planted within the right-of-way. 2. Street trees shall be planted according to the Boundary Street classification per the Transportation System Plan: c. Small trees shall be planted along all other streets. Refer to Table 3.06B below for the definition of size categories at maturity. 3. Root barriers: The developer shall install root barriers per the public works construction code. 4. Fee in-lieu: Per Section 4.02.12. B.Site landscaping shall comply with Table 3.06A. Planting Requirements Table 3.06A Location Planting Density, Minimum Area to be Landscaped, Minimum 1. Setbacks abutting a street 1 PU/15 square feet Entire setback excluding driveways 2. Buffer yards 1 PU/20 square feet Entire yard excluding off-street parking and loading areas abutting a wall 3. Other yards 1 PU/50 square feet Entire yard, excluding areas subject to more intensive landscaping requirements and off-street parking and loading areas DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 43 73 4. Off-street parking and • 1 small tree per 10 parking • RS, R1S, RSN, RM, RMN, P/SP, CO, loading areas spaces; or 1 CG and MUV zones: 20%of the paved surface area for off-street • 1 medium tree per 15 1 parking, loading and circulation parking spaces; or • DDC, NNC, IP, IL, and SWIR zones: • 1 large tree per 25 parking 10%of the paved surface area for spaces 1 off-street parking, loading and and circulation 1 PU/20 square feet excluding • Landscaping shall be within or required trees 2 immediately adjacent to paved areas 5. Common areas, except 3 PU/50 square feet Entire common area those approved as natural common areas in a PUD 1. Trees shall be located within off-street parking facilities, in proportion to the distribution of the parking spaces. 2. Required landscaping within a setback abutting a street or an interior lot line that is within 20 feet of parking, loading and circulation facilities may also be counted in calculating landscaping for off-street parking, loading and circulation areas. Plant Unit(PU)Value Table 3.06B Material Plant Unit(PU)Value Minimum Size 1. Significant tree 1 15 PU each 24" Diameter 2. Large tree (60-120 feet high at maturity) 1 10 PU each 10' Height or 2"Caliper 3. Medium tree(40-60 feet high at maturity 1 8 PU each 10' Height or 2"Caliper 4. Small tree (18-40 feet high at maturity)1 4 PU each 10' Height or 2"Caliper 5. Large shrub(at maturity over 4'wide x 4' 2 PU each 3 gallon or balled high) 1 6. Small to medium shrub(at maturity 1 PU each 1 gallon maximum 4'wide x 4' high) 1 7. Lawn or other living ground cover 1 1 PU/50 square feet 8. Berm 2 1 PU/20 lineal feet Minimum 2 feet high 9. Ornamental fence 2 1 PU/20 lineal feet 2%-4 feet high 10. Boulder 2 1 PU each Minimum 2 feet high DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 44 74 Plant Unit(PU)Value Table 3.06B Material Plant Unit(PU)Value Minimum Size 11. Sundial, obelisk,gnomon, or gazing ball 2 2 PU each Minimum 3 feet high 12. Fountain 2 3 PU each Minimum 3 feet high 13. Bench or chair 2 0.5 PU/lineal foot Minimum 1 foot high, 14. Raised planting bed constructed of brick, 0.5 PU/lineal foot of stone or similar material except CMU 2 greatest dimensionminimum 1 foot wide in least interior dimension 15. Water feature incorporating stormwater 2 2 per 50 square feet None detention 1. Existing vegetation that is retained has the same plant unit value as planted vegetation. 2. No more than twenty percent(20%)of the required plant units may be satisfied by items in lines 8 through 15. Findings: The landscaping plans illustrate conformance with the requirements in 3.06.02 and the planting requirements in Table 3.06A. For clarity in determining the exact planting requirements (measured in "Plan Units"), Staff requested that the applicant provide a separate landscaping sheet (LS-01) below, which depicts in color each of the three planting areas (Buffer, Off-Street, and Setback). The plan provides landscaping that far exceeds the requirements of the WDO. At Staff's request the applicant enhanced the landscaping buffers and plantings along the both frontages. A'double layer' of street tree plantings are provided and the depth of the landscaped buffers are approximately 30 feet and 45 feet in depth along both Evergreen and Stacy Allison Way, respectively. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 45 75 PLANT BNNPPULE STACY ALLISON WAY .. . - { I LS 02 LS 03 LS- 4 zr u a ICI m � ryg -NCOFCOD55TOKE I LS 05 U LS-06 I LS-07 RMAL"NNBCAP6 AREA PLANT UNITS PN4 MER, . r r Y A ,n O 4 yy � r f P TUNIT NltlNINNMtlNT9 "— Y 41tlr �.. A uu'm v EVERGREEN RD Ii !y IIIIIIIIIIIIIIf rnn 'r,w era r.yen Ignh Landscaping Sheet 01 (LS-01) C. Parking area landscape island standards: Landscape islands or peninsulas shall cap each aisle end to protect parked vehicles from moving vehicles, emphasize vehicular circulation patterns, and shade vehicles and pedestrians. Structured parking is exempted. 1. Each south, southwest, and west island or peninsula cap of a parking aisle shall be minimum 84 square feet within back of curbing, narrowest dimension 6 feet within back of curbing, and contain a tree. 2. Remaining islands and peninsulas shall be minimum 28 square feet within back of curbing and narrowest 2 feet within back of curbing, except where subsection 3 below supersedes. 3.There shall be no more than 10 consecutive parking spaces in a parking aisle without a mid-aisle landscape island or peninsula. For consecutive parking spaces that include one or more accessible/ADA spaces and their aisles,the maximum shall be 9 consecutive parking spaces. Mid-aisle landscape islands or peninsulas shall be to the same standards as subsection 1 above. 4. At drive aisle crossings of walkways and wide walkways that respectively Sections 3.04.06D and 3.05.02N describe, each south, southwest, and west side shall have a landscape island or peninsula to the same standards as subsection 1 above. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 46 76 Finding: The plans indicate parking lot landscape islands that meet all of the requirements of this section in terms of number, size, and dimension. Importantly, during their review of the preliminary stormwater plans for this site,the City's Public Works Department raised concerns about the long-term viability of the public storm facility to the west of Stacy Allison Way. This facility was originally sized over 30 years ago to accommodate development activity along Stacy Allison Way(including this property) however, since that time,the stormwater requirements relating to retention, quality and treatment have become much more stringent. With new, more extensive requirements being placed on the City DEQ related to our stormwater treatment—the City Engineer has requested that additional on-site storm detention areas be included on this property. While there are no immediate issues related to accepting the stormwater from this particular site, the City Engineer has expressed concerns about the compounding impacts of future developments in this area. In an effort to minimize the impacts on the site plan and minimizing the costs to the developer. City Council is recommending Condition of Approval 12 that requires at least 50%of the parking landscape islands to be modified to incorporate rain gardens or similar storm water management systems. 3.06.05 Screening A.Screening between zones and uses shall comply with Table 3.06D. Screening Requirements Table 3.06D N = No screening required F =Sight-obscuring fence required W=Architectural wall required D=Architectural wall,fence, or hedge may be required in the Design Review process Adjacent properties—zone or use that receives the benefit of a N screening no c a; - aJ = c s Property being Developed— must provide screening if no Z a, 2 c ,M "x 3 aJ c N U c O comparable screening exists on o ° N o a aJ aJ o a a, -°Ja 3 C Y abutting protected property vi o O oc oc U 5. CG or MUV zone W2 D D D D D W2 W2 D W2 DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 47 77 1. Screening is only required from the view of abutting streets, parking lots, and residentially zoned property. Storage shall not exceed the height of the screening. 2. Six to seven feet in height 3. Six to nine feet in height 4. Abutting streets must also be screened. 5. Screening is required abutting multiple-family dwellings, commercial or industrial uses only. 6. In industrial zones, screening is required only where the refuse collection facility is in a yard abutting a public street, parking lot, or residentially zoned property. 7. Child care facility for 12 or fewer children,group home for five or fewer persons. 8. Child care facility for 13 or more children,group home for six or more persons. General notes: 9. Screening is subject to height limitations for Vision Clearance Areas(Section 3.03.06) and adjacent to streets(Section 2.01.02). 10. No screening is required where a building wall abuts a property line. 11. Where a wall is required and is located more than two feet from the property line, the yard areas on the exterior of the wall shall be landscaped to a density of one plant unit per 20 square feet. Findings: The proposal is a permitted use. It is for a new retail grocery store within the Commercial General zone. Most of the adjacent properties are also within the Commercial General zone and therefore no perimeter screening on the majority of the perimeter. However, a portion of the southern property line abuts a three story multi-family development with RMN (Medium Residential Nodal) zoning. For these uses,Table 3.06D provides the Planning Commission the option of determining the appropriate screening. The options listed are, "Architectural wall,fence, or hedge may be required in the Design Review process". Presently,the property line between the apartment property and the proposed grocery store includes a six-foot CMU wall with a solid row of mature trees approximately 30 feet in height. 9; V / N / 1 n The Applicant is proposing, and Staff concurs to leave this wall and landscaping in place since it meets DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 48 78 the screen wall height and texture/pattern requirements of WDO Table 3.06D and section 3.06.06B.7. While it doesn't meet some of the specific architectural requirements (horizontal and vertical articulation), replacing the wall with a similar wall that meets these articulation requirements would result in an almost identical wall in appearance and be a bothersome and intrusive process to the existing Cascade Meadows Apartments residents. The Applicant proposes to clean and paint the wall to meet sections 3.06.06B.5 and 6. B.All parking areas, except those for single-family dwellings and dwellings other than multiple-family, abutting a street shall provide a 42-inch (3.5-foot)vertical visual screen from the abutting street grade. Acceptable design techniques to provide the screening include plant materials, berms, architectural walls, and depressed grade for the parking area.All screening shall comply with the clear vision standards of this ordinance(Section 3.03.06). Findings: As outlined in the Landscaping Section above,the plans include an enhanced buffer with landscaping in excess of the requirements of the WDO. This includes double-rows of trees as well dense shrubs and groundcover which will provide screening for parking spaces along both streets. 3.07 Architectural Design 3.07.01 Applicability of Architectural Design Standards and Guidelines A. For a Type I review, the criteria of this Section shall be read as"shall"and shall be applied as standards. For a Type II or III review,the criteria of this Section shall be read as"should"and shall be applied as guidelines. 3.07.06 Standards for Non-Residential Structures in Residential, Commercial and Public/Semi Public Zones A.The following design guidelines shall be applicable to all non-residential structures and buildings in the RS, RSN, R1S, RM, RMN, CO, CG, and P/SP zones. B.Architectural Design Guidelines 1. Mass and Bulk Articulation Guidelines a. Building facades visible from streets and public parking areas should be articulated, in order to avoid the appearance of box-like structures with unbroken wall surfaces. b.The appearance of exterior walls should be enhanced by incorporating three-dimensional design features, including the following: (1) Public doorways or passage ways through the building (2)Wall offsets or projections DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 49 79 (3)Variation in building materials or textures (4)Arcades, awnings, canopies or porches 2. Materials and Texture Guidelines a. Building exteriors should exhibit finishes and textures that reduce the visual monotony of bulky structures and large structural spaces. Building exteriors should enhance visual interest of wall surfaces and harmonize with the structural design. b.The appearance of exterior surfaces should be enhanced by incorporating the following: (1)At least 30%of the wall surface abutting a street should be glass. (2)All walls visible from a street or public parking area should be surfaced with wood, brick, stone, designer block, or stucco, or with siding that has the appearance of wood lap siding. (3)The use of plain concrete, plain concrete block, corrugated metal, plywood, T-111 and sheet composite siding as exterior finish materials for walls visible from a street or parking area should be avoided. (4)The color of at least 90 percent of the wall, roof and awning surface visible from a street or public parking area should be an"earth tone" color containing 10 parts, or more of brown or a "tinted" color, containing 10 parts or more white. (5) Fluorescent, "day-glo,"or any similar bright color shall not be used on the building exterior. 3. Multi-Planed Roof Guidelines a.The roof line at the top of a structure should establish a distinctive top to the building. b.The roof line should not be flat or hold the same roof line over extended distances. Rather,the roof line should incorporate variations, such as: (1)Offsets or jogs in the plane of the roof; (2)Changes in the height of the exterior wall for flat roof buildings, including parapet walls with variations in elevation or cornices 4. Roof-Mounted Equipment Guidelines All roof-mounted equipment, except solar collectors, should be screened from view by: a. Locating roof-mounted equipment below the highest vertical element of the building, or b.Screening roof-mounted equipment using materials of the same character as the structure's basic materials 5. Weather Protection Guidelines All building faces abutting a street or a public parking area should provide weather protection for pedestrians. Features to provide this protection should include: a. A continuous walkway at least eight feet wide along the face of the building utilizing a roof overhang, arcade, awnings or canopies b.Awnings and canopies that incorporate the following design features: DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 50 80 (1)Angled or curved surfaces facing a street or parking area (2)A covering of fabric, or matte finish vinyl (3)A constant color and pattern scheme for all buildings within the same development (4) No internal back lighting 6. Solar Access Protection Obstruction of existing solar collectors on abutting properties by site development should be minimized. C. Building Location Guidelines 1. Within the prescribed setbacks, building location and orientation should complement abutting uses and development patterns. 2.The maximum setback from each street should/shall be 80 feet. Minimum 80 percent of the width of a street-facing facade should/shall meet the setback maximum. Finding: The proposal is a Type III review therefore the applicable criteria are guidelines. All roof mounted equipment is proposed to be screened with materials of the same character as the structure. elevation drawings demonstrate conformance with the provisions. While the proposed building follows many of these guidelines, it does not strictly adhere to all of them. The exterior building walls are proposed as composite precast sandwich wall panels. The exterior of the panels is textured with four-inch on center horizontal scores along the bottom, a random vertical scoring at the dark colored pilasters and an exposed aggregate finish throughout the remainder of the panels. The panels will be painted in earthtones as indicated on the Exterior Building Elevations. The proposed design does has horizontal rooftop articulation on the west (front) and south facades but not as much on the north or east (rear)walls. and the building (as with all WinCo's) has minimal glazing. According the applicant, "the addition of horizontal offsets would not benefit the project, and we believe that faux architectural elements do not add to the overall architectural quality or aesthetics of the building. The building offers an attractive, inviting main entry point. The remainder of the design mimics the same quality of materials and is designed with functionality and material efficiency in mind." Staff finds the minimalist and generic architecture acceptable and consistent with the guidelines of the Code, particularly considering the proposed use (big box/discount grocery) and styles of similar buildings in the vicinity. Its worth noting that, early in the review process, the applicant involved staff in discussions and reviews of different architectural options—particularly for the entry feature. Staff's comments were considered and incorporated into the final plans submitted. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 51 81 3.10 Signs 3.10.05 Sign Permit Required A.A sign permit is required to erect, replace, construct, relocate, or alter a sign, unless such sign is exempt under Section 3.10.07.To initiate consideration of a sign permit, a complete City application, accompanying information, and a filing fee must be submitted to the Director.The Director shall issue a sign permit if the applicant demonstrates compliance with all provisions of Section 3.10. Findings: Because new signage is reviewed separately through the Sign Permit process, City Council adds Condition of Approval 4 to apply for and obtain approved Sign Permits for any new signage. However, it should be noted that the applicant, as part of this Design Review application, is requesting a variance to exceed the maximum square footage of a wall sign. That application and Council's findings are found later in this report. 3.11 Lighting 3.11.02 Standards A. Full cut-off:All exterior lighting shall be full cut-off or fully shielded. Figure 3.11A illustrates examples of both unacceptable and acceptable fixtures. B. Heights: Mounting height limits as measured to light fixture underside shall be: 1. Wall:8 feet above finished grade within 5 feet. a. Within a commercial or industrial zoning district and above a loading bay, berth, or dock,the height limit shall instead be 14.5 feet above vehicular grade. b. For all developments and uses,ground floor wall-mounted fixtures are exempt if: (1) placed under a canopy,fixed awning, roof overhang, secondary roof, or building recess; (2)a ground floor canopy or fixed awning is minimum 96 square feet and 8 feet narrowest dimension; (3)a roof overhang or secondary roof is minimum 72 square feet and 8 feet narrowest dimension; (4)a building recess is minimum 72 square feet and 8 narrowest dimension; (5)an adjacent combination of building recess and, projecting from the main wall plane, either(a) a ground floor canopy or fixed awning or(b) a roof overhang or secondary roof,total minimum 72 square feet and 8 narrowest dimension; (6)a ground floor canopy,fixed awning, roof overhang, secondary roof, or building recess is with maximum 14 feet height clearance above grade; and DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 52 82 (7)the fixture is mounted no lower than at the same level as the underside of the ground floor canopy or fixed awning or within and flush with the building recess ceiling. 2. Poles within parking areas: 14.5 feet above vehicular grade within 5 feet of any parking or vehicular circulation area or its curbing. Parking area poles within 24 feet of ROW, greenways, or off-street public bicycle/pedestrian facilities, shall have the public-facing perimeter of the fixture underside with housing or a shield minimum 6 inches high. 3. Other poles: 10 feet above finished grade. Includes poles along walkways,wide walkways, and off- street bicycle/pedestrian facilities where they do not pass through or along parking areas. Within an industrial zoning district operations or storage yard, minimum 20 feet from a lot line the height limit shall instead rise to 20 feet. C. Hue/color temperature: Excepting industrial development, if a fixture uses light emitting diode (LED)technology, it shall emit a warm,yellowish white light instead of cool, bluish white light. A color temperature within the range of 2,700 to 4,000 degrees Kelvin presumptively meets the requirement. D. Property line: Lighting shall not shine or reflect onto(1) ROW, (2)greenways, (3) off-street public bicycle/pedestrian corridors, or(4)adjacent residentially zoned property. Pole-mounted fixtures other than those in parking areas, and wall-mounted fixtures,that abut any of(1)-(3) are exempt if they are sited within 20 feet of any of(1)-(3), and conform to subsection B.1 or 3 above. Finding: A photometric study was provided with the plans all exterior lighting is via full cut-off(shielded) building wall and pole mounted fixtures. The wall mounted fixtures are proposed to meet the height requirements of WDO3.11.02B.1. However, the applicant is requesting a variance to the height of the parking lot lighting this is described in detail under the variance section 4.01 Decision-Making Procedures 4.01.07 Consolidated Applications An applicant may request,in writing,to consolidate applications needed for a single development project. Under a consolidated review, all applications shall be processed following the procedures applicable for the highest type decision requested. It is the express policy of the City that development review not be segmented into discrete parts in a manner that precludes a comprehensive review of the entire development and its cumulative impacts. Finding: The application package includes a Type III Design Review,Type III Street Adjustment,Type I Property Line Adjustment and Type III Variances. Per 4.01.07, they have been consolidated into a single package for review at the Type III level. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 53 83 4.01.16 Request of Continuance and to Keep the Record Open Finding: The Planning Commission reviewed all the evidence, testimony, and argument in the record, including the April 21, 2026, letter submitted on behalf of Protect Our Valley Alliance and the April 23, 2026, final argument submitted on behalf of the applicant.The Planning Commission disagreed with the objections stated in the April 21 letter and hereby finds that the post-hearing process has not denied any substantial right provided by statute to Protect Our Valley Alliance and that the applicant has not submitted evidence in violation of applicable statute. The City Council concurred with the Planning Commission's finding but also addresses this issue through the supplemental findings herein. 5.01.01 Property Line Adjustment: Consolidation of Lots A. Purpose:The purpose of this review is to ensure that adjustments to property lines or the consolidation of existing lots and parcels, complies with the standards of this ordinance(Section 2), and State Statutes(ORS Chapters 92 and 209). Property line adjustments and consolidation of lots are allowed in all zones. B. Criteria: 1. Lot area, depth,width,frontage, building setbacks,vehicular access and lot coverage comply with the standards of this ordinance(Sections 2 and 3); 2. Existing easements are accurately reflected; 3. Existing land use and development on the subject property comply with the requirements of prior land use actions; and 4. Buildings and structures abutting the adjusted property lines comply with State building codes and with respect to current occupancy. 5. Property line adjustments are surveyed and monumented to the requirements set forth in State statutes(ORS Chapters 92 and 209) and recorded by the County Surveyor. C. Procedure:The Director shall review and approve the application when it is found that it meets this Ordinance and the State Building Codes. D. Building permit application: A developer may apply for building permit or permits for the adjusted or consolidated property upon completion of: (1) recordation with the County of the final plat, including public easements and any separate conveyance documents, (2)submittal to both the Director and the Public Works Department no later than through building permit application of electronic copies of required documents per Section 2.01.05, unless regarding as-builts specifically the Public Works Director in writing defers to a specific set of later circumstances or date. This section does not abrogate additional requirements elsewhere in the WDO or in land use conditions of approval necessary for a developer to meet before building permit application. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 54 84 Finding: The proposed property line adjustment meets all of the lot criteria of this Section (lot area, depth, width, frontage, etc.). The site is vacant so there are no setback or lot coverage considerations. However, City Council is including Public Works Condition of Approval 3 requiring recordation of easements and right-of-way in accordance with the requirements of the Marion County Surveyor. To meet subsection B5, City Council added Condition of Approval 15 to record the property line adjustment in a manner acceptable to the Marion County Surveyor. 5.03 Type III (Quasi-Judicial) Decisions 5.03.02 Design Review,Type III B.Type III Design Review is required for the following: 5. For sites with existing buildings in the CO, CG, MUV, DDC, NNC, IP, IL, and SWIR zones;expansions or new buildings that increase lot coverage by more 25%. Finding: The proposal is for a new non-residential structure on a vacant lot in the CG zone. Therefore,the Design Review is a Type III. 5.03.03 Adjustment to Street Improvement Requirements("Street Adjustment") Same as Section 5.02.04 except that land use review is Type Ill. 5.02.04 Adjustment to Street Improvement Requirements("Street Adjustment") A. Purpose:The purpose of a Type II Street Adjustment is to allow deviation from the street standards required by Section 3.01 for the functional classification of streets identified in the Woodburn Transportation System Plan.The Street Adjustment review process provides a mechanism by which the regulations in the WDO may be adjusted if the proposed development continues to meet the intended purposes of Section 3.01. Street Adjustment reviews provide discretionary flexibility for unusual situations.They also allow for alternative ways to meet the purposes of Section 3.01.They do not serve to except or exempt from or to lessen or lower minimum standards for ROW improvements, with exceptions of subsections B& H. A Street Adjustment is for providing customized public improvements that substitutes for what standards require,while a Variance is for excepting or exempting from, lessening, or lowering standards,with exceptions of subsections B& H. A Street Adjustment for a development reviewed as a Type I or II application shall be considered as a Type II application,while development reviewed as a Type Ill application shall be considered a Type Ill application. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 55 85 B.Applicability: Per the Purpose subsection above about improvements, and regarding ROW Street Adjustment may be used to narrow minimum width. Regarding alleys or off-street bicycle/pedestrian corridor or facility standards, see instead Zoning Adjustment. C. Criteria: 1.The estimated extent, on a quantitative basis,to which the rights-of-way and improvements will be used by persons served by the building or development, and whether the use is for safety or convenience; 2.The estimated level, on a quantitative basis, of rights-of-way and improvements needed to meet the estimated extent of use by persons served by the building or development; 3.The estimated impact, on a quantitative basis, of the building or development on the public infrastructure system of which the rights-of-way and improvements will be a part; 4.The estimated level, on a quantitative basis, of rights-of-way and improvements needed to mitigate the estimated impact on the public infrastructure system. 5.The application is not based primarily on convenience for a developer or reducing civil engineering or public improvements construction costs to a developer. 6.The application is not based primarily on the existence of adjacent or nearby nonconforming Boundary Street frontages. 7. Narrowing of ROW minimum width,if proposed, is not to a degree more than necessary to meet other criteria. In no case shall ROW total fewer than 35 feet,whether or not the total is allocated across centerline or to its side, except that this base requirement would not apply if subsection H below applies. 8. A Street Adjustment would provide a customized cross section alternative to the standard or standards and that meets the relevant purposes of Section 3.01, or the City reasonably can condition approval to achieve such. D. Minimum Standards:To ensure a safe and functional street with capacity to meet current demands and to ensure safety for vehicles, bicyclists and pedestrians, as well as other forms of non-vehicular traffic,the minimum standards for rights-of-way and improvements for Boundary and Connecting Streets per Sections 3.01.03C& D continue to apply. Exempting from or lessening or lowering those standards shall require a Variance. Deviation from applicable public works construction code specifications would be separate from the WDO through process that the Public Works Department might establish. E. Factors:Street Adjustment applications,where and if approved, shall have conditions that customize improvements and secure accommodations for persons walking and cycling, not only driving, that meet the purposes of Section 3.01.The City may through approval with conditions require wider additional ROW dedication along the part or the whole of an extent of the subject frontage to accommodate either adjusted improvements or improvements that vary from standards. F. Bicycle/pedestrian facility: If and where a Street Adjustment application requests to substitute or omit one or more required bicycle facilities, such as bicycle lanes, and the City approves the application,then the following should apply: For each substitute or omitted facility, the developer would construct a minimum width 8 feet bicycle/pedestrian facility on the same side of street centerline as the substituted or omitted facility.The City may condition wider. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 56 86 G. Landscape strip: If and where a Street Adjustment application requests to adjust one or more required landscape strips from between curb and sidewalk, and the City approves the application, then the list below should apply.This subsection is not applicable to bridge/culvert crossing. 1. Sidewalk:Construction of sidewalk minimum width 8 feet on the same side of street centerline as the adjusted landscape strip.The City may condition wider. 2. Planting corridor: For each landscape strip that is relocated, delineation and establishment of a street tree planting corridor along the back of sidewalk in such a way as to allow newly planted trees to not conflict with any required streetside PUE to the extent that the Public Works Department Engineering Division in writing defines what constitutes a conflict.To give enough room for root growth, the corridor minimum width would be either 6 feet where along open yard or 7 ft where it would be flush with a building foundation. This would include installation of root barriers between the trees and street centerline to public works construction code specification. 3. ROW:Where necessary to meet the above standards, dedication of additional ROW even if the additional is more than the minimum additional dedication that Section 3.01 requires. 4. Planting in ROW required:Street trees would not be planted in the yard outside ROW. H. If the applicable Boundary Street minimums are the lesser minimums for residential development of 4 or fewer dwellings and where no land division is applicable, as Section 3.01.03C.2 allows,then allowed adjustment is: 1. ROW: Relating to Section 3.01.03C.2a,to lower ROW minimum dedication either(a)from a number greater than 5 feet to no fewer than 5 feet or(b)from a number equal to or fewer than 5 feet to no dedication. Greater deviation requires Variance. 2. PUE, streetside: Relating to Section 3.01.03C.2b,to lower streetside PUE minimum dedication to no fewer than 3 feet. Greater deviation requires Variance. This subsection is not relevant to deviation from improvements. I. Plan review:An applicant shall submit among other administratively required application materials scaled drawings, including plan and cross section views,of proposed street improvement widths, extents, and details as well as existing conditions and proposed development site plans that include property and easement lines and physical features some distance beyond the boundaries of the subject property for fuller context. Finding: Stacy Allison Way is unique in that the City Council previously approved a modified 'preferred' cross- section for this roadway when the apartments (Allison Way apartments)just south of this proposal were previously approved. Therefore, when the current applicant(WinCo) initially discussed developing this site, City Staff directed them to use the 'modified' cross-section. The classification of Stacy Allison Way is Service Collector with a specific cross-section that is required per the City's TSP. Unfortunately, the only way to use a cross-section that doesn't align with the TSP (even if requested to do so by Staff) is through the Street Exception process. Needless to say, staff strongly supports the proposed modified cross section and recommends its approval. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 57 87 The application provided a detailed description of the request, as well as the differences between the TSP cross-section and modified one: iP r tf Lpi I I rrt+«r ;e ,� I y 00R �w a e rlrVHIIa - , F sure 1—C ty of'dWoodburn Service Collector "We are requesting to maintain the current street section for Stacy Allison Way across the entirety of the project frontage. This request is consistent with guidance from City Engineering staff. The project proposes mitigating frontage improvements, including a 5-foot ROW dedication, removal and replacement of the existing sidewalk with a new 6-foot detached sidewalk, and a 5.5 foot landscape strip located between the detached sidewalk and the existing 6-foot bike lane. The proposed improvements have been designed to meet the City's current Service Collector Standard to the maximum extent practicable and improve pedestrian safety through the installation of a detached sidewalk, while maintaining the alignment of Stacy Allison Way and preserving the 6-foot bike lane and underground utilities along the east side of the road." I pH 9IX .lif L»t i114kv py mart aI i1W Yl Lq il.W IFI ll n 4Iw'gd^fhNf G6kf I:W![ r PRAM6 fMdF 4CNI�gY IUCtiU IAINC iNA4fL UNr fNNf V:Mf I:ANGSf!P7 � u I ',. k. iaouux I ST,ACYALLISON YM1 Y(XAJ Rgure 2—Stacy AIIVsor:Way Proposed Im-rovemuerls Proposed Stacey Allison Way cross-section DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 58 88 "In summary, we are proposing a 0.5 foot reduction of the planter strip as a reasonable deviation from the City's current Service Collector standard. This deviation will maintain the current constructed section of Stacy Allison Way, including the 6-foot northbound bike lane, which is 1 foot wider than the City's current Service Collector standard. It is our belief that the combination of the existing 6-foot bike lane, 5- foot ROW dedication, new 5.5 foot planter strip, and a 6-foot detached sidewalk provides safety enhancements for pedestrians, cyclists, and vehicles along WinCo's frontage, while limiting impacts to the existing storm water, water, power, and natural gas utility infrastructure." City Council approves the Street Adjustment request. 5.03.12 Variance A. Purpose: The purpose of this Type III Variance is to allow use of a property in a way that would otherwise be prohibited by this Ordinance. Uses not allowed in a particular zone are not subject to the variance process. Standards set by statute relating to siting of manufactured homes on individual lots; siding and roof of manufactured homes; and manufactured home and dwelling park improvements are non-variable. B. Criteria: A variance may be granted to allow a deviation from development standard of this ordinance where the following criteria are met: 1. Strict adherence to the standards of this ordinance is not possible or imposes an excessive burden on the property owner, and 2. Variance to the standards will not unreasonably impact existing or potential uses or development on the subject property or adjacent properties. C. Factors to Consider: A determination of whether the criteria are satisfied involves balancing competing and conflicting interests.The factors that are listed below are not criteria and are not intended to be an exclusive list and are used as a guide in determining whether the criteria are met. 1.The variance is necessary to prevent unnecessary hardship relating to the land or structure,which would cause the property to be unbuildable by application of this Ordinance. Factors to consider in determining whether hardship exists, include: a. Physical circumstances over which the applicant has no control related to the piece of property involved that distinguish it from other land in the zone, including but not limited to, lot size, shape, and topography. b.Whether reasonable use similar to other properties can be made of the property without the variance. c. Whether the hardship was created by the person requesting the variance. 2. Development consistent with the request will not be materially injurious to adjacent properties. Factors to be considered in determining whether development consistent with the variance materially injurious include, but are not limited to: a. Physical impacts such development will have because of the variance, such as visual, noise,traffic DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 59 89 and drainage, erosion and landslide hazards. b. Incremental impacts occurring as a result of the proposed variance. 3. Existing physical and natural systems, such as but not limited to traffic, drainage, dramatic land forms or parks will not be adversely affected because of the variance. 4. Whether the variance is the minimum deviation necessary to make reasonable economic use of the property; 5. Whether the variance conflicts with the Woodburn Comprehensive Plan. 6. If and where a variance includes a request to vary from minimum public improvements per Section 3.01,from Section 5.02.04E about Street Adjustment factors, those factors are applicable as Variance additional factors. Findings: The applicant submitted three Variance applications: Variance Request 1: Number of Electric Vehicle ("EV") parking spaces Per WDO Table 3.05E, for commercial developments at least 5%of the total number of parking stalls must be allocated for EV charging with a minimum Level 2 charger. This means that 17 spaces with chargers are required for the proposed WinCo. The applicant asserts that this is an excessive number and creates an unnecessary burden. They are proposing instead to provide eight spaces with Tesla's Level 3 superchargers. Quoting from their application narrative: "Installation of eight Level 3 charges in lieu of 17 Level 2 chargers provides more charging power, would not unreasonably impact the subject property or adjacent properties and should be considered an upgrade to the WDO EV parking requirement. Tesla, one of the nation's largest EV charging manufacturers and providers, has recommended eight Level 3 charging spaces for this site and has described and justified this recommendation in the attached letter. If EV charging demand increases, additional stalls would be added later as warranted. Level 3 charging provides up to two hundred miles of range in 15 minutes vs. 7-10 miles per 15 minutes of charge time with Level 2 chargers(20x faster charging)." (p. 45) At the City's request,the applicant provided a letter from the manufacturer(Tesla) outlining their anticipated EV charging needs for this site (Attachment 106) . They agree that eight Level 3 Superchargers are adequate and state that their technology can "serve more vehicles with fewer stalls". EV charging is still a relatively new and evolving technology. The EV parking provisions were adopted as part of the City's WDO just four years ago. Staff believes that it's important that the Code be able to provide flexibility to allow for reasonable modifications to the code in response to shifting market and DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 60 90 technological forces. Staff gives broad deference to the manufacturer's recommendations on the number of EV stations that will be required. It's reasonable to assume that the manufacturer's goal would be provide as many EV stations as are necessary to serve their customers. Based on the type of chargers proposed, and the use being considered, City Council agrees that eight Level 3 Superchargers will adequately address the needs of the public. It is also fair to note that the WDO's metric for measuring the required number of EV stalls is based on the zoning district; all "non-residential development within commercial zoning districts". In essence, this means that the required number of EV stalls is based on the parking requirements of a zone as opposed to the EV charging needs for an individual use. This fails to take into account that different uses may have different needs for EV chargers. For example, an office or warehouse may have more employees staying in their spaces for a longer period; whereas a fast food restaurant or florist has much faster turnover and would likely have less need for EV chargers. Yet the WDO has the same minimum requirements for both. It also doesn't consider that different chargers (speed) impact the number of spaces required. Level 3 chargers charge much faster than Level 2 chargers, so it is reasonable to assume that there will be more turnover of these spaces and the need for less. The request would have no negative impact on adjacent properties and in any case, the applicant can always add to the number of EV chargers in the future. In fact, it would be financially advantageous for them (Tesla)to do so if demand increases. City Council approves Variance#1: EV parking space variance. Variance Request 2: Wall signage area The applicable sign requirements are found in WDO Table 3.10.10B. For this proposal, the Code allows wall signage on the front of the building to be up to 300 SF in area. The applicant is requesting that this be increased by 143 SF which allow them to have wall signage on the front of their building that would be 453 SF in area. Their elevations depict the front elevation with the proposed increased signage: FRONT ELEVATION The Applicant submitted the following justification for this variance request: DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 61 91 "Strict adherence to WDO Table 3.10.10B and section 3.10 would allow 300 square feet of signage on the front and left(facing Center St.)building elevations because those facades are more than 200 feet from the public right-of-way. It would allow 200 square feet of signage on the rear elevation. The Applicant is meeting this standard on the left and rear elevations but is requesting a variance to increase the front elevation signage by 153 square feet to 453 square feet to ensure readability from both Stacey Allison Way and Interstate 5. The front of the proposed building is approximately 380 feet from the center of Stacey Allison, 560 feet from the center of northbound 1-5 and 660 feet from the center of southbound!- 5. Strict compliance with the front elevation signage limit imposes an excessive burden on the Applicant because it forces signage to be reduced to the point that it will not be legible from 1-5 and likely even difficult to identify from Stacey Allison for some customers. The proposed increase in signage area would not unreasonably impact the subject property or adjacent properties. The front of the building and associated signage face directly toward both Stacey Allison Way and 1-5. It will be visible only from those public roadways and will not be visible from any neighboring residential properties. The signage is proposed in just two locations of the front elevation as shown on the Front Elevation drawing. The largest letters of the primary, 'WinCo Foods'sign are proposed as 66- inches in height. While this may seem large, the general rule of thumb for optimal readability is 1-inch of letter height for every 10 feet of distance. This means that letters need to be 38-inches high at minimum to ensure recognition from Stacey Allison and 66-inches in height to be legible from southbound 1-5. The proposed 66-inch-high letters ensure the building signage can be read from 1-5 allowing customers and passersby to quickly and safely identify and locate the building. This benefits both the development and surrounding community."(Pg. 46) There are several unique circumstances specific to this property and use that need to be discussed. It's true that this property is located along 1-5 and therefore the signage (visibility) requirements for uses in this area may be different from those of rest of the community. However, the City WDO specifically makes an accommodation (exception)for uses along 1-5. The sign provisions of the WDO include an overlay("Freeway Overlay")that permits users in this area (including WinCo)to have pole signs that are both larger in area and taller in height that the rest of the City. Specifically, WinCo will be permitted a pole sign that is 45 feet tall with a maximum sign area of 300 feet. In all other locations in the City, WinCo would be limited to a 20 foot high pole sign that is 100 SF in area. City Council believes that the "Freeway Overlay" provisions of the WDO serve to adequately address the unique locational dynamics of this site. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 62 92 M LI /iAIJ Figure 3.YOL Freeway Overlay It's also important to note that other similar properties in the area have operated successfully without the need for a variance from the sign code requirements. The WalMart supercenter along Stacey Allison is operating under the same sign code provisions that will be applied to WinCo and it did not receive any variances. Allowing larger signage would be unfair to other properties in the area, and would have a deleterious effect on the aesthetics of the area, hence the need for detailed signage requirements in the first place. City Council approves Variance#2. The Planning Commission did not issue a finding on this variance.The City Council approves this variance pursuant to the supplemental findings herein. Variance Request#3: Parking Light pole height increase Per WDO 3.11.02, parking area light poles are restricted to 14.5 feet in height. During the pre- application conference,the applicant indicated that they wanted to install parking lot lighting poles that were 24.5 feet in height. Staff indicated that we would be amenable to allowing some of the lighting to exceed the code maximum, but that under no circumstances should the lighting along the south property (adjacent to the apartments) exceed the code. The applicant modified plans to include this restriction; as described in their justification for the variance request: "Strict adherence to WDO 3.11.02 would require the Applicant to restrict parking area light poles to 14.5 feet above grade. Doing so imposes an excessive burden because it would necessitate nearly double the number of site lighting poles and fixtures. The additional poles would encroach into parking stalls DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 63 93 necessary to meet customer parking demand. The Applicant proposes 24.5-foot-tall light fixtures(to underside of fixture) throughout the main parking area west(in front of) the building. Shorter poles meeting the 14.5 foot restriction are proposed in the parking area southwest of the building, adjacent to the Cascade Meadow Apartments."(p. 46) Several variances to the City's parking lot lighting height requirements have been granted since these code provisions were adopted three years ago. In fact, Staff has identified this Section of the Code as one that the City should consider modifying to allow for more flexibility to developers. Staff contends that lower light poles near residential properties can be an appropriate mitigation and that allowing higher poles within a large parking lot has few, if any negative impacts. In fact, requiring lower lights, means more light poles need to be installed, resulting in higher costs and more potential conflicts for little benefit. City Council concurs with the applicant's arguments and, with the limitations on the pole heights near the apartments as shown in the plans, approves Variance#3: Parking light pole height. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 64 94 IV. City Council Supplemental Analysis and Findings Application of Criteria and Findings Analysis and Findings from City Council Staff Report This Final Decision adopts the analysis and findings from Planning Commission Final Decision, dated April 28, 2026,which is attached to this Final Decision and is hereby incorporated by reference herein. City Council is supplementing but not changing the Planning Commission Analysis and findings, as reflected in the Supplemental Findings below. Supplemental Analysis and Findings regarding Applicant's Variance Request#2(Increase in wall signage area) The Applicant requested a variance to increase their signage area above that which is permitted under WDO Table 3.10.108 and section 3.10. Strict adherence to the WDO standards would allow 300 square feet of signage on the front and left (facing Center St.) building elevations because those facades are more than 200-feet from the public right-of-way. It would allow 200 square feet of signage on the rear elevation.The Applicant is meeting this standard on the left and rear elevations but is requesting a variance to increase the front elevation signage by 153 square feet to 453 square feet to ensure readability from both Stacy Allison Way and Interstate 5.The front of the proposed building is approximately 380 feet from the center of Stacy Allison, 560-feet from the center of northbound I-5 and 660-feet from the center of southbound I-5.The Applicant argues that strict compliance with the front elevation signage limit imposes an excessive burden because it forces signage to be reduced to the point that it will not be legible from I-5 and likely even difficult to identify from Stacy Allison for some customers. Prior to the April 23, 2026, Planning Commission meeting, the Applicant entered renderings into the record which compared the WDO compliant sign to the sign with the extra signage area proposed in the variance. The Planning Commission reviewed those materials and recommended approval of the sign variance. City Council finds that those renderings constitute substantial evidence that the proposed increase in signage area would not unreasonably impact the subject property or adjacent properties. City Council further finds that the Applicant's project narrative constitutes substantial evidence that the proposed signage area would not unreasonably impact the subject property or adjacent properties. In that narrative,the Applicant notes that the front of the building and associated signage face directly toward both Stacy Allison Way and I-5. It will be visible only from those public roadways and will not be visible from any neighboring residential properties.The signage is proposed in just two locations of the front elevation as shown on the Front Elevation rendering.The largest letters of the primary, 'WinCo Foods' sign are proposed as 66-inches in height. While this may seem large, the general rule of thumb for optimal readability is 1-inch of letter height for every 10-feet of distance.This means that letters need to be 38-inches high at minimum to ensure recognition from Stacy Allison and 66-inches in height to be legible from southbound I-5. City Council finds that the proposed 66-inch-high letters ensure the building signage can be read from I-5 allowing customers and passersby to quickly and safely identify and locate the building. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 65 95 Supplemental Analysis and Findings based on other testimony and evidence from the City Council Hearing Based on testimony at the City Council hearing and evidence in the record,the City Council further adopts the following supplemental findings.To the extent that any of the findings and conclusions of law in the Planning Commission Final Decision conflict with any of the supplemental findings below, the supplemental findings shall hereby control. On May 11, 2026, Attorney Andrew Mulkey, representing an unofficial coalition called Protect Our Valley Alliance (the "Appellant"),filed a Notice of Appeal of the Planning Commission's Final Decision on this matter. Included in his submission were letters submitted to both City Council and the Planning Commission dated April 9, 2026,April 26, 2026, March 11, 2026, and June 8, 2026. Along with their Notice of Appeal, the Appellant also submitted letters from their traffic consultant, Greenlight Engineering, dated May 11, 2026, and March 12, 2026, as well as a March 11, 2026, letter from UFCW Local 555, a grocery union, a letter from Naomi Zwerdling of ODOT, a letter from the Salem Audubon Society, and other letters from individuals in opposition to the application. The Primary issues raised by the Appellant and others are (1) that the Planning Commission erred by failing to extend the open record period as requested by the Appellant in their April 21, 2026 procedural objection letter; (2)that the findings of fact and conclusions of law outlined in the Planning Commission's Final Decision were inadequate regarding whether the Project "will contribute substantially to the economic objectives found in the Comprehensive Plan," as required by WDO 2.05.02.G in order to exceed the maximum peak hour vehicle trips specified in Table 2.05A; and (3) traffic concerns, specifically, that the Applicant has failed to demonstrate that various aspects of their TIA comply with the requirements of WDO 3.04.05. The issues raised by the Appellant and others are summarized in bold below. City Council's findings responding to that issue appear below each issue. A. The Planning Commission erred by failing to extend the open record period as requested by Appellant in its April 21, 2026, procedural objection letter. Finding: In their Notice of Appeal, Appellant argues that the Planning Commission committed a procedural error by allowing the Applicant to submit evidence into the record after the closure of the open record period and by not allowing the Appellant the opportunity to respond to the objected to evidence. Appellant therefore argues that City Council must allow Appellant the opportunity to respond to that evidence. WDO 4.01.16 stipulates that when an application is appealed to City Council "the presentation of testimony, arguments and evidence shall not be limited to issues raised in a notice of appeal." Although not expressly stated as such, City Council interprets this provision of the WDO to mean that an appeal to City Council is heard de novo, or anew. Having reviewed the record, City Council agrees with the Planning Commission's finding that no procedural DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 66 96 error occurred. However, City Council also finds that because the appeal to City Council is de novo, any procedural error that may have occurred is moot. Council reaches this conclusion because the de novo appeal process provided the Appellant with the opportunity to respond to the evidence they objected to in their April 21, 2026, letter to the Planning Commission. Through their appeal, the Appellant has had the opportunity to respond to any and all evidence and argument raised in front of the Planning Commission. Accordantly, City Council finds that the Appellants procedural objection has been appropriately remedied through the de novo appeal process and therefore does not provide grounds for City Council to reverse the Planning Commission's Final Decision. B. The approval criteria in WDO 2.05.02 (Interchange Management Area Overlay District) are not satisfied for various reasons, including that the Applicant has failed to demonstrate, and the Planning Commission's findings have not adequately explained, how the Project"will contribute substantially to the economic objectives found in the Comprehensive Plan," as required by WDO 2.05.02.G for developments which are anticipated to exceed the maximum peak hour trips specified in WDO Table 2.05.02.G.1.a. 1. The City has failed to specify the economic objectives that the code requires the Applicant to meet, and inappropriately prioritized commercial development over industrial development. Finding: WDO 2.05.02.G does not specify which aspects of the Comprehensive Plan are "economic objectives." It also does not specify what level of contribution is sufficient to show that development will "contribute substantially"to such goals. City Council interprets WDO 2.05.02.G as follows:The applicable "economic objectives"found in the Comprehensive Plan refer to select goals and policies that relate directly to the type of development being proposed.The Applicant has proposed a commercial development.Therefore, City Council finds that select goals and policies established in Section F of the Comprehensive Plan (Commercial Land Development& Employment) are applicable to the proposed project. In their April 16, 2026, letter to the Planning Commission,the Applicant discusses numerous goals and policies found in Section F of the Comprehensive Plan and explains how the proposed development will contribute to those goals and policies.That letter also included exhibits containing information and data which City Council finds constitutes substantial evidence demonstrating that the proposed development will contribute to the economic objectives found in the Comprehensive Plan, specifically to the goals and policies established in Section F. Therefore, City Council finds the Applicant has met the requirements of WDO 2.05.02. The Appellant argues that certain goals and policies found in Section E of the Comprehensive Plan (Industrial Land Development and Employment), are inadequately addressed by the Applicant. City Council finds that, with the possible exception of Policy E-1.8, (discussed more below),the goals and policies established in Section E of the Comprehensive Plan are not applicable to the proposed development. That interpretation is supported by the structure of the WDO itself which expressly delineates the goals and policies found in Section E of the Comprehensive Plan (Industrial Land Development and Employment)from the goals and policies found in Section F (Commercial Land DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 67 97 Development and Employment). It is clear from the structure of the WDO that the goals and policies in Section E are appliable to industrial developments whereas the goals and policies in Section F are applicable to commercial ones. Regarding Comprehensive Plan Policy E-1.8,that policy reads: "Industrial lands shall be protected from encroachment by commercial or other uses that will either increase the price of industrial land or generate traffic that will interfere with normal industrial practices." Again, City Council interprets this policy to most plausibly apply to industrial developments, not commercial ones. However, Because the policy touches on the intersection of industrial and commercial development, and because the Appellant raised the issue, Policy E-1.8 is addressed in response to Issue B-3 below. Lastly, the Appellant's June 11, 2026, letter to City Council argues that a recent UGB expansion for industrial land requires that the City prioritize industrial over commercial development, or, at least, to balance those two economic objectives. But the plain language of the code requires only that the proposed development substantially contributes to the economic objectives found in the Comprehensive Plan. Nothing in the code requires the City to balance industrial and commercial economic objectives or to prioritize one over the other. City Council therefore finds that to meet WDO 2.05.02.G, it is sufficient for the Applicant to illustrate compliance with Section F of the Comprehensive Plan and to the extent relevant, Policy E-1-8. 2. The Applicant failed to demonstrate how the proposed development will substantially contribute to the economic objectives found in Comprehensive Plan, specifically, Policies E-1.8, E-1.9, Goal F-2 and Policy F-2.1. Finding: As noted above, City Council finds the economic objectives established in Section E of the Comprehensive plan are not applicable to this project and that there is no code requirement to balance industrial and commercial economic objectives. Regarding Comprehensive Plan Policy F-1.3, Goal F-2 and Policy F-2.1, City Council finds that there is substantial evidence in the record demonstrating that the proposed development meets these economic objectives. In their April 16, 2026, letter to the Planning Commission, the Applicant addresses how the proposed development will contribute substantially to economic development policies found in the Comprehensive Plan, specifically Section F of the Comprehensive Plan ("Commercial land Development and Employment): • The proposed development is an infill project in a designated commercial area. The project fits within the goal of the area as a large commercial node (Goal F-1). It will provide commercial services to adjacent and nearby residential areas and is walkable to a significant number of residential housing units, including 180 newly-constructed multi-family apartment units. • Regarding traffic, there is substantial evidence in the record to support that the proposed development will provide needed funding to the City to help alleviate current and future traffic issues at three currently failing intersections (Evergreen & Stacy Allison Way, Evergreen and Hayes Street and Evergreen and Harvard St), and one intersection projected to fail by the year 2040(Hwy 214& Evergreen) (Policy F-1.2). The record supports that the Applicant will provide traffic impact fees to address improvements to each of these intersections. These improvements are funded in the City's CIP and the Applicant's traffic engineer provided analysis illustrating that with the proposed improvements, and taking into account traffic generated by the proposed development,the proposed improvements will cause the three DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 68 98 currently failing intersections to meet performance standards. The findings detailing City Council's response to the Appellant's traffic concerns can be found in Section C below. • The proposed development will reduce reliance on motor vehicles (Goal F-1). The Applicant is installing bicycle racks as required by the code and has agreed to install a bus shelter on Evergreen Road to serve the proposed development.The Applicant is also installing an RRFB crossing on Evergreen Rd., completing a pedestrian corridor between neighboring residential areas and the proposed development, thus promoting pedestrian connectivity between commercially and residentially zoned areas. Finding C-8 below further discusses the Applicant's Transportation Demand Management (TDM) Plan and the other improvements the Applicant has committed to constructing to reduce reliance on motor vehicles. • The record supports that the proposed development will provide a low-cost alternative to higher priced grocery stores for residents of the City. Both the Planning Commission and City Council received testimony from several City residents regarding the need for lower priced groceries in the community. At least two individuals testified that they currently drive to WinCo in Tigard or Salem because it saves them significant amounts of money compared to local grocery stores. The Applicant also submitted screenshots from their Facebook page in which numerous individuals commented on the need for affordable groceries and that the proposed development would save them from driving to other WinCo locations. • Regarding employment opportunities and high-quality jobs (Goal F-2), the Appellant submitted a letter dated March 11, 2026, from UFCW Local 555, a Grocery Store Union. In that letter UFCW asserts that"WinCo is non-union employer whose business model relies on low wages, unpredictable scheduling, and minimal staffing levels." UFCW further asserts that after a non- union grocery store opens "existing union and independent grocers often experience reduced sales, cuts to worker hours, and long-term job instability" and that"these impacts are well- documented and will directly affect the livelihoods of hundreds of Woodburn-area grocery workers." City Council finds that UFCW's claims are not supported in the record. UFCW provided no documentation or data to substantiate their claims. Furthermore, nothing in the code or the applicable criteria requires the Applicant to demonstrate that approval of the proposed development would not have a negative impact on a competitor's business.The code only requires that the Applicant illustrate that the proposed development will substantially contribute to the economic objectives found in the City's Comprehensive Plan. As explained below,the Applicant's April 16, 2026, letter to the Planning Commission and its attachments demonstrate the economic benefits the proposed project will bring to the City. The Applicant's letter and its attachments state that the Applicant plans to hire between 130 and 150 employees for the Woodburn store,that the store is employee owned with an average employee stock ownership plan contribution of 20%of wages at no cost to the employee,that WinCo offers health insurance at rates below the national average, offers short term and long term disability benefits, life insurance and accidental death insurance, a 401(k) and other competitive benefits. At the Planning Commission Hearing, Mark Lavin, representing WinCo, testified regarding these benefits. Other individuals, some of whom currently work at DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 69 99 the WinCo distribution center in Woodburn, also testified that WinCo is an excellent employer offering great employee benefits. Lastly, WinCo submitted written testimony highlighting the employee development and career advancement program it offers including a Manager-In- Training Program, Manager Apprentice Program, and tuition assistance for employees who wish to pursue a Retail Management Certificate Program or associates degree in retail management. City Council has reviewed the UFCW letter and weighed it against the Applicant's April 16, 2026, letter and attachments and finds the Applicant's materials to be more persuasive. City Council finds that the claims made in the UFCW letter are unsupported by substantial evidence in the record. By contrast, City Council finds that the Applicant's letter and attachments constitute substantial evidence demonstrating that the proposed development will provide high quality jobs as required by Goal F-2. City Council finds the above evidence and testimony convincingly demonstrates that the proposed development will substantially contribute to the economic objectives found in the Comprehensive Plan. 3. The Applicant failed to accurately document cumulative peak hour trip impacts from the development subject to IMA limits and the Planning Commission failed to "ensure that the remaining vacant lands in the IMA—such as other vacant commercial lands and industrial lands—are protected from incompatible development generating excessive vehicle trips." Finding: As an initial matter, the quoted language is from WDO 2.05.02.A,which is the purpose statement for the IMA Overlay District and is not an approval criterion. The IMA overlay consists of parcels within the Commercial General (CG) zone as well as parcels within the Southwest Industrial Reserve (SWIR).The proposed development is an outright permitted use in the CG zone. The proposed commercial development is located on a property that is physically separate and apart from the SWIR, and the industrial parcels to the south can and will be served through additional roadway facilities that are not directly impacted by this development proposal.There is no evidence in the record to support a conclusion that the proposed development will interfere with or impact current or future industrial developments within the IMA and SWIR. In fact, as discussed below, evidence in the record supports our conclusion that the proposed development will improve conditions for all parcels within the IMA, including industrial parcels in the SWIR. As discussed by staff at the City Council hearing, the total number of peak hour trips allocated to the IMA is 6,028 trips. The current cumulative allocation of peak hour trips in the IMA is 1,798 trips. The Applicant is proposing adding 511 trips to the current cumulative allocation of peak hour trips which would increase the current cumulative total to 2,309 peak hour trips. Importantly, even with the proposed development's trips added to the current cumulative trip total, there are 3,719 peak hour trips remaining for allocation within the IMA. City Council finds these numbers to be credible evidence supporting a conclusion that there are sufficient trips available for future development of vacant commercial and industrial parcels within the IMA and that the proposed development will not adversely impact current or future developments within the IMA. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 70 100 As noted in Section B-1 above, the Appellant argues that Compressive Plan Policy E-1.8 is inadequately addressed by the Planning Commission's findings. And, as noted above, City Council interprets Policy E- 1.8 to apply to industrial developments, not commercial ones and therefore finds that policy is not applicable to this development. Nevertheless, because it was raised by the Appellant, and because the policy does mention commercial development, City Council finds that the evidence presented regarding the number of remaining trips within the IMA is compelling evidence that the proposed development will not encroach upon or generate traffic that will unduly interfere with industrial development within the IMA as required by Policy E-1.8. Finally, evidence illustrates that the intersection improvements proposed for construction concurrently with the proposed development, and the eventual designation of Stacy Allision Way as a truck route,will improve traffic flow throughout the IMA. (See evidence presented by the Applicant's traffic consultant in their letters dated March 19, 2026, and June 4, 2026, as well as orally at the City Council hearing.)Therefore, City Council finds that to the extent Policy E-1.8 may be peripherally relevant to this application, there is substantial evidence in the record to support that the proposed development will not encroach upon or generate traffic that will interfere with normal industrial practices. Indeed, evidence in the record supports the opposite conclusion. C. The Applicant's TIA and related materials are insufficient in a number of areas, and do not satisfy WDO 3.04.05(A)through (F). 1. Summary of Traffic Related Evidence in the Record: At the start of the TIA process, the Applicant submitted a traffic scoping letter dated June 18, 2025.The Applicant then submitted a revised traffic scoping letter, renamed a traffic methodology memo, dated July 18, 2025.These submittals documented project-specific information and were used by City and ODOT staff to identify the appropriate analysis parameters.The Applicant then submitted a traffic impact analysis(TIA) dated January 2026, as required by WDO 3.04.05.The Appellant submitted a letter from their traffic consultant, Greenlight Engineering, dated March 12, 2026.The Applicant responded with a letter from their traffic engineer, GVC Transportation Solutions, dated March 19, 2026.The Appellant then submitted a second letter from Greenlight Engineering, dated May 11, 2026.The Applicant responded with a second letter from GVC Transportation Solutions dated June 4, 2026.The Appellant submitted a third letter from their Attorney, Mr. Mulkey dated June 8, 2026. A summary of each of the issues raised by Appellant, and the City's findings regarding each issue follows: 2. The Applicant has failed to demonstrate that the improvements proposed for the intersection Highway 214/Evergreen Road will appropriately mitigate the proposed development. In their June 8, 2026 letter,the Appellant argues that the Applicant has failed to "evaluate the transportation impacts of the development proposal" as is required by WDO 3.04.05(C). Specifically, the Appellant argues that the Applicant has not demonstrated that it meets the intersection mobility targets required by ODOT and WDO 3.04.05(F). In their May 11, Notice of Appeal, the Appellant also that the Applicant failed to provide queue analysis for the Hwy 214/Evergreen Rd. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 71 101 Finding: As explained below, and as a threshold matter, City Council finds that because ODOT recommended, but did not require mitigation at this intersection, no further analysis is required by the applicant. ODOT provided two comment letters, dated February 6, 2026, and March 12, 2026. In the February 6, 2026, letter, ODOT states that no mitigation measures to any state facility have been proposed (by ODOT) but that the proposed development will impact future PM peak hour conditions at the intersection of Hwy 214 and Evergreen Rd. ODOT therefore recommended, but did not require, that the Applicant signalize the eastbound and northbound right-turn lanes. In their March 12, 2026, letter, Naomi Zwerdling, of ODOT, confirmed ODOT's recommendation and requested that the City include that recommendation as a condition of approval for the proposed project. Both ODOT letters clearly identify the proposed mitigation as a recommendation to mitigate a future projected failure at the intersection, not a requirement to mitigate a failure caused by the proposed development. Nevertheless, the Applicant has voluntarily agreed to construct the recommended improvement. Per Ms. Zwerdling's request,that agreement is reflected in condition of approval 15. Ignoring the fact that the proposed improvement is voluntary, Appellant nevertheless argues that the Applicant must provide queue analysis for this intersection. As established above, no such analysis is required. However, even if further analysis of the intersection was required (which it is not), that does not necessarily mean a queue analysis is required as the Appellant asserts. Indeed, in their June 4, 2026, letter the Applicant's traffic consultant, GVC Transportation Solutions, notes that they coordinated with ODOT on the TIA and that ODOT did not request or require a queue evaluation. They further note that the ODOT Analysis Procedures Manual lists a queue analysis as one potential task, but that not all tasks in the manual will apply to every TIA. City Council finds the June 4, 2026, letter to be substantial evidence that, with regard to Hwy 214/Evergreen Rd., no queueing analysis or other technical analysis is required for purposes of meeting the TIA criteria standard for the proposed project. That evidence also supports ODOT's recommendation, but not requirement, to include improvements to the Hwy 214/Evergreen Road intersection. Because that improvement is not required for approval of the proposed development, the TIA need not provide technical evaluation. 3. The Applicant understates pass-by-trips and misapplies the technical definition. Because the Hwy 214/Evergreen Road intersection is projected to operate at only.01 below the ODOT mobility threshold, this understatement could cause the intersection to fall below ODOT's mobility threshold. Finding: In their June 8, 2026, letter the Appellant argues that the Applicant's "pass-by-trip" analysis inappropriately assumes that pass-by-trips will come from the nearest high-volume road (here Hwy. 214) instead of the roads adjacent to the proposed project.The Appellant asserts that such a misapplication could cause the intersection to fall below ODOT's mobility threshold. As an initial matter,the Appellant's assertion is not supported by the record.The Appellant did not provide direct references or excerpts from the ITE manual or any evidence to support their assertion that the Applicant misapplied the pass-by-trip definition. Without such evidence,the Appellant's DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 72 102 assertion is simply conjecture. By contrast, in their March 19, 2026, and June 4, 2026 letters,the Applicant's traffic engineer, GVC Transportation Solutions, explained that their calculation of pass-by-trips is consistent with the pass-by- trip calculation used by other recently approved City projects such as the traffic impact study for Unitus Community Credit Union. They further stated that their methodology for calculating pass-by-trips is common in situations where, as is the case here, the proposed development sits on lower volume roads but close to a major arterial. They note that in so doing, the Applicant is actually providing a conservative analysis of the pass-by-trips on the roads adjacent to the proposed development. As to whether this method of calculating pass-by-trips could cause the intersection of Hwy 214/Evergreen Road to fall below the mobility threshold for that intersection, ODOT reviewed the Applicant's TIA, including its pass-by-trip calculation methodology and approved of it, even without ODOT's recommended improvement at Hwy 214/Evergreen Rd. If ODOT had an issue with the pass-by- trip calculation used by the Applicant, ODOT could have raised that issue in its February 6, 2026, and March 12, 2026, letters. ODOT did not do so. Furthermore, as discussed extensively above, ODOT recommended signalization of specific turn movements at Hwy 214/Evergreen Rd., specifically to increase future capacity and improve future operations at that intersection.The Applicant has voluntarily agreed to construct that improvement. It is reasonable to conclude that even if, as the Appellant postulates,the Applicant's pass-by-trip calculation was to cause the Hwy 214/Evergreen Rd., intersection to exceed the current mobility standard, it likely would not do so after completion of the signalization improvement recommended by ODOT. After all, ODOT would not have recommended the improvement if it did not anticipate that it would improve future mobility standards at that intersection. Given the above, City Council finds that the Appellant's assertion that the Applicant misapplied the definition of pass-by-trips lacks substantial evidence in the record. City Council finds it reasonable to conclude, as the GVC Transportation Solutions consultant did, that only a portion of pass-by-trips will come from adjacent streets where, as here, there is a major commuter arterial nearby. City Council further finds that the Applicant's reasoning in calculating pass-by-trips is supported by substantial evidence in the record, namely, the March 19, 2026, and June 4, 2026, letters from GVC Transportation Solutions asserting that they based their calculation on standard practice and that the calculation is consistent with other recently approved projects and is within industry standard. Accordingly, City Council finds that the proposed development meets the requirements of WDO 3.04.05. 4. The Applicant has not demonstrated that it has correctly addressed pipeline development assumptions. Finding: In their June 4, 2026 letter, GVC Transportation Solutions notes that the complete list of pipeline projects is included on page 18 of the TIA report and that Appendix B of the TIA provides traffic volume forecast calculations, which include the total volume of pipeline development traffic. That letter also attaches a table documenting individual pipeline development volumes for each study intersection. City Council finds the June 4, 2026, letter and its attached table to constitute substantial evidence that the TIA adequately addressed pipeline development assumptions. That substantial evidence is DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 73 103 supported by the reasoning detailed in the letter. 5. The Applicant incorrectly assumes an opening year of 2026, rather than 2027 thus resulting in understated background traffic volumes and artificially improved operational results. Finding: At the time the Applicant began working with the city, the Applicant had anticipated that the proposed development would open its doors in 2026. Accordingly,the Applicant's TIA reflected a 2026 opening date. However,various delays, including the appellate land use process, have pushed the anticipated opening date to 2027. However, WDO 3.04.05 (the City code criteria for TIAs) does not specify that the opening year traffic assumption must match-up to the resulting construction schedule for a project. In fact, under WDO 4.02.04,vesting for an approved project permits initiation of construction up to three years past the approval date.Therefore, having the TIA include assumptions of the current year it is submitted aligns with the City's code criteria. In any case, substantial evidence supports the conclusion that a change in opening year from 2026 to 2027 will have a negligible and inconsequential effect on forecasted traffic volumes. In their June 4, 2026, letter, GVC Transportation Solutions calculates that with an annual growth rate of 0.50%,the change in forecasted traffic volumes if one additional year of growth were added, would be negligible (fewer than 5 trips for each turning movement, with most being 1-2 additional trips.). The letter includes updated operations at Hwy 214/Evergreen Road illustrating that the intersection will continue to operate within mobility standards even if WinCo opens in 2027. Updated Open ng Year Anal s s on IH m .uway 21.1 AM Peak Hour PM Peak Hour 2026 v/c 2027 v/c 2026 v/c 2027 v/c No intersection ratio ratio ratio ratio 3 Highway 214 at Evergreen Rd 0.669 0.671 4.939 0.943 5 Highway 214 at Boones Ferry Rd 0.729 0.729 0.937 0.940 Importantly,that data does not even consider the Applicant's voluntary agreement to construct ODOT's recommended mitigation at that intersection which, as noted above, will only improve mobility standards for that intersection. City Council finds that there is substantial evidence in the record to support that a change in opening from 2026 to 2027 will have negligible impact on forecasted traffic volumes and that evidence is supported by substantial reason provided in the June 4, 2026, GVC letter. 6. The Applicant has not sufficiently analyzed the impacts of three proposed traffic mitigation improvements on Evergreen Road, has not provided sufficient technical analysis for these intersection improvements, and has not provided signal warrant analysis for these intersections. Finding: In their May 11, 2026, letter,the Appellant argues that the Applicant has failed to provide DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 74 104 sufficient evidence that the proposed mitigations at three intersections on Evergreen Road will, in fact, mitigate traffic concerns for the proposed project. As discussed in pages 29-35 of the Applicant's TIA as well as in the GVC Transportation System letter dated June 4, 2026, the City has identified intersection improvements at three study area intersections, all of which are shown to operate below the adopted performance standard before and after the proposed project. These improvements are: • Stacy Allision Way at Evergreen Road: Install traffic signal control and construct a southbound right turn lane. • Hayes Street at Evergreen Road: Install traffic signal control and restripe eastbound and westbound approaches to Hayes Street to provide turn lanes. • Harvard Drive at Evergreen Road: Install single lane roundabout. Evidence in the record supports that these projects are on the city's current CIP list (project number 2025-017-12), and that the city is advancing intersection improvements at each of these intersections concurrent with construction of the proposed development. Because these intersections are already in the City's CIP and the City has already determined signalization of those intersections is the preferred improvement, City Council finds that analysis of them is not a required element of the Applicant's TIA or required for project approval. Importantly, even if further analysis was required, (which it is not)the Applicant has provided that analysis. Using the current city designs for each intersection a technical analysis has been performed to document that, after construction and with the inclusion of expected WinCo traffic, each intersection will operate within the adopted performance standard.These results are provided below. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 75 105 D26 AIV II III' ell licn.11li° IIIIn1C:r,ir�liecllil in "Illueirn floin : "' cx3 irlli�w.�rrm Illlrm r�rlln�r,:+p:l dlll.11hl IPIVelnilnre l llnll)lnoveirrneints With Project with With Project with Existing Proposed Existing Control Proposed Control Traffic Traffic No Intersection Control Delay LOS Control Delay LOS 6 Stacy Allison Way at Evergreen Road TWSC' 58.3 F Siigrrai 14.7 B 7 Hayes Street at Evergreen Road AWSC2 103.6 F Signal 25.2 C 8 Harvard Drive at Evergreen Road TWSC' 34.1 D RAB3 5.9 A 1. Two way stop contrcul 2. All-way-stop-control 3. ROOundabcut control 20,25 III' en lk Moil i-Illlrmll: rlr . aaiirllrm "II)E,Ir°rrllloo ll.n Allminl Illlnil�.rsecfl F'IVn lnllrme�l llinllrlroveirnelnrts With Project with With Project with Existing Proposed Existing Control Proposed Control Traffic Traffic No Intersection Control Delay LOS Control Delay LOS 6 Stacy Allison Way at Evergreen Road TWSC 400+ F Signal 31.4 C 7 Hayes Street at Evergreen Road AWSC' 98.5 F Signal 24.3 C 8 Harvard Drive at Evergreen Road TWSC' 230.3 F RAB' 6.8 A 1. Two-way- top-co tb 2. All-way-stop-control 3. Roundabout control The above tables, included in the June 4, 2026, letter from GVC Transportation Consultants, clearly illustrate that the proposed improvements to these three intersections will cause the currently failing level of service to meet performance standards.To the extent that Appellant challenges the methodology by which these numbers were reached,the GVC Transportation Consultants letter of June 4, 2026, also included updated traffic volume development calculations and analysis worksheets as well as an explanation of the methodology in calculating traffic volumes (page 17 of the TIA) and a description of the overall analysis methodology(pages 27-28 of the TIA). City Council finds that the June 4, 2026, GVC Transportation Consultants letter and its attachments constitute substantial evidence that the proposed mitigations to three intersections on Evergreen Road will cause the currently failing level of service at those intersections to meet performance standards. City Council finds that evidence to be supported by substantial reasoning both in the letters from GVC and in the Applicant's TIA. To the extent that the Appellant's traffic consultant disagrees with the Applicant's, City Council has weighed the evidence and testimony and finds the Applicant's evidence to be more convincing and thoroughly documented in the record than that of the Appellant. 7. There are discrepancies in the Applicant's TIA when compared to the TIA's of other recently approved projects. Finding: In their March 11, 2026, and May 11, 2026, letters,the Appellant's Traffic Consultant, DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 76 106 Greenlight Engineering, argues that the Applicant's TIA is inconsistent with TIA's of other recently approved projects. Greenlight suggests that the Applicant has failed to account for these discrepancies "despite substantially similar conditions."The Applicant's traffic consultant GVC Transportation Consultant's responded to those concerns in their March 19, 2026 and June 4, 2026 letters. WDO 3.04.05 does not require that an applicant's TIA be consistent with TIAs approved from previous projects.There is no code requirement, regulation or law that would require such consistency, nor has City Council ever interpreted the code to that effect. Therefore, no analysis of the inconsistencies raised by the Appellant is required. However, even if the WDO did require an applicant to explain why their TIA differs from those of other recently approved projects (which it does not), the Applicant has done so in this instance. An inconstancy between the TIA for the proposed development and previously approved developments does not constitute substantial evidence that the current TIA is inadequate or somehow does not meet the requirements of WDO 3.04.05. The analysis and findings in each TIA may differ based on various factors including, but not limited to, the scope of the TIA, the timeframe covered by the TIA,the study area, updated pipeline project data, differing growth rate data, and other information or conditions which may have changed over time. Data collection, including peak hour traffic volumes at an intersection, can also vary widely from day to day depending on conditions (congestion,weather, time of year, etc.). It follows that differences in the use of current data verses older data would lead to inconsistencies between a current TIA and one for a previously approved development. Those inconsistencies do not illustrate an infirmity with the current TIA.To that end, in their March 19, 2026, and June 4, 2026, letters,the Applicant's traffic consultant notes that the distinction in the Applicant's TIA compared to other recently approved projects is due to the Applicant's use of current traffic volume data, a growth rate calculation different than that which was used in the TIAs of previously approved projects, and updated pipeline development information. City Council finds that nothing in WDO 3.04.05 or any other applicable code provision requires consistency between the Applicant's TIA and the TIAs of other previously approved projects. Therefore, any inconsistency does not provide grounds to deny the proposed project. Additionally, City Council finds compelling the data and reasoning presented in the GVC Transportation Consultant's letters, which explain why the Applicant's TIA differs from those of previously approved projects.The fact that the Appellant's traffic engineer, Greenlight Consulting, disagrees with the analysis and conclusions in the Applicant's TIA, or that there are inconsistencies between the Applicant's TIA and those of previously approved projects does not provide grounds for denial of the proposed project when, as is the case here,the Applicant's TIA is supported by evidence in the record and sound reasoning.To the extent that the Appellant argues otherwise, City Council has weighed the evidence and testimony provided by both GVC and Greenlight and finds that of GVC to be more compelling. 8. The Applicant has failed to provide a sufficient Transportation Demand Management (TDM) Plan. Finding: Page 35 and Page 36 of the TIA describe the pedestrian, bicycle, and transit networks that will serve the Project. Condition of Approval 14 lists extensive TDM requirements the applicant has agreed to. The TDM Plan shall include the following: i. An information board for employees that will have the city transit schedule posted DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 77 107 ii. Potential employee rewards for use of transit and/or bike/walk iii. Identify a TDM manager on site,who will be a point of contact for City staff iv. Potential carpool-only parking spaces v. Providing employees with bus passes vi. Periodic updates to the posted information, based on feedback from City staff or changes to travel options. vii. Provisions for an annual report for five years to be provided to the City to the attention of the Community Development Director that references this condition of approval, includes a summary of what the targets were, review of how well targets were met, performance measures, comparison with the prior report, and the effectiveness of the TDM program elements implemented. Pursuant to 3.01.09, prior to Certificate of Occupancy the applicant has agreed to install a bus stop shelter on Evergreen Rd and grant an easement that meets the Woodburn Transit System and Public Works requirements.To offset transportation impacts to the existing network,the Applicant will construct multiple on-site pedestrian facilities to promote walking to and from the site.The Applicant will also provide bicycle parking on site as required by code. The Applicant has also agreed to install a Rectangular Rapid Flashing Beacon (RRFB) on Evergreen Road, south of Oxford Drive.The Appellant asserts that the Applicant has not provided sufficient safety analysis regarding the placement of the RRFB. The RRFB will be constructed in conformance with ODOT guidelines and approved equipment, curb ramps will comply with current federal and ODOT accessibility requirements. Continental crosswalk striping, a concrete refuge island, and street lighting will be installed along with the RRFB. The RRFB will be permitted through the City's public works department which will require the construction to meet public works standards, including but not limited to, site visibility, site location, vehicle queueing, among others. More to the point, construction of the RRFB is not required for approval of this project. Rather, it was voluntarily agreed to by the Applicant. For that reason, no further analysis is required. City Council finds that the Applicants TIA as well as Condition of Approval 14 constitute substantial evidence that the applicant will provide a TDM plan and will make various improvements to the transportation system to support pedestrian access to the site. The Applicant further testified to many of these improvements at the June 8, City Council meeting. City Council finds that evidence and testimony to be compelling. 9. The Applicant has generally failed to show compliance with WDO 3.04.05 (Transportation Impact Analysis). Finding: To the extent not otherwise expressly summarized above, City Council has reviewed the record regarding compliance with WDO 3.04.05. Based on that review, City Council finds the following constitute substantial evidence that the criteria outlined in WDO 3.04.05 have been met: • The Applicant's TIA. • The March 19, 2026, and June 4, 2026, letters from the Applicant's traffic consultant GVC Transportation Systems. • The letter from the Applicant's attorney, Cozette Tran-Caffee, explaining that the Applicant's TIA satisfies WDO 3.04.05. • The letters from ODOT dated February 6, 2026, and March 12, 2026. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 78 108 City Council recognizes that the Appellant has submitted competing evidence from their own traffic consultant, Greenlight Engineering, and has reviewed that evidence along with the letters provided from the Appellant's attorney Mr. Mulkey and the arguments made in the May 11, Notice of Appeal. City Council finds that reasonable professionals may disagree regarding subjective elements of traffic engineering. However, that disagreement does not provide grounds for City Council to deny a proposed development when the TIA meets the requirements of the WDO and is supported by substantial evidence and reasoning. In this instance, City Council weighed the evidence submitted by both parties and, after a thorough review, finds, based on the above evidence and reasoning, that the Applicant has illustrated compliance with WDO 3.04.05._ 10. Other miscellaneous concerns raised during the City Council Hearing. Finding:The record includes a number of concerns related to the impact of the Project on nearby properties.These include the following: • The Project will have a negative impact on wildlife. • The bus stop on Evergreen Road will cause traffic issues. It may expose children at nearby playground to predators who ride the bus and increase potential theft in adjacent neighborhood by people who ride the bus. • The Project will obstruct existing views from nearby residential properties. • The Project will have a negative impact on nearby property values. • General concerns about increased traffic, not related to a specific section of the WDO. • General concerns about noise and late-night operations. City Council finds that the above concerns are not relevant to the applicable approval criteria. Some of these concerns are also not supported by evidence in the record (e.g. increase in crime, reduction in property values).They do not provide a reason to deny approval of the Application. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 79 109 V. Conditions of Approval Based on the findings of fact and conclusions of law above,the City Council, in this Final Decision, adopts the following conditions of approval. These conditions are the same conditions approved by the Planning Commission. General Conditions 2. Substantial conformance: The applicant or successor shall develop the property in substantial conformance with the final plans submitted and approved with this application, except as modified by these conditions of approval. 3. Grading Permit: Prior to beginning any grading work on-site, the developer shall apply for and obtain a Grading Permit per WDO 5.01.04. 4. Fence Permits: To demonstrate conformance with 2.06.02 and 5.01.03, the developer shall submit application for and obtain approval of a Fence Permit for any new or modified fencing. 5. Sign Permits:To demonstrate conformance with 3.10 and 5.01.10,the developer shall submit application for and obtain approval of a Sign Permit for any new or modified signage that is required by 3.10.05 to obtain such permit. 6. Addressing: Prior to receiving Final Plat approval from the City, the developer shall submit an Address Assignment Request, with accompanying fee payment and materials, to the Community Development Department to begin the address assignment process. 7. Public Works Department: The developer shall comply with the Public Works Department conditions in Attachment 101B. Design Review DR 25-14 8. Mid-block bike/ped corridor: To meet 3.01.05C and consistent with the approved plans, the developer shall build a 6-foot pedestrian and bikeway corridor to provide midblock connection between Stacy Allison Way and Evergreen Rd. 9. Easements:The developer shall grantor obtain the following easements prior to building permit issuance: a. Cross access: i. Pursuant to 3.04.01A.2., 3.04.03C.4.a., and 3.04.03D.2., the developer shall grant an access easement over the proposed vehicular drive aisle on the subject property to benefit Tax Lot 052W130001600.The easement shall be a minimum of 20 feet wide. ii. Pursuant to 3.04.01A.2., the developer shall grant an access easement through Tax Lot 052W12C002200,connecting the subject property(tax lot 052W12C002100)to Center St. The easement shall be at least 20 feet wide. b. Mid-block bike/ped corridor access: Pursuant to 3.01.05C., 3.01.07E., and 3.02.01E., the developer shall grant a public access easement over the mid-block bicycle/pedestrian corridor path. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 80 110 10. Cross access: To meet 3.04.03 D2, the developer shall provide a cross access to tax lot 052W130001600 paved to the edge of the property line. 11. Driveway width:To demonstrate conformance with Table 3.04A, prior to building permit issuance, revise the northernmost driveway on Stacy Allison Way to meet the driveway width requirements (either 24 ft or 36 ft if adding a turn pocket). 12. Parking: Include a parking, signage, and striping plan addressing the following: a. Accessible parking: Pursuant to 3.05.03B, accessible parking shall be provided to meet applicable state statutes and building code requirements. b. Carpool/vanpool parking: Carpool/vanpool parking stalls shall meet the signage and striping requirements in 3.05.03H. c. Electric vehicle parking: Electric vehicle parking stalls shall meet the charging level, striping, and signage requirements in 3.05.031. 13. Storm drainage: Per 3.05.02G, revise plans to incorporate rain gardens or similar storm water management systems into at least 50% of the required parking islands to provide stormwater management and pollution mitigation for the parking lot. 14. Traffic mitigation: a. Truck access: In the future,when the City designates Stacy Allison as a truck route the owner will be required to post signage limiting trucks from entering at the Evergreen Rd driveway. Additionally, exiting trucks will only be allowed on Stacy Allison Way. 15. Transportation Demand Management(TDM): a. Pursuant to 2.05.02 G3,the developer shall include within six months of Certificate of Occupancy a document entitled, "Transportation Demand Management (TDM) Strategies". b. The Plan shall include a list of enforceable, programmatic TDM strategies and measures intended to reduce peak hour vehicle trips generated by the proposed development. At a minimum, the Plan shall include: i. An information board for employees that will have the city transit schedule posted ii. Potential employee rewards for use of transit and/or bike/walk iii. Identify a TDM manager on site,who will be a point of contact for City staff iv. Potential carpool-only parking spaces v. Providing employees with bus passes vi. Periodic updates to the posted information, based on feedback from City staff or changes to travel options. vii. Provisions for an annual report for five years to be provided to the City to the attention of the Community Development Director that references this condition of approval, includes a summary of what the targets were, review of how well targets were met, performance measures, comparison with the prior report, and the effectiveness of the TDM program elements implemented. c. Transit: Pursuant to 3.01.09, prior to Certificate of Occupancy the developer shall install a bus stop shelter on Evergreen Rd and grant an easement that meets the Woodburn Transit System and Public Works requirements. d. Prior to final inspection, the developer shall construct a pedestrian crossing on Evergreen Road, south of Oxford Drive. The pedestrian crossing shall include the installation of rectangular rapid DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 81 111 flashing beacon (RRFB) in accordance with the Oregon Department of Transportation (ODOT) guidelines and approved equipment, curb ramps complying with current federal and ODOT accessibility requirements, continental crosswalk striping, concrete refuge island, and street lighting. 16. Applicant shall provide for the signalization of the eastbound and northbound right-turn lanes at the Evergreen Road and OR 214 intersections.The Applicant shall conduct a traffic analysis justifying the signal modifications and preliminary design layouts to gain ODOT approval. Prior to certificate of occupancy issuance, the applicant shall provide to the City a copy of an executed ODOT permit for the completion of both signal modifications. Installation and final inspection of the signal modifications shall be completed within three years of the date of the certificate of occupancy. 17. Prior to Certificate of Occupancy, the developer shall install an electronic cart containment system to prevent shopping carts from being removed from the premises, in a manner acceptable to the Community Development Director. This is to minimize any nuisance from abandoned shopping carts in neighboring properties. Property line adjustment PLA 25-04 18. Recordation:The applicant shall record the property line adjustment with Marion County in a manner acceptable to the County Surveyor. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 82 112 WINCO GROCERY STORE DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01, VAR 25-06 Public Works Conditions March 5, 2026 CONDITIONS OF LAND USE APPROVAL: 1. The Applicant, not the City, is responsible for obtaining any necessary permits from the State, Marion County, Oregon Division of State Lands, US Army Corps of Engineering, and/or federal agencies that may require such permits or approval for the construction of this development. All work within the Oregon Department of Transportation (ODOT) right-of-way requires the applicant to obtain approval and permits from ODOT. 2. Department of Environmental Quality Erosion Control 1200C permit will need to be obtained for this development prior to City issuing approval of civil plans. 3. Applicant shall prepare and record the following right-of-way dedication and public utility easements in accordance with the requirements of the City of Woodburn and the Marion County Surveyor's Office. a. Applicant shall dedicate 5 feet of right-of-way along Stacy Allison Way. b. Applicant shall grant a 5-foot-wide public utility easement along all abutting street frontages. 4. Applicant to provide a performance bond for City right-of-way improvements, in the amount of 120% of the construction cost prior to permits being issued for the Civil Plans approval. 5. Applicant to pay all public improvements (right-of-way) fees for all public improvements which are to be maintained by the City as per Ordinance #1795. 6. Applicant to provide street lighting in accordance with street lighting plan approved by the City and conforming to Portland General Electric installation and plan under option B, if required. 7. All City-maintained facilities located on private property require a minimum of 16-foot-wide utility easement conveyed to the City by the property owner. This is the applicant's responsibility to provide, not the City's. Utilities of unusual depth, size or location may require a larger width. 8. The Applicant, by this Development, shall not cause storm water runoff to be impounded on adjacent properties. 9. All sanitary sewer laterals serving the proposed developments are private up to the main line. 10. The water mains serving this development shall be a looped system, shall be sized in accordance with flow and fire protection requirements. 11. Fire hydrants locations and fire protection requirements shall be as per the Woodburn Fire Districts and City of Woodburn requirements. Actual fire hydrant locations fire department connections (FDC) and in-line valving locations shall be determined during the final Civil Plans approval and building permit issuance. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 83 113 12. All sanitary sewer and storm drainage laterals serving the proposed developments are private up to the main public line. 13. All onsite private storm systems and sewer lateral lines shall comply with Marion County plumbing permit and requirements. 14. Final review of the Civil Plans will be done during the permit application for public improvements. Public infrastructure will be designed and constructed in accordance with plans approved by Public Works and complying with City, State and Federal requirements/guidelines current at the time of the development application. 15. All public improvements shall be deemed complete prior to final building permit inspection. 16. System Development charges shall be paid prior to building permit issuance. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 84 114 VI. Decision Based on the above findings of fact, conclusions of law, and imposed conditions of approval,the City Council makes the following decision: (1) Uphold the Planning Commission's Decision; (2) Approve the consolidated WinCo Grocery applications, DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26- 01, VAR 25-06 based on the findings and conditions found herein. VII. Appeals Per WDO 4.01.11E., the decision is final unless appealed pursuant to Oregon Revised Statutes (ORS), .02.0 ...ORS , state administrative rules, and WDO 4 A copy of the decision is available for inspection at no cost, and the City would provide a copy at reasonable cost at the Community Development Department, City Hall, 270 Montgomery Street, Woodburn, OR 97071. For questions or additional information, contact Cassandra Bassich, Administrative Specialist, at (503) 982-5246 or Cassandra.Bassich@ci.woodburn.or.us DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 85 115 VIII. Testifiers The following testifiers provided testimony to the Planning Commission Table_A Name Address Verbal Written Ryan Barnett (Applicant) 3156 South Bown Way, X X Boise, ID 83706 Byron Hills (Applicant) 3156 South Bown Way, X X Boise, ID 83706 Mark Lavin (WinCo) 650 N Armstrong PL., Boise, X X ID 83704 Deirdre Rickard 3234 Jonah Place, X X Woodburn, OR 97071 Matthew Rickard 3234 Jonah Place, X X Woodburn, OR 97071 Ruben Vazquez 581 Paradise Street, X Woodburn, OR 97071 Alejandro Chavez 2100 Arney LN, Apt#J104, X Woodburn, OR 97071 Melissa Vazquez 581 Paradise Street, X Woodburn, OR 97071 Charlynn Chambers 360 Hawley Street, X Woodburn, OR 97071 Gina Freeland 615 Fir Street,Woodburn, X OR 97071 Devon Freeland 615 Fir Street,Woodburn, X OR 97071 Foma I. Kraskov 7433 Keene RD NE, Gervais X OR, 97025 Esmeralda Negrete 2100 Arney LN, Apt#J104, X Woodburn, OR 97071 Rachel Smail 311 S Evergreen Rd, Apt X A100 Woodburn, OR 97301 Heather King (Willamette 8940 N Bradford St., X River Keeper) Portland, OR 97203 or 454 Willamette St. #218 Eugene, OR 97401 Chris Propeck Keizer, OR (no street X address) Miles Eshaia (United Food 7095 SW Sandburg St X and Commercial Workers Tigard, OR 97223 UFCW Local 555) Kay Eichsteadt McEwen 54 Smith Drive Woodburn X OR 97071 Protect our Valley Alliance PO Box 66562 Portland, OR X DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 86 116 97290 Adria Young No address provided X Carla Arriaga 703 Evergreen Road I X Woodburn, Oregon 97071 Naomi Zwerdling on behalf 455 Airport Road SE X of ODOT Building B Salem, Oregon 97301 Les Poole No address provided X Monica Ovalle No address provided X Maria Torres Lara No address provided X Debera Knox 1960 Santiam Dr X Woodburn, OR Ellen Redel 267 N Settlemier Ave, X Woodburn, OR 97071 Carla Claxton Gervais(no street address) X Russ No address provided X Diane Nelson Cooper 298 Aksenia St,Woodburn, X OR 97071 Larry Staff No address provided X Winona No address provided X Kevin Rakestraw 1999 Jansen way#20 X Woodburn, OR 97071 James (Brian) Smith 1390 independence Ave, X Woodburn, OR 97071 Eva Gurney No address provided X Paul Powers 1526 Astor Way, Woodburn, X OR 97071 Anne Marie Powers 1527 Astor Way, Woodburn, X OR 97071 Christine Johnson No address provided X Debi Hamilton No address provided X Debra Gravitt 1490 Country Club Circle X Delight Coburn No address provided X Elise Fitz Gerald No address provided X James Audritsh No address provided X Jerry D. Pierce No address provided X Linda Metz 1330 Independence Ave, X Woodburn 97071 Christian Cooper 298 Aksenia St Woodburn, X OR 97071 Mary Bixby No address provided X Tammy Coleman No address provided X Pennie Manning 16263 French Prairie Rd NE, X Woodburn, OR 97071 DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 87 117 Susan Montano 280 E Clackamas Cir, X Woodburn, OR, 97071 Salem Audubon Society PO BOX 2084 Salem OR X 97308 The following testifiers provided written testimony to the City Council: Table_B Name Address Verbal Written For Against Amy Walker Ogle Street, no address provided X X Kevin Dean 1387 Mulberry Dr, Woodburn, OR X X Mackenzie Pratt No address provided X X Yuliyana Lozovan 3247 Linfield Ave X X Matthew 3234 Jonah Place, Woodburn, OR Rickard 97071 X X Jackie Burden 235 W Clackamas Circle X X Paul Sharp 467 Clackamas Circle X X Mary Sharp 467 Clackamas Circle X X Deborah Haines 3084 Oxford St X X Jake Wurdinger 253 Boean Ln Woodburn OR 97071 X X Sherry Wurdinger 253 Boean Ln Woodburn OR 97071 X X 781 Harcastle Ave, Woodburn OR Braiden Drew 97071 X X 781 Harcastle Ave, Woodburn OR Elena Raschio 97071 X X Bob Burden 235 W Clackamas Circle X X X Elizabeth Ramirez 246 Skyler Dr,Woodburn OR X X Andrew Mulkey obo Protect Our Valley Alliance PO Box 66562 Portland, OR 97290 X X X DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 88 118 IX. Exhibits A. City Council June 3, 2026, Staff Memo and attachments: 1. Planning Commission Final Decision and attachments a. Conditions of Approval b. Approved Site Plans c. Planning Commission Staff Report with Analysis and Findings 2. Appellant (POVA) Notice of Intent to Appeal (May 11, 2026) 3. Project Webpage with all application materials and correspondence: htt s:JJwww,woodburn-or.gov/774f info-Grocery-Store Sincerely, Chris Kerr,AICP Community Development Director As authorized by the City Council on July 14, 2026: July 14, 2026 Frank Lonergan, Mayor Date DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 89 119 List of Exhibits Exhibit Number Title ExhibitA City Council June 3, 2026, Staff Memo and attachments DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, &VAR 25-06 Appeal City Council Final Decision 90 120 l 'll 'lt A WOODBURN Inc orpornte / 1889 June 3, 2026 To: Honorable Mayor and City Council Through: Scott Derickson, City Manager From: Chris Kerr, Community Development Director Fernando Torres, Associate Planner Subject: Appeal of a Planning Commission approval involving a Design Review, Property Line Adjustment, Street Adjustment, and Variance application package for the "WinCo Grocery Store" (DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, & VAR 25-06) Recommendation: Conduct a public hearing and make a motion to affirm the Planning Commission approval with conditions (Attachment 1 ) and directing staff to prepare a final land use decision for consideration at the next available Council meeting. Project Background: The item before the Council is an appeal of the Planning Commission's April 23, 2026, approval with conditions of WinCo's consolidated application package which includes a Design Review, Property Line Adjustment, Street Adjustment and Variances (3). The Winco development site is approximately 10.6 acres. It is within the Commercial General (CG) zoning district. The proposal is an 84,073 square foot retail grocery store that is anticipated to be open 24 hours a day, seven days a week. � of Front (N/W) elevation facing Stacy Allison Agenda Item Review: City Administrator City Attorney Finance 121 Honorable Mayor and City Council June 3, 2026 (WinCo Grocery Appeal) Page 2 �� tr � Illp „�IiI N,fl 2l "' IIIIIII I� �Q. �1� u / IFFY. JONAH Pk.. iLl Project Site (outlined in red) The front of the building faces west towards 1-5. Access will be from two driveways on Stacy Allison Way, one on Evergreen Rd. and another through a future, currently undeveloped lot along Center St. Parking spaces for 504 vehicles will wrap around the west and south side of the building. An existing block wall at the Cascade Meadow Apartments and 30-foot-high trees screen this development from the apartment complex. Stacy Allison Way a11IlIV IJ IIIDIJll�1�,Ill,I�IIIII�IIINu1U1�l llll II11p11� — ���Nl1NIIIIU1111101UU����111 1�9 __— -- -_ W9JEMID P,YG%AN) INMAN, 91IId4V bUVEY/m a /D/v W!AUD SIN/ONIE IIaPRA,I (6 I IY@ I tll@IYWO INNI M iPAm11D" uNIM111N 4922 7 I0.J/ ,911 !JIIIIMA ✓Op/m//Ih ul�ltillN I MINNE IYdNNIIIAIIflt Rlf MIA INNIIIINING >NlilAafiSUD IWL!�OINiY VAI1NIlGi OfIkYlaz �MllfilITY, E°NI FIB�IVd6 vdall�nl NoluF�np�t groi uu i�li�lWG�I 47Ul�pUll+b 71�,+u Y' UIVV ... ,v HumiNlrIDJ r�ti�ammu f��Dli .. °s peps 6WdIIIIIIIUk ! % fi4W f „�+ � ' � A r + � i Evergreen Rd. Illustrative Site Plan 122 Honorable Mayor and City Council June 3, 2026 (WinCo Grocery Appeal) Page 3 As part of the Commission's approval, the applicant is conditioned to install a Rectangular Rapid Flashing Beacon (RRFB) at the intersection of Oxford St and Evergreen Rd and a bus stop shelter along the site frontage on Evergreen Rd. The applicant will pay System Development Charges (SDC) that will be used to mitigate capacity and safety issues at three nearby intersections: (1) New traffic signal at Evergreen Rd & Stacy Allison Way (2) New Traffic signal at Evergreen Rd & Hayes St; and (3) New roundabout at the intersection of Evergreen Rd & Harvard St. Additionally, based on a recommendation from ODOT, the applicant offered (and has been conditioned) to install traffic lights at the Evergreen Road & OR 214 intersection; specifically, the southbound right-turn onto Evergreen Rd. and the eastbound right-turn lane onto OR 214. The approval also included a Street Adjustment request , which is the process for applicants to request modified street improvement requirements for abutting street rights-of-way. The Adjustment will allow for a street cross-section consistent with the recent approval to the south along Stacy Allison Way. This modified cross- section was previously supported by the Council. The applicant requested three variances: 1 . Reducing the number of Electric Vehicle (EV) parking spaces: The WDO requires 5 percent of the required parking stalls to be minimum Level 2 EV charging spaces, which for this project would be 17 EV stalls. The applicant is requesting to reduce this requirement to provide eight Level 3 chargers. The Commission approved this variance based on a letter in the record from Tesla which indicated that, based on their data for similar sites, fewer level 3 charges will more efficiently serve the site than a greater number of level 2 chargers. Staff support the Commission's approval. 2. Increasing the allowable signage area on front elevation: Adherence to the WDO would allow 300 square feet of signage on the front elevation. The request is to increase the front elevation signage by 153 square feet to 453 square feet. Staff did not support this variance request, but the Commission approved it. 3. Increasing parking area light pole height: The WDO limits parking light poles to 14.5 feet above grade. The applicant is proposing 24.5-foot-tall light fixtures, stating that taller pole height results in fewer light poles needed, which in turn frees up space for customer parking. The Commission approved this variance request with a condition that the light poles in the south/southeast of the property (closest to the residential neighbors) meet 123 Honorable Mayor and City Council June 3, 2026 (WinCo Grocery Appeal) Page 4 the 14.5 feet height requirement to reduce light spillage into adjacent residential lands. Staff recommended approval based on the following factors: • Conformance with all WDO standards (ROW, architectural, utilities, etc.) • Transportation Demand Management requirements (on-site manager, annual reporting , etc.) • New transit stop and shelter along Evergreen Rd. • Elevated landscaping beyond the minimum code requirements • Bioretention facilities within parking lot islands to mitigate stormwater overflow • Payment of the IMA Transportation fee (approximately $2 million) • Public mid-block pedestrian corridor provided from east to west • New Rectangular Rapid Flashing Beacon (RRFP) and pedestrian crossing at Evergreen and Oxford St. • Magnetic cart locking system to prevent theft/off-site spillage; and, • Restriction on light pole heights adjacent to residential. Summary of Planning Commission Hearincis: The Planning Commission held a public hearing on March 12, 2026 for this Type III application package. During the hearing, five people testified in favor of the project, stating that the project would bring much needed affordable groceries, eliminate the need to travel to WinCo in Tigard or Salem and generate new jobs. Proponents also mentioned that Woodburn's economy would benefit by having visitors and residents spend money in Woodburn, and the savings would increase their purchasing power. Opponents raised concerns about increased traffic, construction noises, diminishing property values and potential light and noise encroachment from the WinCo signs and the proposed bus stop. Additionally, staff received 34 written comments in favor of the project and 11 against it. The applicant also presented a social media post by WinCo that obtained 427 comments, the overwhelming majority in favor of the proposal. Based on the volume of testimony received, the applicant requested to keep the record open for 28 days until April 9 and the Planning Commission unanimously granted the extension. In accordance with ORS 197.797(6)(c), (7) from April 10 to April 16 all parties had an opportunity to provide rebuttal testimony. From April 17 to April 23, the applicant had 7 days to provide final argument. On April 21 , a procedural objection was raised by a group known as the Protect Our Valley 124 Honorable Mayor and City Council June 3, 2026 (WinCo Grocery Appeal) Page 5 Alliance ("POVA"). The applicant submitted a response to the objection on April 23. At their April 23, 2026, Planning Commission meeting, after review and discussion of the objection by City staff, the Commission did not find any procedural issues and proceeded with their hearing. The Commission deliberated and unanimously approved the application package. The Commission considered all oral and written arguments presented; including those submitted by both an opposition attorney/engineer as well as the applicant's attorney/engineer. The approval included the Design Review, the Property Line Adjustment, the three Variance requests and Street Adjustment with the conditions recommended by staff through the staff report published on March 5, as well as a new Finding reflecting the Planning Commission's conclusion that no procedural issues occurred and two additional conditions via motion. The additional conditions were: • Applicant shall provide for the signalization of the eastbound and northbound right-turn lanes at the Evergreen Road and OR 214 intersections. The Applicant shall conduct a traffic analysis justifying the signal modifications and preliminary design layouts to gain ODOT approval. Prior to certificate of occupancy issuance, the applicant shall provide to the City a copy of an executed ODOT permit for the completion of both signal modifications. Installation and final inspection of the signal modifications shall be completed within three years of the date of the certificate of occupancy. • Prior to Certificate of Occupancy, the developer shall install an electronic cart containment system to prevent shopping carts from being removed from the premises, in a manner acceptable to the Community Development Director. This is to minimize any nuisance from abandoned shopping carts in neighboring properties. Regarding the sign variance, at a Commissioner's request, WinCo provided a visual representation of the front elevation sign with and without the variance allowance. The Planning Commission concurred with the applicant's justification for the sign variance and determined that the impacts of permitting the variance were negligible. The Planning Commission also approved the lighting and EV charging variance requests. Appeal of Planning Commission Decision: On May 11 , 2026, the appellant, POVA, submitted a Notice of Intent to Appeal the Commission's (Type III) decision pursuant to WDO 4.02.01 . The appeal was 125 Honorable Mayor and City Council June 3, 2026 (WinCo Grocery Appeal) Page 6 filed within 12 days of mailing the notice of final decision and the appellant established their legal standing to appeal by participating in the Commission hearing. Staff scheduled this public hearing before the City Council to consider the appeal in accordance with WDO 4.01 .15. POVA's notice of appeal letter sets out the basis or grounds for its appeal (Attachment 2). Generally, these grounds include procedural errors, inadequate findings, and objections to the approved traffic analysis. Appellant also includes as grounds for their appeal any issue raised by commenters during the prior hearings. During the Council's hearing process, the Applicant and other parties will have the opportunity to present testimony, arguments and evidence on all applicable criteria, not just those issues raised in the appeal. Staff recommends affirming the Planning Commission's approval (thereby denying appellant's request) with no additional changes to the conditions of approval and directing Staff to include additional findings or modify prior findings as needed to further address Appellant's raised objections. Staff's position is that the arguments raised by the appellant are the same as those raised during the Planning Commission's public hearing and were duly considered by the Planning Commission in their deliberation and approval. With regard to objections related to the TIA - these are counter to the stated opinions of city staff, our contracted traffic engineer, and ODOT's engineers. Staff concurs with the Planning commission and finds the application meets or exceeds all of the criteria of the WDO and in fact, provides on and off-site amenities that will benefit the public and alleviate any adverse impacts. Next Steps Following the public hearing, the Council may: 1 . Affirm the Planning Commission decision and approve the project with conditions; 2. Approve with modified conditions; or 3. Deny, based on objections raised by the appellant or other WDO criteria. Staff will prepare the Final Decision based on the action taken by the City Council and return with a written decision document at a future meeting. 126 Honorable Mayor and City Council June 3, 2026 (WinCo Grocery Appeal) Page 7 Attachment(s): 1 . Planning Commission Final Decision and attachments: a. Conditions of Approval b. Approved Site Plans c. Planning Commission Staff Report with Analysis and Findings 2. Appellant (POVA) Notice of Intent to Appeal (May 11 , 2026) 3. Project Webpage with all application materials and correspondence: ro : ✓✓✓✓✓✓.✓✓ I uirir�..or. OV 774 W C:::; ...C.::xir er'.. t ire 127 WsuRN Incorporated 1889 Final Decision Planning Commission File number(s): DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, VAR 25-06 Project name: WinCo Grocery Store Date of decision: April 23, 2026 Date of mailing: April 29, 2026 Applicant: Ryan Barnett, b.hills architecture, P.C. Landowner: Capital Development Company Project location: Tax lots 052W12C002100 and 052W12C002200 (no assigned address) Staff Reviewers: Chris Kerr, Community Development Director Fernando Torres, Associate Planner Decision: Approved with Conditions Summary The project site is east of Interstate 5 and comprises two vacant lots totaling 10.6 acres in the Commercial General (CG) zoning district.The proposal is for an approximately 84,073 square foot retail grocery store, which is a permitted use in the CG zone. This proposal is consistent with the purpose of the CG zone and the economic goals of the Woodburn Comprehensive Plan. The proposed building is approximately 42 ft tall at its highest point and located on the east side of the property. Landscaping and parking facilities wrap around it, including parking for 504 vehicles and a loading dock. The applicant anticipates the store open 24 hours 7 days a week. Four driveways are proposed, two on Stacy Allison Way, one off of Center St and one on Evergreen Rd. Delivery trucks will use the southernmost driveway on Stacy Allison. As part of the proposal, the applicant will install a Rectangular Rapid Flashing Beacon (RRFB) at the intersection of Oxford St and Evergreen Rd and a bus stop shelter along the site frontage on Evergreen Rd. The applicant will pay System Development Charges (SDC) that will be used to mitigate capacity and safety issues at three nearby intersections: to complete the design and 128 construction of new traffic signals at both Evergreen Rd &Stacy Allison Way and Evergreen Rd & Hayes St; and a roundabout at the intersection of Evergreen Rd & Harvard St. Additionally, the applicant has agreed to install traffic lights at the eastbound and northbound right-turn lanes at the Evergreen Road & OR 214 intersections in coordination with ODOT. There were three Variance requests: 1. Reducing the number of Electric Vehicle (EV) parking spaces: The WDO requires 5 percent of the required parking stalls to be minimum Level 2 EV charging spaces, which for this project would be 17 EV stalls. The applicant is requesting to reduce this requirement to provide eight Level 3 chargers. To support this, the applicant included a letter from Tesla stating that Level 3 chargers are 20x faster than Level 2 chargers and can be used by all EV brands. The applicant indicated that eight EV stalls would meet the charging demand for this site. 2. Increasing Allowable Signage Area on Front Elevation: Adherence to the WDO would allow 300 square feet of signage on the front elevation. The request is to increase the front elevation signage by 153 square feet to 453 square feet. The applicant states that this extra sign allowance would ensure the sign is visible and recognizable from I-5 and Stacy Allison Way. Staff did not support this variance and recommended denial. 3. Increasing parking area light pole height: The WDO limits parking light poles to 14.5 feet above grade. The applicant proposed 24.5-foot-tall light fixtures, stating that taller pole height results in fewer light poles needed, which in turn frees up space for customer parking. Staff supported this variance with the compromise that light poles in the southwest of the property meet the 14.5 feet height requirement to reduce light encroachment into adjacent residential properties. The applicant has agreed to this, modified their plans accordingly and provided a photometric plan demonstrating there would not be light spill over with the approved variance. Additionally, the applicant requested a Street Adjustment to deviate from street improvement requirements for Stacy Allison Way. The applicant's request is to provide a street cross-section consistent with the recent approval to the south along Stacy Allison Way (Allison Way Apartments DR 2019-05). This modified cross-section was previously supported by the Council. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01,VAR 25-06 Final Decision Page 2 of 7 129 III'' / O' J, Aerial view of the subject property outlined in red(2025) r ti As:'V15 O 1 l f/r I..II.ttjjjI ;_ 1 / L .' ' �lls""11{t} Pr; ` 941\4'r1 k't )[)y S'I'OIth — M � i L r � o f' Proposed site plan DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01,VAR 25-06 Final Decision Page 3 of 7 130 Summary of Public Hearing The Planning Commission held a public hearing on March 12, 2026 for this Type III application package. The applicant requested to keep the record open for 28 days until April 9 and the Planning Commission unanimously granted the extension. In accordance with ORS 197.797(6)(c), (7) from April 10 to April 16 all parties had an opportunity to provide rebuttal testimony. From April 17 to April 23, the applicant had 7 days to provide final argument.The parties that testified are listed in the table labeled "Testifiers". On April 21, a procedural objection was raised by Protect Our Valley Alliance.The applicant submitted a response to the objection on April 23.After review of the objection by City staff,the Planning Commission did not find any procedural issues. On April 23, 2026, the Planning Commission deliberated and approved the application package. The approval includes the Design Review, the Property Line Adjustment, the three Variance requests and Street Adjustment with the conditions recommended by staff through the staff report published on March 5, as well as a new finding reflecting the Planning Commission's conclusion that no procedural issues occurred and two additional conditions as discussed during deliberation. The applicant presented visual representation of the front elevation sign with and without the variance allowance. The Planning Commission concurred with the applicant's justification for the sign variance and determined that the impacts of permitting the variance were negligible. The additional conditions are listed below: • Applicant shall provide for the signalization of the eastbound and northbound right-turn lanes at the Evergreen Road and OR 214 intersections. The Applicant shall conduct a traffic analysis justifying the signal modifications and preliminary design layouts to gain ODOT approval. Prior to certificate of occupancy issuance, the applicant shall provide to the City a copy of an executed ODOT permit for the completion of both signal modifications. Installation and final inspection of the signal modifications shall be completed within three years of the date of the certificate of occupancy. • Prior to Certificate of Occupancy, the developer shall install an electronic cart containment system to prevent shopping carts from being removed from the premises, in a manner acceptable to the Community Development Director. This is to minimize any nuisance from abandoned shopping carts in neighboring properties. Testifiers Name Address Verbal Written Ryan Barnett (Applicant) 3156 South Bown Way, X X Boise, ID 83706 Byron Hills (Applicant) 3156 South Bown Way, X X Boise, ID 83706 Mark Lavin (WinCo) 650 N Armstrong PL., Boise, X X ID 83704 Deirdre Rickard 3234 Jonah Place, X X Woodburn, OR 97071 DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01,VAR 25-06 Final Decision Page 4 of 7 131 Matthew Rickard 3234 Jonah Place, X X Woodburn, OR 97071 Ruben Vazquez 581 Paradise Street, X Woodburn, OR 97071 Alejandro Chavez 2100 Arney LN,Apt#J104, X Woodburn, OR 97071 Melissa Vazquez 581 Paradise Street, X Woodburn, OR 97071 Charlynn Chambers 360 Hawley Street, X Woodburn, OR 97071 Gina Freeland 615 Fir Street,Woodburn, X OR 97071 Devon Freeland 615 Fir Street,Woodburn, X OR 97071 Foma I. Kraskov 7433 Keene RD NE,Gervais X OR, 97025 Esmeralda Negrete 2100 Arney LN,Apt#J104, X Woodburn, OR 97071 Rachel Smail 311 S Evergreen Rd,Apt X A100 Woodburn, OR 97301 Heather King(Willamette 8940 N Bradford St., X River Keeper) Portland,OR 97203 or 454 Willamette St.#218 Eugene,OR 97401 Chris Propeck Keizer,OR(no street X address) Miles Eshaia (United Food 7095 SW Sandburg St X and Commercial Workers Tigard, OR 97223 UFCW Local 555) Kay Eichsteadt McEwen 54 Smith Drive Woodburn X OR 97071 Protect our Valley Alliance PO Box 66562 Portland,OR X 97290 Adria Young No address provided X Carla Arriaga 703 Evergreen Road I X Woodburn, Oregon 97071 Naomi Zwerdling on behalf 455 Airport Road SE X of ODOT Building B Salem,Oregon 97301 Les Poole No address provided X Monica Ovalle No address provided X Maria Torres Lara No address provided X Debera Knox 1960 Santiam Dr X Woodburn, OR DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01,VAR 25-06 Final Decision Page 5 of 7 132 Ellen Redel 267 N Settlemier Ave, X Woodburn, OR 97071 Carla Claxton Gervais(no street address) X Russ No address provided X Diane Nelson Cooper 298 Aksenia St, Woodburn, X OR 97071 Larry Staff No address provided X Winona No address provided X Kevin Rakestraw 1999 Jansen way#20 X Woodburn, OR 97071 James(Brian) Smith 1390 independence Ave, X Woodburn, OR 97071 Eva Gurney No address provided X Paul Powers 1526 Astor Way, Woodburn, X OR 97071 Anne Marie Powers 1527 Astor Way, Woodburn, X OR 97071 Christine Johnson No address provided X Debi Hamilton No address provided X Debra Gravitt 1490 Country Club Circle X Delight Coburn No address provided X Elise Fitz Gerald No address provided X James Audritsh No address provided X Jerry D. Pierce No address provided X Linda Metz 1330 Independence Ave, X Woodburn 97071 Christian Cooper 298 Aksenia St Woodburn, X OR 97071 Mary Bixby No address provided X Tammy Coleman No address provided X Pennie Manning 16263 French Prairie Rd NE, X Woodburn, OR 97071 Susan Montano 280 E Clackamas Cir, X Woodburn, OR, 97071 Salem Audubon Society PO BOX 2084 Salem OR X 97308 DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01,VAR 25-06 Final Decision Page 6 of 7 133 Appeals Per WDO 4.01.11E, the decision is final unless appealed pursuant to Oregon Revised Statutes (ORS), state administrative rules, and WDO 4.02.01. The appeal to City Council due date is twelve (12) days from the mailing date of this final decision notice per 4.02.01B1. A valid appeal must meet the requirements of 4.02.01. A copy of the decision is available for inspection at no cost, and the City would provide a copy at reasonable cost at the Community Development Department, City Hall, 270 Montgomery Street, Woodburn, OR 97071. For questions or additional information, contact the Planning Division at (503) 982-5246 or i � awu �Cg� � iroa��� � aas Expiration Per Woodburn Development Ordinance (WDO) 4.02.04B., a final decision expires within three years of the date of the final decision unless: 1. A building permit to exercise the right granted by the decision has been issued; 2. The activity approved in the decision has commenced; or 3. A time extension, Section 4.02.05, has been approved. Sincerely, " ___________________ 1( / Chris Kerr, Community Development Director ° Date Affirmed, ( 2O ( c)/RI / Lisa Ellsworth, Chair, Planning Commission Date Attachments: 1. Conditions of Approval 2. Approved site plans 3. Staff report with analysis and findings DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01,VAR 25-06 Final Decision Page 7 of 7 134 Recommended Conditions of Approval Staff recommends the following conditions of approval. Section references throughout the conditions are to the Woodburn Development Ordinance (WDO). General Conditions 1. Substantial conformance: The applicant or successor shall develop the property in substantial conformance with the final plans submitted and approved with this application, except as modified by these conditions of approval. 2. Grading Permit: Prior to beginning any grading work on-site,the developer shall apply for and obtain a Grading Permit per WDO 5.01.04. 3. Fence Permits: To demonstrate conformance with 2.06.02 and 5.01.03, the developer shall submit application for and obtain approval of a Fence Permit for any new or modified fencing. 4. Sign Permits: To demonstrate conformance with 3.10 and 5.01.10, the developer shall submit application for and obtain approval of a Sign Permit for any new or modified signage that is required by 3.10.05 to obtain such permit. 5. Addressing: Prior to receiving Final Plat approval from the City,the developer shall submit an Add„it s ..s........... ...........It.„r i „ , with accompanying fee payment and materials, to the Community Development Department to begin the address assignment process. 6. Public Works Department:The developer shall comply with the Public Works Department conditions in Attachment 101B. Design Review DR 25-14 7. Mid-block bike/ped corridor:To meet 3.01.05C and consistent with the approved plans, the developer shall build a 6-foot pedestrian and bikeway corridor to provide midblock connection between Stacy Allison Way and Evergreen Rd. 8. Easements:The developer shall grant or obtain the following easements prior to building permit issuance: a. Cross access: i. Pursuant to 3.04.01A.2., 3.04.03C.4.a., and 3.04.03D.2., the developer shall grant an access easement over the proposed vehicular drive aisle on the subject property to benefit Tax Lot 052W130001600. The easement shall be a minimum of 20 feet wide. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 101a Page 1 of 4 135 ii. Pursuant to 3.04.01A.2., the developer shall grant an access easement through Tax Lot 052W12C002200, connecting the subject property(tax lot 052W12C002100) to Center St. The easement shall be at least 20 feet wide. b. Mid-block bike/ped corridor access: Pursuant to 3.01.05C., 3.01.07E., and 3.02.01E., the developer shall grant a public access easement over the mid-block bicycle/pedestrian corridor path. 9. Cross access: To meet 3.04.03 D2, the developer shall provide a cross access to tax lot 052W130001600 paved to the edge of the property line. 10. Driveway width:To demonstrate conformance with Table 3.04A, prior to building permit issuance, revise the northernmost driveway on Stacy Allison Way to meet the driveway width requirements (either 24 ft or 36 ft if adding a turn pocket). 11. Parking: Include a parking, signage, and striping plan addressing the following: a. Accessible parking: Pursuant to 3.05.03B, accessible parking shall be provided to meet applicable state statutes and building code requirements. b. Carpool/vanpool parking: Carpool/vanpool parking stalls shall meet the signage and striping requirements in 3.05.03H. c. Electric vehicle parking: Electric vehicle parking stalls shall meet the charging level, striping, and signage requirements in 3.05.031. 12. Storm drainage: Per 3.05.02G, revise plans to incorporate rain gardens or similar storm water management systems into at least 50% of the required parking islands to provide stormwater management and pollution mitigation for the parking lot. 13. Traffic mitigation: a. Truck access: In the future, when the City designates Stacy Allison as a truck route the owner will be required to post signage limiting trucks from entering at the Evergreen Rd driveway. Additionally, exiting trucks will only be allowed on Stacy Allison Way. 14. Transportation Demand Management (TDM): a. Pursuant to 2.05.02 G3,the developer shall include within six months of Certificate of Occupancy a document entitled, "Transportation Demand Management (TDM) Strategies". b. The Plan shall include a list of enforceable, programmatic TDM strategies and measures intended to reduce peak hour vehicle trips generated by the proposed development. At a minimum, the Plan shall include: DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 101a Page 2 of 4 136 i. An information board for employees that will have the city transit schedule posted ii. Potential employee rewards for use of transit and/or bike/walk iii. Identify a TDM manager on site,who will be a point of contact for City staff iv. Potential carpool-only parking spaces v. Providing employees with bus passes vi. Periodic updates to the posted information, based on feedback from City staff or changes to travel options. vii. Provisions for an annual report for five years to be provided to the City to the attention of the Community Development Director that references this condition of approval, includes a summary of what the targets were, review of how well targets were met, performance measures, comparison with the prior report, and the effectiveness of the TDM program elements implemented. c. Transit: Pursuant to 3.01.09, prior to Certificate of Occupancy the developer shall install a bus stop shelter on Evergreen Rd and grant an easement that meets the Woodburn Transit System and Public Works requirements. d. Prior to final inspection, the developer shall construct a pedestrian crossing on Evergreen Road, south of Oxford Drive. The pedestrian crossing shall include the installation of rectangular rapid flashing beacon (RRFB) in accordance with the Oregon Department of Transportation (ODOT) guidelines and approved equipment, curb ramps complying with current federal and ODOT accessibility requirements, continental crosswalk striping, concrete refuge island, and street lighting. 15. Applicant shall provide for the signalization of the eastbound and northbound right-turn lanes at the Evergreen Road and OR 214 intersections. The Applicant shall conduct a traffic analysis justifying the signal modifications and preliminary design layouts to gain ODOT approval. Prior to certificate of occupancy issuance, the applicant shall provide to the City a copy of an executed ODOT permit for the completion of both signal modifications. Installation and final inspection of the signal modifications shall be completed within three years of the date of the certificate of occupancy. 16. Prior to Certificate of Occupancy, the developer shall install an electronic cart containment system to prevent shopping carts from being removed from the premises, in a manner acceptable to the Community Development Director. This is to minimize any nuisance from abandoned shopping carts in neighboring properties. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 101a Page 3 of 4 137 Property line adjustment PLA 25-04 17. Recordation:The applicant shall record the property line adjustment with Marion County in a manner acceptable to the County Surveyor. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 101a Page 4 of 4 138 WooDBuRN Inc. or /2o ° aie ` 88 " WINCO GROCERY STORE DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, VAR 25-06 Public Works Conditions March 5, 2026 CONDITIONS OF LAND USE APPROVAL: 1. The Applicant, not the City, is responsible for obtaining any necessary permits from the State, Marion County, Oregon Division of State Lands, US Army Corps of Engineering, and/or federal agencies that may require such permits or approval for the construction of this development. All work within the Oregon Department of Transportation (ODOT) right-of-way requires the applicant to obtain approval and permits from ODOT. 2. Department of Environmental Quality Erosion Control 1200C permit will need to be obtained for this development prior to City issuing approval of civil plans. 3. Applicant shall prepare and record the following right-of-way dedication and public utility easements in accordance with the requirements of the City of Woodburn and the Marion County Surveyor's Office. a. Applicant shall dedicate 5 feet of right-of-way along Stacy Allison Way. b. Applicant shall grant a 5-foot-wide public utility easement along all abutting street frontages. 4. Applicant to provide a performance bond for City right-of-way improvements, in the amount of 120% of the construction cost prior to permits being issued for the Civil Plans approval. 5. Applicant to pay all public improvements (right-of-way) fees for all public improvements which are to be maintained by the City as per Ordinance#1795. 6. Applicant to provide street lighting in accordance with street lighting plan approved by the City and conforming to Portland General Electric installation and plan under option B, if required. 7. All City-maintained facilities located on private property require a minimum of 16-foot- wide utility easement conveyed to the City by the property owner. This is the applicant's responsibility to provide, not the City's. Utilities of unusual depth, size or location may require a larger width. 8. The Applicant, by this Development, shall not cause storm water runoff to be impounded on adjacent properties. Engineering&Project Delivery 190 haarfielld Same.A a,,AVoodbunrr ,4 Dre o n 9711711 ."11 11.9 2-.57 0 a, u aax 50 98z..y242 At�t..��Ihixii at 1��� 1 III 139 9. All sanitary sewer laterals serving the proposed developments are private up to the main line. 10. The water mains serving this development shall be a looped system, shall be sized in accordance with flow and fire protection requirements. 11. Fire hydrants locations and fire protection requirements shall be as per the Woodburn Fire Districts and City of Woodburn requirements. Actual fire hydrant locations fire department connections (FDC) and in-line valving locations shall be determined during the final Civil Plans approval and building permit issuance. 12. All sanitary sewer and storm drainage laterals serving the proposed developments are private up to the main public line. 13. All onsite private storm systems and sewer lateral lines shall comply with Marion County plumbing permit and requirements. 14. Final review of the Civil Plans will be done during the permit application for public improvements. Public infrastructure will be designed and constructed in accordance with plans approved by Public Works and complying with City, State and Federal requirements/guidelines current at the time of the development application. 15. All public improvements shall be deemed complete prior to final building permit inspection. 16. System Development charges shall be paid prior to building permit issuance. Engineering&Project Delivery 190 Caar u d '4FJauardbunm,4 Drre on 970711 M 5030 982 5240 a Faax 50: 9&x2.5747 140 � � aUxO E o � II II � LLLL 0- 9 I a © ___ Nz zt iol M N — aw — 4 —\— — . LLLLLLLLU U W 1111 I � U - , H +-llH '1 jTIIII 01 aAi N a a N u9-,6 a Uflu I � Q � O ccj fr N W aN� 0 oq o'�o O0O �o HO HO o �x� aFQ oE0 oN a NQ� w�0 �wN w�P a / O F E H a�w CaOQ Hz x� r Sao � F woo ww¢ F o a a�0 0 ti w o 0aa vaz0 x xa o m o t7 o q I3 IH 000 illlll� 415 „� IliiUuu� a �� i ii uuui � 11i u�llln vu �e . ,Rti",TIIII!IIIP�o 1�illlllllfl uuum ------------------ - ----------------- --------------------------- - SI ------------------ ------------------ ----------------- VIEW ----------- --------------------- 4 b UTMMHm- OHM U HUHLHLHLHLULULH _ : 1 L - J a j H O � w JI � O � JJA 0-S d1I,L..0-.£ NUN.,0-S --I d NI ..0,Z �O HHI lIaaa � a i .a � z � aq > wo w z � � oz oox �jo day a � � 4 ID O � O F 00 O r O w H z M W CA z CA U a E E E E VIII O O III O a / O IIIIIIIII" p O V v N 3 v co v ._ w w m o a II�III co :.�+ :1 : . : � : : + : 4 : : + + + + + + + + + + + +M m m m m m m a o m m o m m 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 "+ '6 "+ "+::: 't' + + + �4. + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + 1 " _ m " I.�. �" °F '+ '"+ '"+ "+ "+ "+11 ' t + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + °� Illllf VIII m uuuuuuuuuuum i �IIIIIIIIIIIIIIII ' " � `� `� `r r r r r r r r r r IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII(�IIIIIIII r r r r r r r r "r r r r '"r r r r r r � � fi, r r '"r '"r '"r `r `r r r r r , ""r r �r �r �r �r �r �r �r �r �r Ill II r "r r r r r r o 0 I' r '"r '"r "r "r "r r r r r 'Si. r r "r "r "r "r "r "r "r "r "r r uVlllllr "r "r r r r r r " °r '"r "p "r "r r r ''p 'ê' ^4F 4. ? r r r r r r r r r rr r r r r r r r 'r r "r "r "r "r "r "r r "`—r r ^r' " : ? r �r �r �r �r �r �r �r �r �r �IIIIII+IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII �r "r "r "r "r "r "r q" " IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 0 0 0 0 0 0 * r r o 0 0 0 0 0 0 r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r "r r "r i r r mr `' 'r "4 "r "r "r "r "r "r or *IIIIIIIIII " or r r r r r r " mr" � r� �r �r �r �r �r �r �r �r r Ir �r "r r r r r r fi " " " o or III m ^'" '" '� �r "r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r � o 0 0 0 o IIIIIIIIII�IIIIII o " v o 0 0 0 � � o 0 r r m r.... ++ 4^ r o 0 0 0 0 0 W °p :allµ ::ill �I H.. . .. .. . .... .. ... . . . . . . . r r ..... r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r rIV" "'"r "r '"r 'r r �rfi "r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r 0 0 0 r �r �r �: : : : 0 0 0r �r �r � r ", r r r r r r r r r r r� ,. IVppuuuuulllll V� �r ,�r � �r �r �r �r �r �r �r �r IIIII��iiilluuuuuuuupppppjplMu r r r r r r r uuul�uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu�uuuu r °r "r "r "r "r "r r r rI1 r r "r "r r r r r r r r r r r p r r r r r r r r uuVppVuuuo "P °r "r "r '"r "r "r r r r r r ? ? r r r "r "r "r "r "r "r "r VIII IIIIIIII or �r �r r r r r r r r '"r r r r . *" uuulluVlumuum "P � �r "r mr ? �r �r �r �r �r �r �r �r �r or I uuuour �r �r �r �r �r �r �r " " "° " " r 'r 'r "r "r "r "r "r r r ;..... r ? ? ? r �r �r �r �r �r �r �r �r �r �r �r �r "r "r "r "r "r "r 'r 'r "r "r "r "r "r "r "r "r r `r `r r r �r �r �r �r �r �r �r �r �r �r �r �r �r �r �r �r �r �r "P "r "r "r "r "r "r "r "r r r r `r ;r r "r "r "r r r r r r " " " o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 "P "r "r r '"r r rr r r ? ? r r' `ter "r r r "r' 4."•R . � �r "r r r r r r i H___ ___ ___ CO CO w m N M N N J co O CO CO - - - - - - — CEIt) CELT) COQ O � Op wIt) N J :It) L� Zer L Q L pQ S N CO C7 � � Q = N L- U Z Q I>_ � 00 3 0 � O OZO I Jo o o oI() o 91() o Joo LJ �ZZo x Q x o o x Q 3 x x w x L < b0 0 0 L, L, 0 W Z M I..I- CDZpr) Z l �i o i w O F N O C, 0 I E Q .2 0 > /) 0U) ic < OZ DaaU v� 3tcooFdU 111 0 Li 0 000 0 < z a moo ca I cD CD cn l 0 0 hb 2 N 2 �cc _ mp m WEZ � U �_ N MQ Q � m0LJJ OF- /kn,O N= \ C) \ \ WW J J 0 a \\ W /3N N J Mew Li \\ n OJ W Li 0 N Z a O O \ \W �� W N 7 \\\ W W m \\\ \ Uw Of D \zI Q O a \ — 0_i 0^ o rn N N \ W N X w� W Wm O ZO to 9 (nim�n Z \ Z ` O N W W W o N) Li N ) Q \/ ZQ M \ \ d N UN ccv \ \ U \tiJ �ryO^� O� •299oS \ ati °s \ \'00. ° °z c ss?NN \ \'< a W m N N Q w Z a O � `YOA\ \\ w a x \l \ ULm Oros J\ N N00\90S N N NN N N \O+ boo // \ o / / O \\ / / " OF - N\ J / / W \/\ // aw N N \ / W}W \ Z F- \ F U J d Z D \ \\ W \\ Wrm \ O a 0 - II rsm tee, N m> rs N ® •r N a •r9s® II iv `J fb'S9t U `P m ~� \ S r9er w 9B •s• e � o \.o. N yor® •sso 'J ZZ'481 or 69'48! W 0 0 •sir ' �8( sa z m� I 9a 'J 9L'£B 9`�'A � •�' 19Z'48t • oor® r Z � � (� dse■ £0 c^O oo• ® s O1 I I d fro 2g��m o�� � � ssr° / • II II3 ! �` • / ,sue a° z �z m 01'182.79 0 • • ?—O II •sY •s. Q s e, Z SA 00J a� \ • ° O V • a U fr or r fir® •sSoi WWW m\ \l Sar• o ^ r I 'sy o B o •o. ® l� • U Z I .use® .`90 q / �%F� co h ra oc) ssa \C` `2` I s • _\ 5 07 9A �G/ o h� I r • % sssr drys sm® _ ° / se io / • �nmN�� J ��� mss / �sr® //m r O II ■ ��sns ��rr Z II II II I U ® w II ww3z /U% J� / •s£ = w II II II II z cn cn" • ® s• N6'UUUU '� 's• m m zd�---- �aaaa • �° ¢ c. 00maa.a / J /7/ Y / ¢ II` + ss o-aaaoo z N ANN / /�.�,/ " s II N��tp cp tnawwww //./�`6+ e n r® m� u)iawwwww / A/ Yo / I O / a m 00F.I"j�„� •' aka � J f rm Qo�> ■ m�a / Y n 1 / fir® / /> / / Q! 8 L •F.4! rm c s / r / / W £ B // de'Yr r ■ / // / / s'J o.rso � Yxs o ,�y� / // Yo • '®jd , / sYe Z ' sh ° ° Y° Ya / a Z ` - •s s m os. /� / ra • • r. '\ ,\ a 'Soy // /�°sas` m�m •s. "oY d SrS / • x9 i "ra a w r£ • •�iS / s�(® h Q •219 •9� \;o a • •r. 0 r. st , • ® .a s� ( 7 \ •ry m Y°`• "sa • e 2s • • N • •S Bi • ra 'rte • a • zs, • "rr e, • \ t2 N x \ ® 00 a0r s 00Mtn a2B y, 9 1. �` ... s\\JAL Q II II ° s`• � W aO ` \ ODU •Q�ada o. U \ F g U W .g� •Sg a • • s�`® s� •rs s� e o • •r. SS .F. !erg , 9= Jsa �O2 • Asa g, ti� • \ryO g�• .a� ® ® •zsg s s • 2 •sx "sib � Z • "s' sg,sa 165 �, SA SAi • M s. �I�"� dSg! �• W �N� JSm J c0�� a .g U N II Z II II Q ° Q __- , v3�v� ssg �n o~o = og � *: 3� • d'UU gi \.�\ •m\\ UW7NZZU .25 Ulnw ° \ r0000 e® r w�z0 \ aad gg m oN g G . \ oomoo ss, az: o_ m. „ zg • QOroo t\ \ rsa ��i�� •ss 00µG SS hG.. N\.../' `1\\ .>Sg• N NN 0 G \`' GS S �g 00 N � (� y \ j • U \ Zd m• / z0 Q (j �'' H 0 o z o 0 > z oW 0 w o ¢ o O z o w ° o z i = O O pj m O Z ¢ 0 w U Z U) m Z D Z 0 $ Q Ow 0 U 0O = Q 0 d Z O m Z � H _ w z 300 O O X O = O O z 0 Li Li W w X d Z m O N H 0 N W Q O Z 3 OJ J 2 0 N li Z z pJ Ll"Iw 5 (n 0 W O z 0 0 U) W0 m U) Z U z z N Z m Ow w p N O 0 0 I O Z 0- a: " = = H 0 uiP = L a a o w 41 0 H Z o H D O W Z 2 U U O K i Z U7 ¢ N W m w Z N OH O= h W N Z Z g m 0 0 ¢ p N U) Z U O 0 d j V m ~ 0 m of C ¢ J z Vi r U U w W < W Z J m o z W U o0 o < w o z a z 3 H J g ON z a > o 00 V) W ¢ • Z U v m 3 m H J H H 0 ¢ 41 CU)) O W Z K W Y w ' W Q Z m' U 50 I 0 0 CC N O p O U W p m 0 a p Q O N N H a: < W' U) i H } J } Q O W w H J 0 ¢ X W = p U O H Uj W O Z Z J Z H H H < Z O W D Z H Z Z U > d n- H z Ni O U)0 .i v p S Z W 0 0 N W Z U 0 Z CC O O > U I a CC N aa N w S H U S U O W O m N H N w a CC) 0 z w W J W U) Z W Z O W O U CC H J W 0 d' d' W Z < U) z W U 0 ?. U) _ ¢ = o ¢ m Z ¢ W N W z CC CD O Z U- o Q o o U) m o a > o �g a Q z U o 0 Z (MD W Q QNQ O i O D W 1= Z z U ~ m J = P H W 0 W m U7 QH -ml Z = w W W H o g j N W Q U- 0 W g N 0U. H o O H H p d z UI ¢ p W g > Z Z O w w N ¢ z p z Z W d0 0 o Q w0 DO < H W w So = z 0 I Of O> J Z O Z0 UU 0 0220U)O W U) W W -0 H >> > O W Q tj ¢ < m ww O NN m Mm pF H W .t.i PO W ¢ w m X 0 =U- m w x O O ZO ¢ N 0 0 W C H .. W Z HO U > ¢ W U) Z O� z Z Z 0 d Z - O� _ g , Li W W .- .M- - (0 N 0) )ywj W m H Q of of j0 m H a U) a a W as a 000 as s ca °r Li- Li W p m W d m m ¢ N w U) N p Q w F O 0 0 �O U O a� 0 0 o 0 U Ui 0 x W Li N Uj= Q 0 m J 0 0 ' �¢ U = a U 0 0 N W¢ U- U U Iwi_ w 0 m J W �J 0 U- W O cr m m J J W U 0 0 )y J J 0 O V1 00 L` O O U) o O O U U W O ly m o m m twi p 0 W 0 O 0 0 00 N tb 0 0 0 0 {. a 0 W W W W O)p ¢ w Of w W Q O o Of n. W 0: J 0 0 d 0 I.0 - 0 O U J ¢ a < 0) 0 W cNi w 0 a w W U I.� N 0D 0 of a vi o 0 LL w 0) w CC) cwt 0- H m z m U 00) U- W WO 0 m m W a w w O U U� 0 0 J J 0 w 0 W Wo O a W )yj W 0 W m O 0 W W (0 0) W F LC > m o N O a: a: < 00) J 00 0 p} Q Q U) W W N (0 < < J W ¢ W J U ¢ 0 0 W W V) m W O w (n U- 0_ < Q Q W 0 0) m m U) J Z o0 w Wo ° 0) co a a LU 0 °) _ m < w ¢ K00. x W N d- d- 0 } m < 0) 0 0 H N W 0 N m m m m Cl 0) U) K K z p z O w W ^ ^ J w a: m 00) ¢ 0 0 Q d' O¢ U) d' > > W ¢ O CL m m O 0) W W O CC d W V) W U m O O J J U- d LU d C J J z 0 ) W >> > 0 0 U 0 H CL N W _ Q ¢ < J /� Il flrn . __LILU HEEL fl uIi _ _ _ 1b1Lt1'H U) O iq \ O � fl : / w I LO c_) Li J � w � CC Y tp l m t w l O O J U w Q l O Or cn X w m w J LU LU 0 0 0 0 0 0 CJ III Ui I W C) w l C, o O J O . w l O O CC Y cd l m i U- W Ui1 d" it it it dl i� dI -�:,W S� N J � W U UT fl Z / � p Ln O cfl 00 ... Ildllo W W W W W— 0 O Ott) O cfl L _ 00 U w - u 3= a) O w 00 � N- O n I 00 U n cr W WI- = 0) Cn 0O vi vi C10 N-03C_) O N- N- w 3 zcn22 w w " I- N N Cn M 0' N- � N `iv — — — � O O — — — — — — 00200 n 2 Z U W W L '0 ® 9L J0 Jl L9Z N - O) : 0 O O O O 00 MZ 00 C) � N � O 00 U W U - O c,..i N N Z Z 0 D L� C!J LC00 00 00 0 Z O W O .__. I O Q CCJ O N- Z n n Z zN � w w w wo z m 0a .91JoJl LL2 ovw w N ^ v) O F- O 03 0 z LL. 00 O Co O OO U ® cfl U ' ` LU � O _�� Q N- F- w N Z N ? O z L.L. wcn cn � rnQw LL. CO CC) F Q N 6U 4J C Z 2 00 CT N- U D L9 N- ^ Oi Z_ O W L i l W O C V F- m i O O Z U N- 1 0_ r7 C-) Z O p W Z 03 I Q N Z_ 2 , C-, °, U) O N m Z v- O co U W w N 00 N co 4- u) 00 I CY) R LO W C) W Z Q U W of m W D F- m rn CCD — — — — — — — — — — L 00 00 " I I F W W W W— ,, a �0 il 98Z > � P LO oo Qm W Z W Cn .Q _ (0 �` rn p - I = of } iti n = n 000 W u T 0o 0 0 O �3 O � I U- Oo U w CD J O 3 `o W `n cG Oo rn o W Q W QY C-D Q ma O pZ (.nom � WJ 00 WT cD CC D F- m � = � fl = m C n W N Z Z F Z W ~ z _ O Q o N p ��.................................. n • W W Q 0 U W o C2 — o W C-j ..... ............ .............................................................................................. 0 O Q LC) 0o LL 00 U w Z LL LL O U u1 I O 8 o cn 0 J -, Hr - U z Q � + � I . ___ IO00 ? 9 ® Cl) • . z 2 . �! } \\. ; « � 2 • »§< � / \ � ) _ » \ � � / ` \ / < / ?�� i\\i / /� \i / /��� \i . / / i / ' \% � �, . « : //�/ / / . \ / / /\ N /�� �® ���. � / � \ ` � • \ �2§ � � • < x� » / < Z \ \ , w . y y / �: \ � _ ° I EO-S1J 1HS g1S DNI1-H3±VW , , > , , , , > , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , > , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , > , , , , , , , , , , , > , , , , , , , , , , , , , > , , , , , , , , , , , > , > , , , , , , > , , , , , > , , , , , > , , > , , , , , > , , , > , , , , , , , , , > , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , > , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , > , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , > , > , , > , , , > , , , , , > , , > , , > , , > , , , , , , , , , > , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , > , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , > , > , , > , , , > , , , , , , , , > , , > , , > , , , , , > , , , > , , , , , , , , , , , > , , > , , , , , , , , , , , , > , , , , , , , , > , , > , , , , , > , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , > , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , > , , , , , > , , , , , > , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , > , , , , , , > , , > , , > , , , , , , , , > , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , > , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , > , , , , , , , , , , , , ° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° > ° > ° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° 7 ° ° ° ° ° 7 ° ° 7 , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , > , , > , , > , , , , , > > , , , , > , , , > , , , , , > , , > , , , , , > , , > , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , > , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , > , , , , , > , , , , , , , , , , , , > , , , , , > , , > , , , , , , > , , > , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , > , , > , , > , , > , , > > , , , > , , , > , , , , , > , , > , , > , , > , , > , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , > , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , > , > , , > , , , > , , , , , > , , > , , > , , , , , , , , > , , , > , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , > , , , > , , , , > > , , > , , , , , > , , , , , > , , , , , , , , , , , , > , , , , , , > , , > , , > , , , > , , , , , , , , > , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , > , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , > , > , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , > , , > , , > , , > > , , , , > , , , > , , , , , > , , > , , > , , > , , > , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , > , , > , , , , , > , , , , , , , , > , , , > , , , , , > , , , , , , , , , , , , > , , > , , > , , , > , , , , , , , , > , , , , , > , , , , , > , , > , , , , > , , , > , , > , , > , , > , , , , , , , , > , , , , , > , , , > , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , > , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , > , , , , , > , , , , , > , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , > , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , _ - ° �_° _ - — - CO-Si ±ggHS g1S DNI-HO±VW O v o o : ± o Lg < ≥ a ® / � i �0000 i W a • iii � a i W z U �� _ u W 0 Z w W o v v Z W cc m W 2E U) - _ _ - SO-S-1 JD1HS D1S DNIi-HOIVW ) 5 5 i 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 i 5 5 ) S d 3 j d 3 -) d 3 j 3 5 3 3 j d 3 3 j 3 3 j d ) j 3 3 j d 3 -) j 3 5 90-Si i�DHS 1S DNIl-H3±VW o w U p _ a _Jo Q z LU \ O O0L Q m O -i m p O z 0 CO- ..8L i < OZ J a 0 m I— w Z ofzW Hz \) � w 0 z 0 < C7pm o UQ } Q > W z o QL - > 0 > _ c� UQ \° \ 0 �cLLUQ \ LUO LU Z_ < O W Q O - \ W z oo° / OOO ><O H Q z 0o W J O O d � \ >_ QHH Z m °°o H Z Z °�°° ^x o0 0 Li I p w H < K! m LU OQQ U W H Q W J = Q O \ J pH NIW ,Z Q H W \ O W p H W p U c \ 7O fann � � \ QQcw w LULU m � Q = z Z ° \o zc,) m z L H \ Z o 0° \ O LUXD W W LU o oo° Q J ��r its fl r d WOODBURN Incorporated 4889 Staff Report Project Title: WinCo Grocery Store Project Location: Tax lots 052W12C002100 and 052W12C002200 (no assigned address) File Numbers: Design Review DR 25-14 Property Line Adjustment 25-04 Street Adjustment SA 26-01 Variance VAR 25-06 Property Owner: Capital Development Company Applicant: Ryan Barnett, b.hills architecture, P.C. Public Hearing Date: March 12, 2026 Date of Report: March 5, 2026 Staff Reviewer: Chris Kerr, Community Development Director Fernando Torres, Associate Planner Staff Recommendation: Approval with Conditions Executive Summary Action on a Type III land use application package consisting of: Design Review; Property Line Adjustment; Street Adjustment; Variances (three requests). The project site includes two vacant properties near the I-5 interchange, south of Center St., and totals approximately 10.6 acres. It is within the Commercial General (CG) zoning district. The proposal is an 84,073 square foot retail grocery store that is anticipated to be open 24 hours a day, seven days a week. 167 r4 ti4 � r Project Site (outlined in red) I AI..➢.0S(s4 1k.,A'd' I.. 0 d n M. Illustrative Site Plan The front of the building faces west towards 1-5. Access will be from two driveways on Stacy Allison Way,one on Evergreen Rd.and another through a future, currently undeveloped lot along Center St. Parking spaces for 504 vehicles will wrap around the west and south side of the building. Trucks will enter through the southernmost driveway on Stacy Allison Way. A truck dock is proposed on the south side of the building with loading bay doors facing the freeway to minimize any impacts of trucks on the adjacent residential properties. An existing block wall at the Cascade Meadow Apartments and 30-foot-high trees screen this development from the apartment complex. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Grocery Store Staff Report Page 2 of 4 168 Several public improvements are proposed to alleviate traffic concerns and to promote pedestrian/transit users. To facilitate pedestrian access, wide walkways are provided from Stacy Allison Way and Evergreen Rd to the building entrance. The applicant will also build a pedestrian crossing at the intersection of Evergreen Rd and Oxford Dr featuring a rectangular rapid flashing beacon (RRFB). The developer will install a bus stop shelter on Evergreen Rd to serve a recently implemented bus route. In accordance with the adopted Transportation System Plan, the City will also be using the fees paid by the applicant to complete the design and construction of new traffic signals at both Evergreen Rd & Stacy Allison and Evergreen Rd & Hayes St; additionally, a roundabout will be completed at the intersection of Evergreen Rd and Harvard St. "kl Front Elevation Rendering Discretionary Reviews The applicant submitted Variance applications, which is the process for applicants to request to to deviate from certain code provisions. In this case, the applicant is requesting to deviate from three requirements in the WDO summarized below (these are discussed in greater detail in the attahed Analyses and Findings): 1. Reducing the number of Electric Vehicle (EV) parking spaces: The WDO requires 5 percent of the required parking stalls to be minimum Level 2 EV charging spaces, which for this project would be 17 EV stalls.The applicant is requesting to reduce this requirement to provide eight Level 3 chargers. To support this, the applicant included a letter from Tesla stating that Level 3 chargers are 20x faster than Level 2 chargers and can be used by all EV brands. The applicant indicated that eight EV stalls would meet the charging demand for this site. Staff supports this variance. 2. Increasing Allowable Signage Area on Front Elevation: Adherence to the WDO would allow 300 square feet of signage on the front elevation.The request is to increase the front elevation signage by 153 square feet to 453 square feet.The applicant states that this extra sign allowance would ensure the sign is visible and recognizable from I-5 and Stacy Allison Way. Staff does not support this variance because there are already provisons in the sign code that allow them taller and larger signage which provides them with greater visibility from I-5. Additionally, other similar properties (e.g. WalMart) operate succcessfully without having received sign code variances. 3. Increasing parking area light pole height: The WDO limits parking light poles to 14.5 feet above grade.The applicant is proposing 24.5-foot-tall light fixtures, stating that taller DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Grocery Store Staff Report Page 3 of 4 169 pole height results in fewer light poles needed, which in turn frees up space for customer parking. Staff supports this variance with the compromise that light poles in the southwest of the property will meet the 14.5 feet height requirement to reduce light encroachment into adjacent residential properties.The applicant has agreed to this and modified their plans accordingly. The applicant also submitted a Street Adjustment application,which is the process for applicants to request modified street improvement requirements for abutting street rights-of-way. The applicant's request is to provide a street cross-section consistent with the recent approval to the south along Stacy Allison Way. This modified cross-section was previously supported by the Council. Recommendation Approval with conditions of all but the sign code variances: Staff recommends the Planning Commission consider the staff report and its attachments and approve the application package with the recommended conditions in Attachment 101. Staff recommends approval of the Street Adjustment and light poles and EV parking variances but does not recommend approval of the sign variance. Actions The Planning Commission may act on the land use application to: 1. Approve per staff recommendations, 2. Approve with modified conditions, or 3. Deny, based on WDO criteria or other City provisions. If the Planning Commission were to act upon the recommendation, staff would prepare a final decision for approval with any Conditions or Findings recommended by the Commission. Attachment List 101a. Conditions of Approval 101b. Public Works Conditions of Approval 102. Notes to the Applicant 103. Analyses & Findings 104. Traffic Impact Analysis 105. ODOT Letter 106. Tesla Letter of Justification for variance 107. Public Testimony from Matthew and Deirdre Rickard (3234 Jonah Place) 108. Site Plans The entire application is available on-line on the City's Current Project page here: I�tt s.. www„woodl�uirn-oir„ ov 774 WiinCo-�iroceir _Stoire DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Grocery Store Staff Report Page 4 of 4 170 Analyses & Findings This attachment to the staff report analyzes the application materials and finds through statements how the application materials relate to and meet applicable provisions such as criteria, requirements, and standards. They confirm that a given standard is met or if not met, they call attention to it, suggest a remedy, and have a corresponding recommended condition of approval. Symbols aid locating and understanding categories of findings: Symbol Category Indication Requirement (or guideline) met No action needed Requirement (or guideline) not met Correction needed Requirement (or guideline) not applicable No action needed • Requirement (or guideline) met with condition of Modification or approval condition of • Other special circumstance benefitting from approval required attention Deviation from code: Street Adjustment or Variance Request to modify, adjust, or vary from a requirement Location & Legal Lot Status Address No formal address—vacant Tax Lot 052W12C002100 & portion of 052W12C002200 (Lot 11 and portion of Lot 12,Town Center at Woodburn) Nearest intersection Stacey Allison/Evergreen & Center St. The subject property is lots 11 and 12 of the Town Center at Woodburn Plat. It is a legal lot of record. Land Use & Zoning Comprehensive Plan Land Use Commercial Designation Zoning District Commercial General (CG) Overlay Districts Interchange Management Area (IMA) Overlay District Existing Use Vacant—with minimal street improvements DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 1 of 57 171 For context, the subject property and adjacent zoning are illustrated and tabulated on the following page. IU5� Illii - i �I�I�I�I�IUUUUppp�iirrr / _ / __ �I� I Illllllllllllllll "'VIII Ill ✓ 'rl./1111 �' f _= �� aE' weeoav , Zoning map excerpt Cardinal Direction Adjacent Zoning and use North Commercial General (CG) —Vacant East Residential Medium Nodal (RMN) — Evergreen Rd. /Single family homes South CG & RMN — partially vacant and apartment buildings West Stacey Allison Way! 1-5 Section references throughout this staff report are to the ° Statutory Dates The application package was submitted on December 12, 2025 and deemed complete on February 18, 2026 making the 120-day decision deadline June 18, 2026. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 2 of 57 172 Applicable WDO Provisions 2.03 Commercial Zones A.The City of Woodburn is divided into the following commercial zones: 2. The Commercial General (CG) zone is the community's primary commercial area, providing for businesses requiring extensive land intensive outdoor storage and display of merchandise, equipment, or inventory. B.Approval Types(Table 2.03A) 3. Permitted Uses (P) are allowed outright, subject to the general development standards of this Ordinance. Uses Allowed in Commercial Zones Table 2.03A Use Zone Accessory Uses(A) Conditional Uses(CU) Permitted Uses(P) DDC CG CO MUV NNC S ecial Permitted Uses(S) Specific Conditional Uses(SCU) B Commercial Retail and Services 3 Bakeries, delicatessens,grocery and convenience stores P P P P 1. Not allowed in the Gateway Overlay District 2. Only allowed in the Gateway Overlay District 3. Allowed outright if not within 200 feet of residentially zoned properties 4. Within a building, no outdoor storage or repair 5. All outdoor storage and display shall be enclosed by a seven foot masonry wall. 6. Existing uses are allowed as a permitted use, new uses are not allowed in the MUV 7. Drive-throughs are not allowed 8. Child care facility for 13 or more children,group home for six or more persons 9. Except allowed as a permitted use in the Gateway Overlay District and prohibited in the Interchange Management Area Overlay District(Amended by Ordinance 2573, passed June 24, 2019) Staff Finding: The proposed supermarket is permitted outright as a "Grocery" store within the CG zone. The store will not have a drive-through. It has been reviewed (traffic, parking, landscaping, etc.) to meet the standards of the proposed use which is permitted outright in the CG zone; subject to a Design Review approval. C. Development Standards(Tables 2.03C) DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 3 of 57 173 Commercial General (CG) - Site Development Standards Table 2.03C Lot Area, Minimum (square feet) No minimum Lot Width, Minimum (feet) No minimum Lot Depth, Minimum (feet) No minimum Street Frontage, Minimum (feet) No minimum Front Setback and Setback Abutting a Street, Minimum (feet) 5 1 Side or Rear Setback, Abutting RS, R1S, or RM zone 10 Minimum (feet) Abutting CO, CG, DDC, NNC, P/SP, IP, SWIR, or 0 or 5 4,5 IL zone Setback to a Private Access Easement, Minimum (feet) 1 Lot Coverage, Maximum Not specified 2 Townhouse 12 Child care facility, group home, or 12 Minimum nursing home riplex, Stand-alone 12 Residential Density uad lex, development p In mixed use develo ment No minimum (units per net acre) multiple- family dwelling Row house 24 Child care facility, group home, or 32 Maximum nursing home riplex, Stand-alone 32 quadplex, In mixed use development 32 multiple- family dwelling Primary or Outside Gateway subarea 70 Building Height, accessory Western Gateway subarea 50 Maximum (feet) structure Eastern Gateway subarea 10 Features not used for habitation 100 DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 4 of 57 174 1. Measured from the Street Widening Setback (Section 3.03.02), if any 2. Lot coverage is limited by setbacks, off-street parking, and landscaping requirements. 3. Only allowed in the Gateway Overlay District 4. A house of worship shall be set back at least 20 feet from a property line abutting a residential zone or use. 5. A building may be constructed at the property line, or shall be set back at least five feet. Staff Findings: The site plan demonstrates the proposed building will meet or exceed the minimum front, side, and rear setbacks. There is no maximum lot coverage. No residential dwellings are proposed therefore the density standards do not apply. A setback in excess of 10-feet is proposed adjacent to the RMN - Nodal Medium Density Residential zone (Cascade Meadow Apartments) to the south. The allowable building height is 70-feet and the proposed building height is 42-feet. No residential is proposed. The Development Standards of the CG zone are met. 2.05 Overlay Districts 2.05.01 Interchange Management Area Overlay District A. Purpose The purpose of the Interchange Management Area Overlay District(IMA) is to preserve the long-term capacity of the 1-5/Highway 214 Interchange. Preserving the capacity of the interchange is essential for the City's future. Continued access to I-5 is critical for existing businesses and for attracting new businesses and development to the community. The IMA complements the provisions of the Southwest Industrial Reserve (SWIR)Zoning District by ensuring that industrial land is retained for the development envisioned in the Woodburn Comprehensive Plan.The IMA also ensures that needed industrial, commercial and residential lands within the IMA are protected from incompatible development generating excessive vehicle trips. The vehicle trip budget(Table 2.05A)identifies by parcel the maximum amount of peak hour trips for each parcel within the IMA and is intended to be high enough to accommodate peak hour trips anticipated by the Woodburn Comprehensive Plan and the Transportation Systems Plan (TSP), but low enough to restrict unplanned vehicle trips that could adversely affect the 1-5/Hwy 214 Interchange. B. Applicability The provisions of this Section apply to all Type II—V land use applications that propose to allow development that will generate more than 20 peak hour vehicle trips(based on the latest Institute of Transportation Engineers Trip Generation Manual) on parcels identified in Table 2.05A.The provisions of Section 2.05.02F apply to all properties within the boundary of the IMA. C. Vehicle Trip Budgets This Section establishes a total peak hour trip generation budget for planned employment (commercial and industrial) land uses within the IMA. 1. The IMA vehicle trip budget is allocated to parcels identified in Table 2.05A on a first- developed,first-served basis. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 5 of 57 175 2. Parcel budgets are based on 11 peak hour trips per developed industrial acre, and 33 peak hour trips per developed commercial acre. 3. The parcel budget for each parcel will be reduced in proportion to actual peak hour vehicle trips generated by new development on any portion of the parcel. 4. The City may allow development that exceeds the parcel budget for any parcel in accordance with this Section. i_ Site A ir Figure 2.05B — Interchange Management Area Boundary and Subareas DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 6 of 57 176 Vehicle Trip Budget by Parcel (Parcel Budget)Table 2.05A Subarea ssessor's Tax Lot Comprehensive Plan Buildable Acres Maximum Peak Hour Number Designation Vehicle Trips 52W12C 02100 7 23 52W12C 02200 6 198 K .........� .........�........aCommercial 52W13 01600 5 165 52W14 02300 6 198 D. Administration This Section delineates responsibilities of the City and ODOT to monitor and evaluate vehicle trip generation impacts on the I-5 interchange from development approved under this Section. TIA: In addition to Section 3.04.05,the following applies: A Transportation Impact Analysis(TIA)is required for all land use applications subject to the provisions of this Section.The TIA must meet City and ODOT administrative rule(OAR Chapter 734, Division 51) requirements and shall include an evaluation and recommendation of feasible Transportation Demand Management(TDM) measures that will minimize peak hour vehicle trips generated by the proposed development. 1. For a land use application subject to the provisions of this Section: a. The City shall not deem the land use application complete unless it includes a TIA prepared in accordance with TIA Requirements; b. The City shall provide written notification to ODOT when the application is deemed complete.This notice shall include an invitation to ODOT to participate in the City's review process; c. ODOT shall have at least 20 days to provide written comments to the City, measured from the date the completion notice was mailed. If ODOT does not provide written comments during this 20-day period,the City's decision may be issued without consideration of ODOT comments. 2. The details of City and ODOT monitoring and coordination responsibilities are found in the Woodburn—ODOT Intergovernmental Agreement(IGA). a. The City shall be responsible for maintaining a current ledger documenting the cumulative peak hour trip generation impact from development approved under this Section, compared with the IMA trip budget. b. The City may adjust the ledger based on actual development and employment data, subject to review and concurrence by ODOT. c. The City will provide written notification to ODOT when land use applications approved under this Section, combined with approved building permits, result in traffic generation estimates that exceed 33%and 67%of the IMA trip budget. 3. This Section recognizes that vehicle trip allocations may become scarce towards the end of the planning period, as the I-5 Interchange nears capacity.The following rules apply to allocations of vehicle trips against the IMA trip budget: a. Vehicle trip allocations are vested at the time of design review approval. b. Vehicle trips shall not be allocated based solely on approval of a comprehensive plan amendment or zone change, unless consolidated with a subdivision or design review application. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 7 of 57 177 c. Vesting of vehicle trip allocations shall expire at the same time as the development decision expires. E. Allowed Uses Uses allowed in the underlying zoning district are allowed, subject to other applicable provisions of the Woodburn Development Ordinance and this Section. F. Comprehensive Plan and Zoning Map Amendments 1. The provisions of this Section (2.05.02.F) apply to all Comprehensive Plan Map amendments within the IMA. This Section does not apply to Zoning Map amendments that result in conformance with the applicable Comprehensive Plan Map designation, such as Zoning Map amendments that occur when land is annexed to the City. 2. Applications for Comprehensive Plan Map amendments and for Zoning Map amendments shall determine whether the proposed change will significantly affect a collector or arterial transportation facility. 3. To ensure that the remaining capacity of the I-5 Interchange is reserved for targeted employment opportunities and needed housing, this section imposes the following prohibitions on Comprehensive Plan Map amendments within the IMA: a. Comprehensive Plan Map amendments that will increase the net commercial land area within the IMA shall be prohibited. b. Comprehensive Plan Map amendments that allow land uses that will generate traffic in excess of the IMA trip budget shall be prohibited. G. Interchange Capacity Preservation Standards Land use applications subject to the provisions of this Section shall comply with the following: 1. Peak hour vehicle trips generated by the proposed development shall not exceed the maximum peak hour vehicle trips specified in Table 2.05A for the subject parcel, except: a. Development may be allowed to exceed the maximum, if the development will contribute substantially to the economic objectives found in the Comprehensive Plan. b. Residential development on a parcel zoned Commercial shall be allowed to exceed the maximum. Transportation Demand Management(TDM) measures shall be required to minimize peak hour vehicle trips and shall be subject to annual review by the City. Staff Finding: This proposal is for Type III review that will generate more than 20 peak hour vehicle trips for a property in the City's IMA Overlay District. The proposed development site occupies part of the northeast portion of Subarea K of the IMA District. A TIA was provided meeting all ODOT, OAR 737, Division 51 and City requirements (see ODOT correspondence). City Staff and applicant worked together to determine TDM measures to minimize peak hour vehicle trips for the development. These are included in Condition of Approval 14. Staff provided the required notices when the application was deemed complete (as well as at the time of submittal) and 20 days prior to the public hearing. ODOT provided comments to the City and applicant on the TIA, which was been DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 8 of 57 178 revised to their satisfaction. Based on the ODOT approved TIA, no additional traffic mitigations were warranted. Although ODOT agreed that no additional traffic mitigations were warranted for the applicant's current proposal, they nevertheless offered recommendations for potential improvements to address future (2040) issues at the intersection for 214 and Evergreen. Specifically, ODOT recommended adding signals at the eastbound (from Evergreen) and southbound (from 214) movements. These mitigations would not be directly attributable to the applicant's proposal, which, as noted above, meets ODOT standards. Additionally, because the recommended mitigations address future (2040) issues, it is not possible to proportionally allocate a share of these future mitigations to the applicant's current proposal. However, these recommended future mitigations will be considered as alternatives in future TSP's completed by the City. The applicant is proposing a number of TDM measures that will facilitate transit usage as well as pedestrian and cycling opportunities for employees and visitors. These are tailored to working directly with the future tenants and enhancing the City's transit system in this area. These include: i. An information board for employees that shows the city transit schedule ii. Potential employee rewards for use of transit and/or bike/walk iii. Identify a TDM manager on site,who will be a point of contact for City staff iv. Potential carpool-only parking spaces v. Providing employees with bus passes vi. Periodic updates to the posted information, based on feedback from City staff or changes to travel options. vii. An annual report referencing how the TDM measures and targets are met viii. Installation of a bus stop shelter on Evergreen Rd to serve a future bus route ix. Construction of a pedestrian crossing with a flashing beacon at the intersection of Evergreen Rd and Oxford St DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 9 of 57 179 \\\\I 111 l\1\11R\\\111\\11W111\\1011\1\1\I\I\\\11161NIllIN1\\1111111111\11\1111\ll➢\\\11111111111111111116RY1111111111g1111\0.1111111111YRIIIIIIIIIVIIIIP111111111114611111111111111111119A1\Ill\\111\111111U1\1A1\1ll1\1ll1\1ll1\1ll1\1ll1\1ll1\1ll1\1ll1\1ll1\1ll1\1ll1\111Ylllllll161111111111111\Y11111111111691\1P1\1111\1111\1111\1111\1111\1111\1111\1111\1111\1111\1111\11\1111\1111\1111\1111\1111\1111\1111\11\\111111A\1\\111111161\111111111111\\P`AI1\41V�411\111P`IIIA111161161111111111P`1V�41P`11111198119`,\\1YA1161111\1111111161811911111\111111111\\\11\11llP11 rat 1 � 1 1V1tv1n1v6 1 11 v9yq�y1�➢�1v�»1v>)���)���5�169119ipv�1�)oD�YdmlvAvlo»6m6m6m6m6m6m6m6m6m6m6m6m6m6m6m6m6m6m6m6m6m69� Ilu6uu11916m6m6m6m6m6m6m6m69ava�olV p ,wl.,,,, o I1 Y r I !✓ f � �rPry�%(I lG��(r) %f/lr/ / //( %'Y/ //r�(��� y���n//l n�l'?I✓�r]gVl !SIP �1Y//�/r � �'�fY1,t'rJ�l�'jfYF �//I�,{�I�Y I�Y�' n wJ� fi( a"�' t"�4ir"u""'Mruu 'tl,rv"u'� �IM`u r w�,riuZn " ' h1(GS1vv61vva1�1vvoXv6�16tQ(\� 10 v(�1vv�vA�A661�11�V11Gi�{vv�YV111�n�{1�t16�vv�tn�v�tld�t��l'Y�o��fi\1�11o��1vt�vli11��1���111ffih����1���lvvwv�vlavo�vv'l1lC�t����\� �i'1�i�ttln�mVl�1t�1�1�i Approximate location of PROPPSED FLASHING RRFB crossing (looking west from eastside of Evergreen St., with Oxford St. on the left.) DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 10 of 57 180 With the proposed conditions of approval related to those TDM requirements, this criterion can be met. See Section 3.04.05 for a detailed review of the TIA The proposed development is expected to generate 511 new peak hour trips and encumbers two lots. Pursuant to the table 2.05A, these two lots have a maximum peak "allocation" of 429 peak hour trips. Pursuant to 2.05.02G.2(a) a development may exceed the allocated parcel budget if the development will contribute substantially to the economic objectives found in the Comprehensive Plan. In their TIA, the applicant provided the following justification for exceeding the parcel peak hour trip allotment: "While the proposed development does exceed the 429 peak hour trips allocated per Table 2.05A, this should be allowed per 2.05(G) because the project will contribute substantially to the economic objectives found in the Woodburn Comprehensive Plan as outlined below. Part F of the Comprehensive Plan states in part, "The third large area of commercial development in the City is the 1-5 Interchange. This contains one small shopping center, a large retail use (WalMart), a premium outlet mall, restaurants, and other highway related uses. In general, commercial uses in West Woodburn, which is the west side of the freeway, should be limited to highway related interchange type uses, while on the east side, a more general commercial nature should be encouraged. Land available for development located west and southwest of Evergreen Road should be developed as a large commercial retail node when Woodburn's population makes it economically feasible. Access management in the 1-5 interchange area is extremely important because the traffic capacity limit of the improved interchange in turn limits commercial growth in West Woodburn. This issue is addressed further in the 2019 Woodburn Transportation System Plan." The Plan anticipates and promotes different types of commercial uses on either side of 1-5. The proposed project is for general commercial retail on the east side of the freeway, which is specifically encouraged at this location. It is not a highway-related interchange use (e.g. regional mall, gas station). Allowing the parcel budget to be exceeded is necessary to allow this development to occur. Without this allowance, the site will remain vacant and the city's goals of having general commercial/retail uses in the commercial area east of 1-5 will not be realized. In addition, the City of Woodburn Economic Opportunities Analysis (EOA) adopted by the city in January 2024 indicates that Woodburn faces a deficit of 107 gross Commercial acres, and 273 gross Industrial acres,for a total employment land deficit of 380 gross acres. The 2025 Urban Growth Boundary (UGB) expansion into the Urban Reserve Area (URA) did not address any of this commercial land need as the 237 URA acres are strictly zoned Southwest Industrial Reserve. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 11 of 57 181 The proposed project contributes to the following adopted economic need and goal of the City of Woodburn as concluded in the EOA: • The EOA concludes that "The projected 20-year need for Commercial land trails the supply significantly, with an estimated 65 acres of commercial land remaining to meet a projected need for 171 gross acres."It goes on to state "The largest remaining contiguous development sites in Woodburn are under 20 acres in size, with most being five acres or less. In addition, roughly one third of the remaining buildable land is found in partially vacant parcels where the decision to add further development is subject to the desires of current property owners and/or tenants. The land for large-lot industrial or large commercial employers is very limited." The proposed project makes use of one such vacant parcel to provide a needed and desirable large commercial employer." Staff concurs with this analysis and justification and finds with Condition of Approval 14 the provisions of this Section are met. 2.06 Accessory Structures 2.06.02 Fences and Walls A. Location and Height Abutting a Street in Residential Zones 1. The height shall comply with the vision clearance area standards,Section 3.03.06. 2. The height shall not exceed 42 inches (3%feet) above the ground elevation under the fence or wall located at the lot line abutting the street. 3. The height may increase one foot for each 6 feet of setback from the lot line abutting the street. Fences may increase to their maximum height (7 ft) when flush with the house or garage. 4. For corner lots, one frontage shall not exceed the standards in #2 above. The alternative frontages are treated as interior lot line(s), allowing fencing in excess of 42 inches up to, and equal with, the house frontage. The remaining frontage shall not exceed the 42 inch limitation. 5. For through lots, abutting streets and/or alleys on two opposite frontages,the rear frontage opposite the front is be treated as an interior lot line, allowing a maximum height of 7 ft. 6. Fences and free-standing walls may be constructed in the Street Widening Setback, provided the property owner agrees to removal at such time as street improvements are made; however, free-standing walls within this setback also require Public Works Director written authorization. B. Height in Yards Not Abutting a Street 1. In residential zones, the maximum height of a fence or wall other than for corner and/or through lots, shall be seven feet, relative to the ground elevation under the fence or wall. C. Height in Non-Residential Zones DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 12 of 57 182 1. In commercial, industrial, or public zones, the maximum height of a fence or wall located in a yard abutting a street shall be 6 feet, relative to the ground elevation under the fence or wall. Fence height may increase to 9 feet once flush with the building face, or 20 feet from street right-of-way. 2. Fences and walls may be constructed in the Street Widening Setback provided the property owner agrees to removal at such time as street improvements are made. D. Fence Materials 1. Materials: Fences and walls shall be constructed of any materials commonly used in the construction of fences and walls, such as wood, stone, rock, or brick, or other durable materials. 2. Coating and slats: Chain link fences are acceptable as long as the fence is coated and includes slats made of vinyl, wood or other durable material. Chain link fence in a residential zone, except where part of refuse and recycling collection facility gates, is exempt from the slats requirement. Slats may not be required when visibility into features such as open space, natural areas, parks and similar areas is needed to assure visual security,or into on-site areas in industrial zones that require visual surveillance. 3. Industrial: For manufacturing, assembly, fabricating, processing, packing, storage and wholesale and distribution activities which are the principle use of a building in industrial districts, the preceding standards apply when visible from, and within 20 feet of, a public street. Prohibition: A fence constructed of materials that could cause bodily harm, including, but not limited to, those conveying electric current, barbed wire, razor wire, spikes and broken glass, is prohibited2.06.02 Fences and Walls Staff Finding: The fencing and walls included with the site plan appear to meet all of the fencing requirements of the WDO. The proposed project includes coated chain link fencing with vinyl slats in the following three locations: 1. A 42-inch-high fence at the southwest side of the Truck Dock for fall protection along the top of the dock retaining wall. 2. A 72-inch-high (6-feet) fence at the Covered Deck on the southwest side of the building connected to the Truck Dock to provide security and screening. This fence is flush with the building face. 3. A 42-inch-high fence along the southeast and northeast sides of the Compactor Dock also for fall protection. These fences are all well over 20-feet from the street rights-of-way and the proposed heights and materials are allowed per WDO 2.06.02. The Generator Enclosure walls are 12-feet, 6-inches high and are attached to the building. These walls as well as the Covered Deck roof structure meet the requirements of WDO 2.06.03 as accessory structures. See the Architectural Site Plan for locations of the proposed fencing, Generator Enclosure and Covered Deck. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 13 of 57 183 A Any new fencing is reviewed separately via a Fence Permit, staff adds Condition of Approval 3 to obtain a Fence Permit for any new fencing. 3.01 Streets, Greenways&Other Off-Street Bicycle/Pedestrian Corridors, and Bus Transit 3.01.01 Applicability A. Right-of-way standards apply to all public streets and public alleys. B. Improvement standards apply to all public and private streets, public alleys, sidewalks, landscape strips, and on and off-street public bicycle pedestrian corridors.Standards do not exclude conformance with the public works construction code that the Public Works Department administers. C.The Woodburn Transportation System Plan (TSP)designates the functional class of major thoroughfares and local streets. D.This applies to all development as Section 1.02 defines, and is not limited to partitions, subdivisions, multi-family,commercial or industrial construction, or establishment of a manufactured dwelling or recreational vehicle park; however, a lesser set of standards applies to infill residential development of 4 or fewer dwellings and where no land division or Planned Unit Development is applicable, including construction of a single-family dwelling or placement of a manufactured dwelling on an infill lot.See Section 3.01.03C.2. 3.01.02 General Provisions A. No development shall be approved, or access permit issued, unless the internal streets, boundary streets and connecting streets are constructed to at least the minimum standards set forth in this Section, or are required to be so constructed as a condition of approval. C. Materials and construction shall comply with specifications of the City of Woodburn. D.The standards of this Section may be modified, subject to approval of a Street Adjustment, Planned Unit Development,Zoning Adjustment, or Variance. Other sections restrict where and how these application types apply. E. When all public improvements are due:The construction of all public improvements, their passing City inspections, and acceptance by the City are due no later than by either 5.01.06B in the context of land division final plat application to the City or by building permit issuance, except if(1)the developer applies to the City through the Public Works Department for deferral and (2)the City Administrator or designee issues a document approving and describing a bond or performance guarantee pursuant to Section 4.02.08.Administration of bonding and performance guarantees for improvements that are public defaults to the Public Works Department, and the department shall notify the Community Development Director of deferral applications and any approvals and conditions of approval. F. Fees in-lieu: Per Section 4.02.12. 3.01.03 Improvements Required for Development A. With development, the Internal, Boundary, and Connecting streets shall be constructed to at least the minimum standards set forth below. C. Boundary Streets 1.The minimum improvements for a Boundary Street may be termed "half-street"improvements and shall be as follows, except per subsection 2: a. One paved 11-foot travel lane in each direction, even though this results in required improvements being slightly more than half-street by exceeding what the applicable cross section figure would require for a half-street; DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 14 of 57 184 b. On-street parking on the side of the street abutting the development, if the required cross section includes on-street parking; c. Curb on the side of the street abutting the development; d. Drainage facilities on the side of the street abutting the development; e. Landscape strip with street trees and lawn grass on the side of the street abutting the development; and f. Sidewalk on the side of the street abutting the development. G. ADA: The minimum standards of this Section 3.01 apply to development such that implementation includes constructing new or upgrading existing public improvements to be ADA- compliant. K. Signage:A developer shall remove prohibited signage that Section 3.10.08R identifies. 3.01.04 Street Cross-Sections A.These standards are based on the functional classification of each street as shown in the Woodburn TSP.The street right-of-way and improvement standards minimize the amount of pavement and right-of-way required for each street classification, consistent with the operational needs of each facility, including requirements for pedestrians, bicycles, and public facilities. B.All public streets under the jurisdiction of the City of Woodburn shall comply with the cross- sections depicted in this Section, unless the developer obtains approval of Street Adjustment, modification through Planned Unit Development,Zoning Adjustment, or Variance as the WDO allows them to be applicable. 1. For local residential streets,the standard cross section is Figure 3.01G.Another among local cross section figures, or a custom cross section, may apply through Street Adjustment or Planned Unit Development. Landscape or planter strips shall have area remaining after street tree plantings landscaped with lawn grass or, if the Public Works Director in writing allows, a species of groundcover. Cobblestones, gravel, pebbles, and rocks are prohibited. Bark dust, mulch, or wood chips are permissible only within the immediate vicinity of a street tree trunk.The developer shall install landscape strip irrigation, and shall provide temporary irrigation during construction, per the public works construction code. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 15 of 57 185 111�1f11f 1, f 'Pik fwy f/�,�vJ tf AAL%, F,API, t„,M�.?� - is�-"�I J(✓,k f„w"'»i' 4,'AV- %,*,+ ,i�'.#el�'f a"IJ6r�:b °f' e ................................................................................ r�- � ra .................................................................................. Figure 3.01C WOODLAND A ' // c143 IT ° r: , /2' H'U VI l !'d A'7 TSP: Fi uare 3 Roadway Plan elements (Note: R43 is a requirement to make upgrades to Stacey Allison consistent with the future truckway. R35- R37 are intersection improvements that are funded in the city's Urban Redevelopment Area and which the City has already started design & engineering.) Staff Findings: The proposal is a commercial development therefore the provisions within 3.01 are applicable. The proposed project fronts both Stacey Allison Way and Evergreen Road. Note that no improvements are justified along Center Street at this time since that will remain undeveloped. When future development occurs on the northern property, all DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 16 of 57 186 street frontage improvements along that frontage will be required at that time. Evergreen Road is a minor arterial street therefore improvements must match WDO Figure 3.01C. A new 6-foot-wide sidewalk is proposed to allow for a 6-foot-wide planter strip with new landscaping to meet WDO 3.01.03C.1.e, 3.01.04 and 3.06.03A. This will bring the Evergreen frontage improvements up to the requirements shown in Figure 3.01C. As directed by City staff(and consistent with the City's Council's previous determination), Stacey Allison Way frontage improvements include a new 6-foot-wide detached sidewalk and 5-foot planter strip to match the modified cross-section that was approved for the Allison Way Apartments Phase 1. OFF-SITE TYPICAL SECTION: APPROVED TYPICAL SECTION STACY ALLISON WAY PHASE 1 [RIOT TO SCALED ROW Pt LW I/OW 1G TOTAL PUE ROW 3Q _ .. Sly I FIAT DLII) STREET : f� PUE PUE i.(T FENCEf' I BIKE SOGLHLt0GN0 TI/UN NGRIEIRGGNL) BIKE F' 4.5' .. 1?0' ...» 1711 .... 170 Rp� _5YYU ... 60 .. CANTER SIDEWALK LANE LANE LANE LANE IANI SMIV fXl IlNG CUOWN I ' EXISTING STORM / 0E STREET !XISRNG IJ II17ll5 SHUWNAT WATER EACIIIIY ✓ Y A[I-'I LOCATION An additional 5 foot ROW is required along Stacy Allison;which is indicated on the Plan. No additional ROW dedication is required along Evergreen or Center St. at this time. ADA compliant sidewalk curb ramps will be installed at all driveway access points from the subject site onto Stacey Allison and Evergreen. 3.01.05 Street Layout B.Termination of Streets and Off-Street Bicycle/Pedestrian Facilities 3. Continuity of Off-Street Bicycle/Pedestrian Facilities Public bikeway and pedestrian facilities, other than those incorporated in a street right- of-way, shall either: a. Provide for a continuous system, with each segment originating and terminating with a connection to a public street, a public alley, a shared rear lane, a greenway, a public park, or to a designated activity center;or b. Provide stubbed facilities to not preclude subsection(a.)and that may extend beyond the limits of an approved development, when such a public facility has been required by the decision- maker. C. Block Standards DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 17 of 57 187 1. Block length shall not be less than 200 feet and not more than 600 feet, except where street location is precluded by any of the following; b. Blocks adjacent to arterial streets, limited-access highways, collectors or railroads; 2. In any block that is longer than 600 feet, as measured from the right-of-way line of the street to the right-of-way line of the adjacent street,a bikeway/pedestrian facility shall be required through and near the middle of the block. 3. On any block longer than 1,200 feet, corridors per Section 3.01.07 and 3.01.08 may be required through the block at 600 foot intervals. 4. In a proposed development including partition and subdivision, or where redevelopment potential exists and a street connection is not proposed, one or more off-street bicycle/pedestrian facilities may be required as partition or subdivision connection paths or shortcut paths to connect a cul-de-sac or other public street to other public streets, to other bicycle/pedestrian facilities, or to adjoining land to allow for future connections. Staff Finding: The distance along Stacey Allison between Hooper Street to the south and Center Street to the north is more than 2,000 feet. Additional public streets between Hooper and Center are not feasible given the existing development. The proposed project includes 717 feet of property frontage along Stacey Allison. An ADA compliant bikeway/pedestrian sidewalk is proposed along the south property line to provide a pedestrian connection roughly mid-block from Stacey Allison to Evergreen. An additional ADA compliant pedestrian pathway is proposed roughly 420 feet further north to connect Stacey Allison to the main entrance and front walkway of the building. This pedestrian route will continue around the northeast side of the building and connect to Evergreen. See Condition of Approval 7. 3.01.09 Bus Transit Improvements A. Purpose: The purpose of this section is to provide for apparent, attractive, and dignified regional and City bus transit facilities, to improve service, especially to include and be equitable toward Woodburn residents who cannot or do not own private vehicles or drive,to extend the reach of those walking and cycling, to implement Woodburn Comprehensive Plan policies, to implement the Transportation System Plan (TSP), to implement the Transit Plan Update that supplements the TSP, to guide City capital improvement projects, and to have developers improve bus transit stops that have few or no improvements. The provision of bus transit improvements is guided also by the Highway 99E Corridor Plan and other WDO sections. B. Applicability: The standards apply along a frontage for which development causes street improvements and either where a bus stop exists that lacks conforming improvements or the City has adopted a long-range transit plan identifying a new bus stop. The standards apply also to off-site bus stop improvements where and as conditioned. D. Improvements: Per the Director. E. Fees in-lieu: Per Section 4.02.12. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 18 of 57 188 Staff Finding: Considering the adopted Transit Development Plan, approved by City Council via Resolution No. 2213 on June 12, 2023, the preferred service plan illustrates the Highway 214 Express route within a quarter of a mile from the subject property. The City recently implemented the preferred public transit service plan outlined in the Transit Development Plan. The plan identifies a new route ("B") running along Evergreen Road which aligns perfectly with a new bus stop shelter for southbound buses along the proposed project frontage. The City is expected to start operation this new route on May 1St of this year. .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. I'i IEIII'I".:IIR.IIR.II�,nlI IIFIR III IIh.- III 'II, III Figure 59 Preferred Fixed Route So c'Plan Overview Preferred Scenario Based on input finer,the'TDP'.Steeringi a'''"""'�Route A Committee.the cornntunity survey results,and %` Route s the focus groiup conducted inn Spanlish,a Preferrei Service Plan wras'developed that r r lnCl,rdes,rmodified versions of the conceptual ., -_.. .,�„� rouhks tNevell� e^ef in tFrr SeRv arc Scen�nlos r.. prasented above. The Preferred Service Plaor includes three rouites" Jr (3`w+ °`! •Route A. Direct Thrs route prudes bidirectional connecting the major destinations in Woodburn wur„ n t old r „6f w)) © VarP0a The focus of this route Is to provide the most direct sr Idli� �v,�„ r r, _ ... rautmg possib3e while also serving these ma,�r yrr r< mi r �rd virile; „ r .>cw rrIfl won w.rve'.x destlnat"rons- ,I na f r ". A Route B-Local.Thrs route provi1-------I -major r a u deshmetions in the community as well as to several residentllal neighborhoods that are not served by Route A. �0 •Route C-Highway 214 Express.Thus near route T. r n P." rr - onne tto'a 114 and o erates -ire the nol etiothe (� raw reat aamnrafl am l7ehwaem-------------- Ii- thannd ! � � s to serve Dolor am rrumunuty acid rr m�r„ tonal ttrensitsenruaes, s -... rsn,�r,.ri� a w More detail about dh�e three routes included)in the Preferred Service Plan are provided below✓. u sciinar iris _ C,IIY I,li"i'rrtY (t ng.4'anr! p rlYYiv"el'y U (-'ttr B I I'"ry O!kli O I..Oavmry P h 0 ae,t:a h-;e 0 City H'If Q T"iris H.....��ry Ya r r nsJo p!yWo u r a� o�,ri JI Consistent with that plan as well as the applicant's requirements under the IMA provisions related to reducing vehicular trips, the applicant will install a bus stop shelter consistent with the City's transit and public works standards. Pursuant to the C above, the applicant is conditioned to provide an easement over the transit shelter as well. 3.02 Utilities and Easements 3.02.01 Public Utility Easements&Public Access Easements A.The Director shall require dedication of specific easements for the construction and maintenance of municipal water, sewerage and storm drainage facilities located on private property. B.Streetside: A streetside public utility easement(PUE)shall be dedicated along each lot line abutting a public street at minimum width 5 feet. Partial exemption for townhouse corner lot: DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 19 of 57 189 Where such lot is 18 to less than 20 feet wide, along the longer frontage, streetside PUE minimum width shall be 3 feet; or,where the lot is narrower than 18 feet,the longer side frontage is exempt from streetside PUE. C. Off-street: The presumptive minimum width of an off-street PUE shall be 16 feet, and the Public Works Director in writing may establish a different width as a standard. D. City& public access: The minimum width of a public access easement along either a bicycle/pedestrian corridor or sidewalk overlap of property,where the easement serves instead of dedication of either land or ROW to the City, shall be per Section 3.01.07C. E. As a condition of approval for development, including property line adjustments, partitions, subdivisions, design reviews, Planned Unit Developments(PUDs),Street Adjustments,Zoning Adjustments, or Variances,the Director may require dedication of additional public easements, including off-street public utility easements and other easement types such as those that grant access termed any of bicycle/pedestrian access, cross access, ingress/egress, public access, or shared access, as well as those that identify, memorialize, and reserve future street corridors in place of ROW dedication. F. Streetside PUE maximum width: 2.Standards: Exempting any lot or tract subject to Figure 3.01B"Major Arterial",the following standards are applicable to a lot or tract with: a. No alley or shared rear lane: 8 feet streetside. Nothing in this section precludes a streetside PUE from variable width where necessary such as to expand around public fire hydrants. Staff Findings: . The applicant will be conditioned (Public Works Condition 3) on dedicating a 5- foot ROW along Stacey Allison as well as a 5 foot PUE along all street frontages. This is based on the recommendations of both PGE and the city's Public Works Dept. 3.02.03 Street Lighting A. Public Streets: Public streets abutting a development shall be illuminated with street lights installed to the standards of the City and the electric utility. A developer shall provide documentation to the attention of the Public Works Director indicating that any needed illumination complies with the standards. A developer is to refer to Illuminating Engineering Society (IES) of North America Recommended Practice 8, Roadway Lighting(RP-8) or other source as the public works construction code specifies. Staff Finding: A Staff adds Public Works Condition 6 to either provide documentation that existing street lighting meets the requirement, or, if it doesn't, install new lighting to meet this requirement. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 20 of 57 190 3.02.04 Underground Utilities C. Off-street: All permanent utility service to and within a development shall be underground,except where overhead high-voltage (35,000 volts or more)electric facilities exist. Staff Finding: Regarding subsection C., site plans illustrate underground utility connections for the proposed building. 3.03 Setbacks and Open Space Staff Finding: As analyzed for 2.03, the development complies with setback requirements. Site plans demonstrate the proposal complies with setbacks, projections, and vision clearance area standards. 3.04 Vehicular& Bicycle/Pedestrian Access 3.04.01 Applicability and Permit A.Street Access Every lot and tract shall have minimum access per subsection 1. or 2.: 1. Direct access to an abutting public street, alley, or shared rear lane; or 2.Access to a public street by means of a public access easement and private maintenance agreement to the satisfaction of the Director, revocable only with the concurrence of the Director, and that is recorded.The easement shall contain text that pursuant to Woodburn Development Ordinance(WDO)3.04.03B.3,the public shared access(ingress and egress) right of this easement is revocable only with the written concurrence of the Community Development Director. 3.04.03 Access Management: Driveway Guidelines and Standards B. Number of Driveways 3. For nonresidential uses,the number of driveways should be minimized based on overall site design, including consideration of: a.The function classification of abutting streets; b.The on-site access pattern, including parking and circulation,joint access, turnarounds and building orientation; c.The access needs of the use in terms of volume, intensity and duration characteristics of trip generation. 4. Unused driveways shall be closed. 5. For all development and uses,the number of driveways shall be further limited through access management per subsections C&D below. C. Joint Access 3. Every joint driveway or access between separate lots shall be per the same means as in Section 3.04.01A.2. 4.Standards: a. Easement: Per Section 3.04.01A.2 and minimum width 20 feet. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 21 of 57 191 b. Improvements:The easement and the drive aisle or aisles it follows shall align along centerline. Each shared access drive aisle shall extend to the property line with no terminating curb and no fixed barrier mounted to the drive aisle.The drive aisle minimum width is 20 feet if without side curbs and 21 feet inclusive of side curbs. D. Access management: 2. Commercial: Any development within a commercial zoning district that Section 2.03A lists shall grant shared access to adjacent lots and tracts partly or wholly within any of the same districts. An alley or shared rear lane may substitute for meeting this standard if the alley provides equivalent public access. Zoning Adjustment is permissible. E. Interconnected Parking Facilities 1.All uses on a lot shall have common or interconnected off-street parking and circulation facilities. 2.Similar or compatible uses on abutting lots shall have interconnected access and parking facilities. Access Requirements Table 3.04A 1 to 4 Dwellings, 5 or More Dwelling or Commercial or Living Units or Living Units,School, or Industrial Use 6 6 Individual Lots House of Worship 1-way 8 minimum 10 minimum 10 minimum 20 maximum 20 maximum Paved Width 20 minimum Commercial/Mixed- of Driveway 2-way 14 minimum 24 maximum* Use: 3,4,7,8 (feet) 16 maximum 7 *(Add 6 ft maximum if 20 minimum a turn pocket is added) 24 maximum* *(Add 12 ft maximum if a turn pocket is added) Industrial: 22 minimum 36 maximum* *(Add 8' if a turn pocket is added) Manufactured 10 minimum n/a n/a Dwelling Park Major Arterial, Commercial Minor Arterial, n/a 36 minimum 36 minimum, Throat Service Collector Industrial: Length (feet) 50 minimum Access or Local n/a 18 minimum 18 minimum Street DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 22 of 57 192 Corner Access or Local 30 minimum 30 minimum 30 minimum Clearance Street (feet) Guidelines 1 Service Collector 50 minimum 50 minimum 50 minimum (See Figure Minor Arterial 245 minimum 245 minimum 245 minimum 3.04B) Major Arterial 300 minimum 300 minimum 300 minimum Driveway on the 22 minimum 50 minimum 50 minimum Driveway same parcel Separation Access or Local none none none Guidelines Street 1,2 (feet) Service Collector 50 minimum 50 minimum 50 minimum (See Figure 3.04B) Minor Arterial 245 minimum 245 minimum 245 minimum Major arterial 300 minimum 300 minimum 300 minimum Access to a Major or Minor Required RequiredRequired Arterial Turnarounds Required if the 9 driveway length to Requirements Access to any the lot located Requirements per the per the other street furthest from the Woodburn Fire District Woodburn Fire street exceeds 150 District feet 1. The separation should be maximized. 2. Driveways on abutting lots need not be separated from each other, and may be combined into a single shared driveway. 3. Driveways over 40 feet long and serving one dwelling unit may have a paved surface minimum 8 feet wide. 4. Notwithstanding the widths listed in this table,the minimum clearance around a fire hydrant shall be provided (See Figure 3.04D). 5. Throat length is measured from the closest off-street parking or loading space to the right-of-way. A throat applies only at entrances(See Figure 3.058). 6. Maximum of 4 individual lots can be served from single shared driveway(See Figure 3.04A)except where and as Section 3.04.03D.3 "Flag Lots"supersedes. 7. It is permissible that the Oregon Fire Code (OFC) as administered by the independent Woodburn Fire District may cause driveway widths to exceed minimums and maximums. It is a developer's responsibility to comply with the OFC. 8. Width measurement excludes throat side curbing, if any. 9. Refer to OFC Appendix D, Figure D103.1. Staff Findings: A As a minor arterial street, only one driveway access is allowed along Evergreen Road pursuant to WDO 3.04.03B.3. The driveway is proposed to be roughly 150 DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 23 of 57 193 feet from the existing driveway into the Cascade Meadow Apartments to the south. The 245-foot separation shown in Table 3.04A is a guideline rather than a required standard. Staff can support this driveway location. The Applicant is proposing this driveway location to allow easier (less circuitous) vehicle access into the site as well as more direct fire access to the Fire Department Connection (FDC) which will be located southwest of the building. Per the project Traffic Impact Analysis (TIA), traffic volumes at the Hooper Street/Evergreen Road intersection just south of the Oxford intersection are exceptionally low during peak hours. Hooper serves a similar function to Oxford and therefore would also have low traffic volumes at the intersection with Evergreen. The apartment access may be slightly busier than the Oxford intersection but traffic from both would be minimally impacted by the new, proposed access point to Evergreen. All driveways meet the width requirements of Table 3.04A, except for the northern driveway on Stacy Allison, which needs to be modified in the final engineering drawings. This is addressed through Condition of Approval 10. The two driveways accessing Stacey Allison are separated by more than 400 feet, meeting the minimum separation distance required by Table 3.04A. To meet 3.04.03D.2 and 3.04.03C.4, a driveway will be installed to connect the subject property to the commercial properties and Center Street to the north. As indicated on the Architectural Site Plan, a future driveway will connect to commercial properties to the south. 3.04.05 Traffic Impact Analysis B. A transportation study known as a transportation impact analysis (TIA) is required for any of the following: 1. Comprehensive Plan Map Change or Zone Change or rezoning that is quasi-judicial, excepting upon annexation designation of zoning consistent with the Comprehensive Plan. 2. A development would increase vehicle trip generation by 50 peak hour trips or more or 500 average daily trips(ADT) or more. 3.A development would raise the volume-to-capacity(V/C) ratio of an intersection to 0.96 or more during the PM peak hour. 4. Operational or safety concerns documented by the City or an agency with jurisdiction, such as ODOT or the County, and submitted no earlier than a pre-application conference and no later than as written testimony entered into the record before the City makes a land use decision. 5. A development involves or affects streets and intersections documented by ODOT as having a high crash rate, having a high injury rate of persons walking or cycling, having any cyclist and pedestrian deaths, or that partly or wholly pass through school zones that ODOT recognizes. 6. Where ODOT has jurisdiction and ORS or OAR, including OAR 734-051, compels the agency to require. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 24 of 57 194 A developer shall submit a traffic impact letter or memo when the City or an agency with jurisdiction does not require a TIA. A development within the Downtown Development and Conservation (DDC) zoning district is exempt from TIA submittal. Staff Finding: A The applicant provided a traffic impact analysis (attachment 104) from a registered professional engineer and which has been reviewed and deemed in conformance with all of the above requirements by City Staff, the City's contract traffic engineer, as well as ODOT(see attachment 105).The analysis indicates that all 16 intersections included in the study will operate within the identified standards with the exception of three intersections along Evergreen Rd., specifically: • Stacy Allison Way/Evergreen Rd. • Hayes Street/Evergreen Rd. • Harvard Drive/Evergreen Rd. These three intersections are projected to exceed there operating standards even without this project being approved. The City had identified these projects in the recently adopted TSP for updates and the engineering work has already begun on designing new signal improvements at Stacy Allison/Evergreen and Hayes and Evergreen. Harvard/Evergreen is being designed with roundabout. Construction on these important public projects is expected to be underway later this year. The TIA includes an analysis of these intersections after these improvements are completed (and the store is open) and it indicates that all three will operate within the mobility standards. The cost of these three projects is expected to be approximately the same as the transportation SDC's that will be collected at time of building permit issuance. Owing to the impacts this project will have on these intersections, and the desire to have development pay its "own way" to the greatest degree possible, staff anticipates using all of the transportation SDC's collected for the project to go paying for these three nearby intersections. 3.04.06 Bicycle/Pedestrian Access between Sidewalk and Building Entrances B. Wide walkway: Excluding residential development other than multiple-family dwellings, 1 wide walkway minimum or with each of two frontages for sites of two or more frontages. Where a development includes or abuts a public off-street bicycle/pedestrian facility, a wide walkway shall also connect to the facility. Minimum width 8 feet,ADA-compliant, and not gated. Gating is allowed only if the development driveway throat or throats are gated. C. Walkway: Minimum 1 per frontage except where a wide walkway supersedes. Minimum width 6 feet and may have stairs. For residential development of other than multiple-family dwellings, each lot shall have a walkway minimum 2 feet wide of minimum length such that it connects sidewalk with an entrance to each DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 25 of 57 195 and every dwelling on a given lot. The walkway shall not overlap a driveway, and where a walkway is flush with a driveway, it shall either(1) be raised minimum 3 inches, have curbing which may be mountable, and be minimum 3 feet and 3 inches wide, or(2) be dyed, patterned, stamped or otherwise treated or of a different paving material than the driveway to visually distinguish it from the adjacent driveway. D. Walkway and wide walkway crossings: A development with crossings of drive aisles shall have one or more crossings made visually distinct from adjacent vehicular pavement and minimum width equal to that of the walkway. 1. Wide walkways: Minimum width 8 ft each. Every crossing along a wide walkway shall be either an extension of wide walkway poured concrete at the same grade as adjacent vehicular area or in the form of a speed table, also known as a raised walkway crossing, minimum 4 inches high and with vehicular side ramps maximum slope ten percent and with striped warning triangles. ADA-compliant transitions or ramps shall be minimum 5 feet wide. For multiple-family dwelling development,the speed table option shall be a requirement. 2. Walkways: Where there are walkways and any of them cross drive aisles, all of the crossings along minimum 1 walkway shall be either an extension of walkway poured concrete at the same grade as adjacent vehicular area and same width as the walkway or in the form of a speed table, also known as a raised walkway crossing, minimum 4 inches high. A developer shall stripe remaining walkway crossings with any of hatch or ladder pattern or three or more bars perpendicular to the crossing. 3. See Section 3.05.02N regarding crossings within multiple-aisle parking areas. Staff Finding: The proposal is new commercial development therefore the provisions apply.The plans illustrate a six-foot-wide public sidewalk connection along the south side of the property between Stacey Allison and Evergreen Rd. Separately, wide walkways eight feet in width meeting WDO 3.04.06 are proposed from the building to both Stacey Allison Way and Evergreen Road. Where these wide walkways cross drive aisles, they will be poured concrete to provide visual cues further delineating the walking space from the vehicular drives. These walkways also connect to the privately owned on- site bicycle parking. The walkways will be ADA compliant and not gated. 3.05 Off-Street Parking and Loading 3.05.01 Applicability 3.05.02 General Provisions A. All required parking and loading spaces shall be retained and maintained in accordance with the standards of the WDO. B.The land for off-street parking and loading areas shall either be: 1. Owned in fee title by the owner of the structure or site being served by the parking area, or D. Location 4. In non-residential districts, off-street parking and storage shall be prohibited within a setback adjacent to a street,except if screened per Section 3.06.05B.Vehicle parking within the public right- of-way shall not be eligible for fulfilling any required off-street parking requirement. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 26 of 57 196 E. Setback 1. In commercial and industrial zones, the parking, loading, and circulation areas shall be set back from a street a minimum of five feet. 2. Parking, loading, and circulation areas shall be set back from a property line a minimum of five feet, excepting any of (a) interior lot lines of lots in a development that have the same owner or that have outbuildings as part of a complex of buildings sited amid parking, such as in an office or industrial park or strip mall, (b)a shared access and use agreement between or among landowners per Section 3.04, and (c) shared access in the specific context of residential development of other than multiple-family dwellings. F. All vehicle parking and loading areas shall be paved to the standards of this ordinance (Section 3.04.04), except that in the IP, IL, SWIR, and P/SP zones, storage areas used for equipment that may damage pavement may be stored on a gravel-surface storage area. A gravel storage area shall be constructed to a minimum of surfacing of: six inches of one inch minus to three inch minus gravel. If three inch minus is used, the top two inches shall be one inch minus. The property owner shall maintain a gravel storage area to ensure continued drainage and dust control. A paved access apron to any paved access road is required, regardless of the storage area surface. G.All vehicle parking, loading,and storage areas shall be graded and provide storm drainage facilities approved by the Director. H.All parking spaces, except those for residential development other than multiple-family dwellings, shall be constructed with concrete or rubber bumper guards or wheel barriers maximum 4 inches high that prevent vehicles from damaging structures, projecting over walkways so as to leave less than 4.5 feet of unobstructed passage, or projecting over wide walkways, abutting properties, or rights-of- way. I. Maneuvering areas shall be designed in compliance with this Section (Table 3.05B). Off- street parking areas shall be designed so that no backing or maneuvering within a public right-of-way is required.These provisions do not apply to dwellings other than multiple-family. J. All uses required to provide 20 or more off-street parking spaces shall have directional markings or signs to control vehicle movement, and any dead-end drive aisle 50 feet or longer shall have an MUTCD-compliant"no outlet"sign. K. Except for dwellings other than multiple-family, off-street parking spaces shall be delineated by double parallel lines on each side of a space, except a side adjacent to any of curb or ADA parking accessible aisle. The total width of the lines shall delineate a separation of two feet. The lines shall be four inches wide (See Figure 3.05C). L. Parking area lighting for all developments shall conform to Chapter 3.11. M. Required parking spaces shall be available for parking of operable vehicles of residents,customers, patrons and employees and shall not be used for the storage of vehicles or materials or for the parking of fleet vehicles, except for those fleet vehicles: 1. Driven by an employee to the site each work day from home, or 2.Stored during periods other than normal business hours. N. Walkway crossings: Parking areas with multiple aisles shall have minimum 1 walkway or wide walkway that passes through the parking area to the aisle farthest from the building. Each walkway crossing shall conform to Section 3.04.06D. 3.05.03 Off-Street Parking A. Number of Required Off-Street Parking Spaces 1. Off-street vehicle parking spaces shall be provided in amounts not less than those set forth in this Section (Table 3.05A). DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 27 of 57 197 2. Off-street vehicle parking spaces shall not exceed two times the amount required in this Section (Table 3.05A). B.ADA:Accessible parking shall be provided in amounts not less than those that ORS 447.233 requires.The number of accessible spaces shall be included as part of total required vehicle parking spaces. C. A maximum of 20 percent of the required vehicle parking spaces may be satisfied by compact vehicle parking spaces. D. Off-street vehicle parking spaces and drive aisles shall not be smaller than specified in this Section (Table 3.05C). E. A developer shall provide off-street bicycle parking per the minimums and standards in Tables 3.05D&G and the additional standards in Section 3.05.06. Off-Street Parking Ratio Standards Table 3.05A Use 1,2 Parking Ratio-spaces per activity unit or square feet of gross floor area 7. General retail sales(such as food and beverages, clothing, sporting goods, health and personal care 1/ square feet items, and motor vehicle parts) 1.The Director may authorize parking for any use not specifically listed in this table.The applicant shall submit an analysis that identifies the parking needs, and a description of how the proposed use is similar to other uses permitted in the zone.The Director may require additional information, as needed,to document the parking needs of the proposed use. 2.There is no required parking ratio for non-residential uses and residential units above first floor commercial uses in the DDC zone (See Section 3.07.07.C.12). 3.See Tables 3.05C&E for minimum carpool/vanpool and electric vehicle parking and Table 3.05D for minimum bicycle parking. 4. In compliance with OAR 660-046-0220(2)(e). Parking Space and Drive Aisle Dimensions Table 3.058 Stall Curb Stripe Stall to Drive Aisle Width Parking Type of Space Width Length Length Curb (feet) Angle feet (feet) (feet) (feet)) ( ) 1-way 2-way A B C D E F G Standard 9.0 9.0 18.0 18.0 24.0 90° Compact 7.5 7.5 15.0 15.0 22.0 (Perpend- 24.0 icular) Car Accessible Aisle 6.0 6.0 18.0 18.0 24.0 Van Accessible Aisle 8.0 8.0 18.0 18.0 DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 28 of 57 198 Parking Space and Drive Aisle Dimensions Table 3.05B Stall Curb Stripe Stall to Drive Aisle Width Parking Angle Type of Space Width Length Length Curb (feet) (feet) (feet) (feet) (feet) 1-way 2-way A B C D E F G 1. A parking space other than compact may occupy up to 1.5 feet of a landscaped area or walkway as measured from face of curb. Compact may occupy up to six inches. At least 4.5 feet clear width of a walkway must be maintained. 2. Space width is measured from the midpoint of the double stripe. 3. Curb or wheel stops shall be utilized to prevent vehicles from encroaching on abutting properties, rights-of-way, or wide walkways. 4. The access aisle must be located on the passenger side of the parking space, except that two adjacent parking spaces may share a common access aisle. 5. Where the angle of parking stalls differ across a drive aisle,the greater drive aisle width shall be provided. 6. In the context of residential development of other than multiple-family dwellings, parking space minimum dimensions shall be 8 feet wide by 18 feet long, including within a carport or garage. See also Section 3.05.03F.1. 7. The Oregon Fire Code(OFC) as administered by the independent Woodburn Fire District may cause drive aisle widths to exceed the minimum and maximums in this table. 8. Zoning Adjustment permissible. Staff Findings: Pursuant to WDO 3.05.02D.1, off-street vehicle parking is proposed on the same lot as the proposed building. Per Table 3.05A, a minimum of 336 off-street parking stalls must be provided as part of the proposed development.The number of stalls proposed (i.e., 504 stalls) exceeds that required by Table 3.05A, however, is less than double that required in order to stay under the limit imposed by WDO 3.05.03A.2. As required by WDO 3.05.02D.4 and 3.05.02E, no parking is proposed within the setbacks, and all parking and circulation areas are setback a minimum of 5-feet from boundary streets as well as interior property lines. All parking and circulation areas are paved, graded, and include storm drainage facilities in compliance with WDO 3.05.02F and G. Concrete curbs, wheel stops and steel pipe bumpers are proposed as necessary to meet the requirements of 3.05.02H. Stall width and length, accessible aisles and drive aisles meet or exceed the minimum dimensions shown in Table 3.05B and are in compliance with WDO 3.05.021. Directional markings and double stall delineation lines are proposed pursuant to 3.05.02) and K. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 29 of 57 199 A wide walkway meeting WDO 3.04.06D is proposed to pass through the parking area and extend all the way to Stacey Allison way to meet 3.05.02NThe proposal is a new commercial office building totaling 14,052 square feet. Pursuant to Table 3.05A row 12, the minimum parking requirement for the proposal is 40 stalls. Site plans illustrate 41 new parking stalls proposed, 7 of which are compact size and the remainder are standard size. Parking stalls and drive aisles are noted to conform with the dimension requirements in Table 3.05B. Bicycle parking is analyzed further under Section 3.05.06. A Staff adds Condition of Approval 11a to memorialize the accessible parking requirement. Carpool/Vanpool Parking Table 3.05C .q N- Development or Use Description Stall Minimum Number or Percent 1. Non-residential Zero to 19 total minimum required off- n/a development within street parking spaces commercial zoning 20 to 33 total 1 stall districts 34 to 65 total 2 stalls 66 or more total 2 stalls or 3%,whichever is greater 1. Standard applies even if the site is not zoned P/SP. 2. See Section 3.05.03H for carpool/vanpool (C/V)development standards. H. Carpool/vanpool (C/V)stalls shall meet the following standards: 1. Convenient locations: The distance from a stall, in whole or in part, shall be maximum 50 feet to a building perimeter walkway or,where there is no perimeter walkway, a building main or staff-only entrance. 2.Striping: Stripe each stall in lettering 1 ft high min"CARPOOL/VANP00L"or similar. 3.Signage: Post at each stall a wall-mounted or pole-mounted sign for"Carpool/Vanpool"or similar. Each sign 1% by 1 foot minimum with top of a posted sign between 5%and 7 feet high max above vehicular grade. Staff Findings: `The proposal is a new commercial office building within the Commercial Office zone. As analyzed for Table 3.05A, the minimum parking requirement for the DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 30 of 57 200 proposal is 40 stalls. The carpool/vanpool parking requirement is therefore 2 stalls. Plans illustrate 2 carpool/vanpool parking stalls provided. . Staff adds Condition of Approval 11b to memorialize the striping and signage requirements for carpool/vanpool parking. Electric Vehicle Parking Table 3.05E Development or Use Description Stall Minimum Number or Percent 2. Non-residential Zero to 19 total minimum required spaces n/a development within 20 to 39 total 2 stalls commercial zoning 40 or more total 2 stalls,or 5%of total districts minimum required spaces, whichever is greater 1. Standard applies even if the site is not zoned P/SP. 2. The Director may authorize EV parking for any use that the Development or Use column does not clearly include. 3. See Section 3.05.031 below for EV development standards. 4. Administrative note: As of January 2022, electrical permitting remains through the County instead of the City by agreement between the City and County. 1. Electric vehicle(EV) includes both electric vehicle and plug-in hybrid vehicle, and EV parking stalls shall meet the following standards: 1. Convenient locations: The distance from a stall, in whole or in part, shall be maximum 50 feet to a building perimeter walkway or,where there is no walkway, a building main or staff-only entrance. 2. Charging level: minimum Level 2 (240 volt alternating current [AC] charging), or faster charging. 3.Striping: Stripe each stall in lettering 1 ft high min"ELECTRIC VEHICLE CHARGING"or similar and stencil of an EV image or logo. 4.Signage: Post at each stall a wall-mounted or pole-mounted sign for"Electric Vehicle Charging" or similar and include an EV image or logo. Each sign 1% by 1 foot minimum with top of a posted sign between 5%and 7 feet high max above vehicular grade. 5. Management/operations: The landowner or property manager shall keep EV stalls available for EVs and plug-in hybrid vehicles and keep conventional gasoline vehicles from parking in them, and in the context of multiple-family dwelling development: a. Priority users shall be tenants, and guests/visitors would be secondary. b. May charge EV stall users for the costs of charging an EV through a charging station, but shall not(1)charge users for either simply parking an EV or plug-in hybrid vehicle in an EV stall or for leaving such a vehicle parked without actively charging, and (2)shall charge to recoup costs to DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 31 of 57 201 the landowner or property manager and not generate profit for the landowner or property manager. (This does not preclude the landowner or property manager contracting with a for- profit company to manage EV charging stations). c. Shall not charge any fee that discriminates among particular EV parking stalls based on the perception of some stalls being more convenient or otherwise desirable than others. It is anticipated but not required that the layout would be that each charging station would serve a pair of stalls. Staff Findings: The proposal is a new retail building within the CG zone. The minimum electric vehicle charging stall requirement is to provide 17 (Level 2) EV stalls. The plans propose eight Type 3 Tesla chargers; hence the need for a variance. The variance criteria are outlined in Section 5.03.12 of the WDO and reviewed later in this report. A Regardless of the result of the variance request,Staff adds Condition of Approval 11cto memorialize the charging level, striping, and signage requirements. 3.05.04 Off-Street Loading& Unloading A.Standard: Loading and unloading for all multiple-family dwelling and non-residential development shall not encroach within the ROW of a street with a functional class designation higher than local. B.Administration:The Director may require a developer to submit a site plan sheet or sheets illustrating where and how loading and unloading would occur such that a development would meet subsection A above. Staff Finding: The site plan demonstrates that no loading will encroach into street right-of- way. 3.05.05 Shared Parking Staff Finding: The applicant's narrative states no shared parking is proposed therefore the provisions do not apply. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 32 of 57 202 Off-Street Bicycle Parking Table 3.05D IIIIIIIII. Development or Use Description Stall Minimum Number, Percent, or Ratio 2. Non-residential Whichever of the two rates,it greater: development within (1)2 stalls or,15%of total minimum commercial zoning required parking spaces,whichever is districts greater;or, (2)2 stalls or equal to 0.6/1,000 square feet GFA,whichever is greater. 1. Standard applies even if the site is not zoned P/SP. 2. Each modular classroom counts as a classroom. 3. The Director may authorize off-street bicycle parking for any use that the Development or Use column does not clearly include. 4. See Section 3.05.06 for bicycle parking development standards. 3.05.06 Bicycle Parking Standards B.Applicability:Applies to total minimum required bicycle parking per Table 3.05D and any excess. C. Standards: Developers shall install parking in lockers or racks that meet the following: 1.Surface:The area devoted to bicycle parking shall be paved if outdoors or otherwise hard surfaced if enclosed or indoors. Outdoor pavement shall be asphalt, bricks, cobblestone rectangular pavers, concrete pavers, poured concrete, structurally supported fiber cement or wood planking, or combination. 2. Facility:Where bicycle parking is provided with racks,they shall meet the following: a.The rack shall be designed so that the bicycle frame and one wheel can be locked to a rigid portion of the rack with a U-shaped shackle lock,when both wheels are left on the bicycle; b. If the rack is a horizontal rack, it shall support the bicycle at two points, including the frame; and c.The rack must be securely anchored with tamper-resistant hardware. 3. Dimensions: Bicycle parking spaces, aisles and clearances shall be per Table 3.05G,which Figures 3.05E, F, &G illustrate. 4.Signage: If bicycle parking is not visible from sidewalk,wide walkway, or the main entrance of the building(s), a developer must install a permanent sign, minimum 1 by 1.5 feet, at the main entrance of each primary building indicating the location of bicycle parking. Figure 3.05H illustrates examples. 5. Proximity:A developer shall construct or install bicycle parking within maximum 50 feet of the main entrance and per Figures 3.05J-L. 6. Covered/sheltered:A developer shall cover or shelter from precipitation among the total required bicycle parking minimum 50 percent of any and all parking that is outdoors. 7. Multiple-family dwellings: In multiple-family dwelling development where buildings have no elevators, some of the bicycle parking that a developer may provide in stairwells and patio and DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 33 of 57 203 balcony outdoor closets may count towards the total minimum required bicycle parking stalls. Specifically, all stall facilities in stairwells and patio outdoor closets may count,while 50 percent of stall facilities in balcony outdoor closets may count. A developer may provide a stall in an indoor closet or alcove of a dwelling if the space meets the minimum dimensions per Table 3.05G and includes a hook or rack meets the locking standards of above subsection 2 and is foldable or retractable. All patio physical separations from common area shall have a gate minimum 2 feet,4 inches wide. 8. Plan review:The developer or contractor shall submit the following information with applications for any of land use or building permit review: a. Location;where not obvious, access route(s)to; and number of bicycle parking stalls; b. Notated dimensions of all stalls, aisles, maneuvering areas, and clearances; and c. If applicable, information adequate to illustrate the racks and stalls that meet a particular set of standards. Bicycle Parking Stall Minimum Dimensions Table 3.05G ................................................................................................................ 2 f I 6' Dimension Conventional Alternative(feet) 2 Horizontal 1 Horizontal as Wall- Vertical or Wall-Mounted 1,4,5 (feet) Attached 3 Length 6 6 3 ft,4 inches Width 2 2 1 ft, 5 inches Height 3 ft,4 inches 3 ft,4 inches 6 Maneuvering width 7 5 5 5 Clearance 0.5 8 1 9 n/a 1. See Figure 3.05E. 2.The purpose of alternatives primarily is to allow multiple-family dwelling developments to include more easily a number of stalls through any of communal storage rooms and sheds and on building, freestanding, and trash and recycling enclosure walls. 3.See Figure 3.05F. 4. See Figure 3.05G. 5. Vertical or wall-mounted maximums: a. Where the total minimum required bicycle parking is fewer than 4 stalls,vertical and wall- mounted stalls are prohibited. b. Where the total minimum required bicycle parking is 4 or more stalls, of the subtotal that is outside a building, maximum 50 percent may be vertical stalls. 6.See Figure 3.05H. 7.Sidewalk:Where a bicycle parking stall is adjacent to a sidewalk, off-street bicycle/pedestrian facility,walkway, or access way,the maneuvering area may overlap it. 8. Measured to stall length or width boundary. 9. Measured to centerline of outermost bar of facility. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 34 of 57 204 Main entrance u h� rt_t rm Landscaping ' Walk -rr L g than ," STREET Figure 3.05J—Bicycle Parking Proximity: One Building, One Entrance Staff Finding: The proposal is for a new 84,073 SF retail use within the Commercial General zone. As analyzed forTable 3.05A,the minimum parking bike parking requirement is 50 stalls. All stalls are provided on a paved surface and of the 50 stalls provided, 66%are covered. The plans illustrate 50 spaces meeting all of the size and signage location requirements; however, it may not be apparent that the requirement to have bike parking within 50 feet of the entrance (per 3.05J) is being met. Therefore, the Director has made an interpretation that pursuant to the Figure, not all of the required bike stalls must be within 50 feet of the door. Staff interprets this Figure to indicate that short term parking spaces need to be within 50 feet of an entrance. The proposed plans provide for 12 spaces within the 50 of the entry,the remaining DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 35 of 57 205 are under a shelter approximately 100' feet away. It is the Director's interpretation that this meets the letter, and intent, of the provided within 50 feet of the entrance as is required per 3.05.06. 3.06 Landscaping 3.06.01 Applicability The provisions of this Section shall apply: A.To the site area for all new or expanded multiple-family dwelling and non-residential development, parking and storage areas for equipment, materials and vehicles. 3.06.02 General Requirements A. Building plans for all uses subject to landscaping requirements shall be accompanied by landscaping and irrigation plans. B.All required landscaped areas shall be irrigated unless it is documented that the proposed landscaping does not require irrigation. C. All shrubs and ground cover shall be of a size upon installation so as to attain 80%of ground coverage within 3 years. D. Installation of plant materials and irrigation specified in an approved landscaping plan shall occur at the time of development and shall be a condition of final occupancy.Should site conditions make installation impractical, an acceptable performance guarantee may be approved, subject the requirements of this Ordinance (Section 4.02.08). E.The property owner shall be responsible for maintaining all landscaping, fences, and walls in good condition, so as to present a healthy and orderly appearance. Unhealthy and dead plants shall be removed and replaced, in conformance with the original landscape plan. F.The required number of plant units shall be met by a combination of plant materials listed in this Ordinance(Table 3.06B). G. Required plant units need not be allocated uniformly throughout specified landscaping areas, but may be grouped for visual effect. H. Landscaped areas that are not covered by plant materials shall be covered by a layer of bark mulch or decorative rock, a minimum of two inches in depth. I. A minimum 4 inch high and wide concrete curb shall be provided between landscaped areas and parking and circulation areas. J. Plant materials shall be appropriate to the climate and environment of Woodburn. Inclusion of plants identified in "Suggested Plant Lists for Required Landscaping", published by the Portland Bureau of Development Services, can be used to meet this standard.A landscape architect, certified arborist or nursery person may also attest to plant appropriateness. 3.06.03 Landscaping Standards A.Street Trees The purpose of the street tree provisions is to get and preserve street trees, to shade those walking and provide them psychological protection from passing vehicles,to calm those driving, to help spatially define streets through canopy, to absorb stormwater and pollutants,to reduce the urban heat island effect, and to raise value of adjacent property. Within the public street right-of-way abutting a development, street trees shall be planted to City standards, prior to final occupancy or earlier if conditioned. 1.A number of trees equal to one tree per every 30 feet of street frontage within a block face, shall be planted within the right-of-way. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 36 of 57 206 2.Street trees shall be planted according to the Boundary Street classification per the Transportation System Plan: c. Small trees shall be planted along all other streets. Refer to Table 3.06B below for the definition of size categories at maturity. 3. Root barriers: The developer shall install root barriers per the public works construction code. 4. Fee in-lieu: Per Section 4.02.12. B.Site landscaping shall comply with Table 3.06A. Planting Requirements Table 3.06A Location Planting Density, Minimum Area to be Landscaped, Minimum 1.Setbacks abutting a street 1 PU/15 square feet Entire setback excluding driveways 2. Buffer yards 1 PU/20 square feet Entire yard excluding off-street parking and loading areas abutting a wall 3. Other yards 1 PU/50 square feet Entire yard, excluding areas subject to more intensive landscaping requirements and off-street parking and loading areas 4. Off-street parking and • 1 small tree per 10 parking • RS, R1S, RSN, RM, RMN, P/SP, CO, loading areas spaces; or1 CG and MUV zones: 20%of the paved surface area for off-street • 1 medium tree per 15 1 parking, loading and circulation parking spaces; or • DDC, NNC, IP, IL, and SWIR zones: • 1 large tree per 25 parking 10%of the paved surface area for spaces 1 off-street parking, loading and and circulation 1 PU/20 square feet excluding • Landscaping shall be within or required trees 2 immediately adjacent to paved areas 5. Common areas, except 3 PU/50 square feet Entire common area those approved as natural common areas in a PUD 1. Trees shall be located within off-street parking facilities, in proportion to the distribution of the parking spaces. 2. Required landscaping within a setback abutting a street or an interior lot line that is within 20 feet of parking, loading and circulation facilities may also be counted in calculating landscaping for off-street parking, loading and circulation areas. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 37 of 57 207 Plant Unit(PU)Value Table 3.06B Material Plant Unit(PU)Value Minimum Size 1. Significant tree 1 15 PU each 24" Diameter 2. Large tree (60-120 feet high at 10 PU each 10' Height or 2"Caliper maturity) 1 3. Medium tree(40-60 feet high at 8 PU each 10' Height or 2"Caliper maturity 1 4. Small tree(18-40 feet high at maturity)1 4 PU each 10' Height or 2"Caliper 5. Large shrub(at maturity over 4'wide x 2 PU each 3 gallon or balled 4' high) 1 6. Small to medium shrub(at maturity 1 PU each 1 gallon maximum 4'wide x 4' high) 1 7. Lawn or other living ground cover 1 1 PU/50 square feet 8. Berm 2 1 PU/20 lineal feet Minimum 2 feet high 9. Ornamental fence 2 1 PU/20 lineal feet 2%-4 feet high 10. Boulder 2 1 PU each Minimum 2 feet high 11. Sundial, obelisk, gnomon, or gazing ball2 2 PU each Minimum 3 feet high 12. Fountain 2 3 PU each Minimum 3 feet high 13. Bench or chair 2 0.5 PU/lineal foot 14. Raised planting bed constructed of 0.5 PU/lineal foot of Minimum 1 foot high, brick,2stone or similar material except greatest dimension minimum 1 foot wide in CMU least interior dimension 15. Water feature incorporating i 2 2 per 50 square feet None stormwater detention 1. Existing vegetation that is retained has the same plant unit value as planted vegetation. 2. No more than twenty percent(20%)of the required plant units may be satisfied by items in lines 8 through 15. Staff Findings: The landscaping plans illustrate conformance with the requirements in 3.06.02 and the planting requirements in Table 3.06A. For clarity in determining the exact planting requirements (measured in "Plan Units"), Staff requested that the applicant provide a separate landscaping sheet (LS-01) below, which depicts in color each of the three planting areas (Buffer, Off-Street, and Setback). The plan provides landscaping that far DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 38 of 57 208 exceeds the requirements of the WDO. At Staff's request the applicant enhanced the landscaping buffers and plantings along the both frontages. A'double layer' of street tree plantings are provided and the depth of the landscaped buffers are approximately 30 feet and 45 feet in depth along both Evergreen and Stacy Allison Way, respectively. ANT asNeuuaE STACY ALL1SON WAN row LS 02 LS 03.. ( t� U S-D5 U 07 LS-06 I LS- 1" r i..u,n X...a Ti PRWPYUPEP r- X� w l 11 R(UTF'L IxANMB6RPPAREp PLIMT UNI a � � �.. y a.,' l Y ; u a I N$P.T UNIT NEQUTAEMEMTli n i ....� K - w EWfz�EGif#HEJ'J dY47 II I�nFl%?�n11: ra w Landscaping Sheet 01 (LS-01) C. Parking area landscape island standards: Landscape islands or peninsulas shall cap each aisle end to protect parked vehicles from moving vehicles, emphasize vehicular circulation patterns, and shade vehicles and pedestrians. Structured parking is exempted. 1. Each south, southwest, and west island or peninsula cap of a parking aisle shall be minimum 84 square feet within back of curbing, narrowest dimension 6 feet within back of curbing, and contain a tree. 2. Remaining islands and peninsulas shall be minimum 28 square feet within back of curbing and narrowest 2 feet within back of curbing, except where subsection 3 below supersedes. 3.There shall be no more than 10 consecutive parking spaces in a parking aisle without a mid-aisle landscape island or peninsula. For consecutive parking spaces that include one or more accessible/ADA spaces and their aisles,the maximum shall be 9 consecutive parking spaces. Mid- aisle landscape islands or peninsulas shall be to the same standards as subsection 1 above. 4.At drive aisle crossings of walkways and wide walkways that respectively Sections 3.04.06D and 3.05.02N describe, each south, southwest, and west side shall have a landscape island or peninsula to the same standards as subsection 1 above. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 39 of 57 209 Staff Finding: The plans indicate parking lot landscape islands that meet all of the requirements of this section in terms of number, size, and dimension. Importantly, during their review of the preliminary stormwater plans for this site, the City's Public Works Department raised concerns about the long-term viability of the public storm facility to the west of Stacy Allison Way. This facility was originally sized over 30 years ago to accommodate development activity along Stacy Allison Way (including this property) however, since that time, the stormwater requirements relating to retention, quality and treatment have become much more stringent. With new, more extensive requirements being placed on the City DEQ related to our stormwater treatment —the City Engineer has requested that additional on-site storm detention areas be included on this property. While there are no immediate issues related to accepting the stormwater from this particular site, the City Engineer has expressed concerns about the compounding impacts of future developments in this area. In an effort to minimize the impacts on the site plan and minimizing the costs to the developer. Staff is recommending Condition of Approval 12 that requires at least 50% of the parking landscape islands to be modified to incorporate rain gardens or similar storm water management systems. 3.06.05 Screening A.Screening between zones and uses shall comply with Table 3.06D. Screening Requirements Table 3.06D N = No screening required F=Sight-obscuring fence required W=Architectural wall required D=Architectural wall, fence, or hedge may be required in the Design Review process Adjacent properties—zone or use that receives the benefit of a N screening no c a' a; = ao c � v N aJ o a1 a1 aJ N fa n T ._ 3 N N N - > ø E E ° •L +• P a1 Property being Developed— c Z z > s s must provide screening if no Z a, D c ,M " 3 comparable screening exists on c ° c N 2 8a Q M 3 'a E Y abutting protected property o O3 u a a in -3a o u so 5. CG or MUV zone WZ D D D D D W2 W2 D w2 DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 40 of 57 210 1. Screening is only required from the view of abutting streets, parking lots, and residentially zoned property. Storage shall not exceed the height of the screening. 2. Six to seven feet in height 3. Six to nine feet in height 4. Abutting streets must also be screened. 5. Screening is required abutting multiple-family dwellings, commercial or industrial usesonly. 6. In industrial zones, screening is required only where the refuse collection facility is in a yard abutting a public street, parking lot, or residentially zoned property. 7. Child care facility for 12 or fewer children,group home for five or fewer persons. 8. Child care facility for 13 or more children,group home for six or more persons. General notes: 9. Screening is subject to height limitations for Vision Clearance Areas(Section 3.03.06) and adjacent to streets(Section 2.01.02). 10. No screening is required where a building wall abuts a property line. 11. Where a wall is required and is located more than two feet from the property line, the yard areas on the exterior of the wall shall be landscaped to a density of one plant unit per 20 square feet. Staff Findings: The proposal is a permitted use. It is for a new retail grocery store within the Commercial General zone. Most of the adjacent properties are also within the Commercial General zone and therefore no perimeter screening on the majority of the perimeter. However, a portion of the southern property line abuts a three story multi-family development with RMN (Medium Residential Nodal) zoning. For these uses,Table 3.06D provides the Planning Commission the option of determining the appropriate screening. The options listed are, "Architectural wall,fence, or hedge may be required in the Design Review process". Presently, the property line between the apartment property and the proposed grocery store includes a six-foot CMU wall with a solid row of mature trees approximately 30 feet in height. rM; 7� iininn � DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 41 of 57 211 The Applicant is proposing, and Staff concurs to leave this wall and landscaping in place since it meets the screen wall height and texture/pattern requirements of WDO Table 3.06D and section 3.06.06B.7. While it doesn't meet some of the specific architectural requirements (horizontal and vertical articulation), replacing the wall with a similar wall that meets these articulation requirements would result in an almost identical wall in appearance and be a bothersome and intrusive process to the existing Cascade Meadows Apartments residents. The Applicant proposes to clean and paint the wall to meet sections 3.06.06B.5 and 6. B.All parking areas, except those for single-family dwellings and dwellings other than multiple- family, abutting a street shall provide a 42-inch (3.5-foot)vertical visual screen from the abutting street grade.Acceptable design techniques to provide the screening include plant materials, berms, architectural walls, and depressed grade for the parking area.All screening shall comply with the clear vision standards of this ordinance(Section 3.03.06). Staff Findings: As outlined in the Landscaping Section above, the plans include an enhanced buffer with landscaping in excess of the requirements of the WDO. This includes double-rows of trees as well dense shrubs and groundcover which will provide screening for parking spaces along both streets. 3.07 Architectural Design 3.07.01 Applicability of Architectural Design Standards and Guidelines A. For a Type I review, the criteria of this Section shall be read as"shall"and shall be applied as standards. For a Type II or III review,the criteria of this Section shall be read as"should"and shall be applied as guidelines. 3.07.06 Standards for Non-Residential Structures in Residential, Commercial and Public/Semi Public Zones A.The following design guidelines shall be applicable to all non-residential structures and buildings in the RS, RSN, R1S, RM, RMN, CO, CG, and P/SP zones. B.Architectural Design Guidelines 1. Mass and Bulk Articulation Guidelines a. Building facades visible from streets and public parking areas should be articulated, in order to avoid the appearance of box-like structures with unbroken wall surfaces. b.The appearance of exterior walls should be enhanced by incorporating three-dimensional design features, including the following: (1) Public doorways or passage ways through the building (2)Wall offsets or projections (3)Variation in building materials or textures (4)Arcades,awnings, canopies or porches 2. Materials and Texture Guidelines DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 42 of 57 212 a. Building exteriors should exhibit finishes and textures that reduce the visual monotony of bulky structures and large structural spaces. Building exteriors should enhance visual interest of wall surfaces and harmonize with the structural design. b.The appearance of exterior surfaces should be enhanced by incorporating the following: (1)At least 30%of the wall surface abutting a street should be glass. (2)All walls visible from a street or public parking area should be surfaced with wood, brick, stone, designer block, or stucco, or with siding that has the appearance of wood lap siding. (3)The use of plain concrete, plain concrete block, corrugated metal, plywood, T-111 and sheet composite siding as exterior finish materials for walls visible from a street or parking area should be avoided. (4)The color of at least 90 percent of the wall, roof and awning surface visible from a street or public parking area should be an "earth tone"color containing 10 parts, or more of brown or a "tinted"color, containing 10 parts or more white. (5) Fluorescent, "day-glo,"or any similar bright color shall not be used on the building exterior. 3. Multi-Planed Roof Guidelines a.The roof line at the top of a structure should establish a distinctive top to the building. b.The roof line should not be flat or hold the same roof line over extended distances. Rather, the roof line should incorporate variations, such as: (1)Offsets or jogs in the plane of the roof; (2)Changes in the height of the exterior wall for flat roof buildings,including parapet walls with variations in elevation or cornices 4. Roof-Mounted Equipment Guidelines All roof-mounted equipment, except solar collectors, should be screened from view by: a. Locating roof-mounted equipment below the highest vertical element of the building, or b. Screening roof-mounted equipment using materials of the same character as the structure's basic materials 5. Weather Protection Guidelines All building faces abutting a street or a public parking area should provide weather protection for pedestrians. Features to provide this protection should include: a. A continuous walkway at least eight feet wide along the face of the building utilizing a roof overhang, arcade, awnings or canopies b. Awnings and canopies that incorporate the following design features: (1)Angled or curved surfaces facing a street or parking area (2)A covering of fabric, or matte finish vinyl (3)A constant color and pattern scheme for all buildings within the same development (4) No internal back lighting 6.Solar Access Protection Obstruction of existing solar collectors on abutting properties by site development should be minimized. C. Building Location Guidelines 1. Within the prescribed setbacks, building location and orientation should complement abutting uses and development patterns. 2.The maximum setback from each street should/shall be 80 feet. Minimum 80 percent of the width of a street-facing facade should/shall meet the setback maximum. Staff Finding: DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 43 of 57 213 The proposal is a Type III review therefore the applicable criteria are guidelines. All roof mounted equipment is proposed to be screened with materials of the same character as the structure. elevation drawings demonstrate conformance with the provisions. While the proposed building follows many of these guidelines, it does not strictly adhere to all of them. The exterior building walls are proposed as composite precast sandwich wall panels. The exterior of the panels is textured with four-inch on center horizontal scores along the bottom, a random vertical scoring at the dark colored pilasters and an exposed aggregate finish throughout the remainder of the panels. The panels will be painted in earthtones as indicated on the Exterior Building Elevations. The proposed design does has horizontal rooftop articulation on the west (front) and south facades but not as much on the north or east (rear) walls. and the building (as with all WinCo's) has minimal glazing. According the applicant, "the addition of horizontal offsets would not benefit the project, and we believe that faux architectural elements do not add to the overall architectural quality or aesthetics of the building. The building offers an attractive, inviting main entry point. The remainder of the design mimics the same quality of materials and is designed with functionality and material efficiency in mind." Staff finds the minimalist and generic architecture acceptable and consistent with the guidelines of the Code, particularly considering the proposed use (big box/discount grocery) and styles of similar buildings in the vicinity. Its worth noting that, early in the review process, the applicant involved staff in discussions and reviews of different architectural options— particularly for the entry feature. Staff's comments were considered and incorporated into the final plans submitted. 3.10 Signs 3.10.05 Sign Permit Required A. A sign permit is required to erect, replace, construct, relocate, or alter a sign, unless such sign is exempt under Section 3.10.07.To initiate consideration of a sign permit, a complete City application, accompanying information,and a filing fee must be submitted to the Director.The Director shall issue a sign permit if the applicant demonstrates compliance with all provisions of Section 3.10. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 44 of 57 214 Staff Findings: Because new signage is reviewed separately through the Sign Permit process, staff adds Condition of Approval 4 to apply for and obtain approved Sign Permits for any new signage. However, it should be noted that the applicant, as part of this Design Review application, is requesting a variance to exceed the maximum square footage of a wall sign. That application and Staff's findings are found later in this report. 3.11 Lighting 3.11.02 Standards A. Full cut-off: All exterior lighting shall be full cut-off or fully shielded. Figure 3.11A illustrates examples of both unacceptable and acceptable fixtures. B. Heights: Mounting height limits as measured to light fixture underside shall be: 1.Wall:8 feet above finished grade within 5 feet. a. Within a commercial or industrial zoning district and above a loading bay, berth, or dock, the height limit shall instead be 14.5 feet above vehicular grade. b. For all developments and uses,ground floor wall-mounted fixtures are exempt if: (1) placed under a canopy,fixed awning, roof overhang, secondary roof, or building recess; (2)a ground floor canopy or fixed awning is minimum 96 square feet and 8 feet narrowest dimension; (3)a roof overhang or secondary roof is minimum 72 square feet and 8 feet narrowest dimension; (4)a building recess is minimum 72 square feet and 8 narrowest dimension; (5)an adjacent combination of building recess and, projecting from the main wall plane, either(a)a ground floor canopy or fixed awning or(b) a roof overhang or secondary roof,total minimum 72 square feet and 8 narrowest dimension; (6)a ground floor canopy,fixed awning, roof overhang, secondary roof, or building recess is with maximum 14 feet height clearance above grade; and (7)the fixture is mounted no lower than at the same level as the underside of the ground floor canopy or fixed awning or within and flush with the building recess ceiling. 2. Poles within parking areas: 14.5 feet above vehicular grade within 5 feet of any parking or vehicular circulation area or its curbing. Parking area poles within 24 feet of ROW, greenways, or off-street public bicycle/pedestrian facilities, shall have the public-facing perimeter of the fixture underside with housing or a shield minimum 6 inches high. 3. Other poles: 10 feet above finished grade. Includes poles along walkways,wide walkways, and off-street bicycle/pedestrian facilities where they do not pass through or along parking areas. Within an industrial zoning district operations or storage yard, minimum 20 feet from a lot line the height limit shall instead rise to 20 feet. C. Hue/color temperature: Excepting industrial development, if a fixture uses light emitting diode (LED)technology, it shall emit a warm,yellowish white light instead of cool, bluish white light. A color temperature within the range of 2,700 to 4,000 degrees Kelvin presumptively meets the requirement. D. Property line: Lighting shall not shine or reflect onto(1) ROW, (2)greenways, (3) off-street public bicycle/pedestrian corridors, or(4)adjacent residentially zoned property. Pole-mounted fixtures DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 45 of 57 215 other than those in parking areas, and wall-mounted fixtures, that abut any of(1)-(3) are exempt if they are sited within 20 feet of any of(1)-(3), and conform to subsection B.1 or 3 above. Staff Finding: A photometric study was provided with the plans all exterior lighting is via full cut-off (shielded) building wall and pole mounted fixtures. The wall mounted fixtures are proposed to meet the height requirements of WDO3.11.02B.1. However, the applicant is requesting a variance to the height of the parking lot lighting this is described in detail under the variance section 4.01 Decision-Making Procedures 4.01.07 Consolidated Applications An applicant may request, in writing, to consolidate applications needed for a single development project. Under a consolidated review, all applications shall be processed following the procedures applicable for the highest type decision requested. It is the express policy of the City that development review not be segmented into discrete parts in a manner that precludes a comprehensive review of the entire development and its cumulative impacts. Staff Finding: The application package includes a Type III Design Review,Type III Street Adjustment, Type I Property Line Adjustment and Type III Variances. Per 4.01.07, they have been consolidated into a single package for review at the Type III level. 4.01.16 Request of Continuance and to Keep the Record Open Staff Finding: The Planning Commission has reviewed all the evidence, testimony, and argument in the record, including the April 21, 2026, letter submitted on behalf of Protect Our Valley Alliance and the April 23, 2026, final argument submitted on behalf of the applicant. The Planning Commission disagrees with the objections stated in the April 21 letter and hereby finds that the post-hearing process has not denied any substantial right provided by statute to Protect Our Valley Alliance and that the applicant has not submitted evidence in violation of applicable statute. 5.01.01 Property Line Adjustment: Consolidation of Lots A. Purpose: The purpose of this review is to ensure that adjustments to property lines or the consolidation of existing lots and parcels, complies with the standards of this ordinance (Section 2),and State Statutes(ORS Chapters 92 and 209). Property line adjustments and consolidation of lots are allowed in all zones. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 46 of 57 216 B. Criteria: 1. Lot area,depth,width,frontage, building setbacks,vehicular access and lot coverage comply with the standards of this ordinance(Sections 2 and 3); 2. Existing easements are accurately reflected; 3. Existing land use and development on the subject property comply with the requirements of prior land use actions; and 4. Buildings and structures abutting the adjusted property lines comply with State building codes and with respect to current occupancy. 5. Property line adjustments are surveyed and monumented to the requirements set forth in State statutes(ORS Chapters 92 and 209) and recorded by the County Surveyor. C. Procedure:The Director shall review and approve the application when it is found that it meets this Ordinance and the State Building Codes. D. Building permit application: A developer may apply for building permit or permits for the adjusted or consolidated property upon completion of: (1) recordation with the County of the final plat, including public easements and any separate conveyance documents, (2) submittal to both the Director and the Public Works Department no later than through building permit application of electronic copies of required documents per Section 2.01.05, unless regarding as- builts specifically the Public Works Director in writing defers to a specific set of later circumstances or date. This section does not abrogate additional requirements elsewhere in the WDO or in land use conditions of approval necessary for a developer to meet before building permit application. Staff Finding: The proposed property line adjustment meets all of the lot criteria of this Section (lot area, depth, width, frontage, etc.). The site is vacant so there are no setback or lot coverage considerations. However, Staff is including Public Works Condition of Approval 3 requiring recordation of easements and right-of-way in accordance with the requirements of the Marion County Surveyor. To meet subsection B5, staff added Condition of Approval 15 to record the property line adjustment in a manner acceptable to the Marion County Surveyor. 5.03 Type III (Quasi-Judicial) Decisions 5.03.02 Design Review,Type III B.Type III Design Review is required for the following: 5. For sites with existing buildings in the CO,CG, MUV,DDC, NNC, IP, IL,and SWIR zones;expansions or new buildings that increase lot coverage by more 25%. Staff Finding: The proposal is for a new non-residential structure on a vacant lot in the CG zone. Therefore, the Design Review is a Type III. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 47 of 57 217 5.03.03 Adjustment to Street Improvement Requirements("Street Adjustment") Same as Section 5.02.04 except that land use review is Type Ill. 5.02.04 Adjustment to Street Improvement Requirements("Street Adjustment") A. Purpose:The purpose of a Type II Street Adjustment is to allow deviation from the street standards required by Section 3.01 for the functional classification of streets identified in the Woodburn Transportation System Plan.The Street Adjustment review process provides a mechanism by which the regulations in the WDO may be adjusted if the proposed development continues to meet the intended purposes of Section 3.01. Street Adjustment reviews provide discretionary flexibility for unusual situations.They also allow for alternative ways to meet the purposes of Section 3.01.They do not serve to except or exempt from or to lessen or lower minimum standards for ROW improvements,with exceptions of subsections B& H.A Street Adjustment is for providing customized public improvements that substitutes for what standards require,while a Variance is for excepting or exempting from, lessening, or lowering standards,with exceptions of subsections B& H.A Street Adjustment for a development reviewed as a Type I or II application shall be considered as a Type II application,while development reviewed as a Type Ill application shall be considered a Type Ill application. B.Applicability: Per the Purpose subsection above about improvements, and regarding ROW Street Adjustment may be used to narrow minimum width. Regarding alleys or off-street bicycle/pedestrian corridor or facility standards, see instead Zoning Adjustment. C. Criteria: 1.The estimated extent, on a quantitative basis, to which the rights-of-way and improvements will be used by persons served by the building or development, and whether the use is for safety or convenience; 2.The estimated level, on a quantitative basis, of rights-of-way and improvements needed to meet the estimated extent of use by persons served by the building or development; 3.The estimated impact, on a quantitative basis, of the building or development on the public infrastructure system of which the rights-of-way and improvements will be a part; 4.The estimated level, on a quantitative basis, of rights-of-way and improvements needed to mitigate the estimated impact on the public infrastructure system. 5.The application is not based primarily on convenience for a developer or reducing civil engineering or public improvements construction costs to a developer. 6.The application is not based primarily on the existence of adjacent or nearby nonconforming Boundary Street frontages. 7. Narrowing of ROW minimum width, if proposed, is not to a degree more than necessary to meet other criteria. In no case shall ROW total fewer than 35 feet,whether or not the total is allocated across centerline or to its side,except that this base requirement would not apply if subsection H below applies. 8.A Street Adjustment would provide a customized cross section alternative to the standard or standards and that meets the relevant purposes of Section 3.01, or the City reasonably can condition approval to achieve such. D. Minimum Standards:To ensure a safe and functional street with capacity to meet current demands and to ensure safety for vehicles, bicyclists and pedestrians, as well as other forms of non- vehicular traffic,the minimum standards for rights-of-way and improvements for Boundary and Connecting Streets per Sections 3.01.03C& D continue to apply. Exempting from or lessening or lowering those standards shall require a Variance. Deviation from applicable public works DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 48 of 57 218 construction code specifications would be separate from the WDO through process that the Public Works Department might establish. E. Factors:Street Adjustment applications,where and if approved, shall have conditions that customize improvements and secure accommodations for persons walking and cycling, not only driving,that meet the purposes of Section 3.01.The City may through approval with conditions require wider additional ROW dedication along the part or the whole of an extent of the subject frontage to accommodate either adjusted improvements or improvements that vary from standards. F. Bicycle/pedestrian facility: If and where a Street Adjustment application requests to substitute or omit one or more required bicycle facilities, such as bicycle lanes, and the City approves the application,then the following should apply: For each substitute or omitted facility,the developer would construct a minimum width 8 feet bicycle/pedestrian facility on the same side of street centerline as the substituted or omitted facility.The City may condition wider. G. Landscape strip: If and where a Street Adjustment application requests to adjust one or more required landscape strips from between curb and sidewalk, and the City approves the application, then the list below should apply.This subsection is not applicable to bridge/culvert crossing. 1.Sidewalk: Construction of sidewalk minimum width 8 feet on the same side of street centerline as the adjusted landscape strip.The City may condition wider. 2. Planting corridor: For each landscape strip that is relocated, delineation and establishment of a street tree planting corridor along the back of sidewalk in such a way as to allow newly planted trees to not conflict with any required streetside PUE to the extent that the Public Works Department Engineering Division in writing defines what constitutes a conflict.To give enough room for root growth,the corridor minimum width would be either 6 feet where along open yard or 7 ft where it would be flush with a building foundation. This would include installation of root barriers between the trees and street centerline to public works construction code specification. 3. ROW:Where necessary to meet the above standards, dedication of additional ROW even if the additional is more than the minimum additional dedication that Section 3.01 requires. 4. Planting in ROW required:Street trees would not be planted in the yard outside ROW. H. If the applicable Boundary Street minimums are the lesser minimums for residential development of 4 or fewer dwellings and where no land division is applicable, as Section 3.01.03C.2 allows, then allowed adjustment is: 1. ROW: Relating to Section 3.01.03C.2a,to lower ROW minimum dedication either(a)from a number greater than 5 feet to no fewer than 5 feet or(b)from a number equal to or fewer than 5 feet to no dedication. Greater deviation requires Variance. 2. PUE, streetside: Relating to Section 3.01.03C.2b,to lower streetside PUE minimum dedication to no fewer than 3 feet. Greater deviation requires Variance. This subsection is not relevant to deviation from improvements. I. Plan review:An applicant shall submit among other administratively required application materials scaled drawings, including plan and cross section views, of proposed street improvement widths, extents, and details as well as existing conditions and proposed development site plans that include property and easement lines and physical features some distance beyond the boundaries of the subject property for fuller context. Staff Finding: DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 49 of 57 219 Stacy Allison Way is unique in that the City Council previously approved a modified 'preferred' cross-section for this roadway when the apartments (Allison Way apartments) just south of this proposal were previously approved. Therefore, when the current applicant (WinCo) initially discussed developing this site, City Staff directed them to use the 'modified' cross-section. The classification of Stacy Allison Way is Service Collector with a specific cross-section that is required per the City's TSP. Unfortunately, the only way to use a cross-section that doesn't align with the TSP (even if requested to do so by Staff) is through the Street Exception process. Needless to say,staff strongly supports the proposed modified cross section and recommends its approval. The application provided a detailed description of the request, as well as the differences between the TSP cross-section and modified one: yn °' it ��p ,� �v 1 _... f V, „„_,,,,M�'",,,,,,,,,,, t w „_,,,,,,SIP„P_„ ,a s�' �% "'. e`, Fiigure 1—C t of Woodburn Service Collector "We are requesting to maintain the current street section for Stacy Allison Way across the entirety of the project frontage. This request is consistent with guidance from City Engineering staff. The project proposes mitigating frontage improvements, including a 5-foot ROW dedication, removal and replacement of the existing sidewalk with a new 6-foot detached sidewalk, and a 5.5 foot landscape strip located between the detached sidewalk and the existing 6-foot bike lane. The proposed improvements have been designed to meet the City's current Service CollectorStandard to the maximum extent practicable and improve pedestrian safety through the installation of a detached sidewalk, while maintaining the alignment of Stacy Allison Way and preserving the 6-foot bike lane and underground utilities along the east side of the road." DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 50 of 57 220 p ......... ......... ... .... ... 94 U6 .... ... ... ... ... ....., pFUICA110N rc 06 6W EW AN9SCAPIF 611 LAME tAAC IANF ,CMiCa NAN LANE iPnAlWIANC U fpnE LANp5CAG( Hp(�p5EU"""- I ^t IoEwnLx I I I I STACY.ALLISON WAY{A.A) Figure 2—Stacy Allison Way Proposed Improvements Proposed Stacey Allison Way cross-section "In summary, we are proposing a 0.5 foot reduction of the planter strip as a reasonable deviation from the City's current Service Collector standard. This deviation will maintain the current constructed section of Stacy Allison Way, including the 6-foot northbound bike lane, which is 1 foot wider than the City's current Service Collector standard. It is our belief that the combination of the existing 6-foot bike lane, 5-foot ROW dedication, new 5.5 foot planter strip, and a 6-foot detached sidewalk provides safety enhancements for pedestrians, cyclists, and vehicles along WinCo's frontage, while limiting impacts to the existing stormwater, water, power, and natural gas utility infrastructure." "Staff recommends approval of the Street Adjustment request. 5.03.12 Variance A. Purpose: The purpose of this Type III Variance is to allow use of a property in a way that would otherwise be prohibited by this Ordinance. Uses not allowed in a particular zone are not subject to the variance process. Standards set by statute relating to siting of manufactured homes on individual lots; siding and roof of manufactured homes; and manufactured home and dwelling park improvements are non-variable. B. Criteria: A variance may be granted to allow a deviation from development standard of this ordinance where the following criteria are met: 1.Strict adherence to the standards of this ordinance is not possible or imposes an excessive burden on the property owner, and 2.Variance to the standards will not unreasonably impact existing or potential uses or development on the subject property or adjacent properties. C. Factors to Consider: A determination of whether the criteria are satisfied involves balancing competing and conflicting interests.The factors that are listed below are not criteria and are not intended to be an exclusive list and are used as a guide in determining whether the criteria are met. 1.The variance is necessary to prevent unnecessary hardship relating to the land or structure, which would cause the property to be unbuildable by application of this Ordinance. Factors to consider in determining whether hardship exists, include: DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 51 of 57 221 a. Physical circumstances over which the applicant has no control related to the piece of property involved that distinguish it from other land in the zone, including but not limited to, lot size, shape, and topography. b. Whether reasonable use similar to other properties can be made of the property without the variance. c. Whether the hardship was created by the person requesting the variance. 2. Development consistent with the request will not be materially injurious to adjacent properties. Factors to be considered in determining whether development consistent with the variance materially injurious include, but are not limited to: a. Physical impacts such development will have because of the variance, such as visual, noise, traffic and drainage, erosion and landslide hazards. b. Incremental impacts occurring as a result of the proposed variance. 3. Existing physical and natural systems, such as but not limited to traffic, drainage, dramatic land forms or parks will not be adversely affected because of the variance. 4.Whether the variance is the minimum deviation necessary to make reasonable economic use of the property; 5.Whether the variance conflicts with the Woodburn Comprehensive Plan. 6. If and where a variance includes a request to vary from minimum public improvements per Section 3.01,from Section 5.02.04E about Street Adjustment factors,those factors are applicable as Variance additional factors. Staff Findings: The applicant submitted three Variance applications: Variance Request 1: Number of Electric Vehicle ("EV") parking spaces Per WDO Table 3.05E, for commercial developments at least 5% of the total number of parking stalls must be allocated for EV charging with a minimum Level 2 charger. This means that 17 spaces with chargers are required for the proposed WinCo. The applicant asserts that this is an excessive number and creates an unnecessary burden. They are proposing instead to provide eight spaces with Tesla's Level 3 superchargers. Quoting from their application narrative: "Installation of eight Level 3 charges in lieu of 17 Level 2 chargers provides more charging power, would not unreasonably impact the subject property or adjacent properties and should be considered an upgrade to the WDO EV parking requirement. Tesla, one of the nation's largest EV charging manufacturers and providers, has recommended eight Level 3 charging spaces for this site and has described and justified this recommendation in the attached letter. If EV charging demand increases, additional stalls would be added later as warranted. Level 3 charging provides up to two hundred miles of range in 15 minutes vs. 7-10 miles per 15 minutes of charge time with Level 2 chargers (20x faster charging)." (p. 45) DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 52 of 57 222 At the City's request,the applicant provided a letter from the manufacturer(Tesla) outlining their anticipated EV charging needs for this site (Attachment 106) . They agree that eight Level 3 Superchargers are adequate and state that their technology can "serve more vehicles with fewer stalls". EV charging is still a relatively new and evolving technology. The EV parking provisions were adopted as part of the City's WDO just four years ago. Staff believes that it's important that the Code be able to provide flexibility to allow for reasonable modifications to the code in response to shifting market and technological forces. Staff gives broad deference to the manufacturer's recommendations on the number of EV stations that will be required. It's reasonable to assume that the manufacturer's goal would be provide as many EV stations as are necessary to serve their customers. Based on the type of chargers proposed, and the use being considered, Staff agrees that eight Level 3 Superchargers will adequately address the needs of the public. It is also fair to note that the WDO's metric for measuring the required number of EV stalls is based on the zoning district; all "non-residential development within commercial zoning districts". In essence, this means that the required number of EV stalls is based on the parking requirements of a zone as opposed to the EV charging needs for an individual use. This fails to take into account that different uses may have different needs for EV chargers. For example, an office or warehouse may have more employees staying in their spaces for a longer period; whereas a fast food restaurant or florist has much faster turnover and would likely have less need for EV chargers. Yet the WDO has the same minimum requirements for both. It also doesn't consider that different chargers (speed) impact the number of spaces required. Level 3 chargers charge much faster than Level 2 chargers, so it is reasonable to assume that there will be more turnover of these spaces and the need for less. The request would have no negative impact on adjacent properties and in any case, the applicant can always add to the number of EV chargers in the future. In fact, it would be financially advantageous for them (Tesla) to do so if demand increases. V Staff recommends approval of Variance #1: EV parking space variance. Variance Request 2: Wall signage area DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 53 of 57 223 The applicable sign requirements are found in WDO Table 3.10.10B. For this proposal,the Code allows wall signage on the front of the building to be up to 300 SF in area. The applicant is requesting that this be increased by 143 SF which allow them to have wall signage on the front of their building that would be 453 SF in area. Their elevations depict the front elevation with the proposed increased signage: FRONT ELEVATION The Applicant submitted the following justification for this variance request: "Strict adherence to WDO Table 3.10.108 and section 3.10 would allow 300 square feet of signage on the front and left(facing Center St.) building elevations because those facades are more than 200 feet from the public right-of-way. It would allow 200 square feet of signage on the rear elevation. The Applicant is meeting this standard on the left and rear elevations but is requesting a variance to increase the front elevation signage by 153 square feet to 453 square feet to ensure readability from both Stacey Allison Way and Interstate 5. The front of the proposed building is approximately 380 feet from the center of Stacey Allison, 560- feet from the center of northbound 1-5 and 660 feet from the center of southbound 1-5. Strict compliance with the front elevation signage limit imposes an excessive burden on the Applicant because it forces signage to be reduced to the point that it will not be legible from 1-5 and likely even difficult to identify from Stacey Allison for some customers. The proposed increase in signage area would not unreasonably impact the subject property or adjacent properties. The front of the building and associated signage face directly toward both Stacey Allison Way and 1-5. It will be visible only from those public roadways and will not be visible from any neighboring residential properties. The signage is proposed in just two locations of the front elevation as shown on the Front Elevation drawing. The largest letters of the primary, 'WinCo Foods' sign are proposed as 66-inches in height. While this may seem large, the general rule of thumb for optimal readability is 1-inch of letter height for every 10- feet of distance. This means that letters need to be 38-inches high at minimum to DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 54 of 57 224 ensure recognition from Stacey Allison and 66-inches in height to be legible from southbound 1-5. The proposed 66-inch-high letters ensure the building signage can be read from 1-5 allowing customers and passersby to quickly and safely identify and locate the building. This benefits both the development and surrounding community."(Pg. 46) There are several unique circumstances specific to this property and use that need to be discussed. It's true that this property is located along 1-5 and therefore the signage (visibility) requirements for uses in this area may be different from those of rest of the community. However, the City WDO specifically makes an accommodation (exception) for uses along 1-5. The sign provisions of the WDO include an overlay ("Freeway Overlay") that permits users in this area (including WinCo) to have pole signs that are both larger in area and taller in height that the rest of the City. Specifically, WinCo will be permitted a pole sign that is 45 feet tall with a maximum sign area of 300 feet. In all other locations in the City, WinCo would be limited to a 20 foot high pole sign that is 100 SF in area. Staff believes that the "Freeway Overlay" provisions of the WDO serve to adequately address the unique locational dynamics of this site. r � 1iii 3- � w � r m Figure 3.10L — Freeway Overlay It's also important to note that other similar properties in the area have operated successfully without the need for a variance from the sign code requirements. The WalMart supercenter along Stacey Allison is operating under the same sign code provisions that will be applied to WinCo and it did not receive any variances. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 55 of 57 225 Allowing larger signage would be unfair to other properties in the area, and would have a deleterious effect on the aesthetics of the area, hence the need for detailed signage requirements in the first place. X Based on the above findings, Staff recommends denial of Variance #2: to increase the allowable wall signage. Variance Request#3: Parking Light pole height increase Per WDO 3.11.02, parking area light poles are restricted to 14.5 feet in height. During the pre-application conference, the applicant indicated that they wanted to install parking lot lighting poles that were 24.5 feet in height. Staff indicated that we would be amenable to allowing some of the lighting to exceed the code maximum, but that under no circumstances should the lighting along the south property (adjacent to the apartments) exceed the code. The applicant modified plans to include this restriction; as described in their justification for the variance request: "Strict adherence to WDO 3.11.02 would require the Applicant to restrict parking area light poles to 14.5 feet above grade. Doing so imposes an excessive burden because it would necessitate nearly double the number of site lighting poles and fixtures. The additional poles would encroach into parking stalls necessary to meet customer parking demand. The Applicant proposes 24.5-foot-tall light fixtures (to underside of fixture) throughout the main parking area west (in front of) the building. Shorter poles meeting the 14.5 foot restriction are proposed in the parking area southwest of the building, adjacent to the Cascade Meadow Apartments."(p. 46) Several variances to the City's parking lot lighting height requirements have been granted since these code provisions were adopted three years ago. In fact, Staff has identified this Section of the Code as one that the City should consider modifying to allow for more flexibility to developers. Staff contends that lower light poles near residential properties can be an appropriate mitigation and that allowing higher poles within a large parking lot has few, if any negative impacts. In fact, requiring lower lights, means more light poles need to be installed, resulting in higher costs and more potential conflicts for little benefit. V Staff concurs with the applicants arguments and, with the limitations on the pole heights near the apartments as shown in the plans, recommends approval of Variance #3: Parking light pole height. DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 56 of 57 226 DR 25-14, PLA 25-04,SA 26-01&VAR 25-06 WinCo Staff Report Attachment 103 Page 57 of 57 227 Andrew Mulkey Attorney at Law PO Box 66562, Portland, OR 97290 • (503) 334-9899 • andrew@mulkeylegal.com May 11, 2026 Via Email Chris Kerr, Community Development Director 270 Montgomery Street Woodburn, OR 97071 Chris.Kerr@ci.woodburn.or.us Re: Notice of Intent to Appeal DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, VAR 25-06 Proposed WinCo Foods Grocery Store Tax Lots 052W12C002100 and 052W12C002200 Dear Director Kerr: This letter provides notice of an appeal of the planning commission's recent decision to approve the WinCo Foods Grocery Store application. The information required by WDO 4.02.01 is provided below. Department File Number: DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, VAR 25-06 Appellant Name, Mailing Address, and Phone Number: Andrew Mulkey obo POVA and members: PO Box 66562, Portland OR, 97290; (503) 334-9899 Protect Our Valley Alliance (POVA) PO Box 66562, Portland OR, 97290; (503) 334-9899 Statement of standing: Appellant Mulkey on behalf of POVA submitted comment letters during the proceedings before the planning commission. See Attached. Notice of Appeal - Woodburn WinCo 1 of 5 228 Appellant POVA submitted comments through its attorney during the proceedings before the planning commission. See Attached. Statement of Grounds for Appeal: The following contains the grounds for appeal as well as the grounds for appeals/errors raised in the attached comment letters. Appellants incorporate those letters and attachments by reference. Appellants also include as grounds for appeal, any issue raised by commenters during the prior hearings on this matter and incorporate those recordings by reference. In addition to the issues raised in the attached letters and testimony incorporated by reference, appellants provide the following additional grounds for appeal. First, the planning commission erred by failing to extend the open record period as requested by PVOA in its April 21, 2026 objection letter. For the reasons explained in the objection letter, that error requires the City Council to allow appellants the opportunity to respond to the objected material by submitting additional evidence. PVOA's objection letter explained that the applicant submitted evidence during the response period (or second open record period) that was directed at responding to evidence submitted by opponents prior to the hearing. Pursuant to ORS 197.797, the applicant's evidence needed to have been submitted during the first open record period. By submitting that evidence late, the applicant deprived participants of their statutory right to respond during the response open record period. The planning commission erred when it determined that it was not required to strike the applicant's evidence or reopen the record to allow PVOA and other members of the public the opportunity to respond. To that end, appellants have attached a response to the applicant's GVC Technical Memo prepared by Greenlight Engineering. Next, the findings adopted by the planning commission are inadequate and fail to address the issues raised by appellants and others. See Heiller v. Josephine County, 23 Or LUBA 551, 556 (1992). Specifically, findings for 2.05.01 fail to address issues raised in the March 12, 2026 Greenlight Engineering letter that the exceedance of the required trip budget fails to account for the remaining vacant commercial and industrial properties in the Interchange Management Area Overlay District. The decision fails to ensure that remaining vacant lands in the IMA—such Notice of Appeal - Woodburn WinCo 2 of 5 229 as other vacant commercial lands and industrial lands—"are protected from incompatible development generating excessive vehicle trips." In addition, the decision misconstrues the WDO 2.05.02(G) criteria that requires a development that exceeds the maximum peak hour vehicle trips to "contribute substantially to the economic objectives found in the Comprehensive Plan." The findings provided in the decision are simply inadequate. Heiller, 23 Or LUBA at 556. POVA addressed this issue in its comment letters attached. The decision fails to connect the proposal to the specific "economic objectives" of the comprehensive plan or demonstrate how the proposed development will "contribute substantially" to those economic objectives. The findings' general reference to the need for commercial land stated in the EOA or the fact that land on the east side of I-5 has been designated for commercial retail, fails to identify or address the "economic objectives" of the comprehensive plan, much less how that applicant's proposal contributes substantially to those objectives. Appellants and other commenters have argued that the decision and staff report misconstrue and misapply the requirements of the comprehensive plan. For that reason, the planning commission has misconstrued applicable law, and the findings in the planning commission's decision and staff report are inadequate. The findings also fail to address the impacts to the City's economic objectives that the project will have on remaining traffic allocation for currently vacant commercial and industrial land. The decision and findings fail to address the issues raised by appellants and others. Finally, the planning commission and planning staff are wrong to conclude that the TIA meets ODOT and City requirements pursuant to WDO 2.05.01/.02(D) and 3.04.05. Notably, "[a] TIA shall evaluate the transportation impacts projected of a development proposal, and where a development would fail to meet a transportation standard or would hinder public safety, [the TIA] shall list and describe mitigation to the satisfaction of the City." Opponents identified numerous instances in which the TIA failed to provide the information required to adequately determine the projected transportation impacts. Opponents also identified numerous instances in which (1) the development would fail to meet a Notice of Appeal - Woodburn WinCo 3 of 5 230 transportation standard or would hinder public safety, and/or (2) the applicant failed to demonstrate, due to inadequate analysis, that transportation and safety standards could be met. Notably, the planning commission's decision and staff report also failed to adequately respond to the issues raised by opponents in the context of the requirements in WDO 2.05.01/.02 and 3.04.05. The TIA addressed the ODOT and City intersection standards (including those found in 3.04.05) in its section 6, and Greenlight Engineering responded. Yet the planning commission did not address the inadequacies of the applicant's analysis in the context of the requirements of WDO 3.04.05 or propose mitigation measures required by WDO 3.04.05. Heiller, 23 Or LUBA at 556 (requiring decision maker to "identify the relevant approval standards," explain how the facts lead to a decision of compliance, and "address and respond to specific issues relevant to compliance with applicable approval standards that were raised in the proceedings below."). Greenlight has identified the following errors or inadequacies with the applicant's TIA. • Improper application of pass-by trip reductions; • Lack of queue analysis despite corridor conditions triggering such analysis under ODOT requirements; • Failure to substantiate that proposed mitigation measures will restore acceptable operations; • Incomplete documentation regarding pipeline developments and background growth assumptions; • Use of an opening year inconsistent with the application materials; and • Lack of substantial evidence demonstrating compliance with the Interchange Management Area (IMA) trip budgeting framework. To that end the record fails to demonstrate that: • OR 214 corridor operations will comply with applicable ODOT mobility standards; Notice of Appeal - Woodburn WinCo 4 of 5 231 • Queue spillback and storage issues have been adequately evaluated; • Proposed mitigation measures are feasible and effective; • The project complies with the IMA trip budgeting framework; and • Transportation impacts have been fully identified and mitigated concurrent with development. Without correcting those deficiencies, the applicant has failed to demonstrate that it complies with the requirements for identifying and mitigating traffic impacts in WDO 2.05.01 (Interchange Management Area Overlay District (also listed as WDO 2.05.02) and 3.04.05 (Transportation Impact Analysis). These include the requirements in WDO 2.05.01/.02(A) through (G) and 3.04.05(A) through (F). Respectfully, Andrew Mulkey (OSB No. 171237) PO Box 66562 Portland, OR 97290 (503) 334-9989 adrew@mulkeylegal.com On behalf of Protect Our Valley Alliance Notice of Appeal - Woodburn WinCo 5 of 5 232 / iiiI GREEN LIGHT ENGINEERING May 11, 2026 Andrew Mulkey Attorney at Law PO Box 66562 Portland, OR 97290 RE: Response to GVC Transportation Solutions March 19, 2026 Technical Memo— Proposed WinCo Foods Development Mr. Mulkey: Greenlight Engineering has reviewed the March 19, 2026 memorandum prepared by GVC Transportation Solutions ("GVC") responding to concerns previously raised regarding the Transportation Impact Analysis (TIA) for the proposed WinCo Foods development. The GVC memorandum does not resolve the principal concerns identified in March 12, 2026 review. Instead, the response largely relies on unsupported assertions, introduces new claims and calculations that do not appear elsewhere in the record, and continues to rely on assumptions that are inconsistent with accepted transportation engineering practice, ODOT guidance, and the Woodburn Development Ordinance (WDO). WDO 3.04.05(F) requires: "The methodology for a TIA shall be consistent with City standards...Vehicular level of service (LOS) and volume-to-capacity (V/C) ratio shall be as follows: 1. For a signalized and all-way stop-control intersection,the minimum LOS shall be either "E" or if pre-development already operating at lower LOS,then at no lower LOS. 2. For a signalized intersection,the minimum V/C ratio shall be either less than L0U regardless of LOS or if pre-development already operating at 1.00 or higher V/C,then at no higher V/C. 3. For an unsignalized intersection,the minimum V/C shall be 0.95 or lower for minimum the major movement through the intersection, or, if pre-development already operating at higher V/C,then at no higher V/C..." The WinCo TIA itself acknowledges that "OR 214/219 is a district highway which has a v/c target of 0.95," consistent with ODOT requirements. 13554 Rogers Road • Lake Oswego, OR 97035 WWW.grk II„iig.1 ..eng.ii„ir irii..! .g. air „ • 503.317.4559 233 Despite these standards, the GVC response does not adequately explain why multiple prior traffic studies identified operational deficiencies along the OR 214 corridor, while the WinCo TIA now concludes that the same intersections would operate acceptably under near-term conditions despite additional development traffic and no identified operational improvements sufficient to account for those differences. The GVC response also relies on the assumption that the City of Woodburn will address operational deficiencies at three intersections along Evergreen Road. However, the record does not contain substantial evidence demonstrating that any future improvements will restore those intersections to acceptable operating conditions either with or without WinCo-generated traffic. Reliance on undefined future mitigation measures cannot substitute for demonstrating present compliance with applicable approval criteria. The response also fails to cure deficiencies associated with: • Improper application of pass-by trip reductions; • Lack of queue analysis despite corridor conditions triggering such analysis under ODOT requirements; • Incomplete documentation regarding pipeline developments and background growth assumptions; • Use of an opening year inconsistent with the application materials; and • Lack of substantial evidence demonstrating compliance with the Interchange Management Area (IMA) trip budgeting framework. Reliance on staff-level coordination, future design work, or future agency approvals does not substitute for substantial evidence in the record. Although the GVC memorandum repeatedly states that the TIA "received approval from City and ODOT staff," City staff and ODOT staff are not the land use decision-makers, and staff-level concurrence does not relieve the applicant of the obligation to provide substantial evidence demonstrating compliance with applicable standards. TIA Results Discrepancies and Requirements The GVC memorandum acknowledges that prior studies for the same corridor projected failing or near-failing operations at the OR 214/Evergreen Road and OR 214/Settlemier Road intersections, while the WinCo TIA reports compliant near-term operations. However, the response still does not adequately reconcile these materially different results. The GVC response introduces several new factual assertions and calculations that do not appear to have been included in the original TIA or supporting materials, including: • Assertions regarding use of"existing ODOT signal timings"; • Comparisons of seasonally adjusted 2022 and 2025 count volumes; • Newly asserted background growth assumptions; 2 234 • Newly asserted explanations regarding reduced pipeline development traffic; • Calculations regarding projected opening year traffic increases; and • Assertions regarding limitations on adjacent-road pass-by capture percentages. These factual assertions appear to constitute new evidence because they rely on technical calculations, comparative analyses, or assumptions not included in the record. Importantly, even with these new explanations, the response still does not adequately explain the central issue: • The WinCo TIA reports higher existing entering volumes at OR 214/Evergreen Road than some prior studies; • The corridor has experienced additional approved development since the earlier studies; • No operational improvements are identified as having been implemented; yet • The WinCo TIA nevertheless reports materially improved operational performance. The GVC memorandum claims the discrepancy "...is due to some combination of the previously included pipeline development projects having been completed since then, and/or having lost city approval...Overall, the minimal growth observed in the comparison of existing volume data, combined with a lower annual growth rate and fewer pipeline development traffic volumes combine to produce lower short term horizon volume forecasts for the WinCo Foods study than what was previously forecasted in the earlier studies." However, the GVC memorandum fails to provide substantial evidence that supports this claim. This inconsistency is significant because, all else being equal, higher traffic volumes should not produce lower volume-to-capacity ratios. If the WinCo TIA uses higher traffic volumes than the prior studies, then the reported lower v/c ratios necessarily imply that other analytical assumptions are different than several previous analyses that illustrated the opposite result of GVC's analysis. The GVC memorandum states that "the WinCo Foods study used existing ODOT signal timings" and further states that "the same channelization was used in each of the previous studies and the WinCo Foods study, leaving analysis volumes as the only differing variable." However, if the WinCo study truly used the same channelization and higher traffic volumes, then lower v/c ratios would not ordinarily result unless additional operational assumptions were modified, such as signal timing assumptions, saturation flow assumptions, lane utilization assumptions, peak hour factors, heavy vehicle assumptions, or other capacity inputs. The memorandum does not provide the detailed Synchro operational parameters, signal timing comparisons, or side-by-side capacity calculations necessary to independently verify why the WinCo study reports improved operational performance despite higher reported traffic volumes and additional approved development. 3 235 For example: • The Specht Industrial TIA identified the OR 214/Settlemier intersection operating above the ODOT mobility standard at a v/c ratio of 0.97. • The Brighton Pointe TIA similarly identified near-failing or failing conditions. • The WinCo TIA now reports substantially lower baseline conditions despite no substantial evidence as to why. The GVC memorandum attempts to explain these differences by asserting that the WinCo study used a lower annual background growth rate and lower pipeline development traffic assumptions. Specifically, the memorandum states: "The two studies from 2022 both identified an annual growth rate of 1.0% per year. The WinCo Foods study, based on historic volume growth trends, identified an annual growth rate of 0.50% per year." The memorandum further states "The overall pipeline volumes used in the WinCo Foods study, which included both of the 2022 projects, is less than the pipeline volumes from the other studies." The issue is not simply that the numbers are "slightly lower." The issue is that previous studies identified deficient or failing operations while the WinCo study reports compliant operations under substantially similar conditions. Signal timing assumptions materially affect capacity calculations and v/c ratios. If differing signal timing assumptions were used between studies, that alone could significantly alter operational outcomes. However, no signal timing sheets that illustrate how the signals are operating in the field are provided in the record. Without detailed operational inputs and comparative analysis, the City cannot independently verify why the WinCo TIA reaches substantially different conclusions than multiple prior studies evaluating the same corridor. Queue Analysis Remains Necessary Under ODOT Guidance The GVC memorandum states that 95th percentile queue analysis "is not a requirement of the City of Woodburn or ODOT" and that "neither agency has requested this analysis."This assertion is inconsistent with the ODOT Analysis Procedures Manual (APM) and ODOT Development Review Guidelines (DRG), both of which were previously cited. The ODOT APM states that simulation should be used to evaluate queues when v/c ratios exceed 0.70 and shall be used when v/c ratios equal or exceed 0.90 or where congested conditions exist. Several intersections analyzed in the TIA meet or exceed these thresholds. The WinCo TIA itself reports: • OR 214/Evergreen Road operating at a v/c ratio of 0.94; and • OR 214/Oregon Way/Settlemier operating at a v/c ratio of 0.94. 4 236 Under ODOT guidance, these conditions warrant queue analysis and simulation. The absence of queue analysis is significant because: • Closely spaced intersections and interchange facilities are present; • Queue spillback may materially affect upstream operations; • Turn lane storage adequacy cannot be verified; • Average delay and v/c ratio alone do not adequately evaluate system performance; and • Other traffic studies in the area provided queue analysis. The GVC memorandum does not address these ODOT requirements. Condition of Approval 15 Does Not Cure the Analytical Deficiency A recently proposed condition of approval states that the "Applicant shall provide for the signalization of the eastbound and northbound right-turn lanes at the Evergreen Road and OR 214 intersections. The Applicant shall conduct a traffic analysis justifying the signal modifications and preliminary design layouts to gain ODOT approval. Prior to certificate of occupancy issuance, the applicant shall provide to the City a copy of an executed ODOT permit for the completion of both signal modifications. Installation and final inspection of the signal modifications shall be completed within three years of the date of the certificate of occupancy." While this condition appears intended to address ODOT's concerns, it also demonstrates that the current record remains incomplete. The condition effectively acknowledges that: • Additional traffic analysis is still required; • Signal modifications are not yet justified through completed engineering analysis; • Preliminary designs do not yet exist; • ODOT approval has not yet been obtained; and • The operational effectiveness of the mitigation has not yet been demonstrated. Importantly, the condition defers the core operational analysis until after land use approval. The TIA currently contains no completed operational modeling demonstrating that the proposed modification: • Restores the intersection to compliance with ODOT mobility standards; • Avoids queue spillback impacts; • Functions acceptably within the broader OR 214 coordinated corridor; or • Can be physically implemented within the existing corridor constraints. 5 237 The condition therefore does not supply the substantial evidence presently missing from the record. Instead, it effectively postpones required transportation analysis and mitigation design until after approval. Pass-By Trip Assumptions Remain Inconsistent with ITE Methodology The GVC memorandum attempts to justify assigning pass-by trips to OR 214 by arguing that "It is typical to expect an adjacent roadway to support no more than 20%of a proposed project's potential pass-by volume." The memorandum further states that "In cases like this it is a common technique to limit the pass-by impact on lower volume roads. By assigning the pass-by trips to the nearest high- volume roadway, Highway 214." However, these explanations remain inconsistent with the ITE Trip Generation Handbook definitions previously cited. By definition: • Pass-by trips are drawn from traffic already traveling on a roadway directly adjacent to the site; and • Pass-by trips do not divert from non-adjacent roadways. OR 214 is not directly adjacent to the site. The methodology described in the GVC memorandum instead resembles diverted linked trips, not pass-by trips. ITE specifically distinguishes these concepts. The memorandum states that it is a "common technique" to shift pass-by trip reductions to higher-volume roadways such as OR 214. However, no supporting methodology, empirical data, or industry guidance is provided establishing that this approach is consistent with accepted ITE methodology. In fact, it is in direct opposition to the methodology. The memorandum's suggestion that pass-by trips may be reassigned away from adjacent roadways because adjacent volumes are relatively low directly conflicts with the ITE definition of pass-by trips. Pass-by trips are limited to traffic already traveling on adjacent roadways. If the adjacent roadway volumes are insufficient to support the assumed pass-by capture, then the assumed pass-by percentage itself should be reduced rather than reassigned to a non-adjacent corridor. If pass-by reductions are improperly applied: • Project-generated traffic volumes are understated; • v/c ratios are understated; 6 238 • Queue estimates are understated; and • Operational conclusions become unreliable. This issue is particularly significant because the OR 214/Evergreen intersection is reported to operate at a v/c ratio of 0.94, only 0.01 below the ODOT mobility threshold and as noted, previous traffic impact studies illustrate operations above the threshold. Relatively small traffic adjustments could materially alter the reported operational conclusions. Opening Year Assumptions Remain Inconsistent The GVC memorandum now acknowledges that the opening year "may in fact slide to 2027." However, the application materials themselves identify a 2027 construction and opening timeframe, so this is not merely speculative, but proposed by the applicant. The TIA nevertheless modeled a 2026 opening year. The memorandum further introduces new calculations asserting that an additional year of growth would result in "fewer than 5 trips for each turning movement."These calculations do not appear in the original TIA and constitute additional technical analysis not previously included in the record. The OR 214 corridor intersections are already reported to operate very near the ODOT mobility threshold. Previous analyses illustrated operations above the threshold. Where intersections are operating near capacity: • Small traffic increases can materially affect v/c ratios; and • Queue lengths can increase. Accordingly, use of an incorrect opening year undermines the reliability of the opening-year operational analysis. Intersection Failures and Proposed Improvements Remain Unsubstantiated The GVC memorandum states that it was unnecessary for improvements at three Evergreen Road intersections to be "justified or validated" by the TIA because City staff had already identified those improvements. However, the existence of conceptual future improvements does not establish that the intersections will actually operate acceptably. The TIA still does not provide: • Information about the design; • Operational modeling outputs; 7 239 • Signal phasing and timing assumptions; • Queuing analysis; or • Evidence demonstrating compliance after improvement implementation either with or without WinCo traffic. The memorandum further acknowledges that: • "The exact design and channelization planned for each location is unknown"; and • "It is anticipated that final design will include operational analysis to verify sufficient capacity is provided." Again, this confirms that the present record lacks completed operational evidence. Traffic Signal Warrant Analysis Remains Absent The TIA and response memorandum continue to rely on assumed future signalization at multiple intersections without providing warrant analyses. The MUTCD requires an engineering study to determine whether traffic signal installation is justified. No warrant worksheets, analyses, or engineering studies have been provided. Without this information: • The feasibility of the proposed mitigation cannot be verified; • Operational assumptions cannot be independently reviewed; and • The City cannot conclude that the proposed mitigation is compliant with the MUTCD. Pipeline Development Assumptions Remain Insufficiently Documented The GVC memorandum states that City staff provided pipeline development assumptions and completion percentages. However, the applicant retains the burden of demonstrating that the TIA is accurate and complete. The memorandum states that "The pipeline development list was provided by City staff and all specific study information was provided by city staff for use in the traffic volume forecasts." However, the TIA still does not provide sufficient documentation allowing independent verification of: • Pipeline development trip generation; • Development sizes and land uses; • Completion assumptions; • Distribution assumptions; or • Individual project traffic assignments. 8 240 The memorandum's explanation therefore does not cure the transparency and reproducibility concerns previously identified. Driveway Spacing and RRFB Issues Remain Unresolved The GVC memorandum states that the proposed driveway location "was evaluated by city staff, the fire department, and the applicant" and that these parties "collectively agreed that the proposed access point is the desired location." However, staff-level agreement does not substitute for compliance with the WDO variance criteria. Additionally, these parties are not the decision-makers. The record still does not demonstrate: • That compliance with the spacing standards is infeasible; • That strict application imposes an excessive burden; or • That the variance criteria under WDO 5.03.12 are satisfied. Similarly, the memorandum's explanation regarding the RRFB does not provide any engineering analysis supporting the installation of the device. Additional Intersections Potentially Operating Outside Standards The record continues to indicate that additional intersections along the OR 214 corridor may operate near or beyond applicable standards.The most notable examples remain: • OR 214/Evergreen Road; and • OR 214/Settlemier/Oregon Way. Prior studies identified these intersections operating at or above ODOT mobility thresholds.The WinCo TIA reports operations only marginally below the threshold, with reported v/c ratios of 0.94. The following other major issues remain in the operational analyses: • The unresolved pass-by trip methodology issues; • The absence of queue analysis; • The opening year discrepancy; • Unresolved differences with prior studies; and • Lack of completed mitigation analysis, As a result, there remains substantial uncertainty regarding whether these intersections would in fact comply with ODOT and City of Woodburn standards. 9 241 Moreover, without queue simulation and corridor-level analysis, it is not possible to determine whether additional operational deficiencies may occur due to spillback or coordinated signal effects. Conclusion The March 19, 2026 GVC Transportation Solutions memorandum does not resolve the core deficiencies identified in my prior review. Instead, the response: • Relies heavily on new technical assertions and calculations not included in the record; • Fails to adequately reconcile materially different operational conclusions from prior corridor studies; • Continues to rely on pass-by methodologies inconsistent with ITE definitions; • Does not provide queue analysis under ODOT requirements; • Defers critical operational analysis and mitigation design until after approval; • Fails to demonstrate that proposed mitigation measures will restore acceptable operations; and • Continues to rely on incomplete and insufficiently documented assumptions. Most importantly, the current record still does not provide substantial evidence demonstrating that: • OR 214 corridor operations will comply with applicable ODOT mobility standards; • Queue spillback and storage issues have been adequately evaluated; • Proposed mitigation measures are feasible and effective; • The project complies with the IMA trip budgeting framework; and • Transportation impacts have been fully identified and mitigated concurrent with development. Until these issues are addressed through completed engineering analysis and substantial evidence in the record, the City cannot make defensible findings that the transportation impacts of the proposal have been adequately analyzed or mitigated. Sincerely, G N 4 61474 Rick Nys, P.E. c Digitally Date: Principal Traffic Engineer 2026.05.10 Signed 16:51:03-07'00' OREGON RD RENEWS: 12/31/2026 10 242 UJtWJ3 3 March 11, 2026 Woodburn Planning Commission City of Woodburn 270 Montgomery Street Woodburn, OR 97071 Re: DR 25-14 /VAR 25-06/PLA 25-04 /SA 26-01 —Proposed WinCo Foods Grocery Store Dear Planning Commissioners: UFCW Local 555 represents more than 35,000 grocery, retail, and food-processing workers across Oregon, and the Pacific NW, including many who live and work in Woodburn. We appreciate the opportunity to provide comments on the proposed 84,087-square-foot WinCo Foods development currently under Design Review. Our union supports responsible economic development that strengthens local employment, protects public infrastructure, and enhances community well-being. Based on our review of the application materials, we believe the record does not yet demonstrate that this project meets those standards. Labor and Economic Impacts WinCo is a non-union employer whose business model relies on low wages, unpredictable scheduling, and minimal staffing levels. In communities where large, non-union big-box grocers open, existing union and independent grocers often experience reduced sales, cuts to worker hours, and long-term job instability. These impacts are well-documented and will directly affect the livelihoods of hundreds of Woodburn-area grocery workers. The City should not approve a project of this scale without fully considering its effect on job quality, economic stability, and the long-term viability of existing employers who provide family-sustaining union jobs. Transportation and Safety Concerns The City's February 18, 2026, completeness letter confirms that this project requires a Type III public hearing because of its scale and potential impacts. While the applicant has submitted a Traffic Impact Analysis (TIA), the document raises several unresolved issues that should be addressed before any approval is granted. Among the concerns are: • Unclear traffic assumptions. The TIA relies on assumptions about trip generation, distribution, and timing that may not reflect actual conditions once the store opens. • Potential underestimation of congestion. Key corridors such as Evergreen Road, Stacy Allison Way, and Highway 214 already experience heavy traffic. A store of this size will add significant new vehicle trips, and the TIA does not clearly demonstrate that nearby intersections and roadways can absorb this increase without degrading safety or mobility. • Lack of clear mitigation.The TIA identifies areas where traffic conditions may worsen but does not provide specific, enforceable mitigation measures or demonstrate that improvements would be in place before the store opens. 243 • Pedestrian and neighborhood safety. The project will increase turning movements, truck activity, and pedestrian crossings near residential areas. The TIA does not fully evaluate how these changes will affect safety for nearby residents, workers, and school-related traffic. These issues are significant because transportation impacts directly affect emergency response, commute times, neighborhood livability, and the overall functioning of the city's transportation system. Before approving a project of this size, the City should require a clearer, more complete analysis and ensure that any necessary improvements are identified, funded, and timed appropriately. Neighborhood and Community Impacts The site is adjacent to homes, apartments, and senior housing. A store of this size will introduce late-night noise and lighting, increased truck activity, hundreds of new daily vehicle trips, and additional turning movements near residential driveways. The proposed pedestrian improvements on Evergreen Road also require further evaluation to ensure they are appropriate and safe for the surrounding neighborhood. Need for Additional Review Before Approval Given the scale of the project, the gaps in the current traffic analysis, and the potential economic and community impacts, UFCW Local 555 respectfully urges the Planning Commission to require: • A more complete and transparent TIA that fully evaluates traffic, safety, and neighborhood impacts; • Clear, enforceable mitigation measures that are concurrent with development; • Evaluation of job quality, economic displacement, and impacts on existing employers; and • Additional public review once corrected materials are submitted. Until these issues are resolved, approval of the application is not supported by substantial evidence in the record. Thank you for your consideration and for your service to the residents and workers of Woodburn. Sincerely, Miles Eshaia Communications Director UFCW Local 555 244 Andrew Mulkey Attorney at Law PO Box 66562, Portland, OR 97290 • (503) 334-9899 • andrew@mulkeylegal.com March 11, 2026 Via Email City of Woodburn Planning Commission c/o Chris Kerr, Community Development Director 270 Montgomery Street Woodburn, OR 97071 Chris.Kerr@ci.woodburn.or.us Re: Protect Our Valley Alliance, Planning Commission Comment Letter for Land Use Application for Proposed WinCo Foods Transportation, Environmental, and Neighborhood Impacts Dear Chair and Members of the Planning Commission: I represent Protect Our Valley Alliance, a coalition of Woodburn residents, workers, and community stakeholders concerned about the transportation, environmental, and neighborhood impacts of the proposed WinCo Foods development. The Alliance supports growth that is consistent with the Woodburn Comprehensive Plan, protects public safety, and ensures that development does not impose disproportionate burdens on surrounding neighborhoods. At the Alliance's request, Greenlight Engineering conducted an independent technical review of the applicant's Traffic Impact Analysis ("TIA"), revised January 21, 2026. The engineering review is attached as Exhibit A and incorporated herein. The review identifies multiple substantive deficiencies that prevent the City from making the findings required under the Woodburn Development Ordinance ("WDO"), the Interchange Management Area ("IMA") Overlay District, and applicable transportation standards. In addition to the technical transportation issues, the Alliance has identified significant concerns related to emergency access, neighborhood livability, noise and light pollution, pedestrian safety, environmental impacts, and compatibility Planning Commission Comment Letter: Protect Our Valley Alliance 1 of 12 245 with adjacent residential uses. These issues are supported by evidence in the record, by the City's own adopted policies, and by the applicant's materials. Based on the current record, the application does not demonstrate compliance with mandatory approval criteria and does not provide substantial evidence supporting approval. The Alliance respectfully requests that the Commission deny the application or, at minimum, require the applicant to submit corrected materials and return for further public review. A summary of the basis for denial or additional materials is included at the end of this letter. I. Summary of Findings The independent engineering review concludes that the TIA contains four fundamental deficiencies that materially undermine its conclusions: • Impacts are understated • IMA trip cap compliance is not demonstrated • Intersection failures are identified but not mitigated • Required engineering analyses are missing These deficiencies affect the core assumptions that drive all operational modeling, trip generation, and compliance findings. Until corrected, the City cannot make defensible findings that the project meets WDO transportation standards or that public safety will not be hindered. II. The Application Fails to Demonstrate Compliance with the IMA Trip Budget The subject property lies within Subarea K of the IMA Overlay District. Compliance with the PM peak-hour trip budget is mandatory, and exceedance is allowed only if the City makes explicit, evidence-based findings that the development "contributes substantially to the economic objectives" of the Comprehensive Plan. The TIA does not provide: • The parcel's remaining PM peak-hour trip allocation • A comparison between project trips and remaining capacity Planning Commission Comment Letter: Protect Our Valley Alliance 2of12 246 • Any accounting of prior approvals that may have consumed Subarea K's allocation As the engineering review states: "The proposed WinCo would consume and vastly exceed whatever remaining capacity exists within Subarea K... Table 5 of the TIA illustrates that the WinCo itself will generate 672 weekday PM peak hour trips, substantially in excess of the 429-trip allocation." Without a transparent trip-cap analysis, the City cannot determine whether the project complies with WDO 2.05.02 or whether an exception is justified.' See WDO 2.05.02(A), (B), (C), (D), and (G). As explained below, even if the City assumes that the peak hour vehicle trips generated will exceed the maximum peak hour trips allowed in Table 2.05A, the applicant fails to demonstrate that the development will "contribute substantially to the economic objectives found in the Comprehensive Plan." WDO 2.05.02(G)(2)(a). III. The TIA Applies Improper Pass-By Trip Reductions The TIA assigns 80 pass-by trips on Highway 214, even though the site has no driveway access on that roadway. As the engineering review explains: "Pass-by trips are not diverted from another roadway not adjacent to the site." The TIA conflates diverted trips with pass-by trips, contrary to ITE methodology. Because trip generation is the foundation for all subsequent modeling, improper pass-by assumptions propagate errors throughout the entire analysis. IV. The TIA Uses an Incorrect Opening Year The TIA models a 2026 opening year, while the applicant's narrative states the store will not open until mid-to-late 2027. The engineering review notes: 1 2.05.02(D)(1)requires that the TIA meet OAR 734-051 requirements. The OAR requires that TIAs "assess peak hour and average daily trips," "for the year of the analysis, the year of each phase opening, and future years beyond project completion or buildout." OAR 734-051-3030(5) The applicant's failure to provide an adequate analysis of peak hour trips (or as described below, a correct analysis of the opening year)violates these provisions as well. Planning Commission Comment Letter: Protect Our Valley Alliance 3 of 12 247 "Even a one-year difference can meaningfully affect intersection performance.., particularly at locations already operating near capacity." This discrepancy results in understated background volumes and artificially improved operational results. V. The Study Area and Trip Distribution Are Incomplete The TIA assumes no project traffic will use Lawson Avenue, despite the likelihood that navigation apps will route drivers through that corridor during peak congestion. The review states: "It is likely that a meaningful share of eastbound drivers on Highway 214 would be routed via Lawson Avenue rather than Evergreen Road." The TIA also omits several foreseeable intersections, including: • Highway 214 / Lawson Avenue • Lawson Avenue / Stacy Allison Road • Evergreen Road / Center Street A defensible TIA must include all intersections where project traffic is reasonably expected to cause operational change. VI. Required Queueing and Simulation Analyses Are Missing The TIA does not include 95th-percentile queue analysis, despite ODOT requirements that simulation be used when v/c ratios exceed 0.70 and must be used when they exceed 0.90. The engineering review explains: "Without 95th percentile queue estimates, it is not possible to determine whether turn lane storage is adequate, whether ramp terminals could experience spillback, or whether signals may queue into adjacent intersections." Planning Commission Comment Letter: Protect Our Valley Alliance 4of12 248 Given the proximity of Highway 214 ramp terminals and closely spaced signals, queue spillback is a critical safety issue. VII. Intersection Failures Are Identified but Not Mitigated The TIA acknowledges that multiple intersections will operate below mobility standards yet provides no enforceable mitigation. Instead, it relies on: • Speculative future signal timing changes • Assumed future signals not supported by warrant analysis • Improvements not identified as funded capital projects The engineering review highlights the internal inconsistency: "It is unclear how 'All study locations will operate within the identified performance standard' while simultaneously acknowledging that `Three City of Woodburn intersections are projected to operate below the LOS threshold." WDO 3.04.05 requires that mitigation be identified, effective, and concurrent with development. The applicant has not met this requirement. WDO 3.04.05(C), (D), (E). VIII. No Traffic Signal Warrant Analysis Is Provided The MUTCD requires an engineering study demonstrating that a signal is justified under one or more warrants. The TIA provides no warrant worksheets, no crash analysis, and no supporting data. As the review states: "Without a warrant analysis, there is no evidence that signal installation is justified, appropriate, or feasible." The City cannot rely on unsubstantiated assumptions about future signals to meet mobility standards. IX. Access Management Standards Are Not Met Planning Commission Comment Letter: Protect Our Valley Alliance 5 of 12 249 The proposed driveway on Evergreen Road is only 162 feet from the Evergreen/Oxford intersection, far short of the 245-foot minimum in WDO Table 3.04A. The engineering review notes: "Meeting the 245-foot separation standard appears feasible, yet the applicant is choosing not to meet it." The TIA also proposes a mid-block RRFB crossing without any engineering study of spacing, warrants, or safety implications. X. Pipeline Development and School Adjustments Are Not Documented The TIA lists numerous nearby developments but provides no trip tables, no distribution assumptions, and no documentation of how these projects were incorporated. Similarly, the TIA applies school-related adjustment factors (2.0 AM and 1.1 PM) without providing the underlying data. The review states: "No supporting documentation is provided to verify the methodology.., a reviewer cannot independently confirm that the factors are appropriate." Without transparency, the City cannot verify the accuracy of background volumes. XI. Additional Community, Environmental, and Neighborhood Impacts Beyond the technical transportation deficiencies, the Alliance has identified several additional concerns that independently prevent approval. A. Emergency Access and Response Times Residents in nearby apartments and senior communities rely on rapid emergency response. Increased congestion can slow ambulances, fire response, and police access to: • Cascade Meadow Apartments • Silver Creek Senior Living • Country Meadows Village Planning Commission Comment Letter: Protect Our Valley Alliance 6of12 250 • Barclay Square Apartments • Evergreen Estates The TIA does not evaluate: • Emergency vehicle delay • Queue spillback affecting access to residential driveways • Impacts on senior housing and high-needs populations WDO 3.04.05(C) requires evaluation of impacts that "hinder public safety." The applicant has not met this requirement. B. Noise, Light, and Late-Night Operations The proposed store will operate 24 hours, with continuous truck activity, refrigeration units, and parking-lot lighting. Residents report concerns about: • Sleep disruption • Vibration from truck unloading • Light trespass into homes • Increased nighttime noise The applicant has not submitted: • A noise study • A lighting photometric plan • Any analysis of nighttime operations near residential uses C. Pedestrian and Senior Safety The project is adjacent to multiple senior and multifamily housing communities. More turning movements near driveways and parking lots increase the risk of accidents involving seniors, mobility-device users, and pedestrians. The TIA does not evaluate: • Pedestrian crossing delay Planning Commission Comment Letter: Protect Our Valley Alliance 7of12 251 • Senior mobility impacts • Safe routes to transit • Conflicts at the proposed RRFB These are required components of a complete transportation analysis. WDO 3.04.05(C) D. Neighborhood Compatibility and Residential Character The surrounding area is a quiet residential corridor. Big-box stores often bring increased traffic, noise, and late-night activity, which can reduce the appeal of nearby residential communities. The applicant has not demonstrated: • That the scale and intensity of the use is compatible with adjacent housing • That residential quality of life will not be degraded • That the project meets Comprehensive Plan policies on neighborhood protection E. Impacts on Local Businesses and Economic Stability The Alliance is also concerned about economic displacement and the long-term viability of existing businesses. A new WinCo threatens the visibility, foot traffic, and long-term viability of Woodburn's independent businesses. The applicant has not provided: • An economic impact analysis • A retail leakage study • Any evidence that the project will not displace existing employers These impacts are relevant to Comprehensive Plan economic policies and to the City's findings on public welfare. See Policy F-1.3 (discouraging strip development, and encouraging developments to constitute urban districts that allow one-stop dining, shopping, and recreation opportunities). Planning Commission Comment Letter: Protect Our Valley Alliance 8of12 252 The applicant also fails to demonstrate compliance with the "economic objectives found in the Comprehensive Plan," which is required if the proposed project exceeds the maximum peak hour vehicle trips specified in Table 2.05A. WDO 2.05.02(G)(2). The record fails to adequately address this requirement. At most, the applicant quotes the City's Economic Opportunity Analysis, which states that "land.., for large commercial employers is very limited." However, the fact that land for such commercial uses is limited, or that the applicant proposes to use some of that limited land for a commercial use, does not in and of itself address any "economic objectives" of the comprehensive plan. The sections of the Economic Opportunity Analysis ("EOA") quoted by the applicant in the staff report identify a deficit of land available for commercial uses. Those deficits do not identify an economic objective, much less one that the applicant could meet. At best, the EOA identifies the need for more land for commercial uses. Yet the applicant's project does create more commercially zoned land. Therefore, the applicant's project does not address that specific need, much less demonstrate that the development "will contribute substantially to the economic objectives found in the Comprehensive Plan." Moreover, the applicant fails to demonstrate how a project that merely uses commercially zoned land for a commercial purpose "will contribute substantially" to any of the City's economic objectives. Rather than identify an economic objective of the comprehensive plan or explain how the proposed project would substantially contribute to the City's goal of meeting that objective, the applicant simply points to an identified need for more commercially zoned land. Although the City identified this need in its EOA, the City has made a clear policy choice to promote more important economic goals. As the applicant points out, the City's recent 2025 UGB expansion the City made a policy choice not to expand the number of acres for commercial land (at least not in this region of the City). Instead, the City chose to expand the UGB for the purpose of increasing the amount of land zoned as part of the Southwest Industrial Reserve. The City's comprehensive plan map and zoning map demonstrates that a large portion of this Urban Reserve Area and protected industrial land occurs south of the subject property on the east side of Interstate 5. Planning Commission Comment Letter: Protect Our Valley Alliance 9of12 253 In this case, the applicant's proposal to exceed the maximum peak hour vehicle trip limit for this part of the City demonstrates that the project presents a direct conflict with the comprehensive plan's economic objectives. Specifically, the project's traffic will impair the City's economic objective to maintain and preserve land and infrastructure for industrial uses. For that reason, the applicant fails to demonstrate compliance with WDO 2.05.02(G)(2). The Comprehensive Plan explains that maintaining industrial land and that land's access to Interstate 5 "is critical to the economic development efforts of the City." The City's EOA and the City's Economic Development Strategy "provide[s] the basis and policy direction for Woodburn's economic development efforts." Comp. Plan at 17. To that end, the comprehensive plan explains that industrial land "requires good transportation access, served preferably, but not necessarily, by both railroad and highway facilities." Id. at 17-18. The comprehensive plan continues, explaining that "[r]eserving industrial sites with direct access to Interstate 5 is critical to the economic development efforts of the City."Id. By increasing non-industrial traffic beyond the limit allowed by WDO 2.05.02, the applicant's proposal fails to comply with the provisions of the WDO and the City's comprehensive plan. The plan explains that "lands for high traffic generating uses (shopping centers, malls, restaurants, etc.) should be located on well improved arterials." Policy F-1.2 The plan goes on to explain that such "uses should provide the necessary access management and traffic control devices needed to ameliorate their traffic impact on the arterial streets." Id. The applicant admits that the proposal will make traffic worse, not better. Here, the applicant falls far short of meeting the threshold needed to show that its project would contribute substantially to the economic objectives outlined in the comprehensive plan. WDO 2.05.02(G)(2). Here, by exceeding the maximum peak hour vehicle trip limit, the applicant's proposal would threaten rather than serve the City's economic objective of maintaining direct access for industrial lands to Interstate 5. The applicant's project would increase non-industrial traffic on the arterials that the newly reserved industrial land south of the subject property would ultimately use to access the highway. As part of its industrial lands policies, the City has identified numerous economic objectives. These include Policy E-1.8, which protects industrial lands Planning Commission Comment Letter: Protect Our Valley Alliance 10 of 12 254 "from encroachment by commercial or other uses that will either increase the price of industrial land or generate traffic that will interfere with normal industrial practices." The Comprehensive Plan explains that the City's objective in protecting industrial land includes attracting industries that "should generate jobs that would upgrade the skills of the local labor pool." Policy E-1.9. The applicant's proposal runs counter to both of those economic objectives. For that reason, the proposal violates WDO 2.05.02(G)(2). XII. Conclusion The record does not contain substantial evidence demonstrating that the proposed WinCo complies with the Woodburn Development Ordinance, the IMA Overlay District, or applicable transportation, environmental, and neighborhood standards. The TIA contains significant methodological errors, omits required analyses, and fails to identify enforceable mitigation. Additional concerns related to emergency access, noise, light, pedestrian safety, neighborhood compatibility, and economic displacement further prevent approval. Protect Our Valley Alliance respectfully requests that the Planning Commission: • Deny the application, or • Require the applicant to submit a corrected, complete TIA and additional studies, including: • A full IMA trip-cap accounting • Corrected trip generation and distribution • Queueing and simulation analyses • Signal warrant studies • Documented pipeline development assumptions • Access spacing compliance • Noise and lighting studies • Pedestrian and senior safety analysis • Emergency access evaluation Planning Commission Comment Letter: Protect Our Valley Alliance 11 of 12 255 • Identified, funded, and concurrent mitigation The Alliance appreciates the Commission's careful review and its commitment to ensuring that development proceeds responsibly and in accordance with adopted standards. Respectfully, Andrew Mulkey (OSB No. 171237) PO Box 66562 Portland, OR 97290 (503) 334-9989 andrew@mulkeylegal.coin On behalf of Protect Our Valley Alliance Attachments: Exhibit A Greenlight Engineering Review of TIA Planning Commission Comment Letter: Protect Our Valley Alliance 12 of 12 256 Protect Our Valley Alliance Exhibit A Greenlight Engineering Review of TIA 257 ( i GREEN LIGHT HT iI) ENGINEERING March 12, 2026 City of Woodburn Planning Commission 270 Montgomery St Woodburn, OR 97071 RE: Transportation Impacts of Proposed WinCo Planning Commissioners: Greenlight Engineering was retained by Protect Our Valley Alliance to conduct a technical review of the proposed WinCo Foods development and associated land use application. This review evaluated the Traffic Impact Analysis (TIA), revised January 21, 2026, the Design Review Project Narrative, submitted site plans, the City of Woodburn staff report, and supporting materials in the public record. The purpose of this review is to evaluate whether the methods, assumptions, and conclusions of the TIA comply with the Woodburn Development Ordinance (WDO), the Interchange Management Area (IMA) Overlay District requirements, the Woodburn Comprehensive Plan, applicable ODOT requirements, and generally accepted traffic engineering practice. Based on this review, the current record does not demonstrate that the proposed development complies with applicable transportation standards or that the project's transportation impacts have been adequately identified or mitigated. The analysis supporting the application contains significant analytical omissions, unsupported assumptions, and inconsistencies with prior traffic studies prepared for nearby developments. Because transportation impacts form a central component of the City's development review framework, particularly within the IMA Overlay District,the deficiencies identified in the TIA prevent the City from making defensible findings that the proposal complies with adopted standards or that required mitigation has been adequately identified. 13554 Rogers Road • Lake Oswego, OR 97035 ww. ,irk, '„! „II„!!, ,;, '„! ,g,ii„ir, , ,„!rii„! , ,, ,onn • 503.317.4559 258 Executive Summary This review identifies several fundamental deficiencies in the TIA and the supporting record: Intersection failures are identified but not mitigated Multiple intersections are projected to operate below adopted mobility standards under both opening-year and future conditions. In previous applications,two intersections were identified to fail ODOT mobility standards. However, this TIA illustrates those intersections to now to operate adequately without apparent improvements. Where the TIA identifies intersection failures, the TIA does not demonstrate that improvements are funded, or provide operational modeling showing that proposed improvements would restore acceptable operations. Instead, the analysis relies on speculative future signal installations and corridor signal timing adjustments that are not supported by engineering analysis, funding commitments, or traffic signal warrant studies. Project impacts are materially understated Several methodological issues result in an understatement of project traffic and operational impacts.These include the improper application of pass-by trip reductions on Highway 214,the omission of study intersections that should have been included,the use of an incorrect opening year, and the absence of 95th percentile queue analysis. Because trip generation and distribution form the foundation for all operational modeling, these errors propagate throughout the analysis and materially affect the reported intersection performance. Compliance with the Interchange Management Area (IMA) trip cap is not demonstrated. The site is located within the Interchange Management Area Overlay District, which establishes a cumulative PM peak hour trip budget intended to preserve the operational integrity of the I-5 interchange and surrounding arterial network. The TIA does not provide a clear accounting of remaining trip capacity within Subarea K or demonstrate how the project's forecast PM peak hour trips compare to the available allocation. Moreover, the project's trip generation appears to substantially exceed the parcel's allocated trip budget. Additionally, the TIA relies on improper pass-by trip assumptions that artificially reduce the reported trip impact in the IMA. Without a transparent accounting of remaining trip capacity and a quantitative comparison to project demand, the City cannot determine whether the proposal complies with WDO 2.05 or whether an exception to the trip cap is justified. 2 259 Important engineering analyses is missing Several analyses typically required in transportation impact studies are absent from the TIA, including 95th percentile queue analysis and transparent documentation of how approved pipeline developments were incorporated into the forecast traffic volumes. Without these elements, the City and the public cannot independently verify the study's assumptions or conclusions. These deficiencies are not minor technical disagreements. They affect foundational elements of the transportation analysis. Because trip generation and distribution drive all subsequent modeling of intersection operations, queuing, and mobility compliance, unsupported assumptions at the front end of the analysis undermine the reliability of the entire study. Until these issues are addressed, the City cannot make defensible findings that: • The proposal complies with the IMA Overlay District trip budgeting framework; • Adopted mobility standards will be met; or • Required mitigation measures are identified, feasible, and concurrent with development. For these reasons, approval of the application in its current form is not supported by substantial evidence in the record. TIS Results Discrepancies and Requirements Interestingly, a recent TIA prepared for the Specht Industrial Development application, which predates the WinCo TIA, illustrated that the intersections of Highway 214/Evergreen Road and Highway 214/Boones Ferry/Settlemier Road exceed the ODOT mobility standard. However,the subsequent WinCo TIA indicates there are not near-term congestion issues at the intersections even though it does not appear improvements are planned or constructed. Supposedly, the WinCo incorporates the Specht Industrial impacts, but the traffic studies present very different results. Table 10 of the WinCo TIA reports that the intersections of Highway 214/Evergreen Road and Highway 214/Oregon Way (& Settlemier Road) will both operate with volume-to- capacity (v/c) ratios of 0.94 with the development in place. These values are both just 0.01 below the ODOT mobility standard of 0.95. Table 10 also shows that without the proposed project, the Evergreen intersection would operate at a v/c ratio of 0.84 and the Settlemier intersection at 0.89. These baseline conditions already include the traffic associated with the Specht Industrial Development, yet the intersection operations in the WinCo TIA are significantly better than the Specht TIA despite no planned or constructed improvements that improve operations. 3 260 The TIA prepared for the Specht Industrial Development in 2022 concluded that, with that development in place,the intersection of Highway 214/Evergreen Road would operate at a v/c ratio of 0.93 and the intersection of Highway 214/Settlemier/Boones Ferry Road would operate at a v/c ratio of 0.97, well above the ODOT mobility standard. In other words, the Specht TIA projected failing conditions at one of these intersections, whereas the WinCo TIA reports substantially lower v/c ratios and compliant operations. uju� "iui uui uuu u li fu VV a II W- f Po �III Ifw�- r u v . i it ill it m u a 1110 a r h"a'�. Ewer,r "i Rr �DD. .... a ... IC 9, ? fir, D R� 7 -- '_) I "I D5 b 55 D.94-E-58. DI 9r E .Ea f,'' I-"9 R 2 1 reg ay TAl U : IPM 043-0-1951 -E+-i r I " ': 4 OR 2Il k,�RPtth',mjgr Av ��uie'R a rories DODO- A wtl 0.,Rt- .2 t'o,95-E-E .E p 96-E-5D. 9'5 E-59.6 Ferry Road p 9 F,3""IUD-.R2."2 .9 .E-57.91 0D y. ..ca", .R d92 E R R Excerpt of Specht Industrial Development TIA These analyses therefore report significantly different capacity outcomes for the same intersections under similar development assumptions. The basis for these differences is unclear from the materials provided and warrants clarification. It is notable that the Specht Industrial Development TIA recommended that the project provide proportionate-share contributions at several intersections based on PM peak- hour volumes, including: • 0.99% at OR 214/Settlemier • 0.28% at OR 214/Highway 99E • 4.19% at Evergreen Road/Hayes Street That TIA further noted that the City has commonly collected proportionate-share or mitigation fees from developments to address corridor capacity issues and recommended that the Specht project contribute similarly. It is unclear whether these deficiencies still exist. Similar inconsistencies appear in other referenced studies. For example, Table 8 of the Brighton Pointe Subdivision TIA (also referenced in the WinCo TIA) projected that the Highway 214/Settlemier intersection would operate above the ODOT mobility standard at a v/c ratio of 0.96, while the Highway 214/Evergreen intersection was projected to operate at 0.93. In contrast, the WinCo TIA establishes baseline operations at both 4 261 intersections below 0.90 v/c, substantially lower than the values projected in earlier studies. r uV ,f, G,� ew�IV° A Illizsl�r ma3 S�uwrLII if,y � ��� �I Vo�oil h ll�llil�il"u��iluouil0000 o9uluoil loil ������������������^II ill�!I IjVI iunli16��l�liilti i�� . ���r�o �r �� ,u u�� VI � i��!! �, I illy ����II� I I�IV II GU II II Igll��llll�llllll�l � � � � ��� � �� D II VIV IV IV IV VIV I!III 1a 116V2V 11 o��� �� �o u u IO U019V Iu'u III 11V1001� 0� ..0 111 1111 0111 III@ .,Y 0\O�OIU (111 1 1�IIl.. II 2020 Ex'ti�ng Corndlitldn 0.56 E tS OI0 O i CIOCO Ickground Corddtocrn 095 077 C CS OIw9C C SC OOC'S Eulilld uit CondlitiN a 078 C Cd 0OS. C S9 i»>w1u� 1 iti I,U�1IUY\1U\\1\111 >11�I�� �01�11�11D1111�1 u LOCO I xisting Condition 0.73 C SC 013 D 4C COOS Background C; nditlion 0.95 0.55 0 46 0 E t 8 2040 I ul dl lut Condition 085 FD 4b 0,90 E 09 Excerpt of Brighton Pointe TIA (2022) The Smith Creek Subdivision TIA likewise identified operational deficiencies at the Highway 214/Settlemier intersection. OM 7a"T: I fl UbOUT M4 MmI U4 HOUR M MOOWk VIM YC!OiATOMH w.. ................. 4M Pa*Hour PM] ak M auwuur tllin !�r� Nw�Ma�wn mdM!�,� TraMe IV g ci. of a Kfc w 2>I4rEvwgr n M d a,5 V0CI, C 31 •G 615 O 43S 3,78 4 II4 4i •.R'3mgMJ Y 14 WC B 10 7O C 20.9 0..65 3 ]I4C P v, l fl iy4t4 a33,Vn B '0H 0.56 C 20.3 a$a 6 w ¢ 4' �4"hwal Mw: a,9..WC F 31'.2 0 9C F '2.O..8V Nu"fl Excerpt of Smith Creek Subdivision TIA (2018) All of these reports can be reviewed here: JIB„tiff ?„ aaaa,aa.,aa, , ,ll ,!u,pFlii „li. ov " S,SCI�uiiFl!!Fl ,!! ,ti Accordingly, the record indicates that the City of Woodburn has previously been notified several times of capacity issues at these intersections, yet the current TIA identifies no capacity issues at these intersections in the near term. The WinCo TIA does not explain whether any improvements have been implemented with those funds or how previously identified deficiencies have been resolved. Nevertheless, years later, and with substantially more development proposed or underway, the intersections are now reported to operate within acceptable mobility standards. This apparent discrepancy should be clarified, and a consistent analytical approach between applications should be ensured. 5 262 In addition to these discrepancies, the WinCo TIA omits critical analysis that was included in prior studies such as the Specht Industrial TIA, Brighton Point TIA, and Hermanson Preserve TIA. Most notably, the WinCo TIA provides no estimate of intersection or corridor queuing. Queue analysis is a common requirement in ODOT traffic impact analyses because, without it, it is not possible to determine whether vehicle queues can be accommodated within available storage or whether they may spill back and affect upstream intersections. The absence of queue analysis is particularly unusual given that this corridor is approaching or at the ODOT mobility threshold. Additional discussion of this item is provided herein under "Queuing Analysis and Simulation Is Absent". Highway 214/Evergreen Intersection ODOT Concerns ODOT's February 6, 2026 letter states: "No mitigation measures to any state facility have been proposed. However, the study shows the development impacting the OR 214 at Evergreen Road intersection, projecting the intersection operating above mobility target in the future PM peak hour condition. Region 2 Traffic recommends mitigation at the intersection by signalizing the eastbound and northbound right-turn lanes which are currently yield and stop controlled, respectively... No further analysis work should be required. However,ODOT recommends mitigation measures, as noted above in comment #2, to mitigate traffic effects of the proposed development. Additional work may be required to accompany approval requests for proposed mitigation measures (i.e. preliminary design layout, preliminary signal operations design, etc.). In contrast, the staff report states: "... ODOT provided comments to the City and applicant on the TIA, which was been revised to their satisfaction. Based on the ODOT approved TIA, no additional traffic mitigations were warranted. Although ODOT agreed that no additional traffic mitigations were warranted for the applicant's current proposal, they nevertheless offered recommendations for potential improvements to address future (2040) issues at the intersection for 214 and Evergreen. Specifically, ODOT recommended adding signals at the eastbound (from Evergreen) and southbound (from 214) movements.These mitigations would not be directly attributable to the applicant's proposal, which, as noted above, meets ODOT standards. Additionally, because the recommended mitigations address future (2040) issues, it is not possible to proportionally allocate a share of these future mitigations to the applicant's current proposal..." ODOT's letter clearly states that the analysis shows the development affecting operations at the Highway 214/Evergreen Road intersection and recommends mitigation in the form of signalizing specific movements. The City's staff report, however, characterizes ODOT's opinion as indicating that no mitigation is warranted. 6 263 These interpretations conflict. ODOT identifies an operational deficiency associated with the development and recommends mitigation, while the staff report concludes that the recommended improvements are unrelated to the applicant's proposal and therefore need not be addressed. The record does not provide a clear explanation reconciling these differing interpretations or explaining why mitigation recommended by ODOT cannot be proportionally attributed to the project. As discussed earlier in this review, multiple prior traffic studies have already identified operational deficiencies along the Highway 214 corridor, including at the Evergreen Road and Settlemier/Boones Ferry Road intersections. The WinCo development is projected to add traffic to this corridor, yet the application does not include any mitigation for impacts to these state highway intersections. Given the documented congestion conditions and the recommendations provided by ODOT, the absence of identified mitigation for project impacts to Highway 214 raises significant questions regarding whether the proposal satisfies applicable transportation performance standards. Interchange Management Area(IMA) Trip Cap Compliance The subject property is located within the Interchange Management Area (IMA) Overlay District (WDO 2.05), which establishes a cumulative PM peak hour trip budget intended to preserve the long-term operational integrity of the 1-5 interchange and the surrounding arterial network. Compliance with the PM peak hour trip cap is mandatory. Exceedance is permitted only if a development "contributes substantially to the economic objectives found in the Comprehensive Plan," and only after the City makes explicit policy findings supporting such an exception. This exception is not automatic. It is a discretionary mechanism that must be supported by substantial evidence and reasoned findings demonstrating that overriding economic objectives justify additional transportation demand within a capacity-constrained system. The proposed WinCo development would consume, and substantially exceed, whatever remaining capacity exists within Subarea K. As a result, it would constrain or preclude other properties within the subarea from developing under the adopted trip allocation and would shift the burden onto future applicants to demonstrate extraordinary economic justification for additional exceptions. In practical terms, approval would allocate more than Subarea K's limited transportation capacity to a single use, thereby undermining the cumulative trip-budgeting framework established by the overlay district and impact the ability of other developments in other areas from developing. At the very least, ignoring the adopted cap will burden the interchange and transportation network. Although the Traffic Impact Analysis(TIA) references the IMA overlay, it omits critical information necessary to evaluate compliance. Specifically, the report does not identify the parcel's remaining PM peak hour trip allocation or provide a comparison between the project's forecast PM peak hour trips and the remaining allocation. No accounting is provided demonstrating 7 264 whether the 429 PM peak hour trip allocation identified in Table 2.05A has already been partially consumed by prior development approvals. The TIA also fails to address the policy implications of approving a high trip-generating development that could preclude other future development within the subarea due to exhaustion of the trip cap. The City staff report states: "The proposed development is expected to generate 511 new peak hour trips and encumbers two lots. Pursuant to Table 2.05A, these two lots have a maximum peak 'allocation' of 429 peak hour trips. Pursuant to 2.05.02(G)(2)(a), a development may exceed the allocated parcel budget if the development will contribute substantially to the economic objectives found in the Comprehensive Plan." The TIA assumes a reduction of 161 pass-by trips to the total 672 trips generated by the WinCo, as shown in Table 5 of the TIA. As discussed in the section of this report titled "Pass-By Trip Assumptions Are Inappropriate,"these pass-by trips were not properly accounted for as pass-by trips were applied to Highway 214. Pass-by trips cannot be applied to Highway 214 by definition. Correcting this error, and applying the methodology used in Figure 7 of the TIA, results in a revised estimated 672 PM peak hour trips, rather than the 511 trips reported in the staff report. 5 PROJECT TRIP GEN E R TO:°yl flew-to- petwolrlk Tulips Peak Period Si e Total,Trips Pass-k Tota. Enter i.. ter AM Peak Hou° 84.10 2•41 0 241 1:42 99 PM(Peak Hour 94. 12 672 16t 511 255 255 alillN 940 7,'552 1611 7, 9� 9,596 ,1,695 I. TN ms its equal to the PM pack hour psby volumes.'The total)d OV pasby vo1 uuna is,exIpected to be hiii her, Table 5 of the TIA The site has a maximum peak hour vehicle trip budget of 429 trips under Table 2.05A of the WDO. The TIA notes that "pursuant to WDO section 2.05.02(G)(2)(a), development may exceed the identified Parcel Budget." However, this is not merely a theoretical possibility. Table 5 demonstrates that the WinCo store alone would generate approximately 672 weekday PM peak hour trips, substantially exceeding the 429-trip allocation for Subarea K, while land within the subarea remains available for future development but without any corresponding IMA capacity and eroding the capacity for the entire IMA. Because the IMA overlay functions primarily as a transportation capacity preservation mechanism, the failure to provide a quantitative comparison between the project's trip generation and the remaining trip allocation represents a substantive deficiency in the TIA. In 8 265 addition, both the City and the applicant have miscalculated the project's trip generation by improperly accounting for pass-by trips, which understates the project's actual PM peak hour trip generation. Without an accurate trip calculation and a clear accounting of the remaining trip capacity within Subarea K, the City cannot meaningfully evaluate how the proposed development affects the cumulative trip budget established under WDO 2.05. As a result, the record does not provide a sufficient basis for defensible findings that the proposal complies with WDO 2.05 or that an exception to the trip cap is warranted consistent with the Comprehensive Plan's transportation policies and adopted system management framework. Pass-By Trip Assumptions Are Inappropriate The TIA applies pass-by trip credits at the Highway 214/Evergreen Road intersection where such credits are not permissible under accepted traffic engineering methodology. Figure 7 of the TIA incorrectly assigns 80 pass-by trips at the intersection, when by definition there can be zero pass- by trips on Highway 214 associated with this development.411 IH dlI�, m , I� wwMw �Iyrybrmm � �/ i mm i dip agamrnrAw ws �wp,,ww�w,ur'a /�i1 r, "u�V a e 1g »tiq �e rE �r, p i wk R �rom.(tlr �5�»cf Vex �meantilf , Ifl iFrmvrpm�rm Wdd 5mmimFnmm JHnm � �r 7 i/;,, e � � ���vry�� „ :1 1m �% d I� � ■are a %l 1I i e'�'m i /11111// rr CtimlriJr� / ll I nbnour rC tJoI Y4.C i"i4,dk X'bi—f�Irrmn�'PreFEo_{..lYFrou°A / h) aria ,,,,1 IIaNpG xx Ifil n ail 7i 9IX n tl t 1 f Jk p 4:�alh H♦ r ma�ERb JDI m { o. ., „»N Figure 7 from the TIA Illustrating Where Pass-By Trips Were Applied The TIA correctly defines "Pass-by trips are trips made as an intermediate stop from an origin to a primary destination (i.e., stopping to shop on the way home from work) by vehicles passing directly by the project driveway." 9 266 According to the Institute of Transportation Engineers (ITE) Trip Generation Handbook, "A pass- by trip is made as an intermediate stop on the way from an origin to a primary trip destination without a route diversion. Pass-by trips are attracted from traffic passing the site on an adjacent street or roadway that offers direct access to the generator. Pass-by trips are not diverted from another roadway not adjacent to the site." The method in which pass-by trips were estimated in the TIA is what the Trip Generation Handbook cautions against. This definition is clear and restrictive. Pass-by trips must (1) originate from traffic already traveling on a roadway adjacent to the site and (2) access the site directly without diverting from another roadway. Table 10 of the TIA establishes that with the project, the volume to capacity (v/c) ratio of this intersection will be 0.94. With the pass-by trip error, the TIA incorrectly reports the projected traffic volume at the intersection. A higher traffic volume may result in a different v/c at the intersection that may push against ODOT's adopted mobility standard. And as noted previously, previous analysis found this intersection operating above the mobility standard. It appears the TIA is conflating diverted trips with pass-by trips, but the two are not interchangeable. The Trip Generation Handbook defines a diverted trip as: "A diverted trip is attracted from the traffic volume on roadways within the vicinity of the generator but without direct access to the site. A diverted trip requires a diversion from a roadway not adjacent to the site to another roadway to gain direct access to the site. A diverted trip adds traffic to streets adjacent to a site and could remove a trip on streets from which it diverted." ITE further cautions: "Diverted trips are often difficult to identify. Consequently, diverted trips should be estimated in a traffic impact study only if • Reliable data reporting the percentage distribution of the three types of trips (primary, pass-by, and diverted trips) are available for the land use(s) being considered; and • The travel routes for diverted trips can be clearly established." The TIA does not provide reliable empirical data establishing the percentage of diverted trips, nor does it clearly establish the travel routes of such trips. Instead, it attempts to apply pass-by trip reductions in circumstances that meet the ITE definition of diverted trips, not pass-by trips. Pass- by estimates cannot be used as a proxy for diverted trips, as has been done here. Because trip generation forms the foundation for all subsequent capacity, queuing, and v/c ratio modeling, improper application of pass-by credits propagates throughout the entire analysis.The result is an understatement of projected traffic volumes at a critical study intersection and a corresponding overstatement of operational performance. In order to provide an accurate traffic analysis, elements of the traffic analysis will need to be redone. 10 267 TIA Opening Year Is Not Accurate The TIA models a 2026 opening year, while the Design Review Project Narrative states that the store will not open until mid to late 2027. This discrepancy directly affects background traffic volumes, applied growth rates, and cumulative impact assumptions, resulting in an inconsistent analysis. The study year must align with the reasonably anticipated opening year in order to produce defensible operational conclusions. Even a one-year difference can meaningfully affect intersection performance particularly at locations already operating near capacity if assumed growth rates approach the 0.5% maximum. At near-capacity intersections, relatively small increases in background volume can shift level of service and increase v/c ratios. By modeling an earlier opening year than what is represented in the applicant's own narrative, the TIA has understated actual opening-year conditions and associated impacts. As previously established, the Highway 214/Evergreen and Highway 214/Boones Ferry/Settlemier intersections are either over the mobility standard or very close to it. Intersection Failures Are Identified but Not Mitigated or Substantiated The TIA identifies multiple intersections projected to fail City mobility standards, yet it does not propose specific mitigation measures, evaluate feasible improvements, or demonstrate that any referenced improvements are funded or effective. The TIA states: "Based on the analysis described in this report, the following key findings have been identified: • All study locations will operate within the identified performance standard for the 2026 opening year, after completion of the project. • Two ODOT intersections are projected to operate below the LOS threshold during the 2040 PM peak hour: Highway 214 at Evergreen Road and Highway 214 at Boones Ferry Road... • Three City of Woodburn intersections are projected to operate below the LOS threshold during the 2026 opening year: Stacy Allison Way at Evergreen Road, Hayes Street at Evergreen Road, and Harvard Drive at Evergreen Road..." These statements are internally inconsistent. It is unclear how "All study locations will operate within the identified performance standard for the 2026 opening year" while simultaneously acknowledging that "Three City of Woodburn intersections are projected to operate below the LOS threshold during the 2026 opening year." 11 268 Highway 214 Intersections: Speculative Timing Adjustments Regarding deficiencies along Highway 214, the TIA relies on corridor signal timing adjustments identified as Project R10 in the City's TSP. The TIA states "Preliminary analysis suggests that with a longer cycle length this location would operate within the LOS standard." However: • There is no evidence that the signal timing project is funded. • No corridor-level operational modeling is provided. • No documentation is included demonstrating that longer cycle lengths would achieve compliance. • No evaluation is provided of trade-offs (e.g., increased delay or queue spillback at adjacent signals). It is acknowledged in the TIA that "the entire corridor should be analyzed." That analysis is not provided in the TIA. Signal timing changes that improve one intersection can degrade operations at another, particularly on coordinated corridors. Without modeling evidence, there is not substantial evidence that Highway 214/Evergreen Road or Highway 214/Boones Ferry Road will operate adequately. City Intersections:Assumed Future Signals Without Evidence Regarding the failing intersections of "Stacy Allison Way at Evergreen Road, Hayes Street at Evergreen Road, and Harvard Drive at Evergreen Road", the TIA states: "An analysis of traffic signal control at each location indicates that each will operate within the identified performance standard with the improvement." The City staff report states: "The City had identified these projects in the recently adopted TSP for updates and the engineering work has already begun on designing new signal improvements at Stacy Allison/Evergreen and Hayes and Evergreen. Harvard/Evergreen is being designed with roundabout. Construction on these important public projects is expected to be underway later this year. The TIA includes an analysis of these intersections after these improvements are completed (and the store is open) and it indicates that all three will operate within the mobility standards." However, no such analysis is provided in the TIA.There are no signalized intersection models, no phasing assumptions, no timing parameters, and no documentation of operational results with signals in place. Additionally, it is unclear whether these improvements are fully funded. No Traffic Signal Warrant Analysis The TIA also fails to provide any traffic signal warrant analysis. 12 269 The Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD) requires "An engineering study of traffic conditions, pedestrian characteristics, and physical characteristics of the location shall be performed to determine whether installation of a traffic control signal is justified at a particular location." The MUTCD further requires evaluation under the following warrants: • Warrant 1 — Eight-Hour Vehicular Volume • Warrant 2 — Four-Hour Vehicular Volume • Warrant 3 — Peak Hour • Warrant 4 — Pedestrian Volume • Warrant 5 — School Crossing • Warrant 6 — Coordinated Signal System • Warrant 7 — Crash Experience • Warrant 8 — Roadway Network • Warrant 9 — Intersection Near a Grade Crossing No warrant worksheets, traffic counts, crash evaluations, or engineering study findings are provided. Without a warrant analysis, there is no evidence that signal installation is justified, appropriate, or feasible. Driveway Access to Evergreen Road The TIA states: "According to the access requirements identified within the WDO Table 3.04A, Evergreen Road, which is a minor arterial, has a minimum driveway separation of 245 feet. The proposed driveway location provides more than 245 feet to the north (Stacy Allison Way). To the south, it provides approximately 162 feet measured from edge to edge.The project will work with City staff to provide the necessary variance documentation for the proposed driveway location." Note 1 of Table 3.04A specifies that for corner clearance and driveway spacing, "the separation should be maximized." Meeting the 245-foot separation standard appears feasible and it is unclear why the standard cannot be met. The applicant's narrative states that "Per City staff the 245-foot separation... is a guideline rather than a required standard." The City staff report similarly states, "The 245-foot separation shown in Table 3.04A is a guideline rather than a required standard. Staff can support this driveway location." This conclusion conflicts with the WDO section title, 3.04.03 Access Management: Driveway Guidelines and Standards, and with the title of Table 3.04A as "Access Requirements", with the table title quite clear that access spacing is a standard rather than a discretionary guideline. Regardless of interpretation, the spacing standard could reasonably be met in this case, yet the applicant has chosen not to meet it. 13 270 WDO Section 5.03.12 establishes the criteria for granting a variance and states: "A variance may be granted to allow a deviation from a development standard of this ordinance where the following criteria are met... (1) Strict adherence to the standards of this ordinance is not possible or imposes an excessive burden on the property owner..." It does not appear that the City has processed this deviation from the code through the variance procedures required by the WDO and it is unclear why. In addressing this criterion, the applicant's checklist states: "The Applicant is proposing this driveway location to allow easier(less circuitous)vehicle access into the site as well as more direct fire access to the building Fire Department Connection (FDC)that is on the southwest side of the building..." There is no evidence that the Fire District has requested this deviation. Neither the applicant's narrative nor the City staff report demonstrates that the access spacing standard cannot be met or that compliance would impose an excessive burden on the property owner. Rather, the minimal justification provided reflects a preference for a more convenient driveway location. The purpose of access spacing standards is safety. Convenience alone does not appear to satisfy the variance criteria established in WDO 5.03.12. RRFB and Proximity to Evergreen Driveway The site plan shows a proposed "Mid-Block Crossing with RRFB @ Intersection of Oxford St. & Evergreen Rd." An RRFB (Rectangular Rapid Flashing Beacon) is intended to enhance pedestrian safety at uncontrolled crossings by providing a high-visibility, active warning to motorists. It is unclear whether the crossing would be mid-block or at the Oxford Street intersection. In either case, its proximity to the proposed driveway may affect RRFB operations, which should be studied to ensure there are not conflicts. The TIA notes that "...WinCo will be installing RFFB's (or similar) at an existing crosswalk on Evergreen Road to provide a safe crossing of Evergreen Road to/from the project site and the existing residential properties to the east." However, no similar treatment nor marked crosswalk is evaluated or proposed at Evergreen Road/Center Street, which would provide a more direct pedestrian connection from the northeast. The TIA does not evaluate whether the proposed crossing location, treatment type, or spacing from adjacent intersections is appropriate. On pedestrian hybrid beacons (including RRFBs), the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices states: 14 271 "A pedestrian hybrid beacon may be considered for installation to facilitate pedestrian crossings at a location that does not meet traffic signal warrants (see Chapter 4C), or at a location that meets traffic signal warrants under Sections 4C.05 and/or 4C.06 but a decision is made to not install a traffic control signal... If a traffic control signal is not justified under the signal warrants of Chapter 4C and if gaps in traffic are not adequate to permit pedestrians to cross, or if the speed for vehicles approaching on the major street is too high to permit pedestrians to cross, or if pedestrian delay is excessive, the need for a pedestrian hybrid beacon should be considered on the basis of an engineering study that considers major- street volumes, speeds, widths, and gaps in conjunction with pedestrian volumes, walking speeds, and delay." The TIA provides no evidence of traffic signal warrants or any study of the proposed pedestrian crossing location. Without such an analysis, it is not possible to determine whether the proposed crossing adequately addresses pedestrian safety or operational concerns. Approved Developments Not Clearly Accounted For The TIA states: "In addition to the background traffic growth, the following pipeline development projects have been identified near the study area and have been included in the forecast: • Allison Way Apartments (Phases 1 & 2) • Specht Industrial Development • Brighton Pointe Subdivision (Phases 1 & 2) • 9008 Parr Rd Subdivision (assumed 75%complete) • Smith Creek Development (assumed 75% complete) • Unitus Community Credit Union • US Market Gas Station (Newberg Hwy location) • Mill Creek Meadows subdivision • Mill Creek Meadows II subdivision • Dove Landing subdivision (assumed 50% complete) • Marion Pointe subdivision (assumed 50% complete) • Commerce Way Industrial Park • Boones Crossing Townhouses • Parr Rd Cottages" However, the TIA does not provide sufficient detail to verify how these developments were incorporated into the analysis. No information is provided regarding land use type, size, approved trip generation, assumed build-out year, trip distribution, or the methodology used to determine partial completion percentages(e.g., 50%or 75%).There 15 272 are no trip tables, volume adjustments, or modeling summaries that isolate the contribution of each development. Without this documentation, a reviewer cannot confirm whether the correct trip generation rates were used, whether the assumed completion percentages are accurate, or whether traffic was distributed logically within the network. The absence of this supporting data prevents independent verification and limits the transparency and reproducibility of the forecast assumptions. Intersection Study Area Incomplete The TIA omits at the intersection of Evergreen Road/Center Street which could reasonably be expected to receive project-generated traffic based on logical distribution patterns and existing roadway connectivity. A defensible traffic study area should encompass all intersections where project traffic is reasonably anticipated to cause measurable operational change. Queuing Analysis and Simulation Is Absent As noted previously, the TIA does not evaluate vehicle queuing at study despite other similar traffic studies in the area having included that analysis. This omission is particularly significant given the documented congestion on Highway 214 and the proximity of ramp terminals, and closely spaced intersections. Capacity metrics such as v/c ratio or level of service alone do not capture 95th percentile queues, spillback probability, blocked intersections, or the potential to impede upstream intersections. These operational effects are often the primary concern at facilities operating near capacity. The ODOT Analysis Procedures Manual (APM) states that "Simulation to determine queues or other measures of effectiveness should be used if v/c's exceed 0.70 and simulation shall be used if v/c's are equal to or exceed 0.90. Simulation shall also be used if existing conditions show congested conditions, (i.e. intersection queuing backs into adjacent intersections/connections) or if Agency requires it." The Highway 214 corridor certainly has several intersections that fall into this category. Similarly, the ODOT Development Review Guidelines (DRG) states: "Intersection operations analysis needs to include the effects of queuing and blocking... If traffic from the proposed development adds to or creates an overflowing storage lane and/or spills back into another intersection or rail crossing, the TIA should explore whether there are potential mitigation measures to fix overflow or spillback problems. The same goes for storage blocking queues. In cases where a TIA includes a queue analysis for an Interstate or Expressway 16 273 offramp, vehicles should have enough stopping sight distance (determined from the recent AASHTO A Policy on Geometric Design of Highways and Streets) to decelerate from the beginning of the off-ramp to stop at the end of the 95th- percentile queue. If the total traffic does not allow reasonable stopping sight distance,the TIA should state what if any mitigation measure(s) would reduce the queue on the off-ramp." Along corridors such as Highway 214 where signal spacing, ramp proximity, and high peak-hour demand are present,queue spillback can materially degrade system performance even if average delay metrics appear acceptable. Without 95th percentile queue estimates, it is not possible to determine whether turn lane storage is adequate, whether ramp terminals could experience spillback, or whether signals may queue into adjacent intersections. Failure to estimate and compare projected queues to available storage lengths is therefore a substantial analytical omission. Because queuing directly affects safety, access management, and interchange performance, its absence materially limits the City's ability to assess compliance with ODOT operational standards and adopted system management policies. Conclusion Based on this review, the Transportation Impact Analysis does not provide substantial evidence that the proposed development complies with the Woodburn Development Ordinance, the Interchange Management Area (IMA) Overlay requirements, or applicable ODOT transportation analysis requirements. The record, as currently constituted, contains material analytical gaps, internal inconsistencies, and unsupported assumptions that prevent the City from making defensible findings of compliance. The deficiencies identified in this review are not minor technical issues.They affect foundational components of the transportation analysis, including trip generation,trip distribution, study area definition, queuing evaluation, safety analysis, mitigation feasibility, and IMA trip cap compliance. Because trip generation and distribution form the basis for all subsequent operational modeling, errors or unsupported assumptions in these areas propagate throughout the analysis and undermine the reliability of the study's conclusions. Specifically: • Previous traffic analysis illustrates that the Highway 214/Evergreen and Highway 214/Boones Ferry/Settlemier failed to meet ODOT mobility standards with no evidence that these intersections have been mitigated. The WinCo TIA illustrates no near-term issues. • Multiple intersections are projected to fail mobility standards without identified, funded, or technically supported mitigation. • The application does not demonstrate compliance with the Subarea K PM peak hour trip allocation or provide sufficient accounting to support an exception under WDO 2.05. 17 274 • Pass-by trip credits are applied inappropriately, materially understating net new traffic on Highway 214 and for the project as a whole. • The opening-year analysis does not align with the applicant's stated construction timeline. • No analysis, including traffic signal warrant analysis, is provided to justify assumed signalization. • Safety, pedestrian crossing, and access management issues are not evaluated. • Adjustments to background traffic and pipeline development assumptions are not documented in a manner that allows independent verification. Under WDO 3.04.05, where a development would fail to meet a transportation performance standard or could hinder public safety, mitigation must be clearly identified and demonstrated to be effective and concurrent with development. The current TIA instead relies on speculative future improvements, unverified signal timing adjustments and fails to consider previous results that illustrated failed intersections. These elements do not provide the evidentiary basis necessary for the City to conclude that transportation impacts have been adequately mitigated. Until these deficiencies are corrected, the City cannot make defensible findings that: • The proposal complies with the IMA Overlay District trip budgeting framework; • Adopted mobility standards will be met; or • Required mitigation is identified, feasible, and concurrent with development. For these reasons, approval of the application in its current form is not supported by substantial evidence in the record. Sincerely, p P R o,� GINS Rick Nys, P.E. 61474 Principal Traffic Engineer Digitally signed by Rick Nys pat N2026.03.09 2111.58-0-00' OREGON) f RENEWS:: 12/31/2026 18 275 �� bt A - � � lJregon Department of Transportation Delivery&Operations Division-Region 2 Tina Kotek, Governor Headquarters &Tech Center 455 Airport Road SE Building B Salem, Oregon 97301-5395 Telephone (503) 986-2600 Fax (503) 986-2630 March 12,2026 Chris Kerr,Director Woodburn Community Development Department 270 Montgomery Street Woodburn,Oregon 97071 Dear Chris, This letter is in response to a public hearing notice received by ODOT Development Review staff,Brion Scott,via the US Postal Service for a WinCo supermarket with access taken from Center Street and Stacy Allison Way. Comments concerning transportation impacts related to the WinCo development proposal were provided by Brion in February 2026 (Attached). This correspondence ties those comments to overall transportation planning considerations in the identified interchange management area(IMA)for Woodburn.Mitigation measures addressing transportation impacts at the intersection of Evergreen Road and OR214 were recommended in Brion's comment letter to protect the safety and operations of local state highways. Those recommendations have not been reflected in the conditions of approval found in a March 5'2026, staff report articulating the Winco proposal. ODOT requests that the mitigation measures detailed in the attached comment letter be included in the conditions of approval to protect the safety and operations of local state highways. The proposed WinCo development applies to a parcel within the IMA(see Table 2.05A in the currently adopted WDO). As you are aware,local ordinance provisions implementing the Woodburn Interchange Area Management Plan(IAMP), and governing the IMA,are the mechanism that assures compliance with Transportation Planning Rule(TPR)provisions addressing highway capacity,particularly where development proposals could significantly affect highway operations. A significant effect determination(per OAR 660-012-0060)is triggered when planned traffic generation,measured by volume to capacity (v/c),exceeds the mobility target for a facility identified in the Oregon Highway Plan. ODOT also recommends the City and ODOT work together to update and amend the local IAMP. An amendment to the IAMP could focus on the peak hour vehicle trips and could be expedited via a refinement or update to the established IAMP process. Amending the Woodburn IAMP to address current capacity issues would be in the best interest of ODOT Region 2 and the City. Doing so could benefit Woodburn by addressing constraints on economic development while ensuring that ODOT protects the safety and function of roads in the vicinity of the Woodburn I-5 interchange. This is particularly important when considering potential safety impacts related to ramp congestion and queue spillage onto the travel lanes of I-5. Having recurring back-ups from the ramp terminal intersections onto I-5 is a major safety concern. Please include this correspondence in the record of proceedings for DR 25-14,PLA 25-04, SA 26-01 & VAR 25-06 and send the final decision to Naomi.ZWERDLING( odot.oregon.goy and ODOTR2PLANMGR(a(odot.oregon.goy. Thank you. Sincerely yours, M,wmi Zweuding Naomi Zwerdling Region 2 Planning and Development Review Manager Oregon Department of Transportation 276 March 12, 2026 I have over 3 decades of experience with land use and transportation in Oregon, including 8 years as a Planning Commissioner in Clackamas County. There is considerable concern and opposition to the proposed Winco store because of the unacceptable impacts that include safety concerns for pedestrians, bicyclists and drivers. The opposition is well founded and is not an outright rejection of a store at the site. Woodburn is one of the fasted growing cities in Oregon. The ability to accommodate rapid growth creates undue strain on the transportation system and other critical needs. The need for commercial stores is in the mix, but that does not justify an approval. The 84,000 sq ft facility is best described as a warehouse store. The scale of the project raises questions that have not been adequately considered by the applicant. A major concern is the traffic impacts that have already been expressed by many in the community. The plan and traffic analysis fail to ensure that safety and mobility will not be compromised. The volume of large trucks and their interaction with other transportation modes fails to provide adequate separation. The risk of crashes is inherent. Previous crash history and projections do not provide compelling evidence the design is not flawed. The access/egress on Evergreen is a problematic design due to the curved design and limited width. Additionally, the location of a bus shelter on Evergreen creates safety issues for transit riders. Another concern is that a single business should not be allowed to capture an unreasonable number of "trips" that are reserved for future growth in the Comprehensive Plan. The application indicates that traffic analysis was revised to include schools, however the statistics presented are from September 2024 and are out of date and not applicable. Peak 3:00-6:OOPM hour traffic is growing and includes an increasing number of large trucks. Woodburn's emergence as a distribution center is good for the economy but brings commercial traffic that is already choking the area during peak hours from 3:00-6:OOPM. 277 The Staff recommendation includes options to approve or deny the application. It fails to consider the possibility of delaying the decision until a future meeting, an option that would be prudent. Based on the current design, I am requesting the application be denied. Les Poole 278 • Outlook Fw: Winco objections From Fernando Torres <Fernando.Torres@ci.woodburn.or.us> Date Fri 3/13/2026 4:32 PM To deirdre.totten@gmail.com <deirdre.totten@gmail.com> Thanks, Deirdre. I have entered it into the record and will provide it to the Planning Commission. Fernando rr Associate Planner (503) 982-5242 City Website I Community Development Department 270 Montgomery St, Woodburn, OR 97071 From: Deirdre Totten <deirdre.totten@gmail.com> Sent: Friday, March 13, 2026 9:39 AM To: Chris Kerr<Chris.Kerr@ci.woodburn.or.us> Subject: Winco objections m�;ndc.r. E.Ncr�.� c cau C (.1rCh irons frmn uunhnow To Whom It May Concern, We are writing as follow-up to the public testimony we provided at the recent Planning Commission meeting regarding the proposed WinCo development at the intersection of Evergreen Road and Center Street in Woodburn, Oregon. First and foremost, we want to reiterate that we strongly oppose the construction of a WinCo at this location. As stated in our testimony, we believe the project, as proposed, would significantly and negatively impact the surrounding residential neighborhood in terms of traffic, lighting, security, and overall neighborhood character. 279 However, if the City and the developer ultimately decide to proceed with the project despite the concerns raised by nearby residents, we respectfully request that several important modifications be required in order to protect the quality of life, safety, and property values of those who live directly adjacent to the site. 1. No Signage on the Evergreen-Facing Rear of the Building The rear of the building, which faces Evergreen Road and the nearby homes, should have no signage whatsoever. In particular, illuminated signage—such as WinCo's typical red glowing letters—would shine directly into neighboring homes and create an unnecessary light intrusion for residents. This is especially unnecessary given that the store will already have extensive signage on the opposite side of the building facing Interstate 5, where it is most visible to the traveling public. As a point of comparison, the neighboring Walmart building does not display signage on the rear of its building. Maintaining consistency with that approach would be appropriate and would demonstrate consideration for the residential community that directly borders the commercial area. 2. Relocation of the Bus Stop to Center Street We strongly request that any planned bus stop be located on Center Street rather than Evergreen Road. Placing a bus stop on Evergreen would raise both privacy and safety concerns for nearby homes, as people waiting for the bus would have a direct view into neighboring residences. Additionally, Evergreen Road carries heavier traffic, and buses stopping there would create traffic backups as vehicles wait behind a stopped bus. Center Street is significantly less traveled and would provide a safer and more appropriate location for a bus stop. It would also place riders closer to the primary entrance of the store. 3. Installation of Tall, Mature Trees Along the Rear of the Property The rear portion of the development that faces Evergreen should include the planting of tall trees that will mature to effectively screen the large brick facade of the building from nearby homes. Without this landscaping, the building will create a substantial visual impact and become an ongoing eyesore for the surrounding neighborhood. 4. Construction of a Solid Wall Along the Evergreen / Jonah Place Side We also request that a brick or cinder block wall be constructed along the Evergreen side of the development near the Jonah Place cul-de-sac. To avoid any 280 misunderstanding, this wall should be built on the side of the road where the existing homes are located, rather than on the WinCo development side of the street. This wall should be built at the developer's expense and would serve several important purposes: it would provide privacy and security for nearby residents, reduce the ability for individuals to look directly into front yards and into the windows at the front of nearby homes, and help shield the neighborhood from the visual and activity impacts of a 24-hour commercial operation. Such a barrier would also help protect neighborhood property values by providing a clear separation between the residential area and the commercial development. We respectfully ask that these modifications be seriously considered if the project moves forward. These measures would help mitigate the most significant impacts on the surrounding neighborhood and demonstrate a commitment to balancing commercial development with the rights and well-being of nearby residents. Finally, if possible, we would appreciate being informed about the current status of the review process and any opportunities for further public input as decisions regarding this development are made. Thank you for your time and consideration of these concerns Deirdre Rickard and Matt Rickard Real Estate Broker MORE Realty 503 750-6296 deirdre.totten@gmail.com Licensed in the state of Oregon 281 Outlook Objection to Winco building- revised From Deirdre Totten <deirdre.totten@gmail.com> Date Sat 4/4/2026 10:25 AM To Planning <Planning@ci.woodburn.or.us>; Chris Kerr <Chris.Kerr@ci.woodburn.or.us>; Fernando Torres <Fernando.Torres@ci.woodburn.or.us> , , , 11ris(nnnafl k frm a n EX ll R N �L se n�'.r, .Ncr�k c'au t1 o n �1�n�,un op(nri n 1 uu1 ����nunn run�.m or�� rcI fuunhs frmnn unnrh now n s un��;rs ern"unun�; be�t1 d noafll , , , , Dear Mr. Kerr, Members of the Planning Commission, and City Council, I am writing to resubmit and supplement my prior letter regarding the proposed construction of the WinCo grocery store planned near my residence. Since submitting my original correspondence, we have identified additional concerns that we believe warrant your consideration. My husband and I reside directly across the street from the proposed development at 3234 Jonah Place, Woodburn, Oregon 97071. Due to the immediate proximity of this project, we will be directly and significantly impacted. Our objections are based on the following concerns: First, the proposed construction period—anticipated to last approximately one and a half years—will create sustained and excessive noise, disruption, and disturbance. This will substantially interfere with our ability to enjoy our home, our property, and our overall quality of life. Second, once construction is complete, the building and associated lighting will have permanent impacts. Bright exterior and security lighting will shine directly into our bedroom and living areas, disrupting both privacy and nighttime living conditions. In addition, increased noise from deliveries, traffic, and general commercial operations will create an ongoing disturbance. 282 Third, the development will result in a substantial increase in traffic in the immediate residential area, leading to greater congestion, noise, and heightened safety concerns for nearby homeowners and pedestrians. This impact is likely to be significantly greater than originally anticipated, particularly due to the recent construction of a large apartment complex directly adjacent to the proposed WinCo site. As those residential units become occupied, the additional traffic generated— combined with that of a major grocery store—will place an excessive burden on an already impacted area. Further, the intersection at Evergreen Road and Stacy Allison Way presents a serious concern. Large delivery trucks already struggle to safely navigate this corner, often blocking traffic while turning. The addition of regular semi-truck deliveries to the proposed site will exacerbate this issue and create an ongoing safety hazard. It is evident that this intersection would require substantial redesign to safely accommodate the increased volume and size of traffic. Fourth, the structure itself will block our existing view. Instead of open space, we will be faced with the rear of a large commercial building appearing as a solid wall, fundamentally altering the character and livability of our property. From our front porch, we currently enjoy unobstructed sunset views, which will be completely eliminated by this development. Additionally, we have concerns regarding the proposed bus stop location associated with this development. The current proposal places the bus stop directly across from a children's park. This raises significant safety concerns, as it introduces a gathering point immediately adjacent to an area where children are regularly present. We are concerned about the implications of increased foot traffic and unknown individuals in close proximity to the park. Furthermore, we believe the addition of a bus stop in this location could increase the potential for theft and other criminal activity within the neighborhood. There are known concerns at other WinCo locations, including in the Clackamas area, where similar gathering points have been associated with increased crime and drug-related activity. We are concerned that similar patterns could emerge here. In addition, we are deeply concerned about the environmental impact of this development. The open field where the project is proposed currently supports a significant amount of natural wildlife, including a community of Kestrel falcons, 283 and other species. Development of this land will displace these animals and permanently eliminate an existing natural habitat. Additionally, we believe this development will significantly diminish surrounding residential property values. As a licensed real estate broker with over 26 years of experience, I can state that this is not merely an opinion, but a professional assessment based on market behavior and the impact that large-scale commercial developments have on adjacent residential properties. Finally, if the project were to move forward despite these concerns, we strongly request the installation of a substantial barrier wall between the development and neighboring homes. There is already an example of this type of construction just one block away along Evergreen Road, where a cinderblock wall runs along the rear of residential properties and provides an effective visual and sound barrier. Implementing a similar structure here would be consistent with the existing neighborhood design and would help mitigate some of the negative impacts. Taken together, these impacts will negatively affect surrounding residential properties and diminish the overall character, safety, and livability of the neighborhood. For these reasons, we respectfully request that the City reconsider and not move forward with this development at the proposed location. The impact on nearby homeowners is substantial and long-lasting, and we believe these concerns warrant careful and serious consideration by the Planning Commission and City Council. Thank you for your time and attention to this matter. We appreciate your consideration. Sincerely, Deirdre Rickard Matthew Rickard 3234 Jonah Place Woodburn, OR 97071 284 • Outlook Concerns about proposed Winco site From Matthew rickard <shakrmakr@gmail.com> Date Sat 4/4/2026 11:39 AM To Planning <Planning@ci.woodburn.or.us> Cc Cassandra Bassich <Cassandra.Bassich@ci.woodburn.or.us>; Chris Kerr <Chris.Kerr@ci.woodburn.or.us>; Cassandra Bassich <Cassandra.Bassich@ci.woodburn.or.us> Wi 1 attachment(2 MB) Kestrel Falcon along Evergreen.png; , Yh m e nnad k frorn anon H.X ll R ,r1.se na'l.a r, �,aara�aama a;anurflarun r�1�na�,un arlbarnlanl a n��aa�.�nunnarun�.�m or aa�la�alr:iuunhs frarunn uuurlrrnarr un s and rim or uuunc,aNp a.1ad a�,annaul. , , , To the Woodburn Planning Commission: My name is Matt Rickard, and I live at 3234 Jonah PI, Woodburn, OR 97071. I have heard, read and reviewed the proposal to build a Winco store in Woodburn between Stacy Allison Way and Evergreen Rd. I attended and testified at the March 12 Planning Commission meeting, but I have some additional concerns that have come to light which I would like to share with you as the Commission evaluates the decision to approve or disapprove this proposal. • As I stated at the March 12 meeting, there is a serious traffic concern for this development. But I have since read reports suggesting the traffic impact analysis referenced in the meeting likely significantly understated the estimated traffic burden this development would cause. I also believe that the existing apartment development on Stacy Allison Way has not been factored into this traffic assessment. This apartment development is nearly complete, and will add hundreds of vehicles every day to Stacy Allison and Evergreen, even before any work on this Winco project would commence. Adding the Winco will create a huge traffic mess, regardless of the proposed road improvements. • Complicating this traffic situation is the intersection at Evergreen Rd. and Stacy Allison Way. This is the proposed truck route for deliveries to the Winco. Currently, some trucks already use this route to park at Walmart or on Center St. Huge delays and bottlenecks occur at this intersection when trucks turn either way. Adding Winco will severely worsen this situation. • With the proposed bus stop on Evergreen Rd, there are a number of serious concerns. The current proposal places the bus stop on the back side of the Winco, on Evergreen Rd, with no pullout for the bus. With the aforementioned increased traffic on Evergreen Rd, this would block up traffic on an already busy street. Additionally, this proposed site is directly across from a neighborhood playground, on the corner of Evergreen Rd. and Skyler Dr. This would potentially 285 expose the children playing there to predators who may be riding the buses. This would give potential predators direct access to children who regularly use this playground. The increased traffic from the proposed bus stop could endanger children playing in this playground if they need to cross the street or if balls enter the roadway. • This proposed bus stop would also increase the potential for theft in our adjacent neighborhood, as bus riders would be brought directly to the entrance of our neighborhood. If there absolutely must be a bus stop, a different location must be considered. • Our opportunity to view the beautiful sunsets to the West would be completely eliminated. Currently we can sit on our front porch and see the sky lit up in color during beautiful sunsets. The proposed Winco would obliterate this view, completely blocking our ability to see it at all. • The additional lighting in this proposal will be a huge eyesore for neighbors. With light shining directly into our homes all night, this would significantly and negatively impact our quality of life. • I am very concerned about the negative impact this project will have on the property values of my home and others in the surrounding areas. Specifically, my Evergreen Meadows neighborhood will be most impacted. Because potential homebuyers might hesitate to purchase a home directly across from a concrete structure, I will have to lower my asking price significantly to attract buyers. My wife has been a real estate broker for over 2 decades, and has seen this exact situation occur many times. • First and foremost, we are strongly opposed to this Winco proposal. But if it were approved, we strongly urge the council and builders to erect a wall along Evergreen Rd. adjacent to our neighborhood. This same kind of structure was erected along Evergreen Rd.just a block or so to to the North, to protect the adjacent neighborhoods across the street from the Country Meadows Village Retirement facilities. Erecting the same kind of wall next to the Evergeeen Meadows neighborhood across from Winco would at least be consistent with the others on Evergreen Rd., and provide some shielding and protection for our adjacent neighborhood. • I have serious concerns about the wildlife in the area. There are natural wildlife like birds, Owls and birds of prey, call this area home. Specifically, I have watched a community of Kestrel Falcons that perch and roost in the exact location of this proposed Winco site. I see them almost daily on the lampposts around that field, and I believe they would be displaced by this project. I am including a picture I took of a juvenile Kestrel that landed on a fence adjacent to this proposed building site for reference. 286 I ask that the Planning Commission seriously consider these additional concerns as they weigh the decision of approving or disapproving this Winco project. I thank you for your time and consideration, Matt & Deirdre Rickard 3234 Jonah PI Woodburn, OR 97071 sarmarC�?gmail.com 287 ALEM AU DU BO N rl , VIIIIIIII' Illll r PO BOX 2084 Salem OR 9.7308 wwwsaLeriauduboain. org. ............................................................................................................................... April 9, 2026 City of Woodburn Planning Commission 270 Montgomery Street, Woodburn Oregon Re: Winco proposal, Case Files: DR 25-14, VAR 25-06, PLA 25-04, & SA 26-01 Dear Commissioners: The Salem Audubon Society works within Marion, Polk and Yamhill Counties to connect people with nature and promote conservation of wildlife and its habitat. In keeping with that mission, I am writing to encourage the Commission to carefully consider the potential environmental impacts presented by the Winco proposal. Several issues in the record raise clear environmental concerns that fall within Salem Audubon's ambit. The site of proposed development is about the last substantial area of habitat in the general area for grassland birds and associated wildlife, such as the American kestrels that are regularly observed by residents. The parcel has been identified as one of the last undeveloped grass/field areas in this corridor; paving it would be a grievous loss of habitat. The cumulative habitat fragmentation this proposal presents would further the area's steady loss of open space; additional fragmentation further reduces available territory for myriad species. The proposal for 24-hour lighting would further degrade whatever habitat values might remain, such as for migrating birds whose navigation abilities are severely hampered by excessive artificial light. For resident birds, continuous lighting can disrupt hunting behavior and displace sensitive raptors that rely on darker, open edges. This could subject the area to an increase in undesirable rodents. There are also water quality concerns. As is well-noted in other testimony, the natural infiltration currently present would be lost and runoff would carry pollutants to downstream waters and habitats. Finally, I must note that it is not just wildlife that would be adversely impacted. It is well known that people need natural areas; without the stimulus of natural variability children are deprived of essential means of cognitive development. Although the site is not large, it is about all there is in the immediate area. Destroying or unduly compromising its natural value would be a disproportionate loss to residents and workers. I urge you to prevent this habitat destruction, or at least, if the project must go forward, to do your utmost to fully consider the impacts and to protect whatever habitat values can be protected. Sincerely, Michael Babbitt, President, Salem Audubon Society ,Icy,fq„ sallei� �audulloi .oir 288 Andrew Mulkey Attorney at Law PO Box 66562, Portland, OR 97290 • (503) 334-9899 • andrew@mulkeylegal.com April 9, 2026 Via Email City of Woodburn Planning Commission c/o Chris Kerr, Community Development Director 270 Montgomery Street Woodburn, OR 97071 Chris.Kerr@ci.woodburn.or.us Re: Protect Our Valley Alliance, Planning Commission Comment Letter for Land Use Application for Proposed WinCo Foods Transportation, Environmental, and Neighborhood Impacts Dear Chair and Members of the Planning Commission: I represent Protect Our Valley Alliance, a coalition of Woodburn residents, workers, and community stakeholders concerned about the transportation, environmental, and neighborhood impacts of the proposed WinCo Foods development. The Alliance supports growth that is consistent with the Woodburn Comprehensive Plan, protects public safety, and ensures that development does not impose disproportionate burdens on surrounding neighborhoods. First, I write to make a correction to the prior letter I submitted. In that letter, I cited to WDP 2.05.02(G)(2) as the requirement that a proposal that exceeds the maximum peak hour vehicle trip limit must "contribute substantially to the economic objectives found in the Comprehensive Plan." The citation to subsection (G)(2) or (G)(2)(a) for that requirement is wrong. The correct citation is WDP 2.05.02(G)(1), specifically WDP 2.05.02(G)(1)(a): Land use applications subject to the provisions of this Section shall comply with the following: Planning Commission Open Record Comment Letter: Protect Our Valley Alliance 1 of 3 289 1. Peak hour vehicle trips generated by the proposed development shall not exceed the maximum peak hour vehicle trips specified in Table 2.05A for the subject parcel, except: a. Development may be allowed to exceed the maximum, if the development will contribute substantially to the economic objectives found in the Comprehensive Plan. WDP 2.05.02(G). I ask that you please review my prior comment letter with that correction in mind. The applicant has failed to comply with WDO 2.05.02(G) because it has failed to demonstrate that the development will contribute substantially to the economic objectives found in the Comprehensive Plan. In particular, the comprehensive plan explains its objectives include "[u]pgrad[ing] the skills of the local labor pool." Policy E-1.9. The letter submitted by UFCW Local 555 demonstrates exactly why the proposed WinCo does NOT contribute substantially to the economic objectives described in the comprehensive plan. The Planning Commission should review the letter from UFCW Local 555 with the requirements of WDO 2.05.02(G) in mind. As UFCW Local 555 explained, WinCo does not support union jobs, and its "business model relies on low wages, unpredictable scheduling, and minimal staffing levels." UFCW Local 555 also describes that when large, non-union stores like WinCo open, "existing union and independent grocers often experience reduced sales, cuts to worker hours, and long-term job instability." That impact results in the opposite outcome of the economic objectives described in the comprehensive plan. Rather that substantially contributing to upgrading the skills of the local labor pool, a store like WinCo will degrade the stability of the labor pool and will not upgrade worker's skills. Other economic objectives include F-2, the goal of"enhance[ing] the quality of the city workforce..." and the policy to "support the development of a skilled, versatile workforce...." Approval of WinCo's low-wage commercial use with unpredictable staffing runs counter to the City's objective. For that reason as well, I ask that you deny the applicant's proposal. For those reasons, the planning commission has an adequate basis to deny the applicant's proposal. In addition to the traffic impacts and other impacts described Planning Commission Open Record Comment Letter: Protect Our Valley Alliance 2 of 3 290 by numerous commenters, the applicant has failed to demonstrate that it will "contribute substantially" the City's "economic objectives." There is no reason to approve a use that undercuts the objective of developing a skilled labor pool and good jobs within the City. Respectfully, Andrew Mulkey (OSB No. 171237) PO Box 66562 Portland, OR 97290 (503) 334-9989 andrew@mulkeylegal.com On behalf of Protect Our Valley Alliance Planning Commission Open Record Comment Letter: Protect Our Valley Alliance 3 of 3 291 Andrew Mulkey Attorney at Law PO Box 66562, Portland, OR 97290 • (503) 334-9899 • andrew@mulkeylegal.com April 21, 2026 Via Email City of Woodburn Planning Commission c/o Chris Kerr, Community Development Director 270 Montgomery Street Woodburn, OR 97071 Chris.Kerr@ci.woodburn.or.us Re: Objection to Applicant's Final Rebuttal DR 25-14, PLA 25-04, SA 26-01, VAR 25-06 Proposed WinCo Foods Grocery Store Tax Lots 052W12C002100 and 052W12C002200 Dear Chair and Members of the Planning Commission: I write to object to the applicant's submission of its April 16, 2026 letter and attachments A and B. Because the applicant's April 16 submissions violate the requirements of ORS 197.797(6), I ask that the planning commission reject or otherwise strike the applicant's April 16th letter and attachments from the record. The applicant's submission unfairly and improperly deprived the applicant's opponents of their statutory right to respond to the applicant's submissions during the response period provided by ORS 197.797(6)(c). For those reasons, the planning commission must reject the applicant's letters, or allow participants the opportunity to respond.' Failure to take either of those options violates the public's substantial right to respond, and provides the basis for remand on appeal. Id. ' In response to evidence that exceeds the scope of what ORS 197.797(6)(c) allows, LUBA has determined that a hearings authority "either should have rejected that additional evidence.., or given petitioner an opportunity to rebut that additional evidence." Grahn v. City of Yamhill, 76 Or LUBA 258 (LUBA No 2017-070, Oct 26, 2017) (slip op at 17) (citing Dept. of 11ansportation v City of Eugene 38 Or LUBA 814, 838 (2000); Brome a City of Corvallis, 36 Or LUBA 225, 234-35 (1999)); Woodstock Neigh. Ass'11 a City ofPortland, 28 Or LUBA 146 (1994) (citing Fasano v. Washington County, 264 Or 574 (1973)). Planning Commission Objection Letter: Protect Our Valley Alliance 1 of 6 292 A. The Applicant's April 16, 2026 Submissions Violate ORS 197.797. ORS 197.797 allows for two distinct comment periods after an initial hearing during which the record may be held open for additional evidence and testimony. The first comment period must be "at least seven days" and is commonly referred to as the first open record period or the open record period. ORS 197.797(6)(a), (c). During the open record period, any participant may "present additional evidence, arguments or testimony regarding the application."Id. (6)(a). This allows participants to comment on any information submitted at, or prior to, the hearing. Here, the planning commission opened the record pursuant to ORS 197.797(6)(a), (c) for 28 days, until April 9, 2026. Thereafter, statute allows the hearings authority to "reopen the record." ORS 197.797(6)(c). This second open record period must also be "at least seven days," but the statute limits the information that a person may submit. Id. When the hearings authority reopens the record pursuant to ORS 197.797(6)(c) it does so only to provide "an opportunity to respond to new evidence during the period the record was left open."Id. (6)(c). For that reason, this period is commonly referred to as the "response"period. Unlike the first open record period, the response period only allows participants to respond to new evidence submitted during the first open record period. See Grahn v. City of Yamhill, 76 Or LUBA 258 (LUBA No 2017-070, Oct 26, 2017) (slip op 15-16) (citing Freedman v. City of Grants Pass, 57 Or LUBA 385, 393 (2008) and Brome v. City of Corvallis, 36 Or LUBA at 234). Any evidence included in the applicant's April 16 letter, "must be limited to evidence to `respond to new evidence submitted during the period the record was left open." Grahn, (slip op at 16) (quoting ORS 197.797(6)(c) (former ORS 197.763)). In this case, the response period ran from April 10 to April 16. During the response period, the applicant could only respond to new evidence submitted by participants after the hearing between March 13 and April 9. ORS 197.797(6)(c). The applicant violated the statute and the planning commission must strike or otherwise reject the letters. Planning Commission Objection Letter: Protect Our Valley Alliance 2 of 6 293 B. The Applicant's Letter and Attachments Contain New Evidence, and The Public Has a Right to Respond. The applicant's April 16 letter referenced attachments inappropriately respond to evidence and testimony submitted prior to the March 12, 2026 planning commission hearing. The applicant's April 16, 2026 letter explains that it responds with Attachment A (an unsigned Technical Memo by a planner at GVC Transportation Solutions), to evidence and testimony submitted prior to the hearing. The GVC planner's memo responds to a letter by Greenlight Engineering, submitted on March 11, 2026. Attachment B also states that it responds to PO VA's letter submitted on March 11, 2026 and the issues that POVA raised in that letter. Both the GVC technical memo and Attachment B include new evidence that the public and POVA have a right to respond to. Although GVC's memo was drafted by a planner and not an engineer, it still seeks to provide technical evidence and professional opinion. LUBA has determined that such expert submissions "frequently, if not inevitably, introduce 'new' technical evidence or professional opinion, even if the expert is simply commenting on evidence already in the record." Rogue Advocates v. Josephine County, (LUBA 2014-095/96, October 15, 2025) (slip op at 8). Here, the expert letter clearly contains or meets the definition of"evidence," defined as "facts, documents, data or other information offered to demonstrate compliance with the standards believed by the proponent to be relevant to the decision."Haugen v. City of Scappoose, (LUBA 2023-001, April 20, 2024) (slip op at 5) (quoting ORS 197.797(9)). The GVC letter makes statements and provides professional opinions about evidence that is not currently in the record. The letter makes numerous assertions about the opinions and actions of third-parties like the city or ODOT apparently based on conversations or review of evidence that is not in the record. Those professional opinions all constitute new "evidence" within the meaning of ORS 197.797(9). The public has a right to respond to that evidence because the applicant was required to submit those comments during the open record period. ORS 197.797(6). The letter includes opinions and conclusions, prefaced by phrases like "[w]e would expect ...," "[i]t is typical to expect...," and "this is a common technique...," as well as references to analysis, studies, events, and conversations Planning Commission Objection Letter: Protect Our Valley Alliance 3 of 6 294 that are not in the record. The author provides numerous assertions and opinions about extra-record evidence. These opinions and references to extra-record conversations and studies are in and of themselves a form of"evidence;" the document seeks to present information in the form of asserted facts and professional opinion in an attempt to not only respond to Greenlight's analysis but also demonstrate compliance with standards that the applicant believes are relevant. ORS 197.797(9). For those reasons, it is clear that the entire memo constitutes evidence in the form of the author's professional opinion about various topics. The letter also demonstrates that it was drafted specifically to respond to evidence submitted prior to the open record period. All of those reasons support PO VA's motion to strike. The Applicant's Attachment B does not fare any better. The letter provides multiple opinions and assertions of fact by the applicant. Attachment B cites Newsweek articles, explains details about stock ownership plans, insurance benefits, and provides details about its broader business plans and operations. None of that information appears to be in the record. Moreover, the letter contains numerous characterizations and personal opinions about the facts on the ground, such as opinions about what the project may or may not "enhance" or improve, statements about how various "fees" will be used, opinions about how customers would use the proposed improvements, and statements about what laws the applicant proposes to "abide by." Those too, meet the definition of new evidence under ORS 197.797(9). These are all opinions and statements of fact that constitute information that the applicant has presented for the purpose of demonstrating compliance with the approval criteria that the applicant believes is relevant. Finally, the letter walks through numerous criteria that the applicant asserts are relevant to the decision. Yet those criteria do not appear to have been included in the initial public notice as required by ORS 197.797(3)(b) and (5)(a). The City's failure to provide that notice provides an alternative basis for remand. For those reasons, the planning commission should strike or reject the applicant's April 16 submissions. Planning Commission Objection Letter: Protect Our Valley Alliance 4 of 6 295 C. Conclusion and Remedy: Reject the Applicant's April 16 Submissions. By responding out of turn, the applicant deprived opponents and members of the public, such as POVA, of the ability to respond to the applicant's evidence during the response period. Had the applicant complied with ORS 197.797(6)(a) and (c) and submitted its response to PO VA's pre-hearing materials during the first open record period that ended on April 9, POVA would have had the opportunity to respond during the response period pursuant to ORS 197.797(6)(c). Now that time has passed, and the planning commission is scheduled for deliberations on Thursday, April 23, 2026. It is also important to note that the applicant appears to have purposefully delayed submitting its response to PO VA's pre-hearing materials. The GVC letter is dated March 19, 2026. The applicant's second letter, Exhibit B, includes a combined response to PO VA's pre-hearing March 11, 2026 letter as well as its April 9, 2026 letter that address similar topics. That makes it difficult for the planning commission to separate the legitimately submitted material from the improperly submitted material. For that reason, the appropriate remedy is to strike or reject the applicant's April 16, 2026 letters. In the alternative, POVA requests that the record be held open an additional two weeks, from April 23 to May 7, 2026, to provide opponents an adequate opportunity to respond to the evidence improperly submitted by the applicant. POVA was not expecting the applicant to flagrantly violate the procedural rules by submitting a response to its engineer's analysis on April 16, 2026. For that reason, POVA was not ready to provide a response by the April 23, 2026 hearing. In addition, prior to filing this objection, POVA also has no ability to determine whether or not the planning commission will accept any letter or evidence that responds to the applicant's late submitted evidence. The procedural rules for land use hearings do not require participants to needlessly waste time or resources. Without a ruling on this objection, POVA and members of the public cannot be expected to guess at what the planning commission's response to the applicant's procedural violation will be. POVA also asks that the planning commission not provide the applicant any further opportunity to respond, other than to provide final written rebuttal that contains argument only. ORS 197.797(6)(e), (9). Pursuant to ORS 197.797(6)(c), Planning Commission Objection Letter: Protect Our Valley Alliance 5 of 6 296 the applicant does not have a right to respond with additional evidence to evidence submitted during the response period. The framework provided by ORS 197.797 does not allow parties an "endless" opportunity to rebut new evidence. Friends of Hood River Waterfront v. City of Hood River, 67 Or LUBA 179 (2013) (describing how ORS 197.797(6)(c) applies). Finally, please note that POVA alternatively requests two weeks for the public to respond, not the one week minimum required by statute. This is because the applicant requested four weeks to respond to Greenlight's engineering analysis and ultimately used five weeks for its response. Given the need for expert analysis and review of the applicant's technical submissions, POVA asks that the planning commission provide the public a reasonable and comparable amount of time to respond. Two weeks should meet that requirement. The applicant's procedural violation now provides the planning commission the opportunity to consider providing the public an adequate response period, and such time does not impose any burden on the planning commission or the applicant. Anything less violates the public's right to a fair and impartial hearing in accordance with the rights to due process. Respectfully, Andrew Mulkey (OSB No. 171237) PO Box 66562 Portland, OR 97290 (503) 334-9989 adrew@mulkeylegal.com On behalf of Protect Our Valley Alliance Planning Commission Objection Letter: Protect Our Valley Alliance 6 of 6 297