Loading...
February 26, 2024 AgendaCITY OF WOODBURN CITY COUNCIL AMENDED AGENDA FEBRUARY 26, 2024 - 7:00 P.M. FRANK LONERGAN, MAYOR DEBBIE CABRALES, COUNCILOR WARD 1 MARK WILK, COUNCILOR WARD II ROBERT CARNEY, COUNCILOR WARD III SHARON SCHAUB, COUNCILOR WARD IV MARY BETH CORNWELL, COUNCILOR WARD V ERIC MORRIS, COUNCILOR WARD VI CITY HALL COUNCIL CHAMBERS - 270 MONTGOMERY STREET 1. CALL TO ORDER AND FLAG SALUTE 2. ROLL CALL 3. ANNOUNCEMENTS Announcements: None. 4. COMMUNITY/GOVERNMENT ORGANIZATIONS None. 5. PROCLAMATIONS/PRESENTATIONS Proclamations: None. Presentations: A. Community Center Polling Results B. Mid -Willamette Valley Community Action Agency C. Use of Force Report 1 D. Senate Bill 111 13 6. COMMUNICATIONS None. 7. BUSINESS FROM THE PUBLIC - This allows the public to introduce items for Council consideration not already scheduled on the agenda. This facility is ADA accessible. If you need special accommodation, please contact the City Recorder at 503-980- 6318 at least 24 hours prior to this meeting. **Habrd int6rpretes disponibles para aquellas personas que no hablan Ingl6s, previo acuerdo. Comunfquese al (503) 980-2485.** February 26, 2024 Council Agenda Page i 8. CONSENT AGENDA - Items listed on the consent agenda are considered routine and may be adopted by one motion. Any item may be removed for discussion at the request of a Council member. A. Woodburn City Council minutes of February 12, 2024 32 Recommended Action: Approve the minutes. B. Redflex Report - November 2023-January 2024 36 Recommended Action: Receive the report. C. Monthly Financial Report 37 Recommended Action: Receive the report. D. Silverton Fire District IT Services Support Agreement 130 Recommended Action: Authorize the City Administrator to execute an Intergovernmental Agreement with the Silverton Fire District to provide computer and network support. E. Community Center Advisory Committee Draft minutes of February 20, 140 2024 Recommended Action: Receive the minutes. 9. TABLED BUSINESS None. 10. PUBLIC HEARINGS None. 11. GENERAL BUSINESS -Members of the public wishing to comment on items of general business must complete and submit a speaker's card to the City Recorder prior to commencing this portion of the Council's agenda. Comment time may be limited by Mayoral prerogative. A. Council Bill No. 3242 - An Ordinance Amending the Woodburn 142 Development Ordinance (WDO) Related to Significant Tree Preservation, Removal, and Mitigation, and Protection During Construction (LA 21-03) Recommended Action: Adopt the attached Ordinance to implement Legislative Amendment LA 21-03 for the Woodburn Development Ordinance (WDO) relating to tree preservation and removal. B. Council Bill No. 3243 - An Ordinance Adopting Tree Removal and 199 February 26, 2024 Council Agenda Page ii Mitigation Fees as Part of the Planning Division Fee Schedule for Inclusion in the City's Master Fee Schedule (Amending Ordinance 2433) Recommended Action: Adopt the attached Ordinance updating the City Master Fee Schedule related to the Community Development Department Planning Division to implement fees for Significant Tree removal and mitigation following Legislative Amendment LA 21-03 of the Woodburn Development Ordinance (WDO). C. Council Bill No. 3244 - An Ordinance Adopting an Updated Parks 213 and Recreation Master Plan and Associated Amendments to the Woodburn Comprehensive Plan (LA 23-04) Recommended Action: Adopt the attached Ordinance to implement Legislative Amendment LA 23-04, which amends Section L of the Woodburn Comprehensive Plan and adopts the updated Parks and Recreation Master Plan. D. Council Bill No. 3245 - A Resolution Authorizing the City of Woodburn 426 Staff to Apply for a Local Government Grant from the Oregon Parks and Recreation Department for Development of Boones Crossing Park, and Delegating Authority to the City Administrator to Sign the Application Recommended Action: Adopt the attached Resolution, as required prior to LGGP grant fund application, and authorize the City Administrator to sign the grant application and to effectuate an award of the grant contract, if awarded. E. 2022/23 Oregon Community Pathways (OCP) Grant Contract from 431 Oregon Department of Transportation (ODOT) to Support Expansion of Mill Creek Trail Recommended Action: Accept the Oregon Community Pathways grant award from the Oregon Department of Transportation and authorize the City Administrator to effectuate an award of the grant contract. F. ARPA Contract Award for Mid -Willamette Valley Community 435 Action Agency for Shelter Services Recommended Action: Authorize the City Administrator to enter into an ARPA funding agreement with Mid -Willamette Valley Community Action Agency (MWVCAA) in the amount of $80,000 for Shelter Services, and authorize under ORS 197.746 for MWVCAA to operate and oversee, overnight vehicular sheltering, as part of standard operations at 1560 Hardcastle Street, Woodburn, Oregon. G. Community Center Polling Results and Project Scope Determination 760 February 26, 2024 Council Agenda Page iii Recommended Action: Receive a report on the results of the Community Center Likely Voter Survey and the recommendation from the Community CenterAdvisory Committee (CAC) and affirm the City's intent to place a bond measure on the ballot in November 2024 that would fund the fully scoped version of the Woodburn Community Center Project. 12. PLANNING COMMISSION OR ADMINISTRATIVE LAND USE ACTIONS - These are Planning Commission or Administrative Land Use actions that may be called up by the City Council. A. Council Briefing of Planning Commission approval of a Variance 762 application for AWARE Food Bank at 152 Arthur St (VAR 23-08) Recommended Action: Staff recommends no action be taken on this item and provides this summary pursuant to Woodburn Development Ordinance (WDO) Section 4.02.02. The Council may call up this item if desired and, by majority vote, initiate a review of this Commission decision. 13. CITY ADMINISTRATOR'S REPORT 14. APPOINTMENTS Appointments: B. City Councilor Ward III • Jennifer Cantu 15. OATH OF OFFICE AND ELECTION OF COUNCIL PRESIDENT A. Oath of Office for Ward III Appointment B. Election of Council President 16. MAYOR AND COUNCIL REPORTS 17. EXECUTIVE SESSION None. 18. ADJOURNMENT 764 February 26, 2024 Council Agenda Page iv WOODBURN POLICE DEPARTMENT 1060 Mt. Hood Avenue, Woodburn, Oregon 97071 Phone: (503) 982-2345 FAX: (503) 982-2371 Woodburn Police Department Annual Use of Force & Vehicle Pursuit Report 2023 Use ofForce The goal of the Woodburn Police Department is to resolve each call for service safely and peacefully. While most police service calls end with no physical force used, a small number of contacts require physical force to resolve the situation. The Woodburn Police Department's use of force is guided by department policy, state and federal law, from a reasonable officer's perspective and based upon the totality of the circumstances at the time the force was used. The Woodburn Police Department has several policies that outline the types of devices and techniques officers can use and the circumstances for use, including: • Use of Force • Control Devices and Techniques • Conducted Energy Device • Firearms • Vehicle Pursuits • Canine Program After each use of force incident, the involved Police Officer(s) are required to document the event in a Use of Force Report. The report is reviewed by the department's supervisory and command staff. At the end of each year, this annual Use of Force and Vehicle Pursuit Report is completed for review by the Chief of Police, Command Staff and survival skills instructor cadre. This report is used to evaluate current trends and techniques to address any training, equipment needs, or policy changes. Integrity + Respect + Empathy New Use ofForce Reportinram and Data Analtics Software Beginning in 2023, the Woodburn Police Department transitioned into a digital use of force reporting software, moving away from paper -based reports used in previous years. The software program has a variety of features that capture use of force information along with producing use of force summary reports, advanced reporting, and "dashboard" views of use of force encounters. This allows supervisors and survival skills instructors to review use of force incidents and events throughout the year and to improve the accuracy of data collection in use of force reporting. The software program has automated advanced reporting capabilities that capture the same or similar use of force data as in previous annual use of force reports and also groups, categorizes and/or presents the use of force information in a variety of formats when compared to previous annual use of force reports. The most significant change in this annual use of force report would be the redefinition of use of force "incidents" when compared to a use of force "event". In this annual use of force report an event is a single call for service where force was utilized, regardless of the number of officers that may have used force. A use of force incident(s) is the number of uses of force techniques utilized by one or more officers during a single use of force event. When comparing this annual report to previous years, this redefinition is an important distinction and any comparison with previously published reports should be reviewed with these changes in mind. Therefore, and expectedly, there will be more incidents involving use of force than events since it is not uncommon for multiple officers to be present when force must be utilized to resolve a potentially dangerous situation as quickly and safely as possible for officers and subjects alike. The Woodburn Police Department has also begun utilizing a new data analytics software program that allows for more accurate data aggregation, data queries and data presentation involving police calls for service and arrests. The analytic software program works with our current report management system which has been utilized to conduct data queries, provide statistics, and gather information for past annual use of force reports. The new data analytics software reduces the need to conduct time-consuming "hand" review of individual cases, incidents, police arrests for data verification and reduces the chances of human error. Integrity + Respect + Empathy 2 Use ofForce Events 2021-2023 In 2023, the Woodburn Police Department responded to approximately 14,743 calls for service, which was an increase of 998 calls for service (+7%) when compared to 2022. The number of arrests from 2022 to 2023 increased by 122 (14%) for a total of 1,024 subjects arrested and 64 use of force events. For 2023, use of force events occurred at a rate of 1 use of force event for every 16 arrests. Chart 1 2023 2022 e soot 2021 1102022 11111 2023 IIIII Chart 1 shows the number of annual use of force events for the last three years Table 1 Year ff MON Events % + or - 2021 43 39% 2022 38 -12% 2023 64 68% Table 1 shows the yearly increase or decrease f on2 the previous year. Integrity + Respect + Empathy I Table 2 # of # Involving Year Rate Arrests Force 2021 934 43 1 in 22 2022 902 38 1 in 24 2023 1,024 64 1 in 16 Table 2 shows the rate of arrests made per year and those involving the use offorce. The Woodburn Police Department received one internal complaint surrounding a use of force event in 2023. The result of the complaint found that the use of force was justified but a review found that additional de-escalation tactics could have been attempted prior to the use of force. Force Data The Woodburn Police Department records certain information from each use of force report. Gender, intoxication, suspect injury, officer injury, and the types of force used are captured in the following charts and graphs. Chart 2 60 58 50 , 39 40 33 30 20 v 10 0 , 2021 2022 2023 Chart 2 compares the number of force events involving females vs males. Integrity + Respect + Empathy W Mental Condition and/or Impairment Intoxication levels and mental condition are often a key factor when a subject becomes non -compliant, which can result in the need of the officer to utilize force to make a lawful stop, detention, or arrest. The following table indicates when officers observed the following mental conditions and/or substance impairment when force was used with a subject in 2023. Table 3 J J J 1 JJ JJ J JJJ 1� f� 1 JJ �f i Mentally Impaired 14 Suspected Alcohol or Drugs 32 Under the Influence of Alcohol or 16 Drugs Table 3 represents the number incidents of self -reported use of alcohol and/or drugs by suspects and/or officer observations. Multiple observations involving mental condition and substance impairment can be noted for the same individual. Of note, in 2023, with the new use of force reporting platform change a comparison to previous years was not made due to the difference in information aggregation and categorization. Moving forward in the following annual use of force reports a two-year comparison will be made for 2023-2024 and a three-year comparison fi^om 2023-2025. Integrity + Respect + Empathy I Types ofReported Use offorce Officers must report any use of force used that could or would likely cause injury to the suspect. Table 4 shows the type of force used in each use of force event in 2023. Table 4 t Year 2023 Firearm Displayed 20 CED Displayed 17 Arm Bar 5 Takedown 4 K9 4 Focus Blows 2 CED Use (Stun and Probe) 11 Wrist Lock 10 Shoulder Lock 5 Other 13 Pressure Point 2 Spit Hood 2 Handcuffs 2 Hair Hold 3 Joint Lock — Other 2 Table 4 represents the type offorce used and the number of each technique or device was used per reporting officer in 2023. Of note, in 2023, with the new use offorce reporting platform change a comparison to previous years was not made due to the difference in information aggregation and categorization. Moving forward in the following annual use offorce reports a two-year comparison will be made for 2023-2024 and a three-year comparison fi^om 2023-2025. Integrity + Respect + Empathy 9 WRAP Restraint In 2022, the Woodburn Police Department began using the WRAP restraint system. The WRAP restraint system is used to safely and effectively immobilize a subject who is continuously combative and/or actively attempting self -harm prior to transport to jail or transfer to medical personnel. The use of the WRAP restraint system is designed to keep officers and a subject(s) protected by reducing the possibility of injury and death. The WRAP restraint system is designed to be applied with no less than two officers. In 2023, there were five reported uses of the WRAP restraint system. Table 5 Year INS # of Uses 2022 1 2023 5 Table 5 shows the difference in use of the WRAP restraint system from 2022 to 2023. Canine (K9) Proms The Woodburn Police Department has a K9 program consisting of two patrol protection/apprehension canines. The K9 can be deployed in two ways. The first is to track and apprehend a fleeing subject. The second is a show of force to a non -compliant subject. Anytime the K9 deployment results in the canine apprehending (biting) a subject, the incident is considered a use of force, therefore requires reporting. Table 6 # of Deployments # of # of o /o of Deployments resulting Year resulting in a canine Deployments Captures in a canine bite bite 2021 27 3 1 3.7% 2022 20 3 0 0% 2023 48 14 4 8.3% Integrity + Respect + Empathy 7 Conducted EneM Device The Woodburn Police Department utilizes a Conducted Energy Device (CED) as a force option. The CED can be utilized in four ways. Two of the options are considered mere presence and the others are considered a physical use of force. The laser of the CED can be activated showing the subject where the CED probes are targeted. The spark demo is when the probe cartridge(s) is removed and the CED is triggered. The CED's electrodes produce an arc across metal conductors giving off a spark as a visual demonstration to gain compliance from a subject who is or may become combative. The probe mode is when the two CED probes are fired from the device at a subject. The thin insulated wires connected to the CED's metal probes deliver an electrical waveform to attempt to cause neuro muscular incapacitation. The drive stun mode is when the CED is pressed against the subject's body, sending the electrical waveform from the CED itself and is utilized as a form of pain compliance. Table 7 r� � �i,�t�f�i���er�;If�� IBM of Year Arrests Arrest & Use CED's 2021 4 934 0.4% 2022 4 902 0.4% 2023 11 1,024 1 % Table 7 shows the percentage of CED use per arrest. Integrity + Respect + Empathy 9 Injuries reported in Use ofForce Incidents Injuries can occur to both officers and subjects during use of force events. Data shows that officers report fewer injuries than subjects during a use of force event. The following table represents the number of officers and subjects reporting injury during a use of force event. Table 8 Table 8 shows the number of officers and subjects reporting injury after a use of force event. Of note, for 2023, with the new use of force reporting software, specific type of injury to officer or subject is no longer captured as a data point. Therefore, a year-to-year comparisons culminating in a multi- year review will be produced in 2024(two year) and 2025 (three year). For 2023, 91 % of the time during a use of event officers used force, they did not report injuries. For subjects, 78% of them were uninjured during a use of force incident. Days and hours of the Week Table 9 displays the number of police service calls where force was used, and Table 10 displays the number of use of force incidents during each work shift. Table 9 Table 10 Ilia% ,� r� <<,, , , Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday Sunday 11 8 16 11 17 12 12 Integrity + Respect + Empathy I Vehicle Pursuits The Woodburn Police Department reports and reviews each vehicle pursuit. Vehicle pursuits are inherently dangerous to the community, the pursuing officer(s) and the pursued subject(s). Each vehicle pursuit is unique and poses a wide variety of risks and outcomes. Vehicle pursuits are closely monitored and reviewed to ensure best practices and training are adhered to. There has been a growing trend by law enforcement agencies throughout the country in instituting more restrictive pursuit policies. This is due in part because of case law, litigation, and community expectations regarding use of force and law enforcement vehicle pursuits. The annual report is used by the Chief of Police and Command Staff to evaluate the department's pursuit training, response, and liability for each vehicle pursuit. Pursuits in 2020 and 2021 were the same at 8 pursuits per year. In 2022, pursuits decreased by 50%, with 4 initiated pursuits. In 2023, pursuits decreased by 50%, with 2 pursuits reported. One pursuit involved a DU suspect driving recklessly and the second pursuit involved a subject wanted on several person felony crimes. Both pursuits were resolved with the drivers criminally charged and arrested. Table 11 # of Year % + or - Pursuits 2021 8 0% 2022 4 -50% F-2023 2 -50% Integrity + Respect + Empathy 10 Chart 3 Additional facts for 2023 vehicle pursuits: • 1 occurred during dayshift and 1 occurred during nightshift. • 1 occurred on Monday and 1 occurred on Saturday. • There were no injuries reported. A concerning factor with pursuits is in how they end. Vehicle pursuits may end in either a termination or conclusion. Terminations occur when the pursuing officers stop their attempt to apprehend the suspect. Conclusion is when the suspect vehicle stops and is no longer moving. Any officer or supervisor can make the decision to terminate a vehicle pursuit at any point. Pursuits are terminated for a variety of reasons. Often because the risk of apprehension does not rise to the level of the associated dangers of continuing to pursue. Officer(s) must deactivate all emergency equipment and end their attempt to apprehend the suspect upon termination of a pursuit. The conclusion of a pursuit also occurs when the suspect vehicle stops on its own, stopped by intervention techniques (i.e. stop sticks or pursuit intervention technique), or the suspect vehicle becomes disabled. Integrity + Respect + Empathy 11 Chart 4 shows how each of the 2023 pursuits ended. Chart 4 R. • VEHICLE OFC. SPIKESTIR I Eb DISCONTINUED Chart 4 shows how each 2023 pursuits were resolved. 2023 Conclusion All use of force events and incidents were determined to be within policy and in compliance with state and federal laws. Integrity + Respect + Empathy 12 LAW ENFORCEMENT INTENTIONAL USE OF DEADLY PHYSICAL FORCE RESPONSE PLAN (SB 1 I Plan) Marion County Intentional Use of Deadly Physical Force Planning Authority Revision Date 1212022 20 Table of Contents MEMBERS OF THE PLANNING AUTHORITY....................................................2 PREAMBLE.......................................................................................................... 4 SECTION 1: ADMINISTRATION..........................................................................4 SECTION 2: APPLICABILITY OF THE PLAN.....................................................4 SECTION 3: DEFINITIONS..................................................................................4 SECTION 4: IMMEDIATE AFTERMATH.............................................................5 SECTION 5: INTENTIONAL USE OF DEADLY PHYSICAL FORCE ..................6 SECTION 6: INVESTIGATION PROTOCOLS.....................................................8 SECTION 7: DISTRICT ATTORNEY....................................................................9 SECTION 8: DEBRIEFING...................................................................................9 SECTION 9: REPORTING, TRAINING, OUTREACH........................................10 SECTION 10: FISCAL IMPACT.........................................................................11 SECTION 11: PLAN REVISION.........................................................................11 SECTION 12: AGENCY POLICIES....................................................................11 Deadly Physical Force Plan - Marion County 21 1 Members of the Planning Authority Marion County District Attorney (co-chair) Marion County Sheriff (co-chair) Oregon State Police Administrative Representative Salem Police Chief Police Labor Union Representatives Public Member On March 20, 2008, this Plan was approved by the Planning Authority, and submitted for approval to governing bodies of the following jurisdictions: Marion County ----------------------------------------------------- Approved on 4/23/2008 City of Aumsville-------------------------------------------------- Approved 5/12/2008 City of Aurora ------------------------------------------------------ Approved 5/13/2008 City of Detroit ------------------------------------------------------ Approved 4/8/2008 City of Donald----------------------------------------------------- Approved 5/13/2008 City of Gates------------------------------------------------------- Approved 3/20/2008 City of Gervais----------------------------------------------------- Approved 5/l/2008 City of Hubbard ---------------------------------------------------- Approved 4/8/2008 City of Idanha------------------------------------------------------ Approved 4/14/2008 City of Jefferson--------------------------------------------------- Approved 3/27/2008 City of Keizer------------------------------------------------------ Approved 5/19/2008 City of Mill City--------------------------------------------------- Approved 4/8/2008 City of Mt. Angel -------------------------------------------------- Approved 4/8/2008 Cityof St. Paul ----------------------------------------------------- Deadly Physical Force Plan - Marion County 22 2 City of Salem ------------------------------------------------------- Approved 5/5/2008 City of Scotts Mills --- City of Silverton---------------------------------------------------- Approved 5/5/2008 City of Stayton------------------------------------------------------ Approved 4/7/2008 City of Sublimity ---------------------------------------------------Approved 4/14/2008 City of Turner ------------------------------------------------------- Approved 4/10/2008 City of Woodburn-------------------------------------------------- Approved 4/28/2008 Upon receiving a vote of approval from 2/3 of the above jurisdictions, this Plan was submitted to the Attorney General, who approved the Plan on July 3, 2008. Deadly Physical Force Plan - Marion County 23 Preamble Marion County law enforcement agencies recognize the importance to both their agencies and our communities to ensure that any intentional use of deadly physical force by a peace officer is investigated in a professional, competent and impartial manner. The openness with which we proceed in these investigations is critical to establishing and maintaining trust within the community. It is clear our citizens examine closely the actions any law enforcement agency takes when their officers intentionally use deadly physical force, and it is our goal to ensure the community is confident and accepting of the actions Marion County law enforcement agencies take when involved in these situations. Section 1: Administration (1) In the event that a member of the planning authority is unable to continue to serve, a replacement shall be appointed as provided in Section 2(1) of Senate Bill 111, Oregon Laws 2007. (2) The six members of the Planning Authority are the voting members. The approval of the Plan, elements or revisions thereof, shall be by majority vote. (3) The presence of 2/3 of the listed members shall be required in order to hold any vote. Section 2: Applicability of the Plan This plan shall be applicable, as set forth herein, to any intentional use of deadly physical force by a peace officer acting in the course of and in furtherance of his/her official duties, occurring within Marion County. Section 3: Definitions Administrative Inquiry Means the involved agency's internal employment review of their peace officer's use of deadly physical force. Agency Liaison An involved agency's appointed representative who may be present to coordinate resources and assistance to investigators. Deadly Physical Force Plan - Marion County 24 rd Involved Agency Means the law enforcement organization employing the peace officer who intentionally used deadly physical force. Investigation Means law enforcement's process to gather facts and determine law surrounding the peace officer's use of deadly physical force. Investigating Agency Means the law enforcement organization investigating the intentional use of deadly physical force. Plan Means the final document approved by the Planning Authority, adopted by two-thirds of the governing bodies employing law enforcement agencies, and approved by the Attorney General. Any approved revisions shall become a part of the Plan. Deadly Means physical force that under the circumstances in which it is used is Physical readily capable of causing death or serious physical injury. Force Serious Means physical injury which creates a substantial risk of death or which Physical causes serious and protracted disfigurement, protracted impairment of Injury health or protracted loss or impairment of the function of any bodily organ. (ORS 161.015(8)) Physical Means impairment of physical condition or substantial pain that does not Injury amount to "serious physical injury." Involved Means the peace officer whose official action was or who's official order Officer precipitated an intentional use of deadly physical force. Also includes a peace officer who was involved before or during the intentional use of deadly physical force, and this involvement was reasonably likely to expose the officer to a heightened level of stress or trauma. Section 4: Immediate Aftermath When a peace officer intentionally uses deadly physical force, the officer shall immediately take whatever steps are reasonable and necessary to protect the safety and health of the officer and any member of the public. After taking such steps, the officer shall immediately notify his or her agency of the intentional use of deadly physical force. Deadly Physical Force Plan - Marion County 25 Thereafter, the officer, if able, shall take such steps as are reasonably necessary to preserve the integrity of the scene and to preserve evidence. Upon request, the officer shall provide information regarding the circumstances as necessary to protect persons and property, preserve any evidence, and to provide a framework for the investigation. Section 5: Intentional Use of Deadly Physical Force When intentional deadly physical force is used against any person, in addition to the requirements of Section 4 of this Plan and notwithstanding involved agency policy, the following provisions apply: (1) Upon the arrival of additional peace officers, sufficient to manage the scene, each Involved Officer shall be relieved of the above duties set forth in Section 4 of the Plan, and the duties shall be re -assigned to uninvolved peace officer personnel. (2) The on -scene supervisor shall take immediate action to stabilize the situation, ensure notification of the appropriate staff and agencies, and shall obtain information relevant to public safety (e.g., outstanding suspects, location of evidence, direction of travel, etc.). (3) As soon as practicable, each Involved Officer shall leave the scene with a companion officer, as directed by his or her supervisor, and be offered an opportunity for a medical examination. If the officer is not in need of medical treatment, the officer shall be taken to a location designated by the investigating agency. Following the intentional use of deadly physical force, the officer's union representative shall be notified. Management or non -represented employees shall be afforded the same opportunity to consult with legal representation. (4) After consultation with the involved officer, the involved agency or officer shall notify the officer's family according to the involved agency's policy regarding such notification. (5) Notification shall be made to the District Attorney as provided in Section 7(1) of this Plan. This provision does not prevent the involved agency from requiring additional notification requirements within their respective policies. (6) As soon as practicable, any weapon used by an involved officer shall be seized by investigators and, if appropriate, replaced with a substitute weapon. Other involved officers' weapons, even if not used, are also subject to seizure by the investigating agency. (7) Interview of an Involved Officer: Deadly Physical Force Plan - Marion County 26 31 As used in this section "interview" refers to formal interview of an officer by assigned investigating personnel that occurs a reasonable time after the incident, and after the officer has had an opportunity to consult with counsel, if so desired. It's noteworthy that there may be multiple involved officers, and this process shall be followed with each of them. (a) The interview of the involved officer who intentionally used deadly physical force shall occur after a reasonable period of time to prepare for the interview and taking into account the emotional and physical state of the officer(s). The interview shall occur no sooner than 48 hours after the incident, unless this waiting period is waived by the officer. (b) The waiting period does not preclude an initial on -scene debriefing with the officer to assess and make an initial evaluation of the incident. (c) The scene shall be secured and managed consistent with the control of any other major crime scene. Only personnel necessary to conduct the investigation shall be permitted access to the scene. When it is determined that no evidence will be contaminated or destroyed, the involved officer may conduct a "walk through" to assist in the investigation. (8) Immediately after the initial on -scene debriefing (see Section 5(7)(b)), an involved officer shall be placed on administrative leave until sufficient information exists to justify the intentional use of deadly physical force and the officer has had an opportunity for initial mental health counseling. (9) Notwithstanding subsection (8) above, for no less than 72 hours immediately following an incident in which deadly physical force was intentionally used by a peace officer, a law enforcement agency may not return an Involved Officer to duties that might place the officer in a situation in which the officer has to use deadly force. (See also related subsection (10) below.) (10) In the six months following an intentional use of deadly physical force incident that results in a death, the involved agency shall offer each Involved Officer a minimum of two opportunities for mental health counseling. The officer shall be required to attend at least one session of mental health counseling. (a) At the involved agency's expense, the involved officer (s) shall be scheduled for an appointment with a licensed mental health counselor for a counseling session with a follow-up session scheduled at a date determined by the mental health professional. (b) The counseling sessions are not to be considered fitness for duty evaluations, and are to be considered privileged between the officer and counselor. Deadly Physical Force Plan - Marion County 27 7 (11) In the event of an intentional use of deadly physical force, it is required that members of an organization outside the involved officer's agency conduct the investigation under the direction of the District Attorney. Members of the involved officer's agency may assign personnel to assist in the investigation as directed by the lead investigating agency. (a) An investigating agency may include the Oregon State Police, the Marion County Homicide Assault Response Team (HART), or any other agency which has the expertise necessary to investigate a deadly force situation. The District Attorney shall determine the investigating agency in consultation with the involved agency's administration and with agreement from the investigating agency's administration. (12) The investigation as led by the District Attorney does not preclude the involved agency from beginning a concurrent administrative inquiry. Such administrative inquiries may be necessary for civil preparation, determination of policy violations or training issues but shall not interfere with the investigation. (13) In order to preserve the integrity of the investigation, the scene supervisor and investigating supervisor shall notify all involved officers to refrain from making public statements about the investigation, until such time as the investigation has concluded and the District Attorney has made a determination regarding the criminal responsibility of all involved persons. (14) As soon as practical, both the involved agency and investigating agency will follow the Officer Use of Deadly Force Press Release Guidelines process (Exhibit 1 and incorporated herein). (15) To the extent reasonably possible, the involved agency shall not participate as investigators in briefings, formal information sharing, nor fulfill significant investigatory roles in the investigation. Any exception must be approved by the District Attorney. However, an involved agency liaison is allowed to be present to coordinate personnel, equipment, and investigatory support. Section 6: Investigation Protocols (1) The investigation, at a minimum, shall consist of the following: (a) Eyewitness and involved party interviews (b) Evidence collection Deadly Physical Force Plan - Marion County 28 (c) Scene documentation (d) Involved Officer(s) interview(s) (2) The investigation shall be documented in written reports, and all police reports and taped statements shall be provided to the investigating agency, the Involved Officer(s) agency(ies), and the District Attorney. Section 7: District Attorney 1) When an intentional use of deadly physical force by an officer occurs the involved agency shall immediately notify the District Attorney's Office. Notification shall be made through the established on -call procedure. 2) When an intentional use of deadly physical force by an officer occurs, the District Attorney or his or her designee will consult with the involved agency regarding the investigation and implementation of elements of this plan. 3) The District Attorney has the sole statutory and constitutional duty to make the decision on whether to present a matter to a Grand Jury. (a) The District Attorney will consult with the investigating agency and make a decision on whether to present the case to a Grand Jury. (b) The timing of the decision will be made by the District Attorney based upon all considerations. (c) If the District Attorney decides to present a case to the Grand Jury, the District Attorney shall promptly notify the investigating agency, the involved officer's agency, and the involved officer through his or her representative. (d) Upon a final decision by the Grand Jury or the District Attorney, the District Attorney shall notify the investigating agency and the involved officer's agency of the conclusions of the Grand Jury proceeding under this plan. (e) The District Attorney shall release the Grand Jury conclusions to the public. Recordings of the Grand Jury proceedings will only be released as required by law. Section 8: Debriefing The intentional use of deadly physical force by a peace officer has the potential to create strong emotional reactions which have the potential to interfere with an officer's ability Deadly Physical Force Plan - Marion County 29 0j to function. These reactions may be manifested immediately, or over time. Further, these reactions may occur not only in an officer directly involved in the incident, but also in other officers within the involved agency. The requirements of this section provide a minimum framework and are not intended to take the place of agency policy. Agencies are encouraged to develop formal procedures to deal with an officer's stress response following an intentional use of deadly force incident. Such policies should include a procedure that are implemented from the time of the incident and continue over time. (1) Upon a final determination by the District Attorney, the involved agency shall conduct an internal review of the matter for compliance with agency policy. Such review, at a minimum shall include a review of the incident with the involved officer(s). (2) Each agency shall provide a process for any officer(s) who make(s) a request, to participate in a critical incident debriefing. (3) If available, agencies should encourage officers to take advantage of Employee Assistance Programs, and if appropriate, agencies should request assistance from other agencies that may have in place formal programs for dealing with critical incidents. Section 9: Agency Reporting, Training, Outreach (1) Each law enforcement agency within Marion County shall make available a copy of this Plan to every officer and shall incorporate the Plan into agency policies and provide training to officers on the implementation of the plan. (2) Upon the conclusion of an investigation resulting in death due to an officer's intentional use of deadly force, the announcement by the District Attorney pursuant to Section 7(3) of the Plan, and the debriefing, the involved agency shall complete the Attorney General's report regarding the use of force, and submit the report to the Attorney General. (3) Each agency subject to this Plan shall comply with the Department of Public Safety Standards and Training rules on use of force training, as well as establish department training requirements on the use of force. The training must include education on the agency's use of force policy. This training may also include, but is not limited to the following: (a) Defensive Tactics (b) Tactical Shooting Deadly Physical Force Plan - Marion County Q 10 (c) SWAT training (d) Use of force in making an arrest (e) Use of non -lethal force Each agency shall have a written policy and monitoring system to ensure that the training standards are met. (4) After adoption of this Plan, to the extent they are fiscally able, each agency shall take steps to publicize the Plan to their respective communities, by providing information to the media, general public, community organizations, and quasi -governmental bodies. Section 10: Fiscal Impact The Planning Authority has noted only de minimis fiscal impact resulting from the above process. Section 11: Plan Revision The Planning Authority shall conduct a biennial review of the Plan. If a revision of the Plan becomes advisable, the Planning Authority shall meet and discuss such a revision. If the Planning Authority adopts a revision, such revision shall be submitted for approval as provided by statute. Section 12: Agency Policies Agency Policies attaches/. Deadly Physical Force Plan - Marion County 31 11 COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES FEBRUARY 12, 2024 DATE COUNCIL CHAMBERS, CITY HALL, CITY OF WOODBURN, COUNTY OF MARION, STATE OF OREGON, FEBRUARY 12, 2024 CONVENED The meeting convened at 7:00 p.m. with Mayor Lonergan presiding. ROLL CALL Mayor Lonergan Present Councilor Carney Present Councilor Cornwell Present Councilor Schaub Present Councilor Morris Present Councilor Cabrales Present Councilor Wilk Present Staff Present: City Administrator Derickson, City Attorney Granum, Assistant City Administrator Row, Police Chief Pilcher, Economic Development Director Johnk, Community Services Director Cuomo, Finance Director Turley, Assistant City Attorney Killmer, Planner Handel, Community Development Director Kerr, Public Works Director Stultz, Special Projects Director Wakeley, Human Resources Director Gregg, Senior Planner Cortes, Economic Development Project Manager Guerrero, Public Affairs and Communications Coordinator Moore, City Recorder Pierson, Community Relations Manager Herrera ANNOUNCEMENTS Mayor Lonergan announced the following: • City Hall and the Library will be closed on February 19, for President's Day. • Transit will be open holiday hours (8:00 a.m. - 3:00 p.m.) • The Aquatic Center will be open regular hours (6:00 a.m. -10:00 a.m. & 4:00 p.m. -7:00 p.m.) • Agreement made with Church of Christ and Community Action to operate shelter. • Woodburn Chamber announced their Distinguished Service Alma Awards and City Administrator Derickson is being recognized as Senior First Citizen. APPOINTMENT Carney/Cabrales... appoint Noah Carlson to the Woodburn Budget Committee. The motion passed unanimously. Carney/Schaub... appoint Teresa Ibanez -Estrada to the Woodburn Public Arts and Mural Committee. The motion passed unanimously. COMMUNICATIONS Mayor Lonergan announced the City Council has received a letter from Beverlee Koutny. Page 1 - Council Meeting Minutes, February 12, 2024 32 COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES FEBRUARY 12, 2024 PRESENTATIONS Republic Services- Cindy Rogers, Municipal Relationship Manager for Republic Services, Travis Comfort, Municipal Contract Administrator for Republic Services, and Josh Harvey, Operations Manager in Woodburn provided a review of the essential services provided to the City of Woodburn in 2022. Cindy Rogers noted that they will be back this year to present on the Recycling Modernization Act and ask council for a rate adjustment and provide a review of 2023. Liberty House — Community Services Director Cuomo provided a brief history on the resource center. Kyle Tarr, Prevention Program Director of Liberty House, and Bruce Anderson, Deputy CEO of Liberty House, provided information on Liberty House's child abuse prevention services and also provided an update on the Liberty House Clinic. Quarterly Investment Report - Lauren Brant, PFM Asset Management, provided an update on the City's investments. BUSINESS FROM THE PUBLIC Nancy Talbot, Love INC, spoke about the phenomenal support that Love INC. receives from Republic Services. CONSENT AGENDA A. Woodburn City Council minutes of January 22, 2024, B. Acceptance of Easements at 1123 N 3rd Street (Tax Lot 051 W07DBO4400), C. City Attorney Employment Agreement, D. Building Activity for January 2024. Carney/Cornwell... approve the consent agenda. The motion passed unanimously. PUBLIC HEARINGS Legislative Amendment 21-03 Public Hearing: Amendment to the Woodburn Development Ordinance (WDO) Relating to Tree Preservation and Removal (LA 21-03) Mayor Lonergan declared the hearing open at 8:37 p.m. for the purpose of hearing public input on Legislative Amendment 21-03 Public Hearing: Amendment to the Woodburn Development Ordinance (WDO) Relating to Tree Preservation and Removal (LA 21-03). Community Development Director Kerr provided a staff report. Mayor Lonergan asked if any member of the public would like to speak in either support or opposition of Legislative Amendment 21-03 Public Hearing: Amendment to the Woodburn Development Ordinance (WDO) Relating to Tree Preservation and Removal (LA 21-03). Tom Feitl, 1032 Hazelwood Drive, Oregon City, stated that he is a consulting arborist and that in regard to the mitigation requirement he would like to see the City require trees of a certain crown size based off the species profile be replaced with similarly sized trees to maintain the City's tree canopy. Mayor Lonergan closed the hearing at 9:01 p.m. City Councilor discussion included concerns about fees, costs to remove trees, and communication with the public on the process. Carney/Cornwell... tentatively approve Legislative Amendment LA 21-03, related to tree preservation and removal, directing staff to prepare an ordinance for consideration at the next City Council meeting. The motion passed unanimously. Carney/Wilk ... directing staff to prepare an ordinance amending Ordinance 2433, which is the City master fee schedule, regarding tree removal and mitigation for consideration at the next City Council Page 2 - Council Meeting Minutes, February 12, 2024 33 COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES FEBRUARY 12, 2024 meeting. The motion passed unanimously. Legislative Amendment (LA) 23-04 Public Hearing: Adoption of the Parks and Recreation Master Plan and associated Comprehensive Plan Goal and Policy Amendments Mayor Lonergan declared the hearing open at 9:17 p.m. for the purpose of hearing public input on Legislative Amendment (LA) 23-04 Public Hearing: Adoption of the Parks and Recreation Master Plan and associated Comprehensive Plan Goal and Policy Amendments. Community Services Director Cuomo and Planner Handel provided a staff report. Steve Duke, Conservation Technix, Inc. provided an overview of the Parks and Recreation Master Plan, including the community engagement process and key findings, the plan structure, and goals and key project recommendations. No members of the public wished to speak in either support or opposition of Legislative Amendment (LA) 23-04 Public Hearing: Adoption of the Parks and Recreation Master Plan and associated Comprehensive Plan Goal and Policy Amendments. Mayor Lonergan closed the hearing at 9:43 p.m. Carney/Schaub... tentatively approve Legislative Amendment LA 23-04, adopting the Parks and Recreation Master Plan and updated Parks and Recreation Goals and Policies as part of a Comprehensive Plan amendment, based on the Analyses and Findings in the staff report, and direct staff to prepare an ordinance for consideration at the next City Council meeting. The motion passed unanimously. COUNCIL BILL NO. 3240 - AN ORDINANCE REGULATING THE DETECTION AND ELIMINATION OF ILLICIT DISCHARGE IN THE CITY'S STORM WATER SYSTEM; PROVIDING FOR ENFORCEMENT; REPEALING IN -PART ORDINANCE NO. 2556; AND DECLARING AN EMERGENCY Carney introduced Council Bill No. 3240. City Recorder Pierson read the bill twice by title only since there were no objections from Council. Public Works Director Stultz provided a staff report. On roll call vote for final passage, the bill passed unanimously. Mayor Lonergan declared Council Bill No. 3240 duly passed. COUNCIL BILL NO. 3241 - A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE TRANSFER OF ONE HALF (.40) FTE FROM THE TRANSIT FUND TO THE GENERAL FUND FOR THE FISCAL YEAR 2023-2024 Carney introduced Council Bill No. 3241. City Recorder Pierson read the bill by title only since there were no objections from Council. Community Finance Director Turley provided a staff report. On roll call vote for final passage, the bill passed unanimously. Mayor Lonergan declared Council Bill No. 3241 duly passed. COUNCIL BRIEFING OF PLANNING COMMISSION APPROVAL OF A DESIGN REVIEW, STREET ADJUSTMENT, AND VARIANCE APPLICATION PACKAGE FOR THE GRATING PACIFIC BUILDING C PROJECT AT 2775 N. FRONT STREET (DR 23-08, SA 23-05, & VAR 23-06) The Council declined to call this item up. CITY ADMINISTRATOR'S REPORT The Assistant City Administrator reported the following: • An agreement was reached last Friday with Community Action, the City of Woodburn and Ray of Hope. The City is offering a $10,000 grant to Ray of Hope today to help fund their operation through February and the transition with Community Action. The City is going to be committing some other support services to help improve the site. Page 3 - Council Meeting Minutes, February 12, 2024 M COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES FEBRUARY 12, 2024 Mayor Lonergan noted that he is on the board for Community Action, and it is a non-paying volunteer position, and he is impressed with what they are doing. • A display case is going up in the Council Chambers to highlight the City and some of the success the City's had. • There has been an update to our Census data and the City's population has gone from 27, 044 to 28,483. MAYOR AND COUNCIL REPORTS Councilor Wilk stated that he is excited about the things going on in the City. Councilor Cornwell stated that she attended the Fire Districts Banquet, and it was a grand night with good food and good fellowship. Mayor Lonergan mentioned that at least four firemen were recognized. James Gibbs was recognized for five years of service, Dylan Selleck received a letter of appreciation, Jorden Jacobucci received an letter of commendation, Nate Maravilla was named rookie of the year, and Jeffrey Robinson was named volunteer of the year. Mayor Lonergan stated that he attended the Estates Coffee hour and provided a presentation on the status of the City. He added that the League of Oregon Cities sponsors an annual event that gives scholarships away to certain high school students who write a good essay on what they would do to be mayor for a day. He spoke to two different classes at the high school about the Mayors duties and responsibilities. ADJOURNMENT Cornwell/Cabrales... move to adjourn. The motion passed unanimously. Mayor Lonergan adjourned the meeting at 10:05 p.m. ATTEST Heather Pierson, City Recorder City of Woodburn, Oregon APPROVED FRANK LONERGAN, MAYOR Page 4 - Council Meeting Minutes, February 12, 2024 35 Redflex Traffic Systems Report - N. Pacififc Highyway and Mt. Hood Avenue Red Light Enforcement Nov 2023 Dec 2023 Jan 2024 Nov 23 - Jan 24 (Combined) Total Processed Incidents 245 230 173 648 Obstructions* 26 36 25 87 Police Rejections* 123 101 83 307 Registration Issues* 11 19 15 45 Process Rejections* 14 5 5 24 Total Rejections 174 161 128 463 Approved Violations/Notices Printed 71 Speed Enforcement 69 mph+) 45 185 Nov 2023 Dec 2023 Jan 2024 Nov 23 - Jan 24 (Combined) Total Processed Incidents 331 331 114 776 Obstructions* 15 12 3 30 Police Rejections* 80 92 35 207 Registration Issues* 12 17 8 37 Process Rejections* 11 5 2 18 Total Rejections 118 126 48 292 Approved Violations/Notices Printed 213 *REJECTIONS 205 66 484 KEY* Obstructions: Driver, vehicle or license plate obstructed. Police Rejections: Driver not R/O, Face Obstructed, Gender Mismatched, Incorrect DMV, Invalid Offense, Police Discretion, Safe Turn on Red, Sun Glare. Registration Issues: Extended Vehicle, Out of Country Plates, Paper Plates, Wrong or No DMV. Process Rejections: Camera Malfunction, Plate Burn Out, Rear Plate Camera Blurry, Poor Driver Images, Too Old 36 STAFF MEMORANDUM To: The Woodburn City Council From: Scott Derickson, City Administrator Regarding — Consent Calander/Monthly Financial Report Attached for your review and acceptance are the monthly Financial Reports that include Year -to -Date Expenditure and Revenues for all funds, the Accounts Payable Report and the Cash and Investment Reconciliation Report. Placement of up to date monthly Financial Reports on the City Council's Consent Agenda will occur on a monthly basis. As always, if you have comments or questions, please do not hesitate contact me. 37 Year -to -Date Expenditures for All Funds Q i rlr-c 0 ; x ; z? G Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd PdorYear TotaV Fund 001. ""' Ceuimiiialll Il"::surd CDel:rarhnne,n.'101.""'Adimiiiinliiishatlilloin D' v1t,a on 1.1.1.1..'. Couinc'pilll & IMayoui EXPENSE Iaulsolrsra/ 5n"14(,.eF 5112 Part -Time Wages 8,700.00 .00 8,700.00 .00 .00 .00 8,700.00 0 .00 5212 Social Security 650.00 .00 650.00 .00 .00 .00 650.00 0 .00 5214 5214.100 PERS - City 1,450.00 .00 1,450.00 .00 .00 .00 1,450.00 0 .00 5214 - Totals $1,450.00 $0.00 $1,450.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $1,450.00 0% $0.00 5216 Unemployment Insurance 140.00 .00 140.00 .00 .00 .00 140.00 0 .00 5218 Paid Family Leave Insurance 10.00 .00 10.00 .00 .00 .00 10.00 0 .00 fly^r,5'oiwa/.°a"s'^ vicas' Pbta'Js' $10,950.00 $0.00 $10,950.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $10,950.00 0% $0.00 platei'e'fee%s & .5&vfe.as. 5319 Office Supplies 1,000.00 .00 1,000.00 90.27 .00 664.20 335.80 66 5,407.90 5419 Other Professional Sery 1,500.00 .00 1,500.00 .00 .00 1,314.47 185.53 88 2,114.98 5421 Telephone/Data 750.00 .00 750.00 .95 .00 5.58 744.42 1 181.57 5428 IT Support 73,350.00 .00 73,350.00 6,112.50 .00 42,787.50 30,562.50 58 64,260.00 5432 Meals 2,000.00 .00 2,000.00 .00 .00 1,051.37 948.63 53 1,606.41 5433 Mileage 330.00 .00 330.00 .00 .00 568.54 (238.54) 172 444.48 5439 Travel 700.00 .00 700.00 .00 .00 137.86 562.14 20 2,160.26 5464 Workers' Comp 50.00 .00 50.00 4.17 .00 29.19 20.81 58 39.96 5485 Leadership Development 15,000.00 .00 15,000.00 .00 .00 3,935.41 11,064.59 26 .00 5491 Dues & Subscriptions .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 250.00 (250.00) +++ 171.00 5492 Registrations/Training 3,000.00 .00 3,000.00 .00 .00 2,440.00 560.00 81 6,421.00 5493 Printing/Binding 100.00 .00 100.00 .00 .00 .00 100.00 0 .00 Plata^'^sia& aft .°a"ei r,'e;'s' 7bta'ls' $97,780.00 $0.00 $97,780.00 $6,207.89 $0.00 $53,184.12 $44,595.88 54% $82,807.56 EXPENSE TOTALS $108,730.00 $0.00 $108,730.00 $6,207.89 $0.00 $53,184.12 $55,545.88 49% $82,807.56 D' vls ion 1.1.11 Cossinciilll & IMayoui toal„a ($108,730.00) $0.00 ($108,730.00) ($6,207.89) $0.00 ($53,184.12) ($55,545.88) 49% ($82,807.56) D, v'ison 1.2.1.1... ClIii'ty Aduiioliinliis'Ikuiatour EXPENSE /Ielseerera/ 5e14(,.e F 5111 Regular Wages 206,670.00 .00 206,670.00 14,992.21 .00 112,532.26 94,137.74 54 187,073.97 5121 Overtime .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 4.48 5211 OR Workers' Benefit 40.00 .00 40.00 1.57 .00 15.37 24.63 38 30.33 5212 Social Security 14,950.00 .00 14,950.00 1,206.17 .00 7,497.03 7,452.97 50 14,613.39 5213 Med & Dent Ins 25,530.00 .00 25,530.00 2,259.30 .00 13,745.69 11,784.31 54 25,100.60 5214 5214 Retirement .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ (8,783.90) 5214.100 PERS - City 40,560.00 .00 40,560.00 2,920.90 .00 22,079.75 18,480.25 54 35,041.60 5214.600 PERS 6% 12,400.00 .00 12,400.00 974.02 .00 7,328.78 5,071.22 59 13,296.42 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM Page 1 of 57 39 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd PdorYear TotaV Fund 001... Ceui"rouiiallll Il�:r:ssui"rd CDel:r<srhnnen° '101... Ao imiilinliiis'toiatlilloin C',fiv'ison 1.2.1.1...ClItyAdui'nliinliis'toi"atoii EXPENSE Ies:'euarsro:/ 5o14(,.eF 5214 5214.800 DEFERED COMP - CITY 17,500.00 .00 17,500.00 1,241.80 .00 9,607.67 7,892.33 55 19,713.32 5214 - Totals $70,460.00 $0.00 $70,460.00 $5,136.72 $0.00 $39,016.20 $31,443.80 55% $59,267.44 5215 Long Term Disability Ins 310.00 .00 310.00 26.86 .00 162.17 147.83 52 325.72 5216 Unemployment Insurance 2,680.00 .00 2,680.00 194.90 .00 1,463.05 1,216.95 55 1,628.41 5217 Life Insurance 200.00 .00 200.00 17.10 .00 103.22 96.78 52 207.12 5218 Paid Family Leave Insurance 830.00 .00 830.00 54.16 .00 409.00 421.00 49 456.64 fly^r,5'oiwal.°a"s'^ vicas' Pbta'Js' $321,670.00 $0.00 $321,670.00 $23,888.99 $0.00 $174,943.99 $146,726.01 54% $288,708.10 //atei'e'feels & .5&.u,le.otis. 5319 Office Supplies 2,000.00 .00 2,000.00 31.01 .00 804.17 1,195.83 40 1,048.10 5419 Other Professional Sery 2,000.00 .00 2,000.00 12.66 61.32 1,977.67 (38.99) 102 2,107.91 5421 Telephone/Data 1,800.00 .00 1,800.00 291.43 157.03 2,190.39 (547.42) 130 3,876.75 5422 Postage 500.00 .00 500.00 50.63 .00 190.63 309.37 38 506.27 5428 IT Support 31,500.00 .00 31,500.00 2,625.00 .00 18,375.00 13,125.00 58 19,740.00 5432 Meals 1,170.00 .00 1,170.00 540.00 .00 1,169.52 .48 100 620.60 5433 Mileage 1,000.00 .00 1,000.00 .00 .00 568.08 431.92 57 358.14 5439 Travel 5,000.00 .00 5,000.00 .00 .00 1,412.62 3,587.38 28 5,188.52 5449 Leases- Other 600.00 .00 600.00 .00 .00 .00 600.00 0 .00 5464 Workers' Comp 790.00 .00 790.00 65.83 .00 460.81 329.19 58 710.04 5485 Leadership Development 5,000.00 .00 5,000.00 .00 630.00 5,149.25 (779.25) 116 1,155.00 5491 Dues & Subscriptions 10,000.00 .00 10,000.00 766.03 .00 4,814.06 5,185.94 48 6,702.73 5492 Registrations/Training 5,000.00 .00 5,000.00 .00 .00 1,626.00 3,374.00 33 9,596.99 Plate'^ria& aft .°a"ei r,'e;'s' f tuta'ls' $66,360.00 $0.00 $66,360.00 $4,382.59 $848.35 $38,738.20 $26,773.45 60% $51,611.05 EXPENSE TOTALS $388,030.00 $0.00 $388,030.00 $28,271.58 $848.35 $213,682.19 $173,499.46 55% $340,319.15 15ivison '12.1.1. ClItyAdiiinuinliiis'Ikuratoiii toCals ($388,030.00) $0.00 ($388,030.00) ($28,271.58) ($848.35) ($213,682.19) ($173,499.46) 55% ($340,319.15) I'.51v1saorr t.At.t... CllltyAtt,owinmy EXPENSE /lens,'olwa / 5e14(,.e F 5111 Regular Wages 133,750.00 .00 133,750.00 6,730.22 .00 83,153.70 50,596.30 62 126,959.89 5121 Overtime .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 5.75 5211 OR Workers' Benefit 20.00 .00 20.00 1.11 .00 10.31 9.69 52 17.39 5212 Social Security 10,090.00 .00 10,090.00 507.86 .00 5,042.86 5,047.14 50 9,885.25 5213 Med & Dent Ins 21,450.00 .00 21,450.00 1,478.48 .00 10,713.41 10,736.59 50 20,691.69 5214 5214.100 PERS - City 26,030.00 .00 26,030.00 1,157.86 .00 16,634.40 9,395.60 64 23,230.19 5214.600 PERS 6% 8,020.00 .00 8,020.00 416.75 .00 2,161.42 5,858.58 27 7,388.89 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM Page 2 of 57 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd PdorYear TotaV Fund 001... Ceuiireuiiallll Il�:r:sailers Del:rarhnne,n. 'S tr1... Adimiiiinliiis1toia tlilloi n I'.51v1saorr 5.45.5... CllltyAtt,oinmy EXPENSE Iaulsolrsro:/ 5o14(,.eF 5214 5214.800 DEFERED COMP - CITY 12,110.00 .00 12,110.00 215.53 .00 9,762.30 2,347.70 81 12,559.22 5214 - Totals $46,160.00 $0.00 $46,160.00 $1,790.14 $0.00 $28,558.12 $17,601.88 62% $43,178.30 5215 Long Term Disability Ins 210.00 .00 210.00 9.32 .00 93.49 116.51 45 216.45 5216 Unemployment Insurance 1,740.00 .00 1,740.00 87.49 .00 1,080.99 659.01 62 1,106.92 5217 Life Insurance 140.00 .00 140.00 6.01 .00 59.61 80.39 43 137.53 5218 Paid Family Leave Insurance 540.00 .00 540.00 24.95 .00 309.89 230.11 57 313.56 fly^r,5'oiwal.°a"s'^ vicas' Pbta'Js' $214,100.00 $0.00 $214,100.00 $10,635.58 $0.00 $129,022.38 $85,077.62 60% $202,512.73 //atei'e'feels & .5&.u,le.etis. 5314 Books 9,000.00 .00 9,000.00 2,325.92 3,322.30 5,648.22 29.48 100 7,269.02 5319 Office Supplies 2,000.00 .00 2,000.00 583.91 635.00 1,055.59 309.41 85 387.22 5417 HR/Other Employee Expenses .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 145.00 (145.00) +++ .00 5419 Other Professional Sery 1,000.00 .00 1,000.00 12.66 61.32 88.68 850.00 15 193.72 5421 Telephone/Data 1,500.00 .00 1,500.00 177.95 34.64 984.35 481.01 68 1,764.73 5422 Postage 100.00 .00 100.00 .00 .00 .00 100.00 0 .00 5428 IT Support 20,700.00 .00 20,700.00 1,725.00 .00 12,075.00 8,625.00 58 19,320.00 5432 Meals 400.00 .00 400.00 .00 .00 585.30 (185.30) 146 .00 5433 Mileage 530.00 .00 530.00 .00 .00 69.43 460.57 13 .00 5449 Leases- Other 550.00 .00 550.00 .00 .00 .00 550.00 0 .00 5464 Workers' Comp 290.00 .00 290.00 24.17 .00 169.19 120.81 58 330.00 5491 Dues & Subscriptions 3,000.00 .00 3,000.00 1,536.00 65.00 2,476.00 459.00 85 3,976.00 5492 Registrations/Training 7,500.00 .00 7,500.00 .00 .00 1,670.74 5,829.26 22 5,385.00 Plate ia& aft .°a"ei^ r,'e;'s' ftuta'ls $46,570.00 $0.00 $46,570.00 $6,385.61 $4,118.26 $24,967.50 $17,484.24 62% $38,625.69 EXPENSE TOTALS $260,670.00 $0.00 $260,670.00 $17,021.19 $4,118.26 $153,989.88 $102,561.86 61% $241,138.42 Itivr:ion 1411 CllItyAtt,oui"'mmytoaal„a ($260,670.00) $0.00 ($260,670.00) ($17,021.19) ($4,118.26) ($153,989.88) ($102,561.86) 61% ($241,138.42) I'.tivlt,aon 1.51.1...Il::Iiiinaiiroe EXPENSE 5111 Regular Wages 372,470.00 .00 372,470.00 24,402.97 .00 172,755.48 199,714.52 46 273,411.35 5112 Part -Time Wages 35,980.00 .00 35,980.00 2,046.02 .00 13,894.46 22,085.54 39 18,497.56 5121 Overtime 6,020.00 .00 6,020.00 7.13 .00 1,917.93 4,102.07 32 3,806.81 5211 OR Workers' Benefit 120.00 .00 120.00 5.09 .00 43.71 76.29 36 73.84 5212 Social Security 32,110.00 .00 32,110.00 1,915.05 .00 13,732.65 18,377.35 43 23,229.02 5213 Med & Dent Ins 79,570.00 .00 79,570.00 6,172.77 .00 37,329.01 42,240.99 47 56,280.53 5214 5214.100 PERS - City 66,340.00 .00 66,340.00 4,075.49 .00 29,847.68 36,492.32 45 42,454.87 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM 41 Page 3 of 57 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd PdorYear TotaV Fund 001... Geuiireuiiallll Il�:r:rrund Del:rarhnne,n. 'S tr1... Adimiiiinliiis1toia tlilloi n I'.tivlt,aon 1.51.1...Il::Iiiinaiiroe EXPENSE Iaulsolrsro:/ 5o14(,.eF 5214 5214.600 PERS 6% 22,710.00 .00 22,710.00 1,450.43 .00 10,474.84 12,235.16 46 17,147.35 5214.800 DEFERED COMP - CITY 3,720.00 .00 3,720.00 284.68 .00 2,017.78 1,702.22 54 3,459.00 5214 - Totals $92,770.00 $0.00 $92,770.00 $5,810.60 $0.00 $42,340.30 $50,429.70 46% $63,061.22 5215 Long Term Disability Ins 720.00 .00 720.00 53.02 .00 288.58 431.42 40 624.96 5216 Unemployment Insurance 5,400.00 .00 5,400.00 343.94 .00 2,451.32 2,948.68 45 2,612.04 5217 Life Insurance 460.00 .00 460.00 35.32 .00 192.83 267.17 42 414.06 5218 Paid Family Leave Insurance 1,660.00 .00 1,660.00 97.90 .00 692.77 967.23 42 734.82 fly^r,5'euiinal.°a"s'^ vicaF Pbta'LF $627,280.00 $0.00 $627,280.00 $40,889.81 $0.00 $285,639.04 $341,640.96 46% $442,746.21 //atev'fe /s & .5&.u,le.eti,r. 5319 Office Supplies 22,000.00 .00 22,000.00 574.08 225.13 6,947.72 14,827.15 33 18,609.16 5329 Other Supplies .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 246.87 (246.87) +++ 104.07 5414 Accounting/Auditing 25,000.00 .00 25,000.00 8,150.00 5,600.00 16,230.00 3,170.00 87 19,921.12 5417 HR/Other Employee Expenses .00 .00 .00 100.00 .00 100.00 (100.00) +++ .00 5419 Other Professional Sery 30,000.00 .00 30,000.00 2,482.25 12,418.01 13,393.99 4,188.00 86 22,906.62 5421 Telephone/Data 3,000.00 .00 3,000.00 329.75 209.48 2,161.50 629.02 79 3,216.85 5422 Postage 3,800.00 .00 3,800.00 422.97 .00 1,836.13 1,963.87 48 3,376.32 5428 IT Support 69,300.00 .00 69,300.00 5,775.00 .00 40,425.00 28,875.00 58 64,680.00 5430 Red Light Camera Contract 180,000.00 .00 180,000.00 9,390.00 107,679.00 72,321.00 .00 100 190,248.00 5432 Meals 400.00 .00 400.00 .00 .00 149.82 250.18 37 287.10 5433 Mileage 650.00 .00 650.00 .00 .00 138.86 511.14 21 203.75 5439 Travel 800.00 .00 800.00 .00 .00 266.77 533.23 33 929.24 5446 Software Licenses 6,700.00 .00 6,700.00 .00 .00 5,268.58 1,431.42 79 5,503.36 5464 Workers' Comp 950.00 .00 950.00 79.17 .00 554.19 395.81 58 1,179.96 5491 Dues & Subscriptions 2,600.00 .00 2,600.00 555.00 .00 1,310.00 1,290.00 50 2,711.64 5492 Registrations/Training 15,000.00 .00 15,000.00 2,845.96 .00 5,823.24 9,176.76 39 3,288.90 5493 Printing/Binding 3,000.00 .00 3,000.00 .00 .00 55.00 2,945.00 2 3,231.92 5500 Banking Fees & Charges 66,160.00 .00 66,160.00 5,056.00 .00 30,264.12 35,895.88 46 18,252.35 Plata"'^ria& aft .°a"�'^rh r,'as' 7bta'ls' $429,360.00 $0.00 $429,360.00 $35,760.18 $126,131.62 $197,492.79 $105,735.59 75% $358,650.36 EXPENSE TOTALS $1,056,640.00 $0.00 $1,056,640.00 $76,649.99 $126,131.62 $483,131.83 $447,376.55 58% $801,396.57 15lvlsio'r 151.1 @'liiui"raince toaals ($1,056,640.00) $0.00 ($1,056,640.00) ($76,649.99) ($126,131.62) ($483,131.83) ($447,376.55) 58% ($801,396.57) I'.51v1t,aon 1.531... Clllty IR,ecoiideui EXPENSE /Iaulsolwa / 5o14(,.eF 5111 Regular Wages 66,520.00 .00 66,520.00 5,123.02 .00 35,808.01 30,711.99 54 68,672.87 5112 Part -Time Wages 10,120.00 .00 10,120.00 .00 .00 .00 10,120.00 0 .00 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM 42 Page 4 of 57 Expense Budget Performance Report [isca�l Year, to Date 0 � /3 � /24 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp ACCOLInt and R(AklIp to ACCOUnt n c o r p u r a I c d t 8 8 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month YTD YTD Budget - YTD 11/o Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd Pdor Year TotaV Fund 001 Geiiimiiialll l::uind Dej,.,rarhnnen '101 Adimilinlishatilloin [)1v1s�on 1531 ClltylRecoiideii EXPENSE /Ielsolwa/ 5o14(,eF 5121 Overtime .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 . . . 19.52 5211 OR Workers' Benefit 10.00 .00 10.00 .76 .00 6.68 3.32 67 16.35 5212 Social Security 6,080.00 .00 6,080.00 400.69 .00 2,801.65 3,278.35 46 5,481.77 5213 Med & Dent Ins 4,720.00 .00 4,720.00 412.64 .00 2,523.85 2,196.15 53 6,099.64 5214 5214.100 PERS - City 13,440.00 .00 13,440.00 884.08 .00 6,167.55 7,272.45 46 10,052.72 5214.600 PERS 6% 3,990.00 .00 3,990.00 318.20 .00 2,219.87 1,770.13 56 4,195.11 5214.800 DEFERED COMP - CITY 3,010.00 .00 3,010.00 180.36 .00 1,333.65 1,676.35 44 1,933.05 5214 - Totals $20,440.00 $0.00 $20,440.00 $1,382.64 $0.00 $9,721.07 $10,718.93 48% $16,180.88 5215 Long Term Disability Ins 110.00 .00 110.00 10.23 .00 62.13 47.87 56 130.56 5216 Unemployment Insurance 1,000.00 .00 1,000.00 66.60 .00 465.52 534.48 47 590.87 5217 Life Insurance 70.00 .00 70.00 6.60 .00 40.09 29.91 57 84.26 5218 Paid Family Leave Insurance 300.00 .00 300.00 19.56 .00 136.15 163.85 45 174.91 fler,soiwal 5&vicaF 7btaLF $109,370.00 $0.00 $109,370.00 $7,422.74 $0.00 $51,565.15 $57,804.85 47% $97,451.63 plate'lials & 5&vicaF 5319 Office Supplies 1,000.00 .00 1,000.00 121.44 .00 327.06 672.94 33 1,142.01 5419 Other Professional Sery 5,500.00 .00 5,500.00 8.44 40.88 5,010.62 448.50 92 180.90 5421 Telephone/Data 450.00 .00 450.00 44.36 .00 307.95 142.05 68 520.20 5422 Postage 200.00 .00 200.00 .63 .00 3.63 196.37 2 211.10 5428 IT Support 9,450.00 .00 9,450.00 787.50 .00 5,512.50 3,937.50 58 8,820.00 5432 Meals 300.00 .00 300.00 .00 .00 90.90 209.10 30 182.25 5433 Mileage 500.00 .00 500.00 .00 .00 64.85 435.15 13 461.64 5439 Travel 850.00 .00 850.00 .00 .00 769.06 80.94 90 524.45 5464 Workers' Comp 100.00 .00 100.00 8.33 .00 58.31 41.69 58 120.00 5471 Equipment Repair & Maint 920.00 .00 920.00 .00 .00 .00 920.00 0 .00 5491 Dues & Subscriptions 300.00 .00 300.00 80.00 .00 305.00 (5.00) 102 378.40 5492 Reg istrations/Training 3,000.00 .00 3,000.00 .00 .00 590.00 2,410.00 20 736.44 Plate via&aft 5ei^ raF 7bfals $22,570.00 $0.00 $22,570.00 $1,050.70 $40.88 $13,039.88 $9,489.24 58% $13,277.39 EXPENSE TOTALS $131,940.00 $0.00 $131,940.00 $8,473.44 $40.88 $64,605.03 $67,294.09 49% $110,729.02 [)ivrsion 1531 ClltylRecoiideii toals ($131,940.00) $0.00 ($131,940.00) ($8,473.44) ($40.88) ($64,605.03) ($67,294.09) 49% ($110,729.02) [)ivrs'on 1611 illuimainlResouixes EXPENSE /Ielsolwa/ 5�1�4(,eF 5111 Regular Wages 96,930.00 .00 96,930.00 7,444.81 .00 52,113.63 44,816.37 54 96,525.66 5112 Part -Time Wages 10,120.00 .00 10,120.00 .00 .00 .00 10,120.00 0 .00 5121 Overtime .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 ... 16.96 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM Page 5 of 57 43 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd PdorYear ToitaV Fund 001... Geuiireuiiallll Il�:r:sailers Del:rarhnne,n. '1 tr1... Adimiiiinliiis1toia tlilloi n 15ivrs'on 1611 IPlllrrumain IRessussuimes EXPENSE Iaulsolrsro:/ 5o14(,.eF 5211 OR Workers' Benefit 20.00 .00 20.00 1.01 .00 8.35 11.65 42 18.70 5212 Social Security 8,440.00 .00 8,440.00 583.48 .00 4,078.15 4,361.85 48 7,852.08 5213 Med & Dent Ins 11,700.00 .00 11,700.00 1,023.46 .00 6,285.56 5,414.44 54 12,858.04 5214 5214.100 PERS - City 18,810.00 .00 18,810.00 1,303.10 .00 9,121.70 9,688.30 48 14,682.90 5214.600 PERS 6% 5,810.00 .00 5,810.00 469.03 .00 3,283.22 2,526.78 57 6,114.66 5214.800 DEFERED COMP - CITY 4,850.00 .00 4,850.00 372.24 .00 2,605.68 2,244.32 54 4,738.89 5214 - Totals $29,470.00 $0.00 $29,470.00 $2,144.37 $0.00 $15,010.60 $14,459.40 51% $25,536.45 5215 Long Term Disability Ins 160.00 .00 160.00 14.15 .00 85.72 74.28 54 181.59 5216 Unemployment Insurance 1,400.00 .00 1,400.00 96.78 .00 677.46 722.54 48 834.97 5217 Life Insurance 100.00 .00 100.00 8.96 .00 54.31 45.69 54 115.10 5218 Paid Family Leave Insurance 430.00 .00 430.00 27.74 .00 193.65 236.35 45 241.75 fly^r,5'oiwal.°a"s'^ vicaF Pbta'LF $158,770.00 $0.00 $158,770.00 $11,344.76 $0.00 $78,507.43 $80,262.57 49% $144,181.30 Afatevials & .5&u,le.otis. 5315 Computer Supplies 500.00 .00 500.00 .00 .00 .00 500.00 0 345.38 5319 Office Supplies 1,000.00 .00 1,000.00 .00 .00 256.53 743.47 26 521.00 5412 Legal 30,000.00 .00 30,000.00 .00 .00 .00 30,000.00 0 .00 5417 HR/Other Employee Expenses 3,500.00 .00 3,500.00 55.46 .00 3,250.28 249.72 93 2,305.89 5419 Other Professional Sery 32,000.00 .00 32,000.00 2,154.22 419.44 13,677.56 17,903.00 44 27,129.76 5421 Telephone/Data 800.00 .00 800.00 52.48 52.79 364.94 382.27 52 790.28 5422 Postage 30.00 .00 30.00 .00 .00 .00 30.00 0 6.04 5424 Advertising 500.00 .00 500.00 .00 .00 .00 500.00 0 .00 5428 IT Support 19,350.00 .00 19,350.00 1,612.50 .00 11,287.50 8,062.50 58 18,060.00 5433 Mileage 500.00 .00 500.00 .00 .00 161.07 338.93 32 336.33 5439 Travel 2,000.00 .00 2,000.00 779.27 .00 945.13 1,054.87 47 1,625.22 5464 Workers' Comp 390.00 .00 390.00 32.50 .00 227.50 162.50 58 420.00 5491 Dues & Subscriptions 4,000.00 .00 4,000.00 125.00 .00 125.00 3,875.00 3 2,977.46 5492 Registrations/Training 10,000.00 .00 10,000.00 .00 .00 1,955.00 8,045.00 20 2,314.00 Plate^ ia& aft .°a"ei^ r,'aF ftuta'ls $104,570.00 $0.00 $104,570.00 $4,811.43 $472.23 $32,250.51 $71,847.26 31% $56,831.36 EXPENSE TOTALS $263,340.00 $0.00 $263,340.00 $16,156.19 $472.23 $110,757.94 $152,109.83 42% $201,012.66 15ivrson 161.1 IPllssuiinain IResouii,eeo toCals ($263,340.00) $0.00 ($263,340.00) ($16,156.19) ($472.23) ($110,757.94) ($152,109.83) 42% ($201,012.66) Dej,.,Karhnnenr� 101...As'imillinliie1kuratililloin toCals ($2,209,350.00) $0.00 ($2,209,350.00) ($152,780.28) ($131,611.34) ($1,079,350.99) ($998,387.67) 55% ($1,777,403.38) Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM Page 6 of 57 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd PdorYear ToitaV Fund 001... Geuiireuiiallll Il�:r:sound Dej,.,rarhnnenp 12p15.. 15eoinouisoliie IDevelllollpimeint I'.51v1sa on 5.2.50 .. IEcoin IDev EXPENSE Iaulsolrsro:/ 5o14(,.ox,r. 5111 Regular Wages 129,900.00 .00 129,900.00 9,885.87 .00 68,684.47 61,215.53 53 120,312.03 5112 Part -Time Wages .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 3,348.25 (3,348.25) +++ .00 5121 Overtime .00 .00 .00 8.16 .00 795.51 (795.51) +++ 139.91 5211 OR Workers' Benefit 30.00 .00 30.00 1.79 .00 16.37 13.63 55 26.00 5212 Social Security 10,330.00 .00 10,330.00 751.78 .00 5,555.69 4,774.31 54 9,733.97 5213 Med & Dent Ins 17,930.00 .00 17,930.00 1,601.94 .00 9,681.99 8,248.01 54 18,922.84 5214 5214.100 PERS - City 22,700.00 .00 22,700.00 1,716.04 .00 11,973.87 10,726.13 53 18,248.01 5214.600 PERS 6% 7,790.00 .00 7,790.00 617.63 .00 4,309.55 3,480.45 55 7,646.50 5214.800 DEFERED COMP - CITY 5,200.00 .00 5,200.00 399.94 .00 2,765.95 2,434.05 53 5,021.29 5214 - Totals $35,690.00 $0.00 $35,690.00 $2,733.61 $0.00 $19,049.37 $16,640.63 53% $30,915.80 5215 Long Term Disability Ins 240.00 .00 240.00 20.23 .00 123.32 116.68 51 220.34 5216 Unemployment Insurance 1,690.00 .00 1,690.00 128.57 .00 946.43 743.57 56 1,082.44 5217 Life Insurance 150.00 .00 150.00 12.96 .00 78.88 71.12 53 142.72 5218 Paid Family Leave Insurance 520.00 .00 520.00 35.16 .00 266.04 253.96 51 282.21 fly^r,5'oiwal.°a"s'^ vicas' Pbta'Js' $196,480.00 $0.00 $196,480.00 $15,180.07 $0.00 $108,546.32 $87,933.68 55% $181,778.26 Afate'lial��s & .5&.u,le.as. 5315 Computer Supplies 500.00 .00 500.00 .00 .00 .00 500.00 0 .00 5319 Office Supplies 26,700.00 .00 26,700.00 99.63 .00 1,178.38 25,521.62 4 8,121.63 5329 Other Supplies .00 .00 .00 4,982.98 .00 8,955.94 (8,955.94) +++ .00 5419 Other Professional Sery 242,000.00 .00 242,000.00 3,597.57 4,715.44 68,170.96 169,113.60 30 69,848.51 5421 Telephone/Data 2,200.00 .00 2,200.00 221.05 34.64 1,544.36 621.00 72 2,474.28 5422 Postage 300.00 .00 300.00 .00 .00 .63 299.37 0 27.01 5428 IT Support 16,500.00 .00 16,500.00 1,375.00 .00 9,625.00 6,875.00 58 4,200.00 5432 Meals 500.00 .00 500.00 .00 .00 457.92 42.08 92 2,661.45 5433 Mileage 850.00 .00 850.00 .00 .00 310.47 539.53 37 .00 5439 Travel 2,500.00 .00 2,500.00 .00 .00 580.32 1,919.68 23 2,168.69 5464 Workers' Comp 220.00 .00 220.00 18.33 .00 128.31 91.69 58 240.00 5491 Dues & Subscriptions 9,690.00 .00 9,690.00 442.87 .00 8,967.34 722.66 93 8,994.63 5492 Registrations/Training 6,900.00 .00 6,900.00 200.00 .00 4,387.99 2,512.01 64 3,923.22 5520 Grant Program 325,000.00 .00 325,000.00 .00 .00 .00 325,000.00 0 65.00 Plate^ ia& aft .°a"ei r,'e;'s' 7bta'ls' $633,860.00 $0.00 $633,860.00 $10,937.43 $4,750.08 $104,307.62 $524,802.30 17% $102,724.42 EXPENSE TOTALS $830,340.00 $0.00 $830,340.00 $26,117.50 $4,750.08 $212,853.94 $612,735.98 26% $284,502.68 Itivr',alon 1250 Ecoin IPDev toa al„a ($830,340.00) $0.00 ($830,340.00) ($26,117.50) ($4,750.08) ($212,853.94) ($612,735.98) 26% ($284,502.68) De^I,':rarhnne^i' 125 15'Ieoinouisoliie lPDevelllollpimeint toa al„a ($830,340.00) $0.00 ($830,340.00) ($26,117.50) ($4,750.08) ($212,853.94) ($612,735.98) 26% ($284,502.68) Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM Page 7 of 57 45 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt I n c o r p u r a I c d t 8 8 9 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Tr'ansacdons Encumbrances Tr'ansacdons Tr'ansacdons Rec'd PdorYear ToitaV Fund 001. Geul"relllsrlll Il::uilrrd Dej,.,karhrYeP,'Y I199 °° Nollln delpallllhll'nelinta;"q Ill IJlvl':Ion '1219 Otll"miii' Adliinllin III 'tllatlloIin EXPENSE Atate'lial's & .t`&.u,to.otis. 5319 Office Supplies 8,500.00 .00 8,500.00 .00 1,668.12 16,950.10 (10,118.22) 219 11,635.95 5329 Other Supplies 6,000.00 .00 6,000.00 51.94 .00 1,462.94 4,537.06 24 4,368.41 5417 HR/Other Employee Expenses 1,000.00 .00 1,000.00 .00 .00 3,935.35 (2,935.35) 394 61.14 5419 5419 Other Professional Sery 257,000.00 260,000.00 517,000.00 29,043.97 258,457.53 212,503.70 46,038.77 91 156,556.21 5419.201 ToT Grants 65,000.00 .00 65,000.00 .00 .00 65,000.00 .00 100 60,000.00 5419.723 Rental Assistance Program .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 69,159.69 5419 - Totals $322,000.00 $260,000.00 $582,000.00 $29,043.97 $258,457.53 $277,503.70 $46,038.77 92% $285,715.90 5422 Postage 1,700.00 .00 1,700.00 265.25 .00 1,339.25 360.75 79 1,762.05 5425 Publication of Legal Note 2,000.00 .00 2,000.00 923.79 .00 923.79 1,076.21 46 .00 5429 Other Communication Sery 12,500.00 .00 12,500.00 .00 .00 5,988.00 6,512.00 48 7,225.00 5432 Meals .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 543.00 5449 Leases- Other .00 .00 .00 1,245.96 1,668.12 2,592.86 (4,260.98) +++ 411.90 5459 5459 Other Utilities .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 1,800.00 5459.001 CRC Expenses 100,000.00 .00 100,000.00 3,196.44 5,878.84 17,171.01 76,950.15 23 50,655.90 5459 - Totals $100,000.00 $0.00 $100,000.00 $3,196.44 $5,878.84 $17,171.01 $76,950.15 23% $52,455.90 5463 Property/Earthquake Insurance 16,680.00 .00 16,680.00 1,390.00 .00 9,730.00 6,950.00 58 16,410.00 5465 General Liability Insurance 50,100.00 .00 50,100.00 4,175.00 .00 29,225.00 20,875.00 58 49,440.00 5481 Utility Assistance Program 40,000.00 .00 40,000.00 5,000.00 .00 25,000.00 15,000.00 62 25,000.00 5491 Dues & Subscriptions 40,000.00 .00 40,000.00 .00 .00 39,344.16 655.84 98 37,184.68 5492 Registrations/Training 2,000.00 .00 2,000.00 .00 .00 .00 2,000.00 0 .00 5520 Grant Program 482,200.00 450,000.00 932,200.00 64,967.75 .00 184,760.75 747,439.25 20 779,820.48 tt«s'ts'^ria& & °a"s' *,,'as' 7bta'ls' $1,084,680.00 $710,000.00 $1,794,680.00 $110,260.10 $267,672.61 $615,926.91 $911,080.48 49% $1,272,034.41 EXPENSE TOTALS $1,084,680.00 $710,000.00 $1,794,680.00 $110,260.10 $267,672.61 $615,926.91 $911,080.48 49% $1,272,034.41 [)Ivr:'i n 'I219 Otllllmiii"'As'tul'nuinlisIkuatlilloin toCals ($1,084,680.00) ($710,000.00) ($1,794,680.00) ($110,260.10) ($267,672.61) ($615,926.91) ($911,080.48) 49% ($1,272,034.41) [)I vr:'i n 971L .. 011peul"'sr1tliling I'ulsrul"rs'Iteul' Out EXPENSE t"t«vsrsl`,,r,s' Oz(t 5811 5811.110 Transfer to Transit 100,000.00 .00 100,000.00 8,333.33 .00 58,333.31 41,666.69 58 150,000.00 5811.358 Transfer to General Cap Const Fund 66,470.00 .00 66,470.00 .00 .00 20,610.00 45,860.00 31 515,224.00 5811.693 Transfer to Reserve for PERS .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 123,740.04 5811 - Totals $166,470.00 $0.00 $166,470.00 $8,333.33 $0.00 $78,943.31 $87,526.69 47% $788,964.04 TIwi' F'9`ar,vs ttrut't'tta'Js' $166,470.00 $0.00 $166,470.00 $8,333.33 $0.00 $78,943.31 $87,526.69 47% $788,964.04 EXPENSE TOTALS $166,470.00 $0.00 $166,470.00 $8,333.33 $0.00 $78,943.31 $87,526.69 47% $788,964.04 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM Page 8 of 57 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd PdorYear ToitaV Fund 001 .. Geuiireuiiallll Il�:r:sailers Dej,.,rarhnne nr l stst .. Nouir..stellpaiii hiineintalll I'.tivr:lon 9711 f"tllpeiiatiliuing I"'ui ainsfeii"' Out toa al„a ($166,470.00) $0.00 ($166,470.00) ($8,333.33) $0.00 ($78,943.31) ($87,526.69) 47% ($788,964.04) De^I:rartnne^i' Lstlstl Noun dellpaui'1kurneui" talll toal„a ($1,251,150.00) ($710,000.00) ($1,961,150.00) ($118,593.43) ($267,672.61) ($694,870.22) ($998,607.17) 49% ($2,060,998.45) Dej,.,rarhnne np 211 IPolllliiee I'.Slvlsaorr 2111 .• IV'reultorolll EXPENSE Iaulsolrsro:/ 5o14(,.eF 5111 Regular Wages 4,724,300.00 .00 4,724,300.00 360,120.36 .00 2,503,753.23 2,220,546.77 53 4,376,450.69 5112 Part -Time Wages 21,730.00 .00 21,730.00 1,629.08 .00 14,849.84 6,880.16 68 14,700.66 5121 Overtime 191,130.00 .00 191,130.00 15,905.40 .00 148,071.66 43,058.34 77 235,331.72 5211 OR Workers' Benefit 1,000.00 .00 1,000.00 62.88 .00 496.54 503.46 50 955.03 5212 Social Security 382,120.00 .00 382,120.00 28,576.75 .00 201,655.33 180,464.67 53 362,786.97 5213 Med & Dent Ins 950,900.00 .00 950,900.00 86,157.33 .00 477,173.40 473,726.60 50 857,093.92 5214 5214.100 PERS - City 1,060,480.00 .00 1,060,480.00 80,292.48 .00 573,596.96 486,883.04 54 908,125.64 5214.600 PERS 6% 294,910.00 .00 294,910.00 22,042.66 .00 156,733.65 138,176.35 53 277,172.34 5214.800 DEFERED COMP - CITY 75,780.00 .00 75,780.00 4,825.34 .00 33,072.34 42,707.66 44 58,046.04 5214 - Totals $1,431,170.00 $0.00 $1,431,170.00 $107,160.48 $0.00 $763,402.95 $667,767.05 53% $1,243,344.02 5215 Long Term Disability Ins 8,220.00 .00 8,220.00 714.85 .00 4,314.42 3,905.58 52 7,984.64 5216 Unemployment Insurance 64,160.00 .00 64,160.00 4,909.51 .00 34,666.92 29,493.08 54 39,594.71 5217 Life Insurance 5,750.00 .00 5,750.00 482.24 .00 2,905.32 2,844.68 51 5,409.69 5218 Paid Family Leave Insurance 19,780.00 .00 19,780.00 1,346.00 .00 9,679.09 10,100.91 49 10,897.64 fly^r,5'euiinal.°a"s' vicas' Pbta'Js' $7,800,260.00 $0.00 $7,800,260.00 $607,064.88 $0.00 $4,160,968.70 $3,639,291.30 53% $7,154,549.69 A7atevial��s & .5&.u,le.etis. 5319 Office Supplies 7,500.00 .00 7,500.00 957.43 132.42 4,995.28 2,372.30 68 7,456.79 5323 Fuel 90,000.00 .00 90,000.00 8,132.19 .00 42,702.61 47,297.39 47 77,345.45 5324 Clothing 42,400.00 .00 42,400.00 3,395.49 441.07 25,137.86 16,821.07 60 47,903.06 5326 Safety/Medical 4,000.00 .00 4,000.00 45.00 .00 550.70 3,449.30 14 4,086.37 5329 Other Supplies 28,000.00 .00 28,000.00 1,808.24 .00 22,295.58 5,704.42 80 22,706.44 5351 Ammunition 25,000.00 .00 25,000.00 .00 .00 28,032.95 (3,032.95) 112 23,521.11 5400 Code Abatement 3,000.00 .00 3,000.00 .00 .00 .00 3,000.00 0 .00 5415 Computer 120,000.00 .00 120,000.00 375.00 11,270.58 41,187.16 67,542.26 44 33,903.67 5417 HR/Other Employee Expenses 10,000.00 .00 10,000.00 .00 .00 4,523.50 5,476.50 45 10,407.97 5419 Other Professional Sery 26,000.00 .00 26,000.00 2,811.59 404.51 15,431.36 10,164.13 61 48,985.71 5420 Investigation Expenses 7,500.00 .00 7,500.00 .00 .00 .00 7,500.00 0 4,279.95 5421 Telephone/Data 35,000.00 .00 35,000.00 3,355.93 995.00 23,516.96 10,488.04 70 40,459.45 5422 Postage 8,000.00 .00 8,000.00 1,090.74 48.51 4,472.38 3,479.11 57 4,959.85 5424 Advertising 1,000.00 .00 1,000.00 .00 .00 607.39 392.61 61 205.00 5426 Contract Networks 10,000.00 .00 10,000.00 .00 .00 10,000.00 .00 100 9,828.14 5428 IT Support 498,010.00 .00 498,010.00 41,500.83 .00 290,505.81 207,504.19 58 444,969.96 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM Page 9 of 57 47 WQODBURN Inckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account DescrIlptiion Budget Amendments Budget Transacitfions Encumbrances Transacitfions Transacitfions Rec'd Pr'IorYear ToitaV Fund 001... Geuiirourallll Il�:r:sailers Dej,.,rarhnne np 211 IPolllliior I'.Slvlsaorr 2.1.1.1...1 EXPENSE Alatei'rlet��s & .5&u,te.as. 5429 Other Communication Sery 537,200.00 .00 537,200.00 44,758.85 179,035.42 358,070.80 93.78 100 519,037.99 5432 Meals .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 16.99 5439 Travel 22,000.00 .00 22,000.00 344.18 .00 10,013.93 11,986.07 46 20,511.89 5443 Office Equipment 4,500.00 .00 4,500.00 89.94 .00 2,777.54 1,722.46 62 2,143.14 5444 Leases - Vehicle 238,000.00 .00 238,000.00 .00 .00 193,434.75 44,565.25 81 188,421.95 5449 Leases- Other 86,860.00 .00 86,860.00 194.84 822.07 85,323.95 713.98 99 84,358.05 5451 Natural Gas 6,000.00 .00 6,000.00 1,149.80 .00 3,733.61 2,266.39 62 4,520.62 5452 Water/Sewer 900.00 .00 900.00 .00 .00 .00 900.00 0 .00 5453 Electricity 62,500.00 .00 62,500.00 5,303.47 .00 30,441.12 32,058.88 49 63,756.30 5461 Auto Insurance 29,280.00 .00 29,280.00 2,440.00 .00 17,080.00 12,200.00 58 30,810.00 5463 Property/Earthquake Insurance 10,390.00 .00 10,390.00 865.83 .00 6,060.81 4,329.19 58 10,419.96 5464 Workers' Comp 106,100.00 .00 106,100.00 8,841.68 .00 61,891.76 44,208.24 58 124,819.92 5465 General Liability Insurance 100,780.00 .00 100,780.00 8,398.34 .00 58,788.38 41,991.62 58 97,320.00 5471 Equipment Repair & Maint 35,000.00 .00 35,000.00 .00 .00 7,451.12 27,548.88 21 7,356.59 5472 Buildings Repairs & Maint 23,100.00 .00 23,100.00 2,159.50 6,585.00 17,593.49 (1,078.49) 105 36,108.95 5475 Vehicle Repair & Maint 45,000.00 .00 45,000.00 2,935.89 131.00 18,902.65 25,966.35 42 42,849.42 5492 Registrations/Training 35,500.00 .00 35,500.00 4,291.63 .00 36,382.34 (882.34) 102 28,833.38 5493 Printing/Binding 11,000.00 .00 11,000.00 .00 .00 2,383.00 8,617.00 22 4,902.65 Plate^ ia& & .°a"si r,'e's' 7bta'ls' $2,269,520.00 $0.00 $2,269,520.00 $145,246.39 $199,865.58 $1,424,288.79 $645,365.63 72% $2,047,206.72 C tvJ ttr rt ret, 5641 Office Furniture & Equip 30,000.00 .00 30,000.00 .00 .00 .00 30,000.00 0 .00 a,"aye✓tat /truth, t'tsta'& $30,000.00 $0.00 $30,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $30,000.00 0% $0.00 EXPENSE TOTALS $10,099,780.00 $0.00 $10,099,780.00 $752,311.27 $199,865.58 $5,585,257.49 $4,314,656.93 57% $9,201,756.41 I'.Slvi:ion 2111 Irsgkuiolll toaal„a ($10,099,780.00) $0.00 ($10,099,780.00) ($752,311.27) ($199,865.58) ($5,585,257.49) ($4,314,656.93) 57% ($9,201,756.41) De^I,':rarhnne^i'rt' 211 IPolllliice toal„a ($10,099,780.00) $0.00 ($10,099,780.00) ($752,311.27) ($199,865.58) ($5,585,257.49) ($4,314,656.93) 57% ($9,201,756.41) Dee,., <arh ne,n. 411 Couiiouiiousuiirui1tV Seuiiviiices 15ivrs'on 3199 .. III uillCxuiim y Adimiiiinliiis1toiatliioin EXPENSE flaps: ruassse:/ 5e14(,.e F 5111 Regular Wages 355,500.00 .00 355,500.00 28,739.68 .00 190,378.61 165,121.39 54 339,712.20 5112 Part -Time Wages 125,330.00 .00 125,330.00 8,336.01 .00 59,285.12 66,044.88 47 85,085.69 5121 Overtime .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 99.46 (99.46) +++ 24.46 5211 OR Workers' Benefit 170.00 .00 170.00 10.93 .00 83.95 86.05 49 153.55 5212 Social Security 37,120.00 .00 37,120.00 2,773.06 .00 18,796.76 18,323.24 51 33,654.00 5213 Med & Dent Ins 52,030.00 .00 52,030.00 7,133.20 .00 35,254.04 16,775.96 68 53,246.84 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM Page 10 of 57 WQODBURN Inckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account DescrIlptiion Budget Amendments Budget Transacitfions Encumbrances Transacitfions Transacitfions Rec'd Pr'IorYear ToitaV Fund 001... Oeui"rouiiallll ll�:r:ssui"rd Del:r<srh nen° 411 Coiiii'nui'nusui"rui'Ity Seuii"viiices 15ivrs'on 3199 .. III 111111woi"eroi"y As' imiilinliiis'foi"atlilloin EXPENSE Flensolrsro:/ 5o14(,.eF 5214 5214 Retirement 5214.100 PIERS - City 5214.600 PIERS 6% 5214.800 DEFERED COMP - CITY 5215 Long Term Disability Ins 5216 Unemployment Insurance 5217 Life Insurance 5218 Paid Family Leave Insurance Afatei'e'feel�s & .5&.u,le.as. 5319 Office Supplies 5323 Fuel 5340 Print Materials - Teen 5341 Print Materials - Adult 5342 Print Materials - Child 5345 5345 5345.001 5345.002 5347 5347.002 5347.003 5347.004 5347.005 5349 5350 5419 5421 5422 5424 5428 5432 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ (1,175.46) 84,530.00 .00 84,530.00 6,280.16 .00 42,069.72 42,460.28 50 61,045.54 21,330.00 .00 21,330.00 1,739.90 .00 11,523.19 9,806.81 54 17,664.68 4,710.00 .00 4,710.00 364.04 .00 2,520.10 2,189.90 54 4,561.06 5214 - Totals $110,570.00 $0.00 $110,570.00 $8,384.10 $0.00 $56,113.01 $54,456.99 51% $82,095.82 640.00 .00 640.00 58.32 .00 340.32 299.68 53 644.38 6,240.00 .00 6,240.00 482.00 .00 3,247.01 2,992.99 52 3,648.64 400.00 .00 400.00 37.69 .00 219.90 180.10 55 416.66 1,920.00 .00 1,920.00 139.95 .00 956.83 963.17 50 1,088.32 fly^r,5'oiwal.°a"s'^ vicas' Pbta'Js' $689,920.00 $0.00 $689,920.00 $56,094.94 $0.00 $364,775.01 $325,144.99 53% $599,770.56 3,560.00 .00 3,560.00 278.49 .00 1,388.61 2,171.39 39 2,760.32 3,000.00 .00 3,000.00 .00 .00 232.71 2,767.29 8 .00 3,800.00 .00 3,800.00 1,278.26 24.65 2,464.72 1,310.63 66 3,218.00 24,500.00 .00 24,500.00 1,685.84 715.49 13,996.86 9,787.65 60 16,377.92 13,500.00 .00 13,500.00 3,422.18 132.42 9,404.90 3,962.68 71 15,031.19 Audiovisual Materials - Adult 7,000.00 .00 7,000.00 314.87 69.72 1,487.96 5,442.32 22 4,886.23 Audiovisual Materials - Child 2,000.00 .00 2,000.00 68.22 .00 1,160.46 839.54 58 2,025.15 Audiovisual Materials - Teen 1,000.00 .00 1,000.00 .00 .00 167.93 832.07 17 669.63 5345 - Totals $10,000.00 $0.00 $10,000.00 $383.09 $69.72 $2,816.35 $7,113.93 29% $7,581.01 Program Supplies - Adult 2,000.00 .00 2,000.00 180.75 .00 1,497.30 502.70 75 4,652.85 Program Supplies - Child 10,500.00 .00 10,500.00 1,143.92 40.00 4,647.54 5,812.46 45 10,784.93 Program Supplies - Technical Services 5,000.00 .00 5,000.00 .00 .00 1,117.43 3,882.57 22 4,613.47 Program Supplies - Teen 2,000.00 .00 2,000.00 189.11 .00 332.47 1,667.53 17 .00 5347 - Totals $19,500.00 $0.00 $19,500.00 $1,513.78 $40.00 $7,594.74 $11,865.26 39% $20,051.25 Periodicals - Adult 3,380.00 .00 3,380.00 .00 .00 60.00 3,320.00 2 3,035.34 Periodicals - Child 250.00 .00 250.00 .00 .00 .00 250.00 0 182.44 Other Professional Sery 1,500.00 .00 1,500.00 148.42 221.86 666.12 612.02 59 1,257.76 Telephone/Data 2,500.00 .00 2,500.00 247.24 296.91 1,550.34 652.75 74 2,653.03 Postage 230.00 .00 230.00 .00 .00 97.10 132.90 42 355.97 Advertising 630.00 .00 630.00 .00 .00 405.48 224.52 64 349.99 IT Support 103,500.00 .00 103,500.00 8,625.00 .00 60,375.00 43,125.00 58 97,020.00 Meals 300.00 .00 300.00 .00 .00 .00 300.00 0 149.00 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM Page 11 of 57 WQODBURN Inckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account DescrIlptiion Budget Amendments Budget Transacitfions Encumbrances Transacitfions Transacitfions Rec'd Pr'IorYear ToitaV Fund 001... Geuiirsurallll Il�:r:sailers Del:r<srh ne,n. 411 Coiiiiinuiinusuiirui1tV Srsuiiviiices [)ivs'ion 3199..III111111wuiimyAdimiiiinliiis1toiatlilloin EXPENSE flatei'rlels & .5&u,fe.otis. 5433 Mileage 200.00 .00 200.00 .00 .00 .00 200.00 0 218.75 5439 Travel 1,500.00 .00 1,500.00 .00 .00 1,212.08 287.92 81 1,678.91 5443 Office Equipment 3,500.00 .00 3,500.00 .00 524.25 929.57 2,046.18 42 3,369.30 5451 Natural Gas 4,750.00 .00 4,750.00 1,120.70 .00 2,194.64 2,555.36 46 3,160.42 5453 Electricity 54,500.00 .00 54,500.00 3,438.92 .00 20,987.13 33,512.87 39 55,066.85 5461 Auto Insurance 490.00 .00 490.00 40.83 .00 285.81 204.19 58 .00 5463 Property/Earthquake Insurance 13,360.00 .00 13,360.00 1,113.33 .00 7,793.31 5,566.69 58 13,310.04 5464 Workers' Comp 520.00 .00 520.00 43.33 .00 303.31 216.69 58 510.00 5465 General Liability Insurance 9,470.00 .00 9,470.00 789.17 .00 5,524.19 3,945.81 58 8,829.96 5471 Equipment Repair & Maint 3,850.00 .00 3,850.00 .00 715.19 .00 3,134.81 19 2,725.38 5472 5472 Buildings Repairs & Maint 24,000.00 .00 24,000.00 .00 1,500.00 10,335.73 12,164.27 49 13,389.91 5472.001 Fixture Repair 5,090.00 .00 5,090.00 429.98 .00 429.98 4,660.02 8 3,293.69 5472 - Totals $29,090.00 $0.00 $29,090.00 $429.98 $1,500.00 $10,765.71 $16,824.29 42% $16,683.60 5475 Vehicle Repair & Maint 2,000.00 .00 2,000.00 519.48 131.56 519.48 1,348.96 33 1,007.69 5491 Dues & Subscriptions 400.00 .00 400.00 .00 .00 364.00 36.00 91 500.00 5492 Registrations/Training 1,120.00 .00 1,120.00 59.99 .00 1,466.99 (346.99) 131 951.99 5499 5499.001 Reg Lib Sv 1,000.00 .00 1,000.00 49.25 .00 226.55 773.45 23 108.45 5499 - Totals $1,000.00 $0.00 $1,000.00 $49.25 $0.00 $226.55 $773.45 23% $108.45 5500 Banking Fees & Charges .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 299.00 Plate^ ia& & °a"s' *,,'aF 7bta'ls' $315,900.00 $0.00 $315,900.00 $25,187.28 $4,372.05 $153,625.70 $157,902.25 50% $278,443.56 C ftvJ tfr rt rsf, 5642 Passenger Vehicles .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 28,492.69 a,"a eftaf tfrrtlsf, t'tsta& $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 +++ $28,492.69 EXPENSE TOTALS $1,005,820.00 $0.00 $1,005,820.00 $81,282.22 $4,372.05 $518,400.71 $483,047.24 52% $906,706.81 C'.5ivs:on 3199 IIL.liilll�uraui7Adiiii'nuiuiruic1kui"atiliivwuir �oCals ($1,005,820.00) $0.00 ($1,005,820.00) ($81,282.22) ($4,372.05) ($518,400.71) ($483,047.24) 52% ($906,706.81) [)ivs'ion 7419..Aduat1iiosAdiiiiinliiuirlils1toiiatl1loiiir EXPENSE flans: ruassse:/ 5e14(,.e F 5111 Regular Wages 72,080.00 .00 72,080.00 5,565.88 .00 40,475.43 31,604.57 56 72,078.90 5112 5112 Part -Time Wages 21,670.00 .00 21,670.00 1,916.11 .00 14,146.85 7,523.15 65 20,105.54 5112.011 Instruction Wages 40,860.00 .00 40,860.00 492.00 .00 5,671.50 35,188.50 14 5,899.58 5112.012 Lifeguarding Wages 128,890.00 .00 128,890.00 5,333.77 .00 58,793.03 70,096.97 46 83,569.84 5112.014 Administration Wages .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 716.65 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM Page 12 of 57 50 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd PdorYear ToitaV Fund 001... Geuii�rsur�allll Il�:r:rrund Del:rarh ne,n. 411 Coiiiiinuiinuruiirui1ty Srsuiiviiices D5vrs'on 7419..Aquat1iiosAdiiiiinliiuirlils1toiiatl1loiii�r EXPENSE Flaunsolrsro:/ 5o14(,.eF 5112 5112.015 Pool Operator (& Custodial) Wages 10,320.00 .00 10,320.00 .00 .00 .00 10,320.00 0 .00 5112.016 Water Fitness Instructor Wages 28,900.00 .00 28,900.00 2,159.69 .00 17,507.02 11,392.98 61 31,779.55 5112.017 Head Lifeguard Wages 43,120.00 .00 43,120.00 3,224.40 .00 17,078.49 26,041.51 40 14,295.19 5112 - Totals $273,760.00 $0.00 $273,760.00 $13,125.97 $0.00 $113,196.89 $160,563.11 41% $156,366.35 5211 OR Workers' Benefit 210.00 .00 210.00 8.87 .00 85.36 124.64 41 127.36 5212 Social Security 26,720.00 .00 26,720.00 1,438.20 .00 11,796.89 14,923.11 44 17,928.92 5213 Med & Dent Ins 17,510.00 .00 17,510.00 1,631.96 .00 9,554.56 7,955.44 55 16,642.74 5214 5214.100 PERS - City 60,180.00 .00 60,180.00 2,038.64 .00 13,180.03 46,999.97 22 19,877.88 5214.600 PERS 6% 4,320.00 .00 4,320.00 349.28 .00 2,444.96 1,875.04 57 3,937.68 5214.800 DEFERED COMP - CITY 3,600.00 .00 3,600.00 277.20 .00 1,940.40 1,659.60 54 3,554.62 5214 - Totals $68,100.00 $0.00 $68,100.00 $2,665.12 $0.00 $17,565.39 $50,534.61 26% $27,370.18 5215 Long Term Disability Ins 130.00 .00 130.00 11.43 .00 69.48 60.52 53 132.94 5216 Unemployment Insurance 4,500.00 .00 4,500.00 242.99 .00 1,997.84 2,502.16 44 2,003.68 5217 Life Insurance 90.00 .00 90.00 7.38 .00 44.84 45.16 50 85.96 5218 Paid Family Leave Insurance 1,400.00 .00 1,400.00 72.90 .00 601.06 798.94 43 558.01 fly^r,5'oiwal.°a"s'^ vicaF Pbta'LF $464,500.00 $0.00 $464,500.00 $24,770.70 $0.00 $195,387.74 $269,112.26 42% $293,295.04 A7atoe'fe ls & .5&.u,icaF. 5319 Office Supplies 1,500.00 .00 1,500.00 193.60 .00 1,894.15 (394.15) 126 2,054.76 5326 Safety/Medical 2,000.00 .00 2,000.00 46.19 .00 982.24 1,017.76 49 1,867.77 5327 Chemicals 19,000.00 .00 19,000.00 1,859.72 .00 12,576.72 6,423.28 66 18,725.34 5329 Other Supplies 2,500.00 .00 2,500.00 50.66 .00 464.62 2,035.38 19 5,010.56 5390 Merchandise 8,500.00 .00 8,500.00 .00 .00 1,451.57 7,048.43 17 3,626.30 5391 Inventory 13,000.00 .00 13,000.00 355.49 .00 5,032.81 7,967.19 39 9,798.19 5419 Other Professional Sery 20,000.00 .00 20,000.00 1,572.85 1,423.00 9,746.10 8,830.90 56 16,606.84 5421 Telephone/Data 1,200.00 .00 1,200.00 130.70 52.79 777.14 370.07 69 1,342.09 5422 Postage 100.00 .00 100.00 .00 .00 .00 100.00 0 54.95 5424 Advertising 6,000.00 .00 6,000.00 57.01 .00 230.71 5,769.29 4 9,600.14 5428 IT Support 19,800.00 .00 19,800.00 1,650.00 .00 11,550.00 8,250.00 58 18,480.00 5433 Mileage 500.00 .00 500.00 .00 .00 43.23 456.77 9 .00 5439 Travel 500.00 .00 500.00 .00 .00 .00 500.00 0 .00 5451 Natural Gas 60,000.00 .00 60,000.00 4,860.67 .00 24,195.91 35,804.09 40 54,192.36 5453 Electricity 51,150.00 .00 51,150.00 3,925.29 .00 20,698.67 30,451.33 40 46,322.18 5463 Property/Earthquake Insurance 11,230.00 .00 11,230.00 935.83 .00 6,550.81 4,679.19 58 11,190.00 5464 Workers' Comp 10,390.00 .00 10,390.00 865.83 .00 6,060.81 4,329.19 58 9,050.04 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM Page 13 of 57 51 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month YTD YTD Budget - YTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd PdorYear ToitaV Fund 001... Geuiirsurallll Il�:r'ssund Del:r<srh ne,n. 411 Coiiii'nui'nusuiirui1ty Srsuiiviiices 15ivr:'ion 7419..Aquat1iiosAdiiii'nliiuirlils1toiiatl1loiiir EXPENSE A7ate'lial'�s & .5&u,le.otis. 5465 General Liability Insurance 4,840.00 .00 4,840.00 403.33 .00 2,823.31 2,016.69 58 3,800.04 5471 Equipment Repair & Maint 15,000.00 .00 15,000.00 42.83 .00 1,705.53 13,294.47 11 1,841.74 5472 Buildings Repairs & Maint 45,000.00 .00 45,000.00 1,954.23 .00 15,038.56 29,961.44 33 19,252.67 5491 Dues & Subscriptions 1,000.00 .00 1,000.00 .00 .00 387.99 612.01 39 2,407.66 5492 Registrations/Training 6,000.00 .00 6,000.00 250.00 .00 3,130.00 2,870.00 52 5,294.00 5498 Permits/Fees 1,500.00 .00 1,500.00 .00 .00 1,796.00 (296.00) 120 1,141.40 Plate^ ia& & .°a"si r,'e's' 7bta'ls' $300,710.00 $0.00 $300,710.00 $19,154.23 $1,475.79 $127,136.88 $172,097.33 43% $241,659.03 EXPENSE TOTALS $765,210.00 $0.00 $765,210.00 $43,924.93 $1,475.79 $322,524.62 $441,209.59 42% $534,954.07 C',fivr:'ion 7419 AaPssat1liiosAdiiii'nuiuirIs1toiiatl1loiiir toCals ($765,210.00) $0.00 ($765,210.00) ($43,924.93) ($1,475.79) ($322,524.62) ($441,209.59) 42% ($534,954.07) 15ivr:'ion 7429.•IRsoAdiiii'nuiuiruis1tuiiatliisuuiir EXPENSE /laps: euassse:/ 5e14(,.e F 5111 Regular Wages 69,500.00 .00 69,500.00 3,068.57 .00 22,891.08 46,608.92 33 60,449.50 5112 Part -Time Wages 29,970.00 .00 29,970.00 47.20 .00 5,013.06 24,956.94 17 5,305.63 5121 Overtime .00 .00 .00 4.41 .00 424.75 (424.75) +++ 890.74 5211 OR Workers' Benefit 40.00 .00 40.00 .73 .00 10.69 29.31 27 28.34 5212 Social Security 7,840.00 .00 7,840.00 237.41 .00 2,156.53 5,683.47 28 5,285.71 5213 Med & Dent Ins 24,940.00 .00 24,940.00 159.08 .00 930.88 24,009.12 4 687.61 5214 5214.100 PERS - City 17,190.00 .00 17,190.00 512.27 .00 3,886.74 13,303.26 23 8,668.97 5214.600 PERS 6% 4,170.00 .00 4,170.00 184.38 .00 1,398.98 2,771.02 34 3,603.93 5214.800 DEFERED COMP - CITY 3,050.00 .00 3,050.00 .00 .00 .00 3,050.00 0 .00 5214 - Totals $24,410.00 $0.00 $24,410.00 $696.65 $0.00 $5,285.72 $19,124.28 22% $12,272.90 5215 Long Term Disability Ins 130.00 .00 130.00 11.14 .00 70.49 59.51 54 121.43 5216 Unemployment Insurance 1,290.00 .00 1,290.00 40.57 .00 368.26 921.74 29 571.17 5217 Life Insurance 80.00 .00 80.00 7.21 .00 45.55 34.45 57 78.76 5218 Paid Family Leave Insurance 390.00 .00 390.00 12.42 .00 112.79 277.21 29 174.87 fly^r,s'oiwal.°a"s'^ vicas' ttuta'Js' $158,590.00 $0.00 $158,590.00 $4,285.39 $0.00 $37,309.80 $121,280.20 24% $85,866.66 A7atevial'�s & .5&.u,le.otis. 5319 Office Supplies 200.00 .00 200.00 .00 .00 .00 200.00 0 2,346.33 5329 5329 Other Supplies .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 12,532.06 (12,532.06) +++ 904.37 5329.100 Events 37,500.00 .00 37,500.00 .00 .00 30,799.64 6,700.36 82 37,825.45 5329.200 Youth Sports 10,000.00 .00 10,000.00 .00 1,750.00 3,249.09 5,000.91 50 8,899.92 5329.300 Adult Sports 2,500.00 .00 2,500.00 .00 .00 375.94 2,124.06 15 1,088.56 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM Page 14 of 57 52 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd PdorYear ToitaV Fund 001... Geuiireuiiallll Il�:r:sailers CDel:r<srh ne,n. 411 Coiiiiinuiinusuiirui1tV Seuiiviiiees [)ivs'ion 7429.•IR,eeAdiiiiinuiuiruis1tuiiatliisuuiir EXPENSE A7ate'lials & .5&u,te.otis. 5329 5329.405 Fiesta Services 142,000.00 .00 142,000.00 .00 4,015.38 114,996.78 22,987.84 84 149,512.05 5329.600 Rec Ad min 4,000.00 .00 4,000.00 54.73 .00 1,240.68 2,759.32 31 5,091.61 5329.700 Arts & Culture 3,000.00 .00 3,000.00 .00 .00 .00 3,000.00 0 531.58 5329.800 Active Adult 2,000.00 .00 2,000.00 .00 .00 1,280.00 720.00 64 130.20 5329 - Totals $201,000.00 $0.00 $201,000.00 $54.73 $5,765.38 $164,474.19 $30,760.43 85% $203,983.74 5409 5409.140 Garage Services 3,000.00 .00 3,000.00 .00 .00 25.28 2,974.72 1 181.12 5409 - Totals $3,000.00 $0.00 $3,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $25.28 $2,974.72 1% $181.12 5419 5419 Other Professional Sery .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 435.99 (435.99) +++ .00 5419.101 Contract Svcs Teen Center 45,000.00 .00 45,000.00 .00 .00 7,500.00 37,500.00 17 45,000.00 5419 - Totals $45,000.00 $0.00 $45,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $7,935.99 $37,064.01 18% $45,000.00 5421 Telephone/Data 1,500.00 .00 1,500.00 13.00 69.61 88.64 1,341.75 11 768.12 5424 Advertising 1,000.00 .00 1,000.00 .00 .00 909.26 90.74 91 2,488.14 5428 IT Support 20,550.00 .00 20,550.00 1,712.50 .00 11,987.50 8,562.50 58 23,100.00 5432 Meals 300.00 .00 300.00 .00 .00 .00 300.00 0 198.93 5439 Travel 300.00 .00 300.00 .00 .00 790.00 (490.00) 263 1,515.25 5451 Natural Gas 2,200.00 .00 2,200.00 495.95 .00 1,205.69 994.31 55 3,669.23 5453 Electricity 4,950.00 .00 4,950.00 543.34 .00 2,638.02 2,311.98 53 6,976.89 5461 Auto Insurance 4,480.00 .00 4,480.00 373.33 .00 2,613.31 1,866.69 58 5,289.96 5464 Workers' Comp 2,470.00 .00 2,470.00 205.83 .00 1,440.81 1,029.19 58 2,439.96 5465 General Liability Insurance 1,190.00 .00 1,190.00 99.17 .00 694.19 495.81 58 .00 5472 Buildings Repairs & Maint 1,750.00 .00 1,750.00 .00 .00 .00 1,750.00 0 299.55 5475 Vehicle Repair & Maint 1,500.00 .00 1,500.00 .00 .00 .00 1,500.00 0 .00 5492 Registrations/Training 2,000.00 .00 2,000.00 250.00 .00 250.00 1,750.00 12 1,149.66 Plate^ ia& & .°a"si r,'aF 7bta'ls' $293,390.00 $0.00 $293,390.00 $3,747.85 $5,834.99 $195,052.88 $92,502.13 68% $299,406.88 EXPENSE TOTALS $451,980.00 $0.00 $451,980.00 $8,033.24 $5,834.99 $232,362.68 $213,782.33 53% $385,273.54 1)ivsion 7429 IR,eeAdiiiiinuiuiruisltuiiatliiavuir toCals ($451,980.00) $0.00 ($451,980.00) ($8,033.24) ($5,834.99) ($232,362.68) ($213,782.33) 53% ($385,273.54) C',t'iv'ison 751.1... lMuse xin EXPENSE flaps: ruassse:/ 5e14(,.e F 5111 Regular Wages 12,680.00 .00 12,680.00 .00 .00 2,597.33 10,082.67 20 .00 5112 Part -Time Wages 16,770.00 .00 16,770.00 1,012.54 .00 6,971.91 9,798.09 42 .00 5211 OR Workers' Benefit 10.00 .00 10.00 .51 .00 4.56 5.44 46 .00 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM 53 Page 15 of 57 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd PdorYear ToitaV Fund 001. Geui"reuii allll Il"::ui rd Del:r<srh nen° 411 f„eui'nui'nusui"rui'ty Semi"viiieew C',fiv'ison 751.1... llyr soxii'n EXPENSE Ies:'ruarsro:/ 5o14(,.eF 5212 Social Security 2,250.00 .00 2,250.00 77.46 .00 729.28 1,520.72 32 .00 5213 Med & Dent Ins 1,740.00 .00 1,740.00 .00 .00 208.29 1,531.71 12 .00 5214 5214.100 PERS - City 4,910.00 .00 4,910.00 .00 .00 429.66 4,480.34 9 .00 5214.600 PERS 6% 760.00 .00 760.00 .00 .00 154.66 605.34 20 .00 5214 - Totals $5,670.00 $0.00 $5,670.00 $0.00 $0.00 $584.32 $5,085.68 10% $0.00 5215 Long Term Disability Ins 20.00 .00 20.00 .00 .00 1.99 18.01 10 .00 5216 Unemployment Insurance 380.00 .00 380.00 13.16 .00 124.37 255.63 33 .00 5217 Life Insurance 10.00 .00 10.00 .00 .00 1.28 8.72 13 .00 5218 Paid Family Leave Insurance 120.00 .00 120.00 4.05 .00 37.48 82.52 31 .00 fly^r,5'oiwal.°a"s'^ vicas' Pbta'Js' $39,650.00 $0.00 $39,650.00 $1,107.72 $0.00 $11,260.81 $28,389.19 28% $0.00 A7ateiae'feel��s & .5eiae.u,le.otis. 5319 Office Supplies 500.00 .00 500.00 .00 .00 195.10 304.90 39 .00 5347 Program Supplies 3,000.00 .00 3,000.00 .00 .00 202.64 2,797.36 7 .00 5421 Telephone/Data .00 .00 .00 42.62 .00 510.78 (510.78) +++ .00 5422 Postage 100.00 .00 100.00 .00 .00 .00 100.00 0 .00 5428 IT Support 9,450.00 .00 9,450.00 787.50 .00 5,512.50 3,937.50 58 .00 5443 Office Equipment 500.00 .00 500.00 .00 .00 21.79 478.21 4 .00 5451 Natural Gas 850.00 .00 850.00 .00 .00 .00 850.00 0 .00 5453 Electricity 1,000.00 .00 1,000.00 .00 .00 .00 1,000.00 0 .00 5463 Property/Earthquake Insurance 2,310.00 .00 2,310.00 192.50 .00 1,347.50 962.50 58 .00 5472 Buildings Repairs & Maint 5,000.00 .00 5,000.00 .00 .00 89.85 4,910.15 2 .00 Plate ia& & .°a"ei r,'e;'s' 7bta'ls' $22,710.00 $0.00 $22,710.00 $1,022.62 $0.00 $7,880.16 $14,829.84 35% $0.00 EXPENSE TOTALS $62,360.00 $0.00 $62,360.00 $2,130.34 $0.00 $19,140.97 $43,219.03 31% $0.00 [)ivis, on 7"'L1.1 lys soxiie toCasls ($62,360.00) $0.00 ($62,360.00) ($2,130.34) $0.00 ($19,140.97) ($43,219.03) 31% $0.00 15ivis:orr 7711... IPaii°'llleo & I@ scillliiiltliiesa IMauliinteinaince EXPENSE flensruassseal.5e1r 4e.eas. 5111 Regular Wages 417,010.00 .00 417,010.00 29,240.74 .00 210,472.16 206,537.84 50 381,356.62 5121 Overtime .00 .00 .00 315.91 .00 1,609.38 (1,609.38) +++ 2,695.18 5211 OR Workers' Benefit 170.00 .00 170.00 8.29 .00 79.78 90.22 47 148.52 5212 Social Security 32,200.00 .00 32,200.00 2,180.47 .00 15,526.53 16,673.47 48 29,459.68 5213 Med & Dent Ins 138,850.00 .00 138,850.00 11,686.00 .00 71,995.41 66,854.59 52 121,358.92 5214 5214.100 PERS - City 70,630.00 .00 70,630.00 5,004.73 .00 35,894.56 34,735.44 51 58,036.27 5214.600 PERS 6% 25,020.00 .00 25,020.00 1,791.26 .00 12,849.97 12,170.03 51 24,121.51 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM 54 Page 16 of 57 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd PdorYear ToitaV Fund 001... Geuii�reuiiallll Il�:r:sailers Del:r<srh ne,n. 411 f„euiinuiinusuiirui1ty Seuiiviiieew 15ivis:orr 7711...IPauui°I11ev & I@scillliiiltliiesuIMauliinteinaince EXPENSE Flaunsolrsro:/ 5o14(,.eF 5214 5214.800 DEFERED COMP - CITY 3,870.00 .00 3,870.00 297.76 .00 2,084.32 1,785.68 54 3,748.56 5214 - Totals $99,520.00 $0.00 $99,520.00 $7,093.75 $0.00 $50,828.85 $48,691.15 51% $85,906.34 5215 Long Term Disability Ins 580.00 .00 580.00 61.55 .00 388.79 191.21 67 717.44 5216 Unemployment Insurance 5,420.00 .00 5,420.00 384.26 .00 2,757.06 2,662.94 51 3,452.13 5217 Life Insurance 380.00 .00 380.00 39.91 .00 252.14 127.86 66 465.69 5218 Paid Family Leave Insurance 1,660.00 .00 1,660.00 111.26 .00 785.30 874.70 47 880.41 fly^r,5'euiinal.°a"s'^ vicas' Pbta'Js' $695,790.00 $0.00 $695,790.00 $51,122.14 $0.00 $354,695.40 $341,094.60 51% $626,440.93 A7atei'e'feel��s & .5&.u,le.as. 5319 Office Supplies 300.00 .00 300.00 .00 .00 66.50 233.50 22 396.58 5321 Cleaning Supplies 27,500.00 .00 27,500.00 2,334.30 340.33 45,349.81 (18,190.14) 166 40,379.82 5323 Fuel 17,500.00 .00 17,500.00 833.86 722.03 7,548.79 9,229.18 47 13,569.99 5325 Ag Supplies 5,000.00 .00 5,000.00 34.20 .00 34.20 4,965.80 1 8,163.26 5326 Safety/Medical 2,200.00 .00 2,200.00 186.91 .00 664.24 1,535.76 30 1,592.17 5329 Other Supplies 10,000.00 .00 10,000.00 908.51 986.44 945.45 8,068.11 19 7,090.83 5331 Construction Materials 3,000.00 .00 3,000.00 .00 .00 .00 3,000.00 0 1,065.20 5338 Tools 2,000.00 .00 2,000.00 29.99 .00 2,309.47 (309.47) 115 2,437.07 5352 Protective Clothing 1,500.00 .00 1,500.00 1,583.91 .00 2,615.34 (1,115.34) 174 1,634.79 5363 Signs 5,800.00 .00 5,800.00 .00 .00 65.91 5,734.09 1 240.07 5385 Fertilizer 6,000.00 .00 6,000.00 .00 .00 55.44 5,944.56 1 3,051.96 5409 5409.140 Garage Services 18,000.00 .00 18,000.00 .00 .00 10,543.08 7,456.92 59 16,754.01 5409 - Totals $18,000.00 $0.00 $18,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $10,543.08 $7,456.92 59% $16,754.01 5419 Other Professional Sery 117,780.00 .00 117,780.00 4,928.28 6,759.26 48,063.86 62,956.88 47 117,834.50 5421 Telephone/Data 6,000.00 .00 6,000.00 558.10 .00 3,526.76 2,473.24 59 6,424.10 5422 Postage .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .63 (.63) + + + .60 5428 IT Support 19,800.00 .00 19,800.00 1,650.00 .00 11,550.00 8,250.00 58 18,480.00 5445 Work Equipment 4,000.00 .00 4,000.00 .00 .00 6,174.92 (2,174.92) 154 2,224.69 5446 Software Licenses 4,500.00 .00 4,500.00 580.97 298.91 7,566.75 (3,365.66) 175 3,375.00 5449 Leases- Other 2,500.00 .00 2,500.00 .00 .00 539.72 1,960.28 22 2,439.61 5451 Natural Gas 7,700.00 .00 7,700.00 938.46 .00 2,260.59 5,439.41 29 6,431.10 5453 Electricity 45,000.00 .00 45,000.00 5,856.87 .00 32,042.34 12,957.66 71 57,965.47 5461 Auto Insurance 2,910.00 .00 2,910.00 242.50 .00 1,697.50 1,212.50 58 3,425.04 5463 Property/Earthquake Insurance 9,700.00 .00 9,700.00 808.33 .00 5,658.31 4,041.69 58 13,940.04 5464 Workers' Comp 10,940.00 .00 10,940.00 911.67 .00 6,381.69 4,558.31 58 11,300.04 5465 General Liability Insurance 8,770.00 .00 8,770.00 730.83 .00 5,115.81 3,654.19 58 7,149.96 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM 55 Page 17 of 57 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd PdorYear TotaV Fund 001... Ceuiireuiiallll Il�:r:sailers Del:r<srh ne,n. 411 f„euiinuiinusuiirui1ty Seuiiviiieew 15ivis: on 7711 IPauui°Illev & I@ scillliiiltliiesu IMauliinteina ince EXPENSE flate'lials & .5&u,le.as. 5471 Equipment Repair & Maint 16,000.00 .00 16,000.00 678.20 313.28 2,413.87 13,272.85 17 12,129.17 5472 Buildings Repairs & Maint 35,000.00 .00 35,000.00 2,037.94 6.45 20,084.94 14,908.61 57 48,534.00 5475 Vehicle Repair & Maint 5,000.00 .00 5,000.00 962.83 454.46 5,744.12 (1,198.58) 124 9,130.00 5478 Playground Repair & Maint 6,000.00 .00 6,000.00 .00 1,781.60 4,087.30 131.10 98 14,891.72 5484 Urban Forestry Program 20,000.00 .00 20,000.00 .00 129.98 2,010.00 17,860.02 11 11,507.63 5492 Registrations/Training 2,000.00 .00 2,000.00 250.00 .00 3,220.34 (1,220.34) 161 3,820.05 5498 Permits/Fees 1,500.00 .00 1,500.00 365.00 .00 565.00 935.00 38 891.21 Plate^ ia& & .°a"si r,'e's' 7bta'ls' $423,900.00 $0.00 $423,900.00 $27,411.66 $11,792.74 $238,902.68 $173,204.58 59% $448,269.68 1"a7ltvl tfrrtfay 5642 Passenger Vehicles 60,000.00 .00 60,000.00 .00 .00 59,999.43 .57 100 .00 5649 Other Equipment 182,000.00 .00 182,000.00 .00 8,835.61 45,998.32 127,166.07 30 72,452.09 G, [)Aal Oz(tl y t't ta'& $242,000.00 $0.00 $242,000.00 $0.00 $8,835.61 $105,997.75 $127,166.64 47% $72,452.09 EXPENSE TOTALS $1,361,690.00 $0.00 $1,361,690.00 $78,533.80 $20,628.35 $699,595.83 $641,465.82 53% $1,147,162.70 15ivr:lon 7711 IPauuilllsv & Il"'a cillliiiltiiiesu IM liinteui"rs ince toa al„a ($1,361,690.00) $0.00 ($1,361,690.00) ($78,533.80) ($20,628.35) ($699,595.83) ($641,465.82) 53% ($1,147,162.70) I'.51v1t,a on 7991.. Ceuieuiessui°rliity Seui°viiiee Asturniill °r EXPENSE flans: ruassse:/ 5e14(,.e F 5111 Regular Wages 340,000.00 .00 340,000.00 26,387.53 .00 159,873.39 180,126.61 47 241,663.02 5112 Part -Time Wages 14,150.00 .00 14,150.00 38.45 .00 1,640.67 12,509.33 12 2,888.20 5121 Overtime .00 .00 .00 3.97 .00 258.26 (258.26) +++ .00 5211 OR Workers' Benefit 80.00 .00 80.00 4.54 .00 32.56 47.44 41 49.49 5212 Social Security 27,730.00 .00 27,730.00 2,025.96 .00 12,076.65 15,653.35 44 19,093.77 5213 Med & Dent Ins 88,790.00 .00 88,790.00 6,452.35 .00 36,643.03 52,146.97 41 55,217.43 5214 5214.100 PERS - City 68,200.00 .00 68,200.00 3,967.55 .00 28,485.65 39,714.35 42 35,729.87 5214.600 PERS 6% 16,350.00 .00 16,350.00 1,361.92 .00 9,707.71 6,642.29 59 13,174.91 5214.800 DEFERED COMP - CITY 16,110.00 .00 16,110.00 1,017.98 .00 7,124.86 8,985.14 44 11,223.37 5214 - Totals $100,660.00 $0.00 $100,660.00 $6,347.45 $0.00 $45,318.22 $55,341.78 45% $60,128.15 5215 Long Term Disability Ins 590.00 .00 590.00 70.93 .00 283.38 306.62 48 448.83 5216 Unemployment Insurance 4,600.00 .00 4,600.00 343.61 .00 2,103.16 2,496.84 46 2,073.99 5217 Life Insurance 380.00 .00 380.00 45.61 .00 181.61 198.39 48 287.03 5218 Paid Family Leave Insurance 1,420.00 .00 1,420.00 96.04 .00 575.67 844.33 41 610.39 fly^r,s'oiwal.°a"s'^ vicas' ttuta'Js' $578,400.00 $0.00 $578,400.00 $41,816.44 $0.00 $258,986.60 $319,413.40 45% $382,460.30 flatevials & .5&.u,le.as. 5319 Office Supplies 500.00 .00 500.00 95.76 295.00 3,718.59 (3,513.59) 803 881.63 5329 Other Supplies 1,930.00 .00 1,930.00 .00 .00 65.00 1,865.00 3 1,721.80 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM Page 18 of 57 56 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd PdorYear TotaV Fund 001... Geuiireuiiallll F�r:sailers Del:r<srh ne,n. 411 Couiiouiiousuiirui1ty Seuiiviiieew I'.51v1sa on 7995.. Cournurnssui°riiity Seui°viiiee Asturniill °r EXPENSE A7ate'lials & .5&u,te.etis. 5411 Engineering & Architect 1,000.00 .00 1,000.00 .00 .00 .00 1,000.00 0 .00 5417 HR/Other Employee Expenses 2,600.00 .00 2,600.00 155.00 .00 1,723.00 877.00 66 2,341.00 5419 Other Professional Sery 11,050.00 .00 11,050.00 233.38 776.58 4,891.31 5,382.11 51 7,755.97 5421 Telephone/Data 2,500.00 .00 2,500.00 241.35 69.61 1,314.13 1,116.26 55 2,464.22 5422 Postage 4,000.00 .00 4,000.00 .00 .00 4.41 3,995.59 0 307.82 5428 IT Support 19,350.00 .00 19,350.00 1,612.50 .00 11,287.50 8,062.50 58 15,120.00 5432 Meals 200.00 .00 200.00 .00 .00 60.00 140.00 30 .00 5433 Mileage 700.00 .00 700.00 4.50 .00 4.50 695.50 1 254.93 5439 Travel 600.00 .00 600.00 .00 .00 .00 600.00 0 263.27 5443 Office Equipment 3,000.00 .00 3,000.00 .00 .00 .00 3,000.00 0 .00 5446 Software Licenses 2,300.00 .00 2,300.00 .00 (24,484.80) 2,366.66 24,418.14 -962 2,782.32 5449 Leases- Other 2,500.00 .00 2,500.00 .00 .00 .00 2,500.00 0 1,686.48 5463 Property/Earthquake Insurance 480.00 .00 480.00 40.00 .00 280.00 200.00 58 2,780.04 5464 Workers' Comp 2,190.00 .00 2,190.00 182.50 .00 1,277.50 912.50 58 2,400.00 5465 General Liability Insurance 6,580.00 .00 6,580.00 548.33 .00 3,838.31 2,741.69 58 8,300.04 5491 Dues & Subscriptions 800.00 .00 800.00 671.37 .00 1,446.37 (646.37) 181 1,722.75 5492 Registrations/Training 1,500.00 .00 1,500.00 250.00 .00 1,425.00 75.00 95 454.00 5493 Printing/Binding 8,000.00 .00 8,000.00 4,270.70 325.00 9,391.40 (1,716.40) 121 6,758.32 Plate^ ia& & .°a"si r,'e's' 7bta'ls' $71,780.00 $0.00 $71,780.00 $8,305.39 ($23,018.61) $43,093.68 $51,704.93 28% $57,994.59 EXPENSE TOTALS $650,180.00 $0.00 $650,180.00 $50,121.83 ($23,018.61) $302,080.28 $371,118.33 43% $440,454.89 15ivr',alon 7995 Couinuinssui"riiity Seuiviiiee Aduinuimr toal„a ($650,180.00) $0.00 ($650,180.00) ($50,121.83) $23,018.61 ($302,080.28) ($371,118.33) 43% ($440,454.89) I'. 5e^I:rvrhnne^r' 411. Couinuinusui"rliitySeuiviiieev toaal„a ($4,297,240.00) $0.00 ($4,297,240.00) ($264,026.36) ($9,292.57) ($2,094,105.09) ($2,193,842.34) 49% ($3,414,552.01) De^I:rvrhnnenr 511...IVr111suininliling I'.51v1saorr 581.1...IV'r111aininliing EXPENSE /laps: euassse:/ 5e14(,.e F 5111 Regular Wages 409,370.00 .00 409,370.00 32,959.10 .00 222,184.41 187,185.59 54 375,670.84 5112 Part -Time Wages 5,220.00 .00 5,220.00 .00 .00 .00 5,220.00 0 .00 5121 Overtime .00 .00 .00 13.97 .00 402.07 (402.07) +++ 1,396.35 5211 OR Workers' Benefit 100.00 .00 100.00 5.32 .00 45.42 54.58 45 81.76 5212 Social Security 32,510.00 .00 32,510.00 2,515.50 .00 17,198.30 15,311.70 53 30,492.35 5213 Med & Dent Ins 46,570.00 .00 46,570.00 5,121.28 .00 30,428.89 16,141.11 65 44,692.19 5214 5214.100 PERS - City 71,660.00 .00 71,660.00 5,654.83 .00 38,309.28 33,350.72 53 54,864.25 5214.600 PERS 6% 24,570.00 .00 24,570.00 2,035.35 .00 13,788.65 10,781.35 56 22,880.64 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM Page 19 of 57 57 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd PdorYear ToitaV Fund 001... Geuiimurallll Il�:r:sailers Dej,.,rarhnnenp 511...IVr111euininliling I'.51v1saorr 581.1...IV'r111aininliing EXPENSE Iaulsolrsro:/ 5o14(,.eF 5214 5214.800 DEFERED COMP - CITY 12,840.00 .00 12,840.00 949.20 .00 6,877.68 5,962.32 54 12,784.70 5214 - Totals $109,070.00 $0.00 $109,070.00 $8,639.38 $0.00 $58,975.61 $50,094.39 54% $90,529.59 5215 Long Term Disability Ins 710.00 .00 710.00 62.10 .00 377.61 332.39 53 705.63 5216 Unemployment Insurance 5,390.00 .00 5,390.00 428.65 .00 2,898.17 2,491.83 54 3,217.32 5217 Life Insurance 460.00 .00 460.00 39.77 .00 241.85 218.15 53 451.35 5218 Paid Family Leave Insurance 1,670.00 .00 1,670.00 123.67 .00 842.54 827.46 50 969.11 fly^r,5'oiwal.°a"s'^ vicas' Pbta'Js' $611,070.00 $0.00 $611,070.00 $49,908.74 $0.00 $333,594.87 $277,475.13 55% $548,206.49 Afate'lial��s & .5&.u,le.as. 5315 Computer Supplies 1,200.00 .00 1,200.00 .00 .00 .00 1,200.00 0 544.53 5319 Office Supplies 13,000.00 .00 13,000.00 727.41 63.16 1,883.79 11,053.05 15 5,790.12 5323 Fuel 300.00 .00 300.00 .00 .00 20.21 279.79 7 69.47 5409 5409.140 Garage Services 1,000.00 .00 1,000.00 .00 .00 126.40 873.60 13 60.21 5409 - Totals $1,000.00 $0.00 $1,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $126.40 $873.60 13% $60.21 5419 Other Professional Sery 260,000.00 .00 260,000.00 2,875.63 81.76 53,567.05 206,351.19 21 66,907.73 5421 Telephone/Data 1,600.00 .00 1,600.00 113.51 87.43 776.85 735.72 54 1,765.50 5422 Postage 2,100.00 .00 2,100.00 174.48 .00 1,021.84 1,078.16 49 2,002.88 5424 Advertising 1,000.00 .00 1,000.00 .00 .00 144.00 856.00 14 700.00 5425 Publication of Legal Note 1,500.00 .00 1,500.00 .00 100.00 350.00 1,050.00 30 2,055.25 5428 IT Support 39,150.00 .00 39,150.00 3,262.50 .00 22,837.50 16,312.50 58 31,920.00 5429 Other Communication Sery 300.00 .00 300.00 .00 .00 .00 300.00 0 .00 5432 Meals 400.00 .00 400.00 .00 .00 112.84 287.16 28 53.49 5433 Mileage 500.00 .00 500.00 .00 .00 .00 500.00 0 .00 5439 Travel 4,000.00 .00 4,000.00 .00 .00 947.88 3,052.12 24 2,649.39 5449 Leases- Other .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 1,618.68 5461 Auto Insurance 790.00 .00 790.00 65.83 .00 460.81 329.19 58 1,425.00 5464 Workers' Comp 420.00 .00 420.00 35.00 .00 245.00 175.00 58 500.04 5465 General Liability Insurance 10,040.00 .00 10,040.00 836.67 .00 5,856.69 4,183.31 58 9,360.00 5475 Vehicle Repair & Maint 800.00 .00 800.00 .00 .00 240.54 559.46 30 .00 5492 Registrations/Training 6,500.00 .00 6,500.00 1,240.49 .00 5,106.72 1,393.28 79 4,494.00 Plate'^ria& aft .°a"ei r,'e;'s' 7bta'ls' $344,600.00 $0.00 $344,600.00 $9,331.52 $332.35 $93,698.12 $250,569.53 27% $131,916.29 EXPENSE TOTALS $955,670.00 $0.00 $955,670.00 $59,240.26 $332.35 $427,292.99 $528,044.66 45% $680,122.78 Itivr',alon 581.1 IP111squi" rolling toal„a ($955,670.00) $0.00 ($955,670.00) ($59,240.26) ($332.35) ($427,292.99) ($528,044.66) 45% ($680,122.78) De^I:rvrtnsenr 51.1 IP111squi"iniiiing toaal„a ($955,670.00) $0.00 ($955,670.00) ($59,240.26) ($332.35) ($427,292.99) ($528,044.66) 45% ($680,122.78) Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM Page 20 of 57 58 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd PdorYear ToitaV Fund 001... Geuiireuiiallll Il�:r:sailers Dej,.,rarhnne np 651... 1Eing1lineeii hirra3 I'.Slvlsaorr 62.1.1...li"'!ing1iiineeiihira3 EXPENSE Iaulsolrsro:/ 5o14(,.eF 5111 Regular Wages 159,040.00 .00 159,040.00 8,966.18 .00 62,449.22 96,590.78 39 114,325.28 5112 Part -Time Wages 20,100.00 .00 20,100.00 1,759.46 .00 12,063.23 8,036.77 60 13,861.25 5121 Overtime .00 .00 .00 21.04 .00 80.25 (80.25) +++ 404.22 5211 OR Workers' Benefit 40.00 .00 40.00 1.82 .00 15.59 24.41 39 30.58 5212 Social Security 13,900.00 .00 13,900.00 810.10 .00 5,615.07 8,284.93 40 10,304.90 5213 Med & Dent Ins 29,390.00 .00 29,390.00 1,897.96 .00 11,153.52 18,236.48 38 25,957.15 5214 5214.100 PERS - City 34,990.00 .00 34,990.00 2,021.74 .00 14,029.82 20,960.18 40 21,331.98 5214.600 PERS 6% 8,910.00 .00 8,910.00 551.31 .00 3,836.33 5,073.67 43 4,916.92 5214.800 DEFERED COMP - CITY 2,650.00 .00 2,650.00 202.58 .00 1,417.45 1,232.55 53 1,764.28 5214 - Totals $46,550.00 $0.00 $46,550.00 $2,775.63 $0.00 $19,283.60 $27,266.40 41% $28,013.18 5215 Long Term Disability Ins 240.00 .00 240.00 18.00 .00 106.06 133.94 44 218.67 5216 Unemployment Insurance 2,340.00 .00 2,340.00 139.69 .00 969.63 1,370.37 41 1,132.24 5217 Life Insurance 130.00 .00 130.00 11.50 .00 67.88 62.12 52 140.35 5218 Paid Family Leave Insurance 720.00 .00 720.00 40.20 .00 277.82 442.18 39 332.73 fly^r,5'euiinal.°a"s'^ vicas' Pbta'Js' $272,450.00 $0.00 $272,450.00 $16,441.58 $0.00 $112,081.87 $160,368.13 41% $194,720.55 Afatevial��s & .5&.u,le.as. 5315 Computer Supplies 2,500.00 .00 2,500.00 .00 .00 .00 2,500.00 0 1,096.83 5319 Office Supplies 3,000.00 .00 3,000.00 .00 .00 220.69 2,779.31 7 1,166.61 5323 Fuel 4,000.00 .00 4,000.00 162.36 95.34 1,969.71 1,934.95 52 4,409.68 5324 Clothing 2,000.00 .00 2,000.00 .00 .00 .00 2,000.00 0 .00 5326 Safety/Medical 1,500.00 .00 1,500.00 44.55 .00 146.81 1,353.19 10 1,349.16 5329 Other Supplies 3,000.00 .00 3,000.00 .00 (1.45) 653.61 2,347.84 22 625.00 5409 5409.140 Garage Services 2,000.00 .00 2,000.00 .00 .00 1,549.23 450.77 77 1,775.71 5409 - Totals $2,000.00 $0.00 $2,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $1,549.23 $450.77 77% $1,775.71 5411 Engineering & Architect 20,000.00 .00 20,000.00 .00 .00 326.02 19,673.98 2 19,340.00 5417 HR/Other Employee Expenses 500.00 .00 500.00 .00 .00 .00 500.00 0 20.00 5419 Other Professional Sery 25,000.00 .00 25,000.00 25.32 122.64 3,981.28 20,896.08 16 17,075.07 5421 Telephone/Data 5,800.00 .00 5,800.00 554.97 174.85 3,740.57 1,884.58 68 6,396.83 5422 Postage 500.00 .00 500.00 5.61 .00 57.91 442.09 12 11.95 5424 Advertising 500.00 .00 500.00 .00 .00 271.04 228.96 54 549.34 5428 IT Support 55,460.00 .00 55,460.00 4,621.67 .00 35,209.69 20,250.31 63 45,780.00 5439 Travel 4,000.00 .00 4,000.00 .00 .00 .00 4,000.00 0 2,018.98 5446 Software Licenses 12,000.00 .00 12,000.00 5,971.06 91.99 9,141.43 2,766.58 77 7,911.02 5451 Natural Gas 3,100.00 .00 3,100.00 513.31 .00 1,186.45 1,913.55 38 3,484.34 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM Page 21 of 57 59 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descrilption Budget Amendments Budget Transactions Encumbrances Transactions Transactions Rec'd PriorYear Totai Fund 001... Geuiireuiiallll li�:r:uund Dej,.,rarhnnenp 651...15uru01iiurueeui°iiuru0 I'.Slvlsaorr 62.1.1...li"'!ing1iiineeiihira3 EXPENSE Alate'lials & .5&u,te.otis. 5453 Electricity 5,500.00 .00 5,500.00 418.08 .00 2,168.53 3,331.47 39 4,450.75 5461 Auto Insurance 1,230.00 .00 1,230.00 102.50 .00 717.50 512.50 58 1,440.00 5463 Property/Earthquake Insurance 2,180.00 .00 2,180.00 181.67 .00 1,271.69 908.31 58 2,199.96 5464 Workers' Comp 7,090.00 .00 7,090.00 590.83 .00 4,135.81 2,954.19 58 7,370.04 5465 General Liability Insurance 10,730.00 .00 10,730.00 894.17 .00 6,259.19 4,470.81 58 12,399.96 5471 Equipment Repair & Maint 1,000.00 .00 1,000.00 .00 .00 47.60 952.40 5 34.80 5472 Buildings Repairs & Maint 16,000.00 .00 16,000.00 .00 .00 725.00 15,275.00 5 3,203.77 5475 Vehicle Repair & Maint 3,100.00 .00 3,100.00 .00 (96.36) 2,030.30 1,166.06 62 2,097.92 5492 Registrations/Training 16,000.00 .00 16,000.00 145.28 70.00 2,383.71 13,546.29 15 4,145.33 5493 Printing/Binding 500.00 .00 500.00 .00 .00 73.00 427.00 15 .00 5496 Filing/Recording 700.00 .00 700.00 182.00 .00 288.00 412.00 41 .00 5498 Permits/Fees 1,500.00 .00 1,500.00 .00 .00 892.46 607.54 59 1,142.11 tlatevia& & .°a"si r,'e's' 7bta'ls' $210,390.00 $0.00 $210,390.00 $14,413.38 $457.01 $79,447.23 $130,485.76 38% $151,495.16 EXPENSE TOTALS $482,840.00 $0.00 $482,840.00 $30,854.96 $457.01 $191,529.10 $290,853.89 40% $346,215.71 15ivrslorr 6211 li"uing1liiweui"'"ing totals ($482,840.00) $0.00 ($482,840.00) ($30,854.96) ($457.01) ($191,529.10) ($290,853.89) 40% ($346,215.71) I'. 5e^I:rarhnne^r' 651 li"uingl1iurreeuihung totals ($482,840.00) $0.00 ($482,840.00) ($30,854.96) ($457.01) ($191,529.10) ($290,853.89) 40% ($346,215.71) Dee,.,<arhnne,n. 901... 15uindilling li""uuind IBaIllaince I'.51v1saorr 9971. IE'!0uuiiitV EXPENSE Coertil5n"leeretei F aere5 11illuaicaF. 5921 Contingency 4,989,980.00 .00 4,989,980.00 .00 .00 .00 4,989,980.00 0 .00 5981 5981.012 Reserve - SMR 5,687,180.00 .00 5,687,180.00 .00 .00 .00 5,687,180.00 0 .00 5981.014 Reserve - Cascade Dr. Maintenance .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ .04 5981 - Totals $5,687,180.00 $0.00 $5,687,180.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $5,687,180.00 0% $0.04 a"o tirsr/e^ssc'ts';s'«v'sstPt/sv'«tretr7vte^Plalxio'e's'ltuta'& $10,677,160.00 $0.00 $10,677,160.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $10,677,160.00 0% $0.04 EXPENSE TOTALS $10,677,160.00 $0.00 $10,677,160.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $10,677,160.00 0% $0.04 I'.Slvrslorr 9971 15'10uuiutV totals ($10,677,160.00) $0.00 ($10,677,160.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($10,677,160.00) 0% ($0.04) Deq:r<srhnne,n° 901 IEuindilling Il::uuind IBallPsince toCals ($10,677,160.00) $0.00 ($10,677,160.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($10,677,160.00) 0% ($0.04) Fund 001 Geuiueuiallll Il::uund totals $30,803,530.00 $710,000.00 $31,513,530.00 $1,403,924.06 $613,981.54 $10,285,259.82 $20,614,288.64 $17,765,551.46 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM Page 22 of 57 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd PdorYear ToitaV Del:rarhnne,n. 671... 5 uiieruns t 15ivrs'on 4711 Ii:11xed IRoute 'Suiieruns t EXPENSE Iaulsolrsro:/ 5o14(,.eF 5111 Regular Wages 265,670.00 .00 265,670.00 22,802.13 .00 159,130.10 106,539.90 60 357,645.91 5112 Part -Time Wages 222,880.00 .00 222,880.00 14,097.74 .00 102,316.67 120,563.33 46 153,335.63 5121 Overtime .00 .00 .00 .97 .00 2,473.58 (2,473.58) +++ 4,578.75 5211 OR Workers' Benefit 210.00 .00 210.00 13.88 .00 110.85 99.15 53 230.41 5212 Social Security 37,580.00 .00 37,580.00 2,800.60 .00 19,843.03 17,736.97 53 43,343.42 5213 Med & Dent Ins 42,730.00 .00 42,730.00 4,973.88 .00 30,015.07 12,714.93 70 57,329.18 5214 5214.100 PERS - City 76,350.00 .00 76,350.00 5,619.63 .00 40,527.37 35,822.63 53 67,346.95 5214.600 PERS 6% 12,890.00 .00 12,890.00 1,379.39 .00 9,655.53 3,234.47 75 2,544.30 5214.800 DEFERED COMP - CITY 5,310.00 .00 5,310.00 448.34 .00 3,108.55 2,201.45 59 7,497.87 5214 - Totals $94,550.00 $0.00 $94,550.00 $7,447.36 $0.00 $53,291.45 $41,258.55 56% $77,389.12 5215 Long Term Disability Ins 460.00 .00 460.00 45.80 .00 274.11 185.89 60 630.05 5216 Unemployment Insurance 6,330.00 .00 6,330.00 479.73 .00 3,428.77 2,901.23 54 4,811.77 5217 Life Insurance 270.00 .00 270.00 29.52 .00 176.65 93.35 65 407.12 5218 Paid Family Leave Insurance 2,000.00 .00 2,000.00 143.27 .00 1,020.44 979.56 51 1,363.22 fly^r,5'oiwal.°a"s'^ vicaF Pbta'LF $672,680.00 $0.00 $672,680.00 $52,834.88 $0.00 $372,080.72 $300,599.28 55% $701,064.58 A7atei'e'feel��s & .5&.u,le.otis. 5319 Office Supplies 750.00 .00 750.00 24.16 85.49 717.10 (52.59) 107 1,173.85 5323 Fuel 27,000.00 .00 27,000.00 2,725.20 1,493.93 23,006.91 2,499.16 91 56,854.95 5324 Clothing 600.00 .00 600.00 .00 .00 80.81 519.19 13 479.25 5326 Safety/Medical 750.00 .00 750.00 37.92 .04 129.34 620.62 17 131.57 5329 Other Supplies 1,000.00 .00 1,000.00 .00 .00 84.99 915.01 8 96.72 5337 Tires/Parts 500.00 .00 500.00 .00 .00 .00 500.00 0 .00 5409 5409.140 Garage Services 8,500.00 .00 8,500.00 .00 .00 8,271.96 228.04 97 18,938.36 5409 - Totals $8,500.00 $0.00 $8,500.00 $0.00 $0.00 $8,271.96 $228.04 97% $18,938.36 5414 Accounting/Auditing 350.00 .00 350.00 237.50 175.00 490.00 (315.00) 190 626.27 5417 HR/Other Employee Expenses 250.00 .00 250.00 .00 .00 88.55 161.45 35 20.00 5419 Other Professional Sery 1,000.00 .00 1,000.00 114.45 204.33 690.52 105.15 89 164,637.02 5421 Telephone/Data 2,650.00 .00 2,650.00 558.64 69.61 3,363.53 (783.14) 130 5,918.83 5422 Postage 50.00 .00 50.00 12.34 .00 33.31 16.69 67 46.60 5424 Advertising 500.00 .00 500.00 .00 .00 .00 500.00 0 39.00 5428 IT Support 16,430.00 .00 16,430.00 1,369.17 .00 9,584.19 6,845.81 58 26,040.00 5432 Meals 250.00 .00 250.00 .00 .00 129.36 120.64 52 33.52 5433 Mileage 1,000.00 .00 1,000.00 .00 .00 212.67 787.33 21 3,922.36 5439 Travel 500.00 .00 500.00 .00 .00 820.54 (320.54) 164 .00 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM Page 23 of 57 61 Expense Budget Performance Report [isca�l Year, to Date 0 � /3 � /24 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp ACCOLInt and R(AklIp to ACCOUnt n c o r p u r a I c d t 8 8 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month YTD YTD Budget - YTD 11/o Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd Pdor Year TotaV Fund 110 liiainsftli:uind Dej,.,rarhnnen 671 liiainsft [)ivs'ion 4711 i:11xed Route liiainsft EXPENSE platevials & 5&vicaF 5446 Software Licenses 3,500.00 .00 3,500.00 .00 .00 .00 3,500.00 0 7,979.64 5448 Internal Rent 4,430.00 .00 4,430.00 369.17 .00 2,584.19 1,845.81 58 7,870.00 5451 Natural Gas 1,450.00 .00 1,450.00 123.47 .00 323.20 1,126.80 22 1,624.54 5453 Electricity 1,750.00 .00 1,750.00 256.31 .00 1,564.46 185.54 89 3,335.70 5461 Auto Insurance 9,560.00 .00 9,560.00 796.67 .00 5,576.69 3,983.31 58 24,030.00 5463 Property/Earthquake Insurance 1,180.00 .00 1,180.00 98.33 .00 688.31 491.69 58 1,190.04 5464 Workers' Comp 8,790.00 .00 8,790.00 732.50 .00 5,127.50 3,662.50 58 15,069.96 5465 General Liability Insurance 5,340.00 .00 5,340.00 445.00 .00 3,115.00 2,225.00 58 8,460.00 5471 Equipment Repair & Maint 750.00 .00 750.00 .00 .00 .00 750.00 0 1,452.61 5472 Buildings Repairs & Maint 500.00 .00 500.00 .00 541.00 7,536.95 (7,577.95) 1616 59.88 5475 Vehicle Repair & Maint 26,000.00 .00 26,000.00 2,316.06 (3,393.34) 14,098.00 15,295.34 41 49,772.82 5480 Accident Repair 250.00 .00 250.00 .00 .00 .00 250.00 0 .00 5491 Dues & Subscriptions 500.00 .00 500.00 .00 .00 150.00 350.00 30 690.00 5492 Reg istrations/Training 2,250.00 .00 2,250.00 .00 .00 540.00 1,710.00 24 2,792.49 5493 Printing/Binding 400.00 .00 400.00 .00 .00 .00 400.00 0 1,133.00 5500 Banking Fees & Charges .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 . . . 494.92 Platevia& & 5si aF 7 btal, F $128,730.00 $0.00 $128,730.00 $10,216.89 ($823.94) $89,008.08 $40,545.86 69% $404,913.90 C toJ Ozntfa), 5642 Passenger Vehicles 340,000.00 .00 340,000.00 .00 .00 .00 340,000.00 0 416,617.00 5649 Other Equipment 20,000.00 .00 20,000.00 .00 .00 .00 20,000.00 0 .00 Oz(tla), 7bta& $360,000.00 $0.00 $360,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $360,000.00 0% $416,617.00 EXPENSE TOTALS $1,161,410.00 $0.00 $1,161,410.00 $63,051.77 ($823.94) $461,088.80 $701,145.14 40% $1,522,595.48 [)ivs'ion 4711 i:11xed Route liiainsft toCals ($1,161,410.00) $0.00 ($1,161,410.00) ($63,051.77) $823.94 ($461,088.80) ($701,145.14) 40% ($1,522,595.48) [)lvls�on 4712 IPali11alll A IRliide EXPENSE /Ielsolwa/ 5e14(,eF 5111 Regular Wages 87,010.00 .00 87,010.00 4,670.16 .00 32,355.28 54,654.72 37 .00 5112 Part -Time Wages 128,540.00 .00 128,540.00 2,636.85 .00 23,551.56 104,988.44 18 .00 5211 OR Workers' Benefit 100.00 .00 100.00 2.42 .00 22.93 77.07 23 .00 5212 Social Security 16,600.00 .00 16,600.00 550.07 .00 4,210.67 12,389.33 25 .00 5213 Med & Dent Ins 17,670.00 .00 17,670.00 1,435.42 .00 8,120.91 9,549.09 46 .00 5214 5214.100 PERS - City 30,130.00 .00 30,130.00 1,270.52 .00 8,776.87 21,353.13 29 .00 5214.600 PERS 6% 5,220.00 .00 5,220.00 286.41 .00 1,986.52 3,233.48 38 .00 5214.800 DEFERED COMP - CITY 1,910.00 .00 1,910.00 103.52 .00 754.00 1,156.00 39 .00 5214 - Totals $37,260.00 $0.00 $37,260.00 $1,660.45 $0.00 $11,517.39 $25,742.61 31% $0.00 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM Page 24 of 57 62 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd PdorYear ToitaV Fund 1.10 .. "5uiisrunst I@i�r:sailers Del:ra r hnne,n. 6 7 1... 5 uii sr unst1t I'.Slvlsaorr 471.2. IPD111alll A IR,liide EXPENSE Iaulsolrsro:/ 5o14(,.eF 5215 Long Term Disability Ins 160.00 .00 160.00 9.71 .00 62.58 97.42 39 .00 5216 Unemployment Insurance 2,800.00 .00 2,800.00 95.00 .00 726.82 2,073.18 26 .00 5217 Life Insurance 100.00 .00 100.00 6.29 .00 40.47 59.53 40 .00 5218 Paid Family Leave Insurance 860.00 .00 860.00 27.79 .00 213.14 646.86 25 .00 fly^r,5'euiinal.°a"s'^ vicas' Pbta'Js' $291,100.00 $0.00 $291,100.00 $11,094.16 $0.00 $80,821.75 $210,278.25 28% $0.00 A7atei'e'feel��s & .5&.u,le.etis. 5319 Office Supplies 750.00 .00 750.00 69.15 150.21 585.07 14.72 98 .00 5323 Fuel 27,000.00 .00 27,000.00 802.64 672.25 7,550.28 18,777.47 30 .00 5324 Clothing 600.00 .00 600.00 .00 .00 431.58 168.42 72 .00 5326 Safety/Medical 750.00 .00 750.00 .00 .00 26.44 723.56 4 .00 5329 Other Supplies 1,000.00 .00 1,000.00 .00 .00 .00 1,000.00 0 .00 5337 Tires/Parts 500.00 .00 500.00 .00 .00 .00 500.00 0 .00 5409 5409.140 Garage Services 8,500.00 .00 8,500.00 .00 .00 2,410.07 6,089.93 28 .00 5409 - Totals $8,500.00 $0.00 $8,500.00 $0.00 $0.00 $2,410.07 $6,089.93 28% $0.00 5414 Accounting/Auditing 350.00 .00 350.00 .00 .00 .00 350.00 0 .00 5417 HR/Other Employee Expenses 250.00 .00 250.00 .00 .00 .00 250.00 0 .00 5419 Other Professional Sery 1,000.00 .00 1,000.00 .00 .00 21.45 978.55 2 .00 5421 Telephone/Data 2,650.00 .00 2,650.00 .00 .00 370.67 2,279.33 14 .00 5422 Postage 50.00 .00 50.00 .00 .00 .00 50.00 0 .00 5424 Advertising 500.00 .00 500.00 .00 .00 .00 500.00 0 .00 5428 IT Support 16,420.00 .00 16,420.00 1,368.33 .00 9,578.31 6,841.69 58 .00 5429 Other Communication Sery .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 3.33 (3.33) +++ .00 5432 Meals 250.00 .00 250.00 .00 .00 129.36 120.64 52 .00 5433 Mileage 5,000.00 .00 5,000.00 .00 .00 .00 5,000.00 0 .00 5439 Travel 500.00 .00 500.00 .00 274.10 1,481.72 (1,255.82) 351 .00 5446 Software Licenses 3,500.00 .00 3,500.00 .00 .00 6,615.00 (3,115.00) 189 .00 5448 Internal Rent 4,430.00 .00 4,430.00 369.17 .00 2,584.19 1,845.81 58 .00 5451 Natural Gas 1,450.00 .00 1,450.00 118.32 .00 269.31 1,180.69 19 .00 5453 Electricity 1,750.00 .00 1,750.00 .00 .00 104.08 1,645.92 6 .00 5461 Auto Insurance 9,560.00 .00 9,560.00 796.66 .00 5,576.62 3,983.38 58 .00 5464 Workers' Comp 8,780.00 .00 8,780.00 731.67 .00 5,121.69 3,658.31 58 .00 5465 General Liability Insurance 5,340.00 .00 5,340.00 445.00 .00 3,115.00 2,225.00 58 .00 5471 Equipment Repair & Maint 750.00 .00 750.00 .00 .00 .00 750.00 0 .00 5472 Buildings Repairs & Maint 500.00 .00 500.00 .00 .00 .00 500.00 0 .00 5475 Vehicle Repair & Maint 26,000.00 .00 26,000.00 1,249.45 (325.63) 6,484.66 19,840.97 24 .00 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM Page 25 of 57 63 Expense Budget Performance Report [isca�l Year, to Date 0 � /3 � /24 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp ACCOLInt and R(AklIp to ACCOUnt n c o r p u r a I c d t 8 8 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month YTD YTD Budget - YTD 11/o Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd Pdor Year TotaV Fund 110 liiainsftli:uind Dej,.,rarhnnen671 liiainsft [)lvls�on 4712 iNall A IR,iiide EXPENSE plate'lial's & 5&vicaF 5480 Accident Repair 250.00 .00 250.00 .00 .00 .00 250.00 0 .00 5491 Dues & Subscriptions 500.00 .00 500.00 .00 .00 .00 500.00 0 .00 5492 Reg istrations/Training 1,250.00 .00 1,250.00 .00 .00 .00 1,250.00 0 .00 5493 Printing/Binding 400.00 .00 400.00 .00 .00 .00 400.00 0 .00 Platevia& & 5si^ ,k aF 7 btal, F $130,530.00 $0.00 $130,530.00 $5,950.39 $770.93 $52,458.83 $77,300.24 41% $0.00 l"a7 ft J Ozntfay 5642 Passenger Vehicles 358,000.00 .00 358,000.00 .00 .00 .00 358,000.00 0 .00 G�[)Aal Ot(t1a), 7btahF $358,000.00 $0.00 $358,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $358,000.00 0% $0.00 EXPENSE TOTALS $779,630.00 $0.00 $779,630.00 $17,044.55 $770.93 $133,280.58 $645,578.49 17% $0.00 [)ivrslon 4712 iNall A IRi11de totals ($779,630.00) $0.00 ($779,630.00) ($17,044.55) ($770.93) ($133,280.58) ($645,578.49) 17% $0.00 [)ivrs'ion 9711 011peii atiling Iiiiauns'Iteuii Out EXPENSE 7iwiFA,,r,s Oz(t 5811 5811.693 Transfer to Reserve for PERS .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 ... 8,799.96 5811 - Totals $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ... $8,799.96 7iwiFA,vs Oz(t 7btaLF $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ... $8,799.96 EXPENSE TOTALS $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ... $8,799.96 [)ivrslon 971 A 011peii atiling I iii ainsfeii Out totals $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ... ($8,799.96) Dej,.,rarhnnen671 liiainsft �oCals ($1,941,040.00) $0.00 ($1,941,040.00) ($80,096.32) $53.01 ($594,369.38) ($1,346,723.63) 31% ($1,531,395.44) Dej,.,rarhnnen901 Eindiling F:uind Ballaince [)1v1s�on 9971 Equilty EXPENSE Colntillg&?CkF aluf 11il9,ulicaF 5921 Contingency 780,260.00 .00 780,260.00 .00 .00 .00 780,260.00 0 .00 Comt#irlewcM;F ancf llalxicaF 7 btaLF $780,260.00 $0.00 $780,260.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $780,260.00 0% $0.00 EXPENSE TOTALS $780,260.00 $0.00 $780,260.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $780,260.00 0% $0.00 [)lvrslon 9971 1EquuiutV totals ($780,260.00) $0.00 ($780,260.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($780,260.00) 0% $0.00 Dej,.,rarhnnen901 IEuindilling F:uind Ballaince �oCals ($780,260.00) $0.00 ($780,260.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($780,260.00) 0% $0.00 Fund 110 liiainsftli:uind totals $2,721,300.00 $0.00 $2,721,300.00 $80,096.32 ($53.01) $594,369.38 $2,126,983.63 $1,531,395.44 Fund 123 Bu !I! Id !I! iii ug D m1pectilloii u IF:u iii W Dej,.,rarhnnenr 521 BuI11111diling [)1v1s�on 2241 Bull Id !I! iii ug D m1pectilloii EXPENSE flensolwa/ 5�1�4(,eF 5111 Regular Wages 626,370.00 .00 626,370.00 44,774.57 .00 310,158.81 316,211.19 50 527,772.45 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM Page 26 of 57 a WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLauint and IR(Akaulp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd PdorYear ToitaV Fund 1.23.. IBssl11111diiiurra3Insllpectliioin II' "'surd Dej,.,rarhnnenp 521...IBssu1111diiiurra3 I'.51v1saorr 2.2.41...IBssl11111diiiurra3Insllpectliioin EXPENSE /lees: ruarsro:/ 5o14(,.eF 5112 Part -Time Wages 37,390.00 .00 37,390.00 465.29 .00 13,459.55 23,930.45 36 21,669.41 5121 Overtime .00 .00 .00 36.10 .00 2,151.65 (2,151.65) +++ 3,539.22 5211 OR Workers' Benefit 160.00 .00 160.00 7.66 .00 73.06 86.94 46 136.04 5212 Social Security 51,410.00 .00 51,410.00 3,381.09 .00 24,499.34 26,910.66 48 43,060.79 5213 Med & Dent Ins 130,200.00 .00 130,200.00 8,698.56 .00 52,601.96 77,598.04 40 101,056.38 5214 5214.100 PERS - City 5214.600 PERS 6% 5214.800 DEFERED COMP - CITY 5215 Long Term Disability Ins 5216 Unemployment Insurance 5217 Life Insurance 5218 Paid Family Leave Insurance Afateiv'ial��s & .5&.n,le.etis. 5315 Computer Supplies 5319 Office Supplies 5323 Fuel 5409 5409.140 Garage Services 5414 Accounting/Auditing 5419 Other Professional Sery 5421 Telephone/Data 5422 Postage 5428 IT Support 5433 Mileage 5439 Travel 5448 Internal Rent 5461 Auto Insurance 5464 Workers' Comp 5465 General Liability Insurance 5475 Vehicle Repair & Maint 5490 Refunds 5491 Dues & Subscriptions 113,550.00 .00 113,550.00 7,672.23 .00 54,503.56 59,046.44 48 83,082.24 37,580.00 .00 37,580.00 2,728.01 .00 19,010.60 18,569.40 51 33,369.97 9,770.00 .00 9,770.00 721.53 .00 5,333.75 4,436.25 55 9,562.43 5214 - Totals $160,900.00 $0.00 $160,900.00 $11,121.77 $0.00 $78,847.91 $82,052.09 49% $126,014.64 970.00 .00 970.00 89.39 .00 534.03 435.97 55 1,006.29 8,620.00 .00 8,620.00 588.58 .00 4,245.37 4,374.63 49 4,782.86 620.00 .00 620.00 57.58 .00 343.72 276.28 55 647.79 2,650.00 .00 2,650.00 170.65 .00 1,239.72 1,410.28 47 1,376.57 fly^r,5'oiwal.°a"s' vicas' 7bta'& $1,019,290.00 $0.00 $1,019,290.00 $69,391.24 $0.00 $488,155.12 $531,134.88 48% $831,062.44 5,000.00 .00 5,000.00 .00 .00 .00 5,000.00 0 2,223.40 15,000.00 .00 15,000.00 38.44 14.31 6,113.42 8,872.27 41 13,080.52 5,000.00 .00 5,000.00 104.20 5.66 2,670.58 2,323.76 54 3,639.96 1,250.00 .00 1,250.00 .00 .00 278.08 971.92 22 663.78 5409 - Totals $1,250.00 $0.00 $1,250.00 $0.00 $0.00 $278.08 $971.92 22% $663.78 1,800.00 .00 1,800.00 712.50 525.00 1,470.00 (195.00) 111 1,878.86 100,000.00 100,000.00 200,000.00 21.10 169,168.95 13,478.31 17,352.74 91 54,724.29 5,000.00 .00 5,000.00 1,907.53 52.79 3,743.17 1,204.04 76 4,305.72 50.00 .00 50.00 3.30 .00 12.42 37.58 25 17.42 42,300.00 .00 42,300.00 3,525.00 .00 24,675.00 17,625.00 58 31,500.00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 5.00 1,700.00 .00 1,700.00 .00 .00 29.67 1,670.33 2 1,117.07 9,430.00 .00 9,430.00 785.83 .00 5,500.81 3,929.19 58 7,940.00 1,870.00 .00 1,870.00 155.83 .00 1,090.81 779.19 58 1,689.96 4,850.00 .00 4,850.00 404.17 .00 2,829.19 2,020.81 58 5,810.04 8,670.00 .00 8,670.00 722.50 .00 5,057.50 3,612.50 58 6,930.00 1,050.00 .00 1,050.00 .00 .00 105.45 944.55 10 299.05 5,000.00 .00 5,000.00 .00 .00 .00 5,000.00 0 .00 2,000.00 .00 2,000.00 .00 175.00 320.24 1,504.76 25 1,324.99 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM 65 Page 27 of 57 Expense Budget Performance Report [��isca�l Year, to Date 0 � /3 � /24 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp ACCOLInt and R(AklIp to ACCOUnt n c o r p u r a I c d t 8 8 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month YTD YTD Budget - YTD 11/o Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd Pdor Year TotaV Fund 123 BuI11111diling Inspectilloin l::uind Dej,.,rarhnnenp 521 BuI11111diling D' v1sbn 2241 BuI11111diling Inspectilloin EXPENSE plate'lial's & 5&vicaF 5492 Reg istrations/Training 10,000.00 .00 10,000.00 415.00 .00 2,795.00 7,205.00 28 4,945.00 5498 5498.259 St Mfg Fee 500.00 .00 500.00 .00 .00 .00 500.00 0 .00 5498.359 State Surc 160,000.00 .00 160,000.00 28,043.44 .00 54,181.83 105,818.17 34 156,707.47 5498.459 Construction Excise Tax 1,000,000.00 200,000.00 1,200,000.00 34,301.05 .00 586,120.22 613,879.78 49 941,136.93 5498 - Totals $1,160,500.00 $200,000.00 $1,360,500.00 $62,344.49 $0.00 $640,302.05 $720,197.95 47% $1,097,844.40 5500 Banking Fees & Charges 38,950.00 .00 38,950.00 2,859.25 .00 12,611.76 26,338.24 32 80,125.03 5729 Interest for CET 650.00 .00 650.00 .00 .00 .00 650.00 0 .00 Platevia&& 5si^ raF 7bfals $1,420,070.00 $300,000.00 $1,720,070.00 $73,999.14 $169,941.71 $723,083.46 $827,044.83 52% $1,320,064.49 C tolOzntfay 5639 Other Improvements 300,000.00 .00 300,000.00 6,155.45 .00 12,001.55 287,998.45 4 4,715.09 5642 Passenger Vehicles 40,000.00 .00 40,000.00 .00 .00 42,891.14 (2,891.14) 107 28,822.33 G�[)Aal Ot(t1a), 7btaLF $340,000.00 $0.00 $340,000.00 $6,155.45 $0.00 $54,892.69 $285,107.31 16% $33,537.42 EXPENSE TOTALS $2,779,360.00 $300,000.00 $3,079,360.00 $149,545.83 $169,941.71 $1,266,131.27 $1,643,287.02 47% $2,184,664.35 D�vrsbn 2241 BuI11111diling Inspectilloin totals ($2,779,360.00) ($300,000.00) ($3,079,360.00) ($149,545.83) ($169,941.71) ($1,266,131.27) ($1,643,287.02) 47% ($2,184,664.35) D�vrsbn 9711 011peii atiling I'iiiainsIFeuii Out EXPENSE 7iwiFA,,r,s Oz(t 5811 5811.693 Transfer to Reserve for PERS .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 . . . 8,840.04 5811 - Totals $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 . . . $8,840.04 7iwiFA,vs Oz(t 7btaLF $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ... $8,840.04 EXPENSE TOTALS $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ... $8,840.04 Divisbn 9711 011peii atiling I iii ainsfeii Out totals $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ... ($8,840.04) Dej,.,rarhnnen521 BuI11111diling totals ($2,779,360.00) ($300,000.00) ($3,079,360.00) ($149,545.83) ($169,941.71) ($1,266,131.27) ($1,643,287.02) 47% ($2,193,504.39) Dej,.,�arhnnen901 Eindiling l:bind Ballaince D' v1sbn 9971 Equilty EXPENSE Colntillg&?ClemF aluf flablicaF 5921 Contingency 8,178,320.00 .00 8,178,320.00 .00 .00 .00 8,178,320.00 0 .00 Comt#irlewcM;F ancf flabliceF 7 bta& $8,178,320.00 $0.00 $8,178,320.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $8,178,320.00 0% $0.00 EXPENSE TOTALS $8,178,320.00 $0.00 $8,178,320.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $8,178,320.00 0% $0.00 D' vrsbn 9971 15quilutV totals ($8,178,320.00) $0.00 ($8,178,320.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($8,178,320.00) 0% $0.00 Dej,.,rarhnnen901 IEuindilling l:bind Ballaince toCals ($8,178,320.00) $0.00 ($8,178,320.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($8,178,320.00) 0% $0.00 Fund 123 BuI11111diling Inspectilloin l::uind totals $10,957,680.00 $300,000.00 $11,257,680.00 $149,545.83 $169,941.71 $1,266,131.27 $9,821,607.02 $2,193,504.39 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM 0 Page 28 of 57 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month YTD YTD Budget - YTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdlpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd PdorYear ToitaV Fund 132 .. Asset I@""ourteliiltuiie Del:rarhnne np 211 IPolllliioe Ds v'is'ie n 2.131... IDe'tectilii es EXPENSE Atatei'rtal's & .5&u,5e.etis. 5329 Other Supplies 16,600.00 .00 16,600.00 .00 .00 .00 16,600.00 0 .00 Atateviats & .5sigh✓9o'eius' 7btal,s' $16,600.00 $0.00 $16,600.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $16,600.00 0% $0.00 EXPENSE TOTALS $16,600.00 $0.00 $16,600.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $16,600.00 0% $0.00 D5vr:len 2131 IDeltectiiiaea totals ($16,600.00) $0.00 ($16,600.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($16,600.00) 0% $0.00 15el,.:arhnne^i' 211 IPollliiiee totals ($16,600.00) $0.00 ($16,600.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($16,600.00) 0% $0.00 Fund 132 Asset l@oiffeiiiltuiiie totals $16,600.00 $0.00 $16,600.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $16,600.00 $0.00 Fund 136 .. A�oeui'tliearin IRescue IP111a in Il�:r:sailers De^l:rarti ne,n. 101 .. Adimiiiinliiish artliioin Ds v'is'ie n .12..1.E .. I„iiitM Aduiioiiinliish artouii EXPENSE Atatevials & .5as vicatis. 5521 ARPA Funded Internal Projects 8,500.00 .00 8,500.00 .00 .00 .00 8,500.00 0 29,651.98 5522 ARPA Funded Community Projects 272,720.00 .00 272,720.00 25,000.00 .00 155,000.00 117,720.00 57 767,000.00 ttatevia& & .5ri^ , r,'a's' 7btals' $281,220.00 $0.00 $281,220.00 $25,000.00 $0.00 $155,000.00 $126,220.00 55% $796,651.98 ttiac 5523 5523.01 Personnel Costs - Wages .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 554,537.65 5523.02 Personnel Costs - Benefits .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 174,721.00 5523 - Totals $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 +++ $729,258.65 ttiac t'tstaLF $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 +++ $729,258.65 EXPENSE TOTALS $281,220.00 $0.00 $281,220.00 $25,000.00 $0.00 $155,000.00 $126,220.00 55% $1,525,910.63 D5vis'ien 'I2.11. t„lii'tMAdiiieuinliiis'turar'toui �oCals ($281,220.00) $0.00 ($281,220.00) ($25,000.00) $0.00 ($155,000.00) ($126,220.00) 55% ($1,525,910.63) D5 vr:'ie n 9211 ..' 0111aeuiiartliiuing I'uraruinsfeuii Out EXPENSE t"t«aeist`,v,,s Oz(t 5811 5811.001 Transfer to General Fund 5811.110 5811.358 Transfer to Transit 966,000.00 .00 966,000.00 .00 .00 .00 966,000.00 0 409,710.00 127,000.00 .00 127,000.00 .00 .00 .00 127,000.00 0 65,000.00 Transfer to General Cap Const Fund 161,250.00 .00 161,250.00 .00 .00 .00 161,250.00 0 .00 5811 - Totals $1,254,250.00 $0.00 $1,254,250.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $1,254,250.00 0% $474,710.00 Tiwis'to'vas ttrut't'ttaLF $1,254,250.00 $0.00 $1,254,250.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $1,254,250.00 0% $474,710.00 EXPENSE TOTALS $1,254,250.00 $0.00 $1,254,250.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $1,254,250.00 0% $474,710.00 I'.5ivr:len 9711 011Reuiiatiliuing I'"ui ainsfeii"'Out totals ($1,254,250.00) $0.00 ($1,254,250.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($1,254,250.00) 0% ($474,710.00) 15el,.,Karhnnenr� 101. As`imillinliie'turatliioin �oCals ($1,535,470.00) $0.00 ($1,535,470.00) ($25,000.00) $0.00 ($155,000.00) ($1,380,470.00) 10% ($2,000,620.63) Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM 67 Page 29 of 57 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd PdorYear TotaV Fund 1.36 .. Auneui'tlieerin IRescue IP111ain Il�:r:uuund Del:rarhnne,n. 901... 15uindilling Il"":uuind IBallPerince I'.51v1saorr 9971. IEquuiiity EXPENSE C ertfaa5feercfei�Facrel11illuercaF 5921 Contingency 714,920.00 .00 714,920.00 .00 .00 .00 714,920.00 0 .00 a,o t#irl wcM;s' antP t/r '«tr trtvt ^ Pl alxioo s' ttuta'& $714,920.00 $0.00 $714,920.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $714,920.00 0% $0.00 EXPENSE TOTALS $714,920.00 $0.00 $714,920.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $714,920.00 0% $0.00 I'.Slvrslorr 9971 IEquuiuty totals ($714,920.00) $0.00 ($714,920.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($714,920.00) 0% $0.00 Del:rarhnne,n" sltr't IEuindilling Il::uuind IBallPerince toCals ($714,920.00) $0.00 ($714,920.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($714,920.00) 0% $0.00 Fund 't 36 Auneuii'icain IRescue IIrIIP:rurr Il::uuind toCals $2,250,390.00 $0.00 $2,250,390.00 $25,000.00 $0.00 $155,000.00 $2,095,390.00 $2,000,620.63 Fund 1.37 IPlouusliiuing IR,eIlh allb Il::uuund Del:r<urhnne,n° 531. Iillouusliiuing IRellhralllCuliilllliitatliiauuiir C',fiv'iS'i011 591.1... Iillouushiing EXPENSE Iaulsoluuuo:/ 5o14(,.ex,u. 5111 Regular Wages 2,010.00 .00 2,010.00 138.87 .00 1,110.89 899.11 55 1,840.17 5211 OR Workers' Benefit .00 .00 .00 .01 .00 .11 (.11) +++ .24 5212 Social Security 130.00 .00 130.00 11.51 .00 63.47 66.53 49 132.98 5213 Med & Dent Ins 170.00 .00 170.00 15.32 .00 94.18 75.82 55 169.44 5214 5214.100 PERS - City 420.00 .00 420.00 29.83 .00 238.58 181.42 57 384.77 5214.600 PERS 6% 120.00 .00 120.00 9.34 .00 74.71 45.29 62 128.34 5214.800 DEFERED COMP - CITY 240.00 .00 240.00 16.66 .00 133.28 106.72 56 218.07 5214 - Totals $780.00 $0.00 $780.00 $55.83 $0.00 $446.57 $333.43 57% $731.18 5215 Long Term Disability Ins .00 .00 .00 .22 .00 1.32 (1.32) +++ 2.64 5216 Unemployment Insurance 30.00 .00 30.00 1.80 .00 14.41 15.59 48 15.35 5217 Life Insurance .00 .00 .00 .14 .00 .84 (.84) +++ 1.68 5218 Paid Family Leave Insurance 10.00 .00 10.00 .52 .00 4.20 5.80 42 4.52 fly^r,5'oiwal.°a"s'^ vicas' Pbta'Js' $3,130.00 $0.00 $3,130.00 $224.22 $0.00 $1,735.99 $1,394.01 55% $2,898.20 A7ate'lial��s & .5&.u,lc.aF 5419 Other Professional Sery 35,160.00 .00 35,160.00 .00 .00 76.00 35,084.00 0 .00 Plata^aria& & .°a"aidra^us' ftutats $35,160.00 $0.00 $35,160.00 $0.00 $0.00 $76.00 $35,084.00 0% $0.00 EXPENSE TOTALS $38,290.00 $0.00 $38,290.00 $224.22 $0.00 $1,811.99 $36,478.01 5% $2,898.20 [)tvison 591.1 IPIllouushiira3 toCals ($38,290.00) $0.00 ($38,290.00) ($224.22) $0.00 ($1,811.99) ($36,478.01) 5% ($2,898.20) De:rarhnnen° "Slt't IPIllouualiiing IR,elllrallll'wuillllii'tatliiouir toCals ($38,290.00) $0.00 ($38,290.00) ($224.22) $0.00 ($1,811.99) ($36,478.01) 5% ($2,898.20) Fund 137 Plouusliiuing IRellh allb Il::uuind toCals $38,290.00 $0.00 $38,290.00 $224.22 $0.00 $1,811.99 $36,478.01 $2,898.20 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM Page 30 of 57 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLauint and IR(Akaulp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd PdorYear ToitaV Fund 1.00 .. Sltui°eelt I@ s ind Dej,.,rarhnnenp 611...IMallinteinaince 15ivis: on 0211... Slh eelt IM ruinteinaince EXPENSE /lees: ruarsro:/ 5o14(,.eF 5111 Regular Wages 799,220.00 .00 799,220.00 59,848.98 .00 417,444.05 381,775.95 52 766,561.16 5112 Part -Time Wages 32,780.00 .00 32,780.00 2,656.00 .00 14,209.60 18,570.40 43 14,429.79 5121 Overtime 9,800.00 .00 9,800.00 1,554.67 .00 9,244.50 555.50 94 9,722.37 5211 OR Workers' Benefit 250.00 .00 250.00 15.21 .00 120.14 129.86 48 228.02 5212 Social Security 65,060.00 .00 65,060.00 4,768.49 .00 32,428.86 32,631.14 50 61,088.54 5213 Med & Dent Ins 179,280.00 .00 179,280.00 14,892.40 .00 89,069.16 90,210.84 50 168,464.80 5214 5214.100 PERS - City 145,600.00 .00 145,600.00 10,536.42 .00 74,057.85 71,542.15 51 119,234.43 5214.600 PERS 6% 46,690.00 .00 46,690.00 3,688.66 .00 25,295.77 21,394.23 54 47,045.64 5214.800 DEFERED COMP - CITY 13,210.00 .00 13,210.00 727.00 .00 6,463.76 6,746.24 49 12,551.48 5214 - Totals $205,500.00 $0.00 $205,500.00 $14,952.08 $0.00 $105,817.38 $99,682.62 51% $178,831.55 5215 Long Term Disability Ins 1,330.00 .00 1,330.00 114.47 .00 698.88 631.12 53 1,450.00 5216 Unemployment Insurance 10,950.00 .00 10,950.00 832.80 .00 5,731.75 5,218.25 52 6,779.63 5217 Life Insurance 850.00 .00 850.00 73.77 .00 450.03 399.97 53 934.53 5218 Paid Family Leave Insurance 3,360.00 .00 3,360.00 239.13 .00 1,655.71 1,704.29 49 1,934.54 fly^r,5'oiwal.°a"s' vica F 7bta'LF $1,308,380.00 $0.00 $1,308,380.00 $99,948.00 $0.00 $676,870.06 $631,509.94 52% $1,210,424.93 Afatevial��s & .5&.n,le.as. 5315 Computer Supplies 2,000.00 .00 2,000.00 .00 .00 .00 2,000.00 0 1,193.37 5319 Office Supplies 1,500.00 .00 1,500.00 .00 .00 1,308.15 191.85 87 858.06 5321 Cleaning Supplies .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 640.44 5322 Lubricants 13,000.00 .00 13,000.00 142.40 .00 1,411.37 11,588.63 11 6,986.85 5323 Fuel 28,000.00 .00 28,000.00 3,118.36 1,185.13 14,115.03 12,699.84 55 31,014.90 5324 Clothing 4,500.00 .00 4,500.00 .00 .00 .00 4,500.00 0 1,038.05 5326 Safety/Medical 3,200.00 .00 3,200.00 92.04 .01 883.58 2,316.41 28 3,515.92 5329 Other Supplies 6,000.00 .00 6,000.00 .00 .00 2,277.81 3,722.19 38 6,996.74 5337 Tires/Parts 9,500.00 .00 9,500.00 .00 .00 19.98 9,480.02 0 5,574.52 5338 Tools 7,000.00 .00 7,000.00 398.57 (379.27) 5,442.88 1,936.39 72 6,325.49 5339 Other Maintenance Supplies 1,500.00 .00 1,500.00 .00 .00 710.96 789.04 47 4,315.71 5352 Protective Clothing 4,000.00 .00 4,000.00 1,738.25 .00 3,923.98 76.02 98 2,235.55 5361 Road Materials 60,000.00 .00 60,000.00 1,042.88 895.73 26,144.25 32,960.02 45 22,643.36 5362 Concrete 3,500.00 .00 3,500.00 .00 .00 .00 3,500.00 0 893.48 5363 Signs 25,000.00 .00 25,000.00 9,128.11 .00 13,606.72 11,393.28 54 16,816.15 5369 Other Street Supplies 40,000.00 .00 40,000.00 1,032.07 .00 5,495.44 34,504.56 14 6,724.10 5419 Other Professional Sery 100,000.00 .00 100,000.00 13,381.49 (441.60) 46,792.03 53,649.57 46 51,677.67 5421 Telephone/Data 5,900.00 .00 5,900.00 509.68 157.03 3,484.48 2,258.49 62 6,004.06 5424 Advertising 1,500.00 .00 1,500.00 .00 .00 55.00 1,445.00 4 .00 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM Page 31 of 57 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd PdorYear ToitaV Fund 1.40 .. Sltul°eelt @""sslind Dej,.,rarhnnenp 611...IMalllinteinaince 151v1s: on 4211... Slh eelt IM rlinteinaince EXPENSE Alate'lial''�s & .5&h,te.as. 5432 Meals 300.00 .00 300.00 .00 .00 .00 300.00 0 397.41 5433 Mileage 300.00 .00 300.00 .00 .00 .00 300.00 0 .00 5439 Travel 3,500.00 .00 3,500.00 .00 .00 .00 3,500.00 0 1,817.55 5445 Work Equipment 12,000.00 .00 12,000.00 4,357.72 .00 7,312.66 4,687.34 61 6,492.51 5446 Software Licenses 16,000.00 .00 16,000.00 705.77 298.93 9,503.54 6,197.53 61 4,875.00 5449 Leases- Other 4,000.00 .00 4,000.00 .00 .00 .00 4,000.00 0 1,968.11 5451 Natural Gas 4,400.00 .00 4,400.00 743.82 .00 1,452.91 2,947.09 33 4,827.13 5453 Electricity 10,000.00 .00 10,000.00 648.34 .00 3,335.28 6,664.72 33 7,057.21 5454 Solid Waste Disposal 1,500.00 .00 1,500.00 .00 .00 .00 1,500.00 0 .00 5471 Equipment Repair & Maint 15,000.00 .00 15,000.00 291.92 201.94 9,792.07 5,005.99 67 13,964.63 5474 Structures Repair & Maint 8,000.00 .00 8,000.00 .00 .01 149.74 7,850.25 2 786.70 5475 Vehicle Repair & Maint 19,000.00 .00 19,000.00 315.73 2,162.64 5,843.75 10,993.61 42 11,848.04 5476 Laundry 10,000.00 .00 10,000.00 600.51 908.19 5,008.23 4,083.58 59 7,856.89 5479 Other Repair & Maint 600,000.00 .00 600,000.00 .00 113,119.05 758.32 486,122.63 19 629,704.24 5482 Tree Maintenance 15,000.00 .00 15,000.00 .00 .00 .00 15,000.00 0 899.70 5491 Dues & Subscriptions .00 .00 .00 50.00 .00 50.00 (50.00) +++ 112.41 5492 Registrations/Training 10,000.00 .00 10,000.00 .00 .00 1,477.43 8,522.57 15 7,315.50 5498 Permits/Fees 2,000.00 .00 2,000.00 .00 .00 .00 2,000.00 0 274.48 Plate^ ia& & .°a"si r,'e's' 7bta'ls' $1,047,100.00 $0.00 $1,047,100.00 $38,297.66 $118,107.79 $170,355.59 $758,636.62 28% $875,651.93 C ta'J ttr rt ret, 5649 Other Equipment 157,500.00 .00 157,500.00 .00 .00 .00 157,500.00 0 .00 a,"aye✓ta't ltrrtlet, t'tsta'& $157,500.00 $0.00 $157,500.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $157,500.00 0% $0.00 EXPENSE TOTALS $2,512,980.00 $0.00 $2,512,980.00 $138,245.66 $118,107.79 $847,225.65 $1,547,646.56 38% $2,086,076.86 151vrslo r 4211. Slhieet IM rlinteul"rs role toa al„a ($2,512,980.00) $0.00 ($2,512,980.00) ($138,245.66) ($118,107.79) ($847,225.65) ($1,547,646.56) 38% ($2,086,076.86) I'.51v1sa on 4299 .. Slh eelt Adimiilin EXPENSE Alatevial'�s & .5&.n,te.as. 5414 Accounting/Auditing 7,000.00 .00 7,000.00 3,325.00 2,450.00 6,860.00 (2,310.00) 133 8,767.99 5419 Other Professional Sery .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 7,887.84 5428 IT Support 45,110.00 .00 45,110.00 3,759.16 .00 26,314.12 18,795.88 58 28,140.00 5448 Internal Rent 5,700.00 .00 5,700.00 475.00 .00 3,325.00 2,375.00 58 5,070.00 5451 Natural Gas 600.00 .00 600.00 .00 .00 .00 600.00 0 .00 5453 Electricity 2,490.00 .00 2,490.00 171.23 .00 1,078.49 1,411.51 43 2,159.68 5456 Street Lighting 250,000.00 .00 250,000.00 26,954.81 4,239.72 153,818.61 91,941.67 63 311,345.40 5461 Auto Insurance 7,740.00 .00 7,740.00 645.00 .00 4,515.00 3,225.00 58 8,919.96 5463 Property/Earthquake Insurance 9,380.00 .00 9,380.00 781.67 .00 5,471.69 3,908.31 58 10,490.04 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM Page 32 of 57 70 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month YTD YTD Budget - YTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd PdorYear ToitaV Fund 140 .. Sltui°eelt I@ s ind Dej,.,rarhnnenp 6II...IMallinteinaince D' v1sa on 4299 .. Slh eelt Adimiilin EXPENSE Alate'lial��s & .5&h,te.etis. 5464 Workers' Comp 19,540.00 .00 19,540.00 1,628.33 .00 11,398.31 8,141.69 58 19,410.00 5465 General Liability Insurance 14,030.00 .00 14,030.00 1,169.17 .00 8,184.19 5,845.81 58 11,760.00 5472 Buildings Repairs & Maint 10,000.00 .00 10,000.00 .00 .00 198.81 9,801.19 2 377.18 5482 Tree Maintenance 4,000.00 .00 4,000.00 .00 .00 .00 4,000.00 0 .00 5483 Sidewalks 15,000.00 .00 15,000.00 .00 .00 .00 15,000.00 0 .00 5500 Banking Fees & Charges 25,870.00 .00 25,870.00 1,917.33 .00 8,483.91 17,386.09 33 .00 tlatevia& & .°a"si r,'e's' 7bta'ls' $416,460.00 $0.00 $416,460.00 $40,826.70 $6,689.72 $229,648.13 $180,122.15 57% $414,328.09 EXPENSE TOTALS $416,460.00 $0.00 $416,460.00 $40,826.70 $6,689.72 $229,648.13 $180,122.15 57% $414,328.09 D5vrslorr 4299 Sh eelt A imilin totals ($416,460.00) $0.00 ($416,460.00) ($40,826.70) ($6,689.72) ($229,648.13) ($180,122.15) 57% ($414,328.09) D5vr:'ion 9711 ..'ttllpeuiiatiiiuing I'iiiainsfeuii Out EXPENSE l"t verst ev; heat 5811 5811.363 Transfer to Street & Storm Cap Const Fund .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 1,960,940.48 5811.591 Transfer to Equipment Replace 60,000.00 .00 60,000.00 5,000.00 .00 35,000.00 25,000.00 58 60,000.00 5811.693 Transfer to Reserve for PERS .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 11,820.00 5811 - Totals $60,000.00 $0.00 $60,000.00 $5,000.00 $0.00 $35,000.00 $25,000.00 58% $2,032,760.48 Tt«s'sss'9o'vis llrrt't'ttaLF $60,000.00 $0.00 $60,000.00 $5,000.00 $0.00 $35,000.00 $25,000.00 58% $2,032,760.48 EXPENSE TOTALS $60,000.00 $0.00 $60,000.00 $5,000.00 $0.00 $35,000.00 $25,000.00 58% $2,032,760.48 I'.5ivrslorr 9711 011peuiiatiliuing I"'ui ainsfeii"'Out total„a ($60,000.00) $0.00 ($60,000.00) ($5,000.00) $0.00 ($35,000.00) ($25,000.00) 58% ($2,032,760.48) I'. 5ej,.,rarhnne^r' 631 IMallinteui"rsince totals ($2,989,440.00) $0.00 ($2,989,440.00) ($184,072.36) ($124,797.51) ($1,111,873.78) ($1,752,768.71) 41% ($4,533,165.43) Dee,.,<arhnne,n. 901... 15uindilling Il::uind IBallPsrince D' v1saorr 997I. IEquiliitM EXPENSE CoertilttleerCheisaere511illsaso.etis. 5921 Contingency 4,175,770.00 .00 4,175,770.00 .00 .00 .00 4,175,770.00 0 .00 a"o t#sr/e^ssc'ts';s'«s'sstPt/so'«tretrtvte^Plalxio'e's'ltuta'& $4,175,770.00 $0.00 $4,175,770.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $4,175,770.00 0% $0.00 EXPENSE TOTALS $4,175,770.00 $0.00 $4,175,770.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $4,175,770.00 0% $0.00 I'.Slvrslorr 9971 IEquilutM totals ($4,175,770.00) $0.00 ($4,175,770.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($4,175,770.00) 0% $0.00 Deq:r<srhnne,n° 901 1Euindilling Il::uind IBallPsince toCals ($4,175,770.00) $0.00 ($4,175,770.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($4,175,770.00) 0% $0.00 Fund 1.40 Stuieelt@":uind totals $7,165,210.00 $0.00 $7,165,210.00 $184,072.36 $124,797.51 $1,111,873.78 $5,928,538.71 $4,533,165.43 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM Page 33 of 57 71 WQODBURN Inckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month YTD YTD Budget - YTD %u Used/ Account Account Descripitiion Budget Amendments Budget Transactions Encumbrances Transactions Transactions Pec'd Pr'IorYear Toitai Fund 250.. GO lilellbtSeui°Vice I@'":must Del:rarhnnerr 151... I@ uiuire ui°ree I'.51v1„abn 91.1.1... 1 It Seui°viiee EXPENSE Debt .5`ee'uptre 5711 Bond Principal 629,000.00 .00 629,000.00 .00 .00 .00 629,000.00 0 597,000.00 5721 Bond Interest 13,100.00 .00 13,100.00 .00 .00 6,208.80 6,891.20 47 24,835.20 Debt.°a"s'^rh!ice Pbta'Js' $642,100.00 $0.00 $642,100.00 $0.00 $0.00 $6,208.80 $635,891.20 1% $621,835.20 EXPENSE TOTALS $642,100.00 $0.00 $642,100.00 $0.00 $0.00 $6,208.80 $635,891.20 1% $621,835.20 Dtvr:len 9111 I:1eIlbtSeuiviiee totals ($642,100.00) $0.00 ($642,100.00) $0.00 $0.00 ($6,208.80) ($635,891.20) 1% ($621,835.20) 15el:rairrhnneir „1.51 @'liiuireui"ree totals ($642,100.00) $0.00 ($642,100.00) $0.00 $0.00 ($6,208.80) ($635,891.20) 1% ($621,835.20) Fund 250 GO IP:1eIlbtSeuiVice IF:uirst total„a $642,100.00 $0.00 $642,100.00 $0.00 $0.00 $6,208.80 $635,891.20 $621,835.20 Fund 358 .. GeuireuraIII CaIllp Coiiiirslt I iiiiW De^l:rarh ne,n. 121 Clinty Adiiiiieuiuiruisturerteui I'.t1v1t,abn 9531... Ceurrstoi°uctlilloin EXPENSE a,"a2 taJ ttr rt ay 5623 5623.046 Pool Projects .00 .00 .00 32,519.00 .00 32,519.00 (32,519.00) +++ .00 5623 - Totals $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $32,519.00 $0.00 $32,519.00 ($32,519.00) +++ $0.00 5629 Buildings 1,046,250.00 .00 1,046,250.00 .00 .00 20,842.32 1,025,407.68 2 145,336.29 5637 5637 Parks 2,000,000.00 .00 2,000,000.00 .00 52,515.74 11,807.10 1,935,677.16 3 665,263.02 5637.042 Legion Park Playground .00 .00 .00 .00 179,844.91 (3,000.00) (176,844.91) +++ 1,904,389.67 5637 - Totals $2,000,000.00 $0.00 $2,000,000.00 $0.00 $232,360.65 $8,807.10 $1,758,832.25 12% $2,569,652.69 5639 Other Improvements 158,710.00 .00 158,710.00 4,421.00 .00 4,421.00 154,289.00 3 198,276.00 a,"a[)Aal ttrutlet, t't taLF $3,204,960.00 $0.00 $3,204,960.00 $36,940.00 $232,360.65 $66,589.42 $2,906,009.93 9% $2,913,264.98 EXPENSE TOTALS $3,204,960.00 $0.00 $3,204,960.00 $36,940.00 $232,360.65 $66,589.42 $2,906,009.93 9% $2,913,264.98 Dt vr:len 9531 Coinslkuuctililloin totals ($3,204,960.00) $0.00 ($3,204,960.00) ($36,940.00) ($232,360.65) ($66,589.42) ($2,906,009.93) 9% ($2,913,264.98) I"Ieel:rarhnrenr '12.1. Cilii'ItyAdiiiieuiui'uiiiw'Ikui.ateui toCals ($3,204,960.00) $0.00 ($3,204,960.00) ($36,940.00) ($232,360.65) ($66,589.42) ($2,906,009.93) 9% ($2,913,264.98) Fund 358 OeuireuiiaIII CaIlptauiimtlIiiiW toCals $3,204,960.00 $0.00 $3,204,960.00 $36,940.00 $232,360.65 $66,589.42 $2,906,009.93 $2,913,264.98 Fund 360 Sllpeeli III AssessraeuiirIt I W De^l:rarhne,n. 541... Sllpecllalll Assessraeuint D" vr:'ien 5921... Sllpeeiiallll Assessraeuint EXPENSE Materials & .5eevtr.etis. 5419 Other Professional Sery 2,300.00 .00 2,300.00 .00 .00 76.00 2,224.00 3 .00 Materials & .5eir dr'ers' t totals $2,300.00 $0.00 $2,300.00 $0.00 $0.00 $76.00 $2,224.00 3% $0.00 EXPENSE TOTALS $2,300.00 $0.00 $2,300.00 $0.00 $0.00 $76.00 $2,224.00 3% $0.00 D" vr:'ien 5921. Sllpeeiialll A~ssessu'aeint toCals ($2,300.00) $0.00 ($2,300.00) $0.00 $0.00 ($76.00) ($2,224.00) 3% $0.00 11ol:rarhnne,n° 541 Sllpeoliialll Assessu'aeint toCals ($2,300.00) $0.00 ($2,300.00) $0.00 $0.00 ($76.00) ($2,224.00) 3% $0.00 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM 72 Page 34 of 57 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Pec'd PdorYear TotaV Fund 360 .. S111eeiiialll Assessraeuint Il�:r:sailers Del:rarhnnen° 901... 15uindiling Il�:rbind IBallPerince I'.51v1„abn 9971. 15'q unity EXPENSE C ertllttleereke F aerea laa9reero.etis. 5921 Contingency 39,960.00 .00 39,960.00 .00 .00 .00 39,960.00 0 .00 a "o tarrr/ewc'Mr F « ncf a/ ro'«t rat rtvt ^ P l alxio'o' s' t tuta'& $39,960.00 $0.00 $39,960.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $39,960.00 0% $0.00 EXPENSE TOTALS $39,960.00 $0.00 $39,960.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $39,960.00 0% $0.00 I'.alvr:len 9971 Itquiluty totals ($39,960.00) $0.00 ($39,960.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($39,960.00) 0% $0.00 Del:rarhnnen° 901 1Euindiling I@""usund IBallPerince toCals ($39,960.00) $0.00 ($39,960.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($39,960.00) 0% $0.00 Fund 360 "S111eelii rill Assessrneuint Il::uind toCals $42,260.00 $0.00 $42,260.00 $0.00 $0.00 $76.00 $42,184.00 $0.00 Fund 363 .. S�tuii�eet A. Stowuim�a CalIll Couuii�rs�t I@::::ssuii�rd Del:rarhnnerr 631 IMallinteinaince I'.a1v1t,abn 9531... Couurrstoi°uctliiouurr EXPENSE C tal alr rt ay 5631 Streets/Alleys/Sidewalks 800,000.00 .00 800,000.00 40,078.57 143,118.93 195,350.95 461,530.12 42 3,222,759.51 5636 Storm Drains 80,000.00 .00 80,000.00 .00 .00 .00 80,000.00 0 72,970.90 l'a7 tal llr(t/ ), R)f is $880,000.05 $0.00 $880,000.00 $40,078.57 $143,118.93 $195,350.95 $541,530.12 38% $3,295,730.41 EXPENSE TOTALS $880,000.00 $0.00 $880,000.00 $40,078.57 $143,118.93 $195,350.95 $541,530.12 38% $3,295,730.41 laivr:len 9531 Coinstuuctliioin totals ($880,000.00) $0.00 ($880,000.00) ($40,078.57) ($143,118.93) ($195,350.95) ($541,530.12) 38% ($3,295,730.41) I'. 5ej,.,rarhnne^r' 631 IMallinteui"raince totals ($880,000.00) $0.00 ($880,000.00) ($40,078.57) ($143,118.93) ($195,350.95) ($541,530.12) 38% ($3,295,730.41) Fund 363 Stuieet A. Steuiima CalIlp t owuiirst I@""ssuirst toCals $880,000.00 $0.00 $880,000.00 $40,078.57 $143,118.93 $195,350.95 $541,530.12 $3,295,730.41 Fund 364 .. IV'reuui°illas SII)C I@""ssui°rst CJel:rarC ne,n. 491... Itlraurlllos Aduiauimriiistuiiatliiouuiir C',t'iv'is'ien s3P'71.�1... 1Dest'gin 151uing1lineeuii�'tliing EXPENSE A7ateivlals & .5&,u,le.etis. 5419 Other Professional Sery 60,000.00 .00 60,000.00 31,228.08 .00 84,752.66 (24,752.66) 141 .00 Platerlals & .5"ri^ r,'o's' !totals $60,000.00 $0.00 $60,000.00 $31,228.08 $0.00 $84,752.66 ($24,752.66) 141% $0.00 EXPENSE TOTALS $60,000.00 $0.00 $60,000.00 $31,228.08 $0.00 $84,752.66 ($24,752.66) 141% $0.00 15ivr:len 9511 IDesFgin li"uing1liineeui.iiuiroL total„a ($60,000.00) $0.00 ($60,000.00) ($31,228.08) $0.00 ($84,752.66) $24,752.66 141% $0.00 [)t vr:'ie n 971�1... tlllpeuiior'tliiuing t'uroruins'teuii Out EXPENSE Taaersaeve heat 5811 5811.358 Transfer to General Cap Const Fund 1,028,750.00 .00 1,028,750.00 .00 .00 8,807.10 1,019,942.90 1 1,485,954.00 5811 - Totals $1,028,750.00 $0.00 $1,028,750.00 $0.00 $0.00 $8,807.10 $1,019,942.90 1% $1,485,954.00 71a'sss'te'vis alrrt'7ttals $1,028,750.00 $0.00 $1,028,750.00 $0.00 $0.00 $8,807.10 $1,019,942.90 1% $1,485,954.00 EXPENSE TOTALS $1,028,750.00 $0.00 $1,028,750.00 $0.00 $0.00 $8,807.10 $1,019,942.90 1% $1,485,954.00 I'.tivr:len 9711 011peui':utuiui"ra3"t"'ui ainsfeii"'Out �otal„a ($1,028,750.00) $0.00 ($1,028,750.00) $0.00 $0.00 ($8,807.10) ($1,019,942.90) 1% ($1,485,954.00) Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM 73 Page 35 of 57 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month YTD YTD Budget - YTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd PdorYear TotaV Fund 364 .. IPaiiii°illeo SII1C Il'::ui d Del:rarhnnein" 491 ..IIrauiIIIcsAdiiii'nuimruic'Ikuiatiliiouir toCals ($1,088,750.00) $0.00 ($1,088,750.00) ($31,228.08) $0.00 ($93,559.76) ($995,190.24) 9% ($1,485,954.00) Del:rarhnnein. 901... Ituindiling Il�:rbuird 1BallPerince D' v1„ bin 9971. IEq unity EXPENSE C ertillll&?Cke F acrca laee9,eerc.eti,r. 5981 5981.005 Reserve for Future Years 4,805,630.00 .00 4,805,630.00 .00 .00 .00 4,805,630.00 0 .00 5981 - Totals $4,805,630.00 $0.00 $4,805,630.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $4,805,630.00 0% $0.00 a"o t#irle^arc'ao';s'a'ntPa/ro'«tretrtvt^Plalxio'o's'ttuta'& $4,805,630.00 $0.00 $4,805,630.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $4,805,630.00 0% $0.00 EXPENSE TOTALS $4,805,630.00 $0.00 $4,805,630.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $4,805,630.00 0% $0.00 I'.alvr:bin 9971 IEquiluty totals ($4,805,630.00) $0.00 ($4,805,630.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($4,805,630.00) 0% $0.00 Del:rarhnnein° 901 IEuindiling I@""uruird IBallPerince toCals ($4,805,630.00) $0.00 ($4,805,630.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($4,805,630.00) 0% $0.00 Fund 364 IPaiiirlllaoSlPtt;I@":uind total„a $5,894,380.00 $0.00 $5,894,380.00 $31,228.08 $0.00 $93,559.76 $5,800,820.24 $1,485,954.00 Fund 376 .."1uiiauii�rsllrowurtatliiouii�r cIl`t)C I@::::rruii�rd lae^I:rarhnneinr 631...IMalllinteinaince D" vr:'bin 9711...011lpeuiiatliiuiiug t'uiiauiiusteuii larrt EXPENSE l"a«vcrsaev,e heat 5811 5811.001 Transfer to General Fund 200,000.00 .00 200,000.00 .00 .00 .00 200,000.00 0 .00 5811.358 Transfer to General Cap Const Fund 50,000.00 .00 50,000.00 .00 .00 .00 50,000.00 0 .00 5811.363 Transfer to Street & Storm Cap Const Fund 170,000.00 .00 170,000.00 29,752.13 .00 153,970.04 16,029.96 91 1,000,000.00 5811 - Totals $420,000.00 $0.00 $420,000.00 $29,752.13 $0.00 $153,970.04 $266,029.96 37% $1,000,000.00 Ttwi' F'A,v,e'tlrrt't'ttaLF $420,000.00 $0.00 $420,000.00 $29,752.13 $0.00 $153,970.04 $266,029.96 37% $1,000,000.00 EXPENSE TOTALS $420,000.00 $0.00 $420,000.00 $29,752.13 $0.00 $153,970.04 $266,029.96 37% $1,000,000.00 I'.tivr:bin 9711 011peui':utuiing"1"'ui aui'r teui.Out total„a ($420,000.00) $0.00 ($420,000.00) ($29,752.13) $0.00 ($153,970.04) ($266,029.96) 37% ($1,000,000.00) I'. tej,.,rarhnnein' 631 IMallinteui"raince totals ($420,000.00) $0.00 ($420,000.00) ($29,752.13) $0.00 ($153,970.04) ($266,029.96) 37% ($1,000,000.00) De^I:rarhnnein. 901... Ituindiling Il�:rbuird 1BallPerince D' v1t,bin 9971. Itquiliity EXPENSE C ertillll&?Cke s acrca flare!! rel etceteca laee9,eerc.eti,r. 5981 5981.005 Reserve for Future Years 14,628,430.00 .00 14,628,430.00 .00 .00 .00 14,628,430.00 0 .00 5981 - Totals $14,628,430.00 $0.00 $14,628,430.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $14,628,430.00 0% $0.00 Co tarrcic'^arc'MrFancPa/rrallrclr7vtr^cPlkalxicc's'7bta'& $14,628,430.00 $0.00 $14,628,430.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $14,628,430.00 0% $0.00 EXPENSE TOTALS $14,628,430.00 $0.00 $14,628,430.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $14,628,430.00 0% $0.00 I'.tivr:bin 9971 IEquiluty totals ($14,628,430.00) $0.00 ($14,628,430.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($14,628,430.00) 0% $0.00 Deq:rarhnne,inr 901 IEuindiling I@""uruird IBallPaince toCals ($14,628,430.00) $0.00 ($14,628,430.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($14,628,430.00) 0% $0.00 Fund 376 1"111ainsllpoiiitr'tliioinSIP C Il::ui d toCals $15,048,430.00 $0.00 $15,048,430.00 $29,752.13 $0.00 $153,970.04 $14,894,459.96 $1,000,000.00 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM 74 Page 36 of 57 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month YTD YTD Budget - YTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd PdorYear TotaV Fund 377 .. Stoinn SII)C II' "'surd Dej,.,rarhnnenp 611...IMallinteinaince D, v'is'ien s9P'71.�1... 1Dest'agin 151unal1iiuineeuii'tliing EXPENSE A7atei'elet�s & .5&vic.etis. 5419 Other Professional Sery 250,000.00 .00 250,000.00 11,627.75 43,664.22 86,658.01 119,677.77 52 .00 Plate^ ia& & .°a"si^ ,k'e's' 7bta'ls' $250,000.00 $0.00 $250,000.00 $11,627.75 $43,664.22 $86,658.01 $119,677.77 52% $0.00 EXPENSE TOTALS $250,000.00 $0.00 $250,000.00 $11,627.75 $43,664.22 $86,658.01 $119,677.77 52% $0.00 D5vr:len 9511 IDe Faro li"uing1liineeui.iiuirg totals ($250,000.00) $0.00 ($250,000.00) ($11,627.75) ($43,664.22) ($86,658.01) ($119,677.77) 52% $0.00 D5vr:'ien 971�1...0111peuiiatiiiuing Iiiiauinsfeuii Out EXPENSE Tt scrst exec heat 5811 5811.363 Transfer to Street & Storm Cap Const Fund 67,320.00 .00 67,320.00 9,917.38 .00 40,971.85 26,348.15 61 114,126.00 5811 - Totals $67,320.00 $0.00 $67,320.00 $9,917.38 $0.00 $40,971.85 $26,348.15 61% $114,126.00 7t«s'css'9c'vis Oz(t'7rta'Js $67,320.00 $0.00 $67,320.00 $9,917.38 $0.00 $40,971.85 $26,348.15 61% $114,126.00 EXPENSE TOTALS $67,320.00 $0.00 $67,320.00 $9,917.38 $0.00 $40,971.85 $26,348.15 61% $114,126.00 I'.5ivr:len 9711 0111peuiiatiliui"ra3"1"'ui ainsfeii"'Out totals ($67,320.00) $0.00 ($67,320.00) ($9,917.38) $0.00 ($40,971.85) ($26,348.15) 61% ($114,126.00) I'. 5ej,.,rarhnne^r' 631 IMallinteui"rsince totals ($317,320.00) $0.00 ($317,320.00) ($21,545.13) ($43,664.22) ($127,629.86) ($146,025.92) 54% ($114,126.00) Dee,.,<arhnne,n. 901... 15uindilling Il�:rbind IBallPsrince D' v1„abn 9971. 1Eq unity EXPENSE Col tillgeerctei F acrc5 lassblicaF 5981 5981.005 Reserve for Future Years 774,470.00 .00 774,470.00 .00 .00 .00 774,470.00 0 .00 5981 - Totals $774,470.00 $0.00 $774,470.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $774,470.00 0% $0.00 a,o t#sc/ewc'Ms F acscP t/ss'«7r 7rtvt ^ Pl alxioe s' 7tuta'& $774,470.00 $0.00 $774,470.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $774,470.00 0% $0.00 EXPENSE TOTALS $774,470.00 $0.00 $774,470.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $774,470.00 0% $0.00 D' vr:len 9971 1Equiluty totals ($774,470.00) $0.00 ($774,470.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($774,470.00) 0% $0.00 Deq:r<srhnne,n" 901 1Euindilling I@""usund IBallPsince totals ($774,470.00) $0.00 ($774,470.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($774,470.00) 0% $0.00 Fund 377 Stoinn SEX Il::uii d "totals $1,091,790.00 $0.00 $1,091,790.00 $21,545.13 $43,664.22 $127,629.86 $920,495.92 $114,126.00 Fund 465 .. Se err Cap Csuinst Il�:r:sailers Dej,.,rarhnnenr 671... Sesseui. D, v'is'ien 951.1... IR°test'aluiir 151uiirgiiiiuiireeuii'iiuiirg EXPENSE C toJ Ozntfay 5635 Sewer 100,000.00 .00 100,000.00 .00 .00 .00 100,000.00 0 .00 a,"ale✓talOtdl y 7tstaLF $100,000.05 $0.00 $100,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $100,000.00 0% $0.00 EXPENSE TOTALS $100,000.00 $0.00 $100,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $100,000.00 0% $0.00 D5visbn 9511 IDestalurr 15uiral1lineeui°iiuirg totals ($100,000.00) $0.00 ($100,000.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($100,000.00) 0% $0.00 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM 75 Page 37 of 57 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month YTD YTD Budget - YTD % Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Pec'd PdorYear ToitaV Fund 465 .. Se euii" Cap Csuins1t F�r'rrund Dej,.,rarhnnenp 671... Sesureui D' v1t,abn 9531... Coinshuctloin ctliourr EXPENSE 5635 Sewer 2,035,000.00 .00 2,035,000.00 4,080.31 70,669.16 90,371.99 1,873,958.85 8 3,216,090.66 G, [)✓ta'Jttrutlet,t'rta'LF $2,035,000.00 $0.00 $2,035,000.00 $4,080.31 $70,669.16 $90,371.99 $1,873,958.85 8% $3,216,090.66 EXPENSE TOTALS $2,035,000.00 $0.00 $2,035,000.00 $4,080.31 $70,669.16 $90,371.99 $1,873,958.85 8% $3,216,090.66 Dtvr:len 9531 Coinshuctloin totals ($2,035,000.00) $0.00 ($2,035,000.00) ($4,080.31) ($70,669.16) ($90,371.99) ($1,873,958.85) 8% ($3,216,090.66) Ite^I,':rarhnne^i' 621 Se ureui totals ($2,135,000.00) $0.00 ($2,135,000.00) ($4,080.31) ($70,669.16) ($90,371.99) ($1,973,958.85) 8% ($3,216,090.66) Fund 465 Se euii Cap t oins1t I@""rrund �oCals $2,135,000.00 $0.00 $2,135,000.00 $4,080.31 $70,669.16 $90,371.99 $1,973,958.85 $3,216,090.66 Fund 466 .. a teuii" Cap Csuinst F�r'rrund Dee,., <arh ne,n. 61 1..• a teur D, v'is'ien 951.1... IR°)es�a3uiir 111uiira8liiuiireeuii'tliuiirg EXPENSE 5634 Water - Capital 50,000.00 550,000.00 600,000.00 .00 .00 .00 600,000.00 0 14,396.38 G, [)✓ta'Jttrutlet,ltuta'LF $50,000.00 $550,000.00 $600,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $600,000.00 0% $14,396.38 EXPENSE TOTALS $50,000.00 $550,000.00 $600,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $600,000.00 0% $14,396.38 Dtvr:len 9511. IPteMgiin li"uing1liineeui.iiuirg totals ($50,000.00) ($550,000.00) ($600,000.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($600,000.00) 0% ($14,396.38) D, v'is'ie n 952.1 IC1,lilgllft of ay EXPENSE 5611 Land 900,000.00 .00 900,000.00 .00 .00 40,000.00 860,000.00 4 .00 G, [)✓ta'tttrutlet,1tuta'LF $900,000.05 $0.00 $900,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $40,000.00 $860,000.00 4% $0.00 EXPENSE TOTALS $900,000.00 $0.00 $900,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $40,000.00 $860,000.00 4% $0.00 D" vr:'ien 9521 IC1,lilgllftof ay �oCals ($900,000.00) $0.00 ($900,000.00) $0.00 $0.00 ($40,000.00) ($860,000.00) 4% $0.00 D' v1t,abn 9531... Coinshuctloin ctliourr EXPENSE 5634 Water- Capital 1,056,800.00 .00 1,056,800.00 17,637.65 (770,712.88) 698,781.36 1,128,731.52 -7 2,844,144.26 a,' ✓ta'J1trraslrp,ltuta'LF $1,056,800.00 $0.00 $1,056,800.00 $17,637.65 ($770,712.88) $698,781.36 $1,128,731.52 -7% $2,844,144.26 EXPENSE TOTALS $1,056,800.00 $0.00 $1,056,800.00 $17,637.65 ($770,712.88) $698,781.36 $1,128,731.52 -7% $2,844,144.26 Dtvr:len 9531 Coinshuctloin totals ($1,056,800.00) $0.00 ($1,056,800.00) ($17,637.65) $770,712.88 ($698,781.36) ($1,128,731.52) -7% ($2,844,144.26) Ite^I,':rarhnne^i' 611 Wateiii totals ($2,006,800.00) ($550,000.00) ($2,556,800.00) ($17,637.65) $770,712.88 ($738,781.36) ($2,588,731.52) -1% ($2,858,540.64) Fund 466 WateiiiiCap toins'tI@""rrund �oCals $2,006,800.00 $550,000.00 $2,556,800.00 $17,637.65 ($770,712.88) $738,781.36 $2,588,731.52 $2,858,540.64 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM 76 Page 38 of 57 WQODBURN Inckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descr'Vlptflon Budget Amendments Budget Tr'ansactflons Encumbrances Tr'ansactflons Tr'ansactflons Rec'd Pr'IorYear ToitaV Fund 470 .. atoui Il�:r:sailers C',t'iv'is'ion 641.1... atour SsslII Illy EXPENSE yaulsolrsro:/ 5o14(,.eF 5111 Regular Wages 1,329,090.00 .00 1,329,090.00 89,837.13 .00 653,092.03 675,997.97 49 1,168,831.02 5112 Part -Time Wages 21,170.00 .00 21,170.00 1,046.21 .00 6,681.32 14,488.68 32 9,001.58 5121 Overtime 19,260.00 .00 19,260.00 518.12 .00 5,992.76 13,267.24 31 16,031.38 5211 OR Workers' Benefit 380.00 .00 380.00 17.95 .00 152.93 227.07 40 298.14 5212 Social Security 105,420.00 .00 105,420.00 6,809.94 .00 48,549.85 56,870.15 46 92,308.50 5213 Med & Dent Ins 308,900.00 .00 308,900.00 23,796.95 .00 140,894.96 168,005.04 46 261,831.23 5214 5214 Retirement .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 2,927.97 5214.100 PIERS - City 247,100.00 .00 247,100.00 15,717.52 .00 115,296.84 131,803.16 47 186,777.63 5214.600 PIERS 6% 79,060.00 .00 79,060.00 5,350.62 .00 37,479.97 41,580.03 47 70,778.27 5214.800 DEFERED COMP - CITY 23,800.00 .00 23,800.00 1,502.92 .00 14,714.39 9,085.61 62 21,367.73 5214 - Totals $349,960.00 $0.00 $349,960.00 $22,571.06 $0.00 $167,491.20 $182,468.80 48% $281,851.60 5215 Long Term Disability Ins 2,190.00 .00 2,190.00 174.77 .00 1,067.69 1,122.31 49 2,160.81 5216 Unemployment Insurance 17,790.00 .00 17,790.00 1,188.13 .00 8,654.65 9,135.35 49 10,315.85 5217 Life Insurance 1,400.00 .00 1,400.00 112.60 .00 687.32 712.68 49 1,392.37 5218 Paid Family Leave Insurance 5,450.00 .00 5,450.00 339.75 .00 2,469.72 2,980.28 45 2,892.81 ye,soiinal.°a"s' vica F Pbta'LF $2,161,010.00 $0.00 $2,161,010.00 $146,412.61 $0.00 $1,035,734.43 $1,125,275.57 48% $1,846,915.29 A7atevial��s & .5&.u,le.as. 5315 Computer Supplies 500.00 .00 500.00 .00 .00 .00 500.00 0 .00 5319 Office Supplies 1,750.00 .00 1,750.00 66.31 .00 1,459.95 290.05 83 1,285.21 5323 Fuel 20,000.00 .00 20,000.00 252.05 806.11 6,119.58 13,074.31 35 14,421.11 5324 Clothing 4,500.00 .00 4,500.00 72.00 .00 340.36 4,159.64 8 477.31 5326 Safety/Medical 3,000.00 .00 3,000.00 196.71 .00 1,566.22 1,433.78 52 2,085.93 5327 Chemicals 130,000.00 .00 130,000.00 1,728.67 88,698.85 57,013.32 (15,712.17) 112 107,000.42 5328 Lab Supplies 2,500.00 .00 2,500.00 4,310.70 .00 5,031.18 (2,531.18) 201 906.72 5329 Other Supplies 3,200.00 .00 3,200.00 33.94 .00 1,702.96 1,497.04 53 3,060.16 5338 Tools 3,000.00 .00 3,000.00 .00 .00 3,925.76 (925.76) 131 1,369.40 5339 Other Maintenance Supplies 2,000.00 .00 2,000.00 10.88 .00 35.86 1,964.14 2 468.78 5379 5379 Water/Sewer Supplies 20,000.00 .00 20,000.00 .00 1,475.00 2,622.05 15,902.95 20 29,072.26 5379.001 Line Repair Supplies 20,000.00 .00 20,000.00 299.59 .00 2,704.32 17,295.68 14 3,483.39 5379.002 Customer Service 20,000.00 .00 20,000.00 3,310.53 .00 7,607.57 12,392.43 38 13,993.21 5379.003 Pump Supplies 4,500.00 .00 4,500.00 2,604.58 .00 3,624.53 875.47 81 831.81 5379.004 Meter Parts 20,000.00 .00 20,000.00 .00 .00 438.62 19,561.38 2 13,175.06 5379.005 Protective Equipment 2,500.00 .00 2,500.00 .00 .00 1,972.10 527.90 79 2,004.67 5379 - Totals $87,000.00 $0.00 $87,000.00 $6,214.70 $1,475.00 $18,969.19 $66,555.81 23% $62,560.40 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM Page 39 of 57 77 WQODBURN Inckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descr'Vlptflon Budget Amendments Budget Tr'ansactflons Encumbrances Tr'ansactflons Tr'ansactflons Rec'd Pr'IorYear ToitaV Fund 470 .. atoui Il�:r'ssund C',t'iv'ison 641.1... atour SsslII Illy EXPENSE Alate'lial''�s & .5&u,te.otis. 5419 5419 Other Professional Sery 16,000.00 20,000.00 36,000.00 16,828.12 265.65 17,656.97 18,077.38 50 18,223.60 5419.501 Testing/Lab 20,000.00 .00 20,000.00 .00 162.00 2,050.67 17,787.33 11 16,302.39 5419.707 Educ Outreach 3,500.00 .00 3,500.00 .00 .00 .00 3,500.00 0 97.30 5419 - Totals $39,500.00 $20,000.00 $59,500.00 $16,828.12 $427.65 $19,707.64 $39,364.71 34% $34,623.29 5421 Telephone/Data 10,000.00 .00 10,000.00 982.25 103.92 6,221.57 3,674.51 63 11,496.10 5422 Postage 1,000.00 .00 1,000.00 .00 .00 .00 1,000.00 0 .00 5445 Work Equipment 1,500.00 .00 1,500.00 14.98 .00 14.98 1,485.02 1 671.79 5446 Software Licenses 20,000.00 .00 20,000.00 1,281.94 689.81 7,724.57 11,585.62 42 25,643.00 5449 Leases- Other .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 1,916.11 5451 Natural Gas 3,500.00 .00 3,500.00 417.58 .00 1,101.66 2,398.34 31 3,513.19 5453 Electricity 325,000.00 .00 325,000.00 21,759.82 .00 172,969.66 152,030.34 53 324,738.58 5454 Solid Waste Disposal 1,300.00 .00 1,300.00 .00 .00 .00 1,300.00 0 .00 5471 Equipment Repair & Maint 10,500.00 .00 10,500.00 67.55 278.03 4,800.61 5,421.36 48 4,523.55 5472 Buildings Repairs & Maint 3,000.00 .00 3,000.00 33.98 38.61 5,249.42 (2,288.03) 176 3,292.72 5475 Vehicle Repair & Maint 5,000.00 .00 5,000.00 262.30 1,082.05 3,148.82 769.13 85 8,236.37 5479 Other Repair & Maint 205,000.00 .00 205,000.00 4,107.02 14,576.07 85,291.36 105,132.57 49 184,740.06 5491 Dues & Subscriptions 2,400.00 .00 2,400.00 335.00 .00 2,048.00 352.00 85 1,455.00 5492 Registrations/Training 3,500.00 .00 3,500.00 125.00 .00 4,192.97 (692.97) 120 3,095.32 5493 Printing/Binding .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 35.00 5498 Permits/Fees 1,500.00 .00 1,500.00 200.00 .00 845.00 655.00 56 8,705.30 Plate^ ia& & .°a"si r,'e's' 7bta'ls' $890,150.00 $20,000.00 $910,150.00 $59,301.50 $108,176.10 $409,480.64 $392,493.26 57% $810,320.82 C to'J ttr rt ay 5642 Passenger Vehicles 43,000.00 .00 43,000.00 .00 .00 .00 43,000.00 0 .00 a,"ale✓ta't ltr utl y t'tsta'& $43,000.00 $0.00 $43,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $43,000.00 0% $0.00 EXPENSE TOTALS $3,094,160.00 $20,000.00 $3,114,160.00 $205,714.11 $108,176.10 $1,445,215.07 $1,560,768.83 50% $2,657,236.11 C5ivr:'ion 6411 .. atom"'SillpIpIlIIV tol<als ($3,094,160.00) ($20,000.00) ($3,114,160.00) ($205,714.11) ($108,176.10) ($1,445,215.07) ($1,560,768.83) 50% ($2,657,236.11) 15ivr:'ion 6499.. sr'IkourAsimillinliiis'Ikuiatililloin EXPENSE Alatevial'�s & .5&.u,te.otis. 5319 Office Supplies .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 656.43 (656.43) +++ 256.48 5409 5409.140 Garage Services 20,010.00 .00 20,010.00 .00 .00 5,006.43 15,003.57 25 5,818.48 5409 - Totals $20,010.00 $0.00 $20,010.00 $0.00 $0.00 $5,006.43 $15,003.57 25% $5,818.48 5414 Accounting/Auditing 5,000.00 .00 5,000.00 2,375.00 1,750.00 4,900.00 (1,650.00) 133 6,262.85 5419 Other Professional Sery 15,000.00 .00 15,000.00 .00 .00 .00 15,000.00 0 .00 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM 78 Page 40 of 57 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month YTD YTD Budget - YTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd PdorYear ToitaV Fund 474 .. Wa teuiIl�:r:sailers Del:r<srhnne,n. 611 Wa teii D5vvs'ion 6499.• Wateuii Astuiinuiuiiriiis1tuiiatliieuiir EXPENSE A7ate'lials & .5&,u,te.otis. 5422 Postage 20,000.00 .00 20,000.00 1,321.56 9,312.10 11,327.30 (639.40) 103 21,220.35 5428 IT Support 64,910.00 .00 64,910.00 5,409.16 .00 37,864.12 27,045.88 58 59,220.00 5448 Internal Rent 14,580.00 .00 14,580.00 1,215.00 .00 8,505.00 6,075.00 58 12,950.00 5450 General Right of Way Charge 234,340.00 .00 234,340.00 18,959.83 .00 172,613.50 61,726.50 74 259,159.58 5460 Property Tax Expense 7,000.00 .00 7,000.00 .00 .00 5,313.42 1,686.58 76 14,525.85 5461 Auto Insurance 7,440.00 .00 7,440.00 620.00 .00 4,340.00 3,100.00 58 8,109.96 5463 Property/Earthquake Insurance 31,440.00 .00 31,440.00 2,620.00 .00 18,340.00 13,100.00 58 27,930.00 5464 Workers' Comp 13,950.00 .00 13,950.00 1,162.50 .00 8,137.50 5,812.50 58 15,549.96 5465 General Liability Insurance 16,290.00 .00 16,290.00 1,357.50 .00 9,502.50 6,787.50 58 16,790.04 5472 Buildings Repairs & Maint 5,530.00 .00 5,530.00 .00 .00 .00 5,530.00 0 2,238.38 5493 Printing/Binding 16,000.00 .00 16,000.00 646.52 6,455.09 5,826.91 3,718.00 77 11,229.55 5500 Banking Fees & Charges 55,540.00 .00 55,540.00 5,849.21 .00 40,436.75 15,103.25 73 57,491.34 77ate^vta& & .°a"si r,'e's' 7bta'ls' $527,030.00 $0.00 $527,030.00 $41,536.28 $17,517.19 $332,769.86 $176,742.95 66% $518,752.82 Debt .5aidce 5711 Bond Principal 2,260,000.00 .00 2,260,000.00 .00 .00 2,244,000.00 16,000.00 99 1,442,000.00 5721 Bond Interest 12,000.00 .00 12,000.00 .00 .00 7,513.66 4,486.34 63 87,171.00 Debt.°a"s'^rh!ice ttuta'& $2,272,000.00 $0.00 $2,272,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $2,251,513.66 $20,486.34 99% $1,529,171.00 EXPENSE TOTALS $2,799,030.00 $0.00 $2,799,030.00 $41,536.28 $17,517.19 $2,584,283.52 $197,229.29 93% $2,047,923.82 D5 vvs'ion 6499 Wsr'Ikoui"' As imillinliic'Ikuatililloin toCals ($2,799,030.00) $0.00 ($2,799,030.00) ($41,536.28) ($17,517.19) ($2,584,283.52) ($197,229.29) 93% ($2,047,923.82) D5vvs'ion 9711 t"tllleuiatliiuing I'iiiainslteuii Out EXPENSE 7't«versA,,r,s 7teat 5811 5811.466 Transfer to Water Cap Const 354,000.00 .00 354,000.00 64,805.50 .00 64,805.50 289,194.50 18 1,364,931.77 5811.591 Transfer to Equipment Replace 60,000.00 .00 60,000.00 5,000.00 .00 35,000.00 25,000.00 58 60,000.00 5811.693 Transfer to Reserve for PERS .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 + + + 19,230.00 5811 - Totals $414,000.00 $0.00 $414,000.00 $69,805.50 $0.00 $99,805.50 $314,194.50 24% $1,444,161.77 7twi' F'A,vs ttrut'7ttaLF $414,000.00 $0.00 $414,000.00 $69,805.50 $0.00 $99,805.50 $314,194.50 24% $1,444,161.77 EXPENSE TOTALS $414,000.00 $0.00 $414,000.00 $69,805.50 $0.00 $99,805.50 $314,194.50 24% $1,444,161.77 I'.5ivr:lon 9711 011peuiiatiliuing I"'ui ainsfeii"'Out total„a ($414,000.00) $0.00 ($414,000.00) ($69,805.50) $0.00 ($99,805.50) ($314,194.50) 24% ($1,444,161.77) De^l,':rarhnne^i' 611. Wateui totals ($6,307,190.00) ($20,000.00) ($6,327,190.00) ($317,055.89) ($125,693.29) ($4,129,304.09) ($2,072,192.62) 67% ($6,149,321.70) Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM Page 41 of 57 79 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month YTD YTD Budget - YTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd PdorYear TotaV Fund 070 .. Wateuii Il�:r:uuund Del:rarhnne,n. 901... 15uindilling Il"":uuind IBallPerince I'.51v1saorr 997I. IE'!0uuiiity EXPENSE C ertfaa5feercfei�Facrel11illuercaF 5921 Contingency 181,060.00 .00 181,060.00 .00 .00 .00 181,060.00 0 .00 5981 5981.005 Reserve for Future Years 561,800.00 .00 561,800.00 .00 .00 .00 561,800.00 0 .00 5981 - Totals $561,800.00 $0.00 $561,800.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $561,800.00 0% $0.00 a,o tirrc/awcM;s'a'ntPt/r'«tr tr7vt^Plalxioos'ttuta'& $742,860.00 $0.00 $742,860.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $742,860.00 0% $0.00 EXPENSE TOTALS $742,860.00 $0.00 $742,860.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $742,860.00 0% $0.00 I'.Slvrslorr 9971 1Equuiuty totals ($742,860.00) $0.00 ($742,860.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($742,860.00) 0% $0.00 Del:rarhnne,n" 901 IEuindilling Il::uuind IBallPerince toCals ($742,860.00) $0.00 ($742,860.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($742,860.00) 0% $0.00 Fund 470 W uteuiIl::uuind totals $7,050,050.00 $20,000.00 $7,070,050.00 $317,055.89 $125,693.29 $4,129,304.09 $2,815,052.62 $6,149,321.70 Fund 472 .. Seweui° Il""uuind Del:rvrhnnerr 621 .. Seweui. C',fiv'ison I5P'L11 WWI "'lPf^tllueiiatlilloin EXPENSE Iaulsoluuuo:/ 5o14(,.eF 5111 Regular Wages 1,638,390.00 .00 1,638,390.00 100,232.09 .00 703,572.25 934,817.75 43 1,219,666.89 5112 Part -Time Wages 14,070.00 .00 14,070.00 1,749.99 .00 11,506.60 2,563.40 82 16,546.09 5121 Overtime 31,700.00 .00 31,700.00 720.83 .00 13,724.84 17,975.16 43 34,905.28 5211 OR Workers' Benefit 460.00 .00 460.00 20.37 .00 161.61 298.39 35 306.28 5212 Social Security 129,420.00 .00 129,420.00 7,692.68 .00 53,269.68 76,150.32 41 98,054.80 5213 Med & Dent Ins 395,090.00 .00 395,090.00 24,070.49 .00 130,955.22 264,134.78 33 246,740.00 5214 5214 Retirement .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 2,927.97 5214.100 PERS - City 305,170.00 .00 305,170.00 16,541.11 .00 119,425.73 185,744.27 39 195,955.49 5214.600 PERS 6% 98,340.00 .00 98,340.00 5,624.40 .00 38,831.08 59,508.92 39 75,009.72 5214.800 DEFERED COMP - CITY 25,920.00 .00 25,920.00 1,360.72 .00 14,253.74 11,666.26 55 23,339.20 5214 - Totals $429,430.00 $0.00 $429,430.00 $23,526.23 $0.00 $172,510.55 $256,919.45 40% $297,232.38 5215 Long Term Disability Ins 2,680.00 .00 2,680.00 208.92 .00 1,242.98 1,437.02 46 2,247.81 5216 Unemployment Insurance 21,870.00 .00 21,870.00 1,335.08 .00 9,474.42 12,395.58 43 11,030.01 5217 Life Insurance 1,760.00 .00 1,760.00 134.52 .00 799.74 960.26 45 1,445.80 5218 Paid Family Leave Insurance 6,740.00 .00 6,740.00 389.43 .00 2,741.60 3,998.40 41 3,072.45 fly^r,5'oiwal.°a"s' vicas' Pbta'Js' $2,671,610.00 $0.00 $2,671,610.00 $160,080.63 $0.00 $1,099,959.49 $1,571,650.51 41% $1,931,247.79 A7ateiv'ial��s & .5&.u,lc.aF 5315 Computer Supplies 1,000.00 .00 1,000.00 .00 .00 .00 1,000.00 0 2,672.37 5319 Office Supplies 2,000.00 .00 2,000.00 46.23 .00 1,076.72 923.28 54 4,773.58 5322 Lubricants 1,200.00 .00 1,200.00 .00 .00 .00 1,200.00 0 .00 5323 Fuel 30,500.00 .00 30,500.00 164.15 2,480.18 2,970.11 25,049.71 18 17,357.18 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM Page 42 of 57 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpfllon Budget Amendments Budget Tr'ansacdons Encumbrances Tr'ansacdons Tr'ansacdons Rec'd PdorYear ToitaV Fund 472... Se reui° I@'":must Dej,.,rarhnne np 621 .. Se reui. C',S'iv'is'ion I5P'd11 WWI'"IP 011peuiiatililloin EXPENSE A7a7e'lial's & .5&h,5e.etis. 5324 Clothing 4,000.00 .00 4,000.00 .00 .00 .00 4,000.00 0 261.01 5326 Safety/Medical 7,000.00 .00 7,000.00 114.59 560.48 2,638.78 3,800.74 46 10,897.36 5327 Chemicals 30,000.00 .00 30,000.00 .00 1,232.00 11,954.04 16,813.96 44 24,704.10 5328 Lab Supplies 24,000.00 .00 24,000.00 1,523.93 61.30 11,501.20 12,437.50 48 18,994.13 5329 Other Supplies 2,000.00 .00 2,000.00 .00 89.97 6,069.54 (4,159.51) 308 16,126.48 5335 Electrical Supplies 14,500.00 .00 14,500.00 .00 .00 5,620.94 8,879.06 39 .00 5336 HVAC 11,000.00 .00 11,000.00 1,885.29 3,379.90 5,643.89 1,976.21 82 16,002.91 5338 Tools 2,000.00 .00 2,000.00 .00 .00 9,314.92 (7,314.92) 466 6,215.45 5352 Protective Clothing 2,500.00 .00 2,500.00 .00 .00 3,693.37 (1,193.37) 148 1,337.39 5379 Water/Sewer Supplies .00 .00 .00 3,973.10 1,475.00 6,839.21 (8,314.21) +++ 2,975.55 5384 Trees 12,000.00 .00 12,000.00 .00 .00 .00 12,000.00 0 .00 5411 Engineering & Architect 5,000.00 .00 5,000.00 .00 .00 .00 5,000.00 0 .00 5419 5419 Other Professional Sery 25,000.00 .00 25,000.00 7,440.15 2,509.12 20,303.32 2,187.56 91 6,603.47 5419.501 Testing/Lab 26,000.00 .00 26,000.00 384.59 9,711.00 16,125.00 164.00 99 36,421.85 5419.707 Educ Outreach 2,500.00 .00 2,500.00 .00 .00 25.00 2,475.00 1 1,282.47 5419 - Totals $53,500.00 $0.00 $53,500.00 $7,824.74 $12,220.12 $36,453.32 $4,826.56 91% $44,307.79 5421 Telephone/Data 16,000.00 .00 16,000.00 1,816.71 349.03 9,934.02 5,716.95 64 16,040.10 5422 Postage 800.00 .00 800.00 .00 841.57 36.31 (77.88) 110 106.62 5429 Other Communication Sery 5,000.00 .00 5,000.00 .00 .00 434.06 4,565.94 9 299.00 5432 Meals 500.00 .00 500.00 .00 .00 79.67 420.33 16 584.28 5433 Mileage 500.00 .00 500.00 .00 .00 .00 500.00 0 .00 5439 Travel 1,500.00 .00 1,500.00 .00 .00 .00 1,500.00 0 1,232.74 5443 Office Equipment 3,000.00 .00 3,000.00 .00 .00 .00 3,000.00 0 .00 5446 Software Licenses 10,000.00 .00 10,000.00 44.93 .00 15,269.58 (5,269.58) 153 13,400.00 5449 Leases- Other 19,000.00 .00 19,000.00 .00 8,076.30 .00 10,923.70 43 .00 5451 Natural Gas 38,000.00 .00 38,000.00 4,939.32 .00 19,215.52 18,784.48 51 47,212.78 5453 Electricity 395,000.00 .00 395,000.00 34,989.10 .00 201,760.29 193,239.71 51 414,667.62 5454 Solid Waste Disposal 2,500.00 .00 2,500.00 .00 .00 .00 2,500.00 0 1,619.00 5471 Equipment Repair & Maint 125,000.00 .00 125,000.00 4,620.00 2,266.03 60,275.32 62,458.65 50 166,908.29 5472 Buildings Repairs & Maint 15,000.00 .00 15,000.00 160.65 .00 3,246.71 11,753.29 22 13,678.52 5475 Vehicle Repair & Maint 12,000.00 .00 12,000.00 .00 30.05 3,990.22 7,979.73 34 4,703.50 5476 Laundry 19,000.00 .00 19,000.00 749.14 2,982.16 3,017.84 13,000.00 32 10,350.50 5477 Instrumentation & Calibra 5,000.00 .00 5,000.00 .00 .00 1,650.00 3,350.00 33 2,305.00 5479 Other Repair & Maint 550,000.00 .00 550,000.00 9,418.67 7,331.15 200,225.99 342,442.86 38 492,097.63 5492 Registrations/Training 5,000.00 .00 5,000.00 .00 .00 1,529.80 3,470.20 31 2,918.65 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM Page 43 of 57 81 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLauint and IR(Akaulp to ACCOUnt I n c o r p u r a I c d t 8 8 9 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month YTD YTD Budget - YTD % Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Tr'ansacdons Encumbrances Tr'ansacdons Tr'ansacdons Rec'd PdorYear ToitaV Fund 472. °° Se relll"' l"::u IIInd Dej,.,karhnel'.'Y 621. °° Sewell D, v'ison ItP'L11 WWI"'lP1I112eiiatlilloin EXPENSE Alate'lisls & .t`&.h,lo.otis. 5493 Printing/Binding .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 630.00 5498 Permits/Fees 35,000.00 .00 35,000.00 30,966.50 .00 32,663.50 2,336.50 93 34,718.26 hate'^ ia& & °a"s' *,,'as' 7bta'ls' $1,460,000.00 $0.00 $1,460,000.00 $103,237.05 $43,375.24 $657,104.87 $759,519.89 48% $1,390,097.79 C tol tlrrtfay 5649 Other Equipment .00 .00 .00 .00 29,508.43 .00 (29,508.43) +++ .00 Ial tal tlrrtl y I'rstals $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $29,508.43 $0.00 ($29,508.43) +++ $0.00 EXPENSE TOTALS $4,131,610.00 $0.00 $4,131,610.00 $263,317.68 $72,883.67 $1,757,064.36 $2,301,661.97 44% $3,321,345.58 Dt vhson Is"'511 WWI"'lP 11112e111atlilloin toCals ($4,131,610.00) $0.00 ($4,131,610.00) ($263,317.68) ($72,883.67) ($1,757,064.36) ($2,301,661.97) 44% ($3,321,345.58) Dt vr:'ion II"Sslsl .. Se eul"' As imillinliistoatlilloin EXPENSE Alate'lisls & .°a`&h,to.otis. 5409 5409.140 Garage Services 20,610.00 .00 20,610.00 .00 .00 2,408.42 18,201.58 12 6,905.20 5409 - Totals $20,610.00 $0.00 $20,610.00 $0.00 $0.00 $2,408.42 $18,201.58 12% $6,905.20 5414 Accounting/Auditing 16,500.00 .00 16,500.00 7,600.00 5,600.00 15,680.00 (4,780.00) 129 20,161.12 5419 5419 Other Professional Sery 3,500.00 .00 3,500.00 .00 .00 .00 3,500.00 0 .00 5419.003 US Gauging Station Fees 15,000.00 .00 15,000.00 .00 .00 .00 15,000.00 0 .00 5419 - Totals $18,500.00 $0.00 $18,500.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $18,500.00 0% $0.00 5422 Postage 20,000.00 .00 20,000.00 932.67 9,312.12 8,405.88 2,282.00 89 16,199.77 5428 IT Support 91,320.00 .00 91,320.00 7,610.00 .00 53,270.00 38,050.00 58 82,320.00 5446 Software Licenses 2,000.00 .00 2,000.00 .00 .00 .00 2,000.00 0 .00 5448 Internal Rent 27,180.00 .00 27,180.00 2,265.00 .00 15,855.00 11,325.00 58 24,150.00 5449 Leases- Other 20,000.00 .00 20,000.00 .00 .00 .00 20,000.00 0 24,228.90 5450 General Right of Way Charge 454,420.00 .00 454,420.00 45,584.23 .00 318,237.99 136,182.01 70 515,765.74 5461 Auto Insurance 5,450.00 .00 5,450.00 454.17 .00 3,179.19 2,270.81 58 6,270.00 5463 Property/Earthquake Insurance 48,720.00 .00 48,720.00 4,060.00 .00 28,420.00 20,300.00 58 49,420.08 5464 Workers' Comp 27,290.00 .00 27,290.00 2,274.17 .00 15,919.19 11,370.81 58 28,929.96 5465 General Liability Insurance 19,870.00 .00 19,870.00 1,655.83 .00 11,590.81 8,279.19 58 21,450.00 5472 Buildings Repairs & Maint 400.00 .00 400.00 .00 .00 .00 400.00 0 .00 5481 Utility Assistance Program 3,000.00 .00 3,000.00 .00 .00 .00 3,000.00 0 .00 5493 Printing/Binding 20,000.00 .00 20,000.00 646.52 6,455.09 5,826.91 7,718.00 61 11,229.55 5500 Banking Fees & Charges 65,480.00 .00 65,480.00 6,719.94 .00 45,400.63 20,079.37 69 62,997.94 hate'^ ia& & .°a"ai' dr,'as' ttuta'ls $860,740.00 $0.00 $860,740.00 $79,802.53 $21,367.21 $524,194.02 $315,178.77 63% $870,028.26 Debt ..t`aihdrx Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM 82 Page 44 of 57 WQODBURN Inckide R(Aklp CCOLauint and IR(Akaulp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account DescrIlptiion Budget Amendments Budget Transacitfions Encumbrances Transacitfions Transacitfions Rec'd Pr'IorYear ToitaV Fund 472... Se reui° II'::ui d Dej,.,rarhnne nr 621 .. Se reui. 15ivr:'ion I5599 .. Se euii Adimillinliiis1h atliioin EXPENSE G'tetet .f`ee'hplo'e 5721 Bond Interest .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 1,095,402.14 I.?e,,bt $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 +++ $1,095,402.14 EXPENSE TOTALS $860,740.00 $0.00 $860,740.00 $79,802.53 $21,367.21 $524,194.02 $315,178.77 63% $1,965,430.40 15ivr:'ion I5599 Se eui"'Adimillinliie'Ikuatililloin toCals ($860,740.00) $0.00 ($860,740.00) ($79,802.53) ($21,367.21) ($524,194.02) ($315,178.77) 63% ($1,965,430.40) 15ivr:'ion 9711 ..'0112euiiatliiuing I'iiiainsIFeuii Out EXPENSE Tt versI eye, (feat 5811 5811.140 Transfer to Street 90,000.00 .00 90,000.00 7,500.00 .00 52,500.00 37,500.00 58 90,000.00 5811.465 Transfer to Sewer Cap Const 2,035,000.00 .00 2,035,000.00 2,817.25 .00 89,108.93 1,945,891.07 4 1,238,165.78 5811.591 Transfer to Equipment Replace 60,000.00 .00 60,000.00 5,000.00 .00 35,000.00 25,000.00 58 60,000.00 5811.693 Transfer to Reserve for PIERS .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 26,180.04 5811 - Totals $2,185,000.00 $0.00 $2,185,000.00 $15,317.25 $0.00 $176,608.93 $2,008,391.07 8% $1,414,345.82 7I«a'irs'9'ar'v:5'ttrras'7bta'LF $2,185,000.00 $0.00 $2,185,000.00 $15,317.25 $0.00 $176,608.93 $2,008,391.07 8% $1,414,345.82 EXPENSE TOTALS $2,185,000.00 $0.00 $2,185,000.00 $15,317.25 $0.00 $176,608.93 $2,008,391.07 8% $1,414,345.82 I'.5ivrslorr 9711 011peuiiatiliuing I"'ui auinsfeui"'Out total„a ($2,185,000.00) $0.00 ($2,185,000.00) ($15,317.25) $0.00 ($176,608.93) ($2,008,391.07) 8% ($1,414,345.82) De^I,':rarhnne^i' 621 Se reui totals ($7,177,350.00) $0.00 ($7,177,350.00) ($358,437.46) ($94,250.88) ($2,457,867.31) ($4,625,231.81) 36% ($6,701,121.80) Dej,.,rarhnnenr 6II...IMalllinteinaince I'.51v1saorr 6 521 Se reui° Ill..lihm IMerliiui°rt EXPENSE flees: ruarsro:/ 5o14(,.eF 5111 Regular Wages 121,140.00 .00 121,140.00 9,374.44 .00 67,363.24 53,776.76 56 120,037.64 5121 Overtime .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 1,269.39 (1,269.39) +++ 1,796.33 5211 OR Workers' Benefit 40.00 .00 40.00 1.96 .00 17.55 22.45 44 32.99 5212 Social Security 9,270.00 .00 9,270.00 700.80 .00 5,117.82 4,152.18 55 9,488.75 5213 1 & Dent Ins 31,650.00 .00 31,650.00 1,741.04 .00 11,385.72 20,264.28 36 19,591.20 5214 5214.100 PIERS - City 20,200.00 .00 20,200.00 1,562.72 .00 11,441.08 8,758.92 57 18,339.48 5214.600 PIERS 6% 7,270.00 .00 7,270.00 562.49 .00 4,118.03 3,151.97 57 7,650.37 5214 - Totals $27,470.00 $0.00 $27,470.00 $2,125.21 $0.00 $15,559.11 $11,910.89 57% $25,989.85 5215 Long Term Disability Ins 110.00 .00 110.00 19.83 .00 118.65 (8.65) 108 219.80 5216 Unemployment Insurance 1,580.00 .00 1,580.00 121.88 .00 892.36 687.64 56 1,067.76 5217 Life Insurance 70.00 .00 70.00 12.80 .00 76.69 (6.69) 110 142.27 5218 Paid Family Leave Insurance 480.00 .00 480.00 36.54 .00 266.81 213.19 56 304.19 fly^r,soiinal.°a"s'^ vicas' 7bta'Js' $191,810.00 $0.00 $191,810.00 $14,134.50 $0.00 $102,067.34 $89,742.66 53% $178,670.78 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM 83 Page 45 of 57 WQODBURN Inckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account DescrIlptiion Budget Amendments Budget Transacitfions Encumbrances Transacitfions Transacitfions Rec'd Pr'IorYear ToitaV Fund 472... Sesseui° II'::uirst Dej,.,rarhnnenp 611...IMallinteinaince I'.t1v1t,abn 6521. Seweui° Ill..lihm IMerliiui°rt EXPENSE A7a7e'lials & .5&h,le.etis. 5319 Office Supplies 400.00 .00 400.00 .00 .00 291.16 108.84 73 548.36 5321 Cleaning Supplies 300.00 .00 300.00 .00 .00 .00 300.00 0 2,248.98 5323 Fuel 12,000.00 .00 12,000.00 843.87 12,583.91 5,183.77 (5,767.68) 148 4,125.58 5324 Clothing 2,000.00 .00 2,000.00 381.48 .00 381.48 1,618.52 19 850.89 5326 Safety/Medical 2,000.00 .00 2,000.00 114.60 1,526.92 114.60 358.48 82 1,619.93 5329 Other Supplies 5,000.00 .00 5,000.00 .00 141.93 398.08 4,459.99 11 2,234.86 5338 Tools 2,050.00 .00 2,050.00 44.40 .00 3,506.07 (1,456.07) 171 2,523.83 5352 Protective Clothing 1,400.00 .00 1,400.00 44.99 .00 651.97 748.03 47 1,481.71 5379 Water/Sewer Supplies .00 .00 .00 .00 6,175.00 .00 (6,175.00) +++ 838.84 5409 5409.140 Garage Services 10,000.00 .00 10,000.00 .00 .00 1,061.76 8,938.24 11 .00 5409 - Totals $10,000.00 $0.00 $10,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $1,061.76 $8,938.24 11% $0.00 5419 Other Professional Sery 900.00 .00 900.00 64.40 .00 563.72 336.28 63 934.89 5421 Telephone/Data 1,800.00 .00 1,800.00 42.62 .00 297.73 1,502.27 17 561.12 5422 Postage .00 .00 .00 .00 841.55 355.95 (1,197.50) +++ 869.48 5445 Work Equipment 500.00 .00 500.00 .00 .00 .00 500.00 0 195.01 5446 Software Licenses 12,000.00 .00 12,000.00 .00 .00 2,835.00 9,165.00 24 155.00 5471 Equipment Repair & Maint 15,000.00 .00 15,000.00 .00 .00 .00 15,000.00 0 26,698.74 5475 Vehicle Repair & Maint 4,000.00 .00 4,000.00 2,277.46 142.19 2,474.69 1,383.12 65 6,270.99 5476 Laundry 3,000.00 .00 3,000.00 749.18 2,981.99 3,018.01 (3,000.00) 200 1,530.52 5479 Other Repair & Maint 50,000.00 500,000.00 550,000.00 293.36 .00 36,260.41 513,739.59 7 26,926.32 5492 Registrations/Training 1,500.00 .00 1,500.00 .00 .00 37.45 1,462.55 2 520.50 Plate^ ia& & 5si^ dr,'e's' 7bfa'ls $123,850.00 $500,000.00 $623,850.00 $4,856.36 $24,393.49 $57,431.85 $542,024.66 13% $81,135.55 EXPENSE TOTALS $315,660.00 $500,000.00 $815,660.00 $18,990.86 $24,393.49 $159,499.19 $631,767.32 23% $259,806.33 15ivr,alen 652.1 Se reui" III Hine I4erliuur toal„a ($315,660.00) ($500,000.00) ($815,660.00) ($18,990.86) ($24,393.49) ($159,499.19) ($631,767.32) 23% ($259,806.33) I'. 5ej,.,rarhnne^r' 631 IMallinteui"rs ince toal„a ($315,660.00) ($500,000.00) ($815,660.00) ($18,990.86) ($24,393.49) ($159,499.19) ($631,767.32) 23% ($259,806.33) Dee,.,<arhne,n. 641...SssurlFsrce:rteui,/Colllllllee1tliisuuiirs 15ivr:'ien 6611 .• SssurlFsrce :rteuii Colllllllectliisuuiir EXPENSE relsolsssa/ 5e14(,.e F 5111 Regular Wages 85,020.00 .00 85,020.00 6,562.92 .00 46,232.87 38,787.13 54 81,160.94 5121 Overtime .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 580.84 (580.84) +++ 1,005.31 5211 OR Workers' Benefit 30.00 .00 30.00 1.46 .00 12.90 17.10 43 24.16 5212 Social Security 6,510.00 .00 6,510.00 489.35 .00 3,478.33 3,031.67 53 6,367.73 5213 Med & Dent Ins 26,050.00 .00 26,050.00 1,394.86 .00 8,616.30 17,433.70 33 14,657.07 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM Page 46 of 57 84 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLauint and IR(Akaulp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd PdorYear TotaV Fund 472... Sesseui° Il'::uirst Del:r<srhne,n. 641...Sssurtsree:rteui,/Colllllllee1tliisuuiirs [)ivs'ion tltl'F'F .• SrrurlF�rce :rteuii Collllllleetliisuuiir EXPENSE /lees: euarsro:/ 5o14(,.eF 5214 5214.100 PERS - City 14,210.00 .00 14,210.00 1,096.03 .00 7,816.83 6,393.17 55 12,388.23 5214.600 PERS 6% 5,100.00 .00 5,100.00 394.48 .00 2,813.46 2,286.54 55 5,166.40 5214.800 DEFERED COMP - CITY 210.00 .00 210.00 12.00 .00 90.00 120.00 43 121.95 5214 - Totals $19,520.00 $0.00 $19,520.00 $1,502.51 $0.00 $10,720.29 $8,799.71 55% $17,676.58 5215 Long Term Disability Ins 50.00 .00 50.00 13.93 .00 82.71 (32.71) 165 152.47 5216 Unemployment Insurance 1,100.00 .00 1,100.00 85.31 .00 608.48 491.52 55 719.02 5217 Life Insurance 20.00 .00 20.00 8.99 .00 53.46 (33.46) 267 98.68 5218 Paid Family Leave Insurance 340.00 .00 340.00 25.37 .00 180.27 159.73 53 203.08 fly^r,soiinal.°a"s'^ vicas' 7bta'Js' $138,640.00 $0.00 $138,640.00 $10,084.70 $0.00 $70,566.45 $68,073.55 51% $122,065.04 A7atei's'feels & .5&.n,le.etis. 5323 Fuel 4,500.00 .00 4,500.00 .00 .00 490.26 4,009.74 11 891.14 5326 Safety/Medical 1,200.00 .00 1,200.00 .00 .00 84.00 1,116.00 7 290.00 5329 Other Supplies 2,500.00 .00 2,500.00 2,017.10 163.44 4,417.10 (2,080.54) 183 .00 5338 Tools 1,000.00 .00 1,000.00 19.09 .00 19.09 980.91 2 .00 5352 Protective Clothing 1,000.00 .00 1,000.00 .00 .00 .00 1,000.00 0 .00 5379 Water/Sewer Supplies .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 552.39 (552.39) +++ .00 5419 Other Professional Sery 1,200.00 .00 1,200.00 .00 .00 .00 1,200.00 0 267.38 5421 Telephone/Data 1,500.00 .00 1,500.00 42.62 .00 297.73 1,202.27 20 561.12 5428 IT Support 34,200.00 .00 34,200.00 2,850.00 .00 19,950.00 14,250.00 58 31,080.00 5454 Solid Waste Disposal 600.00 .00 600.00 .00 .00 .00 600.00 0 .00 5471 Equipment Repair & Maint 5,000.00 .00 5,000.00 .00 .00 529.60 4,470.40 11 306.00 5475 Vehicle Repair & Maint 5,000.00 .00 5,000.00 .00 .00 .00 5,000.00 0 3,954.43 5476 Laundry 500.00 .00 500.00 .00 .00 .00 500.00 0 .00 5492 Registrations/Training 1,500.00 .00 1,500.00 .00 .00 .00 1,500.00 0 .00 Plate ia& aft .°a"ei^,r,'e;'s' ftuta'ls $59,700.00 $0.00 $59,700.00 $4,928.81 $163.44 $26,340.17 $33,196.39 44% $37,350.07 EXPENSE TOTALS $198,340.00 $0.00 $198,340.00 $15,013.51 $163.44 $96,906.62 $101,269.94 49% $159,415.11 1',fiv'i ion 6611 Sruiitwee ateuii Colllllleetlilloin toCals ($198,340.00) $0.00 ($198,340.00) ($15,013.51) ($163.44) ($96,906.62) ($101,269.94) 49% ($159,415.11) Del:r<srCrnenr 641. Suiitwee Wateiii"'/Collllllee1tlilloins toCals ($198,340.00) $0.00 ($198,340.00) ($15,013.51) ($163.44) ($96,906.62) ($101,269.94) 49% ($159,415.11) Del:r<srhnne,n. 901... 15uindilling Il�::uinst IBallPerince I'.51v1saorr 9971. IE'quiliity EXPENSE Col tfs55fesseke F asset 11illesso.etis. 5921 Contingency 1,000,000.00 .00 1,000,000.00 .00 .00 .00 1,000,000.00 0 .00 5981 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM Page 47 of 57 85 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month YTD YTD Budget - YTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd PdorYear TotaV Fund 472... Seweui° Il'"'raur d Del:rarhnnein. 901... IFuindilling Il�:rbuird IBalllarince D' v1„bin 9971. II"'!gruiiity EXPENSE C ertalltl&?Cke F acrca fl ablic.eti,r. 5981 5981.005 Reserve for Future Years 16,193,130.00 .00 16,193,130.00 .00 .00 .00 16,193,130.00 0 .00 5981 - Totals $16,193,130.00 $0.00 $16,193,130.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $16,193,130.00 0% $0.00 a"o t#irle^arc'ar';s'a'ntPa/ro'«tretrtvt^Plalxio'o's'ttuta'& $17,193,130.00 $0.00 $17,193,130.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $17,193,130.00 0% $0.00 EXPENSE TOTALS $17,193,130.00 $0.00 $17,193,130.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $17,193,130.00 0% $0.00 I'.alvr:bin 9971 Itlgraiuty totals ($17,193,130.00) $0.00 ($17,193,130.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($17,193,130.00) 0% $0.00 Del:rarhnnein" 901 IEuindilling I@""uauird IBalllarince �oCals ($17,193,130.00) $0.00 ($17,193,130.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($17,193,130.00) 0% $0.00 Fund 472. Seweui Il::uii d "�"eat'als $24,884,480.00 $500,000.00 $25,384,480.00 $392,441.83 $118,807.81 $2,714,273.12 $22,551,399.07 $7,120,343.24 Fund 474 .• WarteuiSIR` C Il�::uind Del:rarhnnein. 611... Warteuii D" vr:'bin 9711... 011lleuiiartliiuiirg t'uiiauiirsteuii larrt EXPENSE 7'a«acrsaev,a heat 5811 5811.466 Transfer to Water Cap Const 125,000.00 550,000.00 675,000.00 650,000.00 .00 650,000.00 25,000.00 96 1,475,134.49 5811 - Totals $125,000.00 $550,000.00 $675,000.00 $650,000.00 $0.00 $650,000.00 $25,000.00 96% $1,475,134.49 7twi' F'A,vs alrrt'7ttaLF $125,000.00 $550,000.00 $675,000.00 $650,000.00 $0.00 $650,000.00 $25,000.00 96% $1,475,134.49 EXPENSE TOTALS $125,000.00 $550,000.00 $675,000.00 $650,000.00 $0.00 $650,000.00 $25,000.00 96% $1,475,134.49 I'.tivr:bin 9711 011pcui':utuiing"1"'ui ainsfeui.Out totals ($125,000.00) ($550,000.00) ($675,000.00) ($650,000.00) $0.00 ($650,000.00) ($25,000.00) 96% ($1,475,134.49) Itej,.,Karhnne^inr 611 Warteui �oCals ($125,000.00) ($550,000.00) ($675,000.00) ($650,000.00) $0.00 ($650,000.00) ($25,000.00) 96% ($1,475,134.49) Del:rarhnnein. 901... IFuindilling Il�:rbuird IBalllarince D' v1t,bin 9971. II"quiliity EXPENSE C ertalltl&?Cke s acrca tl rall 'el trrteca laea9aerc.eti,r. 5981 5981.005 Reserve for Future Years 3,892,400.00 .00 3,892,400.00 .00 .00 .00 3,892,400.00 0 .00 5981 - Totals $3,892,400.00 $0.00 $3,892,400.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $3,892,400.00 0% $0.00 Co tarrcic'^arc'MrFancPa/rrallrclr7vtr^cPlkalxicc's'7tuta'& $3,892,400.00 $0.00 $3,892,400.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $3,892,400.00 0% $0.00 EXPENSE TOTALS $3,892,400.00 $0.00 $3,892,400.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $3,892,400.00 0% $0.00 I'.tivr:bin 9971 Itlgraiuty totals ($3,892,400.00) $0.00 ($3,892,400.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($3,892,400.00) 0% $0.00 Del:rarhnnein° 901 IEuindilling I@""uauird IBarlllaince �oCals ($3,892,400.00) $0.00 ($3,892,400.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($3,892,400.00) 0% $0.00 Fund 474 War'teuii SIDC Il::ui d �oCals $4,017,400.00 $550,000.00 $4,567,400.00 $650,000.00 $0.00 $650,000.00 $3,917,400.00 $1,475,134.49 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM Page 48 of 57 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month YTD YTD Budget - YTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd PdorYear TotaV Fund 475 .. Se reui° SIII1, II' "'surd Dej,.,rarhnne np 621 .. Se reui. C',t'iv'is'ien r3P'd1.1... 1DeMgin 151uing1lineeuii'tliing EXPENSE A7ate'eteet��s & .5&vic.etis. 5419 Other Professional Sery 300,000.00 .00 300,000.00 40,096.00 159,904.00 67,269.00 72,827.00 76 .00 Plate^ ia& & .°a"si r,'e's' 7bta'ls' $300,000.00 $0.00 $300,000.00 $40,096.00 $159,904.00 $67,269.00 $72,827.00 76% $0.00 EXPENSE TOTALS $300,000.00 $0.00 $300,000.00 $40,096.00 $159,904.00 $67,269.00 $72,827.00 76% $0.00 15ivr:len 9511 IDe Faro li"uing1liineeui"'iiuiraL boa al„a ($300,000.00) $0.00 ($300,000.00) ($40,096.00) ($159,904.00) ($67,269.00) ($72,827.00) 76% $0.00 15ivr:'ien 9711 ..' 0111peuiiatiiiuing I'iiiainsfeuii Out EXPENSE Tt vast exec cleat 5811 5811.465 Transfer to Sewer Cap Const 100,000.00 .00 100,000.00 .00 .00 (1,437.00) 101,437.00 -1 2,035,035.01 5811 - Totals $100,000.00 $0.00 $100,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($1,437.00) $101,437.00 -1% $2,035,035.01 75«s'casFA,vis Oz(t'7rta'Js $100,000.00 $0.00 $100,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($1,437.00) $101,437.00 -1% $2,035,035.01 EXPENSE TOTALS $100,000.00 $0.00 $100,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($1,437.00) $101,437.00 -1% $2,035,035.01 I'.5ivr:len 9711 0111peuiiatiliuing I"'ui ainsfeii"'Out totals ($100,000.00) $0.00 ($100,000.00) $0.00 $0.00 $1,437.00 ($101,437.00) -1% ($2,035,035.01) De^1,':rarhnne^i' 621 Se reui totals ($400,000.00) $0.00 ($400,000.00) ($40,096.00) ($159,904.00) ($65,832.00) ($174,264.00) 56% ($2,035,035.01) Dee,.,<arhnne,n. 901... 15uindilling Il�:rbind IBallPsrince I'.51v1„abn 997I. 15'q unity EXPENSE Col tillg ercte�s acrc5 lassblicaF 5981 5981.005 Reserve for Future Years 1,508,280.00 .00 1,508,280.00 .00 .00 .00 1,508,280.00 0 .00 5981 - Totals $1,508,280.00 $0.00 $1,508,280.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $1,508,280.00 0% $0.00 a,o t#aclecacMeFacacPt/aso«7re7rtvtr^Plalxioes7tuta& $1,508,280.00 $0.00 $1,508,280.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $1,508,280.00 0% $0.00 EXPENSE TOTALS $1,508,280.00 $0.00 $1,508,280.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $1,508,280.00 0% $0.00 I'.51visbn 9971 15'q uiuty totals ($1,508,280.00) $0.00 ($1,508,280.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($1,508,280.00) 0% $0.00 Deq:r<srhnne,n901 1Euindilling II""usund IBallrsrince totals ($1,508,280.00) $0.00 ($1,508,280.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($1,508,280.00) 0% $0.00 Fund 475 Se reui SIP:I1,Il::uiid "�"oaals $1,908,280.00 $0.00 $1,908,280.00 $40,096.00 $159,904.00 $65,832.00 $1,682,544.00 $2,035,035.01 Fund P'568 In foiir�onatiiioin "I"'eellPruinolllogy Il::uind De^1:rvrti ne nr 152... 'II" C',t'iv'is'ien 1921Infoinnatlilloin"Iecilhiinulllogy EXPENSE Frelsolsssa/ 5e14r.exs. 5111 Regular Wages 467,650.00 .00 467,650.00 32,292.43 .00 223,212.06 244,437.94 48 373,955.47 5121 Overtime .00 .00 .00 43.22 .00 1,426.86 (1,426.86) +++ 1,780.34 5211 OR Workers' Benefit 110.00 .00 110.00 5.80 .00 48.62 61.38 44 89.47 5212 Social Security 36,260.00 .00 36,260.00 2,453.04 .00 16,999.58 19,260.42 47 29,862.22 5213 Med & Dent Ins 103,290.00 .00 103,290.00 7,005.78 .00 37,418.79 65,871.21 36 57,235.30 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM Page 49 of 57 87 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd PdorYear ToitaV Fund 568In�foiioi�natliioin.I.eollPruinolllogyI@�:r:rrund De^I:rvrti ne nr 152... 'IT C',fiv'is'ion 1921..�I[mrtourmnatlillouiir"IeeNhruiirculllcua3y EXPENSE Iaulsolrsro:/ 5o14(,.eF 5214 5214.100 PERS - City 5214.600 PERS 6% 5214.800 DEFERED COMP - CITY 5215 Long Term Disability Ins 5216 Unemployment Insurance 5217 Life Insurance 5218 Paid Family Leave Insurance Afatei'e'feel��s & .5&.u,le.as. 5315 Computer Supplies 5319 Office Supplies 5323 Fuel 5409 5409.140 Garage Services 5414 Accounting/Auditing 5415 Computer 5419 Other Professional Sery 5421 Telephone/Data 5422 Postage 5423 Internet 5433 Mileage 5446 Software Licenses 5448 Internal Rent 5449 Leases- Other 5461 Auto Insurance 5464 Workers' Comp 5465 General Liability Insurance 5471 Equipment Repair & Maint 5492 Registrations/Training f"af ltal Ozntf e), 5645 5645.101 Network 79,970.00 .00 79,970.00 5,522.12 .00 34,696.66 45,273.34 43 53,669.00 28,070.00 .00 28,070.00 1,974.16 .00 12,394.07 15,675.93 44 22,302.76 7,400.00 .00 7,400.00 567.62 .00 3,975.12 3,424.88 54 7,367.41 5214 - Totals $115,440.00 $0.00 $115,440.00 $8,063.90 $0.00 $51,065.85 $64,374.15 44% $83,339.17 580.00 .00 580.00 64.51 .00 354.25 225.75 61 741.02 6,080.00 .00 6,080.00 420.38 .00 2,920.31 3,159.69 48 3,282.69 370.00 .00 370.00 41.56 .00 228.19 141.81 62 477.57 1,880.00 .00 1,880.00 122.97 .00 853.37 1,026.63 45 906.70 fly^r,5'euiinal.°a"s'^ vicas' Pbta'& $731,660.00 $0.00 $731,660.00 $50,513.59 $0.00 $334,527.88 $397,132.12 46% $551,669.95 42,000.00 .00 42,000.00 1,271.60 1,205.79 16,559.83 24,234.38 42 39,564.61 1,000.00 .00 1,000.00 .00 .00 530.84 469.16 53 990.02 1,100.00 .00 1,100.00 35.58 11.65 411.74 676.61 38 1,121.26 1,000.00 .00 1,000.00 .00 .00 .00 1,000.00 0 545.44 5409 - Totals $1,000.00 $0.00 $1,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $1,000.00 0% $545.44 500.00 .00 500.00 237.50 175.00 490.00 (165.00) 133 626.29 77,000.00 .00 77,000.00 .00 .00 10,558.50 66,441.50 14 70,319.02 100,000.00 .00 100,000.00 3,428.35 102.20 84,147.64 15,750.16 84 112,668.18 9,000.00 .00 9,000.00 360.79 244.45 4,352.63 4,402.92 51 5,554.86 200.00 .00 200.00 .64 .00 10.14 189.86 5 47.19 16,000.00 .00 16,000.00 1,283.33 .00 7,704.77 8,295.23 48 15,031.82 500.00 .00 500.00 266.71 .00 810.42 (310.42) 162 228.97 460,800.00 .00 460,800.00 33,145.02 127.76 416,279.09 44,393.15 90 436,577.11 18,430.00 .00 18,430.00 1,535.83 .00 10,750.81 7,679.19 58 15,510.00 25,000.00 .00 25,000.00 2,450.66 12,034.29 17,373.63 (4,407.92) 118 28,807.30 510.00 .00 510.00 42.50 .00 297.50 212.50 58 590.04 3,890.00 .00 3,890.00 324.17 .00 2,269.19 1,620.81 58 3,800.04 10,650.00 .00 10,650.00 887.50 .00 6,212.50 4,437.50 58 9,819.96 7,000.00 .00 7,000.00 .00 .00 1,402.52 5,597.48 20 5,494.03 14,000.00 .00 14,000.00 .00 .00 5,895.08 8,104.92 42 5,000.00 Plate'^ria& aft .°a"ei r,'e;'s' 7bta'ls' $788,580.00 $0.00 $788,580.00 $45,270.18 $13,901.14 $586,056.83 $188,622.03 76% $752,296.14 150,000.00 .00 150,000.00 .00 .00 59,985.83 90,014.17 40 169,751.72 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM Page 50 of 57 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd PdorYear ToitaV Fund 568In�foiioi�natliioin.I.eollPruinolllogyF�r:rrund De^I:rarti ne nr 152... 'I1" C',a'iv'is'ien 1921 .•'I[urtu iiimn rtlillouir "1eeNhruirculllcuagy EXPENSE 5645 - Totals $150,000.00 $0.00 $150,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $59,985.83 $90,014.17 40% $169,751.72 G, [)Aal l zdkiy t't taLF $150,000.00 $0.00 $150,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $59,985.83 $90,014.17 40% $169,751.72 l"a«oer sA,, , heat 5811 5811.693 Transfer to Reserve for PERS .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 5,700.00 5811 - Totals $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 +++ $5,700.00 7iwiFA,vs slat t'tstaLF $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 +++ $5,700.00 EXPENSE TOTALS $1,670,240.00 $0.00 $1,670,240.00 $95,783.77 $13,901.14 $980,570.54 $675,768.32 60% $1,479,417.81 I'.tivi:ien 1921 IurlFunuui'mnatililloin lecilhiin ulllogy boa als ($1,670,240.00) $0.00 ($1,670,240.00) ($95,783.77) ($13,901.14) ($980,570.54) ($675,768.32) 60% ($1,479,417.81) De^I:rvrhnne^r' 152 I1 totals ($1,670,240.00) $0.00 ($1,670,240.00) ($95,783.77) ($13,901.14) ($980,570.54) ($675,768.32) 60% ($1,479,417.81) De^I:rarhnnen° 901 .. 15undiling Frburut IBaIllai ce I'.t1v1t,abn 997I. IEqu iliity EXPENSE Coertil5ll&roto: F aerea laee9,eero.oti,u. 5921 Contingency 216,550.00 .00 216,550.00 .00 .00 .00 216,550.00 0 .00 5981 5981.004 Reserve --Equipment 120,000.00 .00 120,000.00 .00 .00 .00 120,000.00 0 .00 5981 - Totals $120,000.00 $0.00 $120,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $120,000.00 0% $0.00 a "o t arrrlearc'Mu F aneP a/ ro'«t ret r7vte^ P l alxio'e' s' l tuta'LF $336,550.00 $0.00 $336,550.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $336,550.00 0% $0.00 EXPENSE TOTALS $336,550.00 $0.00 $336,550.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $336,550.00 0% $0.00 I'.alvr:len 9971 1Equ ilty totals ($336,550.00) $0.00 ($336,550.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($336,550.00) 0% $0.00 Deq:rarhnnen° 901 IEuindilling @""uourut IBaIllaince toCals ($336,550.00) $0.00 ($336,550.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($336,550.00) 0% $0.00 Fund 568 Infouoinatllloin"I"'eellhinolllaoagylF:uourut toCals $2,006,790.00 $0.00 $2,006,790.00 $95,783.77 $13,901.14 $980,570.54 $1,012,318.32 $1,479,417.81 Fund 581 Insuouiorunce IF:uound Dej,.,rarhnnenr 131 Cllty lRecou°uteu 15ivisbn 1581... IRliisulllk IBainaageuuoeurult EXPENSE Paunsolusuo:/ 5o14(,.ox,u. 5111 Regular Wages 57,450.00 .00 57,450.00 4,406.27 .00 30,846.38 26,603.62 54 52,942.68 5121 Overtime .00 .00 .00 .19 .00 39.58 (39.58) +++ 40.07 5211 OR Workers' Benefit 10.00 .00 10.00 .57 .00 5.12 4.88 51 10.06 5212 Social Security 4,610.00 .00 4,610.00 345.77 .00 2,421.55 2,188.45 53 4,272.93 5213 Med & Dent Ins 3,430.00 .00 3,430.00 290.30 .00 1,749.18 1,680.82 51 3,098.15 5214 5214.100 PERS - City 10,190.00 .00 10,190.00 765.73 .00 5,359.64 4,830.36 53 8,307.60 5214.600 PERS 6% 3,450.00 .00 3,450.00 274.47 .00 1,920.81 1,529.19 56 3,433.62 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM Page 51 of 57 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd PdorYear ToitaV Fund P'BPC1 Insuruiiauince I@�:r:rrund Dej,.,rarhnnenp 131 Cllty IRecou°uteu 15ivis: on 1581... IRliistllls II ainaua3euuoeint EXPENSE Flaunsolusuo:/ 5o14(,.ox,u. 5214 5214.800 DEFERED COMP - CITY 2,660.00 .00 2,660.00 168.68 .00 1,231.92 1,428.08 46 1,847.04 5214 - Totals $16,300.00 $0.00 $16,300.00 $1,208.88 $0.00 $8,512.37 $7,787.63 52% $13,588.26 5215 Long Term Disability Ins 90.00 .00 90.00 8.60 .00 52.27 37.73 58 96.57 5216 Unemployment Insurance 740.00 .00 740.00 57.30 .00 401.68 338.32 54 461.98 5217 Life Insurance 60.00 .00 60.00 5.55 .00 33.68 26.32 56 62.06 5218 Paid Family Leave Insurance 230.00 .00 230.00 16.74 .00 116.86 113.14 51 133.26 fly^r,5'oiwal.°a"s'^ vicas' Pbta'Js' $82,920.00 $0.00 $82,920.00 $6,340.17 $0.00 $44,178.67 $38,741.33 53% $74,706.02 Afatei'e'feel��s & .5&.u,le.etis. 5414 Accounting/Auditing 800.00 .00 800.00 237.50 175.00 490.00 135.00 83 626.29 5419 Other Professional Sery 100.00 .00 100.00 .00 .00 .00 100.00 0 428.00 5432 Meals 150.00 .00 150.00 .00 .00 72.28 77.72 48 .00 5433 Mileage 250.00 .00 250.00 .00 .00 193.88 56.12 78 .00 5439 Travel 350.00 .00 350.00 .00 .00 .00 350.00 0 .00 5461 Auto Insurance 93,500.00 .00 93,500.00 .00 .00 113,821.41 (20,321.41) 122 84,792.49 5463 Property/Earthquake Insurance 180,550.00 .00 180,550.00 .00 .00 197,338.90 (16,788.90) 109 156,374.97 5464 Workers' Comp 230,000.00 .00 230,000.00 .00 .00 221,610.62 8,389.38 96 159,737.89 5465 General Liability Insurance 325,000.00 .00 325,000.00 .00 .00 307,503.63 17,496.37 95 277,489.11 5468 Deductible 10,000.00 .00 10,000.00 .00 .00 .00 10,000.00 0 5,000.00 5469 Other Insurance Costs 35,000.00 50,000.00 85,000.00 1,555.75 .00 21,402.75 63,597.25 25 26,048.06 5491 Dues & Subscriptions 200.00 .00 200.00 .00 .00 565.00 (365.00) 282 170.00 5492 Registrations/Training 1,900.00 .00 1,900.00 .00 .00 175.00 1,725.00 9 816.20 Plate^ ia& aft .°a"ei r,'e;'s' 7bta'ls' $877,800.00 $50,000.00 $927,800.00 $1,793.25 $175.00 $863,173.47 $64,451.53 93% $711,483.01 EXPENSE TOTALS $960,720.00 $50,000.00 $1,010,720.00 $8,133.42 $175.00 $907,352.14 $103,192.86 90% $786,189.03 Itivr',alon 1581 IR,liistllls IMainageuuoeuulk toal„a ($960,720.00) ($50,000.00) ($1,010,720.00) ($8,133.42) ($175.00) ($907,352.14) ($103,192.86) 90% ($786,189.03) 15ivrs'on 9711... flllpeuiatiiiing I'iiiains'Item Out EXPENSE t"t«oersA,,r,s (feat 5811 5811.693 Transfer to Reserve for PERS .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 830.04 5811 - Totals $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 +++ $830.04 Tlwia FA,v s t z(t t'tstals $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 +++ $830.04 EXPENSE TOTALS $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 +++ $830.04 I'.5ivis: on 9711 .. a"IIIReu tiliurua3 I'u ainsfeii Out boa al„a $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 +++ ($830.04) De^I,':rarhnne^i' 131 Cllty lRecou"deu toal„a ($960,720.00) ($50,000.00) ($1,010,720.00) ($8,133.42) ($175.00) ($907,352.14) ($103,192.86) 90% ($787,019.07) Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM Page 52 of 57 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month YTD YTD Budget - YTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Pec'd PdorYear TotaV Fund 581 Insuriiaiince F�r:rrund Del:r<urhnne,n. 901... IFundilling Frburut IBallPeince D' v1„abn 9971. IEquuiiitM EXPENSE Colltilttl&?Cke F aluet llelauuo.eti,u. 5921 Contingency 549,730.00 .00 549,730.00 .00 .00 .00 549,730.00 0 .00 a"o t#ur/e^uucM;s'auutPt/uo'llrelrtvt^Plillallo'o's'ttuta'& $549,730.00 $0.00 $549,730.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $549,730.00 0% $0.00 EXPENSE TOTALS $549,730.00 $0.00 $549,730.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $549,730.00 0% $0.00 I'.tivr:len 9971 IEquuiutM totals ($549,730.00) $0.00 ($549,730.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($549,730.00) 0% $0.00 Dei:r<urhnne,n" rllr't IEundilling @""uuurut IBaIllairce toCals ($549,730.00) $0.00 ($549,730.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($549,730.00) 0% $0.00 Fund 581 'Insuuti:uuuee lF:uund totals $1,510,450.00 $50,000.00 $1,560,450.00 $8,133.42 $175.00 $907,352.14 $652,922.86 $787,019.07 Fund Wlrlt... IEquuliillpuueeint IB,ellplllaceuueeint IF:uuruut Del:rarh ne,n. 61 1... ateu. Dtvr:'ien 9211..• IEquuiiillpimeint li'ruuucilh rses EXPENSE 5649 Other Equipment 519,600.00 .00 519,600.00 .00 .00 .00 519,600.00 0 30,584.89 G' [) tal Oz(tl y t'tstaLF $519,600.00 $0.00 $519,600.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $519,600.00 0% $30,584.89 EXPENSE TOTALS $519,600.00 $0.00 $519,600.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $519,600.00 0% $30,584.89 Dtvr:'ien 921'1 1Equuliillpimeu"r'tIPuti"cilhasea toCals ($519,600.00) $0.00 ($519,600.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($519,600.00) 0% ($30,584.89) Itej,.,Karhnne^n° 611 .. ateu toCals ($519,600.00) $0.00 ($519,600.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($519,600.00) 0% ($30,584.89) Dej,.,rarhnnenr 671...8eu eu. Dt vr:'ie n 9211... Itlapuuliillpimeuir't lPuuureNhrurses EXPENSE 5649 Other Equipment 395,810.00 .00 395,810.00 .00 .00 .00 395,810.00 0 103,474.50 G' [) tal Oz(tl y t'tstaLF $395,810.00 $0.00 $395,810.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $395,810.00 0% $103,474.50 EXPENSE TOTALS $395,810.00 $0.00 $395,810.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $395,810.00 0% $103,474.50 Dtvr:'ien 9211 IEquuliillpimeintIPuti"cilhasea toCals ($395,810.00) $0.00 ($395,810.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($395,810.00) 0% ($103,474.50) Ite^I,':rarhnne^i' 621 8eaureu totals ($395,810.00) $0.00 ($395,810.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($395,810.00) 0% ($103,474.50) Itel:rarhnnerr 611...IMalliuteinaince Dt vr:'ie n 9211... Itlapuuliillpimeuir't lPuuureNhrurses EXPENSE 5649 Other Equipment 329,110.00 .00 329,110.00 .00 .00 .00 329,110.00 0 28,778.24 G' [) tal Oz(tl y t'tstaLF $329,110.00 $0.00 $329,110.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $329,110.00 0% $28,778.24 EXPENSE TOTALS $329,110.00 $0.00 $329,110.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $329,110.00 0% $28,778.24 Dtvr:'ien 921'1 IEquuliillpimeu"r'tIPuti"cilhasea toCals ($329,110.00) $0.00 ($329,110.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($329,110.00) 0% ($28,778.24) I'. tej,.,rarhnne^r' 631 IMalliuteinaince totals ($329,110.00) $0.00 ($329,110.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($329,110.00) 0% ($28,778.24) Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM 91 Page 53 of 57 Expense Budget Performance Report [��isca�l Year, to Date 0 � /3 � /24 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp ACCOLInt and R(AklIp to ACCOUnt n c o r p u r a I c d t 8 8 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month YTD YTD Budget - YTD 11/o Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd Pdor Year TotaV Fund 591 Equillpimeint IR,ellplllaceuieeint F:uind Dej,.,rarhnnen671 liiainsft Dvrsbn 9211 Equillpimeint IPuiicNhases EXPENSE C Ozntfay 5649 Other Equipment 3,730.00 .00 3,730.00 .00 .00 .00 3,730.00 0 .00 G[)Aal Oz(tlay 7btaLF $3,730.00 $0.00 $3,730.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $3,730.00 0% $0.00 EXPENSE TOTALS $3,730.00 $0.00 $3,730.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $3,730.00 0% $0.00 D�vrsbn 921 A Equillpimeint Puii cilhases t oCals ($3,730.00) $0.00 ($3,730.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($3,730.00) 0% $0.00 Dej,.,rarhnnen671 liiainsft toCals ($3,730.00) $0.00 ($3,730.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($3,730.00) 0% $0.00 Dej,.,rarhnnen691 li:PrjllCw11111!cWoiiilllcsAdiiinillmrilistiiiatilloiiir Dvrsbn 9211 Equillpimeint IPuiicNhases EXPENSE C Ozntby 5649 Other Equipment 26,390.00 .00 26,390.00 .00 .00 .00 26,390.00 0 6,666.08 Ozdlay 7btaLF $26,390.00 $0.00 $26,390.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $26,390.00 0% $6,666.08 EXPENSE TOTALS $26,390.00 $0.00 $26,390.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $26,390.00 0% $6,666.08 D�vrsbn 921 A Equillpimeint Puii cilhases t oCals ($26,390.00) $0.00 ($26,390.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($26,390.00) 0% ($6,666.08) Dej,.,rarhnnen691 li:Prjlll'�w11111!cWoiiilllcsAdiiinillmrilistiiiatilloiiir toCals ($26,390.00) $0.00 ($26,390.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($26,390.00) 0% ($6,666.08) Fund 591 Equillpimeint IReIlpIIlaceuieeint F:uind totals $1,274,640.00 $0.00 $1,274,640.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $1,274,640.00 $169,503.71 Fund 693 Resvive foii PIERS Dej,.,rarhnnen901 Eindiling Fbind Ballaince D' v1sbn 9971 Equilty EXPENSE Colntillg&?CkF aluf flablicaF 5921 Contingency 391,120.00 .00 391,120.00 .00 .00 .00 391,120.00 0 .00 Comt#irlewcM,F ancf llalxicaF 7 btaLF $391,120.00 $0.00 $391,120.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $391,120.00 0% $0.00 EXPENSE TOTALS $391,120.00 $0.00 $391,120.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $391,120.00 0% $0.00 Dlvrsbn 9971 Itquiluty totals ($391,120.00) $0.00 ($391,120.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($391,120.00) 0% $0.00 Dej,.,rarhnnen901 IEuindilling Fbind Ballaince toCals ($391,120.00) $0.00 ($391,120.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($391,120.00) 0% $0.00 Fund 693 IReseiiivefuiii PIERS totals $391,120.00 $0.00 $391,120.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $391,120.00 $0.00 Fund 695 lavelk Bllaclk liiustli:uind Dej,.,rarhnnen211 PoIllice Dlvlsbn 2111 P'abioll EXPENSE platevials& 5&vicaF 5329 Other Supplies 2,500.00 .00 2,500.00 700.99 .00 700.99 1,799.01 28 .00 5419 Other Professional Sery 2,500.00 .00 2,500.00 .00 .00 .00 2,500.00 0 .00 5492 Reg istrations/Training 2,500.00 .00 2,500.00 .00 .00 .00 2,500.00 0 .00 Platevia&& 5ih,kaF 7bfals $7,500.00 $0.00 $7,500.00 $700.99 $0.00 $700.99 $6,799.01 9% $0.00 EXPENSE TOTALS $7,500.00 $0.00 $7,500.00 $700.99 $0.00 $700.99 $6,799.01 9% $0.00 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM 92 Page 54 of 57 WQODBURN Inckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account DescrIlptiion Budget Amendments Budget Transacitfions Encumbrances Transacitfions Transacitfions Rec'd Pr'IorYear TotaV Fund 695 I111 avellHe IBIIPsrellls "I"1uuuwt II""uuund Dej,.,rarhnne nr 211 IV'rolllliiee I'.Slvisiorr 2111 Ireutuiolll totals ($7,500.00) $0.00 ($7,500.00) ($700.99) $0.00 ($700.99) ($6,799.01) 9% $0.00 De^I,':rarhnne^i' 211 IPolllliiee totals ($7,500.00) $0.00 ($7,500.00) ($700.99) $0.00 ($700.99) ($6,799.01) 9% $0.00 De^I:rarhnnen° 901 .. 15uindilling 11"":uuuirst lBallPsrince I'.51v1saorr 997I. IE'!0uuiiity EXPENSE Coertfaalfeerefei�F aerel tleraffrofefateel11illaero.otis. 5921 Contingency 25,690.00 .00 25,690.00 .00 .00 .00 25,690.00 0 .00 a "o t#irle^arcM;s' «v'ntP t/ rv'«t ret rtvte^ P l alxio'e' s' l tuta'& $25,690.00 $0.00 $25,690.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $25,690.00 0% $0.00 EXPENSE TOTALS $25,690.00 $0.00 $25,690.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $25,690.00 0% $0.00 I'.Slvrslorr 9921 1Equuiuty totals ($25,690.00) $0.00 ($25,690.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($25,690.00) 0% $0.00 Deq:rarhnne,n° 901 IEuindilling II::uuind IBallPsrince toCals ($25,690.00) $0.00 ($25,690.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($25,690.00) 0% $0.00 Fund 695 IIIavellHe I Iuiiuuvt I@""uuind toCals $33,190.00 $0.00 $33,190.00 $700.99 $0.00 $700.99 $32,489.01 $0.00 Fund 72.0 .• UurllCuain I II::uuund Dej,.,rarhnnenr 125.. 15eoui°uouialiie IPIeveJllollpuiuueui°ut I'.51v1saorr 72.00 . UIR,A EXPENSE Iaulsoluuuo:/ 5o14(,.eF 5111 Regular Wages 192,520.00 .00 192,520.00 14,951.68 .00 103,532.57 88,987.43 54 186,072.04 5121 Overtime .00 .00 .00 .19 .00 69.87 (69.87) +++ 159.32 5211 OR Workers' Benefit 30.00 .00 30.00 1.86 .00 15.31 14.69 51 31.61 5212 Social Security 15,330.00 .00 15,330.00 1,156.61 .00 7,932.55 7,397.45 52 14,925.32 5213 1 & Dent Ins 24,930.00 .00 24,930.00 2,141.90 .00 12,943.98 11,986.02 52 26,287.29 5214 5214 Retirement .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 2,927.97 5214.100 PIERS - City 34,470.00 .00 34,470.00 2,643.12 .00 18,352.09 16,117.91 53 26,096.47 5214.600 PIERS 6% 11,560.00 .00 11,560.00 940.14 .00 6,521.67 5,038.33 56 10,599.59 5214.800 DEFERED COMP - CITY 9,520.00 .00 9,520.00 717.65 .00 5,094.36 4,425.64 54 7,925.38 5214 - Totals $55,550.00 $0.00 $55,550.00 $4,300.91 $0.00 $29,968.12 $25,581.88 54% $47,549.41 5215 Long Term Disability Ins 340.00 .00 340.00 29.11 .00 176.92 163.08 52 347.48 5216 Unemployment Insurance 2,510.00 .00 2,510.00 194.42 .00 1,347.16 1,162.84 54 1,626.09 5217 Life Insurance 220.00 .00 220.00 18.60 .00 112.79 107.21 51 223.37 5218 Paid Family Leave Insurance 770.00 .00 770.00 53.10 .00 370.58 399.42 48 437.71 fly^r,5'oiwal.°a"s'^ vicas' Pbta'Js' $292,200.00 $0.00 $292,200.00 $22,848.38 $0.00 $156,469.85 $135,730.15 54% $277,659.64 Alatevial��s & .5&.u,le.otis. 5414 Accounting/Auditing 3,000.00 .00 3,000.00 1,425.00 1,050.00 2,940.00 (990.00) 133 3,757.71 5419 Other Professional Sery 125,000.00 .00 125,000.00 930.00 10,195.00 54,698.23 60,106.77 52 38,076.87 5428 IT Support 9,450.00 .00 9,450.00 787.50 .00 5,512.50 3,937.50 58 8,820.00 5448 Internal Rent 1,100.00 .00 1,100.00 91.67 .00 641.69 458.31 58 920.00 5520 Grant Program 400,000.00 .00 400,000.00 .00 1,000.00 209,843.00 189,157.00 53 174,302.75 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM Page 55 of 57 93 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd PdorYear TotaV Fund 72.0 .. UoiiIlCusrin IReinewalll IF:uuund Dej,.,rarhnnenp 125.. 1Ecoinuiuoliie IDevelllollpimeint I'.51v1saorr 7200 . UIRA EXPENSE A7atevtal's & .5&u,te.etis. 5530 Design Services 15,000.00 .00 15,000.00 .00 .00 5,726.20 9,273.80 38 22,283.04 77atevia& & .°a"si^ ,k'e's' 7bta'ls' $553,550.00 $0.00 $553,550.00 $3,234.17 $12,245.00 $279,361.62 $261,943.38 53% $248,160.37 5630 Public Art 260,000.00 .00 260,000.00 .00 .00 619.05 259,380.95 0 11,009.75 5631 Streets/Alleys/Sidewalks 240,000.00 .00 240,000.00 .00 .00 .00 240,000.00 0 800.43 5639 Other Improvements 236,000.00 .00 236,000.00 9,683.40 49,980.00 111,585.85 74,434.15 68 327,430.42 G, [)Aal ttrutlet, t't tahF $736,000.00 $0.00 $736,000.00 $9,683.40 $49,980.00 $112,204.90 $573,815.10 22% $339,240.60 G'tebt .5eiv'u,ke 5711 Bond Principal 285,000.00 .00 285,000.00 .00 .00 .00 285,000.00 0 277,000.00 5721 Bond Interest 50,750.00 .00 50,750.00 .00 .00 25,373.20 25,376.80 50 58,419.29 !?ebt.°a"s'^rh!ke ttuta'Js' $335,750.00 $0.00 $335,750.00 $0.00 $0.00 $25,373.20 $310,376.80 8% $335,419.29 EXPENSE TOTALS $1,917,500.00 $0.00 $1,917,500.00 $35,765.95 $62,225.00 $573,409.57 $1,281,865.43 33% $1,200,479.90 15ivrslorr 7200 UIRA totals ($1,917,500.00) $0.00 ($1,917,500.00) ($35,765.95) ($62,225.00) ($573,409.57) ($1,281,865.43) 33% ($1,200,479.90) 15ivr:'ion 9711...0111peuiiatiiiuing I'iiiainwlteuii Out EXPENSE t"taerstevas tteat 5811 5811.693 Transfer to Reserve for PERS .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 2,859.96 5811 - Totals $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 +++ $2,859.96 1'tauuFAvas ttrrt t'tstaLF $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 +++ $2,859.96 EXPENSE TOTALS $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 +++ $2,859.96 I'.5ivis:orr 9711 ° 0111Reui :utiling "I"'ui ainsfeii° Out total„a $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 +++ ($2,859.96) De^l,':rarhnne^i' 125 1Ecoinouiuoliie IPDevelllollpimeint total„a ($1,917,500.00) $0.00 ($1,917,500.00) ($35,765.95) ($62,225.00) ($573,409.57) ($1,281,865.43) 33% ($1,203,339.86) Dee,.,<arhnne,n. 901... 15uindilling IF:uuind IBaIllaince I'.51v1saorr 997I. IE'!0uuiiitM EXPENSE toertillgeereteiFaere511illuaso.aF 5921 Contingency 60,000.00 .00 60,000.00 .00 .00 .00 60,000.00 0 .00 5981 5981.008 Reserve for URA Debt 333,730.00 .00 333,730.00 .00 .00 .00 333,730.00 0 .00 5981 - Totals $333,730.00 $0.00 $333,730.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $333,730.00 0% $0.00 Co tirse5e'^ssc'tr';s' asseP t/rsa«t ret r7vtr^ P l illalio'e' s' l tuta& $393,730.00 $0.00 $393,730.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $393,730.00 0% $0.00 EXPENSE TOTALS $393,730.00 $0.00 $393,730.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $393,730.00 0% $0.00 I'.Slvrslorr 9971 1EquuiutM totals ($393,730.00) $0.00 ($393,730.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($393,730.00) 0% $0.00 Deq:r<srhnne,n" 901 IEuindilling IF:uuind IBallPsince toCals ($393,730.00) $0.00 ($393,730.00) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($393,730.00) 0% $0.00 Fund 72.0 Uoilll ain IReinewalll IF:uuind totals $2,311,230.00 $0.00 $2,311,230.00 $35,765.95 $62,225.00 $573,409.57 $1,675,595.43 $1,203,339.86 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM Page 56 of 57 0> R F G> 0 'N Expense Budget Performance Repor 'I [isca�l Year, to Date 0 � /3 � /' nckide R(Aklp AcCOLInt and R(Akl�p to AcCOLJJ�� Grand �otals $130,286,350.00 $2,680,000.00 $132,966,350.00 $3,564,102.51 $1,108,474.07 $24,908,426.87 $106,949,449.06 $63,951,792.33 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:48:40 AM 95 Page 57 of 57 Year -to -Date Revenue for All Funds R ;B G 0 N Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdlpflon Budget Amendments Budget Tr'ansacdons Encumbrances Tr'ansacdons Tr'ansacdons Rec'd PdorYear ToitaV Fund 001..• Geul"rellla llll Il"::ui rd De^l:rarh ne^In' 000 IReveul°rsae REVENUE FSwmf 11alearce 3081 Beginning Fund Balance 10,470,720.00 .00 10,470,720.00 .00 .00 .00 10,470,720.00 0 .00 Fa.r mf 11«aleare"e 7bfa& $10,470,720.00 $0.00 $10,470,720.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $10,470,720.00 0% $0.00 flAa F 3111 Property Tax - Current 11,700,000.00 .00 11,700,000.00 241,830.72 .00 10,720,293.37 979,706.63 92 11,001,216.33 3112 Property Tax - Delinquent 240,000.00 .00 240,000.00 8,497.55 .00 153,369.43 86,630.57 64 194,809.32 3133 Hotel/Motel Tax 500,000.00 .00 500,000.00 34,351.31 .00 263,938.94 236,061.06 53 499,423.26 fI'Aa F 7'rtals $12,440,000.00 $0.00 $12,440,000.00 $284,679.58 $0.00 $11,137,601.74 $1,302,398.26 90% $11,695,448.91 Lfe&r.'a F «aare'I flea'areft:' 3211 Business License 45,000.00 .00 45,000.00 3,850.00 .00 22,462.50 22,537.50 50 48,995.00 3213 RoW Utility License 1,500.00 .00 1,500.00 300.00 .00 1,200.00 300.00 80 600.00 3219 Other License 3,000.00 .00 3,000.00 .00 .00 445.00 2,555.00 15 2,875.00 3220 Taxicab Permits 3,100.00 .00 3,100.00 55.00 .00 1,350.00 1,750.00 44 2,205.00 L.fe'ears'ar'F ancffla^a'arafts ftuta'ls $52,600.00 $0.00 $52,600.00 $4,205.00 $0.00 $25,457.50 $27,142.50 48% $54,675.00 .Lams:sn^f�uuAs:a�rsrss:artal 3333 Federal Grants Indirect .00 450,000.00 450,000.00 .00 .00 .00 450,000.00 0 180,873.00 3341 State Grants 200,000.00 260,000.00 460,000.00 91,345.00 .00 183,482.09 276,517.91 40 12,049.00 3351 Grants 208,000.00 .00 208,000.00 .00 .00 20,326.00 187,674.00 10 800,000.00 3362 State Liquor Proration 460,000.00 .00 460,000.00 40,767.33 .00 241,329.36 218,670.64 52 528,825.10 3363 State Cigarette Tax 22,000.00 .00 22,000.00 1,356.00 .00 9,461.48 12,538.52 43 19,369.54 3364 State Revenue Sharing 400,000.00 .00 400,000.00 .00 .00 99,853.51 300,146.49 25 390,552.10 3367 State Marijuana Tax Distribution - HB 3400 Local 25,000.00 .00 25,000.00 9,931.22 .00 19,770.73 5,229.27 79 35,703.50 Option Tax tart'^a,ef n ^a'arara;'^art'Jfauta'Js' $1,315,000.00 $710,000.00 $2,025,000.00 $143,399.55 $0.00 $574,223.17 $1,450,776.83 28% $1,967,372.24 I"la«aa,rfaias faun, 66or,& aara'1.5"&,u,fa.as, 3415 Sale of Documents 200.00 .00 200.00 .00 .00 10,882.25 (10,682.25) 5441 546.65 I lra mla^ss' fbi n''oor,ts' aimf 5ai'npsr'ar s 7btvls' $200.00 $0.00 $200.00 $0.00 $0.00 $10,882.25 ($10,682.25) 5441% $546.65 F?aaarlalse Fi'a F 3226 3226 RoW Franchise Revenue 210,000.00 .00 210,000.00 .00 .00 .00 210,000.00 0 .00 3226.001 RoW Franchise Revenue - Bullseye Telecom .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 409.80 3226.002 RoW Franchise Revenue - Consumer Cellular .00 .00 .00 2,733.66 .00 5,320.37 (5,320.37) +++ 10,584.10 3226.003 RoW Franchise Revenue - Dish Wireless .00 .00 .00 20.34 .00 45.39 (45.39) +++ 231.61 3226.004 RoW Franchise Revenue - Dishnet Wireline .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 100.00 3226.005 RoW Franchise Revenue - Granite Telecommunications .00 .00 .00 1,856.23 .00 3,832.43 (3,832.43) +++ 7,719.93 3226.006 RoW Franchise Revenue - LS Networks .00 .00 .00 442.11 .00 884.22 (884.22) +++ 5,751.35 3226.007 RoW Franchise Revenue - Mitel Cloud Services .00 .00 .00 11.97 .00 23.94 (23.94) +++ 53.18 3226.008 RoW Franchise Revenue - Working Assets Funding .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 6.87 Services Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:56:07 AM Page 1 of 23 97 Revenue Budget Performance Report [isca�l Year, to Date 0 � /3 � /24 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp ACCOLInt and R(AklIp to ACCOUnt n c o r p u r a I c d t 8 8 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month YTD YTD Budget - YTD 11/o Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd Pdor Year TotaV Fund 001 Geiiimiiialll l::uind Dej,.,arhnnen 000 IReveiii"je REVENUE F?aiicliise FF'aF 3226 3226.009 RoW Franchise Revenue - Electric Lightwave .00 .00 .00 2,646.78 .00 4,806.67 (4,806.67) . . . 7,891.48 3226.010 RoW Franchise Revenue - vCom QuantumShift .00 .00 .00 276.69 .00 778.00 (778.00) . . . 2,006.58 3226.011 RoW Franchise Revenue - Gabb Wireless .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 13.13 (13.13) . . . 36.67 3226.012 RoW Franchise Revenue - Qwest .00 .00 .00 4,032.93 .00 8,624.86 (8,624.86) . . . 24,153.37 3226.013 RoW Franchise Revenue - Centuryl-ink .00 .00 .00 2,399.82 .00 5,274.54 (5,274.54) ... 13,936.70 3226.014 RoW Franchise Revenue - Level3 .00 .00 .00 2,883.78 .00 5,834.67 (5,834.67) ... 11,679.73 3226.015 RoW Franchise Revenue - Windstream .00 .00 .00 .39 .00 66.94 (66.94) . . . .39 3226.016 RoW Franchise Revenue - McLeod USA .00 .00 .00 70.88 .00 71.27 (71.27) ... 234.97 3226.017 RoW Franchise Revenue - RingCentral .00 .00 .00 125.50 .00 347.91 (347.91) ... 672.02 3226.021 RoW Franchise Revenue - GreatCall .00 .00 .00 241.33 .00 526.03 (526.03) ... 1,088.84 3226.022 RoW Franchise Revenue - Clear Rate Communications .00 .00 .00 88.48 .00 177.13 (177.13) ... 354.55 3226.023 RoW Franchise Revenue - Calpine Energy .00 .00 .00 30,848.77 .00 66,094.34 (66,094.34) ... 128,209.95 3226.025 RoW Franchise Revenue - Constellation New Energy .00 .00 .00 6,478.54 .00 12,763.89 (12,763.89) ... 30,973.57 3226.026 RoW Franchise Revenue - DataVision Telecom .00 .00 .00 1,726.17 .00 3,467.54 (3,467.54) ... 7,444.99 3226.028 RoW Franchise Revenue - Spectrotel, Inc. .00 .00 .00 45.18 .00 89.33 (89.33) . . . 210.68 3226.029 RoW Franchise Revenue - MetTel .00 .00 .00 254.72 .00 470.45 (470.45) ... 765.94 3226.030 RoW Franchise Revenue - Nextiva Inc .00 .00 .00 109.33 .00 197.39 (197.39) ... 425.06 3226.031 RoW Franchise Revenue - iWireless .00 .00 .00 28.05 .00 52.70 (52.70) ... 130.25 3226.032 RoW Franchise Revenue - Marconi .00 .00 .00 17.87 .00 36.29 (36.29) ... 85.78 3226.033 RoW Franchise Revenue - Nuso .00 .00 .00 11.22 .00 29.46 (29.46) ... 36.57 3226.034 RoW Franchise Revenue - Ooma .00 .00 .00 102.02 .00 199.35 (199.35) ... 328.92 3226.035 RoW Franchise Revenue - GC Pivotal .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 27.66 (27.66) ... 91.47 3226.036 RoW Franchise Revenue - Comcast .00 .00 .00 10,222.12 .00 19,538.70 (19,538.70) ... 21,479.62 3226.037 RoW Franchise Revenue - Zoom Voice Comm .00 .00 .00 1.92 .00 2.81 (2.81) ... 529.83 3226.038 RoW Franchise Revenue - 8X8 Inc .00 .00 .00 687.26 .00 1,346.38 (1,346.38) ... 5,319.99 3226.039 RoW Franchise Revenue - Patriot Mobile .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 47.44 (47.44) ... 292.10 3226.040 RoW Franchise Revenue - Interface Security Systems .00 .00 .00 21.15 .00 42.06 (42.06) ... 167.51 3226.041 RoW Franchise Revenue - Mint Mobile .00 .00 .00 73.59 .00 136.71 (136.71) ... 151.58 3226.042 RoW Franchise Revenue - GreenFly Networks .00 .00 .00 56.50 .00 127.40 (127.40) ... 992.37 3226.043 RoW Franchise Revenue - ICIM Corporation .00 .00 .00 8.31 .00 16.60 (16.60) ... 15.87 3226.044 RoW Franchise Revenue - BCN Telecom Inc .00 .00 .00 2.88 .00 2.88 (2.88) ... 2.72 3226.045 RoW Franchise Revenue - Simple VoIP LLC .00 .00 .00 27.75 .00 64.03 (64.03) ... 40.77 3226.046 RoW Franchise Revenue - Intelepeer Cloud Comm. .00 .00 .00 19.01 .00 101.52 (101.52) ... 81.58 3226.047 RoW Franchise Revenue - Plintron .00 .00 .00 2.00 .00 2.00 (2.00) . . . .00 3226.048 RoW Franchise Revenue - Momentum Telecom .00 .00 .00 871.79 .00 871.79 (871.79) ... .00 3226 - Totals $210,000.00 $0.00 $210,000.00 $69,447.04 $0.00 $142,356.22 $67,643.78 68% $284,689.26 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:56:07 AM Page 2 of 23 0 Revenue Budget Performance Report [isca�l Year, to Date 0 � /3 � /24 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp ACCOLInt and R(AklIp to ACCOUnt n c o r p u r a I c d t 8 8 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month YTD YTD Budget - YTD 11/o Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd Pdor Year TotaV Fund 001 Geiiimiiialll l::uind Dej,.,rarhnnenp 000 IReveiii"je REVENUE F?aiicliise Fi�aF 3228 3228.003 PGE Franchise Fees 700,000.00 .00 700,000.00 .00 .00 .00 700,000.00 0 726,291.87 3228.004 NW Natural Franchise Fees 180,000.00 .00 180,000.00 58,358.47 .00 87,818.18 92,181.82 49 231,349.47 3228.006 Republic Services Franchise Fees 360,000.00 .00 360,000.00 100,870.88 .00 180,238.73 179,761.27 50 359,640.55 3228.007 Wave Broadband Franchise Fees 100,000.00 .00 100,000.00 .00 .00 28,245.08 71,754.92 28 92,034.39 3228 - Totals $1,340,000.00 $0.00 $1,340,000.00 $159,229.35 $0.00 $296,301.99 $1,043,698.01 22% $1,409,316.28 3243 3243.470 General Right of Way - Water 248,000.00 .00 248,000.00 18,959.83 .00 172,613.50 75,386.50 70 259,159.58 3243.472 General Right of Way - Sewer 493,000.00 .00 493,000.00 45,584.23 .00 318,237.99 174,762.01 65 515,765.74 3243 - Totals $741,000.00 $0.00 $741,000.00 $64,544.06 $0.00 $490,851.49 $250,148.51 66% $774,925.32 Fi'aiicliise Fi�aF 7btaLF $2,291,000.00 $0.00 $2,291,000.00 $293,220.45 $0.00 $929,509.70 $1,361,490.30 41% $2,468,930.86 Plisce,11xieous Rmevnve, 3611 Interest from Investments 220,000.00 .00 220,000.00 60,708.09 .00 324,384.18 (104,384.18) 147 328,627.40 3617 Change in Fair Value of Investments .00 .00 .00 4,921.00 .00 68,099.80 (68,099.80) ... (3,634.97) 3625 Facilities Rent 2,400.00 .00 2,400.00 .00 .00 .00 2,400.00 0 .00 3641 Annual Access Fee 3,000.00 .00 3,000.00 .00 .00 .00 3,000.00 0 999.24 3691 Sale of Surplus Property 62,000.00 .00 62,000.00 .00 .00 32,000.00 30,000.00 52 44,249.56 3692 3692.101 Copies --Other .00 .00 .00 .10 .00 1.40 (1.40) . . . 15.60 3692 - Totals $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.10 $0.00 $1.40 ($1.40) ... $15.60 3698 Cash Long and Short .00 .00 .00 25.00 .00 27.04 (27.04) ... 1,552.63 3699 Other Miscellaneous Income 70,000.00 .00 70,000.00 5,742.69 .00 118,713.76 (48,713.76) 170 210,614.19 P*,"sce,Axieoz(.F Rmevnve 7btaLF $357,400.00 $0.70 $357,400.00 $71,396.88 $0.00 $543,226.18 ($185,826.18) 152% $582,423.65 Di 3971 3971.136 Transfer from American Rescue Plan Fund 966,000.00 .00 966,000.00 .00 .00 .00 966,000.00 0 409,710.00 3971.376 Transfer From Street SDC 200,000.00 .00 200,000.00 .00 .00 .00 200,000.00 0 .00 3971 - Totals $1,166,000.00 $0.00 $1,166,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $1,166,000.00 0% $409,710.00 7ixi�FA,,r,s Di 7btaLF $1,166,000.00 $0.00 $1,166,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $1,166,000.00 0% $409,710.00 REVENUE TOTALS $28,092,920.00 $710,000.00 $28,802,920.00 $796,901.46 $0.00 $13,220,900.54 $15,582,019.46 46% $17,179,107.31 Dej,.,rarhnnen000 IReveiii"je toals $28,092,920.00 $710,000.00 $28,802,920.00 $796,901.46 $0.00 $13,220,900.54 $15,582,019.46 46% $17,179,107.31 Dej,.,�arhnnen 101 Adimilinlishatilloin REVENUE ClixgaF fbi, 66x& ancf 5& vir, aF 3416 Lien Search Revenue 15,150.00 .00 15,150.00 896.00 .00 7,689.00 7,461.00 51 9,375.00 ChaigaF fbi, Goor,& xmf 5ei ,keF 7 btal, F $15,150.00 $0.00 $15,150.00 $896.00 $0.00 $7,689.00 $7,461.00 51% $9,375.00 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:56:07 AM Page 3 of 23 LOW WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp /CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to /CCOUn IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Tr'ansacdons Encumbrances Tr'ansacdons Tr'ansacdons Rec'd PdorYear ToitaV Fund 001... Geui"reur'allll II"":saurrd Del:rarhnnen° '101... Adimiilinliiistoi'atlilloin REVENUE aluf Fb1fr A''s 3530 Court Fines from Other Jurisdictions 24,750.00 .00 24,750.00 810.00 .00 9,237.49 15,512.51 37 24,855.14 3531 Court Fines 500,000.00 .00 500,000.00 33,643.80 .00 271,692.33 228,307.67 54 454,189.98 Ftises'xstPF�wA,^f;,s'7bta'ls' $524,750.00 $0.00 $524,750.00 $34,453.80 $0.00 $280,929.82 $243,820.18 54% $479,045.12 REVENUE TOTALS $539,900.00 $0.00 $539,900.00 $35,349.80 $0.00 $288,618.82 $251,281.18 53% $488,420.12 Det:rrarhnnenr� 101...Astlimilllulilla'tol"er'tlllalurtoCals $539,900.00 $0.00 $539,900.00 $35,349.80 $0.00 $288,618.82 $251,281.18 53% $488,420.12 Del:rarhnnerr 125 .. 15eaui°reuieliie IP)eaellle111urneui°rt REVENUE .teats:sartouuAo:rosssso:astat 3351 Grants 476,950.00 .00 476,950.00 .00 .00 56,625.00 420,325.00 12 113,699.00 t tuta'Js' $476,950.00 $0.00 $476,950.00 $0.00 $0.00 $56,625.00 $420,325.00 12% $113,699.00 Ada",'s'e:,11rs ieous RmAevnve, 3699 Other Miscellaneous Income 10,000.00 .00 10,000.00 .00 .00 7,041.00 2,959.00 70 2,500.00 AAI;s're,Aeaaeraesfu"m✓evnve 7btats $10,000.00 $0.00 $10,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $7,041.00 $2,959.00 70% $2,500.00 REVENUE TOTALS $486,950.00 $0.00 $486,950.00 $0.00 $0.00 $63,666.00 $423,284.00 13% $116,199.00 De^I,':r<arhnne^i' 125 15'Ieaainoiirnliic Deaelllellpimeint �otal„a $486,950.00 $0.00 $486,950.00 $0.00 $0.00 $63,666.00 $423,284.00 13% $116,199.00 De^I:rarhnnenr A17n...IPoIllliiee REVENUE .gate:saatouuAe:raaaaae:aatat 3332 Federal Grants 20,000.00 .00 20,000.00 .00 .00 .00 20,000.00 0 .00 3333 Federal Grants Indirect .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 10,064.12 (10,064.12) +++ 3,649.09 3341 State Grants 5,000.00 .00 5,000.00 .00 .00 .00 5,000.00 0 .00 ]seta'^a,et n ^raaaaaa'^aata'Jlauta'Js' $25,000.00 $0.00 $25,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $10,064.12 $14,935.88 40% $3,649.09 1"laaag as fir n';;''rarue'& aaae'S.5"&u,te.otis. 3421 3421 Police Reimbursements 15,000.00 .00 15,000.00 3,637.00 .00 14,904.96 95.04 99 16,074.46 3421.001 Reimbursements School District 105,000.00 .00 105,000.00 26,250.00 .00 53,789.90 51,210.10 51 109,873.78 3421.013 Reimbursements Marion County 150,000.00 .00 150,000.00 6,352.55 .00 50,169.80 99,830.20 33 111,801.36 3421 - Totals $270,000.00 $0.00 $270,000.00 $36,239.55 $0.00 $118,864.66 $151,135.34 44% $237,749.60 tlaareleastrsa l"oor,Pxmf 5ri^,r,'e s 7btals' $270,000.00 $0.00 $270,000.00 $36,239.55 $0.00 $118,864.66 $151,135.34 44% $237,749.60 Flrao'^,s aluf Fcuda`oA's 3531 3531.101 Police Training Surcharge 15,000.00 .00 15,000.00 1,505.00 .00 11,277.00 3,723.00 75 18,727.32 3531 - Totals $15,000.00 $0.00 $15,000.00 $1,505.00 $0.00 $11,277.00 $3,723.00 75% $18,727.32 3532 Towing Fee 10,000.00 .00 10,000.00 2,400.00 .00 10,350.00 (350.00) 104 14,100.00 3533 Alarm Fee 500.00 .00 500.00 .00 .00 210.00 290.00 42 (30.00) Ftaaes'aaatPF°t Aa'^leis ]totals' $25,500.00 $0.00 $25,500.00 $3,905.00 $0.00 $21,837.00 $3,663.00 86% $32,797.32 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:56:07 AM 100 Page 4 of 23 WQODBURN Inckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account DescrIlptiion Budget Amendments Budget Transacitfions Encumbrances Transacitfions Transacitfions Rec'd Pr'IorYear ToitaV Fund 001... Geuiiroura llll Il�:r:raund Dej,.,rarhnne np 211 IPolllliice REVENUE Plisce,11xieous RmAevnve, 3673 Donations -Police 4,000.00 .00 4,000.00 .00 .00 .00 4,000.00 0 2,500.00 3699 Other Miscellaneous Income 3,500.00 .00 3,500.00 276.00 .00 506.50 2,993.50 14 11,439.50 3881 3881.001 Reim bursement--Training 3,000.00 .00 3,000.00 .00 .00 .00 3,000.00 0 .00 3881 - Totals $3,000.00 $0.00 $3,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $3,000.00 0% $0.00 AAta're,AAaaae oz(.F fu"m✓evnve 7bta& $10,500.00 $0.00 $10,500.00 $276.00 $0.00 $506.50 $9,993.50 5% $13,939.50 REVENUE TOTALS $331,000.00 $0.00 $331,000.00 $40,420.55 $0.00 $151,272.28 $179,727.72 46% $288,135.51 De^I,':r<arhnne^i' 211 IPolllliice totals $331,000.00 $0.00 $331,000.00 $40,420.55 $0.00 $151,272.28 $179,727.72 46% $288,135.51 Dee,.,<arhnen� 311..•IIIu11l1aoraruiiy REVENUE Pliseei,11xaeous RmAevnve, 3695 Lost Book Revenue .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 1,086.62 AAa",sce,AAaaaeoz(.FRmAevnvettuta& $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 +++ $1,086.62 REVENUE TOTALS $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ... $1,086.62 Dee,.,<arhnnenr 311 III iilCaoiaruiy toCals $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 +++ $1,086.62 Dee,., <arh ne,n. 411 Couiiouiiouauiirui1ty Sraurviiioras REVENUE .gate:saaAouuAe:raaaaae:aataA 3351 Grants 12,000.00 .00 12,000.00 .00 .00 .00 12,000.00 0 31,179.65 3365 Regional Library Services 95,470.00 .00 95,470.00 .00 .00 52,690.05 42,779.95 55 153,175.74 3366 Ready to Read Grant 4,750.00 .00 4,750.00 4,897.00 .00 4,897.00 (147.00) 103 .00 ]seta^a,eAen ^raaaaao'^aataAAAuta& $112,220.00 $0.00 $112,220.00 $4,897.00 $0.00 $57,587.05 $54,632.95 51% $184,355.39 1"Aaaag aF Aor T;;''rarue& «ancf 5&u,Ao.oti,a. 3417 Resale of Merchandise 5,500.00 .00 5,500.00 277.00 .00 2,083.25 3,416.75 38 5,139.00 3418 Concession Sales 6,000.00 .00 6,000.00 479.00 .00 4,156.00 1,844.00 69 6,319.25 3471 3471 Pool Program Revenues .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 + + + (70.00) 3471.101 Pool Admissions 88,000.00 .00 88,000.00 4,591.00 .00 44,726.78 43,273.22 51 73,224.75 3471.102 Pool Memberships 71,000.00 .00 71,000.00 8,380.68 .00 45,802.32 25,197.68 65 59,437.19 3471.103 Pool Rentals 7,000.00 .00 7,000.00 .00 .00 290.50 6,709.50 4 (3,657.00) 3471.104 Swimming Lessons 18,000.00 .00 18,000.00 1,965.00 .00 13,722.00 4,278.00 76 11,821.75 3471.105 Pool Sponsorships 1,500.00 .00 1,500.00 .00 .00 .00 1,500.00 0 200.00 3471.107 Towels/Misc 3,000.00 .00 3,000.00 .00 .00 .00 3,000.00 0 .00 3471 - Totals $188,500.00 $0.00 $188,500.00 $14,936.68 $0.00 $104,541.60 $83,958.40 55% $140,956.69 3472 Rural Readers' Fees 1,000.00 .00 1,000.00 .00 .00 240.00 760.00 24 300.00 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:56:07 AM 101 Page 5 of 23 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp /CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to /CCOUn IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month YTD YTD Budget - YTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd PdorYear ToitaV Fund 001... euiirourallll Il�:r'rrund Del:rarh ne,n. 411 Coiiii'nui'nuruiirui1ty Srauiiviiices REVENUE t"lrae,rlaF f r n';;''rrrue& aere5.5"o: vir,.aF 3473 3473.101 Youth Sports 12,000.00 .00 12,000.00 .00 .00 2,131.43 9,868.57 18 11,034.95 3473.102 Adult Sports 4,000.00 .00 4,000.00 .00 .00 .00 4,000.00 0 1,879.04 3473.103 Youth Program 2,500.00 .00 2,500.00 .00 .00 (4,339.00) 6,839.00 -174 550.00 3473.105 Adult Program .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ (702.27) 3473.106 Recreation - Sponsorship Revenue 3,000.00 .00 3,000.00 .00 .00 3,500.00 (500.00) 117 9,000.00 3473.110 Arts & Culture 2,000.00 .00 2,000.00 .00 .00 .00 2,000.00 0 170.00 3473.111 Active Adult 2,000.00 .00 2,000.00 50.00 .00 50.00 1,950.00 2 345.97 3473 - Totals $25,500.00 $0.00 $25,500.00 $50.00 $0.00 $1,342.43 $24,157.57 5% $22,277.69 3474 3474 Event Admission & Vendor Fees 1,000.00 .00 1,000.00 .00 .00 60.00 940.00 6 2,655.00 3474.099 Fiesta Event Admissions & Vendor Fees 64,000.00 .00 64,000.00 .00 .00 56,345.89 7,654.11 88 41,333.80 3474 - Totals $65,000.00 $0.00 $65,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $56,405.89 $8,594.11 87% $43,988.80 3476 3476 Event Sponsorships 10,000.00 .00 10,000.00 .00 .00 13,350.00 (3,350.00) 134 10,000.00 3476.099 Fiesta Event Sponsorships 65,000.00 .00 65,000.00 .00 .00 51,730.00 13,270.00 80 36,863.00 3476 - Totals $75,000.00 $0.00 $75,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $65,080.00 $9,920.00 87% $46,863.00 3491 Rental Income 31,310.00 .00 31,310.00 1,525.00 .00 31,588.00 (278.00) 101 37,343.00 alrarelaF tree t"oor,& xmf °a"ri^ ,,'o s 7bta'ls' $397,810.00 $0.00 $397,810.00 $17,267.68 $0.00 $265,437.17 $132,372.83 67% $303,187.43 F lrr r;^,s a raP F tudtar;^at s 3536 Library Fines 5,000.00 .00 5,000.00 11.85 .00 119.79 4,880.21 2 187.57 Ftires' xrtPF°t t'^1ts 7bta'ls' $5,000.00 $0.00 $5,000.00 $11.85 $0.00 $119.79 $4,880.21 2% $187.57 Adleee,11xreiwss RmAevnve, 3625 Facilities Rent 4,500.00 .00 4,500.00 2,487.18 .00 9,220.18 (4,720.18) 205 6,542.50 3651 Internal Rent Revenue 85,280.00 .00 85,280.00 7,106.67 .00 49,746.69 35,533.31 58 74,410.00 3672 3672 Donations -Library .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 146.28 (146.28) +++ 660.10 3672.001 Donations -Library - Music in the Park .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 2,000.00 (2,000.00) +++ (1,500.00) 3672 - Totals $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $2,146.28 ($2,146.28) +++ ($839.90) 3675 Donations -Museum .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 + + + 4,969.60 3677 Donations -Pool 2,000.00 .00 2,000.00 .00 .00 .00 2,000.00 0 .00 3695 Lost Book Revenue 2,000.00 .00 2,000.00 100.71 .00 627.03 1,372.97 31 3,880.79 3698 3698.102 Library .00 .00 .00 (.05) .00 4.25 (4.25) +++ 14.60 3698.103 Aquatics .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 1.55 (1.55) +++ (238.75) 3698.104 Recreation .00 .00 .00 16.25 .00 (54.29) 54.29 + + + 243.77 3698 - Totals $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $16.20 $0.00 ($48.49) $48.49 +++ $19.62 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:56:07 AM 102 Page 6 of 23 Revenue Budget Performance Report [isca�l Year, to Date 0 � /3 � /24 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp ACCOLInt and R(AklIp to ACCOUnt n c o r p u r a I c d t 8 8 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month YTD YTD Budget - YTD 11/o Used/ Account Account Descdlpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transactions Encumbrances Transactions Transactions Rec'd Prior' Year Totai Fund 001 Geiiimiiialll l::uind Del,.,rarhnnenC 411 CoiiiniiinRiiiirilitySeiiivilices REVENUE Plisce,11xiews Rmevnve, 3699 3699 Other Miscellaneous Income 1,000.00 .00 1,000.00 .00 .00 .00 1,000.00 0 91.87 3699.102 Library .00 .00 .00 444.95 .00 3,180.15 (3,180.15) . . . 5,516.11 3699.103 Aquatics .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 . . . 70.75 3699.104 Recreation .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 . . . 93.20 3699 - Totals $1,000.00 $0.00 $1,000.00 $444.95 $0.00 $3,180.15 ($2,180.15) 318% $5,771.93 P*",sce,Axieoz(.F Rmevnve 7bta& $94,780.00 $0.00 $94,780.00 $10,155.71 $0.00 $64,871.84 $29,908.16 68% $94,754.54 REVENUE TOTALS $609,810.00 $0.00 $609,810.00 $32,332.24 $0.00 $388,015.85 $221,794.15 64% $582,484.93 Del,.,rarhnnen411 CoiiiniiinRiiiirilitySeiiivilices to�als $609,810.00 $0.00 $609,810.00 $32,332.24 $0.00 $388,015.85 $221,794.15 64% $582,484.93 Del,.,rarhnnenr 511 P111aininiling REVENUE Lir&isaF xmf flewi7fi7' 3451 T&E Planning Develop Fee 125,000.00 .00 125,000.00 6,753.32 .00 72,308.88 52,691.12 58 98,909.11 3456 Planning Fees 250,000.00 .00 250,000.00 5,030.00 .00 80,156.50 169,843.50 32 294,217.00 LkeasaF ancf flewi7fis 7bfals $375,000.00 $0.00 $375,000.00 $11,783.32 $0.00 $152,465.38 $222,534.62 41% $393,126.11 REVENUE TOTALS $375,000.00 $0.00 $375,000.00 $11,783.32 $0.00 $152,465.38 $222,534.62 41% $393,126.11 Del,.,rarhnnen511 P111aininiling to�als $375,000.00 $0.00 $375,000.00 $11,783.32 $0.00 $152,465.38 $222,534.62 41% $393,126.11 Del,.,rarhnnen 651 Einglikimeiiiing REVENUE Lir&isaF xmf flewi7fi7' 3221 3221.111 Demo Permits .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 ... 750.00 3221 - Totals $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ... $750.00 3224 R/W Construction Permits 200,000.00 .00 200,000.00 5,360.00 .00 59,733.08 140,266.92 30 341,972.97 3451 T&E Planning Develop Fee 37,950.00 .00 37,950.00 3,377.68 .00 36,210.30 1,739.70 95 49,469.39 LkeasaF ancf flewi7fis 7bfals $237,950.00 $0.00 $237,950.00 $8,737.68 $0.00 $95,943.38 $142,006.62 40% $392,192.36 3656 Engineering Internal Project WO Revenue 130,000.00 .00 130,000.00 4,646.90 .00 58,310.03 71,689.97 45 266,982.45 7btaLF $130,000.00 $0.00 $130,000.00 $4,646.90 $0.00 $58,310.03 $71,689.97 45% $266,982.45 REVENUE TOTALS $367,950.00 $0.00 $367,950.00 $13,384.58 $0.00 $154,253.41 $213,696.59 42% $659,174.81 Del,.,rarhnnen651 Einglikimeiiiing toals $367,950.00 $0.00 $367,950.00 $13,384.58 $0.00 $154,253.41 $213,696.59 42% $659,174.81 Fund 001 Geiiimiiialll l::uind to�als $30,803,530.00 $710,000.00 $31,513,530.00 $930,171.95 $0.00 $14,419,192.28 $17,094,337.72 $19,707,734.41 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:56:07 AM Page 7 of 23 103 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp /CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to /CCOUn IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Tr'ansacdons Encumbrances Tr'ansacdons Tr'ansacdons Rec'd PdorYear ToitaV Fund 1.10 .• "1ulainsft@""rrllrrd Dee,., aarhnne^In' 000 .. IReveimje REVENUE F Swmf 11al earce 3081 Beginning Fund Balance 713,500.00 .00 713,500.00 .00 .00 .00 713,500.00 0 .00 Fa.r mf flaIxio°e 7bfa& $713,500.00 $0.00 $713,500.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $713,500.00 0% $0.00 .Cartev'r10 ve:vorsr?ewtal 3332 Federal Grants 3333 3333.601 3333.603 3333.605 272,000.00 .00 272,000.00 .00 .00 .00 272,000.00 0 253,987.00 5310 Discretionary Ops 70,300.00 .00 70,300.00 .00 .00 17,295.00 53,005.00 25 85,025.00 5311 Formula Operation 167,500.00 .00 167,500.00 .00 .00 77,299.00 90,201.00 46 500,488.00 Veh Prev Maint 37,000.00 .00 37,000.00 .00 .00 9,414.00 27,586.00 25 69,255.00 3333 - Totals $274,800.00 $0.00 $274,800.00 $0.00 $0.00 $104,008.00 $170,792.00 38% $654,768.00 3341 3341 State Grants 125,000.00 .00 125,000.00 .00 .00 .00 125,000.00 0 138,010.00 3341.601 STF Formula .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 217,000.00 3341 - Totals $125,000.00 $0.00 $125,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $125,000.00 0% $355,010.00 3345 Statewide Transit 1,099,000.00 .00 1,099,000.00 .00 .00 136,431.00 962,569.00 12 469,124.00 tart'^a,et n ^r�r�r�'^artaJtautaLF $1,770,800.00 $0.00 $1,770,800.00 $0.00 $0.00 $240,439.00 $1,530,391.00 14% $1,732,889.00 1"laaag aF f r T;;''rrrue'& aaae'S .5&u,to.ati,r. 3445 Dial a Ride Daily .00 .00 .00 205.75 .00 369.25 (369.25) +++ 24.00 t laamleiar, fbi, t; o its aaaat 5ei ,ke s lr talc $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $205.75 $0.00 $369.25 ($369.25) +++ $24.00 All 'e'e,11xaeo us RmAevnve, 3611 Interest from Investments 4,000.00 .00 4,000.00 2,393.20 .00 13,817.64 (9,817.64) 345 10,244.35 3617 Change in Fair Value of Investments .00 .00 .00 247.68 .00 2,383.70 (2,383.70) +++ 386.08 3676 Donations -Transit 6,000.00 .00 6,000.00 448.00 .00 5,367.50 632.50 89 9,326.86 3694 Gain/Loss on Sale .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ (64.38) 111,s'oe,Axieeuars'fa"e'^u✓e^arrretauta& $10,000.00 $0.00 $10,000.00 $3,088.88 $0.00 $21,568.84 ($11,568.84) 216% $19,892.91 It�rst'^a:' .tar 3971 3971.001 Transfer From General Fund 100,000.00 .00 100,000.00 8,333.33 .00 58,333.31 41,666.69 58 150,000.00 3971.136 Transfer from American Rescue Plan Fund 127,000.00 .00 127,000.00 .00 .00 .00 127,000.00 0 65,000.00 3971 - Totals $227,000.00 $0.00 $227,000.00 $8,333.33 $0.00 $58,333.31 $168,666.69 26% $215,000.00 ltxi' F'A,,5'.ter ttuta& $227,000.00 $0.00 $227,000.00 $8,333.33 $0.00 $58,333.31 $168,666.69 26% $215,000.00 REVENUE TOTALS $2,721,300.00 $0.00 $2,721,300.00 $11,627.96 $0.00 $320,710.40 $2,400,589.60 12% $1,967,805.91 De^I:rartnne^I' 000 IRevelll"rrje toals $2,721,300.00 $0.00 $2,721,300.00 $11,627.96 $0.00 $320,710.40 $2,400,589.60 12% $1,967,805.91 Fund 110 "1ul':ulll'rvttl@":must toaals $2,721,300.00 $0.00 $2,721,300.00 $11,627.96 $0.00 $320,710.40 $2,400,589.60 $1,967,805.91 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:56:07 AM 104 Page 8 of 23 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLauint and IR(Akaulp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd PdorYear ToitaV Fund 1.23 .. IBul11111stliiurr0 'Inslpectliioin Il'::ui rst Dej,.,rarhnne np 000 .. IReveiwe REVENUE f fr mf 11al ence 3081 Beginning Fund Balance 7,474,300.00 .00 7,474,300.00 .00 .00 .00 7,474,300.00 0 .00 fa.ramf11aleasoe;^7bfa& $7,474,300.00 $0.00 $7,474,300.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $7,474,300.00 0% $0.00 Lfr&isaF aerel fraswrefL:s 3221 3221.101 Building Permits 816,200.00 .00 816,200.00 36,233.84 .00 510,997.26 305,202.74 63 696,951.56 3221.102 Mechanical Permits 60,000.00 .00 60,000.00 9,811.60 .00 50,225.78 9,774.22 84 114,935.70 3221.105 Plan Check Fees 867,240.00 100,000.00 967,240.00 57,988.21 .00 426,914.22 540,325.78 44 878,475.21 3221.106 Fire Check Fees 445,940.00 .00 445,940.00 86,765.12 .00 287,790.84 158,149.16 65 278,408.21 3221.109 Plan Check --Mechanical 30,000.00 .00 30,000.00 1,383.30 .00 18,153.20 11,846.80 61 44,860.10 3221.110 CET Administrative Fee 40,000.00 .00 40,000.00 2,162.85 .00 26,373.77 13,626.23 66 28,738.43 3221.111 Demo Permits 2,000.00 .00 2,000.00 .00 .00 .00 2,000.00 0 750.00 3221 - Totals $2,261,380.00 $100,000.00 $2,361,380.00 $194,344.92 $0.00 $1,320,455.07 $1,040,924.93 56% $2,043,119.21 L.fre;a^ arsancffre^ressfts I'ttals $2,261,380.00 $100,000.00 $2,361,380.00 $194,344.92 $0.00 $1,320,455.07 $1,040,924.93 56% $2,043,119.21 .leafs:sn^fouhAo:rrsssso:asLvl 3891 3891 Construction Excise Tax 1,000,000.00 200,000.00 1,200,000.00 51,908.31 .00 632,970.45 567,029.55 53 690,042.24 3891.159 State Surcharge 160,000.00 .00 160,000.00 6,224.83 .00 60,473.60 99,526.40 38 97,674.09 3891.259 State Manufactured Home Fee 1,000.00 .00 1,000.00 .00 .00 .00 1,000.00 0 .00 3891 - Totals $1,161,000.00 $200,000.00 $1,361,000.00 $58,133.14 $0.00 $693,444.05 $667,555.95 51% $787,716.33 FesL'^e/eh ^rsss;'^sL'Jfbfals $1,161,000.00 $200,000.00 $1,361,000.00 $58,133.14 $0.00 $693,444.05 $667,555.95 51% $787,716.33 Plisralleereoaos RmAevnve, 3611 Interest from Investments 60,000.00 .00 60,000.00 27,813.49 .00 186,082.28 (126,082.28) 310 166,883.28 3617 Change in Fair Value of Investments .00 .00 .00 2,955.45 .00 39,048.15 (39,048.15) +++ (770.63) 3699 Other Miscellaneous Income 1,000.00 .00 1,000.00 .00 .00 .00 1,000.00 0 1,143.00 PlZs'ns'aa;llaisaa;'^carts'fa"e;'^h✓aa;'^ssrraa; 7btna''Js' $61,000.00 $0.00 $61,000.00 $30,768.94 $0.00 $225,130.43 ($164,130.43) 369% $167,255.65 REVENUE TOTALS $10,957,680.00 $300,000.00 $11,257,680.00 $283,247.00 $0.00 $2,239,029.55 $9,018,650.45 20% $2,998,091.19 De^I:rartnse^i' 000 IR,eveuiwe toal„a $10,957,680.00 $300,000.00 $11,257,680.00 $283,247.00 $0.00 $2,239,029.55 $9,018,650.45 20% $2,998,091.19 Fund 1.23 IBul11111stuiuir0Inslpectuioin Il::uind toa al„a $10,957,680.00 $300,000.00 $11,257,680.00 $283,247.00 $0.00 $2,239,029.55 $9,018,650.45 $2,998,091.19 Fund 132... Asset I@""ourteiiiltuiie Dej,.,rarhnne np 000 .. IReveiwe REVENUE f framf 11 rlraso°e,'^ 3081 Beginning Fund Balance 16,350.00 .00 16,350.00 .00 .00 .00 16,350.00 0 .00 fa.ramf 11al ime;'^ 7bfals $16,350.00 $0.00 $16,350.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $16,350.00 0% $0.00 Plisralleereoaoss RmAevnve, 3611 Interest from Investments 250.00 .00 250.00 98.88 .00 624.54 (374.54) 250 387.91 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:56:07 AM Page 9 of 23 105 Revenue Budget Performance Report [��isca�l Year, to Date 0 � /3 � /24 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp ACCOLInt and R(AklIp to ACCOUnt n c o r p u r a I c d t 8 8 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month YTD YTD Budget - YTD 11/o Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd Pdor Year TotaV Fund 132 Asset i:oiffelltuiie Dej,.,rarhnnenp 000 Reveiwe REVENUE Plisce,11xiews Rmevnve, 3617 Change in Fair Value of Investments .00 .00 .00 10.34 .00 106.55 (106.55) . . . (2.74) 3692 Confiscated Cash .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 8,495.52 (8,495.52) . . . 30.50 3693 Sale of Confiscated Prop .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 1,719.00 (1,719.00) . . . 2,429.15 PlZscellxieous Rmevnve 7btaLF $250.00 $0.00 $250.00 $109.22 $0.00 $10,945.61 ($10,695.61) 4378% $2,844.82 REVENUE TOTALS $16,600.00 $0.00 $16,600.00 $109.22 $0.00 $10,945.61 $5,654.39 66% $2,844.82 Dej,.,rarhnnen000 IlA,eveuiwe totals $16,600.00 $0.00 $16,600.00 $109.22 $0.00 $10,945.61 $5,654.39 66% $2,844.82 Fund 132 Asset i:oiffelltuiie totals $16,600.00 $0.00 $16,600.00 $109.22 $0.00 $10,945.61 $5,654.39 $2,844.82 Fund 136 A�neiii icain Rescue IP111Pain l::uind Dej,.,rarhnnenp 000 Reveiwe REVENUE Swmf Valance 3081 Beginning Fund Balance 2,220,390.00 .00 2,220,390.00 .00 .00 .00 2,220,390.00 0 .00 a.r mf flaaIxice 7 bfa& $2,220,390.00 $0.00 $2,220,390.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $2,220,390.00 0% $0.00 3351 Grants .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 ... 2,917,812.66 taste to nperaaaase ata9 7bfals $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ... $2,917,812.66 Plisce,11xiews Rmevnve, 3611 Interest from Investments 30,000.00 .00 30,000.00 .00 .00 25,863.42 4,136.58 86 83,792.48 3617 Change in Fair Value of Investments .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 12,424.99 (12,424.99) . . . (63.56) PlZscellxieous Rmevnve 7bta9F $30,000.00 $0.00 $30,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $38,288.41 ($8,288.41) 128% $83,728.92 REVENUE TOTALS $2,250,390.00 $0.00 $2,250,390.00 $0.00 $0.00 $38,288.41 $2,212,101.59 2% $3,001,541.58 Dej,.,rarhnnen000 IlA,eveuiwe totals $2,250,390.00 $0.00 $2,250,390.00 $0.00 $0.00 $38,288.41 $2,212,101.59 2% $3,001,541.58 Fund '136 A�neiiicain IRescue P111ain l::uind toCals $2,250,390.00 $0.00 $2,250,390.00 $0.00 $0.00 $38,288.41 $2,212,101.59 $3,001,541.58 Fund 137 Iplllousliiuing ICA,ellharllb l::uind Dej,.,rarhnnenp 000 Reveiwe REVENUE Swmf Valance 3081 Beginning Fund Balance 27,890.00 .00 27,890.00 .00 .00 .00 27,890.00 0 .00 a.r mf flaaIxice 7 bfa& $27,890.00 $0.00 $27,890.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $27,890.00 0% $0.00 Plisce,11xiews Rmevnve, 3611 Interest from Investments 400.00 .00 400.00 158.35 .00 955.02 (555.02) 239 696.87 3617 Change in Fair Value of Investments .00 .00 .00 16.81 .00 174.80 (174.80) ... 3.51 PlZscellxieous Rmevnve 7bfals $400.00 $0.00 $400.00 $175.16 $0.00 $1,129.82 ($729.82) 282% $700.38 Other Aillallcillrl 5oxuceF 3824 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:56:07 AM Page 10 of 23 106 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp /CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to /CCOUn IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Tr'ansacdons Encumbrances Tr'ansacdons Tr'ansacdons Rec'd PdorYear ToitaV Fund 1.37 .• IPlosswliiurr0 IR,ellh allb Il::uirrd Dej,.'rarhnne np 000 .. IReveurrsse REVENUE Other Ffaraero"falrl .5o aoee.exs. 3824 3824.010 Loan Payback 2010 10,000.00 .00 10,000.00 .00 .00 18,752.12 (8,752.12) 188 .00 3824 - Totals $10,000.00 $0.00 $10,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $18,752.12 ($8,752.12) 188% $0.00 Other fWianr5rrr5.5ruar raF 7btals $10,000.00 $0.00 $10,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $18,752.12 ($8,752.12) 188% $0.00 REVENUE TOTALS $38,290.00 $0.00 $38,290.00 $175.16 $0.00 $19,881.94 $18,408.06 52% $700.38 De^I:rrrtnne^i' 000 IR,eveurrsse totals $38,290.00 $0.00 $38,290.00 $175.16 $0.00 $19,881.94 $18,408.06 52% $700.38 Fund 137 IPlousiiiing IRellh allb Il::uind toCals $38,290.00 $0.00 $38,290.00 $175.16 $0.00 $19,881.94 $18,408.06 $700.38 Fund 1.00 .. Sltui°'eelt I@":uins't Dej,.'rarhnne np 000 .. IReveurrsse REVENUE FSr mf 11aleaso°e;'^ 3081 Beginning Fund Balance 4,369,310.00 .00 4,369,310.00 .00 .00 .00 4,369,310.00 0 .00 Fa.ramf 11al ime;'^ 7bfa'& $4,369,310.00 $0.00 $4,369,310.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $4,369,310.00 0% $0.00 flAe F 3171 City Gas Tax 110,000.00 .00 110,000.00 8,443.27 .00 57,918.48 52,081.52 53 118,032.11 fI'xe;'s'7tuta'Js' $110,000.00 $0.00 $110,000.00 $8,443.27 $0.00 $57,918.48 $52,081.52 53% $118,032.11 t.fr'&is'aF aere'S flaswreftis 3223 Curb Cuts and Bores 400.00 .00 400.00 .00 .00 67.00 333.00 17 67.00 t foam a^rs asse'S flauwssfts t't tafs $400.00 $0.00 $400.00 $0.00 $0.00 $67.00 $333.00 17% $67.00 .Feats:snrfouuAo:rssssso:astaf 3333 3333.001 DoT Fund Exchange .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 1,714,965.12 (1,714,965.12) +++ .00 3333 - Totals $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $1,714,965.12 ($1,714,965.12) +++ $0.00 3361 State Gas Tax 2,075,000.00 .00 2,075,000.00 197,269.52 .00 1,046,341.03 1,028,658.97 50 2,072,999.83 f futa'Js' $2,075,000.00 $0.00 $2,075,000.00 $197,269.52 $0.00 $2,761,306.15 ($686,306.15) 133% $2,072,999.83 Ffaisrlsis'ar;'^ FI'^aF 3141 Privilege Tax, PGE 300,000.00 .00 300,000.00 .00 .00 .00 300,000.00 0 311,101.79 3142 Privilege Tax, NW Natural 120,000.00 .00 120,000.00 38,905.65 .00 58,545.45 61,454.55 49 154,232.97 Ffa' iclslse^ Fa'^e;'s' l'r tafs' $420,000.00 $0.00 $420,000.00 $38,905.65 $0.00 $58,545.45 $361,454.55 14% $465,334.76 flis'calleereiws' RmAevnve, 3611 Interest from Investments 75,000.00 .00 75,000.00 22,314.77 .00 119,136.03 (44,136.03) 159 144,654.01 3617 Change in Fair Value of Investments .00 .00 .00 1,692.35 .00 29,541.07 (29,541.07) +++ 532.61 3654 Garage WO Revenue 25,000.00 .00 25,000.00 .00 .00 31,680.71 (6,680.71) 127 51,596.62 3699 Other Miscellaneous Income 500.00 .00 500.00 67.19 .00 372.77 127.23 75 879.95 fl,s'ns'e^llsdseeus(.s'fa"e;'^u✓e^ssrsefluta'ls' $100,500.00 $0.00 $100,500.00 $24,074.31 $0.00 $180,730.58 ($80,230.58) 180% $197,663.19 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:56:07 AM 107 Page 11 of 23 WQODBURN Inckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descr'Ilptiion Budget Amendments Budget Tr'ansacitfions Encumbrances Tr'ansacitfions Tr'ansacitfions Pec'd Pr'IorYear ToitaV Fund F.00 .. Sltui°'eelt I@ mind Dej,.,rarhnnenr 000 .. IAeaaeui°rrae REVENUE Tt�rs9'^a: .tar 3971 3971.472 Transfer From Sewer 90,000.00 .00 90,000.00 7,500.00 .00 52,500.00 37,500.00 58 90,000.00 3971 - Totals $90,000.00 $0.00 $90,000.00 $7,500.00 $0.00 $52,500.00 $37,500.00 58% $90,000.00 7iairs'9',,,5'.Fer7bta'Js' $90,000.00 $0.00 $90,000.00 $7,500.00 $0.00 $52,500.00 $37,500.00 58% $90,000.00 REVENUE TOTALS $7,165,210.00 $0.00 $7,165,210.00 $276,192.75 $0.00 $3,111,067.66 $4,054,142.34 43% $2,944,096.89 De^I:rartnne^i' 000 IA,eaaeui"rrae toal„a $7,165,210.00 $0.00 $7,165,210.00 $276,192.75 $0.00 $3,111,067.66 $4,054,142.34 43% $2,944,096.89 Fund t140 Stiiieelt@:must toaal„a $7,165,210.00 $0.00 $7,165,210.00 $276,192.75 $0.00 $3,111,067.66 $4,054,142.34 $2,944,096.89 Fund 250.. GO IDellbtSeui°'Vice II::uind De^l:rarhnne nr 000 .. IAeaaeui°rrae REVENUE F rwmf 11alaaace 3081 Beginning Fund Balance 8,790.00 .00 8,790.00 .00 .00 .00 8,790.00 0 .00 Fa.rmf11aalaim e7bfa& $8,790.00 $0.00 $8,790.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $8,790.00 0% $0.00 TlAas 3111 Property Tax - Current 616,000.00 .00 616,000.00 13,146.32 .00 582,773.58 33,226.42 95 602,173.54 3112 Property Tax - Delinquent 14,000.00 .00 14,000.00 476.61 .00 8,603.57 5,396.43 61 11,404.96 tIAx F'ttuta'Js' $630,000.00 $0.00 $630,000.00 $13,622.93 $0.00 $591,377.15 $38,622.85 94% $613,578.50 Ala",'r'all,iieous RmAevnve, 3611 Interest from Investments 3,310.00 .00 3,310.00 2,045.62 .00 5,165.72 (1,855.72) 156 9,576.50 3617 Change in Fair Value of Investments .00 .00 .00 92.97 .00 1,524.73 (1,524.73) +++ 586.82 AA,s'oar'^✓laaaeeuars'fa"e'^h✓e^aarretauta'Js' $3,310.00 $0.00 $3,310.00 $2,138.59 $0.00 $6,690.45 ($3,380.45) 202% $10,163.32 REVENUE TOTALS $642,100.00 $0.00 $642,100.00 $15,761.52 $0.00 $598,067.60 $44,032.40 93% $623,741.82 De^l:rartnne^i' 000 IA,eaaeui"rrae toal„a $642,100.00 $0.00 $642,100.00 $15,761.52 $0.00 $598,067.60 $44,032.40 93% $623,741.82 Fund 250..GOIPaellbtSeui'Vice II::aunt toaal„a $642,100.00 $0.00 $642,100.00 $15,761.52 $0.00 $598,067.60 $44,032.40 $623,741.82 Fund 358 .. Geui"reur'a III Ca Ilp Coiiiiimt I iiii"W De^l:rarhnne nr 000 .. IAeaaeui°rrae REVENUE F rwmf 11alaaace 3081 Beginning Fund Balance 148,490.00 .00 148,490.00 .00 .00 .00 148,490.00 0 .00 Fa.rmf11aalaime'^7bfa'& $148,490.00 $0.00 $148,490.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $148,490.00 0% $0.00 .gatev,rlo ve:vaaaaaewtat 3341 State Grants AAa".'callaaaeouss' RmAevnve, 3671 Donations -Parks 3699 Other Miscellaneous Income 1,750,000.00 .00 1,750,000.00 .00 .00 .00 1,750,000.00 0 .00 ^aaaaaaa'^aataJtautaLF $1,750,000.00 $0.00 $1,750,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $1,750,050.00 0% $0.00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 1,010,000.00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 21,603.86 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:56:07 AM Page 12 of 23 108 WQODBURN Inckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descr'Ilptiion Budget Amendments Budget Tr'ansacitfions Encumbrances Tr'ansacitfions Tr'ansacitfions Rec'd Pr'IorYear ToitaV Fund 358 .. Geui"reur'a III Ca Ilp Couiimt I iiii"W Dej,.,rarhnnenp 000.. IReseui°rrae REVENUE Ada",'re:,AJiro:oz(.FRenAo:arve7auta& $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 +++ $1,031,603.86 Ttwa FA,, ,s' Di 3971 3971.001 Transfer From General Fund 66,470.00 .00 66,470.00 .00 .00 20,610.00 45,860.00 31 515,224.00 3971.136 Transfer from American Rescue Plan Fund 161,250.00 .00 161,250.00 .00 .00 .00 161,250.00 0 .00 3971.364 Transfer From Parks SDC 1,028,750.00 .00 1,028,750.00 .00 .00 8,807.10 1,019,942.90 1 1,485,954.00 3971.376 Transfer From Street SDC 50,000.00 .00 50,000.00 .00 .00 .00 50,000.00 0 .00 3971 - Totals $1,306,470.00 $0.00 $1,306,470.00 $0.00 $0.00 $29,417.10 $1,277,052.90 2% $2,001,178.00 7taaas'A,,5'.tea ttutaLF $1,306,470.00 $0.00 $1,306,470.00 $0.00 $0.00 $29,417.10 $1,277,052.90 2% $2,001,178.00 REVENUE TOTALS $3,204,960.00 $0.00 $3,204,960.00 $0.00 $0.00 $29,417.10 $3,175,542.90 1% $3,032,781.86 De^I:rartnne^i' 000 IR,eseui"rrae totals $3,204,960.00 $0.00 $3,204,960.00 $0.00 $0.00 $29,417.10 $3,175,542.90 1% $3,032,781.86 Fund 358 Geui"reuiiallll Cap touui'rs1t lI::uind toCals $3,204,960.00 $0.00 $3,204,960.00 $0.00 $0.00 $29,417.10 $3,175,542.90 $3,032,781.86 Fund 360 .• Sllpeeliialll Assessrneint II"::uind Dej,.,rarhnnenp 000.. IReseui°rrae REVENUE F rwmf 11alaaace 3081 Beginning Fund Balance 39,960.00 .00 39,960.00 .00 .00 .00 39,960.00 0 .00 Fa.r mf 11alaaaoe 7bfa& $39,960.00 $0.00 $39,960.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $39,960.00 0% $0.00 Ala".a'callaaaews RmAevnve, 3611 Interest from Investments 500.00 .00 500.00 146.79 .00 988.94 (488.94) 198 931.72 3614 Special Assessment-Intere 1,600.00 .00 1,600.00 200.00 .00 1,400.00 200.00 88 2,400.00 3617 Change in Fair Value of Investments .00 .00 .00 15.24 .00 211.97 (211.97) +++ (2.01) 3681 Special Assessment Princi 200.00 .00 200.00 .00 .00 .00 200.00 0 .00 Ala",'re,Alaaaeioz(.F RmAevnve 7bta& $2,300.00 $0.00 $2,300.00 $362.03 $0.00 $2,600.91 ($300.91) 113% $3,329.71 REVENUE TOTALS $42,260.00 $0.00 $42,260.00 $362.03 $0.00 $2,600.91 $39,659.09 6% $3,329.71 De^l:rartnae^i' 000 IR,eseui"rrae totals $42,260.00 $0.00 $42,260.00 $362.03 $0.00 $2,600.91 $39,659.09 6% $3,329.71 Fund 360"SllpeeliirillAssessrneintII::uind toCals $42,260.00 $0.00 $42,260.00 $362.03 $0.00 $2,600.91 $39,659.09 $3,329.71 Fund 363 .. S1tui"ee1t A. Stowur'mn Ca lIlp Coui"rs1t I@::::raui"rd Dej,.,rarhnnenp 000.. IReseui°rrae REVENUE F rwmf 11alaaace 3081 Beginning Fund Balance 140,680.00 .00 140,680.00 .00 .00 .00 140,680.00 0 .00 Fa.rmfflaaJaaaoeAautaLF $140,680.00 $0.00 $140,680.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $140,680.00 0% $0.00 .Agate:snaAouuAe:raaaaae:aataA 3333 3333.001 DoT Fund Exchange .00 .00 .00 333,586.00 .00 667,833.00 (667,833.00) +++ .00 3333 - Totals $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $333,586.00 $0.00 $667,833.00 ($667,833.00) +++ $0.00 3341 State Grants 500,000.00 .00 500,000.00 .00 .00 .00 500,000.00 0 .00 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:56:07 AM Page 13 of 23 109 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp /CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to /CCOUn IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpfllon Budget Amendments Budget Tr'ansacdons Encumbrances Tr'ansacdons Tr'ansacdons Pec'd PdorYear ToitaV Fund 363 .. S1tui"ee1t Su. Stowur'ma Ca lIlp Coui"rs1t I@::::raui"rd Dej,.,rarhnnenr 000 .. IIAeveurrrae REVENUE 7bta'& $500,000.00 $0.00 $500,000.00 $333,586.00 $0.00 $667,833.00 ($167,833.00) 134% $0.00 Plisr'e:,11xreou s RmAevnve, 3611 Interest from Investments 2,000.00 .00 2,000.00 5,007.85 .00 24,808.15 (22,808.15) 1240 5,114.44 3617 Change in Fair Value of Investments .00 .00 .00 424.01 .00 2,452.68 (2,452.68) +++ 772.50 3678 Developer Contributions .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 437,904.66 (437,904.66) +++ 214,833.24 Ttwa FA,, :s' Jai 3971 3971.140 Transfer From Street A7,s'oar',Axieeuars'fa"e'^u✓e^aarretauta'& $2,000.00 $0.00 $2,000.00 $5,431.86 $0.00 $465,165.49 ($463,165.49) 23258% $220,720.18 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 1,960,940.48 3971.376 Transfer From Street SDC 170,000.00 .00 170,000.00 29,752.13 .00 153,970.04 16,029.96 91 1,000,000.00 3971.377 Transfer From Storm SDC 67,320.00 .00 67,320.00 9,917.38 .00 40,971.85 26,348.15 61 114,126.00 3971 - Totals $237,320.00 $0.00 $237,320.00 $39,669.51 $0.00 $194,941.89 $42,378.11 82% $3,075,066.48 7ta'aas'A,,5'.tea ttuta'Js' $237,320.00 $0.00 $237,320.00 $39,669.51 $0.00 $194,941.89 $42,378.11 82% $3,075,066.48 REVENUE TOTALS $880,000.00 $0.00 $880,000.00 $378,687.37 $0.00 $1,327,940.38 ($447,940.38) 151% $3,295,786.66 De^I:rartnne^i' 000 IIA,eveurrrae totals $880,000.00 $0.00 $880,000.00 $378,687.37 $0.00 $1,327,940.38 ($447,940.38) 151% $3,295,786.66 Fund 363 Sheet &.Stowui'maCap Iaui'rs1tIl::uind toCals $880,000.00 $0.00 $880,000.00 $378,687.37 $0.00 $1,327,940.38 ($447,940.38) $3,295,786.66 Fund 364 .. IPauui°illas SII C Il"::uina't De^I:rarhnne nr 000 .. IIAeveurrrae REVENUE F Swmf 11alaaae°e^ 3081 Beginning Fund Balance 4,459,380.00 .00 4,459,380.00 .00 .00 .00 4,459,380.00 0 .00 Fa.r mf flaaIxice'^ 7bfa'& $4,459,380.00 $0.00 $4,459,380.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $4,459,380.00 0% $0.00 Claaa,rtaaF for n';;''rarue'& aaae'S.5"&u,to.oti,a. 3458 3458.501 Park's SDC's 1,400,000.00 .00 1,400,000.00 92,560.00 .00 1,824,607.00 (424,607.00) 130 1,781,863.00 3458 - Totals $1,400,000.00 $0.00 $1,400,000.00 $92,560.00 $0.00 $1,824,607.00 ($424,607.00) 130% $1,781,863.00 Cha'ml as fbi n' oor,P;s xmf °a"r' *,,'e s 7bta'ls' $1,400,000.00 $0.00 $1,400,000.00 $92,560.00 $0.00 $1,824,607.00 ($424,607.00) 130% $1,781,863.00 Alla'e'etlaaaews RmAevnve, 3611 Interest from Investments 35,000.00 .00 35,000.00 21,378.54 .00 134,357.67 (99,357.67) 384 102,174.51 3617 Change in Fair Value of Investments .00 .00 .00 2,196.86 .00 24,848.83 (24,848.83) +++ (141.02) Alis'ce^llaaaa'^ruars' Ro'^n✓e'^aarre 7btals' $35,000.00 $0.00 $35,000.00 $23,575.40 $0.00 $159,206.50 ($124,206.50) 455% $102,033.49 REVENUE TOTALS $5,894,380.00 $0.00 $5,894,380.00 $116,135.40 $0.00 $1,983,813.50 $3,910,566.50 34% $1,883,896.49 De^I:rartnae^i' 000 IIA,eveurrrae totals $5,894,380.00 $0.00 $5,894,380.00 $116,135.40 $0.00 $1,983,813.50 $3,910,566.50 34% $1,883,896.49 Fund .364 IPauui"'lllasSlP Cl:::uind total„a $5,894,380.00 $0.00 $5,894,380.00 $116,135.40 $0.00 $1,983,813.50 $3,910,566.50 $1,883,896.49 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:56:07 AM 110 Page 14 of 23 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp /CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to /CCOUn IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Pec'd PdorYear ToitaV Fund 376 .. "5111"'aui"rsllpowuii"'Ita tlillo in SIR C Il�:r:rrui"rd Dej,.,rarhnnenr 000 .. Illeveuwe REVENUE F 5r mf 11al earo°e;^ 3081 Beginning Fund Balance 12,938,430.00 .00 12,938,430.00 .00 .00 .00 12,938,430.00 0 .00 Fa.ramfflaIxice;^ /'hale $12,938,430.00 $0.00 $12,938,430.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $12,938,430.00 0% $0.00 t"lrae,rlaF for n';;''rrrue'& aere'S.5"&u,io.oti,r. 3458 3458.101 Transportation Impact Fees 2,000,000.00 .00 2,000,000.00 139,760.00 .00 1,235,694.65 764,305.35 62 1,988,328.61 3458 - Totals $2,000,000.00 $0.00 $2,000,000.00 $139,760.00 $0.00 $1,235,694.65 $764,305.35 62% $1,988,328.61 alr«o'ram/ar Ffbi S'oor,&xmf °a"ri^,r,'e s 7bta'ls' $2,000,000.00 $0.00 $2,000,000.00 $139,760.00 $0.00 $1,235,694.65 $764,305.35 62% $1,988,328.61 All 'o'e,11xrews RmAevnve, 3611 Interest from Investments 110,000.00 .00 110,000.00 50,875.49 .00 342,568.14 (232,568.14) 311 303,453.32 3617 Change in Fair Value of Investments .00 .00 .00 5,298.01 .00 71,021.70 (71,021.70) +++ (1,513.80) P,5'c'e,Axieoz(.Ffa"e;'^u✓evrrrelluta'ls' $110,000.00 $0.00 $110,000.00 $56,173.50 $0.00 $413,589.84 ($303,589.84) 376% $301,939.52 REVENUE TOTALS $15,048,430.00 $0.00 $15,048,430.00 $195,933.50 $0.00 $1,649,284.49 $13,399,145.51 11% $2,290,268.13 De^I:rartnne^i' 000 Ill,eveuiwe totals $15,048,430.00 $0.00 $15,048,430.00 $195,933.50 $0.00 $1,649,284.49 $13,399,145.51 11% $2,290,268.13 Fund 376 5"111"'aui"rsllpowui""tatlilloin SIP C Il::ui d toCals $15,048,430.00 $0.00 $15,048,430.00 $195,933.50 $0.00 $1,649,284.49 $13,399,145.51 $2,290,268.13 Fund 377 .. Sltoinn ScliX Il::uind De^l:rarhnne nr 000 .. Illeveuwe REVENUE F5ramf11al ace,'^ 3081 Beginning Fund Balance 1,021,790.00 .00 1,021,790.00 .00 .00 .00 1,021,790.00 0 .00 Fa.ramfflaIxice;^7bfa'& $1,021,790.00 $0.00 $1,021,790.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $1,021,790.00 0% $0.00 t"lrae,rlaF for n';;''rrrue'& asre'F.5"&u,le.oti,r. 3458 3458.201 Storm SDC's 60,000.00 .00 60,000.00 718.00 .00 53,062.60 6,937.40 88 105,664.27 3458 - Totals $60,000.00 $0.00 $60,000.00 $718.00 $0.00 $53,062.60 $6,937.40 88% $105,664.27 Charamle;',Ffbi l"oor,&xmf 5ei^,r,'es 7btals' $60,000.00 $0.00 $60,000.00 $718.00 $0.00 $53,062.60 $6,937.40 88% $105,664.27 All 'o'e,11xrews RmAevnve, 3611 Interest from Investments 10,000.00 .00 10,000.00 3,687.64 .00 26,678.68 (16,678.68) 267 26,450.24 3617 Change in Fair Value of Investments .00 .00 .00 409.78 .00 5,912.98 (5,912.98) +++ (48.78) P,5'c'e,Axieoz(.Ffa"e;'^u✓evrrre5luta'ls' $10,000.00 $0.00 $10,000.00 $4,097.42 $0.00 $32,591.66 ($22,591.66) 326% $26,401.46 REVENUE TOTALS $1,091,790.00 $0.00 $1,091,790.00 $4,815.42 $0.00 $85,654.26 $1,006,135.74 8% $132,065.73 De^l:rartnne^i' 000 Ill,eveuiwe totals $1,091,790.00 $0.00 $1,091,790.00 $4,815.42 $0.00 $85,654.26 $1,006,135.74 8% $132,065.73 Fund 377 Sltoinn SIPah Il::mind "boo al„a $1,091,790.00 $0.00 $1,091,790.00 $4,815.42 $0.00 $85,654.26 $1,006,135.74 $132,065.73 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:56:07 AM Page 15 of 23 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Tr'ansacdons Encumbrances Tr'ansacdons Tr'ansacdons Pec'd PdorYear ToitaV Fund 465 .. Se err' Cap A„oins1t Il"":uind Dej,.,rarhnnenr 000 .. IAeveui°rrae REVENUE Tt«air FA,, :s' .tar 3971 3971.472 Transfer From Sewer 2,035,000.00 .00 2,035,000.00 2,817.25 .00 89,108.93 1,945,891.07 4 1,238,165.78 3971.475 Transfer From Sewer SDC 100,000.00 .00 100,000.00 .00 .00 (1,437.00) 101,437.00 -1 2,035,035.01 3971 - Totals $2,135,000.00 $0.00 $2,135,000.00 $2,817.25 $0.00 $87,671.93 $2,047,328.07 4% $3,273,200.79 Ttxi'F'9',,,5'.ter 7bta'Js' $2,135,000.00 $0.00 $2,135,000.00 $2,817.25 $0.00 $87,671.93 $2,047,328.07 4% $3,273,200.79 REVENUE TOTALS $2,135,000.00 $0.00 $2,135,000.00 $2,817.25 $0.00 $87,671.93 $2,047,328.07 4% $3,273,200.79 De^I:rartnne^i' 000 IA,eveurrrae totals $2,135,000.00 $0.00 $2,135,000.00 $2,817.25 $0.00 $87,671.93 $2,047,328.07 4% $3,273,200.79 Fund 465 Se eui'Carllploins1tIl::uind toCals $2,135,000.00 $0.00 $2,135,000.00 $2,817.25 $0.00 $87,671.93 $2,047,328.07 $3,273,200.79 Fund 466 .. ar1teur' Cap Coins1t Il"":uind De^I:rarhnne nr 000 IAeveui°rrae REVENUE F rwmf 11alaaace 3081 Beginning Fund Balance 719,800.00 .00 719,800.00 .00 .00 .00 719,800.00 0 .00 Fa.r mf flaaaaaaaoe 7bfa& $719,800.00 $0.00 $719,800.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $719,800.00 0% $0.00 Alisce:,11xieous RmAevnve, 3611 Interest from Investments 8,000.00 .00 8,000.00 .00 .00 9,831.84 (1,831.84) 123 6,920.07 3617 Change in Fair Value of Investments .00 .00 .00 85.04 .00 1,287.19 (1,287.19) +++ 445.39 3691 Sale of Surplus Property 800,000.00 .00 800,000.00 .00 .00 .00 800,000.00 0 .00 3699 Other Miscellaneous Income .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 1,458.00 Alas'oar',Axieeuars'fa"e'^u✓e^aarretauta'& $808,000.00 $0.00 $808,000.00 $85.04 $0.00 $11,119.03 $796,880.97 1% $8,823.46 Ttaas9 o'^a, Di 3971 3971.470 Transfer From Water 354,000.00 .00 354,000.00 64,805.50 .00 64,805.50 289,194.50 18 1,364,931.77 3971.474 Transfer From Water SDC 125,000.00 550,000.00 675,000.00 650,000.00 .00 650,000.00 25,000.00 96 1,475,134.49 3971 - Totals $479,000.00 $550,000.00 $1,029,000.00 $714,805.50 $0.00 $714,805.50 $314,194.50 69% $2,840,066.26 7ta'aas'A,,5'.tea 7tuta'Js' $479,000.00 $550,000.00 $1,029,000.00 $714,805.50 $0.00 $714,805.50 $314,194.50 69% $2,840,066.26 REVENUE TOTALS $2,006,800.00 $550,000.00 $2,556,800.00 $714,890.54 $0.00 $725,924.53 $1,830,875.47 28% $2,848,889.72 De^I:rartnne^i' 000 IA,eveurrrae totals $2,006,800.00 $550,000.00 $2,556,800.00 $714,890.54 $0.00 $725,924.53 $1,830,875.47 28% $2,848,889.72 Fund 466 Wateiii' Cap loinst Il::uind toCals $2,006,800.00 $550,000.00 $2,556,800.00 $714,890.54 $0.00 $725,924.53 $1,830,875.47 $2,848,889.72 Fund 070 .. ar1teur' Il"":uind De^I:rarhnne nr 000 .. IIAeveurrrae REVENUE F rwmf 11alaaace 3081 Beginning Fund Balance 1,834,600.00 .00 1,834,600.00 .00 .00 .00 1,834,600.00 0 .00 Fa.r mf flaaIxice'^ 7bfa'& $1,834,600.00 $0.00 $1,834,600.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $1,834,600.00 0% $0.00 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:56:07 AM Page 16 of 23 112 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp /CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to /CCOUn IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd PdorYear ToitaV Fund 070 .. a teui Il�:r'rrund Dej,.,rarhnnenr 000 .. IReveimje REVENUE t"lrae,rlaF 7o r n';;''rrrue& aere5.5"o: vir,.aF 3434 3434.101 Water Sales Revenue 4,926,750.00 20,000.00 4,946,750.00 342,767.68 .00 3,248,278.48 1,698,471.52 66 4,871,497.10 3434.102 New Services 75,000.00 .00 75,000.00 6,507.52 .00 32,119.53 42,880.47 43 78,341.48 3434.103 Re -connection Fees 20,000.00 .00 20,000.00 1,825.00 .00 12,305.00 7,695.00 62 21,155.00 3434.104 Vacations 2,200.00 .00 2,200.00 210.00 .00 2,135.00 65.00 97 2,380.00 3434.106 NSF Check Fee 1,000.00 .00 1,000.00 75.00 .00 1,115.00 (115.00) 112 1,305.00 3434.108 Bulk Water Sales 2,000.00 .00 2,000.00 410.16 .00 32,303.11 (30,303.11) 1615 7,003.94 3434.111 Collections 500.00 .00 500.00 .00 .00 737.89 (237.89) 148 .00 3434.112 Late Fees 70,000.00 .00 70,000.00 7,090.00 .00 44,550.00 25,450.00 64 76,294.77 3434 - Totals $5,097,450.00 $20,000.00 $5,117,450.00 $358,885.36 $0.00 $3,373,544.01 $1,743,905.99 66% $5,057,977.29 alr«o'rgar F fbi S'oor,& xmf °a"ri^ ,,'e s 7bta'ls' $5,097,450.00 $20,000.00 $5,117,450.00 $358,885.36 $0.00 $3,373,544.01 $1,743,905.99 66% $5,057,977.29 Plisce,11xieous RmAevnve, 3611 Interest from Investments 50,000.00 .00 50,000.00 5,466.90 .00 36,883.80 13,116.20 74 66,334.74 3617 Change in Fair Value of Investments .00 .00 .00 464.92 .00 10,296.75 (10,296.75) +++ (55.88) 3625 Facilities Rent 60,000.00 .00 60,000.00 14,773.05 .00 46,123.71 13,876.29 77 60,051.28 3691 Sale of Surplus Property 2,000.00 .00 2,000.00 .00 .00 .00 2,000.00 0 .00 3699 Other Miscellaneous Income 6,000.00 .00 6,000.00 .00 .00 1,251.33 4,748.67 21 7,038.95 P,5'c'e^lar«rdreoz(.Ffa"e;'^u✓evrrreltuta'ls' $118,000.00 $0.00 $118,000.00 $20,704.87 $0.00 $94,555.59 $23,444.41 80% $133,369.09 REVENUE TOTALS $7,050,050.00 $20,000.00 $7,070,050.00 $379,590.23 $0.00 $3,468,099.60 $3,601,950.40 49% $5,191,346.38 De^I:rartnne^i' 000 IR,eveurrrje toal„a $7,050,050.00 $20,000.00 $7,070,050.00 $379,590.23 $0.00 $3,468,099.60 $3,601,950.40 49% $5,191,346.38 Fund 470 Wateiii,Il::uind toal„a $7,050,050.00 $20,000.00 $7,070,050.00 $379,590.23 $0.00 $3,468,099.60 $3,601,950.40 $5,191,346.38 Fund 472... 0eweui° Il'::ui d De^I:rarhnne nr 000 .. IReveimje REVENUE F 5r mf Valance 3081 Beginning Fund Balance 15,161,480.00 500,000.00 15,661,480.00 .00 .00 .00 15,661,480.00 0 .00 Fa.ramfflaIxice;^7bfa'& $15,161,480.00 $500,000.00 $15,661,480.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $15,661,480.00 0% $0.00 t"lrae,rlaF for n';;''rrrue& ancf 5&u,lo.ati,r. 3434 3434.112 Late Fees 77,000.00 .00 77,000.00 7,090.00 .00 44,550.00 32,450.00 58 76,294.76 3434 - Totals $77,000.00 $0.00 $77,000.00 $7,090.00 $0.00 $44,550.00 $32,450.00 58% $76,294.76 3435 3435.101 Sewer System Revenue 9,350,000.00 .00 9,350,000.00 804,537.69 .00 5,858,335.60 3,491,664.40 63 9,800,131.55 3435.103 Septage Dumping 100,000.00 .00 100,000.00 25,534.08 .00 90,452.54 9,547.46 90 130,288.72 3435.111 Collections 500.00 .00 500.00 .00 .00 737.93 (237.93) 148 .00 3435 - Totals $9,450,500.00 $0.00 $9,450,500.00 $830,071.77 $0.00 $5,949,526.07 $3,500,973.93 63% $9,930,420.27 Charamle;',F fbi l"oor,& xmf 5"ei^ ,,'es /totals' $9,527,500.00 $0.00 $9,527,500.00 $837,161.77 $0.00 $5,994,076.07 $3,533,423.93 63% $10,006,715.03 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:56:07 AM Page 17 of 23 113 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp /CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to /CCOUn IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd PdorYear ToitaV Fund 472... Seaaeui° Il'"'saurrat Dej,.,rarhnnenr 000 .. IReveurrsae REVENUE aluf Fb1frA's 3535 Sewer Discharge Fines .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 100.00 (100.00) +++ .00 FArse F «ssmPF°rwA,,ft s 7btals $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $100.00 ($100.00) +++ $0.00 Plisce,11xieous RmAevnve, 3611 Interest from Investments 190,000.00 .00 190,000.00 68,320.22 .00 435,905.21 (245,905.21) 229 353,296.00 3617 Change in Fair Value of Investments .00 .00 .00 6,813.37 .00 88,277.06 (88,277.06) +++ (6,428.61) 3699 3699 Other Miscellaneous Income 1,500.00 .00 1,500.00 .00 .00 .00 1,500.00 0 75.00 3699.472 PGE Energy Partner Program (WWTP) 4,000.00 .00 4,000.00 .00 .00 3,279.82 720.18 82 5,646.83 3699 - Totals $5,500.00 $0.00 $5,500.00 $0.00 $0.00 $3,279.82 $2,220.18 60% $5,721.83 Alas'oar',Axieeuaas'fa"e'^h✓e^aarrettuta'Js' $195,500.00 $0.00 $195,500.00 $75,133.59 $0.00 $527,462.09 ($331,962.09) 270% $352,589.22 REVENUE TOTALS $24,884,480.00 $500,000.00 $25,384,480.00 $912,295.36 $0.00 $6,521,638.16 $18,862,841.84 26% $10,359,304.25 De^I:rartnse^i' 000 IReveuirsae totals $24,884,480.00 $500,000.00 $25,384,480.00 $912,295.36 $0.00 $6,521,638.16 $18,862,841.84 26% $10,359,304.25 Fund 072. Seaaeui I@"sauirat"�otal„a $24,884,480.00 $500,000.00 $25,384,480.00 $912,295.36 $0.00 $6,521,638.16 $18,862,841.84 $10,359,304.25 Fund 074 .• a teui ScliX Il�::ui nd De^l:rarhnne nr 000 .. IReveurrsae REVENUE F Swmf 11alaase°e^ 3081 Beginning Fund Balance 2,967,400.00 550,000.00 3,517,400.00 .00 .00 .00 3,517,400.00 0 .00 Fa.r mf flaaIxice'^ 7bfals $2,967,400.00 $550,000.00 $3,517,400.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $3,517,400.00 0% $0.00 t"laaag as for n';;''reru & aaae5.5"&u,to.atis. 3458 3458.301 Water SDC's 1,000,000.00 .00 1,000,000.00 78,880.00 .00 482,519.60 517,480.40 48 756,403.95 3458 - Totals $1,000,000.00 $0.00 $1,000,000.00 $78,880.00 $0.00 $482,519.60 $517,480.40 48% $756,403.95 tlsarelaFfba l"oor,Pxmf 5ri^,r,'e s /totals' $1,000,000.00 $0.00 $1,000,000.00 $78,880.00 $0.00 $482,519.60 $517,480.40 48% $756,403.95 Allseellxaeous RmAevnve, 3611 Interest from Investments 50,000.00 .00 50,000.00 15,070.94 .00 98,971.97 (48,971.97) 198 107,801.77 3617 Change in Fair Value of Investments .00 .00 .00 1,539.97 .00 22,346.09 (22,346.09) +++ 401.85 Alis'a'e^Visas'^euars' Ra'^n✓e'^aarre 7bta'ls' $50,000.00 $0.00 $50,000.00 $16,610.91 $0.00 $121,318.06 ($71,318.06) 243% $108,203.62 REVENUE TOTALS $4,017,400.00 $550,000.00 $4,567,400.00 $95,490.91 $0.00 $603,837.66 $3,963,562.34 13% $864,607.57 De^I:rartnae^i' 000 IR,eveurrsae totals $4,017,400.00 $550,000.00 $4,567,400.00 $95,490.91 $0.00 $603,837.66 $3,963,562.34 13% $864,607.57 Fund 074 stein ScliX Il::uirat toCals $4,017,400.00 $550,000.00 $4,567,400.00 $95,490.91 $0.00 $603,837.66 $3,963,562.34 $864,607.57 Fund 475 .. Seaaeui° ScliX I@""wind De^I:rarhnne nr 000 IReveui°rsae REVENUE F Swmf 11alaase°e^ 3081 Beginning Fund Balance 558,280.00 .00 558,280.00 .00 .00 .00 558,280.00 0 .00 Fa.r mf flaIxice^ 7bfals $558,280.00 $0.00 $558,280.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $558,280.00 0% $0.00 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:56:07 AM 114 Page 18 of 23 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp /CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to /CCOUn IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd PdorYear ToitaV Fund 475 .. Seweui° ScliX Il'::ui d Dej,.,rarhnnenr 000 .. IReveimje REVENUE t"lrae,rlaF Tour T;;''rurue& aere5.5"o: vir,.aF 3458 3458.401 Sewer SDC's 1,300,000.00 .00 1,300,000.00 59,540.00 .00 1,235,951.40 64,048.60 95 1,329,366.24 3458 - Totals $1,300,000.00 $0.00 $1,300,000.00 $59,540.00 $0.00 $1,235,951.40 $64,048.60 95% $1,329,366.24 tlrarrlaFtree l"oor,&xmf 5ri^,r,'e s 7bta'ls' $1,300,000.00 $0.00 $1,300,000.00 $59,540.00 $0.00 $1,235,951.40 $64,048.60 95% $1,329,366.24 Plisce,11xieous RmAevnve, 3611 Interest from Investments 50,000.00 .00 50,000.00 13,728.49 .00 87,894.91 (37,894.91) 176 80,592.39 3617 Change in Fair Value of Investments .00 .00 .00 1,419.87 .00 16,967.04 (16,967.04) +++ 1,823.87 P,5'oe^llrrdreoz(.F'fa"e'^h✓e^urrueltuta'ls' $50,000.00 $0.00 $50,000.00 $15,148.36 $0.00 $104,861.95 ($54,861.95) 210% $82,416.26 REVENUE TOTALS $1,908,280.00 $0.00 $1,908,280.00 $74,688.36 $0.00 $1,340,813.35 $567,466.65 70% $1,411,782.50 De^I:rartnne^i' 000 IR,eveurrrje toal„a $1,908,280.00 $0.00 $1,908,280.00 $74,688.36 $0.00 $1,340,813.35 $567,466.65 70% $1,411,782.50 Fund 475 Seweui Soli , Il::uii d "�"eat'als $1,908,280.00 $0.00 $1,908,280.00 $74,688.36 $0.00 $1,340,813.35 $567,466.65 $1,411,782.50 Fund 568 Infouioinatllloin I"'eellhuinolllau07 ll�:r:rrund De^l:rarhnne nr 000 IReveui°rrje REVENUE F Swmf Valance 3081 Beginning Fund Balance 464,000.00 .00 464,000.00 .00 .00 .00 464,000.00 0 .00 Fa.r mf flaIxice 7bfa'& $464,000.00 $0.00 $464,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $464,000.00 0% $0.00 t"lrae,rlaF four T;;''rurue& asre5.5"&u,lo.ati,r. 3421 3421.002 Reimbursements Hubbard .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 1,572.50 3421.003 Reimbursements Mt Angel 4,000.00 .00 4,000.00 2,613.75 .00 3,208.75 791.25 80 4,018.75 3421.004 Reimbursements Silverton 28,000.00 .00 28,000.00 5,546.25 .00 10,455.00 17,545.00 37 30,438.00 3421.005 Reimbursements Aurora FD 1,000.00 .00 1,000.00 467.50 .00 510.00 490.00 51 1,168.75 3421.006 Reimbursements Monitor FD 500.00 .00 500.00 .00 .00 .00 500.00 0 63.75 3421.007 Reimbursements Mt Angel FD 2,000.00 .00 2,000.00 382.50 .00 2,210.00 (210.00) 110 (1,673.75) 3421.008 Reimbursement METCOM (Norcom) 60,000.00 .00 60,000.00 15,300.42 .00 30,654.88 29,345.12 51 68,729.18 3421.009 Reimbursement Gervais 2,000.00 .00 2,000.00 1,487.50 .00 4,228.75 (2,228.75) 211 3,688.75 3421.010 Reimbursement Woodburn Fire Dist .00 .00 .00 1,275.00 .00 1,423.75 (1,423.75) +++ 1,931.25 3421.018 Reimbursements Monitor Fire District .00 .00 .00 42.50 .00 42.50 (42.50) +++ 21.25 3421.019 Reimbursements Hubbard Fire Department .00 .00 .00 21.25 .00 191.25 (191.25) +++ .00 3421.020 Reimbursements Silver Falls Library .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 21.25 (21.25) +++ 191.25 3421 - Totals $97,500.00 $0.00 $97,500.00 $27,136.67 $0.00 $52,946.13 $44,553.87 54% $110,149.68 3422 3422.002 Rec Mgmt (RMS) Hubbard 14,320.00 .00 14,320.00 3,580.00 .00 7,160.00 7,160.00 50 13,300.00 3422.003 Rec Mgmt (RMS) Mt Angel 14,650.00 .00 14,650.00 3,662.50 .00 7,325.00 7,325.00 50 13,700.00 3422.004 Rec Mgmt (RMS) Silverton 42,510.00 .00 42,510.00 10,627.50 .00 21,255.00 21,255.00 50 40,000.00 3422.007 Rec Mgmt (RMS) Mt Angel FD 1,220.00 .00 1,220.00 305.00 .00 610.00 610.00 50 1,100.00 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:56:07 AM Page 19 of 23 115 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp /CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to /CCOUn IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Rec'd PdorYear ToitaV Fund 568Infoiioi'natliioin.I.eollPruinulllogyI@�:r:rrund Dej,.,rarhnnenr 000 .. IReveui°uuue REVENUE t"lrae,rlaF for n';;''rurue& aere5.5"o: vir,.aF 3422 3422.011 Rec Mgmt (RMS) Stayton PD 14,190.00 .00 14,190.00 3,547.50 .00 7,095.00 7,095.00 50 13,100.00 3422.012 Rec Mgmt (RMS) Turner PD 3,780.00 .00 3,780.00 945.00 .00 1,890.00 1,890.00 50 3,500.00 3422.017 Rec Mgmt (RMS) Aumsville PD 4,060.00 .00 4,060.00 1,015.00 .00 2,030.00 2,030.00 50 3,800.00 3422 - Totals $94,730.00 $0.00 $94,730.00 $23,682.50 $0.00 $47,365.00 $47,365.00 50% $88,500.00 aluaraulaF tree l"oor,& xmf °a"ri^ ,,'e s 7bta'ls' $192,230.00 $0.00 $192,230.00 $50,819.17 $0.00 $100,311.13 $91,918.87 52% $198,649.68 Plisce,11xieous RmAevnve, 3611 Interest from Investments 5,000.00 .00 5,000.00 725.65 .00 4,098.49 901.51 82 6,877.00 3617 Change in Fair Value of Investments .00 .00 .00 62.74 .00 1,558.56 (1,558.56) +++ (32.64) 3652 3652.001 IT Revenue - General Fund 1,025,220.00 .00 1,025,220.00 85,435.00 .00 598,045.00 427,175.00 58 893,949.96 3652.110 IT Revenue - Transit 32,850.00 .00 32,850.00 2,737.50 .00 19,162.50 13,687.50 58 26,040.00 3652.123 IT Revenue - Building Inspection 42,300.00 .00 42,300.00 3,525.00 .00 24,675.00 17,625.00 58 31,500.00 3652.140 IT Revenue - Street 45,110.00 .00 45,110.00 3,759.16 .00 26,314.12 18,795.88 58 28,140.00 3652.470 IT Revenue - Water 64,910.00 .00 64,910.00 5,409.16 .00 37,864.12 27,045.88 58 59,220.00 3652.472 IT Revenue - Sewer 125,520.00 .00 125,520.00 10,460.00 .00 73,220.00 52,300.00 58 113,400.00 3652.720 IT Revenue - Urban Renewal 9,450.00 .00 9,450.00 787.50 .00 5,512.50 3,937.50 58 8,820.00 3652 - Totals $1,345,360.00 $0.00 $1,345,360.00 $112,113.32 $0.00 $784,793.24 $560,566.76 58% $1,161,069.96 3699 Other Miscellaneous Income 200.00 .00 200.00 .00 .00 2,769.37 (2,569.37) 1385 106.00 P,5'c'e^lau«rdreoz(.Ffa"e;'^u✓evrrueltuta'ls' $1,350,560.00 $0.00 $1,350,560.00 $112,901.71 $0.00 $793,219.66 $557,340.34 59% $1,168,020.32 REVENUE TOTALS $2,006,790.00 $0.00 $2,006,790.00 $163,720.88 $0.00 $893,530.79 $1,113,259.21 45% $1,366,670.00 De^I:rartnne^i' 000 IR,eveurrrje totals $2,006,790.00 $0.00 $2,006,790.00 $163,720.88 $0.00 $893,530.79 $1,113,259.21 45% $1,366,670.00 Fund 568''.Infouonor'tllloin"I"'eellhuinolllogyll::uuurut toCals $2,006,790.00 $0.00 $2,006,790.00 $163,720.88 $0.00 $893,530.79 $1,113,259.21 $1,366,670.00 Fund 581 Insuuuiaunce Il""'uuund De^I:rarhnne nr 000 .. IReveuruuue REVENUE F 5r mf Valance 3081 Beginning Fund Balance 753,400.00 50,000.00 803,400.00 .00 .00 .00 803,400.00 0 .00 Fa.ramfflaIxice;^7bfa'& $753,400.00 $50,000.00 $803,400.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $803,400.00 0% $0.00 Plisce,11xieous RmAevnve, 3611 Interest from Investments 3617 Change in Fair Value of Investments 3658 3658.101 General Liability 3658.104 Workers Comp 5,000.00 .00 5,000.00 1,144.16 .00 5,595.22 (595.22) 112 13,625.87 .00 .00 .00 82.89 .00 3,173.39 (3,173.39) +++ (159.82) 521,050.00 .00 521,050.00 43,420.83 .00 303,945.81 217,104.19 58 523,090.08 230,000.00 .00 230,000.00 19,166.67 .00 134,166.69 95,833.31 58 249,999.96 3658 - Totals $751,050.00 $0.00 $751,050.00 $62,587.50 $0.00 $438,112.50 $312,937.50 58% $773,090.04 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:56:07 AM Page 20 of 23 116 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month YTD YTD Budget - YTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Pec'd PdorYear ToitaV Fund P'BPC1 In uriiaiince I@�:r:rrui"rd Dej,.,rarhnnenr 000 .. 111eveurnue REVENUE Ada",'r'e:,11ru ieous RmAevnve, 3699 Other Miscellaneous Income 1,000.00 .00 1,000.00 .00 .00 25.00 975.00 2 2,559.54 Ali,S'oe,Axieeuaas' fa"e'^u✓e^aarue 7bta'& $757,050.00 $0.00 $757,050.00 $63,814.55 $0.00 $446,906.11 $310,143.89 59% $789,115.63 REVENUE TOTALS $1,510,450.00 $50,000.00 $1,560,450.00 $63,814.55 $0.00 $446,906.11 $1,113,543.89 29% $789,115.63 Ite^I:rartnne^i' 000 11,eveu"nue toal„a $1,510,450.00 $50,000.00 $1,560,450.00 $63,814.55 $0.00 $446,906.11 $1,113,543.89 29% $789,115.63 Fund 581 ',Insuuu:uuuee Il::uund toal„a $1,510,450.00 $50,000.00 $1,560,450.00 $63,814.55 $0.00 $446,906.11 $1,113,543.89 $789,115.63 Fund 591... li"quuiii111uneint I11,e111111uueeurneint II""uuruu't De^I:rarhnne nr 000 1leveu°nue REVENUE Fr,u mf Valence 3081 Beginning Fund Balance 1,086,640.00 .00 1,086,640.00 .00 .00 .00 1,086,640.00 0 .00 Fa.rmfflaIxic'e'^7bfa'& $1,086,640.00 $0.00 $1,086,640.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $1,086,640.00 0% $0.00 Ala".'e'e,11xreoaus RmAevnve, 3611 Interest from Investments 8,000.00 .00 8,000.00 3,738.19 .00 24,481.86 (16,481.86) 306 23,590.60 3617 Change in Fair Value of Investments .00 .00 .00 380.22 .00 5,203.56 (5,203.56) +++ 153.03 Alas'ae,Axieeuars'fa"e'^u✓e^aarre 7bta'Js' $8,000.00 $0.00 $8,000.00 $4,118.41 $0.00 $29,685.42 ($21,685.42) 371% $23,743.63 Ttaas9 a'^a: Di 3971 3971.140 Transfer From Street 60,000.00 .00 60,000.00 5,000.00 .00 35,000.00 25,000.00 58 60,000.00 3971.470 Transfer From Water 60,000.00 .00 60,000.00 5,000.00 .00 35,000.00 25,000.00 58 60,000.00 3971.472 Transfer From Sewer 60,000.00 .00 60,000.00 5,000.00 .00 35,000.00 25,000.00 58 60,000.00 3971 - Totals $180,000.00 $0.00 $180,000.00 $15,000.00 $0.00 $105,000.00 $75,000.00 58% $180,000.00 7iesists^a,s'Di ltutaLF $180,000.00 $0.00 $180,000.00 $15,000.00 $0.00 $105,000.00 $75,000.00 58% $180,000.00 REVENUE TOTALS $1,274,640.00 $0.00 $1,274,640.00 $19,118.41 $0.00 $134,685.42 $1,139,954.58 11% $203,743.63 Ite^I:rartnue^i' 000 11,eveu"nue toal„a $1,274,640.00 $0.00 $1,274,640.00 $19,118.41 $0.00 $134,685.42 $1,139,954.58 11% $203,743.63 Fund 591 lEquulii111uneint 111e11111laceuneint Il::uund toal„a $1,274,640.00 $0.00 $1,274,640.00 $19,118.41 $0.00 $134,685.42 $1,139,954.58 $203,743.63 Fund 1193 .. 11,esueuve tou°' IV'al"'!IRS De^I:rarhnne nr 000 1leveu°nue REVENUE r,u mf 11aleasce 3081 Beginning Fund Balance 391,120.00 .00 391,120.00 .00 .00 .00 391,120.00 0 .00 Fa,umfflaIxic°e'^t'tstas's' $391,120.00 $0.00 $391,120.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $391,120.00 0% $0.00 Ttausta'^a,' .tau 3971 3971.001 Transfer From General Fund .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 123,740.04 3971.110 Transfer From Transit .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 8,799.96 3971.123 Transfer From Building .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 8,840.04 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:56:07 AM Page 21 of 23 117 WQODBURN Inckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month XTD XTD Budget - XTD %u Used/ Account Account Descr'Ilptiion Budget Amendments Budget Tr'ansacitfions Encumbrances Tr'ansacitfions Tr'ansacitfions Rec'd Pr'IorYear ToitaV Fund 693 .. IR,e eui°'ve foul°' IVaI"'!IR,S Dej,.,rarhnne np 000 .. IReveui°uuae REVENUE Tt«air FA,, :s' .tar 3971 3971.140 Transfer From Street .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 11,820.00 3971.470 Transfer From Water .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 19,230.00 3971.472 Transfer From Sewer .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 26,180.04 3971.568 Transfer from Information Technology .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 5,700.00 3971.581 Transfer From Insurance .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 830.04 3971.720 Transfer from Urban Renewal .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 2,859.96 3971 - Totals $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 +++ $208,000.08 7iaiiFA,,,s'.tar 7autaLF $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 +++ $208,000.08 REVENUE TOTALS $391,120.00 $0.00 $391,120.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $391,120.00 0% $208,000.08 De^I:rartnne^i' 000 IR,eveui"uuae totals $391,120.00 $0.00 $391,120.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $391,120.00 0% $208,000.08 Fund 693 IR,e eui"'va team' IVaI"'IIRS totals $391,120.00 $0.00 $391,120.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $391,120.00 $208,000.08 Fund 695 .• IlLarvellk IBIIParellla "I"1u"'uaw1t II::uaurrd Dej,.,rarhnne np 000 .. IReveui°uuae REVENUE F rwmf 11alaauce 3081 Beginning Fund Balance 32,690.00 .00 32,690.00 .00 .00 .00 32,690.00 0 .00 Fa.r mf 11aaaaauoe 7bfa'& $32,690.00 $0.00 $32,690.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $32,690.00 0% $0.00 Ala",'r'all,iieous RmAevnve, 3611 Interest from Investments 500.00 .00 500.00 125.49 .00 852.54 (352.54) 171 798.86 3617 Change in Fair Value of Investments .00 .00 .00 13.25 .00 180.00 (180.00) +++ .52 3673 Donations -Police .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 2,167.00 (2,167.00) +++ .00 P*,soe,AJiieioz(.F fu"m✓evnve 7btats' $500.00 $0.00 $500.00 $138.74 $0.00 $3,199.54 ($2,699.54) 640% $799.38 REVENUE TOTALS $33,190.00 $0.00 $33,190.00 $138.74 $0.00 $3,199.54 $29,990.46 10% $799.38 De^I:rartnne^i' 000 IR,eveui"uuae totals $33,190.00 $0.00 $33,190.00 $138.74 $0.00 $3,199.54 $29,990.46 10% $799.38 Fund 695 IlLarvellk IBIIParellla Iui'uav1t II::u ind totals $33,190.00 $0.00 $33,190.00 $138.74 $0.00 $3,199.54 $29,990.46 $799.38 Fund 72.0 .• LhilIlbarurr IR,eui"re arlll II::uaurrd Dej,.,rarhnnenr 000..1 REVENUE F rwmf 11alaauce 3081 Beginning Fund Balance 1,187,230.00 .00 1,187,230.00 .00 .00 .00 1,187,230.00 0 .00 Fa.rmf11aalaim'^7bfa& $1,187,230.00 $0.00 $1,187,230.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $1,187,230.00 0% $0.00 TlAos 3111 Property Tax - Current 1,088,000.00 .00 1,088,000.00 23,625.45 .00 1,047,276.67 40,723.33 96 912,532.50 3112 Property Tax - Delinquent 16,000.00 .00 16,000.00 693.53 .00 12,495.15 3,504.85 78 15,485.59 tIAx F'ttutaLF $1,104,000.00 $0.00 $1,104,000.00 $24,318.98 $0.00 $1,059,771.82 $44,228.18 96% $928,018.09 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:56:07 AM Page 22 of 23 118 WQODBURN nckide R(Aklp CCOLInt and IR(AklIp to ACCOUnt IncorpuraIcd t889 Adopted Budget Amended Current Month YTD YTD Budget - YTD %u Used/ Account Account Descdjpflon Budget Amendments Budget Transacdons Encumbrances Transacdons Transacdons Pec'd PdorYear ToitaV Fund 72.0 .. Uur'IIbain ICA,eine alll Il�:rbui"rd Dej,.,rarhnne np 000 .. IIAeveiwe REVENUE .taro:sar�ouuAo:rorsr�o:artv9 3341 State Grants .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 +++ 103,720.20 t rto s� npor�r r�o rtv97btaLF $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 +++ $103,720.20 Ala",'r'e:,11raareou s RmAevnve, 3611 Interest from Investments 20,000.00 .00 20,000.00 5,615.72 .00 28,311.76 (8,311.76) 142 38,783.14 3617 Change in Fair Value of Investments .00 .00 .00 412.79 .00 7,013.58 (7,013.58) +++ 681.59 Alis'r'e',Axis'oz(.F'Rm✓e'^arrre7btaLF $20,000.00 $0.00 $20,000.00 $6,028.51 $0.00 $35,325.34 ($15,325.34) 177% $39,464.73 REVENUE TOTALS $2,311,230.00 $0.00 $2,311,230.00 $30,347.49 $0.00 $1,095,097.16 $1,216,132.84 47% $1,071,203.02 Ite^I:rartnne^i' 000 IIA,eveuiwe toals $2,311,230.00 $0.00 $2,311,230.00 $30,347.49 $0.00 $1,095,097.16 $1,216,132.84 47% $1,071,203.02 Fund 72.0 1Foillbain IIA,einewaulll Il:bind toals $2,311,230.00 $0.00 $2,311,230.00 $30,347.49 $0.00 $1,095,097.16 $1,216,132.84 $1,071,203.02 Grand �o�als $130,286,350.00 $2,680,000.00 $132,966,350.00 $4,670,132.00 $0.00 $41,157,298.34 $91,809,051.66 $69,473,348.53 Run by Karen AIC on 02/13/2024 09:56:07 AM 119 Page 23 of 23 Accounts Payable Report 120 City of Woodburn Payment Register From Payment Date: 1/1/2024 - To Payment Date: 1/31/2024 Reconciled/ Transaction Reconciled Number Date Status Void Reason Voided Date Source Payee Name Amount Amount Difference AP-A/P - Accounts Payable Check 152002 01/02/2024 Reconciled 01/08/2024 Utility Management ESTATE OF JANICE DAVIDSON $60.06 $60.06 $0.00 Refund 152003 01/02/2024 Reconciled 01/08/2024 Utility Management LENNAR NW LLC $53.50 $53.50 $0.00 Refund 152004 01/02/2024 Reconciled 01/08/2024 Utility Management LENNAR NW LLC $37.38 $37.38 $0.00 Refund 152005 01/02/2024 Reconciled 01/08/2024 Utility Management LENNAR NW LLC $48.92 $48.92 $0.00 Refund 152006 01/02/2024 Reconciled 01/08/2024 Utility Management LENNAR NW LLC $54.05 $54.05 $0.00 Refund 152007 01/02/2024 Reconciled 01/08/2024 Utility Management LENNAR NW LLC $49.31 $49.31 $0.00 Refund 152008 01/02/2024 Reconciled 01/08/2024 Utility Management LENNAR NW LLC $13.42 $13.42 $0.00 Refund 152009 01/02/2024 Reconciled 01/16/2024 Utility Management REFRESH REAL ESTATE LLC $20.28 $20.28 $0.00 Refund 152010 01/02/2024 Reconciled 01/26/2024 Utility Management RENDER, DENNIS & ELIZABETH $75.00 $75.00 $0.00 Refund 152011 01/02/2024 Reconciled 01/24/2024 Utility Management SYLVESTER, ANDREW & SALLY $35.45 $35.45 $0.00 Refund 152012 01/02/2024 Reconciled 01/23/2024 Utility Management TONA, DARARTU $40.00 $40.00 $0.00 Refund 152013 01/02/2024 Reconciled 01/24/2024 Utility Management VACHTER, PATRICIA $56.39 $56.39 $0.00 Refund 152014 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/17/2024 Accounts Payable 911 SUPPLY $2,011.37 $2,011.37 $0.00 152015 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/26/2024 Accounts Payable ACTIVE MEDIA INC $4,270.70 $4,270.70 $0.00 152016 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/18/2024 Accounts Payable ADDIELOISE INC. dba CITY WIDE $1,453.00 $1,453.00 $0.00 FACILITY SOLUTIONS 152017 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/25/2024 Accounts Payable ADT SECURITY SERVICES $37.99 $37.99 $0.00 152018 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/17/2024 Accounts Payable AIRGAS USA LLC $1,359.55 $1,359.55 $0.00 152019 01/11/2024 Open Accounts Payable ALEJANDRO BARRAGAN dba $1,593.00 PROPULSION WORKS LLC 152020 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/16/2024 Accounts Payable AMAZON CAPITAL SERVICES, INC $232.54 $232.54 $0.00 152021 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/18/2024 Accounts Payable ANDERSON POOLWORKS INC $1,744.60 $1,744.60 $0.00 152022 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/19/2024 Accounts Payable APEX LABORATORIES LLC $285.00 $285.00 $0.00 152023 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/17/2024 Accounts Payable BAVCO $1,441.00 $1,441.00 $0.00 152024 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/16/2024 Accounts Payable BAXTER AUTO PARTS INC. $2,130.49 $2,130.49 $0.00 152025 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/16/2024 Accounts Payable BECKWITH & KUFFEL, INC. $1,480.00 $1,480.00 $0.00 152026 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/17/2024 Accounts Payable CAPITOL CITY DOOR $203.50 $203.50 $0.00 152027 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/16/2024 Accounts Payable CASCADE COLUMBIA DIST CO $1,728.67 $1,728.67 $0.00 152028 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/26/2024 Accounts Payable CFM STRATEGIC $5,000.00 $5,000.00 $0.00 COMMUNICATIONS, INC dba CFM ADVOCATE 152029 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/22/2024 Accounts Payable CINTAS CORPORATION - 463 $2,666.71 $2,666.71 $0.00 152030 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/18/2024 Accounts Payable CONSERVATION TECHNIX INC $31,228.08 $31,228.08 $0.00 152031 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/18/2024 Accounts Payable CONSOR NORTH AMERICA, INC. $55,621.49 $55,621.49 $0.00 152032 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/18/2024 Accounts Payable CORE & MAIN LP $5,865.60 $5,865.60 $0.00 152033 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/16/2024 Accounts Payable DATAVISION COMMUNICATIONS $1,444.86 $1,444.86 $0.00 152034 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/16/2024 Accounts Payable DAVISON AUTO PARTS, INC. $874.83 $874.83 $0.00 user: IKar(.,ln AlIC, =waufesp 1 of 7 iUo-,s:: ay, li::o-,i.:alr"uuary 13, 2024 121 City of Woodburn Payment Register From Payment Date: 1/1/2024 - To Payment Date: 1/31/2024 Reconciled/ Transaction Reconciled Number Date Status Void Reason Voided Date Source Payee Name Amount Amount Difference 152035 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/22/2024 Accounts Payable DECA ARCHITECTURE INC $300.00 $300.00 $0.00 152036 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/24/2024 Accounts Payable DELTA SYSTEMS INTEGRATION $300.00 $300.00 $0.00 INC 152037 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/26/2024 Accounts Payable DOWNTOWN DECORATIONS, INC $9,683.40 $9,683.40 $0.00 152038 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/24/2024 Accounts Payable DUKE'S ROOT CONTROL INC $16,708.85 $16,708.85 $0.00 152039 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/22/2024 Accounts Payable EASYVISTA, INC $6,100.00 $6,100.00 $0.00 152040 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/22/2024 Accounts Payable ELAINE HOWARD dba ELAINE $630.00 $630.00 $0.00 HOWARD CONSULTING LLC 152041 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/17/2024 Accounts Payable ENGELMAN ELECTRIC INC $1,177.09 $1,177.09 $0.00 152042 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/26/2024 Accounts Payable EVIDENT INC $370.10 $370.10 $0.00 152043 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/22/2024 Accounts Payable FEDERAL EXPRESS CORP $35.12 $35.12 $0.00 152044 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/18/2024 Accounts Payable GALE/CENGAGE LEARNING $41.23 $41.23 $0.00 152045 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/18/2024 Accounts Payable GARTEN SERVICES INC $30.00 $30.00 $0.00 152046 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/24/2024 Accounts Payable GLOCK INC $400.00 $400.00 $0.00 152047 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/18/2024 Accounts Payable GOVERNMENT FINANCE $530.00 $530.00 $0.00 OFFICERS ASSN 152048 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/22/2024 Accounts Payable GRANITE TELECOMMUNICATIONS, $2,352.33 $2,352.33 $0.00 LLC 152049 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/18/2024 Accounts Payable GRIFFIN, IAN $475.00 $475.00 $0.00 152050 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/19/2024 Accounts Payable GROVE, MUELLER & SWANK P.C. $23,750.00 $23,750.00 $0.00 152051 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/17/2024 Accounts Payable HD SUPPLY, INC dba $2,904.17 $2,904.17 $0.00 USABLUEBOOK 152052 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/17/2024 Accounts Payable HILLTOP REFRIGERATION INC $2,688.54 $2,688.54 $0.00 152053 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/17/2024 Accounts Payable HILLYER'S MID CITY FORD $462.41 $462.41 $0.00 152054 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/22/2024 Accounts Payable HOFFMAN PRESSURE WASHING $365.00 $365.00 $0.00 152055 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/19/2024 Accounts Payable IDEXX DISTRIBUTION CORP $5,180.58 $5,180.58 $0.00 152056 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/16/2024 Accounts Payable INDUSTRIAL BOLT & SUPPLY INC $28.13 $28.13 $0.00 152057 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/18/2024 Accounts Payable INGRAM LIBRARY SERVICES $758.59 $758.59 $0.00 152058 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/16/2024 Accounts Payable JUBITZ CORPORATION $3,467.36 $3,467.36 $0.00 152059 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/18/2024 Accounts Payable K&E EXCAVATING INC $270,107.67 $270,107.67 $0.00 152060 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/23/2024 Accounts Payable KIWANIS CLUB OF WOODBURN $452.00 $452.00 $0.00 152061 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/19/2024 Accounts Payable LANGUAGE TESTING $146.00 $146.00 $0.00 INTERNATIONAL INC 152062 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/18/2024 Accounts Payable LAZCANO, GUIOVANNI $158.51 $158.51 $0.00 152063 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/22/2024 Accounts Payable LES SCHWAB TIRE CENTER $695.84 $695.84 $0.00 152064 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/30/2024 Accounts Payable LOVE SANTA, INC $25,000.00 $25,000.00 $0.00 152065 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/22/2024 Accounts Payable MARION COUNTY CLERK $182.00 $182.00 $0.00 152066 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/22/2024 Accounts Payable MARION COUNTY FINANCE $3,923.40 $3,923.40 $0.00 152067 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/19/2024 Accounts Payable MARION POLK FOOD SHARE INC $20,326.00 $20,326.00 $0.00 152068 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/18/2024 Accounts Payable MCCROMETER INC. $569.95 $569.95 $0.00 152069 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/23/2024 Accounts Payable METRO PRESORT $3,158.38 $3,158.38 $0.00 152070 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/19/2024 Accounts Payable MIDWEST TAPE, LLC $22.49 $22.49 $0.00 152071 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/23/2024 Accounts Payable MONITORING NW LLC $102.00 $102.00 $0.00 152072 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/16/2024 Accounts Payable MULTI -CULTURAL BOOKS & $4,397.87 $4,397.87 $0.00 VIDEOS 152073 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/18/2024 Accounts Payable NATALYS CONSTRUCTION LLC $40,000.00 $40,000.00 $0.00 152074 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/19/2024 Accounts Payable NET ASSETS CORPORATION $480.00 $480.00 $0.00 152075 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/31/2024 Accounts Payable NORTHWEST CAPITAL $625.00 $625.00 $0.00 MANAGEMENT INC 152076 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/18/2024 Accounts Payable NORTHWEST NATURAL GAS $15,729.39 $15,729.39 $0.00 152077 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/19/2024 Accounts Payable OFFICE DEPOT $451.58 $451.58 $0.00 user: IKaro-,, n AlIC, Pages2 of .7 122 ue d y, IFebruary 13, 2024 City of Woodburn Payment Register From Payment Date: 1/1/2024 - To Payment Date: 1/31/2024 Reconciled/ Transaction Reconciled Number Date Status Void Reason Voided Date Source Payee Name Amount Amount Difference 152078 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/16/2024 Accounts Payable OLDCASTLE INFRASTRUCTURE, $4,421.00 $4,421.00 $0.00 INC 152079 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/23/2024 Accounts Payable ONE CALL CONCEPTS INC $193.20 $193.20 $0.00 152080 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/23/2024 Accounts Payable OR DEPT OF ENVIRONMENTAL $30,859.00 $30,859.00 $0.00 QUALITY 152081 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/22/2024 Accounts Payable OR DEPT OF REVENUE $12,360.00 $12,360.00 $0.00 152082 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/22/2024 Accounts Payable OREGON DEPT OF CONSUMER & $28,043.44 $28,043.44 $0.00 BUS SERV 152083 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/19/2024 Accounts Payable OSCAR LUNDEEN INC $38.25 $38.25 $0.00 152084 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/17/2024 Accounts Payable PERFORMANCE SYSTEMS $1,481.00 $1,481.00 $0.00 INTEGRATION LLC 152085 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/16/2024 Accounts Payable PETROCARD $2,403.54 $2,403.54 $0.00 152086 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/22/2024 Accounts Payable PORTLAND GENERAL ELECTRIC $102,413.69 $102,413.69 $0.00 152087 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/16/2024 Accounts Payable POWERS, BRIAN $56.66 $56.66 $0.00 152088 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/19/2024 Accounts Payable QUADIENT FINANCE USA, INC. $600.00 $600.00 $0.00 152089 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/22/2024 Accounts Payable RICHARD ALBECK DBA SUPPLY $3,364.57 $3,364.57 $0.00 SOLUTIONS LLC, RICHARD, ALBECK DBA SUPPLY SO 152090 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/19/2024 Accounts Payable RITZ SAFETY LLC $496.80 $496.80 $0.00 152091 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/17/2024 Accounts Payable RMT EQUIPMENT $678.20 $678.20 $0.00 152092 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/22/2024 Accounts Payable ROSE CITY PHILANTHROPY $20,000.00 $20,000.00 $0.00 152093 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/26/2024 Accounts Payable ROTARY CLUB OF WOODBURN $485.00 $485.00 $0.00 152094 01/11/2024 Reconciled 02/01/2024 Accounts Payable S&F LAND SERVICES LLC $5,534.00 $5,534.00 $0.00 152095 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/17/2024 Accounts Payable SHI INTERNATIONAL CORP $16,217.89 $16,217.89 $0.00 152096 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/19/2024 Accounts Payable SIERRA SPRINGS $228.36 $228.36 $0.00 152097 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/18/2024 Accounts Payable SOLUTIONS YES, LLC $1,558.19 $1,558.19 $0.00 152098 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/23/2024 Accounts Payable SOUTHLAND INDUSTRIES $32,519.00 $32,519.00 $0.00 152099 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/18/2024 Accounts Payable STEARNS, MATT $34.92 $34.92 $0.00 152100 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/19/2024 Accounts Payable STEELE ELECTRIC LLC $923.10 $923.10 $0.00 152101 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/19/2024 Accounts Payable STOUT, JACOB $30.08 $30.08 $0.00 152102 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/16/2024 Accounts Payable TECHNOLOGY INTEGRATION $7,510.22 $7,510.22 $0.00 GROUP 152103 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/18/2024 Accounts Payable THE AUTOMATION GROUP INC $2,434.00 $2,434.00 $0.00 152104 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/16/2024 Accounts Payable THE POOL & SPA HOUSE $423.45 $423.45 $0.00 152105 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/17/2024 Accounts Payable THOMSON REUTERS-WEST $1,328.92 $1,328.92 $0.00 PAYMENT CENTER 152106 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/17/2024 Accounts Payable TIMECLOCK PLUS, LLC $464.00 $464.00 $0.00 152107 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/16/2024 Accounts Payable TOVUTI, INC. $399.00 $399.00 $0.00 152108 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/17/2024 Accounts Payable TRANSUNION RISK AND $325.00 $325.00 $0.00 ALTERNATIVE DATA SOLUTIONS INC 152109 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/16/2024 Accounts Payable WATERSHED LLC $1,139.32 $1,139.32 $0.00 152110 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/17/2024 Accounts Payable WAVE BROADBAND $300.83 $300.83 $0.00 152111 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/16/2024 Accounts Payable WAXIE SANITARY SUPPLY $2,334.30 $2,334.30 $0.00 152112 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/19/2024 Accounts Payable WHEELER, ALAN $108.20 $108.20 $0.00 152113 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/22/2024 Accounts Payable WOODBURN CHAMBER OF $250.00 $250.00 $0.00 COMMERCE 152114 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/25/2024 Accounts Payable WOODBURN SCHOOL DIST 103C $34,301.05 $34,301.05 $0.00 152115 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/18/2024 Accounts Payable XYLEM WATER SOLUTIONS USA $53.02 $53.02 $0.00 INC 152116 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/19/2024 Accounts Payable YES GRAPHICS PRINTING CO. INC. $527.00 $527.00 $0.00 user: IKar(.,irn AlIC, 123 .i.Uo-,p:Nn: ay, IFebruary 13, 2024 City of Woodburn Payment Register From Payment Date: 1/1/2024 - To Payment Date: 1/31/2024 Reconciled/ Transaction Reconciled Number Date Status Void Reason Voided Date Source Payee Name Amount Amount Difference 152117 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/24/2024 Accounts Payable ALLEN, MICHAEL, DAVID $64.00 $64.00 $0.00 152118 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/19/2024 Accounts Payable CARBAJAL, MARIO, RAMON $120.00 $120.00 $0.00 152119 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/24/2024 Accounts Payable CRAFORD, MICHAEL , DAVID $64.00 $64.00 $0.00 152120 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/24/2024 Accounts Payable CUNNINGHAM, KELLI , ANN $265.00 $265.00 $0.00 152121 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/22/2024 Accounts Payable FERNANDEZ CARLOS, JORGE $31.00 $31.00 $0.00 152122 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/22/2024 Accounts Payable FERNANDEZ CARLOS, JORGE $132.00 $132.00 $0.00 152123 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/23/2024 Accounts Payable GALLAGHER, ANJALIK $80.00 $80.00 $0.00 152124 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/30/2024 Accounts Payable HELMKAMP, ALYSSA $100.00 $100.00 $0.00 152125 01/11/2024 Reconciled 02/05/2024 Accounts Payable NICHOLS , JOSH $80.00 $80.00 $0.00 152126 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/24/2024 Accounts Payable TORRES, ROSA $212.00 $212.00 $0.00 152127 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/22/2024 Accounts Payable WANG, REN $64.00 $64.00 $0.00 152128 01/11/2024 Reconciled 01/19/2024 Accounts Payable WEISMANN, LYDIA, JO $53.00 $53.00 $0.00 152129 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/29/2024 Accounts Payable A & A PEST CONTROL INC $108.00 $108.00 $0.00 152130 01/25/2024 Open Accounts Payable ABAKELIA, LIANA $59.99 152131 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/29/2024 Accounts Payable ADDIELOISE INC. dba CITY WIDE $1,625.00 $1,625.00 $0.00 FACILITY SOLUTIONS 152132 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/29/2024 Accounts Payable AMAZON CAPITAL SERVICES, INC $585.47 $585.47 $0.00 152133 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/30/2024 Accounts Payable APSCO LLC $3,129.23 $3,129.23 $0.00 152134 01/25/2024 Open Accounts Payable AVILA, FABRIZZIO $244.80 152135 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/30/2024 Accounts Payable BAKER & BAKER INC $197.54 $197.54 $0.00 152136 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/30/2024 Accounts Payable BATTERIES NORTHWEST $291.92 $291.92 $0.00 152137 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/31/2024 Accounts Payable BATTERIES PLUS $36.50 $36.50 $0.00 152138 01/25/2024 Reconciled 02/07/2024 Accounts Payable BIO-MED TESTING SERVICE $190.00 $190.00 $0.00 152139 01/25/2024 Reconciled 02/01/2024 Accounts Payable BOYS & GIRLS CLUB OF SALEM $2,500.00 $2,500.00 $0.00 152140 01/25/2024 Reconciled 02/01/2024 Accounts Payable CDW GOVERNMENT INC $352.92 $352.92 $0.00 152141 01/25/2024 Reconciled 02/06/2024 Accounts Payable CENTURYLINK $616.31 $616.31 $0.00 152142 01/25/2024 Reconciled 02/07/2024 Accounts Payable CHEMEKETA COMMUNITY $49.25 $49.25 $0.00 COLLEGE 152143 01/25/2024 Reconciled 02/06/2024 Accounts Payable CINTAS CORPORATION - 463 $629.20 $629.20 $0.00 152144 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/29/2024 Accounts Payable CIT BANK NA $2,450.66 $2,450.66 $0.00 152145 01/25/2024 Reconciled 02/05/2024 Accounts Payable CITY OF SALEM $1,475.00 $1,475.00 $0.00 152146 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/30/2024 Accounts Payable CONSOR NORTH AMERICA, INC. $3,128.30 $3,128.30 $0.00 152147 01/25/2024 Reconciled 02/07/2024 Accounts Payable CRIMINAL INFORMATION SERV INC $30.00 $30.00 $0.00 152148 01/25/2024 Open Accounts Payable CROWLEY & SON SECURITY $240.00 SYSTEMS 152149 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/29/2024 Accounts Payable DAY WIRELESS SYSTEMS $475.00 $475.00 $0.00 152150 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/30/2024 Accounts Payable DECA ARCHITECTURE INC $6,155.45 $6,155.45 $0.00 152151 01/25/2024 Reconciled 02/06/2024 Accounts Payable DELPHIA CONSULTING, LLC $1,944.11 $1,944.11 $0.00 152152 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/31/2024 Accounts Payable DGK INCORPORATED dba BRANDS $4,905.00 $4,905.00 $0.00 AND LOGOS 152153 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/29/2024 Accounts Payable ENGELMAN ELECTRIC INC $3,855.44 $3,855.44 $0.00 152154 01/25/2024 Reconciled 02/06/2024 Accounts Payable EVIDENT INC $154.61 $154.61 $0.00 152155 01/25/2024 Reconciled 02/02/2024 Accounts Payable FEDERAL EXPRESS CORP $80.37 $80.37 $0.00 152156 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/30/2024 Accounts Payable GALE/CENGAGE LEARNING $132.45 $132.45 $0.00 152157 01/25/2024 Reconciled 02/01/2024 Accounts Payable GANNETT MEDIA CORP dba $923.79 $923.79 $0.00 GANNETT OREGON LOCALIQ 152158 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/25/2024 Accounts Payable GEORGE KUZNETSOV $75.28 $75.28 $0.00 152159 01/25/2024 Reconciled 02/05/2024 Accounts Payable GFS CHEMICALS INC $98.33 $98.33 $0.00 152160 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/31/2024 Accounts Payable HACH CHEMICAL CO $108.19 $108.19 $0.00 152161 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/31/2024 Accounts Payable HARDY DIAGNOSTICS $99.59 $99.59 $0.00 user: IKar(.,irn AlIC, :wagesp 4 of 124 .i.Uo-,p:Nn: ay, IFebruary 13, 2024 City of Woodburn Payment Register From Payment Date: 1/1/2024 - To Payment Date: 1/31/2024 Reconciled/ Transaction Reconciled Number Date Status Void Reason Voided Date Source Payee Name Amount Amount Difference 152162 01/25/2024 Reconciled 02/07/2024 Accounts Payable HILLTOP REFRIGERATION INC $875.00 $875.00 $0.00 152163 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/30/2024 Accounts Payable HILLYER'S MID CITY FORD $262.30 $262.30 $0.00 152164 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/30/2024 Accounts Payable HOFFMAN PRESSURE WASHING $355.00 $355.00 $0.00 152165 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/31/2024 Accounts Payable IDEXX DISTRIBUTION CORP $124.91 $124.91 $0.00 152166 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/29/2024 Accounts Payable INDUSTRIAL BOLT & SUPPLY INC $129.39 $129.39 $0.00 152167 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/30/2024 Accounts Payable INDUSTRIAL CHEM LABS & SVCS $299.00 $299.00 $0.00 152168 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/31/2024 Accounts Payable INGRAM LIBRARY SERVICES $659.06 $659.06 $0.00 152169 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/29/2024 Accounts Payable JUBITZ CORPORATION $6,053.09 $6,053.09 $0.00 152170 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/29/2024 Accounts Payable K&E ROCK PRODUCTS LLC $1,042.88 $1,042.88 $0.00 152171 01/25/2024 Reconciled 02/02/2024 Accounts Payable KIMBALL MIDWEST $360.32 $360.32 $0.00 152172 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/31/2024 Accounts Payable KITTELSON & ASSOC INC $2,858.75 $2,858.75 $0.00 152173 01/25/2024 Reconciled 02/01/2024 Accounts Payable KPA SERVICES LLC $224.64 $224.64 $0.00 152174 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/31/2024 Accounts Payable LABOR RELATIONS INFO SYSTEMS $125.00 $125.00 $0.00 152175 01/25/2024 Open Accounts Payable LAKE OSWEGO POLICE DEPT $1,200.00 152176 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/30/2024 Accounts Payable LANGUAGE LINE SERVICES INC $1,885.95 $1,885.95 $0.00 152177 01/25/2024 Reconciled 02/05/2024 Accounts Payable LANGUAGE TESTING $73.00 $73.00 $0.00 INTERNATIONAL INC 152178 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/29/2024 Accounts Payable LEGACY MEDICAL GROUP $278.00 $278.00 $0.00 152179 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/29/2024 Accounts Payable LES SCHWAB TIRE CENTER $2,733.76 $2,733.76 $0.00 152180 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/30/2024 Accounts Payable LOOMIS $343.60 $343.60 $0.00 152181 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/26/2024 Accounts Payable LOVE INC OF NORTH MARION $5,000.00 $5,000.00 $0.00 COUNTY 152182 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/31/2024 Accounts Payable MARION COUNTY TREASURY $6,242.15 $6,242.15 $0.00 DEPT 152183 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/29/2024 Accounts Payable MATT LAMBERT dba SPOT FREE $980.00 $980.00 $0.00 WINDOW CLEANING 152184 01/25/2024 Reconciled 02/06/2024 Accounts Payable METCOM $44,758.85 $44,758.85 $0.00 152185 01/25/2024 Reconciled 02/01/2024 Accounts Payable MIDWEST TAPE, LLC $360.60 $360.60 $0.00 152186 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/31/2024 Accounts Payable MULTI -CULTURAL BOOKS & $764.40 $764.40 $0.00 VIDEOS 152187 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/29/2024 Accounts Payable NURNBERG SCIENTIFIC $269.60 $269.60 $0.00 152188 01/25/2024 Reconciled 02/05/2024 Accounts Payable OFFICE DEPOT $709.39 $709.39 $0.00 152189 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/31/2024 Accounts Payable OR DEPT OF ENVIRONMENTAL $302.45 $302.45 $0.00 QUALITY 152190 01/25/2024 Reconciled 02/01/2024 Accounts Payable OR DEPT OF TRANSPORTATION $4,118.91 $4,118.91 $0.00 152191 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/31/2024 Accounts Payable OREGON PORTABLE TOILETS LLC $420.00 $420.00 $0.00 152192 01/25/2024 Reconciled 02/01/2024 Accounts Payable PEREZ 1 PEST CONTROL INC $475.00 $475.00 $0.00 152193 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/30/2024 Accounts Payable PETERSON MACHINERY $4,434.23 $4,434.23 $0.00 152194 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/30/2024 Accounts Payable PETROCARD $5,250.47 $5,250.47 $0.00 152195 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/31/2024 Accounts Payable PORTLAND GENERAL ELECTRIC $2,735.34 $2,735.34 $0.00 152196 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/29/2024 Accounts Payable PREMIER GEAR & MACHINE $3,140.00 $3,140.00 $0.00 WORKS INC 152197 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/31/2024 Accounts Payable QUADIENT LEASING USA, INC. $1,596.16 $1,596.16 $0.00 152198 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/25/2024 Accounts Payable R&R GENERAL CONTRACTORS, $40,686.02 $40,686.02 $0.00 INC 152199 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/29/2024 Accounts Payable R.L. REIMERS COMPANY $13,700.00 $13,700.00 $0.00 152200 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/31/2024 Accounts Payable REDFLEX TRAFFIC SYSTEMS INC $9,390.00 $9,390.00 $0.00 152201 01/25/2024 Reconciled 02/06/2024 Accounts Payable RICHARD ALBECK DBA SUPPLY $237.41 $237.41 $0.00 SOLUTIONS LLC, RICHARD, ALBECK DBA SUPPLY SO 152202 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/31/2024 Accounts Payable ROTARY CLUB OF WOODBURN $915.00 $915.00 $0.00 user: IKaro-,, n AlIC, Pages5 of .7 125 ue d y, IFebruary 13, 2024 City of Woodburn Payment Register From Payment Date: 1/1/2024 - To Payment Date: 1/31/2024 Reconciled/ Transaction Reconciled Number Date Status Void Reason Voided Date Source Payee Name Amount Amount Difference 152203 01/25/2024 Reconciled 02/01/2024 Accounts Payable SIERRA SPRINGS $30.27 $30.27 $0.00 152204 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/31/2024 Accounts Payable SNAP -ON CREDIT LLC $124.82 $124.82 $0.00 152205 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/29/2024 Accounts Payable SOLUTIONS YES, LLC $1,549.06 $1,549.06 $0.00 152206 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/31/2024 Accounts Payable TECH DATA CORP dba DLT $5,761.20 $5,761.20 $0.00 SOLUTIONS LLC 152207 01/25/2024 Reconciled 02/02/2024 Accounts Payable TIMMONS GROUP, INC. $4,123.35 $4,123.35 $0.00 152208 01/25/2024 Reconciled 02/05/2024 Accounts Payable ULINE $358.54 $358.54 $0.00 152209 01/25/2024 Reconciled 02/05/2024 Accounts Payable US BANCORP ASSET MNGMNT dba $4,043.97 $4,043.97 $0.00 PFM ASSET MNGMNT 152210 01/25/2024 Reconciled 02/05/2024 Accounts Payable US BANK EQUIPMENT FINANCE $194.84 $194.84 $0.00 152211 01/25/2024 Reconciled 02/01/2024 Accounts Payable VERIZON WIRELESS $9,350.03 $9,350.03 $0.00 152212 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/29/2024 Accounts Payable WHA INSURANCE AGENCY INC $1,377.75 $1,377.75 $0.00 152213 01/25/2024 Reconciled 02/05/2024 Accounts Payable WOODBURN VETERINARY CLINIC $112.99 $112.99 $0.00 PC 152214 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/29/2024 Accounts Payable ZUMAR INDUSTRIES INC $9,128.11 $9,128.11 $0.00 152215 01/25/2024 Reconciled 02/05/2024 Accounts Payable ASSINK, ZACHARY $70.00 $70.00 $0.00 152216 01/25/2024 Reconciled 01/31/2024 Accounts Payable SCHMOLL, PAUL $3,663.00 $3,663.00 $0.00 Type Check Totals: 215 Transactions $1,149,791.18 $1,146,453.39 $0.00 EFT 2056 01/29/2024 Reconciled 01/30/2024 Accounts Payable US BANK $4.50 $4.50 $0.00 2057 01/29/2024 Reconciled 01/30/2024 Accounts Payable US BANK $1,229.98 $1,229.98 $0.00 2058 01/29/2024 Reconciled 01/30/2024 Accounts Payable US BANK $618.42 $618.42 $0.00 2059 01/29/2024 Reconciled 01/30/2024 Accounts Payable US BANK $423.11 $423.11 $0.00 2060 01/29/2024 Reconciled 01/30/2024 Accounts Payable US BANK $720.42 $720.42 $0.00 2061 01/29/2024 Reconciled 01/30/2024 Accounts Payable US BANK $438.49 $438.49 $0.00 2062 01/29/2024 Reconciled 01/30/2024 Accounts Payable US BANK $222.31 $222.31 $0.00 2063 01/29/2024 Reconciled 01/30/2024 Accounts Payable US BANK $686.74 $686.74 $0.00 2064 01/29/2024 Reconciled 01/30/2024 Accounts Payable US BANK $2,114.43 $2,114.43 $0.00 2065 01/29/2024 Reconciled 01/30/2024 Accounts Payable US BANK $1,384.49 $1,384.49 $0.00 2066 01/29/2024 Reconciled 01/30/2024 Accounts Payable US BANK $314.10 $314.10 $0.00 2067 01/29/2024 Reconciled 01/30/2024 Accounts Payable US BANK $2,935.53 $2,935.53 $0.00 2068 01/29/2024 Reconciled 01/30/2024 Accounts Payable US BANK $272.10 $272.10 $0.00 2069 01/29/2024 Reconciled 01/30/2024 Accounts Payable US BANK $2,333.56 $2,333.56 $0.00 2070 01/29/2024 Reconciled 01/30/2024 Accounts Payable US BANK $299.85 $299.85 $0.00 2071 01/29/2024 Reconciled 01/30/2024 Accounts Payable US BANK $736.04 $736.04 $0.00 2072 01/29/2024 Reconciled 01/30/2024 Accounts Payable US BANK $87.77 $87.77 $0.00 2073 01/29/2024 Reconciled 01/30/2024 Accounts Payable US BANK $423.57 $423.57 $0.00 2074 01/29/2024 Reconciled 01/30/2024 Accounts Payable US BANK $589.57 $589.57 $0.00 2075 01/29/2024 Reconciled 01/30/2024 Accounts Payable US BANK $2,825.96 $2,825.96 $0.00 2076 01/29/2024 Reconciled 01/30/2024 Accounts Payable US BANK $1,794.12 $1,794.12 $0.00 2077 01/29/2024 Reconciled 01/30/2024 Accounts Payable US BANK $1,783.61 $1,783.61 $0.00 2078 01/29/2024 Reconciled 01/30/2024 Accounts Payable US BANK $4,052.03 $4,052.03 $0.00 2079 01/29/2024 Reconciled 01/30/2024 Accounts Payable US BANK $4,154.37 $4,154.37 $0.00 2080 01/29/2024 Reconciled 01/30/2024 Accounts Payable US BANK $1,152.97 $1,152.97 $0.00 2081 01/29/2024 Reconciled 01/30/2024 Accounts Payable US BANK $70.00 $70.00 $0.00 Type EFT Totals: 26 Transactions $31,668.04 $31,668.04 $0.00 AP-A/P - Accounts Payable Totals Checks Status Count Transaction Amount Reconciled Amount Open 5 $3,337.79 $0.00 Reconciled 210 $1,146,453.39 $1,146,453.39 user: IKaro-,In AlIC, Pages6 of 7 ue day, li::o-,br"uuary 13, 2024 126 City of Woodburn Payment Register From Payment Date: 1/1/2024 - To Payment Date: 1/31/2024 Reconciled/ Transaction Reconciled Number Date Status Void Reason Voided Date Source Payee Name Amount Amount Difference Voided 0 $0.00 $0.00 Stopped 0 $0.00 $0.00 Total 215 $1,149, 791.18 $1,146,453.39 EFTs Status Count Transaction Amount Reconciled Amount Open 0 $0.00 $0.00 Reconciled 26 $31,668.04 $31,668.04 Voided 0 $0.00 $0.00 Total 26 $31,668.04 $31,668.04 All Status Count Transaction Amount Reconciled Amount Open 5 $3,337.79 $0.00 Reconciled 236 $1,178,121.43 $1,178,121.43 Voided 0 $0.00 $0.00 Stopped 0 $0.00 $0.00 Total 241 $1,181,459.22 $1,178,121.43 Grand Totals: Checks Status Count Transaction Amount Reconciled Amount Open 5 $3,337.79 $0.00 Reconciled 210 $1,146,453.39 $1,146,453.39 Voided 0 $0.00 $0.00 Stopped 0 $0.00 $0.00 Total 215 $1,149,791.18 $1,146,453.39 EFTS Status Count Transaction Amount Reconciled Amount Open 0 $0.00 $0.00 Reconciled 26 $31,668.04 $31,668.04 Voided 0 $0.00 $0.00 Total 26 $31,668.04 $31,668.04 All Status Count Transaction Amount Reconciled Amount Open 5 $3,337.79 $0.00 Reconciled 236 $1,178,121.43 $1,178,121.43 Voided 0 $0.00 $0.00 Stopped 0 $0.00 $0.00 Total 241 $1,181,459.22 $1,178,121.43 userIKar(.,irn AlIC, Pafro- s 7of.7 127 1. e d y, February 13, 2024 Cash and Investment Reconciliation Report 128 City of Woodburn CASH & INVESTMENT RECONCILIATION January 31, 2024 (rounded to $1,000's) Statement Balance 12/31/2023 Change in Market Value & Gain/(Loss) on Maturity/Sale Deposits/Security Purchases Interest Withdrawals/Disbursements/Maturities Statement Balance 01/31/2024 Deposits in Transit Outstanding Checks - A/P & Payroll General Ledger Balance 01/31/2024 CASH & INVESTMENT CLASSIFICATION Unrestricted Restricted Capital Construction System Development Charges Debt Reserve Other Restrictions URA SMR Reserve Held in Trust PFMAM Investment Bank Accounts LGIP Portfolio Total $ 1,012,000 $ 42,775,000 $ 50,587,000 $ 94,374,000 $ 4,694,000 $ 880,000 $ 989,000 $ 6,563,000 $ - $ 179,000 $ 131,000 $ 310,000 $ (4,466,000) $ (1,000,000) $ (1,101,000) $ (6,567,000) $ 1,240,000 $ 42,834,000 $ 50,606,000 $ 94,680,000 $ 351,000 $ 351,000 $ (124,000) $ (124,000) $ 1,467,000 $ 42,834,000 $ 50,606,000 $ 94,907,000 $ 39,082,000 $ 2,317,000 $ 30,271,000 $ 15,879,000 $ 1,634,000 $ 5,687,000 $ 37,000 $ 94,907,000 INVESTMENT REPORTING (in compliance with City policy) 1/31/2024 Average Rate Balance LGIP 5.00% $ 42,834,000 $ 42,834,000 PFMAM Investment Portfolio 4.83% $ 50,606,000 $ 50,606,000 $ 42,834,000 $ 50,606,000 $ 93,440,000 129 �i �.. Ag4,-.44 fun.- WboibBURN In �or�arn reA 188� February 26, 2024 TO: Mayor and City Council through City Administrator FROM: Brian Miles, IT Manager SUBJECT: Silverton Fire District IT Services Support Agreement RECOMMENDATION: Authorize the City Administrator to execute an Intergovernmental Agreement with the Silverton Fire District to provide computer and network support. BACKGROUND: The Silverton Fire District recently requested that the City begin providing them with computer network support services. Currently, the City provides assistance to several local governments and special districts in the area by providing network and computer support, including software installation services. The City determined that it has the capacity to provide support to the Silverton Fire District and has prepared the enclosed agreement for the City Council's consideration. The proposed agreement with the Silverton Fire District is to provide network support services at a set fee of $300 per PC. All equipment, software and peripherals are to be provided by the Silverton Fire District. The agreement will be in effect through June 30, 2024, and, unless otherwise terminated, will renew for subsequent one-year periods that correspond to the City fiscal year of July 1 - June 30. The City will have the opportunity to request annual fee increases by providing notice of such adjustments at least 120 days prior to the expiration date of each annual agreement. DISCUSSION: For many years, the City has provided IT services to a number of other local jurisdictions. This arrangement benefits our smaller partners by making these services much more affordable than they could otherwise obtain on the open market or by hiring their own IT employees. And the additional revenue this Agenda Item Review: City Administrator x_ City Attorney _x_ Finance 130 Honorable Mayor and City Council February 26, 2024 Page 2 approach generates allows us to carry a larger staff with a more comprehensive set of skills than we would otherwise be able to afford. The City is in the process of updating similar agreements with the other jurisdictions we provide network and computer support service to, primarily to adjust our fees to keep up with our increasing costs of providing this service. However, while updating these agreements, we determined that it would be helpful to our partner organizations to provide them with flexibility in the type of fee model available to them. Previously, the only option for local jurisdictions was to pay an hourly fee for service. Through the fee model available in the updated agreements, local jurisdictions will have the option of being billed an hourly rate for service - increasing to $100/ hr. from the current rate of $85/ hr. Alternatively, they can select a fixed rate model that provides them with predictive costs that could be helpful with their budgeting processes. The fixed rate model is structured, as follows: Tier 1 Plan Trouble -shoot and remediate IT support issues submitted to Woodburn by Silverton staff. This includes mostly remote support with some on -site work as needed. Includes Tier 1 Services; and Woodburn will also provide additional on -site visits and regularly scheduled monthly meetings with Silverton to carry out the following work: • Support for and maintenance of server and network Tier 2 Plan infrastructure, including desktop computers, printers, and any other computer or network -related equipment for Silverton; • Set-up and installation and/or relocation of computer or network -related equipment; • Work with hardware and/or software vendor support to resolve issues; • Work with Silverton to backup and maintain Silverton's data; and • Provide general advice regarding proper planning and third- 131 Honorable Mayor and City Council February 26, 2024 Page 3 party services involving the network, telecommunications, and data access. Tier 3 Plan Includes Tier 2 Services, but Woodburn will provide Services through regularly scheduled weekly meetings and/or on -site visits. Tiered Pricing Plan: Tier 1 Plan $200 per PC / year Tier 2 Plan $300 per PC / year Tier 3 Plan $400 per PC / year The Silverton Fire District selected the Tier 3 Fixed Rate model at a cost of $400 per PC per year, which is reflected in the enclosed agreement. Updated agreements are currently being negotiated with the other jurisdictions the City provides service to and will be presented to the City Council for their approval at an upcoming meeting. FINANCIAL IMPACT: The agreement with the Silverton Fire District would supplement the IT department's revenue by approximately $7,500 annually. 132 INTERGOVERNMENTAL AGREEMENT FOR INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY SERVICES THIS Intergovernmental Agreement for Information Technology Services ("IGA"), entered into between the City of Woodburn, an Oregon municipal corporation ("Woodburn"), and the Silverton Fire District, an Oregon fire district ("District"), is made pursuant to ORS 190.010 (Cooperative Agreements). BACKGROUND A. District has a need for qualified personnel to provide certain information technology ("IT") services in lieu of their own employees; B. Woodburn employs IT professional personnel who are qualified and can perform certain IT Services for District; and C. The purpose of this IGA is to establish the terms and conditions under which the City will provide Tier 1 Plan - IT Services, including Computer and Network Support Services, for the District. NOW THEREFORE, the Parties agree as follows: AGREEMENT 1. IT Services. 1.1. Woodburn shall provide the following IT Services ("Services") to the District based upon the Tier Plan selected for services: Trouble -shoot and remediate IT support issues submitted to Tier 1 Plan Woodburn by District staff. This includes mostly remote support with some on -site work as needed. Includes Tier 1 Services; and Woodburn will also provide additional on -site visits and regularly for 2 P' an scheduled monthly meetings with District to carry out the following work: • Support for and maintenance of server and network infrastructure, including desktop computers, printers, and any IT SERVICES IGA - Silverton Fire District 133 Page 1 of 7 other computer or network -related equipment for the District; • Set-up and installation and/or relocation of computer or network -related equipment; • Work with hardware and/or software vendor support to resolve issues; • Work with the District to backup and maintain the District's data; and • Provide general advice regarding proper planning and third - party services involving the network, telecommunications, and data access. Tier 3 Plan Includes Tier 2 Services, but Woodburn will provide Services through regularly scheduled weekly meetings and/or on -site visits. a) All ownership rights to any equipment shall remain with the District. b) Network drop locations, power receptacle location, and furniture relocation will be the responsibility of the District. c) The Woodburn IT team is not intended to replace third-party/line-of- business applications support. 1.2. In providing Services under this IGA, Woodburn will not: a) Provide any physical hardware; but it may help make hardware choice recommendations and assist the District with ordering any necessary hardware. 1.3. Services shall be provided during normal business hours, 8 a.m. — 5 p.m., Monday through Friday, following receipt of a written request from the District. After- hours and weekend support may also be available on a mutually agreed -upon time frame and at the discretion of Woodburn. Conditions of Services. 2.1. Personnel. Woodburn shall, at its sole discretion, select and assign suitable personnel that will provide Services under this IGA. As the employer of such personnel, Woodburn reserves the right to prioritize the workload of its personnel and manage the means by which its personnel carry out assignments and duties. 2.2. Standard of Care. Woodburn agrees that all Services provided under this IGA IT SERVICES IGA - Silverton Fire District 134 Page 2 of 7 shall be performed in a professional manner with the degree of care and skill ordinarily exercised under similar circumstances by professionals in the State of Oregon. 2.3. Security. In providing Services under this IGA, Woodburn may use an existing or established encrypted VPN connection to remotely access the District's computers to help troubleshoot and resolve issues. 2.4. Non -Performance. Woodburn shall not be held responsible for delay or failure to provide services to the District when such delay or failure is due to fire, flood, epidemic, strikes, acts of God or the public enemy, unusually severe weather, legal acts of public authorities, or delays or defaults caused by public carriers, which cannot be reasonably foreseen or provided against. 2.5. Ownership of Work Product. Any and all goods and services developed for District pursuant to this IGA are intended as works made for hire. Works made for hire are the exclusive property of District. 3. Compensation. 3.1. Fees & Charges. Services rendered will be charged to the District as follows: a) Tiered Pricing: Tier 1 Plan $200 per PC / year Tier 2 Plan $300 per PC / year .... Tier 3 Plan $400 per PC / year The annual period shall run in alignment with Woodburn s fiscal year (Ju ly my 1—June 30th of the following year). b) There are no additional costs to District for travel time by Woodburn employees in providing Services under this IGA. c) Since the City will not be providing any hardware or materials, all hardware or material costs, whether purchased by the District directly or by Woodburn on behalf of District will be the responsibility of the District. 3.2. Rat . Fees and Charges will be billed to the District by annual invoice issued IT SERVICES IGA - Sillverton Fire District 135 Page 3 of 7 within thirty (30) days of the beginning of each fiscal year starting on July 1st. During the first partial year of service (the "Initial Term"), the annual invoice amount will be prorated to account for the time remaining in the current fiscal year and will be issued within thirty (30) days of execution of this IGA. Fees and Charges shall be due from Silverton to Woodburn within thirty (30) days following receipt of any invoice. 4. Term & Termination. 4.1. Initial Term. The Initial Term of this IGA commences upon the last date of signature below, and runs until June 30, 2024, unless earlier terminated or extended as provided below. 4.2. IGA Renewal. This IGA will automatically renew for successive annual periods, running July 1—June 30th of the following year ("Renewal Term"), unless District notifies Woodburn in writing of its intention not to renew the IGA at least sixty (60) days prior to the expiration of the Initial Term or any Renewal Term. Any Renewal Term will be governed by the same terms and conditions of this IGA, except for the provisions regarding Fees. Woodburn may request to annually increase the Fee charged to District where it submits new pricing and requests for a Fee increase at least one hundred twenty (120) days prior to expiration of the current IGA Term. In the event the District agrees to a said increase, the IGA will be extended for the following 1-year Renewal Term with the newly agreed upon pricing. In the event the District does not agree, this IGA will terminate at the end of the given Term. This section will not limit the ability of either party to terminate this IGA pursuant to Section 4.3. 4.3. Termination. This IGA may be terminated as follows: a) Upon nonrenewal at the end of the Initial Term or a successive Renewal Term. b) By mutual written consent of both parties. c) Provided neither party is in default under this IGA beyond the applicable cure period, by either party unilaterally giving at least ninety (90)-days prior written notice to the other party. d) By either party giving 10-days' prior written notice to the other party when that party has committed a material breach or default of any covenant, warranty, or obligation under this IGA, and such breach, default, or failure is not cured within 10 business days after receipt of a notice of breach, or such longer period of cure as the terminating party may specify in its notice. Notwithstanding the giving of notice of termination as provided under this IT SERVICES IGA - Silverton Fire District 136 Page 4 of 7 Section, the District shall remain obligated with respect to any unfulfilled financial obligations which accrued hereunder prior to the effective date of such termination. Similarly, if this IGA is terminated early, Woodburn shall refund to the District the proportionate share of any prepaid annual Fee that represents the remaining period of time allocable under the given Term or Renewal Term of the IGA. 5. Legal Relationship. The Parties intend the legal relationship between the parties to be at all times and for all purposes under this IGA that of independent contracting agencies. 6. Compliance with Applicable Laws. The Parties agree that both shall comply with all federal, state, and local laws and ordinances applicable to the work to be done under this IGA. 7. Nondiscrimination. The Parties agree to comply with all applicable requirements of federal and state civil rights and rehabilitation statutes, rules, regulations in the performance of this IGA. 8. Confidentiality. Woodburn shall treat as confidential any District Confidential Information that has been made known or available to Woodburn or that Woodburn has received, learned, heard or observed; or to which Woodburn has had access. Woodburn shall use District's Confidential Information exclusively for District's benefit and in furtherance of the Services provided hereunder. Except as may be expressly authorized in writing by District, in no event shall Woodburn publish, use, discuss or cause or permit to be disclosed to any other person such Confidential Information. Woodburn shall (i) limit disclosure of the District's Confidential Information to only those officers, employees and agents of Woodburn who need to know the Confidential Information in connection with providing ongoing Services; (ii) exercise reasonable care with respect to the District's Confidential Information, at least to the same degree of care as Woodburn employs with respect to protecting its own proprietary and confidential information; and (iii) return immediately to District, upon its request, all materials containing District's Confidential Information, in whatever form, that are in Woodburn's possession or custody or under its control. This IGA shall apply to all District Confidential Information previously received, learned, observed, known by or made available to Woodburn in providing the identified Services. This IGA shall not apply to District's Confidential Information which (i) is or later becomes part of the public domain without breach of this IGA and through no wrongful act of Woodburn; (ii) Woodburn lawfully receives from a third party; (iii) was developed independently by and was reduced to writing by Woodburn prior to the earlier of the date of this IGA or the date of any access or exposure to any District Confidential Information; or (iv) is required to be disclosed under operation of law. Woodburn's confidentiality obligations under this IGA shall survive termination. 9. Limitations on Liability. IT SERVICES IGA - Silverton Fire District 137 Page 5 of 7 9.1. Limitations. Woodburn assumes no liability for the accuracy of any data on the District's network. Further the District understands and agrees that Woodburn shall not be liable to the District for any damage that may occur while the District's computer and network system is being serviced by Woodburn, including liability for indirect, special, exemplary, or consequential damages. 9.2. Indemnification. Other than as limited above, each party shall, to the extent it may under the Constitution and laws of Oregon, indemnify, defend, and hold harmless the other party and its officers, employees, and agents against all claims, demands, suits, actions, losses, damages, liabilities, costs and expenses of any kind or nature arising directly out of the party's intentional, reckless, or negligent acts, errors, or omissions in carrying out any activity under this IGA. 9.3. Insurance. Each party shall insure or self -insure and be independently responsible for the risk of its own liability for claims within the scope of the Oregon tort claims act (ORS 30.260 to 30.300). Woodburn represents that it is insured for workers' compensation as required by law and shall provide benefits as prescribed by the State of Oregon. 10. Notices. Any Notice provided for or concerning this IGA must be in writing and will be deemed sufficiently given when personally delivered or mailed by Certified mail, to the respective address of each party as follows: 10.1. For Woodburn. City of Woodburn, Attn: City Administrator, 270 Montgomery Street, Woodburn, Oregon 97071. 10.2. For the District. Silverton Fire District, Attn: Fire Chief, 819 Rail Way NE, Silverton, OR 97381. 9. Assignments; Successors and Assigns. Neither party shall subcontract or assign any part of the IGA without the prior written approval of the other party. Any attempted assignment of this IGA without the prior written approval of the other party shall be void. 10. No Third -Party Beneficiaries. No provision of this IGA is intended or will be construed to confer upon or give to any person or entity other than the signatories to this IGA any rights, remedies or other benefits under or by reason of this IGA. 11. Records. Each Party shall retain all its own records relating to this IGA and projects/activities carried out under this IGA for a period of six years following expiration or termination of this IGA. 12. Governing Law. This IGA is governed by and will be construed in accordance with the laws of the State of Oregon. Any legal action involving any question arising under this IGA must be brought in Marion County Circuit Court. IT SERVICES IGA - Silverton Fire District 138 Page 6 of 7 13. Severability. The Parties agree that if any term or provision of this IGA is declared by a court of competent jurisdiction to be illegal or in conflict with any law, the validity of the remaining terms and provisions shall not be affected, and the rights and obligations of the Parties shall be construed and enforced as if the IGA did not contain the particular term or provision held to be invalid. 14. Merger Clause; Waiver. This IGA constitutes the entire agreement between the Parties on the subject matter hereof. There are no understandings, agreements, or representations, oral or written, not specified herein regarding this IGA. No waiver, consent, modification or change of terms of this IGA shall bind either Party unless in writing and signed by both Parties. Such waiver, consent, modification or change, if made, shall be effective only in the specific instance and for the specific purpose given. The failure of either party to enforce any provision of this IGA shall not constitute a waiver by that party of that or any other provision. The Parties execute this IGA effective as of the last date of signature specified below. CITY OF WOODBURN, an Oregon municipal corporation Scott Derickson, City Administrator Date SILVERTON FIRE DISTRICT, an Oregon fire district 4. Bill Miles, Fire Chief 2/5/2024 Date IT SERVICES IGA - Silverton Fire District 139 Page 7 of 7 COMMUNITY CENTER ADVISORY COMMITTEE MINUTES February 20, 2024 Convened The meeting convened at 3:37 p.m. in the Woodburn City Hall Council Chambers Citizen Advisory Committee Members Present Frank Lonergan, Mayor Debbie Cabrales, City Councilor Sharon Schaub, City Councilor Marybeth Cornwell, City Councilor Bernadette Krewson Juan Bravo Kathy Figley, Chair Michael Nelson Wendy Veliz John Zobrist Anthony Veliz Teresa Alonso Leon Andrew Yoshihara Staff Present: Community Services Director Cuomo, Assistant City Administrator Row, Special Projects Director Wakeley, Finance Director Turley, Economic Development Director Johnk, Aquatics Supervisor Powers, Economic Development Specialist Maxwell, Rare AmeriCorps Member Betancourt, Events and Special Programs Manager Duran, Community Relations Manager Herrara, City Recorder Pierson Others Present: Mark Parker, Rose City Philanthropy Jeri Alcott, Rose City Philanthropy Jake Weigler, Praxis Political Megan Wever, Praxis Political Ben Patinkin, Elections Strategies Citizen Advisory Committee (CAC) Re -Introductions Chair Figley thanked everyone for participating on the committee and asked those in attendance to introduce themselves. General Project Update Community Services Director Cuomo provided a general update on the project. Rose City Philanthropy Updates Mark Parker, with Rose City Philanthropy reported that they are testing general response to the project, and they have found that there is strong enthusiasm for the scope of the project. Jeri Alcott with Rose City Philanthropy reported that they are seeing a strong willingness to contribute to the proj ect. Praxis Political Consultant Introductions, Scope, and Update Assistant City Administrator Row introduced Jake Weigler and Megan Wever with Praxis Political. Page 1 140 COMMUNITY CENTER ADVISORY COMMITTEE MINUTES February 20, 2024 Jake Weigler stated that their goal for the next few months is to help the community understand why this project is needed and what it will provide for them. Megan Wever stated that their two primary strategies are going to communication and engagement. Patinkin Research Strategies — Community Election Polling Results Bent Patinkin, Patinkin Research Strategies, discussed the results of the election polling that was conducted. He noted that overall, the results were positive and supportive of the project. Questions and next steps Committee members provided comments and asked questions. Bernadette Krewson made a motion to recommend to the City Council that we go for the full forty -million -dollar Community Center Project as illustrated and refer it to the voters for the November election. John Zobrist seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. The meeting adjourned at 5:17 p.m. ATTEST Heather Pierson, City Recorder City of Woodburn, Oregon APPROVED Kathy Figley, CHAIR 141 Page 2 4?4 4' *7 4N g ewk WWODBURN In or�arn reA 188� February 26, 2024 TO: Honorable Mayor and City Council through City Administrator FROM: Chris Kerr, Community Development Director Colin Cortes, AICP, CNU-A, Senior Planner SUBJECT: Ordinance 2621 Implementing Legislative Amendment 21-03 of the Woodburn Development Ordinance (WDO) Relating to Tree Preservation and Removal (LA 21-03) RECOMMENDATION: Adopt the attached Ordinance to implement Legislative Amendment LA 21-03 for the Woodburn Development Ordinance (WDO) relating to tree preservation and removal. BACKGROUND: The City Council held a public hearing on February 12, 2024 and tentatively approved LA 21-03, directing staff to prepare an ordinance. DISCUSSION: n/a FINANCIAL IMPACT: n/a Agenda Item Review: City Administrator _x City Attorney x_ 142 Finance COUNCIL BILL NO. 3242 ORDINANCE NO. 2621 AN ORDINANCE AMENDING THE WOODBURN DEVELOPMENT ORDINANCE (WDO) RELATED TO SIGNIFICANT TREE PRESERVATION, REMOVAL, AND MITIGATION, AND PROTECTION DURING CONSTRUCTION (LA 21-03). WHEREAS, the Woodburn Development Ordinance (WDO) establishes the standards that development is required to meet and that clarity of those standards is critical as the community continues to grow and prosper; and WHEREAS, periodic revisions and updates to the Woodburn Comprehensive Plan and WDO are necessary and expected to comply with revisions to statutes and administrative rules, administer new and revised long-range plans, and address current issues; and WHEREAS, Section 4.10.09 of the WDO requires the City Council to initiate the consideration of any potential legislative amendments to the WDO by resolution; and WHEREAS, following a 2021 winter ice storm, the City Attorney and Community Development Director briefed the Council about existing Woodburn Development Ordinance (WDO) regulations for tree preservation and removal and presented ideas about improved enforcement provisions and fines; and WHEREAS, on July 26, 2021, the Council in conformance with WDO 4.01.09.A, initiated Legislative Amendment 21-03 (LA 21-03) via Resolution No. 2175, directing staff to review and revise the WDO tree regulations to improve relevance and clarity; and WHEREAS, the Planning Commission conducted six workshops about LA 21-03 between September 23, 2021, and ending July 27, 2023; and WHEREAS, on September 28, 2023, the Planning Commission, in conformance with WDO 4.01.0913. and 4.01.1013. held a public hearing and recommended approval of the amendment; and WHEREAS, on February 12, 2024, the City Council held a public hearing and requested this Ordinance effecting the amendment (LA 21-03); NOW, THEREFORE, THE CITY OF WOODBURN ORDAINS AS FOLLOWS: Page - 1 - Council Bill No. 3242 Ordinance No. 2621 143 Section 1. For purposes of this ordinance amendment, all new text is shown as underlined (i.e. new text) and all deleted text is shown as stricken (i.e. deleted #e t). After this ordinance amendment is adopted, the Community Development director shall correct the WDO to incorporate all revisions contained herein. Section 2. The WDO is amended as specified in Exhibit A which is attached hereto. Section 3. The legislative action taken by the Ordinance is explained and justified by the findings and analysis attached hereto and incorporated herein as FXhihit R Approved as to form: City Attorney Date Passed by the Council Submitted to the Mayor Approved by the Mayor Filed in the Office of the Recorder ATTEST: Approved: Heather Pierson, City Recorder City of Woodburn, Oregon Page - 2 - Council Bill No. 3242 Ordinance No. 2621 Frank Lonergan, Mayor 144 Woodburn Development Ordinance WDO Adopted by Ordinance 2313 on April 9, 2002 Acknowledged December 22, 2006 Amended by Ordinance 2423 on July 28, 2007 Amended by Ordinance 2446 on September 8, 2008 Amended by Ordinance 2465 on March 24, 2010 Amended by Ordinance 2473 on December 13, 2010 Amended by Ordinance 2480 on September 26, 2011 Amended by Ordinance 2492 on September 10, 2012 Amended by Ordinance 2509 on August 12, 2013 Amended by Ordinance 2510 on September 23, 2013 Amended by Ordinance 2520 on July 28, 2014 Amended by Ordinance 2526 on February 9, 2015 Amended by Ordinance 2538 on September 26, 2016 Amended by Ordinance 2541 on November 14, 2016 Amended by Ordinance 2544 on January 9, 2017 Amended by Ordinance 2561 on July 9, 2018 Amended by Ordinance 2562 on September 10, 2018 Amended by Ordinance 2573 on June 24, 2019 Amended by Ordinance 2579 on April 13, 2020 Amended by Ordinance 2602 on May 9, 2022 (LA 21-01) Amended by Ordinance 2603 effective June 30, 2022 (LA 21-02) aina mule, bn Ordipay ce 2621 op ➢I.v@rorai 26 2(p2 N...��1 -03 Ordinance No. 2621 Exhibit 49 pages 145 '� ��|�m�����'�'���'�� mzmu�m�m� ���' °~����mm���m�� VOLNME1 ORGANIZATION AND STRUCTURE 1.01 �1nic [� ire-------------------------------------------3 1.02 lDefilli1ions.............................................................................................................................. 7 1l8 -----------------------------------'25 1.04 -------------------------'27 l�� -----------------------------------3l llW -----------------------------------35 VOLUME LAND USE ZONING AND SPECIFIED USE STANDARDS 2.01 General Provisions -------------------------------------37 2.02 -------------------------------------'4l Commercial /ones 2.03 -------------------------------------.k5 2.04 --------------------------------'79 2.05 IS --------------------------------------.89 2lW -----------------------------------]03 2���1��d�l��........................................................................................................................ l07 2l8 ---------------------------------l25 VOLNME3 DEVELOPMENT GUIDELINES AND STANDARDS 3.01 —l3l 3.02 ----------------------------------]53 3.03 ---------------------------------l57 3.04 -------------------------'l63 3.05 ------------------------------l77 3lW1,�������........................................................................................................................ 20l 3.07 -----------------------------------]l3 3l8 --------------------------------243 3.09 Planned Unh Devek --------------------------------245 3]0�,b�s.................................................................................................................................... 57 VOLNME4 ADMINISTRATION AND PROCEDURES 4.01 Decision Makii. Procedures -------------------------------285 4.02 -------------------------299 VOLK]ME 5 APPLICATION REQUIREMENTS 5.01 ----------------------------307 5�� ------------------------3l5 5.03 ----------------------------325 5�4 ---------------------------'335 1.02 Definitions Note: Terms not defined in this Section have the meaning set forth in the New Oxford American Dictionary, 2010 edition (see Section 4.02.06.B.6.) Abutting: Touching on the edge or on the line, including at a corner. It shall include the terms adjacent, adjoining and contiguous. Access: The place, means or way by which pedestrians or vehicles have ingress and egress to and/or from a lot or use. Accessory Building, Structure or Use: A detached building, structure or use which is incidental and subordinate to, and supports the primary use on, the same premises. Accommodations: • Bed and Breakfast Inn: A single-family dwelling with at least one room offered to the general public for lodging on an overnight or weekly basis, with a meal provided. • Hotel: A building in which rooms are offered to the general public for lodging on an overnight or weekly basis, where the primary entrance is through a lobby or foyerwith internal circulation to the rooms. • Living Unit: A room or suite of rooms, providing living and sleeping facilities for one or more persons where either cooking or eating and/or sanitation facilities are shared. In a rooming and boarding house, each bed rented for compensation is a "Living Unit." Note: Living unit is not synonymous with "dwelling unit." • Motel: a group of attached or detached buildings, in which more than five rooms are offered to the general public for lodging on an overnight or weekly basis, where the rooms have direct access to the outside without the necessity of passing through the main lobby of a building. • Rooming and Boarding House: A residential building or portion thereof with guest rooms, providing lodging or lodging and meals, for three or more persons for compensation. ADA: The acronym refers to the federal Americans with Disabilities Act (1992) and in the context of WDO standards means compliance with contemporary federal provisions with which developers are bound to comply as standards and compliance with any contemporary supplemental state of Oregon provisions with which developers are bound to comply as standards. Adjacent: Near, close or bordering but not necessarily contiguous with; adjoining but separated by a right-of-way. Administrative Body: The City Council, Planning Commission, Design Review Board, or staff member having the jurisdiction to hear and decide proceedings on land use actions. Alley: A public right-of-way not more than 20 feet wide and not less than 10 feet in width that provides vehicular access to property instead of or in addition to a public street, that intersects with a public street, and that can serve as a utility corridor. Distinct from "Shared Rear Lane". Woodburn Development Ordinance Chapter 1.02 Page 7 147 Building, Primary: A building within which is conducted the main or principal use of the property. Cabana: A stationary structure with two or more walls, used in conjunction with a manufactured dwelling to provide additional living space and meant to be moved with the manufactured dwelling. Caliper: The diameter of a tree measured 6 inches above ground level for trees up to 4 inches in diameter, or 12 inches above ground level for trees 4 inches or more in diameter. Note: A 11 t62� C4', `"hIE"p](i!�d I "or u�ql"llIIV�VP;"ltlllh 1 iCu,:e is 0..4il4'm11kw':d r'o' ki'hdrka°tl+pllo4']f..measured A: ;� above €" � � �Te� ewl„y per Ifial,. definii oo i, regardless of its caliper. �� &k�k�t ��iror 4 r�na�nal ik�r k irB,l Figure 1.02C — 44'.Caliper and �igo4ic-aw. V ree Diameter .11. Vkc lsl �(VA U�p Co,mep1s, Care services: • Child Care: The care, supervision and guidance on a regular basis of a child, unaccompanied by a parent, guardian or custodian, provided to a child during a part of the 24 hours of the day, in a place other than the child's home, with or without compensation. • Child Care Facility: A facility that provides child care, including a day nursery, nursery school, day care center, or similar unit operating under any name, but not including: o a facility providing care that is primarily group athletic or social activities sponsored by or under the supervision of a church or an organized club or hobby group. o a facility operated by a school district or a governmental agency. o a facility providing care while the child's parent remains on the premises and is engaged in an activity offered by the facility or in other non -work activity. o a Child Care Home. • Child Care Home: A residential facility certified by the Oregon Child Care Division. Woodburn Development Ordinance Chapter 1.02 Page 10 148 I . Non� al co�i I ex I: Hic dia�� C10- Of �I I I �-Uflb �!I �! �2Ci2fi I ofl �5 �'eel above Ific u. growid� VJ,ayl I o Calm I ale hA U l is I o B0Iclstlre Ific circw11l,ereAICC OfflIC I fUflk aqid divide fic valbw bV Ific �oIalfie�Ialical com I aii I 12i, Wlidl is 3. Hj lJ,21M-C I �02H Mea�gbig Free, Si/e fiw ��Xisii�lg Frees ill NonOial ('oWexl. ol SloVe: \Vfieg Ific lrw2k is !I dM oi is oi ! slol)4:, Ific lrwik is BOieasgred al, hl lligles lo Ific lrwik j .5 l,ed dIIM121 IfiC C(MI(Y Offl]C 1�'Uflk �lXiS, SO lfi�ll IfiC fiCi,21fil is. !114� ofific sfiorlesl aflid lbe ]6)n2esl sides offfic lrgiik. SCC Fi2M-C I .02J, l J,21M-C I ,02J Measgbig l'xisiim, Frees �kilfi ai A�igje �w o�l sh)I)L. Woodburn Development Ordinance Chapter 1.02 Page 13 149 3. B„]fdtlpw`X 4'b...6, Dlf S jY Ii � lfllpA: \V`X 4'pi i `X 4':...i lf4lpA Ylf„dtlgi"-`X4"s or sVIis less i `X dtlg„1.:7 �4'4"i ]f6 DBp 11 i `X c;, E"1C,dD41p�b.l, 111,4' lrllpA is B011edtlS0.11C,eb.l dtll 1l`X4,', sXOVdtlll4"si, i"-Ill"i"-4180V�'4'tl4'pii"-4' b,4'ldD"w 1l`X4' l6D"w4"sl bratlpIi"11.,. `" i e Figfl-e 1.112 V ,,..,. V ihMrc 1.112VMcdisl �rinig Slrlil V riinigl:; Free ,I. Mtilfi til4'BICIIBOIIeb.: For BOV41 li 514 BOIIBOIIPdlr4'4"ti, 114' tit./4' isi 4'14'rX011i„ledtlti0.lrip�„����, d � 4' e YV B O 1„ P' tl 1 `X 4,. I.rLHAS agd !ddimi Ific 16Dw1diatlB Iele:r o ific. l,arnesl li-11 l dtlild,l7all ific. dial 0iele.Il'o eadi addiliomil.lriYi - cic l iE"M-C 1. 21 - A BOit li sleB0i18 11ed lrce. fia s lrtinAs Ifial are con Ii Iecled. above llrc: [^rotii id ar id does marl iiic]We inidividtial lrc:cc inn kimi dance: lone ellre:r or from 11 it ccraouaouaaai nasal sloA Ifi al do veal fi arc: lriiaAs comiecled d!12oYe tlic 2rotii id V '21M-e: 1.02L ..- Me aciirzirg Mtilfi `alga iva iced Frees Director: The Director of the Community Development Department of the City of Woodburn or designee. Door area: The area of the portion of a door, other than a garage door, that is operable, excluding the doorframe. Driveway: A private vehicular means of access to and from a property, a parking space or area, a garage, or a use, intended to allow vehicular ingress and egress but not intended to provide the traffic circulation function of a street. Dwellings Woodburn Development Ordinance Chapter 1.02 Page 14 150 • Single -Family Dwelling: A detached building constructed on a single lot, containing one dwelling unit designed exclusively for occupancy by one family. • Triplex: Three (3) attached dwelling units on a lot. • Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) — An interior, attached, or detached residential structure that is used in connection with, or that is accessory to, a single-family dwelling. Note: Where it appears in the WDO, reference to dwelling or dwellings "other than multiple -family" excludes ADU unless a specific provision specifies otherwise. Employees: All persons, including proprietors, performing work on a premises. For calculating required off-street parking, it shall be the number present during the largest shift or peak season. Family: An individual or two or more persons related by blood, marriage, legal adoption or guardianship, or a group of not more than five persons (excluding servants) who need not be related by blood or marriage, living together in a dwelling unit. "Family" shall include two or more handicapped persons as defined in the Fair Housing Amendments Act of 1988 living as a single housekeeping unit. Final Action and Final Decision: The City's final decision on a permit application for which there is either no appeal to another decision -maker within the City, or, if there is the possibility of a local appeal, an appeal was not timely perfected in accordance with the Woodburn Development Ordinance. Frontage: That portion of a lot which abuts a public street. Garage: A building, or portion of a building, which is completely enclosed and designed for the storage or parking of a vehicle. Grade: Adjacent ground elevation is the lowest point of elevation of the finished surface of the ground, paving or sidewalk within the area between the building and property line or, when the property line is more than 5 feet from the building, between the building and a line 5 feet from the building. Greenway: For purpose of applying greenway standards, the Mill Creek Greenway as the Mill Creek Greenway Plan (2006-2007 and as amended) identifies. Greenway trail: The mainline bicycle/pedestrian facility within a greenway, as distinct from spurs and supplemental paths and trails. Gross Floor Area (GFA): The sum of the gross horizontal areas of the several floors of a building, measured from the exterior faces of the exterior wall or from the centerline of walls separating two buildings, but not including: 1. Attic and basement space providing headroom of less than seven feet; 2. Uncovered steps or fire escapes; 3. Private garages, carports, or porches; 4. Accessory water towers or cooling towers; 5. Off-street parking or loading spaces. V hilyad6li,g am �Ia l zd��"�<tllg:V... ) �Ial ,cast Ific tarp) or sides of a trce reveriilg t�rs� �riiaiil brd gd] or.. ➢lfdtlaI�"�`M4'r'aar irIBpIIBr11IpIE" dtl In e I N, �"41i'6Ig of bra gcfi4'ratlg l4'dtl4?; Igl a slut larE"Prlfiaal 1 In7, fi JnI te or Cv !tl Dopy o da,tree by B1[,Va Dre lfiall dtl �Y4'rbv 4',n'�t dtl E"4':u iB,Sdtl80114't4'tl;,,,,,,aDrrPb�416�Sll�E" �X4' t6J�tatli i"Iri"�1BOV�4'r4'a�C„ ... Woodburn Development Ordinance Chapter 1.02 Page 16 151 nYn"4"s0.INnll)YiI4'4' 4'lfc4g( is 25,1 Ir4 -cent, rimless d)cg 6fied. dnlf)Yoris .'s lf4',n)orl6.ndncg41 lien is Ifial,.ii, qi Bn] 6Dnin`X4' AI)YjPi"i ilf�'4" ann" ilf4'4.';`� "wlin`X fic liBn i„. IddrV 0.�4' n`XLE?n`X4'lf "wli,�`Xdn41i 4'n'�b.�,,,nn� µ,41fIn�,Eµ,, in`X4' n`XPdn�„ `�,,,,, in`X ann" )In4P t„ldnt dnnegr�nt nnudnv a, lhn k fanmnnuaxnnnugnnu 35 1).1�g-cen1... Home Occupation: A business or professional activity engaged in by a resident of a dwelling unit as a secondary use of the residence, and in conformance with the provisions of the Woodburn Development Ordinance. Such a term does not include the lease or rental of a dwelling unit (See Section 2.02.10). House of Worship: A church, synagogue, temple, mosque or other permanently located building primarily used for religious worship. A house of worship may also include accessory buildings for related religious activities and one dwelling unit. Interested Person: With respect to a land use action, any person or organization, or the duly authorized representative of either, having a right of appeal under the Woodburn Development Ordinance. TIE: E: The acronym refers to the Institute of Transportation Engineers, which publishes both the Trip General Handbook (IOrh Ed. or as amended) and the manual Designing Walkable Urban Thoroughfares: A Context Sensitive Approach (2010 or as amended). Kennel: Any lot or premises on which four or more dogs and/or cats over the age four months are kept for sale, lease, boarding or racing. Landscaping: Areas primarily devoted to the planting and preservation of trees, shrubs, lawn and other organic ground cover, together with other natural or artificial supplements such as watercourses, ponds, fountains, decorative lighting, benches, arbors, gazebos, bridges, rock or stone arrangements, pathways, sculpture, trellises and screens. Legal Description: The description of a subject property by either metes and bounds or in reference to a lot, or lot and block, number of a recorded subdivision or partition. Legislative Action: Any final decision of the city that adds to, amends or repeals the City's land use regulations, comprehensive plan or related maps and does not pertain to a particular property or small set of properties. Loading Space: An on -site space or berth on the same lot with a building, or contiguous to a group of buildings, for the temporary parking of a commercial vehicle while loading or unloading merchandise or material. Woodburn Development Ordinance Chapter 1.02 Page 17 152 The term includes camping trailer, motor home, park trailer, travel trailer, and truck camper Recreational Vehicle Park or RV Park: A plot of land upon which two or more recreational vehicle sites are located, established or maintained for occupancy by recreational vehicles belonging to the general public as temporary living quarters for recreational or vacation purposes. Recycling Center: An area or structure used for the collection and temporary storage of non-putrescible, discarded materials, which will be transported elsewhere to be reused or recycled. Repair: The reconstruction or renewal of any part of an existing building or structure for the purposes of maintenance. The term shall not include structural alteration. Review Area: The review area that defines the character of surrounding dwellings and immediately surrounding dwellings shall encompass the five nearest dwellings to the subject lot that are on the same street and that are within 500 feet of the subject lot. ��6D6Di Pmd Di,4'i"i I6 Dg /6�1fl4' (E�I7�: A circular areaareadtl1f6D41pf b.ailf4'4" i ...xd tli is based 6Dpi i `X 4' i Idtl80114'i4', If 6Dfi `X 4,', q i> ':P � IE L f4.':. I .02M,;,' i1C,4'4'. ll'dtli"�1i"II� . 1 Ipfi�,Idtl80114'i4'If dD� ilf4'4' 4'6;.J[4ldtliti 1 �,6,D6Di radius �6Dlf �X4', ��� �. �4r. I2Ullf4' 1.02��6 D6 Dl. Pmd DiPci t6,Dpi /dDm',,,,,.Pdtl`f 0.11f4',BO114'ffl ROW: The acronym refers to right-of-way. Unless a WDO provision specifies otherwise, ROW excludes railroad right-of-way. School, Elementary, Middle or High: A public or private institution offering instruction in the several branches of learning and study, in accord with the rules and regulations of the State Department of Education. Screening: A sight -obscuring fence, architectural wall, or evergreen hedge at least 6 feet in height. Woodburn Development Ordinance Chapter 1.02 Page 21 153 Setback, Average: For any continuous wall, "average setback" shall be as follows: 1. For a straight wall: The distance derived from dividing the sum of the closest and furthest points of the building wall from the property line by two; or 2. For an articulated wall: The location of a wall where the yard area abutting the property line (accounting for offsets and jogs) is equal to the yard area computed by multiplying the length of the wall by the standard for the allowable average setback. Figure 1.02F — Average Setback for a Straight Wall Figure 1.02G — Average Setback for an Articulated Wall Shared Rear Lane: Similar to "Alley", except that it remains privately maintained and a legal instrument grants the City and the public access to it. �^7vk plk�ki�a@R lf4'4": -z�wly 4'e'k'w�:kll1 �, ll4'a°Bllly' �ee 24 inc-her 4* ki1 klka°tl+�fll4' eF7 4111ea°tl'vd.�q" A �i4*4' �M: aboveground level (-'Sec `4� cfion Woodburn Development Ordinance Chapter 1.02 Page 23 154 Townhouse Project: One (1) or more townhouse structures constructed together with the site development area where there is land division establishing townhouse lot lines and any common area tracts. Free, `"roigj2ific w: Ag exisfi„lig jjf l,fial is 2,1;iiid` es or B➢ ore Ji diu➢ el,g al lYlfeasi fieiOil, "wl`MI�"l;,X, egtld es idh 0 l4'4't, 3'�n Iml` es or B➢ ore Ills circtuu&ereP ice, atl id omn aal mo cldas;ses:.. • Class S: l I1r tan l'(nk e; tlidaai 30 aaiclies.� acid • U.,ass l : 30 Jaic`es or "kider:,,W`Midi 8u ay be lee Iied a F1fP8➢VPg6.ous 11fPa:., (� diad ueler al lYlf4',atltit lX4'Ig)<Xt aal 30 tmlX4"s 4'q41dtlt4"s tah, 9l4'a"t, 5Illii"lX4"s ororBOVaDlf4' I„li i"Ill i"418p1,1,�4'lf4'pii"4'„�.l . .( )iad ➢Va' er al lYre,C tit lIeJLJ`C is ila;figed dtllYove "kilfiiii Ifiis Q �,�`Mdtl,�Yt4'lf 1,.412„ . UGB: The acronym refers to urban growth boundary. See the Comprehensive Plan and its land use map. Use: (noun) An activity or a beneficial purpose for which a building, structure or land is designed, developed or occupied. • Ancillary Use: An ancillary use is a use that is subsidiary to a predominant use and is either vertically integrated with, or directly linked with, the conduct of a predominant use, or is exclusively for the benefit of occupants, or employees, of a predominant use. • Nonconforming Use: A use which met all applicable use standards imposed by applicable City or county zoning ordinance provisions when it was established, but which does not comply with the use standards of the Woodburn Development Ordinance solely because of the adoption of or amendment of the Woodburn Development Ordinance, or because annexation to the City resulted in the application of different use standards to the subject property (See also Nonconforming Development). • Permitted Use: Those land uses permitted in a zoning district that are allowed outright, subject to the standards of the Woodburn Development Ordinance. • Required Supporting Use: An on -site space or facility necessary to fulfill a dimensional or development standard of the Woodburn Development Ordinance, or a condition of a land use approval. Required supporting uses include access facilities, parking, loading, landscaping, and open space. Utilities: Water, sanitary sewer, storm drainage, natural gas, electrical, wire communication service, cable television and all persons and companies supplying the same. Vision Clearance Area (VCA): An area defined by the standards within which visual obstructions are regulated for safety purposes (See Section 3.03.06). Also known as "sight triangle". Wall, Architectural: A brick, poured concrete, precast concrete, or CMU wall that meets the design standards of Section 3.06.06. Wall, Common: A wall or set of walls in a single structure shared by 2 or more dwelling units. The common wall is shared for at least 25 percent of the length of the side of the building of the dwellings. The common wall may be any wall of the building, including the walls of attached garages. (This definition has no necessary relationship to any that might exist in the state building code.) Woodburn Development Ordinance Chapter 1.02 Page 25 155 3.01 Streets, Greenways & Other Off -Street Bicycle/Pedestrian Corridors, and Bus Transit The purpose of this Section is to provide for attractive, safe, comfortable, interesting, and efficient streets, off-street bicycle/pedestrian corridors and facilities, and transit improvements within the city, especially to include and be equitable toward Woodburn residents who cannot or do not own private vehicles or drive, to implement the Woodburn Comprehensive Plan and the Transportation System Plan (TSP), to use civil engineering of streets to reduce speeding, to guide City capital improvement projects, and to have developers upgrade nonconforming streets and construct extended and new streets and off-street bicycle/pedestrian facilities that conform. An objective is to have developers construct or fund street improvements, and other proportional share of improvements for the public, to lessen the cost of land development to the City in order to lessen taxpayer burden for landowners in the context of Oregon Ballot Measures 5 (1990) and 50 (1997). The provision of streets is guided by the applicable goals and policies of the Comprehensive Plan, the TSP, the Highway 99E Corridor Plan, creek greenway plans, the Transit Plan, and other WDO sections. 3.01.01 Applicability 3.01.02 Street General Provisions 3.01.03 Street Improvements Required for Development 3.01.04 Street Cross Sections 3.01.05 Street Layout 3.01.06 Street Names 3.01.07 Off -Street Public Bicycle/Pedestrian Corridors 3.01.08 Mill Creek Greenway 3.01.09 Bus Transit Improvements 3.01.01 Applicability A. Right-of-way standards apply to all public streets and public alleys. B. Improvement standards apply to all public and private streets, public alleys, sidewalks, landscape strips, and on and off-street public bicycle pedestrian corridors. Standards do not exclude conformance with the public works construction code that the Public Works Department administers. C. The Woodburn Transportation System Plan (TSP) designates the functional class of major thoroughfares and local streets. D. This applies to all development as Section 1.02 defines, and is not limited to partitions, subdivisions, multi -family, commercial or industrial construction, or establishment of a manufactured dwelling or recreational vehicle park; however, a lesser set of standards applies to infill residential development of 4 or fewer dwellings and where no land division or Planned Unit Development is applicable, including construction of a single- family dwelling or placement of a manufactured dwelling on an infill lot. See Section 3.01.03C.2. Woodburn Development Ordinance Chapter 3.01 Page 135 156 3.01.02 Street General Provisions A. No development shall be approved, or access permit issued, unless the internal streets, boundary streets and connecting streets are constructed to at least the minimum standards set forth in this Section, or are required to be so constructed as a condition of approval. B. Private streets are prohibited, except in manufactured dwelling parks, pursuant to State statute (ORS Chapter 446 and OAR 918-600). All private streets in manufactured dwelling parks shall comply with statute and WDO standards. C. Materials and construction shall comply with specifications of the City of Woodburn. D. The standards of this Section may be modified, subject to approval of a Street Adjustment, Planned Unit Development, Zoning Adjustment, or Variance. Other sections restrict where and how these application types apply. E. When all public improvements are due: The construction of all public improvements, their passing City inspections, and acceptance by the City are due no later than by either 5.01.0613 in the context of land division final plat application to the City or by building permit issuance, except if (1) the developer applies to the City through the Public Works Department for deferral and (2) the City Administrator or designee issues a document approving and describing a bond or performance guarantee pursuant to Section 4.02.08. Administration of bonding and performance guarantees for improvements that are public defaults to the Public Works Department, and the department shall notify the Community Development Director of deferral applications and any approvals and conditions of approval. F. Fees in -lieu: Per Section 4.02.12. Woodburn Development Ordinance Chapter 3.01 Page 136 157 3.01.03 Street Improvements Required for Development A. With development, the Internal, Boundary, and Connecting streets shall be constructed to at least the minimum standards set forth below. B. Internal Streets Internal streets shall meet all standards of WDO and the TSP. C. Boundary Streets 1. The minimum improvements for a Boundary Street may be termed "half -street" improvements and shall be as follows, except per subsection 2: a. One paved 11-foot travel lane in each direction, even though this results in required improvements being slightly more than half -street by exceeding what the applicable cross section figure would require for a half -street; b. On -street parking on the side of the street abutting the development, if the required cross section includes on -street parking; c. Curb on the side of the street abutting the development; d. Drainage facilities on the side of the street abutting the development; e. Landscape strip with street trees and lawn grass on the side of the street abutting the development; and f. Sidewalk on the side of the street abutting the development. 2. Infill residential development of 4 or fewer dwellings and where no land division or Planned Unit Development is applicable, per Section 3.01.011): A developer shall: a. Dedicate ROW per the required cross section; b. Dedicate one or more streetside PUEs per Section 3.02.0113; c. Either construct sidewalk per the required cross section or pay fee in -lieu per Section 4.02.12; d. Plant a street tree or trees per Section 3.06.03A and specifically sited to conform with where a landscape strip would be per the required cross section, or pay fee in -lieu per Section 4.02.12; and e. Provide minimum access per Section 3.04, and where a driveway approach, apron, curb cut, or ramp within ROW is relevant, have it meet the public works construction code. Woodburn Development Ordinance Chapter 3.01 Page 137 158 D. Connecting Streets 1. The minimum improvements for a Connecting Street shall be one paved 11-foot travel lane in each direction. 2. Connecting streets shall extend from the boundary street of a development, to the nearest intersection that meets the cross-section and improvement requirements of this Section, or 1,000 feet, whichever is less. Figure 3.0IA — Internal, Boundary, and Connecting Streets E. When the Director determines that a required improvement of a Boundary Street would not be timely, such as due to pending development of properties in the immediate vicinity or the area for Boundary Street ROW being wholly on adjacent property outside a developer's control, the developer shall pay fees in -lieu per Section 4.02.12. F. When the Director determines that a required improvement of a Boundary or Connecting Street would not be feasible, due to physical constraints of properties in the immediate vicinity or an inability to obtain right-of-way dedication from property outside a developer's control, the developer shall pay fees in -lieu per Section 4.02.12, the Director may approve construction of a partial -width street to the minimum standards set forth above, or a combination of both. G. ADA: The minimum standards of this Section 3.01 apply to development such that implementation includes constructing new or upgrading existing public improvements to be ADA-compliant. Woodburn Development Ordinance Chapter 3.01 Page 138 159 H. Bridges / culvert crossings: 1. ROW: Required ROW shall remain such regardless of the physical width of the crossing, unless the developer obtains approval of Street Adjustment, modification through Planned Unit Development (PUD), or Variance. 2. Parking: Any parking lane(s) required by the applicable standard cross section shall remain required unless the developer obtains approval of Street Adjustment, modification through PUD, or Variance. 3. Sidewalk widths: A developer may omit from a bridge or culvert the street landscape strips, thereby resulting in curb -tight sidewalk, the minimum width of which shall be either 8 ft where there is to be no adjacent on -street parking or 9 ft where there is to be. Where the City considers a segment of a bicycle/pedestrian facility that is Class A or B to be along sidewalk, the minimum width shall widen to the class standard as applicable. Wider width shall apply where ADA per subsection G applies such that it is required. 4. Fence/railings: Where (1) a street segment is a bridge or culvert crossing, and (2) the public works construction code requires any pedestrian guardrail, handrail, fall protection railing, or safety railing, then it shall be decorative or ornamental (as examples, having an artistic pattern or resembling wrought iron), and a color other than black or charcoal. Any required fence at each end of railings shall be the same color(s). 5. Bridge sides: If the bridge sides are concrete, the surface shall be stamped or treated to resemble either cut stone or rough stone. I. TSP and other adopted long-range plans: Where such plans identify improvements within a Boundary Street, on the subject property of a development, or abutting a side or rear boundary of the subject property, the improvement or a proportional share of the improvement shall apply as a public improvement standard for the development. Applying a proportionate share may necessitate a developer applying to modify, adjust, or vary from a standard where and as the WDO allows. J. Off -site public improvements: To provide for the safety of the traveling public and ensure improved access to a development site consistent with Comprehensive Plan policies and WDO purposes and objectives for orderly urbanization and extension of public facilities, the Director may require off -site improvements reasonably related to a development and concurrent with it. „, Signage: A developer shall remove prohibited signage that Section 3.10.08R identifies. K,.J, Jgli icaw V ree rgrioval M r eserva i 3.00.07J . Woodburn Development Ordinance Chapter 3.01 Page 139 160 3.01.05 Street Layout A. Purpose: To: 1. Implement Woodburn Comprehensive Plan Policies including those regarding avoiding dead-end streets, cul-de-sacs, and out -of -direction travel; 2. Implement the TSP including the Figure 6 "Local Street Connectivity Plan"; 3. Shorten out -of -direction travel for emergency responders; 4. Lessen physical vehicular access to the end of a street stub (from adjacent unimproved land where there is no driveway) that damages an improved street such as by demolishing curb or sidewalk or dragging dirt, mud, or gravel onto an improved street; 5. Not allow outer areas of the city to have street networks so sparse such that a few major thoroughfares are burdened with almost all vehicular traffic; 6. Encourage constructing new means of public access across on -site or adjacent creeks or creek tributaries; 7. Prompt developers to construct alleys or shared rear lanes where they can serve for vehicular travel and access as well as and at less expensive construction cost than public streets; and 8. Allow off-street public bicycle/pedestrian facilities to substitute for a public street, such as an Internal Street, where justified. B. Termination of Streets and Off -Street Bicycle/Pedestrian Facilities 1. Cul-de-sac Streets a. The maximum length of a cul-de-sac street shall be 250 feet. Cul-de-sac length shall be measured along the center line from the nearest right-of-way line of the nearest intersecting street, to the point of curvature of the cul-de-sac bulb. b. The minimum radius of a cul-de-sac bulb right-of-way shall be 55 feet. c. The minimum improved street radius of a cul-de-sac shall be the number of feet per OTC Figure D 103.1 or as amended plus the number that fits curb, planting strip and sidewalk. d. The Director may require bikeway and pedestrian facilities to connect from one cul-de-sac to an adjacent cul-de-sac or street, except where the cul-de-sac abuts developed property, or where the Director determines that there is no need for a connection. 2. Temporary Dead End Streets Streets extensions that result in temporary dead end streets, or stub streets, shall: a. Be extended to the adjoining land when it is necessary to give access to, or permit, a future division of adjoining land; b. Require a barricade at the end of the street to be installed and paid for by the property owners. It shall not be removed until authorized by the City of Woodburn. c. Have an all-weather sign at the temporary street terminus, installed by the Woodburn Development Ordinance Section 3.01 Page 148 161 property owners, that states: "This Street is Planned for Future Extension". d. If the Public Works Director in writing requires, provide either a one foot -reserve strip deeded to the City, or an alternative method for limiting access approved by the City, at the temporary end of the right-of-way. 3. Continuity of Off -Street Bicycle/Pedestrian Facilities Public bikeway and pedestrian facilities, other than those incorporated in a street right- of-way, shall either: a. Provide for a continuous system, with each segment originating and terminating with a connection to a public street, a public alley, a shared rear lane, a greenway, a public park, or to a designated activity center; or b. Provide stubbed facilities to not preclude subsection (a.) and that may extend beyond the limits of an approved development, when such a public facility has been required by the decision -maker. C. Block Standards 1. Block length shall not be less than 200 feet and not more than 600 feet, except where street location is precluded by any of the following; a. Natural topography, wetlands, significant habitat areas or bodies of water, or pre- existing development; b. Blocks adjacent to arterial streets, limited -access highways, collectors or railroads; c. Residential blocks in which internal public circulation provides equivalent access. 2. In any block that is longer than 600 feet, as measured from the right-of-way line of the street to the right-of-way line of the adjacent street, a bikeway/ pedestrian facility shall be required through and near the middle of the block. 3. On any block longer than 1,200 feet, corridors per Section 3.01.07 and 3.01.08 may be required through the block at 600 foot intervals. 4. In a proposed development including partition and subdivision, or where redevelopment potential exists and a street connection is not proposed, one or more off-street bicycle/pedestrian facilities may be required as partition or subdivision connection paths or shortcut paths to connect a cul-de-sac or other public street to other public streets, to other bicycle/pedestrian facilities, or to adjoining land to allow for future connections. D. Street Access Residential development subject to either OFC Section D106 (100 or more multiple -family dwellings) or D107 (30 or more single-family or duplex dwellings) shall comply. Where applicability of either section to a residential development is unclear, then the presumptive standard shall be that if a development has 30 or more dwellings, it shall have two or more means of public access to any of a street, alley, or shared rear lane if a shared rear lane has a public access easement. E. Alleys and Shared Rear Lanes: 1. Purpose: To use alleys and shared rear lanes as a means of access management for the same purposes that Section 3.04.03A lists and to have developers to construct public Woodburn Development Ordinance Section 3.01 Page 149 162 alleys and shared rear lanes where they can serve for vehicular travel and access as well as and at less expensive construction cost than public streets. 2. Cross section: The alley standard cross section is Figure 3.01J. 3. For development within the RSN and RMN zoning districts, see the standards in Section 2.05.04B. For development that is outside those districts and is specifically planned unit development, see the standards in Section 3.09.06C. F. Local street connectivity plan: 1. Purpose: To implement Woodburn Comprehensive Plan policies and TSP Figure 6 "Local Street Connectivity Plan" and related plan text and serve purposes to improve access and circulation for walking, cycling, and rolling along as well as driving and to have developers bring about extended and new local class streets. 2. Applicability: Applicable to a development where TSP Figure 6 indicates a future street corridor into, through, along, or near a development. The Director may determine what the word "near" means. 3. Standards: a. Cross section: Based on Section 3.01.04B.1, the presumptive minimum width shall be 70 feet for a full width future street corridor or 35 feet for a half -street corridor. The Director may establish a wider standard if more than a half -street width but less than full width is within the development. b. Extent: The presumptive minimum extent begins at an existing street and either connects to a different street or protects future connection. The Director may determine extent of a street connection by considering factors including: (1) TSP Figures 2, 8 & 9; (2) An applicable off-street bicycle/pedestrian facility in or adjacent to a development; (3) Access management per Section 3.04; (4) Existing and future bus transit; (5) Proximity to parks and public schools; (6) Context of developments in the vicinity; (7) Whether a development is in a region within the UGB that has a sparse street network; (8) The layout of regional public potable water, sanitary sewer, and drainage and stormwater management lines and facilities; and (9) Where applicable, the ability of development to conform to subsection D above regarding two means of public access. (10) Where applicable, the RCWOD that Section 2.05.05 regulates. c. Future street corridor: Within the width and extent of a future street corridor where there is a street reservation easement instead of ROW, a developer shall not build buildings, install, mount, or place pre -fabricated buildings, or construct free- standing walls or structures such as carports and trash and recycling enclosures. Woodburn Development Ordinance Section 3.01 Page 150 163 d. Subsurface/underground: The Public Works Director may direct a developer's arrangement of private utility lines and facilities if and where they pass under a future street corridor. j, Implementation: The City may implement this section in concert with Section 3.01 at large by using any of full, wider than half -street, half -street, or narrower than half -street ROW dedication. The City may instead or also use any of off-street PUE dedication or dedication of other types of public easements to identify, memorialize, and reserve future street corridors in place of ROW dedication. Where an easement or easements substitute for ROW, a public easement as a street reservation easement shall include text that identifies and memorializes the future street corridor and makes apparent the easement purpose. The Director may apply this subsection F when administering a street reservation for a street that TSP Figure 2 classifies as higher than local. 1.5. S,iggifii°aw tree rgova !i flid 1YI-es4',]fvafi6Dw....See Sediog 3.00.07B.2c.,r. 3.01.06 Street Names A. All public streets and private manufactured dwelling park streets shall be named, after providing the Woodburn Fire District with an opportunity to review and comment. B. Public and private manufactured dwelling park streets shall be named as follows: 1. The street name shall not duplicate an existing street name, unless there is reasonable assurance the named streets will be connected in the future. 2. New streets shall be designated with the same names as existing streets only if they fall in the same grid line and there are reasonable assurances that the street will connect with another section of the numbered street. 3. Street names shall not sound like another street name or cause confusion. 4. Street names that are deliberately misspelled, frivolous, or reflect the name of the developer or family members shall not be allowed. C. Streets shall be further named with a suffix. 1. Except as indicated in the Woodburn Transportation System Plan, the following suffixes designations apply to new streets, as follows: a. North/South streets shall be designated as a "Street", with the exception that major streets classified as an arterial in the Woodburn TSP may be designated as a "Road" or a "Highway" b. East/West streets shall be designated as an "Avenue", with the exception that major streets classified as an arterial in the Woodburn TSP may be designated as a"Road" or "Highway" c. A skewed or meandering street shall be named a "Drive". Woodburn Development Ordinance Section 3.01 Page 151 164 3.06 Landscaping The purpose of this Section is to identify the requirements for rmte a�n a��a a�tr n� , amid rtreel la$i sc,!IY4:siri.pY ,,, street trees, 6Dpm tili4', ],!pidtim"an.ilE", d!pid ir4'4' lyeserWyallor i atl id re�Oioval Landscaping enhances the beauty of the City, provides shade and temperature moderation, mitigates some forms of air and water pollution, reduces erosion, promotes stormwater infiltration, and reduces peak storm flows. 3.06.01 Applicability 3.06.02 General Requirements 3.06.03 Landscaping Standards 3.06.04 Plant Unit Value 3.06.05 Screening 3.06.06 Architectural Walls 3.0607 .....Significant Trees amiPfiva@h4'7-��r8D�ID4TMfl"ha,��r4"4'rW';tlil6Dp�&��,4'Bpioval 3....J)p ' -4)444...Q➢.��e'�r Free. ➢'ra Dl r.Cild Dp'� � �A�C,Sll'�S" Cd DllXSi rlI CiI61]„C 3.06.01 Applicability The provisions of this Section shall apply: A. To the site area for all new or expanded multiple -family dwelling and non-residential development, parking and storage areas for equipment, materials and vehicles. B. Dwellings other than multiple -family need comply only with the street tree and significant tree provisions of this Section. 3.06.02 General Reauirements A. Building plans for all uses subject to landscaping requirements shall be accompanied by landscaping and irrigation plans. B. All required landscaped areas shall be irrigated unless it is documented that the proposed landscaping does not require irrigation. C. All shrubs and ground cover shall be of a size upon installation so as to attain 80% of ground coverage within 3 years. D. Installation of plant materials and irrigation specified in an approved landscaping plan shall occur at the time of development and shall be a condition of final occupancy. Should site conditions make installation impractical, an acceptable performance guarantee may be approved, subject the requirements of this Ordinance (Section 4.02.08). E. The property owner shall be responsible for maintaining all landscaping, fences, and walls in good condition, so as to present a healthy and orderly appearance. Unhealthy and dead plants shall be removed and replaced, in conformance with the original landscape plan. F. The required number of plant units shall be met by a combination of plant materials listed in this Ordinance (Table 3.06B). Woodburn Development Ordinance Chapter 3.06 Page 205 165 C. Parking area landscape island standards: Landscape islands or peninsulas shall cap each aisle end to protect parked vehicles from moving vehicles, emphasize vehicular circulation patterns, and shade vehicles and pedestrians. Structured parking is exempted. 1. Each south, southwest, and west island or peninsula cap of a parking aisle shall be minimum 84 square feet within back of curbing, narrowest dimension 6 feet within back of curbing, and contain a tree. 2. Remaining islands and peninsulas shall be minimum 28 square feet within back of curbing and narrowest 2 feet within back of curbing, except where subsection 3 below supersedes. 3. There shall be no more than 10 consecutive parking spaces in a parking aisle without a mid -aisle landscape island or peninsula. For consecutive parking spaces that include one or more accessible/ADA spaces and their aisles, the maximum shall be 9 consecutive parking spaces. Mid -aisle landscape islands or peninsulas shall be to the same standards as subsection 1 above. 4. At drive aisle crossings of walkways and wide walkways that respectively Sections 3.04.06D and 3.05.02N describe, each south, southwest, and west side shall have a landscape island or peninsula to the same standards as subsection 1 above. 3.06.04 Plant Unit Value Plant Unit (PU) Value Table 3.06B Material Plant Unit (PU) Value Minimum Size 1. Significant tree 1 15 PU each 24" Diameter 2. Large tree (60-120 feet high at 10 PU each 10' Height or 2" Caliper maturity) 1 3. Medium tree (40-60 feet high at 8 PU each 10' Height or 2" Caliper maturity 1 4. Small tree (18-40 feet high at 4-PU each 10' Height or 2" Caliper maturity)1 Woodburn Development Ordinance Section 3.06 Page 208 M. 3.06.06 Architectural Walls A. This Section shall apply to required architectural walls. B. Design Standards and Guidelines 1. An architectural wall shall meet the texture, color, and articulation requirements on the face away from the proposed development. 2. An architectural wall should meet the texture, color, and articulation requirements on the face toward the proposed development. 3. An architectural wall shall have a minimum three inch horizontal articulation of at least one linear foot of the wall of intervals not more than 40 feet; and 4. An architectural wall shall have a minimum six inch vertical articulation of at least one linear foot of the wall of intervals not more than 40 feet. 5. An architectural wall shall incorporate at least two colors. 6. An architectural wall shall have an earth tone coloration other than grey on at least eighty percent (80%) of the surface. 7. An architectural wall shall be architecturally treated with scoring, texture, or pattern on at least eighty percent (80%) of the surface. C. Retaining walls should/shall meet the texture and color requirements of architectural walls in or abutting residential districts, where the texture and color requirements apply to the visible face of the retaining wall. D. For multiple -family dwelling development, each refuse and recycling collection facility shall have a pedestrian opening minimum 3 feet, 4 inches wide in addition to the truck gates. If the pedestrian opening is gated, the gate shall swing inward. 3.06.07 �� ill` loll 4 ); (I ml�v�g�m�imr aT�': � m 4 �e on arm iv��li�t ➢I2rlptt jj�): m� „rmm m� mrmt m a m r� m m4ma A. lfY6le: The purposes. of this l41i4wl 04Matl4444a14 s-liB^1kisgd4dl'mII II4k lilI6' e eew h ll= of al4*rlrt�'CIinoll or siagllikea@ lr� Ifees 'v*iIfiinl II -Kr-( 4yl `° iagllitil"a@ lr� trces elhklR lce B14'igfiborfioods by erealing a sc4 is of l"lla raRcie klpld ji4'fl Nnklnelce4 hl g4'm14 kll 'hklaplkfkev.°tlgll 1r414'°w_Off pf+'mle propeoyl rllasll 1X1 lfel;iskW'0..1, 1X 4H,41rklO4aS40 ht'e orprol,4M:y:;. 1. Presen'e siEmllli°aIW 1rcel as laidBOiaijs atlplb l6Dr "ka!v„fii IllIg,,,. 1 Presen,etree eatlplojh l rillry Ifia�l is lfic YV Y4'lf4'lf'wIl `Xlpli"IlV IBOIIII`4 atlplb. 411C),Ipli"6Dr YfiD„],Catll4'b. 14'tl,,,,,. rgllJ)4 Cl gr-am�rly ail atl l a ml,iexatlll61pl 3SllarRe ,I. l,,vpl`40.1r4' `4tl,Ilatl Y 4' lre4' r4'ph cg0iew 61,]C 141p1b.IlllE)i, 6Dl 10.1c" x,,,, "wl`Xm al,),plicatlpll`)rPB01ioveIre 4" °,du. 14�igfiborfioodsby arelei a�nlrfl,,lr4�rxoua�nxs�nl 7, l,,vpl `Xatlpli"4'1, i"rPa�llgl„lµ, atl `44'pl`446Dl i" `Xatlr„ O1iedaice tirbai lrew allaid efl'e .. F 1. ��elarc ra1.l 4�ranrtan fir, l'�V r4'6141I]C,IllIE" atl lY4',]CXOIIII lYrdDC,4'Iti, Ipli"1C,4'atlti4' 1 `X4':... I C4' I `X6D6J�i 6Dl lY4'1C,,ti6Dplti r4'Blrll,dDr'IllIE" 11f„4'4"`4 1l`Xatl,�a trey or llxcar coWraellrl v ill do sal s,!l'elv', Woodburn Development Ordinance Section 3.06 Page 214 167 9. Absorb slot ,aler daaaaB I I . NSIiMUINI I)CMC(Al IfiC COwexls ofexisliiilg developiew aW mnk developiew or 11 Alhnk cowimied reasomible ecoiooiic tise of 13, lvsl,!121isl) jy9cesses agd sl.qidards Ifial igjjfl-V a2r daalfi ofsigaiil i . c,!w agd. FAII]aalce Ific bcwly ofific city.,. 411e 14,..14A!+HIHWA1444111�1 S-igH44C41W lf�le M*1 4-w feplkwemefl� feqjl4femeii�s rof siagiiificaii�ll 1. ReB oval aE 1yeservall . og M aflv si� Iificaw Free ol jjjyd!w Wiich is defiged. ig CfiajYj4'r 1 .02 wider " Free,SIg➢](,fIcaw".,,,,,.Ajlj, licabilil,y exigids to gfligcoUh�jaled 1(m-ilory lbd!l is lbe stlijecl n , awa�rly ofag Amiexaiioii .11)plicalwai.. I lEll om: hwasive species Ifial Fable 3.00F lisis. (A Iioai Iialive species is Iiol 1 � Formatted: Indent: Left: 0.68", No bullets or 'numbering lohever, eve�l 1 ( !) �! rg�iovaj l'ee or l'ees rggiu lig Formatted: Indent: Left: 0.94", No bullets or applicable, (2� Ific Cily ��Iay slill apply a la�id tise co�idilioal ofapproval Ifial req[wres [numbering JYr-esgyaliog of or ➢more W M' ftees, dMd (]j 14'gardim�, llow-e sireel conidors (Al parlicillar, rel Ioval shall Ilol occlir wilil ComInIclio 1 and pllblic 11 such conidors gecessilales If.. lv])4�: SiE��Iificagl Free Rg�ioI�d Pen�iil 1�� Seclio�i 5.01 A I . A�iv ofific. l'olhnkiiig laW tise applicaliom loiay stibslilwe ihiecessar,y aai,yvkay aaid Ific Nreclor 11ses I . I lo ahiim�sler lbe sigLflicd�11 FESM'Cservalu)al aaid rgaiovaj p�-ovisiogs: ( 'o�idiliomlj � Jse, l�6"tJgI2 l�.PrJeh:, Plamied l JaA l)reNaiigar,y Parliliog or Stibdivisioal:, Rij�arla�l (�'onidor aaid \Vellaaids ( h,(Aay Ncjjicl l tj i � VJ� ce:, d / E aaflifl2i Neilher ( �radiilg P4'Diil gor bgildilil' deBaIolilloal JY4'mil I I sstlaalce �12�!iwle any�wal lo re��Iove fe*iewed w� is 4yjxl l ispp4c+1400 14kwlllof+se Ille feiwml 4441 lfee� 14) 41e l'ollow4l�e- t A I)i wov A o V i giii fi� kia 1 11 'fee R ei i ")v A I lefi w i s s h al I be lie 14 i a I abe y kia I e e 1) e,�* e ea I N4weff4ef I isliki MoN, 17 �4) allov, iwrjxlc-40044411e leafl,ij� 2 . For Ific removal ofa diseased ordktaigerotis frcca reporl From a Certified arborisf orkl�tl isrboa 4s-1 kqpr4wed by Ill e a: -ley �44011 1X! 40MHIi4ek1, Ci!414'VR,2: 1401 fl4�aAle +4 Chikid 4w dyillg, slflwrwafly lfllsot+tId, of 11a"aftloos err I 4ofpropefly Woodburn Development Ordinance Section 3.06 Page 215 168 a. 9 NM llAr4,n WF ns n�mna ,ranann ar fie, OF phO uargmeaHM S 0)H nOfl H r uagn4l, dl�W I�iR,00F nr Kr F04t4fe aa._wx C4)orl..••arlraarna4l°nanap+n n4an aanarl+HIAaV r4'm444r4nr140a 144n..Wr &Onfal0p+Rn4ana.ly4 rinana4�..4•aks rn ekos ^.' wki .be k4ly hoanredl I. ..nl,` rla°nro'k 4'rL44n'w Fee-+aioy 4e a!e411l0"r4'4.1pr4* 4) arolAawnllk l g A p4'wwntl141 +R anff 41^Snll4'r�4'rkF�'?, And 14e owflef shall awppmsa... �w l�wnr flifee days l%ar Ifieremovalp4"n nrowat,pa+rra+awnaalo lis iofl, l ll4' kmF0.nawnan4' of a a'Fnjaopswnal Inn r4'wnllrwk, p4'rwA propeAy nT^wn of to fen )IRCi 4na°ab'44 we farwed N null one -lf41d wbv4'.mw one, �41Crvl-fq)la@C"�4offieff1 If4'4'.'4`011 No Al I4'W4 I:xr^O iRC-IIC4 nna'cklhper. E'aa'Ch replaace nmif tree wlwawll A o as sp4'cies n of pr4Dl tided by 1.his `^4'i°IIom l he r4'jPl ma 4'w0114'n1 a44 Ohl`+aallNo Opine 40wn 1i 4,/e lfa°tlq'kt6.n4k04 MllMan^FAY 001he' FnjaAKRII Ifeep ra�jamnaca�rlQ �4�na4�nanl �tannaaBsr4B�;:: 1. IrlrawhVs repan I is anpp, txannat subnllt led yna anrlraartst°s report lmv as xcn rtlied aaslraartrt A r g4 pmanpanr4�4B am r4 lln m d tlraat ks t�`X a' t r4' 4" a h,tI4,,,, ljf �%. ant4'and Ii4':,n`XtIlI4'r anm4 praDVl4'r xannatda,xt InflaDrB][,IlantlaDnf lar,r t `�4' an Y,,,,p Ii"annft, dtl,nfb. I Myat Aar4n mrlranrnrtdnna4B tlr4� naa�n,.ul �rlranrnrt"s x4�rtnl�nx�tnanna bVi Pnft,alles t `MP street address or addresses resses aal t re 4AI rjeci ar'Opertv,,or ifnone, on e, titaatlnf,g x lent nave iber(s.)� r0.1i" r and t `X4' j,,,�6D41nf1V lax C. 1s4B4Bress4's tls4':,,,,s] b t lag rPBnll Waal annfb.l „mP`4PrW'anlhT praIzstaanas, nib an WY,plI4"ann A narrative able tan stlbsfiwie lint tlsns nnaartail as relxwi.: .... `�aYP 4°t,,�I4'r t r4' ant 4' am i �.14'r and IICX`4a YP G�t Ia DlX:a, I= tan nnllntk,we in cannalaarxmn w v nt.lx W a¢ t `^lc:xthm IMr.4l%l.Q lr4 h w: mid 1h sign aYrP`4Paantho I`"..]fP Paannat,„, Inf1i°ant4,'`4 "wl`XPtI`XPn anna anaoli"po anm„aTatran sm 11 „4" prant4�c„t,tanna 4Ba�rnaaa"�,. tan aaan..11mv tls4� p,m4�sxrnptnv4� am 4Bnscr4�tnannaanm✓ stanna4Baa,m4Bs anl�tr4; xannastma� ttanna pgn� :a.42ar 94 s ll he l anrectaar allay regllire an second aarbornst"s optnaionp Woodburn Development Ordinance Section 3.06 Page 216 169 c. �1rcxjes agd �mjiij�oiwoii si/e .11 IrIaWjlig: Per Fables 3.00B & 5jonificant 'I"'irce lPireseirvatiOfl & Reirnoyal: I of InvasM S ............... ............... ............ 3 hwse chesimil Aescidus himocasfanwi� ,I Q ooldei chaiii Iree 14"aftwerl 5, FAiglish fiawfioni 0 hlOisfi holly, I/ex aqIqfi)1iw'IP law -el. Prwnus lwwocenLUS 8, h)CIISI. Woodburn Development Ordinance Section 3.06 Page 217 170 9, Norwav ��Iaple j � 0, 12/�Ifan o ides 10sycauioleBaIajY]4� A d0 I I . \kl2iw 1r2ph!r. 1 °(0dus afl)a 12, FAUV l-ess,/Primess Irce, PwdoI4,,nia ImmInfosy 13Free, M'fieave�i A ilanthus aliissiiiw. II Fhlbl e able is based o�i Ific Cit ,v ofhwflanid Mireati ofPjamAig longStislaiiiabilily (BPS�. .111.11. I ')", I I M,,- I ' I Woodburn Development Ordinance Section 3.06 Page 218 171 �Jjmificant lPirescirvatiMM & Reirnoval: 'lleirs of Standards 3.061"" kvch) m liew or � Jsc Seclion 3.00.07 Fla of Slandards J. Exisling a. Singldi' C,awily ormant011clured &kelling, Lie! I dl� on i . ndividual h)l Ifial is residenlial1v /oned b� � JndeveloPed lol fiw Wiich Ificre is no �'ig 2 (J'2) hind use Final decision Ifial con dilions Irce. preso wifion and nm loval, no land use. .Wplicalion fiw annexalion and/or developmew, or no buildbuila img pernill . I fiw d4"vChm"1011, -applicalion c. Any Who cxisfinl�" developmew or usc�, I Mnk aMfill/minor: Nel lolal I to I &kcllings Ong Fla 3 F3�, Llchwmcnl. a h)l "wilfi no land division in Mulfiple Fi a 'I A �I!wil&nmnmba of&elfil 2sv "Idevelo �'i( ld/� le n or wher: AnNoffier mnk pmewor use, in Buixed uses Anon ex "kiifi no mnk developmeni: Sce inslead Seclion 3MOM7J: Whae ii vkould be unclear Wmi fie r would be applicab1c, Ific Nreclor mlav dcicrwinci Fla I Slandards: Where H is Wjlic,abjc pg Fable 3.00 FA 4ee FeqtdFed by Ilse, dewlojmieW 4444i4 OftliRMICil l ) of w• a C4)okl4ioo 44, jxlflni4 of I klllkl ose approval sliall qjlmlir, ' � as a feplkwemeI4 lfee� hl 4-w Neigilbodlood 4, �veflay 4�4�C-1 4 )), fl4d1 felaIklCilfflleW lAle S14011 IX!j)4l)1kA Off lllill 40fflle I WOffF4 'IV As4lle 4C+111� Ifee Feplisc-ecl. l n ofl4dlf AOW!s� I 4j)A)j)eA 'IV OWWIf S14011 C44)0W 414Qfl4)kl 44' rcplklccllmll� Replacellmll shall be acomnplisfied by: 1. Removal crilaia: Fhe ray M- 1�'CCS M'C MINI M]JIlkill�iR12: OW! �Rle Off 14�1 'hWPjeC-1 properl v )cd!d, lerminally diseased, or olfienkise dying. 1). Posimdanll^(n or fia/ard of. Collapse or !loll, Udall of branch or branches, or Udall of hard a2nija2 pg-sons ouldoM's, existing buijdllgs, or one or more molor vehicles parked in a driv(nkav Ifial confiwms "wilfi Seclion 3.4)1,4),l and, WlcrC Wj�licabh:,, Seclion 3.05.02D.3. 172 ar ann2 a!n] �!�Id �m llhi!! ts� gnus (31 L2i!dim! a!nId an lm2!1 okme wee M an RMMT Ise 1, we (my 411e propeoy ovoef map P" 0 WNYMOM we of MA ism"fed MMMw 4. IwAf nof phinfed PlirstianI 14) Ihis -,Scoion. Fhe api 4i'Cani sh kill pay Ifie Inifigalion lee in Ifie 441y'n�, Me km? NeximiWelthe +;Qgolioo �`ee a44011 lxC4404444ed 4yfl4e (41y C 4 mn eil in 4h e M 040 Re Keh edUQ M ed On In e aVeRWe MHe 0 P an IWO in e4 MPH Woodburn Development Ordinance Section 3.06 Page 220 173 I fee available rrof I W 4wal lllwsefies, plos 3 Slandards: I . Removal crilaia: Same a� Fl, "wilfi I fic limils Ifial fiw a bui I ding! fiw �kfiicfi I fic Cily has issued do demoliliOn Ific JYarl ofi-emoval crilerion (12j abOill CM . S11 . na buildinn as �cll as removal crilaion (d. i aboul breach ofbuildimn fimndalion �koujd no h)�igjcr be applicable. I Preservalion: shall 1��-cscrvc al leasl 33,3 pg,cem and .111 SiLlnificani. Frees Ifial do nol micel removal crilcria,rounding, any fraclion less Ifian I .0 upjaD I Mill2allon remal . ils rcqj�j . i-ed fiw Ific remainin,21 JYg-ccnl, 3. 1 kvialion: /a)niDg 1Yg-wissiblc fiw Ific �r-cscrvalion slandards. HFici I Slandards: 1. Removal crilaia: Sawle as H , I Preservalion: shall lyeserve al leasl 50,0 1�g`ccnl oi .111 Significanl Frees Ifial do nol micel removal criteria roan dimanv fraclion less Ifian I M Im to I Njijlg�!Ilon rejulu!] ils rcqlt�ircd fiw Ific rcmai�]112g pg-ccnl 3Devialion: /oning A(tiusimew permissible fiw Ific preservalion slandanti s., L .EP`Y4nllcdj JAnon exalion Slandards: a Ferrilory Ifial is Ific subject ly21Yg-lv ofan anon exalion applicd!Iloil,. bFhe anon exalion dumlica atom does nol come �ilfi addilional hand use mmlicalion 174 m4�scmtgrtt�ve Stanidamds. Woodburn Development Ordinance Section 3.06 Page 222 175 M C)W nieterrat"fire t ---------- 4.5" "oves gr de P " E,',"Croachmente 5hll be, eu regU4^ et raaazta proteotion zone raaatha Root protection Encroachments haupi s...o ,., ,ve, aezrre ire Qa 12 foot raGctjpy no mr ore t ,haaam rtaMU4 Vra�te. of t he, t ot,raN Yareaa ( 4" ala;rri ter) ha the root parotaertiaamt 20"e'r1rcle ble ➢ � / p� ientts Fxann I rl4,�;. V n�l��m4' ��.il�ml� .�'4�mnnun��...t' : ➢�-ntt"man"n�. 1.:. P1f6DiPb,I,Iv4' i"6DnISilflli"iI6DnX,,,,,,14'n�i"In�E, Woodburn Development Ordinance Section 3.06 Page 223 176 �JL,Iirc 3c00B Proleclive ('onSlfUCli0fl FOIC4 Pd!Mj 177 (1) �iwl Ca,wy: � kW<�S.?L21u2d "Ilile:orau�, CnOber Vejhnk):, �2�- M 1��jillg: � JU)il agd ififiere is stich .1 fiww:, Formatted: Indent: Left: 0.88" aW stik�iil lo Ific � kveh)U�Ieffl � )�A�arWigll a cerlfficafio6 l fi)ni. Ifial each �,elce h)cafio6 l has begi p�-9p4 fly almcfiipig, dqiv addiliomd. docwieWafio6 i Ifial Ific fiwwi reqtiires., 2. Arborisi's Nscrefiomiry Slc above stibsecli )ni I I E�� S C -H. ri !. �, e. s I ap i d ar d s ar e i p I �,e .1 s i 1) 1 e, I h e i re C I o r Bp 11 aNY apjYrO v e a I I 4'tl pIdtlily e Bp I e as t I re s:, 1 YrO v i d e d I h al Ific applicaw aW/or cowraclor doieel Ific swidards: Fhe allemalive RP/ is )ared bv aDi arboris `'0 o rdtlti i� s )ecled Ific sile adid exdn0iiiied fiw cicfi stilYjecl Irce. Ific di�n�iewr al breasi fiei��fil (� AU locafiopi, apid exleffl ofrool Cover:, evahialed fiw cdicfi Ific lolengice lo Coj1sjr41C11oj1 m1pacl based og ils W4xies Uld ficalflL idewified dtlDIy 1�� s I . � cis 11 � I I 11�� ! �kilfiig Ific roof /o i( � � Iid. s0.1N01il Ied a rep6Djj 162 )Jreclor. Stich B0iav be Jdiwrp6Djawd by revisiog iwo Ifie. Irbori I's r(a D D11 lb I secfioDi 3MOM7 r ]111ired or ➢Oiay be a ti0.1p,pllP iew lo Ifial sgbloii!Ied revorl, bFhe arborisl prepared aid stikiilIed a phi�i providiiilg Ific rabid tired to dgiomqaw Ifial Ific allgli!w BOielfiod 1Dl-9yides ag adeqjj1d!w level og. based o�i Ific figdiligflw� rile msl)ecllolT,. C. ffific allemalive BOIelfiods nxii6re Ifial Ific arborisl be oi site dw-imcomlnicfioi 12d' al)plicaw or coglraclor shall sgkoiil a C6DDV ofific arborisl cowracl fi)r 1h6Dse se4 \'ices prior lo lsst4l�lce of a Free Re�� oval or Imildiii,g petl i0il, aW a fimil reporl frod ii Ific arborisl docw1ic�jfi�j�� fl i➢Ig , i� 1�1�1�clwgs qid vgify i g Ific viabilily ofific Irce. or Irces JDJor lo Film] illsjDPCjiodl by � kvejoj�i4'd]j � ShO �], d. ffific afig]all . ve free jljecfioi BDielfiod im,olves allergalive comlnwfiol Woodburn Development Ordinance Section 3.06 Page 225 178 Woodburn Development Ordinance Section 3.06 Page 226 179 If the PUD plan proposes stormwater mitigation measures that exceed minimum City standards by at least 25 percent, the Commission may allow up to an additional 10percent of the density to be transferred, upon a recommendation by the Public Works Department. If the PUD plan proposes other environmental, sustainability, or architectural enhancements, the Commission may allow up to an additional 10 percent of the density to be transferred, commensurate with the amount, quality, and community benefit of the enhancements. Such enhancements may include, but are not limited to, solar heating or electrical generation, community gardens, public art, mitigation of off -site stormwater, and greywater diversion. 3.09.04 Conceptual Development Plan A. PUDs require both a Conceptual Development Plan and a Detailed Development Plan. These reviews may be accomplished sequentially or as a consolidated review, at the applicant's discretion. B. A Conceptual Development Plan shall include drawings and a narrative describing the surrounding neighborhood, existing site conditions, general development areas, phasing, land uses, building envelopes, architectural theme, landscaping and buffering, streets, bicycle and pedestrian circulation, common areas, utility locations, sign theme, and other information the Director may deem necessary to convey the concept plan. 3.09.05 Detailed Development Plan A. PUDs require both a Conceptual Development Plan and a Detailed Development Plan. These reviews may be accomplished sequentially or as a consolidated review, at the applicant's discretion. B. No building, grading, access, or other development permit may be issued until aDetailed Development Plan has been approved for at least one phase of the project. C. Buildings shown on a Detailed Development Plan are exempt from Design Review if they are in substantial conformity to the Detailed Development Plan (see Section 3.07.01.13). D. A Detailed Development Plan shall include drawings and a narrative sufficient to demonstrate compliance with the Conceptual Development Plan and any conditions of approval previously imposed. A Detailed Development Plan shall provide specific information regarding the site layout, architecture, and proposed amenities. A Detailed Development Plan that proposes land uses not in the Conceptual Development Plan or that deviates by more than ten percent from any development standard in the Conceptual Development Plan for any phase, or that does not meet the standards of this Section shall not be approved. The applicant may request that the decision -maker approve such a plan as an amended Conceptual Development Plan. 3.09.06 Development Standards A PUD is intended to allow flexibility in the development standards of Sections 2.02 through 2.04 and 3.01 through 3.11. The Detailed Development Plan may propose modified standards without a separate Street Adjustment, Zoning Adjustment, or Variance. Any standard that the City does not accept in writing as a modification shall apply to the PUD. The development standards stated Woodburn Development Ordinance Section 3.09 Page 262 180 below shall not be modified through the PUD process. A. Common area and density shall comply with Table 3.09A. Common Area and Density Standards for Planned Unit Developments Table 3.09A Transfer Residential Mixed -Use of Density Common Four or fewer dwelling units All undevelopable site area 6 Area, Five or more dwelling units, 30 percent of gross site area, including all Minimum or nonresidential uses undevelopable site area 1, 5, 6 Improved Four or fewer dwelling units None Common Five or more dwelling units 100 square feet per dwelling unit Area, Minimum Nonresidential uses None None None Residential Density, Sites less than 20 Pursuant to the Comprehensive Plan a Minimum (units per gross acres net acre) Sites 20 or more Either pursuant to the Comprehensive Plan or gross acres 7 15. Residential Density, Maximum (units per Not specified a net acre) 1. At least one common area shall be sized to accommodate a circle 25 feet in diameter. 2. In residential zones only. There is no minimum for non-residential zones. 3. Child care facility for 13 or more children, group home for six or more persons. 4. The maximum density is determined by setbacks, off-street parking, open space, and other requirements. Pursuant to Comprehensive Plan Policy Table 1, Note (p. 7), allowable densities may be increased through PUD above the maximum(s) of the base zone(s). 5. See Table 3.09B. 6. An existing or proposed golf course may count towards the common area minimum as follows: Of the 30 percent minimum, maximum 10 percent (1/3) if the course is public, 5 percent (1/6) if private, or 15 percent (half) if the course has a bicycle/pedestrian path with public easement and both connect to the course boundary at minimum two points allowing access across the course. 7. 15 is the standard if OAR 660-046-0020(10) "Master Planned Community" & 660-046- 0205(2)(b) are applicable. B. Improved Common Area 1. Common areas are deemed improved ifthey are providedwith benches, playground equipment, gazebos, picnic facilities, or similar amenities. Lawn area by itself does not constitute improvement. Trails or paths do not constitute improvement, unless they connect to the public trail system. Woodburn Development Ordinance Section 3.09 Page 263 181 2. Common meeting or recreation rooms are deemed to be improved common areas. 3. Improved common areas are subject to the performance guarantee provisions of Section 4.02.08. C. Streets 1. A PUD shall conform to and, where possible, enhance existing or planned vehicle, pedestrian and bicycle networks, including connections and functionality. Note: See Figures 7-1 (Functional ClassificationDesignations), 7-3 (Pedestrian Plan), and 7-4 (BicyclePlan)of the Transportation System Plan. 2. All streets shall be public. 3. Boundary and connecting streets shall use the street sections of Section 3.01.04. 4. Internal streetsmay usethe street sections of Section 3.01.04, orthe PUD may propose other street sections, provided that the streets: a. conform to the Oregon Fire Code (see Figures 3.04C and 3.04D) b. include sidewalks, and c. are constructed to the specifications of the Public Works Department. 5. Alley / shared rear lane: Where the PUD is not within the RSN or RMN zoning district, is 3 or more acres, includes residential use, and is proposed for a total of 20 or more lots, then one or more alleys or shared rear lanes as Section 1.02 defines shall serve minimum 20 percent of all lots and tracts. D. Parking If a front setback of less than 20 feet is proposed, the requirement of Section 3.05.03 for an improved parking pad for single-family and duplex dwellings may be satisfied by on -street parking or by a common off-street parking lot. E. Signs 1. A PUD may include asignplanto requireacommonarchitecturaldesign and location. . The standardsofthe MixedUse Village (MUV)zone shall apply to commercial uses in the residential zones of a Mixed -Use PUD. F. Si S"piIIi"dtlW hff4"plf4"s4'1C;W'dtlil6Dpi dtl,�Xb lf4'BOV6nVdtl: A P� 1) i"atlmLX6Di BOV6DiIi V `"r4'i"ildh,n,��3.4D0.0"l dtlpi,,,, Woodburn Development Ordinance Section 3.09 Page 264 182 C. Possible Actions at the Revocation Hearing: Depending on the situation, the City may take any of the actions described below. If the decision is to modify the permit, the City may not approve a use that is more intense than originally approved, unless the possibility of this change has been stated in the public notice. Uses or development which are alleged to have not fulfilled conditions, violate conditions or to be inconsistent with the City's approval may be subject to the following actions: 1. The City may find that the use or development is complying with the conditions of the approval. In this case, the permit shall not be altered. 2. The City may modify the permit if it finds that the use or development does not fully comply with the conditions of approval or otherwise does not comply with what was approved, that the violations are not substantial enough to warrant revocation and that the use can comply with the original approval criteria if certain conditions are met. In this case, the City may modify the existing conditions, add new conditions to ensure compliance with the approval criteria, or refer the case to the code compliance officer for enforcement of the existing conditions. 3. The City may revoke a permit if it finds there are substantial violations of conditions or failure to implement conditions of a permit, such that the original approval criteria for the use or development are not being met. D. Effect of Revocation: In the event permit approval is revoked, the use or development becomes illegal. The use or development shall be terminated within thirty days of the date that all appeals periods have been exhausted, unless the decision provides otherwise. In the event the City Council's decision on a revocation request is appealed, the revocation action shall be automatically stayed until the appeal is resolved. 4.02.11 Transfer of Approval Right Any final decision granted under this ordinance shall run with the land and shall transfer with ownership of the land, unless otherwise specified in the decision. Any conditions, time limits or other restrictions imposed with a decision shall bind all subsequent owners of the subject property. 4.02.12 Fees in -Lieu A. In lieu of public improvements: 1. Permissible if the Director allows, whether wholly in -lieu for one, some, or all of the kinds of required improvements or for some or all of a kind. 2. Fees in lieu of public improvements are due before either building permit application or, when and where any of Partition or Subdivision Final Plat is involved, completion of recordation with the County, specifically no later than before a City official signs a plat or re -plat Mylar per Section 5.01.06C.1. A developer may request in writing to pay later, specifically by issuance of building permit, or if the Director allows, across issuance of two or more structural building permits for the subject development. Woodburn Development Ordinance Section 4.02 Page 321 rFormatted: Indent: Left: 0.36 , No bullets or numbering 183 L J11I I4'41 6D d,hn� `�Ii4' IBOI,I L. Sa�ie as stibsec ioni A 1 above �2. AdB� ijuijstrafiow Per Ific V)Jreclor. Woodburn Development Ordinance Section 4.02 Page 322 184 5.01.04 Grading Permit A. Purpose: The purpose of this review is to ensure that grading is in compliance with the Woodburn Storm Management Plan, Woodburn Flood Plain Ordinance, Public Works Department Construction Standards and Specifications, and the State Building Code. B. Applicability: The requirement for a grading permit applies to any of the following activities: 1. Any fill, removal, or grading of land identified within the boundaries of the regulatory floodplain, 2. Any fill, removal, or grading of land identified within the Riparian Corridor and Wetlands Overlay District (RCWOD), 3. Any fill, removal, or grading of land that requires a permit from the Oregon Department of State Lands, 4. Any fill, removal, or grading of land area that equals or exceeds one acre, or 5. Any development activity required by the WDO to submit a grading plan or permit. C. Criteria: Grading Permits shall be reviewed pursuant to the policies and standards of the Woodburn Storm Management Plan, Woodburn Flood Plain Ordinance, Public Works Construction Standards and Specifications, kuidState Building Code, aid:. ` ecfion l 3.410.0/ °°S4µnxsficaw V.�..s"s" ➢ ins"sem ,afion i & ➢ie" uoval", iuicludiB i'�" 3..06.07C, asapplicable. D. Procedure: The Director shall review the proposed grading plan to ensure compliance with City and State requirements. 5.01.05 Manufactured Dwelling Park, Final Plan Approval A. Purpose: The purpose of this review is to ensure substantial conformance of the final plan and improvements with the conditions of the Manufactured Dwelling Park Preliminary Approval, including compliance with applicable Oregon Administrative Rules. B. Criteria: 1. The final plan shall be submitted within two years of date of the initial approval. 2. The final plan shall include all information required by the preliminary approval and shall substantially conform to all conditions of the preliminary approval and applicable Oregon Administrative Rules. C. Procedures: The Director shall determine whether the final plan substantially conforms to the preliminary approval, applicable State requirements, and City ordinances. Woodburn Development Ordinance Chapter 5.01 Page 325 185 5.01.09 Riparian Corridor and Wetlands Overlay District (RCWOD) Permit A. Purpose: The purpose of this review procedure is to ensure that all grading, excavation, fill, and vegetation removal (other than perimeter mowing and other cutting necessary forhazard prevention) within a delineated, significant wetland, complies with applicable City and State standards and procedures, including those of ORS Chapter 196 and Chapter 227 and OAR 660-023. B. Criteria: 1. The applicable standards of this Ordinance and the findings and action proposed by the Division of State Lands; or 2. A finding, verified by the Division of State Lands, of error in delineation of the RCWOD boundary. C. Procedure: The Director shall review the permit and approve it upon a determination that it meets the criteria of this ordinance. 5.01.10 Sign Permit A. Purpose: The purpose of this review is to ensure that signs comply with standards found within the Sign Standards (Section 3.10). B. Criteria: Applications shall be reviewed for compliance with the sign standards of this Ordinance. C. Procedure: The Director shall review proposal signs for compliance to City regulations. 5.01.11 Significant Tree Removal Permit A. Purpose: pie pia+mpp se orlfiis feviev, is o ewe we Iiaw Ille.feflwamval orsigiliIfees f p �, , �"�tiDk011 �k4'fih 4^�kl.����1 `*4' Yq"i@.xfkaw�kiDw1�'hih�� � "kk'w�� ���^� kq'ka°tlw1��4' �� v4 C4Do 44*4'1 )r� p 6D 4'mtl1f4' i fial i,fie. rePB i6Dval o `"h(,�MificawFrees cop ifi)nf i1tiU ilfi SecllaDwl .p.4p�).07 as �h,'„4'ii dtlti 1pf4°, pnra�mpnrswcii, „ B. Apppi,Scabillly: Per Sediawm 3.00,07B &]fe,,4'v�ed cam�wwp�lw�ww���� ���ilpf 1pfw�aimap�w��ww�c.��.,. C. Crile p : Per y"hecfioD � .fir 00� l��.p�roc-e*,I e4 4�pi p�k�41:&lof'4*11^1� 1f4lvie4�r��..urtlIl�4 ]Cldtl dtlwff Y,]CdDi"Pb.411f4',,,, Ajpff4W411 ff0prQ qI] f;win 44�44i4 ¢ 4kliwllw-,, 5.01.12 Temporary Outdoor Marketing and Special Event Permit A. Purpose: The purpose of this review is to ensure that temporary outdoor marketing or special events conform to the standards of this Ordinance (Section 2.07.17). B. Criteria: Temporary Outdoor Marketing and Special Events shall conform to all standards of this Ordinance. C. Procedure: The Director shall review the application and shall approve a permit based on compliance with this Ordinance. Woodburn Development Ordinance Chapter 5.01 Page 329 :: 5.02.06 Zoning Adjustment A. Purpose: The purpose of a Type II zoning adjustment review is to provide a mechanism by which the regulations in the WDO may be adjusted if the proposed development continues to meet the intended purpose of those regulations. Adjustment reviews provide flexibility for unusual situations. They also allow for alternative ways to meet the purposes of the WDO.. B. Criteria: A zoning adjustment involves the balancing of competing and conflicting interests. The following criteria will be considered in evaluating zoning adjustments. 1. The adjustment is necessary to prevent unnecessary constraint relating to the land or structure. Factors to consider in determining whether constraint exists, include: a. Physical circumstances over which the applicant has no control, related to the piece of property involved, that distinguish it from other land in the same zone, including but not limited to lot size, shape, and topography. b. Whether the constraint was created by the applicant requesting the adjustment. 2. The zoning adjustment will not be materially injurious to adjacent properties or to the use of the subject property. Factors to be considered in determining whether development is not materially injurious include, but are not limited to: a. Physical impacts such development will have because of the adjustment, such as visual, noise, traffic and drainage, erosion and landslide hazards. b. If the adjustment concerns joint -use parking, the hours of operation for vehicle parking shall not create a competing parking demand. c. Minimal impacts occur as a result of the proposed adjustment. 3. The adjustment is the minimum deviation from the standard necessary to make reasonable use of the property; 4. The adjustment does not conflict with the Woodburn Comprehensive Plan. Factors to be considered include, but are not limited to: a. The adjustment serves to administer or implement a Woodburn Comprehensive Plan goal or policy. b. The adjustment serves to administer or implement an action item, goal, objective, policy, or strategy from an adopted long-range plan. 5. The adjustment provides an alternative to the standard that meets the relevant purposes of the WDO standard and the context of the standard. C. Maximum Adjustment permitted: 1. Lot Area: Up to a five percent reduction in the minimum lot area. 2. Lot Coverage: Up to an increase of five percent in lot coverage. 3. Front Yard Setback or Setback Abutting a Street: Up to a 10 percent reduction of a setback. 4. Side Yard Setback: Up to a 20 percent reduction in setback, but no less than a five foot setback in a RS or RIS zone or less than the requirements of the state building code, whichever is more restrictive; however, for RM and RMN zones where a building type Woodburn Development Ordinance Chapter 5.03 Page 337 187 or residential use side setback is dependent on tiers of building height, setback reduction as follows: For building height of: a. 16 feet or less, reduction to no fewer than 5 feet; b. More than 16 feet and less than 28, reduction to no fewer than 5 feet; or c. 28 feet or more, reduction to no fewer than 10 feet at the 28th foot and higher and to no fewer than 5 feet below the 28th foot. 5. Rear Yard Setback: Up to a 20 percent reduction in setback, but no less than a five foot setback, except in those zones permitting zero setbacks the minimum setback shall be either 5 feet or zero; however, for RM and RMN zones where a building type or residential use side setback is dependent on tiers of building height, setback reduction as follows: For building height of: a. 16 feet or less, reduction to no fewer than 10 feet; b. More than 16 feet and less than 28, reduction to no fewer than 18 feet above the 16th foot and higher and to no fewer than 10 feet at the 16th foot and below; or c. 28 feet or more, reduction to no fewer than 24 feet at the 28th foot and higher and, below the 28th foot, to no fewer than per (b) 6. Lot Width: Up to a ten percent reduction. 7. Lot Depth: Up to a ten percent reduction. 8. Building Height: Up to a ten percent increase in height. 9. Parking Standards: Up to a five percent reduction in required parking spaces except no reduction in the number of handicapped vehicle parking spaces or in dimensional standards. 10. Joint -Use Vehicle Parking: Up to 20 percent of the required vehicle parking may be satisfied by joint use of the parking provided for another use. 11. Fences and Freestanding Walls: The location or height of a fence or free-standing wall, excluding the adjustment of any such facilities within a clear vision area, height limited to 16 percent increase. 12. Access management in RSN & RMN districts / alleys: Relating to Section 2.05.04B.2, reduce the minimum to no less than either 60 percent or 12 lots, whichever is greater. 13. Alley or shared rear lane widths (in any zoning district): a. ROW/tract: Reduce alley minimum ROW or shared rear lane tract width to no fewer than 16 feet. b. Pavement: Reduce minimum pavement width to no fewer than 14 feet. 14. Bicycle/pedestrian corridor width: a. Relating to Table 3.O1A corridor contexts lb & c, reduction of corridor width to no fewer than 18 feet, or where a newly granted off-street PUE along the corridor would neither cover the entire corridor width nor preclude a row of newly planted trees, then no fewer than 16 feet. b. Relating to context 3, reduction to no fewer than either 35 feet or actual extent of RCWOD relative to lot line where the actual extent is fewer than 50 feet, whichever Woodburn Development Ordinance Chapter 5.03 Page 338 188 is less. 15. Bicycle/pedestrian facility class: Relating to Section 3.01.07D, to lower from Class B to Class C. 16. PUE: a. Streetside: For each lot or tract that abuts both a street and an alley, narrowing the PUE along the street to no fewer than 3 feet minimum. b. Off-street: Narrowing to no fewer than 10 ft minimum. 17. Vision clearance area: Decreasing any Figure 3.03A sight triangles to no fewer than street intersections 20 by 20 feet, driveways at streets 5 by 5 feet limited to driveways of residential development other than of multiple -family dwellings, and any of alley and shared rear lane junction with a street to 5 by 5 feet. A developer shall submit a safety analysis stamped by a civil engineer. 18. Commercial access management: Relating to Section 3.04.03D.2, to relax the standard as the Director allows. 19. Driveway width: a. Triplex and Quadplex: To increase maximum one driveway along the lot street frontage, including both interior and corner lot contexts, to a maximum width of 24 feet. b. 5 or more dwellings or living units, school, or house of worship: To increase maximum width to either 26 feet or, if a turn pocket is included, to a total maximum of 31 feet. c. Commercial use: To increase maximum width to either 26 feet or, if a turn pocket is included, to a total maximum of 38 feet. 20. Compact parking: To raise the maximum to no more than 40 percent. 21. Drive aisle width: Relating to Table 3.05B, to narrow two-way drive aisles with parking spaces that are angled to no fewer than 20 feet or that are at 90' to no fewer than 22 feet. To narrow one-way drive aisles to no fewer than from 22 or 24 feet to 20, from 15 or 18 feet to 14, or from 12 feet to 11. 22. Lighting: Relating to Section 3.11.02B, to increase the height limit: a. For wall, to no higher than 10 feet. b. For poles within parking areas of developments other than of multiple -family dwellings, to no higher than 18 feet. c. For other poles, to no higher than 12 feet. d. For sports, to no higher than as the zoning district allows for features not used for habitation or 70 feet, whichever is less. 23. Architectural & Design Standards: Relating to Table 3.07A and for manufactured dwellings only, to adjust any standard other than minimum roof pitch and as the Director allows. 2,1 MUV: Relating to Table 2.03E and for side and/or rear minimum setback from property zoned other than RS, to lower to zero. Woodburn Development Ordinance Chapter 5.03 Page 339 189 24 .�25, SigE ]Jficaw g & n ovafigg 162 Fig F3 p a�id Fig J C F11 slanidards, to lohg flle 1yese1fyaliog to 25,0 p'rcew fi)r F3,350 pPrcew fi)r F'I �� 1 5,0 1YP cew fi)r .1 sglJxi IV Vkilfiil Ific M � JV /opAlg disiricl or Ific ( 411(nk av C( h,e� lay � )islricl� or /em fi)r a stllJecl properl'y �k ifl1ill Ific X, Z6212Jp2g, dislricl.. D. Prohibited Adjustments: 1. Adjustments to the number of permitted dwellings and to the use of property shall be prohibited. 2. Standards established by Oregon Revised Statutes for manufactured dwellings and manufactured dwelling parks are non -variable. Woodburn Development Ordinance Chapter 5.03 Page 340 190 5.04 Type IV (Quasi -Judicial) Decisions 5.04 General Reauirements A. The purpose of this Section is to identify what types of actions are considered Type IV decisions. Type IV decisions involve the greatest amount of discretion and require evaluation of approval standards. These decisions are heard by the Planning Commission and City Council. The process for these land use decisions is controlled by ORS 197.763. Notice of the land use application and public hearing is published and mailed to the applicant, recognized neighborhood associations and property owners. The City Council decision is the City's final decision and is appealable to the Land Use Board of Appeals. B. To initiate consideration of a Type IV decision, a complete City application, accompanying information, and filing fee must be submitted to the Director. The Director will evaluate the application as outlined in this Section. 5.04.01 Annexation 5.04.02 Comprehensive Plan Map Change, Owner Initiated 5.04.03 Formal Interpretation of the Woodburn Development Ordinance 5.04.04 Official Zoning Map Change, Owner Initiated 5.04.01 Annexation A. Purpose: The purpose of this Type IV review is to provide a procedure to incorporate contiguous territory into the City in compliance with state requirements, Woodburn Comprehensive Plan, and Woodburn Development Ordinance. B. Mandatory Pre -Application Conference: Prior to requesting annexation to the City, a Pre - Application Conference (Section 4.01.04) is required. This provides the city an opportunity to understand the proposed annexation and an opportunity to provide information on the likely impacts, limitations, requirements, approval standards, and other information that may affect the proposal. C. Criteria: 1. Compliance with applicable Woodburn Comprehensive Plan goals and policies regarding annexation. 2. Territory to be annexed shall be contiguous to the City and shall either: a. Link to planned public facilities with adequate capacity to serve existing and future development of the property as indicated by the Woodburn Comprehensive Plan; or b. Guarantee that public facilities have adequate capacity to serve existing and future development of the property. 3. Annexations shall show a demonstrated community need for additional territory and development based on the following considerations: a. Lands designated for residential and community uses should demonstrate substantial conformance to the following: Woodburn Development Ordinance Chapter 5.04 Page 352 191 1) The territory to be annexed should be contiguous to the City on two or more sides; 2) The territory to be annexed should not increase the inventory of buildable land designated on the Comprehensive Plan as Low or Medium Density Residential within the City to more than a 5-year supply; 3) The territory proposed for annexation should reflect the City's goals for directing growth by using public facility capacity that has been funded by the City's capital improvement program; 4) The site is feasible for development and provides either: a) Completion or extension of the arterial/collector street pattern as depicted on the Woodburn Transportation System Plan; or b) Connects existing stub streets, or other discontinuous streets, with another public street. 5) Annexed fulfills a substantial unmet community need, that has been identified by the City Council after a public hearing. Examples of community needs include park space and conservation of significant natural or historic resources. b. Lands designated for commercial, industrial and other uses should demonstrate substantial conformance to the following criteria: 1) The proposed use of the territory to be annexed shall be for industrial or other uses providing employment opportunities; 2) The proposed industrial or commercial use of the territory does not require the expansion of infrastructure, additional service capacity, or incentives that are in excess of the costs normally borne by the community for development; 3) The proposed industrial or commercial use of the territory provides an economic opportunity for the City to diversify its economy. D. Procedures: 1. An annexation maybe initiated by petition based on the written consent of: a. The owners of more than half of the territory proposed for annexation and more than half of the resident electors within the territory proposed to be annexed; or b. One hundred percent of the owners and fifty percent of the electors within the territory proposed to be annexed; or c. A lesser number of property owners. 2. If an annexation is initiated by property owners of less than half of property to be annexed, after holding a public hearing and if the City Council approves the proposed annexation, the City Council shall call for an election within the territory to be annexed. Otherwise no election on a proposed annexation is required. 3. The City may initiate annexation of an island (ORS 222.750), with or without the consent of the property owners or the resident electors. An island is an unincorporated territory surrounded by the boundaries of the City. Initiation of such an action is at the discretion of the City Council. Woodburn Development Ordinance Chapter 5.04 Page 353 192 i i P$1f4�'. j. F,,,`XC `"CIE"ll2(,�Ibvatl>I11 � ]C,4'4" jYfl 4"s4'�,A'dtlil6Dpl dtl,n�b. lf4'BpVdh„� dtl 1Ylf6D�,t,`�I6Dp�`� 6D `�Pi"iI6DpX, .�r.4���.4�� dtl„ Y�YiIE"dtl�Yi4,': to lflllulcorjha lolled 1griiory, Ifiai I�;;;, Ific sgbj,4'Cl �Ylf6D�„Y4'ifiV o dtl,g Amiex,a;tlllog., Itll )pl I c afi d h,)I 1. E. Zoning Designation for Annexed Property: All land annexed to the City shall be designated consistent with the Woodburn Comprehensive Plan, unless an application to re -designate the property is approved as part of the annexation process. F. The timing of public improvements is as follows: 1. Street dedication is required upon annexation. 2. Dedication of public utility easements (PUE) is required upon annexation. 3. Street improvements are required upon development. 4. Connection to the sanitary sewer system is required upon development or septic failure. 5. Connection to the public water system is required upon development or well failure. 6. Connection to the public storm drain system is required upon development. 5.04.02 Comprehensive Plan Man Change, Owner Initiated A. Purpose: The purpose of an Owner Initiated Comprehensive Map Change is to provide a process for the consideration of a change in use designation on the Woodburn Comprehensive Plan, initiated by the property owner. B. Criteria: The applicant shall demonstrate the following: 1. Proof that the current Comprehensive Plan Map is in error, if applicable. 2. Substantial evidence showing how changes in the community warrant the proposed change in the pattern and allocation of land use designations. 3. Substantial evidence showing how the proposed change in the land use designation complies with: a. Statewide Planning Goals and Oregon Administrative Rules; b. Comprehensive Plan goals and policies; and c. Sustains the balance of needed land uses within the Woodburn Urban Growth Boundary. 4. Amendments to the comprehensive plan and land use standards which significantly affect a transportation facility shall ensure that allowed land uses are consistent with the function, capacity, and level of service of the facility identified in the Transportation System Plan. This shall be accomplished by one of the following: a. Limiting allowed land uses to be consistent with the planned function of the transportation facility; or b. Amending the Transportation System Plan to ensure that existing, improved, or new transportation facilities are adequate to support the proposed land uses consistent with the requirement of the Transportation Planning Rule; or, c. Altering land use designations, densities, or design requirements to reduce demand Woodburn Development Ordinance Chapter 5.04 Page 354 193 Exhibit B Analyses & Findings Legislative Amendment Provisions 4.01 Decision -Making Procedures ... 4.01.02E. Type V Decisions (Legislative): Type V decisions involve legislative actions where the City Council enacts or amends the City's land use regulations, comprehensive plan, Official Zoning Map or some component of these documents. Type V decisions may only be initiated by the City Council. The Planning Commission holds an initial public hearing on the proposal before making a recommendation to the City Council. The City Council then holds a final public hearing and renders a decision. Public notice is provided for all public hearings (Section 4.01.14). The City Council's decision is the City's final decision and is appealable to LUBA within 21 days after it becomes final. The City Council on July 26, 2021 passed Resolution No. 2175 initiating Legislative Amendment 21-03. The Planning Commission will have held a public hearing on August 10, 2023, or a later date certain, prior to making a formal recommendation to the City Council regarding LA 21-03. The provisions are met. ORS 227.186 Notice to property owners of hearing on certain zone change; form of notice; ... (3) ... at least 20 days but not more than 40 days before the date of the first hearing on an ordinance that proposes to amend an existing comprehensive plan or any element thereof, or to adopt a new comprehensive plan, a city shall cause a written individual notice of a land use change to be mailed to each owner whose property would have to be rezoned in order to comply with the amended or new comprehensive plan if the ordinance becomes effective.... (9) For purposes of this section, property is rezoned when the city: (a) Changes the base zoning classification of the property; or (b) Adopts or amends an ordinance in a manner that limits or prohibits land uses previously allowed in the affected zone. LA 21-03 involves none of comprehensive plan text amendment, comprehensive plan map amendment, zone change (a.k.a. rezoning). It also involved no amendment of any land uses of any of the zoning districts, including nothing that limits or prohibits land uses that zoning districts currently allow, so additional notice per Oregon Ballot Measure 56 (1998) codified in Oregon Revised Statutes (ORS) 227.186 was not applicable. Staff issued notices of public hearing pursuant to state law and Woodburn Development Ordinance (WDO) 4.01.14C & D and sent a required notice of proposed amendment to the Oregon Department of Land Conservation and Development (DLCD) on May 23, 2022, which DLCD confirmed received as agency file number 002-22. The provisions are met. LA 21-03 Ordinance No. 2621 (February 26, 2024) Exhibit B 194 Page 1 of 5 Legislative Intent The Woodburn Development Ordinance (WDO) establishes the standards that land development is required to meet, and relevance and clarity of standards is critical as the city grows. Periodic revisions and updates to the WDO are necessary and expected to comply with revisions to statutes and administrative rules, administer new and revised long-range plans, and address current issues. A winter ice storm pummeled the city and its tree canopy during Presidents' Day weekend that was approximately February 12-15, 2021. The City Council on February 22, 2021 passed Ordinance No. 2584 that waived the tree removal fee and removed the requirement for an applicant to submit a report by a certified arborist for tree removals in the aftermath of the ice storm. This emergency ordinance was effective for three months only. N. Robert Shields, City Attorney and the Community Development Director on July 26, 2021 briefed the Council about existing WDO tree preservation and removal regulations and presented ideas about improved enforcement provisions and fines. On August 9, 2021, the Council passed Ordinance No. 2592 establishing an enhanced penalty for intentional violations of the tree permit requirements of both the WDO and the street tree ordinance. The Council on July 26, 2021 also passed Resolution No. 2175 initiating Legislative Amendment 21-03. Staff held Planning Commission workshops about LA 21-03 on: • September 23, 2021 • April 28, 2022 • July 28, 2022 • October 13, 2022 • May 11, 2023, and • July 27, 2023. The Planning Commission held a public hearing on September 28, 2023 and recommended that the City Council approve LA 21-03 and its related fees. LA 21-03 Ordinance No. 2621 (February 26, 2024) Exhibit B Page 2 of 5 195 The strikethrough-and-underline edits related to tree preservation and removal are based on: 1. Existing regulations being limited to existing properties and totally lacking inclusion of new developments, resulting in ad hoc Significant Tree preservation efforts by Community Development Department staff development by development; 2. Difficulties posed by existing listed reasons to remove trees from existing properties being too lax and too open to interpretation, complicating fair and predictable administration of regulations relevant to Significant Tree Removal Permit applications; 3. Daily, in-depth Community Development Department staff experience with review of land use applications and land developments; 4. Needing to revise and add definitions to the WDO to administer revised Significant Tree preservation and removal regulations; 5. Revising and adding preservation and removal regulations that are clearer and more objective; 6. Revising and adding regulations that are tailored to context, that of existing properties and of new developments or redevelopments, through "tiers" of regulations; 7. Establishing a tier for new developments of houses and "middle housing" that is less stringent than for other new developments — out of abundance of caution and consistency of how the WDO regulates such housing types relative to the middle housing mandate resulting from 2019 Oregon House Bill 2001 (HB 2001), Oregon Department of Land Conservation and Development (DLCD) rule -making resulting in Oregon Administrative Rules (OAR) 660-046, and the subsequent LA 21-02 amendment adopted as Ordinance No. 2602 (June 2022), though staff believes that for tree preservation and removal regulations neither statute nor ORS requires such; 8. Being more stringent for new developments and redevelopments than for existing properties; 9. Being more lax with homeowners than landlords; 10. Anticipating and lessening conflict of tree preservation with Transportation System Plan (TSP) long-range planning through Figures 2 "Functional Roadway Classification" & 6 "Local Street Connectivity Plan" for extended and new streets and WDO 3.01 requirements for extended and new rights -of -ways (ROWs) and street improvements; 11. Adapting the best relevant parts of City of Portland, Oregon Title 11 "Trees", particularly the following Chapters amended by City of Portland Ordinance No. 191030 effective November 11, 2022: 0 11.50.040 "Tree Preservation Standards", 0 11.50.070 "Tree Plan Submittal Requirements", and 0 11.60.030 "Tree Protection Specifications"; 12. Exempting from scrutiny the same invasive species as found in the City of Portland Bureau of Planning and Sustainability (BPS) "nuisance" plant list within the June 2016 Portland Plant List, Section 4, Ranks A-C — species that are not merely non-native; 13. Anticipating and regulating tree removal for territory under review for annexation into city limits; LA 21-03 Ordinance No. 2621 (February 26, 2024) Exhibit B Page 3 of 5 14. Anticipating and providing for reasonable situations warranting exemption from preservation and for emergencies; and 15. Responding to direction from the Planning Commission across at least six workshops. Note that separate ordinances that the Public Works Department administers regulate maintenance and removal of existing street trees, the ones found in rights -of -way (ROWs), usually within landscaped strips between curbs and sidewalks. The WDO already regulates additional street trees that developers are to plant. This amendment project scope excludes existing and new street trees and is limited to off-street trees (on private property). Amon the Council ��„ „-„ � _s�_u a „gu„c; g a„�s, two appear relevant to this amendment project: g • "Create an inclusive environment where residents participate and are engaged in the community (that is vibrant, safe and active)." A way to serve the goal is strengthening standards that preserving off-street trees (on private property), which are larger and taller the longer they remain. Preserved trees create an environment that is attractive, calming, cooling, and hospitable to wildlife. This in turn, particularly during summer and especially during heat waves, helps cool the town and give people confidence they can travel outdoors, keeping up personal physical activity, being safer from heat injuries, and more likely to engage with other people. • "Grow and support strategic partnerships for economic health." A way to serve the goal is strengthening tree preservation standards for both existing and new developments to shade those walking and provide them psychological protection from passing vehicles, calm those driving, help spatially define streets through canopy, absorb stormwater and pollutants, reduce the urban heat island effect, raise value of property, and maintain wildlife habitat. Preserving trees, which are larger and taller the longer they remain, create an environment that is attractive, calming, cooling, and hospitable to wildlife. This in turn would raise property values, increasing assessable value, and better attract landowner investments in property. LA 21-03 Ordinance No. 2621 (February 26, 2024) Exhibit B Page 4 of 5 197 It seems only one Woodburn Comprehensive Plan policy is directly applicable: J-1.1 from p. 40: "Trees within designated floodplains and riparian corridors shall be preserved. Outside of designated floodplains and riparian corridors, developers should be required to leave standing trees in developments where feasible." Major objectives are to: • Correct the defects of existing tree removal and preservation regulations revealed by (1) the aftermath of the February 2021 ice storm, and (2) Community Development Department staff daily, in-depth experience with review of land use applications and land developments; and • Respond well to Council direction to improve tree removal and preservation regulations as it expressed by passing Resolution No. 2175 on July 26, 2021. LA 21-03 Ordinance No. 2621 (February 26, 2024) Exhibit B Page 5 of 5 198 4?4 4' *7 4N g ewk WWODBURN Inr or�arnreA 188� February 26, 2024 TO: Honorable Mayor and City Council through City Administrator FROM: Chris Kerr, Community Development Director Colin Cortes, AICP, CNU-A, Senior Planner SUBJECT: Ordinance 2622 Updating the City Master Fee Schedule Related to Legislative Amendment LA 21-03 of the Woodburn Development Ordinance (WDO) Related to Significant Tree Removal and Mitigation RECOMMENDATION: Adopt the attached Ordinance updating the City Master Fee Schedule related to the Community Development Department Planning Division to implement fees for Significant Tree removal and mitigation following Legislative Amendment LA 21-03 of the Woodburn Development Ordinance (WDO). BACKGROUND: The City Council on February 12, 2024, directed staff to prepare an ordinance amending Ordinance No. 2433, which is the City master fee schedule, regarding tree removal and mitigation. (The Council last updated the Master Fee Schedule through Ordinance No. 2609 on April 24, 2023.) DISCUSSION: n/a FINANCIAL IMPACT: n/a Attachment(s): 1. Existing Planning Division fee schedule (2023; 2 pages) 2. Proposed Planning Division fee schedule (3 pages) Agenda Item Review: City Administrator _x_ City Attorney _x 199 Finance Attachment l: Existing Planning Division fee schedule (2023; 2 pages) 200 IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII° � ° � � � ��� � - � � III Land Use Application Type or Planning Fee Note Service Annexation - more than 1.00 acre $5 130 Annexation - less than orequal to 1.00 acre $2 565 Appeal, Land Use: See Note. $135 + 1/z of original application fee, Appeal to City Council (Type III but maximum total $2 700. Maximum $250 per Oregon Revised Appeal to City Council (Type II) $250 Statutes (ORS) 227.175(10)(b) (2019). -more than 1.00 acre $4 700 -less than orequal to 1.00 acre $4 670 Conditional Use (CV) $5,,190 W,DO 5.03.01 Design Review (DR): Type I $685 WDO 5.01.02 Type II or higher: Up to 3,000 square feet (sq $6,115 WDO 5.02.03 or 5.03.02 ft) total Type II or higher: More than 3,000 and fewer $9 490 WDO 5.02.03 or 5.03.02 Type II or higher: More than 30,000 total sq ft $19 440 WDO 5.02.03 or 5.03.02 Grading Permit GRAD $685 WDO 5.01.04 Interpretation [of the WDO], formal (INT) $2,640 Plus costs if and as Oregon Ballot Measure 56 (1998), codified in ORS 227.186, is applicable. WDO 1.03.04, 2.01.03, & 4.02.06. Manufactured Dwelling Park: Preliminary Approval $4 710 Final Plan Approval $1 625 Modification of Conditions (MOC) See Note. $135 plus '/z of original fee for related application or consolidated applications. WDO 4.02.07. Preliminary Approval PAR $3 720 WDO 5.02.05 Final Plat Approval (FPAR) $1 860 WDO 5.01.06 Phasin Plan (PP) $2,145 WDO 5.03.05 Conceptual Development Plan / Preliminary $4 480 plus $55 per lot. WDO 3.09 & 5.03.06. Design Final Plan / Detailed Development Plan $1 375 WDO 5.01.07 & 5.03.07 Final Plat Approval $3 880 WDO 5.01.06 & 5.01.07 IIII� W W Residential Architectural Standards Substitution $540 WDO 5.02.02 Riparian Corridor Wetland Overlay District $670 WDO 2.05.05 & 5.01.09 Sign Permit (SIGN): WDO 3.10 -Permanent: freestanding (includes monument $520 When an applicant applies for multiple signs and pole) for a given business, complex, development, landowner, lot, property, or tenant, each and every sign for which a sign permit is required requires fee payment. -Permanent: other than freestanding (includes $115 Same as Note above. wall) _Temporary Free Specific Conditional Use— Historically WDO 5.03.08 or Architecturallv Si nificant Building $1 725 "Street Adjustment" (Adjustment to Street Improvement Requirements; SA): Type II $4,040 WDO 5.02.04 Type III or higher $4,560 WDO 4.01.07 & 5.03.03 Preliminary Approval (SUB) $5,665 plus $55 per lot. WDO 5.01.10. per Note. Final Plat Approval (FSUB) $3 880 WDO 5.01.06 & ORS 92 2021 Telecommunication Facility, Specific WDO 5.03.11 Conditional Use $3 285 Temporary Outdoor Marketing and Special Event WDO 5.01.12 Permit (TMKT) $165 Significant Tree Removal Permit TREE $220 WDO 3.06.07 & 5.01.11 0 -consolidated with another land use application $3,285 -standalone application $4,695 i Zoning Adjustment (ZA) WDO 5.02.06 Continues next page 201 s u- III MINE If for two or more lots or tracts, then plus $4 Addressing Assignment, Street $220 plus per for each subsequent lot and tract. If for Note. apartment complex of two or more apartment buildings, then plus $4 for each subsequent apartment building. Applicable to such held by the Planning Bond or performance guarantee release or status $50 Division, not any by the Public Works letter Department. Follows land use final decision (approval). Civil engineering plan(s) (CEP) review, Planning Due upon CEP application to the Public Division review of Public Works Department Works Dept. Does not abrogate any fees permit application materials: that the Public Works Department requires through its fee schedule. -original/1st submittal $350 -2 nd and successive submittal $250 Development agreement: ORS 94.504 Drafting of development agreement, $2,500 (2007). intergovernmental agreement (IGA), or IGA, MOU: ORS 190.010 (1991). memorandum of understanding (MOU) Exception to when all public improvements are due $4,695 Applicable if developer obtains Public Works / delay or deferral of frontage/street improvements Department approval of exception (delay/deferral) through WDO 3.01.02E(1) & (2). Fee serves as exception disincentive. Expedited Land Use Review: ORS 197.360-380 2021 - Partition other than middle housing) $6 320 - Subdivision (other than middle housing) $9,060 - Middle Housing Land Division $9,060 ORS 197.380 (2021) Distinct from "Expedited Land Use Review" above relating to statute. Subject to staff Expedited review (for land use review, not building $90 availability and as allowed by law for use. In permit review) per hour addition to application fees based on an hourly rate for overtime. Fence permit Free WDO 2.06.02 & 5.01.03 Home occupation review Free WDO 2.07.10 Land Use Compatibility Statement (LUCS) or $100 other Jurisdictional permit sign -off Extension of a development decision $685 WDO 4.02.05 Site inspection, planning & zoning (P&Z): Relates particularly to on -site private improvements resulting from building permit and civil/frontage/public/street improvements resulting from CEP approval. -0riginal/1st inspection & 2 nd inspection (re- Free inspection) -3" inspection and successive inspection $250 i i i o i i r i i i 0 i o ----------- Significant Tree mitigation fee $250 WDO 3.06.07E.3. & F. Zoning confirmation letter / zoning verification $100 letter Planning service 1 �/z hours or more through $90 Applied per Director discretion. meeting by appointment instead of Planning per hour counter unscheduled service Planning counter and phone inquiry service Free Printing and copying: Mimics the Public Works fee schedule printing and copying items. Applicable only if total charge would be $10 or more. -Letter / 8�/z by 11 inches black and white or 5¢ per page. (Min. 200 pages to charge.) ra scale -Letter / 8�/z by 11 inches color 75¢ per page. (Min. 14 pages to charge.) -Ledger / 11 by 17 inches Twice the per sheet. applicable (B&W: min. 100 sheets to charge; letter rate color: min. 7 sheets to charge) -Plan size / 24 by 36 inches, or any large map $25 per sheet. L\Coruiuunity DevelopmentTlanning\Fonus & Fee ScheduleA Ordinance No. 2609, effective 7/01/2023 202 Attachment 2: Proposed Planning Division fee schedule (3 pages) 203 IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII ���� � � � � � � - � � ��� � � - - - � � - Land Use Application Type or Planning Fee Note Service "5,130 Annexation - more than 1. 0 acre Annexation - less than or equal to 1.00 acre Appeal, Land Use: See Note $135 + 1/z of original application fee, Appeal to City Council(Type III) but maximum total $2 700. Maximum 250 per Uregon Revise Appeal to City Council (Type II) $250 Statutes (ORS) 227.175(10)(b) (2019). ON ON ON ON ON ON ON ON I -more than 1.00 acre $4,700 -less than or equal to 1.00 acre Conditional Use (C U) $5,,390 WDO 5.03.01 Design Review (DR): Type I 685 WDO 5.01.02 Type II or higher: Up to 3,000 square feet (sq $6,115 WDO 5.02.03 or 5.03.02 ft) total ype or ig er: ore than an ewer or 5.03.02 than 30 000 total sq ft ype 11 or higher: or more total sq t $19,440 WD 5.02.03 or 5.03.02 Grading Permit (GRAD) 685 WDO 5.01.04 Interpretation [of the WDO], formal (INT) $2,640 Plus costs if and as Oregon Ballot Measure 56 (1998), codified in ORS 227.186, is applicable. WDO 1.03.04, 2.01.03, & 4.02.06. Manufactured Dwelling Park: Preliminary Approval $4,710 Final an pprova Modification of Conditions (MOC) See Note $135 plus '/z of original fee for related application or consolidated applications. WDO 4.02.07. Preliminary Approval (PAR)3,720 WDU 5.02.05 Final Plat Approval (FPAR)1,860 WDO 5.01.06 Phasing Plan (PP) $2,145 WDO 5.03.05 Uonceptual Development Plan Preliminary $4,480 pus per lot. Design Final Plan Detailed eve opment Plan Final Plat Approval $3,880 WDO 5.01.06 & 5.01.07 N 'N N N iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiillillillillillillillii 1111 Residential rc itectura tan ar s Nuhstitution Riparian Corridor Weiland Overlay District Sign Permit (SIGN): WDO 3.10 -Permanent: freestanding (includes monument $520 When an applicant applies for multiple signs and pole) for a given business, complex, development, landowner, lot, property, or tenant, each and every sign for which a sign permit is required requires fee payment. -Permanent: other than freestanding (includes $115 Same as Note above. wall) -Temporary Free Specific Conditional Use Historically WDO 5.03.08 or Architecturally Significant Buildin $1,725 "Street Adjustment" (Adjustment to Street Improvement Requirements; SA): Type II $4,04 WDO 5.02.04 Type III or higher $4,56C WDO 4.01.07 & 5.03.03 1, • Preliminary Approval (SUB) $5,665 plus $55 per lot. WDO 5.01.10. per Note. Final at Approval Telecommunication Facility, Specific WDO 5.03.11 Conditional Use $3,285 Temporary Outdoor Marketing and Special Event WDO 5.01.12 Permit LTMKT $165 SEEM -consolidated with another land use application $3,285 -standalone application $4,695 Zoning Adjustment (ZA) $3,520 WDO 5.02.06 Continues next page 204 u- If for two or more lots or tracts, then plus $4 Addressing Assignment, Street $220 plus per for each subsequent lot and tract. If for Note. apartment complex of two or more apartment buildings, then plus $4 for each subsequent apartment building. Applicable to such held by the Planning Bond or performance guarantee release or status $50 Division, not any by the Public Works letter Department. Follows land use final decision (approval). Civil engineering plan(s) (CEP) review, Planning Due upon CEP application to the Public Division review of Public Works Department Works Dept. Does not abrogate any fees permit application materials: that the Public Works Department requires through its fee schedule. -original/1st submittal $350 -2nd and successive submittal $250 Development agreement: ORS 94.504 Drafting of development agreement, $2,500 (2007). intergovernmental agreement (IGA), or IGA, MOU: ORS 190.010 (1991). memorandum of understanding (MOU) Exception to when all public improvements are due $4,695 Applicable if developer obtains Public Works / delay or deferral of frontage/street improvements Department approval of exception (delay/deferral) through WDO 3.01.02E(1) & (2). Fee serves as exception disincentive. Expedited an UseReview: ORS 197.360-7M - Partition (other than middlehousing) - Subdivision (other than middle housing) $9,060 - Middle Housing Land Division $9,060 ORS 197.380 (2021) Distinct from "Expedited Land Use Review" above relating to statute. Subject to staff Expedited review (for land use review, not building $90 availability and as allowed by law for use. In permit review) per hour addition to application fees based on an hourly rate for overtime. Fence permit Free WDO 2.06.02 & 5.01.03 Home occupation review Free WDO 2.07.10 Land Use ompatl i ity tatement LU or $100 other jurisdictional permit sign -off Extension of a development decision 685 WDO 4.02.05 Site inspection, planning & zoning (P&Z): Relates particularly to on -site private improvements resulting from building permit and civil/frontage/public/street improvements resulting from CEP approval. -Original/1st inspection & 2nd inspection (re- Free inspection) _3rd inspection and successive inspection $250 r� i i i i i 0 i i o Zoning confirmation letter zoning verification $100 letter Planning service 1 �/z hours or more through $90 Applied per Director discretion. meeting by appointment instead of Planning per hour counter unscheduled service Planning counter and phone inquiry service Free Printing and copying: Mimics the Public Works fee schedule printing and copying items. Applicable only if total charge would be $10 or more. -Letter / 8�/z by 11 inches black and white or 5¢ per page. (Min. 200 pages to charge.) grayscale -Letter / 8�/z by 11 inches color 750 per page. (Min. 14 pages to charge.) -Ledger / 11 by 17 inches Twice the per sheet. applicable (B&W: min. 100 sheets to charge; letter rate color: min. 7 sheets to charge) -Plan size / 24 by 36 inches, or any large map $25 per sheet. Continues next page 205 Significant1 �• 1 Removal of tree approved for removal, per tree: • •Table 3.06T D• 1.02 Fee in lieu of • per tree: ' 1 1 D• 1.02 i Removal of tree approved for removal, per tree: • •Table 3.06T ' 11 11 D• 1.02 Fee in lieu of • per tree: ' 1 1 D• 1.02 Tier 3 (T3); Removal of tree approved for removal, per tree: WDO Table 3.06T 11 D• 1.02 Fee in lieu of • per tree: ' 1 11 D• 1.02 Tier 4 (T4); Removal of tree approved for removal, per tree: WDO Table 3.06T Multiple -dwelling development 11 Other than multiple-dwellingdevelopment 11 D• 1.02 Multiple -dwelling • •• • 1 • • • • �: of removed tree, but capped at $6,300 Other than multiple -dwelling• •• • 1 • • • • �: of removed tree, but capped at $12,600 Fee in lieu of • per tree: ' 11 1 D• 1.02 % Removal of tree approved for removal, per tree ���Equal to highest removal fee among those for T4. L\Coruiuunity DevelopluentTlanning\Fonus & Fee ScheduleA Ordinance No. 2622, effective 3/27/2024 206 COUNCIL BILL NO. 3243 ORDINANCE NO. 2622 AN ORDINANCE ADOPTING TREE REMOVAL AND MITIGATION FEES AS PART OF THE PLANNING DIVISION FEE SCHEDULE FOR INCLUSION IN THE CITY'S MASTER FEE SCHEDULE (AMENDING ORDINANCE 2433) WHEREAS, in September 1998, the City Council adopted the first Master Fee Schedule to account for the City's reasonable costs in providing special services; and WHEREAS, under Ordinance 2433 the City stated it desired to establish a policy of recovering the full costs reasonably borne of providing services of a voluntary and limited nature, such that general taxes are not diverted from general services of a broad nature and thereby utilized to subsidize unfairly and inequitably such special services; and WHEREAS, under the current Planning Division Fee Schedule, the City provides for a permit fee to be charged by City staff to process a permit for the removal of Significant Trees, but there is not further financial fee structure around the removal of such trees; and WHEREAS, as part of the Council's recent decision to amend the Woodburn Development Ordinance through Legislative Amendment LA 21-03 related to significant tree preservation, removal, and mitigation, the Council determined it to be in the City' best interest to also update the correlating fee structure for tree removal fees; thereby, establishing a tiered pricing system that will both encourage preservation and provide financial mitigation options for tree removals; and WHEREAS, pursuant to ORS 294.160, at its meeting on February 26, 2024, the City Council provided an opportunity for interested persons to comment on the enactment of this Ordinance and its proposed fee increases; NOW, THEREFORE, THE CITY OF WOODBURN ORDAINS AS FOLLOWS: Section 1. The schedule of Community Development, Planning Division fees and charges affixed and incorporated as Attachment "A" is hereby adopted by the City, repealing the previously adopted Planning Division Fee Schedule (Ordinance 2609, effective July 1, 2023), and shall be included in the City's Master Fee Schedule. Page 1 - COUNCIL BILL NO. 3243 ORDINANCE NO. 2622 207 Approved as to form: City Attorney Date Approved: Passed by the Council Submitted to the Mayor Approved by the Mayor Filed in the Office of the City Recorder ATTEST: City Recorder City of Woodburn, Oregon Page 2 - COUNCIL BILL NO. 3243 ORDINANCE NO. 2622 Frank Lonergan, Mayor 208 Attachment A: Planning Division fee schedule (3 pages) 209 210 If for two or more lots or tracts, then plus $4 Addressing Assignment, Street $220 plus per for each subsequent lot and tract. If for Note. apartment complex of two or more apartment buildings, then plus $4 for each subsequent apartment building. Applicable to such held by the Planning Bond or performance guarantee release or status $50 Division, not any by the Public Works letter Department. Follows land use final decision (approval). Civil engineering plan(s) (CEP) review, Planning Due upon CEP application to the Public Division review of Public Works Department Works Dept. Does not abrogate any fees permit application materials: that the Public Works Department requires through its fee schedule. -original/1st submittal $350 -2 d and successive submittal $250 Development agreement: ORS 94.504 Drafting of development agreement, $2,500 (2007). intergovernmental agreement (IGA), or IGA, MOU: ORS 190.010 (1991). memorandum of understanding (MOU) Exception to when all public improvements are due $4,695 Applicable if developer obtains Public Works / delay or deferral of frontage/street improvements Department approval of exception (delay/deferral) through WDO 3.01.02E(1) & (2). Fee serves as exception disincentive. Expedited an UseReview: ORS 197.360-7M - Partition (other than middlehousing) - Subdivision (other than middle housing) $9,060 - Middle Housing Land Division $9,060 ORS 197.380 (2021) Distinct from "Expedited Land Use Review" above relating to statute. Subject to staff Expedited review (for land use review, not building $90 availability and as allowed by law for use. In addition to application fees based on an permit review) per hour hourly rate for overtime. Fence permit Free WDO 2.06.02 & 5.01.03 Home occupation review Free WDO 2.07.10 Land Use Compatibility Statement (LUCS) or $100 other jurisdictional permit sign -off Extension of a development decision 685 WDO 4.02.05 Site inspection, planning & zoning (P&Z): Relates particularly to on -site private improvements resulting from building permit and civil/frontage/public/street improvements resulting from CEP approval. -Original/1st inspection & 2 nd inspection (re- Free inspection) -3r inspection and successive inspection $250 �r Zoning con irmationletter/ zoning verification $100 letter Planning service 1'/2 hours or more through $90 Applied per Director discretion. meeting by appointment instead of Planning per hour counter unscheduled service Planning counter and phone inquiry service Free Printing and copying: Mimics the Public Works fee schedule printing and copying items. Applicable only if total charge would be $10 or more. -Letter / 8'/2 by 11 inches black and white or 5¢ per page. (Min. 200 pages to charge.) grayscale -Letter / 8'/z by 11 inches color 750 per page. (Min. 14 pages to charge.) -Ledger / 11 by 17 inches Twice the per sheet. applicable (B&W: min. 100 sheets to charge; letter rate color: min. 7 sheets to charge) -Plan size / 24 by 36 inches, or any large map $25 per sheet. Continues next page 211 Significant Tree Removal Permit (TREE) $220 WDO 5.01.11 Removal of tree approved for removal, per tree: WDO Table 3.06T Class S Free Class T Free WDO 1.02 "Tree, Significant" Fee in lieu of mitigation tree, per tree: Class S $150 Class T $150 WDO 1.02 "Tree, Significant" Removal of tree approved for removal, per tree: WDO Table 3.06T Class S $200 Class T $300 WDO 1.02 "Tree, Significant" Fee in lieu of mitigation tree, per tree: Class S $150 Class T $150 WDO 1.02 "Tree, Significant" Removal of tree approved for removal, per tree: WDO Table 3.06T Class S $400 Class T $600 WDO 1.02 -Tree, Significant" Fee in lieu of mitigation tree, per tree: Class S $250 Class T $500 WDO 1.02 -Tree, Significant" ®'1111111=WDO Removal of tree approved for removal, per tree: Table 3.06T Class S: Multiple -dwelling development $600 Other than multiple -dwelling development $1,200 Class T: WDO 1.02 "Tree, Significant" Multiple -dwelling development Per Note. $150 per inch of diameter at breast height (DBH) of removed tree, but capped at $6,300 Other than multiple -dwelling development Per Note. $150 per inch of diameter at breast height (DBH) of removed tree, but capped at $12,600 Fee in lieu of mitigation tree, per tree: Class S $500 Class T $950 WDO 1.02 "Tree, Significant" §22�������IIIIIIIIIIIIJEWWDO Removal of tree approved for removal, per tree I Per Note. 3.06.07J JEqual to highest removal fee among those for T4. I:\Community DevelopmentTlanning\Forms & Fee Schedule\ Ordinance No. 2622, effective 3/27/2024 212 4?4 4' *7 4N g ewk WWODBURN In or�arnreA 188� February 26, 2024 To: Honorable Mayor and City Council through City Administrator From: Chris Kerr, Community Development Director Jesse Cuomo, Community Services Director Subject: Ordinance 2623 Implementing Legislative Amendment 23-04 of the Woodburn Comprehensive Plan and Adopting the Parks and Recreation Master Plan (LA 23-04) RECOMMENDATION: Adopt the attached Ordinance to implement Legislative Amendment LA 23-04, which amends Section L of the Woodburn Comprehensive Plan and adopts the updated Parks and Recreation Master Plan. BACKGROUND: The City Council held a public hearing on February 12, 2024, and tentatively approved LA 23-04, directing staff to prepare an ordinance. DISCUSSION: n/a FINANCIAL IMPACT: n/a Agenda Item Review: City Administrator _x City Attorney _x_ 213 Finance COUNCIL BILL NO. 3244 ORDINANCE NO. 2623 AN ORDINANCE ADOPTING AN UPDATED PARKS AND RECREATION MASTER PLAN AND ASSOCIATED AMENDMENTS TO THE WOODBURN COMPREHENSIVE PLAN (LA 23-04) WHEREAS, Oregon Revised Statute (ORS) 197 and Oregon Administrative Rule (OAR) 660-034 provide the statutes and rules that guide local governments in how they prepare, plan, adopt, amend, and revise their comprehensive plans in compliance with Statewide Planning Goal 8 - Recreational Needs; and WHEREAS, periodic revisions and updates to the Comprehensive Plan are necessary and expected to comply with statutes and administrative rules, administer new and revised long-range plans, and address current issues; and WHEREAS, the City of Woodburn entered into a contract with Conservation Technix, Inc. for planning consulting services related to drafting an updated Parks and Recreation Master Plan; and WHEREAS, the Woodburn Planning Commission held a public hearing on January 25, 2024 and unanimously recommended approval of the amendment to the City Council; and WHEREAS, the Woodburn City Council held a public hearing on February 12, 2024, and tentatively approved the legislative amendment, NOW, THEREFORE, THE CITY OF WOODBURN ORDAINS AS FOLLOWS: Section 1. The Parks and Recreation Master Plan (Exhibit A) attached hereto and incorporated herein, is hereby adopted as an element of Volume II of the Woodburn Comprehensive Plan, thereby repealing and replacing the previously adopted version of the Parks and Recreation Master Plan (Ordinance 2458, July 2009). Section 2. The City's Comprehensive Plan goals and policies are amended as specified in Exhibit B. Amendments are shown as underlined (i.e. new text) and strikeout (i.e. deleted text). After this ordinance amendment is adopted, the Community Development Director shall update the Woodburn Comprehensive Plan to incorporate all revisions contained herein. Page - 1 - Council Bill No. 3244 Ordinance No. 2623 214 Section 3. The legislative action taken by the Ordinance is explained and justified by the analysis and findings attached hereto and incorporated herein as Exhibit C. Approved as to form: City Attorney Date Approved: Passed by the Council Submitted to the Mayor Approved by the Mayor Filed in the Office of the Recorder ATTEST: Heather Pierson, City Recorder City of Woodburn, Oregon Page - 2 - Council Bill No. 3244 Ordinance No. 2623 Frank Lonergan, Mayor 215 216 217 Table of Contents Acknowledgments Chapter l:|ntnoducdmn&Overv�es-------------2 CitwCounc�U �onk��nmrgan' Mayor Chapter Z� Cunnnnun�v Pnzh|e ________________ 1Q Debbie Cabra|es,Ward | Chapter 3: Cmnnmun�ty Engagement ------------ 17 Mark Wilk, Ward x Robert Carney, Ward III Chapter 4� Q|aaafficafluna & |nventury ____________ 23 Sharon Schaub'Ward |v Mary Beth Cornwell, Ward v Chapter S: Parks & Open Space ------------ SO Eric Morris, Ward VI Chapter6: Recrea6mna|TraUa --------------- 79 ���������� �� ����� ����� Chapter 7:Recreat�mn,/\quat�ca§�E�ents----------9l Richard Irish Chapter 8:Gma|a&CJbjectves---------------lOO Justin May madPankey Chapter9: Cap�ta| P|ann�ng & |mp|ennenta6mn --------- 108 David Piper, Board Chair Ricardo Rodriguez /\ppend�cea-------------------------ll7 BmmnicaRios Isabella Baldisseri (StUdent Position) �� ��� �N� Director ����������N���� �0N���0������� ��������� "== �� ~"��� " Nanning Commission VVeUoommetmthe 2024Woodburn Parks and Recmeat|mmMaster Nam Debra Bartel, Position xnabm|Hernandez- I\Aejia'Position || TheParksand Recreation IMas^erP|an(PRIVIP)was 6eve|ope6through JuanBravo, Position III extensive input6om the community, as weU as careful consideration of industry Lisa Ellsworth, Chair, Position |v standards and trends. Sharon Coming' Position The PRIVIP represents a coUa6orative effort of our nesi6ents' community I\Amrri Berlin, Position VI stakeho|6ers' and staff who together 6e|ieve in a strategic direction to achieve |s ourgoa. The Flan aimsto pm6| vi6e a sustoinae and 6a|ance6 sys^em Of [Darks Chris Lassen, Posiuonv|| ' and recreation programs that are accessi6|e and inc|usive for every one of our residents to en�oy. We a|so 6e|ievethis Flan wiU continue our commitment to shape the character of Woodburn and enhance the qua|ity of |ife for our ��it�St��� residents. IMany of the ideas found within this document mirror emerging needs that Scott Derickson'City Administrator citizens 6e|ieve are important DurcoUective chaUenge is to use this P|an as a Jim Row, Assistant City Administrator foun6ationto6ui|6upon^zensunefumnegenerationswiUhaveanopportunity Jesse CUOMO, Community Services Director to e*yan outstanding [Dark and recreation system. It is our nesponsi6i|ity^z Dan Handel, City Planner strategicaUyeva|uate ourfaci|ities and operations to meet our future vision' This P|an wiU a||owustofocus on maintaining and impmving our Emily Duran, Evmm��Spmcia| Programs Manager assets and 6ebetter equippe6tomeet the chaUengesofthe future. Brian Powers, xquaucsProgram Supervisor As staff, we feel privi|ege6 to semethis tremendous community and honored Je*Crabtrmm Parks &Faci|iumsMaintenance Supm�isor ' tohave the supportofthe Recreation &ParksBoard with the 6eve|opmentof the PRIVIP We are especiaUygra^efu| to our residents who have voiced their opinionsand attended our pu6|icmeetings. Durpmmise is to use this PRIVIPto continue our efforts to create a community ConsWtant Team that offers qua|ityofHe, whi|e anticipating future community needs. Conservatimn7echniv' Inc. |ZOPub|icRelations 8Marketing JesseCuomo Ju\Pub|icInvolvement Community Service Director 218 apter I ACTIVE, THRIVING, ENGAGED, In'troduction & Overview Purpose of the Man The City of Woodburn 2024 Parks and Recreation Master Plan (PRIMP) is an update to the 2009 Parks and Recreation Master Plan that builds on the previously cornplleted planning work and incorporates the feedback from an extensive community engagement process conducted in 2023. This Plan creates a vision for an innovative, inclusive and interconnected system of parks, trails and open space that promotes recreation, health, environmental) conservation and fiscal responsibility as integ4l ellernents of a thriving, livable Woodburn. The PRIMP serves as a blueprint for the management, enhancement and growth of Woodburn's park and recreation system. It assists in guiding decisions related to planning, developing and maintaining parks, open space and recreational) facilities. This Plan also identifies priorities for recreation programs, community events and culltu4l activities. The 2024 PRIMP provides updated system inventories, community profile, needs analyses and a comprehensive capital) project list. The Plan identifies parks and recreation goals and establishes a �long-range plan for the Woodburn parks and recreation system, including action items and strategies for irnpllernentation over the next ten years or more. The recommendations in this Plan are based on community input, evaluations of the existing park system, operating conditions and fiscal considerations. The PRIMP is part of the City's broader Comprehensive Plan and reflects the guidelines established by Oregon's Statewide Planning Goall 8 on Recreation Planning. Locall residents are proud of Woodburn for its sense of srr4H town character and for what has been accomplished in the park system with modest resources, but they also are interested in improvements. This Plan documents those desires and provides a framework for addressing cap tall clevelloprnent and funding in the near -term. 219 BUILD A NEW COMMUNITY CENTER COMPLEX - SURVEY RESPONDENT 220 Planning Process This PRIMP represents the culmination ofayeap |(.Nngp|anningefft)rt and reflects the cc)mmunitv's interests and needs for parks, open space, trails and programming. The planning process, which included avariety ofpublic outreach activities, encouraged public engagement toinform the development of the priorities and future direction ofVVoodburn's park and recreation system. Community members expressed their interests through surveys, public meetings, stakeholder discussions, online outreach, tabling events and Recreation and Parks Board meetings. |naddition tocommunity engagement, the actcnsidentified inthis Plan are based c)n: 10 Aninventory and assessment ofthe Oty's ex�sting[Dark and necneat�onfaci|it�es^oesto6|ish the system'scurrent performanceand ^zi6ent�fy needed main^enanceand capito|nepairand nep|acementpno�ects'and 10 Service |eve| and wa|ka6i|ityassessments ^o quantify the system'sa6i|itytoserve current and future residents. The P|an'scapital improvements section and accompanying implementation strategies are intended tosustain and enhance, preserve and steward the City'scritical parks and recreation infrastructure. Department Overview The Community Services Department serves as the community's key resource for providing parks, trails, recreation, aquatic facilities and programs, and community events and supports tourism and economic development, aswell asproviding anenhanced quality oflife for its citizens. Thousands of participants and visitors join the many programs offered each year. There are 25 city -owned park sites totaling 135 acres and more than 4.5 miles of trails in the Woodburn park system. The park and recreation system issupported by2O.5full-time employees in four divisions: Aquatics, Recreation, Parks &Faci|ities Maintenance, and Recreation Administration. 10 TheAquat�cs6Msionstaffs the Woodburn Aquatic Center, which offersfhness. recreational and |eam-to-swim pmgramsfor in6ivi6ua|s ofa|| ages. Faci|ityamenities inc|u6e a 1O- |aneswimmingpoo|with water s|i6e'mpe sw�ng'gmupexercise room, pauynemo|room, 6oake�6oU hoop.006inB poo|.apo.fhness equipmentand saunas. 10 The Recreation division offers community - wide |eisune opportunities inc|u6ing youth and a6u|tsports'communityevents, youth |ea6ersHp programs' summercamps' active a6u|tan6 recreation trips and community education c|asses.The6ivisiona|socoordinates and maintoinsactive partnershipswith severa| community partners' inc|u6ing YIMCA of Marion and Po|kCounties' VVoo66um 1:::'C'VVoo66um Ybuth Base6a||and Soft6aU'and Boys and Gr|s Ou6' in supportofrecreation options for the VVoo66um community. 10 The 1::)arksan6 Faci|ities IMaintenance6ivision is responsi6|e for maintaining parks' grounds, 6ui|6ingsand pmvi6ingcusto6ia|services for Otyfaci|ities. The Parks and Faci|ities IMain^enanceSupenisornepous^othe CommunitySemices IManagec Oty staff custo6ia| services pmvi6essupportservices ^z departments. Commercia|contracts support other faci|ityservices initiated 6yfaci|ities maintenance staff. Commercia||y-contracted faci|itiesmain^enanceservices inc|u6eheating, venti|ation'and aip\A con6itioning(HA�)� e|ecthcian senicesfor both main^enancean6 improvements; fire pntectionequipment elevator, |ocksmh1h;roofing and pointinB� 10 A6ministratonfocuses on|ong-rangep|anning' acquis�on and 6eve|opmentof[Dark fad|hjes' the 6eve|opmentof[Dark site master p|ans' and pursuingand a6ministeringgrants. A6ministrat�onpmvi6esoveraUsupport for the Oepartmentinareas ofbudgeting, communicat�ons' customer service, contracts and capita| pno�ects administration' among others. Additionally, the efforts ofthe Department are guided bythe Recreation and Parks Board, aseven'memberadvisory group tothe City Council. The Board meets monthly toprovide guidance and give necommenclationsonpolicy and issues relating tothe delivery ofpark and recreation services. The Recreation and Parks Board is appointed by the Mayor and City Council, and members serve for three year terms. 221 Guided by Values Woodburn's City Council adopted its most recent annual Ibudget in June 2022, and it reinforced the vision and priorities for the City's future. City C4 W161 ViSiOrl StateMerlt Woodburn will Ibe a safe, vibrant, full -service community. Woodburn will Ibe a community of unity, pride, and charm. It will Ibe a sustainable, technologically advanced community with a functional multi -modal transportation system. Woodburn will thrive as a regional focus for the advancement and enjoyment of the arts, culture, leisure and recreational activities. Woodburn will Ibe a great place to live, work and visit. COW161 1"riorities Create an inclusive environment where residents and civic organizations participate and are engaged in the community that is vibrant, safe, and active. Promote an environment that encourages sustainable economic health maximizing our geographic, workforce, cultural, and community assets. These citywide values provided a foundation for the policies and recommenclations within this Plan. Also, the Department's mission statement provides a framework for future planning and guided the development of goals and project recommenclations for this PRIMP. COMMUrlity Services f,)epartment Mission Statement It is the mission of the Community Services Department to Ibuild a strong sense of community and improve the quality of life for all Woodburn residents. We accomplish this mission Iby providing an excellent system of parks, open spaces, facilities and leisure services, as well as a strong collection of informational materials, opportunities for lifelong learning and the promotion of literacy. 222 223 Current Challenges & Future Considerations As with any citywide strategic planning effort, current community challenges provide a context for developing and assessing strategies for the future. The following macrotrends are anticipated to Ibe important priorities over the next decade. Growth, f,)evelopment & fl)ensity The City of Woodburn has witnessed tremendous growth in recent years, and the City's population has risen nearly 40% between 2000 and 2020. By 2045, Woodburn is projected to Ibe home to more than 31,000 residents. More residents and new development will increase the use of existing parks and facilities and increase the need for recreational spaces and experiences across the city. Rapid growth also will intensify existing community needs for safe and accessible walking and Ilbiking routes, as well as the preservation of open space and natural resources. In response, this Plan outlines several policies and projects to improve recreation facilities and parks to adapt to emerging needs, complete important connections in the City's burgeoning trail network, and acquire or preserve open space in strategic areas. I,,,qL9ity, IrICIUSiVity & Accessibility Maintaining and enhancing social equity across recreational opportunities and facilities should Ibe a core function of municipal park and recreation systems. Through this Plan, the City of Woodburn made a concerted effort to reach out to, connect with, and engage the diversity of local communities, and the City also committed to outreach in its three major languages: English, Russian and Spanish. Through direct engagement during various community and cultural events, a three -language community survey, and live interpretation during open house meetings, the City endeavored to make all voices welcome during the PRIMP process. A focus on diversity, equity and inclusion also carries into adaptive recreation programs and ongoing accessibility upgrades of parks and amenities. The City must cc::)nthnue t(::) find ways tc::) orc::)vide safe and equitable access to parks, trails, facilities, recreation programs and other services. 224 COrltirlUed Investments in Flark and Recreation system From accessible playgrounds to splash pads to connected trails to natural areas, the range of play experiences offered Iby the City will need to change and diversify over time. Also, the diversity of the %::)c::)d1ounn cc::)rnrnunity will Influence the needs F(::)ir different or expanded recreational experiences, such as extended family gatherings, cultural programs, community events and social activities, and cultural arts, among others. The demand for new amenities also must Ibe Ibalanced against preserving and maintaining existing parks and natural areas. The development of new amenities may require the use or re -use of existing parkland or more parkland may �be required to support the community's evolving, future needs. The on -going planning for, and anticipated construction of, a new Woodburn Community Center will Ibe an expansion and restoration of the existing Aquatics Center tc::) orc::)vide a significant Dc::x::)n for indoor recreation and activities in Woodburn and offer a variety of gathering places for the community. Recent conversations with community members suggest a continued interest in expanding, or having access to additional, indoor recreation facilities, as well as additional spaces for classes, exhibits and multi -purpose uses. Research on recreation also provides information on how park distribution, park proximity, park facilities and conditions have an impact on people's desire to engage in physical activity. It will Ibe valuable to re-evaluate current park designs and maintenance policies to ensure Ibarrier-free, engaging park envirc::mirrients and c::)1oeratk:)naI efficiencies. I lie City will continue to play a major role in enabling healthy lifestyles for Woodburn citizens and should continue to adapt the park and trail system and recreation offerings. Stewardship & Asset Management Established park systems require ongoing maintenance in order to safely and effectively serve the community. Public recreation providers across the country consider maintaining existing park facilities to Ibe a key management issue. Poorly maintained assets — from Ibernches to playgrounds to pools — can fail, either structurally or operationally, posing safety risks and reducing their recreational value. Aging infrastructure also may fail to meet community expectations or need capital upgrades to adapt to changing community interests. However, recreation providers often struggle to establish adequate funding mechanisms for routine and preventative maintenance and repair of facilities, as well as the major rehabilitation of existing outdoor recreation facilities at the end of their useful life. 225 This Plan includes acondition assessments ofCity parks to provide a baseline of current conditions toinform facility, maintenance and operations policies and improvements. Proper maintenance of recreation assets will prevent deterioration, thereby reducing long-term capital and operating costs, maintaining safety, improving public perception and facilitating extended community use. Active Older AdUltS Older adults, ages 55years plus, make up29%of VVoodburn's population, and Woodburn Estates isthe largest community for adults over 55in Oregon. This indicates a potential local need for active recreation opportunities for active older adults. Nationwide, active seniors are often looking atretirement age differently, and many are transiticning tc) new careers, finding ways tc) engage with their community, and focusing on their health and Fitness. Tc)meet the needs c)factive c)|der residents, Woodburn will need toconsider how the City's park and recreation facilities, programming, and partnerships can meet the needs of this growing group. F�'iscal Challenges As a fast-growing city with a strong agricultural heritage, tremendous pressure exists on capital and operating funding sources for the maintenance and expansion of City services and amenities. This Plan is structured with these constraints in mind and considers listed capital projects for their potential toleverage other funding sources, affects to future maintenance and operations demands, and estimated development costs. Guiding Documents This PRIMP isone ofseveral documents that comprise VVoodburn'slong-range planning and policy framework. Past community plans and other relevant documents were reviewed for policy direction and goals asthey relate to parks, open space, trails, and recreation opportunities across Woodburn. 10 Parksand Recreat�onIMasterP|anUp6ate(2O09) 10 KUCreek GneenwayIMasterP|an(2OO7) 10 Community and Aquatic Center MarketAna|ysis (2019) 10 OtyofWoodburn Compnehens�veP|an(2O22 10 Woodburn Iransporta ionSystem P|an(2O19) 10 Highway99EConi6orP|an(2O12) Plan Contents The remainder ofthis Parks and Recreation Master Plan is organized as follows: 10 Chopter2: CommunhyPmf|e—pnmk6esonoverview of the Oty of Woodburn and its 6emograpHcs. 10 Chapter3: CommunityEngagement—high|ightsthe methods used ^oengage the Woodburn community in the 6eve|opment of the P|an. 10 Chopt*r4: Classifications & |nventory-6esoi6eathe inventory and classifications for existing porkaya ern. 10 Chapters 5: Parks &Dpen Space-6escri6es communityfee66ack, trends, |oca| needs and po^entia| impozvementsfor [Darks and openspace. 10 Chapter6: 1 rai|s-6escri6es communityfee66ack, |oca| interests and potentia| improvements for the necreationa| trai| network. 10 Chapter7: Recreation-6escri6es community feedback, trends, |oca| needs and potentia| impmvementsfor recreation semices'faci|itiesand events. 10 Chapterg: Goa|s &D1D�ectives—pmvi6es a po|icy frameworkfor the [Dark and recreation system gmupe66yma�orpmgramarea. 10 Chapter9: Pno�ects & |mp|ementation Strategies —6escri6es a range of strategies to consider in the imp|ementation of the P|an and 6etai|s a 10- yearpmgram for addressing [Dark and faci|ity enhancement orexpansion pno�ects. 10 Appendices: Pmvi6es^echnica|orsupporting information^zthe p|anning effort and inc|u6esa summary ofthe communitysurvey, stakeho|6ernotes, funding options'among others. 226 apter 2 COMMUNITY PROFILE Woodburn is a diverse community of over 26,000 residents in Marion County, Oregon. The City is located along both Interstate 5 and State Route 99 and is surrounded by the fertile farrnllancls of the cent4l WHHamette VaIHley. It offers residents a srr4H-town feel) with convenient access to both the Portland and Salern-Keizer metropohtan areas. The community is home to downtown shopping, the Woodburn Premium Outlet Ma11, as welHl as numerous Mexican restaurants and shops, historic attractions, and popular events Ilike Fiesta Mexicana and regionall events Ilike the Wooden Shoe Tulip FestivaL Woodburn's downtown area is centered on Front Street, just to the west of the Union Pacific rail line, and includes rndltip�le restaurants and srr4H stores, the Woodburn City Ha�H, Downtown 1`1aza, and Library. The Woodburn Aquatic Center and Setflernier Park are located just to the south and the Woodburn branch of Cherneketa Community College just to the east of downtown. The City has two major commerc4l areas, located along 1-5 to the east and State Route 99E to the west. Most of the City's resiclent4l neighborhoods, a mix of singlle-farnHy, rnullti-farnHy and mobHe home areas, are located in between 1-5 and 1-99E, including Woodburn Estates, one of the state's largest 55+ communities. The northeastern portion of the City includes Woodburn's primary inclusti-41 areas and the MacLaren Youth Correctionall FacHity. 227 Profile Today, Woodburn is a rapid�ly growing community whose popullation has grown by more than 25% over the past twenty years. It is home to many farniNes with chHdren, making up neady four in ten househ6lds, who enjoy the recreationall opportunities provided by the City's parks and open spaces. Figure'I. Population Clio r acter isfics: Woodburn, Morron County, and Oregon State Population Characteristics Population (2022) 1 26,468 348,616 4,281,851 Population (20 10)2 25,377 315,335 3,831,074 Population (2000) 3 20,861 284,834 3,421,399 Percent Change (2000-22) 26.9% 22.4% 25.1% Persons with Disabilities (%)4 14.9% 15.0% 14.4% Household Characteristics 4 Households 8,605 121,132 1,658,091 Percent with children 36.0% 33.0% 28.2% Median Household Income $54,330 $64,880 $70,084 Average Household Size 2.49 2.76 2.99 Average Family Size 3.03 3.3 3.59 Owner Occupancy Rate 64.3% 61.2% 63.2% Age Groups 4 Median Age 38.6 37 39.6 Population < 5 years of age 6.9% 6.4% 5.3% Population < 18 years of age 28.0% 24.6% 20.8% Population 18 - 64 years of age 54.1% 59.7% 61.5% Population > 65 years of age 17.9% 15.7% 17.7% *1: 2022 Portland State University Certified Population Estimates '12: U.S. Census Bureau, 2010 Decennial Census. '13: U.S. Census Bureau, 2000 Decennial Census. '14: U.S. Census Bureau, 2021 American Community Survey 5-Year Estimates 228 After incorporation in 1889 with a population of about 400 residents, Woodburn's population grew quickly to about 1,600 residents in 1910 as settlers moved to the area, Ibefore remaining stable through the first half, c)f the 20th Century. 1:::I)eg 'Ill 11 'Ill g in the 1940s, the Bracero Program brought thousands of Mexicans to the Willamette Valley to work on farms short of workers due to World War 11. These Mexican workers, their families, and future migrants, made up the City's early I atino population. In the 1950s, members of the Molokans religious sect moved to the Woodburn area. They encouraged fellow Old Believers, who had also IbrokeFn away from the Russian Orthodox Church, to immigrate to the area. These two groups helped the City's population more than double in the 1960s and formed the foundation for Woodburn's large present-day I atino and Russian -language communities.' The development of Senior Estates, now Woodburn Estates, the largest community for adults over 55 in Oregon, brought approximately 2,500 retirees to the City IbetweeFn 1960 and 1980. In the decades since, Woodburn's population has continued to Figure 2. Population Change - Actual and Projected: 1960 - 2045 000 w,m)() 000 m,m)() 1rs,000 000 grow approximately 4% annually. As of the 2022 State population forecast, the City's population was 26,468 residents. Woodburn's urban growth IbouFndary includes numerous agricultural and low -density residential lots that could Ibe annexed into city limits, supporting future growth. The Portland State Population Research Center forecasts that Woodburn will grow slowly over the coming decades, at an average of about 1% per year, reaching approximately 31,121 residents Iby �045. The size of a community and its anticipated growth over time are key indicators of whether existing joark and recreatic)n facilities will be sufficient tc) meet future needs. Population growth can also result in increased residential density and/or the development of currently vacant land within a city, potentially increasing the need for away -from -home recreation opportunities, while simultaneously reducing potential locations for park and open space acquisition. Planning for parks and recreation facilities can help ensure residents can enjoy sufficient, ccmveniently 1(::)cated joarks, c)IDen space, and recreation facilities, while the community grows and evolves. 21 960 970 a980 a990 2000 0:� 0 O�20 2030 040 36% households Increased diversity with children (2000-2020) A11116 0i 229 Age Group Distribution VVoodbunn'spopulation has amedian age of386 (2021), older than Marion County as a whole (37.0) but lower than the statewide average (39.6). Youth under 2Oyears ofage make upthe City'slargest 2O'yearpopulation group, comprising 31%ofthe overall population in2O21.This has important implications for park and recreation needs. 10 Appozxmate|y7%ofVVoo66um'sFmpu|at�onare youth under 5years o|6.This gmup represents users ofpneschoo| and ^ztpmgrams and faci|ities' and as trai|sand openspaceusers, are often instroUers. These in6M6ua|s are the future participants in youth activities. 10 Chi|6nen5^o14years make upcurrent youth program participants. Appmx�ma^e|y 17% of the city's popu|at�on faUs into this age range. 10 Teensand young a6u|ts'age 15^o24years, are in transition from youth program to a6u|t programs and pardcipa^einteen/young a6u|tpmgramswhere avai|a6|e. Members oftHs age group are often seasona|emp|oymentseekers. About 12%percentof the city'sresidents are teens and young a6u|ts. ri 201.0 im 2021. Under 5vears 5msyears 10m14years 15m19years 20m24years 25m29years '10mmyears '15m'1syears 40m44years 45m4syears 50m54years 55m5syears 60m64years 65masyears mm74years 75mrsyears 80m84years 85 years and over 10 A6u|tsages 25^o34years are users ofa6uk pmgrams.About 11%ofresidents are intHsage category, see Figure 2.1 hese residents may be entering |ong-tenn ne|at�onsHpsand esto6|ishing fami|ies.About 36%ofhouseho|6sinthe city are fami|ies with chi|6nen. 10 A6u|ts between 35 and 54years of age represent users of wide range ofa6u|t programs and park faci|it�es. Theircharacteristicsextend from having chi|6nen using pneschoo| and youth pmgrams^o 6ecomingemptynesters. This age gmupmakes up 24%ofVVoo66um'spopu|at�on. 10 D|6era6u|ts'ages 55years p|us,make up29%of VVoo66um'spopu|at�on.This gmupnepresentsusers ofa6ukand senior pmgrams.Theseresidents may beappmacHngnet�rementora|nea6yret�ne6and may 6espen6ingt�mewith gran6chi|6nen.THsgmup a|soranges from very hea|tiXacdveseniors ^zmore physicaUyinacdveseniors. S-c)-Ijiroe-u s � it tpsW*wmvr eovnencyclopea/a.yo/amcIes/ *owyiDum/ and ��s�x*�*mowy�umvcovw museum/paoexvova�um'u�v,v 6 us�Census Bureau, 2021. 230 Race & Ethnicity I Woodburn is a diverse community whose residents predominantly identify as White or Hispanic/l. atino. In 2021, 62% of the population of Woodburn identified as White, 23% as sc::)rne c:Aher race n(:A listed on Census forms, 11 % as two or more races, 1.5% as Asian or American Indian and Alaskan Native (each), and 1% as Black or African American. I\Jc::) residents identified as Native I lawaiian c::)i- c:Aher Pacific Islander. Over half (56%) c::)f residents identify as Hispanic or I atino of any race, with most identifying as Mexican. While Woodburn's population has retained similar overall levels of diversity over the past decade, there has been an increase in the percentage of residents identifying as two or more races and a decline in those identifying as American Indian or Alaskan Native, see Figure 4. Figure 4. Changes in Racial Cornposil-ion 2010 I-o 2021 White 62.8% 62.0% Some other race 28.1% 23.2% Two or more races 2.3% 11.3% Asian 1.2% 1.4% American Indian and Alaska Native 5.3% 1.4% Black or African American 0.3% 0.8% Native Hawaiian and Other Pacific Islan 0.0% 0.0% Hispanic or Latino (of any race) 53.9% 56.3% According to the 2021 American Community Survey, about 73% of Woodburn's residents were born in the United States, with about 26% born abroad. The vast majority of foreign -born residents (90%) have lived in the U.S. for at least a decade. Approximately 55% of residents speak a language other than ::.::.nglish at lic::)rne, and significantly, c::)vei- 23% speak English less than very well. Most of these residents speak Spanish. The City should continue to provide information and programming in Spanish to ensure recreation is accessible to these residents. People of color and residents who speak languages Other than English may face Ibarriers in accessing parks, recreation facilities, and activities. The City's planning for future park and recreational opportunities should prioritize inclusivity and consider how Ibest to meet the diverse recreational needs of its growing and vibrant community. Inclusion will not only enhance social cohesion, Ibut also enrich the community's overall well-being and quality of life. Persons with Disabilities 6 The 2021 American Community Survey reported 15% of Woodburn's population (3,850 persons) have a disability that interferes with life activities. This is on par with county and state averages (14-15% each). Approximately 3% of youth under 18 years of age, 11 % of adu Its 18 to 64, and 46% of residents over age 65 live with a disability, signaling a potential need to design inclusive parks, recreational facilities, and programs. Planning, designing, and operating a park system that facilitates participation Iby residents of all abilities will help ensure compliance with Title 11 Of the Americans with Disabilities Act (AAA). In addition to ADA, there are other accommodations that people with disabilities may need to access parks and participate in recreation programs. Woodburn should consider community needs for inclusive and accessible parks, recreational facilities, programs, marketing, and communications. Household Characteristi CS 6 In 2019, the average household in Woodburn was 2.99 people, higher than the state (2.49) and county (2.76) average. The average family is larger, at 3.59 people. Of the 8,605 households in the City, 36% were families with children under 18, and 26% were individuals living alone. Most Woodburn households own their home (64%), on par with the average throughout Marion County (61.2%), while 36% rent. This ratio is indicative of the mix of housing stock in the city, which includes both single-family homes and multiple apartment complexes. Employment & Education 6 The 2021 work force population (16 years and over) Of Woodburn is 19,314 (75%). Of this population, 56% percent is employed, 3% is unemployed, and 41% is not in the labor force. Residents work in a wide variety of industries - about 22% of employed residents work in manufacturing, while 16% work in the education and health care industry and 12% work in retail trade. Several other industries — professional and management services, construction, and agricultural and forestry sectors — each employ between 7 and 10 percent of workers and contribute significantly tc::) the k:)cal ecc::)nc::)rny. The majority (70%) of Woodburn residents over 25 years of age have a high school degree or higher, significantly 1(::)wei- than the statewide average 231 (92%). About 16% of city residents have a Bachelor's degree or higher, lower than statewide rates (35%). Higher levels of employment and educational attainment positively correlate with both the income and health status of a community — Iboth of which have further impacts on the use and need for park and recreation facilities, as described in the next two sections. Income & Poverty 6 A community's level of household income can impact the types of recreational services prioritized �by community members as well as their ability to pay for recreational services. In 2021, the median household income in Woodburn was $54,330. This income level was about $10,500 (19%) lower than the median income for Marion County households. Higher income households typically have an increased capacity to pay for recreation and leisure services and often face fewer Ibarriers to participation. Approximately 21 % of Woodburn households have household incomes in the higher income Ibrackets ($100,000 and greater), lower than the county average (29%). I ower-income residents may face Ibarriers to physical activity, including reduced access to parks and recreational facilities, a lack of transportation options, a lack of time, and poor health. I ow -income residents may a1sc) be less Financially able tc) affc)rd recreational service fees or to pay for services, such as childcare, that can make physical activity possible. In Woodburn, 19% of households earn less than $25,000 annually, and 9% of local families live Ibelow the poverty level ($26,500 for a family of four), slightly higher than county rates. Poverty affects 19% of youth under 18 and 14% of adults. sources 6 LLS. Census Bureau, 2021 7 LLS� Census Bureau, 2010 American Community Survey, 5 year estimates. Health Status The overall health of a community's residents can impact their ability to participate in recreation and c)ther physical activity and may a1sc) reflect, in Dart, the locality's level of access to appropriate and convenient green spaces, recreation opportunities, and active transportation facilities. Information on the health of Woodburn's residents is not readily available. However, according to the 2022 County Health Rankings, Marion County ranks in the higher -middle range compared to all Oregon counties for health outcomes, including length and quality of life, and the low -middle quartile for health factors like health behaviors, clinical care, social and economic factors, and the physical environment." In Marion County, 81 % of residents have access to adequate physical activity opportunities, which is also on par with the average for all Oregon residents (80%). This suggests that the County has a reasonable number of places where residents can participate in physical activity, including parks, trails, and public or private community centers, gyms, or other recreational facilities. Approximately 37% of Marion County adults are overweight or obese, higher than the average among all Oregon adults (29%). Also, 29% of Marion County adults aged 20 and older report getting no leisure -time physical activity — a rate similar to the statewide average of 24% and the nationwide average of 26%. 81 Data on the health status of Varic)n County and Oregon State residents taken frorm University of VViscc)nsin Population Health Institute. "Oregon Rankings Data". County Health Rankings. Available at Accessed January 2023. 232 233 apter 3 WN) 0/1119M I MW Several outreach methods were used to connect with the community, seek their input and provide information about the Flan through convenient onNne and in -person activities. PuNic outreach methods were varied and extensive, indluding: • IRaridorn-sarnple mail survey and orilirie cornrnuriity-wide survey iri Eriglish, Spariish and IRussiari • One hybrid iri-persori/virtual public rneetirig • One orilirie operi house • Stakeholder group discussions • Tabling and outreach at multiple cornrnuriity events • IMeetirigs with IRecreatiori and Parks lBoard and City Council • Woodbum city website with plari iriformatiori and Feedback opportunities • Multiple social rnedia postings, ernail notifications, and city newsletter articles Community Survey A community -wide, onNne survey was conducted to assess the recreational needs and priorities of Woodburn residents. The survey was avaHaUle in EngHsh and Spanish, and the cover �letter accompanying the printed rnaH survey was written in both Ilan guages and indluded unique QR codes to access each in-IIanguage survey onNne. The City rnaHed 2,500 surveys to randorn�ly chosen househ6lds in Woodburn on March 16, 2023, of which 262 surveys were cornpleted and returned (10.5% response rate, 5% margin of error). OnNne versions of the survey in EngHsh, Spanish and Russian were posted to the City's website on March 27th. An additional 256 surveys were cornpleted from the gene4l, community -wide onhne surveys. In aIH, 518 surveys were c6lHlected, which indludes 44 Spanish surveys. 234 Information about the survey was promoted through several channels, including onthe City'swebsite, through multiple social media postings, arid through direct outreach topartner organizations arid recreation program participants. The survey was closed onJune 3,2O23. The survey measured current levels ofsatisfaction arid which facilities were primarily being used by residents. Residents were asked about future improvements arid the types ofrecreational amenities they would like tosee considered for the park system. Survey respondents were asked about: 10 Performance and qua|tynfprograms and parks; 10 Usage of city parks and recreation faoi|ties; 10 [)veraU satisfaction with the va|ue of services being de|vemd6ythe city; 10 Opinions about the need for various park, recreation, and tmi|improvements; and 10 Priorities for future park. and recreation services and Survey Findings are highlighted be|cum and a m:)re detailed discussion ofresults can be found in the needs assessment chapters covering parks arid open space, recreation, arid trails (Chapters 5 7). MajmrSmrvoy F�hi di rigs: 10 Livabi|ity: 0ear|y a|| respondents (96%) fee| that pu6|io parks and recreation opportunities are important nressentia|tnthe qua|itynf|ifenn VVnnd6um. 10 Usage: Park. visitation is high' with 72% of respondents visiting parks nrrecreation faoi|itiesat |eastnnoe a month. Respondents visit |noa| parks and recreation faoi|itiesfor avariety nfreasons, but the most pnpu|ar reason is to wa|k or run (69%). More than one inthree respondents visit tnuse op|oyBmun6(44%).walk odog (42%).for fhnesa or exercise (40%)' to re|ax (39%)' or to attend community events nrconcerts (3b%). 10 Park Upgrades: When asked tnprioritize pntenda| improvements, community members ranked improving and upgrading existing parks astheir top prinrity. In other questions, they oaUedfor additinna| wa|kingtmi|s'picnic areas, p|aygmunds'and sport courts. |nopen-ended responses, community members a|snasked for additinna|amenities |ike covered 6asket6aUcourts, piok|e6aUcourts, disc gn|f courses, skateparks'and picnic areas. 'Ibp Priority SPLASHPAD 82% Support 86% Support 11 FAMPHITHEATER HE 81 % Support . ZOO DOG PARK 66% Support 10 Park. Maintenance and Safety: Communitymem6ers cited maintenance and safety concerns astop reasons why they dn riot visit more often, and written comments expressed adesire for improved maintenance and safety in existing parks. They advocated for additinna|deaningand trash mmnva| inparks, repairs tnbroken equipment, and increased |ighting and enforcement nfpark. ru|es. 10 VVa|kingTmi|s:The community seeks anexpansion The complete survey summary isprovided in nfwa|king trai|s and the eta6|ishment of bike paths' Appendix A. emphasizing the importance nfconnectivity between porka.Residents also apecifico||yrequested 6euer |ighting a|nng trai|s' whee|ohaipfrien&y paths' and 235 DuaI In. -Person & VirtuaI Public eeting On May 31, 2023, the City hosted an in -person public meeting from 7:00 - 8:30 p.m. at the Woodburn City Hall. The project team prepared a presentation and informational displays covering the major themes of the Parks Master Plan. These displays included Project Overview, Survey Highlights, Parks & Outdoor Recreation, and Investing in the Future. The meeting was conducted as a hybrid (online & in -person) event and in English and Spanish. Attendees were encouraged to talk to project team members and record their comments. City staff and project team staff engaged with participants to identify general needs and interests for park and recreation in Woodburn. Approximately 12 people attended the meeting to review materials and provide comment. A summary of comments for the first c::)n1hne c::)1pen hc::)use is orc::)vided in Appendix B. Online Open House The City hosted a second public forum as an online open house to allow community members to participate at their convenience. On September 15, 2023, the City published an online open house in English and Spanish that was open through October 1, 2023. The online open house provided residents an opportunity to respond to a series of questions about Woodburn's recreational opportunities and solicit input about which park and recreation amenities, services and facilities are important to them. The online open house was promoted in multiple languages via social media posts, email Iblasts, radio announcements and public meeting announcements. In all, 170 responses were collected. OrIfirle Operl 1"IOUSL- 1"h_qhfi_qhtS: 1 1 he rnaoHty want to see urn[Droved rnantenance of exustung fa6htVes and [Darks. 10 BuHd'ng a cornrnunuty center and renovatung Sealer-fler F)ark and U[Dgrad'ng [D�aygrounds were the tO[D two unvestrnent [DHoHtues. 10 IMOSt [Deo[D�e were un favor Of [DuHd'ng a 6tywude traH k)O[D, as weH as [DuHd'ng more traHs un natural areas. 10 F)artuci[Dants would hke to see the fokwung traH arnenutues unstakd: traHhead restroorns, benches akong traHs, and dHnking fountauns or water bottle filling st.at.ions. 1 1 he rnaoHty are unterested un more [Drograrn offeHngs, un generaL 1 Ns unciuded unterest un more rned'urn- or �arge-suzed city events, more swami lesson offeHngs, and more affordaHe S[Dorts [Drograrns. A summary of responses to the second online open house is provided in Appendix C. Community Event'Tabluing City staff, Recreation and Parks Board members and project team members conducted a series of tabling activities at community events and festivals. Tabling occurred between July and September to Ibuild awareness of the Plan and solicit input on park and recreation program enhancements. Tabling activities were held at Fiesta Mexicana and Music in the Park events. 236 Stakeholder Discussions In -person and online group discussions with external stakeholder were conducted to more Ibroadly assess local needs and opportunities for partnership, coordination and communication. Stakeholders were identified loy City staff loosed c::)n their lDast coordination their involvement or interest in the future of recreation, park, and sport or trail facilities. Group discussions were held with participants from the Farmworker Housing Development Corporation, an English class for Spanish speakers at Chemeketa Community College, and a mix of local residents with various park and recreation interests. Many recommended development of a community center, additk:)nal sloc::)rt fields and cc::)urts, splash load, trails and playground upgrades. Other comments included interest in improved restrooms at parks, enhanced maintenance and additional parkland, in general. Specific -ecc::)rnrnendati(::)ns are hlrated in the needs assessment sections (Chapters 5 - 7), and a full summary is provided in Appendix D. Recreation and Parks Board IMeetings The Recreation and Parks Board provided feedback on the development of the PRIMP during three regularly scheduled public sessions during 2023. 1 lie first sessk:)n c::)ccurred c::)n ::::�eloruary 14 th, shortly after the planning project was initiated. The Board discussed the update and provided their perspectives c::)n a visk:)n fc::)i- the system, specific challenges, opportunities and ideas about parks, trails and programs. Subsequent sessions were used to review public feedback and solicit direction from the Board on priorities and recommendations for the new Parks and Recreation Master Plan, Other Outreach In addition to the direct outreach opportunities described above, the Woodburn community was informed about the planning process through a variety of media platforms. The following methods were used to share information about the project and provide opportunities to participate and offer their comments: 10 Oty websute horne [rage 10 1::)arl<s and Recreatuon IMaster Flan [Droect [rage 10 ErnaH outreach through the Oty's &strbutuon hst and through Gartner organuzatuons 10 Socia� me6a vua 1:::�ace[DOOl< 10 Announcements at CouncH and Recreatuon and 1::)arl<s Board [DUlDhc rneetungs il [mill Ac lo, rn, p,,,i i6e v i e,,Ts A i1ru, a I rraitte 410. V'aW'6h0- J�-d' Mw4b. - M i le 4,,,w 11 ie,, s, 34 dr.,, rnx%r *, a I a s 7 p , ni. Vocadbuin cay Hail 270 p4antgomevy St. Wood J,wir ni, OR 97071 1 plartklpe Y corra Ila, volt W.0 N 237 238 239 Parkland is classified tc) assist in planning fc)rthe cc)mmunitv'srecreaticna| needs. Tlie c|assificatic)ns a|sc)reflect standards that hnfc)rmdeme|opment decisions during site planning, inaddition to operations and maintenance expectations for the level of developed facilities or natural lands. The Woodburn park system is composed of hierarchy ofvarious park types, each offering recreational opportunities and natural environmental functions. Collectively, the park system is intended to serve the full range ofcommunity needs. Classifying parkland 6vfunction allows the City to evaluate its needs and tc)p|antc)ranefficient, cost effective, and usable park system that minimizes cc)nflictsbetmeen parkusers and adjacent uses. Several factors are considered when classifying 10 Specfficneeds inneiBh6o,hoo6.service area, or community; 10 Suito6i|ityofa she fora pardcu|ar use-, 7 F" 10 Cost and effort of devek)[Drnent-I 10 Possi6i|ityfor pu6|ic-phvate partnershiFe� and 10 Dperat�ngand main^enancecosts. Eachparkc|assificatic)ndefines the site's functicn, expected amenities, and recreational uses. The classification chanscteristics serve as general guidelines addressing the size and use ofeach park tyloe.Tlie fc)Ucumhng six c|assificationsare used in VVoodburn'spark system: 10 CommunityPare 10 N6gh6o/hoo6Parks 10 PocketParks 10 C}penSpace 10 1 rai|s/LinearParks 10 Specia| UseFaci|ities 240 Community parks are larger parks, typically between six and 30 acres, providing a wide variety of recreation opportunities that appeal to the entire community. Typically, these sites are designed for active and passive recreaticm, suloloc)rted loy facilities such as sjoc)rt fields, c)utdc)c)r cc)urts, skate barks and recreatic)n centers. Athletic fields may loe natural, synthetic turf, c)ir a cc)rnloinatic)n c)f surfaces, with c)ir withcwt field lighting. Cc)rni-nunity parks can accommodate large numbers of people and offer a wider variety of facilities than neighborhood parks, such as skate parks, volleyball, tennis courts, performance stages, dog parks and group picnic areas. These barks a1sc) may include significant natural areas and trails. ::::�c)r this reascm, community parks require support facilities such as restrooms, parking lots and maintenance facilities. Community parks can also serve as local neighborhood parks for their immediate areas, and they may Ibe connected to schools or other community facilities. 'Typicall Amenities Passive Recreation Z Seating • Casual Use Spaces • Internal Walking Trails Z Water Access • Community Gardens • Unique Landscape Features • Natural Spaces Active Recreation • Creative Play Attractions • Playgrounds • Biking Trails • Outdoor Fitness / Exercise Facilities • Rectangular Fields • Diamond Fields • Basketball Courts • Tennis / Pickleball Courts • Volleyball Courts • Water Play Size 0 6 to 30 acres Service Area 0 2-mile travelshed Existing Facilities • Centennial Park • Legion Park • Settlemier Park Facilities Z Individual Picnic / Sitting Areas Z Group Picnic Areas • Park Shelters • Skateparks / Bike Skills • Splash Pads / Spray Parks • Outdoor Event Spaces • Off -leash Areas Z Restrooms Z Parking 241 A neighborhood park is typically 0.5 to 5 acres in size, depending on a variety of factors including neighborhood need, physical location, and opportunity. Neighborhood parks are intended to serve residential areas within close proximity (up to 1/2-mile walking or biking distance) of the park and should �be geographically distributed throughout the community. Topography and Ioc::)Iou1atk:)n density can influence the k:)cati(::)n c::)f a neigh1oc::)rhc::)c::)d Dark. Access to neighborhood parks is mostly pedestrian, and park sites should Ibe located such that people living within the service area can reach the park safely and conveniently. Connecting and frontage streets should include sidewalks or other safe pedestrian access. Neighborhood parks should Ibe located along road frontages to improve visual access and community awareness of the sites. Additionally, street plans should encourage maximum connectivity and public access to park sites. These parks can offer both active and passive recreation on a limited scale, Ibut they are used primarily for unstructured recreational activities. Amenities may include playgrounds, picnic areas, small facilities for active recreation, open lawn areas, and gathering spaces. Support facilities may include restrooms and off-street parking. 'Typicall Amenities Passive Recreation Z Seating • Casual Use Spaces • Internal Walking Trails 1:1 Water Access • Community Gardens • Unique Landscape Features • Natural Spaces Active Recreation • Creative Play Attractions • Playgrounds El Biking Trails Z Outdoor Fitness / Exercise Facilities El Rectangular Fields 1:1 Diamond Fields • Basketball Courts • Tennis / Pickleball Courts Size 0 0.5 to 5 acres Service Area 0 1/2-mile travelshed Existing Facilities • Burlingham Park • Hermanson Park North • Nelson Park • North Front St Park • Senior Estates Park • Wyffels Park Future Facilities • Boones Crossing (undeveloped) • Dove Landing (undeveloped) Facilities Z Individual Picnic / Sitting Areas Z Group Picnic Areas • Park Shelters • Skateparks / Bike Skills • Splash Pads / Spray Parks El Outdoor Event Spaces Z Off -leash Areas Z Restrooms • Volleyball Courts • Water Play 242 El Parking POCKET/ MINI PARKS These are small parks that provide a single purpose such as a garden, historic marker, resting places, benches or civic recognition. These parks are typically located on small parcels and provide passive or limited active recreation opportunities. They are generally less than 0.5 acres in size and provide modest recreational amenity to residents within a 'V4-mile walking distance. Development of these types of park spaces will depend on the values of the community and available opportunities to preserve special spaces. No specific numerical devek:)Iornent standard is established as this type c)f Dark space often comes about as the result of special circumstances (such as a personal dedication of land) that may not lend themselves for advanced planning. 'Typicall Amenities Passive Recreation Z Seating Z Casual Use Spaces El Internal Walking Trails 1:1 Water Access • Community Gardens • Unique Landscape Features El Natural Spaces Active Recreation • Creative Play Attractions • Playgrounds El Biking Trails Z Outdoor Fitness / Exercise Facilities El Rectangular Fields 1:1 Diamond Fields • Basketball Courts • Tennis / Pickleball Courts • Volleyball Courts El Water Play Size 0 < 0.5 acres Service Area 0 1/4-mile travelshed Existing Facilities • Alvah Cowan Park • Dahlia Plaza Pocket Park • Downtown Plaza Park • Hazel Smith Plaza • Heritage Park • Library Square 0 Future Facilities 0 Killian's Well Park (undeveloped) Facilities Z Individual Picnic / Sitting Areas El Group Picnic Areas Z Park Shelters El Skateparks / Bike Skills El Splash Pads / Spray Parks El Outdoor Event Spaces 1:1 Off -leash Areas 1:1 Restrooms El Parking 243 Size 0 Unique to each site Service Area 0 N/A Existing Facilities • Hermanson Pond • Seneca|Creek Park Open spaces are undeveloped lands primarily left inanatural state and typically places that are geographically orgeologically unique, with passive recreation use as secondary objective. Open spaces can provide for connected or linked corridors that can support broader ecological functions than standalone properties. Open spaces can beindividual orisolated tracts of open space or connected to a larger natural area network. Open spaces may serve astrail corridors, and low -impact orpassive activities, such as walking and nature observation may beallowed, where appropriate. No standards exist orare proposed for open spaces asthey are often dependent on characteristics of the natural resources within the City. Tv il� Amenities Passive Recreation Active Recreation Facilities 6D Seating O Creative Play Attractions 6D Individual Picnic / Sitting Areas 6D Casual Use Spaces O Playgrounds O Group Picnic Areas 6D Internal Walking Trails 6D Biking Trails 6D Park Shelters 6D Water Access O Outdoor Fitness / Exercise Facilities O Skateparks/ Bike Skills O Community Gardens O Rectangular Fields O Splash Pads /Spray Parks 6D Unique Landscape Features O Diamond Fields O Outdoor Event Spaces 6D Natural Spaces O Basketball Courts O Off -leash Areas O Tennis/ Pick|eba|| Courts O Restruums O Volleyball Courts O Parking O Water Play 244 TRAILS / LINEAR PARKS The purpose of trails/linear parks is to provide safe and readily accessible connections between neighborhoods, City parks, and centers of local importance to encourage walking, jogging, bicycling, and other forms of non -motorized recreational travel. Trail development may coincide with the installation of sidewalks in some locations where there is a logical connection between activity centers or there is a need to place pedestrian walkways adjacent to City streets. Trails/linear parks help people of all ages incorporate exercise into their daily routines lby connecting them with places they want or need to go. The Mill Creek Greenway has some segments completed and will eventually provide a complete north -south connection throught Woodburn — linking multiple City parks. Typicall Amenities Passive Recreation Z Seating El Casual Use Spaces Z Internal Walking Trails Z Water Access El Community Gardens • Unique Landscape Features • Natural Spaces Active Recreation Z Creative Play Attractions El Playgrounds • Biking Trails • Outdoor Fitness / Exercise Facilities El Rectangular Fields 1:1 Diamond Fields 1:1 Basketball Courts 1:1 Tennis / Pickleball Courts El Volleyball Courts El Water Play Size 0 Unique to each site Service Area 0 N/A Existing Facilities • Hermanson Park Middle • Hermanson Park South • Mill Creek Greenway Future Facilities 0 Madame Dorion Trail Facilities Z Individual Picnic / Sitting Areas El Group Picnic Areas 1:1 Park Shelters El Skateparks / Bike Skills El Splash Pads / Spray Parks El Outdoor Event Spaces 1:1 Off -leash Areas Z Restrooms Z Parking 245 Special use areas are sites that are occupied 6v a specialized facility or that fulfill a specialized purpose. &:)me uses that fall intc::) this parktype include recreation or aquatic centers, plazas, historic sites, botanical gardens, cc::)mmunitvgardens,sing|epurposesitesusedfc::)raparticu|arfie|dspc::)rt, c::)r other sites that offer indoor recreation opportunities. Tv il� Amenities Passive Recreation Z Seating 6D Casual Use Spaces 6D Internal Walking Trails 1:1 Water Access 6D Community Gardens 6D Unique Landscape Features 6D Natural Spaces Active Recreation O Creative Play Attractions O Playgrounds O Biking Trails O Outdoor Fitness / Exercise Facilities O Rectangular Fields O Diamond Fields O Basketball Courts O Tennis /Pick|ebaUCourts O Volleyball Courts O Water Play Size 0 Unique to each site Service Area 0 N/A Existing Facilities • Bungalow Theatre • Frank Scheer Locomotive Park • Woodburn Aquatic Center • Woodburn Museum Future Facilities 0 Future Community Center Facilities 6D Individual Picnic / Sitting Areas O Group Picnic Areas O Park Shelters O Skateparks/Bike Skills O Splash Pads /Spray Parks O Outdoor Event Spaces O Off -leash Areas O Restruums O Parking U. / % i/ /pen Space Inventory ..o%i I lie oark and Cc)loen sloace II' ventCc)ry identifies the recreati anal assets within Wc)c)dlourn. I lie City lorc)vid s 135 acres of public parkland and recreation facilities distributed among 25 parks and natural areas. Figure 5. Woodburn Park Systern Inventory Community Parks Centennial Park Community 24.8 Legion Park Community 16.2 Settlemier Park Community 10.0 Neighborhood Parks Boones Crossing Neighborhood Undeveloped 3.0 Burlingham Park Neighborhood 5.4 Dove Landing Neighborhood Undeveloped 8.0 Hermanson Park North Neighborhood 1.7 Killian's Well Park Neighborhood Undeveloped 0.5 Nelson Park Neighborhood 3.2 North Front St Park Neighborhood 1.1 Senior Estates Park Neighborhood 4.0 Wyffels Park Neighborhood 2.3 Pocket/Mini Parks Alvah Cowan Park Pocket 0.2 Dahlia Plaza Pocket Park Pocket 0.05 Downtown Plaza Park Pocket 0.5 Hazel Smith Plaza Pocket 1.4 Heritage Park Pocket 0.3 Library Square Pocket 0.3 Special Use Facility Frank Scheer Locomotive Park Special Use 0.3 Woodburn Aquatic Center* Special Use Woodburn Museum / Bungalow Theatre** Special Use Trail/Linear Park Hermanson Park Middle Linear Park 1.2 Hermanson Park South Linear Park 3.0 Madame Dorion Trail Linear Park 13.2 Mill Creek Greenway Linear Park 10.6 Open Space Hermanson Pond Open Space 3.8 Senecal Creek Park Open Space 20.0 Total City -Owned Park Acres 135.0 Note: acreage included as part of Settlernier Bark "" Note: no outdoor recreation area provided The following maps shows the location of existing parks and open space within the City. I..li fC:)IIC:Ming s ctIC::)I'is lorc)vide and Ccwerview Cc)'f cAl er nearby recreatic)I al Cc)loloc)rtunities and site sloecific inventory information and recommendations for public parklands managed Icy City of Woodburn. 247 II �vOOa o U a' b, — O .. m u O W m N 1yH w T O o to _r O o a u 48 �� C nulu 3 f^ u.�w.ry � Dull � $n �N 4y r J � n t n.., 3 q � �ViGrVO°.a � Qa oN�ao aw�Ltass nill�,,, ry^b � � 'd' b nutnD. oay bM /eoa aoN M "� my t ', 3 e Wto z Ilk s Mop ' a �- z 3 pII m F a a a m w vas u v- v- N �z v"i33 ��03 Q va��' a Il��uni�oii o a w g �r omy000 �3'Ns a k � z s -E E E E E m m o -u s 0 NYIta''ry ? o s 248 Woodburn Aquatic Center The Aquatic Center currently isthe only permanent indoor recreation space in Woodburn. Its amenities include a25meter x25yard lap pool, awading pool, water slide, rope swing and warm water thenspypc)cL |nadditicn,there is a fitnessrc)c)m,spa and saunas. Tlie Center c)fferslifeguard certificaticn classes, swim lessons and runs an entry level swim team. Swim team participation includes coaching on proper swim strokes and options to compete in swim meets. Sett|emier Park adjoins the Aquatic Center and the future expansion ofaCommunity Center. The Woodburn Museum was founded in 1986 byWoodburn Citizens. Since then the City and Community partners have renovated the Museum and the Bungalow Theatre inaspace for history and community gathering reopening inJanuary of2O23. Settlernier 'Teen Center (Boys & Girls Cl�ub) The Boys & Girls Club ofWoodburn operates the Teen Center located atSet1|emier Park. Programs for youth and teens inexperiential learning are designed toempower young people's capacity for healthy and successful growth and development. The continuum of services target teenagers in the Woodburn Teen Center ' renovated in2O14.The center features free meals, computers and daily activities and is open Monday through Friday from 2'6pmduring the school year. VVoodburn'sprograms focus onopportunities for teenagers grades 6'12to encourage academic success, citizen and character development, and he|athy lifestyles. Woodburn School�District The Woodburn School District comprises one high school, one alternative school, two middle schools and four elementary schools. Spring athletics include baseball, golf, softball, tennis and track. Winter sports programming includes basketball, cheer and wrestling. Fall sports involve cheer cross country, football, soccer and volleyball. Outdoor sports are supported bythe high school football and track facility, cnebaseba||field, cnesc)ftba||fields and tmc) multi use spc)irtsfields. ::::�c)urtennis cc)uirtsand two) futsa|courts are also onthe high school campus. The O(5A golf Course isnear the high school campus providing support for the spring golf season. The Va|c)r IMidd|e Schc)c)| has a mu|ti -usespc)rt field suitable for football and soccer. The French Prairie IMidd|e Schc)c)| has a mu|ti -usespc)rt field that can suppc)rt threeyc)uthsc)ccerfields. Tlie tc)urpub|ic elementary schools in Woodburn have playgrounds, but like the spc)irtsfields, these c)utdc)c)rrecreation facilities are not open tothe general public during school hours. Woodburn Family YMCA The Woodburn Family YMCA, located in the Woodburn Aquatic Center, ispart ofthe Family YMCA ofMarion and Polk Counties. Youth sport prc)gramsInclude sc)cceir, vc||eyba|Lflag tc)c)tba||, basketball and t'ba||.Adult sports ofkickball and basketball may be available seasonally. Other youth sports programming for gymnastics, cheer|eading and cross country may beavailable within the YMCA outside ofWoodburn but within the group ofMarion & Polk County'sFamily YMCA facilities. The Woodburn YMCA co|aborateswith the City ofWoodburn Recrartionand Parks Department to provide a robust slate of programming for the VVoodurncommunity. 10 TheOregon GoKAssodat�onyOGAJGo|fCourse is one ofsix amateur go|fassociations across the country triotopeiratesofoi- pmfhpu6|icgolf course. The1g-ho|ecourse encourages the 6eve|opment ofthe next generation ofgo|fersand offers p|ayer 6eve|opmentpmgramsthroughout the year. The DGA offers |essons'junior go|fpmgrams and |a6ies c|inics and hosts a varietyofevents and tournaments. 10 The Senior Estates Go|fan6 Country C|u6 (aka VVoo66urn ::::.states & Go|f) is affiliated with the 55+ netinementcommunity This is a priva^e' 1g- ho|ecourse with ac|u6housewith anau6i^zrium' swimming pool. restaurant, 6U|ior6a mom.fitnesa center and crafts room. TheC|u6offers avarietyof socia|events and activitiestoits residents. 10 The VVoo66um Go|fC|u6' a nine-ho|e go|fcourse' is |ocate6outside city |imits'west ofSeneca|Creek and north ofHighway219. 10 Woodburn Oragstripisa'V4-mi|eNationa|Hot Rod Association6ragstripthat hosts annua|event onthe NHRA Lucas Di| Series. Race track is |ocate6 about mi|es west of Woodburn on Highway 219. 10 Jesse H. Sett|emierHouse Museum is|ocate6on Sett|emierAvenue. 249 MKIM, MDVWI� M Alvah Cowan Park is located on the corner of Setflernier Avenue and Garfield Street and was originally adopted by the Settlernier Knott Garden Society. The Society initiated a beautification project in summer 2013 that spruced up the flower beds and added new perennials and flowers. This spring, the diseased roses were replaced, boxwood hedges were planted, and invasive ivy was removed from the Parks trees during an Earth Day event. The Park was narned by a CouncO Res6lution in 1984, recognizing Mr. Cowan's accomphshments and years of service to the community, particularly in the area of recreation and parks. The parks original) narne was Triangle Park, which, along with Setflernier Park, was one of Woodburn's first two parks. Design Opportunities M Site has no ADA access6hty. A paved pathway system couH be added to create universal access and help define the garden beds and accentuate the parterre �ayout. Management Considerations 250 Budingharn Park is located at 3350 Linda Street in West Woodburn. The park has a playground, basketball court, and large play field. Design Opportunities • No formai access from ftHow Avenue. A side entry couVd be added with a paved pathway that connects to a perimeter paved kx)p path connec'ung to site's amenities. • Currenfly, there are no ADA accessuHe routes to park features. More recreatuon amenities couH be added to the park and a perimeter paved pathway couH hnk to aH park areas. • ( onsucler adding a permanent restroom with smaH picnic sheter to support k)nger visits (and soccer uses). Management Considerations • �Remnant concrete pad in eastern sec'uon of wooded area couH be removed and ad&tk)nai rec amenities added to the park (further from edge of property). • As non-native ornarnental trees die -off, replace with native Pacific Northwest canopy trees. 251 Centennial Park is Woodburn's largest park and includes 4 baseball fields, 2 full soccer fields, a playground, workout stations, a picnic shelter and splash pad. This park is also horne to Woodburn's largest dog park. Centennial Park has many amenities that make it great, but it is also a wonclerfull gathering place for community events. Each year, Woodburn's Fourth of Jully Celebration takes place at Centennial Park bringing in food vendors, live music, fireworks and fun to the whole community. Design Opportunities Picnic tables to be added to the ballfield pavilion should have wheelchair seating space to help balance adequate ALGA arneriities. Pave path around soccer field. Management Considerations INewly planted trees exist ori site; inspect for need of replacernerits (at least one appears to be failing) Bleachers should all have safety railing to rneet IIr7ternatiorial lBuildirig Code requirernerits. IRestroorns need sigri upgrades to improve visibility & rneet ADD requirernerits. 252 The Downtown Rlaza is located in the heart of downtown Woodburn and is the site of many spec:41 events each year. From Taste of Woodburn, to Trunk or Treat, you will always find community gathering here. Not only is it horse to sorne great events, but it is also a great spot to sit and rellax among many downtown businesses. You will find benches, picnic tables, and even a community checkers and chess taUle. Design Opportunities Management Considerations • Some trash cans overflowing; consider more frequent pick-up cycles. • Plaza has no park identification sign; consider installing one. 253 Heritage Park is a Ilovelly neighborhood park with a sm4H (allay structure and a singlle hoop basketbalHl court. Design Opportunities • Add a formai connectuon to the Lexungtc)n cukde-sac. • Add park identification sign age. • Add basktebaH court striping Management Considerations • Nay area has access barrier and needs a ramp or other ADA access treatment. • The pay equipment has no ADA accommoclatuons. IProvude ADA-comphant pay equipment when renova'uon or repacement is schecluVecl. • TactHe warning strip is needed at curb cut unto parking area. • A dedicated handicapped parking space(s) is needed. 254 Design Opportunities • South sactonnfpathway has enzdedgravel. Sactinnsofboardwalk have uneven cnnnedinnswith trai| surface that create tripping hazards &ADA barriers. Afu||y-paved tnai| wnu|d a||nvvADAaccess and eliminate tripping hazards atvvood cleckinQconnectinns. • Play equipment has limited physical play opportunities. When replaced, provicleawider range ofplay options. • Picnic tables are free-stan6nQ in grass areas without any ADA accessible _ route. Add paved pathway for ADAcomp|ianceto5O%nfsite furnishings. Management Considerations • TactHe warning strip isneeded atStark Street pedestrian crosswalk and grinding of curb cut Hp to meet ADA comp|iance. • Wood fiber play surfacing needs comp|eterep|aoementevidenced 6ylack of buoyancy and weed growth. 255 Design Opportunities • TraH at thin end of Greenway us surfaced wuth crushed rock (unpaved). IEdges of the gravel have eroded due to the last flooding event. Consider providing paved asphalt to create an ADA-comphantpathway at the pond to connect to rest of paved Greenway TraH. • Parking can then be reasonably configured to accommodate an ADA han&capped space. Management Considerations • PrcMcle permanent unformatkmal sugn age for Hgh water warn ngs and envuronment safety eclucatkm sagas. • The observatkm cleck requures a step up onto the boardwalk — creatung an arcHtectural barHer for ADA access. Ilf the gravel pathway was permanently paved that step could be ehmunatecl. 256 Legion Park is Woodburn's oldest park site. At nearly 16 acres, Legion Park has a full sized soccer field, stadium, picnic pavilion, numerous picnic tables, grass playfields, and densely wooded Douglas Fir tree grove. An arche6logicalHly the rned nature play area was installed in May 2013. Design Opportunities M Permanent sign age needed on restrooms within soccer fadhty. Management Considerations M Poison oak in naturai areas adjacent to pathways needs to be controHed. Add plant identification and cautionary signs along the path. M �PcnVc tubes across the grass are not on accessoHe r(,:)utes for unVversai access. Consucler how best to provucle access for 50% of those taHes. 257 At the corner of First and Garfield, Library Square is a one acre site situated on the grounds of the Woodburn Pubhc Library. The Park hosts the popullar "Music in the Park" program, featuring a fdHl schedule of outdoor concerts. Design Opportunities Management Considerations M Trash receptacles were overflowing. Heavy use over the weekend rnay warrant extra cans and more frequent pck-up cycVes. 258 A =I WS I I =11""'IM, � In 1957, Woodburn wouH receive a d1assic 1902 built stearn Ilocornotove through donation by the Southern Pacific Railroad, which is displayed as part of the community's history. Design Opportunities M Does not functk)n as a pubhc park space, due to Iack of access or other park amenities. Management Considerations 259 The City's vision for an interconnected trail systern through the WHI Creek Greenway corridor dates back to the 1960's, as properties were acquired and set aside for future clevelloprnent. The City furthered its plans with the cornp�letion of the WHI Creek Greenway Master FIan in 2006. The first phase of the trail system, completed in 2011, is approximately one m0e in length and runs from Cleveland Street at the North to Deer Run Street at the south. The majority of the trail surface is asphallt, but transitions to gravel in the natural area around Hermanson Pond, south of WOson Street. Design Opportunities M Contunue to implement the Wi Creek Greenway Trail IPlan. Management Considerations • Parldng area at traHhead needs fresh striping to identify designated spaces. • �lnstali solar trail hghtung. 260 Nellson Park is (located at 1200 ("ireenview Drive on the east side of Hwy 99E. The park indludes amenities such as a picnic she liter and playgrouncl, Opportunities Re-ahgn k)op path to prcMde shght meanders and more distance from (Pun Oak trees. IRS pace Voop path wood chip surfacing with asphaVt pavement. Add more native canopy/shacle trees. Low spot in picnic sheter shouH be aHevuatecl if perimeter pathway is graded (to hep clraun sheter pad) when k)op path is paved. Management Considerations �Pin Oaks growing adjacent to perimeter path wHi constanfly create eye- poldng hazard due to genetic branching pattern. Controi the hazard untH pathway can be rek)cated further away. Create muVch rings around tree trunks to keep mowers and string trimmers from damaging tree bark. 261 North Front Street Park is (located at 1080 N. Front St. The park has a playground and open play field. Design Opportunities • Create a paved pathway conne6on between 'I st Street and IFront Street, 6agonaHy thr(,:)ugh park. • A k)t of room exists for ad6tkmai recrea'uon amenities. Consuder a master pVan for park upgrades and paved pathway k:)op. Management Considerations • No ADA comphance within park. IMan for numerous upgrades. • Nay safety surfacing may need to be compVetey repV aced to ensure adequate depth. M 262 Senecall Creek Greenway is a 20 acre natu4l wooded riparian area that runs allow Senecall Creek near BuHngharn Park, Currenfly this area does not have any functionall improvements as the space stays in its natu4l state. Design Opportunities M Jmutecl access. Management Considerations M �Naturai area may need hazard tree management and eventuai reforestatk)n efforts if native trees are dying back from root rot. 263 Senior Estates Park is a great space filled with a paved walking path, benches, beautifull vegetation and an off-IIeash dog area. Design Opportunities • Park has roorn for more amenities, if desired by immediate n6ghborhood. • PrcMcle accessuHe routes to aH park amenities. • Add new picnic tubes and be with ADA access. Management Considerations • �Bench repacements needed at horseshoe pts. • �Pcnuc tube s and benches are paced in grass and are not ADA accessHe. 264 Setflernier Park is a 10 acre site that was donated to the City by the Setflernier Park Association in 1946. The Park has a p�laygrouncl, restroorns, and 2 covered picnic shellters to the north and south of the park. You will find paved walking paths that take you through the grove of mature fir trees. Settlemier Park is nestled behind the Woodburn Aquatic Center and near the Boys & Gids Club Teen Center. Design Opportunities • Site has limited ADD access. Ilri corijurictiori with future cornmurlity center project, park should get complete upgrade of arneriities to provide better Park layout and AAA access. • Ballfield is no longer used (arid otherwise would require corriplete renovation). Park space should be reconfigured when newith future cornrnuriity center is plariried/coristructed to maximize Park arneriities and its outdoor recreational value. Management Considerations • IPavernerit repairs needed iri parking lot (at Aquatic center) and along Pathways. Termis courts will need resurfacing. • Replace beriches at skate park. • Parkirig lot needs Fresh stripirig for spaces & travel aisles for handicapped space. IPathway From parking lot should have tactile warning strip and a bollard. • Aquatic Center lacks identification signage at street entry. • ILarge dead tree could have topmost brariches removed to elirniriate any potential hazard (while retaining much of the trurilk for wildlife value). 265 Design Opportunities • [ont�nuetopursue development nfyWiUCreek Greenwaytraii • Consicler value of restoHng this sec'don of the Creek to its hist(,)Hc ahgnment and character. The 'straiBhtness'ofthe steamchannel onthis flat land suggests that the stream was channe|izedtoaccommodate past land uses. yWosteco|nQica| value could onmefrnm necneat�nQthe Hstoricstream channel. Management Considerations • Some neiQh6oHnQproperdesare encroacHnQnnpu6|icparkland. • Southernmost neiQh6oruses veHc|aaccess for Hsbackyard gate. • Consider identifying the parkland with anidentification sign. apter 5 PARKS & 0 P E N Szz,j- .......... ASS NG CGN&MUVI I Y III ............. GI .......... Z III III; III III IIISYS IIII; ............ III III; .............III III;............III I S The park system planning process assesses recreationall needs and priorities for park facilities, active use areas, and trails in Woodburn, The park assessment includes a discussion of specific local needs with consideration given to the City's broader park system. Pubhc input and information on park inventory conditions also were heavily relied upon in the planning process. =11 A review of seve4l recognized park and recreation resources provide a background on national, state, and regionall trends, market demands, and agency comparisons. These outdoor recreation trends, combined with community interests in parks, trails, and open space and an assessment of current conditions and levels of service, help identify and shape recommendations for park system improvements. Examining current recreation trends can help inform potent4l park and recreation improvements and opportunities that may enhance the community and create a more vibrant parks system as it moves into the future. The following nationall and state data highlights some of the current park usage trends and may frame future considerations for Woodburn's park system. Aciclitionall trend data and summaries are provided in Appendix G. * 90% of U.S. aduVts beheve that parks and recreatuon is an umportant service prcMded by their k)cai governments. (') * 84% of U.S. aduVts seek Hgh-quahty parks and recreatuon when choosung a pk�ce to hve. (') * �Runnung, joggung, and traH running are the most popukr outdoor activities across the nation, based on levels of participation, followed by hiking, fishing, biking, and campung. (2) 267 268 10 A significantly higher oeircent.age of seniors (ages 55-1-) are [Dartuci[Datung un outdoor recreatuon. In 2022, the senuor [Dartuci[Datuon rate but a record Hgh of 35% and Os Hsng. 12) 10 F)artuci[Datuon nearby dol,]Hed for [DuCldebaH un 2022, uncreasung Icy 85.7% year -over -year. In 2022 for the first ffirrie In over seven years, every racquet sl,,.)oit uncreased uts total [Dartf6[Datuon number corn[Dared to the [Drevoous year. iI) 10 McIffe vuewung and [Daddue S[Dort [DartuCi[Datuon uncreased statewude by 28% sunce 2017. il) 10 NatuonaHy, outdoor recreatuon econon-flc actMty uncreased '19% from 2020 to 2022, whHe the overall U.S. economy only saw a 5.9% uncrease. i'') According to the Sports arid Fitness Industry Association, participation nearly doubled for pickleball in 2022, increasing Iby 85% year -over - year. In 2022 fc)r the first time in c)ver Seven years, every racquet sport increased its total participation riumber compared to the previous year. In terms of team sports, the overall participation rate approached, Ibut did riot exceed, the 2019 rate. E.:)asketloall, c..)utdc..x.)r sc)ccer, and flag fc..X.Aloall all posted three-year increases of over 4.5%, with basketball leading the way with a 13% increase since 2019. 1 ifestyle activities gerierally remained very popular. Golf arid terinis have grown more than 20% since 2019, arid yoga grew more than 10% in that same time period. Trail running arid day hiking joarticiloatic.)n grew fc)r the fifth Straight year. The 2019-2023 Statewide Comprehensive Outdoor Recreation Plan (SCORP), entitled Outdoor Recreation in Oregon: Responding to Demographic arid Societal Charige, constitutes Oregon's Ibasic five year jolan for outdc..X)r recreatk.m. I lie jolan addresses five irnjoc)rtant dernc)grajohic and sc.Kietal chariges facing outdoor recreation providers in the coming years including: 'I. An agung [DO[DU�atuon; 2. An uncreasung�y cluverse [DO[DU�atuon; 3. 1 ack of youth engagement un outdoor recreatuon; 4. An underserved how-uncorne [DO[Du�atuon; and S. Fhe health oenefits of johysical activity. As part of its SCORP process, the State of Oregon coriducted the 2017 Oregon Resident Outdoor Recreation Survey. The survey showed that 95% of Oregonians participated in at least orie outdoor recreation activity in Oregon during the past year. Close -to -home activities dominated the total user occasions for Oregon residents, since these activities can occur on a daily Ibasis with limited travel time. Aside from walking, bicycling arid jogging on local streets, top outdoor activities include walking on local trails, dog walking, walking or day hiking on riorr-local trails. Top activities Ibased on total user occasions for Oregonians in 2017 are provided in the Figure 6. User occasions are the riumber of times people erigage in an activity. Figure 6. User Occasions and Porficiparhon in Oul-door Recreation in Oregon (OR SCORP) Walking on local streets/sidewalks 313 Walking on local trails/paths 113 Relaxing, hanging out, escaping heat/noise, etc 93 Dog walking/going to dog parks/off-leash areas 78 Taking your children or grandchildren to a play! 57 Sightseeing/driving or motorcycling for pleasur 55 Bicycling on roads,strees/sidewalks 51 Walking/day hiking on non -local trails/paths 44 Jogging/running on streets/sidewalks 37 Bicycling on paved trails 26 The survey inquired about the top rieeds in "your community" to help gauge priorities for the future. These responses can help direct park arid forest agericies to determine in which outdoor recreation facilities arid amenities to invest. Figure 7. T(.-)p Outdoor Recreation Needs Ideal ified for Local Park Sysferns (OR SCORP) Cleaner restrooms Soft surface walking trails More restrooms Playgrounds with natural materials (natural play areas) Nature and wildlife viewing areas Public access to waterways Sources: (1) 2022 American Engagement with Parks Report, National Recreation and Park Association (2) 2023 Outdoor Participation Trends Report, Outdoor Foundation (3) 2023 Sports, Fitness, and Leisure Activities Topline Participation Report, Sports and Fitness Industry Association (4) 2022 Assessment of Resident Demand, Washington State 2023 Recreation & Conservation Plan (draft) (5) 2022 Outdoor Recreation Satellite Account data, U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis 269 M� WIN, IM Beyond the Ibroader perspectives of national and state recreation trends, local needs were explored through a community survey, online commerits, stakeholder interviews, tabling everits, and public operi house meetings to gather feedback ori priorities, interests, and future needs for Woodburn's park system. I lie cc::)i-ni-runny survey cc::)nHi-i-ned that %::)c::)d1oui-n residerits strongly value their local parks, recreation options and operi space opportunities. Virtually all survey resporiderits (96%) feel that local parks and recreation opportunities are importarit or essential to the quality of life in Woodburn. Residents of all ages value parks and recreation similarly — there were nc::) significant differences between age girc::)ujos. Respondents visit local parks and recreation facilities for a variety of reasons, Ibut the most popular reason is to walk or ruri (69%). More thari orie in three resporiderits visit to use a playground (44%), walk a dc::)g (42%), fc::)i- fitiness c::)i- exercise (40%), tc::) relax (39%), or to atterid community everits or concerts (36%). Figure B. Main Reasons far Visiting Local Parks Wa 11 IId in o it irua in in i ing Pllaygirouinds ID og wa 11 Id ing o it dog 1pa irk IFitiness / IFxeircise IRellaxatioin Community events / coinceirts Fairnilly gatherings / picinicliding T Work with what we have already and increase accessibility! It's important that S" W-Alile—,K*79�&-Vll k#A#- AAI�Wft programs, etc. And I think making it more accessible would increase interest! Add for events and programs, and a lot more people will be interested in engaging in them without worrying about if they can even participate.." SUI'VOY 'OS4Dondont 44% 42% 40% 39% 36% 0 Youth spoirt 1pirogirairns 2:1% Spoirt fiellds :1.9% Willd1life viewing :1.9% Outdoor spoirt couirts :1.5% Recreation 1pirogirairns, c1lasses it cairnIps :1.2% Skate pairk 8% N/A 11 didin't use ainy 6% Otheir 5% 270 Survey resporndernts showed a high use of parks regardless of arse and location of residernce. When asked which parks they visit most, over 60% of resporndernts cited Centennial Park as most frequented. Woodburn residents, where asked about the overall condition of the parks they have visited, shared a positive view With 79% of responses Ibeirig fair to excellent, leaving 14% stating poor condition and 7% With rno opinion. Although there is a positive perception of the mairnternarnce condition of parks, the community desires more amenities and perk upgrades, With curly 57% c:)f resloc:mdents being satisfied tc::) very satisfied With Wc)c)dlourn's loarks„ recreatic:)n facilities and opera spaces. Figure 9. Senliment Toward Condition of City Parks C Facililies ME 20 % 1.0% 0% IExcellent Good If ahr Poor IMot S uire / NO opiiirniio n Figure 10. Relative Prioril ies for Various Amenities Walkingtrails Upgraded playgrounds Indoor fitness facilities Amphitheater Outdoor splash pad Picnic areas & shelters Additional playgrounds Community gardens Off -leash dog areas (dog parks) Basketball courts Outdoorfitness equipment Sport fields (soccer, football, lacrosse) Disc golf course Sport fields (baseball/softball) Tennis courts Pickleball courts Sand volleyball Bike skills course / Pump track Futsal courts Respondents Were asked to rarnk a list of poterntial park system investments. Survey resporndernts identified impi-cwhig and upgrading existing lDarks as their tops priority, followed closely Icy expanding trail opportunities. Adding rneW recreatiornal options in existing parks and acquiring additional land for future parks Were moderate priorities. The survey asked residernts about their support for a variety of poterntial additions to the perk system. Virtually all residernts are either very or somewhat supportive of additional walking trails (92%), picnic areas and shelters (86%), upgraded or renovated playgrounds (83%), outdoor splash pads (82%), am amphitheater or outdoor performarnce area (81%), and II'ldc::)c::)ir fitness and exercise facilities (81%). I.....arge majorities are also supportive of the City adding more playgrounds (77%), community garderns (78%)„ basketball cc::)urts (71%)„ and c::)utdc::)c::)r fitness equipment (71 %). More tharn half of residernts support the City adding more off -leash dory areas, Sl0c:)r'ts 'Fields„ Sl0c:)rts Cc:)UI ts, a disc c:)IF Cc:)urSe, and a kbike skills course or pump track. 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 10 Very Supportive IIIIIII Somewhat Supportive IIII Not Supportive Not Sure 271 Respondents were asked todescribe one thing that they would like to see the City of Woodburn do to improve parks, trails, aquatics, and/or recreation programs. With cwer38Uspecific cc)mmentsand ideas, a few themes emerged: 10 Park Maintenance and Safety: ResFmn6ems expressed adesire for impozve6 main^enancean6 safety in ex�sdng parks. IMany spoke of concerns about the upkeepofparks'inc|u6ingnegu|ar c|eaning'|awmcare, nemova|of|iuer,and nepairs ^obroken equipmentOthers ment�one6concerns about safety in parks' inc|u6ing issues |ike drugs, home|essin6M6ua|s'and the need for po|icepatro|s. There were requests for |ightingand enforcement of [Dark m|es^oensure a safeenv�mnment 10 Park Upgrades: VVhi|ecommunitymembers emphasize6the impouonceofmaintoiningexisting [Darks and faci|it�es'they a|socaUe6for upgra6es such asimpmve6p|aygmun6s'nestmomrenovations, and weU-maintoine6 wa|<ing trai|s. In their responses' communitymembers a|soasked for a66itiona| amenities|ikecovered 6asket6aUcourts' pick|e6aU courts, 6isc go|fcourses, ska^eparks' and picnic areas. There are a|so suggestions to renovate existing faci|itiesand p|aygmun6s^zpmvi6esafe and en�oya6|eexperiencesfor aUage gmups. 10 Dog Parks & Off -Leash Areas: Enhancing dog parks is a prioritXwith requests for impmvementssuch as she|ters'seating areas, and increased main^enance and c|ean|iness. The communitya|so desires the creation of more dog parks and ofHeash areas to cater to the needs ofpetowners. 10 Communication 8(Information: Some survey nespon6entsasked for impmve6communication channe|s'such asacityca6|echanne|ornewo|etter, to inform residents about communityevents, park oRerings'and importanthappeningsintown. Others requested a more usepffien6|ywe6si^e that provides easy access to information' inc|u6ing programs' activities' and registrations, reducing the need to search through mu|tip|e sources. Stakeholder Discussion Sessions Aseries ofstakeholder groups for formed todiscuss issues, opportunities and needs for city park and recreation amenities. Participants were queried about improvements that are needed in the park system and thoughts for enhanced infrastructure and services for the future. Suggestions were varied and included programming elements, recreational amenities and infrastructure improvements. Common themes were around park maintenance and expanding recreation options. The following highlights the suggestions that were offered: 10 Conduct more genera|[Dark maimenance'c|eanand renovate restroom'and add safety enhancements such as night |ights in parks 10 Expan6the p|aygmun6sand inc|u6emore games for kids; Pmv�6esp|ash [Dads for kids 10 Add more benches and resting areas with shade; Add more to6|esand ghUsfor barbecue 10 Enhance apoi-t fields and exlo|om* optionato host tournaments 10 Include o 6ikeatotion or location tofix 6icyces 10 Buy pmperty^oexpan6or6ui|6more [Darks 10 Invest in oR|eash areas and expand dog parks around the city 10 Bui|6 more skateboard parks Public �Meetings The City ofWoodburn hosted two public meetings togather community feedback and identify gaps or deficiencies inthe parksystem. [)uring the first c)pen house, meeting displays included a'dot'exercise toexplore top investment priorities using a list of eight potential project types. The highest rated amenities included additional walking trails, picnic shelters, outdoor splash pad, and shade structures for playgrounds. Through the second open house (conducted as an online open house), participants indicated interest in maintaining and enhancing existing parks, such as adding orupgrading playground equipment, picnic shelters, splash pads and nestroomfaci|ities. The top priority listed 6vparticipants istobuild a new community center and renovate Set |emier Park. Other priorities included building additional picnic shelters for group gatherings, building additional paved and/or accessible walking trails in parks, and building sport courts atNelson and North Front Street Parks. When asked tc) rank a set c)fspecific prc1ect types,the msyority identifiedp|aygrc)und upgrades and replacement, followed closely by improved, permanent nestroomsand picnic shelters and tables for gathering. Participants also commented that they would like to see improved maintenance and upgrades to existing parks and facilities. Participants specifically ncAed Centennial Park(e.g.,fix brcken picnictab|es, clean splash pad, and power wash picnic shelter), Hermanson Pond and trail, Legion Park (e.g., upgrade playground), Burlingham Park, Nelson Park, Heritage Park, park atSenior Estate andVVvffe|s Park,aswell as the aquatic center, baseball fields, dog park and park ortrail bathrooms. 272 LI(MMIN, =; M111M, 11MAW- - IMUMP �-WWWPM -- _ - - J- recreation facilities and park playgrounds are an N mportant element in outdoor recreation. Reported in Landscape Architect magazine, the top five playground industry trends for 2021 were compiled from data and feedback from parks professionals, landscape architects, and educators. 1. Inclusive Playgrounds, increasingly popular over the last few years, have been evolving beyond meeting basic ADA guidelines. Designers are seeking to expand accessible playground equipment, consider multi -generational play, and leverage inclusive play to help overcome societal �,,;�rriers. 2. Rope -based Playgrounds, climbers and playground nets provide a technique for working around natural environments and unusual topography. Their flexibility in placement offers more options for connecting with the landscape rather than working around difficult topography. 3. Outdoor Fitness has increased importance during the COVID-19 pandemic as many gyms and indoor fitness centers closed and forced more people to seek outdoor options. Outdoor fitness spaces are being increasingly integrated into park and trail designs to encourage health and physical fitness for all ages. 4. Outdoor Learning has been implemented during the pandemic to replace or supplement indoor classrooms. Outdoor classrooms can encourage activity in children to counteract the reduction in recess time due to hybrid class schedules and remote learning. Seating, tables, shelters, hand sanitizer stations and other outdoor products are helping create outdoor classrooms. 5. Human -powered Play engages users to provide physical energy to "power -up" the activity, such as turning a handle, pressing foot pedals, rotating wheels. These products often relate to sensory experiences like lights and music, story -telling, or social games. Spurred on by the social distancing of the pandemic, these five trends in playground design and development point to more human -to - human interactions that reinforce the value of s*ci?.l-&#Axeci*xs, eveA--�A ;-. p�,ysic;-.11y!0.ist;-.Ace,0. environment. 273 The overall condition ofpark infrastructure and amenities isone measure ofpark adequacy and assurance ofpublic safety. Proper stewardship of park infrastructure requires developing a long-term maintenance and capital plan toensure the safety of park users that aligns with community needs and allocates limited funding resources properly. General park infrastructure include walkways, parking lots, nestrooms, drainage and irrigation, lighting systems and vegetation. Amenities include picnic shelters, play equipment, site furnishings, sports courts, spc::)rtsfields and c::)therrecreatkona| assets. [)eferred maintenance over along time period can result in unusable amenities when perceived as unsafe or undesirable bypark patrons. Compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) guidelines also provide ameasure ofacceptable condition. The current conditions ofthe Woodburn park system were assessed to identify existing site maintenance issues and opportunities for future capital improvements. The assessment included walkways, parking lots, park furniture, drainage and irrigation, vegetation, and other amenities. The following conditions assessment matrix (Figure 1 1) summarizes the results of these assessments. These inform developing project prioritization strategy for park improvements, identifying funding strategies, and updating the ten'yearPark Improvement Plan. we already have, before at Centennial Park need a The matrix onthe following page indicates the types of amenities within each park facility, and park infrastructure and amenities are rated based onthe following scale: 1 —Good Con6hjon: Genera|k/ amenhjes in 'good' con6hjonoffer fuUfuncdona|tyand 6onot need repairs. Good faci|it�eshave p|aya6|espous surfaces and equipmentworking fixtures, and fully intact safety features (rai|ings' fences' etc.). Good faci|it�esmay have minorcosmedcdefects and encourage area residents ^ouse the park. 2— Fair: In genera|' amenities in 'fair' con6ition are main�yfuncdona|'but need minorormoderate repairs. Fairfad|it�es have p|aysurfaces equipmentfixtures, and safety features that are operationo|and allow p|oB6uthave deficiencies or peho6s where they are unusa6|e. Fairfaci|it�es remain essentia| amenitiesfor the community6ut may s|ighdy6iscouragethe use ofthe [Dark 6y residents given the current condition. 3— Poor: In genera|' amenit�es in '[Door' con6it�on are |arge|yorcomp|ete|yunusa6|e. They need significant m*poirato 6efunctionoi Some examples include athletic fields that are toouneven for 6oU games' irrepara6|ybroken features, 6ui|6ingsthat need structural retrofitting, etc. Floor facilities 6iscourageresidents from using the [Dark and may pnesentsafety issues if|eftopenoroperationai Good conditions should bethe goal for the management and stewardship ofpark facilities. Where infrastructure oramenities are rated as 'fair' strategies should be developed for repair or restoration. Park features, structures, amenities, orlandscapes rated as'poor'should receive immediate attention and beprioritized for near - term maintenance,capita|nepairs,oranewcapita| project. Facilities inpoor condition should also be evaluated and taken out ofoperation ifthey are deemed unsafe. 274 0 Compliance* - - 111, - - - - - - - 1111�1 I . Natural Areas . . . . . . IIIIIII111, Landscaped Beds 111 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Park Trees Natural Turfgrass Kiosks . . .�1J1, . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Concession Stand Picnic Shelters Restrooms Parking Areas r4 r4 N N r, Signage rl r4 r4 r4 Lighting (Y/N) Site Furnishings r4 r4 r4 r4 r4 r4 Other Rec Element . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Exercise Stations . . . 111) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Skate Park . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 111 - - Splash Pad / Spray Park . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Pathways / Trails r4 r4 11111111 Baseball/ Softball Fields I r4 Soccer Fields 111) . . . . . . . . . Sports Courts r4 Playgrounds r4 r, r, r, r, r, -1 'q %cq r4 'R 24 4 0 Ln q -Q LQ rq M -:t 0 0 -:t ti -Q N rq M t0 0 rq LQ -1 N 0 -:t ti M q q q N 0 -:t 0 -:t rq 0 CL 0 -0Y a- 06 -T) > 0 0 0) . > 0 E 0 E E 0 Z '0 M U m 3 o o -0 0 0 0 0 In 0 U Ln E u > co 0 0 W 0 co U 0 W W = = .2 W W .2 = - 0 0 W - 2 z Z U 0 E In In In In 275 In good condition: no drainage issues; 0-10%mate rial deterioration safety surfacing with a border at the 1 site. In fair condition: drainage issues; 10-25% material deterioration; some small compliance issues that 2 could be spot fixed. In poorcondition: drainage issues; 25%orgreater material 3 deterioration; needs repair or replacement (but workable). 1 In good condition: no cracks in surfacing; fencing is functional, free of protrusions, and free of holes/passages; painting and striping are appropriately located, whole, and uniform in color. 2 In fair condition: hairline cracks to %", surfacing required; fencing has minor protrusions, or holes/passages that do not affect game play; painting and striping have flaking or color fading. In poor condition: horizontal cracks more than Yz" wide, surfacing required; fencing has large 3 protrusions,holes/passages ordefects; paintingand stripingare patchy and color hasfaded dramatically. 1 In good condition: a signage system forthe site, appropriate signs, no damaged signs. In fair condition; multiple signage system within one site, a few damaged signs (0-10%), need 2 maintenance. In poor condition; multiple signage systems within one site, signs that are not legible from a reasonable 3 distance, some damaged signs (10-25%), old logos, deteriorated materials, no signage. :M'-1 I7 1 In good condition: no vandalism; no signs of weathering. 2 In fair condition: minor signs of weathering orwear. In poor condition: metal leach ing/concrete efflorescence/paint peeling/wood chipped or carved into or 3 warping: vandalized. In good condition: surface generally smooth and even; proper width and material fortype of pathway; 1 proper clearances; minimal drainage issues. 2 In fair condition: uneven surfaces in places; some drainage issues; some cracking: narrow widths in some places. 3 In poor condition: uneven surfaces; inadequate width; significant cracking or heaving; clearance issues. FM 1 In good condition: lush and full, fewweeds, no drainage problems. 2 In fair condition: some bare spots, some drainage problems. 3 In poor condition: irrigation problems, bare spots, weeds, soil compacted. In good condition; not damaged; free of peeling or chipped paint; consistent throughout park. Trash 1 receptacles, drinking fountain, picnic tables, benches on paved surface. In fair condition; 0-20%furnishings are damaged and require replacing parts; some peeling or chipped 2 paint; furnishings are not consistent, but are operational. In poor condition; 20%or more are damaged and require replacing parts; significant peeling or chipped 3 paint; multiple styles within park site require different maintenance. In good condition: paving and drainage do not need repair; pavement markings clear; pathway 1 connection provided to facility; proper layout. 2 In fair condition: paving needs patching or has some drainage problems; has wheel stops and curbs. 3 In poor condition: surfaces (gravel, asphalt, or concrete) needs repair; uneven grading; limited signage; no delineation forvehicles. Park Structures (Restroos, Picnic Shelters, Etc.); Natural Areas: In good condition: roof has no leaks; floor shows little sign of wear; finishes are fresh with no graffiti or 1 vandalism; all elements are in working order. In fair condition: roof shows signs of wear but is structurally sound; floor shows some wear; finishes 2 show some wear with some marks or blemishes. In poor condition: roof leaks or otherwise needs repair; floor show significant wear and is difficult to 3 maintain; finishes are dull or discolored, have graffiti, or are not easily maintained; some elements not lworking or in need of repair (e.g., non-functioning sink). In good condition: trees overall have good form and spacing: no topping; free of disease or pest 1 infestation; no vandalism; no hazard trees. In fair condition; some crowding may exist but overall health is good; less than 5%of trees show signs of 2 topping, disease or pest infestation; vandalism has not impacted tree health (graffiti, not girdling). 3 In poor condition; Form or spacing issues may exist; evidence of disease or pests; vandalism affecting tree health; some hazard trees ortrees in danger of becoming hazard trees. 1 Appears to comply with ADA standards. 2 Some items appearto not comply, but could be fixed by replacingwith relative ease. 3 A number of park assets appear notto comply, including large-scale items like regrading. 1 In good condition: thick grass with few bare spots; few depressions; no noticeable drainage issues, proper slope and layout; fencing if present is functional, free of protrusions, and free of holes. In fair condition: grass with bare turf areas in high -use locations, some drainage issues in overuse areas, slope is within one percent of properfield slope, infields have grading problems (bump) at transition to 2 grass and have no additive, may not have proper layout and/or orientation, fencing if present has minor protrusions, or holes/passages that do not affect game play. In poor condition: bare areas throughout the year, uneven playing surface that holds water in certain 3 places, drainage issues, slopes not uniform and/or more than one percent from proper field slope, improper layout and/or orientation; fencing has large protrusions, holes/passages or defects. 1 In good condition: barely noticeable invasives, high species diversity, healthy plants. 2 In fair conditions: Noticeable invasives, fewer species but still healthy. 3 In poor condition: Invasives have taken over, low diversity, unhealthy plants. In good condition: paving, stage and stair materials have little to no cracking or peeling; vegetation that 1 is present is healthy; seating and other furnishings show modest signs of wear; views to stage from all seating vantage points. In fair condition: paving stage and stair materials have some cracking or peeling: vegetation that is 2 present is healthy, but some soil compaction might be present; seating and other furnishings show signs of wear, but are still usable; stage orientation not be ideal for all viewers. In poor condition: paving, stage and stair materials have significant cracking or peeling; vegetation is 3 unhealthy (pests, disease, topped trees), compacted soil; seating and other furnishings need repair or replacement; redesign of space is needed for proper viewing and access. 1 In good condition: few weeds; no bare or worn areas; plants appear healthy with no signs of pest or disease infestation. 2 In fair condition: some weeds present; some bare orworn spots; plants are still generally healthy. 3 In poor condition: many weeds present; large bare or worn areas; plants show signs of pests or disease; compacted soils. 276 MERMMMMW"U� Beyond the individual park facilities, the following summaries offer highlights from park conditions observations as well as some suggestions for improvement and upgrade considerations, More detailed notes are provided within each park summary noted in the previous chapter. Park Infrastructure Site [�'Urnishin_qs Benches, picnic tables, drinking fountains, Ibike racks, and trash & recycling receptacles are common site furnishings provided in public parks. In Woodburn's park system, there is an assortment of different styles, ages and types of park benches, picnic tables and Ibike racks. In conjunction with a unified signage system, the City cc)uld devek:)jo a set of standards for its site furnishings such as benches, picnic tables and Ibike racks. Coordinated colors and styles can Ibe linked to AAA -compliant designs and alk:)w fc)r sirrijolified rejolacernent orc)cesses as different amenities age or need repair. For future park improvements and prior to implementing new master plans for undeveloped parks, it would Ibe beneficial tc) use the same standard design, style and color for benches, picnic tables, etc. F'aVeMerlt & SUrfacing Sections of Iboardwalk along the Hermanson Park greenway trail have uneven connections with the crushed rock trail surface that create tripping hazards and accessibility Ibarriers. A fully -paved trail would allow AD access and eliminate tripping hazards at wood decking transitions. In parks where site furnishings are installed on concrete and the pathways are asphalt pavement, aging and settling can create a gap or lip resulting in non-compliance with ADA access. Pavement/Asphalt management should Ibe identifying pavement cracks as they occur and marking them with paint to alert path users to the tripping hazard, while awaiting repairs or resurfacing Tennis and other sport courts should Ibe inspected semi-annually to predict the need for resurfacing. The cost for resurfacing warrants inclusion in the capital improvement program. Cracks at Settlemier Park tennis may Ibe affecting quality of play. The City should consider resurfacing these courts. Some parking areas were in need of fresh striping, as well as sports court needing re -applied paint lines. Myfinding & 13y'anding Sign types and signage consistency varies within the park system. Trail signs are typically found at the beginning or ends of existing trail segments. The "Greenway Trail" signs are wood with inset lettering in green. While perfectly adequate for designating the trail, the design is difficult tc) see firc)rn a distance in a vehicle and misses the opportunity to clearly identify this great park system feature and also giving credit to the City for providing the amenity. Hermanson Park has a greenway trail sign identifying the joaved joathway, lout it Iacks a joark identi(icatic)n sign. North Front Street Park also lacks a park identi(icatic)n sign. I lie Park identi(icatic)n signs used thirc)ughcwt the system a1sc) are difficult tc) read firc)rn a distance. I )ark lettering on dark wood is not clearly distinguished as approached in a vehicle or from afar on foot. The new Smith Creek greenway and park space is identified as joart c)f the IMill Creek Greenway 1i-ail. Adopting this signage design for all the greenway wayfinding wc)uld jorcwide cc)nsistency thirc)ughcwt the trail system. The new style could Ibe gradually integrated Iby using the new style for smaller side entry joark identificatic)n signs (generally lacking in most parks with secondary access points). Side entry signs could remain at a similar size to those used on Smith Creek's trail and park development sites. I'llay 11l Play equipment in City parks has been installed over different years, and some equipment parts are showing signs of wear. The need for replacements should Ibe Ibased on existing conditions, as well as predicted Iby charting past installation dates and planning for complete replacements when the assets have reached their expected lifespan. Older structures (greater than 20 years) should Ibe scheduled for replacement in the near future to avoid potential injury and manage play safety risk. Some of Woodburn's parks have old play equipment that needs to Ibe inspected to ensure safe continued use or planned future replacement. Access to playground areas was not always Ibarrier- free. Several play areas used plastic edging (to contain wood chips) that created accessibility barriers from park pathway pavement to the lower safety surfacing of the playground. The drop-off edges varied, exceeding the maximum 1/2-inch tolerance. 277 1"lay Safety SUrfacing In sc::)rne jolay areas, the wc::)c::)d Fiber jolay surfacing needs complete replacement, as evidenced Iby lack of Ibuoyancy and weed growth. Regular playground inspections should include checking the depth and cc::)nditk:)n c::)f engineered wc::)c::)d Fiber ((::)r its resiliency to provide safe fall support. Most playgrounds using wc::)c::)d Fiber require additk:)nal alololicatk:ms at least every two years. The City should consider transitioning to longer lasting safety surfacing, such as tiled or poured-in-p lace rubber. Flark StrUCtUres While this planning process does not include any architectural or engineering assessments of Ibuilt structures, a general recommendation includes regular inspections for structural integrity and operational function. I ights, outlets, roof coverings, surfacing and other elements can Ibe visually inspected. Tracking the age of typical structures, such as restrooms and picnic shelters, can help predict the likelihood and timing for repair, renovation or replacement for the capital investment program. AID A Compliance Universal Access As with many older parks, some architectural Ibarriers were present in the park system. Updating and providing Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) accessibility and compliance with federal guidelines should Ibe part of a regular capital repair schedule to ensure the reasonable access on older pavements, parking, playgrounds, picnic amenities, restrooms and recreational elements. AAA compliance issues were observed regarding park access at parking areas, missing tactile warning strips, and Ibarriers to access into playground areas, as well as many benches and picnic tables lacking accessible routes. In several parks, picnic tables are free-standing in grass areas without any accessible route. Trash receptacles also are placed out of reach of paved pathways and may limit access for persons with mobility limitations. In older parks, the picnic shelters and restrooms may lack accessible routes. Picnic tables within the shelters may not provide for wheelchair seating of afford the space for a wheelchair to maneuver between tables. The dog park at Centennial Park could have the pavement extended beyond entry gates to provide improved accessibility. Standards for park furnishing such as picnic tables, drinking fountains, Ibike racks, trash receptacles and other common amenities used throughout the park system can Ibe instrumental in assuring consistent AAA compliance and streamlined maintenance and repairs. The City will want to develop an AD Compliance Checklist to identify and prioritize these deficiencies and devek:)Io a -netIhc::)dc::)Ik:)gy (c::)r bringing all their parks into compliance. Landscape/Environment Flark Trees Dead or missing trees exist within some City parks and should Ibe scheduled for replacement. Some tree trunks in natural areas could Ibe retained when the trees die to provide nesting sites for Ibirds and small mammals. Parking lot shade trees in Centennial Park were recently planted, and some have died and need replacement. The City should continue to monitor the success of tree establishment to ensure future tree health and good canopy cover. Park Site Planning, Development & Improvements Older parks where previous park elements have been removed, are outdated, or need replacement may provide an opportunity to conduct a site planning process to involve the public to help determine the future park amenities to Ibe provided. The proposed Settlemier Park improvements presented in the Community Center plan would provide great new additions to the facility and park. North Front Street, Nelson and Burlingham Parks have room for additional park amenities, and including neighborhoods voices into the design orc::)cess wc::)uld be beneficial tc::) identify 1(::)cal preferences for outdoor recreation amenities. Site olans that incc::)r1oc::)rate significant loublic invc::)Ivernent weigh favorably with granting agencies when seeking funding for improvement projects. Safety & Crime Prevention 'Through EnvironmentaI IDesign (CPTEID) Much of the park layouts and landscapes seemed to meet the Ibasic Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design (CPTED) principles of good visibility and overall positive perceptions of public safety. Park safety conditions were generally good throughout the park system with a few notable exceptions. At Centennial Park, the bleachers did not all have safety railings. The International Building Code (IBC) requires safety rails on any bleacher 278 seating with two or more tiers. These bleachers shc)uId be retrc)fitted with E.:'C cc)rnjoliant designs. Playground fall safety surfaces were in a range of conditions. The wood chips surfacing at several parks has deteriorated enough to support grass and other vegetative growth. To meet required safety specificatic)ns, engineered wc)c)d Fiber needs tc) be a minimum of 15 inches in depth. This depth rarely can support plant growth, since it dries very quickly. When weeds are growing beneath play equipment, it is a good indication that the safety material is deteriorating. Hermanson Park and North Front Street Park also appeared to need full replacement of the play safety fall surfacing material. Understanding the known gaps in the park system and evaluating the City's existing levels of service for parks will provide a foundation for strategic planning to ensure that tomorrow's residents have equitable access to a Ibalancecd distribution of parks, trails, and recreation amenities to stay healthy and active. To (better understand the distribution of existing recreation amenities and where acquisition efforts should Ibe considered, a gap analysis of the park system was conducted to examine and assess the community's current access to various recreation opportunities across the City. The gap analysis used travelsheds for each park classificatic)n and calculated travel distances alcmg the road network starting from known and accessible access points at each park: 10 F:=or [Docket/rrflnu [Darks, travekheds were deHved usung a 'V4-mHe servuce area wuth travel cl'ostances ca�cu�ated a�ong the road network startung from known and accessbke access [D6nts at each [Dark. 10 F:'or n6ghborhood [Darks, travekheds were deHved usung a 'V4-mHe [DHrnary and 'Y2-mHe secondary servuce area wuth travel cl'ostances ca�cu�ated from known and accessbke access [D6nts. 10 F:=or cornrnunuty [Darks, travekheds were deHved usung 'V4-mHe, 'Y2-mHe, 'I -rnHe and 2-rnHe travel cl'ostances to acknow�edge that these [Dark ty[Des (uncVud'ong atHetuc fields) serve a wider array of users and driving to such sates us ty[DucaL 10 A corriloosite rnalo of these classifications and all City [Darks and O[Den S[Dace uHustrate the enturety of Oty [Darks to the 'Y2-mHe travekhed. Maps 2 through 5 illustrate the application of the distribution criteria from existing parks. Areas in white do not have a public park within reasonable Residential areas within 1 it of community or distance of their home (1/2-mile). The illustrated 'travelshed' for each existing Woodburn park highlights that certain areas within the City do not have the desired proximity to a local park. Gaps between these service areas constitute "unserved" neighborhoods. Striving to provide a neighborhood park within a reasonable distance (e.g., 1/2-mile) may require acquiring new park properties in currently under - served locations or improving multi -modal transportation connections to allow local residents to safely and conveniently reach their local park. The mapping of park distribution and 'travelsheds' helps to illustrate the underserved parts of Woodburn. Areas of south, east and west Woodburn have limited access to public parks or are in areas of future growth as indicated Iby white areas on Map 6. These areas of the City should Ibe targeted for future acquisitions to help create more equitable access for all residents. While these generalized acquisitic)n areas dc) nc)t identify a specific joarcel(s) for consideration, the area encompasses a broader region in which an acquisition would Ibe ideally suited. Gap analysis modeling also assessed the distribution of various recreation amenities, including jolaygrcwnds, sjoc)rt fields, sjoc)rt cc)urts, and trails, among others. Maps 7 through 14 illustrate the geographic distribution of these amenities, and this information is helpful in future park planning to improve access to the variety of recreation options desired Iby the community. 279 mm wo o � 3 - b,,, mK m N U o K u m w1 � o o � u v = _ C7 Z AX i .... o MM 1� r s a v o 0 U v D J� r � � _ ou � � t I om, d'w4rrYAMY J�rlAI Ai'r r e ¢°w III I � � j rbi. ° �... ,may mix, a V ss tio� r v s v o v o - v o 11 motiNma��o V�I V .. � .yNNNNN NN o = � z o E E E E � pp 4 s a 0 o 2 E w 280 281 m �m mw E (y4 No INI u C s K K v m,murr„ 1% O w O O K ry r W A c= u M, A A w- a a a" a" 0 E E E E U U o E �MWW �' Z U U NWT Idl m w w / E E E E D p 10 O r � o = yea s� v oo�v;a e da 3 ,rtryIIp����Vp���yqp�Il, ,, go VAI o v IV �zz°O v°'i v°'i133 IV o r _ y o a � m m m m m m=_ - E E E E� o� YM 0 wok¢ „ 0 ,�� wy„�"�w,. ., •. N m a o ,o n m m 282 283 284 285 287 288 289 290 291 292 Service standards offer a benchmark for measuring how well the City is meeting the expectations for the provisions of parks, open space, and outdoor recreation facilities for the community. As guidance for assessing current quantities and qualities of parklands and facilities, the level of service (I OS) in Woodburn can Ibe compared other agencies across the country. The traditional measurement focused on acres of parkland for the population. While this standard should not Ibe used exclusively, it can offer a starting point for examining a number of more customized and diverse approaches to evaluating the City's current service levels through a variety of metrics. NationA Recreation & Parks Association Agency Performance Review The 2023 National Recreation and Parks Association (NRPA) Agency Performance Review and accompanying Park Metrics provide comprehensive park and recreation -related data to inform park and recreation professionals and key stakeholders about the state of the industry. The 2023 NRPA Agency Performance Review presents data from more than 1,000 unique park and recreation agencies across the United States, as reported between 2020 and 2022. These data provide guidance to inform decisions and demonstrate the full Ibreadth Of service offerings and responsibilities of park and recreation agencies across the United States. This comparison of nationwide data with the City of Woodburn can provide guiding insights rather than target IbeFnchmarks. The NRPA data are used to compare different park and recreation providers in communities across the country; however, the Park Metrics database relies on self -reporting Iby municipalities. Some agencies only include developed, active parks, while others include natural lands with limited or no improvements, amenities, or access. The comparative standards in the table on the following page should Ibe viewed with this variability in mind. Acreage -based Metrics The NRPA Agency Performance Review provides a comparative of parkland acreage metrics across a range of jurisdiction population sizes. Parkland refers to Iboth maintained parks and open space areas, such as greenspaces and plazas. The current oc::)jouIati(::)n c::)f Wc::)c::)dIourn fits within the categ(::)ry (::)f communities 20,000 and 49,999 people. For that population category, the median is 11.3 acres of parkland per 1,000 residents. The current parkland acreage per 1,000 residents in Woodburn is 5.1 acres per 1,000 residents, which is lower than the median and Ibelow the lower quartile for comparably -sized communities — Ibased on a parkland inventory of 135 acres and excludes the acreage of local homeowners association open space and golf courses. Figure 12. NRPA Park Acreage Mel-rics py-)urisdichon Size per 1000 Population Median 10.8 13.0 11.3 11.2 8.9 10.1 Lower Quartile 5.3 6.0 5.9 5.0 4.5 5.2 Upper Quartile 18.4 21.1 17.9 17.3 17.1 17.7 T Offer a city map and informational flyer or newsletter to let us all know with dates of community events or important happenings in town." .. Survey reS�Dondent Staffing & Investment pay, Capita Mety,ic!s, Another method for assessing park levels of service examines the investment in parks and facilities using population and Ibudget allocations. The NRPA data provides a comparison of annual operating expenses with other agencies and jurisdictions with similar population sizes. Applying the City's 2022- 2023 Ibudget data for the Community Services Department (expenditures of $2,447,372, which exclude line items for the I ibrary), the operating expense per capita is $92.47 per resident, which is slightly less than the $94.77 median for all agencies 293 and the $103.95 median for park providers in cities With 20,000 to 49,999 residents, see Figure 13. With 135 acres of p arklarnd (includes developed and undeveloped sites), Woodlburrn's operating expernses per p arklarnd acre equates to $ ,703, which also is lower tharn the median expernditures of all agerncies in aggregate and those of other similarly -sized jurisdictions. Figure 13 also provides the nationwide comparison coupled With aggregate metrics and data of jurisdictions With a similar population sire to Woodburn. In most of the listed categories, the ity's provision of parks and recreation is Within the rarige of other agerncies in terms of residernts per park and operating expernses per acres of p arklarnd. Figure 13. NRPA Agency Performance Comparison Residents per Park (by jurisdiction size) 2,287 Acres of Parkland per 1,000 Residents 10.8 Miles of Trails 15 Park & Recreation Staffing (FTEs) 51.5 Parks & Recreation FTEs per 10,000 Residents 8.9 Parks & Recreation Annual Operating Expenses $5,500,000 Parks & Recreation Operating Expenses per Capita $94.77 Maintenance Operating Expenses per Park Acre $7,388 Five-year Capital Budget Spending (prior years) $10,000,000 Figure 14. NRPA & Woodburn Metrics by Arnenity Type Median Acres per 1,000 10.8 11.3 5.1 Median Trail Miles per 1,000 15 8 4.5 � ii�i�lwl�m�lm�f�(f� Playgrounds 3,759 3,028 2,941 Baseball (youth) 6,863 5,033 5,294 Soccer (youth) 7,228 4,947 8,823 Rectangular Field (multi -use) 9,177 7,674 13,234 Dog Parks 43,532 28,000 13,234 Skate Parks 53,144 32,000 26,468 Tennis Courts (outdoor) 5,860 5,815 13,234 Pickleball Courts (outdoor) 13,922 9,257 4,411 Multi -Use Courts (outdoor) 15,948 9,667 N/A Basketball Courts (outdoor) 7,404 7,117 6,617 However, the rnurnlber of full-time equivalent (FTEs) employees and the FTE ratio to population n deviate from the NRPA median data, With Woodlburrn's FTEs slighltly lower tharn comparable agerncies. As the park and recreation system expands, the City Will need to consider how Ikbest to Ibalarnce the growing demands placed corn park mairnternarnce and operations staff to care for parks at the level desired y the community. I lie City's Capital loud et spending c::)ver the loa t five years also is in lime With the median of all agerncies reporting ng to the NRPA. 2,014 1,059 11.3 5.1 8 4.5 32.3 20.5 10.7 7.7 $3,255,771 $2,447,372 $103.95 $92.47 $8,106 $5,703 $5,000,000 $10,596,990 I....00kirng at the provision of recreation amenities Within the park system provides another perspective corn the adequacy of park service delivery. from the NRPA Park Metrics data, tern amenities Were compared With the median values from am aggregate of all agerncies across the country, as Well as from similarly -sized jurisdictions to that of Woodburn, see Figure 14. The comparisons ns indicate that Woodburn is nc::)t deficient in Iolay rc::)unds, loa eloall field„ dog parks, picklelball courts and skate parks. I Ic::)Wever„ the City Iorc::)vides fewer sc::)ccer field„ multi use rectangular field and tennis cc::)urts thorn the median of agerncies reporting. ng. Also, kbased corn the mapping arnalysis provided earlier in this chapter, several areas of Woodburn do not have easy access to existing r'ecr'eatiornal amenities, and r'esldernts have to drive for access for various activities. 294 00per Performance Metrics In reviewing the park system as a whole, Figure 15 illustrates the current levels of service across different performarice measurements. From the community survey results, the frequency of park and trail visitation rariked as the strongest indicator for the park system. These level of service metrics include distribution Criteria'Cc::) reflect the percent c::)f travelshed cc:werage for each type of park in the community. Based on the gap assessment mapping, the City's community parks within a 2-mile travelshed cover approximately Figure 15. Distribution & Seri 1-irnen I- Metrics 92% of Woodburn. Areas outside these community park travelsheds are mostly located along the east and southwest perimeters of the City. Coverage measured as a'/2-mile walking distarice for pocket, neighborhood or community parks was considerably lower, providing access to existing parks for only 36% of the City. The gap arialysis coriducted for this Plan reinfc::)rces the need R::)ir new joark k:)cati(::)ns t(::) fill known gaps in parklarid distribution. Community Life Quality Scale Importance of parks & recreation (Essential or important) Uio 11 IM = >90% LOS Grade 1111dill 8 = 80 - 89.9% Satisfaction with City's parks or open space ('very' or 'somewhat') 57% C = 70 - 79.9% D = 50 - 69.9% LOS Grade D = <50% Agency -based Assessment Condition Assessment Rating of Existing Parks (3-point scale) 1.4 Condition Assessment Scale LOS Grade B 10 = <1.2 8 -1.2-1.74 C = 1.75 - 2.24 Community Park Access (within 2-mile travelshed) D = 2.25 - 2.79 Percent Service Area with Access to Community Pa r k 01111 = >2.8 LOS Grade lid Usage / Distribution Scale Parkland Access (within 1-mile travelshed) Percent Service Area with Access to Community & Neighborhood Parks VuuPnsn>85% LOS Grade C = 50 - 69.9% Parkland Access (within 1/2-mile travelshed) D = 30 - 49.9% Percent Service Area with Access to Community & Neighborhood Parks 57% 1 = <30% LOS Grade C Trail System Access (within 1-mile travelshed) Percent Service Area with Access to Recreational Trails 81% LOS Grade 8 Trail System Access (within 1/2-mile travelshed) Como la ciudad esta creciendo Percent Service Area with Access to Recreational Trails 59% demasiado es necesario mas LOS Grade C amplitud en los parques o crear Frequency of Park or Trail Use Percent visiting parks and open space at least once per month 71% LOS Grade 8 * i the percentage or land area covered by service area walksheds is a proxy for the population within the residential portion or - the city. la cuidad para acortar el tiempo de trasporte oreo Ilegar mas r6pido al parque mas cerca. (As the city is growing too much, it is necessary to have more space in tl-te lit, vi-k-s #" ir-cre Y-te-Trni in opposite sides of the city to .. SUI'VOY MS�Dondont 295 Chapter 6 RECREATIONAL TRAI LS Trails and paths provide peoplle with valuable links between neighborhoods, parks, schools, transit, business centers, and other destinations. 'This chapter provides an overview of the trails system in Woodburn, inclludinq recommendations on continuing initiatives. Completing and expanding trail system connections was identified as c::)ne c::)f the jo rk:)ri ties during the community engagement process, and walking was the top activity for Woodburn residents. The community seeks an expansion of walking trails and the establishment of Ibike paths, emphasizing the importance of connectivity between parks. Continuing to manage and invest in the trail system, while also improving trail access to transit options, is essential to maintaining a healthy and livable community and promoting alternatives to vehicle use. Walking and hiking continue to Ibe the most popular recreational activities nationally and regionally. Furthermore, national recreation studies have consistently ranked walking and hiking as the most popular forms of outdoor recreation over the last ten years, and summaries of recreation trends are provided in Appendix G. The Oregon Statewide Comprehensive Outdoor Recreatk:)n FlIan cc::)nHn-ned that c::)utdc::)c::)r recreatk:)n is an integral part of life for most Oregon residents, with strong participation in the most popular category of activities, which includes walking on local streets/sidewalks (313 million user occasions) and walking on local trails/paths (113 million user occasions). Across the state, outdoor recreation participants rated the development of walking and hiking trails closer to home as high in importance. The most important funding need expressed Iby public recreation providers was for community trail systems. U. I lie COVI I ) 19 loandernic significantly irriloacted outdoor recreation activities, including trail use. I ocal and regional park and recreation agencies that managed trail systems were pressed to adapt to heavy usage and crowded trailhead parking, as many people shifted their daily exercise routines to outdoor activities, such as walking and Ibicycling. An August 2020 report from the Outdoor Industries Association revealed that Americans took up new activities in significant nurnbers, with the biggest gains in running, cycling, and hiking. Walking, running, and hiking were widely considered the safest activities during pandemic shutdowns. Participation rates for day hiking rose more than any other activity. I lie 2022 Outdc)c)r ::'articipatic)n Reloc)rt cc)nFin-ris the increase in outdoor recreation participants into 2021. Participation retained its momentum indicating that once someone begins to participate, they are likely to continue to participate. Hiking and running were the top two outdoor activities, a trend that has continued to Ibuild in recent years. Notably, this 2022 report shares that the number of seniors, ages 65 and older, participating in outdoor activities grew Iby 16.8% (an astounding 2.5 million) since 2019. Trails and pathways are essential infrastructure to support outdoor recreation. The annual study from the National Recreation and Parks Association of how Americans use their parks determined that people who live near parks and recreation facilities are more likely to arrive at that park Iby walking, biking or running, with walking being the most common method of transport. With the rapid increase in electric -assist mobility and the loc)tential fc)r user cc)nflicts due tc) increased speeds, Woodburn will want to determine the Ibest approach for ensuring safety for all trail users and how Ibest to promote trail etiquette on shared -use pathways. As noted in previous chapters, feedback from the community surveys and two public meetings provided a wealth of local insights on current usage and interests in various recreation amenities, including trails. Survey respondents visit local parks and recreation facilities for a variety of reasons, Ibut the most popular reason is to walk or run (69%). About two-thirds of survey respondents would like to see more walking and biking trails (72%). Respondents were asked about their support for a variety of potential additions to the park system. Virtually all residents were either very or somewhat supportive of additional walking trails (92%). From a list of potential park system investments, reslocmdents identified imlorc)ving and upgrading existing parks as their top priority, followed closely �by expanding trail opportunities. Respondents were asked to describe one thing that they would like to see the City of Woodburn do to improve parks, trails, aquatics, and/or recreation programs. One of the common themes that emerged Firc)rn the 380 specific cc)rnirrients was walking trails and connectivity. The community seeks an expansion of walking trails and the establishment of Ibike paths, emphasizing the importance of connectivity between parks. Residents also specifically requested better lighting alcmg trails, wheelchair -friendly paths, and pet -friendly trails. The fall 2023 online open house provided additional community input toward trail improvements. Several respondents advocated for safe pathways connecting various parts of the community, schools, and downtown areas. Others mentioned they would like improvements to trail safety with lighting. Regarding potential trail amenities, open house participants more strongly favored trailhead restrooms, benches along trails, and drinking fc)untahns c)ir water loc)ttle Filling static)ns. The top three trail segments include a citywide loop trail around Woodburn, expanding Mill Creek trail between Settlemier Park and Woodburn High School, and connecting Centennial Park to Settlemier Park. Other comments included: 10 nsta�hng more seatung akng [Daths, 10 Add'ng a bke re[Daur center, and 10 rn[Drovung traH accessbhty. These community needs are already informing future investments. The City's adopted Budget for 2023- 2024 proposes to invest in additional development of the Mill Creek Greenway Trail with an estimated $850,000, that was made possible Iby an approved grant application to help fund several proposed segments of the Mill Creek Greenway Trail and connector pathways. The Oregon Community Pathways Grant helps fund off-street, shared use trails to connect employment, social services and sclhc)c)l sites. I lie grant alololicatic)n targets five different trail segments that would help connect to existing trails, neighborhoods and destinations. 297 Implementing Woodburn's network of trails will expand access for all community members and support sustainability goals around reducing vehicle dependence. The trail network serves as foundational infrastructure for an interconnected system of outdoor recreation facilities. Connecting trails into and through urban centers and new neighborhoods will allow for alternative modes of accessing goods and services. Several past plans have articulated the need for, and continue to guide, an expanded trail system. The City of Woodburn Cornpirelheinsive IPlain recently amended in 2022 states the intent of the City to provide adequate parks, recreation facilities and open space to maintain Woodburn's livability and managed growth, and to provide social, economic and envircmirriental benefits tc) individuals, families and the community. The Plan articulates policies for acquisition and development of adequate parkland for neighborhood parks, trails and open spaces. The City established a one-third mile walkability target for residents to have easy access to parks, trails, and indoor facilities. The implementation of the Mill Creek Greenway Master Plan and the provision of a continuous public greenway and pathway system is another policy within the Comprehensive Plan. The Mill Cireek Gireenway Masteir IPlain drafted in 2007 created system -wide recommenclations for trail design, alignments and improvements along the Greenway. The Master Plan provides recommenclations for trail routes, transition nodes, and support facilities such as restrooms, trailheads, benches, and signage. The Master Plan also provided a six -year plan for project implementation along sections currently owned Iby the City. The Plan cited the Marion County Transportation Plan as including a trail route along Mill Creek that would connect Woodburn with the City of Gervais to the south and Hubbard and Aurora to the north. This trail would continue Woodburn's Mill Creek Greenway system to the Pudding River, just north of Aurora. The previous 2009 Woodburn IPairlks Masteir IPlain included recc)rnrnendatic)ns that identified the need to improve walkability to parks and recreation facilities and to the community as a whole. The Parks Master Plan also provided a ten-year list of recommended capital projects with proposed irrilolernentatic)n timing and estimated cc)sts. I lie First phase of the Mill Creek Greenway was constructed in 2011. Acquisition of properties and future trail cc)nstructic)n orc)jects were identified corer the next ten years. The Highway 991E Conridoir IPlain was developed for the transportation corridor that runs through the eastern edge of the City of Woodburn for the purpose of facilitating the revitalization of the corridor. The Plan examined pedestrian and (bicycle access and safety and promoted redevelopment that would result in a more walkable safe streetscape with connections to adjacent neighborhoods. The Plan includes an access management plan to Ibe irrilolernented incrementally tc) hmlorcwe traffic safety for motorists, (bicyclists and pedestrians. The Transportation Systern IPlain (TSP) for the City of Woodburn set the goals for multimodal mobility to provide a multimodal transportation system that includes a network of (bike lanes and routes, as well as sidewalks and off-street pathways, that improve (bicycle and pedestrian mobility within neighborhoods and link other community destinations. The TSP names the Mill Creek Greenway as a high priority project and numerous connecting pathways as medium priority projects for implementation. The TSP cites the value of wayfinding signs fc)ir use cm orii-nary loicycle i-(::)utes and multi use loaths tc) hello define the rc)ute and direct users towards destinations with information about distances and average travel times. The TSP orc)jects include a city wide wayfinding signage system to support (bike routes, multi -use paths, parks, schools and other destinations. 10 13", MI DD 11 F-cf, =N' As Woodburn's trail system grows and the extent of the Mill Creek Greenway Trail connects to neighloc)rhng cities, it will be beneficial tc) adc)IDt a trail classificatic)n system tc) distinguish loetweell types of trails and the standards of maintenance that would Ibe expected. The Mill Creek Greenway Trail currently functions to connect the community across different neighborhoods, parks and destinations. The Greenway Trail also travels through some parks. Individually, some parks have interior paved pathways and trails that provide easy access to park amenities. I lie Wc)cAlourn recreaticmal trail classificatic)n system should Ibe (based on a tiered network and includes three primary trail categories: Regional, Connector, and I ocal/Park Trails. The differences Ibetweern trail classificatic)ns are based cm the ourloc)se and intensity c)f use, which influences the trail width, material, and recommended support facilities. 298 Regionall 'Tr fills Regional trails are typically planned and designed with active transportation and high volume recreation use as their primary purpose. The Mill Creek Greeriway Trail future segments are planned as 10' paved pathways with 2' ori each side (per current VVDO). In gerieral, regional trails are completely separated from roads Iby distarice or Ibarriers, and at -grade crossings of roadways are rninirnized tc::) avc::)id cc::)nflicts. Regk:mal trails should Ibe a minimum of 10 feet wide under most conditions, with a minimum two -foot wide graded area c::)n loc::)t17 sides that shc::w1d loe Flush with the trail. These trails are iriterided to Ibe long-distance routes that connect to other trails and exterid to other cities. Coordination with adjacent jurisdictions including Marion Courity, community development programs, and transportation planning is central to developing a complete system of regional trails. ConnectorTrafills Connector trails are the key linkages Ibetweern regional trails and other major areas. These trails earn �Ike paved or soft surface trails, but these are typically more marrow thari regional trails, due to more limited Figure 16. Recommended Trail Oassificalions Regional Trail Major connections through Multi -use community and beyond Connector Trail Connects parks, trails, Multi -use neighborhoods and destinations use and possible land access issues. These trails are designed for recreation and transportation uses. Connector trails should meet the City's sidewalk standards at a minimum and have a width of six to eight feet. Where feasible, connector trails could match the width and character of regional trail to provide a smooth transition and meet local demand. Local/Park 'Tr fills I ocal trails are typically within or connected to parks and may Ibe paved or soft surface trails that earn rarige from a few feet foot to tern feet wide. These trails are typically designed for recreatiorial uses, such as neighborhood links, park trails, and hiking, off -road bicycling, and equestrian trails. These trails earn also meet special interest activities, such as BMX and mountain Ibiking. Park trails are typically paved with concrete or asphalt. Other local trails may be coristructed with riative soil from the site or with a surface of gravel or wood chip material if additional reinforcement is required. Trail surfaces are graded slightly to reduce the poteritial for erosion. Pedestrians, cyclists, skaters Equestrians (where feasible) Pedestrians, cyclists, skaters Local / Park Trail Interior loops or point-to-point Multi- or single use Pedestrians, cyclists, skaters routes in public spaces. Asphalt, concrete, boardwalk. Asphalt, concrete, boardwalk. Gravel, possible. Asphalt, concrete, boardwalk. Gravel, native soil, forest duff, wood chips also possible. 12-18' 8-12' 2-10' 299 o� „ f a v o o � m w o 0 Z o " m v oc v p �eN o m € G m m �L�Illllll� 0 �oOU III V s w m mg u� a � s w M ®a3 1 I .i III ti MiP. q6 n " mnuM p gg .s v. l o" 1 h NN oa s eti IJ MIle o� b E oar as s s cEi e �• m ==«ox rvo s I$ � W. .yNNNNN NN a 0 ea,Z. E E E E ' m lY o 3 v v v v v �� a Ana � � .................. �pp s N a v s wR s W °NIyJ a ................. x u a a A � o � m unm o E E r`v o L vEi 300 In addition to paved pathways and natural surfaced trails within individual parks and open spaces, Woodburn has a growing network of trails providing outdoor recreation opportunities and connections across the city. These trails generally are part of the Mill Creek Greenway Trail system and offer a variety of surface types and accommodate pedestrians and cyclists. The existing recreation trail segments provide 5 miles for walking and biking. Figure -17. Woodburn Trail Inventory Centennial Park Park Trail 5,255 Legion Park Park Trail 1,358 Mill Creek Greenway Trail Regional Trail 7,065 Nelson Park Park Trail 1,174 Right -of -Way Route Connector Trail 3,017 Senior Estates Park Park Trail 1,311 Smith Creek Trail Connector Trail 6,430 Other Local Trail 875 Total Length 26,486 A gap analysis was conducted to examine and assess the accessibility of existing recreational trails. As with the parkland analysis, travel distances were calculated along the road network starting from each existing trail segment's known access points. I ocal trails within parks were also depicted. Travelsheds were calculated with 'V4-mile, 1/2-mile and 1-mile distances for major trails (e.g., Mill Creek Greenway Trail) and 'V4-mile and 1/2-mile travelsheds for the remainder (e.g., local/park trails). Map 16 illustrates the citywide distribution of recreational trails and the relative access to these corridors within reasonable travel walksheds. Approximately 59% of the City has access to regional and recreational trails within a'/2-mile. The service area grows to 81 % of the City when the travelshed is expanded to a 1-mile distance for major trails and 1/2-mile distance for minor trails. Similar to transportation planning, recreational trail planning should Ibe geared toward connectivity as a system performance metric, rather than mileage. Only considering a mileage standard for paths within the Woodburn park system will result in an isolated and inadequate assessment of community needs with little consideration for Ibetter trail connectivity. T Add walking trails and wildlife preserve areas. The city has a 4,F-5 �_—r&C dfl�-Fr�nVYMTY&rK buildings going up. Those people need nice places to get out and oy the outdoors." .. SUI'VOY 'OSpDondont 5.02 This Plan recommends a connectivity goal that re -states and reinforces the desire to improve overall connections across the City to enhance off- street linkages between parks, schools, and major destinations, as feasible. The use of policies and objectives is more appropriate for the expansion of the trails network with a focus on connectivity, rather than the use of a per capita distance metric (e.g., miles per 1,000 population). Therefore, this Plan does not propose a mileage -based trail facility standard. To Ibe clear, the proposed exclusion of a mileage -based standard for trails does not diminish or reduce the importance of or value in continuing to expand and grow the trail network; the intent is merely to orient the City's efforts toward a policy- �based approach of trail connectivity. 301 m� c2 N 0 v00 a o s o v u p .. r c Tyl ro N In Y "SINA a uyf `�S 4. e er iP ji NNNN rc � o / k' 8 m r� Im T b� I� Ce p �oNw, mug m s a /B m ? m m $ nrM hp z y � a s n o VQ b� LIAItl ,f �M, .,v�op i� �Y M j + r AIL, m T m � 3 iNvis � s° / � a m N � � z „ U s m a E s Eaa s w a 9 �r oNy oo ���Ns k z `��° E E E E o s o w m m v v m a +r � n � �� a Ana j .................. �pp s N a � s wR , s W °NIyJ a ................. uWuuwmmmmn �M„ _, a � m kv �° A � o � m m NvvY�lta''ry � ? o s 302 Alignments & Connections The expansion of the trail network should prioritize trail alignments and locations that are optimal from multiple perspectives: trail user, trail experience, and trail connectivity. Cost, regulatory, and site suitability factors are typically incorporated into implementation timing. New trail alignments should strive to accommodate different trail use types (i.e., commuter vs. recreational/destination oriented) and utilize interim solutions, such as widening sidewalks and utilizing existing or planned utility corridors as opportunities for trail improvements. Integration of trail projects with other pedestrian infrastructure projects and other transportation projects implemented Iby the City is essential for expanding the reach of trail opportunities. Trail alignments for neighborhood and park trails should serve as connections to regional, shared -used trails to provide access and reduce the sole reliance on trailheads for providing access to the trail network. New developments also should provide for connections to nearby trails and pathways, wherever feasible. The Conceptual Recreational Trail System map (Map 17) indicates potential alignments that can vary depending upon landowner willingness, along with environmental constraints and design considerations. Areas of Respite Beyond trailheads that can provide access to the trail with parking, restrooms, drinking water or seating, rest areas along trail segments can enhance the trail user's experience to enjoy the natural settings and/ or urban dynamics of the trail's environment. Areas of respite are usually available within developed parks connected to the trail system, Ibut longer sections of trails between trailheads and parks could offer places to rest, stop and chat, enjoy wildlife viewing, reconnoiter, meet -up with fellow trail users, etc. Differentiated from trailheads, these ,rest stops' can simply offer pull -offs with benches or picnic tables, observation or viewing platforms, or interpretive signs. These sites should also Ibe included in the emergency response system with an identifying code to provide locator information. Parks are known to contribute to a healthier community by providing accessible outdoor recreation particularly through the walking trail within each park. Getting to a park by foot or bike can also offer a healthier choice integrated with the park destination and its amenities. In the NRPA publication Safe Routes to Parks, the elements of walkable, healthy community design are outlined as convenience, comfort, access and design, safety, and the park itself. Sidewalks, bikeways, transportation system for residents to access parks and other destinations within their community. As further emphasis for the importance of a walkable community to promote public health, the Surgeon General has issued a Call to Action to "step it up" and promote more walking and build a more W-2 sidewalks, and bike lanes with links to public transit also provides economic values. 303 finding ways to engage with their community, and focusing on their health and fitness. It will be critical for Woodburn's park and recreation system to take a comprehensive approach to the City's aging population needs. Accessibility and barrier - free parking and paths, walkability, and connectivity will be paramount to future planning. Providing experiences for today's older adults includes not only active and ,.-assive recreation but also the of equipment needed to engage in certain activities. and frequent outdoor recreation activity of older adults: walking. Access &Trailheads Safe, convenient entryways to the trail network expands access for users and are a necessary component of a robust and successful system. A trailhead typically includes parking, kiosks, and signage and may consist of site furnishings, such as trash receptacles, benches, restrooms, drinking fountains, Ibike repair stations, and Ibike racks. More recent trailhead installations are adding electric Ibike charging stations to continue to expand alternative modes of transportation. Trailheads may Ibe within public parks and open space or provided via interagency agreements with partner organizations (e.g., Marion County, Woodburn School District, ODOT, etc.) to increase use and reduce unnecessary dulolicaticm c)f suloloc)rt facilities. Specific trailhead designs and layouts should Ibe created as part of planning and design development for individual projects and consider the intended user groups and unique site conditions. Trad Development Opportunities Opportunities to develop additional trails and connections may Ibe limited in areas with existing dense urban development. One underlying tenet of the recreational trail system is to enable the placement of trails within or close to natural features to provide access to the City's unique landscapes and connect outdoor recreational access to parks and natural areas. Mill Creek Greenway Trail follows the alignment of the creek and connects to parks, and new development has added the Smith Creek path system to the Greenway Trail. The future planning and design of trail routes through natural areas should Ibe Ibased on sensitive and low -impact design solutions that offer controlled access to protect the resource, while providing for a positive experience for all modes of trail user. The determination of future trail alignments should prioritize natural resource and natural hazards planning and protections, in part to meet local land use policies and Oregon State requirements. 304 �m���w������N����v�~ ���lm� Integrating ~�==- '�� ===~�"%� Elements The Monon Trail, a rail trail heading north almost 17miles from downtown Indianapolis, illustrates some tools for helping visitors find the trail and find their way along the trail. The combination ofasignature color, unified logos and icons, matching site furnishing, and signagestyles help identify the location and direction of the trail and its support facilities, as part of a unified navigation system. At crossroads and trai|heads, the bright red colors used consistently in signs and furnishings mark the trai|'s presence. Kiosks and information signs help orient the trail user. Rule signs alert the user totrail behavior expectations and reinforce trail identity. The signage system helps identify place, provide information about trail distances and amenities, locate connections and interpret history and culture. Traill Sigins & Wayfindiiing Coordinated signageplays an important role in facilitating a successful trail system. A comprehensive and consistent signage system, implemented according to the type, scale, and site of the trail setting, is a critical component of the trail network. It also is necessary to inform, orient, and educate users about the trail system itself, as well asappropriate trail etiquette. Such a signage system shcu|d Include trail identification infc)rmation, orientation markers, safety and regulatory messages, and a unifying design identity for branding. Have a walking path or map to connect to all Survey reS�Dondent 305 II vo a` MO OM E U p a o o 0 c7 z a a ff�1r _ !,� s � m '0 3 y E `o i ^fi y �' !h� J b �, o o E. � v M y O w a N p p ~ �a a E a v@ v E° v v w m T m v . T O ¢ U W U = a w IIIIIII o u z 3 n.��, �I I1111V o m a ° m K m g N ° O � I 1,17 o e M r 8 e ems, � e m., w � ' 3 invis � a a �w ono s° V v y v s v V �m e ri. o iw I� � IIII m E E E E 3 a m o v uN� s a s .. a ww =�amCl EEC sE 306 ��l,. r rr ,w a ,, r, rt or av t ii swim, Ming', r l S. r � i 'Ob"90 !rr �4 V; , 307 � v RECREATION, AQUATICS & EVENTS The recreation facifties, offerings and events avaflaHe within Woodburn are a major community asset and support heakh of community members. Various recreation options are available through arange ofpublic and private recreation, health and fitness providers and facilities. The City currently provides pnogmanning through a mix mfCity-run programs and through partnerships and prmgranncmntractmrs. Atthe present, the City has limited space and staffing fmrtraditimna�l programming. The 6oNmwingnatimma�l and state data highlights smnne of the current trends inrecreation and may franne future considerations inVVmmdburn's recreation offerings, events and partnerships. Additimna�ltrend data are provided inAppendix {5. * Natonwicle,82%ofU.S.acluhs be|iavethat parks and necneatonare essantiai m * 72%nfsurvey respondents indicate that having a HQh-qua|itypark' p|ayQrouncl'pu6|icopen space ornecneatnncenter nearby isan important factor indeciding where they want tn |ive. m * NeadyaU(93%)park and necreaton agencies proviclerecreaton programs and services. The top five most commnn|yoffered programs inc|uclehn|idayorother specia| events (65%)'educationa| programs (59%)' group exercise (59%)'fitness programs (58%)'and day orsummer camps(57%). m 308 10 IMonethan eightinten agencies pozv6etheme6 specia|events (9O%ofagencies)'team spous(g7%)' social recreation events (gg%)'youth summercamps (83%).fhness enhonoementclasses (82%).and health and weUnesseducation (gO%).(,') 10 America'schi|6nenare spen6ingmore timeoutdoors over the pastdecade, and the CDV|Opan6emic acce|erate6 that trend. Dvera||' the percentage of chi|6nen participating in outdoor recreation was Hgh in2O21'atjust over 7O%. w 10 Over the pasttwo years' participation rates are up across the board forAmerica's youth' with strong growth in participation 6ygir|s (49% Hgherfor gir|s ages 6 to 12' and 53% higher for gir|s 13 to 17). w 10 Yoga condnued^ohave one ofthe |argestgains in fhneaaactivities. p) 10 Activities with the highest 5-year increase in pardcipat�oninc|u6eindoor c|im6ing(13%)and pick|e6aU (12%). (��) 10 NeadyaU[Dark and recreat�onpozv6ersinthe U.S. expehenceda6ec|ineinrevenue in2O2Odue ^o the CDV|O19pan6emicAseadyasIMay2O2O' most pmv�6ers had to c|ose faci|ities ^emporari|y in accordance with heaWi and safety6inectives. Neady ha|fa|sofudoughe6or|ai6off staff due ^othe funding and faci|ityimpactsofthe pan6emicw 10 Research from the US Bureau ofEconomicAna|ysis shows that arts and cu|mne6hve4.2%ofthe US gross domestic product V3OP)' generating $ 8767 6iUion in 2020.m 10 Peop|e who saytheir n6gh6orhoo6 has easy access ^oqua|ityarts and cu|mra|actMt�estend ^o6e mom*satisfie6. Identify mom*ohh local lifestyle and cu|mne' and invest more t�me and resources in their communit�es. (P�) Sources: <z> American Engagement with Parks Survey <4 202omnPwAgency Performance Review <s> zozzmnPwAgency Performance Review <m zozzOutdoor Participation Report <s> zozzSport mFitness Industry Association Sports, Fitness, And Leisure Activities mmm°Participation Report <W 20mState ofthe Industry Repo* (7) US Bureau of Economic Analysis, 2022 uU Knight Foundation Community Ties survey Comm ""uy-n°s-p/na I-pg. nur<I(nightfo""dam"".org).Builds off Soul ofCommunity Longitudinal study(2008-20z0) conducted b'the Knight Foundation found l(ey drivers "rcommunity attachment mb°social offerings, openness, and aesthetics. https:/a"/mh*"""u"fi""."rg/smc/"veran-fi"umgs/ Recreation Management magazine's 2022 Report on the State of the Managed Recreation Industry summarizes information provided by a wide range ofprofessionals working in the recreation, sports, and Fitness industry. Regarding prc)gramc..)ptk.)ns, respondents from community centers, park departments, and health clubs reported that they plan toadd programs over the next few years. The ten most commonly planned program additions 10 Kn6-body6a|ancepozgrams 10 Fimesspmgrams 10 Gmupexercise pmgrams 10 E6ucationa|pmgrams 10 Arts and crafts pmgrams 10 Teenpmgrams 10 Functiono|fitness pmBroma 10 Performingarts pmgrams 10 Env�mnmento|e6ucat�on 10 Ho|i6aysand other specia|events According to the 2022 Outdoor Participation Report, published 6vthe Outdoor Foundation, justover half (54%)ofAmericans ages 6and older participated inoutdoor recreation atleast once in2O21.The outdoor participant base has increased 6.9%since the COV|Dpandemic began inearly 2O2O. Addressing the COV|C-19pandemic required many respondents toeither put programs orservices on hold (82%) orcut programs orservices entirely (34%). Additionally, marry respondents have had to rethink their programming portfolios. Two'thirds c)frespc)ndents(6796)had added c)n|inefitnessand wellness programming asofMay 2O2O, 39%were involved in programs toaddress food insecurity, and one in four was involved in programs to provide educational support toout'of-schoo|children. 309 Participants ofboth openhouses and stakeholder group discussions offered feedback onrecreation programs, facilities, and cultural activities. [c::)mmunityFeedback firc::)mthe first c::)penhc::use meeting included the following: 10 Ybmh programs &cam[DS, such as potter/ arts, SIE.M. or outdoor programs' summer youth camps' an66eeor|ow/resourcepmgramopdonsforvarious agegmups 10 A6u|torsenior potteryc|asses From the second openhouse meeting (on|ine),the majority (61%) of respondents said they would like more adult orsenior classes, adult sports leagues, youth programs, teenactivities, and outdoor or natunecamps. Community survey respondentswere asked about their level ofinterest in avariety ofnecneationa| programs and activities that the City of Woodburn does, or could, offer. More thanthree quarters of nespondentswere very orsomewhat interested in seeing more community events, adult classes, and aquatics programs. More than half of respondents were interested inall the other necneationa| programs and activities listed, with the exception of E'sports,see Figure 18. Younger residents, particularly those under 44,and those with children athome were more likely than older nesidentstoexpress interest in youth activities and sports, family programs, adult classes, and swimming lessons. Older nespondentsshowed more interest inprograms for adults over 55. Open-ended responses onthe survey included other feedback about recreation programs and facilities: 10 Aquat�cCenter Enhancements: Communitymem6ers expnessedadesire for upgra6es^zthe aquat�c center, inc|u6ingexpan6e6hours, a66it�ona|aquat�c c|asses' and impozve6 in600rfaci|ities. Theya|so caUe6for the addition ofmore s|i6es'6Mngboards, and awave poo|^oenhance the overaUexperience. 10 CommunityCenter and Recreation Programs: Bui|6ing a new communitycenter that offers various amenitiesand recreation pmgramsisanother common desire. The communitywou|6 |ike to see more options for youth sports |eagues' a66itiona| fitnesafacilities, and impmve6staffing and ovoUo6Uhy ofpmgrams'inc|u6ingswimming|essonsand senior activities'to cater to the 6iverse needs and interests of residents. 10 Communicatonand |nfonnat�on: Some survey nespondentsasked for impozve6communication channe|s'such asacityca6|echanne|ornewo|etter, to inform residents about communityevents, park oRehngs'and importonthappeningsintown. Others requested amore usep6ien6|ywe6si^ethat pmvi6es easy access ^o infonnation' inc|u6ing programs' activities' and registrations, reducing the need to search through muffip|e sources. Figure la.|meresi far Various necmolionProgram Types Connimunifty Events AAexarn06s parqWes Adult classes s y teAerWAceAtro wqummxcs prograims con0WAitario para YommhmcUviUes n06s actiVidades deAtro yfWera,(Add Youth sports more parks and have �x� x x lessons a community center �mimxny progrmims for more activities inside and outside.)" Prograimsfor adults ss* Surveyrespon6ent Adult sports 1� eenmctxWUem 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% 111111111Very Interested Somewhat Interested 1111�Not Interested Not Sure 310 r�l Ml=ll The City of Woodburn provides access to recreation programs and activities in its parks and in several municipal buildings. The day-to-day management, ongoing maintenance, and long-term reinvestment in City facilities are crucial to the success of Woodburn's recreation programs. Additionally, efficient scheduling and use c)f the facilities ensures that cost recovery, inclusion, program vitality and other goals are met. Woodburn Aquatic Center I lie Wc)c)dlourn Aquatic Center c)ffers fitness, recreational and learn -to -swim programs for individuals of all ages. Facility amenities include a 1 0-lane swimming pool with water slide, rope swing, group exercise room, party rental room, Ibasketlball hc)c)jo, wading joc)cfl, sloa, Fitness equilornent and saunas. I lie Center c)ffers lifeguard certificaticm classes, swim lessons and runs an entry level swim team. Swim team participation includes coaching on proper swim strokes and options to compete in swim meets. The Woodburn Aquatic Center also is part of the Silver & Fit and Renew Active membership programs. These programs provides free pool memberships for seniors (60+) with eligible health care plans. Settllemier 'Teen Center The Boys & Girls Club of Woodburn operates the Teen Center located at Settlemier Park. The center features daily activities and is open Monday through Friday from 3-7pm during the school year. These programs focus on opportunities for teenagers (grades 6-12) to encourage academic success, citizen and character development, and healthy lifestyles. Woodburn Library Aside from providing access to Ibooks, Periodicals, and digital media materials the Woodburn I ibrary also serves as a venue for youth and community programs onsite at the library as well as remotely across the city with its Ibookmolbile and community outreach. These include story times, cultural performances, ESI classes, arts and crafts, and traditional games and electronic games. Woodburn IMuseum & Bung alowTheatre Museum) was constructed in 1905, and the Bungalow Theatre, the town's only remaining historic theater, was established as a theater in 1911. Both structures were recently restored to include seismic updates, facade improvements and interior remodels. Together, the two buildings offer a unique community meeting and event space that houses a stage for plays, presentations, and movies. The space also highlights the rich cinematic, architectural, and cultural history of Woodburn. Future Community Center Since 2017, the City has been planning and engaging the community in discussions for a new community center, as an expansion on the current Aquatic Center at Settlemier Park. Through an extensive design process, building footprint and functional spaces were conceptualized, and the future community center is programmed to include the following possible amenities: 10 Gyrnnasaurn and a waHdng/ oggang track 10 1:::�utness & cardWw6ghts S[Dace 10 Warm water thera[Dy and recreation [DOOM 10 VlUffi[Dur[DOse caassroorns for farnHy, teen, and senior [Drograrrurflng 10 Cornrnunaty rneetang rooms 10 :::Iexbk� event S[Dace 10 Arts & crafts caassroorns 10 Cornrnunaty [partners/service [Drovaders' S[Daces The construction of the future community center is dependent ujocm financing tc) suloloc)rt the estimated $60 million cost for the Ibuilcding. The City is currently reviewing the potential timing for a Iboncd measure electicm fc)r joulolic Financing c)f the jorc)ject, and the current timeline suggests a November 2024 election. Several City parks provide amenities or space available for events, parties, or special group visits. 10 Aquatic Center [DOo� and Carty room 10 Centennua� F)ark sheater 10 Woodburn IMuseurn & I heatre 10 Downtown 1::)�aza Gazebo 10 Hazen Srrflth 1::)aaza 10 1 egaon F)ark sheater 10 Senator Estates sheater 10 Setflerrfler F)ark sheater The Woodburn Historical Museum (formerly known as the Woodburn World's Berry Center 311 Room Legend I Entry Lobby �2 Rezapflon fAdministrative 3 Commun4 Muffi-Purpose Room 4 Partner Office Sufte 5 Locker Room 6 Exisfing Lap Pool 7 New Water Slide 8 Now, Wam Water Tharapy a f F Recreation Pool 9 Gymnasium TWD-Court - DivIsIble Renderings of -future Community Center (Credit: Opsis Architecture) cc Aquatics; I was very excited out the is for a new recreation center and hope that is something that can be added to our community!" Survey res[-.)ondent 312 MI Ell I � CC 1 1, IT M, The City isthe primary provider for aquatic programs and partnerswith other providers for most other recreation services. The YMCA, Boys &Girls Club, Woodburn Baseball/Softball Association and Woodburn Futbo|Club are the primary providers of many programs and services that are associated with recreation, athletics and youth services. There are programs, such asAfter School Club, are provided bythe Woodburn School District. Program Area Categories The categories below represent the major areas of focus for current Woodburn recreation programs. Program lists are based on a review of program offerings between2O18and 2023. Figure l9.smslingoily Programs by0zssificaxon 10101110101 1 , - pi'J'i 1 0 W1, I sanitation in all areas." Sports Youth Soccer, Co -Ed Tee Ball, Youth Track, Youth Basketball, Volleyball, Basketball Camp, Flag Football, Baseball, Softball, Cheer Camp Teen+ Adult Basketball, Co -Ed Volleyball Fitness Preschool vouth+ Gentle Yoga &Yoga, Youth & Adult Small Group Conditioning, zumba Cultural Arts All ages or ofade|o,xxuertos,Hispanic Heritage Month Celebration, Woodburn Teen+ piemaxxexicana Aquatics Youth Swim Lessons, Swim Team, Parent/child swim, Open swim Teen+ Swim Lessons, Lap Swim, 4quambic,/Water Fitness, Deep Water Fitness, Aqua Zumba Education Youth Language Exchange |ntercambios,uabv,itting,First Aid CPR Classes Specialty/ General Interest Adult Adult Trips, ESL Classes, 44nPTax Preparation Adaptive / Special Needs Special Events City Council uuQ,Taste ofWoodburn, Easter Egg Hunt, Fourth ofJuly Fireworks Celebration, Relay for Life Run, Fiesta xxexicanaUnderwater Egg Hunt, Water Safety Day, Music inthe Park, Bassett Hound Games, Trunk-orTneat,Mayor's Tree Lighting, Community Connection Day, Community ClUp Day Outdoor Education Self -Directed Teen+ Fitness Room Drop -in Senior/ Human Services Adult Senior -specific programs provided bvNorth Marion Adult Center Prc)gnsm Area [)efinitions (generalized): 10 Wmra| Arts— Performing arts c|asses'visua| arts c|asses' |i^eraryaus' musidvi6eo pm6ucdon and arts 10 Sports —Team and in6M6ua| sports inc|u6ing camps' events. c|inics'and tournaments. A|so inc|u6esa6venmre/ 10 Aquatics —Swim |essons' aqua exercise c|asses' ��m non�ra6i�ona| spo�s. team, and other pmgrams. 10 Fhnesa—Gmup fitness classes, personal training, 10 E6ucation—Language pmgrams'm^ohng' science e6ucation'an6 nuth�on. (STEIM)classes, computer, and financial p|onninB./4|ao inc|u6e6 is CPR/AEO/FiptAi6. 313 10 Speda|ty/Genera|Interest —Persona|6eve|opment dassesand activities. 10 A6aptive/Specia| Needs — Inclusive and a6apt�ve pmgramsfor the physicaUyand mentoUyimpaire6. 10 Specia| Events —Otywide specia|events that are conducted throughout the year. 10 Outdoor E6ucaton—Env�mnmento|e6ucaton' hiking'camping' kayaking, farm activities'an6 other activities. 10 |ndM6ua|/SeK-Oirected—THsinc|u6esthe opFmrtunit�esfor in6M6ua|s^o recreate on theirown. Thiscan include activitiessuch as6mp-ins'open gym'use ofweight±ar6iospace'and |ap/recneat�ona| owimming.A|tioughnot anorganized pmgram'time and space must be aUoca^e6 for tHs purpose. 10 Senior/ Human Serviceshis can inc|u6e senior nutritionan6 mea| pmgrams'socia|service support j06training' |ifeskiUstraining, chi|6cane' and other Programs Available by Age Groups Below islisted the basic program categories that are available for different age groups. Figumz0. SegmeniaxonofCily Programs byAge Group Aquatics Education Specialty/ General Interest Adaptive/ Special Needs Special Events Outdoor Education Program C11assii-ficaflions The following are the projected programming c|assificatic::nsfc::)rthe City. It is impc::)i-taint t(::) realize that while certain program areas may beafocus for growth inprograms arid services, the Department's role in providing the actual service may bedifferent asindicated below. 10 Cone Programs are those pmgramsthat are a primarynesponsib|ityofthe Parl<sand Recneat�on Oepartment^zpmv�6easOt+6ase6acdMt�es. Make your website easier to navigate and find information especially for programs and activities. I feel like I have to look in at least 3 or 4 different places to find out about things going on. Seasonally it would be great to get a brochure with class and activity offerings to register for." 1110r,citv ipirogirairn 10 Secondary Pmgramsare those pmgramsthat are a|owerphohty^z6epozv6e66irecdy6y the Oepartmentbut may 6eoffered 6yother organizations through contract with the Oty. 10 SupportPmgramsare pmgramsthat are not a priohtyfor the Oepartment^z6epmv�6ing6inecdy to the community, but where the Oty may pmv�6e supportthmugh faci|ities' program coordination, and pmmot�on ofactivities for other organizat�ons. Tlie fc::)Ucumngchart identifies andsummarizes necommendedfuture core programs, secondary programs arid support program areas for the Department. 314 Figure 21. Future Prograrn Types by Focus Area Adult Sports Education Aquatics General Interest Cultural Arts Outdoor Education Fitness Youth Sports Self -Directed Special Events Speciall Events The Community Services Department is responsible for the coordination of several community and special events throughout the year. These public events provide gathering opportunities, celebrations and activation of the downtown and City parks. While not every event is hosted or run Iby the City, these special events draw the community together, attract tourists and visitors from across Marion County and are popular with residents. A selection of recent community events include the following: 10 IMusuc un the Flark 10 Easter Egg Hunt 10 Cornrnunuty Clean UCH Day 10 4th of Judy Cekebratuon 1 1<aste of Woodburn 10 KS[Danuc, I atuno & Ind'genous HeHtage IMonth Cekebratuon 10 Woodburn 1:::'uesta IMexucana 10 1 runk-or- I reat 10 Da de I os IMuertos 10 IMayor's tree I ughtung 10 Cornrnunuty Connectuon Day 10 Basset Hound Games Opportunities to connect are clearly crucial to Woodburn's residents. Survey and public meeting responses showed strong interest for additional community events. Additionally, the City could explore ideas for additional events that draw from the diversity of the community; Woodburn Fiesta Mexicana, Dia de los Muertos and Mexican Heritage Month are great current events celebrating I atin American culture. There still may Ibe additional events to celebrate Russian or Native American heritage and traditions. Also, when the new the community center is completed, it can provide another venue to promote cultural gatherings and other family celebrations. Community gathering and special events should continue to Ibe an area of emphasis; however, the overall number and Ibreacdth of City -sponsored special events should Ibe carefully managed to align with the availability of resources and impacts to general park and facility use. This will ensure the City can adequately invest in its overall recreational offerings and maintain high -quality special events. Other community groups should Ibe encouraged to �be the primary funders and organizers of as many community -wide events as possible. A structured approach will help the City manage the growth of these popular offerings; ensure high -quality, adequately resourced events; and enlist community sponsorships, partnerships, and support. In addition to maintaining the various events and program offerings, the City should continue to coordinate with local artists, galleries, and art organizations to periodically refresh the major events and explore other options to engage the community with the arts and attract visitors. Small- scale projects can take the form of electrical Ibox coverings, Ibuilcding murals or temporary art, and larger -scale endeavors can include drone shows or expanded studio or maker space at the library or future community center. An asset management program and art conservation fund should Ibe considered for the nascent public art collection, in addition to the current Arts and Murals Committee. Each permanent art installation project should Ibe accompanied with an allowance or calculation of future maintenance and costs. Artists shc::w1d orc::)vide technical specificatk:ms aloc::)ut IDest management practices for the materials integrated in the art work, as well as a forecast of likely timing for the necessary cleaning and upkeep of the piece of work. The asset management practice for the public art collection should help track and manage the entire life cycle of each asset, as well as their distribution across Woodburn. In such a system, 315 the life cycle costs of each asset can be better predicted and managed tohelp engage appropriate maintenance tasks for each art work. Program & Facility Considerations The CJtv'scurrent programming philosophy isto utilize other organizations and providers as the primary sources for many, non'aquaticnecneation program services. The City has taken a strong role in coordinating with providers and promoting recreation offerings. To assist with future program planning, staff periodically should request and review participant data from providers to stay abreast ofclass and program utilization and consider the available program mix. Also, the Department has demonstrated its commitment toexcellence and continuous improvement. Staff should periodically review data from the following sources todetermine community needs for programs and services: 10 Histohca|registratontrends/success of current pmgramsand services 10 Surveys and quest�onnaines 10 Oregon Statewide CompnehensiveOutdoor Recreat�onP|an 10 Suggest�onspmvi6e66ycurrent orpmspecdve instructors and current emp|oyees Additional, expanded ornew program options may be limited tc)dayby indcx)rfacility capacity, staffing, and available instructors. However, with the planned construction of the new community center, the City will be poised to expand recreation program offerings. Doing so will require advance program planning todetermine the range ofpotential programs, scheduling, and the needs for full-time and temporary staff for programming and facility operations. Comments from public outreach indicate alatent demand for additional program options tC)rtsmi|y prc)grams, adult classes (Fitness, art, etc), and aquatics programs (lap swim, aerobics class, etc�.Con side ration sabout existing and planned programs should gauge performance and priority offerings based onamix ofcriteria that include: 10 Cornrnunk.y int.eirest. or deficiencies 10 Potentia|for increased pardcipat�on 10 FM rates for programs (registrants compared to pmgramcapacity) 10 Rate ofpmgramcance||at�ons 10 AxoUo6Uhyofqualified and knoo|e6Beo6|estaff or contractors to provide consistency and ne|ia6i|ityfor program 6e|ivery 10 F:'�nanda| performance ofin6M6ua| programs (operatingexpensesys. revenues) 10 Program |ifecyc|e assessment to 6a|ancethe suite of new, mature, and 6ec|ining programs 10 Revenue po^entia|'aRor6a6i|itXand accessi6i|ity 10 Cost ofservice po|icy metrics Also, asnoted inthe Parks and Open Space chapter, renovations to existing facilities are necessary for proper maintenance and toextend service life. Several components ofthe Aquatic Center are due forneapterm renovations orreplacements. These renovations will refresh the Aquatic Center asa main feature ofthe new community center and extend the life of the facility. These projects are noted in the Park Improvement Plan and include the following: 10 Roof repair&nep|acement 10 Cei|ing nepair&paint 10 HVAC systemupgra6e 10 Poo| ne-p|aster(muffip|etanks) 10 Re-ti|e poo| area Communications & Marketing Feedback from the community surveysuggested some limited awareness ofthe recreation options and amenities available toWoodburn residents. The City should continue to take a strong role in coordinating and promoting recreation services to improve awareness and inclusion for residents. The City'snewsletter, websiteand Facebookpage were noted asthe three ways survey respondents would prefer to learn aboutVVoodburn's parks, programs, and events. Stronger marketing efforts will be needed to inform and promote the recreation programs that are available and should continue to focus onthe following areas: 10 VVe6she enhancement to better promote programs and services in a66ition to the perio6ic program guide, inc|u6ingsearcha6|epmgramofferingsand services offered 6yother pmv�6ers; 10 Social me6io, emoU.flyers, and aiBnoBe promotions ofpmgram registration options; 10 Cont�nue6cross marketingand/or pmmot�ona| opportunit�eswith otherorganizat�ons' such as the Boys& Gr|sCUD, schoo|6isthctand others; and 10 Using appmpria^ecommunicationchanne|s^z 316 alper 8 The god and objectives described in this chapter define the recreation and park services that Woodburn aims to provide. These god and objectives were derived from input received throughout the punning process, from city staff, the Recreation and Parks Board, and community members. Taken together, the goals and objectives provide a framework for the Parks and Recreation Master Plan. The City's Comprehensive Plan follows statewide planning goals and provides the overarching direction for the City, while these goals and objectives focus the efforts toward tangible parks and recreation achievements. Oregon's Statewide Planning Goal) 8 on Recreation Planning states: "The requirements for meeting such needs, now and in the future, shall be planned for by governmental agencies having responsibility for recreation areas, facilities and opportunities: (1) in coordination with private enterprise; (2) in appropriate proportions; and (3) in such quantity, quality and locations as is consistent with the availability of the resources to meet such requirements. State and federal agency recreation plans shall be coordinated with local and regional recreational needs and plans." These elements are reflected in this Plan, which wHH1 guide future efforts for City of Woodburn. The goals and objectives are built on the foundation established in the previous Parks Master Plan, adopted in 2009, but have been updated to reflect feedback from the community, stakeholders and staff during this planning update process. Also, these goals align with the Nationall Recreation and Parks Association's Three Pillars, which are foundationall concepts adopted by the nationall organization and help frarne recreation advocacy at the nationall level. These core values (bellow) are cruc4l to improving the quality of life for aIHl Americans by inspiring the protection of naturall resources, increasing opportunities for physicall activity and healthy eating, and empowering citizens to improve the livability of their communities. • Conserva`uon — IPubhc parks are cHtucaV to preserving communu`ues' naturaV resources and wildlife habitats, which offer significant social and econornic benefits. • [--IeaVth and WeHness — IPark and recreatk)n departments Vead the natkm in umprovung the overaH heaVth and weHness of citizens, and fighting obesity. • Scx.-JaV Ecluuty — UnuversaV access to pubhc parks and recreatk)n is fundamenta� to aH, not just a pn0ege for a few. 317 Goal 1: Encourage and support public involvement in park and recreation issues. 1.1 Involve residents and stakeholders in park and recreation facility planning and design and recreation program development in order to solicit community input, facilitate project understanding and engender public support. 1.2 Continue to support and promote the Recreation and Parks Board as the forum for public discussion of park and recreation issues. 1.3 Conduct periodic joint sessions Ibetweern the Recreation and Parks Board and other standing City �boards, such as the Planning Commission, Public Art Mural Committee and Tourism Advisory Committee, and with the City Council to improve coordination and discuss policy matters of mutual interest pertaining to recreational resources, opportunities and funding. 1.4 Encourage and promote volunteer park improvement and maintenance projects from a variety of individuals, service clulos, 1(::)cal nc)n orc)fits, faith c)rganizaticms and IOusinesses. 1.5 Develop and expand volunteer programs for office and highly skilled vcflunteers, including the continued development of internships and creation job -shadowing opportunities. 1.6 Track and evaluate recreation trends, park use patterns, and park user needs. 1.7 Communicate the value of the City's investment in parks, open spaces, and recreational opportunities and provide information to the public about park and recreation funding and the stewardship of tax dollars. 1.8 Continue to use a variety of methods and media to publicize and increase resident awareness about recreational opportunities available in local neighborhoods and citywide. 1.9 Develop an evaluation process for marketing media such as newspaper, seasonal brochures, website, direct mail, targeted emails, radio, and television advertising to continuously determine effectiveness of marketing dollars. 1.10 Regularly update the City website and mobile interfaces to provide easy access to information about parks, trail routes, activities, events, and maps along with ensuring the website follows Ibest practices for accessibility and inclusion. 1.11 Work with the Woodburn Area Chamber of Commerce and the Tourism Advisory Committee to coordinate on information packets that promote City services to tourists and new residents. 318 Goal 2: Provide park and recreation opportunities throughout parks, facilities and programming that engage all members of the community to the best of their ability. 2.1 Develop a Culturally and Community focused policy that creates a framework for the removal accessibility Ibarriers (socio-economic, language, physical, geographic, transportation) to activities, facilities, programs, parks and trails. 2.2 Provide programming and services, as well as accompanying communications and marketing materials, that reflect City gc)als arc)und I )iversity, Equity and Inclusicm. 2.3 Design and maintain parks and facilities to offer universal accessibility for residents of all physical abilities, skill levels and age; beyond compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Standards for Accessible Design. Upgrade existing parks to remove any physical Ibarriers. 2.4 Explore unique and/or specialized recreational amenities that expand the range of outdoor play experiences beyond the traditional options. 2.5 Have intentional engagement with diverse community groups to create and partner on new diverse events and community celebrations. 2.6 Continue to, and expand, translating program, event and communication materials into the most frequently spoken languages and provide additional language translation services upon request. 2.7 Pursue opportunities for alternative outreach and education to diverse groups, such as piloting youth joarks stewardship jorc)grarns and active cc)rTirnunicatic)n thirc)ugh Faith loased girc)ujos and ncm jorc)fit organizations that work with minority and underserved communities. 2.8 Continue to implement signage and information in multiple languages at parks and trails, and include information about amenities, etiquette, trail length, difficulty, i-naterial/accessibility. 2.9 Prioritize park and recreation investments in underserved communities to improve equitable access to public amenities. 2.10 Identify appropriate locations within parks and public spaces for the installation of public art, interpretive signs or cultural displays while ensuring that these features are incorporated through a diversity, equity and inclusion lens. 319 Goal 3: Maintain Woodburn parks and recreation facilities to ensure longevity of assets, a positive aesthetic and sensory experience, preservation of habitat and natural systems, and safety for park patrons. 3.1 Maintain all parks and facilities in a manner that keeps them in safe and attractive condition; repair or remcwe damaged cc)rrilocments Immediately ujoc)n identi(icaticm. 3.2 Maintain an inventory of assets and their condition; update the inventory as assets are added, updated or removed from the system and periodically assess the condition of park and recreation facilities and infrastructure. Integrate needed replacements into capital planning. 3.3 Conduct regular safety inspections of play equipment and play safety surfacing. Schedule replacement of older play equipment to upgrade & update play experiences and assure safe play environments. 3.4 Seek opportunities to eliminate Ibarriers at existing facilities and prepare a city-wide AD Transition Plan for park and recreation assets with Ibudget allocations for annual ADD upgrades. 3.5 Standardize the use of graphics and signage to establish a consistent identity at all parks and facilities. ncc)rjoc)rate intc) a signage and wayfinding 101an. 3.6 Standardize park furnishings and amenities (trash cans, tables, Ibernches, fencing) to reduce inventory and replacement costs and improve appearance of, and maintenance consistency within the park system. 3.7 1 )evel(::)Io city c)wned c)r maintained joark sites based cm site specific rnaster plans c)r c)ther adc)joted strategies to ensure joarks reflect cxal needs, cc)rni-nunity injout, recreaticmal and ccmservatic)n gc)als, and available financial resc)urces. 3.8 Incorporate sustainable development and low impact design practices into the design, planning, and rehabilitation of new and existing facilities. 3.9 Utilize, as appropriate, native and lower resource requiring vegetation for landscaping in parks and city owned properties to minimize maintenance requirements, conserve water, reduce the need for fertilizer, provide native habitat for wildlife, and control invasive vegetation. 3.10 Develop tree planting guidelines and protocols to determine planting locations and species selection to foster resilient plant communities that can recover from disturbances and adapt to climate change and its irrijoacts, such as fc)rest fire and dirc)ught. 3.11 Improve tree management policies and practices and promote tree retention and succession. 3.12 Anticipate global climate change and foster climate -resilient landscapes in parks and open space areas. Assess greenway cc)rridc)r facilities fc)i, jocAential fIc)c)d tcflerant design tc) reduce reccwery times and joc)tential (Ic)c)d damage tc) trails and joark amenities. 3.13 Promote environmental learning through interpretive signage programs in City parks and preserves, Including native plant identi(icatic)n signs In and arcwnd restc)ratic)n orc)jects In city joarks. 320 Goal 4: Provide a diversity of parks, recreation facilities and open space and a balance of opportunities for of passive and active recreation that meet the needs of different age groups, abilities, and interests. 4.1 Provide a distributed park and open space system, such that all residents live within a'/2-mile access of a park, trail or open space. 4.2 Identify and prioritize lands for inclusion in the park and open space system Ibased on factors such as contribution to level of service, known service gaps, connectivity, preservation and scenic or recreational opportunities for residents. 4.3 Evaluate older, existing parks for opportunities to upgrade and increase amenities to expand outdoor recreation experiences and serve wider user types. Revive aging park infrastructure to improve current facilities. 4.4 Pursue use or development agreements, easements, fee simple purchases or other arrangements to secure suitable locations for new parks and trails to serve existing and future residents. 4.5 Prioritize facility development Ibased on demonstrated demand, population served, local user appeal, fiscal c)jojoc)rtunity and revenue -generating potential. 4.6 Plan for a range of play types, universal access and a phasing plan when replacing or upgrading playground equipment. 4.7 Pursue opportunities to add an additional "clestination playground" or a "boundless playground" to the park system. 4.8 Develop a wider variety of recreatic)n c)jo joc)rtu n i ties and jolan fc)r sjoc)rt fields, cc)urts and specialized recreational facilities (e.g., pump track, splash pad, off -leash area, disc golf, etc.) with consideration of local needs, partner support/capacity, recreational trends, and availability of similar facilities within the city and region. 4.9 Consider incorporating alternative sport opportunities for youth and adults in the park system such as disc golf, futsal, bouldering, parkour, and other non -team physical activities. 4.10 Pursue opportunities to create an outdoor events/community gathering space to host community -wide events. 4.11 Integrate public art and park design from the onset of facility planning to create compelling, engaging, and captivating public places. Prioritize experiences that are interactive and allow for dynamic sensory exploration. 4.12 Provide environmental education opportunities in open space areas with creative and interactive interpretation strategies, such as hands-on displays, self -guided walks, and other engaging experiences. 321 III Jill III 1 11111 1 11 Jill III illirlillill lipill I Jill 1� I and public amenities. 5.1 Pursue the completion of the Mill Creek Greenway Master Plan. 5.2 Prioritize trail projects that address gaps between existing paths, create longer, more usable connections, and improve safety. 5.3 Work with City departments and community groups to ensure safe pedestrian access across physical barriers tc) parks and reciii facilities. il)irate traffic calil strategies at access oc)iints tc) IDail c)loein sloace, and trailheads. incc)i-loc)irate traffic calil desigin techniques ill desigin guidelines, as appropriate. 5.4 Integrate the planning for and prioritization of recreational trails with the City's Transportation Master F11ail utilizing the classificaticms and cc)iIal aligini-neints loiId within this F11ain. 5.5 Continue to integrate the siting of proposed trail segments into the development review process; require development projects along designated trail routes to Ibe designed to incorporate trail segments as part of the project. 5.6 Connect trails to nearby sidewalk facilities, wherever feasible, to facilitate the use of the off-street trail systems for non -motorized transportation and recreation. Where sidewalks are an integrated component of a trail system, sidewalks may Ibe needed and should Ibe designed to accommodate multiple uses. 5.7 Establish a maximum spacing standard for trail linkages within new residential developments, such that multiple entry points to a trail corridor are provided to improve access and convenience for residents. 5.8 Coordinate construction of trail projects with other capital improvement projects including utility and transportation projects. 5.9 Support the implementation of the Marion County Transportation System Plan for pedestrian and Ibicycle connections and coordinate with County to provide coordinated trail alignments that enable continuous walking and Ibiking access between major local parks and other key destinations. 5.10 Work with regional agencies, utilities and private landholders to secure trail rights -of -way and easements and access to open space for trail connections. 5.11 Furnish trail systems with appropriate supporting trailhead improvements that may include interpretive and directory signage systems, rest stops, drinking fountains, restrooms, parking and loading areas, water, and other services. 5.12 Where appropriate, locate trailheads at or in conjunction with park sites, schools, and other community facilities to increase local area access to the trail system and reduce duplication of supporting improvements. 5.13 Develop and implement a system of signs (e.g., trailhead, etiquette, directional, mile markers, emergency location markers, etc.) to mark trails and non -motorized routes that coordinates with the City's stireetscaloe and full standards and wayfinding siginage loili in accc)i-daince with loest practices. 5.14 Create maps and guides with a universal graphic style for parks, trails, recreation facilities, and natural areas. 322 GOALS ft OBJECTIVES I'll, "Nfl mw . . . . .. . .. . . .. . . Goal 6: Provide a varied and inclusive suite of recreation opportunities and experiences to promote health and wellness, year-round activity', and social engagement. 6.1 Provide a variety of recreational programs that meet the community's demands for swimming and aquatic activities, sports, and other activities. 6.2 Strategically expand and enhance the diversity of recreation programs offered, considering programs that are in high demand, serve a wide range of users, utilize the City's unique indoor and c)utdc)c)r assets, and cc)rnjolernent services c)f cAher jorc)viders as facilities, staffing levels and IDartner opportunities allow. 6.3 1 everage City resources loy fc)rrning and maintaining partnerships with c)ther joublic, nc)n jorcffit, and private organizations to deliver recreation services and secure access to existing facilities for community recreation. 6.4 Periodically evaluate recreation program offerings in terms of attendance, current trends, customer satisfaction, cost -to -subsidy, and availability of similar programs through other providers and make adjustments as necessary. 6.5 Provide and develop additional amenities, multi -purpose facilities, and centers that support and accommodate Ibroad recreational usage; Construct a new community recreation center. 6.6 Periodically review and update the fee policy for programs, indoor facility uses and rental rates that support operational requirements and are measured against cost recovery goals. 6.7 Maintain and enhance program scholarships and other mechanisms to support recreation access for low-income residents. 6.8 Monitor local and regional recreation trends to ensure community needs and interests are addressed �by available programming. 6.9 Foster the City's role as a convener of artists, arts organizations, and community groups to facilitate cc)IIaIoc)rati(::)n and efficiently serve the cc)rTirnunity thirc)ugh arts and culture jorc)grarns and experiences. 6.10 Partner with the community and local organizations to foster a variety of cultural events and support community cultural celebrations. 6.11 Identify and implement opportunities for integrating arts and culture into parks and open space, including, where feasible and appropriate, through permanent and temporary public art installations, arts performance and events, interpretive strategies, and other dynamic expressions. 6.12 Encourage the collaboration of arts and culture marketing and communication efforts through shared event calendars, social media management, and other cohesive strategies. 323 Goal 7: Provide clear leadership through exceptional management, partnerships, collaborations, and agreements that supports and promotes park, recreation, and open space system. 7.1 Assign responsibility and time frames and allocate resources necessary to complete each action identified in annual wc::)rk plans. 7.2 Flursue sufficient financial resources to ensure a vibrant and well -maintained parks and recreation system and alk:)cate adequate funding fc::)i- maintenance, staffing and asset Dreservatic::m. 7.3 Identify and irrilolernent partnerships with c::Aher loulolic, orivate, nc::)n orc::)fit, and cc::)rnrnunity organizations to support capital projects, community events, programs, and other special initiatives. 7.4 Expand and promote a volunteer program to include recruiting, training, retaining, and rewarding volunteers in all program areas. 7.5 Continue to collaborate with developers for future park, facility or trail projects to meet the goals of this Plan. 7.6 Continue to develop a strong working relationship with the Police Department to ensure regular patrolling of parks and facilities, quick response times. 7.7 Explore "Park Ambassador" or adopt -a -park pr(::)grarns t(::) hello with loark maintenance, beautificatic::m, and civic pride. 7.8 Create an annual "Sponsorship Manual" listing all the opportunities for the year and distribute within the community in a menu format that creates a sense of urgency within the Ibusiness community. 7.9 Create and work with a Parks and Recreation Foundation to facilitate the receipt of grant funds and to conduct other fundraising activities. 7.10 Pursue alternative funding options and dedicated revenues, such as private donations, sponsorships, partnerships, and grants, along with support through partnerships with service organizations, volunteer groups, Ibusirnesses and other agencies. 7.11 Stay abreast of Ibest practices in technology and implement systems and tools to improve customer service and suloloc::)rt efficient c::)Ioeratk:)ns. 7.12 Invest in professional development opportunities that strengthen the core skills and commitment from staff, :::;c::)ard rnernbers and key w:flunteers, tc::) include trainings, materials and/c::)ir affiliatk:)n with relevant national and regional associations. 7.13 Periodically update the Park Improvement Plan to address facility improvement needs. 7.14 Periodically review and update the Park System Development Charges and methodology and utilize SD Cs to accommodate growth through the expansion of the recreation system. 7.15 Update the Parks and Recreation Master Plan periodically and approximately every ten years to ensure facilities and services meet current and future community needs and maintain eligibility for State grants. 324 apter CAPITAL PLANNING IMPLEMENTATION The f6lHlowing is a summary of key project recommendations which wollll require commitment from the Doty and its residents for the continued support a Ihaalltlhy park and recreation systarn that preserves and enhances the safety, Ilivaabihty and character of the Woodburn community. By securing new parklands through recent developer agreements, the City is poised to implement phased development of Dove (Landing and Boones Crossing Darks that will offer residents a more diverse range of recreational experiences. Additionally, planned renovations to Settlemier Park as part of the design layout for a new community center will create an attractive destination and engage future park Users. Considering local needs for types of park facilities and national trends, new park designs should include some of the following amenities, in addition to always supporting walking trails: IN Inclusive, boundless, or destination playgrounds, • Splash pack/water play, • (Picnic areas for small group gatherings, • Sport. courts, including ffu.atsal and pickleball, and • Off -leash dog areas. Several parks have aging infrastructure that warrants upgrades. As older benches and tables are replaced, they should be re -installed with ADA-compliant versions that also include accessible routes to at least halt of the furnishings per park. The City should upgrade playground experiences with new equipment and safety surfacing at sites including I< udingham, North Front Street and Nelson Darks. Also, the sport courts at Centennial and Nelson Darks should be resurfaced and re -striped for safer play. Other projects may include adding amenities to existing parks, such as picnic shelters for small gatherings and paved pathway connections to improve User circulation and ADA-compliant routes. A general consideration for the public is to create a park system that provided year- round facilities for all ages and all abilities to gather and recreate in diverse range of safe, clean and well - maintained park facilities that also balance fiscal stability. ,,, �� 325 �% Renovations to existing Aquatic Center is necessary for proper maintenance, to extend service life and to improve accessibility and usage. The City should proceed with a roof replacement and HVAC upgrade for the Aquatic Curter. Also, building on the local interest and momentum for a community center at Settlemier Park, the City should continue to pursue financing options to facilitate construction in the near -term. The new center will greatly expand the City"s capacity to gaffer and program indoor recreation for athletics, fitness, classes and community activities for all ages and abilities. Trail connections, including sidewalk and bike laries improvements, are needed to help link destinations across Woodburn. Acquiring additional lands, easements, arid/ or rights -of -way for the expansion of the trail network are necessary and should be coordinated with the City"s Public Works Department and Marlon County. Priority trail segments should include the planned additional phases of the Mill Creek GUeenway Trail, as well as linkages that extend existing routes or create looped routes. One potential extended loop route could connect the Mill Creek GUeenway Trail along the Smith Creek trail to Centennial Park to Hermanson Pond. The City also should continue to review, comment and coordinate with the Community Development Department on local land development applications to facilitate the inclusion of pedestrian and bicycle routes that connect to the conceptual trail network. The acquisition of additional neighborhood parks is necessary to address existing gaps in park services in Woodburn and in anticipation of future growth. As land development continues, opportunities to acquire large park sites will be more difficult and require Woodburn to follow an intentional acquisition program, as well as think creatively and foster partnerships to provide desired public parkland with sufficient room for park amenities. To implement the acquisition program, the City may need to actively search out potential locations and property owners to secure future park sites, ahead of or concurrent with anticipated new development. Additionally, the City should continue to coordinate with local residential developers to include public parks in new subdivisions and Utilize tools, such as system development charges, to facilitate the process. Minor improvements to access, such as providing ramped entrances to playgrounds or stable surface access to site furnishings, are necessary to conform to the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and ensure universal accessibility. The site assessment summaries and the capital project list identified and includes upgrades to remove barriers and improve universal access. in general, the City should make improvements to existing parks as needed to ensure proper mainteria ce, usability, accessibility, and quality of park features and grounds. 326 Parlks, traiills, and other publliic open spaces are the priimary targets for uniifyiing the urban envlronment iinto a cohesilve, accessiibl�e, and connected communiity through an ildentilfiIabl�e wayfinding program. The City currently uses a varilety of parlk iidentilfilcatilon siigns, which lack a unilfyilng ildentilty. Tb cllarilfy ownership and the managiing agency, the Ciity should instaIJ addiitiionall, graphically -unified angina to help users navlgate the outdoor recreatiion experiiences offered by the Ciity. Siignage should be iinstalllled at Ikey traiI nodes and alI Ciity parks (priimary and secondary entry poiints) to iincllude directionW and miilleage iinformatiion, ante and system maps, uniique features, and user etiiquette iinformatiion. The new signage iinstalIlIed as part of the Smilth Creelk greenway and parlk space pro\Ades a good exampl�e of clear siignage the Ciity could iimpl�ement across the parlk system. Pairk Capital Improvement Planning I In R::)ll(::)wing Flark lmlorc:wernent FIlan (1::111::') identifies the park, trail, and facility projects considered for the next ten years, along with Ibrief project descriptions. The majority of these projects entail the maintenance, acquisition, and development of parks, recreational amenities, and trails. Based on survey results and other feedback, Woodburn residents have indicated an interest in park facility upgrades and enhanced trail connections as priorities, and the Flark IrTilorc:weiTient FIlan is reflective c::)f that desire. The following table summarizes the aggregate capital estimates Iby park types for the next ten years. Figure 23. 10 Year Capital Project Expenditures _$6,046,000 $4,565,000 The following Park Improvement Plan provides Ibrief project descriptions and sequencing to assist staff in preparing future capital Ibudget requests. As projects are phased over the next ten or more years, the planning -level project costs have been inflated at an increase c::)f 6% annually. Overall, the inflated cc::)sts R::)ir lorc::)jects identified in the FIIIFI tc::)tal over $92 million. The proposed project list focuses primarily on improving existing facilities through timely repairs, replacements, and upgrades to ensure an ongoing, healthy, and safe recreation system for Woodburn. IIII Ac(0.iisi"pal oins iiiiiii l�) a ii- ll< II:: ) e v e l o 113 rn e in t iiiiiii l�)Iaininiing Reinovatioin m l umalillc im Recireatioin Il::acikties 327 Woodburn Parks & Recreation 10-Year Park Improvement Plan Inflation factor of 6%added to outgoing years to address rising rates and construction costs (rounded to 51000). PARK IMPROVEMENTS Boones Crossing Park Park development Phase I D $450,000 $477,000 $477,000 Park development Phase 11 D $750,000 $1,195,000 $1,195,000 Burlingham Park Improvement planning P $10,000 $11,000 $11,000 Rebuild existing shelter R $65,000 $77,000 $77,000 Paved loop trail -connect all amenities and side entries D $125,000 $149,000 $149,000 Play equipment upgrade & playground surfacing D $240,000 $286,000 $286,000 Restroom & drinking fountain D $800,000 $953,000 $953,000 Interactive play feature D $100,000 $119,000 $119,000 Sport court resurfacing R $90,000 $107,000 $107,000 Soccer field upgrade R $45,000 $54,000 $54,000 Centennial Park Dog off -leash area (OLA) upgrades R $125,000 $133,000 $133,000 Parking lot repairs R $100,000 $106,000 $106,000 Restroom upgrade R $50,000 $53,000 $53,000 Sports field improvments D $900,000 $1,136,000 $1,136,000 Sports court resurfacing & lighting R $300,000 $379,000 $379,000 Dove Landing Dog Park (drinking fountain, shelter, play features, irrigation, fencing, concrete entry) D $200,000 $268,000 $268,000 Paved pump track (small and large) D $600,000 $803,000 $803,000 Playground Surfacing D $120,000 $161,000 $161,000 Irrigation extension D $60,000 $80,000 $80,000 Heritage Park Playground replacement, safety surfacing & improved access R $180,000 $214,000 $214,000 Connecting paved pathway (Lexington Ct. to Jamestown St.) D $30,000 $36,000 $36,000 Sport court resurfacing & striping D $45,000 $54,000 $54,000 ADA-compliant picnic table & bench D $12,000 $14,000 $14,000 Hermanson Park Playground replacement, safety surfacing & improved access R $190,000 $240,000 $240,000 Paved loop trail - connect all amenities to Trail D $20,000 $25,000 $25,000 Hermanson Pond Paved trail upgrade R $80,000 $90,000 $90,000 Viewing platform access improvements R $30,000 $34,000 $34,000 Legion Park Expand & improve parking areas D $500,000 $562,000 $562,000 Park and playground improvments D $125,000 $133,000 $133,000 North Front St Park Playground replacement & playground surfacing R $190,000 $240,000 $240,000 Paved interior loop trail & connecting pathway (N. Front St. to N. 1st St.) D $80,000 $101,000 $101,000 Sport court D $70,000 $88,000 $88,000 Nelson Park Paved loop trail, plus connect all amenities & side entries D $100,000 $119,000 $119,000 Playground replacement & playground surfacing R $190,000 $226,000 $226,000 Replace shelter D $60,000 $71,000 $71,000 Sport court resurfacing & striping D $45,000 $54,000 $54,000 Senior Estates Park Exercise stations D $60,000 $80,000 $80,000 Picnic tables & benches (ADA-compliant) D $15,000 $20,000 $20,000 Settlemier Park Sports court complex (replaces ballfield) D $1,250,000 $1,578,000 $1,578,000 Skate park upgrade R $500,000 $631,000 $631,000 Restroom replacement R $600,000 $757,000 $757,000 Replace shelter R $250,000 $316,000 $316,000 Expand parking lot D $500,000 $631,000 $631,000 Destination / boundless playground (inclusive) D $750,000 $947,000 $947,000 328 Wyffels Park Riparian restoration R $200,000 $238,000 $238,000 Systemwide Wayfinding & signage D $100,000 $40,000 $30,000 $30,000 $100,000 Shade trees & tree replacement R $70,000 $15,000 $15,000 $15,000 $15,000 $10,000 $70,000 Security or low-level lighting R $150,000 $30,000 $30,000 $30,000 $30,000 $30,000 $150,000 Additional ADA Improvements D $150,000 $25,000 $25,000 $25,000 $25,000 $25,000 $25,000 $150,000 Minor repairs & renovations R $450,000 $50,000 $50,000 $50,000 $50,000 $50,000 $200,000 $450,000 Total Park Improvements $12,122,000 $1,017,000 $847,000 $2,921,000 $7,189,000 $1,532,000 $1,460,000 $14,966,000 FACILITY PROJECTS Woodburn Aquatic Center Spray features & water slides D $400,000 $400,000 $400,000 Roof repair & replacement R $150,000 $189,000 $189,000 Ceiling repair & paint R $45,000 $54,000 $54,000 HVAC system upgrade R $150,000 $179,000 $179,000 Pool re -plaster (multiple tanks) R $175,000 $208,000 $208,000 Re -tile pool area R $75,000 $89,000 $89,000 Replace storefront doors/windows R $36,000 $45,000 $45,000 Woodburn Community Center Center Design P $1,000,000 $1,000,000 $1,000,000 Woodburn Community Center Center construction D $60,000,000 $2,500,000 $12,500,000 $30,000,000 $15,000,000 $60,000,000 Total Facilities Projects $62,031,000 $3,500,000 $12,900,000 $30,530,000 $15,234,000 $0 $0 $62,164,000 PARK ACQUISITIONS (* Acquisition target areas are estimations and will require due diligence & negotiation with current landowners) Neighborhood Park Acquisition in SW area (A) A $800,000 $899,000 $899,000 Acquisition in SW area (B) A $800,000 $953,000 $953,000 Acquisition in SE area (C) A $1,000,000 $1,594,000 $1,594,000 Acquisition in E area (D) A $1,000,000 $1,338,000 $1,338,000 Acquisition in NW area (E) A $1,000,000 $1,262,000 $1,262,000 Total Park Acquisitions $4,600,000 $0 $899,000 $953,000 $1,262,000 $1,338,000 $1,594,000 $6,046,000 TRAILS Mill Creek Greenway (MCG) Trail Acquisitions for MCG Trail alignment A $600,000 $200,000 $200,000 $200,000 $600,000 Mill Creek Greenway Oregon Community Pathways grant for trail construction D $1,932,369 $500,000 $500,000 $500,000 $250,000 $182,369 $1,932,369 MCG Trailhead upgrades Add restrooms, lighting, drinking fountains, bike racks D $700,000 $500,000 $500,000 Centennial to Hermanson Trail Acquisitions for alignment A $400,000 $476,000 $476,000 Trail construction D $1,500,000 $2,391,000 $2,391,000 Hermanson Pond Hermanson Trail connections westward to Brown Street connections (OCP funds) D $400,000 $400,000 $400,000 Settlemier Park Trail construction (OCP funds) D $250,000 $250,000 $250,000 Wyffels Park Trail construction (OCP funds) D $250,000 $250,000 $250,000 Trail System Acquisitions/Easements Acquisitions or easements to support conceptual trail alignments A $2,000,000 $500,000 $500,000 $500,000 $500,000 $2,000,000 Trail System Management Pavement & surfacing repairs or rehabilitations R $250,000 $30,000 $30,000 $30,000 $160,000 $250,000 Total Trail Projects $8,282,369 $700,000 $900,000 $1,956,000 $1,530,000 $912,369 $3,051,000 $9,049,369 Total CIP Projects $87,035,369 $5,217,000 $15,546,000 $36,360,000 $25,215,000 $3,782,369 $6,105,000 $92,225,369 Acquisition A NOTES: Planning/Permitting P This list identifies planning -level cost estimates and does not assume the value of volunteer or other non -City contributions. Renovation/Repair R Detailed emgineering, design and/or costing may be necessary for projects noted. Development/Expansion D This list is not an official budget and is intended as a guiding document for City staff in the preparation of departmental budgets. 329 A number of strategies exist to enhance and expand park and recreation service delivery for the City of Woodburn; however, clear decisions must Ibe made in an environment of competing interests and limited resources. A strong community will is necessary to Ibring many of the projects listed in this Plan to life, and the Woodburn City Council has demonstrated its willingness in the past to support parks and recreation and a high quality of life for local residents. The recommenclations for park and recreation services noted in this Plan may trigger the need for funding Ibeyoncd current allocations and for additk:)nal staffing, c::)1oerati(::)ns and maintenance responsibilities. Given that the operating and capital Ibudget of the Community Services I )e1oartirrient is finite, additk:)nal resc::)urces may be needed to leverage, supplement, and support the implementation of proposed objectives, programs, and orc::)jects. While grants and c::)ther efficiencies may help, these alone will not Ibe enough to realize many ideas and projects noted in this Plan, especially regarding the construction of a community center. The following recommenclations and strategies are presented to offer near -term direction to realize these projects and as a means to continue dialogue between City leadership, local residents, and partners. The tools presented only capture development of the capital improvements and not the long-term operations of the new assets. Additionally, a review of potential implementation tools is included as Appendix G, which addresses 1(::)cal Financing, Federal and state grant and conservation programs, acquisition methods and others. Enhanced LocA Funding The City of Woodburn could explore a variety of local funding options for parks and recreation acquisition, development, operations and maintenance. The likelihood of success for local funding options depends on the community's willingness and ability to pay additional property taxes or fees to support higher levels of parks and recreation services. According to the City Ibudget, Woodburn maintains reserve debt capacity for local Iboncds and voter approved debt. The potential to Ibuncdle several projects from the Park Improvement Plan or take advantage of unforeseen opportunities, such as acquisitions, may warrant a review of debt implications and operating costs for the City, along with the need to conduct polling of voter support for such projects. General Obligation (G.O.) Bonds R:) Finance a Iarge capital orc::)ject, such as a community center, the City explore the use and timing of G.O. bonds, which are debt instruments sold Iby the City to fund new parks and recreation facilities or to make improvements to existing facilities. Bonds are repaid with property tax revenue generated Iby a special levy that is outside the limits imposed Iby Iballot Measures #5 (1990) and #50 (1997). Voters must approve G.O. Bond sales either in a General Election, or in another election in which a minimum of 50% of registered voters participate. G.O. Bond revenues may not Ibe used for operations, maintenance or repairs, Ibut they may Ibe used for renovations to existing facilities. I Ocal Option I evies I ocal option levies are separate property tax levies that can Ibe assessed to fund capital improvements or operations and maintenance activities. Such levies are outside of the City's permanent tax rate limit, subject to the combined rate limit imposed under Measure #5. 1 ocal option levies require voter approval and are subject to the double majority (50% voter turnout and 50% approval) requirement of Measure #5. If used to fund capital improvements, revenues can Ibe used to secure Iboncds or complete one or more projects on a pay-as-you-go Ibasis, over a period of up to 10 years. Operations and maintenance levies are limited tc::) a oerk:)d c::)F five years. Flarks Utility F�'ee A parks utility fee is an ongoing fee (often Ibilled monthly) that provides revenue for the needs of the park system. When charged Iby a city, such a fee can Ibe an additional line item on an existing utility bill. The revenue received can Ibe used for both operational and capital needs, and it can Ibe pledged to the debt service of revenue bonds. Establishment of a parks utility fee in Oregon requires compliance with legal requirements at both state and local levels. Several jurisdictions across Oregon have implemented and utilized a parks utility fee as supplemental funding to maintain and enhance their park systems. Woodburn could consider enacting a parks utility fee for the purpose of providing for the operation and maintenance of parks and facilities within the City and to ensure adequate resources are available for the sound and timely maintenance of existing recreation amenities. 330 System Development Charges (SIDCs) Park System Development Charges (SDCs) are fees paid Iby new development to meet the increased demand for parks resulting from the new growth. SDCs can only Ibe used for parkland acquisition, planning and/or development. They cannot Ibe used for operations and maintenance of parks and facilities. The City of Woodburn currently assesses a Parks System Development Charges (SD ) on new residential development to assist with the cost of improvements needed to accommodate new growth. The City should prioritize the usage of Parks Sl )Cs tc) secure new loark orc)loerties and Finance park or path/trail development consistent with the priorities within this Plan. Also, the City should periodically update the methodology and rate structure, as appropriate, to Ibe Ibest positioned to cflotain future acquisitic)n and develc)lornent financing from residential development. Parkland Donations & Dedications I and donations from development projects, individuals, or conservation organizations could occur to complement the acquisition of park and open space lands across Woodburn. Gift deeds or bequests from philanthropic -minded landowners could allow for lands to come into City ownership upon the death of the owner or as a tax-deductible charitable donation. The Department should vet any potential dedications to ensure that such land is located in an area of need and can Ibe developed with site amenities appropriate for the projected use of the property. Grants & Appropriations Several state, federal and private grant programs are available on a competitive Ibasis, including those offered Iby the Oregon State Parks & Recreation Department (such as the I and and Water Conservation Fund). Pursuing grants is not a panacea for park system funding, since grants are oc)th cc)rnloetitive and c)ften require a significant percentage of local funds to match the request to the granting agency, which depending on the grant program can Ibe as much as 50% of the total project �budget. Woodburn should continue to leverage its local resources to the greatest extent Iby pursuing grants independently and in cooperation with other local partners. Appropriations from state or federal sources, though rare, can supplement projects with partial funding. State and federal funding allocations are particularly relevant on regional transportation projects, and the likelihood for appropriations could Ibe increased if multiple partners are collaborating on projects Internal) Project Coordination & Collaboration Internal coordination with the Public Works and Community Development Departments can increase the potential of discrete actions toward the implementation of the proposed trail and path network, which relies heavily on street right-of-way enhancements, and in the review of development applications with consideration toward potential property acquisition areas, planned path corridors, and the need for easement or set -aside requests. However, to expand the extent of the park system and recreation programs, additional partnerships and collaborations should Ibe considered. �MM Public -private partnerships are increasingly necessary for local agencies to leverage their limited resources in providing park and recreation services to the community. Corporate sponsorships, health organization grants, stewardship programs and nc)n lorcffit c)rganizaticms are just a few exarriloles c)f partnerships where collaboration provides value to both partners. The City has existing partners and should continue to explore additional and expanded partnerships, where feasible, to help implement these Plan recommendations, Coordination with the Boys and Girls Club, Woodburn School District, YMCA and other private recreation providers should Ibe ongoing to assess the range and type of recreation programs offered in the City and to maximize use of community facilities, such as fields, sloc)rt cc)urts, gyrninasiurns, and other indoor spaces. The City may need to Find and cc)c)rdinate with c)ther recreatic)n Orc)grarn vendors for new programs and services to meet the interests of the community and address current gaps in program coverage. Hleall-th IBeine-fift Partnerships Woodburn also should explore partnership opportunities with regional health care providers and services, such as Salem Health Medical Clinic, I egacy Medical Group and the Marion County Health & Human Services Department, to further promote wellness activities, healthy living, and 331 cc..)rnrnunicati(..)ns aloc)ut the benefits c::)f loarks and recreation. For example, this group could more directly cross -market services and help expand communications about local wellness options, and they could sponsor a series of organized trail walks through Woodburn as a means to expand public awareness of local trail opportunities and encourage residents tc::) stay fit. ::::�c::)ir exarrilole, c::)ther cc::)rn rn u n i ties have Ibeen successful with funding requests to regional hospitals for the development and printing of community walking guides that highlight the health benefits c::)f walking and include trail system maps and descriptions. Volunteer & Community -based Action Successful volunteer efforts — through volunteer groups, students, neighborhood groups, or sport and service c::)rganizati(::)ns . can result in significant site improvements and can allow community members to gain a sense of ownership in the parks and recreation system. Volunteers and community groups already contribute to a variety of community programs and events, such as youth sport or aquatics support, at the I ibrary, and special events like Fiesta Mexicana. The City could engage volunteers in additional park and recreation projects like tree plantings, trail maintenance, park clean- ups, and other small works or volunteer -appropriate projects. Woodburn currently maintains a webpage of volunteer -appropriate projects, which should continue to Ibe updated and promoted through the website and social media platforms and via partnerships with school district. While supporting organized groups and community - minded individuals adds value to the Woodburn parks and recreation system, volunteer coordination requires a substantial amount of staff time. Additional resources may Ibe necessary to expand volunteer coordination to more fully utilize the community's willingness to support park and recreation efforts. Other Implementation'Tools Appendix G identifies c::Aher irnlolernentatk:)n tools, such as voter -approved funding, grants and acquisition tactics, that the City could utilize to further the implementation of the projects noted in the Park Improvement Plan projects I ist. 332 333 334 i-ty of Woodburn -Ia I<.s & -dc:hci (.mtioiq IVlastc:hr -plaiq To: Jesse Cuomo, Director, Community Services Department From: Steve Duh, Conservation Technix, Inc. Date: July 24, 2023 Re: Woodburn Parks & Recreation Master Plan Community Survey Summary Results ulz;uge 1 Conservation Technix is pleased to present the results of a survey of the general population of the City of Woodburn that assesses residents' recreational needs and priorities. Woodburn ire.slicdeints .s�tiroinSlly valluue th61r 1pairll<.s and irecird.:.,a loin faclillh lie.s�. Nearly all respondents (96%) think parks and recreation are important or essential to quality of life in Woodburn. Very few, about 3%, feel they are useful, but not necessary, or not important at all. R: eslicdeints vdslit Woodburn 1pairll<.sfire.: quuein lly to 1pairfiiclilpate liim a irainge ofactkdtlie.s. Residents of Woodburn frequently use the City's parks and recreation facilities, with more than four in ten visiting at least once a week, if not every day. The most common reasons for park visits included walking or running, using a playground, walking a dog, and for fitness or exercise. \/VNille ire.slicdeints 1pirlioirli lize in aua imtaliimliimg exsUling 1pairll<.s and fabl lh lie.s, they aire geineiraIIIIy suuplpoirUk/e of liinr pirovding the Oi�ty''.s 1pairll< and irecird.:.,a loin system as W1d41�. Woodburn residents, when asked about the overall condition of the parks they have visited, shared a positive view with 79% of responses being fair to excellent, leaving 14% stating poor condition and 7% with no opinion. Although there is a positive perception of the maintenance condition of parks, the community desires more amenities and park upgrades, with only 57% of respondents being satisfied to very satisfied with Woodburn's parks, recreation facilities and open spaces. Overall, survey respondents would like to see the City prioritize: Park Upgrades: When asked to prioritize potential improvements, community members ranked improving and upgrading existing parks as their top priority. In other questions, they called for additional walking trails, picnic areas, playgrounds, and sport courts. In open-ended responses, community members also asked for additional amenities like covered basketball courts, pickleball courts, disc golf courses, skateparks, and picnic areas. Walking Trails: The community seeks an expansion of walking trails and the establishment of bike paths, emphasizing the importance of connectivity between parks. Residents also specifically requested better lighting along trails, wheelchair -friendly paths, and pet -friendly trails. • Park Maintenance and Safety: Community members cited maintenance and safety concerns as top reasons why they do not visit more often, and written comments expressed a desire for 335 -Ia ks & Idc:hci (.mtir..an IVIa.st(.:hr ::plan improved maintenance and safety in existing parks. They advocated for additional cleaning and trash removal in parks, repairs to broken equipment, and increased lighting and enforcement of park rules. SLIRVIEY II I.::1F1 DI::)U...OGY In close collaboration with City of Woodburn staff, Conservation Technix developed the 16-question survey that was estimated to take less than ten minutes to complete. The mail survey was available in English and Spanish, and the cover letter accompanying the printed survey was written in both languages and included unique OR codes to access each in -language survey online. The City mailed 2,500 surveys to randomly chosen households in Woodburn on March 16, 2023, of which 262 surveys were completed and returned (10.5% response rate, 5% margin of error). Residents who did not receive a mail survey were able to complete the survey online. Online versions of the survey in English, Spanish and Russian were posted to the City's website on March 27th. An additional 256 surveys were completed from the general, community -wide online surveys. In all, 518 surveys were collected, which includes 44 Spanish surveys. The survey was closed on June 3, 2023, and the full dataset was compiled and reviewed. Information about the survey was promoted through several channels, including on the City's website, through multiple social media postings, and through direct outreach to partner organizations and recreation program participants. Although households were randomly chosen to receive the mail survey, respondents were not necessarily representative of all city residents. Mail survey responses underrepresent residents under 35 years of age and over -represent residents over the age of 65. See Figure 1 below for age demographics for the mail and online surveys, as well as comparative percentages for Woodburn's population. See page 12 for other demographic subgroup data comparisons. Figure 1. Age demographics of survey respondents This report includes findings of community opinions based on the combined responses from the mail survey and online. Each section also notes key differences between different demographic groups and among responses to the online -only survey, where applicable. Percentages in the report may not add up to 100% due to rounding. 336 Q-ty Of 'WoodbuauIrIre -Ia k.s & [u - E:'c (. cltIori lVlast(.:'r -11an Usage and satisfaction of Ipairlks and Ireclrea�tlion facHli lies I loylrr Imuch do re.slicdQ.:.int.s value 1palrlk.s and recrea�tlioIn? Virtually all respondents (96%) feel that local parks and recreation opportunities are important or essential to the quality of life in Woodburn. Eighty-one percent of respondents overall feel that they are essential; while an additional 15% believe that they are important to quality of life, but not essential, see Figure 2. Only about 3% of respondents believe parks are useful, but not important, or not important. Online respondents more frequently rated parks and recreation opportunities as `essential' to Woodburn's quality of life as compared to mail respondents. lzige 3 :::igture 2A/B. When you think about what contributes to the quality of life in Woodburn, would you say public IDarks and recreation rrpportun Ities are... Combined results IIIIIIIII Essential to the quality of life here Illli Useful, but riot necessary Illllf Don't know IIIIIIIII Important, but riot really essential Not Important Residents of all ages value parks and recreation similarly — there were no significant differences between age groups. There were also no significant differences based on where respondents live or whether they had children in their home. Online survey respondents were slightly more likely to deem park and recreation opportunities as essential to quality of life than mail survey respondents. I lovlrr oftd.: in do re.slicdQ.: int.s use Oi�ty 1parks and recrea�tloin faclillli�tlie.s? Respondents were asked how often they visit a City park, recreation facility, or open space in a typical year. A plurality of respondents (43%) visit at least once a week, if not every day, see Figure 3. Another 29% visit one to three times per month, while about 19% visit a few times per year. About one in ten respondents (9%) do not visit a park at all. :::igure 3. In a typical year, how often do you visit oruse City of Woodburn (Darks, recreation Facilities or open spaces" Everyday 12°6 At: least once a week 31°� Iwo or more tames a month 19,6 About: once a month 10% Survey respondents showed a high use of parks Afew timesover the year 19% regardless of age and location of residence. Do not: visit: 9% Respondents without children at home were significantly more likely to visit every day, while Don't: know 1% those with children were more likely to visit at least once per week. Online respondents reported more frequent use than mail survey respondents. 337 i-ty Of 'Woodbuaulrin -Ia k.s & [u - E:'c (. cltIori lVlast(.:'r -11an VVNclh 1park do re.slicden�t.s vli.sli�t inr>os�t often? Respondents were asked, in an open-ended question, which local park they visit most frequently. Of the 399 responses, over 60% listed Centennial Park. Another 20% of respondents listed Legion Park, with smaller numbers mentioning the Woodburn Aquatic Center (11%), Settlemier Park (9%), and Senior Estates Park (7%). A few respondents listed Library Square, Hermanson Park, Burlingham Park, Smith Creek Park, Nelson Park, Downtown Plaza, and Heritage Park as their most frequented park locations, see Figure 4. Other City parks and facilities, including Wyffels Park, the Mill Creek Greenway Trail, Alvah Cowan Park, Dahlia Park, Hazel Smith Park, North Front Street Park, and Frank Scheer Locomotive Park, were not listed by any survey respondents. :::igure 4. Which (Dark OrFacility dry you visit most often"," (ripen ended) Centennial Park 511/6 Legion Park 20% Aquatic Center 11% Settlemier Park 9% Senior Estates Park 7% Library Square 3% Hermanson Park 3% Burlingham Park 2% Smith Creek Park 11/. Nelson Park 1% Downtown Plaza 1% Heritage Park 1% Why do re.slicdeint.s vli.sli�tWoo dlburim'.s parks and recrea loin faclillli�tlie.s? Respondents visit local parks and recreation facilities for a variety of reasons, but the most popular reason is to walk or run (69%). More than one in three respondents visit to use a playground (44%), walk a dog (42%), for fitness or exercise (40%), to relax (39%), or to attend community events or concerts (36%), see Figure 5. Between twenty and thirty percent of respondents visit for family gatherings, swimming, bike riding, or youth sports programs. Fewer than one in five respondents chose sports fields, wildlife viewing, sports courts, recreation programs, or the skate park as a primary reason why they visit local parks. Approximately one in twenty respondents identified an 'other' reason for visiting parks, such as to play pickleball or tennis, enjoy nature, or horseshoes. ::�igure 5. What would you say are the main reasons your household visits Woodburn parks and recreation facilities" Walking or running IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII Playgrounds IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 44% Dog walking or dog nark (IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 42% Fit / Exercise IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 40% Relaxation IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 39% Community events /concerts IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 36% Family gathering s/picnicking IIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIII 30% Swimming IIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIII 27% Bike riding IIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIII 23% Youth snort: programs IIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIII 21% Snort: fields IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 19% Wildlife viewing IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 190/ Out snort: courts 15% Recreation programs, classes or camas 12% Skate nark 8% N/A - I didn't: use any 6% 0t:her (please specify) 5% 69 The reasons for visiting city parks and recreation facilities varied slightly between mail and online respondents, with part of the difference attributable to the age group composition between the two. Online respondents were more inclined to visit city parks for most listed activities, including walking and running, playgrounds, sport fields and courts, and community events and festivals. Mail respondents were more likely to visit for wildlife viewing or to state that they didn't use parks. 338 i-ty of Woodbuaulrin -Iai k.s & Idc:hci c:h tif..an Ii I -plan y Respondents under the age of 44 were more likely than older residents to visit for playgrounds, youth programs, and skate parks. However, many activities, including running and walking, fitness or exercise, relaxation, dog walking, and community events are similarly popular across all age groups. Respondents with children in their home are more likely to visit parks to visit playgrounds, have family gatherings, participate in youth sports, swim, or use sports fields, compared to respondents without children in the home. Residents who live south of 214 were more likely than residents to the north of 214 to visit to use playgrounds, skate parks, or to ride a bike. Satisfaction with existing recreation and p,-)alrk� Aire Ire.sOeint.s .satll.s'fileCd Wldllrthl Woo db ulrn'.s Ireclyea lloln, pairk.s, and open .spaces? Most residents are somewhat to very satisfied with Woodburn's parks, recreation facilities, and open spaces (57%). However, more than one in three survey respondents (36%) are either somewhat or very dissatisfied in the city's park and recreation system, see Figure 6. :::igure:a S. Rate your households satisfaction with City of Woodburn's Darks, recreation Facilities, and ripen spaces. s0% 40% p�ggqql gpp�il a0% 20% There were no significant differences in 1.0% satisfaction between residents of various 0% ages, between those with versus those Verysatisfied Somewhat Somewhat Very Don't know :satisfied dissatisfied dissatisfied without children at home, or between residents living in various areas of the city. Online respondents had lower overall ratings of satisfaction than mail respondents. I loylrr v/diouullcd Ire.slicdQ.: int.s Irate the coin dli�tloin of 1pairlk.s thQ.:.,y have vli.sli�ted? Survey respondents have varying views on the condition of Woodburn's parks, as shown in Figure 7. While 44% of respondents rate the condition of parks they have visited as either excellent or good, 51% rate them as fair or poor. This may reflect a community desire for increased maintenance, cleanliness, and security within parks and/or community needs for additional park amenities, as expressed in other survey questions. : igure 7. 1 low would you rate the condition of Woodburn's parks you have visited"r' s0% 40% 30` IIII�II�II�IIII� 20% 10% Excellent Good Fair Boor Not Sure / No (DIainion Respondents who live north of 214 were significantly more likely than those to the south to rate the condition of City parks as 'poor'. There were no significant differences in how residents of various ages or household makeup rated the condition of the City's parks. 339 i-ty Of 'Woodbuaulrin -Ia ks & [u - E:'c (. cltIori IVIast(.:'r -11an W h y cd o im''t ire.s li cd e in t.s v li.s li t im o ire often? EMS When asked why they do not visit Woodburn's parks, recreation facilities, and open spaces more often, one quarter responded that they do visit often. However, similar numbers do not visit more because they feel parks are not well maintained (28%), don't feel safe in parks or facilities (27%), or because there are not enough restrooms (21%), see Figure 8. Seventeen percent don't know what is offered. Smaller percentages of respondents : gur e 3. Check Al I... the reasons why your household dries not use noted that parks are too crowded (13%), Woodbur�n's recreation Facilities, IDarks orripen spaces orattend have insufficient parking (13%), do not City events more often. (Check all that apply) have the right equipment (9%), are too far away (8%), or have accessibility Are .not well maintained iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiillillillillillillilliillillillilliillillillillillillilliillillillillillillilliillillillillillillilliillillillillillillillillillillilliillillillII28% barriers (3%) preventing them from Do not feel safe IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 27% visiting local parks more often. N/A.. I/we use them offer' iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiillillillillillillilliillillilillillillillillillillillillillillillillillillilliillillillillillillilliillillillillillillllllllllllll 2s% Some residents use parks or facilities provided by other cities or organizations (13%), face age or physical limitations (12%), are too busy (7%), or are generally not interested (3%), suggesting that further improvements may not increase their use of parks. In addition, about one in six respondents wrote in responses citing needs for improved safety and cleanliness in facilities, expanded pool hours, a lack of well-connected trails, concerns about off - leash dogs, and the weather as reasons why they do not visit more frequently. Not enough restrooms IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII1111111111IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIllIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII111 21% Do not know what is offered 17% (Dither (please specify) 16% use those provided by mother... IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 13% too crowded IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 13% Not enough laarkin IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 13% Age or physical limitations 12% Do not have the right equipment 9% 1 oo far away / L.ack... 8% Ioobusy 7% Not interested 4% Physical accessibility barriers 3% Online respondents were more likely to cite concerns about maintenance and safety or a lack of parking, restrooms, or preferred equipment as reasons they didn't visit more often. Mail respondents were more likely to note a lack of interest, age, or physical limitations — likely attributable to the higher average age of mail respondents. Respondents with children at home were more likely than those without to cite concerns about maintenance, a lack of preferred equipment, a lack of parking, or being too busy as a reason they do not visit parks more frequently. Respondents living to the north of 214 were more likely to cite a lack of parking or restrooms as a reason they don't visit more, compared to those living south of 214. There were no significant differences in responses based on age. 340 i-ty of Woodbuaulrin I -'a k.s �'u IdE:'c (. cltioiq IVIast(.:'i, I -'Ian C:)oes the number of existing park and recreation amenities meet residents' needs`? lzuge 7 Residents were generally split on Figure 9. When it corrrc=s to meeting the needs ForDark and whether they feel the City provides recreation facilities, how Would you rate the availability of each of enough park, trails, and recreation the following.," facilities. IIIIII More than enough IIII About the right number Not enough i Don't Know About two-thirds of survey Walking/ pedestrian trails respondents would like to see more walking and biking trails (72%), while Picnic areas & shelters 59% would like the City to provide Sport courts more picnic areas and shelters, see Developed parks Figure 9. Approximately half of Aquatics / pool programs residents would like to see more sports courts and developed parks with Recreation programs playground. Between 40%and 50% Community events would like to see more aquatics and Sport fields recreation programs and community events. of 25i soi psi iooi Residents with children in their home were more likely than those without to believe there are not enough of every listed amenity except walking trails and picnic areas, where their responses were similar. Respondents who live north of 214 were significantly more likely than those to the south to feel the City did not have enough sports fields. There were no significant differences between respondents based on age. 341 irty of Woodbuaulrin -Ia k.s & [u - E:'c (. cltIori lVlast(.:,r -11an Investiment IFlidurrir ties What Ipairlk and irecird.:.,a lon ainruenli lie.s W/diouulH ire.slicdent.s Support a d&ng lin Woodburn? The survey asked residents about their Fi1gulre 10. the following list includes additional amenities that the support for a variety of potential City of Woodburn could consider adding; tO the laark system. Please additions to the park system. More than indicate your level OF support for each. half of residents were either very supportive or somewhat supportive of adding nearly all listed amenities. As shown in Figure 10, virtually all residents are either very or somewhat supportive of additional walking trails (92%), picnic areas and shelters (86%), upgraded or renovated playgrounds (83%), outdoor splash pads (82%), an amphitheater or outdoor performance area (81%), and indoor fitness and exercise facilities (81%). Large majorities are also supportive of the City adding more playgrounds (77%), community gardens (78%), basketball courts (71%), and outdoor fitness equipment (71%). More than half of residents support the City adding more off -leash dog areas, sports fields, sports courts, a disc golf course, and a bike skills course or pump track. IIIIII Very Supportive IIIIIIIII Somewhat Supportive IIIIIIIII Not Supportive IIIIII Not Sure Walking trails Upgraded playgrounds Indoor fitness facilities Amphitheater Outdoor splash pad Picnic areas & shelters Additional playgrounds Community gardens Off -leash dog areas (dog parks) Basketball courts Outdoor fitness equipment Sport fields (soccer, football, lacrosse) Disc golf course Sport fields (baseball/softball) Tennis courts Pickleball courts Sand volleyball Bike skills course/ Pump track Futsal courts of 25i soi psi iooi Younger residents, especially those under 45, expressed a greater interest in additional or upgraded playgrounds and outdoor splash pads as compared to older residents. Residents with children at home were more likely to support additional playgrounds, splash pads, and basketball courts, as compared to those without children at home. Those without children in the household were more likely to support additional dog parks and pickleball courts. While they were still generally supportive, respondents living north of 214 and west of Boones Ferry Road (map area A) were less supportive of additional sports fields, splash pads, and playgrounds as compared to residents of other areas. What, Ipairlk and irecirea loin IiimVe.s�tinruent.s W/diouulH ire.slicdeint.s Ipirlioirli lize? Respondents were asked to rank a list of potential park system investments. In aggregated survey data, respondents identified improving and upgrading existing parks as their top priority, followed closely by expanding trail opportunities, see Figure 11A. Adding new recreational options in existing parks and acquiring additional land for future parks were moderate priorities. Expanding recreation programs and camps was ranked as the lowest priorities by respondents. 342 i-ty of Woodbuaulrrn -Ia ks & [u - E:'c (. cltIoiq IVlast(.:'r ::11an Respondents to the mail and online surveys differed slightly in their selection of ranked priorities, with online survey respondents more strongly supportive of expanding recreational options in existing parks and mail respondents more supportive of expanding trail opportunities, see Figure 1113. Respondents from households with children were more likely to prioritize expanding recreation classes and camps compared to those without. There were no significant differences in priorities based on age or location of residence. :::igur-e :1..1..A/B. For thefollowing list, indicate howyou would rank the priority foreach ('.I.st priority is highest and `:ith priority is lowest). chart shows cornbined data frorn the marl rind online surveys. Improving or upgrading existing parks Expanding trail opportunities Adding new recreational options in existing parks Acquiring additional land for future parks I 111ilg1hest 11111 or l owest Expanding recreation classes & camps IIIIIIIII 1 11112 3 4 5 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% Improving or upgrading existing parks Expanding trail opportunities Adding new recreation options in existing parks Acquiring additional land for future parks Expanding recreation classes and camps Improving or upgrading existing parks Adding new recreation options in existing parks Expanding trail opportunities Acquiring additional land for future parks Expanding recreation classes and camps 343 i-ty of Woodburn -Ia k.s & [u - (.:'cI (.mtioiq IVlast(.:'r ::11a i VVhliclh irecird.:.,a lon l irogirainru.s and actllyJ lie.s aire of liim'tQ.: ire.s't'to ire.slicdQ.:.int.s? Survey respondents were asked about their level of interest in a variety of recreational programs and activities that the City of Woodburn does, or could, offer. More than three quarters of respondents were very or somewhat interested in seeing more community events, adult classes, and aquatics programs. More than half of respondents were interested in all the other recreational programs and activities listed, with the exception of E-sports, see Figure 12. Younger residents, particularly those under 44, were more likely than older residents to express interest in youth activities and sports, family programs, adult classes, and swimming lessons. Older respondents showed more interest in programs for adults over 55. Survey respondents with children at lzugge 10 Fi1gulre 1.2....Foreach of the Following, please indicate the level of interest your household has in the program or activity. Community Events Adult classes Aquatics programs Youth activities Youth sports Swimming lessons Family programs Programs for adults 55 + Adult sports Teen activities E-Sports of 25i 50i psi iooi IIIIII Very Interested IIII'.. Somewhat Interested Not Interested IIIII Not Sure home were more likely than those without to note interest in family, youth, and teen programs as well as swimming lessons. Residents without children at home were more likely to express interest in programs for adults and people over 55, which reflects the demographics of this group. Do ire.slicden�t.s have .slpe6flic liinrulpiroveinruen�t.s tlhlQ.:.y v/diouulH Illilke to .see? Respondents were asked to describe one thing that they would like to see the City of Woodburn do to improve parks, trails, aquatics, and/or recreation programs. While respondents provided 380 specific comments and ideas, a few themes emerged: Park Maintenance and Safety: Community members frequently expressed a desire for improved maintenance and safety in existing parks. Many spoke of concerns about the maintenance and upkeep of parks, including regular cleaning, lawn care, removal of litter, and repairs to broken equipment. Others mentioned concerns about safety in parks, including issues like drugs, homeless individuals, and the need for police patrols. There are also requests for better lighting and enforcement of park rules to ensure a safe environment. • Park Upgrades: While community members emphasized the importance of maintaining existing parks and facilities, they also called for upgrades such as improved playgrounds, restroom renovations, and well -maintained walking trails. In their responses, community members also asked for additional amenities like covered basketball courts, pickleball courts, disc golf courses, skateparks, and picnic areas. There are also suggestions to renovate existing facilities and playgrounds to provide safe and enjoyable experiences for all age groups. 344 dirty of Woodburn -Ia k.s & [u - (.:'cI (.mtioiq IVlast(.:'r ::11a i "zuge 11 • Walking Trails and Connectivity: The community seeks an expansion of walking trails and the establishment of bike paths, emphasizing the importance of connectivity between parks. Residents also specifically requested better lighting along trails, wheelchair -friendly paths, and pet -friendly trails. • Aquatic Center Enhancements: Community members expressed a desire for upgrades to the aquatic center, including expanded hours, additional aquatic classes, and improved indoor facilities. They also called for the addition of more slides, diving boards, and a wave pool to enhance the overall experience. • Dog Parks and Off -Leash Areas: Enhancing dog parks is a priority, with requests for improvements such as shelters, seating areas, and increased maintenance and cleanliness. The community also desires the creation of more dog parks and off -leash areas to cater to the needs of pet owners. • Community Center and Recreation Programs: Building a new community center that offers various amenities and recreation programs is another common desire. The community would like to see more options for youth sports leagues, additional fitness facilities, and improved staffing and availability of programs, including swimming lessons and senior activities, to cater to the diverse needs and interests of residents. • Communication and Information: Some survey respondents asked for improved communication channels, such as a city cable channel or newsletter, to inform residents about community events, park offerings, and important happenings in town. Others requested a more user-friendly website that provides easy access to information, including programs, activities, and registrations, reducing the need to search through multiple sources. A compilation of write-in comments is on file with the Woodburn Community Services Department. CoImurnunllca'tlion u)referelnces I loWrdr do Ire.slicdelm�t.s Wrdralm�t to Ihear about Woocdlbalrn'.s Ipalrlk.s, Iplroglralnru.s, and events? A majority of residents prefer to learn Ir: quire 1.3. Please check AI...I... the ways you would prefer to learn about City parks, recreation facilities and about Woodburn`s parks, programs, and events. special events through the burn Newsletter (66%), the City ebste (62%), 0 o Woodburn Newsletter 66% or Facebook (51%), see Figure 13. These Cityvvebsite 62/ methods were popular across all age acel ook 51/ groups. The Woodburn Independent, community event signs, and direct email were also popular ways of learning about Woodburn parks, preferred by 37-39% of respondents each. Twitter was less popular. Some residents wrote in other preferred methods of contact, predominately direct mail. Woodburn Independent: IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 39/ Community event: signs 38/ Direct email 37/ Other (please specify) L 6/ 1wit.ter 5/ None of: these 3/ 345 i-ty of Wood lbuauirin Fla ks & Idc:hci (.mtioiq IVIa.stc:hr flan f Iz;uge 12 Perhaps unsurprisingly, residents who responded to the online survey to prefer online sources of information, notably the City's website and Facebook, as compared to respondents to the mail survey. Residents with children at home were more likely to prefer communication through Facebook than those without children at home. There were no significant differences in communication preferences between residents living in different areas of the city. M. i-ty Of 'Woodbuaulrin 11lzige 13 I -'a ks & -dc:hc (.mtion IVlastc:hr flan Age girouulp.s Overall, nearly half of mail respondents were above 65 years of age (47%). Online -only survey respondents tended to be younger than mail respondents — 55% were under 44 years and only 17% were over 65. Mail survey responses 30%, 20% ^ III III 10% 4% 0%, V IM <20 20-34 35..44 45-54 55-64 65..74 75+ Number ofclhldidiren lin Ihouu.seIh6lcd Online -only survey responses 30% rm^^ 20% III III 0% MM 111 N N NO < 20 20-34 35..44 45-54 55-64 65..74 75 + The majority (68%) of respondents to the mail survey live in households with no children under 18, while about thirty percent live in a household with either one (10%), two (11%), or three or more (10%) children. Online -only survey respondents were significantly more likely to live in households with children than respondents to the mail survey — 61% had children in the home. Mail survey responses Online -only survey responses 50% 50% 25% 10% 11% 10% 25% 01y, Em Im Elm 01y, F! EM 0 I. 2 3 or more 0 I. 2 3 or more I._ocatlion of Ire.s II6'denc4 Nearly all survey respondents live within the City of Woodburn. About 42% of mail respondents live to the north of 214 (map areas A and B) and 58% live to the south (map areas C and D). The largest portion of respondents to the mail survey, 32%, live in the southwest portion of the City (map area C). Online survey respondents were more likely to live south of 214 (64%). See map on following page. Mail survey responses Online -only survey responses 30%, 20% 1.0% o% o%, (A (B (C) (D) Don't live Northwest Northeast: southwest Southeast: in City 30% , 20% 1.0% 0%, EJ (A) ( B ( C) ( D Don't: live Northwest: Northeast southwest: southeast in City 347 Q-ty of Woodbuirin Flarks & F(.:hcr(.ntioiq IVIast(.:,i, flan Survey map for location responses �Izige 14 348 Q-ty of Woodbuirin Flarks & Fd(.:hcir(.mtioiq IVIast(.:,i, Fllaiq AIPFACI IME.Aq IF 1. SURVEN IHNSIRRIII EN IF 115 349 Q-ty of Woodbuirin 11�lzige 16 Flarks & d(.:hcr(.mtkm V1ast(.:,,r flan SUirvey on Parks and Recrentioin 1IN Dear Woodbuirm IRLmpdii I rte ICrt.,y of Woodbian has skartewl a Ou'llin in I Unity'led III UJ Updale! iii. btywkie Parks And Reueahiii Mar, ter Nan, We need vrmu hp�jin tar , die teii how tti�wnbrifiwie prcqiects a I I'd Vuli'M vve shaulri locus mi lo keelp Kngr jpzirks 'rind fbir 7"tip next 1(1 1, year""'As an IN1yri - ap, 1k*(Ity err c-mmociting tlnlV% shoirt "Irvelto ilr%SMS the, ccw in rn u rI i Ov's ro,,cfeator, mmAsi. We as)k Ihm You Corilrider Voi,11, ria�,edIs for i;he future as yo,u eyvml�ivatrr,- YiDtjr,Dr)in ions are rmi II ',Ivvy Tilie, survey has 16 questions and wM only take a few miniatebs to comp [ete Us4 the QR1 cat -de to take fts, survey ciii at 1. When I thiinkabout wh;it contributes to the miality of fife lin Wooftji III you sway thart grimbilicc parks an,di recreation opportunitfies On- 1) Es6elTal tcw t1he of ilfe bere I INCA ir"i 1:1 111 tanit, hot rsolI Ieaiiliv eswinlfiaii Di lkrmv El USefilh, but I rieciessary 4 When 0 comes to nweting the nii For pai and fecreation facilibi how would you T-i the avaiiability Of each M thir, foflooui I Check only one box in emaich row ]I iNal EINam"01 DORI Omw ............... �El El 1:1 1111111111111 ...... ................................................................ .. ....... ...................... ....................... ....................... ........................ II El 0 0 El ............................................... .................. 1:1 0 ID �D Spemn e,,oum rKAOwibAh, iwnrds p'Mob"01 EJ 01 .. ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... . ... ... ... ...... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... .J. ... ... ... ... .. ... ... ... ... ... . � ... .111 I& I�1.............. I �,,] . ........... .. In tyP"MMM W4; P;IC93 "OK,01-11P E1 .. ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... . r cud ...................................... I lb a typical year, how i d1d you visit or u&e City of Woodburn, parks, recreationi fmflfties or open spaice? At iraoist oniix, a ii I noil vIsIl tOcil4li / rmi ks I Spowes Tiqio ar nim e Iimi mirmi 0 Di krjm6iJ Cl Abolot art e an manth 4, Which park or fadfity I your vi�sgt rwi of to! a? 5Rate your householdils saitisfawctionl ith the City of WoodblUrn's parks, recreianion faciftes or open Space. 0 Very Saifished 10 Sorneii Mssat.,,sfiied ICJ Don't Know 0 ScmiewhAii-, SAbisfiedl 10 1 ilIsmitr&PId 350 Q-ty of Woodburn Flarks & Fd(.:hciI II flan we a stairnpill Use the QR cWe and takv thN survey onflne; ftM,,J1WWW,;wrM1xMP 00 RaddIUMMM 0 liv, backoll ft andiarmf i Thafflk wivu, imal for jpoirilclpaMnjgT 6How wotdO you rate the'Qf CRY WWoodburn paxlks off recreation faclUill Exfi Falu 0 Not $uji e/No Opig-Oon Cooej Pot�r 7, Mat would Viousay are Ole mahi relai5vns your b1ofmiehiold visilfts WoWbrArrs parks or r"il faciRties? 1[ CHECK ALL THAT AIP FLY ) IlIzilge 17 In F i 1,11 es;�, / �,, xeqcJw Ell S k,,,,i to pa v 0, 10 I'll"rygip cou"dr, 0 Spon Wd,, 0 vva I k I rig or runril ng Outdoor spiuf cidyu'lls Mike ii WHdIllo vievvin.g [N-�g waMirlig or rlog park Swill,li'millig I rarnily ,gilhvi 0 RelavatOn 13 (cownilinky `J/A- P£ (fidn't use any Mxm2mrin facilikie,� II 6(ec~ alI 67rO$,-r3 t15, rkasseq, ar car"Im 0 CMI'llf"ll: .......................................................................................................................... I , J Y',M,,l J-1 s,YplcmlC Prop"i o l irls 13� Check ALL the reasons why yourhousehold recreaticuil fa6h des, park$ or Openspaice.5 more often ( Cl-ItCK At. L THNr AII ) 10 N/A Cwvs i apjp61y; 11we ii Lheim L1f101 Not eriough parkino Age, oi 1.Vholcal hrlllitatwn� I enimigh I es till wirn., Are rict well rnaintain,ed Too, busy To go tm pia im or op Pnispat ln Dar I ier s 1;rk pl aq, c efsi WRY 7bo crowyded 10 Tov,�l fi,ir away I Lack tramlpartmicm Q Neil, in im ested in pail k, ry r ipri 4",atic,�n alcrivifie, y N) i iot kriow %0 ia ( is offered 0 LA e fA 11-i0i I:Rp% V,,q al lei I'Ll vir 4, it Y, lxlgral ol PM hva Le ?,, 11,A) (N) llcdhav*+ Ole ll El (Ttlilivl: ()o nnit fml y0e hb IiJayk v)ii 5parP" 9,. Cu�rreindy, the (Lty oll"Wood burn offers aquatitil prog;ams, eweri'm, adult trlpand %pechil imch A,% bobysil"ing. Progrorh oHeArrgs enoy rioed to ch,mogo, Ovor fime, to re'll, corri,rink4nity'Arl For oo(+ oftho folilow1hr, Fideom,,- Indiwe the level of interfrist your hou%pfil has, for ill progrorni or activitles I ........ . ............................ Vey .................... ........ S*MOWIl .......... . . .............. Wt ......................... C,QQrIrDOIAN .............................................. ..................... .. . .. ..... ............... ... ........ ................................................................................................................................................ Splye"u, of rlrqu�wlu�c 0,amlrg on, .. .................. . .... ... .......... ..... 1.1 ... ........ .. . . .. . ................... ............ - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 71m, 'ALViNPRAF-7, l�RAPFr rpight%, Ivilm" ap h RA Ffh, mxjl - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - — - - I'D IF.] Ad(wft,i,Vcm fWkc,1b9(O, mtj .............. kn'twillo), vVis,, mzgj . ........... .... 0 Aipm,lkv pfogymirm rUjpiiowliq, maobll:m claln,eltc) U 11 12 c 351 Q-ty of Wood lbu irin Flarks & Fd(.:hcir(.mtioiq Vlast(.:hr Fllaiq IMM-1 \v Comn-omity Survey an Park & Recreation Pmfere, vlces 101, The f9l1low[rig R�IhicIludes additional amermitk-T, that Um (iw 0 Woofflnulk comil(I opmailer -4jgling to the park. Oiysteni. Pleaat Indicatt your kwel of �Iuppoirt �6f &aidi, V'OMV w wOw uwlaa au p" R!�Ftlw, Flk-c avta,!N & Adkm Nw gT('upxAh&,,,p E."I U1,4iraded ar ircriamied [AyV�our,63 M ------______ ------------____ ------------____ -------_________ -------_________ Addh brall pbaygrau urmdm, ------_________ ------___ El ______ --------____ [.1 ___ ------________ ----------_______ [3 - ED w,kkatg I llrog'g .. ... .... .. .. I ........ .. ......... Pmd,,v,w 0, 0 . .... . .... . . . ........... . ..... . .... .... OwAx"llir . ................ . ............ .. ... .. .. . .................................................................................................. 1 0 � R, a Od0h ra Nov, 0 1 Ftvmp I F a ld )l Um M, ��...... . .... . .......... EZI [3,j 0 �,qo011l f��yqlcj,,, fat I pat,�W, pklal� E cm� �,O E-1 ED 13 El" . ...................................................................................................... fur Omkoh ;'cfl hAH b b 1] 13 13 13 12 1, �:3 12 M U M 01 ------____----------______________________________________________________ p kiklk�bj�� coul u ------ ------------------- [3 ------------------ 1"'.1 ------------------ ID ----------------- El' kMw ......................... 11 ................ ........ - 1.1, F'o'r the followhig RA, how w.,pu woluld rank the priorl,tv for each �1" prriodtV rs higbest and S"' prioriN laww.st). flank irif p6arity each �of the folffowlng- (Chock one b,ox per kern . *uo, mw�h prknlky OWt, lion't krow I II qhert p6,vm,,y "I . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .................................. nwest .. . . . . pHnrky ;,iq v Mon . .............................................................................................................................................................................................................................. J,fl .. . .. . .. . .. . .. . .... 2,0 .............................. , v .. . .. . .. . .. . .. . .. . . ................................. ... . .. . .. . .. . .. . .. . . ........................................................... . AAdwjkv, neve � ecmmUcmo� OpVdm!� "", mm!aimg li El I. 3 AcquhHii igaddIftbna,', lay iid ror fluvu,m paii 0 In .. 10 .......... .......... n 10 , El Lmp,wflnidiiinig rii,&A tpptiiil hAin, r, em . ............................. I-j . .............................. . . �Ll . ............ .... .................... . 1-1 1:1 M M El IMlqwcl'jo,,�,,Rof ,lpjrWmg vc� E: . 1:1 ............................... D Ej El 352 Q-ty of Woodburn Flarks & F(.:hcr(.mtioiq Vlast(.:hr flan 12, Plleaw, check AL I the ways you would preter to learn about Wmx1burnirs, p4mAs, prograrm—mid everim 01 C) f� w @ bI tt 0 Direct,emad 0 Woodbuf ri Wwflime r WAD ComimiAnity even't signs 13 IFaoebco k IF"] None 00wmw 0 TYvITT*jr D Cikhei,: 0 Woodburn lndependent 11�lzige 19 13, If VOILI Wainted the City 04 Wood4wirn to da,liust one, CIifiig to Crqprowe pwks, tealls, aquatics, andlor evveation programs, whait woWd it be? Um falIlowing quesUlans 1d4-bIip us undarstan,d wkiether vve have gathered respoinses Irani a, broad segment of the C0,111117MIllty, It's irnponapt that you provide a resporm to each quesliogi„ 14. 14ow mamy chjWrein vindeir age 18 live fin your hcruse.hold? 15. whatlis your ap? Q yokonser 0 5r, 1. fP14 0 20 w 34 FJ �4 and 74 0 35 to w.w; El 75 writ older 0 45, to 54 J& Alf 'Stffljg� tkqeL fnj4jj, in WfVitfj, section of WoodbtoflAb you live? Q IA kwfdii of � 14 & We s t of N DoQnes� Ferf V Rcjm9 E3 I � P No. th of 414 & East jcf N BoQner� Ferr t, Road 0 SOLlt�`, of 214 & La%r,: of R, SehlemierAvenue Do n't We kil Aka,Od L�rr m Al rniuwr D g" VNe 04y of VOwmturru h °#Ojmg Vh* mvA4%)O a mcei xhIr, tR r n ,wNf Spoc1borti ii�N [park, amd, rvememOCA' )pWimrg, Ow o4d4wod i4a o gm,, llbofirme�)Orl §7112 353 354 1� mNmx MEETING NOTES PROJECT NUMBER: #22-148PLN ISSUE DATE: June 4, 2023 PROJECT NAME: Woodburn Parks & Recreation Master Plan RECORDED BY: Steve Duh TO: FILE PRESENT: Members of the public City staff Project team members from Conservation Technix and Izo PR & Marketing SUBJECT: Parks & Recreation Master Plan: Open House #1 Meeting Notes (May 31-1) Community members were invited to an open house for citywide Woodburn Parks and Recreation Master Plan on Wednesday, May 31, 2023 from 7:00 - 8:30 p.m. at the Woodburn City Hall. The project team prepared a presentation and informational displays covering the major themes of the Parks Master Plan. These displays included Project Overview, Survey Highlights, Parks & Outdoor Recreation, and Investing in the Future. The meeting was conducted as a hybrid (online & in -person) event and in English and Spanish. Attendees were encouraged to talk to project team members and record their comments. City staff and project team staff engaged with participants to identify general needs and interests for park and recreation in Woodburn. Approximately 12 people attended the meeting to review materials and provide comment. PUBLIC COMMENTS The following represents a summary of the comments received during the evening meeting. Recreation Program Area Ideas ■ Youth Programs & Camps: Extremely necessary / Pottery, arts / STEM outdoor / Summer youth camps, School -engaged year round events / jSi! Gratuitos o de bajos recursos y varias edades (Yes! Free or low -resource and various ages) / S.T.E.M. or outdoor programs ■ Adult Sport Leagues: Great! ■ Adult or Senior Classes: Pottery ■ Aquatic Classes: Becas Para natacion (swimming gowns) / Transporte es un problema o horario (Transportation is a problem or schedule ■ Other: Would love to see intergenerational events/classes Targeting Future Needs (Are there types of experiences you would like to see?� ■ Indoor pickleball ■ Great fields! ■ Year-round access / covered areas ■ Trees; shaded areas with different sitting options; reading drawing outside 355 Parks & Recreation Master Plan: Open House #1 Meeting Notes (May 31st) Woodburn Parks & Recreation Master Plan Project Number #22-148PLN Page 2 Targeting Future Needs (,map comments, ■ Indoor pickleball close to Estates ■ Senior exercise at Senior Park (classes) ■ Disc golf (at Hermanson Pond) ■ Skatepark ■ Parks here with restrooms. There are minimal parks this side of 99E (near NE section of 99E & 214) ■ Develop wetland area to eliminate homelessness in residential backyards (near SE section of 99E & 211) ■ I would like to see additional parks, structures or trails in East woodbum on the other side of 99e. Many people have to cross 99 in order to get to park that meets their needs. There are also many apartment complexes being built on that side of Woodburn and there is only 1 park located on that side. 356 Parks & Recreation Master Plan: Open House #1 Meeting Notes (May 31st) Woodburn Parks & Recreation Master Plan Project Number #22-148PLN Page 3 Targeting Future Needs - Walking & Biking Trails ■ Lighted trails ■ Emergency access plans ■ Wider trails for strollers/wheelchairs/mobility devices ■ Tree lined walking trails ■ More trails this side (east of 99E; NE corner of city ■ Expand trail system from 3 miles to 20 miles (not on streets In addition to connecting trails, wider trails would benefit people who use wheelchairs or other mobility devices as well as help parents or caregivers with strollers Exploring Investment Priorities (dot exercise) ■ 7 - Additional walking / biking trails ■ 6 - Picnic shelters ■ 5 - Shade structures for playgrounds ■ 5 - Outdoor splash pad / water spray park ■ 3 - Outdoor fitness equipment ■ 3 - PicklebaIl / futsal / multi -sport courts ■ 2- Additional art in parks ■ 1 - Additional sport fields ■ 1- Other (write-in: disc golf Other Comments ■ Year round access to parks that are renewed ■ More picnic tables ■ Community parties (block -like parties) in different parts of town or park ■ Museo de informacion (information museum ■ Mas accessible Para connectar a genie de fuera (More accessible to connect with people from outside ■ Lots of trees to make walking more pleasing ■ More shade and toilets for camping ■ Additional lighting for evening events and physical activities in current parks Every effort has been made to accurately record this meeting. If any errors or omissions are noted, please provide written response within five days of receipt. -- End of Notes -- cc: Jesse Cuomo, Community Services Director File 357 358 WOODBURN PARKS AND RECREATION MASTER PLAN 2023 ILIA 2023 ONLINEIR IE I L)SE StYMMARY Prepared for City of Woodburn Prepared by JLA Public Involvement, Inc. Date October 2023 359 TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction ....................................... Overall Participation and Notification Feedback Summary .......................... Key Takeaways ............................. Detailed Summary ......................... Demographics Information............ NextSteps ........................................ Appendix A: Open-ended comments Woodburn Parks and Recreation Master Plan 2023 1 Fall 2023 Online Open House Summary Page 1 360 II IR 0 IL'o'*`'1 The City of Woodburn held an online open house from September 15 to October 1, 2023, to share information about the Parks and Recreation Master Plan update (PRMP). The purpose of the online open house was to: • Share project details, timeline and plan progress. • Share what we've heard so far through previous outreach efforts and field assessments. • Share information about proposed park improvement projects, new trail connections and programs being considered. • Gather feedback from the community. The online open house was made available in English and Spanish. Feedback received from the online open house will help refine the PRMP. OVERALL IPARII .'t" IU IPATIC AND NOTIFIC.'t"ATION Overall, 170 people participated in the online survey. Additionally, the project page received 282 visitors while the online survey was open. Community members were informed about the online open house through the following: • Social media posts to the City's Facebook page. • 11,819 postcards were sent to residents living in the City of Woodburn • A digital flyer was shared with the Woodburn School District's Director of Communication and various organization for distribution to their communities. • A press release distributed to local media. • An email to the City's E-blast list. FEEDBAC.'t"K SLIMMARY Key Takeaways The following themes emerged from the online open house responses. Potential Park Improvements • The majority want to see improved maintenance of existing facilities and parks. • Several people mentioned they would like additional facilities like sport courts and turf fields. • Others want to see improvements to existing parks, such as adding or upgrading playground equipment, picnic shelters, splash pads and restroom facilities. • Most people were in favor of building a community center and renovating Settlemier Park. • Others noted feeling unsafe and asked for additional lighting at parks. Potential Trail Connections • Most people were in favor of building a citywide trail loop as well as building more trails in natural areas. Woodburn Parks and Recreation Master Plan 2023 1 Fall 2023 Online Open House Summary Page 2 361 • Participants would like to see the following amenities to be installed in the near term: trailhead restrooms, benches along trails, and drinking fountains or water bottle filling stations. • Several people advocated for safe pathways connecting various parts of the community, schools, and downtown areas. • Others mentioned they would like improvements to trail safety with lighting. • Others advocated for upgrading trail accessibility. Potential Recreation Programming Improvements • The majority are interested in more program offerings, in general. • Participants were interested in more medium- or large -sized city events. • Several participants would like more swim lesson offerings and more affordable sports programs. Detailed Summary Below is a summary of the feedback received through the online open house. W If you h to pick Just oine lii mIl iroveirni t to ood a irn's pairk s st irn, Whidh ofthe following would you dhoose? The majority (35%) want playground upgrades and replacement, followed closely by improved, permanent restrooms and picnic shelters and tables for gathering (28%). I you had to pick just one improvement to Woodburn's park system, which of the following would you choose? Picnic shelters and tables for gatherings .v �"� .. - , ,� Updated playground surfacing 1% 0 I0 20 30 40 50 60 Woodburn Parks and Recreation Master Plan 2023 1 Fall 2023 Online Open House Summary Page 3 362 2. "rhefollowing is Ipairtliu l IUst of irripiroveirneints andfaciliflesthat Imu Ibe consideired forthefutuire. IFoir eadh IftIrn, IpIIeasetell us Iff Ift stiould Ibe a "rop Priority, IIVIediurn Priority, ILow Priority oir INot a Priority at all. Costs aire estirnated as soirnewl,lat expensive ($), modeirately expensive ($$), expensive ($$$), oir veiry expensive ($$$$),. The top priority listed by participants is to build a new community center and renovate Settlemier Park (54%). The majority (approximately 45%) ranked the following three improvements as medium priorities: build additional picnic shelters for group gatherings, build additional paved and/or accessible walking trails in parks, and build sport courts at Nelson and North Front Street Parks. Participants rated upgrading playgrounds at North Front Street, Heritage, and Burlingham Parks as either medium or low priority and add a splash pad to a park as either a low or medium priority (with a quarter of participants noting it as not a priority). Upgrading playgrounds at North Front Street, Heritage and Burlingham Parks Not a priority W 0 110 20 30 40 50 Build a new community center Et Add a splash pad to the park z3mmmam 0 110 20 30 40 50 m I'll MMEEN , M M. Top Priority Top Priority Medium Priority Medium Priority Low Priority Low Priority Not a priority 0 6% Not a priority 0 20 40 60 80 0 '10 20 30 40 50 60 70 Woodburn Parks and Recreation Master Plan 2023 1 Fall 2023 Online Open House Summary Page 4 363 - 9% 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 100 . . I + - ■ 10% 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 I Airetheire otheir Iiir ipiroveirnit is you wouldIH t see at existing City pairl s Many participants commented that they would like to see improved maintenance and upgrades to existing parks and facilities. Participants specifically noted Centennial Park (e.g., fix broken picnic tables, clean splash pad, and power wash picnic shelter), Hermanson Pond and trail, Legion Park (e.g., upgrade playground), Burlingham Park, Nelson Park, Heritage Park, park at Senior Estate and Wyffels Park as well as the aquatic center, baseball fields, dog park and park or trail bathrooms. Other improvements mentioned frequently included the addition of basketball courts, tennis courts, frisbee golf and a second turf field. Several people asked for additional lighting and noted feeling unsafe in the parks. Others asked for more trees or shaded structures, more walking trails, and more all-inclusive park features or handicap accessible parks. Additional suggestions include: • Offer more youth sports programs. • More seating along paths. • Add exercise machines. • Build a bigger dog park. • Add moveable tables and chairs. • Offer more bike trails. • Build a senior center. For a complete list of comments, see AgRendix A. • Add trail mileage signage. • Add Oregon leash law signage. • Start a volunteer litter pick up crew. • Add a community garden. • Add more drinking fountains. • Add a bike repair center. 4. Asthe City p lu i t girow and irripirovethe t cir atio r u ll trrai l systeirn, Whidh ofthe following options aire most irnpoirtain'tto you? The majority (43%) want the City to add more trails to natural areas, followed closely by adding more paved paths within City Parks for small walking loops (30%). For those that selected "Other," they mentioned maintaining existing facilities, prioritizing youth sports programs, adding more trails and buying more land to convert into parks or green space. Woodburn Parks and Recreation Master Plan 2023 1 Fall 2023 Online Open House Summary Page 5 364 As the If to grow and improve the recreational trail system, which of the following options are most important you? I Adding more trails in natural areas walking loops Adding more park -to -park connections Connecting to retail, employment, and commercial areas Other 4% 0 110 20 30 40 50 60 70 5. IExpaindingthe Citystrail systeirn was Il ntified asthe higtiest IpidOilrilty,foir iirnpiroviing thood a it Ipairl systeirn. Wtint is imost iirnpoirtaintto youfoir iirnpiroviingtirails in Woodburn? (Select all'that apply.) The majority (48%) would like the City to build new trails in existing parks and open spaces, followed closely by purchase more land or easements and build new trail connections (39%). For those that selected "Other," they are interested in more bike lanes, more swimming lessons and youth programs, safer walking routes from Woodburn Estate/Broughton Way to Centennial Park, and better response times on inquiries. If you had to pick just one improvement to Woodburn's park system, which of the following would you choose? r . PTT KWNT.9 trail connections Improve signage and trails information to increase awareness of opportunities R improve connectivity 0 110 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 Woodburn Parks and Recreation Master Plan 2023 1 Fall 2023 Online Open House Summary Page 1 365 6. In a llfloi t i aki inswtirail coininections, a vairiety of airrienifies could Ibe installed 'to iimpirovethetrail systeirri. Whidh ofthefollowing pirojects stiould Ibe iimpleirriented in the iimirriediatefutuire (next 1 'to 3 years)? (Ghoose youirtop thiree.) The majority (approximately 42%) rated trailhead restrooms, benches along trails, and drinking fountains or water bottle filling stations as their top three amenities. In addition to making new trait connections, a variety of amenities coutd be instatted to improve the trait system. Which of the fo[towing projects shoutd be imptemented in the immediate future (next 1 to 3 years)? Trailhead restrooms EUIAI=� 9EM1Eff-=- Wildlife viewing areas Directional signage or mileage markers 0 110 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 T. "ritinking abouttrails u i Ipu ths, Whidh Ipotentliu ltrail coininections a ilr th Ihigtiest pirioirity,foir youir Ihousetiold? Rainkthetirails Iby selectingfroirri'thdrop-d imenus. The majority (39%) said creating a citywide loop trail around Woodburn is their top priority. They also ranked expanding Mill Creek trail between Seftlemier Park and Woodburn High School as another priority, followed closely by connecting Centennial Park to Seftlemier Park. Woodburn Parks and Recreation Master Plan 2023 1 Fall 2023 Online Open House Summary Page 2 I r �- Settlemier • w oodb School Highest priority - 1 II�IIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 2 VlUlIIUlUlU1D1D1VJJJ1lJ���������� ,,,,,,,.,,, Aeavraii�J 4 - 13% Lowest priority 5 wj11!M! � 0 10 20 .30 40 Settlemier Park Highest priority - 1 III�IIIIIIII 2 4 Lowest priority - 5 0 10 Woodburn Parks and Recreation Master Plan 2023 1 Fall 2023 Online Open House Summary 20 30 40 Page 3 367 Expanding Hermanson Pond Trail and adding a walking loop Highest priority - 1 2 3 4 Lowest priority - 5 0 10 20 30 40 Creating a citywide loop trail arou 4 Woodburn I Highest priority - I 2 3 4 Lowest priority - 5 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 Connecting to retail, employment and commercial areas Highest priority - I 2 3 4 Lowest priority - 5 IIIII 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 8. the Cit Ilinsforfutuire recir do Iirogwirniming, sItiouldtheire Ibe moire or less of thefollowling activifies or pirogirairris avaE4ble Ilan 'thefutuire? The majority (61 %) said they would like more adult or senior classes, adult sports leagues, youth programs, teen activities, and outdoor or nature camps. The majority (87%) said the current offering of aquatic classes and programs are either adequate or are needed. Woodburn Parks and Recreation Master Plan 2023 1 Fall 2023 Online Open House Summary Page 4 368 I r1linglummilt More needed IIII00MEN M. Current offerings are 111101JI1111 adequate Fewer needed 4% Not sure/ Don't know 0 30 60 90 a 0 0 - More needed Current offerings are adequate Fewer needed 1 2% Jill 0VI Idl1��091 Not sure/ Don't know 0 '10 20 30 40 50 60 70 OMAN M KIIIIIIANW-JOUVII IANWININI More needed IMERIMIUM. Current offerings are 112% adequate 1111111 Fewer needed 1 2% 11�IPIIIIIIJJII Not sure/ Don't know 111 0 20 40 60 80 100 More needed 1111011101� Current offerings are ILI" 2 adequate Fewer needed 3% Not sure/ Don't know 0 20 40 60 80 day camps, arts or gymnastics More needed IIII Current offerings are adequate Fewer needed 1% Not sure/ Don't know 0 30 60 90 Outdoor or nature camps, including environmental educatil More needed Current offerings are 111% adequate 111111 Fewer needed 5% Not sure/ Don't know 0 30 60 90 9. Iheard inteirest in addifloinal coirnimunity events. Wtint types of events stiouldthe City,focus on? (Ghoose oine.) The majority (51 %) wanted more medium -size or big events. Woodburn Parks and Recreation Master Plan 2023 1 Fall 2023 Online Open House Summary Page 5 369 More big events No preference 0 l0 20 30 40 50 . Istheire anythingIts you'd IIIII usto Ikinow about pairks,tirails and Ipirogiw°u i is Overall, people seemed enthusiastic about park updates and several people expressed gratitude for current park offerings and recent improvements. Below are the main themes from participants' comments: • Maintain current parks and trails. o Examples include vegetation maintenance, trash bins, dog waste bag stations and a City-wide campaign to encourage cleaning up litter. • Buy more land for future parks and green spaces. o One person recommended finding grant funding and focusing on ADA improvements. • Improve or update current parks. o Examples included expanding Legion Park and the Aquatic Center, building a new community center, adding a gym facility to the Aquatic Center and building an indoor track and pickleball courts. o Others asked for improved safety with lighting. • Offer more programming. o Examples included an improved farmers market, more swim lessons, more affordable classes or sports programs and adult day trips like "Out and About." Additionally, a few people asked for improved bike and walking facilities to access the parks and others asked for a community garden. One person asked for a connection from West Woodburn to Woodburn parks and recreation facilities, as there are currently none. Another person suggested we discuss park improvements with vulnerable communities and apartment communities that currently don't have access to parks. One person wanted to know if there are any plans for Burlingham Park. For a complete list of comments, see Appendix A. Woodburn Parks and Recreation Master Plan 2023 1 Fall 2023 Online Open House Summary Page 6 370 Demographics Information Out of the 170 participants, 93 people completed the demographics information below. W Usingthe map, in hIicti section of Woodburno you II 38% of participants live south of 214 and east of N Settlemier Avenue, followed closely by south of 214 and west of N Settlemier Avenue (26%). - , r -I sM13s`II ss�rIM I ' don't live in Woodburn 0 y IC1 15 20 25 30 35 The majority (68%) identified as White. Woodburn Parks and Recreation Master Plan 2023 1 Fall 2023 Online Open House Summary Page 7 371 I What lainguages aire spokein oir sigined at Ihoirne? (Gheck a llll tIhat apply.) The majority (69%) speak English at home and almost a fifth speak Spanish. For those that answered "Other," they listed the following languages: Mixteco, French, Spanglish, and Tongan. 4. What Its youir urge? Almost half (40%) identified as either 45-54 years old or 35-44 years old and a quarter (25%) identified as 65 years or older. Woodburn Parks and Recreation Master Plan 2023 1 Fall 2023 Online Open House Summary Page 8 372 W What Its youir higtiest Revell of education? The majority (59%) have some college / technical / community college / 2-year degree or a college degree / 4- year degree. What is your highest level of education? Postgraduate College degree/ 4-year degree Some college/technical/community college/ 2-year degree High school degree or less Prefer not to answer 11 2% 0 y I C1 15 20 25 30 . What was youirtotal housetiold incoirrie last year befoir taxes? (Select o i W) The majority (48%) make at least $80,000 a year. 0 y IC1 15 20 25 30 35 T. IHow mainy.Ih Il ll ilr i undeir urge 18 Hve in youir Iho u tio l " The majority (65%) said they do not have any children under the age of 18 in their household. Woodburn Parks and Recreation Master Plan 2023 1 Fall 2023 Online Open House Summary Page 9 373 ����� ���������� m�m���m STEPS ��m �� The City will review the online open house feedback and refine the draft Parks and Recreation Master Plan (PRMP) then present the draft plan to the City Council in fall 2023. Once approved, the PRMP will be incorporated into the City of Woodburn's Comprehensive Plan and guide future recreation projects and programs. Woodburn Parks and Recreation Master Plan 2023 1 Fall 2023 Online Open House Summary Page1O 374 APPENDIX A: GREN-ENDED C'*GMUENTS Below are the unabridged, unedited responses to the open-ended survey questions. Question 3. Are there other improvements you would like to see at existing City parks? 1. Would love to have a move inclusive cultural involvement other than all Spanish festivities and activities. Many other cultures and holidays are being left out. Makes us feel supremely um welcomed in the community you're trying to build. 2. 1 believe that Woodburn has awesome parks. I think that Legion Park is marked off the list, and is a good park (No need for construction) . Cenntanial Park can use better bathroom, but overall I think it's a good park, I go jogging there 2-3 times a week. I do believe that Settlemier Park need the most improvment. I rarley go there, a mijority of the trees need to be cut, and it needs improvment in is playground (Not including the aquatic center) 3. 1 would love to see an upgraded playground at Legion Park, with more things for the kids to play on. Also, a splash pad would be nice to see there as well. 4. At times a little better weed and pest abatement would be nice at Heritage Park. Otherwise our little neighborhood park here in Heritage Park could just use a little play structure upgrade and maybe a picnic table or two for gatherings. Thank you for asking and taking our input. 5. A bike repair center (air refill center) like the one Canby and Tualatin have. 6. Not letting adults drink and maybe having patrol at night I have four countless needles and stuff 7. The restrooms at the parks are dark and unsafe. Not sure exactly what can help change that but it is needed with all the kiddos 8. Improve the baseball fields at centennial!! 9. Turf the infields at centennial baseball fields make them useful and more kids will want to play !! 10. Improve the baseball fields and restroom facilities at Centennial park. Field have so many holes it's dangerous for kids to play. These fields are also used for little kid soccer. Bathrooms at Centennial need updating and maintenance 11. More maintenance of bathrooms 12. Anything at Nelson park. Including parking, better playground, infrastructure, sports area, except Soccer. There is already plenty of soccer fields around Woodburn already. 13. Lighting should be adequate for safety 14. Better maintenance at Burlingham park 15. Accesible playground for children with needs. I was a centennial one time and a little girl was in a wheelchair, she could not go into the playground due to the bark dust. She watched everyone play as she was just in the shelter area. All children should be able to enjoy the park. We as a city should have more disability friendly areas. 16. Keep them clean and free of dangers 17. Better landscaping and more walking paths 18. Wildlife safe/observation areas. We need to protect our wildlife. They are losing their habits due to construction. Woodburn Parks and Recreation Master Plan 2023 ! Fall 2023 Online Open House Summary Page 11 375 19. Community garden 20. Community garden! 21. Improve dog park sections at the parks, turf fields at centennial 22. Lighting upgrade and shelter picnic area replacement at Burlingham. 23. Tennis, pickle ball courts. Racquet or hand ball courts. 24. Hermanson park. The pond needs to be revitalized. That area could become a wonderful natural area, with native plantings and effective management of the pond. Right now it's a stagnant pond whose trails are frequently underwater in the rainy months. 25. Yes, our roads going to the parks. 26. The park in the Heritage Park Neighborhood is inadequate and could be improved. 27. Wouldn't it be cool to have a doggy water fountain and their own play yard next to the kiddos? Also consider installing community bathrooms nearby. Thank you for your consideration. 28. 1) Adding Gardens Also need to continue buying land for additional parks even if unable to make improvements at the current time 29. Settlemire Park 30. Is there a way to organize volunteers to regularly pick up litter at the parks? I notice this is an issue in general in Woodburn, lots of litter. Possibly provide recycling receptacles at the parks as well? Also wondering if the picnic shelter ground can be power washed at Centennial Park? It's a nice facility, I think a good spray down would go far! Ideally new or cleaner public restrooms at Centennial Park also. Thank you. 31. Pothole repair on all city streets. 32. Improve safety and clean up (drug paraphernalia) at existing parks. 33. Water park for kids for the summer and more walk trails 34. We need to significantly improve and maintain our baseball fields. While we have made a wonderful and very appreciated effort with our soccer resources, our baseball program is struggling to develop in town, and part of that is due to the condition of the fields. 35. Disc golf course 36. WE NEED COMMUNITY CENTER FOR CLASSES FOR SENIORS, GATHERINGS, CONCERTS ETC WITH USABLE KITCHEN, POSSIBLE POOL 37. Signage about OR State leash laws 38. Sign that say DOGS ON LEASH 39. Brush clearing and better lighting for safety. Too many secluded areas and insufficient lighting. Doesn't matter how much resources are put in place to improve walking paths, shelters, restrooms, playgrounds and sports courts if residents don't feel safe visiting those locations 40. Any improvement related to walking trails. 41. lighting for the evenings, cleanliness, landscaping to make parks look more inviting 42. Access Logs Via Mobile Devices for Facilities that are Subjected to Vandalism to Enable Police Investigations 43. 1 would like to see improvement made at our aquatic centre. 44. Regular cleaning of playground surfaces and pick up of litter in the park Clean splash pad at Centennial park Woodburn Parks and Recreation Master Plan 2023 1 Fall 2023 Online Open House Summary Page 12 376 Enforce a fine for people who do not pick up their dog's poop A complete revamp of Legion park playground, one slide? Seriously? 45. Fixing broken water pipes and more vegetation 46. More Trees. 47. Just a comment: our goal should be to make all parks equal so that everyone in our community has access to the same amenities. I know that is expensive but it's equitable. 48. More waking trails and green ways! 49. 1 would love to see a nature park like Wilsonville's nature park. There is not a park in Woodburn like it. There is Hermanson Pond but it's not easily accessible due to homes and there is no official public parking. We need paved nature trails on large plots of land and restored habitats. The trails currently are all cut up and split up by busy roads. Woodburn is growing and there are mature trees being cut to make way for homes. 50. There needs to be more cooling gardens. Whatever gets built needs to include shade trees and water features for the 100°+ days. Many people in our town don't have air conditioning and don't know how to swim, which is a danger combination for area rivers. We need safe places to cool off, and honestly, there needs to be a lot more swim lesson spots available, especially free lessons. 51. Let's get a tennis court with some shade in there. Also build some few payphones that are for emergency just in case someone feels unsafe while they are there or on their trail run or walk 52. Please place splash pads farther away from play structures. Also add communication boards and more sensory toys/experiences 53. Wyffels Park desperately needs work 54. Turf fields at centennial. 55. Updates that would allow people with disabilities to access the parks. 56. 1 would like to see bike paths 57. Signage to inform walkers how many laps are a mile in all of our walking trails.For example the new walking trail around Legion Park soccer field. Create a downtown walking trail with signage on mileage etc. 58. The youth sports needs to completely re done before parks 59. You can not place a community center and park upgrades in the same survey, as it's not comparable. People will clearly choose a community center, leaving city parks in their continued poor condition. The 5500+ children in Woodburn need access to shaded parks in their neighborhoods. Families should not need to travel to another city to have access to a park. 60. We can't afford to pay any more taxes. Woodburn is in the top for taxes @ just shy of $20.00 per 1000. We, the tax payers, cannot afford another bond measure. You are simply choking most property owners to death. 61. Updating settlemier park is useless if it doesn't feel safer and less secluded. Bringing less isolation and sunlight would help as well as activity/more people. It could be a great area for a frisbee golf course. Also, broken picnic tables need to be fixed, especially at centennial. 62. Our city needs an accessible park for children with disabilities, such as adaptive swings, wheelchair accessible play areas and swings, and safe soft ground surfaces 63. More turf soccer fields and basketball courts. Centennial baseball and softball fields hardly ever are used. More parking. Woodburn Parks and Recreation Master Plan 2023 1 Fall 2023 Online Open House Summary Page 13 377 64. Improvements to the Baseball fields and facilities at Centennial Park, in very bad shape and have been neglected for many years. 65. Basketball courts 66. A senior center for seniors to socialize, have resources, classes, games, meals, etc. 67. Plant more trees and improve the quality of the grass at Senior Estates Park. Most users of the park are older and some of the areas have hidden problems that have been neglected and could lead to injuries if people trip or fall. More trees in the northern area of park might help reduce the soggy soil during rainy seasons. 68. All inclusive parks for our disabled children! 69. Regular Landscape Maintenance 70. More restrooms, drinking fountains on trails if possible, supervised dog parks with little to no gopher holes, covered dog play areas, more handicapped and senior access. 71. Leveling the ground and putting in a water spigot and shade/cover at the dog park(s) 72. 1 would like to see the flower and shrub beds around the city and especially the city buildings trimmed, weeded, and cleaned up. Too many of the city properties are in need of work. Why is the city focused on building more when they cannot keep up with the cleaning, weeding, trimming of the properties and open spaces they now have??? 73. Community Center!!! 74. Consistently good maintenance, taking good care of trees and ensuring security and safety in the parks should be the top priorities. 75. Bike trails 76. Improve the park at Senior Estates. Maintain it. 77. More seating along paths 78. Bigger dog Park 79. Top thing, moveable tables and chairs for eating. Next a few more drinking fountains. Old fashioned ornamental fountains like at the plaza downtown. Old fashioned band shells (covered podiums for musical acts). 80. You need to maintain what you have, especially the Aquatic Center, before making new investments! 81. Another Turf field. Legion Park Turf field gets overcrowded and not enough parking spaces. 82. 1 think every park should have a basketball hoop added somewhere. 83. More trees!!! 84. Expand Hermanson Pond and its walking trails. Create a true park with picnic tables, playgrounds and open grasslands. Question 10. Is there anything else you'd like us to know about parks, trails and programs improvements? 1. Create more programs for all religions would be great 2. 1 think Woodburn has some pretty great parks and we definitely have the need and it seems ability to take the resources we already have and improve the places of nature and beauty as well as recreational and educational use areas even better! Woodburn Parks and Recreation Master Plan 2023 ! Fall 2023 Online Open House Summary Page 14 378 3. It be great to expand Legion Park or even have the community center in the empty space between Legion and Police Station 4. It would be great to have indoor spaces for basketball and volleyball and fittness 5. For safety of the kids the trail priority should be towards the high school to downtown. We were sad to see all the summer swim lessons fill up this year. It isn't fair that I pay property taxes here and more than half of the families who signed up for swim lessons live OUTSIDE of Woodburn 6. Nope 7. Farmers markets and such 8. Focus on conserving nature so less habitats are lost. 9. Community garden 10. We'd really like a community garden 11. Big celebrations are great already! Having more smaller events would be fun. 12. The classes/sports programs that are offered feel over priced. Especially when you consider that families have multiple children who they would like to enroll 13. Please connect West Woodburn to our beautiful parks and recreation system with a safe path. Apply for grants, ADA compliance enhancement funding, anything out there! I'll help! We know how it's plotted for development already. Land and right of way costs will never be cheaper than now. Let's lock in business/vibrancy attracting connectivity by connecting our parks. Our walking/biking scores are beyond pale but just one vital link away from being exceptional. 14. Please buy land for more parks. 15. Need more attract such as amusement parks. 16. The trimming and removal of dangerous dead trees. Would love to see more community gardens around also. 17. Would like to see a new community center including a senior center. 18. Really hoping for the expansion of Woodburn Aquatic Center! I feel like the city does a great job overall providing a lot of family friendly events. I feel like the parks are nice here and there are many, especially considering the size of Woodburn, so no complaints there. My one critique would be to somehow encourage less littering at the parks. 19. Give maintenance and take care of it.not just built and neglect it. 20. There are so many great ideas here! 21. Heritage park would be better used as covered area for gatherings and maybe a sports court. Not a playground. 22. kEEP THE NEIGHBORHOOD FAMILY UNITED 23. 1 wish you wouldn't water the designated off -leash dog parks first thing in the morning when people actually would like to use them before it gets too warm. When they are just watered, they are muddy and slippery and dangerous for your dog when they run. If you could water in the middle of the night or late evening, that would be better. Thank you. 24. We should leverage public money where we can obtain multiple good effects on the community. Look for multiple benefits .... combine public safety & health & recreation & livability that is marketable to both residents and visitors 25. Is there anything we can do to improve and clean up our down town area? 26. A bike share program would be awesome. A shaded park for summer Woodburn Parks and Recreation Master Plan 2023 1 Fall 2023 Online Open House Summary Page 15 379 27. For a festival, we ought to have a berry festival. Didn't we used to be the berry capitol of the world? 28. Is there any plans Burlington park? 29. Is there any plans Burlington park? 30. Improve swimming lessons, always full, never any teachers, pool manager doesn't return calls or is never there. Youth sports registration closes way too early and we have never been able to get into a sport because you ended registration for a sport in November. We are not thinking about a sport in august that's in November. It's ridiculous. We don't even use the parks or programs here because it's so chaotic and you can't even get ahold of any one, or get into anything unless it's 3-4 months in advance. This is why lots of kids in this community lose out on youth sports/swimming in this community. Money need to go to this. Ymca run is too expensive and not run very well. I miss my small town park and rec department without big ymca. Why do we have money for these giant parks and trails but not money for actually getting the youth involved in organized sports??? 31. 1 think it's important to consider your audience; who is completing your survey as the survey response may not include what is best for the community. I hope you consider your most vulnerable population and consider their need for parks, access to parks, and what parks can provide, such as access to physical movement. Especially, considering the many apartment complex's and children/adult lack of physical movement. Exposure to green space and nature is known to have positive impact on physical and mental health. We also know that the most vulnerable families in Woodburn currently don't have access to a neighborhood park. I hope you are able to see current park locations and make up of residents in those areas as well as access to current parks before making informed decisions. 32. Woodburn basically only has one safe and usable play structure currently which is centennial and it's very disappointing and boring to have so few options. 33. More trees in the parks and maintain cleans more trails for the people, for walking specially lights for the nigh . 34. Make sure they are wheelchair accessible 35. Would like to see pickleball courts with nets and lighting for night play as well. 36. It would be nice to have other activities other then Mexican heritage activities. Something Anglo folks would be interested 37. More adult activity trips. In the past we've been to places like Crater Lake, Tillamook County Museum, Lincoln city outlets, and my favorite was a balloon ride. It's understandable that these trips stopped during the covid shutdown for safety. But hope the city will sponsor more of these adult day trips year round. I also miss the "Out and About " flyers that came in the mail. 38. We need a bigger & better Farmers Market, that isn't hosted by a religious school 39. Yes. The four new PICKLEBALL COURTS are fantastic. Congratulations on serving the players who had no place to play between Wilsonville and Salem. 40. We need inclusive parks for the disabled! 41. I'm thankful for what we currently have but with all the new housing going on we will definitely need more parks, trails & programs. 42. Would really like an indoor place to walk in bad weather. Seniors need to keep active. What happened to the plans for the aquatic center? Was going to have walking area, meals on wheels etc. 43. Increased placement of garbage cans and doggie bags (recycling options as well) may help decrease litter. Woodburn Parks and Recreation Master Plan 2023 ! Fall 2023 Online Open House Summary Page 16 380 44. trim the shrubs , mow the grass, pull the weeds, clean up the garbage surrounding the parks 45. Consistently good park maintenance, including taking care of trees, and ensuring security and safety in the parks should be the top priorities. 46. 1 will be honest, I have not been to the 4th of July celebration here in Woodburn in a long time. I think last time I went there was a stage set up on Centennial park. I've been to other places for 4th of July, such as Independence, OR, and Longview, WA. I like how they have vendors selling all sorts of things in the locations in which they will have the fireworks show, making it an all day event that leads to the fireworks show. 47. Would like to see a full gym facility to partner with the pool. Pool needs upgraded locker room facilities. 48. Bathrooms of some sort along walking trails. 49. Please don't let new growth on the edge of Woodburn take all the land without new parks and shortcut trails (trails not in parks, that go past or behind private land and between streets.) An empty field as a city park is better than no park at all. 50. 1 Support the community center idea and the trail loop to attract people to Woodburn - A complete loop for walking, cycling and nature watching with restrooms. 51. Create a town that its current residents want to continue living in. Make it safe to walk, shop and use its park systems anytime during the day and evening. Stop building low income housing and selling or granting land for that purpose. Expand and create more wildlife sanctuaries with connecting walking trails. Strive to create a Woodburn that is both clean and beautiful that its residents enjoy its wealth of beauty and are proud to live in. There's currently enough strip malls, thrift shops, drug houses, etc. There isn't enough good dining options, quality small businesses and places to take a stroll and see the wildlife that is still prevalent. Living together with indigenous wildlife with open green spaces throughout the town will begin to disappear if care isn't taken. 52. Mas iluminacion en parques para poder caminar con seguridad (Translation: More lighting in parks to be able to walk safely). Woodburn Parks and Recreation Master Plan 2023 1 Fall 2023 Online Open House Summary Page 17 381 382 CONSFRVATION Project Name: Location: Notes by: Participants: Subject: STAKEHOLDER DISCUSSION SUMMARY Woodburn Parks & Recreation Master Plan Project No.: Proj-# 22-148PLN Microsoft Teams Interview Date: May 24, 2023 Time: 11:30am Steve Duh Jenne Marquez Karen Linton Becki Hayes Dylan Wells Parks & Recreation Master Plan: Stakeholder Discussion Randi Garcia Cruz Emily Duran, City of Woodburn Brian Powers, City of Woodburn Steve Duh, Conservation Technix To discuss current issues, opportunities and needs for city park and recreation amenities. The discussion occurred on March 24, 2023, virtually via Microsoft Teams. The discussion began with a brief introduction and an overview of the city's Park & Recreation Master Plan process. A set of questions were used to initiate the discussion and explore ideas about system planning and local recreation needs. General Comments & Values about Woodburn's City Park System • Love the city! • Need more greenery around seniors complex • Add more trails and splash pad (a 2nd, other than Centennial Park) • Make it equitable — provide spaces for everyone to access • Link pedestrians with trails • Very important to maintain existing parks, even small areas OK like a bench with greenery • As it expands, there are less trees; senior area near 1-5 feels separated from the rest of city • Older areas and newer have no greenery, no sidewalks; walkability is important • City does well bring all the cultures together to celebrate What's Missing or Needs to be Improved? • Overuse at new Legions Park field. Consider adding more fields • Re -vamp Centennial Park for multi -use turf, what does maintenance/use look like if we can add tournaments Interview Notes 1 June 1, 2023 383 Interview Notes (continued) • Soccer tournament concept — field maintenance is horrible; recruiting for a tournament was dead -ended due to poor field condition. Poor maintenance means Woodburn is missing out on revenue. Drainage is poor at Centennial; field pools when it rains. Grants are great, but need operations and maintenance money for consistent maintenance • Return on investment — invest in our city; keep the money in the community through improvements to parks like Legion. Look at Wilsonville as an example. Tourism potential — hotels, gas, snacks, etc. • Community center rebuild, market to public what the improvements are. Project has been quiet for a while • Aquatic center — kiddie pool and locker room are out of shape. Operations need improvement and more staff needed for more hours • Outdoor auditorium — Library space can only handle 100-200 people • Larger areas needed to host fiesta and other large events • Parking often full at Legion Park and Centennial. Woodburn draws from other areas, like Gervais • Tough or people to come into park because parking is limited • Overflow parking areas needed, consider utilizing Park & Ride space near transit center as overflow • Centennial Park needs trees, needs to be easier to get to • Hard to get to Centennial from Legion to use splash pad • Smith addition — good access to walk to parks, walk past Settlemier Park to Centennial Park, maintenance needed, so update • Trails — park to park for walking and biking • Community Development should look at how to fill gaps in sidewalk network • Legion Park — expansion has been great, but playground needs space for little kids to play when others are there at the park • For recreation programs, add more adult activities — softball leagues, volleyball, basketball; Infant to toddler group is hard to serve • Marketing plan for volunteers • Invest in off leash areas • Consider adding solar where you can, i.e., roofs of picnic shelters, covered parking lots Priority Protect Ideas for Next 5+ Years • Build the new community center • Enhance walkability—trail expansion • More marketing/PR/info about what is offered and available • Do roundtables with partners on programs; coordinate don't duplicate; find opportunities to co - marketing -- End of Notes -- Interview Notes 2 June 1, 2023 384 Discussion Group 1 - May 16, 2023 English class for Spanish speakers at Chemeketa Community College in Woodburn. 13 participants Do you currently use any of Woodburn's Parks or Recreation Programs? If so, which ones? • Legion Park • Settlemier Park • Centennial Park - Feels the most complete with all the amenities. Could you describe your preferred activities to engage in while at the park? • Running • Soccer • Walking trails • Basketball • Tennis Which activities motivate you to visit or participate in programs? • Bike routes • Basketball tournaments • Exercising • May 5th event • Kids playground A wide array of amenities exists today - from sport fields and courts, to aquatics, to walking/running trails to playgrounds to water access to dog parks. What recreation opportunities are missing or should be improved? • More basketball courts in the parks. • Improve the playground for kids and include more activities. • Improve the maintenance of existing parks. • Provide more bicycle routes • Add more water fountains to existing parks. • Provide more swimming pool locations. • Include exercise stations in parks. • Include meditation spaces in the parks for relaxation. • Improving the parks safety by installing cameras • Provide artistic activities during the weekends. • Include soft -fall rubber to kids playgrounds • Provide more activities for children 385 • Provide more rest spaces with shades • Plant more trees in the parks, in particular in Centennial Park. Any recommendations on repair upgrades or improvements? What would you like to see in 5 years? • More BBQ stations. • Build more aquatic centers locations. • Upgrade the restrooms. • Become more diligent with the parks maintenance. • Include a bike station. • Include night lights in the park. • Provide a location to fix bicycles. • Free wifi. • Expand the size of the parks. Do you have any comments or experiences that you would like to share? • A participant shared that they stopped visiting the park because they saw people drinking and believed there should be more surveillance for people to feel safe. • The participants would like to be better informed of the city's social media accounts as well as the city's website to look for events and city news. A good place to provide information is at the aquatic center, library and in schools. :: Discussion Group 2 - May 22, 2023 FHDC - Farmworker Housing Development Corporation in Woodburn. 9 participants Do you currently use any of Woodburn's Parks or Recreation Programs? If so, which ones? • Legion Park • Centennial Park Could you describe your preferred activities to engage in while at the park? • Fiesta Mexicana (Festivals) • Walking • Sports Which activities motivate you to visit or participate in programs? • Walking • Running • Exercising • Kids playground • Soccer team • Meditation A wide array of amenities exists today - from sport fields and courts, to aquatics, to walking/running trails to playgrounds to water access to dog parks. What recreation opportunities are missing or should be improved? • Provide splash pads for kids. • Buy property to expand parks or plan on building more parks around town. • Expand the playgrounds and include more games for kids. • Add more benches and resting areas with shade. • Add and renovate restrooms. • Add more tables and grills for barbecue. • Free internet access. • Include a space to play volleyball. • Include more water fountains. • Expand dog parks around town. • Build more skateboard parks. Any recommendations on repair upgrades or improvements? What would you like to see in 5 years? • Provide more security at the parks. • Provide more park locations. • Maintain clean bathrooms. 387 Do you have any comments or experiences that you would like to share? • n/a 388 389 390 IZO Public Relations & Marketing Woodburn Parks Master Plan 2023 Community Feedback Report September 12, 2023 City Events Incorporating music into events has the power to attract larger crowds. The community expresses a strong desire for more musical events. Such an effort would not only enhance community engagement but also serve as a wonderful means of connecting neighborhoods. Enhancements to Recreational Facilities 1. Picnic Shelters: The community has strongly requested additional picnic shelters in various parks, as they would provide residents with more comfortable space for outdoor gatherings. 2. Walking Trails with resting Areas: Expanding walking trails and ensuring the presence of resting areas with shade would encourage more outdoor activities, even on sunny days. 3. Park Expansion: Community members would like to expand walking trails, include bicycle racks, and add more playground activities such as a splash pad, mechanical chime, and spring rider for kids. These enhancements would enrich the experience for children and also involve expanding the parking area. 4. Amenities: The community has requested renovated and well -maintained restrooms across all parks. Additionally, there is a desire to make water fountains more accessible throughout the parks and consider replacements where necessary. Aquatic Center Improvements The expansion of the Aquatic Center is essential, especially considering the expanding population in Woodburn. The current pool size is inadequate to accommodate various activities and gatherings. Therefore, it is necessary to expand the building, the pool itself, as well as the changing areas and washing facilities. Additionally, ensuring adequate staffing is crucial, as the center frequently 391 experiences uderstaffing issues. Furthermore, installing a prominent sign to guide both the community and visitors to the Aquatic Center's location is recommended. Outdoor Facilities and Accessibility 1. Outdoor Splash Pads: Integrating outdoor splash pads in every park would provide a playful water feature for people of all ages. Many parks in other cities in Oregon already have splash pads. Numerous community members have mentioned traveling to these parks for this specific reason. Implementing spash pads in various parks throughout Woodburn would cater to this 2. Multi -Sport Courts: Addressing the high demand for basketball courts, tennis courts, soccer fields, and baseball fields is vital. Ensuring that each park has multi -sport courts would help meet this demand. Many community members have noticed that the addition of multi -sport courts in Legion Park has encouraged more community members to spend time playing basketball, tennis, and badminton. Many believe that implementing these multi -sport courts in other parks around Woodburn is necessary. 3. Water Access: The community members have mentioned many water fountains in the parks do not work or are old. The parks need to upgrade and provide more water fountains as parks are improved more community members will visit the park and the demand now and in the future for water access will increase. Community Engagement Due to the influx of families resulting from new housing developments, outdoor recreation facilities should prioritize meeting their needs. This involves integrating outdoor exercise equipment, coordinating community events, and creating playgrounds and park activities for all age groups. To ensure effective communication, the City should disseminate updates and news not only online but also through physical locations like stores, parks, libraries, and other places frequently visited by individuals who might not be as comfortable with technology. 392 Legion Park and Recreational Activities The community has shown keen interest in the expansion of current parks, with a specific focus on Legion Park. Given its strategic location near downtown, which draws numerous visitors, it is recommended to enhance the walking trail within Legion Park. Moreover, expanding the park's parking space ranks high on the priority list. Overall The community has expressed a desire for more courts and fields, encompassing basketball, tennis, soccer, and baseball. Providing clear and easily accessible information about joining leagues for both kids and adults is essential to encourage community involvement. Although Legion Park has undergone remodeling, the community feels that there is still room for further improvements to enhance the fun and gathering experience for all park attendees. The addition of water stations in parks, increased shading along walking trails, the installation of benches and playgrounds, and the incorporation of outdoor fitness equipment would significantly elevate the overall park experience. 393 394 p 09 IUNT _11 Past community plans and other relevant documents were reviewed for policy direction and goals as they pertain to the provision and planning for parks, trails and recreation opportunities in Woodburn. The development of each involved public input and adoption Iby their respective responsible legislative Ibody. Woodburn Comprehensive Plan, 2022 Most recently amended in June 2022, the Comprehensive Plan for the City of Woodburn is the controlling land use document that provides the framework and vision for implementing the City's goals and future land uses. The Woodburn Comprehensive Plan is documented in two volumes. Volume I includes goals and ocflicies with specific directic)n fc)r Iand use decisicms. Vcflurne I a1sc) includes the cc)rnlorehensive 101an majo that must conform to the stated goals and policies. Volume 11 includes the background information that served as the foundation for the goals and policies adopted Iby the City. The Plan states in intent of the City to provide adequate parks, recreation facilities, and open space to maintain Woodburn's livability and managed growth, and tc) orc)vide sc)cial, ecc)nc)rnic and envircmirriental benefits tc) individuals, Families and the cc)rnrnunity. I ibrary Park, the Downtown Plaza, Woodburn Aquatic Center, Settlemier Park, the Woodburn World's Berry Center Museum, and I ocomotive Park are intended to Ibe used as catalysts for downtown revitalization. To meet the goals for their parks and recreation system, the Plan articulates policies for acquisition and development of adequate parkland for neighborhood parks, trails and open spaces. Parks system development charges and coordination with development review processes are policies to help ensure the park system can keep up with population growth. The City established a one-third mile walkability target for residents to have easy access to parks, trails, and indoor facilities. The implementation of the Mill Creek Greenway Master Plan and the provision of a continuous public greenway and pathway system is another policy within the Comprehensive Plan, The Plan also establishes the policy for adequate maintenance of the park system with the determination of maintenance level of service standards and adequate annual Ibudgets to meet those established service levels. Woodburn 'Transportation System Plan, 2019 The Transportation System Plan (TSP) for the City of Woodburn serves as the Transportation element of the City's Comprehensive Plan sets the vision for the transportation facilities and services needed to accommodate future growth and development. The TSP 2019 update provides a list of projects to address 1(::)cal transloc)rtatic)n needs and deficiencies. I lie I Sl::' set the gc)aIs fc)r rnultirricAal rncfloility tc) orc)vide a multimodal transportation system that avoids or reduces a reliance on one form of transportation and minimizes energy consumption and air quality impacts. The goal incorporates objectives to develop a network of Ibike lanes and routes as well as sidewalks and off-street pathways that improve Ibicycle and pedestrian mobility within neighborhoods and link residential areas to schools, parks, commercial areas, and employment centers. Safety and connectivity are also overarching goals within the TSP. For multi -use paths and trails the I Sl::' recc)rnirriends a minirriurn width c)f 10 feet fc)r 1(::)w pedestrian/loicycle traffic cc)ntexts and 12 tc) 20 feet in area with mc)derate tc) high levels c)f loicycle and pedestrian traffic. I lie I Sl::' narnes the IMill Creek Greenway as a high priority project and numerous connecting pathways as medium priority projects for irnplernentaticm. I lie I Sl::' cites the value c)f wayffinding signs fc)r use cm orii-nary loicycle rc)utes and multi use loaths tc) hello define the rc)ute and direct users tc)wards destinatic)ns with infc)i-irnatic)n aloc)ut distances and average travel times. I lie I Sl::' orc)jects include a city wide wayffinding signage system tc) suloloc)rt Dike i-cwtes, multi -use paths, parks, schools and other essential destinations. 395 Highway 99E Corridor Plan, 2012 The Highway 99E Corridor Plan was developed for the transportation corridor that runs through the eastern edge of the City of Woodburn. The purpose of the Plan was to facilitate revitalization of the corridor aas a business district addressing economic development, motor vehicle mobility & safety, pedestrian & Ibicycle access & safety, property access, aesthetics and neighborhood connections. The Highway 99E Corridor Plan identifies needed transIoc::)rtati(::)n irTilorc:wernents, recc::)rnrnends alolorc::)Ioriate Iand uses, and illustrates the urban design vision for the section of Highway 99E running through the City of Woodburn. Implementation measures include amending the City's Transportation System Plan (TSP), Comprehensive Plan, and Development Code to implement the land use, urban design, access management, and transportation improvements associated with the Corridor Plan. The corridor plan centers on a mixed use village concept intended to provide an activity node on Highway 99E and a sense of connection to Downtown Woodburn. Over time, redevelopment would result in a more walkable safe streetscape with connections to adjacent neighborhoods. The Plan includes an access management plan to Ibe implemented incrementally to improve traffic safety fc::)i, rnc::)tc::)rists, loicyclists and pedestrians. Mill Creek Greenway �Master Plan, 200-7 The National Park Service's (NPS) Rivers, Trails & Conservation (RTCA) agreed to provide staff assistance to help draft a master plan for the Mill Creek corridor and tributaries. Together with a 1 5-member Task Force, NPS and city staff conducted the master planning process to create system -wide recommendations for trail design standards, alignirrients, and imlorc::)vernents orc::)Ioc::)sed fc::)i- the five different planning units 1(::)cated al(::)ilg the Greenway. The establishment of a Mill Creek Greenway and Trail system has Ibeen a goal of the City since the 1960's when the City began acquiring and setting aside properties along Mill Creek. The Master Plan provides recommendations for trail routes, transition nodes, support facilities such as restrooms, trailheads, benches, and signage. The master plan also provided a six -year plan for project implementation along sections currently owned Iby the City. Woodburn Parks and Recreation IMaster Plan Update, 2009 The 2009 Woodburn Parks and Recreation Master Plan Update evaluated existing parks and recreation facilities and provided direction for enhancing the park and recreation system to manage existing and future cc::)rnrnunity needs. I lie tc::)ID three maintenance io rk:)ri ties identified during the planning update were restrooms, trash pickup, and amenities care. The top overall park and recreation priorities to Ibe addressed included increasing youth programs, improving existing parks and facilities, improving security, and increasing cc::)rnrnunicati(::)ns c::)n services and orc::)grarns. Recc::)rTirTiendati(::)ns firc::)rn the 2009 1::IIMI::' update identified the need to create a master plan for Burlingham Park, update playground equipment throughout the park system, continue to develop parks according to established master plans and improve walkability to parks and recreation facilities and to the community as a whole. The PIMP also provided a ten-year list of recommended capital projects with proposed implementation timing and estimated costs. M. 397 398 The following summaries from recognized park and recreation resources provide background on national, state and local park and recreation trends. Examining current recreation trends may inform potential park and recreation improvements and opportunities to enhance programs and services. il 1 1 ppiq IIIIIIII IpI In the 2023 National Recreation and Parks Association (NRPA) Agency Performance Review and its accompanying Park Metrics share comprehensive park and recreation -related data collected and analyzed to inform park and recreation professionals and key stakeholders about the state of the industry. The 2023 NRPA Agency Performance Review presents data from more than 1,000 unique park and recreation agencies across the United States as reported between 2020 and 2022. These resources provide guidance to inform decisions and demonstrate the full breadth of service offerings and responsibilities of park and recreation agencies throughout the United States. This data can offer a perspective for Sammamish Parks and Recreation to compare their service provision to other agencies across the country. However, every park & rec agency has its own unique characteristics, combination of responsibilities and community composition. This comparison of nationwide data with the City of Sammamish can provide guiding insights rather than target benchmarks. I lie agency IIr7ance I indicated recent trends in staffing and vc::flunteers R::)ir II and reciI agencies show that numbers of authorized full-time positions has steadily rebounded since 2011. Key Findings & Characteristics Park facilities and operations vary greatly across the nation. The typical agency participating in the NRPA park metric survey serves a jurisdiction of approximately 45,000 people, Ibut population size varies widely across all responding jurisdictions. The typical park and recreation agency has jurisdiction over 22 parks comprising over 571 acres. When including non -park sites (such as city halls and roadway medians), the median management scale for park agencies increases to 30 sites encompassing 676 acres. Park facilities also have a range of service levels in terms of acres of parkland per population and residents per park. These metrics are categorized Iby the agency's population size. Flark F�'acilffies The typical park and recreation agency has: 10 One [Dark for every 2,287 resudents 10 One [DIayground for every 3,759 resudents 10 '10.8 acres Of [Dark (and for every 1,000 resudents un uts puHsd'ctuon 10 '15 mHes of traHs for waIking, hHdng, runnung and/or bking 10 8.9 fuIkturne equuvaIent erri[DIoyees [Der '10,000 resudents 399 Figure G-1. Median Residents per Park Based On Population Size 7,000 6,000 5,791 "000 4,()()() 3,240 3,000 2,287 2,014 2,240 ��°°�; 1,115 'e Ile Figure G2. Acres of Parkland per 1,000 Residents based on Populalion Size 13 11 10 101, IIIII IIIIIIIIII iiiii ,Iliil e ry�p�,' � U b� � � � ry �.� ,� ��, W,,. "le s" A large majority of park and recreation agericies provide playgrounds (95%) and Ibasketlball courts (86%) in their oc)rtfc)1ic) c)f c)utdc)c)r assets. Mc)st agencies (three in five) c)ffer cc)rni-nunity and/c)r recreatic)n centers. Recreation centers (63%) are provided more often thari community centers (59%). Senior centers (41%), performarice amphitheaters (37%) and mature centers (33%) are also common. The typical park and recreation agericy that mariages or maintains trails for walking, hiking, running arid/or biking has 15 miles of trails. Agencies serving more thari 250,000 residerits have a median of 89 miles of trails under their care. Park and recreation agericies often take ori responsibilities Ibeyornd their core functions of operating parks and providing recreatiorial programs. Other responsibilities may include tourist attractions, golf courses, outdoor amphitheaters, indoor swim facilities, farmer's markets, indoor sports complexes, campgrounds, performing arts centers, stadiums/arerias/racetracks, fairgrounds arid/or marinas. 1"rogramming At least seven in torn agericies provide themed special events (89% of agericies), team sports (86%), social recreatic)n events (88%), ycwth summer carrilos (82%), Fitness enhancement classes (81%), and health and wellriess education (80%). Staffing Park and recreation employees are responsible for operations and mairiteriarice, programming and administration. The typical park and recreation agericy has: 10 51.5 fd-turne equuva�ent staff (F:: I Es) on [DayroH IN &9 1:::I Es on staff for every '10,000 resudents un uts puHs&ctuon Median ATE courits also positively correlate with the mummer of acres maintained, the mummer of parks maintained, operating experiditures, and the population served. For example, agericies that serve populations Ibetweern 20,000 and 49,999 residerits employ am average of 32.3 ATE, while agericies that serve 50,000 to 99,000 people employ am average of 75.8 ATE. MA Figure FsPark arid necmo I iomAoencysI a ffino: Full -Time sqowolenIs(ey.Joriodmionpopola non �"° 12 111 �"° Anc::Aherwway c::)fc:)mparing agency staffing acrc::)ssdifferent parkand recreatcnagencies examines number ofstaff per 10,000 residents. These comparative numbers hold fairly steady across population sizes with the median for all agenciesat8.9 FTEs. Figure c4.Park and Recreation Agency pTcs Perl0,000 Residents ° � � � 103 =" 10 SA " 4A �^ � , .. .. .. .. .. ..| Capital and Operating 1,�� Xpenses For capital experises, the typical park agericy: 10 Oe6icatesabout 56%^zrenovatonpno�ectsand 3O%^onew 6eve|opmentpno�ects. 10 P|onato apen6 o6out $8 million on copho| exloen6hures over the next five years. For operations, the typical park agencyspends: 10 $5.5 miUion [Der year on tot | operat�ng expenses 10 $7,823 on annua| O[Derating ex[Denses [Der acre Of [Dark and non -[Dark sites managed IDY the agency 10 $9477onannua|operatingexpenses[Der capito 10 $1O5'4g4inannua|operat�ngexpen6imnes[Der emp|oyee 10 55%ofthe annua|operatingbudget onpersonne|costs, 3g%onoperatingexpenses'and 5%oncapito|expenses not included inthe agency's capito|impozvementp|an 10 46%ofitsoperating6u6getonparkmanagementan6main^enance'41%onnecneat�on'an613%onotheractivit�es Agency 1��'Undiny The typical park arid recreation agency: 10 Oerives61%oftheiroperatingexpen6imnesfrom genera|fund tax support22%from generated revenues, g%from dedicated taxes or |e�es, 3% from other dedicated taxes and 6% from grants, S[DonsorsH[Ds and other sources 10 Generates $2171 inrevenue annuaUyfor each resident inthe juhs6iction 401 Recreation Management magazine's 2022 Report on the State of the Managed Recreation Industry summarizes the opinions and information provided Iby a wide range of professionals (with an average 21.9 years c)f experience) wc)iI in the recreaticm, slI and Fitness industry. I lie 2022 1 indicated that I1 (82.3%) recreaticm, slI and Fitness facility c)wners fc)iI III with other organizations as a means of expanding their reach, offering additional programming opportunities or as a way to share resources and increase funding. I ocal schools are shown as the most common partner (59.6%) for all facility types. Youth -serving organizations (Ys, JCC, Boys & Girls Clubs) and park and recreation organizations were the most likely to report that they had partnered with outside organizations, at 98% and 94% respectively. Revenue Outlook The year 2020 represented a dramatic departure from the norm, with nearly two-thirds (64.9%) of respondents indicating that their revenues for the year were lower than the previous year. By 2021, the number reporting a drop in revenue fell to 26.7%—still a dramatically different result from most survey years, Ibut an obvious improvement over 2020. At the same time, while only 13.4% of respondents saw their revenues increase in 2020, Iby 2021, more than half (51.7%) were reporting revenues on the rise again. Respondents were much more optimistic about 2022 and 2023, with 60% indicating they expect to see higher revenues in Iboth years. At the same time, 9.8% still expect revenues to fall in 2022. Facilities & Improvements A majority of park respondents (43%) reported plans to add features at their facilities and were also the most likely to Ike planning to construct new facilities in the next few years (39%). The top 10 planned features for all facility types include: 'I. S[DIash [DIay areas (21.4% of res[Dondents wuth Glans to add features are pIannung to add SpIaSh [DIay) 2. Synthetic turf s1I fields (1 9.5%) 3. F)Iaygrounds ('17.7%) 4. 1:::utness centers ('15.5%) S. F)ark sheIters ('14.1 %) 6. Dog [Darks ('13.6%) 7. F)ark restroorn structures ('12. 7%) 8. F::I[tiness trails and outdoor fit.iness equiII (12-3%) 9. Exercise stud'o roorns ('11.8%) '10. Dsc goIf courses '11. Concessuon areas Programming Nearly all respondents (96.4%) offer programming of some kind. The top 10 most commonly offered programs include: holiday events and other special events (provided Iby 57% of respondents); day camps and surni-ner carrilos (54%),- giI exercise 111 (53%),- Fitness 111 (53%),- educaticmal III (51%); youth sports teams (50%); mind -body balance programs such as yoga and tai chi (43%); arts and crafts programs (41 %); adult sports teams (38%); and programs for active older adults (38%). 402 Respondents from community centers, parks and health clubs were the most likely to report that they had plans to add programs at their facilities over the next few years. The ten most commonly planned program additions were: 'I. Knd-body baonce [Drograrns (29.9%, U[D from 23.4% un 2021) Z F::utness [Drograrns (27.9%, U[D from 25.5%) 3. GroU[D exercise [Drograrns (27.9%, U[D from 25.7%) 4. Educatuona� [Drograrns (25.9%, U[D from 20.8%) 5. Arts and crafts [Drograrns (21.9%, U[D from '17.4%) 6. leen [Drograrns (21.9%, down from 23.7%) 7. F::unctional fitness ,.)rograrns (21 A%, ul,,.) from '17.8%) 8. Flerforn-flng arts [Drograrns (21.4%, U[D from '17.4%) 9. EnvVronrnenta� educatuon (20.9%, U[D from 20%) '10. Holidays and other S[Decia� events (20.4%, down from 21 %) General) Challenges Facility managers were asked about the challenges they anticipated impacting their facilities in the future. Generally, cwerall loudgets are the tc)lo cc)ncern fc)r mc)st reslocmdents including staffing (63%) and their ability to support equipment and facility maintenance needs (50%). With COVID-1 9s impact on the wane, we asked respondents to tell us about their top goals for their facilities in the coming year. The most common responses centered around increasing participation and membership, as well as building and renovating facilities. Recruiting and training staff, as well as just "getting Iback to normal" also made up a large number of the responses. o J.I WWII I 1IMM� According to 2023 Outdoor Participation Trends Report, published Iby the Outdoor Foundation in Boulder, Colorado, the outdoor recreation participant Ibase grew 2.3% in 2022 to a record 168.1 million Americans (55%) ages 6 and older. The number of outdoor participants has grown over the last eight years, however, the numb c)f cwtings per participant declined in 2022 fc)r the first time since the loandernic Megan in 2020. Key Insights include the following: The recreational participant Ibase is much more diverse than ever Ibefore. New and young outdoor participants are significantly mc)re diverse than the current c)utdc)c)r loose and are accelerating quickly. 117e participation rate for Hispanic people has increased from 34% in 2015 to 56% in 2022. A significantly higher percentage c)f senic)rs (ages 55 1-) are participating in c)utdc)c)r recreaticm. In 2022, the senior participation rate hit a record high of 35% and rising. This equates to 1 in every 5 outdoor participants and a total of 1 million new participants in 2022. Gateway Activities & Growth'Trends Gateway activities, cme c)( the first c)utdc)c)r recreatic)n activities oec)lole participate in at any age, serve as magnets to outdoor activity and commonly lead to more activity in niche categories like backpacking and 403 adventure racing. Gateway activities continue to drive new entrant outings and frequency of participation. I liking is the mc)st joc)joular activity. Running, bicycling, Fishing and carrijoing rcwnd cwt the tc)jo five. Running has the highest average outings per runner at In 54 per year. Camping has the highest growth rate over the past three years at 29.1 % per year. The outdoor activity categories with the highest growth rates among kids included Ibackp acking, snowshoeing, canoeing, climbing, and off -road triathlon. Participation Rate Decline The frequency of participation is declining across outdoor recreation. In 2013, the average number of outings per participant was 84.6. Over the last ten years, average number of outings has dropped to 71.8 per participant. Demographics are changing quickly in the U.S. population, and the outdoor recreation market has lagged behind. Park and recreation agencies are recognizing the need for increased diversity in the participant Ibase c)f joark and recreatic)n users. I lie new and ycwng c)utdc)c)r participant bases are significantly mc)re diverse than the total participant Ibase, a formula for long-term growth in diversity for outdoor recreation. Monitoring progress on diversity is key to understanding if outreach is Ibeing effective. 2023 Sports, Fitness & Leisure ActivitillesTophune Participation Report Prepared Iby a partnership of the Sports and Fitness Industry Association (SFIA) and the Physical Activity Ccwncil (IFIAC), this ::::�eloruary 2023 joarticiloatic)n rejoc)rt summarizes levels c)f activity and identifies key trends in sjoc)rts, fitness, and recreatic)n in the US. I lie rejoc)rt is based cm c)ver 18,000 cm1ine interviews c)f a naticmwide sample that provides a high degree of statistical accuracy using strict quotas for gender, age, income, region, and ethnicity. The study looked at more than 124 different team and individual sports and outdoor activities, including a section dedicated to the impact of COVID-1 9 on participation results. Compared to 2017, activity increased Iby 9.2% in total participation rates. Activity in the U.S. continues to increase fc)r the Fifth cc)nsecutive year. In 2022, 77.6% c)f all Arnericans, c)ir 236.9 millic)n joec)jole participated in at least one activity during the 2022 calendar year. I here were mc)re things tc) dc) as c)utdc)c)r activities thrived, Fitness at hc)rne became mc)re joc)joular, and team sports started Iback up after the COVID-19 hiatus. Participation nearly doubled for pickleball in 2022, increasing loy 85.7% year c)ver year. In 2022 Fc)r the first time in c)ver seven years, every racquet sjoc)rt increased its total participation number compared to the previous year. In terms of team sports, the overall participation rate approached, Ibut did not exceed, the 2019 rate. .:;'asketloall, c)utdc)c)r sc)ccer, and flag fc)c)tIoall all joc)sted three year increases c)f c)ver 4.5%, with basketball leading the way with a 13% increase since 2019. 1 ifestyle activities generally remained very popular. Golf and tennis have grown more than 20% since 2019, and yoga grew more than 10% in that same time period. Trail running and day hiking participation grew for the Fifth straight year. I lc)wever, facility based Fitness activities like elliptical, grc)ujo staticmary cycling, and weight resistance machines, which suffered as clubs were shuttered during COVID, have struggled to return to pre -pandemic levels. LIS I Figure G5. 2021Tofal Participation Rafe by Activity Category (U.S. population, ages 6-0 VItness Sports mmmmmmmmmm= Outdoor Sports NEEMENEEM 1111(fividuall Sports mommommomm li eann Sports momma Water Sports Em Racquet Sports Wilinteir Sports Figure Ga. Activities with the Highest 5-year Increase, in Participation (average a rinua I growth, 2018 2022) Middelball Golf (off couirse only; didiviing irairnge, etc) IMairdall Arts SIkatelboardiing Camphig li rail Runniing suirung lienniis lflilkhag(f)ay) Kayalkiing (Iflecireabionall) The 2019-2023 Statewide Comprehensive Outdoor Recreation Plan (SCORP), entitled Outdoor Recreation in Oregcm: Reslocmdhng tc) I )eirric)grajohic and Sc)cietal Change, ccmstitutes Oregcm's basic five year jolan fc)r c)utdc)c)r recreaticm. I lie jolan addresses five irriloc)rtaint derric)grajohic and sc)cietal changes facing c)utdc)(::)r recreation providers in the coming years including: 'I. An agung [DO[DU�atuon-' 2. An uncreasungy cl'verse [DO[DU�atuon-' 3. 1 ack of youth engagement un outdoor recreatuon; 4. An underserved how-uncorne [DO[Du�atuon-' and 5. Fhe health oenefits of johysical activity. As part of developing the SCORP, the Oregon Parks and Recreation Department (OPRD) conducted a statewide survey of Oregon residents regarding their 2017 outdoor recreation participation in Oregon, as well as their opinions about park and recreation management. This data can help local park and recreation providers Ibetter understand public opinions and the preferences of outdoor recreation participants. 1::::'ifty six (56) recreaticm activities were identified as irriloc)rtaint recreaticm activity tyloes. I hese activities were grouped into eight (8) categories including Non -motorized Trail or Related Activities, Motorized Activities, Non -motorized Snow Activities, Outdoor I eisure and Sporting Activities, Nature Study Activities, Vehicle- �based Camping Activities, Hunting and Fishing Activities, and Non -motorized Water -based and Beach WE Activities, The tops three activities with the largest annual user occasions include Walking orn local streets / sidewalks (313 million); Walking orn local trails / paths (113 million); and Dog walking / going to dog parks / off -leash areas (78 million). Figure G7. User Occasions for Oregon ResidenIs in Outdoor Activities Walking on local streets / sidewalks 313 Walking on local trails / paths 113 Relaxing, hanging out, escaping heat / noise, etc. 93 Dog walking / going to dog parks / off -leash areas 78 Taking your children or grandchildren to a playground 57 Sightseeing / driving or motorcycling for pleasure 55 Bicycling on roads, streets / sidewalks 51 Walking / day hiking on non -local trails / paths 44 Jogging / running on streets / sidewalks 37 Bicycling on paved trails 26 Figure G8. Pori icipa I ion Boles for Oregon Residents in Outdoor Activities MEMEMEMENIM Walking on local streets / sidewalks 83 Walking on local trails / paths 74 Sightseeing / driving or motorcycling for pleasure 59 Relaxing, hanging out, escaping heat / noise, etc. 59 Beach activities —ocean 57 Walking / day hiking on non -local trails / paths 55 Attending outdoor concerts, fairs, festivals 50 Visiting historic sites / history-themed parks 49 Picnicking 49 Beach activities - lakes, reservoirs, rivers 40 Figure G9. Frequency Per Household for Oregon ResidenIs in Outdoor Activities Walking on local streets / sidewalks 204 Walking on local trails / paths 75 Relaxing, hanging out, escaping heat / noise, etc. 60 Dog walking / going to dog parks / off -leash areas 51 Taking your children or grandchildren to a playground 37 Sightseeing / driving or motorcycling for pleasure 36 Bycycling on roads, streets / sidewalks 34 Walking / day hiking on non -local trails / paths 29 Jogging / running on streets / sidewalks 24 Bicycling on paved trails 17 The survey also asked about priorities for local community rneecds revealing the tops six (6) local (close to home) rneecds as 10 0eaner restroorns. 10 Soft surface waH<ing traHs. 10 IMore restroorns. 10 Flaygrouncls wuth natural rnateHak (I`Jatura� Flay Areas). 10 Nature and wHc hfe vuewung areas. 10 I=UDHc access to waterways. When asked about recreation priorities for dispersed recreation opportunities, survey respondents indicated their top priorities as 10 0eanerrestmoms. 10 Soft surface wa|<ingtrai|s. 10 Nature and wi|6|ife viewing areas. 10 IMonenestmoms. 10 Pu6|icaccess ^zwaterways. 10 IMone p|acesan6 benches toobserve nature and others. 10 Picnicaneas and she|^ersfor smaU visi^zrgmups. Outdoor recreation participants were asked what their local parks and recreation agency could do to improve/increase participation and value. Across the state, providing more free'of-chargerecreation opportunities was the most important action, with ensuring clean and well -maintained parks and facilities, and developing walking / hiking trails closer to home also high in importance. OPIRD also conducted a statewide survey of Oregon public recreation providers to determine outdoor recreation funding priorities for OPIRD grant programs and identify top management issues and challenges faced 6v public recreation providers. The survey showed that across the state within urban growth boundaries, the most important funding need was for community trail systems; restrooms; children's playgrounds and play areas built with manufactured structures like swing sets, slides, and climbing apparatuses; picnic areas and shelters for small visitor groups; trails connected to public lands; and picnicking/day use and facilities. In rural areas across the state, the most important funding need was for nestrooms, RV/ trailer campgrounds and facilities, day -use hiking trails, connecting trails into large trail systems, interpretive displays, and tent campgrounds and facilities (car camping). Creating new park and recreation facilities was the greatest maintenance/management challenge for urban and urban growth areas. Other pressing issues were maintaining existing local parks in the community, addressing Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) issues, and providing safe walking and biking routes to parks and trails. More rural, dispersed setting park providers faced challenges maintaining existing park and recreation facilities. Adequate funding was lacking by most park and recreation providers for renovation, rehabilitation; updating facilities for universal access (A[)Acomp|iance); growing homeless population pressures, responding to new recreation trends and technology. In many cases, park and recreation providers were concerned that inadequate funding would increase safety and security issues associated with public use ofpark and recreation facilities and services. This annual study from the National Park and Recreation Association (NRFA) probes Americans' usage of parks, the key reasons that drive their use, and the greatest challenges preventing greater usage. Each year, the study examines the importance of public parks in Americans' lives, including how parks compare to other services and offerings of local governments. The survey of 1,000 American adults looks at frequency and drivers ofparks/recreation facilities visits and the barriers tothat prevent greater enjoyment. Survey respondents also indicate the importance of park and recreation plays in their decisions at the voting booth and their level c::)fsuppc::)rt tc::)r greater funding. Key Findings include: 10 Eighty-four [Dercent of U.S. aduks seek Hgh-quahty [Darks and recreat�on when choosing a [D|ace to hve. 10 Neady3 in 4 U.S. residents have at |eastone |oca| park, p|aygmun6' open space or necreat�on center within wa|<ing 6istonceoftheirhomes. 10 Mne in ten [Deo[D|e agree that [Darks and recreation in an irn[Dortant service [Dro�ded IDY the |oca| government. 10 Neady 3 in 4 adu|ts agree that equity shouH be an extrerne|y or very irn[Dortant goa| for th6r |oca| [Dark and necreat�onagency 407 People who live near parks and recreation facilities are more likely to Ibe park and recreation users. Individuals living near at least orie park are much more likely to arrive at that park Iby am "active" mearis (e.g., walking, biking, rurining), with walking Ibeirig the most common method of transport. Conversely, 80 percent of U.S. adults who do not live within a walkable distarice to parks or recreation opportunities travel to those amenities Iby car. The typical adult in the United States visits their local parks or recreation facilities every other morith. Four main reasons for visiting local parks and recreation facilities stand out Ibeirig with family and Friends, exercising and being physically fit, taking a Ioreak Frc::)rn day tc::)day stresses, and being ck:)ser t(::) nature. Park and recreatk:)n agencies can custc::)rnize their c::)fferings tc::) the specific needs, wants and desires c::)f their community members Iby knowing their motivation for visiting parks. Figure G10. NRPA Park Engagernerd: Key Reasons for Park Visils To have someone care for my children while I am at work 5% To learn a skill or craft 13% to connect with members of my community 22% To experience excitement/adventure 30% To be closer to nature 50% To have a break from day-to-day stresses 52% To exercise or be physically fit 53% To be with familv or friends 54% According to the Americans Engagement with Parks report, "Parks and recreation's success results from its vast offerings of parks, trail rietworks and other recreation facilities that deliver critical programs for every segment of a community. Each person's relatk:mship with joarks and recreatk:)n is unique. &:)rne joec::)1ole Fk:)ck tc::) their k:)cal joark tc::) stay physically fit, meet with Friends and family, c::)r recc::)nnect with nature. Others depend c::)n their k:)cal joark and recreation agericy for indispensable services that improve their lives. But there remairis much work to do. Orie-huridred million people do not live within a walkable distarice of at least orie park or recreation facility. Further, many survey resporiderits indicate they have felt unwelcome at a park or recreation facility or say the infrastructure and programming are not inclusive. Parks and recreation is for everyone — regardless of age, income, race, ethnicity, ability, gerider identity or sexual orientation. Professionals, advocates and political leaders have the opportunity to marrow any accessibility or iriclusivity gaps through greater community engagement and addressing inequitable funding and infrastructure investments that have deprived millions of people of access to parks and recreation." iiiii�ilillill� IIIIIIIII Illiliilll�ilillill�� =1111111 IIII =111111pj In November 2022, the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA) released its annual report ori the economic impact of the outdoor recreation industry at national and state levels. The gross economic output for the outdoor recreation economy was $862 Ibilliorn in 2021, accounting for 1.9% of the gross domestic product that year. Outdoor recreation economic activity showed am 18.95% increase from 2020 while the overall U.S. ecc::)nc::)rny c::)nly saw a 5.9% increase. l::Iec::)joIe Finding ernjok:)yrnent in the c::)utdc::)c::)r recreatk:)n industry increased �by 13.1% from 2020 to a total of 4.5 million people. The research group Headwaters Economics, in collaboration with the State Outdoor Recreation Business Alliance, published a report in 2021 ori the state of the outdoor recreation economy nationally. The outdoor recreation industry employed nearly 5.2 million people in the U.S. in 2019 and contributed $459.8 Ibilliorn to the economy. The report emphasizes that investments in outdoor recreation directly result in visitor spending that supports jobs, busiriesses, and industries across the country. ME, V MMMM, MCNIUMM, Across the country, local municipalities and park and recreation providers with older public infrastructure have been upgrading their facilities to comply with the outdoor recreation guidelines for universal access and the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). The removal of existing architectural Ibarriers in park facilities has Ibeern ongoing and should continue until renovations, upgrades and newer construction provide Ibarrier-free access to all users. Access and inclusion in public parks extends Ibeyond the physical amenities and incorporates cc::)nsideratk:)ns c::)f anguage, tedhnc::)k:)gy, wayffinding, jorc::)grarn equity and equitable gec::)grajohic distributk:)n (::)f facilities. Park and recreation agencies are in a unique position to champion efforts that advance diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI). By assuring representation of diverse life experiences and voices, park and recreation orc::)fessk:)naIs will better reflect the cc::)rn rn u n i ties their agencies serve. Inequity is the ultimate challenge Facing the nation, and parks and recreation can make a profound difference. Numerous studies have Ibeern documenting the contributions of parks and public lands to Ibetter climate resiliency. Flarks, c::)joen sloace and natural Iands can cc::x:)l urban heat islands, buffer fk:)c::)d irrijoacts, impirc:we water quality and improve air quality. Urban tree canopy in parks can remove air pollution and sequester carbon. Parks and greenways along storm -affected coastlines are Ibeing create to help Ibuffer impacts of anticipated Fk:)c::)dhng due tc::) sea level rise, stc::)n-n surges, and increased joreciloitatic::m. Clirnate resilience strategies involving parks can focus on resilient shoreline development, green stormwater infrastructure and increased tree groves. As the climate changes, outdoor recreation opportunities and availability can Ibecome more inconsistent. Wildfires, fk:)c::)dhng, reduced snc::)wjoadk and c::)ther envirc::mirriental irrijoacts Firc::)rn curate changes can directly and indirectly affect visitor -use patterns. Recreation planners and managers play a role in climate resiliency Iby protecting vulnerable resources that can impact outdoor recreation opportunities. 410 The City of Woodburn possesses a range of local Funding tc)cfls that ccw1d be accessed fear the benefit of growing, developing and maintaining its parks and recreation system. The sources listed Ibelow represent likely potential sources, Ibut some also may Ibe dedicated for other local purposes which limit applicability and usage. Therefore, discussions with city leadership is critical to assess the political landscape to modify or expand the use of existing city revenue sources in favor of parks and recreation efforts. LOCAL FUNDING OPTIONS General) Obligation Bond These are voter -approved bonds with the authority to levy an assessment on real and personal property. The money can only Ibe used for capital construction and improvements, Ibut not for maintenance. This orc)loerty tax is levied fear a specified oeric)d c)f time (usually 15-20 years). Passage requires a simple majority in November and May elections, unless during a special election, in which case a double majority (a majority of registered voters must vote and a majority of those voting must approve the measure) is required. Cities in Oregon have a legal debt limit on general obligation (GO) debt equal to 3% of their real market value. For the City of Woodburn, this limit calculates to $61.7 million. At the Ibeginning of 2022-2023 Ibudget cycle, the City had $1.2 million in GO Debt. The available amount of additional debt the City can incur is $60.4 million. Park Utility Fee A park utility fee provides dedicated funds to help offset the cost of park maintenance and could free up general fund dollars for other capital project uses. Most city residents pay water and sewer utility fees. Park utility fees apply the same concepts to city parks, and a fee is assessed to all businesses and households. The monthly fee would Ibe paid upon connection to the water and sewer system. Woodburn does not assess a park utility fee. System Development Charges Woodburn currently assesses a parks system development charge (SDC). SD Cs are charged fear new residential devek:)1ornent tc) hello Finance the demand for park facilities created Iby the new growth. Oregcm gas taxes are cc)11ected as a fixed amcwnt per gallon of gasoline purchased. The Oregon Highway Trust Fund collects fuel taxes, and a portion is paid to cities annually on a per -capita Ibasis. By statute, revenues can Ibe used for any road -related purpose, which may include sidewalk repairs, AD upgrades, Ibike routes and other transportation - oriented park and trail enhancements. 411 Rivers, 'Tr fills and Conservation Assistance Program .- NationA Park Service The Rivers, Trails and Conservation Assistance Program, also known as the Rivers & Trails Program or RTC, , is a community resource administered Iby the National Park Service and federal government agencies, so they can conserve rivers, preserve open space and develop trails and greenways. The RTC, assists communities and public land managers in developing or restoring parks, conservation areas, rivers, and wildlife habitats, as well as creating outdoor recreation opportunities and programs that engage future generations in the outdoors. Urban and Community Forestry Grants Oregon Department of Forestry The Oregon Department of Forestry provides a range of grants and incentives for private landowners and municipalities. Program areas range from community forestry to weed control to conservation and resiliency efforts. North American Wetlands Conservation Act Grants Program .- US Fish & Wildlife Service The North American Wetlands Conservation Act of 1989 provides matching grants to organizations and individuals who have developed partnerships to carry out wetland conservation projects in the United States, Canada, and IMexicc::) R::)ir the IDenefit of wetlands -associated migratory Ibirds and other wildlife. Both are Two competitive grants programs exist (Standard and a Small Grants Program) and require that grant requests Ibe matched Iby partner contributions at no less than a 1-to-1 ratio. Funds from U.S. Federal sources may contribute towards a project, Ibut are not eligible as match. The Standard Grants Program supports projects in Canada, the United States, and Mexico that involve long-term protection, restoration, and/or enhancement of wetlands and associated uplands habitats. In Mexico, partners may also conduct projects involving technical training, environmental education and outreach, organizational infrastructure development, and sustainable -use studies. The Small Grants Program operates only in the United States; it supports the same type of projects and adheres to the same selection criteria and administrative guidelines as the U.S. Standard Grants Program. However, project activities are usually smaller in scope and involve fewer project dollars. Grant requests may not exceed $75,000, and funding priority is given to grantees or partners new to the Act's Grants Program. Locall Government Grant .- Oregon Parks and Recreation I ocal government agencies who are obligated �by state law to provide public recreation facilities are eligible for OPR's I ocal Government Grants, and these are limited to public outdoor park and recreation areas and facilities. Eligible projects involve land acquisition, development and major rehabilitation projects that are consistent with the outdoor recreation goals and objectives contained in the Statewide Comprehensive Outdoor Recreation Plan. Land and Water Conservation Fund (LWCF) Grant .- Oregon Parks and Recreation I VVCF grants are available through OPR to either acquire land for public outdoor recreation or to develop Ibasic outdoor recreation facilities. Projects must Ibe consistent with the outdoor recreation goals and objectives stated in the Statewide Comprehensive Outdoor Recreation Plan and elements of local comprehensive land use plans and park master plans. A 50% match is required from all successful applicants of non-federal funds, in -kind services and/or materials. RecreationA 'Tr fills Program Grant .- Oregon Parks and Recreation Recreational Trails Grants are national grants administered Iby OPRID for recreational trail -related projects, such as hiking, running, Ibicycling, off -road motorcycling, and all -terrain vehicle riding. Yearly grants are awarded Ibased on available federal funding. RTP funding is primarily for recreational trail projects, rather than utilitarian transportation -based projects. Funding is divided into 30% motorized trail use, 30% non -motorized trail use and 40% diverse trail use. A 20% minimum project match is required. 412 Oregon Heritage Grants .- Oregon Parks and Recreation Oregon Heritage offers a variety of grant programs for heritage projects from historic building preservation to oral history projects and more. Grant orc::)grarns fc:xus c::)n specific fc:xi, including faqade renovation, main street revitalization, Veterans' and War Memorials, the preservation of historic resources, among others. Bicycle & Pedestrian Program Grants .- Oregon Department of 'Transportation The Pedestrian and Bicycle Grant Program is a competitive grant program that provides resources to Oregon cities, counties and ODOT regional and district c::)ffices Fc::)r design and cc::)nstructi(::)n (::)f pedestrian and Ibicycle facilities. Proposed facilities must Ibe within public rights -of -way. Grants are awarded Iby the Oregon Bicycle and Pedestrian Advisory Committee. Project types include sidewalk in(ill, Al )A ulogrades, street circ::)ssings, intersectk:m improvements, minor widening for Ibike lanes. Oregon Watershed Enhancement Board Grant The Oregon Watershed Enhancement Board focuses on projects that approach natural resources management from a whole -watershed perspective. OVVEB encourages projects that foster interagency cooperation, include other sources of funding, provide for local stakeholder involvement, include youth and volunteers and promote learning aloc::)ut watershed cc::)ncelots. I here are five general categories of projects eligible for OVVEB funding: watershed management (restoration and acquisition), resource monitoring and assessment, watershed education and outreach, and technical assistance. Arts Grants .- Oregon Arts Commission The Oregon Arts Commission funds arts programs and individual artistic innovation throughout Oregon. Grant programs serve as investments in our state's culture. They are supported Iby contributions from the State of Oregon, the Oregon Cultural Trust, and the National Endowment for the Arts. Private Grants, Donations & Gifts Many trusts and private foundations provide funding for park, recreation and open space projects. Grants from these sources are typically allocated through a competitive application process and vary drarnatically in size based c::)n the Financial resources and funding criteria of the organization. Philanthropic giving is another source of project funding. Efforts in this area may involve cash gifts and include donations through other mechanisms such as wills or insurance policies. Community fund raising efforts can also support park, recreation or open space facilities and projects. �Mever emoriall 'Trust The Meyer Memorial Trust seeks opportunities to make program -related investments in Oregon and Clark County, VVA. General Purpose Grants support projects related to arts and humanities, education, health, social welfare, and a variety of other activities. Proposals may Ibe submitted at any time under this program, and there is no limitation on the size or duration of these grants. REII in the Community .- Noin.-Piro-fift Partnerships and Grants Partnerships begin with store teams who may cc::mnect with nc::)n orc::) fits loy orc::)rTx:)thIg (::)i- lDartnering for events and service projects, raising visibility with REI customers, offering product donations, and inviting and selecting organizations for an REI grant. Kaiser Permanence Healthy Environments - Community IBeine-fit Pirogiranns These programs work with community -based organizations, public agencies, businesses and residents to translate their vision for healthy communities into visible, concrete changes — and ultimately healthier neighborhoods. Kaiser has several assistance programs that encompass support for Environmental Stewardship, Community Health Initiatives, Every Body Walk , and Physical Activity Guiding Principles. 413 Business Sponso rsh ips/lDo nations Business sponsorships for programs may Ibe available throughout the year. In -kind contributions are often received, including food, door prizes and equipment/material. Interagency Agreements State law provides for interagency cooperative efforts between units of government. Joint acquisition, development and/or use of park and open space facilities may Ibe provided between parks, school districts, other municipalities and utility providers. ACQUISITIONTOOLS & METHODS DIRECT PURCHASE METHOIDS Market ValUe 1"Urchase Through a written purchase and sale agreement, the city purchases land at the present market value Ibased on an independent appraisal. Timing, payment of real estate taxes and other contingencies are negotiable. Partial ValUe 1"Urchase (or Bargain Sale) In a Ibargain sale, the landowner agrees to sell for less than the property's fair market value. A landowner's decision to proceed with a Ibargain sale is unique and personal; landowners with a strong sense of civic pride, long community history or concerns about capital gains are possible candidates for this approach. In addition to cash proceeds upon closing, the landowner may Ibe entitled to a charitable income tax deduction Ibased on the difference between the land's fair market value and its sale price. fo 1111states & BeqUeStS In the event a landowner wishes to remain on the property for a long period of time or until death, several variations on a sale agreement exist. In a life estate agreement, the landowner may continue to live on the land Iby donating a remainder interest and retaining a "reserved life estate." Specifically, the landowner donates or sells the property to the city, Ibut reserves the right for the seller or any other named person to continue to live on and use the jorc::)joerty. When the c::)wner c::)i- c::)ther specified Ders(::)n dies or releases his/her life interest, full title and control over the property will Ibe transferred to the city. By donating a remainder interest, the landowner may Ibe eligible for a tax deduction when the gift is made. In a Ibequest, the landowner designates in a will or trust document that the property is to Ibe transferred to the city upon death. While a life estate offers the city some degree of title control during the life of the landowner, a Ibequest does not. Unless the intent to Ibequest is disclosed to and known Iby the city in advance, no guarantees exist with regard to the condition of the property upon transfer or to any liabilities that may exist. OptiOrl to 1"Urchase Agreement This is a Ibinding contract between a landowner and the city that would only apply according to the conditions of the option and limits the seller's power to revoke an offer. Once in place and signed, the option agreement may Ibe triggered at a future, specified date c::)i- ujoc::)n the cc::)rnjo1etk:)n c::)f designated conditions. Option agreements can Ibe made for any time duration and can include all of the language pertinent to closing a property sale. Right of F�'irst RehiSal In this agreement, the landowner grants the city the first chance tc::) jourchase the jorc::)joerty c::)nce the landowner wishes to sell. The agreement does not establish the sale price for the property, and the landowner is free to refuse to sell it for the price offered Iby the city. This is the weakest form of agreement between an owner and a prospective �buyer. Conservation 1,,Asements Through a conservation easement, a landowner voluntarily agrees to sell or donate certain rights associated with his or her property — often the right to subdivide or develop — and a private organization or public agency agrees to hold the right to enforce the landowner's promise not to exercise those rights. In essence, the rights are forfeited and no longer exist. This is a legal agreement between the landowner and the city (or private organization) that permanently limits uses of the land in order to conserve a portion of the property for public use or protection. Typically, this approach is used to provide trail corridors where only a small portion of the land is needed or for the strategic protection of natural resources and habitat. The landowner Mill owns the property, Ibut the use of the land is restricted. Conservation easements may result in an income tax deduction and reduced property taxes and estate taxes. The preservation and protection of habitat or resources lands may Ibest Ibe coordinated 414 with the local land trust or conservancy, since that organization will likely have staff resources, a systematic planning approach and access to non- governmental funds to facilitate aggressive or large scale transactions. LANDOWNER INCENTIVE �MEASURES fl)erlSity BOrIUSL-S Density bonuses are a planning tool used to encourage a variety of public land use objectives, usually in urban areas. They offer the incentive of being able to develop at densities beyond current regulations in one area, in return for concessions in another. Density bonuses are applied to a single parcel or development. An example is allowing developers of multi -family units to Ibuild at higher densities if they provide a certain number of low- income units or public open space. For density bonuses to work, market forces must support densities at a higher level than current regulations. "I ransfor of L� )evelopment Ri _9 1, P ts The transfer of development rights (TDR) is an incentive -based planning tool that allows land owners to trade the right to develop property to its fullest extent in one area for the right to develop beyond existing regulations in another area. I ocal gc:wernirrients may establish the specific area In which development may Ibe limited or restricted and the areas in which development beyond regulation may Ibe allowed. Usually, Ibut not always, the "sending" and "receiving" property are under common ownership. Some programs allow for different ownership, which, in effect, establishes a market for development rights to Ibe Ibought and sold. IRC 1031 1,,,xchanye If the landowner owns Ibusiness or investment property, an IRC Section 1031 Exchange can facilitate the exchange of like -kind property solely for Ibusiness or investment purposes. No capital gain or loss is recognized under Internal Revenue Code Section 1031 (see www.irc.gov for more details). 1 111 i 11 11 0111111111,11 16,110111, 1101MM I Land 'Trusts & Conservancies I and trusts are Iorivate nc::)n jorc::ffit c::)rganizati(::)ns that acquire and protect special open spaces and are traditionally not associated with any government agency. The Greenbelt I and Trust is the local land trust serving the Woodburn area. Other national organizations with local representation include the Nature Conservancy, Trust for Public I and and the Wetlands Conservancy. 415 �J I )' "v cu a ; - �� i ,w " ,d Exhibit B L. Parks and Recreation 111% "Jly g"Vfl� sfld maititaitis valrious jecTeatioti �'acjljties, atId op�j] �"oir iresidetits atid visiturs t:) e oyThese assets aire essetitial �'oir maititaitiitig the setise 4' commutii1y gfld I?Iide ( tj : that makes "�oodl)urti a vil)iratit atid attiractive pl�lu:,e tag live., woirk, atid visit. Open Space/ Parks Goals and Policies Goals L- 1. Flie Woof#*WiI 12afks afid Reefeatio,ofi CoHipfekefisi've Nafl shall establish a 4affiewof]( k)f latid aequisitioti atid [,'Hufe pilfk 'Witkitl tke ('()HIM Utl i ty . It is Me goal o Me City to pfavide pilfhs; feefeatio,ofl �iaeijities; afid apefl Sf)ffile to fflaffl4offl Jival)ility atid iiiatiat"ed gis,)wthl atid to perovide social, economic, and environmental benefits to individuals, families, and the community t ]jQqgb as IQ12111, did eTse, itich'BlvwY.w ni (2� " 12aajh.16 a,Teatjoti �'acjljtaes, alld (mji L-2. Maititaiti Dd,owntown Woodburn should iremaitias a centerpiece of activity, culture, and commerce within the City. Library $qjIgle Park, the Downtown Plaza, Woodburn Aquatic Center, Settlemier Park, Me Woodburn WOfld'S Beffy Gefitef Museum, Buiiga ]QG y Theatire, and 1w iratik Scheeir Locomotive Park should be used as catalysts for downtown revitalization. Policies 1, 1 , I rhe (Jly ,vill utilize the Pairks atid Recireatioti Masteir Plati sur.a g!jide �"olr itivesIlD9 lres(aql�'es urtaa pglrha, le'Ireatjotl �'acjljtjes atid spg,es,,. L- 1.2.1 . The City will ensure that sufficient land is made available to meet current and future parks and open spaces needs by acquiring and developing new parks in the areas idetiti 'Jed iti the Parks atid Recireatioti Masteir Plati..,,vest (.4� 5: Me 04he eity; east e) [I Ititefstate 5atid the "ieuthea"it afea (')0 the City, west (')0 I fit�lvvvay 99121 L-1.3,2 Where feasible, the City will acquire and develop neighborhood parks, trails, and open spaces through the development review process. L- 1.47';. The City will ensure that parks system development charges are adequate to meet the parks, trails, and open space needs created by development. L-1.54 To ensure walkability, the City will strive to provide parks, trails, and indoor facilities within one- qj!aajjgjhiird mile of Woodburn residents. 1, 1 fi The (Jjy ,vill strive to etisulre that p�jks, tirails., atid irecireatiotial �'acjljtjes alre iticlusive atid pj(Dyjde access to all aNlities. LA-23-04 Planning Commission Staff Report Attachment 102: Comprehensive Plan Goal and Policy updates Paget of 417 Exhibit B L-1.7.5 The City will ensure the most efficient and effective means of providing sufficient land for neighborhood parks by pursuing partnerships with schools and other agencies to establish joint parkland acquisition, development, and operational ventures. L-1.8.6 It is the policy of the City to implement the Mill Creek Greenway Master Plan, and to manage the Mill Creek, Goose Creek, and Senecal Creek corridors as public greenways and pathways,ultiple ii�unctions ( these cor idoir swii.i. include open space and habitat preservation, flood control, cycling and walking on all-weather pathways, nature recreation and education, and limited playground activities where there is a deficiency of neighborhood parks. The City will establish and enforce a healthy streams policy to ensure that Woodburn's waterways are preserved and well -maintained. L-1.9.7 To provide for a continuous public greenway and pathway system, it is the policy of the City to acquire privately -owned segments along Mill Creek, Goose Creek, and Senecal Creek and other stream corridors itiol ditig tke...WeSt 44)HHIFY 4001... eWefflief ilflfk 4).:PEW �Road. It is the policy of the City to seek dedication of floodplains and creek corridors for natural areas, neighborhood recreation areas, open space and transportation. L-1.10,9 To ensure adequate maintenance of the City's parks, open spaces, and recreation facilities, the City will prepare comprehensive management plans, including maintenance level of service standards for each site. L-1.1 P) The City will ensure that adequate funds are budgeted annually to meet established .. level of service standards for parks, open spaces, and recreation facilities. L-1.12,0 The City will support the development of an "Adopt a Park" program to encourage community involvement in the stewardship of parks and trails. L-1.1"11 Because recreation participation preferences and interests vary among employment, ethnic, social, and cultural groups, it is the policy of the City to ensure that parks, open spaces, facilities, and programs are developed to meet the diverse needs and interests of Woodburn's population. LA-23-04 Planning Commission Staff Report Attachment 102: Comprehensive Plan Goal and Policy updates Page 2 of 2 418 Exhibit C II iretirOducdOire The Woodburn Development Ordinance (WDO) does not include specific approval criteria for legislative amendments, beyond initiation per WDO 4.01.09, processing, and notification requirements. However, per state law, amendments to a Comprehensive Plan, including the adoption of implementing documents such as a Parks & Recreation Master Plan (PRMP), are required to be consistent with: • Statewide Planning Goals • Oregon Administrative Rules (OAR) • Woodburn Comprehensive Plan goals and policies The findings for adoption of the PRMP and associated Comprehensive Plan amendments address these same criteria. The present version of the Comprehensive Plan was last amended through Legislative Amendment LA 23-02 as Ordinance No. 2619 on January 10, 2024 (goals and policies relating to an Economic Opportunities Analysis). Statewide Planning Goals There are a total of 19 Statewide Planning Goals. Staff finds Goals 1, 2, and 8 are applicable Statewide Planning Goals to the adoption of the PRMP and identified updates to the Woodburn Comprehensive Plan goals and policies. The PRMP does not contain regulations that pertain to these goals and is not proposing changes to existing associated regulations. Applicable goals include Goal 1 (Citizen Involvement), Goal 2 (Land Use Planning), and Goal 8 (Recreational Needs). Of these, Goal 8, titled Recreational Needs, is the primary goal of consideration in review of this proposal. The fundamental purpose of Goal 8 is to ensure that a local government plans for the recreational needs of its residents. This proposal is for the adoption of the Parks & Recreation Master Plan (PRMP), which contains information pertaining to Goal 8 and for findings in support of adoption. Rules that implement Goal 8 are described in Chapter 660, Division 34 of the Oregon Administrative Rules (OAR). Local government park plans are specifically mentioned in OAR 660-034-0040. The proposed PRMP was produced to meet the requirements of Goal 8 and all implementing administrative rules. The PRMP provides a factual basis for updating Woodburn Comprehensive Plan Section L (Parks and Recreation). The City of Woodburn created these existing policies in concert with the adoption of the previous PRMP. The proposed amendments include new and modified policies for the City to support a robust system of parks and recreational offerings. LA-23-04 Planning Commission Staff Report Attachment 101: Analyses & Findings Page 1 of 7 419 Exhibit C Goal 1 --- Citizen Involvement Statewide Planning Goal 1 requires cities to involve community members in planning processes and decisions. The City and its consultants have done this in a variety of ways as part of the planning process. - Surveys. The City distributed a random -sample mail survey and an online community - wide survey in English, Spanish, and Russian. - Advisory Group. The Woodburn Recreation and Parks Board functioned as a technical advisory group (TAG) for the PRMP. The committee met three times to review materials and provide direction at key milestones. - Public Forums. The City hosted two open house meetings (May 31 and September 15, 2023) and conducted a series of tabling activities at various community events between July and September 2023. - Planning Commission and City Council Meetings. Staff provided for public meetings before the Planning Commission and City Council to present information. The City followed State and Local public notice procedures to inform members of the public about these meetings. - Notification to the Department of Land Conservation and Development (DLCD). Staff provided notice to DLCD of the proposed Comprehensive Plan amendments on December 18, 2023, in compliance with OAR 660-018-0020 and notified affected government agencies in conformance with WDO 4.01.14D. - Online Access to Draft Materials. Staff made draft copies of the PRMP and proposed Comprehensive Plan Goal and Policy changes available on the City's website for public review and comment on January 18, 2024. Based on the above findings, the PRMP is consistent with Statewide Planning Goal 1. Goal 2 --- Land Use Planning Goal 2 requires each local government in Oregon to establish a land use planning process and policy framework as a basis for all decisions and actions related to use of land and to assure an adequate factual base for such decisions and actions. Goal 2 also includes requirements for coordination with other jurisdictions and government agencies, requires that plans include implementation measures, and that plans be reviewed periodically and amended as needed. The City last updated and adopted its Parks & Recreation Master Plan (PRMP) via Ordinance No. 2458 on July 15, 2009. To ensure that the City has an accurate understanding of the community's recreation interests and needs, the City Council initiated a Type V legislative process to update the City's PRMP and consider correlating updates to the Comprehensive Plan Goals and Policies. The City appointed the Recreation and Parks Board as the technical advisory group (TAG) for the preparation of a new PRMP. The committee met three times to review materials and provide direction at key milestones. One purpose of the committee meetings was to ensure that there LA-23-04 Planning Commission Staff Report Attachment 101: Analyses & Findings Page 2 of 7 420 Exhibit C was a forum for affected government agencies to express concerns with proposed updates to the plan and provide the City with the opportunity to consider and accommodate modifications to the plan during the preparation phase of work. These meetings also provided a venue for coordination discussions with Marion County staff as needed. The proposed PRMP is now being reviewed for adoption under the City's Type V legislative procedure as outlined in the Woodburn Development Ordinance. That procedure includes the City undertaking the following steps, which includes additional opportunities for review and comment by citizens and affected governmental units: - The City notified affected government agencies in conformance with WDO 4.01.14.D. on January 5, 2024, and published notice of both the Planning Commission and City Council hearings in the Woodburn Independent newspaper on January 17, 2024. - Project update presentations to Planning Commission on December 14, 2023, and City Council on September 25, 2023; - The Planning Commission hearing scheduled for January 25, 2024; - The City Council hearing is tentatively scheduled for February 12, 2024; - On December 18, 2023, staff sent a Post -Acknowledgement Plan Amendment (PAPA) to the Department of Land Conversation and Development (DLCD) in compliance with OAR 660-018-0020. Based on the above findings, the PRMP is consistent with Statewide Planning Goal 2. Goal 8--- Recreational Needs Goal 8 requires the City to plan for the recreation needs of our residents and visitors. The goal prioritizes non -motorized forms of recreation, and recreation areas that serve high -density populations with limited transportation options and limited financial resources. It also places priority on recreation areas that are free or available at a low cost to the public. The draft Parks & Recreation Master Plan (PRMP) being considered does exactly what Goal 8 requires. This plan details a profile of the community today, including demographics and interests of residents; it inventories the existing parkland, trail network, and recreational programming that the City offers; it outlines a series of goals and objectives for the City to work towards; and provides an implementation and investment plan for the City Council to consider. The PRMP and Comprehensive Plan update are consistent with Oregon Statewide Planning Goal 8. iregoire Adimiireistiradve Rules Oregon Administrative Rules (OAR) 660-034-0040 guide planning efforts for local parks in Oregon. The following is a summary of consistency with those rules. (1) Local park providers may prepare local park master plans, and local governments may amend acknowledged comprehensive plans and zoning ordinances pursuant to the LA-23-04 Planning Commission Staff Report Attachment 101: Analyses & Findings Page 3 of 7 421 Exhibit C requirements and procedures of ORS 197.610 to 197.625 in order to implement such local park plans. Local governments are not required to adopt a local park master plan in order to approve a land use decision allowing parks or park uses on agricultural lands under provisions of ORS 215.213 or 215.283 or on forestlands under provisions of OAR 660-006- 0025(4), as further addressed in sections (3) and (4) of this rule. If a local government decides to adopt a local park plan as part of the local comprehensive plan, the adoption shall include: (a) A plan map designation, as necessary, to indicate the location and boundaries of the local park, and (b) Appropriate zoning categories and map designations (a "local park" zone or overlay zone is recommended), including objective land use and siting review criteria, in order to authorize the existing and planned park uses described in local park master plan. Response: The City has prepared this Parks and Recreation Master Plan (PRMP) to guide local park planning in Woodburn. Adoption of the PRMP is proposed as part of an amendment to the comprehensive plan. As required by subsection (a), local park boundaries are illustrated throughout Chapters 4-6 of the PRMP. The Comprehensive Plan Map already includes a land use category titled "Open Space and Parks" and the Zoning Map already contains an associated zoning district titled "Public / Semi -Public". The Woodburn Development Ordinance, the implementing ordinance for the comprehensive plan, already outlines land use and siting review criteria for the Public / Semi -Public zoning district. No changes are proposed to this land use category or zoning district. (2) Unless the context requires otherwise, this rule does not require changes to: (a) Local park plans that were adopted as part of an acknowledged local land use plan prior to July 15, 1998, or (b) Lawful uses in existence within local parks on July 15, 1998. Response: The City last updated and adopted its Parks & Recreation Master Plan (PRMP) via Ordinance No. 2458 on July 15, 2009. (3) All uses allowed under Statewide Planning Goal 3 are allowed on agricultural land within a local park and all uses allowed under Statewide Planning Goal 4 are allowed on forest land within a local park, in accordance with applicable laws, statewide goals, and rules. Response: The proposed Parks & Recreation Master Plan (PRMP) does not involve any agricultural lands or uses, nor any forest lands or uses, within local parks. Goals 3 and 4 are addressed by counties. (4) Although some of the uses listed in OAR 660-034-0035(2)(a) to (g) are not allowed on agricultural or forest land without an exception to Goal 3 or Goal 4, a local government is not required to take an exception to Goals 3 or 4 to allow such uses on land within a local LA-23-04 Planning Commission Staff Report Attachment 101: Analyses & Findings Page 4 of 7 422 Exhibit C park provided such uses, alone or in combination, meet all other statewide goals and are described and authorized in a local park master plan that: (a) Is adopted as part of the local comprehensive plan in conformance with Section (1) of this rule and consistent with all statewide goals, (b) Is prepared and adopted applying criteria comparable to those required for uses in state parks under OAR chapter 736, division 18, and (c) Includes findings demonstrating compliance with ORS 215.296 for all uses and activities proposed on or adjacent to land zoned for farm or forest use. Response: The proposed Parks & Recreation Master Plan (PRMP) does not involve any agricultural lands or uses, nor any forest lands or uses, within local parks. Goals 3 and 4 are addressed by counties. Conclusion: The PRMP is consistent with the OAR requirements for preparation of a local parks plan. Consistency wii [i Woodburn Coiml ireIheiresive PIIaire Goals and Policies The City's Comprehensive Plan already contains goals and policies that help the City achieve its recreation and park planning objectives. These existing goals and policies, which center around providing a variety of benefits to the community through a diverse offering of recreational spaces and programs, provide a strong policy basis and framework to support adoption of the PRMP. As part of this legislative amendment, only minor amendments are proposed to Section L of the Comprehensive Plan. Generally, the amendments cover name changes for certain facilities and focus on making goals and policies more concise. Two new policies are recommended — one to more directly refer to the PRMP as a guiding document for recreation planning, and one stating it is the City's policy to ensure facilities are inclusive and accessible. Conformance w i i [i i l7 e Woodburn Development ir&n a ire ce 4.01 Decision -Making Procedures 4.01.02 Assignment of Decision -Makers: The following City entity or official shall decide the following types of decisions: E. Type V Decisions (Legislative): Type V decisions involve legislative actions where the City Council enacts or amends the City's land use regulations, comprehensive plan, Official Zoning Map or some component of these documents. Type V decisions may only be initiated by the City Council. The Planning Commission holds an initial public hearing on the proposal before making a recommendation to the City Council. The City Council then holds a final public hearing and renders a decision. Public notice is provided for all public hearings (Section LA-23-04 Planning Commission Staff Report Attachment 101: Analyses & Findings Page 5 of 7 423 Exhibit C 4.01.14). The City Council's decision is the City's final decision and is appealable to LUBA within 21 days after it becomes final. 4.01.09 Initiation of a Legislative Proposal A. The City Council may initiate the consideration of a legislative decision by resolution. B. Actions initiated by the Council shall be referred to the Planning Commission for a public hearing and recommendation to the Council. C. The City Council shall hold the final public hearing on a proposed legislative decision. The Planning Commission hearing is scheduled for January 25, 2024, and the City Council hearing is tentatively scheduled for February 12, 2024, pending a recommendation to the Council by the Planning Commission. On December 18, 2023, staff sent a Post - Acknowledgement Plan Amendment (PAPA) to the Department of Land Conversation and Development (DLCD) in compliance with OAR 660-018-0020. The City notified affected government agencies in conformance with WDO 4.01.14.D. on January 5, 2024, and published notice of both the Planning Commission and City Council hearings in the Woodburn Independent newspaper on January 17, 2024. The provisions are met. Notice: ORS 227.186 Notice to property owners of hearing on certain zone change; form of notice; ... (2) All legislative acts relating to comprehensive plans, land use planning or zoning adopted by a city shall be by ordinance. Pending a decision from the City Council following its public hearing, the Council would be able to direct staff to return with an ordinance for adoption at a subsequent Council meeting. (3) ... at least 20 days but not more than 40 days before the date of the first hearing on an ordinance that proposes to amend an existing comprehensive plan or any element thereof, or to adopt a new comprehensive plan, a city shall cause a written individual notice of a land use change to be mailed to each owner whose property would have to be rezoned in order to comply with the amended or new comprehensive plan if the ordinance becomes effective. (4) At least 20 days but not more than 40 days before the date of the first hearing on an ordinance that proposes to rezone property, a city shall cause a written individual notice of a land use change to be mailed to the owner of each lot or parcel of property that the ordinance proposes to rezone.... (5) An additional individual notice of land use change required by subsection (3) or (4) of this section shall be approved by the city and shall describe in detail how the proposed ordinance would affect the use of the property. The notice shall:.. . (6) At least 30 days prior to the adoption or amendment of a comprehensive plan or land use regulation by a city pursuant to a requirement of periodic review of the comprehensive plan LA-23-04 Planning Commission Staff Report Attachment 101: Analyses & Findings Page 6 of 7 424 Exhibit C under ORS 197.628, 197.633 and 197.636, the city shall cause a written individual notice of the land use change to be mailed to the owner of each lot or parcel that will be rezoned as a result of the adoption or enactment.... (7) Notice provided under this section may be included with the tax statement required under ORS 311.250. (8) Notwithstanding subsection (7) of this section, a city may provide notice of a hearing at any time provided notice is mailed by first class mail or bulk mail to all persons for whom notice is required under subsections (3) and (4) of this section. (9) For purposes of this section, property is rezoned when the city... The City proposes no rezoning or WDO amendment at this time. Because the City is not changing the base zoning classification of property, in other words neither rezoning nor making a zone change, Sections (3), (4) and (5) above are not applicable. Because the proposed amendment is not pursuant to a requirement of periodic review, Sections (6) & (7) & (8) are not applicable. (10) The provisions of this section do not apply to legislative acts of the governing body of the city resulting from action of the Legislative Assembly or the Land Conservation and Development Commission for which notice is provided under ORS 197.047 or resulting from an order of a court of competent jurisdiction. Staff finds the proposed PRMP update and proposed updates to Comprehensive Plan Economic Goals and Policies do not result from actions of the Legislative Assembly or the Land Conservation and Development Commission (LCDC) and that ORS 197.047 is not applicable. As a result, the City of Woodburn is not required for LA 23-04 to do a "Measure 56" notice, the phrase referring to Ballot Measure 56 (1998) that the legislature codified in ORS 227.186, which the legislature later revised via Senate Bill 516 (2003). The provisions are met. LA-23-04 Planning Commission Staff Report Attachment 101: Analyses & Findings Page 7 of 7 425 rr � Ig Ag4,-.44 fun.- W4OO�N Inc orpornreA 1889 February 26, 2024 TO: Honorable Mayor and City Council through City Administrator FROM: Renata Wakeley, Special Projects Director Jesse Cuomo, Community Services Director SUBJECT: 2024 Local Government Grant Program (LGGP) from Oregon Parks and Recreation Department to support Boones Crossing Park RECOMMENDATION: Adopt the attached Resolution, as required prior to LGGP grant fund application, and authorize the City Administrator to sign the grant application and to effectuate an award of the grant contract, if awarded. BACKGROUND: The City of Woodburn is eligible to apply for a 2024 Local Government Grant Program (LGGP) Large grant with a cap of $1,000,000 from the Oregon Parks and Recreation Department. These particular grant funds can be used for land acquisition, development, and/or major rehabilitation projects that are consistent with the outdoor recreation goals and objectives of OPRD and/or recreation elements of local comprehensive plans and local parks master plans. The City's Parks Master Plan was updated in January 2024 and a priority project is the development of the recently acquired Boones Crossing Park. The city has previously secured funding assistance through the LGGP program for the Centennial Dog Park improvements (2023), Centennial Park Splash Pad (2016), and Legion Park Rehabilitation (2013). Oregon Parks and Recreation Dept (OPRD) receives 7.5% of State Lottery proceeds that are then allocated to various programs. For 2024, OPRD expects to have over $28 million in Large Grant funds available, the largest sum available to date. DISCUSSION: Following completion of two community meetings and an online survey soliciting feedback on design concepts, the City of Woodburn is proposing to submit an application for 2024 Local Government Grant Program (LGGP) from Oregon Parks Agenda Item Review: City Administrator _X City Attorney _X_ Finance _X_ Honorable Mayor and City Council February 26, 2024 Page 2 and Recreation for improvements to Boones Crossing Park to include, but not limited to: • Site preparation, earthwork, and landscaping, including a rain garden to address stormwater, and irrigated lawn and plant beds; • Site features and furnishing (playground equipment, park signage, furniture and fixtures, drinking foundations, fencing, walking paths, etc.); and • Structures such as a sports court and new shelter/pavilion. Council adoption of the attached Resolution allows City staff to move forward with submitting the LGGP application by the April 1 deadline, with any awarded funds expected to be received in October 2024. If our application advances, the City will also be asked to make a presentation to the Local Government Advisory Committee in June -July 2024. If awarded, projects must be completed within a 2-year project period. FINANCIAL IMPACT: The City is seeking up to $700,000 in LGGP funding for the Boones Crossing Park development, estimated at $1,400,000. The LGGP Large Grant program requires a match of 50% (or 1: 1). This means the City would need to match up to $700,000 in Parks SDC's if awarded. However, we are in the process of contracting for an appraisal of the donated 3-acre property as it has been determined to be eligible for match, if we can secure an appraisal valuation by June 1, 2024. That appraisal could reduce the cash/Park SDC match requirement significantly. Additional costs to the City include completion of the grant application and grant administration, which are not eligible for reimbursement. Attachment(s): 1. Boones Crossing concept plan (DLA) 427 B OWES C"TtY OF WOODMILIFN OONES FERRY, CROSSING, PARK% oar "wnm wjj r SME 15 301 1 k, 428 COUNCIL BILL NO. 3245 RESOLUTION NO. 2229 A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE CITY OF WOODBURN STAFF TO APPLY FOR A LOCAL GOVERNMENT GRANT FROM THE OREGON PARKS AND RECREATION DEPARTMENT FOR DEVELOPMENT OF BOONES CROSSING PARK, AND DELEGATING AUTHORITY TO THE CITY ADMINISTRATOR TO SIGN THE APPLICATION WHEREAS, the Oregon Parks and Recreation Department is accepting applications for the Local Government Grant Program (LGGP); and WHEREAS, the City of Woodburn desires to participate in this grant program to the greatest extent possible as a means of providing needed park and recreation acquisitions, improvements and enhancements; and WHEREAS, the Woodburn City Council have identified the build out and development of improvements at Boones Crossing (identified as Tax Lot 1406 of Map 051 W 18C) as a high priority need in the City of Woodburn and as identified in our 2024 Parks Master Plan; and WHEREAS, the Boones Crossing Park property is a currently undeveloped 3-acre park that was dedicated to the City of Woodburn as part of the phased Boones Crossing residential development. The park is identified as a future neighborhood park in the 2024 Parks Master Plan. With funding assistance from the LGGP program, the City proposed to complete final design, permitting, and build out of the 3-acre property; and WHEREAS, the City of Woodburn has available local matching funds to fulfill its share of obligation related to this grant application should the grant funds be awarded; and WHEREAS, the City of Woodburn will provide adequate funding for on -going operations and maintenance of this park and recreation facility should the grant funds be awarded, NOW, THEREFORE, THE CITY OF WOODBURN RESOLVES AS FOLLOWS: Section 1. The Woodburn City Council demonstrates its support for the submittal of a grant application to the Oregon Park and Recreation Department for development of planned Boones Crossing Park, as identified in our 2024 Parks Master Plan, located at Boones Crossing and more generally the SE corner of Boones Crossing Road and Iris Street. Page 1 - Council Bill No. 3245 Resolution No. 2229 429 Section 2. This Resolution shall be effective following its adoption by Woodburn City Council. Approved as to form: City Attorney Date Approved: Passed by the Council Submitted to the Mayor Approved by the Mayor Filed in the Office of the Recorder ATTEST: Heather Pierson, City Recorder Page 1 - Council Bill No. 3245 Resolution No. 2229 Frank Lonergan, Mayor 430 rr N 4?4 4' *7 Ag4,-.44 f�i WTOODBURN Inc orpornreA 1889 February 26, 2024 TO: Honorable Mayor and City Council through City Administrator FROM: Renata Wakeley, Special Projects Director Jesse Cuomo, Community Services Director SUBJECT: 2022/23 Oregon Community Pathways (OCP) Grant Contract from Oregon Department of Transportation (ODOT) to Support Expansion of Mill Creek Trail RECOMMENDATION: Accept the Oregon Community Pathways grant award from the Oregon Department of Transportation and authorize the City Administrator to effectuate an award of the grant contract. BACKGROUND: The City of Woodburn submitted an application to the Oregon Community Pathways (OCP) program through the Oregon Department of Transportation (ODOT) in January 2023. The OCP program supports project development, construction, reconstruction, major resurfacing or other improvements of multi -use paths that improve access and safety for people walking and bicycling. More specifically, this is a unique ODOT program that primarily funds off -road pathways instead of work within existing roadway networks. While project development and planning were also eligible under the OCP program, the largest allocation of OCP funding was earmarked for construction ready projects where the applicant already controlled the majority of property or easements for the proposed trail location. The City of Woodburn adopted the Mill Creek Trail Master Plan in 2006 and has steadily made progress toward full build out of the trail, either by City initiated and funded projects or via private development conditions of approval, where a nexus could be assigned. Prior to the January 2023 OCP application deadline, Staff reviewed corridors remaining to be built out from the adopted plan for opportunities to meet the OCP funding and scoring criteria, including ownership or easements for the proposed trail segments. Those segments included: • Hermanson Pond, Agenda Item Review: City Administrator _X City Attorney _X_ Finance _X_ 431 Honorable Mayor and City Council February 26, 2024 Page 2 • Woodburn High School, • Settlemier Park, • Evergreen, and • Wyffels' Park Cost estimates for an estimated 6,850 additional linear feet of trail, including administration, final design and surveying, pathway fixtures, and contingency funding, amounted to $1,932,369.75, of which 10.27% is required to be cash match from the City. The City provided a match commitment letter as part of the OCP application in the amount of $198,454.37, which was proposed to be divided between the budgets of the Parks and Transportation SDCs funds. In July 2023, the Oregon Bicycle and Pedestrian Advisory Committee reviewed application submissions and we received word that we ranked #1 out of 19 projects submitted for OCP construction funding. The top nine (9) projects received notices of intent to award and the City received our draft OCP contract in January 2024. DISCUSSION: A condition of the Oregon Community Pathways funding is that ODOT will deliver the project, meaning all contractual services and construction contracts will be with ODOT and not the City of Woodburn. OCP funds will not pass through the City budget. Staff met with ODOT on several occasions to discuss this project and ODOT has provided assurances that they will work with the City on costs, potentially removing amenities to stay within the budget, and will discuss any potential scope reductions with the city. For example, if the costs for constructing the five segments are too high, one or more segments may need to be removed to stay within the award and match budget. The city has also been encouraged to apply for additional funds, including OCP funds to construct others segments in the future. Once awarded, projects are expected to be completed within a 5-year project period. FINANCIAL IMPACT: The City's match requirement for Oregon Community Pathways (OCP) funding is 10.27%, or $198,454.37. As part of the Grant Award, the City also agrees to cover all costs in excess of the federal funds, which could include up to a 10% increase in the project's overall cost estimate. The City distributed the match requirement 432 Honorable Mayor and City Council February 26, 2024 Page 3 between Park and Transportation SDC funds in FY23/24. While ODOT is assigned to deliver the project, additional costs to the City include grant reporting, technical advisory committee, and other general support to ODOT staff to ensure timely completion of the project and general outreach and project updates. These are not eligible for reimbursement and cannot be used to meet the match requirement. 433 Agency/State Agreement No. 73000-00020952 EXHIBIT A — Project Location Map & Description (1) Evergreen Blvd extension north of Smith Addition, from Ben Brown Drive to S. Evergreen Road, estimated at 2,000 linear feet of new trail. (2) Hermanson Pond connection/extension westward, from existing Hermanson Pond loop to Hermanson Street dead-end, estimated at 1,500 linear feet of new trail. (3) Wyffles Park, from E Lincoln Street to Hardcastle Ave, estimated at 1,190 linear feet of new trail. (4) Woodburn High School connection, from Hwy 214 to Hazelnut Drive, estimated at 1,300 linear feet of new trail. (5) Settlemier Park, from S Front Street to Settlemier Ave, estimated at 800 linear feet of new trail. 0 434 WTOODBURN Ig i�e� Its Inc orpora teA 1889 February 26, 2024 TO: Honorable Mayor and City Council FROM: Scott Derickson, City Administrator SUBJECT: ARPA Contract Award for Mid -Willamette Valley Community Action Agency for Shelter Services RECOMMENDATION: Authorize the City Administrator to enter into an ARPA funding agreement with Mid - Willamette Valley Community Action Agency (MWVCAA) in the amount of $80,000 for Shelter Services, and authorize under ORS 197.746 for MWVCAA to operate and oversee, overnight vehicular sheltering, as part of standard operations at 1560 Hardcastle Street, Woodburn, Oregon. BACKGROUND: In June 2021, Oregon House Bill 3115 (Local Camping Ordinances) was made effective following the 9th Circuit decisions in Martin v. City of Boise and Blake v. Grants Pass. H133115, requires that any city or county law regulating the acts of sitting, lying, sleeping, or keeping warm and dry outside on public property must be "objectively reasonable" based on the totality of the circumstances as applied to all stakeholders, including persons experiencing homelessness. (Exhibit A) On August 14, 2023, former City Attorney Bob Shields presented to the City Council on HB 3115 and ORS 195.530, the statute addressing the use of public property by homeless individuals, and attorney fees. City Attorney Shields presented the wide array of pathways taken by communities across the state to ensure compliance with the new regulations. (Exhibit B) Following the presentation, City Council adopted Council Bill No. 3226; An Ordinance Requiring Compliance with ORS 195.530 and Declaring an Emergency; in addition, the City Council directed the City Administrator to evaluate the best possible solution for the City of Woodburn and all its residents to meet the recent statue. Additionally, in June of 2023, Oregon House Bill 3395 was made effective. As part of HB 3395, cities are required to approve applications for an Emergency Shelter Agenda Item Review: City Administrator _x City Attorney x_ Finance _x_ 435 Honorable Mayor and City Council February 26, 2024 Page 2 location regardless of state or local land use laws as long as the application complies with the following state law approval criteria (Exhibit C): - The Emergency Shelter: o Includes sleeping and restroom facilities. o Will comply with applicable building and fire life safety codes. o Is located within the City's urban growth boundary. o Will not result in a new building that is sited within an area designated under a statewide land use planning goal relating to natural disasters and hazards (e.g. flood plains or mapped environmental health hazards) unless the development complies with regulations directly related to the hazard. o Has adequate transportation access to medical and commercial services. o Will not pose any unreasonable risk to public health or safety. - The Emergency Shelter must be operated by: o A local government, a religious corporation, a public benefit corporation whose charitable purpose includes the support of homeless individuals and that has been recognized as exempt from income tax under section 501(a) of the Internal Revenue Code on or before January 1, 2017, or a nonprofit corporation partnering with any of those entities. - An Emergency Shelter may include: o Youth shelters, veterans' shelters, winter or warming shelters, day shelters, and family violence shelter homes. Under the requirements stated in H133395, MWVCAA submitted a "Super Site" application to the City Building and Planning Department, which has been reviewed by the Planning Director, Building Official, and the Woodburn Fire District Fire Marshal and approved under the requirements outlined in state statue. (Exhibit D) DISCUSSION: Following direction provided by the City Council on August 14th, 2023, the City Administrator and City Staff evaluated possible locations across the city that would meet the state requirements for overnight sheltering for a seven-day-a- Honorable Mayor and City Council February 26, 2024 Page 3 week operation and would be ideal for a managed program to allow for the best possible outcome for all Woodburn residents. City staff held meetings with Ray of Hope Today and MWVCAA to discuss the possibility of program expansion to meet the state requirements of a year-round sheltering location and it was identified that MWVCAA had an interest in expanding their sheltering services to Woodburn and felt that they would be able to assume management and expand on the program services that were being offered by Ray of Hope Today while meeting the new state requirements. Ray of Hope Today fully supported a transition in program management to MWVCAA. MWVCAA is a community -based nonprofit organization that through its ARCHES Project has experience offering low -barrier sheltering solutions using a variety of models within Marion County, including an inventory of 261 year-round shelter beds. With this extensive expertise, MWVCAA agreed to operate a low -barrier shelter at 1560 Hardcastle St. that would provide overnight sheltering from 7 pm to 7 am, 365 days a year for up to 30 clients in in temporary emergency management tents that will be deployed and stored daily with a mobile HVAC unit to provide proper warming and cooling. MWVCAA will also act as the city's warming shelter (activated at 32 degrees) and a cooling shelter (activated at 100 degrees) throughout the year. The location will also allow for onsite vehicle sheltering with a max capacity of 5 vehicles on the site in marked locations and that the clients and vehicles meet the following requirements: - Vehicular overnight sheltering is designated for family sheltering only. Families include those accompanied by minor children. All other clients are required to take shelter in the emergency management tents provided onsite. - All vehicles must be operational and be moved from the site daily. - RV's and Campers will not be allowed on the site as part of the vehicular overnight sheltering per a requirement by the lessor of 1560 Hardcastle. Additionally, MWVCAA will provide a wide range of services for its clients which includes, but is not limited to, meals, laundry, shower services, and navigation and support to aid in finding employment and permanent housing for participants with trained navigators Monday - Friday. 437 Honorable Mayor and City Council February 26, 2024 Page 4 - MWVCAA Timeline for Operations: o February 12h, 2024, MWVCAA signed an agreement with the Church of Christ for use of the 1560 Hardcastle location for overnight sheltering services. (18-month lease) o February 29th, 2024, Ray of Hope will stop oversight of the current drop in shelter. o March 1 St, 2024, MWVCAA will provide drop -in services 2-3 days a week while site improvements are made to the 1560 Hardcastle St. location to ensure all fire life safety and other site improvements are completed. Improvements include but are not limited to parking lot striping, driveway widening, fencing, security camera installation, and interior painting. o On April 1, 2024, MWVCAA will begin the overnight sheltering program. FINANCIAL IMPACT: On December 11, 2023, City Council authorized the reallocation of $80,000 of ARPA funding to MWVCAA for sheltering services. This funding will only provide a small percentage of the total operational cost of MWVCAA's shelter services, and the remainder of the funding will come from other federal, state, and local grants and foundation funding. ATTACHMENTS: - Exhibit A: Oregon House Bill 3115 - Exhibit B: August 14, 2023 Staff Report: ORS 195.530 - Exhibit C: Oregon House Bill 3395 - Exhibit D: Building and Planning Approved "Super Site" Application - Exhibit E: MWVCAA ARPA Agreement 438 Exhibit A 81st OREGON LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY--2021 Regular Session Enrolled House Bill 3115 Sponsored by Representative KOTEK; Representatives DEXTER, MARSH, MCLAIN, POWER, REYNOLDS, WILDE, Senators DEMBROW, MANNING JR, RILEY CHAPTER ................................................. AN ACT Relating to the regulation of public property with respect to persons experiencing homelessness; and declaring an emergency. Be It Enacted by the People of the State of Oregon: SECTION 1. (1) As used in this section: (a) "City or county law" does not include policies developed pursuant to ORS 203.077 or 203.079. (b)(A) "Keeping warm and dry" means using measures necessary for an individual to survive outdoors given the environmental conditions. (B) "Keeping warm and dry" does not include using any measure that involves fire or flame. (c) "Public property" has the meaning given that term in ORS 131.705. (2) Any city or county law that regulates the acts of sitting, lying, sleeping or keeping warm and dry outdoors on public property that is open to the public must be objectively reasonable as to time, place and manner with regards to persons experiencing homelessness. (3) It is an affirmative defense to a charge of violating a city or county law described in subsection (2) of this section that the law is not objectively reasonable. (4) A person experiencing homelessness may bring suit for injunctive or declaratory relief to challenge the objective reasonableness of a city or county law described in subsection (2) of this section. The action must be brought in the circuit court of the county that enacted the law or of the county in which the city that enacted the law is located. (5) For purposes of subsections (2) and (3) of this section, reasonableness shall be deter- mined based on the totality of the circumstances, including, but not limited to, the impact of the law on persons experiencing homelessness. (6) In any suit brought pursuant to subsection (4) of this section, the court, in its dis- cretion, may award reasonable attorney fees to a prevailing plaintiff if the plaintiff: (a) Was not seeking to vindicate an interest unique to the plaintiff; and (b) At least 90 days before the action was filed, provided written notice to the governing body of the city or county that enacted the law being challenged of an intent to bring the action and the notice provided the governing body with actual notice of the basis upon which the plaintiff intends to challenge the law. (7) Nothing in this section creates a private right of action for monetary damages for any person. SECTION 2. Section 1 of this 2021 Act becomes operative on July 1, 2023. Enrolled House Bill 3115 (HB 3115-INTRO) Page 1 439 Exhibit A SECTION 3. This 2021 Act being necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health and safety, an emergency is declared to exist, and this 2021 Act takes effect on its passage. Passed by House April 15, 2021 .................................................................................. Timothy G. Sekerak, Chief Clerk of House .................................................................................. Tina Kotek, Speaker of House Passed by Senate June 9, 2021 .................................................................................. Peter Courtney, President of Senate Enrolled House Bill 3115 (HB 3115-INTRO) Received by Governor: ........................ M.,......................................................... 1 2021 Approved: ........................ M.,......................................................... 1 2021 Kate Brown, Governor Filed in Office of Secretary of State: ........................ M.,......................................................... 1 2021 .................................................................................. Shemia Fagan, Secretary of State Page 2 Exhibit B MEMORANDUM FR OM THE CITY TTOR NFYS OFFICE TO: Mayor and City Council FROM: N. Robert Shields, City Attorney DATE: Legal framework concerning the use of public property SUBJECT: August 9, 2023 Introduction The Mayor believes it is important that the City Council conduct a work session on the use of public property. This is scheduled for the August 14th City Council meeting. This memorandum is intended only to provide a legal framework. How the City moves ahead with this issue will depend on policy decisions made by the City Council. In addition to legal staff, the City Administrator, Police Chief, and Community Development Director will be at the work session. Background There has been a flurry of recent activity by city officials across Oregon adopting ordinances to regulate the "time, place, and manner" of how public property can be used. As with most subjects, the quality of the press coverage reporting this has varied. The May 21, 2023 article in the Statesman Journal (Exhibit A) provides a good summary. Martin v Boise The City of Boise, Idaho had an ordinance that prohibited "sitting, lying, or sleeping" outside and imposed criminal penalties on violators. As a result, Boise was sued in federal court for violation of individual constitutional rights. In 2018, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that the Eighth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution (addressing cruel and unusual punishment) ''prohibits the imposition of criminal penalties for sitting, sleeping, or lying outside on public property for homeless individuals who cannot obtain shelter ... because sitting, IQ Exhibit B lying, and sleeping are ... universal and unavoidable consequences of being human.'' The court further stated that a city cannot "criminalize conduct that is an unavoidable consequence of being homeless - namely sitting, lying, or sleeping.'' Martin v. Boise, 902 F3d 1031, 1048 (2018) (Exhibit B). After this ruling was issued, the Woodburn City Attorney's Office made the Mayor and City Council aware of its legal implications (Exhibit C). Legal rulings of the Ninth Circuit are binding on Woodburn. If the City violated this ruling, it could be sued in federal court and the public could be liable for payment of the plaintiff's attorney fees. What Boise Says Under Boise, a municipality may legally impose city-wide prohibitions against persons sitting, sleeping, or lying in public spaces if it provides a shelter that is accessible to the homeless person against whom the prohibition is being enforced. However, if no shelter is provided to the homeless person by the City, the Eighth Amendment is violated. Johnson v Grants Pass On July 5, 2023, the Ninth Circuit, in a 155 page opinion (Exhibit D), refused to have its entire judicial panel (30 judges) reconsider this case. Denial of review by the entire court (an "en Banc" hearing) prompted scathing statements by some judges. Grants Pass attorneys are petitioning for review by the United States Supreme Court. Grants Pass, a city of 38,000, was estimated to have 50 to 600 homeless individuals with nowhere to sleep other than on city streets or in city parks. City ordinances prohibited people from using a blanket, a pillow, or a cardboard box for protection from the elements while sleeping on public property. In 2013, the Grants Pass City Council convened a Community Roundtable "to identify solutions to current vagrancy problems." Participants discussed the possibility of "driving repeat offenders out of town and leaving them there." One City Councilor made clear the City's goal should be "to make it uncomfortable enough for [homeless persons] in our city so they will want to move on down the road." What Grants Pass Says Following Boise, this case found that the anti -camping ordinances enforced by Grants Pass against homeless persons for the act of sleeping outside on public Exhibit B property or for sleeping in a car at night, when there was no other place in the City for them to go, violated the Eighth Amendment. Disagreement of Ninth Circuit Judges It is apparent from the most recent opinion that a significant number of Ninth Circuit judges disagree with the Grants Pass ruling: "This Circuit's jurisprudence now effectively guarantees a personal federal constitutional `right' for individuals to camp or to sleep on sidewalks and in parks, playgrounds, and other public places in defiance of traditional health, safety, and welfare laws..." "Local governments are hard-pressed to find any way to regulate the adverse health and safety effects of homeless encampments without running afoul of this court's case law —or, at a minimum, being saddled with litigation costs." "The Eighth Amendment provides, `Excessive bail shall not be required, nor excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted.' U.S. Const. amend. VIII (emphasis added). The Amendment's bar on excessive "bail," excessive "fines," and the infliction of cruel and unusual "punishments" indicates the Amendment's punitive focus. And the text of the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause itself provides no substantive limit on what conduct may be punished. Instead, it only prohibits "punishments" (i.e., pain or suffering inflicted for a crime or offense) that are "cruel" (i.e., marked by savagery and barbarity) and "unusual" (i.e., not in common use), reflecting a constitutional prohibition originally and traditionally understood to forbid the government from "authorizing particular forms or `modes' of punishment —specifically, cruel methods of punishment that are not regularly or customarily employed." Harmelin v. Michigan, 501 U.S. 957, 976 (1991) (opinion of Scalia, J.); id. at 979 (`[b]reaking on the wheel," "flaying alive," and "maiming, mutilating, and scourging to death.'" Despite the apparent disagreement of some of the judges, Woodburn is legally obligated to follow the majority opinion. Interestingly, there is a distinct possibility that the U.S. Supreme Court could agree to hear this case. ORS 195.530 After the ruling in Boise, the 2021 Oregon Legislature enacted ORS 195.530: (1) As used in this section: 62 Exhibit B (a) ''City or county law'' does not include policies developed pursuant to ORS 195.500 or 195.505. (See Exhibit E) (b) (A) ''Keeping warm and dry'' means using measures necessary for an individual to survive outdoors given the environmental conditions. (B) ''Keeping warm and dry'' does not include using any measure that involves fire or flame. (c) ''Public property'' has the meaning given that term in ORS 131.705. (See Exhibit F) (2) Any city or county law that regulates the acts of sitting, lying, sleeping or keeping warm and dry outdoors on public property that is open to the public must be objectively reasonable as to time, place and manner with regards to persons experiencing homelessness. (3) It is an affirmative defense to a charge of violating a city or county law described in subsection (2) of this section that the law is not objectively reasonable. (4) A person experiencing homelessness may bring suit for injunctive or declaratory relief to challenge the objective reasonableness of a city or county law described in subsection (2) of this section. The action must be brought in the circuit court of the county that enacted the law or of the county in which the city that enacted the law is located. (5) For purposes of subsections (2) and (3) of this section, reasonableness shall be determined based on the totality of the circumstances, including, but not limited to, the impact of the law on persons experiencing homelessness. (6) In any suit brought pursuant to subsection (4) of this section, the court, in its discretion, may award reasonable attorney fees to a prevailing plaintiff if the plaintiff: (a) Was not seeking to vindicate if homeless individuals are subject to criminal penalties under a City ordinance for sitting, sleeping, or lying on public property; and (b) At least 90 days before the action was filed, provided written notice to the governing body of the city or county that enacted the law being challenged of an intent to bring the action and the notice provided the governing body with actual notice of the basis upon which the plaintiff intends to challenge the law. MW Exhibit B (7) Nothing in this section creates a private right of action for monetary damages for any person. Note: 195.530 becomes operative July 1, 2023. What ORS 195.530 Says ORS 195.530 provides that all "city or county law" regulating "the acts of sitting, lying, sleeping, or keeping warm and dry outdoors on public property that is open to the public" be "objectively reasonable." There is no definition in this statute of "objectively reasonable," but it does state that "reasonableness shall be determined, based on the totality of the circumstances, including, but not limited to, the impact of the law, on persons experiencing homelessness." This indicates that, legally, what is "reasonable" will vary based upon the facts and circumstances involved in a particular situation. In other words, in a legal challenge based upon ORS 195.530, the focus would be not specifically on the actual language of an ordinance, but upon how this ordinance is applied by those enforcing it (i.e., the facts and circumstances). Under this statute, if an ordinance is not "objectively reasonable," this is not only an affirmative defense to ordinance enforcement but constitutes the basis for a lawsuit against the city. However, prior to filing a lawsuit, the plaintiff must first provide 90 days written notice to the governing body that the plaintiff intends to file a legal action and the basis of the challenge. Remedies under ORS 195.530 are limited to injunctive or declaratory relief, and do not include monetary damages. However, the trial court, at its discretion may award reasonable attorneys fees, to a prevailing plaintiff. What Woodburn Ordinances are Impacted by ORS 195.530 and What Actions are Required The passage of ORS 195.530 had a minimal impact on existing Woodburn city ordinances, with only three existing ordinances being potentially affected. These are Ordinance 2060 (the park ordinance), Ordinance 2577 (the camping in public right-of-way ordinance), and Ordinance 2578 (the camping site removal ordinance). (See Exhibit G) Woodburn currently has no "sit lie ordinance" like many cities. Regardless of what policy decisions the City Council ultimately makes, the City Attorney's Office recommends that an ordinance be enacted acknowledging the passage of ORS 195.530 and that the City will not initiate any enforcement actions that are inconsistent with this state statute. Since this meeting has been 69 Exhibit B publicly noticed and the proposed ordinance has been drafted, it is legally possible for the City Council to enact such an ordinance at this meeting. What Other Oregon Cities Have Done The City Attorney's Office spent a significant amount of time researching what other Oregon cities have done and then placed this information in the attached spreadsheet (Exhibit H). Initially, we intended to incorporate this information into this narrative but did not do this because of the extensive amount of information collected and the variety of approaches taken by different municipalities. We decided that the spreadsheet format was more helpful both to demonstrate the different processes employed and to enable a comparison of these processes. Some cities have enacted ordinances after engaging in an extensive public process. Others have proceeded to pass ordinances with apparently little public input. Finally, some jurisdictions have opted to further study the issues or to wait until later to address them. Clearly, the scope of any action Woodburn takes, and the process employed is a policy matter to be decided by the City Council. Attachments: Exhibit A: Stateman Journal Article Exhibit B: Martin v. City of Boise Exhibit C: Legal Lightning Publication Exhibit D: Johnson v. City of Grants Pass Exhibit E: ORS 195.500 & ORS 195.505 Exhibit F: ORS 131.705 Exhibit G: Woodburn Ordinances Exhibit H: Other Cities Response to ORS 195.530 69 EXH113 x�T,,tj 1 of 5 s ta teslll1, journal Law intended to decriminalize homelessness but c Wes focus on where people can't sleep I I Whitne y,,3Yco94WR!1h and Tatiana Parafiniuk-Talesnick Salem StatesmaxiJournal Publishod 6 C10 rin, pnT1 May 2 1 , 2023 Oregon cities are overhauling homeless camping ordinances ahead of a new state law that goes into effect this summer. The law was created to change the way cities address homeless camps, reflecting federal court rulings that require governments to move away from crimi.nalizing the unhoused and toward increasing housing solutions. But many of the new ordinances in the Willamette Valley remain focused on where people aren't allowed to sleep, as opposed to where they can. And some warn they fail to comply with the new state law and legal precedent. An estimated 14,476 people are homeless in Oregon. Cities have struggled to uphold the rights of those living unsheltered while also responding to other residents' concerns about public health and safety. In 2021, the Oregon Legislaftffe passed law requiring cities to make "objectively reasonable" regulations about when, where and how people can sit, lie, sleep and keep warm and dry outdoors on public property. House Bill 3115, introduced by then -House Speaker Tina Kotek, now Oregon's governor, required local. governments to make sure their ordinances on urban camping aligned with the federal court rulings. The law goes into effect July i. It states that "reasonableness shall be determined based on the totality of the circumstances, including, but not firrii.ted to, the impact of the law on persons experiencing homelessness." Those behind the bill shaped it so cities could decide what would be most reasonable for their indi�ridlial community, as every municipality has different shelter inventory and a different number of people experiencing homelessness, said Becky Straus, a staff attorney with Oregon Law Center who helped develop the law. "Criminalizing homelessness is inhumane, and it doesn't work,"' StraUS said. "We came together on. that principle to figure, out how we can create a roadmal) for cities to address public space issues." But as cities around the state adjust their ordinances, some appear focused on regulating where people cannot be and issuing costly citations. In the Willamette Valley, Eugene, Salem and Springfield are proposing to trade broad camping bans, for ordinances that specifically detail where people cannot sleep. The specific locations add Lip -to cover tnosl of the cities. In Eugene, the niaximum penalty for breaking the rule would be doubled, to a inaxitnuin fine Of $500 Or up 10 10 days in jail. "Any approach that is swinging more toward enforcement is counter to the spit -it of House Bill 3115, which was meant to get away from that approach," Straus said. 0 EXH113 x�T,,tj 2 of 5 "I'm really hopeful that this process pushes cities to be thinking about the issue... in a solutions Based inindset that engages people who are living outside to what they need and what structure will work for them." Law built on past court decision In 2019, in the case of Martin v Boise, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit, which also covers Oregon, ruled th-at it is unconstitutional for the government to punish people for conduct such as, lying, sitting or sleeping on the streets that is unavoidable as a result of homelessness when there is no place for them to shelter. Past iCovera ge: Are downtown protest camps legal? It depends on who's talking The court also determined that local governments could pass reasonable laws regulating when, where and how persons experiencing homelessness shelter on public property. Years later, a case in Grants Pass reinforced this, ruling. In. Blake v Grants Pass, the same court again found cities cannot make it illegal for people to sleep or rest outside without providing sufficient indoor alternatives. The now state law was intended to reinforce those rulings in Oregon. Oregon judge: Cities, cannot fine people for living outside Homelessness tops city surveys of resident concerns. Encampments popping up in parks and along thoroughfares -have led to a variety ofactions in recent years, including a blanket ban on tent camping, a sit -lie ordinance and die creation of` emergency shelters. Salem is in the midst of holding public hearings and votes on its proposed ordinance changes. Keizer is waiting to see whether their existing rules already are "olbjectively reasonable." Keizer City Manager Adam Brown said leaders held a work group meeting with attorneys to discuss the impact of the laws, but the city has not made any changes. He said the city's current ordinance may already comply with state law. "We have taken a proactive approach with our homeless to immediately contact the and have a conversation with the about what they need," Brown said. "The city is committed to living the spirit of the laws, which is to treat all. persons with dignity and compassion," Keizer bans camping on sidewalks and in rights -of -way. Officials said they worked to avoid having to enforce the code citation, not a criminal charge, tied to the ban. Moi-e: City of Keizer passes camping ban in a unanimous vote, concerns homeless advocates In Salem, three e.odes and ordinances are under review: • Salem Revised Code 95.720 prohibits camping on all public property. • Ordinance 6-20, which the city does not currently enforce, restricts sitting and lying on sidewalks during daytime hours,. Enforcement of this ordinance was dependent on having adequate shelter and restroolils. • Salem Revised Code 95-730 prohibits leaving personal property unattended on a sidewalk for more than two hours. Citv officials said this code also was not enforced and may violate the new Orm,,on laws. W` EXHIP ff,itj 3 of The City Council is proposing repealing the personal property ordinance and revising the camping code.5 A new proposal would specify that camping is not allowed in parks, building entrances, residential zones, near existing shelters or in areas designated by the city manager as "no camping." Camping is not prohibited on Tnost sidewalks within city limits, city spokeswoman Courtney Knox Busch said. Camps on sidewalks are required to maintain a three-foot ADA-accessible pedestrian path. Sidewalks typically run five to eight feet wide. Salem law states that a violation of the camping rules carries of fine of up to $250. Knox Busch said staff works with nonprofit and community -based service partners to engage and reach people living unsheltered to connect the with available services and housing or shelter options before reaching the point of citation. In a report to council, city attorney Dan Atchison noted the regulations don't "affirmatively" allow campi-n- in C public spaces. Rather, the rules prohibit camping in soine locations while leaving other areas, like non -blocking spots on sidewalks, available. The addition of allowing the city nianager to prohibit camping in certain spots allows the city to protect sensitive areas or address camps that present public safety or public health risks, city staff said. —Me —increase in nom.etessness over Me past several years an acK o resources to a e inipact.7 m.eans=a emirw?dr-diit ��dom-,441.drit alrd-f�MVEM Atchison said in the report. "Given recent investments in emergency shelters, there are often shelter beds available for som e eligible people. Not every person experiencing unsheltered hom elessness is able to access available [teds." Some shelters do have daily vacancies. But the number of shelter beds in Marion and Polk counties is outnUmbered by the estimated 1,500 people living unsheltered in the region. During the May 8 Tneeting, Mayor Chris Hoy said he felt the changes were the "best path forward," allowing the city to avoid criminalizing hoinelessness with a blanket ban on all camping while allowing staff to address camps that block sidewalks or present a public safety or health risk. "We're codifying recent case law and new legislation from the state and then also factoring in our current practices," Hoy said. "It's a kind of an artful solution that does all of those things and doesn't stray us too far from our current practice." If passed, the new ordinance will become effective June 22. Local homeless advocates said they appreciate the city's recent mo-vement away from criminalizing; homelessness. By dropping the sit -lie ordinance and rule regarding unattended property, the city will have gotten rid of rules that would have created even more hardship for people living unsheltered. "I am happy to see the council moving to set aside the tent camping ban and the sit -lie ordinance," Jimmy Jones, executive director of the Mid-INTlamette Valley Community Action Agency, said. "People have a fundamental right to shelter themselves from the elements. They're Aanerican citizens and Oregon residents, and they deserve the same dignity and respect that each one of us do, no matter the poverty of their condition." 69 EXHI�ffit# Jones said the shift away from draconian laws and the addition of new services like the navigation center, future !,unsheltered. * * * * * * . Eugene, Springfield respond in Eugene and Springfield, city councilors also drafted ordinances that struck the cities' all-out camping bans and replaced them with detailed, location -specific bans. Eugene's proposal would ban camping: • Within i feet of I of * high bank of • Within •M feet of all other • Within * feet of ditches, wetlands, • M M from educational • Within five feet of property intended to be used primarily by inotor vehicles. • Sidewalks * camps can provide ! feet of clearance. • Shared -use paths unless camps can provide io,** of ** io days in jail. It remains a misdemeanor to be in any park or open space during nighttime hours. Advocates for the unhoused argue that while the proposed ordinance may change city code, it fails to provide a change useful for those in need of a place to rest and it actually expands criminal penalties. In written testimony, Heather Msrek, a staff attorney with the Oregon Law Center's Lane County Legal Aid Office, said the proposed ordinance "will only make matters worse for the community" and "fails to comply with state law." U'llile the city has grown its shelter inventory over the years, 1,251 shelter units exist in the county while there are 4,748 unhoused residents, Msrekwrote. At a public hearing, i * CEO of the Eugene Area Chamber of * * expressed support councilfor the ordinance. However, she asked to see a police officer assigned to enforce the rules in city parks and for ! continue work' opportunities for those in need. "We're supportive of what counsel has proposed and we recognize that it has to be paired with adequate shelter," Quick -Warner told the Register -Guard. "Our community and communities across the �'Vest Coast have to find a way to balance *Ij and and services and Ii! She said business leaders believe the council struck a good balance with the proposed ordinance. Other speakers at the public hearing echoed a need for safety, as well as a need for inure places people can go. Springfield's proposed ordinance would ban all "established campsites," which would be defined as sites where camp materials have been set up for mcre than 24 hours. EXHIP ff,,tj • Residential zoned areas. 5 of 5 • Downtown. • Within the riparian corridor of a Water Quality Limited lVatercourse. • Within any storm water quality facility. • In the way of exits and entrances. • On sidewalks, any street or public rights -of -way. • Within 1,000 feet of any temporary emergency shelter. • On any street or right-of-way the city has closed to camping. • In any public park or multi -use path. 111111111 11 !!11111111111111 ; I, ,: ! i min • No obstructing sidewalks, fire hydrants, city infrastructure. • No accumulating garbage. • No open flaines. • No dumping gray water. • No unauthorized connection or taps to electrical or other utilities. • No structures that are not readily portable, such as tents. • No storage of personal property other than what is related to camping, sleeping or keeping warm and dry. "The proposed code revisions would allow for sleep/rest in some public areas zoned mixed commercial, commercial, and industrial subject to time and. manner restrictions," a city spokesperson said. Those who break the rules can be fined up to $720, the current maximum penalty, council decided May 15. This city will revisit rules around vehicle camping later in the summer. The final version of the proposed ordinance will come to the council for approval June S. Since it takes 3o days for ordinances to go into effect, Springfield will be slightly behind the July 1 deadline. "I think that's an OK legal risk to get the ordinance the way you want it," City Attorney Mary Bridget Smith told the council. For questions, comments and news tips, email reporter ;471iitney 1410-odworth at wmwood7..�.�ort)'z.Cc6statesmaniournal.co7Ti. calltiQJ-_Q1_0-6616 or follow on Twitter at Contact reporter Tatiana Parafiniuk-Talesnick at Tatiana@,registerguard.com or 541-521-7512, and follow her on Twitter ( TatianaSophiaPT. U9, Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 1 of 72 FOR PUBLICATION UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT ROBERT MARTIN; LAWRENCE LEE SMITH; ROBERT ANDERSON; JANET F. BELL; PAMELA S. HAWKES; and BASIL E. HUMPHREY, Plaintiffs -Appellants, CITY OF BOISE, V. Defendant -Appellee. No. 15-35845 D.C. No. 1:09-cv-00540- REB ORDER AND AMENDED OPINION Appeal from the United States District Court for the District of Idaho Ronald E. Bush, Chief Magistrate Judge, Presiding Argued and Submitted July 13, 2017 Portland, Oregon Filed April 1, 2019 Before: Marsha S. Berzon, Paul J. Watford, and John B. Owens, Circuit Judges. Order; Concurrence in Order by Judge Berzon; Dissent to Order by Judge Milan D. Smith, Jr.; Dissent to Order by Judge Bennett; Opinion by Judge Berzon; Partial Concurrence and Partial Dissent by Judge Owens Im Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 2 of 72 2 MARTIN V. CITY OF BOISE SUMMARY` Civil Rights The panel amended its opinion filed September 4, 2018, and reported at 902 F.3d 1031, denied a petition for panel rehearing, denied a petition for rehearing en bane on behalf of the court, and ordered that no further petitions shall be entertained. In the amended opinion, the panel affirmed in part and reversed in part the district court's summary judgment in favor of the City of Boise in an action brought by six current or formerly homeless City of Boise residents who alleged that their citations under the City's Camping and Disorderly Conduct Ordinances violated the Eighth Amendment's prohibition on cruel and unusual punishment. Plaintiffs sought damages for the alleged violations under 42 U.S.C. § 1983. Two plaintiffs also sought prospective declaratory and injunctive relief precluding future enforcement of the ordinances. In 2014, after this litigation began, the ordinances were amended to prohibit their enforcement against any homeless person on public property on any night when no shelter had an available overnight space. This summary constitutes no part of the opinion of the court. It has been prepared by court staff for the convenience of the reader. Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 3of72 MARTIN V. CTTY OF BOTSE 3 The panel first held that two plaintiffs had standing to pursue prospective relief because they demonstrated a genuine issue of material fact as to whether they faced a credible risk of prosecution on a night when they had been denied access to the City's shelters. The panel noted that although the 2014 amendment precluded the City from enforcing the ordinances when shelters were full, individuals could still be turned away for reasons other than shelter capacity, such as for exceeding the shelter's stay limits, or for failing to take part in a shelter's mandatory religious programs. The panel held that although the doctrine set forth in Heck v. Humphrey, 512 U.S. 477 (1994), and its progeny precluded most but not all of the plaintiffs' requests for retrospective relief, the doctrine had no application to plaintiffs' request for an injunction enjoining prospective enforcement of the ordinances. Turning to the merits, the panel held that the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause of the Eighth Amendment precluded the enforcement of a statute prohibiting sleeping outside against homeless individuals with no access to alternative shelter. The panel held that, as long as there is no option of sleeping indoors, the government cannot criminalize indigent, homeless people for sleeping outdoors, on public property, on the false premise they had a choice in the matter. Concurring in part and dissenting in part, Judge Owens disagreed with the majority's opinion that Heck v. Humphrey did not bar plaintiffs' claim for declaratory and injunctive relief. Judge Owens stated that a declaration that the city ordinances are unconstitutional and an injunction against their future enforcement would necessarily demonstrate the Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 4 of 72 4 MARTIN V. CTTY OF BOTSE invalidity of plaintiffs' prior convictions. Judge Owens otherwise joined the majority in full. Concurring in the denial of rehearing en banc, Judge Berzon stated that on the merits, the panel's opinion was limited and held only that municipal ordinances that criminalize sleeping, sitting, or lying in all public spaces, when no alternative sleeping space is available, violate the Eighth Amendment. Judge Berzon further stated that a photograph featured in Judge M. Smith's dissent from the denial of rehearing en banc, depicting tents on a Los Angeles public sidewalk, was not part of the record, was unrelated, predated the panel's decision and did not serve to illustrate a concrete effect of the panel's holding. Judge Berzon stated that what the pre -Martin photograph did demonstrate was that the ordinances criminalizing sleeping in public places were never a viable solution to the homelessness problem. Dissenting from the denial of rehearing en banc, Judge M. Smith, joined by Judges Callahan, Bea, Ikuta, Bennett and R. Nelson, stated that the panel severely misconstrued three areas of binding Supreme Court precedent, and that the panel's opinion created several splits with other appellate courts. Judge M. Smith further stated that the panel's holding has already begun wreaking havoc on local governments, residents, and businesses throughout the circuit. Judge M. Smith stated that the panel's reasoning will soon prevent local governments from enforcing a host of other public health and safety laws, such as those prohibiting public defecation and urination, and that the panel's opinion shackles the hands of public officials trying to redress the serious societal concern of homelessness. 41 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 5of72 MARTIN V. CTTY OF BOTSE 5 Dissenting from the denial of rehearing en bane, Judge Bennett, joined by Judges Bea, Ikuta, R. Nelson, and joined by Judge M. Smith as to Part II, stated that the panel's decision, which allows pre -conviction Eighth Amendment challenges, is wholly inconsistent with the text and tradition of the Eighth Amendment. COUNSEL Michael E. Bern (argued) and Kimberly Lcefatt, Latham & Watkins LLP, Washington, D.C.; Howard A. Belodoff, Idaho Legal Aid Services Inc., Boise, Idaho; Eric Tars, National Law Center on Homelessness & Poverty, Washington, D.C.; Plaintiffs -Appellants. Brady J. Hall (argued), Michael W. Moore, and Steven R. Kraft, Moore Elia Kraft & Hall LLP, Boise, Idaho; Scott B. Muir, Deputy City Attorney; Robert B. Luce, City Attorney; City Attorney's Office, Boise, Idaho; for Defendant - Appellee. 102 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 6of72 6 MARTIN V. CTTY OF BOTSE ORDER The Opinion filed September 4, 2018, and reported at 902 F.3 d 1031, is hereby amended. The amended opinion will be filed concurrently with this order. The panel has unanimously voted to deny the petition for panel rehearing. The full court was advised of the petition for rehearing en bane. A judge requested a vote on whether to rehear the matter en bane. The matter failed to receive a majority of votes of the nonrecused active judges in favor of en bane consideration. Fed. R. App. P. 35. The petition for panel rehearing and the petition for rehearing en bane are DENIED. Future petitions for rehearing or rehearing en bane will not be entertained in this case. BERZON, Circuit Judge, concurring in the denial of rehearing en bane: I strongly disfavor this circuit's innovation in en bane procedure —ubiquitous dissents in the denial of rehearing en bane, sometimes accompanied by concurrences in the denial of rehearing en bane. As I have previously explained, dissents in the denial of rehearing en bane, in particular, often engage in a "distorted presentation of the issues in the case, creating the impression of rampant error in the original panel opinion although a majority —often a decisive majorityofthe active members of the court . . . perceived no error." Defs. of Wildlife Ctr. for Biological Diversity v. EPA, 450 F.3d 394, 402 (9th Cir. 2006) (Berzon, J., concurring in denial of U. Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 7of72 MARTIN V. CTTY OF BOTSE 7 rehearing en bane); see also Marsha S. Berzon, Dissent, "Dissentals, " and Decision Making, 100 Calif. L. Rev. 1479 (2012). Often times, the dramatic tone of these dissents leads them to read more like petitions for writ of certiorari on steroids, rather than reasoned judicial opinions. Despite my distaste for these separate writings, I have, on occasion, written concurrences in the denial of rehearing en bane. On those rare occasions, I have addressed arguments raised for the first time during the en bane process, corrected misrepresentations, or highlighted important facets of the case that had yet to be discussed. This case serves as one of the few occasions in which I feel compelled to write a brief concurrence. I will not address the dissents' challenges to the Heck v. Humphrey, 512 U.S. 477 (1994), and Eighth Amendment rulings of Martin v. City of Boise, 902 F.3d 1031 (9th Cir. 2018), as the opinion sufficiently rebuts those erroneous arguments. I write only to raise two points. First, the City of Boise did not initially seek en bane reconsideration of the Eighth Amendment holding. When this court solicited the parties' positions as to whether the Eighth Amendment holding merits en bane review, the City's initial submission, before mildly supporting en bane reconsideration, was that the opinion is quite "narrow" and its "interpretation of the [C] onstitution raises little actual conflict with Boise's Ordinances or [their] enforcement." And the City noted that it viewed prosecution of homeless individuals for sleeping outside as a "last resort," not as a principal weapon in reducing homelessness and its impact on the City. 0 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 8of72 8 MARTTN V. CTTY OF BOTSE The City is quite right about the limited nature of the opinion. On the merits, the opinion holds only that municipal ordinances that criminalize sleeping, sitting, or lying in all public spaces, when no alternative sleeping space is available, violate the Eighth Amendment. Martin, 902 F.3d at 1035. Nothing in the opinion reaches beyond criminalizing the biologically essential need to sleep when there is no available shelter. Second, Judge M. Smith's dissent features an unattributed color photograph of "a Los Angeles public sidewalk." The photograph depicts several tents lining a street and is presumably designed to demonstrate the purported negative impact of Martin. But the photograph fails to fulfill its intended purpose for several reasons. For starters, the picture is not in the record of this case and is thus inappropriately included in the dissent. It is not the practice of this circuit to include outside -the -record photographs in judicial opinions, especially when such photographs are entirely unrelated to the case. And in this instance, the photograph is entirely unrelated. It depicts a sidewalk in Los Angeles, not a location in the City of Boise, the actual municipality at issue. Nor can the photograph be said to illuminate the impact of Martin within this circuit, as it predates our decision and was likely taken in 201 V ' Although Judge M. Smith does not credit the photograph to any source, an internet search suggests that the original photograph is attributable to Los Angeles County. See Implementing the Los Angeles County Homelessness Initiative, L.A. County, http://homeless.lacounty. gov/lmplementln,--the-los-angeles-county-homeless-initiative/ [https:// Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 9 of 72 MARTIN V. CTTY OF BOTSE 9 But even putting aside the use of a pre -Martin, outside - the -record photograph from another municipality, the photograph does not serve to illustrate a concrete effect of Martin's holding. The opinion clearly states that it is not outlawing ordinances "barring the obstruction of public rights of way or the erection of certain structures," such as tents, id. at 1048 n.8, and that the holding "in no way dictate[s] to the City that it must provide sufficient shelter for the homeless, or allow anyone who wishes to sit, lie, or sleep on the streets ... at any time and at any place," id. at 1048 (quoting Jones v. City ofLos Angeles, 444 F.3d 1118, 1138 (9th Cir. 2006)). What the pre -Martin photograph does demonstrate is that the ordinances criminalizing sleeping in public places were never a viable solution to the homelessness problem. People with no place to live will sleep outside if they have no alternative. Taking them to jail for a few days is both unconstitutional, for the reasons discussed in the opinion, and, in all likelihood, pointless. The distressing homelessness problem —distressing to the people with nowhere to live as well as to the rest of society —has grown into a crisis for many reasons, among them the cost of housing, the drying up of affordable care for people with mental illness, and the failure to provide adequate treatment for drug addiction. See, e.g., U.S. Interagency Council on Homelessness, Homelessness in America: Focus on Individual Adults 5-8 (2018), https://www.usich.gov/res ources/?uploads/as set_library/HIA_Individual_Adults.pdf. web. archive. org/web /?20170405225 03 6/homele s s.lacounty. gov/imp lem enting-the-los-angeles-county-homeless-initiative/#]; see also Los Angeles County (@CountyofLA), Twitter (Nov. 29, 2017, 3:23 PM), https://twitter.com/CountyofLA/status/936012841533894657. Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 10 of 72 10 MARTTN V. CTTY OF BOTSE The crisis continued to burgeon while ordinances forbidding sleeping in public were on the books and sometimes enforced. There is no reason to believe that it has grown, and is likely to grow larger, because Martin held it unconstitutional to criminalize simply sleeping somewhere in public if one has nowhere else to do so. For the foregoing reasons, I concur in the denial of rehearing en banc. M. SMITH, Circuit Judge, with whom CALLAHAN, BEA, IKUTA, BENNETT, and R. NELSON, Circuit Judges, join, dissenting from the denial of rehearing en banc: In one misguided ruling, a three judge panel of our court badly misconstrued not one or two, but three areas of binding Supreme Court precedent, and crafted a holding that has begun wreaking havoc on local governments, residents, and businesses throughout our circuit. Under the panel's decision, local governments are forbidden from enforcing laws restricting public sleeping and camping unless they provide shelter for every homeless individual within their jurisdictions. Moreover, the panel's reasoning will soon prevent local governments from enforcing a host of other public health and safety laws, such as those prohibiting public defecation and urination. Perhaps most unfortunately, the panel's opinion shackles the hands of public officials trying to redress the serious societal concern of homelessness! ' With almost 553,000 people who experienced homelessness nationwide on a single night in January 2018, this issue affects communities across our country. U.S. Dep't of Hous. & Urban Dev., Im Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 11 of 72 MARTIN V. CTTY OF BOTSE 11 I respectfully dissent from our court's refusal to correct this holding by rehearing the case en banc. I. The most harmful aspect of the panel's opinion is its misreading of Eighth Amendment precedent. My colleagues cobble together disparate portions of a fragmented Supreme Court opinion to hold that "an ordinance violates the Eighth Amendment insofar as it imposes criminal sanctions against homeless individuals for sleeping outdoors, on public property, when no alternative shelter is available to them." Martin v. City ofBoise, 902 F.3d 1031, 1035 (9th Cir. 2018). That holding is legally and practically ill-conceived, and conflicts with the reasoning of every other appellate court that has considered the issue. I1 The panel struggles to paint its holding as a faithful interpretation of the Supreme Court's fragmented opinion in Powell v. Texas, 392 U.S. 514 (1968). It fails. To understand Powell, we must begin with the Court's decision in Robinson v. California, 370 U.S. 660 (1962). There, the Court addressed a statute that made it a "criminal Office of Crary. Planning & Dev., The 2018 Annual Homeless Assessment Report (AHAR) to Congress 1 (Dec. 2018), https://www.hudexchange. info/resources/documents/2018-AHAR-Part- Lpdf. z Our court previously adopted the same Eighth Amendment holding as the panel in Jones v. City ofLos Angeles, 444 F.3d 1118, 1138 (9th Cir. 2006), but that decision was later vacated. 505 F.3d 1006 (9th Cir. 2007). 12 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 12 of 72 12 MARTIN V. CTTY OF BOTSE offense for a person to `be addicted to the use of narcotics."' Robinson, 370 U.S. at 660 (quoting Cal. Health & Safety Code § 11721). The statute allowed defendants to be convicted so long as they were drug addicts, regardless of whether they actually used or possessed drugs. Id. at 665. The Court struck down the statute under the Eighth Amendment, reasoning that because "narcotic addiction is an illness . . . which may be contracted innocently or involuntarily ... a state law which imprisons a person thus afflicted as criminal, even though he has never touched any narcotic drug" violates the Eighth Amendment. Id. at 667. A few years later, in Powell, the Court addressed the scope of its holding in Robinson. Powell concerned the constitutionality of a Texas law that criminalized public drunkenness. Powell, 392 U.S. at 516. As the panel's opinion acknowledges, there was no majority in Powell. The four Justices in the plurality interpreted the decision in Robinson as standing for the limited proposition that the government could not criminalize one's status. Id. at 534. They held that because the Texas statute criminalized conduct rather than alcoholism, the law was constitutional. Powell, 392 U.S. at 532. The four dissenting Justices in Powell read Robinson more broadly: They believed that "criminal penalties may not be inflicted upon a person for being in a condition he is powerless to change." Id. at 567 (Fortas, J., dissenting). Although the statute in Powell differed from that in Robinson by covering involuntary conduct, the dissent found the same constitutional defect present in both cases. Id. at 567-68. Justice White concurred in the judgment. He upheld the defendant's conviction because Powell had not made a Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 13 of 72 MARTIN V. CTTY OF BOTSE 13 showing that he was unable to stay off the streets on the night he was arrested. Id. at 552-53 (White, J., concurring in the result). He wrote that it was "unnecessary to pursue at this point the further definition of the circumstances or the state of intoxication which might bar conviction of a chronic alcoholic for being drunk in a public place." Id. at 553. The panel contends that because Justice White concurred in the judgment alone, the views of the dissenting Justices constitute the holding of Powell. Martin, 902 F.3d at 1048. That tenuous reasoning —which metamorphosizes the Powell dissent into the majority opinion —defies logic. Because Powell was a 4-1-4 decision, the Supreme Court's decision in Marks v. United States guides our analysis. 430 U.S. 188 (1977). There, the Court held that "[w]hen a fragmented Court decides a case and no single rationale explaining the result enjoys the assent of five Justices, `the holding of the Court may be viewed as that position taken by those Members who concurred in the judgments on the narrowest grounds."' Id. at 193 (quoting Gregg v. Georgia, 428 U.S. 153, 169 n.15 (1976) (plurality opinion)) (emphasis added). When Marks is applied to Powell, the holding is clear: The defendant's conviction was constitutional because it involved the commission of an act. Nothing more, nothing less. This is hardly a radical proposition. I am not alone in recognizing that "there is definitely no Supreme Court holding" prohibiting the criminalization of involuntary conduct. United States v. Moore, 486 F.2d 1139, 1150 (D.C. Cir. 1973) (en bane). Indeed, in the years since Powell was decided, courts —including our own —have routinely upheld state laws that criminalized acts that were allegedly Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 14 of 72 14 MARTIN V. CITY OF BOISE compelled or involuntary. See, e.g., United States v. Stenson, 475 F. App'x 630, 631 (7th Cir. 2012) (holding that it was constitutional for the defendant to be punished for violating the terms of his parole by consuming alcohol because he "was not punished for his status as an alcoholic but for his conduct"); Joshua v. Adams, 231 F. App'x 592, 594 (9th Cir. 2007) ("Joshua also contends that the state court ignored his mental illness [schizophrenia], which rendered him unable to control his behavior, and his sentence was actually a penalty for his illness .... This contention is without merit because, in contrast to Robinson, where a statute specifically criminalized addiction, Joshua was convicted of a criminal offense separate and distinct from his `status' as a schizophrenic."); United States v. Benefield, 889 F.2d 1061, 1064 (llth Cir. 1989) ("The considerations that make any incarceration unconstitutional when a statute punishes a defendant for his status are not applicable when the government seeks to punish a person's actions." ).' To be sure, Marks is controversial. Last term, the Court agreed to consider whether to abandon the rule Marks established (but ultimately resolved the case on other grounds and found it "unnecessary to consider . . . the proper application of Marks"). Hughes v. United States, 138 S. Ct. 1765, 1772 (2018). At oral argument, the Justices criticized the logical subset rule established by Marks for elevating the outlier views of concurring Justices to precedential status.' s That most of these opinions were unpublished only buttresses my point: It is uncontroversial that Powell does not prohibit the criminalization of involuntary conduct. a Transcript of Oral Argument at 14, Hughes v. United States, 138 S. Ct. 1765 (2018) (No. 17-155). 141 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 15 of 72 MARTIN V. CTTY OF BOTSE 15 The Court also acknowledged that lower courts have inconsistently interpreted the holdings of fractured decisions under Marks.' Those criticisms, however, were based on the assumption that Marks means what it says and says what it means: Only the views of the Justices concurring in the judgment may be considered in construing the Court's holding. Marks, 430 U.S. at 193. The Justices did not even think to consider that Marks allows dissenting Justices to create the Court's holding. As a Marks scholar has observed, such a method of vote counting "would paradoxically create a precedent that contradicted the judgment in that very case."' And yet the panel's opinion flouts that common sense rule to extract from Powell a holding that does not exist. What the panel really does is engage in a predictive model of precedent. The panel opinion implies that if a case like Powell were to arise again, a majority of the Court would hold that the criminalization of involuntary conduct violates the Eighth Amendment. Utilizing such reasoning, the panel borrows the Justices' robes and adopts that holding on their behalf. But the Court has repeatedly discouraged us from making such predictions when construing precedent. See Rodriguez de Quijas v. Shearson/Am. Express, Inc., 490 U.S. 477, 484 (1989). And, for good reason. Predictions about how Id. at 49. ' Richard M. Re, Beyond the Marks Rule, 132 Harv. L. Rev. (forthcoming 2019), https://papers.ssm.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_i d=3090620. Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 16 of 72 16 MARTIN V. CITY OF Bom Justices will rule rest on unwarranted speculation about what goes on in their minds. Such amateur fortunetelling also precludes us from considering new insights on the issues —difficult as they may be in the case of 4-1-4 decisions like Powell —that have arisen since the Court's fragmented opinion. See E.J. du Pont de Nemours & Co. v. Train, 430 U.S. 112,135 n.26 (1977) (noting "the wisdom of allowing difficult issues to mature through full consideration by the courts of appeals"). In short, predictions about how the Justices will rule ought not to create precedent. The panel's Eighth Amendment holding lacks any support in Robinson or Powell. B. Our panel's opinion also conflicts with the reasoning underlying the decisions of other appellate courts. The California Supreme Court, in Tobe v. City of Santa Ana, rejected the plaintiffs' Eighth Amendment challenge to a city ordinance that banned public camping. 892 P.2d 1145 (1995). The court reached that conclusion despite evidence that, on any given night, at least 2,500 homeless persons in the city did not have shelter beds available to them. Id. at 1152. The court sensibly reasoned that because Powell was a fragmented opinion, it did not create precedent on "the question of whether certain conduct cannot constitutionally be punished because it is, in some sense, `involuntary' or `occasioned by a compulsion. "' Id. at 1166 (quoting Powell, 392 U.S. at 533). Our panel —bound by the same Supreme Court precedent —invalidates identical California ordinances W. Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 17 of 72 MARTIN V. CITY OF Bom 17 previously upheld by the California Supreme Court. Both courts cannot be correct. The California Supreme Court acknowledged that homelessness is a serious societal problem. It explained, however, that: Many of those issues are the result of legislative policy decisions. The arguments of many amici curiae regarding the apparently intractable problem of homelessness and the impact of the Santa Ana ordinance on various groups of homeless persons (e.g., teenagers, families with children, and the mentally ill) should be addressed to the Legislature and the Orange County Board of Supervisors, not the judiciary. Neither the criminal justice system nor the judiciary is equipped to resolve chronic social problems, but criminalizing conduct that is a product of those problems is not for that reason constitutionally impermissible. Id. at 1157 n.12. By creating new constitutional rights out of whole cloth, my well-meaning, but unelected, colleagues improperly inject themselves into the role of public policymaking.' ' Justice Black has also observed that solutions for challenging social issues should be left to the policymakers: I cannot say that the States should be totally barred from one avenue of experimentation, the criminal process, in attempting to find a means to cope with this difficult social problem .... [I]t seems to me that the Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 18 of 72 18 MARTIN V. CITY OF Bom The reasoning of our panel decision also conflicts with precedents of the Fourth and Eleventh Circuits. In Manning v. Caldwell, the Fourth Circuit held that a Virginia statute that criminalized the possession of alcohol did not violate the Eighth Amendment when it punished the involuntary actions of homeless alcoholics. 900 F.3d 139, 153 (4th Cir. 2018), reh g en Banc granted 741 F. App'x 937 (4th Cir. 2018).S The court rejected the argument that Justice White's opinion in Powell "requires this court to hold that Virginia's statutory scheme imposes cruel and unusual punishment because it criminalizes [plaintiffs'] status as homeless alcoholics." Id. at 145. The court found that the statute passed constitutional muster because "it is the act of possessing alcohol —not the status of being an alcoholic —that gives rise to criminal sanctions." Id. at 147. Boise's Ordinances at issue in this case are no different: They do not criminalize the status of homelessness, but only the act of camping on public land or occupying public places without permission. Martin, 902 F.3d at 1035. The Fourth Circuit correctly recognized that these kinds of laws do not run afoul of Robinson and Powell. present use of criminal sanctions might possibly be unwise, but I am by no means convinced that any use of criminal sanctions would inevitably be unwise or, above all, that I am qualified in this area to know what is legislatively wise and what is legislatively unwise. Powell, 392 U.S. at 539 40 (Black, J., concurring). s Pursuant to Fourth Circuit Local Rule 35(c), "[g]rantmg ofrehearing en bane vacates the previous panel judgment and opinion." I mention Manning, however, as an illustration of other courts' reasoning on the Eighth Amendment issue. Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 19 of 72 MARTIN V. CITY OF Bom 19 The Eleventh Circuit has agreed. In Joel v. City of* Orlando, the court held that a city ordinance prohibiting sleeping on public property was constitutional. 232 F.3d 1353, 1362 (11th Cir. 2000). The court rejected the plaintiffs' Eighth Amendment challenge because the ordinance "targets conduct, and does not provide criminal punishment based on a person's status." Id. The court prudently concluded that "[t]he City is constitutionally allowed to regulate where `camping' occurs." Id. We ought to have adopted the sound reasoning of these other courts. By holding that Boise's enforcement of its Ordinances violates the Eighth Amendment, our panel has needlessly created a split in authority on this straightforward issue. C. One would think our panel's legally incorrect decision would at least foster the common good. Nothing could be further from the truth. The panel's decision generates dire practical consequences for the hundreds of local governments within our jurisdiction, and for the millions of people that reside therein. The panel opinion masquerades its decision as a narrow one by representing that it "in no way dictate[s] to the City that it must provide sufficient shelter for the homeless, or allow anyone who wishes to sit, lie, or sleep on the streets ... at any time and at any place." Martin, 902 F.3d at 1048 (quoting Jones v. City of Los Angeles, 444 F.3d 1118, 1138 (9th Cir. 2006)). 400 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 20 of 72 20 MARTIN V. CITY OF Bom That excerpt, however, glosses over the decision's actual holding: "We hold only that ... as long as there is no option of sleeping indoors, the government cannot criminalize indigent, homeless people for sleeping outdoors, on public property." Id. Such a holding leaves cities with a Hobson's choice: They must either undertake an overwhelming financial responsibility to provide housing for or count the number of homeless individuals within their jurisdiction every night, or abandon enforcement of a host of laws regulating public health and safety. The Constitution has no such requirement. Under the panel's decision, local governments can enforce certain of their public health and safety laws only when homeless individuals have the choice to sleep indoors. That inevitably leads to the question of how local officials ought to know whether that option exists. The number of homeless individuals within a municipality on any given night is not automatically reported and updated in real time. Instead, volunteers or government employees must painstakingly tally the number of homeless individuals block by block, alley by alley, doorway by doorway. Given the daily fluctuations in the homeless population, the panel's opinion would require this labor- intensive task be done every single day. Yet in massive cities such as Los Angeles, that is simply impossible. Even when thousands of volunteers devote dozens of hours to such "a herculean task," it takes three days to finish counting —and 401 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 21 of 72 MARTIN V. CITY OF BOISE 21 even then "not everybody really gets counted."' Lest one think Los Angeles is unique, our circuit is home to many of the largest homeless populations nationwide.1" If cities do manage to cobble together the resources for such a system, what happens if officials (much less volunteers) miss a homeless individual during their daily count and police issue citations under the false impression that the number of shelter beds exceeds the number of homeless people that night? According to the panel's opinion, that city has violated the Eighth Amendment, thereby potentially leading to lawsuits for significant monetary damages and other relief. v Matt Tinoco, LA Counts Its Homeless, But Counting Everybody Is Virtually Impossible, LAist (Jan. 22, 2019, 2:08 PM), https://Iaist.com/2019/01/22/los_angeles_homeless_count_2019_how v olunteer.php. The panel conceded the imprecision of such counts in its opinion. See Martin, 902 17.3d at 1036 n.1 (acknowledging that the count of homeless individuals "is not always precise"). But it went on to disregard that fact when tying a city's ability to enforce its laws to these counts. " The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development's 2018 Annual Homeless Assessment Report to Congress reveals that municipalities within our circuit have among the highest homeless populations in the country. In Los Angeles City and County alone, 49,955 people experienced homelessness in 2018. The number was 12,112 people in Seattle and King County, Washington, and 8,576 people in San Diego City and County, California. See supra note 1, at 18, 20. In 2016, Las Vegas had an estimated homeless population of 7,509 individuals, and California's Santa Clara County had 6,556. Joaquin Palomino, How Many People Live On Our Streets?, S.F. Chronicle (June 28, 2016), https://projects.sfchronicle.com/sf-homelcss/numbers. 402 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 22 of 72 22 MARTIN V. CITY OF BOISE And what if local governments (understandably) lack the resources necessary for such a monumental task?11 They have no choice but to stop enforcing laws that prohibit public sleeping and camping.12 Accordingly, our panel's decision " Cities can instead provide sufficient housing for every homeless individual, but the cost would be prohibitively expensive for most local governments. Los Angeles, for example, would need to spend $403.4 million to house every homeless individual not living in a vehicle. See Los Angeles Homeless Set -vices Authority, Report on Emergency Framework to Homelessness Plan 13 (June 2018), https://assets. documentcloud.org/documents/4550980/LAHSA-Shelteting- Report.pdf. In San Francisco, building new centers to provide a mere 400 additional shelter spaces was estimated to cost between $10 million and $20 million, and would require $20 million to $30 million to operate each year. See Heather Knight, A Better Model, A Better Result?, S.F. Chronicle (June 29, 2016), https://projects.sfchronicle.com/sf- homeless/shelters. Perhaps these staggering sums are why the panel went out of its way to state that it "in no way dictate[s] to the City that it must provide sufficient shelter for the homeless." Martin, 902 F.3d at 1048. 12 Indeed, in the few short months since the panel's decision, several cities have thrown up their hands and abandoned any attempt to enforce such laws. See, e.g., Cynthia Hubert, Sacramento County Cleared Homeless Camps All Year. Now It Has Stopped Citing Campers, Sacramento Bee (Sept. 18, 2019, 4:27 PM), https://www.sacbee.com/ne ws/local/homeless/article218605025.html ("Sacramento County park rangers have suddenly stopped issuing citations altogether after a federal court ruling this month."); Michael Ellis Langley, Policing Homelessness, Golden State Newspapers (Feb. 22, 2019), http://www.goldenstatenews papers.com/tracy_press/news/policing-homelessness/article_5fe6a9ca- 3642-11e9-9b25-37610ef2dbae.html (Sheriff Pat Withrow stating that, "[a]s far as camping ordinances and things like that, we're probably holding off on [issuing citations] for a while" in light of Martin v. City of Boise); Kelsie Morgan, Moses Lake Sees Spike in Homeless Activity Following 9th Circuit Court Decision, KXLY (Oct. 2, 2018, 12:50 PM), https://www.kxly.com/news/mo ses-lake-sees-spike-in-homeless-activity- following-9tli-circuit-court-decision/801772571 ("Because the City of Moses Lake does not currently have a homeless shelter, city officials can 403 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 23 of 72 MARTIN V. CITY OF BOISE 23 effectively allows homeless individuals to sleep and live wherever they wish on most public property. Without an absolute confidence that they can house every homeless individual, city officials will be powerless to assist residents lodging valid complaints about the health and safety of their neighborhoods.13 As if the panel's actual holding wasn't concerning enough, the logic of the panel's opinion reaches even further in scope. The opinion reasons that because "resisting the need to . . . engage in [] life -sustaining activities is impossible," punishing the homeless for engaging in those actions in public violates the Eighth Amendment. Martin, 902 F.3d at 1048. What else is a life -sustaining activity? Surely bodily functions. By holding that the Eighth Amendment proscribes the criminalization of involuntary conduct, the panel's decision will inevitably result in the no longer penalize people for sleeping in public areas."); Brandon Pho, Buena Park Residents Express Opposition to Possible Homeless Shelter, Voice of OC (Feb. 14, 2019), https://voiceofoe.org/2019/02/buena-park- residents-express-opposition-to-possible-homeless-shelter/ (stating that Judge David Carter of the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California has "wam[ed] Orange County cities to get more shelters online or risk the inability the enforce their anti -camping ordinances"); Nick Welsh, Court Rules to Protect Sleeping in Public: Santa Barbara City Parks Subject of Ongoing Debate, Santa Barbara Indep. (Oct. 31, 2018), http://www.independent.com/news/2018/oct/31 /court-rules-protect- sleeping-public/?jqm ("In the wake of what's known as `the Boise decision,' Santa Barbara city police found themselves scratching their heads over what they could and could not issue citations for."). 13 In 2017, for example, San Francisco received 32,272 complaints about homeless encampments to its 311-line. Kevin Fagan, The Situation On The Streets, S.F. Chronicle (June 28, 2018), https://proj ects.sfchronicle.com/sf-homeless/2018-state-of-homelessness. 404 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 24 of 72 24 MARTIN V. CITY OF Bom striking down of laws that prohibit public defecation and urination." The panel's reasoning also casts doubt on public safety laws restricting drug paraphernalia, for the use of hypodermic needles and the like is no less involuntary for the homeless suffering from the scourge of addiction than is their sleeping in public. It is a timeless adage that states have a "universally acknowledged power and duty to enact and enforce all such laws ... as may rightly be deemed necessary or expedient for the safety, health, morals, comfort and welfare of its people." Knoxville Iron Co. v. Harbison, 183 U.S. 13, 20 (1901) (internal quotations omitted). I fear that the panel's decision will prohibit local governments from fulfilling their duty to enforce an array of public health and safety laws. Halting enforcement of such laws will potentially wreak havoc on our communities.15 As we have already begun to witness, our neighborhoods will soon feature "[t]ents ... 14 See Heater Knight, It's No Laughing Matter SF Forming Poop Patrol to Keep Sidewalks Clean, S.F. Chronicle (Aug. 14, 2018), http s: //www. sfchronicic. com/bayarea/heatherknight/article/It-s-no- laughing-matter-SF-forming-Poop-13153 517.php. 15 See Anna Gorman and Kaiser Health News, Medieval Diseases Are Infecting California's Homeless, The Atlantic (Mar. 8, 2019), https: //www. theatlantic.com/health/archive/2019/03/typhus-tuberculo sis- medieval-diseases-spreading-homeless/584380/ (describing the recent outbreaks of typhus, Hepatitis A, and shigellosis as "disaster[s] and [a] public -health crisis" and noting that such "diseases spread quickly and widely among people living outside or in shelters"). 405 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 25 of 72 MARTIN V. CITY OF Bom 25 equipped with mini refrigerators, cupboards, televisions, and heaters, [that] vie with pedestrian traffic" and "human waste appearing on sidewalks and at local playgrounds."16 A Los Angeles Public Sidewalk II. The panel's fanciful merits -determination is accompanied by a no -less -inventive series of procedural rulings. The panel's opinion also misconstrues two other areas of Supreme Court precedent concerning limits on the parties who can " Scott Johnson and Peter Kiefer, LA's Battle for Venice Beach: Homeless Surge Puts Hollywood's Progressive Ideals to the Test, Hollywood Reporter (Jan. 11, 2019, 6:00 AM), https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/features/las-homeless- surge-puts- hollywoods-progressive-ideals-test-1174599. 406 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 26 of 72 26 MARTIN V. CITY OF Bom bring § 1983 challenges for violations of the Eighth Amendment. a The panel erred in holding that Robert Martin and Robert Anderson could obtain prospective relief under Heck v. Humphrey and its progeny. 512 U.S. 477 (1994). As recognized by Judge Owens's dissent, that conclusion cuts against binding precedent on the issue. The Supreme Court has stated that Heck bars § 1983 claims if success on that claim would "necessarily demonstrate the invalidity of [the plaintiff's] confinement or its duration." Wilkinson v. Dotson, 544 U.S. 74, 82 (2005); see also Edwards v. Balisok, 520 U.S. 641, 648 (1997) (stating that Heck applies to claims for declaratory relief). Martin and Anderson's prospective claims did just that. Those plaintiffs sought a declaration that the Ordinances under which they were convicted are unconstitutional and an injunction against their future enforcement on the grounds of unconstitutionality. It is clear that Heck bars these claims because Martin and Anderson necessarily seek to demonstrate the invalidity of their previous convictions. The panel opinion relies on Edwards to argue that Heck does not bar plaintiffs' requested relief, but Edwards cannot bear the weight the panel puts on it. In Edwards, the plaintiff sought an injunction that would require prison officials to date -stamp witness statements at the time received. 520 U.S. at 643. The Court concluded that requiring prison officials to date -stamp witness statements did not necessarily imply the invalidity of previous determinations that the prisoner was 407 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 27 of 72 MARTIN V. CITY OF BOISE 27 not entitled to good-time credits, and that Heck, therefore, did not bar prospective injunctive relief. Id. at 648. Here, in contrast, a declaration that the Ordinances are unconstitutional and an injunction against their future enforcement necessarily demonstrate the invalidity of the plaintiffs' prior convictions. According to data from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, the number of homeless individuals in Boise exceeded the number of available shelter beds during each of the years that the plaintiffs were cited.17 Under the panel's holding that "the government cannot criminalize indigent, homeless people for sleeping outdoors, on public property" "as long as there is no option of sleeping indoors," that data necessarily demonstrates the invalidity of the plaintiffs' prior convictions. Martin, 902 F.3d at 1048. The panel also erred in holding that Robert Martin and Pamela Hawkes, who were cited but not convicted of violating the Ordinances, had standing to sue under the Eighth Amendment. In so doing, the panel created a circuit split with the Fifth Circuit. The panel relied on Ingraham v. Wright, 430 U.S. 651 (1977), to find that a plaintiff "need demonstrate only the " See U.S. Dep't of Hous. & Urban Dev., PIT Data Since 2007, https: //www.hudexchange.info/resources/documents/2007-2018-PIT- Counts-by-CoC.xlsx; U.S. Dept of Hous. & Urban Dev., HIC Data Since 2007, https://www.hudexchange.info/resources/documents/2007-2018- HIC-Counts-by-CoC.xlsx. Boise is within Ada County and listed under CoC code ID-500. 408 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 28 of 72 28 MARTIN V. CITY OF Bom initiation of the criminal process against him, not a conviction," to bring an Eighth Amendment challenge. Martin, 902 F.3d at 1045. The panel cites Ingraham's observation that the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause circumscribes the criminal process in that "it imposes substantive limits on what can be made criminal and punished as such." Id. at 1046 (citing Ingraham, 430 U.S. at 667). This reading of Ingraham, however, cherry picks isolated statements from the decision without considering them in their accurate context. The Ingraham Court plainly held that "Eighth Amendment scrutiny is appropriate only after the State has complied with the constitutional guarantees traditionally associated with criminal prosecutions." 430 U.S. at 671 n.40. And, "the State does not acquire the power to punish with which the Eighth Amendment is concerned until after it has secured a formal adjudication of guilt." Id. (emphasis added). As the Ingraham Court recognized, "[T]he decisions of [the Supreme] Court construing the proscription against cruel and unusual punishment confirms that it was designed to protect those convicted of crimes." Id. at 664 (emphasis added). Clearly, then, Ingraham stands for the proposition that to challenge a criminal statute as violative of the Eighth Amendment, the individual must be convicted of that relevant crime. The Fifth Circuit recognized this limitation on standing in Johnson v. City of Dallas, 61 F.3d 442 (5th Cir. 1995). There, the court confronted a similar action brought by homeless individuals challenging a sleeping in public ordinance. Johnson, 61 F.3d at 443. The court held that the plaintiffs did not have standing to raise an Eighth Amendment challenge to the ordinance because although "numerous tickets ha[d] been issued . . . [there was] no indication that any Appellees ha[d] been convicted" of 409 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 29 of 72 MARTIN V. CITY OF BOisE 29 violating the sleeping in public ordinance. Id. at 445. The Fifth Circuit explained that Ingraham clearly required a plaintiff be convicted under a criminal statute before challenging that statute's validity. Id. at 444-45 (citing Robinson, 370 U.S. at 663; Ingraham, 430 U.S. at 667). By permitting Martin and Hawkes to maintain their Eighth Amendment challenge, the panel's decision created a circuit split with the Fifth Circuit and took our circuit far afield from "[t]he primary purpose of (the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause) ... [which is] the method or kind of punishment imposed for the violation of criminal statutes." Ingraham, 430 U.S. at 667 (quoting Powell, 392 U.S. at 531-32. None of us is blind to the undeniable suffering that the homeless endure, and I understand the panel's impulse to help such a vulnerable population. But the Eighth Amendment is not a vehicle through which to critique public policy choices or to hamstring a local government's enforcement of its criminal code. The panel's decision, which effectively strikes down the anti -camping and anti -sleeping Ordinances of Boise and that of countless, if not all, cities within our jurisdiction, has no legitimate basis in current law. I am deeply concerned about the consequences of our panel's unfortunate opinion, and I regret that we did not vote to reconsider this case en banc. I respectfully dissent. 480 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 30 of 72 30 MARTIN V. CITY OF BOisE BENNETT, Circuit Judge, with whom BEA, IKUTA, and R. NELSON, Circuit Judges, join, and with whom M. SMITH, Circuit Judge, joins as to Part II, dissenting from the denial of rehearing en banc: I fully join Judge M. Smith's opinion dissenting from the denial of rehearing en banc. I write separately to explain that except in extraordinary circumstances not present in this case, and based on its text, tradition, and original public meaning, the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause of the Eighth Amendment does not impose substantive limits on what conduct a state may criminalize. I recognize that we are, of course, bound by Supreme Court precedent holding that the Eighth Amendment encompasses a limitation "on what can be made criminal and punished as such." Ingraham v. Wright, 430 U.S. 651, 667 (1977) (citing Robinson v. California, 370 U.S. 660 (1962)). However, the Ingraham Court specifically "recognized [this] limitation as one to be applied sparingly." Id. As Judge M. Smith's dissent ably points out, the panel ignoredIngraham's clear direction that Eighth Amendment scrutiny attaches only after a criminal conviction. Because the panel's decision, which allows pre -conviction Eighth Amendment challenges, is wholly inconsistent with the text and tradition of the Eighth Amendment, I respectfully dissent from our decision not to rehear this case en banc. I. The text of the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause is virtually identical to Section 10 of the English Declaration of 481 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 31 of 72 MARTIN V. CITY OF BOiSE 31 Rights of 1689,' and there is no question that the drafters of the Eighth Amendment were influenced by the prevailing interpretation of Section 10. See Solem v. Helm, 463 U.S. 277, 286 (1983) (observing that one of the themes of the founding era "was that Americans had all the rights of English subjects" and the Framers' "use of the language of the English Bill of Rights is convincing proof that they intended to provide at least the same protection"); Timbs v. Indiana, 586 U.S. (2019) (Thomas, J., concurring) ("[T]he text of the Eighth Amendment was `based directly on . . . the Virginia Declaration of Rights,' which `adopted verbatim the language of the English Bill of Rights. "' (quoting Browning -Ferris Indus. of' Vt., Inc. v. Kelco Disposal, Inc., 492 U.S. 257, 266 (1989)). Thus, "not only is the original meaning of the 1689 Declaration of Rights relevant, but also the circumstances of its enactment, insofar as they display the particular `rights of English subjects' it was designed to vindicate." Harmelin v. Michigan, 501 U.S. 957, 967 (1991) (Scalia, J., concurring). Justice Scalia's concurrence in Harmelin provides a thorough and well -researched discussion of the original public meaning of the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause, including a detailed overview of the history of Section 10 of the English Declaration of Rights. See id. at 966-85 (Scalia, J., concurring). Rather than reciting Justice Scalia's Harmelin discussion in its entirety, I provide only a broad description of its historical analysis. Although the issue Justice Scalia confronted in Harmelin was whether the ' 1 Wm. & Mary, 2d Sess., ch. 2, 3 Stat. at Large 440, 441 (1689) (Section 10 of the English Declaration of Rights) ("excessive Baile ought not to be required, nor excessive Fines imposed; nor cruell and unusuall Punishments inflicted."). 482 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 32 of 72 32 MARTIN V. CITY OF BOisE Framers intended to graft a proportionality requirement on the Eighth Amendment, see id. at 976, his opinion's historical exposition is instructive to the issue of what the Eighth Amendment meant when it was written. The English Declaration of Rights' s prohibition on "cruell and unusuall Punishments" is attributed to the arbitrary punishments imposed by the King's Bench following the Monmouth Rebellion in the late 17th century. Id. at 967 (Scalia, J., concurring). "Historians have viewed the English provision as a reaction either to the `Bloody Assize,' the treason trials conducted by Chief Justice Jeffreys in 1685 after the abortive rebellion of the Duke of Monmouth, or to the perjury prosecution of Titus Oates in the same year." Ingraham, 430 U.S. at 664 (footnote omitted). Presiding over a special commission in the wake of the Monmouth Rebellion, Chief Justice Jeffreys imposed "vicious punishments for treason," including "drawing and quartering, burning of women felons, beheading, [and] disemboweling." Harmelin, 501 U.S. at 968. In the view of some historians, "the story of The Bloody Assizes ... helped to place constitutional limitations on the crime of treason and to produce a bar against cruel and unusual Punishments." Furman v. Georgia, 408 U.S. 238, 254 (1972) (Douglas, J., concurring). More recent scholarship suggests that Section 10 of the Declaration of Rights was motivated more by Jeffreys's treatment of Titus Oates, a Protestant cleric and convicted perjurer. In addition to the pillory, the scourge, and life imprisonment, Jeffreys sentenced Oates to be "stript of [his] Canonical Habits." Harmelin, 501 U.S. at 970 (Scalia, J., concurring) (quoting Second Trial of Titus Oates, 10 How. St. 483 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 33 of 72 MARTIN V. CITY OF BOisE 33 Tr. 1227, 1316 (K.B. 1685)). Years after the sentence was carried out, and months after the passage of the Declaration of Rights, the House of Commons passed a bill to annul Oates's sentence. Though the House of Lords never agreed, the Commons issued a report asserting that Oates's sentence was the sort of "cruel and unusual Punishment" that Parliament complained of in the Declaration of Rights. Harmelin, 501 U.S. at 972 (citing 10 Journal of the House of Commons 247 (Aug. 2, 1689)). In the view of the Commons and the dissenting Lords, Oates's punishment was "`out ofthe Judges' Power,' `contrary to Law and ancient practice,' without `Precedents' or `express Law to warrant,' `unusual,' `illegal,' or imposed by `Pretence to a discretionary Power."' Id. at 973 (quoting 1 Journals of the House of Lords 367 (May 31, 1689); 10 Journal of the House of Commons 247 (Aug. 2, 1689)). Thus, Justice Scalia concluded that the prohibition on "cruell and unusuall punishments" as used in the English Declaration, "was primarily a requirement that judges pronouncing sentence remain within the bounds of common- law tradition." Harmelin, 501 U.S. at 974 (Scalia, J., concurring) (citing Ingraham, 430 U.S. at 665; 1 J. Chitty, Criminal Law 710-12 (5th Am. ed. 1847); Anthony F. Granucci, Nor Cruel and Unusual Punishments Inflicted: The Original Meaning, 57 Calif. L. Rev. 839, 859 (1969)). But Justice Scalia was careful not to impute the English meaning of "cruell and unusuall" directly to the Framers of our Bill of Rights: "the ultimate question is not what `cruell and unusuall punishments' meant in the Declaration of Rights, but what its meaning was to the Americans who adopted the Eighth Amendment." Id. at 975. "Wrenched out of its common-law context, and applied to the actions of a 484 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 34 of 72 34 MARTIN V. CITY OF BOisE legislature . . . the Clause disables the Legislature from authorizing particular forms or `modes' of punishment —specifically, cruel methods of punishment that are not regularly or customarily employed." Id. at 976. As support for his conclusion that the Framers of the Bill of Rights intended for the Eighth Amendment to reach only certain punishment methods, Justice Scalia looked to "the state ratifying conventions that prompted the Bill of Rights." Id. at 979. Patrick Henry, speaking at the Virginia Ratifying convention, "decried the absence of a bill of rights," arguing that "Congress will loose the restriction of not ... inflicting cruel and unusual punishments.... What has distinguished our ancestors? —They would not admit of tortures, or cruel and barbarous punishment." Id. at 980 (quoting 3 J. Elliot, Debates on the Federal Constitution 447 (2d ed. 1854)). The Massachusetts Convention likewise heard the objection that, in the absence of a ban on cruel and unusual punishments, "racks and gibbets maybe amongst the most mild instruments of [Congress's] discipline." Id. at 979 (internal quotation marks omitted) (quoting 2 J. Debates on the Federal Constitution, at 111). These historical sources "confirm[] the view that the cruel and unusual punishments clause was directed at prohibiting certain methods of punishment." Id. (internal quotation marks omitted) (quoting Granucci, 57 Calif. L. Rev. at 842) (emphasis in Harmelin). In addition, early state court decisions "interpreting state constitutional provisions with identical or more expansive wording (i.e., `cruel or unusual') concluded that these provisions . . . proscribe[d] . . . only certain modes of punishment." Id. at 983; see also id. at 982 ("Many other Americans apparently agreed that the Clause only outlawed certain modes of punishment."). 485 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 35 of 72 MARTIN V. CITY OF BOisE 35 In short, when the Framers drafted and the several states ratified the Eighth Amendment, the original public meaning of the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause was "to proscribe ... methods of punishment." Estelle v. Gamble, 429 U.S. 97, 102 (1976). There is simply no indication in the history of the Eighth Amendment that the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause was intended to reach the substantive authority of Congress to criminalize acts or status, and certainly not before conviction. Incorporation, of course, extended the reach of the Clause to the States, but worked no change in its meaning. II. The panel here held that "the Eighth Amendment prohibits the imposition of criminal penalties for sitting, sleeping, or lying outside on public property for homeless individuals who cannot obtain shelter." Martin v. City of' Boise, 902 F.3d 1031, 1048 (9th Cir. 2018). In so holding, the panel allows challenges asserting this prohibition to be brought in advance of any conviction. That holding, however, has nothing to do with the punishment that the City of Boise imposes for those offenses, and thus nothing to do with the text and tradition of the Eighth Amendment. The panel pays only the barest attention to the Supreme Court's admonition that the application of the Eighth Amendment to substantive criminal law be "sparing[],"Martin, 902 F.3d at 1047 (quoting Ingraham, 430 U.S. at 667), and its holding here is dramatic in scope and completely unfaithful to the proper interpretation of the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause. 486 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 36 of 72 36 MARTIN V. CITY OF Bom "The primary purpose of (the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause) has always been considered, and properly so, to be directed at the method or kind of punishment imposed for the violation of criminal statutes." Ingraham, 430 U.S. at 667 (internal quotation marks omitted) (quoting Powell v. Texas, 392 U.S. 514, 531-32 (1968)). It should, therefore, be the "rare case" where a court invokes the Eighth Amendment's criminalization component. Jones v. City of Los Angeles, 444 F.3d 1118, 1146 (9th Cir. 2006) (Rymer, J., dissenting), vacated, 505 F.3d 1006 (9th Cir. 2007).2 And permitting a pre -conviction challenge to a local ordinance, as the panel does here, is flatly inconsistent with the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause's core constitutional function: regulating the methods of punishment that may be inflicted upon one convicted of an offense. Harmelin, 501 U.S. at 977, 979 (Scalia, J., concurring). As Judge Rymer, dissenting in Jones, observed, "the Eighth Amendment's `protections do not attach until after conviction and sentence. ,,3 444 F.3d at 1147 (Rymer, J., dissenting) 'Jones, of course, was vacated and lacks precedential value. 505 F.3d 1006 (9th Cir. 2007). But the panel here resuscitated Jones's errant holding, including, apparently, its application of the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause in the absence of a criminal conviction. We should have taken this case en banc to correct this misinterpretation of the Eighth Amendment. 3 We have emphasized the need to proceed cautiously when extending the reach of the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause beyond regulation of the methods of punishment that may be inflicted upon conviction for an offense. See United States v. Ritter, 752 F.2d 435, 438 (9th Cir. 1985) (repeating Ingraham's direction that "this particular use of the cruel and unusual punishment clause is to be applied sparingly" and noting that Robinson represents "the rare type of case in which the clause has been used to limit what may be made criminal"); see also United States v. Ayala, 35 F.3d 423, 426 (9th Cir. 1994) (limiting application ofRobinson 487 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 37 of 72 MARTIN V. CITY OF BOisE 37 (internal alterations omitted) (quoting Graham v. Connor, 490 U.S. 386, 392 n.6 (1989)).4 The panel's holding thus permits plaintiffs who have never been convicted of any offense to avail themselves of a constitutional protection that, historically, has been concerned with prohibition of "only certain modes of punishment." Harmelin, 501 U.S. at 983; see also United States v. Quinn, 123 F.3d 1415, 1425 (1 Ith Cir. 1997) (citing Harmelin for the proposition that a "plurality of the Supreme Court ... has rejected the notion that the Eighth Amendment's protection from cruel and unusual punishment extends to the type of offense for which a sentence is imposed"). Extending the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause to encompass pre -conviction challenges to substantive criminal law stretches the Eighth Amendment past its breaking point. I doubt that the drafters of our Bill of Rights, the legislators of the states that ratified it, or the public at the time would ever have imagined that a ban on "cruel and unusual punishments" would permit a plaintiff to challenge a substantive criminal statute or ordinance that he or she had not even been convicted of violating. We should have taken this case en banc to confirm that an Eighth Amendment challenge does not lie in the absence of a punishment following conviction for an offense. to crimes lacking an actus reus). The panel's holding here throws that caution to the wind. 4 Judge Friendly also expressed "considerable doubt that the cruel and unusual punishment clause is properly applicable at all until after conviction and sentence." Johnson v. Glick, 481 F.2d 1028, 1032 (2d Cir. 1973). 488 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 38 of 72 38 MARTIN V. CITY OF BOisE At common law and at the founding, a prohibition on "cruel and unusual punishments" was simply that: a limit on the types of punishments that government could inflict following a criminal conviction. The panel strayed far from the text and history of the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause in imposing the substantive limits it has on the City of Boise, particularly as to plaintiffs who have not yet even been convicted of an offense. We should have reheard this case en banc, and I respectfully dissent. OPINION BERZON, Circuit Judge: "The law, in its majestic equality, forbids rich and poor alike to sleep under bridges, to beg in the streets, and to steal their bread." Anatole France, The Red Lily We consider whether the Eighth Amendment's prohibition on cruel and unusual punishment bars a city from prosecuting people criminally for sleeping outside on public property when those people have no home or other shelter to go to. We conclude that it does. The plaintiffs -appellants are six current or former residents of the City of Boise ("the City"), who are homeless or have recently been homeless. Each plaintiff alleges that, between 2007 and 2009, he or she was cited by Boise police 489 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 39 of 72 MARTIN V. CITY OF BOisE 39 for violating one or both of two city ordinances. The first, Boise City Code § 9-10-02 (the "Camping Ordinance"), makes it a misdemeanor to use "any of the streets, sidewalks, parks, or public places as a camping place at any time." The Camping Ordinance defines "camping" as "the use of public property as a temporary or permanent place of dwelling, lodging, or residence." Id. The second, Boise City Code § 6- 01-05 (the "Disorderly Conduct Ordinance"), bans "[o] ccupying, lodging, or sleeping in any building, structure, or public place, whether public or private ... without the permission of the owner or person entitled to possession or in control thereof." All plaintiffs seek retrospective relief for their previous citations under the ordinances. Two of the plaintiffs, Robert Anderson and Robert Martin, allege that they expect to be cited under the ordinances again in the future and seek declaratory and injunctive relief against future prosecution. In Jones v. City ofLos Angeles, 444 F.3d 1118, 1138 (9th Cir. 2006), vacated, 505 F.3d 1006 (9th Cir. 2007), a panel of this court concluded that "so long as there is a greater number of homeless individuals in Los Angeles than the number of available beds [in shelters]" for the homeless, Los Angeles could not enforce a similar ordinance against homeless individuals "for involuntarily sitting, lying, and sleeping in public." Jones is not binding on us, as there was an underlying settlement between the parties and our opinion was vacated as a result. We agree with Jones's reasoning and central conclusion, however, and so hold that an ordinance violates the Eighth Amendment insofar as it imposes criminal sanctions against homeless individuals for sleeping outdoors, on public property, when no alternative shelter is available to them. Two of the plaintiffs, we further hold, may be entitled 490 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 40 of 72 40 MARTIN V. CITY OF BOISE to retrospective and prospective relief for violation of that Eighth Amendment right. I. Background The district court granted summary judgment to the City on all claims. We therefore review the record in the light most favorable to the plaintiffs. Tolan v. Cotton, 134 S. Ct. 1861, 1866 (2014). Boise has a significant and increasing homeless population. According to the Point -in -Time Count ("PIT Count") conducted by the Idaho Housing and Finance Association, there were 753 homeless individuals in Ada County the county of which Boise is the seat in January 2014, 46 of whom were "unsheltered," or living in places unsuited to human habitation such as parks or sidewalks. In 2016, the last year for which data is available, there were 867 homeless individuals counted in Ada County, 125 of whom were unsheltered.l The PIT Count likely underestimates the number of homeless individuals in Ada County. It is "widely recognized that a one-night point in ' The United States Department of Housing and Urban Development ("HUD") requires local homeless assistance and prevention networks to conduct an annual count of homeless individuals on one night each January, known as the PIT Count, as a condition of receiving federal funds. State, local, and federal governmental entities, as well as private service providers, rely on the PIT Count as a "critical source of data" on homelessness in the United States. The parties acknowledge that the PIT Count is not always precise. The City's Director of Community Partnerships, Diana Lachiondo, testified that the PIT Count is "not always the ... best resource for numbers," but also stated that "the point -in -time count is our best snapshot" for counting the number of homeless individuals in a particular region, and that she "cannot give ... any other number with any kind of confidence." 491 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 41 of 72 MARTIN V. CITY OF BOisE 41 time count will undercount the homeless population," as many homeless individuals may have access to temporary housing on a given night, and as weather conditions may affect the number of available volunteers and the number of homeless people staying at shelters or accessing services on the night of the count. There are currently three homeless shelters in the City of Boise offering emergency shelter services, all run by private, nonprofit organizations. As far as the record reveals, these three shelters are the only shelters in Ada County. One shelter "Sanctuary" is operated by Interfaith Sanctuary Housing Services, Inc. The shelter is open to men, women, and children of all faiths, and does not impose any religious requirements on its residents. Sanctuary has 96 beds reserved for individual men and women, with several additional beds reserved for families. The shelter uses floor mats when it reaches capacity with beds. Because of its limited capacity, Sanctuary frequently has to turn away homeless people seeking shelter. In 2010, Sanctuary reached full capacity in the men's area "at least half of every month," and the women's area reached capacity "almost every night of the week." In 2014, the shelter reported that it was full for men, women, or both on 38% of nights. Sanctuary provides beds first to people who spent the previous night at Sanctuary. At 9:00 pm each night, it allots any remaining beds to those who added their names to the shelter's waiting list. 492 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 42 of 72 42 MARTIN V. CITY OF Bom The other two shelters in Boise are both operated by the Boise Rescue Mission ("BRM"), a Christian nonprofit organization. One of those shelters, the River of Life Rescue Mission ("River of Life"), is open exclusively to men; the other, the City Light Home for Women and Children ("City Light"), shelters women and children only. BRM's facilities provide two primary "programs" for the homeless, the Emergency Services Program and the New Life Discipleship Program.' The Emergency Services Program provides temporary shelter, food, and clothing to anyone in need. Christian religious services are offered to those seeking shelter through the Emergency Services Program. The shelters display messages and iconography on the walls, and the intake form for emergency shelter guests includes a religious message.' Homeless individuals may check in to either BRM facility between 4:00 and 5:30 pm. Those who arrive at BRM facilities between 5:30 and 8:00 pm may be denied shelter, depending on the reason for their late arrival; generally, anyone arriving after 8:00 pm is denied shelter. Except in winter, male guests in the Emergency Services Program may stay at River of Life for up to 17 consecutive 2 The record suggests that BRM provides some limited additional non -emergency shelter programming which, like the Discipleship Program, has overtly religious components. 3 The intake form states in relevant part that "We are a Gospel Rescue Mission. Gospel means `Good News,' and the Good News is that Jesus saves us from sin past, present, and future. We would like to share the Good News with you. Have you heard of Jesus? ... Would you like to know more about him?" 493 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 43 of 72 MARTIN V. CITY OF Bom 43 nights; women and children in the Emergency Services Program may stay at City Light for up to 30 consecutive nights. After the time limit is reached, homeless individuals who do not join the Discipleship Program may not return to a BRM shelter for at least 30 days.4 Participants in the Emergency Services Program must return to the shelter every night during the applicable 17-day or 30-day period; if a resident fails to check in to a BRM shelter each night, that resident is prohibited from staying overnight at that shelter for 30 days. BRM's rules on the length of a person's stay in the Emergency Services Program are suspended during the winter. The Discipleship Program is an "intensive, Christ -based residential recovery program" of which "[r]eligious study is the very essence." The record does not indicate any limit to how long a member of the Discipleship Program may stay at a BRM shelter. The River of Life shelter contains 148 beds for emergency use, along with 40 floor mats for overflow; 78 additional beds serve those in non -emergency shelter programs such as the Discipleship Program. The City Light shelter has 110 beds for emergency services, as well as 40 floor mats to handle overflow and 3 8 beds for women in non -emergency shelter programs. All told, Boise's three homeless shelters contain 354 beds and 92 overflow mats for homeless individuals. a The parties dispute the extent to which BRM actually enforces the 17- and 30-day limits. 494 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 44 of 72 44 MARTIN V. CITY OF Bom A. The Plaintiffs Plaintiffs Robert Martin, Robert Anderson, Lawrence Lee Smith, Basil E. Humphrey, Pamela S. Hawkes, and Janet F. Bell are all homeless individuals who have lived in or around Boise since at least 2007. Between 2007 and 2009, each plaintiff was convicted at least once of violating the Camping Ordinance, the Disorderly Conduct Ordinance, or both. With one exception, all plaintiffs were sentenced to time served for all convictions; on two occasions, Hawkes was sentenced to one additional day in jail. During the same period, Hawkes was cited, but not convicted, under the Camping Ordinance, and Martin was cited, but not convicted, under the Disorderly Conduct Ordinance. Plaintiff Robert Anderson currently lives in Boise; he is homeless and has often relied on Boise's shelters for housing. In the summer of 2007, Anderson stayed at River of Life as part of the Emergency Services Program until he reached the shelter's 17-day limit for male guests. Anderson testified that during his 2007 stay at River of Life, he was required to attend chapel services before he was permitted to eat dinner. At the conclusion of his 17-day stay, Anderson declined to enter the Discipleship Program because of his religious beliefs. As Anderson was barred by the shelter's policies from returning to River of Life for 30 days, he slept outside for the next several weeks. On September 1, 2007, Anderson was cited under the Camping Ordinance. He pled guilty to violating the Camping Ordinance and paid a $25 fine; he did not appeal his conviction. Plaintiff Robert Martin is a former resident of Boise who currently lives in Post Falls, Idaho. Martin returns frequently to Boise to visit his minor son. In March of 2009, Martin was 495 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 45 of 72 MARTIN V. CITY OF Bom 45 cited under the Camping Ordinance for sleeping outside; he was cited again in 2012 under the same ordinance. B. Procedural History The plaintiffs filed this action in the United States District Court for the District of Idaho in October of 2009. All plaintiffs alleged that their previous citations under the Camping Ordinance and the Disorderly Conduct Ordinance violated the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause of the Eighth Amendment, and sought damages for those alleged violations under 42 U.S.C. § 1983. Cf. Joiies, 444 F.3d at 1138. Anderson and Martin also sought prospective declaratory and injunctive relief precluding future enforcement of the ordinances under the same statute and the Declaratory Judgment Act, 28 U.S.C. §§ 2201-2202. After this litigation began, the Boise Police Department promulgated a new "Special Order," effective as of January 1, 2010, that prohibited enforcement of either the Camping Ordinance or the Disorderly Conduct Ordinance against any homeless person on public property on any night when no shelter had "an available overnight space." City police implemented the Special Order through a two-step procedure known as the "Shelter Protocol." Under the Shelter Protocol, if any shelter in Boise reaches capacity on a given night, that shelter will so notify the police at roughly 11:00 pm. Each shelter has discretion to determine whether it is full, and Boise police have no other mechanism or criteria for gauging whether a shelter is full. Since the Shelter Protocol was adopted, Sanctuary has reported that it was full on almost 40% of nights. Although BRM agreed to the Shelter Protocol, its internal policy is never to turn any 496 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 46 of 72 46 MARTIN V. CITY OF Bom person away because of a lack of space, and neither BRM shelter has ever reported that it was full. If all shelters are full on the same night, police are to refrain from enforcing either ordinance. Presumably because the BRM shelters have not reported full, Boise police continue to issue citations regularly under both ordinances. In July 2011, the district court granted summary judgment to the City. It held that the plaintiffs' claims for retrospective relief were barred under the Rooker -Feldman doctrine and that their claims for prospective relief were mooted by the Special Order and the Shelter Protocol. Bell v. City of Boise, 834 F. Supp. 2d 1103 (D. Idaho 2011). On appeal, we reversed and remanded. Bell v. City of Boise, 709 F.3d 890, 901 (9th Cir. 2013). We held that the district court erred in dismissing the plaintiffs' claims under the Rooker -Feldman doctrine. Id. at 897. In so holding, we expressly declined to consider whether the favorable -termination requirement from Heck v. Humphrey, 512 U.S. 477 (1994), applied to the plaintiffs' claims for retrospective relief. Instead, we left the issue for the district court on remand. Bell, 709 F.3d at 897 n.11. Bell further held that the plaintiffs' claims for prospective relief were not moot. The City had not met its "heavy burden" of demonstrating that the challenged conduct enforcement of the two ordinances against homeless individuals with no access to shelter "could not reasonably be expected to recur." Id. at 898, 901 (quoting Friends of the Earth, Inc. v. Laidlaw Envtl. Servs. (TOC), Inc., 528 U.S. 167, 189 (2000)). We emphasized that the Special Order was a statement of administrative policy and so could be amended 497 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 47 of 72 MARTIN V. CITY OF Bom 47 or reversed at any time by the Boise Chief of Police. Id. at 899-900. Finally, Bell rejected the City's argument that the plaintiffs lacked standing to seek prospective relief because they were no longer homeless. Id. at 901 & n.12. We noted that, on summary judgment, the plaintiffs "need not establish that they in fact have standing, but only that there is a genuine issue of material fact as to the standing elements." Id. (citation omitted). On remand, the district court again granted summary judgment to the City on the plaintiffs' § 1983 claims. The court observed that Heck requires a § 1983 plaintiff seeking damages for "harm caused by actions whose unlawfulness would render a conviction or sentence invalid" to demonstrate that "the conviction or sentence has been reversed on direct appeal, expunged by executive order, declared invalid by a state tribunal ... or called into question by a federal court's issuance of a writ of habeas corpus." 512 U.S. at 486-87. According to the district court, "a judgment finding the Ordinances unconstitutional ... necessarily would imply the invalidity of Plaintiffs' [previous] convictions under those ordinances," and the plaintiffs therefore were required to demonstrate that their convictions or sentences had already been invalidated. As none of the plaintiffs had raised an Eighth Amendment challenge as a defense to criminal prosecution, nor had any plaintiff successfully appealed their conviction, the district court held that all of the plaintiffs' claims for retrospective relief were barred by Heck. The district court also rejected as barred by Heck the plaintiffs' claim for prospective injunctive relief under § 1983, reasoning that "a ruling in favor of Plaintiffs on even a 498 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 48 of 72 48 MARTIN V. CITY OF Bom prospective § 1983 claim would demonstrate the invalidity of any confinement stemming from those convictions." Finally, the district court determined that, although Heck did not bar relief under the Declaratory Judgment Act, Martin and Anderson now lack standing to pursue such relief. The linchpin of this holding was that the Camping Ordinance and the Disorderly Conduct Ordinance were both amended in 2014 to codify the Special Order's mandate that "[flaw enforcement officers shall not enforce [the ordinances] when the individual is on public property and there is no available overnight shelter." Boise City Code §§ 6-01-05, 9-10-02. Because the ordinances, as amended, permitted camping or sleeping in a public place when no shelter space was available, the court held that there was no "credible threat" of future prosecution. "If the Ordinances are not to be enforced when the shelters are full, those Ordinances do not inflict a constitutional injury upon these particular plaintiffs ...." The court emphasized that the record "suggests there is no known citation of a homeless individual under the Ordinances for camping or sleeping on public property on any night or morning when he or she was unable to secure shelter due to a lack of shelter capacity" and that "there has not been a single night when all three shelters in Boise called in to report they were simultaneously full for men, women or families." This appeal followed. 499 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 49 of 72 MARTIN V. CITY OF Bom 49 II. Discussion A. Standing We first consider whether any of the plaintiffs has standing to pursue prospective relief.' We conclude that there are sufficient opposing facts in the record to create a genuine issue of material fact as to whether Martin and Anderson face a credible threat of prosecution under one or both ordinances in the future at a time when they are unable to stay at any Boise homeless shelter.' "To establish Article III standing, an injury must be concrete, particularized, and actual or imminent; fairly traceable to the challenged action; and redressable by a favorable ruling." Clapper v. Amnesty Int'l USA, 133 S. Ct. 1138, 1147 (2013) (citation omitted). "Although imminence is concededly a somewhat elastic concept, it cannot be stretched beyond its purpose, which is to ensure that the alleged injury is not too speculative for Article III purposes that the injury is certainly impending." Id. (citation omitted). A plaintiff need not, however, await an arrest or prosecution to have standing to challenge the constitutionality of a criminal statute. "When the plaintiff has alleged an Standing to pursue retrospective relief is not in doubt. The only threshold question affecting the availability of a claim for retrospective relief a question we address in the next section — is whether such relief is barred by the doctrine established in Heck. ' Although the SAC is somewhat ambiguous regarding which of the plaintiffs seeks prospective relief, counsel for the plaintiffs made clear at oral argument that only two of the plaintiffs, Martin and Anderson, seek such relief, and the district court considered the standing question with respect to Martin and Anderson only. 00 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 50 of 72 50 MARTIN V. CITY OF Bom intention to engage in a course of conduct arguably affected with a constitutional interest, but proscribed by a statute, and there exists a credible threat of prosecution thereunder, he should not be required to await and undergo a criminal prosecution as the sole means of seeking relief." Babbitt v. UnitedFarm Workers Nat'l Union, 442 U.S. 289,298 (1979) (citation and internal quotation marks omitted). To defeat a motion for summary judgment premised on an alleged lack of standing, plaintiffs " need not establish that they in fact have standing, but only that there is a genuine question of material fact as to the standing elements." Cent. Delta Water Agency v. United States, 306 F.3d 938, 947 (9th Cir. 2002). In dismissing Martin and Anderson's claims for declaratory relief for lack of standing, the district court emphasized that Boise's ordinances, as amended in 2014, preclude the City from issuing a citation when there is no available space at a shelter, and there is consequently no risk that either Martin or Anderson will be cited under such circumstances in the future. Viewing the record in the light most favorable to the plaintiffs, we cannot agree. Although the 2014 amendments preclude the City from enforcing the ordinances when there is no room available at any shelter, the record demonstrates that the City is wholly reliant on the shelters to self -report when they are full. It is undisputed that Sanctuary is full as to men on a substantial percentage of nights, perhaps as high as 50%. The City nevertheless emphasizes that since the adoption of the Shelter Protocol in 2010, the BRM facilities, River of Life and City Light, have never reported that they are full, and BRM states that it will never turn people away due to lack space. 01 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 51 of 72 MARTIN V. CITY OF Bom 51 The plaintiffs have pointed to substantial evidence in the record, however, indicating that whether or not the BRM facilities are ever full or turn homeless individuals away for lack of space, they do refuse to shelter homeless people who exhaust the number of days allotted by the facilities. Specifically, the plaintiffs allege, and the City does not dispute, that it is BRM's policy to limit men to 17 consecutive days in the Emergency Services Program, after which they cannot return to River of Life for 30 days; City Light has a similar 30-day limit for women and children. Anderson testified that BRM has enforced this policy against him in the past, forcing him to sleep outdoors. The plaintiffs have adduced further evidence indicating that River of Life permits individuals to remain at the shelter after 17 days in the Emergency Services Program only on the condition that they become part of the New Life Discipleship program, which has a mandatory religious focus. For example, there is evidence that participants in the New Life Program are not allowed to spend days at Corpus Christi, a local Catholic program, "because it's ... a different sect." There are also facts in dispute concerning whether the Emergency Services Program itself has a religious component. Although the City argues strenuously that the Emergency Services Program is secular, Anderson testified to the contrary; he stated that he was once required to attend chapel before being permitted to eat dinner at the River of Life shelter. Both Martin and Anderson have objected to the overall religious atmosphere of the River of Life shelter, including the Christian messaging on the shelter's intake form and the Christian iconography on the shelter walls. A city cannot, via the threat of prosecution, coerce an individual to attend religion -based treatment programs consistently with the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment. Inouye v. 02 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 52 of 72 52 MARTIN V. CITY OF Bom Kemna, 504 F.3d 705, 712-13 (9th Cir. 2007). Yet at the conclusion of a 17-day stay at River of Life, or a 30-day stay at City Light, an individual may be forced to choose between sleeping outside on nights when Sanctuary is full (and risking arrest under the ordinances), or enrolling in BRM programming that is antithetical to his or her religious beliefs. The 17-day and 30-day limits are not the only BRM policies which functionally limit access to BRM facilities even when space is nominally available. River of Life also turns individuals away if they voluntarily leave the shelter before the 17-day limit and then attempt to return within 30 days. An individual who voluntarily leaves a BRM facility for any reason perhaps because temporary shelter is available at Sanctuary, or with friends or family, or in a hotel cannot immediately return to the shelter if circumstances change. Moreover, BRM's facilities may deny shelter to any individual who arrives after 5:30 pm, and generally will deny shelter to anyone arriving after 8:00 pm. Sanctuary, however, does not assign beds to persons on its waiting list until 9:00 pm. Thus, by the time a homeless individual on the Sanctuary waiting list discovers that the shelter has no room available, it may be too late to seek shelter at either BRM facility. So, even if we credit the City's evidence that BRM's facilities have never been "full," and that the City has never cited any person under the ordinances who could not obtain shelter "due to a lack of shelter capacity," there remains a genuine issue of material fact as to whether homeless individuals in Boise run a credible risk of being issued a citation on a night when Sanctuary is full and they have been denied entry to a BRM facility for reasons other than shelter capacity. If so, then as a practical matter, no shelter is 03 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 53 of 72 MARTIN V. CITY OF Bom 53 available. We note that despite the Shelter Protocol and the amendments to both ordinances, the City continues regularly to issue citations for violating both ordinances; during the first three months of 2015, the Boise Police Department issued over 175 such citations. The City argues that Martin faces little risk of prosecution under either ordinance because he has not lived in Boise since 2013. Martin states, however, that he is still homeless and still visits Boise several times a year to visit his minor son, and that he has continued to seek shelter at Sanctuary and River of Life. Although Martin may no longer spend enough time in Boise to risk running afoul of BRM's 17-day limit, he testified that he has unsuccessfully sought shelter at River of Life after being placed on Sanctuary's waiting list, only to discover later in the evening that Sanctuary had no available beds. Should Martin return to Boise to visit his son, there is a reasonable possibility that he might again seek shelter at Sanctuary, only to discover (after BRM has closed for the night) that Sanctuary has no space for him. Anderson, for his part, continues to live in Boise and states that he remains homeless. We conclude that both Martin and Anderson have demonstrated a genuine issue of material fact regarding whether they face a credible risk of prosecution under the ordinances in the future on a night when they have been denied access to Boise's homeless shelters; both plaintiffs therefore have standing to seek prospective relief. B. Heck v. Humphrey We turn next to the impact of Heck v. Humphrey and its progeny on this case. With regard to retrospective relief, the 04 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 54 of 72 54 MARTIN V. CITY OF Bom plaintiffs maintain that Heck should not bar their claims because, with one exception, all of the plaintiffs were sentenced to time served.' It would therefore have been impossible for the plaintiffs to obtain federal habeas relief, as any petition for a writ of habeas corpus must be filed while the petitioner is "in custody pursuant to the judgment of a State court." See 28 U.S.C. § 2254(a); Spencer v. Kemna, 523 U.S. 1, 7, 17-18 (1998). With regard to prospective relief, the plaintiffs emphasize that they seek only equitable protection against future enforcement of an allegedly unconstitutional statute, and not to invalidate any prior conviction under the same statute. We hold that although the Heck line of cases precludes most but not all of the plaintiffs' requests for retrospective relief, that doctrine has no application to the plaintiffs' request for an injunction enjoining prospective enforcement of the ordinances. 1. The Heck Doctrine A long line of Supreme Court case law, beginning with Preiser v. Rodriguez, 411 U.S. 475 (1973), holds that a prisoner in state custody cannot use a § 1983 action to challenge the fact or duration of his or her confinement, but must instead seek federal habeas corpus relief or analogous state relief. Id. at 477, 500. Preiser considered whether a prison inmate could bring a § 1983 action seeking an injunction to remedy an unconstitutional deprivation of good- time conduct credits. Observing that habeas corpus is the traditional instrument to obtain release from unlawful Plaintiff Pamela Hawkes was convicted of violating the Camping Ordinance or Disorderly Conduct Ordinance on twelve occasions; although she was usually sentenced to time served, she was twice sentenced to one additional day in jail. 05 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 55 of 72 MARTIN V. CITY OF Bom 55 confinement, Preiser recognized an implicit exception from § 1983's broad scope for actions that lie "within the core of habeas corpus" specifically, challenges to the "fact or duration" of confinement. Id. at 487, 500. The Supreme Court subsequently held, however, that although Preiser barred inmates from obtaining an injunction to restore good- time credits via a § 1983 action, Preiser did not "preclude a litigant with standing from obtaining by way of ancillary relief an otherwise proper injunction enjoining the prospective enforcement of invalid prison regulations." Wolff v. McDonnell, 418 U.S. 539, 555 (1974) (emphasis added). Heck addressed a § 1983 action brought by an inmate seeking compensatory and punitive damages. The inmate alleged that state and county officials had engaged in unlawful investigations and knowing destruction of exculpatory evidence. Heck, 512 U.S. at 479. The Court in Heck analogized a § 1983 action of this type, which called into question the validity of an underlying conviction, to a cause of action for malicious prosecution, id. at 483-84, and went on to hold that, as with a malicious prosecution claim, a plaintiff in such an action must demonstrate a favorable termination of the criminal proceedings before seeking tort relief, id. at 486-87. "[T]o recover damages for allegedly unconstitutional conviction or imprisonment, or for other harm caused by actions whose unlawfulness would render a conviction or sentence invalid, a § 1983 plaintiff must prove that the conviction or sentence has been reversed on direct appeal, expunged by executive order, declared invalid by a state tribunal authorized to make such determination, or called into question by a federal court's issuance of a writ of habeas corpus." Id. 06 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 56 of 72 56 MARTIN V. CITY OF Bom Edwards v. Balisok, 520 U.S. 641(1997) extendedHeck's holding to claims for declaratory relief. Id. at 648. The plaintiff in Edwards alleged that he had been deprived of earned good-time credits without due process of law, because the decisionmaker in disciplinary proceedings had concealed exculpatory evidence. Because the plaintiff's claim for declaratory relief was "based on allegations of deceit and bias on the part of the decisionmaker that necessarily imply the invalidity of the punishment imposed," Edwards held, it was "not cognizable under § 1983." Id. Edwards went on to hold, however, that a requested injunction requiring prison officials to date -stamp witness statements was not Heck -barred, reasoning that a "prayer for such prospective relief will not `necessarily imply' the invalidity of a previous loss of good- time credits, and so may properly be brought under § 1983." Id. (emphasis added). Most recently, Wilkinson v. Dotson, 544 U.S. 74 (2005), stated that Heckbars § 1983 suits even when the relief sought is prospective injunctive or declaratory relief, "if success in that action would necessarily demonstrate the invalidity of confinement or its duration." Id. at 81-82 (emphasis omitted). But Wilkinson held that the plaintiffs in that case could seek a prospective injunction compelling the state to comply with constitutional requirements in parole proceedings in the future. The Court observed that the prisoners' claims for future relief, "if successful, will not necessarily imply the invalidity of confinement or shorten its duration." Id. at 82. The Supreme Court did not, in these cases or any other, conclusively determine whether Heck's favorable -termination requirement applies to convicts who have no practical opportunity to challenge their conviction or sentence via a 07 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 57 of 72 MARTIN V. CITY OF Bom 57 petition for habeas corpus. See Muhammad v. Close, 540 U.S. 749, 752 & n.2 (2004). But in Spencer, five Justices suggested that Heck may not apply in such circumstances. Spencer, 523 U.S. at 3. The petitioner in Spencer had filed a federal habeas petition seeking to invalidate an order revoking his parole. While the habeas petition was pending, the petitioner's term of imprisonment expired, and his habeas petition was consequently dismissed as moot. Justice Souter wrote a concurring opinion in which three other Justices joined, addressing the petitioner's argument that if his habeas petition were mooted by his release, any § 1983 action would be barred under Heck, yet he would no longer have access to a federal habeas forum to challenge the validity of his parole revocation. Id. at 18-19 (Souter, J., concurring). Justice Souter stated that in his view "Heck has no such effect," and that "a former prisoner, no longer `in custody,' may bring a § 1983 action establishing the unconstitutionality of a conviction or confinement without being bound to satisfy a favorable -termination requirement that it would be impossible as a matter of law for him to satisfy." Id. at 21. Justice Stevens, dissenting, stated that he would have held the habeas petition in Spencer not moot, but agreed that "[g]iven the Court's holding that petitioner does not have a remedy under the habeas statute, it is perfectly clear ... that he may bring an action under 42 U.S.C. § 1983." Id. at 25 n.8 (Stevens, J., dissenting). Relying on the concurring and dissenting opinions in Spencer, we have held that the "unavailability of a remedy in habeas corpus because of mootness" permitted a plaintiff released from custody to maintain a § 1983 action for damages, "even though success in that action would imply the 08 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 58 of 72 58 MARTIN V. CITY OF Bom invalidity of the disciplinary proceeding that caused revocation of his good-time credits." Nonnette v. Small, 316 F.3d 872, 876 (9th Cir. 2002). But we have limited Nonnette in recent years. Most notably, we held in Lyall v. City ofLos Angeles, 807 F.3d 1178 (9th Cir. 2015), that even where a plaintiff had no practical opportunity to pursue federal habeas relief while detained because of the short duration of his confinement, Heck bars a § 1983 action that would imply the invalidity of a prior conviction if the plaintiff could have sought invalidation of the underlying conviction via direct appeal or state post -conviction relief, but did not do so. Id. at 1192 & n.12. 2. Retrospective Relief Here, the majority of the plaintiffs' claims for retrospective relief are governed squarely by Lyall. It is undisputed that all the plaintiffs not only failed to challenge their convictions on direct appeal but expressly waived the right to do so as a condition of their guilty pleas. The plaintiffs have made no showing that any of their convictions were invalidated via state post -conviction relief. We therefore hold that all but two of the plaintiffs' claims for damages are foreclosed under Lyall. Two of the plaintiffs, however, Robert Martin and Pamela Hawkes, also received citations under the ordinances that were dismissed before the state obtained a conviction. Hawkes was cited for violating the Camping Ordinance on July 8, 2007; that violation was dismissed on August 28, 2007. Martin was cited for violating the Disorderly Conduct Ordinance on April 24, 2009; those charges were dismissed on September 9, 2009. The complaint alleges two injuries stemming from these dismissed citations: (1) the continued 09 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 59 of 72 MARTIN V. CITY OF Bom 59 inclusion of the citations on plaintiffs' criminal records; and (2) the accumulation of a host of criminal fines and incarceration costs. Plaintiffs seek orders compelling the City to "expunge[] ... the records of any homeless individuals unlawfully cited or arrested and charged under [the Ordinances]" and "reimburse[] ... any criminal fines paid ... [or] costs of incarceration billed." With respect to these two incidents, the district court erred in finding that the plaintiffs' Eighth Amendment challenge was barred by Heck. Where there is no "conviction or sentence" that may be undermined by a grant of relief to the plaintiffs, the Heck doctrine has no application. 512 U. S. at 486-87; see also Wallace v. Kato, 549 U.S. 384, 393 (2007). Relying on Ingraham v. Wright, 430 U.S. 651, 664 (1977), the City argues that the Eighth Amendment, and the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause in particular, have no application where there has been no conviction. The City's reliance on Ingraham is misplaced. As the Supreme Court observed in Ingraham, the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause not only limits the types of punishment that may be imposed and prohibits the imposition of punishment grossly disproportionate to the severity of the crime, but also "imposes substantive limits on what can be made criminal and punished as such." Id. at 667. "This [latter] protection governs the criminal law process as a whole, not only the imposition of punishment postconviction." Jones, 444 F.3d at 1128. Ingraham concerned only whether "impositions outside the criminal process" in that case, the paddling of schoolchildren "constituted cruel and unusual MO Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 60 of 72 60 MARTIN V. CITY OF Bom punishment." 430 U.S. at 667. Ingraham did not hold that a plaintiff challenging the state's power to criminalize a particular status or conduct in the first instance, as the plaintiffs in this case do, must first be convicted. If conviction were a prerequisite for such a challenge, "the state could in effect punish individuals in the preconviction stages of the criminal law enforcement process for being or doing things that under the [Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause] cannot be subject to the criminal process." Jones, 444 F.3d at 1129. For those rare Eighth Amendment challenges concerning the state's very power to criminalize particular behavior or status, then, a plaintiff need demonstrate only the initiation of the criminal process against him, not a conviction. 3. Prospective Relief The district court also erred in concluding that the plaintiffs' requests for prospective injunctive relief were barred by Heck. The district court relied entirely on language in Wilkinson stating that "a state prisoner's § 1983 action is barred (absent prior invalidation) ... no matter the relief sought (damages or equitable relief) ... if success in that action would necessarily demonstrate the invalidity of confinement or its duration." Wilkinson, 544 U.S. at 81-82. The district court concluded from this language in Wilkinson that a person convicted under an allegedly unconstitutional statute may never challenge the validity or application of that statute after the initial criminal proceeding is complete, even when the relief sought is prospective only and independent of the prior conviction. The logical extension of the district court's interpretation is that an individual who does not successfully invalidate a first conviction under an unconstitutional statute will have no opportunity to challenge t41 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 61 of 72 MARTIN V. CITY OF Bom 61 that statute prospectively so as to avoid arrest and conviction for violating that same statute in the future. Neither Wilkinson nor any other case in the Heck line supports such a result. Rather, Wolff, Edwards, and Wilkinson compel the opposite conclusion. Wolff held that although Preiser barred a § 1983 action seeking restoration of good-time credits absent a successful challenge in federal habeas proceedings, Preiser did not "preclude a litigant with standing from obtaining by way of ancillary relief an otherwise proper injunction enjoining the prospective enforcement of invalid ... regulations." Wolff, 418 U.S. at 555. Although Wolff was decided before Heck, the Court subsequently made clear that Heck effected no change in the law in this regard, observing in Edwards that '[o]rdinarily, a prayer for ... prospective [injunctive] relief will not `necessarily imply' the invalidity of a previous loss of good-time credits, and so may properly be brought under § 1983." Edwards, 520 U.S. at 648 (emphasis added). Importantly, the Court held in Edwards that although the plaintiff could not, consistently with Heck, seek a declaratory judgment stating that the procedures employed by state officials that deprived him of good-time credits were unconstitutional, he could seek an injunction barring such allegedly unconstitutional procedures in the future. Id. Finally, the Court noted in Wilkinson that the Heck line of cases "has focused on the need to ensure that state prisoners use only habeas corpus (or similar state) remedies when they seek to invalidate the duration of their confinement," Wilkinson, 544 U.S. at 81 (emphasis added), alluding to an existing confinement, not one yet to come. M Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 62 of 72 62 MARTIN V. CITY OF Bom The Heck doctrine, in other words, serves to ensure the finality and validity of previous convictions, not to insulate future prosecutions from challenge. In context, it is clear that Wilkinson's holding that the Heck doctrine bars a § 1983 action "no matter the relief sought (damages or equitable relief) . . . if success in that action would necessarily demonstrate the invalidity of confinement or its duration" applies to equitable relief concerning an existing confinement, not to suits seeking to preclude an unconstitutional confinement in the future, arising from incidents occurring after any prior conviction and stemming from a possible later prosecution and conviction. Id. at 81-82 (emphasis added). As Wilkinson held, "claims for future relief (which, if successful, will not necessarily imply the invalidity of confinement or shorten its duration)" are distant from the "core" of habeas corpus with which the Heck line of cases is concerned, and are not precluded by the Heck doctrine. Id. at 82. In sum, we hold that the majority of the plaintiffs' claims for retrospective relief are barred by Heck, but both Martin and Hawkes stated claims for damages to which Heck has no application. We further hold that Heck has no application to the plaintiffs' requests for prospective injunctive relief. C. The Eighth Amendment At last, we turn to the merits does the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause of the Eighth Amendment preclude the enforcement of a statute prohibiting sleeping outside against homeless individuals with no access to alternative shelter? We hold that it does, for essentially the same reasons articulated in the now -vacated Jones opinion. M3 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 63 of 72 MARTIN V. CITY OF Bom 63 The Eighth Amendment states: "Excessive bail shall not be required, nor excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted." U.S. Const., amend. VIII. The Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause "circumscribes the criminal process in three ways." Ingraham, 430 U.S. at 667. First, it limits the type of punishment the government may impose; second, it proscribes punishment "grossly disproportionate" to the severity of the crime; and third, it places substantive limits on what the government may criminalize. Id. It is the third limitation that is pertinent here. "Even one day in prison would be a cruel and unusual punishment for the `crime' of having a common cold." Robinson v. California, 370 U.S. 660, 667 (1962). Cases construing substantive limits as to what the government may criminalize are rare, however, and for good reason the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause's third limitation is "one to be applied sparingly." Ingraham, 430 U.S. at 667. Robinson, the seminal case in this branch of Eighth Amendment jurisprudence, held a California statute that "ma[de] the `status' of narcotic addiction a criminal offense" invalid under the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause. 370 U.S. at 666. The California law at issue in Robinson was "not one which punishe[d] a person for the use of narcotics, for their purchase, sale or possession, or for antisocial or disorderly behavior resulting from their administration"; it punished addiction itself. Id. Recognizing narcotics addiction as an illness or disease "apparently an illness which may be contracted innocently or involuntarily" and observing that a "law which made a criminal offense of... a disease would doubtless be universally thought to be an infliction of cruel and unusual punishment," Robinson held W Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 64 of 72 64 MARTIN V. CITY OF Bom the challenged statute a violation of the Eighth Amendment. Id. at 666-67. As Jones observed, Robinson did not explain at length the principles underpinning its holding. See Jones, 444 F.3d at 1133. In Powell v. Texas, 392 U.S. 514 (1968), however, the Court elaborated on the principle first articulated in Robinson. Powell concerned the constitutionality of a Texas law making public drunkenness a criminal offense. Justice Marshall, writing for a plurality of the Court, distinguished the Texas statute from the law at issue in Robinson on the ground that the Texas statute made criminal not alcoholism but conduct appearing in public while intoxicated. "[A]ppellant was convicted, not for being a chronic alcoholic, but for being in public while drunk on a particular occasion. The State of Texas thus has not sought to punish a mere status, as California did in Robinson; nor has it attempted to regulate appellant's behavior in the privacy of his own home." Id. at 532 (plurality opinion). The Powell plurality opinion went on to interpret Robinson as precluding only the criminalization of "status," not of "involuntary" conduct. "The entire thrust of Robinson's interpretation of the Cruel and Unusual Punishment Clause is that criminal penalties may be inflicted only if the accused has committed some act, has engaged in some behavior, which society has an interest in preventing, or perhaps in historical common law terms, has committed some actus reus. It thus does not deal with the question of whether certain conduct cannot constitutionally be punished because it is, in some sense, `involuntary' ...." Id. at 533. M5 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 65 of 72 MARTIN V. CITY OF Bom 65 Four Justices dissented from the Court's holding in Powell; Justice White concurred in the result alone. Notably, Justice White noted that many chronic alcoholics are also homeless, and that for those individuals, public drunkenness may be unavoidable as a practical matter. "For all practical purposes the public streets may be home for these unfortunates, not because their disease compels them to be there, but because, drunk or sober, they have no place else to go and no place else to be when they are drinking.... For some of these alcoholics I would think a showing could be made that resisting drunkenness is impossible and that avoiding public places when intoxicated is also impossible. As applied to them this statute is in effect a law which bans a single act for which they may not be convicted under the Eighth Amendment the act of getting drunk." Id. at 551 (White, J., concurring in the judgment). The four dissenting Justices adopted a position consistent with that taken by Justice White: that under Robinson, "criminal penalties may not be inflicted upon a person for being in a condition he is powerless to change," and that the defendant, "once intoxicated, ... could not prevent himself from appearing in public places." Id. at 567 (Fortas, J., dissenting). Thus, five Justices gleaned from Robinson the principle that "that the Eighth Amendment prohibits the state from punishing an involuntary act or condition if it is the unavoidable consequence of one's status or being." Jones, 444 F.3d at 1135; see also United States v. Roberston, 875 F.3d 1281, 1291 (9th Cir. 2017). This principle compels the conclusion that the Eighth Amendment prohibits the imposition of criminal penalties for sitting, sleeping, or lying outside on public property for homeless individuals who cannot obtain shelter. As Jones M6 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 66 of 72 66 MARTIN V. CITY OF Bom reasoned, "[w]hether sitting, lying, and sleeping are defined as acts or conditions, they are universal and unavoidable consequences of being human." Jones, 444 F.3d at 1136. Moreover, any "conduct at issue here is involuntary and inseparable from status they are one and the same, given that human beings are biologically compelled to rest, whether by sitting, lying, or sleeping." Id. As a result, just as the state may not criminalize the state of being "homeless in public places," the state may not "criminalize conduct that is an unavoidable consequence of being homeless namely sitting, lying, or sleeping on the streets." Id. at 1137. Our holding is a narrow one. Like the Jones panel, "we in no way dictate to the City that it must provide sufficient shelter for the homeless, or allow anyone who wishes to sit, lie, or sleep on the streets ... at any time and at any place." Id. at 1138. We hold only that "so long as there is a greater number of homeless individuals in [a jurisdiction] than the number of available beds [in shelters]," the jurisdiction cannot prosecute homeless individuals for "involuntarily sitting, lying, and sleeping in public." Id. That is, as long as there is no option of sleeping indoors, the government cannot criminalize indigent, homeless people for sleeping outdoors, on public property, on the false premise they had a choice in the matter.' x Naturally, our holding does not cover individuals who do have access to adequate temporary shelter, whether because they have the means to pay for it or because it is realistically available to them for free, but who choose not to use it. Nor do we suggest that a jurisdiction with insufficient shelter can never criminalize the act of sleeping outside. Even where shelter is unavailable, an ordinance prohibiting sitting, lying, or sleeping outside at particular times or in particular locations might well be constitutionally permissible. See Jones, 444 F.3d at 1123. so, too, might an ordinance barring the obstruction of public rights of way or the erection M7 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 67 of 72 MARTIN V. CITY OF BOISE 67 We are not alone in reaching this conclusion. As one court has observed, "resisting the need to eat, sleep or engage in other life -sustaining activities is impossible. Avoiding public places when engaging in this otherwise innocent conduct is also impossible.... As long as the homeless plaintiffs do not have a single place where they can lawfully be, the challenged ordinances, as applied to them, effectively punish them for something for which they may not be convicted under the [E]ighth [A]mendment sleeping, eating and other innocent conduct." Pottinger v. City of Miami, 810 F. Supp. 1551, 1565 (S.D. Fla. 1992); see also Johnson v. City of Dallas, 860 F. Supp. 344, 350 (N.D. Tex. 1994) (holding that a "sleeping in public ordinance as applied against the homeless is unconstitutional"), rev'd on other grounds, 61 F.3d 442 (5th Cir. 1995).' Here, the two ordinances criminalize the simple act of sleeping outside on public property, whether bare or with a of certain structures. Whether some other ordinance is consistent with the Eighth Amendment will depend, as here, on whether it punishes a person for lacking the means to live out the "universal and unavoidable consequences of being human" in the way the ordinance prescribes. Id. at 1136. v In Joel v. City of Orlando, 232 F.3d 1353, 1362 (11th Cir. 2000), the Eleventh Circuit upheld an anti -camping ordinance similar to Boise's against an Eighth Amendment challenge. In Joel, however, the defendants presented unrefuted evidence that the homeless shelters in the City of Orlando had never reached capacity and that the plaintiffs had always enjoyed access to shelter space. Id. Those unrefuted facts were critical to the court's holding. Id. As discussed below, the plaintiffs here have demonstrated a genuine issue of material fact concerning whether they have been denied access to shelter in the past or expect to be so denied in the future. Joel therefore does not provide persuasive guidance for this case. US Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 68 of 72 68 MARTIN V. CITY OF Bom blanket or other basic bedding. The Disorderly Conduct Ordinance, on its face, criminalizes "[o]ccupying, lodging, or sleeping in any building, structure or place, whether public or private" without permission. Boise City Code § 6-01-05. Its scope is just as sweeping as the Los Angeles ordinance at issue in Jones, which mandated that "[n]o person shall sit, lie or sleep in or upon any street, sidewalk or other public way." 444 F.3d at 1123. The Camping Ordinance criminalizes using "any of the streets, sidewalks, parks or public places as a camping place at any time." Boise City Code § 9-10-02. The ordinance defines "camping" broadly: The term "camp" or "camping" shall mean the use of public property as a temporary or permanent place of dwelling, lodging, or residence, or as a living accommodation at anytime between sunset and sunrise, or as a sojourn. Indicia of camping may include, but are not limited to, storage of personal belongings, using tents or other temporary structures for sleeping or storage of personal belongings, carrying on cooking activities or making any fire in an unauthorized area, or any of these activities in combination with one another or in combination with either sleeping or making preparations to sleep (including the laying down of bedding for the purpose of sleeping). Id. It appears from the record that the Camping Ordinance is frequently enforced against homeless individuals with some elementary bedding, whether or not any of the other listed M9 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 69 of 72 MARTIN V. CITY OF Bom 69 indicia of "camping" the erection of temporary structures, the activity of cooking or making fire, or the storage of personal property— are present. For example, a Boise police officer testified that he cited plaintiff Pamela Hawkes under the Camping Ordinance for sleeping outside "wrapped in a blanket with her sandals off and next to her," for sleeping in a public restroom "with blankets," and for sleeping in a park "on a blanket, wrapped in blankets on the ground." The Camping Ordinance therefore can be, and allegedly is, enforced against homeless individuals who take even the most rudimentary precautions to protect themselves from the elements. We conclude that a municipality cannot criminalize such behavior consistently with the Eighth Amendment when no sleeping space is practically available in any shelter. III. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons, we AFFIRM the judgment of the district court as to the plaintiffs' requests for retrospective relief, except as such claims relate to Hawkes's July 2007 citation under the Camping Ordinance and Martin's April 2009 citation under the Disorderly Conduct Ordinance. We REVERSE and REMAND with respect to the plaintiffs' requests for prospective relief, both declaratory and injunctive, and to the plaintiffs' claims for retrospective relief insofar as they relate to Hawkes' July 2007 citation or Martin's April 2009 citation.10 iu Costs shall be awarded to the plaintiffs. 00 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 70 of 72 70 MARTIN V. CITY OF Bom OWENS, Circuit Judge, concurring in part and dissenting in part: I agree with the majority that the doctrine of Heck v. Humphrey, 512 U.S. 477 (1994), bars the plaintiffs' 42 U.S.C. § 1983 claims for damages that are based on convictions that have not been challenged on direct appeal or invalidated in state post -conviction relief. See Lyall v. City of Los Angeles, 807 F.3d 1178, 1192 n.12 (9th Cir. 2015). I also agree that Heck and its progeny have no application where there is no "conviction or sentence" that would be undermined by granting a plaintiff's request for relief under § 1983. Heck, 512 U.S. at 486-87; see also Wallace v. Kato, 549 U.S. 384, 393 (2007). I therefore concur in the majority's conclusion that Heck does not bar plaintiffs Robert Martin and Pamela Hawkes from seeking retrospective relief for the two instances in which they received citations, but not convictions. I also concur in the majority's Eighth Amendment analysis as to those two claims for retrospective relief. Where I part ways with the majority is in my understanding of Heck's application to the plaintiffs' claims for declaratory and injunctive relief. In Wilkinson v. Dotson, 544 U.S. 74 (2005), the Supreme Court explained where the Heck doctrine stands today: [A] state prisoner's § 1983 action is barred (absent prior invalidation) —no matter the relief sought (damages or equitable relief), no matter the target of the prisoner's suit (state conduct leading to conviction or internal prison proceedings) —if success in that action 01 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 71 of 72 MARTIN V. CITY OF Bom 71 would necessarily demonstrate the invalidity of confinement or its duration. Id. at 81-82. Here, the majority acknowledges this language in Wilkinson, but concludes that Heck's bar on any type of relief that "would necessarily demonstrate the invalidity of confinement" does not preclude the prospective claims at issue. The majority reasons that the purpose of Heck is "to ensure the finality and validity of previous convictions, not to insulate future prosecutions from challenge," and so concludes that the plaintiffs' prospective claims mayproceed. I respectfully disagree. A declaration that the city ordinances are unconstitutional and an injunction against their future enforcement necessarily demonstrate the invalidity of the plaintiffs' prior convictions. Indeed, any time an individual challenges the constitutionality of a substantive criminal statute under which he has been convicted, he asks for a judgment that would necessarily demonstrate the invalidity of his conviction. And though neither the Supreme Court nor this court has squarely addressed Heck's application to § 1983 claims challenging the constitutionality of a substantive criminal statute, I believe Edwards v. Balisok, 520 U.S. 641(1997), makes clear that Heck prohibits such challenges. In Edwards, the Supreme Court explained that although our court had recognized that Heck barred § 1983 claims challenging the validity of a prisoner's confinement "as a substantive matter," it improperly distinguished as not Heck -barred all claims alleging only procedural violations. 520 U.S. at 645. In holding that Heck also barred those procedural claims that would necessarily imply the invalidity of a conviction, the Court did not question our conclusion that claims challenging a conviction "as a substantive matter" are barred by Heck. 02 Exhibit B EXHIBIT B 72 of 72 72 MARTIN V. CITY OF Bom Id.; see also Wilkinson, 544 U.S. at 82 (holding that the plaintiffs' claims could proceed because the relief requested would only "render invalid the state procedures" and "a favorable judgment [would] not `necessarily imply the invalidity of [their] conviction[s] or sentence[s] "' (emphasis added) (quoting Heck, 512 U.S. at 487)). Edwards thus leads me to conclude that an individual who was convicted under a criminal statute, but who did not challenge the constitutionality of the statute at the time of his conviction through direct appeal or post -conviction relief, cannot do so in the first instance by seeking declaratory or injunctive relief under § 1983. See Ahusaid v. Hillsborough Cty. Bd. of Cty. Comm'rs, 405 F.3d 1298, 1316 n.9 (1 lth Cir. 2005) (assuming that a § 1983 claim challenging "the constitutionality of the ordinance under which [the petitioner was convicted]" would be Heck -barred). I therefore would hold that Heck bars the plaintiffs' claims for declaratory and injunctive relief. We are not the first court to struggle applying Heck to "real life examples," nor will we be the last. See, e.g., Spencer v. Kemna, 523 U.S. 1, 21 (1998) (Ginsburg, J., concurring) (alterations and internal quotation marks omitted) (explaining that her thoughts on Heck had changed since she joined the majority opinion in that case). If the slate were blank, I would agree that the majority's holding as to prospective relief makes good sense. But because I read Heck and its progeny differently, I dissent as to that section of the majority's opinion. I otherwise join the majority in full. 03 Yesterday the U.S. Supreme Court declined to review the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeal's ruling in the City of Boise case regarding the constitutionality of the city's camping ordinance. Since Woodburn is located in the Ninth Cir- cuit, we have been closely monitoring this litigation. It is interesting that Theodore Olson, a well-known advocate before the Supreme Court and a former Solicitor Gen- eral, agreed to represent the City of Boise, reportedly at a greatly reduced rate. https://www.latimes.com/local/ caIifornia/la- me- In- home less-encampment-sweep-boise-case-appeal-theodore-olson-sup reme-court-zo1. oc�7oz- story.html Idaho Legal Aid Services represented the six homeless people who originally filed the lawsuit. Never- theless, the Court did not grant Boise review and the entire West Coast (including Woodburn) continues to be sub- ject to this legal ruling. The background is that Boise, like many cities, regulates camping and sleeping in public spaces to ensure that these areas remain safe, accessible, and sanitary for use of its residents. This case was brought on behalf of home- less people arguing that the camping ordinance was unconstitutional. The Ninth Circuit held that Boise's enforce- ment of its camping ordinance constitutes "cruel and unusual punishment" prohibited by the Eighth Amendment of the U. S. Constitution when "there is a greater number of homeless individuals in [the jurisdiction] than the number of available beds [in shelters]." Seen in a historical context, the Ninth Circuit ruling that the City of Boise violated the "cruel and unusual punish- ment" language contained in the Eighth Amendment by enforcing its camping ordinance is an extreme ruling. The phrase "cruel and unusual punishment" was copied by the constitutional framers from the 1689 English Decla- ration of Rights and was originally intended to address extreme punishments imposed as a matter of course (i.e., theft punished by death). The Ninth Circuit held that the ordinance barring public camping and sleeping is uncon- stitutional insofar as it applies to "any conduct [that] is involuntary and inseparable from status."' The Supreme Court's prior decisions, however, confirm that the authority of local governments to enforce laws promoting public health, safety, and welfare is not contingent upon inquiries into the voluntariness of the regulated conduct. Finally, it is somewhat surprising that the Supreme Court did not take review. The procedures in the Ninth Circuit are complicated and not worth going into here. However, sixjudges in the Ninth Circuit filed a dissenting opinion emphasizing that other courts, including the Fourth, Seventh, and Eleventh Circuits, as well as the California Su- preme Court, "have routinely upheld state laws regulating acts that were allegedly compelled or involuntary," and warning that the decision will "prevent local governments from enforcing a host of other public health and safety laws, such as those prohibiting public defecation and urination." Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 1 of 155 FOR PUBLICATION UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT GLORIA JOHNSON; JOHN LOGAN, individuals, on behalf of themselves and all others similarly situated, Plaintiffs Appellees, V. CITY OF GRANTS PASS, Defendant Appellant. Nos. 20-35752 20-35881 D.C. No. 1:18- cv-01823-CL ORDER AND AMENDED OPINION Appeal from the United States District Court for the District of Oregon Mark D. Clarke, Magistrate Judge, Presiding Argued and Submitted December 6, 2021 San Francisco, California Filed September 28, 2022 Amended July 5, 2023 Before: Ronald M. Gould and Daniel P. Collins, Circuit Judges, and Roslyn O. Silver,* District Judge. * The Honorable Roslyn O. Silver, United States District Judge for the District of Arizona, sitting by designation. 05 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 2 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRANTS2S0f 155 Order; Opinion By Judge Silver; Dissent by Judge Collins; Statement by Judges Silver and Gould; Statement by Judge O'Scannlain; Statement by Judge Graber; Dissent by Judge M. Smith; Dissent by Judge Collins; Dissent by Judge Bress SUMMARY** Civil Rights / Homelessness The panel issued an order amending the opinion and dissent filed September 28, 2002, and reported at 50 F.4th 787; filed an amended opinion and dissent concurrently with its order; and denied a petition for rehearing en banc after a request for a vote on whether to rehear the matter en banc, and the matter failed to receive a majority of the votes of the nonrecused active judges in favor of en banc consideration, in an action challenging City of Grants Pass ordinances which, among other things, preclude homeless persons from using a blanket, pillow, or cardboard box for protection from the elements while sleeping within City limits. In the amended opinion, the panel affirmed in part and vacated in part the district court's summary judgment and ** This summary constitutes no part of the opinion of the court. It has been prepared by court staff for the convenience of the reader. 06 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRANTS4+S®f 155 3 permanent injunction in favor of plaintiffs; affirmed certification pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 23(b)(2), of a class of "involuntary homeless" persons; and remanded. The five municipal ordinances, described as an "anti - sleeping" ordinance, two "anti -camping" ordinances, a "park exclusion" ordinance, and a "park exclusion appeals" ordinance, result in civil fines up to several hundred dollars per violation. Persons found to violate ordinances multiple times could be barred from all City property. If a homeless person is found on City property after receiving an exclusion order, they are subject to criminal prosecution for trespass. The panel stated that this court's decision in Martin v. City of Boise, 902 F.3d 1031 (9th Cir. 2018), which held that "the Eighth Amendment prohibits the imposition of criminal penalties for sitting, sleeping, or lying outside on public property for homeless individuals who cannot obtain shelter" served as the backdrop for this entire litigation. Pursuant to Martin, it is an Eight Amendment violation to criminally punish involuntarily homeless persons for sleeping in public if there are no other public areas or appropriate shelters where those individuals can sleep. The panel first rejected the City's argument that the district court lacked jurisdiction because plaintiffs' claims were moot or because plaintiffs failed to identify any relief that was within a federal court's power to redress. The panel held that there was abundant evidence in the record establishing that homeless persons were injured by the City's enforcement actions in the past and it was undisputed that enforcements have continued. The panel further held that the relief sought by plaintiffs, enjoining enforcement of a few municipal ordinances aimed at involuntary homeless 07 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 4 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRANTS4s®f 155 persons, was redressable within the limits of Article III. The death of class representative Debra Blake while the matter was on appeal did not moot the class's claims as to all challenged ordinances except possibly the anti -sleeping ordinance. The panel vacated the summary judgment as to that ordinance and remanded to allow the district court the opportunity to substitute a class representative in Blake's stead. The remaining class representatives had standing to challenge the park exclusion, criminal trespass and anti - camping ordinances. The panel held that, based on the record in this case, the district court did not err by finding plaintiffs satisfied the requirements of Fed. R. Civ. P. 23(a) such that a class could be certified under Rule 23(b)(2). Although the City appeared to suggest that Martin's need for an individualized inquiry of each alleged involuntary homeless person's access to shelter defeated numerosity, commonality and typicality, the panel held that nothing in Martin precluded class actions. The panel held that the district court did not abuse its discretion in concluding the numerosity requirement was met; that plaintiffs' claims presented at least one question and answer common to the class; and that the class representatives' claims and defenses were typical of the class in that they were homeless persons who claimed that the City could not enforce the challenged ordinances against them when they have no shelter. Addressing the merits, the panel affirmed the district court's ruling that the City of Grants Pass could not, consistent with the Eighth Amendment, enforce its anti - camping ordinances against homeless persons for the mere act of sleeping outside with rudimentary protection from the elements, or for sleeping in their car at night, when there was no other place in the City for them to go. The panel held that 08 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRANTSS sOf 155 5 Martin applied to civil citations where, as here, the civil and criminal punishments were closely intertwined. There was no need to resolve whether the fines imposed under the anti -sleeping and anti -camping ordinances violated the Eighth Amendment's prohibition on excessive fines because the permanent injunction would result in no class member being fined for engaging in such protected activity. Finally, the panel held that it was unnecessary to decide whether plaintiffs properly pled their procedural due process challenge to the park exclusion appeals ordinance because subsequent to the district court's order, the City amended the ordinance. The panel directed the district court on remand to narrow its injunction to enjoin only those portions of the anti - camping ordinances that prohibited conduct protected by Martin and this opinion. In particular, the district court should narrow its injunction to the anti -camping ordinances and enjoin enforcement of those ordinances only against involuntarily homeless persons for engaging in conduct necessary to protect themselves from the elements when there was no shelter space available. Dissenting, Judge Collins stated that Martin seriously misconstrued the Eighth Amendment and the Supreme Court's caselaw construing it, but even assuming that Martin remains good law, today's decision —which both misreads and greatly expands Martin's holding —is egregiously wrong. Although the majority's phrasing pays lip service to the fact that the persons at issue must be "involuntarily homeless," the majority also explicitly rejects the City's contention that the holding of Martin can only be applied after an individualized inquiry of each alleged involuntary homeless person's access to shelter. The net result, for class 09 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 6 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRANTSGS®f 155 certification purposes, is that any issue of individualized involuntariness is set aside and Martin is thereby reduced to a simplistic formula to be resolved on a classwide basis — into whether the number of homeless persons in the jurisdiction exceeds the number of available shelter beds. The majority's analysis fails because Martin does not allow the individualized inquiry into involuntariness to be set aside in this way. Further, the majority opinion combines its gross misreading of Martin, which requires an individualized inquiry, with a flagrant disregard of settled class -certification principles pertaining to commonality under Fed. R. Civ. P. 23(a) and the requirements of Fed. R. Civ. P. 23(b). The end result of this amalgamation of error is that the majority validates the core aspects of the district court's injunction in this case, which effectively requires the City of Grants Pass to allow all but one of its public parks to be used as homeless encampments. In a joint statement regarding the denial of rehearing, District Judge Silver and Judge Gould wrote that Judge O'Scannlain's statement regarding the denial of rehearing and the dissent from Judge M. Smith significantly exaggerate the holding in Johnson v. Grants Pass. Grants Pass, relying on Martin, holds only that governments cannot criminalize the act of sleeping with the use of rudimentary protections from the elements in some public places when a person has nowhere else to sleep. It does not establish an unrestrained right for involuntarily homeless persons to sleep anywhere they choose. Nor does it require jurisdictions to cede all public spaces to involuntarily homeless persons. Judges Silver and Gould also explained that class certification was proper, that the commonality requirement was met, that the majority applied existing Supreme Court and Ninth Circuit authority to the record too Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRANTSTsof 155 7 presented by the parties, and that Judge O' Scannlain greatly overstated the extent to which Martin and Grants Pass fall on one side of an existing circuit split. Respecting the denial of rehearing en banc, Judge O'Scannlain, joined by Judges Wallace, Callahan, Bea, Ikuta, Bennett, R. Nelson, Bade, Collins, Lee, Bress, Forrest, Bumatay, and VanDyke, and with whom Judge M. Smith joins as to all parts except Part II -A, states that with this decision, this Circuit's jurisprudence now effectively guarantees a personal federal constitutional `right' for individuals to camp or to sleep on sidewalks and in parks, playgrounds, and other public places in defiance of traditional health, safety, and welfare laws —a dubious holding premised on a fanciful interpretation of the Eighth Amendment. Judge O'Scannlain writes that the Boise panel made no effort to ground its decision in the text, history, or tradition of the Eighth Amendment. Unfortunately, the problems created by Boise have now been visited upon the City of Grants Pass by the panel majority here, which has expanded Boise's faulty holding to affirm an injunction effectively requiring the City to resign all but one of its public parks to be used as homeless encampments. This Circuit is the first and only federal circuit to have divined such a strange and sweeping mandate from the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause. The jurisprudence in this case is egregiously flawed and deeply damaging —at war with constitutional text, history, tradition, and Supreme Court precedent. And it conflicts with other circuits on a question of exceptional importance —paralyzing local communities from addressing the pressing issue of homelessness, and seizing policymaking authority that the federal system of government leaves to the democratic process. tat Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 8 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRANTS&S®f 155 Respecting the denial of rehearing en banc, Judge Graber agreed with the basic legal premise that the Eighth Amendment protects against criminal prosecution of the involuntary act of sleeping but stated that the injunctive relief in this case goes too far. The extension of Martin to classwide relief, enjoining civil statutes that may eventually lead to criminal violations but have never resulted in criminal convictions for any named plaintiff, is a step too far from the individualized inquiries inherent both in the Eighth Amendment context and in the context of injunctive relief. Even assuming that classwide injunctive relief were available against a prosecution for criminal trespass, the Eighth Amendment does not prohibit all civil remedies that could, in theory, lead to such a prosecution. In this way, Johnson unjustifiably expands the reach of the Eighth Amendment. Dissenting from the denial of rehearing en banc, Judge M. Smith, joined by Judges Bennett, Bumatay, and VanDyke, and with whom Judges Ikuta, R. Nelson, Bade, Collins and Bress join as to Parts I and II, stated that Martin cannot be squared with the Supreme Court's Eighth Amendment precedent; that the amendment to the original opinion is not accompanied by any downstream changes to the majority's application of its rule to the facts or its ultimate conclusion; and that by wholly collapsing the merits into the class definition, the majority opinion certifies an impermissible "fail safe" class. Local governments are hard-pressed to find any way to regulate the adverse health and safety effects of homeless encampments without running afoul of this court's case law —or, at a minimum, being saddled with litigation costs. Judge M. Smith states that Martin, particularly now that it has been supercharged by Grants Pass, has proven to be a runaway train that has W Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRANTS%s®f 155 9 derailed and done substantial collateral damage to the governmental units in which it has been applied and those living therein. These cases use a misreading of Supreme Court precedent to require unelected federal judges —often on the basis of sloppy, mixed preliminary -injunction records —to act more like homelessness policy czars than as Article III judges applying a discernible rule of law. Dissenting from the denial of rehearing en bane, Judge Collins states that the panel majority's joint statement regarding the denial of rehearing confirms and illustrates the layers of self-contradiction that underlie its opinion in this case, and that the panel majority is wrong to suggest that a newly enacted Oregon statute regulating the application of local ordinances to homeless individuals provides another reason to not rehear this case en bane. Dissenting from the denial of rehearing en bane, Judge Bress, joined by Judges Callahan, M. Smith, Ikuta, Bennett, R. Nelson, Miller, Bade, Lee, Forrest, Bumatay and VanDyke, states that with no mooring in the text of the Constitution, our history and traditions, or the precedent of the Supreme Court, the court has taken our national founding document and used it to enact judge -made rules governing who can sit and sleep where, rules whose ill effects are felt not merely by the States, and not merely by our cities, but block by block, building by building, doorway by doorway. Local leaders —and the people who elect them — must be allowed the latitude to address on the ground the distinctly local features of the present crisis of homelessness and lack of affordable housing. Not every challenge we face is constitutional in character. Not every problem in our country has a legal answer that judges can provide. This is one of those situations. M3 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 10 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRA4Gsof 155 COUNSEL Aaron P. Hisel (argued), Capitol Legal Services, Salem, Oregon; Gerald L. Warren, Law Office of Gerald L. Warren, Salem, Oregon; Daniel R. Adler, Samuel Eckman, Theane Evangelis, Patrick J. Fuster, and Bradley J. Hamburger, Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP, Los Angeles, California; for Defendant -Appellant. Edward Johnson (argued) and Walter Fonseca, Oregon Law Center, Portland, Oregon; Elise M. Baranouski and Kelsi B. Corkran, Georgetown University Law Center Institute for Constitutional Advocacy and Protection, Washington, D.C.; Benjamin A. Gifford, Georgetown University, Brooklyn, New York; for Plaintiffs -Appellees. Eric S. Tars, National Homelessness Law Center, Washington, D.C., for Amicus Curiae University of Miami School of Law Human Rights Clinic, Homelessness Law Center, and the Shift. Ruthanne M. Deutsch, Deutsch Hunt PLLC, Washington, D.C., for Amicus Curiae Fines and Fees Justice Center. John He, Leslie Bailey, and Brian Hardingham, Public Justice, Oakland, California; John Thomas H. Do, ACLU Foundation of Northern California, San Francisco, California; Kelly K. Simon, ACLU Foundation of Oregon, Portland, Oregon; William R. Maurer, Institute for Justice, Seattle, Washington; for Amici Curiae ACLU of Northern California, ACLU of Southern California, ACLU of Oregon Institute for Justice, National Center for Law and Economic Justice, and Rutherford Institute. M4 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRA41stsof 155 11 Nicolle Jacoby, Dechert LLP, New York, New York; Tharuni A. Jayaraman and Eric Auslander, Dechert LLP, Washington, D.C.; for Amici Curiae National Homelessness Law Center, The Homeless Rights Advocacy Project at the Korematsu Center for Law and Equality at Seattle University School of Law, and the National Coalition for the Homeless. Jennifer B. Henning, California State Association of Counties, Sacramento, California, for Amici Curiae California State Association of Counties and League of California Cities. Brandon M. Rain, Assistant City Attorney; Ann Davison, Seattle City Attorney; Seattle City Attorney's Office; Seattle, Washington; for Amicus Curiae City of Seattle. Eric S. Boorstin, Horvitz & Levy LLP, Burbank, California; Jeremy B. Rosen, Horvitz & Levy, San Francisco, California; for Amicus Curiae Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce. Anit K. Jindal and Hannah K. Hoffman, Markowitz Herbold PC, Portland, Oregon, for Amici Curiae League of Oregon Cities, City of Portland, Association of Idaho Cities, International Municipal Lawyers Association, Special Districts Association of Oregon, League of Arizona Cities and Towns, and Washington State Association of Municipal Attorneys. Jeffrey C. Briggs, Briggs Law Office, Thousand Oaks, California, for Amici Curiae LA Alliance for Human Rights, Historic Core Business Improvement District Property Owners Association, Central City East Association of Los M5 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 12 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRA42sof 155 Angeles, and Hollywood Media District Property Owners Association. Wt-']1N The Opinion filed September 28, 2022, and reported at 50 FAth 787, is hereby amended. The amended opinion will be filed concurrently with this order. The full court was advised of the petition for rehearing en banc. A judge requested a vote on whether to rehear the matter en banc, and the matter failed to receive a majority of the votes of the nonrecused active judges in favor of en banc consideration. Fed. R. App. P. 35. Judge Watford did not participate in the deliberations or vote in this case. Future petitions for rehearing or rehearing en banc will not be entertained in this case. The petition for rehearing en banc is DENIED. $G6 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTv OF GRA43sof 155 13 OPINION SILVER, District Judge: The City of Grants Pass in southern Oregon has a population of approximately 38,000. At least fifty, and perhaps as many as 600, homeless persons live in the City. And the number of homeless persons outnumber the available shelter beds. In other words, homeless persons have nowhere to shelter and sleep in the City other than on the streets or in parks. Nonetheless, City ordinances preclude homeless persons from using a blanket, a pillow, or a cardboard box for protection from the elements while sleeping within the City's limits. The ordinances result in civil fines up to several hundred dollars per violation and persons found to violate ordinances multiple times can be barred from all City property. And if a homeless person is found on City property after receiving an exclusion order, they are subject to criminal prosecution for trespass. In September 2018, a three judge panel issued Martin v. City of Boise, 902 F.3d 1031 (9th Cir. 2018), holding "the Eighth Amendment prohibits the imposition of criminal penalties for sitting, sleeping, or lying outside on public property for homeless individuals who cannot obtain shelter." Id. at 1048. Approximately six weeks after the initial Martin panel opinion, three homeless individuals filed a putative class action complaint against the City arguing a number of City ordinances were unconstitutional. The district court certified a class of "involuntarily homeless" i During this litigation the parties have used different phrases when referring to this population. For simplicity, we use "homeless persons" throughout this opinion. W Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 14 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRAN 4sof 155 persons and later granted partial summary judgment in favor of the class.' After the plaintiffs voluntarily dismissed some claims not resolved at summary judgment, the district court issued a permanent injunction prohibiting enforcement against the class members of some City ordinances, at certain times, in certain places. The City now appeals, arguing this case is moot, the class should not have been certified, the claims fail on the merits, and Plaintiffs did not adequately plead one of their theories. On the material aspects of this case, the district court was right.' ' Persons are involuntarily homeless if they do not "have access to adequate temporary shelter, whether because they have the means to pay for it or because it is realistically available to them for free." See Martin, 920 F.3d at 617 n.8. However, someone who has the financial means to obtain shelter, or someone who is staying in an emergency shelter is not involuntarily homeless. See id. at 617 n.8. Contrary to the City's argument, this definition of involuntary homelessness is not the same as the definition of "homeless" found in regulations for the Department of Housing and Urban Development, 24 C.F.R. § 582.5, or the McKinney- Vento Act, 42 U.S.C. § 11434a(2), the federal law regarding the right of homeless children to a public education. For example, the McKinney- Vento Act includes as "homeless children and youths" persons who may not qualify as involuntarily homeless under Martin, such as children and youths "living in emergency or transitional shelters." 42 U.S.C. § 11434a(2). Though the district court noted in part that Plaintiffs met the definition of homelessness set forth in 24 C.F.R. § 582.5, the district court also relied on the specific definition of unsheltered homeless persons set forth in the Department of Housing and Urban Development's regulations regarding point -in -time counts: "persons who are living in a place not designed or ordinarily used as a regular sleeping accommodation for humans must be counted as unsheltered homeless persons." 24 C.F.R. § 578.7(c)(2)(i). Our dissenting colleague's strong disagreement with the majority largely arises from his disapproval of Martin. See, e.g., Dissent 56 ("Even assuming Martin remains good law ..."); Dissent 90 ("... and the gravity of Martin's errors."); Dissent 92 (claiming, without evidence, tas Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRA4Ssof 155 15 I. This case involves challenges to five provisions of the Grants Pass Municipal Code ("GPMC"). The provisions can be described as an "anti -sleeping" ordinance, two "anti - camping" ordinances, a "park exclusion" ordinance, and a "park exclusion appeals" ordinance. When the district court entered judgment, the various ordinances consisted of the following. First, the anti -sleeping ordinance stated, in full Sleeping on Sidewalks, Streets, Alley Within Doorways Prohibited A. No person may sleep on public sidewalks, streets, or alleyways at any time as a matter of individual and public safety. B. No person may sleep in any pedestrian or vehicular entrance to public or private property abutting a public sidewalk. C. In addition to any other remedy provided by law, any person found in violation of this section may be immediately removed from the premises. GPMC 5.61.020. A violation of this ordinance resulted in a presumptive $75 fine. If unpaid, that fine escalated to $160. If a violator pled guilty, the fines could be reduced by a state that "it is hard to deny that Martin has `generate[d] dire practical consequences") (modification in original and citation omitted). But Martin is controlling law in the Ninth Circuit, to which we are required to adhere. tog Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 16 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRA46sof 155 circuit court judge to $35 for a first offense and $50 for a second offense. GPMC 1.36.010(K). Next, the general anti -camping ordinance prohibited persons from occupying a "campsite" on all public property, such as parks, benches, or rights of way. GPMC 5.61.030. The term "campsite" was defined as any place where bedding, sleeping bag, or other material used for bedding purposes, or any stove or fire is placed, established, or maintained for the purpose of maintaining a temporary place to live, whether or not such place incorporates the use of any tent, lean- to, shack, or any other structure, or any vehicle or part thereof. GPMC 5.61.010. A second overlapping anti -camping ordinance prohibited camping in public parks, including "[o]vernight parking" of any vehicle. GPMC 6.46.090. A homeless individual would violate this parking prohibition if she parked or left "a vehicle parked for two consecutive hours [in a City park] ... between the hours of midnight and 6:00 a.m." Id. Violations of either anti -camping ordinance resulted in a fine of $295. If unpaid, the fine escalated to $537.60. However, if a violator pled guilty, the fine could be reduced to $180 for a first offense and $225 for a second offense. GPMC 1.36.010(J). Finally, the "park exclusion" ordinance allowed a police officer to bar an individual from all city parks for 30 days if, within one year, the individual was issued two or more citations for violating park regulations. GPMC 6.46.350(A). Pursuant to the "park exclusion appeals" ordinance, exclusion orders could be appealed to the City Council. U0 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRAN Tsof 155 17 GPMC 6.46.355. If an individual received a "park exclusion" order, but subsequently was found in a city park, that individual would be prosecuted for criminal trespass. Since at least 2013, City leaders have viewed homeless persons as cause for substantial concern. That year the City Council convened a Community Roundtable ("Roundtable") "to identify solutions to current vagrancy problems." Participants discussed the possibility of "driving repeat offenders out of town and leaving them there." The City's Public Safety Director noted police officers had bought homeless persons bus tickets out of town, only to have the person returned to the City from the location where they were sent. A city councilor made clear the City's goal should be "to make it uncomfortable enough for [homeless persons] in our city so they will want to move on down the road." The planned actions resulting from the Roundtable included increased enforcement of City ordinances, including the anti -camping ordinances. The year following the Roundtable saw a significant increase in enforcement of the City's anti -sleeping and anti - camping ordinances. From 2013 through 2018, the City issued a steady stream of tickets under the ordinances.4 On September 4, 2018, a three judge panel issued its opinion in a The City issued the following number of tickets under the anti -sleeping and anti -camping ordinances: 2013: 74 total tickets 2014: 228 total tickets 2015: 80 total tickets 2016: 47 total tickets 2017: 99 total tickets 2018: 46 total tickets U1 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 18 JOHNSON V. CTTy OF GRA48sof 155 Martin v. City ofBoise, 902 F.3d 1031 (9th Cir. 2018). s That case served as the backdrop for this entire litigation. In Martin, six homeless or recently homeless individuals sued the city of Boise, Idaho, seeking relief from criminal prosecution under two city ordinances related to public camping. Martin, 920 F.3d at 603-04. As relevant here, Martin held the Cruel and Unusual Punishment Clause of the "Eighth Amendment prohibits the imposition of criminal penalties for sitting, sleeping, or lying outside on public property for homeless individuals who cannot obtain shelter." Id. at 616. Martin made clear, however, that a city is not required to "provide sufficient shelter for the homeless, or allow anyone who wishes to sit, lie, or sleep on the streets ... at any time and at any place." Id. at 617 (quoting Jones v. City of Los Angeles, 444 F.3d 1118, 1138 (9th Cir. 2006), vacated, 505 F.3d 1006 (9th Cir. 2007)) (omission in original). s Following the opinion, the City of Boise petitioned for rehearing en banc. On April 1, 2019, an amended panel opinion was issued and the petition for rehearing was denied. Judge M. Smith, joined by five other judges, dissented from the denial of rehearing en banc. He argued the three judge panel had, among other errors, misinterpreted the Supreme Court precedents regarding the criminalization of involuntary conduct. Martin, 920 F.3d at 591-92 (M. Smith, J., dissenting from denial of rehearing en banc). Judge Bennett, joined by four judges, also dissented from the denial of rehearing en banc. Judge Bennett argued the three - judge panel's opinion was inconsistent with the original public meaning of the Cruel and Unusual Punishment Clause. Id. at 599 (Bennett, J., dissenting from denial of rehearing en banc). The merits of those dissents do not alter the binding nature of the amended Martin panel opinion. Unless otherwise indicated, all citations to Martin throughout the remainder of this opinion are to the amended panel opinion. $42 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRA49sof 155 19 Pursuant to Martin, it is an Eighth Amendment violation to criminally punish involuntarily homeless persons for sleeping in public if there are no other public areas or appropriate shelters where those individuals can sleep. Id. at 617 n.8 ("Naturally, our holding does not cover individuals who do have access to adequate temporary shelter, whether because they have the means to pay for it or because it is realistically available to them for free, but who choose not to use it."). When assessing the number of shelter spaces, Martin held shelters with a "mandatory religious focus" could not be counted as available due to potential violations of the First Amendment's Establishment Clause. Id. at 609-10 (citing Inouye v. Kemna, 504 F.3d 705, 712-13 (9th Cir. 2007)). In October 2018, approximately six weeks after the Martin opinion, Debra Blake filed her putative class action complaint against the City. The complaint alleged enforcement of the City's anti -sleeping and anti -camping ordinances violated the Cruel and Unusual Punishment Clause of the Eighth Amendment, the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment, and the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. The complaint was amended to include additional named plaintiffs and to allege a claim that the fines imposed under the ordinances violated the Excessive Fines Clause of the Eighth Amendment. On January 2, 2019, a few months after the initial complaint was filed, and before Plaintiffs filed their class certification motion, the City amended its anti -camping ordinance in an attempt to come into compliance with Martin. Prior to this change, the anti -camping ordinance was worded such that "`sleeping' in parks . . . automatically constitut[ed] ,camping."' According to the City, "in direct response to Martin v. Boise, the City amended [the anti -camping $43 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 20 JOHNSON V. CTTy OF GRA2GS®f 155 ordinance] to make it clear that the act of `sleeping' was to be distinguished from the prohibited conduct of 'camping."' The City meant to "make it clear that those without shelter could engage in the involuntary acts of sleeping or resting in the City's parks." Shortly after the City removed "sleeping" from the "camping" definition, Plaintiffs moved to certify a class. Plaintiffs requested certification of a class defined as All involuntarily homeless individuals living in Grants Pass, Oregon, including homeless individuals who sometimes sleep outside city limits to avoid harassment and punishment by [the City] as addressed in this lawsuit. Plaintiffs' class certification motion was accompanied by a declaration from the Chief Operating Officer and Director of Housing and Homeless Services for United Community Action Network ("UCAN"), a non-profit organization that serves homeless people in Josephine County, the county where the City is located.' UCAN had recently conducted a "point -in -time count of homeless individuals in Josephine County."' Based on that count, the Chief Operating 6 The Department of Housing and Urban Development regulations impose obligations on the "continuum of care," which is defined as "the group composed of representatives of relevant organizations ... that are organized to plan for and provide, as necessary, a system of outreach, engagement, and assessment ... to address the various needs of homeless persons and persons at risk of homelessness for a specific geographic area." 24 C.F.R. § 576.2. As the "continuum of care" in the City, UCAN was required to conduct point -in -time counts ("PIT counts") of homeless persons within that geographic area. 24 C.F.R. § 578.7(c)(2). PIT counts measure the number of sheltered and unsheltered homeless individuals on a single night. 24 C.F.R. § 578.7(c)(2). The Martin court relied on PIT counts t44 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTv OF GRA21AS®f 155 21 Officer's declaration stated "[h]undreds of [homeless] people live in Grants Pass," and "almost all of the homeless people in Grants Pass are involuntarily homeless. There is simply no place in Grants Pass for them to find affordable housing or shelter. They are not choosing to live on the street or in the woods." The City opposed class certification, arguing Plaintiffs had not provided sufficient evidence to meet any of the requirements for certifying a class. The district court disagreed and certified the class proposed by Plaintiffs. The parties proceeded with discovery and filed cross -motions for summary judgment. At the time the parties filed their summary judgment motions, there were only four locations in the City that temporarily housed homeless persons, which proved inadequate. One location was run by the Gospel Rescue Mission, an explicitly religious organization devoted to helping the poor. The Gospel Rescue Mission operated a facility for single men without children, and another facility for women, including women with children. These two facilities required residents to work at the mission six hours a day, six days a week in exchange for a bunk for 30 days. Residents were required to attend an approved place of worship each Sunday and that place of worship had to espouse "traditional Christian teachings such as the Apostles Creed." Disabled persons with chronic medical or mental conducted by local non -profits to determine the number of homeless people in the jurisdiction. See Martin, 920 F.3d at 604. Courts and experts note that PIT counts routinely undercount homeless persons, but they appear to be the best available source of data on homelessness. See, e.g., id. U5 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 22 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRA22sof 155 health issues that prevented them from complying with the Mission's rules were prohibited.' In addition to the Gospel Rescue Mission, the City itself operated a "sobering center" where law enforcement could transport intoxicated or impaired persons. That facility consisted of twelve locked rooms with toilets where intoxicated individuals could sober up. The rooms did not have beds. The City also provided financial support to the Hearts with a Mission Youth Shelter, an 18-bed facility where unaccompanied minors aged 10 to 17 could stay for up to 72 hours, and could stay even longer if they had parental consent. Finally, on nights when the temperature was below 30 degrees (or below 32 degrees with snow), UCAN operated a "warming center" capable of holding up to 40 individuals. That center did not provide beds. The center reached capacity on every night it operated except the first night it opened, February 3, 2020. Between February 3 and March 19, 2020, the warming center was open for 16 nights. The center did not open at all during the winter of 2020-2021. Presented with evidence of the number of homeless persons and the shelter spaces available, the district court concluded "[t]he record is undisputed that Grants Pass has far more homeless individuals than it has practically available shelter beds." The court then held that, based on the unavailability of shelter beds, the City's enforcement of its anti -camping and anti -sleeping ordinances violated the s Multiple class members submitted uncontested declarations to the district court stating they did not stay at the Gospel Rescue Mission because they suffer from disqualifying disabilities and/or were unwilling to attend church. U6 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRA241S®f 155 23 Cruel and Unusual Punishment Clause. The fact that Martin involved criminal violations while the present case involved initial civil violations that matured into criminal violations made "no difference for Eight Amendment purposes." Next, the court held the system of fines violated the Eighth Amendment's Excessive Fines Clause.' Finally, the court held the appeals process for park exclusions violated procedural due process under the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. In reaching its decision the district court was careful to point out that, consistent with Martin, the scope of its decision was limited. The court's order made clear that the City was not required to provide shelter for homeless persons and the City could still limit camping or sleeping at certain times and in certain places. The district court also noted the City may still "ban the use of tents in public parks," "limi[t] the amount of bedding type materials allowed per individual," and pursue other options "to prevent the 9 Part of the City's argument on this issue was that the fines are not mandatory because state court judges retain discretion not to impose fines. This is inconsistent with the text of the ordinances and not supported by the record. The provision of the municipal code defining penalties for ordinance violations clarifies that the fines are mandatory. It provides, the fines "shall be $295" and "shall be $75." GPMC 1.36.010(J)-(K) (emphasis added). Conversely, it is only discretionary to reduce fines because the relevant ordinance provides that, "[u]pon a plea of guilty ... the penalty may be reduced" to the amount listed for a first or second offense. Id. (emphasis added). After a second citation, there is no authority within the municipal code that permits judges to reduce fines, and there is no evidence in the record demonstrating circuit court judges have reduced fines except pursuant to GPMC 1.36.010. W Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 24 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRA1 4sof 155 erection of encampments that cause public health and safety concerns." 10 Approximately one month after the summary judgment order, the district court issued a judgment which included a permanent injunction that provided a complicated mix of relief. First, the district court declared the ordinance regarding the appeals of park exclusions failed to provide "adequate procedural due process," but that ordinance was not permanently enjoined. Instead, the district court enjoined only the enforcement of the underlying park exclusion ordinance. Next, the district court declared enforcement of the anti -sleeping and anti -camping ordinances against class members "violates the Eighth Amendment prohibition against cruel and unusual punishment" and "violates the Eighth Amendment prohibition against excessive fines." Without explanation, however, the district court did not enjoin those ordinances in their entirety. Rather, the district court entered no injunctive relief regarding the anti -sleeping ordinance. But the district court permanently enjoined enforcement of the anti -camping ordinances, as well as an ordinance regarding "criminal trespassing on city property related to parks," in all City parks at night except for one park where the parties agreed the injunction need not apply." The district court also permanently enjoined enforcement of the anti -camping ordinances during daytime hours unless an initial warning was given "at least 24 hours before enforcement." 10 The district court denied summary judgment on other claims brought by Plaintiffs. Those claims were subsequently voluntarily dismissed. " The City ordinance regarding "criminal trespass" was never at issue in the litigation until the permanent injunction. Plaintiffs explain it was included in the injunction "[b]y agreement of the parties." US Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRA2,SsOf 155 25 Accordingly, under the permanent injunction, the anti - camping ordinances may be enforced under some circumstances during the day, but never at night. The City appealed and sought initial en banc review to clarify the scope of Martin. The petition for initial hearing en banc was denied. II. The core issue involving enforcement of the anti - camping ordinances is governed in large part by Martin. While there are some differences between Martin and the present case, the City has not identified a persuasive way to differentiate its anti -camping ordinances from the questioned ordinances in Martin. Therefore, the district court's ruling that the Cruel and Unusual Punishment Clause bars enforcement of the anti -camping ordinances will be mostly affirmed. We need not address the potential excessiveness of the fines issue or whether Plaintiffs adequately pled their due process challenge. Our analysis proceeds in five parts. First, we reject the City's argument that the district court lacked jurisdiction. 12 Second, we find no abuse of discretion in the district court's certification of a class of involuntarily homeless persons. Third, we agree with the district court that at least portions of the anti -camping ordinance violate the Cruel and Unusual Punishment clause under Martin. Fourth, we conclude there is no need to resolve whether the fines violate the Excessive 12 However, we vacate summary judgment and remand as to the anti - sleeping ordinance to afford the district court the opportunity to substitute a class representative in place of Debra Blake, who passed away while this matter was on appeal. $49 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 26 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRA26sof 155 Fines clause. Fifth, we hold it is unnecessary to decide Plaintiffs' procedural due process claim. 913 Standing and mootness are questions of law that we review de novo. Hartman v. Summers, 120 F.3d 157, 159 (9th Cir. 1997); Foster v. Carson, 347 F.3d 742, 745 (9th Cir. 2003). "Federal courts must determine that they have jurisdiction before proceeding to the merits," and plaintiffs must demonstrate standing as a necessary component of jurisdiction. Lance v. Coffman, 549 U.S. 437, 439 (2007). To have Article III standing, a plaintiff must show (1) a concrete and particularized injury, (2) caused by the challenged conduct, (3) that is likely redressable by a favorable judicial decision. Friends of the Earth, Inc. v. Laidlaw Env't Servs. (TOC), Inc., 528 U.S. 167, 180-81 (2000). For purposes of injunctive relief, "[a]bstract injury is not enough" —the plaintiff must have sustained or be in immediate danger "of sustaining some direct injury as the result of the challenged" law. O'Shea v. Littleton, 414 U.S. 488, 494 (1974) (quotation marks and citation omitted). The City's appellate briefing makes two standing arguments. First, the City argues Plaintiffs' claims are now moot because Plaintiffs no longer face a risk of injury based on the City's changed behavior after Martin. Second, the City argues Plaintiffs have not identified any relief that is within a federal court's power to redress. Both arguments are without merit. A claim becomes moot, and no longer justiciable in federal court, if it has been remedied independent of the court. See Genesis Healthcare Corp. v. Symczyk, 569 U.S. 66, 72 (2013). There is abundant evidence in the record establishing homeless persons were injured by the City's t8o Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRA27AS®f 155 27 enforcement actions in the past. The City argues, however, that it made changes after Martin such that there is no longer a threat of future injury. The problem for the City is that voluntary cessation of challenged practices rarely suffices to moot a case and, in any event, there is evidence the challenged practices have continued after Martin. "It is well settled that `a defendant's voluntary cessation of a challenged practice does not deprive a federal court of its power to determine the legality of the practice."' Friends of the Earth, 528 U.S. at 189 (quoting City of Mesquite v. Aladdin's Castle, Inc., 455 U.S. 283, 289 (1982)). This is so "because a dismissal for mootness would permit a resumption of the challenged conduct as soon as the case is dismissed." Knox v. Serv. Emps. Int'l Union, Local 1000, 567 U.S. 298, 307 (2012). Thus, the City "bears the formidable burden of showing that it is absolutely clear the allegedly wrongful behavior could not reasonably be expected to recur." Friends of the Earth, 528 U.S. at 190. Instead of the City making it "absolutely clear" it has stopped enforcement activities, the record shows ongoing enforcement. The parties diverge substantially on how to characterize the degree of enforcement after Martin was issued in September 2018. The City argued in its briefing and at oral argument that it has largely complied with Martin, noting the 2019 amendment to an anti -camping ordinance, that citations were issued "sparingly" in 2019, and in particular it says it issued only two citations during the late evening and early morning since Martin. The City supports its petition with a declaration from a City police officer stating "[i]t is the regular practice of every officer I know of on this department to enforce these Ordinances sparingly and in recognition of the different circumstances we encounter." t8i Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 28 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRA28sof 155 As for Plaintiffs, they offered evidence showing enforcement continued after Martin such that class members received citations and exclusion orders for camping or sleeping and were prosecuted for criminal trespass between the point the lawsuit was filed and the close of discovery. Although the record does show the rate of enforcement of the various ordinances decreased since Martin, even accepting the City's position the evidence is undisputed that enforcement continued.13 It is plainly inaccurate for the City to claim all enforcement ceased. The ongoing enforcement activities establish the City did not meet its "formidable burden" of showing the challenged activities will not recur. Friends of the Earth, 528 U.S. at 190. The City's mootness argument fails.14 13 The City also argues "there was no evidence that anyone was ever cited for the simple act of sleeping in a City park" after Martin. But the citation issued to Dolores Nevin in late December 2019 pursuant to the City's "criminal trespass" ordinance included a narrative explaining, "[d]uring an area check of Riverside Park, Dolores Nevin was found sleeping during closed hours. Nevin, who has been warned in the past, was issued a citation for Trespass on City Property." (emphasis added). And on September 11, 2019, Grants Pass Police Officer Jason McGinnis issued citations to Debra Blake and Carla Thomas for being in Riverside Park at approximately 7:30 a.m. with sleeping bags and belongings spread around themselves. The citation given to Debra Blake, a named plaintiff, identified the offense as "Criminal Trespass on City Property." Debra Blake was later convicted of that offense and fined. Other individuals cited for camping in a city park in 2019 include class members: Gail Laine, William Stroh, Dawn Schmidt, Cristina Trejo, Kellie Parker, Colleen Bannon, Amanda Sirnio, and Michael and Louana Ellis. 14 Mootness was also considered during the Martin litigation. See Bell v. City ofBoise, 709 F.3d 890, 898, 900-01 (9th Cir. 2013). The City of Boise argued that a combination of an amended definition of "camping" $8L Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRA29KS®f 155 29 The City's other jurisdictional argument is that Plaintiffs' claims are not redressable. According to the City, any possible relief intrudes inappropriately upon matters of policy best left to executive and legislative discretion. We disagree. Consistent with Martin, the district court granted limited relief enjoining enforcement of a few municipal ordinances at certain times, in certain places, against certain persons. None of the cases cited by the City credibly support its argument that the district court injunction overstepped the judiciary's limited authority under the Constitution. Contrary to the City's position, enjoining enforcement of a few municipal ordinances aimed at involuntarily homeless persons cannot credibly be compared to an injunction seeking to require the federal government to "phase out fossil fuel emissions and draw down excess atmospheric CO2." Juliana v. United States, 947 F.3d 1159, 1164-65 (9th Cir. 2020). The relief sought by Plaintiffs was redressable within the limits of Article III. See Renee v. Duncan, 686 F.3d 1002, 1013 (9th Cir. 2012) (holding a plaintiff's burden to demonstrate redressability is "relatively modest") (citation omitted). in the ordinance and a "Special Order," prohibiting police officers from enforcing the ordinances when a person is on public property and there is no available overnight shelter, mooted the case. Id. at 894-95. We rejected the argument that the change to the definition of "camping" rendered the case moot because "[m]ere clarification of the Camping Ordinance does not address the central concerns of the Plaintiffs' Eighth Amendment claims" —that the ordinance "effectively criminalized their status as homeless individuals." Id. at 898 n.12. And we held the adoption of a "Special Order" did not moot the case because the Special Order was not a legislative enactment, and as such it "could be easily abandoned or altered in the future." Id. at 901. t83 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 30 JOHNSON V. CTTy OF GRAi` GS®f 155 Finally, we raise sua sponte the possibility that the death of class representative Debra Blake while this matter was on the appeal has jurisdictional significance. Cf. FortBend Cty. v. Davis, 139 S.Ct. 1843, 1849 (2019) (holding courts must raise issues of subject matter jurisdiction sua sponte). We hold Blake's death does not moot the class's claims as to all challenged ordinances except possibly the anti -sleeping ordinance. As to that ordinance, we remand to allow the district court the opportunity to substitute a class representative in Blake's stead. With respect to the park exclusion, criminal trespass, and anti -camping ordinances, the surviving class representatives, Gloria Johnson 15 and John Logan,16 have standing in their ' 5 The dissent suggests Gloria Johnson does not have standing to challenge the park exclusion and criminal trespass ordinances. Dissent 71-72. The dissent concedes, however, Johnson has standing to challenge the anti -camping ordinances, GPMC 5.61.030, 6.46.090. But the dissent does not provide a meaningful explanation why it draws this distinction between the ordinances that work in concert. It is true Johnson has not received a park exclusion order and has not been charged with criminal trespass in the second degree. However, there is little doubt that her continued camping in parks would lead to a park exclusion order and, eventually, criminal trespass charges. Johnson is positioned to bring a pre -enforcement challenge against the park exclusion and criminal trespass ordinances, because they will be used against her given the undisputed fact that she remains involuntarily homeless in Grants Pass. She established a credible threat of future enforcement under the anti - camping ordinances which creates a credible threat of future enforcement under the park exclusion and criminal trespass ordinances. " The dissent claims John Logan has not established standing. Dissent 69-71. During the course of this case, Logan submitted two declarations. At the class certification stage, his declaration stated he "'lived out of [his] truck on the streets in Grants Pass for about 4 years." During that time, he was "awakened by City of Grants Pass police officer and told that I cannot sleep in my truck anywhere in the city and ordered to move t84 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRAZIAS®f 155 31 own right. Although they live in their cars, they risk enforcement under all the same ordinances as Blake and the class (with the exception of the anti -sleeping ordinance, GPMC 5.61.020, which cannot be violated by sleeping in a car) and have standing in their own right as to all ordinances except GPMC 5.61.020. on." To avoid those encounters, Logan "usually sleep[s] in [his] truck just outside the Grants Pass city limits." However, Logan stated "[i]f there was some place in the city where [he] could legally sleep in [his] truck, [he] would because it would save valuable gas money and avoid. .. having to constantly move." Logan also explained he has "met dozens, if not hundreds, of homeless people in Grants Pass" over the years who had been ticketed, fined, arrested, and criminally prosecuted "for living outside." At summary judgment, Logan submitted a declaration stating he is "currently involuntarily homeless in Grants Pass and sleeping in [his] truck at night at a rest stop North of Grants Pass." He stated he "cannot sleep in the City of Grants Pass for fear that [he] will be awakened, ticketed, fined, moved along, trespassed and charged with Criminal Trespass." The dissent reads this evidence as indicating Logan failed to "provide[] any facts to establish" that he is likely to be issued a citation under the challenged ordinances. Dissent 70. We do not agree. The undisputed facts establish Logan is involuntarily homeless. When he slept in Grants Pass, he was awoken by police officers and ordered to move. His personal knowledge was that involuntarily homeless individuals in Grants Pass often are cited under the challenged ordinances and Grants Pass continues to enforce the challenged ordinances. And, but for the challenged ordinances, Logan would sleep in the city. Therefore, as the district court found, it is sufficiently likely Logan would be issued a citation that Logan's standing is established. That is especially true given the Supreme Court's instruction that a plaintiff need not wait for "an actual arrest, prosecution, or other enforcement action" before "challenging [a] law." Susan B. Anthony List v. Driehaus, 573 U.S. 149, 158 (2014). Finally, even if Logan had not demonstrated standing, the dissent's analysis regarding Logan is irrelevant because this case could proceed solely based on the standing established by Gloria Johnson and the class. See Bates v. United Parcel Serv., Inc., 511 F.3d at 985 (9th Cir. 2007) (en banc). M Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 32 JOHNSON V. CTTy OF GRAi` ZS®f 155 With respect to the anti -sleeping ordinance, the law is less clear. Debra Blake is the only class representative who had standing in her own right to challenge the anti -sleeping ordinance. Under cases such as Sosna v. Iowa, 419 U.S. 393, 401 (1975), and Franks v. Bowman Transportation Co., Inc., 424 U.S. 747 (1976), a class representative may pursue the live claims of a properly certified class —without the need to remand for substitution of a new representative17—even after his own claims become moot, provided that several requirements are met.18 See Bates v. United Parcel Serv., Inc., 511 F.3d 974, 987-88 (9th Cir. 2007) (en banc). If Debra Blake's challenge to the anti -sleeping ordinance became moot before she passed away, she could have continued to pursue the challenge on behalf of the class under the doctrine of Sosna. But we have not found any case applying Sosna and Franks to a situation such as this, in 17 See Sosna, 419 U.S. at 403 ("[W]e believe that the test of Rule 23(a) is met."); id. at 416-17 (White, J., dissenting) (It is claimed that the certified class supplies the necessary adverse parties for a continuing case or controversy ... The Court cites no authority for this retrospective decision as to the adequacy of representation which seems to focus on the competence of counsel rather than a party plaintiff who is a representative member of the class. At the very least, the case should be remanded to the District Court."). 1S The class must be properly certified, see Franks, 424 U.S. at 755-56, or the representative must be appealing denial of class certification. See United States Parole Comm'n v. Geraghty, 445 U.S. 388, 404 (1980). The class representative must be a member of the class with standing to sue at the time certification is granted or denied. See Sosna, 419 U.S. at 403. The unnamed class members must still have a live interest in the matter throughout the duration of the litigation. See Franks, 424 U.S. at 755. And the court must be satisfied that the named representative will adequately pursue the interests of the class even though their own interest has expired. See Sosna, 419 U.S. at 403. M Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTv OF GRAZ41S®f 155 33 which the death of a representative causes a class to be unrepresented as to part (but not all) of a claim. The parties did not brief this issue and no precedent indicates whether this raises a jurisdictional question, which would deprive us of authority to review the merits of the anti -sleeping ordinance challenge, or a matter of Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23, which might not. Because Plaintiffs have not moved to substitute a class representative pursuant to Federal Rule of Appellate Procedure 43 (a) or identified a representative who could be substituted, because no party has addressed this question in briefing, and because we are not certain of our jurisdiction to consider the challenge to the anti -sleeping ordinance, we think it appropriate to vacate summary judgment as to the anti -sleeping ordinance and remand to determine whether a substitute representative is available as to that challenge alone. See Cobell v. Jewell, 802 F.3d 12, 23-24 (D.C. Cir. 2015) (discussing substitution of a party during appeal). Substitution of a class representative may significantly aid in the resolution of the issues in this case. Remand will not cause significant delay because, as we explain below, remand is otherwise required so that the injunction can be modified. In the absence of briefing or precedent regarding this question, we do not decide whether this limitation is jurisdictional or whether it arises from operation of Rule 23. We therefore hold the surviving class representatives at a minimum have standing to challenge every ordinance except the anti -sleeping ordinance. As to the anti -sleeping ordinance, we vacate summary judgment and remand for the district court to consider in the first instance whether an adequate class representative, such as class member Dolores Nevin, exists who may be substituted. t87 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 34 JOHNSON V. CTTv OF GRAZ4s®f 155 ru The City's next argument is the district court erred in certifying the class. We "review a district court's order granting class certification for abuse of discretion, but give the district court `noticeably more deference when reviewing a grant of class certification than when reviewing a denial."' Patel v. Facebook, Inc., 932 F.3d 1264, 1275 (9th Cir. 2019) (internal citation omitted) (quoting Just Film, Inc. v. Buono, 847 F.3d 1108, 1115 (9th Cir. 2017)). Factual findings underlying class certification are reviewed for clear error. Parsons v. Ryan, 754 F.3d 657, 673 (9th Cir. 2014). A member of a class may sue as a representative party if the member satisfies Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23(a)'s four prerequisites: numerosity, commonality, typicality, and adequacy of representation. Fed. R. Civ. P. 23(a); Mazza v. Am. Honda Motor Co., Inc., 666 F.3d 581, 588 (9th Cir. 2012). Assessing these requirements involves "rigorous analysis" of the evidence. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. v. Dukes, 564 U.S. 338, 351 (2011) (quoting Gen. Tel. Co. of the Sw. v. Falcon, 457 U.S. 147, 161 (1982)). If the initial requirements of Rule 23(a) are met, a putative class representative must also show the class falls into one of three categories under Rule 23(b). Plaintiffs brought this suit under Rule 23(b)(2), seeking injunctive or declaratory relief based on the City having "acted or refused to act on grounds that apply generally to the class, so that final injunctive relief or corresponding declaratory relief is appropriate respecting the class as a whole." Fed. R. Civ. P. 23(b)(2). The district court found the Rule 23(a) requirements satisfied and certified a class under Rule 23(b)(2). The City's arguments against this class certification are obscure. $88 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTv OF GRAZS+S®f 155 35 It appears the City's argument is that class certification was an abuse of discretion because the holding of Martin can only be applied after an individualized inquiry of each alleged involuntarily homeless person's access to shelter.19 The City appears to suggest the need for individualized inquiry defeats numerosity, commonality, and typicality. While we acknowledge the Martin litigation was not a class action, nothing in that decision precluded class actions.20 And based on the record in this case, the district court did not err by finding Plaintiffs satisfied the requirements of Rule 23 such that a class could be certified. To satisfy the numerosity requirement a proposed class must be "so numerous that joinder of all members is impracticable." Fed. R. Civ. P. 23(a)(1). For purposes of this requirement, "`impracticability' does not mean `impossibility,' but only the difficulty or inconvenience of joining all members of the class." Harris v. Palm Springs Alpine Ests., Inc., 329 F.2d 909, 913-14 (9th Cir. 1964) (quotation omitted). There is no specific number of class members required. See Gen. Tel. Co. of the Nw., Inc. v. EEOC, 446 U.S. 318, 330 (1980). However, proposed 19 There is no reason to believe the putative class members are voluntarily homeless. To the contrary, at least 13 class members submitted declarations to the district court indicating that they are involuntarily homeless. 20 Other courts have certified similar classes. See e.g., Lehr v. City of Sacramento, 259 F.R.D. 479 (E.D. Cal. 2009) (addressing numerosity, commonality, and typicality for homeless persons in Sacramento); Joyce v. City & Cty. of S.F., 1994 WL 443464 (N.D. Cal. Aug. 4, 1994), dismissed as moot, 87 F.3d 1320 (9th Cir. 1996) (finding typicality despite some differences among homeless class members); Pottinger v. City ofMiami, 720 F.Supp. 955, 960 (S.D. Fla. 1989) (certifying a class of homeless persons). $89 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 36 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRAi` ssof 155 classes of less than fifteen are too small while classes of more than sixty are sufficiently large. Harik v. Cal. TeachersAss'n, 326 F.3d 1042, 1051-52 (9th Cir. 2003). When the district court certified the class on August 7, 2019, it found there were at least 600 homeless persons in the City based on the 2018 and 2019 PIT counts conducted by UCAN. The City does not identify how this finding was clearly erroneous. In fact, the City affirmatively indicated to Plaintiffs prior to the class certification order that the number of homeless persons residing in Grants Pass for the past 7 years was "unknown." Further, the only guidance offered by the City regarding a specific number of class members came long after the class was certified. A City police officer claimed in a declaration that he was "aware of less than fifty individuals total who do not have access to any shelter" in the City. The officer admitted, however, it "would be extremely difficult to accurately estimate the population of people who are homeless in Grants Pass regardless of the definition used." The officer's guess of "less than fifty" homeless persons is inconsistent with the general understanding that PIT counts routinely undercount homeless persons. See Martin, 920 F.3d at 604 ("It is widely recognized that a one-night point in time count will undercount the homeless population.") (internal quotation marks omitted). But even accepting the officer's assessment that there were approximately fifty homeless persons in the City, the numerosity requirement is satisfied. Joining approximately fifty persons might be impracticable and especially so under the facts here because homeless persons obviously lack a fixed address and likely have no reliable means of NO Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CITY OF GRAWAS®f 155 37 communications.21 At the very least, the district court did not abuse its discretion in concluding the numerosity requirement was met. A class satisfies Rule 23's commonality requirement if there is at least one question of fact or law common to the class. Wang v. Chinese Daily News, Inc., 737 F.3d 538, 544 (9th Cir. 2013). The Supreme Court has said the word "question" in Rule 23(a)(2) is a misnomer: "What matters to class certification . . . is not the raising of common `questions' —even in droves —but rather, the capacity of a class -wide proceeding to generate common answers apt to 21 Moreover, there is a well -documented correlation between physical and mental illness and homelessness. See, e.g., Sara K. Rankin, Punishing Homelessness, 22 N. CRIM. L. REV. 99, 105 (2019) ("Psychiatric disorders affect at least 30 to 40 percent of all people experiencing homelessness."); Stefan Gutwinski et al., The prevalence of mental disorders among homeless people in high -income countries: An updated systematic review and meta -regression analysis, 18(8) PLoS MED. 1, 14 (Aug. 23, 2021), ("Our third main finding was high prevalence rates for treatable mental illnesses, with 1 in 8 homeless individuals having either major depression (12.6%) or schizophrenia spectrum disorders (12.4%). This represents a high rate of schizophrenia spectrum disorders among homeless people, and a very large excess compared to the 12-month prevalence in the general population, which for schizophrenia is estimated around 0.7% in high -income countries."); Greg A. Greenberg & Robert A. Rosenheck, Jail Incarceration, Homelessness, and Mental Health: A National Study, 59 PSYCHIATRIC SERVS. 170, 170 (2008) ("Homeless individuals may also be more likely to have health conditions ... Severe mental illness is also more prevalent among homeless people than in the general population."); CTR. FOR DISEASE CONTROL & PREVENTION, HOMELESSNESS AS A PUBLIC HEALTH LAW ISSUE: SELECTED RESOURCES (Mar. 2, 2017) ("Homelessness is closely connected to declines in physical and mental health; homeless persons experience high rates of health problems such as HIV infection, alcohol and drug abuse, mental illness, tuberculosis, and other conditions."). tel Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 38 JOHNSON V. CTTy OF GRAi` asof 155 drive the resolution of the litigation." Wal Mart, 564 U.S. at 350 (quoting Richard A. Nagareda, Class Certification in the Age of Aggregate Proof, 84 N.Y.U. L. Rev. 97,132 (2009)) (emphasis and omission in original)). "[C]lass members' claims [must] `depend upon a common contention' such that `determination of its truth or falsity will resolve an issue that is central to the validity of each [claim] in one stroke."' Mazza, 666 F.3d at 588 (quoting Wal Mart, 564 U.S. at 350). As correctly identified by the district court, Plaintiffs' claims present at least one question and answer common to the class: "whether [the City's] custom, pattern, and practice of enforcing anti -camping ordinances, anti -sleeping ordinances, and criminal trespass laws . . . against involuntarily homeless individuals violates the Eighth Amendment of the Constitution." An answer on this question resolved a crucial aspect of the claims shared by all class members. The City argues the commonality requirement was not met because some class members might have alternative options for housing, or might have the means to acquire their own shelter.22 But this argument misunderstands the class " The dissent adapts the City's argument that enforcement of the anti - camping ordinances depends on individual circumstances and is therefore not capable of resolution on a common basis. Dissent 77-79. That misunderstands how the present class was structured. The dissent attempts to reframe the common question as a very general inquiry. It appears the dissent interprets the question whether an Eighth Amendment violation must be determined by an individualized inquiry as whether each individual is "involuntarily homeless." To assess that, a court would have to conduct an individualized inquiry and determine if an individual was "involuntarily homeless." But that is not the common question in this case. Rather, the question is whether the City's enforcement of the anti -camping ordinances against all involuntarily homeless individuals violates the Eighth Amendment. This question is M Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTv OF GRAi` 9KS®f 155 39 definition. Pursuant to the class definition, the class includes only involuntarily homeless persons.23 Individuals who have shelter or the means to acquire their own shelter simply capable of common resolution on a prospective class -wide basis, as the record establishes. 13 The dissent argues this created a prohibited "fail safe" class. That is erroneous. As noted in a recent en bane decision, "a `fail safe' class ... is defined to include only those individuals who were injured by the allegedly unlawful conduct." Olean Wholesale Grocery Coop., Inc. v. Bumble Bee Foods LLC, 31 F.4th 651, 669 n.14 (9th Cir. 2022) (en bane). Such classes are prohibited `-because a class member either wins or, by virtue of losing, is defined out of the class and is therefore not bound by the judgment." Id. See also Ruiz Torres v. Mercer Canyons Inc., 835 F.3d 1125, 1138 (9th Cir. 2016) (noting a fail safe class "is one that is defined so narrowly as to preclude[ ] membership unless the liability of the defendant is established"). No such class is present here. The class was defined, in relevant part, as "[a]11 involuntarily homeless individuals living in Grants Pass." Membership in that class has no connection to the success of the underlying claims. Put differently, the class would have consisted of exactly the same population whether Grants Pass won or lost on the merits. The obvious illustration of this is the class population would not change if a court determined the anti - camping ordinance violated the Eighth Amendment while the anti - sleeping ordinance did not. In that situation, class members would not be "defined out of the class." Olean, 31 F.4th at 669 n.14 (citation omitted). Rather, class members would be "bound by the judgment" regarding the anti -sleeping ordinance. Id. In any event, the dissent's concerns regarding individualized determinations are best made when the City attempts to enforce its ordinances. Cf. McArdle v. City of Ocala, 519 F.Supp.3d 1045, 1052 (M.D. Fla. 2021) (requiring that officers inquire into the availability of shelter space before an arrest could be made for violation of the City's "open lodging" ordinance). If it is determined at the enforcement stage that a homeless individual has access to shelter, then they do not benefit from the injunction and may be cited or prosecuted under the anti -camping ordinances. Moreover, as we noted above, several classes of homeless individuals have been certified in the past. See supra note 20. M Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 40 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRAAGS®f 155 are never class members.24 Because we find there existed at least one question of law or fact common to the class, the district court did not abuse its discretion in concluding commonality was satisfied. Typicality asks whether "the claims or defenses of the representative parties are typical" of the class. Fed. R. Civ. P. 23(a)(3). Typicality is a "permissive standard[]." Staton v. Boeing Co., 327 F.3d 938, 957 (9th Cir. 2003) (citation omitted). It "refers to the nature of the claim or defense of the class representative, and not to the specific facts from which it arose or the relief sought." Parsons, 754 F.3d at 685 (citation omitted). The class representatives' claims and defenses are typical of the class in that they are homeless persons who claim that the City cannot enforce the challenged ordinances against them when they have no shelter. The defenses that apply to class representatives and class members are identical. The claims of class representatives and class members are similar, except that some class representatives live in vehicles while other class members may live on streets or in parks, not vehicles. This does not defeat typicality. The class representatives with vehicles may violate the challenged ordinances in a different manner than some class members—i.e., by sleeping in their vehicle, rather than on the ground. But they challenge the same ordinances under the same constitutional provisions as other 24 We do not, as the dissent contends, "suggest[ ] that the class definition requires only an involuntary lack of access to regular or permanent shelter to qualify as 'involuntarily homeless."' Dissent 84. It is unclear where the dissent finds this in the opinion. To be clear: A person with access to temporary shelter is not involuntarily homeless unless and until they no longer have access to shelter. t94 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRA41AS®f 155 41 class members. Cf. Staton, 327 F.3d at 957 ("[R]epresentative claims are `typical' if they are reasonably coextensive with those of absent class members; they need not be substantially identical.") (citation omitted). The district court did not abuse its discretion in finding the typicality requirement met. The City does not present any other arguments regarding class certification, such as the propriety of certifying the class as an injunctive class under Rule 23(b)(2). We do not make arguments for parties and the arguments raised by the City regarding class certification fail. C. Having rejected the City's jurisdictional arguments, as well as its arguments regarding class certification, the merits can be addressed. The City's merits arguments regarding the Cruel and Unusual Punishment Clause take two forms. First, the City argues its system of imposing civil fines cannot be challenged as violating the Cruel and Unusual Clause because that clause provides protection only in criminal proceedings, after an individual has been convicted. That is incorrect. Second, the City argues Martin does not protect homeless persons from being cited under the City's amended anti -camping ordinance which prohibits use of any bedding or similar protection from the elements. The City appears to have conceded it cannot cite homeless persons merely for sleeping in public but the City maintains it is entitled to cite individuals for the use of rudimentary bedding supplies, such as a blanket, pillow, or sleeping bag "for bedding purposes." See GPMC 5.61.010(B). Again, the City is incorrect. Here, we focus exclusively on the anti -camping ordinances. According to the City, citing individuals under the anti - camping ordinances cannot violate the Cruel and Unusual t95 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 42 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRA42sof 155 Punishment Clause because citations under the ordinances are civil and civil citations are "categorically not `punishment' under the Eight Amendment."25 The City explains "the simple act of issuing a civil citation with a court date [has never] been found to be unconstitutional `punishment' under the Eighth Amendment." While not entirely clear, the City appears to be arguing the Cruel and Unusual Punishment Clause provides no protection from citations categorized as "civil" by a governmental authority.26 25 This position is in significant tension with the City's actions taken immediately after Martin was issued. As noted earlier, the City amended its anti -camping ordinance "in direct response to Martin v. Boise" to allow for "the act of 'sleeping"' in City parks. If the City believed Martin has no impact on civil ordinances, it is unclear why the City believed a curative "response" to Martin was necessary. 26 The primary support for this contention is Ingraham v. Wright, 430 U.S. 651 (1977). In Ingraham, the Supreme Court addressed whether the Cruel and Unusual Punishment Clause was implicated by corporal punishment in public schools. The Court stated the Cruel and Unusual Punishment Clause limits "the criminal process in three ways: First, it limits the kinds of punishment that can be imposed on those convicted of crimes; second, it proscribes punishment grossly disproportionate to the severity of the crime; and third, it imposes substantive limits on what can be made criminal and punished as such." Id. at 667. The Court interpreted the challenge to corporal punishment as, in effect, asserting arguments under only the first or second limitation. That is, the challenge was whether "the paddling of schoolchildren" was a permissible amount or type of punishment. Id. at 668. The Ingraham decision involved no analysis or discussion of the third limitation, i.e. the "substantive limits on what can be made criminal." Id. at 667. Thus, it was in the context of evaluating the amount or type of punishment that Ingraham stated "Eighth Amendment scrutiny is appropriate only after the State has complied with the constitutional guarantees traditionally associated with criminal prosecutions." Id. at 671 n.40. When, as here, plaintiffs are raising challenges to the "substantive limits on what can be M Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTv OF GRA441S®f 155 43 Plaintiffs' focus on civil citations does involve an extra step from the normal Cruel and Unusual Clause analysis and the analysis of Martin. Usually, claims under the Cruel and Unusual Clause involve straightforward criminal charges. For example, the situation in Martin involved homeless persons allegedly violating criminal ordinances and the opinion identified its analysis as focusing on the "criminal" nature of the charges over ten times. 920 F.3d at 617. Here, the City has adopted a slightly more circuitous approach than simply establishing violation of its ordinances as criminal offenses. Instead, the City issues civil citations under the ordinances. If an individual violates the ordinances twice, she can be issued a park exclusion order. And if the individual is found in a park after issuance of the park exclusion order, she is cited for criminal trespass. See O.R.S. 164.245 (criminal trespass in the second degree). Multiple City police officers explained in their depositions this sequence was the standard protocol. The holding in Martin cannot be so easily evaded. Martin held the Cruel and Unusual Punishment clause "prohibits the imposition of criminal penalties for sitting, sleeping, or lying outside on public property for homeless individuals who cannot obtain shelter." 920 F.3d at 616. A local government cannot avoid this ruling by issuing civil citations that, later, become criminal offenses. A recent decision by the en banc Fourth Circuit illustrates how the made criminal," Ingraham does not prohibit a challenge before a criminal conviction. See Martin, 920 F.3d at 614 ("Ingraham did not hold that a plaintiff challenging the state's power to criminalize a particular status or conduct in the first instance, as the plaintiffs in this case do, must first be convicted."). W Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 44 JOHNSONV. CTTY OF GRA44s®f 155 Cruel and Unusual Punishment Clause looks to the eventual criminal penalty, even if there are preliminary civil steps. The disputes in Manning v. Caldwell for City of Roanoke, 930 F.3d 264 (4th Cir. 2019) (en banc) arose from a Virginia law which allowed a state court to issue a civil order identifying an individual as a "habitual drunkard." Id. at 268. Once labeled a "habitual drunkard," the individual was "subject to incarceration for the mere possession of or attempt to possess alcohol, or for being drunk in public." Id. at 269. A group of homeless alcoholics filed suit claiming, among other theories, the "habitual drunkard" scheme violated the Cruel and Unusual Punishment Clause. In the plaintiffs' view, the scheme resulted in criminal prosecutions based on their "status," i.e. alcoholism. See id. at 281. Using reasoning very similar to that in Martin, the Fourth Circuit found the statutory scheme unconstitutional because it provided punishment based on the plaintiffs' status. Of particular relevance here, the Fourth Circuit reasoned the fact that Virginia's "scheme operate[d] in two steps" did not change the analysis. Id. 283. Issuing a civil order first, followed by a criminal charge, was a "two -pronged statutory scheme" potentially "less direct" than straightforwardly criminalizing the status of alcohol addiction. Id. But the scheme remained unconstitutional because it "effectively criminalize[d] an illness." Id. The fact that Virginia "civilly brands alcoholics as `habitual drunkards' before prosecuting them for involuntary manifestations of their illness does nothing to cure the unconstitutionality of this statutory scheme." Id. The same reasoning applies here. The anti -camping ordinances prohibit Plaintiffs from engaging in activity they cannot avoid. The civil citations issued for behavior $®s Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CITY OF GRA4,SS0f 155 45 Plaintiffs cannot avoid are then followed by a civil park exclusion order and, eventually, prosecutions for criminal trespass. Imposing a few extra steps before criminalizing the very acts Martin explicitly says cannot be criminalized does not cure the anti -camping ordinances' Eighth Amendment infirmity. The City offers a second way to evade the holding in Martin. According to the City, it revised its anti -camping ordinances to allow homeless persons to sleep in City parks. However, the City's argument regarding the revised anti - camping ordinance is an illusion. The amended ordinance continues to prohibit homeless persons from using "bedding, sleeping bag, or other material used for bedding purposes," or using stoves, lighting fires, or erecting structures of any kind. GPMC 5.61.010. The City claims homeless persons are free to sleep in City parks, but only without items necessary to facilitate sleeping outdoors.27 The discrepancy between sleeping without bedding materials, which is permitted under the anti -camping ordinances, and sleeping with bedding, which is not, is intended to distinguish the anti -camping ordinances from Martin and the two Supreme Court precedents underlying Martin, Robinson v. California, 370 U.S. 660 (1962) and 27 The Grants Pass ordinance does not specifically define "bedding" but courts give the words of a statute or ordinance their "ordinary, contemporary, common meaning" absent an indication to the contrary from the legislature. See Williams v. Taylor, 529 U.S. 420, 431 (2000) (citation omitted). The Oxford English Dictionary defines "bedding" as " [a] collective term for the articles which compose a bed." OXFORD ENGLTSH DICTIONARY. And "bed" is defined as "a place for sleeping." MERRTAM-WEBSTER COLLEGIATE DICTIONARY 108 (11th ed.). The City's effort to dissociate the use of bedding from the act of sleeping or protection from the elements is nonsensical. $®9 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 46 JOHNSON V. CTTy OF GRAAGS®f 155 Powell v. Texas, 392 U.S. 514 (1968). Under those cases, a person may not be prosecuted for conduct that is involuntary or the product of a "status." See Martin, 920 F.3d at 617 (citation omitted). The City accordingly argues that sleeping is involuntary conduct for a homeless person, but that homeless persons can choose to sleep without bedding materials and therefore can be prosecuted for sleeping with bedding. In its order granting summary judgment, the district court correctly concluded the anti -camping ordinances violated the Cruel and Unusual Punishment Clause to the extent they prohibited homeless persons from "taking necessary minimal measures to keep themselves warm and dry while sleeping when there are no alternative forms of shelter available." The only plausible reading of Martin is that it applies to the act of "sleeping" in public, including articles necessary to facilitate sleep. In fact, Martin expressed concern regarding a citation given to a woman who had been found sleeping on the ground, wrapped in blankets. 920 F.3d at 618. Martin noted that citation as an example of the anti -camping ordinance being "enforced against homeless individuals who take even the most rudimentary precautions to protect themselves from the elements." Id. Martin deemed such enforcement unconstitutional. Id. It follows that the City cannot enforce its anti -camping ordinances to the extent they prohibit "the most rudimentary precautions" a homeless person might take against the elements." The City's position that it is 2' Grants Pass is cold in the winter. The evidence in the record establishes that homeless persons in Grants Pass have struggled against frostbite. Faced with spending every minute of the day and night outdoors, the choice to use rudimentary protection of bedding to protect 0 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRA47AS®f 155 47 entitled to enforce a complete prohibition on "bedding, sleeping bag, or other material used for bedding purposes" is incorrect. The dissent claims we have misread Martin by "completely disregard[ing] the Powell opinions on which Martin relied, which make unmistakably clear that an individualized showing of involuntariness is required." Dissent 82. The dissent concedes that pursuant to Martin, the City cannot impose criminal penalties on involuntarily homeless individuals for sitting, sleeping, or lying outside on public property. Dissent 62. Thus, our purported "complete disregard[ ]" for Martin is not regarding the central holding that local governments may not criminalize involuntary conduct. Rather, the dissent believes, based on its interpretation of the Supreme Court opinions underlying Martin, that the Eighth Amendment provides only "a case - specific affirmative defense" that can never be litigated on a class basis. Dissent 59. To reach this counterintuitive conclusion, the dissent reads limitations into Robinson, Powell, and Martin that are nonexistent. In Robinson, the Supreme Court struck down, under the Eighth Amendment, a California law that made "it a criminal offense for a person to `be addicted to the use of narcotics."' Robinson, 370 U.S. at 666. The law was unconstitutional, the Court explained, because it rendered the defendant "continuously guilty of this offense, whether or not he has ever used or possessed any narcotics within the State." Id. Six years later, in Powell, the Court divided 4-1-4 over whether Texas violated the Eighth Amendment under against snow, frost, or rain is not volitional; it is a life -preserving imperative. 201 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 48 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRAA&S®f 155 Robinson by prosecuting an alcoholic for public drunkenness. In a plurality opinion, Justice Marshall upheld the conviction of Leroy Powell on the ground that he was not punished on the basis of his status as an alcoholic, but rather for the actus reus of being drunk in public. Powell, 392 U.S. at 535. Four justices dissented, in an opinion by Justice Fortas, on the ground that the findings made by the trial judge —that Powell was a chronic alcoholic who could not resist the impulse to drink —compelled the conclusion that Powell's prosecution violated the Eighth Amendment because Powell could not avoid breaking the law. Id. at 569- 70 (Fortas, J., dissenting). Justice White concurred in the judgment. He stressed, "[i]f it cannot be a crime to have an irresistible compulsion to use narcotics, I do not see how it can constitutionally be a crime to yield to such a compulsion." Id. at 549 (White, J., concurring). However, the reason for Justice White's concurrence was that he felt Powell failed to prove his status as an alcoholic compelled him to violate the law by appearing in public. Id. at 553 (White, J., concurring). Pursuant to Marks v. United States, 430 U.S. 188 (1977), the narrowest position which gained the support of five justices is treated as the holding of the Court. In identifying that position, Martin held: "five Justices [in Powell] gleaned from Robinson the principle that `that the Eighth Amendment prohibits the state from punishing an involuntary act or condition if it is the unavoidable consequence of one's status or being."' Martin, 920 F.3d at 616 (quoting Jones, 443 F.3d at 1135). Martin did not —as the dissent alleges —hold that Powell's "controlling opinion was Justice White's concurrence." Dissent 60. See id., 920 F.3d at 616-17. It would have violated the rule of Marks to adopt portions of Justice White's concurrence that did not 202 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRA49KS®f 155 49 receive the support of five justices. The dissent claims Justice White's concurrence requires that the individual claiming a status must prove the status compels the individual to violate the law —here, that each homeless individual must prove their status as an involuntarily homeless person to avoid prosecution.29 Dissent 59-63. The 29 The dissent's attempt to create a governing holding out of Justice White's concurrence is erroneous. By citing a word or two out of context in the Powell dissenting opinion (e.g., "constitutional defense") our dissenting colleague argues both Justice White and the dissenting justices in Powell agreed any person subject to prosecution has, at most, "a case -specific affirmative 'defense."' Dissent 59-60, 77. We disagree. Though status was litigated as a defense in the context of Leroy Powell's prosecution, no opinion in Powell held status may be raised only as a defense. The Powell plurality noted trial court evidence that Leroy Powell was an alcoholic, but that opinion contains no indication "status" may only be invoked as "a case -specific affirmative 'defense."' As for Justice White, the opening paragraph of his concurrence indicates he was primarily concerned not with how a status must be invoked but with the fact that certain statuses should be beyond the reach of the criminal law: If it cannot be a crime to have an irresistible compulsion to use narcotics, I do not see how it can constitutionally be a crime to yield to such a compulsion. Punishing an addict for using drugs convicts for addiction under a different name. Distinguishing between the two crimes is like forbidding criminal conviction for being sick with flu or epilepsy but permitting punishment for running a fever or having a convulsion. Unless Robinson is to be abandoned, the use of narcotics by an addict must be beyond the reach of the criminal law. Similarly, the chronic alcoholic with an irresistible urge to consume alcohol should not be punishable for drinking or for being drunk. Powell, 392 U.S. at 548-49 (White, J., concurring) (internal citation omitted). Finally, neither the remainder of Justice White's concurrence 203 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 50 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRASGS®f 155 dissent claims this renders class action litigation inappropriate. But no opinion in either Powell or Martin discussed the propriety of litigating the constitutionality of such criminal statutes by way of a class action.30 The law that the dissent purports to unearth in Justice White's concurrence is not the "narrowest ground" which received the support of five justices. No opinion in Powell or Martin supports the dissent's assertion that Powell offers exclusively an "affirmative `defense"' that cannot be litigated in a class action.31 Dissent 59, 77. Although the nor the dissenting opinion explicitly indicates one's status may only be invoked as a defense. Rather, Justice White and the dissenters simply agreed that, if Powell's status made his public intoxication involuntary, he could not be prosecuted. There is no conceivable way to interpret Martin as adopting our dissenting colleague's position that one's status must be invoked as a defense. But even assuming the burden must be placed on the party wishing to invoke a status, the class representatives established there is no genuine dispute of material fact they have the relevant status of being involuntarily homeless. 30 Federal courts have certified classes of homeless plaintiffs in the past, see supra note 20, which counsels against the City's and the dissent's position that such classes are impermissible under Rule 23. 3' As noted above, Martin did not hold homeless persons bear the burden of demonstrating they are involuntarily homeless. See supra note 29. Because the record plainly demonstrates Plaintiffs are involuntarily homeless, there similarly is no reason for us to determine what showing would be required. We note, however, that some district courts have addressed circumstances in which the question of burden was somewhat relevant. See, e.g., McArdle, 519 F.Supp.3d at 1052 (requiring, based in part on Martin, that officers inquire into the availability of shelter space before making an arrest for violation of the City's "open lodging" ordinance); Butcher v. City ofMarysville, 2019 WL 918203, at *7 (E.D. Cal. Feb. 25, 2019) (holding plaintiffs failed to make the "threshold showing" of pleading that there was no shelter capacity and that they had no other housing at the time of enforcement). 204 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRASIAS®f 155 51 dissent might prefer that these principles find support in the controlling law, they do not. We thus do not misread Martin by failing to apply the principles found solely in Justice White's concurrence. Rather, we adhere to the narrow holding of Martin adopting the narrowest ground shared by five justices in Powell: a person cannot be prosecuted for involuntary conduct if it is an unavoidable consequence of one's status. In addition to erecting an absolute bar to class litigation of this sort, the dissent would also impose artificial limitations on claims brought pursuant to Martin. The dissent concedes Gloria Johnson has standing to bring individual challenges to most of the City's ordinances. But the dissent then speculates that Gloria Johnson may, in fact, not be involuntarily homeless in the City. The dissent would insist that Gloria Johnson, for example, leave the City to camp illegally on federal or state lands, provide the court an accounting of her finances and employment history, and indicate with specificity where she lived before she lost her job and her home. Dissent 85-88. There, of course, exists no law or rule requiring a homeless person to do any of these things. Gloria Johnson has adequately demonstrated that there is no available shelter in Grants Pass and that she is involuntarily homeless. The undisputed evidence establishes Gloria Johnson is involuntarily homeless and there is undisputed evidence showing many other individuals in similar situations. It is undisputed that there are at least around 50 involuntarily homeless persons in Grants Pass, and PIT counts, which Martin relied on to establish the number of homeless persons in Boise, revealed more than 600. See Martin, 920 F.3d at 604. It is undisputed that there is no secular shelter space available to adults. Many class members, including the class 205 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 52 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRAS2S0f 155 representatives, have sworn they are homeless and the City has not contested those declarations. The dissent claims this showing is not enough, implying that Plaintiffs must meet an extremely high standard to show they are involuntarily homeless. Even viewed in the light most favorable to the City, there is no dispute of material fact that the City is home to many involuntarily homeless individuals, including the class representatives. In fact, neither the City nor the dissent has demonstrated there is even one voluntarily homeless individual living in the City.32 In light of the undisputed facts in the record underlying the district court's summary judgment ruling that show Plaintiffs are involuntarily homeless, and the complete absence of evidence that Plaintiffs are voluntarily homeless, we agree with the district court that Plaintiffs such as Gloria Johnson are not voluntarily homeless and that the anti -camping ordinances are unconstitutional as applied to them unless there is some place, such as shelter, they can lawfully steep.33 " The dissent claims we have "shifted the burden to the City to establish the voluntariness of the behavior targeted by the ordinances." Dissent 87 n.13 (emphasis omitted). To the contrary, as we have explained, we do not decide who would bear such a burden because undisputed evidence demonstrates Plaintiffs are involuntarily homeless. Rather, without deciding who would bear such a burden if involuntariness were subject to serious dispute, we note Plaintiffs have demonstrated involuntariness and there is no evidence in the record showing any class member has adequate alternative shelter. " Following Martin, several district courts have held that the government may evict or punish sleeping in public in some locations, provided there are other lawful places within the jurisdiction for involuntarily homeless individuals to sleep. See, e.g., Shipp v. Schaaf, 379 F.Supp.3d 1033, 1037 (N.D. Cal. 2019) ("However, even assuming (as Plaintiffs do) that [eviction from a homeless encampment by citation or arrest] might occur, remaining at a particular encampment on public Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTv OF GRAS41S®f 155 53 Our holding that the City's interpretation of the anti - camping ordinances is counter to Martin is not to be interpreted to hold that the anti -camping ordinances were properly enjoined in their entirety. Beyond prohibiting bedding, the ordinances also prohibit the use of stoves or fires, as well as the erection of any structures. The record has not established the fire, stove, and structure prohibitions deprive homeless persons of sleep or "the most rudimentary precautions" against the elements.34 Moreover, the record does not explain the City's interest in these prohibitions.35 property is not conduct protected by Martin, especially where the closure is temporary in nature."); Aitken v. City of Aberdeen, 393 F.Supp.3d 1075, 1082 (W.D. Wash. 2019) ("Martin does not limit the City's ability to evict homeless individuals from particular public places."); Gomes v. Cry. of Kauai, 481 F.Supp.3d 1104, 1109 (D. Haw. 2020) (holding the County of Kauai could prohibit sleeping in a public park because it had not prohibited sleeping on other public lands); Miralle v. City of Oakland, 2018 WL 6199929, at *2 (N.D. Cal. Nov. 28, 2018) (holding the City could clear out a specific homeless encampment because "Martin does not establish a constitutional right to occupy public property indefinitely at Plaintiffs' option"); Le Van Hung v. Schaaf, 2019 WL 1779584, at *5 (N.D. Cal. Apr. 23, 2019) (holding Martin does not "create a right for homeless residents to occupy indefinitely any public space of their choosing"). Because the City has not established any realistically available place within the jurisdiction for involuntarily homeless individuals to sleep we need not decide whether alternate outdoor space would be sufficient under Martin. The district court may consider this issue on remand, if it is germane to do so. sa The dissent claims we establish "the right to use (at least) a tent." Dissent 89 n.15. This assertion is obviously false. The district court's holding that the City may still "ban the use of tents in public parks" remains undisturbed by our opinion. 35 The dissent asserts, "it is hard to deny that Martin has `generate[d] dire practical consequences for the hundreds of local governments within our jurisdiction, and for the millions of people that reside therein."' Dissent 92 (quoting Martin, 920 F.3d at 594 (M. Smith, J., dissenting from denial 207 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 54 JOHNSON V. CTTy OF GRA1 4sof 155 Consistent with Martin, these prohibitions may or may not be permissible. On remand, the district court will be required to craft a narrower injunction recognizing Plaintiffs' limited right to protection against the elements, as well as limitations when a shelter bed is available.36 I13 The district court concluded the fines imposed under the anti -sleeping and anti -camping ordinances violated the Eighth Amendment's prohibition on excessive fines. A central portion of the district court's analysis regarding these fines was that they were based on conduct "beyond what the City may constitutionally punish." With this in mind, the district court noted "[a]ny fine [would be] excessive" for the conduct at issue. The City presents no meaningful argument on appeal regarding the excessive fines issue. As for Plaintiffs, they argue the fines at issue were properly deemed excessive because they were imposed for "engaging in involuntary, unavoidable life sustaining acts." The permanent injunction will result in no class member being fined for engaging in such protected activity. Because no fines will be imposed of rehearing en banc)) (modification in original). There are no facts in the record to establish that Martin has generated "dire" consequences for the City. Our review of this case is governed only by the evidence contained in the record. 36 The district court enjoined the park exclusion ordinance in its entirety. The parties do not address this in their appellate briefing but, on remand, the district court should consider narrowing this portion as well because the park exclusion ordinance presumably may be enforced against Plaintiffs who engage in prohibited activity unrelated to their status as homeless persons. Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTv OF GRASSsOf 155 55 for protected activity, there is no need for us to address whether hypothetical fines would be excessive. E. The final issue is whether Plaintiffs properly pled their challenge to the park exclusion appeals ordinance. GPMC 6.46.355. That ordinance provided a mechanism whereby an individual who received an exclusion order could appeal to the City Council. Subsequent to the district court's order, the City amended its park exclusion appeals ordinance. Therefore, the district court's determination the previous ordinance violated Plaintiffs' procedural due process rights has no prospective relevance. Because of this, we need not decide if Plaintiffs adequately pled their challenge to the previous ordinance. III. We affirm the district court's ruling that the City of Grants Pass cannot, consistent with the Eighth Amendment, enforce its anti -camping ordinances against homeless persons for the mere act of sleeping outside with rudimentary protection from the elements, or for sleeping in their car at night, when there is no other place in the City for them to go. On remand, however, the district court must narrow its injunction to enjoin only those portions of the anti -camping ordinances that prohibit conduct protected by Martin and this opinion. In particular, the district court should narrow its injunction to the anti -camping ordinances and enjoin enforcement of those ordinances only against involuntarily homeless person for engaging in conduct necessary to protect themselves from the elements when there is no shelter space available. Finally, the district court on remand should consider whether there is an adequate representative who may be substituted for Debra Blake. Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 56 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRASGS®f 155 We are careful to note that, as in Martin, our decision is narrow. As in Martin, we hold simply that it is "unconstitutional to [punish] simply sleeping somewhere in public if one has nowhere else to do so." Martin, 920 F.3d at 590 (Berzon, J., concurring in denial of rehearing en banc). Our decision reaches beyond Martin slightly. We hold, where Martin did not, that class certification is not categorically impermissible in cases such as this, that "sleeping" in the context of Martin includes sleeping with rudimentary forms of protection from the elements, and that Martin applies to civil citations where, as here, the civil and criminal punishments are closely intertwined. Our decision does not address a regime of purely civil infractions, nor does it prohibit the City from attempting other solutions to the homelessness issue. AFFIRMED IN PART, VACATED IN PART, AND REMANDED. COLLINS, Circuit Judge, dissenting: In Martin v. City of Boise, 920 F.3d 584 (9th Cir. 2019), we held that "the Eighth Amendment's prohibition on cruel and unusual punishment bars a city from prosecuting people criminally for sleeping outside on public property when those people have no home or other shelter to go to." Id. at 603. Even assuming that Martin remains good law, today's decision —which both misreads and greatly expands Martin's holding —is egregiously wrong. To make things worse, the majority opinion then combines its gross misreading of Martin with a flagrant disregard of settled 280 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRASTsof 155 57 class -certification principles. The end result of this amalgamation of error is that the majority validates the core aspects of the district court's extraordinary injunction in this case, which effectively requires the City of Grants Pass to allow all but one of its public parks to be used as homeless encampments.' I respectfully dissent. I Because our opinion in Martin frames the issues here, I begin with a detailed overview of that decision before turning to the facts of the case before us. M In Martin, six individuals sued the City of Boise, Idaho, under 42 U.S.C. § 1983, alleging that the City had violated their Eighth Amendment rights in enforcing two ordinances that respectively barred, inter alia, (1) camping in public spaces and (2) sleeping in public places without permission. 920 F.3d at 603-04, 606. All six plaintiffs had been convicted of violating at least one of the ordinances, id. at 606, but we held that claims for retrospective relief based on those convictions were barred by the doctrine of Heck v. Humphrey, 512 U.S. 477 (1994). See Martin, 920 F.3d at 611-12 (noting that, under Heck, a § 1983 action may not be maintained if success in the suit would necessarily show the invalidity of the plaintiffs criminal conviction, unless that conviction has already been set aside or invalidated). What remained, after application of the Heck bar, were the claims 1 The majority's decision is all the more troubling because, in truth, the foundation on which it is built is deeply flawed: Martin seriously misconstrued the Eighth Amendment and the Supreme Court's caselaw construing it. See infra at 90-92. But i am bound by Martin, and — unlike the majority —I faithfully apply it here. 281 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 58 JOHNSON V. CTTy OF GRAS&S®f 155 for retrospective relief asserted by two plaintiffs (Robert Martin and Pamela Hawkes) in connection with citations they had received that did not result in convictions, and the claims for prospective injunctive and declaratory relief asserted by Martin and one additional plaintiff (Robert Anderson). Id. at 604, 610, 613-15; see also id. at 618-20 (Owens, J., dissenting in part) (dissenting from the majority's holding that the prospective relief claims survived Heck). On the merits of those three plaintiffs' Eighth Amendment claims, the Martin panel held that the district court had erred in granting summary judgment for the City. Id. at 615-18. Although the text of the Eighth Amendment's Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause states only that "cruel and unusual punishments" shall not be "inflicted," U.S. CONST., amend. VIII (emphasis added), the Martin panel nonetheless held that the Clause "places substantive limits" on the government's ability to criminalize "sitting, sleeping, or lying outside on public property," 920 F.3d at 615-16. In reaching this conclusion, the Martin panel placed dispositive reliance on the Supreme Court's decisions in Robinson v. California, 370 U.S. 660 (1962), and Powell v. Texas, 392 U.S. 514 (1968). I therefore briefly review those two decisions before returning to Martin. Robinson held that a California law that made "it a criminal offense for a person to `be addicted to the use of narcotics,"' 370 U.S. at 660 (quoting CAL. HEALTH & SAFETY CODE § 11721 (1957 ed.)), and that did so "even though [the person] has never touched any narcotic drug within the State or been guilty of any irregular behavior there, inflicts a cruel and unusual punishment in violation of the Fourteenth Amendment," id. at 667. The California statute, the Court emphasized, made the "`status' of narcotic 282 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRAS9KS0f 155 59 addiction a criminal offense," regardless of whether the defendant had "ever used or possessed any narcotics within the State" or had "been guilty of any antisocial behavior there." Id. at 666 (emphasis added). In Powell, a fractured Supreme Court rejected Powell's challenge to his conviction, under a Texas statute, for being "found in a state of intoxication in any public place." 392 U.S. at 517 (quoting TEx. PENAL CODE art. 477 (1952)). A four -Justice plurality distinguished Robinson on the ground that, because Powell "was convicted, not for being a chronic alcoholic, but for being in public while drunk on a particular occasion," Texas had "not sought to punish a mere status, as California did in Robinson." Id. at 532 (plurality). The plurality held that Robinson did not address, much less establish, that "certain conduct cannot constitutionally be punished because it is, in some sense, `involuntary' or `occasioned by a compulsion."' Id. at 533 (emphasis added). Justice White concurred in the judgment on the narrower ground that Powell had failed to establish the "prerequisites to the possible invocation of the Eighth Amendment," which would have required him to "satisfactorily show[] that it was not feasible for him to have made arrangements to prevent his being in public when drunk and that his extreme drunkenness sufficiently deprived him of his faculties on the occasion in issue." Id. at 552 (White, J., concurring). And because, in Justice White's view, the Eighth Amendment at most provided a case -specific affirmative "defense" to application of the statute, id. at 552 n.4, he agreed that the Texas statute was "constitutional insofar as it authorizes a police officer to arrest any seriously intoxicated person when he is encountered in a public place," id. at 554 n.5 (emphasis added). Emphasizing that Powell himself "did not show that his conviction offended the Constitution" and 283 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 60 JOHNSON V. CTTy OF GRAAGS®f 155 that Powell had "made no showing that he was unable to stay off the streets on the night in question," Justice White concurred in the majority's affirmance of Powell's conviction. Id. at 554 (emphasis added). The four dissenting Justices in Powell agreed that the Texas statute "differ[ed] from that in Robinson" inasmuch as it "covers more than a mere status." 392 U.S. at 567 (Fortas, J., dissenting). There was, as the dissenters noted, "no challenge here to the validity of public intoxication statutes in general or to the Texas public intoxication statute in particular." Id. at 558. Indeed, the dissenters agreed that, in the ordinary case "when the State proves such [public] presence in a state of intoxication, this will be sufficient for conviction, and the punishment prescribed by the State may, of course, be validly imposed." Id. at 569. Instead, the dissenters concluded that the application of the statute to Powell was unconstitutional "on the occasion in question" in light of the Texas trial court's findings about Powell's inability to control his condition. Id. at 568 n.31 (emphasis added). Those findings concerning Powell's "constitutional defense," the dissenters concluded, established that Powell "was powerless to avoid drinking" and "that, once intoxicated, he could not prevent himself from appearing in public places." Id. at 558, 568; see also id. at 525 (plurality) (describing the elements of the "constitutional defense" that Powell sought to have the Court recognize). While acknowledging that the plurality in Powell had "interpret[ed] Robinson as precluding only the criminalization of `status,' not of `involuntary' conduct," the Martin panel held that the controlling opinion was Justice White's concurrence. 920 F.3d at 616. As I have noted, Justice White concluded that the Texas statute against public drunkenness could constitutionally be applied, even to an 284 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTv OF GRAZIAS®f 155 61 alcoholic, if the defendant failed to "satisfactorily show[] that it was not feasible for him to have made arrangements to prevent his being in public when drunk and that his extreme drunkenness sufficiently deprived him of his faculties on the occasion in issue." Powell, 392 U.S. at 552 (White, J., concurring).' Under Marks v. United States, 430 U.S. 188 (1977), this narrower reasoning given by Justice White for joining the Powell majority's judgment upholding the conviction constitutes the Court's holding in that case. See id. at 193 ("When a fragmented Court decides a case and no single rationale explaining the result enjoys the assent of five Justices, `the holding of the Court may be viewed as that position taken by those Members who concurred in the judgments on the narrowest grounds."' (citation omitted)); see also United States v. Moore, 486 F.2d 1139, 1151 (D.C. Cir. 1973) (en banc) (Wilkey, J., concurring) (concluding that the judgment in Powell rested on the overlap in the views of "four members of the Court" who held that Powell's acts of public drunkenness "were punishable without question" and the view of Justice White that Powell's acts "were punishable so long as the acts had not been proved to be the product of an established irresistible compulsion"). The Martin panel quoted dicta in Justice White's concurrence suggesting that, if the defendant could make the requisite "showing" that "resisting drunkenness is 2 Justice White, however, did not resolve the further question of whether, if such a showing had been made, the Eighth Amendment would have been violated. He stated that the Eighth Amendment "might bar conviction" in such circumstances, but he found it "unnecessary" to decide whether that "novel construction of that Amendment" was ultimately correct. 392 U.S. at 552-53 & nA (emphasis added). 285 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 62 JOHNSON V. CTTy OF GRA42sof 155 impossible and that avoiding public places when intoxicated is also impossible," then the Texas statute "[a]s applied" to such persons might violate "the Eighth Amendment." 920 F.3d at 616 (quoting Powell, 392 U.S. at 551 (White, J., concurring)). These dicta, Martin noted, overlapped with similar statements in the dissenting opinion in Powell, and from those two opinions, the Martin panel derived the proposition that "five Justices" had endorsed the view that "the Eighth Amendment prohibits the state from punishing an involuntary act or condition if it is the unavoidable consequence of one's status or being." Id. (citation omitted). Applying that principle, Martin held that "the Eighth Amendment prohibits the imposition of criminal penalties for sitting, sleeping, or lying outside on public property for homeless individuals who cannot obtain shelter." Id. Because "human beings are biologically compelled to rest, whether by sitting, lying, or sleeping," Martin held that prohibitions on such activities in public cannot be applied to those who simply have "no option of sleeping indoors." Id. at 617. The Martin panel emphasized that its "holding is a narrow one." Id. Martin recognized that, if there are sufficient available shelter beds for all homeless persons within a jurisdiction, then of course there can be no Eighth Amendment impediment to enforcing laws against sleeping and camping in public, because those persons engaging in such activities cannot be said to have "no option of sleeping indoors." Id. But "so long as there is a greater number of homeless individuals in a jurisdiction than the number of available beds in shelters, the jurisdiction cannot prosecute homeless individuals for involuntarily sitting, lying, and sleeping in public." Id. (simplified) (emphasis added). Consistent with Justice White's concurrence, the Martin 286 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRA441S®f 155 63 panel emphasized that, in determining whether the defendant was being punished for conduct that was "involuntary and inseparable from status," id. (citation omitted), the specific individual circumstances of the defendant must be considered. Thus, Martin explained, the panel's "holding does not cover individuals who do have access to adequate temporary shelter, whether because they have the means to pay for it or because it is realistically available to them for free, but who choose not to use it." Id. at 617 n.8. But Martin held that, where it is shown that homeless persons "do not have a single place where they can lawfully be," an ordinance against sleeping or camping in public, "as applied to them, effectively punish[es] them for something for which they may not be convicted under the Eighth Amendment." Id. at 617 (simplified). Concluding that the remaining plaintiffs had "demonstrated a genuine issue of material fact" as to their lack of any access to indoor shelter, Martin reversed the district court's grant of summary judgment to the City. Id. at 617 n.9; see also id. at 617-18. LE With that backdrop in place, I turn to the specific facts of this case. In the operative Third Amended Complaint, named Plaintiffs Debra Blake, Gloria Johnson, and John Logan sought to represent a putative class of "all involuntarily homeless people living in Grants Pass, Oregon" in pursuing a variety of claims under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 against the City of Grants Pass. In particular, they asserted that the following three sections of the Grants Pass Municipal Code ("GPMC"), which generally prohibited sleeping and camping in public, violated the Eighth Amendment's Cruel 287 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 64 JOHNSON V. CTTy OF GRAT 4sof 155 and Unusual Punishments Clause and its Excessive Fines Clause: 5.61.020 Sleeping on Sidewalks, Streets, Alleys, or Within Doorways Prohibited A. No person may sleep on public sidewalks, streets, or alleyways at any time as a matter of individual and public safety. B. No person may sleep in any pedestrian or vehicular entrance to public or private property abutting a public sidewalk. C. In addition to any other remedy provided by law, any person found in violation of this section may be immediately removed from the premises. 5.61.030 Camping Prohibited No person may occupy a campsite in or upon any sidewalk, street, alley, lane, public right of way, park, bench, or any other publicly - owned property or under any bridge or viaduct, [subject to specified exceptions].3 6.46.090 Camping in Parks A. It is unlawful for any person to camp, as defined in GPMC Title 5, within the boundaries of the City parks. B. Overnight parking of vehicles shall be unlawful. For the purposes of this section, The definition of "campsite" for purposes of GPMC 5.61.030 includes using a "vehicle" as a temporary place to live. See GPMC 5.61.010(B). 288 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRAASS®f 155 65 anyone who parks or leaves a vehicle parked for two consecutive hours or who remains within one of the parks as herein defined for purposes of camping as defined in this section for two consecutive hours, without permission from the City Council, between the hours of midnight and 6:00 a.m. shall be considered in violation of this Chapter. Plaintiffs' complaint also challenged the following "park exclusion" ordinance as a violation of their "Eighth and Fourteenth Amendment rights": 6.46.350 Temporary Exclusion from City Park Properties An individual may be issued a written exclusion order by a police officer of the Public Safety Department barring said individual from all City Park properties for a period of 30 days, if within a one-year period the individual: A. Is issued 2 or more citations for violating regulations related to City park properties, or B. Is issued one or more citations for violating any state law(s) while on City park property.4 4 This latter ordinance was amended in September 2020 to read as follows: An individual may be issued a written exclusion order by a police officer of the Public Safety Department barring said 289 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 66 JOHNSON V. CTTy OF GRAAGS®f 155 In an August 2019 order, the district court certified a class seeking declaratory and injunctive relief with respect to Plaintiffs' Eighth Amendment claims, pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23(b)(2).1 As defined in the court's order, the class consists of "[a]ll involuntarily homeless individuals living in Grants Pass, Oregon, including homeless individuals who sometimes sleep outside city limits to avoid harassment and punishment by Defendant as addressed in this lawsuit." After the parties filed cross -motions for summary judgment, the district court in July 2020 granted Plaintiffs' motion in relevant part and denied the City's motion. The district court held that, under Martin, the City's enforcement of the above -described ordinances violated the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause. The court further held that, for similar reasons, the ordinances imposed excessive fines individual from a City park for a period of 30 days, if within a one-year period the individual: A. Is issued two or more citations in the same City park for violating regulations related to City park properties, or B. Is issued one or more citations for violating any state law(s) while on City park property. The foregoing exclusion order shall only apply to the particular City park in which the offending conduct under 6.46.350(A) or 6.46.350(B) occurred. s At the time that the district court certified the class, the operative complaint was the Second Amended Complaint. That complaint was materially comparable to the Third Amended Complaint, with the exception that it did not mention the park -exclusion ordinance or seek injunctive relief with respect to it. 0 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRAWAS®f 155 67 in violation of the Eighth Amendment's Excessive Fines Clause. After Plaintiffs voluntarily dismissed those claims as to which summary judgment had been denied to both sides, the district court entered final judgment declaring that the City's enforcement of the anti -camping and anti -sleeping ordinances (GPMC §§ 5.61.020, 5.61.030, 6.46.090) violates "the Eighth Amendment prohibition against cruel and unusual punishment" and its "prohibition against excessive fines." Nonetheless, the court's final injunctive relief did not prohibit all enforcement of these provisions. Enforcement of § 5.61.020 (the anti -sleeping ordinance) was not enjoined at all. The City was enjoined from enforcing the anti -camping ordinances (GPMC §§ 5.61.030 and 6.46.090) "without first giving a person a warning of at least 24 hours before enforcement." It was further enjoined from enforcing those ordinances, and a related ordinance against criminal trespass on city property, in all but one City park during specified evening and overnight hours, which varied depending upon the time of year. Finally, the City was enjoined from enforcing the park -exclusion ordinance.6 6 The district court's summary judgment order and judgment also declared that a separate ordinance (GPMC § 6.46.355), which addressed the procedures for appealing park -exclusion orders under § 6.46.350, failed to provide sufficient procedural due process. The parties dispute whether this claim was adequately raised and reached below, but as the majority notes, this claim for purely prospective relief has been mooted by the City's subsequent amendment of § 6.46.355 in a way that removes the features that had led to its invalidation. See Opin. at 55. Accordingly, this aspect of the district court's judgment should be vacated and remanded with instructions to dismiss as moot Plaintiffs' challenge to § 6.46.355. 291 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 68 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRAA&S®f 155 The City timely appealed from that judgment and from the district court's subsequent award of attorneys' fees. II Before turning to the merits, I first address the question of our jurisdiction under Article III of the Constitution. Plains Com. Bank v. Long Family Land & Cattle Co., 554 U.S. 316, 324 (2008) (holding that courts "bear an independent obligation to assure [them]selves that jurisdiction is proper before proceeding to the merits"). "In limiting the judicial power to `Cases' and `Controversies,' Article III of the Constitution restricts it to the traditional role of Anglo-American courts, which is to redress or prevent actual or imminently threatened injury to persons caused by private or official violation of law." Summers v. Earth Island Inst., 555 U.S. 488, 492 (2009). "The doctrine of standing is one of several doctrines that reflect this fundamental limitation," and in the context of a request for prospective injunctive or declaratory relief, that doctrine requires a plaintiff to "show that he is under threat of suffering `injury in fact' that is concrete and particularized; the threat must be actual and imminent, not conjectural or hypothetical; it must be fairly traceable to the challenged action of the defendant; and it must be likely that a favorable judicial decision will prevent or redress the injury." Id. at 493. The requirement to show an actual threat of imminent injury -in -fact in order to obtain prospective relief is a demanding one: the Supreme Court has "repeatedly reiterated that threatened injury must be certainly impending to constitute injury in fact, and that allegations of possible future injury are not sufficient." Clapper v. Amnesty Int'l USA, 568 U.S 398, 409 (2013) (simplified). 292 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRA49KS®f 155 69 As "an indispensable part of the plaintiff's case," each of these elements of Article III standing "must be supported in the same way as any other matter on which the plaintiff bears the burden of proof, i.e., with the manner and degree of evidence required at the successive stages of the litigation." Lujan v. Defenders of Wildlife, 504 U.S. 555, 561 (1992). Because, as in Lujan, this case arises from a grant of summary judgment, the question is whether, in seeking summary judgment, Plaintiffs "`set forth' by affidavit or other evidence `specific facts"' in support of each element of standing. Id. (citation omitted). Moreover, "standing is not dispensed in gross," and therefore "a plaintiff must demonstrate standing for each claim he seeks to press." DaimlerChrysler Corp. v. Cuno, 547 U.S. 332, 352-53 (2006) (emphasis added) (citation omitted). Plaintiffs' operative complaint named three individual plaintiffs as class representatives (John Logan, Gloria Johnson, and Debra Blake), and we have jurisdiction to address the merits of a particular claim if any one of them sufficiently established Article III standing as to that claim. See Secretary of the Interior v. California, 464 U.S. 312, 319 n.3 (1984) ("Since the State of California clearly does have standing, we need not address the standing of the other [plaintiffs], whose position here is identical to the State's."); see also Bates v. United Parcel Service, Inc., 511 F.3d 974, 985 (9th Cir. 2007) (en banc) ("In a class action, standing is satisfied if at least one named plaintiff meets the requirements."). Accordingly, I address the showing made by each named Plaintiff in support of summary judgment. In my view, Plaintiff John Logan failed to establish that he has standing to challenge any of the ordinances in question. In support of his motion for summary judgment, Logan submitted a half -page declaration stating, in 293 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 70 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRAZsGs®f 155 conclusory fashion, that he is "involuntarily homeless in Grants Pass," but that he is "sleeping in [his] truck at night at a rest stop North of Grants Pass." He asserted that he "cannot sleep in the City of Grants Pass for fear that [he] will be awakened, ticketed, fined, moved along, trespassed[,] and charged with Criminal Trespass." Logan also previously submitted two declarations in support of his class certification motion. In them, Logan stated that he has been homeless in Grants Pass for nearly seven of the last 10 years; that there have been occasions in the past in which police in Grants Pass have awakened him in his car and instructed him to move on; and that he now generally sleeps in his truck outside of Grants Pass. Logan has made no showing that, over the seven years that he has been homeless, he has ever been issued a citation for violating the challenged ordinances, nor has he provided any facts to establish either that the threat of such a citation is "certainly impending" or that "there is a substantial risk" that he may be issued a citation. Susan B. Anthony List v. Driehaus, 573 U.S. 149, 158 (2014) (citation and internal quotation marks omitted). At best, his declarations suggest that he would prefer to sleep in his truck within the City limits rather than outside them, and that he is subjectively deterred from doing so due to the City's ordinances. But such "[a]llegations of a subjective `chill' are not an adequate substitute for a claim of specific present objective harm or a threat of specific future harm." Laird v. Tatum, 408 U.S. 1, 13-14 (1972). Nor has Logan provided any facts that would show that he has any actual intention or plans to stay overnight in the City. See Lopez v. Candaele, 630 F.3d 775, 787 (9th Cir. 2010) ("[W]e have concluded that pre -enforcement plaintiffs who failed to allege a concrete intent to violate the challenged law could not establish a credible threat of enforcement."). Even if his 294 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRA-71!AS®f 155 71 declarations could be generously construed as asserting an intention to stay in the City at some future point, "[s]uch ,some day' intentions —without any description of concrete plans, or indeed even any specification of when the some day will be —do not support a finding of the `actual or imminent' injury that [the Court's] cases require." Lujan, 504 U.S. at 564; cf.. Driehaus, 573 U.S. at 161 (permitting pre - enforcement challenge against ordinance regulating election -related speech where plaintiffs' allegations identified "specific statements they intend[ed] to make in future election cycles"). And, contrary to what the majority suggests, see Opin. at 30-31 n.16, Logan's vaguely described knowledge about what has happened to other people cannot establish his standing. Accordingly, Logan failed to carry his burden to establish standing for the prospective relief he seeks. By contrast, Plaintiff Gloria Johnson made a sufficient showing that she has standing to challenge the general anti - camping ordinance, GPMC § 5.61.030, and the parks anti - camping ordinance, GPMC § 6.46.090. Although Johnson's earlier declaration in support of class certification stated that she "often" sleeps in her van outside the City limits, she also stated that she "continue[s] to live without shelter in Grants Pass" and that, consequently, "[a]t any time, I could be arrested, ticketed, fined, and prosecuted for sleeping outside in my van or for covering myself with a blanket to stay warm" (emphasis added). Her declaration also recounts "dozens of occasions" in which the anti -camping ordinances have been enforced against her, either by instructions to "move along" or, in one instance, by issuance of a citation for violating the parks anti -camping ordinance, GPMC § 6.46.090. Because Johnson presented facts showing that she continues to violate the anti -camping ordinances and 295 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 72 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRA-72sof 155 that, in light of past enforcement, she faces a credible threat of future enforcement, she has standing to challenge those ordinances. Lujan, 504 U.S. at 564. Johnson, however, presented no facts that would establish standing to challenge either the anti -sleeping ordinance (which, unlike the anti - camping ordinances, does not apply to sleeping in a vehicle), the park -exclusion ordinance, or the criminal trespass ordinance. Debra Blake sufficiently established her standing, both in connection with the class certification motion and the summary judgment motion. Although she was actually The majority concludes that Johnson's standing to challenge the anti - camping ordinances necessarily establishes her standing to challenge the park -exclusion and criminal -trespass ordinances. See Opin. at 30 n.15. But as the district court explained, the undisputed evidence concerning Grants Pass's enforcement policies established that "Grants Pass first issues fines for violations and then either issues a trespass order or excludes persons from all parks before a person is charged with misdemeanor criminal trespass" (emphasis added). Although Johnson's continued intention to sleep in her vehicle in Grants Pass gives her standing to challenge the anti -camping ordinances, Johnson has wholly failed to plead any facts to show, inter alia, that she intends to engage in the further conduct that might expose her to a "credible threat" of prosecution under the park -exclusion or criminal trespass ordinances. Driehaus, 573 U.S. at 159 (citation omitted). Johnson's declaration states that she has been homeless in Grants Pass for three years, but it does not contend that she has ever been issued, or threatened with issuance of, a trespass order, a park -exclusion order, or a criminal trespass charge or that she has "an intention to engage in a course of conduct" that would lead to such an order or charge. Id. (citation omitted). Because "standing is not dispensed in gross," see DaimlerChrysler, 547 U.S. at 353 (citation omitted), Johnson must separately establish her standing with respect to each ordinance, and she has failed to do so with respect to the park -exclusion and criminal - trespass ordinances. Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRA-74&0 155 73 living in temporary housing at the time she submitted her declarations in support of class certification in March and June 2019, she explained that that temporary housing would soon expire; that she would become homeless in Grants Pass again; and that she would therefore again be subject to being "arrested, ticketed and prosecuted for sleeping outside or for covering myself with a blanket to stay warm." And, as her declaration at summary judgment showed, that is exactly what happened: in September 2019, she was cited for sleeping in the park in violation of GPMC § 6.46.090, convicted, and fined. Her declarations also confirmed that Blake's persistence in sleeping and camping in a variety of places in Grants Pass had also resulted in a park -exclusion order (which she successfully appealed), and in citations for violation of the anti -sleeping ordinance, GPMC § 5.61.020 (for sleeping in an alley), and for criminal trespass on City property. Based on this showing, I conclude that Blake established standing to challenge each of the ordinances at issue in the district court's judgment. However, Blake subsequently passed away during this litigation, as her counsel noted in a letter to this court submitted under Federal Rule of Appellate Procedure 43(a). Because the only relief she sought was prospective declaratory and injunctive relief, Blake's death moots her claims. King v. County of Los Angeles, 885 F.3d 548, 553, 559 (9th Cir. 2018). And because, as explained earlier, Blake was the only named Plaintiff who established standing with respect to the anti -sleeping, park -exclusion, and criminal trespass ordinances that are the subject of the district court's classwide judgment, her death raises the question whether we consequently lack jurisdiction over those additional claims. Under Sosna v. Iowa, 419 U.S. 393 (1975), the answer to that question would appear to be no. 297 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 74 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRA-74s®f 155 Blake established her standing at the time that the class was certified and, as a result, "[w]hen the District Court certified the propriety of the class action, the class of unnamed persons described in the certification acquired a legal status separate from the interest asserted by [Blake]." Id. at 399. "Although the controversy is no longer alive as to [Blake], it remains very much alive for the class of persons she [had] been certified to represent." Id. at 401; see also Nielsen v. Preap, 139 S. Ct. 954, 963 (2019) (finding no mootness where "there was at least one named plaintiff with a live claim when the class was certified"); Bates v. United Parcel Service, Inc., 511 F.3d 974, 987-88 (9th Cir. 2007) (en banc). There is, however, presently no class representative who meets the requirements for representing the certified class with respect to the anti -sleeping, park -exclusion, and criminal trespass ordinances.' Although that would s Because —in contrast to the named representative in Sosna, who had Article III standing at the time of certification —Johnson and Logan never had standing to represent the class with respect to the anti -sleeping ordinance, they may not represent the class as to such claims. See Sosna, 419 U.S. at 403 (holding that a previously proper class representative whose claims had become moot on appeal could continue to represent the class for purposes of that appeal); see also Bates, 511 F.3d at 987 (emphasizing that the named plaintiff "had standing at the time of certification"); B.K. ex rel. Tinsley v. Snyder, 922 F.3d 957, 966 (9th Cir. 2019) (stating that "class representatives must have Article TTT standing"); cf. NEI Contracting & Eng'g, Inc. v. Hanson Aggregates Pac. SW., Inc., 926 F.3d 528, 533 (9th Cir. 2019) (holding that, where the named plaintiffs never had standing, the class "must be decertified"). The majority correctly concedes this point. See Opin. at 32-33. Nonetheless, the majority wrongly allows Johnson and Logan to represent the class as to the park -exclusion and criminal -trespass Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRAZSS,s®f 155 75 normally require a remand to permit the possible substitution of a new class member, see Kuahulu v. Employers Ins. of Wausau, 557 F.2d 1334, 1336-37 (9th Cir. 1977), I see no need to do so here, and that remains true even if one assumes that the failure to substitute a new class representative might otherwise present a potential jurisdictional defect. As noted earlier, we have jurisdiction to address all claims concerning the two anti -camping ordinances, as to which Johnson has sufficient standing to represent the certified class. And, as I shall explain, the class as to those claims should be decertified, and the reasons for that decertification rest on cross -cutting grounds that apply equally to all claims. As a result, I conclude that we have jurisdiction to order the complete decertification of the class as to all claims, without the need for a remand to substitute a new class representative as to the anti -sleeping, park -exclusion, and criminal trespass ordinances. Cf.. Steel Co. v. Citizens for a Better Env't, 523 U.S. 83, 98 (1998) (holding that, where "a merits issue [is] dispositively resolved in a companion case," that merits ruling could be applied to the other companion case without the need for a remand to resolve a potential jurisdictional issue). III I therefore turn to whether the district court properly certified the class under Rule 23 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. In my view, the district court relied on erroneous legal premises in certifying the class, and it therefore abused its discretion in doing so. B.K., 922 F.3d at 965. ordinances, based on its erroneous conclusion that they established standing to challenge those ordinances. See supra at 69-72 & n.7. Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 76 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRA-76 sof 155 0 "To obtain certification of a plaintiff class under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23, a plaintiff must satisfy both the four requirements of Rule 23(a)—`numerosity, commonality, typicality, and adequate representation' —and `one of the three requirements listed in Rule 23(b)."' A.B. v. Hawaii State Dep't of Educ., 30 F.4th 828, 834 (9th Cir. 2022) (quoting Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. v. Dukes, 564 U.S. 338, 345, 349 (2011)). Commonality, which is contested here, requires a showing that the class members' claims "depend upon a common contention" that is "of such a nature that it is capable of classwide resolution —which means that determination of its truth or falsity will resolve an issue that is central to the validity of each one of the claims in one stroke." Wal Mart, 564 U.S. at 350. In finding that commonality was satisfied with respect to the Eighth Amendment claims, the district court relied solely on the premise that whether the City's conduct "violates the Eighth Amendment" was a common question that could be resolved on a classwide basis. And in finding that Rule 23(b) was satisfied here, the district court relied solely on Rule 23(b)(2), which provides that a "class action may be maintained" if "the party opposing the class has acted or refused to act on grounds that apply generally to the class, so that final injunctive relief or corresponding declaratory relief is appropriate respecting the class as a whole." FED. R. CIv. P. 23(b)(2). That requirement was satisfied, the district court concluded, because (for reasons similar to those that underlay its commonality analysis) the City's challenged enforcement of the ordinances "applies equally to all class members." The district court's commonality and Rule 23(b)(2) analyses are both flawed because they are based on an incorrect understanding of our decision in Martin. 0 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRA-77s®f 155 77 As the earlier discussion of Martin makes clear, the Eighth Amendment theory adopted in that case requires an individualized inquiry in order to assess whether any individuals to whom the challenged ordinances are being applied "do have access to adequate temporary shelter, whether because they have the means to pay for it or because it is realistically available to them for free, but who choose not to use it." 920 F.3d at 617 n.8. See supra at 61-63. Only when persons "do not have a single place where they can lawfully be," can it be said that an ordinance against sleeping or camping in public, "as applied to them, effectively punish[es] them for something for which they may not be convicted under the Eighth Amendment." Id. at 617 (simplified) (emphasis added). Of course, such an individualized inquiry is not required —and no Eighth Amendment violation occurs under Martin —when the defendant can show that there is adequate shelter space to house all homeless persons in the jurisdiction. Id. But the converse is not true the mere fact that a city's shelters are full does not by itself establish, without more, that any particular person who is sleeping in public does "not have a single place where [he or she] can lawfully be." Id. The logic of Martin, and of the opinions in Powell on which it is based, requires an assessment of a person's individual situation before it can be said that the Eighth Amendment would be violated by applying a particular provision against that person. Indeed, the opinions in Powell on which Martin relied —Justice White's concurring opinion and the opinion of the dissenting Justices —all agreed that, at most, the Eighth Amendment provided a case -specific affirmative defense that would require the defendant to provide a "satisfactor[y] showing that it was not feasible for him to have made arrangements" 231 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 78 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRAZsgs®f 155 to avoid the conduct at issue. Powell, 392 U.S. at 552 (White, J., concurring); id. at 568 n.31 (Fortas, J., dissenting) (agreeing with Justice White that the issue is whether the defendant "on the occasion in question" had shown that avoiding the conduct was "impossible"); see also supra at 59-60.9 In light of this understanding of Martin, the district court clearly erred in finding that the requirement of commonality was met here. "What matters to class certification is not the raising of common `questions' —even in droves —but rather, the capacity of a class -wide proceeding to generate common answers apt to drive the resolution of the litigation. Dissimilarities within the proposed class are what have the potential to impede the generation of common answers." 9 The majority incorrectly contends that the dissenters in Powell did not endorse Justice White's conclusion that the defendant bears the burden to establish that his or her conduct was involuntary. See Opin. at 48-51. On the contrary, the Powell dissenters' entire argument rested on the affirmative "constitutional defense" presented at the trial in that case and on the findings made by the trial court in connection with that defense. See 392 U.S. at 558 (Fortas, J., dissenting). The majority's suggestion that I have taken that explicit reference to Powell's defense "out of context," see Opin. at 49 n.29, is demonstrably wrong —the context of the case was precisely the extensive affirmative defense that Powell presented at trial, including the testimony of an expert. See 392 U.S. at 5 1726 (plurality) (summarizing the testimony). And, of course, in Martin, the issue was raised in the context of a § 1983 action in which the plaintiffs challenging the laws bore the burden to prove the involuntariness of their relevant conduct. The majority points to nothing that would plausibly support the view that Powell and Martin might require the government to carry the burden to establish voluntariness. See Opin. at 50 n.31 (leaving this issue open). The majority claims that it can sidestep this issue here, but that is also wrong: the burden issue is critical both to the class -certification analysis and to the issue of summary judgment on the merits. See infra at 78-89. 232 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRAN7s9+S®f 155 79 Wal Mart, 564 U.S. at 350 (simplified). Under Martin, the answer to the question whether the City's enforcement of each of the anti -camping ordinances violates the Eighth Amendment turns on the individual circumstances of each person to whom the ordinance is being applied on a given occasion. That question is simply not one that can be resolved, on a common basis, "in one stroke." Id. That requires decertification. For similar reasons, the district court also erred in concluding that the requirements of Rule 23(b)(2) were met. By its terms, Rule 23(b)(2) is satisfied only if (1) the defendant has acted (or refused to act) on grounds that are generally applicable to the class as whole and (2) as a result, final classwide or injunctive relief is appropriate. As the Supreme Court has observed, "[t]he key to the (b)(2) class is `the indivisible nature of the injunctive or declaratory remedy warranted —the notion that the conduct is such that it can be enjoined or declared unlawful only as to all of the class members or as to none of them."' Wal Mart, 564 U.S. at 360. It follows that, when the wrongfulness of the challenged conduct with respect to any particular class member depends critically upon the individual circumstances of that class member, a class action under Rule 23(b)(2) is not appropriate. In such a case, in which (for example) the challenged enforcement of a particular law may be lawful as to some persons and not as to others, depending upon their individual circumstances, the all -or - nothing determination of wrongfulness that is the foundation of a (b)(2) class is absent: in such a case, it is simply not true that the defendant's "conduct is such that it can be enjoined or declared unlawful only as to all of the class members or as to none of them."' Id. (emphasis added). 233 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 80 JOHNSON V. CTTy OF GRAr GS®f 155 Because Martin requires an assessment of each person's individual circumstances in order to determine whether application of the challenged ordinances violates the Eighth Amendment, these standards for the application of Rule 23(b)(2) were plainly not met in this case. That is, because the applicable law governing Plaintiffs' claims would entail "a process through which highly individualized determinations of liability and remedy are made," certification of a class under Rule 23(b)(2) is improper. Jamie S. v. Milwaukee Pub. Sch., 668 F.3d 481, 499 (7th Cir. 2012). Moreover, the mere fact that the district court's final judgment imposes sweeping across-the-board injunctive relief that disregards individual differences in determining the defendant's liability does not mean that Rule 23(b)(2) has been satisfied. The rule requires that any such classwide relief be rooted in a determination of classwide liability — the defendant must have acted, or be acting, unlawfully "on grounds that apply generally to the class, so that final injunctive or corresponding declaratory relief is appropriate respecting the class as a whole." FED. R. Civ. P. 23(b)(2) (emphasis added). That requirement was not established here, and the class must be decertified. 10 10 The majority wrongly concludes that the City has forfeited any argument concerning Rule 23(b)(2) because it did not specifically mention that subdivision of the rule in its opening brief. Opin. at 41. This "Simon Says" approach to reading briefs is wrong. The substance of the argument is contained in the opening brief, in which the City explicitly contended that Martin requires "a more individualized analysis" than the district court applied and that, as a result, "neither FED. R. CTV. P. 23 nor Martin provide plaintiffs the ability to establish the type of sweeping class -wide claims advanced in this case." indeed, Plaintiffs themselves responded to this argument, in their answering brief, by 234 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRAr ts®f 155 81 Ifl The majority provides two responses to this analysis, but both of them are wrong. First, the majority contends that Martin established a bright -line rule that the government cannot prosecute "involuntarily homeless persons for sleeping in public" —or, presumably, for camping —"if there are no other public areas or appropriate shelters where those individuals can sleep." See Opin. at 19. As the majority makes clear, that latter inquiry into available shelter space turns on whether "the number of homeless persons outnumber the available shelter beds," except that, "[w]hen assessing the number of shelter spaces," shelters that have a "mandatory religious focus" are not to be counted. See Opin. at 13, 19 (citation omitted). Moreover, although the majority's phrasing pays lip service to the fact that the persons at issue must be "involuntarily homeless," the majority also explicitly rejects the City's contention that "the holding of Martin can only be applied after an individualized inquiry of each alleged involuntarily homeless person's access to shelter." See Opin. at 35. The net result, for class certification purposes, is that any issue of individualized involuntariness is set aside and Martin is thereby reduced to a simplistic formula —to be resolved on a classwide basis —into whether the number of homeless persons in the jurisdiction exceeds the number of available shelter beds. See Opin. at 34-35, 38. The majority's analysis fails, because Martin does not allow the individualized inquiry into involuntariness to be set aside in this way. Martin states that, if there are explaining why they believe that the requirements of Rule 23(b)(2) were met. 235 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 82 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRAr 2s®f 155 insufficient available beds at shelters, then a jurisdiction "cannot prosecute homeless individuals for `involuntarily sitting, lying, and sleeping in public."' 920 F.3d at 617 (emphasis added). The lack of adequate shelter beds thus merely eliminates a safe -harbor that might otherwise have allowed a jurisdiction to prosecute violations of such ordinances without regard to individual circumstances, with the result that the jurisdiction's enforcement power will instead depend upon whether the conduct of the individual on a particular occasion was "involuntar[y]." Id. Martin confirms that the resulting inquiry turns on whether the persons in question have access to "a single place where they can lawfully be," id. at 617 (emphasis added) (citation omitted), and not just on whether they have access to "appropriate shelters" or "other public areas." And the majority's misreading of Martin completely disregards the Powell opinions on which Martin relied, which make unmistakably clear that an individualized showing of involuntariness is required. Second, and relatedly, the majority states that, to the extent that Martin requires such an individualized showing to establish an Eighth Amendment violation, any such individualized issue here has been eliminated by the fact that "[p]ursuant to the class definition, the class includes only involuntarily homeless persons." See Opin. at 38-40 (first emphasis added). As the majority acknowledges, "[p]ersons are involuntarily homeless" under Martin only "if they do not `have access to adequate temporary shelter,"' such as, for example, when they lack "`the means to pay for it"' and it is otherwise not "`realistically available to them for free."' Opin. at 14 n.2 (quoting Martin, 920 F.3d at 617 n.8). Because that individualized issue has been shifted into the class definition, the majority holds, the City's enforcement Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRA 41S®f 155 83 of the challenged ordinances against that class can in that sense be understood to present a "common question" that can be resolved in one stroke. According to the majority, because the class definition requires that, at the time the ordinances are applied against them, the class members must be "involuntarily homeless" in the sense that Martin requires, there is a common question as to whether "the City's enforcement of the anti -camping ordinances against all involuntarily homeless individuals violates the Eighth Amendment." See Opin. at 38-39 & n.22. The majority cites no authority for this audacious bootstrap argument. If a person's individual circumstances are such that he or she has no "access to adequate temporary shelter" —which necessarily subsumes (among other things) the determination that there are no shelter beds available — then the entire (highly individualized) question of the City's liability to that person under Martin's standards has been shifted into the class definition. That is wholly improper. See Olean Wholesale Grocery Coop. v. Bumble Bee Foods, 31 F.4th 651, 670 n.14 (9th Cir. 2022) (en banc) ("A court may not ... create a `fail safe' class that is defined to include only those individuals who were injured by the allegedly unlawful conduct."); see also Ruiz Torres v. Mercer Canyons Inc., 835 F.3d 1125, 1138 n.7 (9th Cir. 2016) (stating that it would be improper to define a class in such a way "as to preclude membership unless the liability of the defendant is established" (simplified)). The majority nonetheless insists that "[m]embership in [the] class" here "has no connection to the success of the underlying claims." See Opin. at 39 n.23. That is obviously false. As I have explained, Martin's understanding of when a person "involuntarily" lacks "access to adequate temporary shelter" or to "a single place where [he or she] can lawfully 237 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 84 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRA44sof 155 be," see 920 F.3d at 617 & n.8 (citations omitted), requires an individualized inquiry into a given person's circumstances at a particular moment. By insisting that a common question exists here because Martin's involuntariness standard has been folded into the class definition, the majority is unavoidably relying on a fail-safe class definition that improperly subsumes this crucial individualized merits issue into the class definition. The majority's artifice renders the limitations of Rule 23 largely illusory.ii To the extent that the majority instead suggests that the class definition requires only an involuntary lack of access to regular or permanent shelter to qualify as "involuntarily homeless," its argument collapses for a different reason. Because Martin's Eighth Amendment holding applies only to those who involuntarily lack "access to adequate temporary shelter" on a given occasion, see 920 F.3d at 617 n.8, such an understanding of the class definition would not The majority contends that, despite the presence of a liability - determining individualized issue in the class definition, there is no fail- safe class here because one or more of the claims might still conceivably fail on the merits for other reasons. See Opin. at 39 n.23. But the majority does not identify any such other reasons and, of course, under the majority's view of the substantive law, there are none. But more importantly, the majority is simply wrong in positing that the only type of class that would qualify as an impermissible fail-safe class is one in which every conceivable merits issue in the litigation has been folded into the class definition. What matters is whether the class definition folds within it any bootstrapping merits issue (such as the "injur[y]" issue mentioned in Olean) as to which "a class member either wins or, by virtue of losing, is defined out of the class and is therefore not bound by the judgment." Olean, 31 F.4th at 670 n.14 (citation omitted). To the extent that the central individualized merits issue in this case has been folded into the class definition, that defect is present here. Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRASS+s®f 155 85 be sufficient to eliminate the highly individualized inquiry into whether a particular person lacked such access at a given moment, and the class would then have to be decertified for the reasons I have discussed earlier. See supra at 75-80. Put simply, the majority cannot have it both ways: either the class definition is co -extensive with Martin's involuntariness concept (in which case the class is an improper fail-safe class) or the class definition differs from the Martin standard (in which case Martin's individualized inquiry requires decertification). IV Given these conclusions as to standing and class certification, all that remains are the individual claims of Johnson for prospective relief against enforcement of the two anti -camping ordinances. In my view, these claims fail as a matter of law. Johnson's sole basis for challenging these ordinances is that they prohibit her from sleeping in her van within the City. In her declaration in support of class certification, however, Johnson specifically stated that she has "often" been able to sleep in her van by parking outside the City limits. In a supplemental declaration in support of summary judgment, she affirmed that these facts "remain true," but she added that there had also been occasions in which, outside the City limits, county officers had told her to "move on" when she "was parked on county roads" and that, when she parked "on BLM land"—i.e., land managed by the federal Bureau of Land Management —she was told that she "could only stay on BLM for a few days." As an initial matter, Johnson's declaration provides no non-conclusory basis for finding that she lacks any option other than sleeping in her van. Although her declaration Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 86 JOHNSON V. CTTy OF GRAr SS®f 155 notes that she worked as a nurse "for decades" and that she now collects social security benefits, the declaration simply states, without saying anything further about her present economic situation, that she "cannot afford housing." Her declaration also says nothing about where she lived before she began living "on the street" a few years ago, and it says nothing about whether she has any friends or family, in Grants Pass or elsewhere, who might be able to provide assistance.12 And even assuming that this factual showing would be sufficient to permit a trier of fact to find that Johnson lacks any realistic option other than sleeping in her van, we cannot affirm the district court's summary judgment in Johnson's favor without holding that her showing was so overwhelming that she should prevail as a matter of law. Because a reasonable trier of fact could find, in light of these evidentiary gaps, that Johnson failed to carry her burden of proof on this preliminary point, summary judgment in her favor was improper.13 12 The majority dismisses these questions about the sufficiency of Johnson's evidentiary showing as "artificial limitations" on claims under Martin, see Opin. at 51, but the standard for establishing an Eighth Amendment violation under Martin and the Powell opinions on which it relies is a demanding and individualized one, and we are obligated to follow it. Indeed, in upholding Powell's conviction for public drunkenness, the controlling opinion of Justice White probed the details of the record as to whether, in light of the fact that Powell "had a home and wife," he could have "made plans while sober to prevent ending up in a public place," and whether, despite his chronic alcoholism, he "retained the power to stay off or leave the streets, and simply preferred to be there rather than elsewhere." 392 U.S. at 553. 13 The majority errs by instead counting all gaps in the evidentiary record against the City, faulting it for what the majority thinks the City has failed to "demonstrate[]," See Opin. at 52 & n.32. That is contrary to well -settled law. See Celotex Corp. v. Catrett, 477 U.S. 317,322 (1986) 240 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRAWAS®f 155 87 But even assuming that Johnson had established that she truly has no option other than sleeping in her van, her showing is still insufficient to establish an Eighth Amendment violation. As noted, Johnson's sole complaint in this case is that, by enforcing the anti -camping ordinances, the City will not let her sleep in her van. But the sparse facts she has presented fail to establish that she lacks any alternative place where she could park her van and sleep in it. On the contrary, her factual showing establishes that the BLM will let her do so on BLM land for a "few days" at a time and that she also has "often" been able to do so on county land. Given that Johnson has failed to present sufficient evidence to show that she lacks alternatives that would allow her to avoid violating the City's anti -camping ordinances, she has not established that the conduct for which the City would punish her is involuntary such that, under Martin and the Powell opinions on which Martin relies, it would violate the Eighth Amendment to enforce that prohibition against her. In nonetheless finding that the anti -camping ordinances' prohibition on sleeping in vehicles violates the Eighth Amendment, the majority apparently relies on the premise that the question of whether an individual has options for avoiding violations of the challenged law must be limited to alternatives that are within the City limits. Under this view, if a large homeless shelter with 1,000 vacant beds were (holding that a movant's summary judgment motion should be granted "against a [nonmovant] who fails to make a showing sufficient to establish the existence of an element essential to that party's case, and on which that party will bear the burden of proof at trial"). The majority's analysis also belies its implausible claim that it has not shifted the burden to the City to establish the voluntariness of the behavior targeted by the ordinances. See supra at 78 n.9. 241 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 88 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRAr &S®f 155 opened a block outside the City's limits, the City would still be required by the Eighth Amendment to allow hundreds of people to sleep in their vans in the City and, presumably, in the City's public parks as well. Nothing in law or logic supports such a conclusion. Martin says that anti -sleeping ordinances may be enforced, consistent with the Eighth Amendment, so long as there is a "single place where [the person] can lawfully be," 920 F.2d at 617 (emphasis added) (citation omitted), and Justice White's concurrence in Powell confirms that the Eighth Amendment does not bar enforcement of a law when the defendant has failed to show that avoiding the violative conduct is "impossible," 392 U.S. at 551 (emphasis added).14 Nothing in the rationale of this Eighth Amendment theory suggests that the inquiry into whether it is "impossible" for the defendant to avoid violating the law must be artificially constrained to only those particular options that suit the defendant's geographic or other preferences. To be sure, Johnson states that having to drive outside the City limits costs her money for gas, but that does not provide any basis for concluding that the option is infeasible or that she has thereby suffered "cruel and unusual punishment." Finally, because the district court's reliance on the Excessive Fines Clause was predicated on the comparable view that the challenged ordinances punish "status and not conduct" in violation of Robinson, that ruling was flawed for the same reasons. And because Johnson provides no other 14 The majority complains that this standard is too high, see Opin. at 52, but it is the standard applied in Martin and in the Powell opinions on which Martin relied. 242 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRAr SS®f 155 89 basis for finding an Excessive Fines violation here, her claims under that clause also fail as a matter of law. V Accordingly, I would remand this case with instructions (1) to dismiss as moot the claims of Debra Blake as well as Plaintiffs' claims with respect to GPMC § 6.46.355; (2) to dismiss the claims of John Logan for lack of Article III standing; (3) to dismiss the remaining claims of Gloria Johnson for lack of Article III standing, except to the extent that she challenges the two anti -camping ordinances (GPMC §§ 5.61.030, 6.46.090); (4) to decertify the class; and (5) to grant summary judgment to the City, and against Johnson, with respect to her challenges to the City's anti -camping ordinances under the Eighth Amendment's Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause and Excessive Fines Clause. That disposes of all claims at issue, and I therefore need not reach any of the many additional issues discussed and decided by the majority's opinion or raised by the parties.15 '' Two of the majority's expansions of Martin nonetheless warrant special mention. First, the majority's decision goes well beyond Martin by holding that the Eighth Amendment precludes enforcement of anti - camping ordinances against those who involuntarily lack access to temporary shelter, if those ordinances deny such persons the use of whatever materials they need "to keep themselves warm and dry." See Opin. at 46. 1t seems unavoidable that this newly declared right to the necessary "materials to keep warm and dry" while sleeping in public parks must include the right to use (at least) a tent; it is hard to see how else one would keep "warm and dry" in a downpour. And the majority also raises, and leaves open, the possibility that the City's prohibition on the use of other "items necessary to facilitate sleeping outdoors" —such as "stoves," "fires," and makeshift "structures" —"may or may not be permissible." See Opin. at 45-46, 53-54. Second, the majority indirectly extends Martin's holding from the strictly criminal context at issue in that case to civil citations and fines. See Opin. at 41-45. As the 243 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 90 JOHNSON V. CTTy OF GRAi` GS®f 155 vl Up to this point, I have faithfully adhered to Martin and its understanding of Powell, as I am obligated to do. See Miller v. Gammie, 335 F.3d 889, 899-900 (9th Cir. 2003) (en bane). But given the importance of the issues at stake, and the gravity of Martin's errors, I think it appropriate to conclude by noting my general agreement with many of the points made by my colleagues who dissented from our failure to rehear Martin en bane. In particular, I agree that, by combining dicta in a concurring opinion with a dissent, the panel in Martin plainly misapplied Marks' rule that "[w]hen a fragmented Court decides a case and no single rationale explaining the result enjoys the assent of five Justices, `the holding of the Court may be viewed as that position taken by those Members who concurred in the judgments on the narrowest grounds."' 430 U.S. at T93 (emphasis added) (citation omitted). Under a correct application of Marks, the holding of Powell is that there is no constitutional obstacle to punishing conduct that has not been shown to be involuntary, and the converse question of what rule applies when the district court noted below, the parties vigorously debated the extent to which a "violation" qualifies as a crime under Oregon law. The majority, however, sidesteps that issue by instead treating it as irrelevant. The majority's theory is that, even assuming arguendo that violations of the anti -camping ordinances are only civil in nature, they are covered by Martin because such violations later could lead (after more conduct by the defendant) to criminal fines, see Opin. at 44-45. But the majority does not follow the logic of its own theory, because it has not limited its holding or remedy to the enforcement of the ultimate criminal provisions; on the contrary, the majority has enjoined any relevant enforcement of the underlying ordinances that contravenes the majority's understanding of Martin. See Opin. at 55. 244 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRAi` IAS®f 155 91 conduct has been shown to be involuntary was left open. See Martin, 920 F.3d at 590-93 (M. Smith, J., dissenting from denial of rehearing en banc) (explaining that, under a proper application of Marks, "`there is definitely no Supreme Court holding' prohibiting the criminalization of involuntary conduct" (citation omitted)). Moreover, the correct answer to the question left open in Powell was the one provided in Justice Marshall's plurality opinion in that case: there is no federal "constitutional doctrine of criminal responsibility." 392 U.S. at 534. In light of the "centuries -long evolution of the collection of interlocking and overlapping concepts which the common law has utilized to assess the moral accountability of an individual for his antisocial deeds," including the "doctrines of actus reus, mens rea, insanity, mistake, justification, and duress," the "process of adjustment" of "the tension between the evolving aims of the criminal law and changing religious, moral, philosophical, and medical views of the nature of man" is a matter that the Constitution leaves within "the province of the States" or of Congress. Id. at 535-36. "There is simply no indication in the history of the Eighth Amendment that the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause was intended to reach the substantive authority of Congress to criminalize acts or status, and certainly not before conviction," and the later incorporation of that clause's protections vis-a-vis the States in the Fourteenth Amendment "worked no change in its meaning." Martin, 920 F.3d at 602 (Bennett, J., dissenting from denial of rehearing en banc); see also id. at 599 (explaining that Martin's novel holding was inconsistent with the "text, tradition, and original public meaning[] [of] the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause of the Eighth Amendment"). Consequently, so long as "the accused has committed some 245 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 92 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRAi` ZS®f 155 act, has engaged in some behavior, which society has an interest in preventing, or perhaps in historical common law terms, has committed some actus reus," the Eighth Amendment principles applied in Robinson have been satisfied. Powell, 392 U.S. at 533 (plurality). The Eighth Amendment does not preclude punishing such an act merely "because it is, in some sense, `involuntary' or `occasioned by a compulsion."' Id.; see also Martin, 920 F.3d at 592 n.3 (M. Smith, J., dissenting from denial of rehearing en bane) ("Powell does not prohibit the criminalization of involuntary conduct."). Further, it is hard to deny that Martin has "generate[d] dire practical consequences for the hundreds of local governments within our jurisdiction, and for the millions of people that reside therein." Id. at 594 (M. Smith, J., dissenting from denial of rehearing en bane). Those harms, of course, will be greatly magnified by the egregiously flawed reconceptualization and extension of Martin's holding in today's decision, and by the majority's equally troubling reworking of settled class-action principles. With no sense of irony, the majority declares that no such harms are demonstrated by the record in this case, even as the majority largely endorses an injunction effectively requiring Grants Pass to allow the use of its public parks as homeless encampments. Other cities in this circuit can be expected to suffer a similar fate. In view of all of the foregoing, both Martin and today's decision should be overturned or overruled at the earliest opportunity, either by this court sitting en bane or by the U.S. Supreme Court. I respectfully but emphatically dissent. 246 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRAi` 41S®f 155 93 Silver, District Judge, and Gould, Circuit Judge, joint statement regarding denial of rehearing: The differences of opinion in this case are hard and there is basis for good -faith disagreements which are reflected in the filings from a variety of judges. The robust defense of the panel majority opinion we offer here should not be read as any comment on the sincerity of our colleagues' quarrels with our position. The statement regarding the denial of rehearing from Judge O'Scannlain and the dissent from Judge M. Smith significantly exaggerate the holding in Johnson v. Grants Pass, 50 F.4th 787 (9th Cir. 2022). Grants Pass, relying on Martin v. City of Boise, 920 F.3d 584 (9th Cir. 2019), holds only that governments cannot criminalize the act of sleeping with the use of rudimentary protections, such as bedding, from the elements in some public places when a person has nowhere else to sleep. It does not establish an unrestrained right for involuntarily homeless persons to sleep anywhere they choose. Nor does it require jurisdictions to cede all public spaces to involuntarily homeless persons. The argued notion that Martin and Grants Pass work together to guarantee a "federal constitutional `right' ... to camp or to sleep on sidewalks and in parks, playgrounds, and other public places" is completely absent from the opinion. The denial of en banc rehearing should not be criticized based on rhetorical exaggerations. Beyond misdescribing the holding of Grants Pass, Judge O' Scannlain extrapolates and proposes that the Ninth Circuit ignore 65 years of Supreme Court precedent in favor of his preferred approach of looking exclusively to what he declares is the "text, history, and tradition" of the Eighth Amendment. But inferior courts are not free to embark on 247 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 94 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRAi` 4sof 155 such freewheeling adventures when the Supreme Court has provided the applicable guidance. Judge M. Smith does not join the portion of Judge O' Scannlain's statement discussing this point, but Judge M. Smith engages in a puzzling error by attributing in part the homelessness problem throughout the Ninth Circuit to Martin and now Grants Pass. The homelessness problem predates Martin, and cities outside the Ninth Circuit, and outside the United States, are experiencing crisis -levels of homelessness. It is implausible to argue the crisis would abate if jurisdictions in the Ninth Circuit regained the authority to punish involuntarily homeless persons for sleeping in public with blankets. I. Limited Holding of Grants Pass Judge O' Scannlain and Judge M. Smith aim most of their fire at the portion of Grants Pass addressing the two overlapping "anti -camping" ordinances. Grants Pass holds the anti -camping ordinances enacted by the City of Grants Pass violate the Eighth Amendment but only to the extent they criminalize sleeping with rudimentary forms of protection from the elements (i.e., bedding or sleeping bags) by those persons without access to any other shelter (i.e., persons who are "involuntarily homeless"). Grants Pass does not expressly preface every reference to "homeless persons" with the adjective "involuntarily." However, in clear reliance on Martin, the opinion is strictly limited to enforcement of the ordinances against "involuntarily" homeless persons. Like Martin, Grants Pass holds only that "it is `unconstitutional to [punish] simply sleeping somewhere in public if one has nowhere else to do so."' Id. (quoting Martin, 920 F.3d at 590 (Berzon, J., concurring in denial of rehearing en banc)). The holding in Grants Pass is not that involuntarily 248 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRAi` SsOf 155 95 homeless persons in the City of Grants Pass and elsewhere in the Ninth Circuit are allowed to sleep wherever and whenever they wish. When there is space available in shelters, jurisdictions are free to enforce prohibitions on sleeping anywhere in public. And emphatically, when an involuntarily homeless person refuses a specific offer of shelter elsewhere, that individual may be punished for sleeping in public. When there is no shelter space, jurisdictions may still enforce limitations on sleeping at certain locations. The assertion that jurisdictions must now allow involuntarily homeless persons to camp or sleep on every sidewalk and in every playground is plainly wrong. Jurisdictions remain free to address the complex policy issues regarding homelessness in the way those jurisdictions deem fit, subject to the single restriction that involuntarily homeless persons must have "somewhere" to sleep and take rudimentary precautions (bedding) against the elements. Id. (quoting Martin, 920 F.3d at 590 (Berzon, J., concurring in denial of rehearing en banc)). Judge M. Smith misinterpreted a statement in the original majority opinion that he believed mandated "a crude jurisdiction -wide inquiry" dictating a local "government cannot prosecute homeless people for sleeping in public if there is a greater number of homeless individuals in a jurisdiction than the number of available shelter spaces." Judge M. Smith's understanding of the original statement was incorrect. To avoid any possibility of confusion, the majority has now removed the statement Judge M. Smith found confounding. But Judge M. Smith is still not satisfied. He complains the change did not result in any "downstream changes" to the majority's analysis. But Judge M. Smith fails to acknowledge the undisputed facts established that in the City of Grants Pass, there were zero shelter beds 249 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 96 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRAi` GS®f 155 available on almost every night of the year. Given that, there was no need to change the remaining analysis. As clearly explained in the majority opinion, the only secular shelter beds in the City of Grants Pass (other than beds for intoxicated adults) were located at a "warming center" that operated on especially cold nights. The warming center could hold 40 individuals and was open 16 nights during the winter of 2020 and zero nights during the winter of 2021. Thus, on 95% of the nights in 2020 and 100% of the nights in 2021, the City of Grants Pass had zero secular shelter beds for non -intoxicated adults. Given that reality, there was no need to make "downstream changes" to the analysis based on the availability of shelter beds in the City of Grants Pass. When a jurisdiction has zero shelter beds even theoretically available, it does not require significant analysis to conclude the jurisdiction is barred from prosecuting the involuntarily homeless persons in that jurisdiction. Judge M. Smith's refusal to acknowledge the lack of shelter space in the City of Grants Pass reveals his actual complaint in this area is the perceived failure to strictly police who will qualify as involuntarily homeless. According to Judge M. Smith, it was inappropriate to find that zero shelter beds, combined with "conclusory allegations of involuntariness," were enough to conclude there were involuntarily homeless persons in the jurisdiction. The "conclusory allegations" Judge M. Smith faults are expressly found in a declaration submitted by Gloria Johnson where she stated, in relevant part, "I have no choice but to live outside and have no place else to go," and "I continue to live without shelter in Grants Pass." It bears repeating this case was resolved on summary judgment. The City of Grants Pass did not present any evidence to the 250 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRASTsof 155 97 district court, nor did it argue on appeal, that Gloria Johnson's declaration was inaccurate. In fact, it is undisputed there are at least fifty involuntarily homeless persons in the City of Grants Pass, as stated in the testimony of a City of Grants Pass police officer. Describing unequivocal and undisputed statements submitted at the summary judgment stage as mere "conclusory allegations" is incorrect. Judge M. Smith worries the amended opinion might still prohibit any enforcement actions against individuals with access to shelter. But the opinion repeatedly notes it only addresses enforcement attempts against "involuntarily homeless persons." Grants Pass goes to great lengths to make this clear. Grants Pass states individuals qualify as "involuntarily homeless" only if they "do not have access to adequate temporary shelter, whether because they have the means to pay for it or because it is realistically available to them for free." Id. at 793 n.2 (internal quotation marks and citation omitted). To remove any doubt, Grants Pass stresses "[i]ndividuals who have shelter or the means to acquire their own shelter simply are never class members," meaning such individuals are not "involuntarily homeless." Id. at 805. And to further illuminate the point, Grants Pass states "To be clear: A person with access to temporary shelter is not involuntarily homeless unless and until they no longer have access to shelter." Id. at 805 n.24. Judge M. Smith's assertion that Grants Pass might prohibit enforcement against persons "no matter their personal situations" is wrong. When an individual has access to a shelter, such as through a "city's offer of temporary housing," that person is not "involuntarily homeless" and anti -camping ordinances may be enforced against that person. Similarly, if a 251 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 98 JOHNSON V. CTTy OF GRAi` &S®f 155 jurisdiction always has shelter beds or other locations available, that jurisdiction is free to enforce its anti -camping ordinances on all other public areas. Judge M. Smith also claims that after Grants Pass local authorities are "powerless to cite" individuals "even for public defecation."' Neither Martin nor Grants Pass involved particular ordinances precluding public urination and defecation and the assertion that Martin and Grants Pass resolved the constitutionality of ordinances addressing public urination and defecation is mistaken.2 1 Judge M. Smith's sole support for this interpretation is an unpublished decision by the Eastern District of California. Mahoney v. City of Sacramento, No. 2:20-cv-00258-KJM, 2020 WL 616302 (E.D. Cal. Feb. 10, 2020). That case involved the removal of portable toilets from public property that had been placed there by private citizens for homeless individuals to use. The plaintiffs alleged many different constitutional claims, including that the removal of the toilets would violate their Eighth Amendment rights. On that point, the City of Sacramento stated "neither the benefactors of the toilets nor the users of the toilets have, or will be, criminally prosecuted." 1n denying a request for a temporary restraining order, the court stated "Extending Martin to these facts, the City may not prosecute or otherwise penalize the plaintiffs . . . for eliminating in public if there is no alternative to doing so." Id. The court continued, arguably based on the city's representations regarding non - prosecution, that "no irreparable injury to plaintiffs' Eighth Amendment rights is likely." Id. Because the plaintiffs voluntarily dismissed their claim nine days after the court's order, the court did not provide a more complete Eighth Amendment analysis based on Martin. A brief statement made in the context of resolving an emergency motion is not a solid foundation for Judge M. Smith's assertion that after Grants Pass local authorities are now "powerless to cite" individuals for public defecation. z The focus of Martin and Grants Pass was sleep. Sleep is not a voluntary act but an '`identifiable human need[]." Rico v. Ducart, 980 F.3d 1292, 1298 (9th Cir. 2020). "[S]leep is critical to human existence." 252 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRAi` SS®f 155 99 As another panel recently noted, it is unwise "to adjudicate slippery -slope hypotheticals." Mayes v. Biden, No. 22-15518, 2023 WL 2997037, at * 17 (9th Cir. Apr. 19, 2023). And Judge O'Scannlain noted almost twenty years ago, "[i]n our system of government, courts base decisions not on dramatic Hollywood fantasies ... but on concretely particularized facts developed in the cauldron of the adversary process and reduced to an assessable record." United States v. Kincade, 379 F.3d 813, 838 (9th Cir. 2004) (en banc). Because there was no challenge to any public urination or defecation ordinances in Grants Pass, the parties did not develop a record regarding those issues such that neither the district court nor Ninth Circuit had a basis to address them. Judge M. Smith's assertion that Grants Pass prohibits citations "even for public defecation" is wrong. II. Class Certification was Proper Connected to the purported "jurisdiction -wide analysis," Judge M. Smith argues, as did the dissent by Judge Collins, that Grants Pass erred in affirming certification of the class. Walker v. Schult, 717 F.3d 119, 126 (2d Cir. 2013). See also Wilkins Kaplan & Sadock's Comprehensive Textbook of Psychiatry, loth Ed. CH23 ("Sleep is a process required for proper brain function. Failure to sleep impairs thought processes, mood regulation, and a host of normal physiological functions."). The lack of sleep may play a role in the development of dementia. See Nedergaard and Goldman, Glymphatic failure as a final common pathway to dementia, available at https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8186542/. And long- term sleep deprivation has been shown to be lethal in some animals. See Why Severe Sleep Deprivation Can be Lethal, available at http s: //brain.harvard.edu/hbi_news/why-severe-sleep-deprivation-can- be- lethal/#:—:text=We%20found%20high%201eveIs%20of,can%20eventua fly%20trigger%20ce1 l %20death. 253 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 100 JOHNSON V. CTTy OF GRIVGS®f 155 According to Judge M. Smith, the opinion "wholly collaps[es] the merits into the class definition" which resulted in an "impermissible fail safe class." The Grants Pass opinion explains why that conclusion is wrong. 50 F.4th at 805 n.23. In brief, the population of the class of "involuntarily homeless" individuals does not change based on whether the class wins or loses. There has never been a possibility that a "class member either wins or, by virtue of losing, is defined out of the class." Olean Wholesale Grocery Coop., Inc. v. Bumble Bee Foods LLC, 31 F.4th 651, 669 n.14 (9th Cir. 2022) (quotation marks and citation omitted). Judge M. Smith, as did Judge Collins, also believes the class should not have been certified due to a "lack of commonality." Judge M. Smith's view is that "commonality" was lacking because determining class membership requires an individualized assessment of each potential class member's access to shelter. This is an incorrect understanding of Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23's "commonality" requirement. To satisfy Rule 23's "commonality" requirement there must be a "common contention" such "that determination of its truth or falsity will resolve an issue that is central to the validity of each one of the claims in one stroke." Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. v. Dukes, 564 U.S. 338, 350 (2011). In Grants Pass, the "common contention" was the assertion that the City's anti -camping ordinances violated the Eighth Amendment as applied to the class. That contention could be resolved in "one stroke," meaning the "commonality" requirement was met. Dukes, 564 U.S. at 350. While not entirely clear, Judge M. Smith might be arguing "commonality" does not exist when a court is unable 254 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRIZtS®f 155 101 to immediately and easily identify each and every class member. But there has never been such a requirement. See In re Google Inc. St. View Elec. Commc'ns Litig., 21 F.4th 1102, 1115 (9th Cir. 2021) (affirming class settlement despite it being "not feasible" to identify class members). Alternatively, Judge M. Smith might be arguing "commonality" does not exist when some effort will be required to identify class members. But it is entirely routine for class actions to require individualized determinations to identify class members. For example, a recent Ninth Circuit opinion involved a class defined as "All individuals who have worked as California -based flight attendants of Virgin America, Inc. while residing in California at any time during the Class Period." Bernstein v. Virgin Am., Inc., 3 FAth 1127, 1134 (9th Cir. 2021). Identifying members of that class necessarily required individualized determinations to identify whether an individual had worked as a flight attendant for Virgin America and where the individual had lived throughout the multi -year class period. Judge M. Smith's view that "commonality" is not present whenever class members can only be identified after an individualized inquiry would preclude certification of most classes. III. Eighth Amendment Doctrine Judge O'Scannlain laments "Grants Pass never meaningfully engaged the text, history, and tradition of the Constitution." For the most part, that criticism is misplaced as the Grants Pass majority was bound to follow Martin. More importantly, however, the present record does not contain sufficient facts to conduct the analysis Judge O'Scannlain wishes to perform, presumably because the parties were aware Judge O'Scannlain's preferred method of 255 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 102 JOHNSON V. CTTy OF GRIZZS®f 155 analysis is foreclosed by long established precedent. The historical inquiry regarding the meaning of constitutional terms may require looking as far back as the 13th Century. See Dobbs v. Jackson Women 's Health Org., 142 S. Ct. 2228, 2249 (2022) (discussing cases from 13th century). The parties in Grants Pass did not gather and present evidence regarding centuries of history to illuminate the complete "text, history, and tradition" of the Eighth Amendment. If, as Judge O'Scannlain believes, courts must assess the Eighth Amendment exclusively under a "text, history, and tradition" approach, the parties must be given the opportunity to present relevant historical evidence. See United States v. Sineneng-Smith, 140 S. Ct. 1575, 1579 (2020) (noting courts should follow "party presentation principle"). That may require the parties retain experts. See, e.g., Miller v. Smith, No. 22-1482, 2023 WL 334788, at *I (7th Cir. Jan. 20, 2023) (remanding for district court to solicit additional expert reports regarding "text, history, and tradition framework" in Second Amendment case). Notably, Judge O'Scannlain is not arguing Grants Pass should be remanded for a proper inquiry under his proposed "text, history, and tradition" test. Rather, he professes he has conducted the relevant inquiry on his own and definitively established the correct interpretation of centuries of history. Our adversarial system takes a dim view of appellate courts embarking on their own fact-finding missions. Alpha Distrib. Co. of California v. Jack Daniel Distillery, 454 F.2d 442, 453 (9th Cir. 1972) ("The appellate court is not the trier of facts and does not ordinarily make findings of fact."). And that is especially true when the inquiry has not been briefed by the parties. Sineneng-Smith, 140 S. Ct. at 1579 (2020). Ultimately, however, Judge O'Scannlain's favored constitutional analysis is beside the point. The Supreme 256 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRIZ41S®f 1 55 103 Court has made clear "text, history, and tradition" is not the correct method when assessing Eighth Amendment claims. According to the Supreme Court, the proper interpretation of the Eighth Amendment does not turn exclusively on standards from hundreds of years ago. In a plurality opinion in 1958, the Supreme Court explained the Eighth Amendment "must draw its meaning from the evolving standards of decency that mark the progress of a maturing society." Trop v. Dulles, 356 U.S. 86, 101 (1958) (plurality opinion). More recently, the Supreme Court stated a proper Eighth Amendment analysis "is determined not by the standards that prevailed when the Eighth Amendment was adopted in 1791 but by the norms that `currently prevail."' Kennedy v. Louisiana, 554 U.S. 407, 419 (2008) (citation omitted). And "courts must look beyond historical conceptions" when assessing Eighth Amendment challenges. Graham v. Florida., 560 U.S. 48, 58 (2010). Given this guidance, lamenting Grants Pass did not delve into the Eighth Amendment's "text, history, and tradition" is a complaint that the majority in Grants Pass followed the Supreme Court's settled guidance. Contrary to Judge O'Scannlain, the majority in Grants Pass was not free to ignore the Supreme Court, embark on its own fact-finding mission, and conclude the correct interpretation of the Eighth Amendment is the one Judge O'Scannlain likes. Instead, the majority chose the more modest approach of applying existing Supreme Court and Ninth Circuit authority to the record presented by the parties.3 Judge Graber agrees with the "underlying legal premise" that the Eighth Amendment prohibits criminal prosecution of involuntarily homeless persons. But she believes Grants Pass "unjustifiably expands the reach of the Eighth Amendment" by prohibiting "civil remedies that could, in 257 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 104 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRIV4s®f 155 IV. Application of Marks Doctrine Both Judge O'Scannlain and Judge M. Smith take issue with the Marks v. United States, 430 U.S. 188 (1977), analysis in Martin and Grants Pass. According to them, the proper application of the Marks doctrine is obvious and should have prevented the result in Martin and Grants Pass. It is not clear if the Marks analyses conducted by Judge O'Scannlain and Judge M. Smith reach the same conclusion.' Moreover, neither Judge O'Scannlain nor Judge M. Smith cite the en banc majority opinion from the Fourth Circuit that conducts the Marks analysis on the relevant Supreme Court authorities and reaches the "same conclusion" as that reached in Martin. Manning v. Caldwell for City of Roanoke, 930 F.3d 264, 283 n.17 (4th Cir. 2019) (en banc). Thus, Judge O'Scannlain and Judge M. Smith show overconfidence that their application of the Marks doctrine is correct. In the end, however, an exhaustive theory, lead to [criminal] prosecution." But all parties in Grants Pass agreed the civil violations were used as the first step in the eventual pursuit of criminal charges. This is not a case where the jurisdiction has disavowed pursuing criminal charges. 4 Judge O'Scannlain describes Justice White's concurrence in Powell v. Texas, 392 U.S. 514 (1968), as "the dispositive fifth vote." But Judge O'Scannlain also relies heavily, without explanation, on statements made by the non -binding plurality in Powell. As for Judge M. Smith, he argues Powell produced "no single rationale and only its specific result is binding." But Judge M. Smith then faults the Martin and Grants Pass majorities for not addressing arguments made by the non -binding plurality in Powell. Judge M. Smith seems to believe proper application of the Marks doctrine means only the result in Powell is binding, but lower courts have an affirmative obligation to address points made by the Powell plurality. Judge M. Smith does not cite any authority for his idiosyncratic view of how the Marks doctrine operates. 258 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRIVSS®f 1 55 105 Marks analysis is not necessary. Everyone agrees Robinson v. California, 370 U.S. 660 (1962) is the binding Supreme Court precedent. It is vital that every justice in Powell v. State of Texas, 392 U.S. 514 (1968), fully embraced the holding in Robinson that a status cannot be prosecuted. In Robinson, the Supreme Court concluded it violated the Eighth Amendment for California to criminalize the status of being "addicted to the use of narcotics." In doing so, the Supreme Court also noted it would violate the Eighth Amendment for a state to make it a criminal offense to be "mentally ill, or a leper, or to be afflicted with a venereal disease." Robinson, 370 U.S. at 666. And "[e]ven one day in prison would be a cruel and unusual punishment for the `crime' of having a common cold." Id. at 667. Judge O'Scannlain and Judge M. Smith interpret Robinson as establishing a conclusive line between constitutionally barred "status crimes" and constitutionally permitted "conduct crimes." But such a definitive line requires Robinson be read rigidly, such that a jurisdiction could avoid Robinson by tying "statuses" to inescapable human activities. For example, under a strict "status -conduct" distinction, the California statute at issue in Robinson could have been cured by tying the addiction status to sleeping. Under such logic, it would have been constitutional for California to make it a criminal offense for a person "addicted to the use of narcotics" to fall asleep. Id. at 660. Similarly, it now would be constitutional for a jurisdiction to criminalize falling asleep while being "mentally ill, or a leper, or [] afflicted with a venereal disease." Id. at 666. Reading 259 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 106 JOHNSON V. CTTy OF GRIVSS®f 155 Robinson as allowing such simple evasion is absurd.-' Regardless of the Marks analysis, Robinson limits the reach of criminal law. Or, as the Supreme Court declared fifteen years after Robinson, the Eighth Amendment "imposes substantive limits on what can be made criminal and punished as such." Ingraham v. Wright, 430 U.S. 651, 667 (1977). Martin and Grants Pass recognize those substantive limits reach the exceptionally narrow situation of prohibiting punishment when involuntarily homeless persons engage in the life -sustaining act of sleeping in public. Criminalizing the act of sleeping in public when an individual has nowhere else to sleep is, in effect, criminalizing the underlying status of being homeless. V. Non -Existent Circuit Split Judge O' Scannlain greatly overstates the extent to which Martin and Grants Pass fall on one side of an existing circuit split. According to Judge O'Scannlain, no "federal circuit or state supreme court ... has ever embraced Grants Pass's sweeping holding" regarding the Eighth Amendment. Judge O' Scannlain then cites opinions from the Eleventh and Fifth Circuits, but neither of those opinions hold what Judge O' Scannlain claims. In fact, no circuit court has reached the merits of a challenge to public camping or sleeping s Even the dissent in the Fourth Circuit opinion Judge O'Scannlain cites with approval understood the logic of Robinson points away from a rigid interpretation. Manning v. Caldwell for City ofRoanoke, 930 F.3d 264, 290 (4th Cir. 2019) (Wilkinson, J., dissenting). That dissent noted "[i]n the rare case where the Eighth Amendment was found to invalidate a criminal law, the law in question sought to punish persons merely for their need to eat or sleep, which are essential bodily functions. This is simply a variation of Robinson's command that the state identify conduct in crafting its laws, rather than punish a person's mere existence." Id. Mi Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRIWAS®f 155 107 restrictions when no shelter space was available and concluded such restrictions were lawful. Judge O'Scannlain also points to a state supreme court opinion but that opinion explicitly does not decide the question presented in Martin and Grants Pass. First, in Joel v. City of Orlando, 232 F.3d 1353 (1 lth Cir. 2000), the Eleventh Circuit addressed a challenge to an anti - camping ordinance. The entire Eighth Amendment analysis in that case was premised on the fact the City of Orlando "presented unrefuted evidence that . . . a large homeless shelter ... never reached its maximum capacity and that no individual has been turned away because there was no space available or for failure to pay the one dollar nightly fee." Id. at 1362. Thus, the Eleventh Circuit concluded the anti - sleeping ordinance did "not criminalize involuntary behavior" because the plaintiff could "comply with the [anti - sleeping] ordinance" by sleeping in the shelter. Id. There is no suggestion the result would have been the same if there were no shelter space available. Judge O'Scannlain claims the availability of shelter space is not a "compelling response" in terms of distinguishing the result in Joel from that in Martin and Grants Pass. But the central holding in Martin and Grants Pass is that the Eighth Amendment analysis turns on whether there are shelter beds or other locations where an involuntarily homeless person can lawfully sleep. It would be hard to imagine a more "compelling" way to distinguish Joel than pointing out Joel did not involve involuntary conduct because shelter space was always available. Judge O'Scannlain also cites Johnson v. City of Dallas, Tex., 61 F.3d 442 (5th Cir. 1995), where the Fifth Circuit concluded the plaintiffs lacked standing to challenge an anti- 261 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 108 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRIV&S®f 155 sleeping ordinance because they had not been prosecuted. The district court had conducted an extensive overview of the Supreme Court cases and concluded the challenged anti - sleeping ordinance impermissibly "punishe[d] the homeless for their status as homeless." Johnson v. City of Dallas, 860 F. Supp. 344, 350 (N.D. Tex. 1994). Instead of rejecting or even addressing such reasoning, the Fifth Circuit concluded no individual had standing to seek pre -enforcement review of a criminal statute. It is not clear whether Judge O'Scannlain agrees with this standing analysis and there is significant reason to doubt it is correct. See, e.g., Holder v. Humanitarian L. Project, 561 U.S. 1, 15 (2010) (allowing "preenforcement review of a criminal statute"). But at the very least, it is misleading to describe the Fifth Circuit's rejection based on standing as establishing any position on the merits of the Eighth Amendment issue.6 6 Judge O' Scannlain also professes to find conflicting decisions from the First and Seventh Circuits. In the First Circuit case, the defendant argued "because his drug addiction is a disease, sentencing him to a term of imprisonment for manifesting a condition of his disease constitutes cruel and unusual punishment in violation of the Eighth Amendment." United States v. Sirois, 898 F.3d 134, 135 (1st Cir. 2018). The First Circuit rejected this argument, primarily because the standard of review was "clear error" based on the defendant's failure to raise the argument in the district court. Thus, the First Circuit held only that existing caselaw did not make it "clear or obvious" that "the Eighth Amendment proscribes criminal punishment for conduct that results from narcotic addiction." Id. at 138. Concluding existing caselaw did not make the issue "clear or obvious" is not the same as reaching the merits of the issue. As for the Seventh Circuit opinion, it is unpublished and is based on an obvious error. The opinion discusses a defendant who, allegedly due to his alcoholism, "failed to attend treatment programs, used cocaine, and abused alcohol so excessively that it led to his arrest for public intoxication." United States v. Stenson, 475 Fed. App'x 630, 631 (7th Cir. 2012). The Seventh Circuit concluded the defendant could be 262 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRjV9KS0f 155 109 Judge O' Scannlain also cites Tobe v. City of Santa Ana, 892 P.2d 1145 (1995) from the California Supreme Court. That case involved a facial challenge to an anti -camping ordinance. Id. at 1154. The California Supreme Court explicitly noted, however, it was not resolving whether an "involuntarily homeless person who involuntarily camps on public property may be convicted or punished under the ordinance." Id. at 1166 n.19. Claiming Tobe is contrary to Grants Pass requires ignoring the language of Tobe. Finally, Judge O'Scannlain does not disclose that reaching his preferred result would create a circuit split with the Fourth Circuit. In Manning v. Caldwell for City of Roanoke, 930 F.3d 264, 268 (4th Cir. 2019) (en bane), the en bane Fourth Circuit addressed Virginia's statutory scheme that made it a criminal offense for individuals identified as "habitual drunkards" to possess or attempt to possess alcohol. The Fourth Circuit concluded this scheme might violate the Eighth Amendment's Cruel and Unusual Punishments clause because it targeted "conduct that is both compelled by [the plaintiffs] illness and is otherwise lawful for all those of legal drinking age." Id. at 281. In reaching that conclusion, the Fourth Circuit unequivocally adopted the same view of the Supreme Court cases regarding status crimes as that adopted in Martin. 930 F.3d at 282 n.17. Judge O' Scannlain acknowledges that Manning holds "involuntary conduct may be exempt" from prosecution. punished for those acts because he was not being "punished for his status as an alcoholic but for his conduct." Id. However, as noted by the Fourth Circuit, the Seventh Circuit "erroneously treated the plurality opinion in Powell as the holding of the Court." Manning v. Caldwell for City of Roanoke, 930 F.3d 264, 283 n.l 7 (4th Cir. 2019). Therefore, Stenson is of little value. 263 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 110 JOHNSON V. CTTy OF GRUGsof 155 But he argues Manning "limited its holding to laws that singled individuals out for special punishment for otherwise lawful conduct that is compelled by their illness." Judge O'Scannlain apparently believes the ordinances addressed in Grants Pass do not "single out" individuals in a similar manner. Judge O'Scannlain is wrong. The ordinances addressed in Grants Pass target the involuntarily homeless the same way the scheme in Manning targeted alcoholics. Under the ordinances addressed in Grants Pass, it would be lawful for an individual with access to shelter to wrap himself in a blanket in a public park because the individual was not using the blanket "for the purpose of maintaining a temporary place to live." 50 F.4th at 793. However, the same conduct could lead to criminal prosecution of an involuntarily homeless person because, with no other place to live, the person would be using the blanket for purposes of maintaining a place to live. In brief, blanket use in a public park is criminal if you are homeless and "lawful conduct" if you are not. As with the ordinances in Manning regarding alcoholics, the ordinances addressed in Grants Pass single out the involuntarily homeless for criminalization of otherwise lawful conduct. Judge O' Scannlain's purported "deep and varied intercircuit split over how to read the Eighth Amendment" is an illusion. The Ninth Circuit is the sole circuit to have addressed, on the merits, a challenge to the criminalization of sleeping in public by involuntarily homeless persons. The Ninth Circuit's current approach is faithful to Supreme Court precedent and consistent with the Fourth Circuit's approach to a similar issue. Thus, Judge O' Scannlain's desire to hear Grants Pass en banc is so that a circuit split with the Fourth Circuit can be created, not that an existing circuit split can be resolved. 264 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GR14tsof 155 111 VI. Evidence Not in the Record Judge M. Smith cites a wide variety of extra -record evidence establishing homelessness is a serious issue "caused by a complex mix of economic, mental -health, and substance -abuse factors." Everyone agrees. Judge M. Smith then states, "local governments have taken a variety of steps intended to ameliorate the crisis . . . but most of these attempts to mitigate the challenging issues of homelessness have been wholly or partially frustrated by an alleged constitutional right conjured by a panel of our court." This appears to say that, but for Martin and now Grants Pass, local governments would be able to pursue policies that would reduce the homeless population. In other words, Judge M. Smith believes Martin and Grants Pass are somewhat responsible for the size of the homeless population. That is not sensible. Judge M. Smith points out the City of Los Angeles has roughly 70,000 homeless persons. Judge M. Smith seems to believe at least some of those 70,000 persons, and more throughout the Ninth Circuit, remain homeless because of the very limited protection offered by Martin. Thus, it follows that if Martin were overruled and criminal penalties were again possible, at least some of those 70,000 persons in Los Angeles would obtain housing. Judge M. Smith does not cite any authority that shows the possibility of criminal penalties would have this effect. Available evidence points away from such a conclusion. See, e.g., Donald Saelinger, Nowhere to Go: The Impacts of City Ordinances Criminalizing Homelessness, 13 Geo. J. on Poverty L. & Pol'y 545, 559 (2006) ("[C]riminalization laws make it much more difficult for the homeless to gain social and economic mobility, and thus the laws have the result of extending the period of time that one is homeless."). 265 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 112 JOHNSONV. CTTY OF GR142sof 155 Judge M. Smith's extra -record evidence is carefully limited to support his causal theory. But if extra -record evidence should be considered, other jurisdictions show Martin is not the problem. New York City is experiencing a crisis in the increase of the involuntarily homeless population. As of February 2023, New York City had more than 77,000 homeless persons, "by far the most ever recorded and an increase of over 70 percent since May." Emma G. Fitzsimmons and Andy Newman, New York City Commissioner Of Social Services Resigns, The New York Times (Feb. 8, 2023). New York City is not in the Ninth Circuit and it seems unlikely the holding in Martin is causing a surge in the homeless population across the country. Thus, Martin is not, as alleged, the driver of the homelessness problem. VII. Conclusion The Eighth Amendment "imposes substantive limits on what can be made criminal and punished as such." Ingraham v. Wright, 430 U.S. 651, 667 (1977). Those substantive limits are implicated only in rare circumstances. One such circumstance is when a jurisdiction attempts to punish as a criminal offense the life -sustaining act of sleeping in public with bedding when a person has nowhere else to go. Because Grants Pass and Martin provide exceptionally limited protection, and are consistent with Supreme Court precedent, the decision not to rehear Grants Pass en banc is correct. 7 The city ordinances addressed in Grants Pass will be superseded, to some extent, on July 1, 2023, when a new Oregon state law takes effect. The new state law requires "[a]ny city or county law that regulates the acts of sitting, lying, sleeping or keeping warm and dry outdoors on public property that is open to the public must be objectively reasonable ME Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTv OF GR143sof 155113 O' SCANNLAIN, Circuit Judge, I with whom Judges WALLACE, CALLAHAN, BEA, IKUTA, BENNETT, R. NELSON, BADE, COLLINS, LEE, BRESS, FORREST, BUMATAY, and VANDYKE join, and with whom Judge M. SMITH joins as to all parts except Part II -A, respecting the denial of rehearing en bane: With this decision, our Circuit's jurisprudence now effectively guarantees a personal federal constitutional `right' for individuals to camp or to sleep on sidewalks and in parks, playgrounds, and other public places in defiance of traditional health, safety, and welfare laws —a dubious holding premised on a fanciful interpretation of the Eighth Amendment. We are the first and only federal circuit to have divined such a strange and sweeping mandate from the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause. Our jurisprudence in this case is egregiously flawed and deeply damaging —at war with constitutional text, history, and tradition, and Supreme Court precedent. And it conflicts with other circuits on a question of exceptional importance —paralyzing local as to time, place and manner with regards to persons experiencing homelessness." Or. Rev. Stat. Ann. § 195.530(2). The statute specifies that "[k]eeping warm and dry means using measures necessary for an individual to survive outdoors given the environmental conditions" but it "does not include any measure that involves fire or flame." Or. Rev. Stat. Ann. § 195.530(1)(b)(B). This change in state law is yet another reason why it was wise to not rehear Grants Pass. 1 As a judge of this court in senior status, i no longer have the power to vote on calls for rehearing cases en bane or formally to join a dissent from failure to rehear en bane. See 28 U.S.C. § 46(c); Fed. R. App. P. 35(a). Following our court's general orders, however, i may participate in discussions of en bane proceedings. See Ninth Circuit General Order 5.5(a). 267 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 114 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GR144sof 155 communities from addressing the pressing issue of homelessness, and seizing policymaking authority that our federal system of government leaves to the democratic process. We should have reheard this case en banc to reconsider our unfortunate constitutional mistake. I Instead of respecting constitutional "text, history, and precedent," Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Org., 142 S. Ct. 2228, 2271 (2022), our Eighth Amendment jurisprudence here has disrupted the "paramount role of the States in setting `standards of criminal responsibility,"' Kahler v. Kansas, 140 S. Ct. 1021, 1028 (2020) (quoting Powell v. Texas, 392 U.S. 514, 533 (1968) (plurality)). In my view, our cases do not inspire confidence that we have faithfully followed the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause —and it is worth explaining how we got here before considering why we should have reheard Grants Pass en banc to fix our constitutional mistakes. See Martin v. City of Boise, 920 F.3d 584, 603 (9th Cir. 2019) (inventing the doctrine); Johnson v. City of Grants Pass, 50 F.4th 787 (9th Cir. 2022) (expanding the doctrine). 0 Our untenable jurisprudence here started in Boise — where a three judge panel first invented a federal constitutional `right' (rooted in the Eighth Amendment, of all places!) to sleep on public property. In Boise, six homeless individuals alleged that the City of Boise, Idaho, had violated their constitutional rights by enforcing municipal ordinances that prohibited unauthorized sleeping on sidewalks and in parks, plazas, and other public places. Even though the Eighth Amendment, on its own terms, only prohibits "cruel and unusual punishments," U.S. Const. Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRa Ssof 155115 amend. VIII, the Boise panel went where no federal circuit had gone before —holding that the Eighth Amendment prohibited a local government from "prosecuting people criminally" for the "involuntary act" of "sleeping outside on public property [including sidewalks] when those people have no home or other shelter to go to." Boise, 920 F.3d at 603, 613, 616 (cleaned up). In doing so, the Boise panel made no effort to ground its decision in the text, history, or tradition of the Eighth Amendment. Instead —after failing to identify a single Supreme Court precedent blessing its approach —the Boise panel attempted to fashion its preferred constitutional rule by stitching together dicta in a lone concurrence with a dissent. Id. at 616 (holding that these separate, unprevailing writings in Powell "compel[led]" Boise's result). While we declined to rehear Boise en banc, see id. at 590-99 (M. Smith, J., dissental) (explaining Boise's misconstruction of Supreme Court precedent); id. at 599-603 (Bennett, J., dissental) (articulating Boise's inconsistency with the Eighth Amendment), our mistake in Boise has (fortunately) not been replicated in other circuits —and, as I have already stated, we remain the only federal court of appeals to have recognized an individual constitutional `right' to sleep or to camp on sidewalks and other public property. I: Unfortunately, the problems created by Boise have now been visited upon the City of Grants Pass by the panel majority here, which has expanded Boise's faulty holding to affirm an injunction effectively requiring the City to resign all but one of its public parks to be used as homeless Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 116 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GR146+sof 155 encampments. See Grants Pass, 50 F.4th at 792-93, 813.2 In this case, several individuals sought to represent a putative class of all involuntarily homeless people living in Grants Pass, seeking a permanent injunction barring the enforcement of municipal ordinances that prohibited unauthorized sleeping or camping in public spaces. Id. at 792-94 (explaining that violating the challenged public - sleeping, public -camping, and park -exclusion ordinances could result in civil citations and fines, that repeat violators could be excluded from specified City property, and that violating an exclusion order could subject a violator to criminal trespass prosecution). The district court sided with the challengers —and it certified a class consisting of "[a]ll involuntarily homeless individuals living in Grants Pass," and held that the City's enforcement of the public -sleeping and public -camping ordinances violated the Eighth Amendment. Id. at 795-97. 1 A divided panel of our Court affirmed in all "material Z The cities of Boise and Grants Pass are, regrettably, not the only victims of our Eighth Amendment jurisprudence here —a point that is not to be celebrated. See, e.g., Fund for Empowerment v. City of Phoenix, No. CV-22-02041-PHX-GMS, 2022 WL 18213522 (D. Ariz. Dec. 16, 2022) (applying Boise); Coal. on Homelessness v. City & Cnty. of San Francisco, No. 22-CV-05502-DMR, 2022 WL 17905114 (N.D. Cal. Dec. 23, 2022) (applying Grants Pass). While our mistaken jurisprudence in this area has some limits, see Grants Pass, 50 F.4th at 812 n.33, we should not pretend that the jurisprudential experiment started by Boise and expanded by Grants Pass —which "effectively strikes down the anti -camping and anti -sleeping [o]rdinances ... of countless, if not all, cities within our jurisdiction," Boise, 920 F.3d at 599 (M. Smith, J., dissental)—is "narrow," contra id. at 617 (majority opinion); Grants Pass, 50 F.4th at 813. 240 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTv OF GRa Tsof 155117 aspects of this case." Id. at 793. After concluding that class certification was proper, the panel majority held, following Boise, that the City could not enforce the public -camping and park -exclusion ordinances against "involuntarily homeless persons" for the "mere act of sleeping" or camping in public spaces when "there is no other place in the City for them to go." Id. at 798 & n.12, 813 (remanding, inter alia, on the public -sleeping ordinance because the relevant plaintiff had died). It also expanded Boise by holding that the City could not deprive persons of whatever materials they needed "to keep ... warm and dry," and by extending Boise from the purely criminal arena to civil fines and citations. Id. at 806-09. In doing so, the panel majority — content to rest on Boise's tortured reading of Supreme Court precedent, see id. at 808-11—declined to devote any serious attention to the text, history, or tradition of the Eighth Amendment. 2 Judge Collins dissented. Id. at 814-31. He explained, inter alia, that the case should be reheard en bane because the panel majority decision combined a "gross misreading of [Boise] with a flagrant disregard of settled class -certification principles," and because "the foundation on which [the panel majority decision] is built is deeply flawed: [Boise] seriously misconstrued the Eighth Amendment and the Supreme Court's caselaw construing it." Id. at 814, n.1. In his view, Boise has "`generate[d] dire practical consequences for the hundreds of local governments within our jurisdiction,"' and those harms will be "greatly magnified by the egregiously flawed reconceptualization and extension of [Boise's] holding." Id. at 831 (quoting Boise, 920 F.3d at 594 (M. Smith, J., dissental)). 241 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 118 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GR149sof 155 II There is a simple reason why we should have reheard Grants Pass en bane: it entrenches a deeply damaging and egregiously wrong construction of the Eighth Amendment in our Circuit's precedent. An "erroneous interpretation" of the Constitution is "always important." Dobbs, 142 S. Ct. at 2265. But some judicial mistakes are "more damaging" than others —and "more than just wrong." Id. at 2265-66. The novel and expansive jurisprudence entrenched by Grants Pass —which thumbs its nose at the "standard grounds for constitutional decisionmaking[:] text, history, and precedent" —stands on "exceptionally weak grounds" and "should be overruled." Id. at 2264, 2266, 2271. 0 The first flaw in Grants Pass's jurisprudence is that it conflicts with the text, history, and tradition of the Eighth Amendment —which demonstrate that the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause does not establish a federal constitutional "doctrine[] of criminal responsibility." Kahler, 140 S. Ct. at 1028 (cleaned up). Constitutional text, history, and tradition make plain that the Clause was directed to modes of punishment —and that it was never intended to arrogate the substantive authority of legislatures to prohibit "acts" like those at issue here, and "certainly not before conviction." Boise, 920 F.3d at 602 (Bennett, J., dissental). Indeed, one might question whether the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause has anything to do with the jurisprudence embraced by Grants Pass —which authorizes a plaintiff who has never been assigned a "punishment," let alone one that is "cruel and unusual," to challenge traditional anti -vagrancy regulations under the Clause. It is regrettable that Grants Pass never meaningfully engaged the text, 242 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTv OF GR149sof 155 , , 9 history, and tradition of the Constitution —which are the "standard grounds for constitutional decisionmaking." Dobbs, 142 S. Ct. at 2271 ("text, history, and precedent"); see, e.g., Ingraham v. Wright, 430 U.S. 651, 664 (1977) ("history" and precedent); Kennedy v. Louisiana, 554 U.S. 407, 421 (2008) ("text, history, meaning, and purpose"); see also, e.g., Kennedy v. Bremerton Sch. Dist., 142 S. Ct. 2407, 2428 (2022) ("historical practices and understandings" (cleaned up)); New York State Rifle & Pistol Ass'n, Inc. v. Bruen, 142 S. Ct. 2111, 2128-29 (2022) ("text and history"); Washington v. Glucksberg, 521 U.S. 702, 721 (1997) ("history and tradition" (cleaned up)). 1 The Eighth Amendment provides, "Excessive bail shall not be required, nor excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted." U.S. Const. amend. VIII (emphasis added). The Amendment's bar on excessive "bail," excessive "fines," and the infliction of cruel and unusual "punishments" indicates the Amendment's punitive focus. And the text of the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause itself provides no substantive limit on what conduct may be punished. Instead, it only prohibits "punishments" (i.e., pain or suffering inflicted for a crime or offense) that are "cruel" (i.e., marked by savagery and barbarity) and "unusual" (i.e., not in common use), reflecting a constitutional prohibition originally and traditionally understood to forbid the government from "authorizing particular forms or `modes' of punishment —specifically, cruel methods of punishment that are not regularly or customarily employed." Harmelin v. Michigan, 501 U.S. 957, 976 (1991) (opinion of Scalia, J.); id. at 979 ("[b]reaking on the wheel," "flaying alive," and "maiming, mutilating, and scourging to death" (cleaned up)). 243 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 120 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GR12GS®f 155 Constitutional text, history, and tradition make clear — contrary to Grants Pass's holding —that the Clause was not originally understood to displace the authority of legislatures to prohibit historically proscribable acts (and certainly not before any punishment was imposed), see Boise, 920 F.3d at 599-603 (Bennett, J., dissental), and that the Clause was not traditionally taken to enshrine a constitutional "doctrine[] of criminal responsibility," Kahler, 140 S. Ct. at 1028 (cleaned up)- 2 Ultimately, the text, history, and tradition of the Eighth Amendment teach a simple truth: the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause —a constitutional prohibition fundamentally centered on modes of punishment —is not a boundless remedy for all social and policy ills, including homelessness. It does not empower us to displace state and local decisionmakers with our own enlightened view of how to address a public crisis over which we can claim neither expertise nor authority, and it certainly does not authorize us to dictate municipal policy here. Given the "centuries -long evolution of the collection of interlocking and overlapping concepts which the common law has utilized to assess the moral accountability of an individual for his antisocial deeds," including the "doctrines of actus reus, mens rea, insanity, mistake, justification, and duress," the "process of adjustment" of the "tension between the evolving aims of the criminal law and changing religious, moral, philosophical, and medical views of the nature of man" has primarily "been thought to be the province of the States." Powell, 392 U.S. at 535-36 (plurality). So long as "the accused has committed some act, has engaged in some behavior, which society has an interest in preventing, or perhaps in historical common law terms, has committed some actus reus," the Eighth 244 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTv OF GRI21AS®f 155 121 Amendment does not prohibit punishing such an act merely "because it is, in some sense, `involuntary' or `occasioned by a compulsion."' Id. at 533. It is troubling that our Circuit —in inventing a new individual `right' unmoored from text, history, or tradition —has twisted the Eighth Amendment to displace the substantive authority of local officials to prohibit a species of antisocial conduct that was neither originally nor traditionally thought to warrant the protection of the Constitution, let alone immunity under the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause. IC The second flaw in Grants Pass's jurisprudence is that it lacks any foundation in the Eighth Amendment doctrine handed down to us by the Supreme Court —which, to be clear, has never accepted Grants Pass's theory that the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause establishes a federal constitutional prohibition on the criminalization of purportedly nonvolitional conduct. While Grants Pass purports faithfully to follow the Supreme Court's decisions in Robinson v. California, 370 U.S. 660 (1962), and Powell v. Texas, 392 U.S. 514 (1968), it actually rests on a plain misreading of the Supreme Court's instructions because it does little more than combine dicta in a solo concurrence with a dissent. In doing so, Grants Pass has clearly erred — embracing a startling misapplication of the Marks doctrine to venture far astray from Supreme Court precedent, see Marks v. United States, 430 U.S. 188, 193 (1977) ("When a fragmented Court decides a case and no single rationale explaining the result enjoys the assent of five Justices, the holding of the Court may be viewed as that position taken by those Members who concurred in the judgments on the narrowest grounds." (cleaned up)). 245 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 122 JOHNSON V. CTTy OF GRI22S®f 155 1 The Supreme Court has never blessed our Circuit's sweeping approach to the Eighth Amendment here —and neither Robinson nor Powell provide any support for Grants Pass's adventurous holding. In Robinson, the Supreme Court first articulated the status -act distinction that should have made this a simple case —holding only that the Eighth Amendment prohibited states from making it a crime "to be addicted to the use of narcotics." Robinson, 370 U.S. at 662 (cleaned up). Unlike laws "punish[ing] a person for the use of narcotics, for their purchase, sale or possession, or for antisocial or disorderly behavior resulting from their administration," the California law invalidated by Robinson punished the mere "status" of narcotics addiction, unmoored from any particular conduct. Id. at 662, 666. The holding of Robinson is simple: the criminal law cannot punish status (e.g., "be[ing] addicted to the use of narcotics"); it can only punish conduct (e.g., "the use of narcotics"). Id. at 662-67 (cleaned up); see Manning v. Caldwell for City of Roanoke, 930 F.3d 264, 288 (4th Cir. 2019) (en banc) (Wilkinson, J., dissenting). The Supreme Court has not wavered from the status -act distinction articulated by Robinson —and Powell is certainly no exception. In Powell, decided soon after Robinson, a fractured Supreme Court upheld a Texas law prohibiting public drunkenness against an Eighth Amendment challenge alleging that the alcoholic's status compelled him to drink in public. Powell, 392 U.S. 514. No controlling majority rejected the status -act line drawn by Robinson: (1) Justice Marshall's four justice plurality upheld the statute based on Robinson's status -act distinction, id. at 516-37 (plurality); (2) Justice White's lone concurrence (the dispositive fifth vote) upheld the statute because it involved a volitional act, 246 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTv OF GRI241S®f 155 123 and he declined to determine whether a non -volitional act could be criminalized, id. at 548-54 (White, J., concurring); and (3) Justice Fortas's four justice dissent rejected Robinson's status -act distinction and deemed the statute's enforcement unconstitutional, id. at 554-70 (Fortas, J., dissenting). Because Justice White did not "reach[] the broader question of compulsion, the judgment in Powell neither extended [n]or contracted Robinson, which was left undisturbed." Manning, 930 F.3d at 289 (Wilkinson, J., dissenting). And the Supreme Court has certainly never understood Powell to have such broad effect: it has neither "walked away from Robinson" nor "embraced [Boise's] whole notion of nonvolitional conduct." Id. 2 Nevertheless, Grants Pass —turning to Powell's fractured decision, see Grants Pass, 50 F.4th at 809-11 (contorting Powell and Marks) —attempts to "tease [its] preferred reading from the dicta of a single justice," Manning, 930 F.3d at 290 (Wilkinson, J., dissenting). Grants Pass's distortion of Powell clearly violates Marks — which, as explained, instructs that the Court's holding is "that position taken by those Members who concurred in the judgment[] on the narrowest grounds." Marks, 430 U.S. at 193 (cleaned up). Because no victorious majority in Powell disrupted Robinson's "status -act" distinction or blessed Grants Pass's "involuntary conduct" theory, we are left with nothing more than Grants Pass's attempt to craft its preferred rule by combining dicta in a concurrence with a dissent —which means that Grants Pass is ultimately predicated on a plain Marks violation. Such a fundamental mistake, which directly implicates the limits on an inferior court's authority to circumvent the limits of such controlling precedents, should not remain the law of our Circuit. 247 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 124 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRI24s®f 155 III The fundamental flaws in Grants Pass are sufficient reason to reject its deeply damaging and egregiously wrong interpretation of the Eighth Amendment. But even apart from the constitutional errors entrenched by Grants Pass, there are additional, compelling reasons why this case warranted rehearing en banc. Perhaps most importantly, our expansive interpretation of the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause diverges from other courts on an issue of exceptional importance —and it is telling that we remain the only circuit bold enough to embrace an Eighth Amendment doctrine that effectively requires local communities to surrender their sidewalks and other public places to homeless encampments. 0 The Eighth Amendment jurisprudence undergirding Grants Pass squarely conflicts with decisions from other circuits and other courts. We should not pretend that our Circuit's divination of a personal constitutional `right' to encamp on public property (including sidewalks) is anything but the inventive, judge -made novelty that we all know it to be. 1 The first set of conflicts —which centers on Grants Pass's result —is plain. No federal circuit or state supreme court (not one!) has ever embraced Grants Pass's sweeping holding that the Eighth Amendment prohibits the enforcement of public -camping restrictions (including before any punishment is imposed). Other circuits to consider the issue have uniformly upheld such laws against Eighth Amendment challenges. See Joel v. City of Orlando, 248 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GR12SS®f 155 125 232 F.3d 1353, 1356, 1361-62 (llth Cir. 2000) (upholding public -camping proscription because "[a] distinction exists between applying criminal laws to punish conduct, which is constitutionally permissible, and applying them to punish status, which is not"); see also Johnson v. City of Dallas, 61 F.3d 442, 443-45, n.5 (5th Cir. 1995) (rejecting challenge to public -camping proscription because the prohibition on cruel and unusual punishments is applicable only after prosecution and conviction, and none of the challengers had been "convicted of violating the sleeping in public ordinance" (relying on Ingraham, 430 U.S. at 664)). And no state supreme court has reached the same result as our aberrant decision here. See Tobe v. City of Santa Ana, 892 P.2d 1145, 1166 (Cal. 1995) (upholding public -camping regulation because the "ordinance permits punishment for proscribed conduct, not punishment for status"); Allen v. City of Sacramento, 234 Cal. App. 4th 41, 60 (2015) (upholding public -camping bar because "the Eighth Amendment does not prohibit the punishment of acts," and the "ordinance punishes the act[] of [illegal] camping, ... not homelessness"). No defender of Grants Pass's jurisprudence has provided a compelling response to these decisions, see Boise, 920 F.3d at 617 n.9 (attempting to reconcile Boise with Joel's alternative rationale, but declining to do much else); Grants Pass, 50 FAth 787 (not even attempting this much) —let alone a federal appellate or state supreme court case that has ever reached Grants Pass's result. While Grants Pass has not been replicated elsewhere, aside from a smattering of trial -level dispositions, a decision that stands so far out of step with so many other courts is one that cries out for correction. 2 The second set of conflicts —which relates to Grants 249 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 126 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRI26S®f 155 Pass's rationale —is similarly troublesome. Our approach to the Eighth Amendment in this area conflicts with decisions from the First Circuit, Fourth Circuit, and Seventh Circuit, which embrace several competing tests for determining whether the Eighth Amendment immunizes involuntary conduct. At least two other circuits —the First Circuit and the Seventh Circuit —have flatly rejected the Grants Pass principle that purportedly "involuntary" conduct is exempt from criminal liability under the Eighth Amendment, or that Justice White's lone concurrence in Powell provides the binding opinion that compels such exemptions. See, e.g., United States v. Sirois, 898 F.3d 134, 137-38 (1st Cir. 2018); United States v. Stenson, 475 F. App'x 630, 631 (7th Cir. 2012) (citing United States v. Black, 116 F.3d 198, 200-01 (7th Cir. 1997)); see also supra (collecting cases rejecting Grants Pass's reading of Robinson, Powell, and Ingraham). And the Fourth Circuit —the only circuit that embraces anything like Grants Pass's approach —provides, at best, only mixed support because even though it held that involuntary conduct may be exempt based on dicta in Justice White's lone concurrence, it limited its holding to laws that "singled" individuals "out for special punishment for otherwise lawful conduct that is compelled by their illness." Manning, 930 F.3d at 281 n.14. Our Circuit is, therefore, locked in a deep and varied intercircuit split over how to read the Eighth Amendment in light of Robinson and Powell — and, as explained, we are the only federal court of appeals to have discovered a personal constitutional `right' for individuals to encamp on public property (including sidewalks) in violation of traditional health, safety, and welfare laws, a result that no other federal circuit or state supreme court in the country has been bold enough to replicate. 0 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRI27AS®f 155 127 Grants Pass also presents a question of exceptional practical and institutional importance. The immodest approach to the Eighth Amendment that it embraces is both troubling and dangerous. It undermines the power of state and local governments to address the homelessness crisis. And it arrogates to federal judges authority that the Constitution reserves elsewhere. We should have granted rehearing en bane to stop the damage already being worked by Boise and to stave off the mischiefs that Grants Pass is sure to worsen. It is regrettable that our Circuit has declined to grapple with the consequences of our mistakes. 1 The practical consequences should have been reason enough to reconsider our jurisprudential experiment before it did any more harm to our communities —and before its dangers were exacerbated by Grants Pass. No one reasonably doubts that our existing precedent in Boise has created grave and troubling consequences for the state and local communities within our jurisdiction. And no one meaningfully contests that these harms will be greatly worsened by the doctrinal innovations introduced by Grants Pass. One need only walk through our neighborhoods — through the Tenderloin (San Francisco) or Skid Row (Los Angeles) —to know that our communities are fast coming undone. Tents crowding out sidewalks, needles flooding parks, and rubbish (and worse) marring public squares reflect a threat to the public welfare that should not be taken lightly. Nor do such troubling blights mark an area where we should be eager to throw caution to the wind and to embrace judicial adventurism so far removed from the guardrails set by the Constitution's text and the Supreme 281 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 128 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GR129S®f 155 Court's precedents. Unfortunately, the "Hobson's choice" imposed by our Circuit effectively requires state and local officials to "abandon enforcement of a host of laws regulating public health and safety," Boise, 920 F.3d at 594 (M. Smith, J., dissental)—and, if today's decision is any guide, our precedents will readily be wielded effectively to require jurisdictions throughout our Circuit to surrender the use of many of their public spaces (including sidewalks) to homeless encampments. It is easy enough for us, behind marble walls and sealed doors, to dismiss the consequences of our decisions. But for those who call these communities home —who must live by the criminal violence, narcotics activity, and dangerous diseases that plague the homeless encampments buttressed by our decisions —the consequences of our judicial arrogation are harder to accept. 0) In addition to the practical harms that our jurisprudence creates for our communities, we also should have ended the jurisprudential mistake embraced by Grants Pass as quickly as possible because it "visit[s] structural and institutional damage in so many respects." Manning, 930 F.3d at 305 (Wilkinson, J., dissenting). In particular, the doctrine embraced by Grants Pass puts "judges in policymaking roles reserved largely for legislatures and states." Id. at 297. It erodes "the states' role as separate sovereigns entrusted to define the criminal law within their own borders," and "pushes the Eighth Amendment as a catch-all corrective" for social ills identified by inexpert and unelected judicial officers. Id. Under our federal system, state and local leaders —not distant federal judges —are primarily entrusted with the power and duty to protect the common welfare of 282 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTv OF GR129,S®f 155 129 our towns, cities, and neighborhoods, and to ensure that our streets, squares, and sidewalks remain clean and safe. See United States v. Lopez, 514 U.S. 549, 561 n.3 (1995). The reason for such "legislative responsibility over criminal law is fundamental: the criminal law exists to protect the safety of citizens, and ensuring the safety of the people is one of those things that popular government exists to do." Manning, 930 F.3d at 297 (Wilkinson, J., dissenting). Unfortunately, this has not swayed our Court —with consequences that will sweep well past the troubles visited upon the City of Boise and the City of Grants Pass. IV Grants Pass is a regrettable mistake that entrenches and expands upon previous deeply damaging jurisprudence. While I do not doubt the good faith of my colleagues, it is hard to imagine a jurisprudence that combines so little regard for the sacred words of the Constitution, with so much disregard for the state and local authorities that our constitutional system entrusts as the primary protectors of the health, safety, and welfare of our communities. Our jurisprudence here is flawed —in conflict with the text, history, and tradition of the Eighth Amendment, and the precedents of the Supreme Court. And it splits from other circuits on a question of exceptional importance, working great violence to our constitutional structure and threatening dire consequences for communities within our jurisdiction. It is most regrettable that our Court has failed to rehear this case en banc. 283 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 130 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRIZGS®f 155 GRABER, Senior Circuit Judge, respecting the denial of rehearing en banc: The constitutional limits on a municipality's ability to address the issue of homelessness present an exceptionally important and complex topic. I appreciate the many thoughtful views expressed by my colleagues. I write separately to offer a middle ground. Whether or not the result is dictated by Powell v. Texas, 392 U.S. 514 (1968), the Eighth Amendment almost certainly prohibits criminal punishment of persons who engage in truly involuntary actions such as sleeping. I thus agree with the underlying legal premise of the decisions in Johnson v. City of Grants Pass, 50 F.4th 787 (9th Cir. 2022), and Martin v. City of Boise, 920 F.3d 584 (9th Cir. 2019). Eighth Amendment protection also extends to individualized injunctive relief, such as precluding a municipality from enforcing a particular criminal provision against a specific person, if past actions by the municipality warrant such equitable relief. Our opinion in Martin, though controversial, reached a reasonable result, particularly because Martin emphasized the "narrow" nature of its holding. 920 F.3d at 617. I did not join, and did not agree with, the dissents from denial of rehearing en banc in Martin. In my view, though, the extension of Martin to classwide relief, enjoining civil statutes that may eventually lead to criminal violations but have never resulted in criminal convictions for any named plaintiff, is a step too far from the individualized inquiries inherent both in the Eighth Amendment context and in the context of injunctive relief. A key part of Johnson's reasoning begins with the observation that civil citations could lead to a civil park - exclusion order which, in turn, could lead to a prosecution 284 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRIZIAS®f 155 131 for criminal trespass (but which never has for the named plaintiffs).' Johnson, 50 F.4th at 807-08. The opinion then concludes that, because the Eighth Amendment would prohibit that ultimate prosecution, it also must prohibit the civil citations. Id. I disagree with that double leap in logic. Even assuming that classwide injunctive relief were available against a prosecution for criminal trespass, the Eighth Amendment does not prohibit all civil remedies that could, in theory, lead to such a prosecution. In this way, Johnson unjustifiably expands the reach of the Eighth Amendment. The challenges faced by individuals experiencing homelessness are severe. And the challenges that face municipalities are daunting. When called upon, we have an obligation to ensure that a municipality's efforts to provide for the common health and safety do not violate the Constitution. I agree with the basic legal premise that the Eighth Amendment protects against criminal prosecution of the involuntary act of sleeping, but the injunctive relief in this case goes too far. Moreover, given the widespread nature of the homelessness crisis in our jurisdiction, it is The amended opinion refers to Debra Blake as "a named plaintiff," and the amended opinion states that she was convicted of "Criminal Trespass on City Property." Amended Op. at 28 n.13. Blake unfortunately died. As the opinion elsewhere recognizes, Johnson, 50 FAth at 800-02, she is no longer a named plaintiff. Moreover, Blake's "conviction" is doubly inapt here. First, despite the name of the citation, the conviction was for a violation, not a crime. Second, Blake was cited for being in a closed park, not for violating any of the civil statutes challenged here. The crux of the opinion's analysis is that a civil citation could lead to a criminal misdemeanor conviction under Oregon Revised Statute section 164.245. Johnson, 50 FAth at 807. No evidence in the record suggests that the civil statutes relevant here have caused Blake or any named plaintiff to be convicted of that crime. 285 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 132 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRIZZS®f 155 crucial that we get it right. Our court should have reheard this case en banc. M. SMITH, Circuit Judge, with whom Judges BENNETT, BUMATAY, and VANDYKE join, and with whom Judges IKUTA, R. NELSON, BADE, COLLINS, and BRESS join as to Parts I and II, dissenting from the denial of rehearing en banc: Homelessness is presently the defining public health and safety crisis in the western United States. California, for example, is home to half of the individuals in the entire country who are without shelter on a given night.' In the City of Los Angeles alone, there are roughly 70,000 homeless persons.' There are stretches of the city where one cannot help but think the government has shirked its most basic responsibilities under the social contract: providing public safety and ensuring that public spaces remain open to all. One-time public spaces like parks —many of which provide scarce outdoor space in dense, working-class neighborhoods —are filled with thousands of tents and makeshift structures, and are no longer welcoming to the HUD, The 2022 Annual Homelessness Assessment Report (AHAR) to Congress 16 2022), http s: //www.huduscr. gov/portal /site s/default/fi 1 e s/p df/2022-AHAR- Part-Lpdf. Doug Smith, Rand Survey Finds Homelessness Up 18% in L.A. Hot Spots Where the Official Count Recorded Decreases, L.A. Times (Jan. 26, 2023), https://www.latimcs.com/califomia/story/2023-01-26/rand- survey-finds-homelessness-up- 18-in-l-a-hot-spots-where-the-official- count-recorded-decreases. Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTv OF GRIZ41S®f 155 133 broader community.3 It is a status quo that fails both those in the homeless encampments and those near them. The homeless disproportionately risk being the victims of violence, sexual assault, and drug -related death,' and encampments' unsanitary conditions have caused resurgences of plagues such as typhus, tuberculosis, and hepatitis -A.' For those who live, work, and attend school near these encampments, they have become a source of fear and frustration. A plurality of California residents rate homelessness and the closely related issue of a lack of affordable housing as the See generally Luis Sinco, Photos: An Unflinching Look at Homelessness During the Pandemic (Mar. 8, 2021), https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2021-03-08/homelessness- and-the-pandemic (depicting homeless encampments); L.A. Homeless Servs. Auth., Car, Van, RV/Camper, Tent, and Makeshift Shelter (CVRTM) (2022), https://www.lahsa.org/documents?id=6533-cvrtm- summary-by-geography (estimating the total number of tents and makeshift structures across the City of Los Angeles). a See Gale Holland, Attacked, Abused and Often Forgotten: Women Now Make Up I in 3 Homeless People in L.A. County, L.A. Times (Oct. 28, 2016), https://www.latimes.com/projects/la-me-homeless-women/; Christian Martinez & Rong-Gong Lin 11, L.A. County Homeless Deaths Surged 56% in Pandemic's First Year. Overdoses Are Largely to Blame, L.A. Times (Apr. 22, 2022), https://www.latimes.com/califomia/story/2022-04-22/l a -county - home le s s-de aths-surge-pandemic-overdoses. s Soumya Karlamangla, L.A. Typhus Outbreak Adds Fuel to Debates Over Homelessness and Housing, L.A. Times (Oct. 11, 2018), https://www.latimes.com/local/cal ifornia/la-me-In-typhus-outbreak- 20181011-story.html; Anna Gorman & Kaiser Health News, Medieval Diseases Are Infecting California's Homeless, Atlantic, https://www.thcatiantic.com/hcalth/archive/2019/03/typhus- tuberculosis-medieval-diseases-spreading-homeless/584380/ (last updated Mar. 11, 2019). 287 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 134 JOHNSONV. CTTY OF GRIZ4s®f 155 state's two most pressing issues.' In the City of Los Angeles, a startling 95% of residents view homelessness as a serious or very serious problem, while roughly 40% of residents report that pervasive homelessness makes them no longer feel safe in their own neighborhoods. Homelessness is caused by a complex mix of economic, mental -health, and substance -abuse factors, and appears to resist any easy solution. In recent years, state and local governments have taken a variety of steps intended to ameliorate the crisis: adopting zoning reforms to increase the supply of housing, declaring public emergencies to bypass red tape and more quickly build new public housing, increasing spending on mental -health services, and contracting with hotels and motels to offer temporary housing to those living on the street. Some local governments have also reasonably chosen to couple these longer -term measures with attempts to enforce public - camping bans and other public health measures —but most of these attempts to mitigate the challenging issues of homelessness have been wholly or partially frustrated by an 6 Mark Murray, California Poll: Homelessness Is Most Urgent Issue in the State, NBC News (Mar. 1, 2023), https://www.nbcnews.com/meet- th e-pre s s/m e etth ep re s sb t o g/c al i forn i s-poll -h om e l e s sn e s s-urgent-i s sue- state-rcna72972. Benjamin Oreskes, Doug Smith & David Lauter, 95% of Voters Say Homelessness is L.A. 's Biggest Problem, Times Poll finds. `You Can't Escape It. ', L.A. Times (Nov. 14, 2019), https://www.Iatimes.com/califomia/story/2019-1 1-14/homeless- housing-poll-opinion; Benjamin Oreskes & David Lauter, L.A. Voters Angry, Frustrated Over Homeless Crisis, Demand Faster Action, Poll Finds, L.A. Times (Dec. 1, 2021), https://www.latimes.com/homeless- housing/story/2021-12-01 /la -voters -are -frustrated -impatient -over - persistent -homelessness -crisis. Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTv OF GRIZSS®f 155 135 alleged constitutional right conjured by a panel of our court that finds no support in United States Supreme Court jurisprudence. Assume, for example, that you are a police officer and you encounter a homeless person in some public space —say, San Francisco's Civic Center near the James R. Browning Building where our court sits. Assume further that the person has set up a tent and "engage[d] in other life - sustaining activities" like defecation and urination on the sidewalk nearby. Martin v. City of Boise, 920 F.3d 584, 617 (9th Cir. 2019) (citation omitted). You also know that, pursuant to the city's good -faith efforts to comply with the dictates of Martin, government workers have conducted outreach and offered temporary housing to the homeless persons in this area. Nonetheless, under the majority's reasoning, you are powerless to cite this person even for public defecation because San Francisco has fewer shelter beds than total homeless persons. It is irrelevant that the city already offered this specific person shelter because "the number of homeless persons outnumber the available shelter beds." Johnson v. City of Grants Pass, 50 F.4th 787, 792 (9th Cir. 2022) (cleaned up).' In a democracy, voters and government officials should be able to debate the efficacy and desirability of these types of enforcement actions. Regrettably, our court has short-circuited the political process and declared a reasonable policy response to be off- limits and flatly unconstitutional. Contrary to Judges Gould and Silver's assertion, neither s This hypothetical is based on two district -court applications of Martin and Grants Pass. See infra section III (San Francisco and Sacramento examples). Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 136 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRIZSS®f 155 my description of the West's homelessness crisis nor my offering of the above hypothetical is meant to "argue the crisis would abate" if Martin and Grants Pass were overruled. Though these decisions certainly add obstacles to local governments' already difficult path to solving the homelessness crisis, I have never and do not here contend that our precedent is an on/off-switch entirely responsible for the crisis. I describe the scope of the West's homelessness crisis to instead make a point about our proper role, as well as our institutional competence and accountability. Unlike the officials tasked with addressing homelessness, the members of our court are neither elected nor policy experts. Of course, the political process must yield to the fundamental rights protected by the Constitution, and some of federal courts' finest moments have come in enforcing the rights of politically marginal groups against the majority. But when asked to inject ourselves into a vexing and politically charged crisis, we should tread carefully and take pains to ensure that any rule we impose is truly required by the Constitution —not just what our unelected members think is good public policy. Unfortunately, the careful constitutional analysis that the West's homelessness crisis calls for is absent from both Martin, 920 F.3d 584, and the majority opinion here, Grants Pass, 50 F.4th 787. Martin misread Supreme Court precedent, yet we failed to give that case the en banc reconsideration it deserved. Grants Pass now doubles down on Martin —crystallizing Martin into a crude population -level inquiry, greenlighting what should be (at most) an individualized inquiry for class - wide litigation, and leaving local governments without a clue of how to regulate homeless encampments without risking legal liability. Martin handcuffed local jurisdictions as they Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRIWAS®f 155 137 tried to respond to the homelessness crisis; Grants Pass now places them in a straitjacket. If this case does not "involve[] a question of exceptional importance," I cannot imagine one that does. Fed. R. App. P. 35(a)(2). We should have taken this second chance to revisit our flawed precedent en banc, and I respectfully dissent from our decision not to do so. I. As Judge O'Scannlain explains in his Statement, Martin cannot be squared with the Supreme Court's Eighth Amendment precedent. What is more, as Judge O'Scannlain also explains, Martin violates Supreme Court precedent regarding what constitutes binding precedent. The Marks rule instructs in no uncertain terms that, "[w]hen a fragmented [Supreme] Court decides a case and no single rationale explaining the result enjoys the assent of five Justices, the holding of the Court may be viewed as that position taken by those Members who concurred in the judgments on the narrowest grounds." Marks v. United States, 430 U.S. 188, 193 (1977) (cleaned up) (emphasis added). Yet Martin counted to five votes for its understanding of the Eighth Amendment by including the four votes of the Powell dissenters. Martin, 920 F.3d at 616 ("The four dissenting Justices adopted a position consistent with that taken by Justice White [in his concurrence] ...."). When the Marks rule is properly applied to Powell v. Texas, 392 U.S. 514 (1968), it produces the holding that Powell's "conviction was constitutional because it involved the commission of an act. Nothing more, nothing less." Martin, 920 F.3d at 591 (M. Smith, J., dissenting from denial of rehearing en banc); see also Grants Pass, 50 F.4th at 830 (Collins, J., dissenting) ("Under a correct application of Marks, the holding of Powell is that there is no constitutional obstacle to punishing conduct that has not been shown to be 291 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 138 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRIZ&S®f 155 involuntary, and the converse question of what rule applies when the conduct has been shown to be involuntary was left open."). Put differently: When the Marks rule is properly applied, Martin cannot hide behind Powell and insist that Supreme Court precedent "compels the conclusion" it reached. Martin, 920 F.3d at 616. Martin therefore had the burden to affirmatively justify its rule —that a "state may not criminalize conduct that is an unavoidable consequence" of a person's status —as consistent with the Eighth Amendment. Id. at 617 (cleaned up). But neither Martin nor the majority in this case even attempts to make that showing, including rebutting the number of reasons Justice Thurgood Marshall and the other Justices in the Powell plurality thought an unavoidable - consequence -of -status rule would be both improper and unworkable. We are left completely in the dark as to why, for example, the Martin panel and Grants Pass majority apparently thought: • The Powell plurality was wrong to interpret Robinson v. California, 370 U.S. 660 (1962) as a ban on "punish[ing] a mere status" and nothing more. Powell, 392 U.S. at 532 (plurality) (Marshall, J.). • The Powell plurality was wrong to be concerned that an unavoidable -consequence -of -status rule would lack "any limiting principle." Id. at 533. • The Powell plurality was wrong to think that a constitutionalized unavoidable -consequence rule would improperly override the ability of states to develop "[t]he doctrines of actus reus, mens rea, insanity, mistake, justification, and duress" to resolve as they think best "the tension between the evolving 292 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GR1Z9,S0f 155 139 aims of the criminal law and changing religious, moral, philosophical, and medical views of the nature of man." Id. at 5 3 5-3 6. • The Powell plurality incorrectly characterized an unavoidable -consequence rule as conferring upon unelected federal judges the impossible task of being "the ultimate arbiter[s] of the standards of criminal responsibility, in diverse areas of the criminal law, throughout the country." Id. at 533. • The punishment flowing from a public -camping prosecution (or even just a civil citation) constitutes the "exceedingly rare" instance —outside the context of capital punishment and juvenile life without parole —where a particular sentence may violate the Eighth Amendment. Rummel v. Estelle, 445 U.S. 263, 272 (1980); see Miller v. Alabama, 567 U.S. 460, 469-70 (2012) (summarizing proportionality case law). Judges Gould and Silver are correct to note that the Powell plurality is, after all, just a plurality. But these questions, and others, still warranted a response —one would hope that a lower court, when fashioning a novel constitutional rule, would at least grapple with the reasons four Supreme Court Justices expressly chose to reject the very same rule. The district courts tasked with applying Martin/Grants Pass, the local governments placed in a straitjacket by these decisions, and the residents of our circuit who now must live with the consequences all deserved better than the half -reasoned decisions they received from our court. II. Moreover, even if one assumes arguendo that the Eighth 293 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 140 JOHNSON V. CTTy OF GRIAGS®f 155 Amendment supports an unavoidable -consequence -of -status principle, Grants Pass's homelessness -specific analysis has nothing to do with that principle. One would reasonably assume that Grants Pass implemented Martin's general Eighth Amendment principle by mandating that courts conduct an individualized inquiry: whether public camping by the individual plaintiffs before the court is an "unavoidable consequence" of their status as homeless persons —inquiring, for example, into whether the plaintiffs declined offers of temporary housing.' But one would be mistaken in that assumption. Instead of calling for an individualized inquiry, the original Grants Pass majority opinion candidly set forth a crude jurisdiction -wide inquiry: "The formula established in Martin is that the government cannot prosecute homeless people for sleeping in public if there is a greater number of homeless individuals in a jurisdiction than the number of available shelter spaces." Grants Pass, 50 F.4th at 795 (cleaned up); see id. at. 823-28 (Collins, J., dissenting) (arguing that Martin provides at most a "case -specific," as -applied claim). The original 9 One short-term housing site in Los Angeles sits nearly empty despite proximity to a large homeless camp, and one of the new Los Angeles mayor's marquee offers of short-term housing had a below-50% acceptance rate. See Helen Li, The Times Podcast: Why Hotel Rooms for L.A. 's Homeless Sit Empty (Feb. 15, 2023), https://www.latimes.com/podcasts/story/2023-02-15/the-times-podcast- cecil-hotel-los-angeles; Benjamin Oreskes, Bass Wants to Bring Homeless People Indoors. Can She Secure Enough Beds?, L.A. Times (Dec. 22, 2022), https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2022-12- 22/karen-bass-homelessness-directive-inside-safe; see also David Zahmser, In Downtown L.A., Bass' Plan to Clear Encampments Faces Crime, Addiction and Resistance (May 30, 2023), L.A. Times, http s: //www.l atim e s. com /cal i forn i a/story/2023 -0 5-3 0/l a-m e-m ayor- bass-homeless-encampment-resistance. 294 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRIAIAS®f 155 141 majority opinion made clear that the beds -versus -population "formula" is all that matters: Because the plaintiffs in this case established a shelter -beds deficit, they are deemed —no matter their personal situations —involuntarily homeless, and the city effectively cannot enforce its ordinances against any homeless person. The majority has now amended its opinion to remove this "formula" language, and the opinion's body now quotes Martin's statement that individuals are outside the purview of its holding if they "have access to adequate temporary shelter, whether because they have the means to pay for it or because it is realistically available to them for free, but [they] choose not to use it." Martin, 920 F.3d at 617 n.8. But I fear that this amendment, in reality, does little to change the substance of Grants Pass and instead simply obscures what Grants Pass holds. Notably, the amendment is not accompanied by any downstream changes to the majority's application of its rule to the facts or its ultimate conclusion. So, the "formula" language may be gone, but the approach that language forthrightly described remains embedded in the opinion. Grants Pass still holds that "[t]here, of course, exists no law or rule requiring a homeless person" to "provide the court an accounting of her finances and employment history" before being deemed "involuntarily homeless." 50 F.4th at 811. It still equates a shelter -beds deficit with jurisdiction -wide involuntariness: "[T]he number of homeless persons outnumber the available beds. In other words, homeless persons have nowhere to shelter and sleep in the City ...." Id. at 792; see also id. at 797 (describing the district court decision, which it largely affirms, as holding "that, based on the unavailability of shelter beds, the City's enforcement of its anti -camping and anti -sleeping ordinances violated the 295 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 142 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRI42S®f 155 Cruel and Unusual Punishment Clause"). And it still treats a shelter -beds deficit, when combined with conclusory allegations of involuntariness, as sufficient for an individual to show that he or she is involuntarily homeless: "Gloria Johnson has adequately demonstrated that there is no available shelter in Grants Pass and that she is involuntarily homeless." Id. at 811. The amendment thus places district courts in an impossible position. They will not be able to reconcile Grants Pass's disparate strands —because they cannot be reconciled. District courts will have to choose between following what Grants Pass now says in one place (there must be a meaningful voluntariness inquiry) and what Grants Pass says and does in another place (a shelter -beds deficit and conclusory allegations are all one needs). Indeed, Grants Pass's class -certification analysis confirms that its nod to the unavoidable -consequence or involuntarily -homeless limitation is just window dressing — and that the amendment to the opinion is one of form, not substance. As Judge Collins explained, if Martin's public - camping ban is truly limited to those who are involuntarily homeless, then Martin -type cases cannot possibly be litigated on a class -wide basis. Grants Pass, 50 F.4th at 823- 28 (Collins, J., dissenting). To be certified, a putative class must satisfy Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23's commonality requirement, among others. "What matters" for purposes of that requirement "is not the raising of common questions —even in droves —but rather, the capacity of a class -wide proceeding to generate common answers apt to drive the resolution of the litigation." Wal- Mart Stores, Inc. v. Dukes, 564 U.S. 338, 350 (2011) (cleaned up). A court must be able to "resolve an issue that is central to the validity of each one of the [class members'] Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTv OF GRIA41S®f 155 143 claims in one stroke." Id. Whether a public -camping ban is unconstitutional as applied to a homeless plaintiff depends (it would seem) on whether that plaintiff is "involuntarily homeless," which in turn depends on a host of individualized factors: Did they decline the city's offer of temporary housing? Do they otherwise "have the means to pay" for temporary housing? Were there areas of the city where they could publicly camp without citation in light of the city's enforcement policies? It blinks reality to say that the district court could, "in one stroke," resolve the constitutionality of the public -camping ban as applied to each of the "at least around 50" class members here. Grants Pass, 50 F.4th at 811. The majority, for what it is worth, tries to backdoor involuntariness into its Rule 23 analysis. But its argument is one that Philosophy 101 professors should consider using as their go -to example of circular reasoning: The class satisfies Rule 23's commonality requirement because the class members' claims all present the question of whether enforcement of public -camping ordinances against "involuntarily homeless individuals violates the Eighth Amendment." Id. at 804-05 n.22. Answering that question resolves the claims of each class member "in one stroke" because "[p]ursuant to the class definition, the class includes only involuntarily homeless persons." Id. at 804-05 (citation omitted). The basis for that premise? "[T]he record establishes" it. Id. at 804-05 n.22. As Judge Collins explained, there is "no authority for this audacious bootstrap argument." Id. at 827 (Collins, J., dissenting). By wholly collapsing the merits into the class definition, the majority opinion certified an impermissible "fail safe" class. Id. (quoting Olean Wholesale Grocery Coop. v. Bumble Bee Foods, 31 F.4th 651, 670 n.14 (9th Cir. 2022) (en banc)). 297 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 144 JOHNSONV. CTTY OF GR144s®f 155 In response to this criticism, Judges Gould and Silver suggest that Grants Pass's class -certification analysis is run of the mill —analogizing it to our court's recent approval of a district court's certification of a class of California residents who worked for a certain employer. See Bernstein v. Virgin Am., Inc., 3 F.4th 1127, 1134 (9th Cir. 2021). It is telling that Judges Gould and Silver think involuntary homelessness is as easily determined as residency and employment history —another piece of evidence that Martin's involuntariness component has faded away or been collapsed into the shelter -beds inquiry. More fundamentally, their analogy overlooks that the Bernstein class definition did not swallow the merits inquiry in the manner that the class definition does here. Separate from class membership (based on residency and employment), the Bernstein plaintiffs still had to make a merits showing that the defendant violated California labor laws by, among other things, failing to pay a minimum wage and to pay for all hours worked. See id. at 1133. Here, by contrast, the game is essentially over as soon as the class is certified. The class (purportedly) consists only of involuntarily homeless people, and application of the challenged ordinances to the class members is unconstitutional (under our flawed precedent) because the class members are involuntarily homeless. Viewing the majority's class -certification analysis, there are only two possible conclusions: Either (1) the majority erred in certifying the class despite a lack of commonality; or (2) the majority read "involuntarily" out of Martin's purported involuntarily -homeless rule. Either conclusion points to profound error that we should have used the en banc process to correct. Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRIASS®f 1 55 145 Judges Gould and Silver insist that Martin and Grants Pass apply only in "exceptionally narrow situation[s]" and that critics of these decisions have resorted to "rhetorical exaggerations." But whose word should one take: that of a panel majority defending its own work or that of several district court judges who have no dog in this fight and are simply trying to understand and apply the law as we have handed it down to them? Several district court decisions have understood Martin and now Grants Pass to run roughshod over normal procedural rules and past any substantive limiting principles. As a result, local governments are hard-pressed to find any way to regulate the adverse health and safety effects of homeless encampments without running afoul of our court's case law —or, at a minimum, being saddled with litigation costs. If one picks up a map of the western United States and points to a city that appears on it, there is a good chance that city has already faced a lawsuit in the few short years since our court initiated its Martin experiment. Without expressing any view on how other district courts or panels of our court should decide these or similar cases pursuant to our existing precedent, I offer a few examples of the judicial adventurism our case law has already produced: 1. San Francisco responded conscientiously to Martin. The police department promulgated an enforcement bulletin intended to comply with that case's dictates while retaining flexibility to clear some of the city's worst encampments. See Coal. on Homelessness v. City & Cnty. of San Francisco, No. 22-cv-05502-DNM, 2022 WL 17905114, at *3-7 (N.D. Cal. Dec. 23, 2022). Pursuant to the bulletin, an officer cannot arrest a homeless person for a set of enumerated offenses unless SFPD first "secure[s] appropriate shelter." Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 146 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRIASS®f 155 Id. at *4 (emphasis omitted). SFPD policy requires officers to work with other city agencies to implement a multi -step process: The city posts a notice that an encampment clearing will occur on a particular date; city workers perform outreach at the encampment the weekend before the clearing; and city workers follow up at the encampment 24 to 72 hours before the clearing. Id. at * 5-7. Only then can an encampment clearing take place. To be sure, the record on SFPD's compliance with this policy was mixed. The defendants asserted that they always comply with the policy—"conduct[ing] regular training[s]" on it, setting aside beds based on an estimated acceptance rate, and providing officers with the means to check shelter -bed availabilities. Id. at * 13-15, *23. Some plaintiffs asserted that they never received advance notice of encampment clearings or offers of housing. Id. at * 8-9. Other plaintiffs asserted that SFPD sometimes complied with the policy and "acknowledge[d] receiving and/or accepting shelter offers at ... encampment closures." Id. at *22; see also id. at * 10- 12. The plaintiffs' expert opined that San Francisco had a shelter -beds deficit but conceded that a "clear way to access shelter is via an encampment [closure] while under threat from law enforcement." Id. at * 14. Nonetheless, the court found the mixed record before it sufficient to issue a sweeping preliminary injunction. The district court repeatedly returned not to the facts of specific plaintiffs in specific encampment clearings but to the consideration at the center of Grants Pass: whether there is a shelter -beds deficit. See id. at *21 ("insufficient stock of shelter beds"); id. *22 ("long-standing shelter bed shortfalls"); id. at *23 ("there are thousands more homeless individuals ... than there are available shelter beds"); id. at *27 ("shortfall of shelter beds"). The court determined that 0 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRIATs®f 155 147 it "need not decide" how offers of housing, when actually made, would impact the constitutionality of arrests or alter the scope of an injunction. See id. at *23-24. The court instead issued a broad, if ambiguous, injunction that appears to effectively prevent SFPD from enforcing five separate prohibitions against homeless persons in San Francisco "as long as there are more homeless individuals ... than there are shelter beds available." Id. at *28. 2. Phoenix suffered a similar fate. Like San Francisco, it adopted a policy that police "officers must make individualized assessments" before issuing citations against homeless persons for certain offenses. Fund for Empowerment v. City of Phoenix, No. CV-22-02041-PHX- GMS, 2022 WL 18213522, at *3 (D. Ariz. Dec. 16, 2022). Unlike the San Francisco case, the district court cited no evidence in the record showing that Phoenix breached its policy. Still, the district court issued a sweeping injunction after conducting a merits inquiry that focused almost exclusively on the Grants Pass beds -versus -population inquiry. The district court noted that it was "not contested that there are more unsheltered individuals than shelter beds in Phoenix" and then concluded that Phoenix's policy "present[s] likely unconstitutional applications especially when the unsheltered in the city outnumber the available bed spaces." Id. The city's enforcement policy —as a mere "statement of administrative policy" —was insufficient to "forestall the Plaintiffs' ultimate likelihood of success on the merits." Id. (quoting Martin, 920 F.3d at 607). 3. Santa Barbara adopted a half -measure: a geographically- and time -limited ban against public sleeping that applied only in the city's downtown area. Boring v. Murillo, No. CV-21-07305, 2022 WL 14740244, at *I (C.D. Cal. Aug. 11, 2022). Despite the ordinance's modest scope, 801 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 148 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRIA&S®f 155 the district court still held that the plaintiffs stated a plausible claim to relief pursuant to Martin and denied the city's motion to dismiss. See id. at *5-6. 4. Sacramento found itself subject to a lawsuit after taking the innocuous step of removing a pot -table toilet from city -owned property. Mahoney v. City of Sacramento, No. 2:20-cv-00258-KJM, 2020 WL 616302, at * 1 (E.D. Cal. Feb. 10, 2020). Though the court ultimately declined to issue a temporary restraining order because the plaintiffs' claims failed on factual grounds, it still interpreted Martin to cover public urination and defecation prosecutions and stated that "the City may not prosecute or otherwise penalize the plaintiffs . . . for eliminating in public if there is no alternative to doing so." Id. at *3. Judges Gould and Silver argue this "brief statement made in the context of resolving an emergency motion is not a solid foundation" on which to suggest that the enforcement of public defecation and urination laws may well be suspect pursuant to our court's precedent. In their view, that is because Martin and Grants Pass did not involve a "challenge to any public urination or defecation ordinances." But our decisions are not good -for -one -ride -only tickets forever bound to their specific facts; they serve as precedent to which parties analogize in related situations. Martin attempted to limit its reach by explaining that sleep is a "life - sustaining activit[y]." Martin, 920 F.3d at 617. In their concurrence, Judges Gould and Silver offer a slightly different version of that limiting principle —that sleep is an "identifiable human need[]." But "[w]hat else is [an identifiable human need]? Surely bodily functions." Martin, 920 F.3d at 596 (M. Smith, J., dissenting from denial of rehearing en bane). It is not a slippery -slope fallacy to note a realistic consequence that flows directly from Martin 802 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GR149,S0f 155 149 and Grants Pass's reasoning. Moreover, Judges Gould and Silver fail to recognize that something is fundamentally amiss with our precedent if a city, even if it ultimately prevails, must first go to court before it can remove a toilet from property it owns. 5. Chico "constructed an outdoor temporary shelter facility at the Chico Municipal Airport that accommodate[d] all 571 of the City's homeless persons." Warren v. City of Chico, No. 2:21-CV-00640-MCE, 2021 WL 2894648, at *3 (E.D. Cal. July 8, 2021). But the district court cited stray lines in Martin in addition to Merriam-Webster's definition of "shelter," conducted a single paragraph of analysis, concluded that the airport shelter was not Martin -type shelter, and subsequently enjoined Chico from enforcing its anti -camping laws against "homeless persons in violation." Id. at * 3-4. As the district court itself recognized, this decision (as well as the others above) shows that, while the Martin analysis may be "straight -forward ... [as] to the facts of [a] case," the "practical ramifications for the community are much more complex" and the "concerns raised in the dissent from the denial of rehearing en banc appear to have come to fruition." Id. at *4 n.4 (citation omitted). As I feared, our case law has "prohibit[ed] local governments from fulfilling their duty to enforce an array of public health and safety laws," and the "[h]alting [of] enforcement of such laws" has "wreak[ed] havoc on our communities." Martin, 920 F.3d at 594 (M. Smith, J., dissenting from denial of rehearing en banc). *** I respect the good intentions of my colleagues on the Martin panel and in the Grants Pass majority. But Martin, 803 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 150 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRISGS®f 155 particularly now that it has been supercharged by Grants Pass, has proven to be a runaway train that has derailed and done substantial collateral damage to the governmental units in which it has been applied and those living therein. These cases use a misreading of Supreme Court precedent to require unelected federal judges —often on the basis of sloppy, mixed preliminary -injunction records —to act more like homelessness policy czars than as Article III judges applying a discernible rule of law. I respectfully dissent from our court's decision not to rehear Grants Pass en banc. COLLINS, Circuit Judge, dissenting from the denial of rehearing en banc: In my dissent as a member of the panel in this case, I explained that: • Martin v. City ofBoise, 920 F.3d 584 (9th Cir. 2019), is a "deeply flawed" decision that "seriously misconstrued the Eighth Amendment and the Supreme Court's caselaw construing it"; • Even if Martin were correct in its Eighth Amendment holding, the panel majority's decision in Johnson "greatly expands Martin's holding" in a way that is "egregiously wrong"; and • The panel majority's decision "make[s] things worse" by "combin[ing] its gross misreading of 804 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRISIAS®f 155 151 Martin with a flagrant disregard of settled class - certification principles." See Johnson v. City of Grants Pass, 50 F.4th 787, 814 & n.l (9th Cir. 2022) (Collins, J., dissenting). In its "joint statement regarding denial of rehearing," the panel majority today recycles many of the flawed arguments in its opinion. I have already explained in my dissent why those arguments are wrong. See id. at 823-31. The statement of Judge O' Scannlain respecting the denial of rehearing en banc and Parts I and II of Judge M. Smith's dissent from the denial of rehearing en banc—which I join —further cogently explain the multiple serious errors in the panel majority's opinion. I will not repeat all of what has already been said, but I think that two points are worth underscoring in response to the panel majority's statement regarding the denial of rehearing. First, the panel majority's statement confirms and illustrates the layers of self-contradiction that underlie its opinion in this case. The panel majority continues implausibly to insist that its opinion is "strictly limited to enforcement of the ordinances against `involuntarily' homeless persons," which would suggest —as Martin itself suggested —an individualized case -specific inquiry. See Panel Majority Statement at 94. But the panel majority also continues to insist that the class was properly certified because any individualized issues concerning involuntariness were moved into the class definition. See Panel Majority Statement at 99-101. As I have explained, that "artifice" ignores the requirements of Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23, because it "rel[ies] on a fail-safe class definition that improperly subsumes this crucial individualized merits issue into the class definition." 50 F.4th at 827 (Collins, J., 805 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 152 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRISZS®f 155 dissenting). The panel majority tries to wave away the problem as merely one of "individualized determinations to identify class members," arguing that what it did in this case is no different than asking whether, for example, a given class member resides in a particular State or performs a given job for a company. See Panel Majority Statement at 101 (emphasis added). But in sharp contrast to the simple factual inquiries in the panel majority's examples, its standard for "identifying" class members here—i. e., whether a given plaintiff's homelessness is involuntary under all of the circumstances —is the central merits issue in the case under a correct reading of Martin. Thus, under the faulty class action upheld by the panel majority, if a particular person's individual circumstances confirm that his homelessness is not "involuntary" in the sense that Martin requires, then his Eighth Amendment claim under Martin fails on the merits —and he is then defined out of the class. But if his homelessness is involuntary under Martin's standards, then (under that decision's reading of the Eighth Amendment) his Martin claim is a winner —and he remains in the class. The result is a classic fail-safe class: each "class member either wins or, by virtue of losing, is defined out of the class." Olean Wholesale Grocery Coop. v. Bumble Bee Foods, 31 F.4th 651, 669-70 n.14 (9th Cir. 2022) (en banc) (citation omitted). Underlying all of this is a fundamental inconsistency between the various propositions endorsed by the panel majority's opinion. As I stated in my panel dissent, "the majority cannot have it both ways: either the class definition is co -extensive with Martin's involuntariness concept (in which case the class is an improper fail-safe class) or the class definition differs from the Martin standard (in which case Martin's individualized inquiry requires Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRIS41S®f 1 55 153 decertification)." 50 F.4th at 827-28 (Collins, J., dissenting). Nothing in the panel majority's statement resolves these internal contradictions, which plague its deeply flawed opinion. Second, I cannot let pass without comment the panel majority's contention that a newly enacted Oregon statute regulating the application of local ordinances to homeless individuals provides "yet another reason why it was wise to not rehear" this case en bane. See Panel Majority Statement at 112-13 n.7. Even assuming that this statute will require that city laws such as those challenged here must be "objectively reasonable as to time, place and manner with regards to persons experiencing homelessness," under "the totality of the circumstances," see Or. Rev. Stat. § 195.530(2), (5), the removal of the objectively unreasonable constitutional straitjacket wrongly imposed by Martin and Johnson would continue to alter the outcome of this case and would also greatly improve the cogency, coherence, and correctness of Eighth Amendment jurisprudence in this circuit. The panel majority is quite wrong in suggesting that this statute provides any grounds for looking the other way and allowing Martin's cancer on our jurisprudence to continue to metastasize. I reiterate what I said in the conclusion of my panel dissent, which is that both Martin and Johnson "should be overturned or overruled at the earliest opportunity, either by this court sitting en bane or by the U.S. Supreme Court." 50 F.4th at 831 (Collins, J., dissenting). By denying rehearing en bane today, we have regrettably failed to overrule Martin and Johnson. I again emphatically dissent. 807 Exhibit B EXHIBIT D 154 JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRIS4s®f 155 BRESS, Circuit Judge, joined by CALLAHAN, M. SMITH, IKUTA, BENNETT, R. NELSON, MILLER, BADE, LEE, FORREST, BUMATAY, and VANDYKE, Circuit Judges, dissenting from the denial of rehearing en banc: Looking out the windows of the Ninth Circuit's courthouse in San Francisco, one sees the most difficult problems plaguing big -city America on display. Homelessness, drug addiction, barely concealed narcotics dealing, severe mental health impairment, the post-COVID hollowing out of our business districts. These problems of disrespect for the law, human suffering, and urban decline would seem connected, the result of a complex interaction of forces that defies any easy solution. But on top of everything that our localities must now contend with, our court has injected itself into the mix by deploying the Eighth Amendment to impose sharp limits on what local governments can do about the pressing problem of homelessness —a problem now so often related to every other in our great cities. With no mooring in the text of the Constitution, our history and traditions, or the precedent of the Supreme Court, we have taken our national founding document and used it to enact judge -made rules governing who can sit and sleep where, rules whose ill effects are felt not merely by the States, and not merely by our cities, but block by block, building by building, doorway by doorway. The antecedent question we must always ask when interpreting the Constitution is whether a matter has been entrusted, in the first instance, to the courts or to the people. The answer to that question here is clear: we must allow local leaders —and the people who elect them —the latitude to address on the ground the distinctly local features of the present crisis of homelessness and lack of affordable Exhibit B EXHIBIT D JOHNSON V. CTTY OF GRISSS®f 1 55 155 housing. And we must preserve for our localities the ability to make tough policy choices unobstructed by court -created mandates that lack any sound basis in law. The expanding constitutional common law our court is fashioning in this area adds enormous and unjustified complication to an already extremely complicated set of circumstances. Not every challenge we face is constitutional in character. Not every problem in our country has a legal answer that judges can provide. This is one of those situations. The decision in Johnson v. City of Grants Pass, 50 F.4th 787 (9th Cir. 2022), and our decision in Martin v. City of Boise, 920 F.3d 584 (9th Cir. 2019), on which Johnson is premised, are clearly wrong and should have been overruled. I respectfully dissent from the denial of rehearing en banc. :i- EXH �8�t� 1� o ORS 195.500 Policy for removal of homeless individuals camping on public property All municipalities and counties shall: (1) Develop a policy that recognizes the social nature of the problem of homeless individuals camping on public property. (2) Implement the policy as developed, to ensure the most humane treatment for removal of homeless individuals from camping sites on public property. [Formerly 203.077] Note: 195.500 (Policy for removal of homeless individuals camping on public property) to 195.510 (Sites not subject to ORS 195.500 to 195.510) were enacted into law by the Legislative Assembly but were not added to or made a part of ORS chapter 195 or any series therein by legislative action. See Preface to Oregon Revised Statutes for further explanation. EXH ��t� 0 ORS 195.505 Elements of camp removal policies (1) A policy developed pursuant to ORS 195.500 (Policy for removal of homeless individuals camping on public property) shall conform, but is not limited, to the following provisions. (2) As used in this section, "personal property" means any item that can reasonably be identified as belonging to an individual and that has apparent value or utility. (3) Except as provided in subsection (9) of this section, at least 72 hours before removing homeless individuals from an established camping site, law enforcement officials shall post a written notice, in English and Spanish, at all entrances to the camping site to the extent that the entrances can reasonably be identified. (4) Intentionally left blank —Ed. (a) When a 72-hour notice is posted, law enforcement officials shall inform the local agency that delivers social services to homeless individuals as to where the notice has been posted. (b) The local agency may arrange for outreach workers to visit the camping site that is subject to the notice to assess the need for social service assistance in arranging shelter and other assistance. (5) Intentionally left blank —Ed. (a) All personal property at the camping site that remains unclaimed after removal shall be given to a law enforcement official, a local agency that delivers social services to homeless individuals, an outreach worker, a local agency official or a person authorized to issue a citation described in subsection (10) of this section, whether notice is required under subsection (3) of this section or not. (b) The unclaimed personal property must be stored: 681 EXH ��t� 0 (A) For property removed from camping sites in counties other than Multnomah County, in a facility located in the same community as the camping site from which it was removed. (B) For property removed from camping sites in Multnomah County, in a facility located within six blocks of a public transit station. (c) Items that have no apparent value or utility or are in an insanitary condition may be immediately discarded upon removal of the homeless individuals from the camping site. (d) Weapons, controlled substances other than prescription medication and items that appear to be either stolen or evidence of a crime shall be given to or retained by law enforcement officials. (6) The written notice required under subsection (3) of this section must state, at a minimum: (a) Where unclaimed personal property will be stored; (b) A phone number that individuals may call to find out where the property will be stored; or (c) If a permanent storage location has not yet been determined, the address and phone number of an agency that will have the information when available. (7) Intentionally left blank —Ed. (a) The unclaimed personal property shall be stored in an orderly fashion, keeping items that belong to an individual together to the extent that ownership can reasonably be determined. (b) The property shall be stored for a minimum of 30 days during which it shall be reasonably available to any individual claiming ownership. Any personal property that remains unclaimed after 30 days may be disposed of or donated to a corporation described in section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code as amended and in effect on December 31, 2020. 682 EXHIPfft� 0 (8) Following the removal of homeless individuals from a camping site on public property, the law enforcement officials, local agency officials and outreach workers may meet to assess the notice and removal policy, to discuss whether the removals are occurring in a humane and just manner and to determine if any changes are needed in the policy. (9) Intentionally left blank —Ed. (a) The 72-hour notice requirement under subsection (3) of this section does not apply: (A) When there are grounds for law enforcement officials to believe that illegal activities other than camping are occurring at an established camping site. (B) In the event of an exceptional emergency at an established camping site, including, but not limited to, possible site contamination by hazardous materials, a public health emergency or other immediate danger to human life or safety. (b) If a funeral service is scheduled with less than 72 hours' notice at a cemetery at which there is a camping site, or a camping site is established at the cemetery less than 72 hours before the scheduled service, the written notice required under subsection (3) of this section may be posted at least 24 hours before removing homeless individuals from the camping site. (10) A person authorized to issue a citation for unlawful camping under state law, administrative rule or city or county ordinance may not issue the citation if the citation would be issued within 200 feet of a notice required under subsection (3) of this section and within two hours before or after the notice was posted. (11) Any law or policy of a city or county that is more specific or offers greater protections to homeless individuals subject to removal from an established camping site preempts contrary provisions of this section. [Formerly 203.079] 683 EXH �B��t 1� o1 ORS 131.705 As used in ORS 131.705 (Definitions for ORS 131.705 to 131.735) to 131.735 (Review of exclusion order), unless the context requires otherwise: (3) "Public property" means public lands, premises and buildings, including but not limited to any building used in connection with the transaction of public business or any lands, premises or buildings owned or leased by this state or any political subdivision therein. [Formerly 145.610] 684 EXHI D% WOOBURN ORDYNANCE COMPILATION 1 1 M ORDINANCE NO. 2060 AN ORDINANCE RELATING TO THE USE OF PARK AREAS: PROVIDING FOR PENALTIES FOR VIOLATION THEREOF; REPEALING ORDINANCE 1918 AND DECLARING AN EMERGENCY. THE CITY OF WOODBURN ORDAINS AS FOLLOWS: Section 1. Policy. The City of Woodburn may develop, construct, improve, operate and maintain park and recreation facilities in a manner which will best afford the public with necessary conveniences and accommodations. In order to protect the health, safety and well-being of the public, and insure the greatest use and benefits from such areas, it is necessary to make regulations and provisions the City Council deems necessary. (2) Council, The Woodburn City Council. (3) Director, The person hired by the City of Woodburn who is in charge of the Community Services Department of the City of Woodburn or his designee. [Section 2 (3) as amended by Ordinance 2412, passed November 13, 2006] (4) Park Area. A City Park, wayside area, community rest areas, scenic or historical areas, public park open spaces and greenbelt areas. (5) Park Employee. Any employee of the City of Woodburn Community Services Department. [Section 2 (5) as amended by Ordinance 2412, passed November 13, 2006.] (6) Person. A natural person, firm, partnership, association, orcorporation. Section 3. General Rules and Regulations. The general rules and regulations for City of Woodburn Parks shall be as follows: (1) Fires in park areas: No person shall build a fire in any park area unless said fire is confined to: (a) Park camp stoves or fireplaces. (b) Portions of parks designated as permitting fires. (c) Portable stoves in established picnic areas and designated where fires are permitted, ORT)MANCE No. 2o6o a PAGE 1 WOODBURN ORDINANCE COMPILATION • (d) No fire shall be left unattended, and every fire shall be extinguished before its user leaves the, park area. (2) No person in a park area shall hunt, pursue, trap, kill, injure or molest any birds or animals or disturb their habitat. [Section 3(2) as amended by Ordinance 2083, passed May 26, 1992.] (3) No person shall pick, cut, mutilate or remove from any park area flowers, shrubs, foliage, trees, plant life, barkdust, or products of any type without the written permission of the Director or his authorized agent, (4) No person shall, except in areas designated by City Council, erect signs, markers, or inscriptions of any type within a park area without permission from the Director. (5) No person in a park area shall sell, peddle or offer for sale any food liquids, edibles for human consumptions, or any goods, wares, service or merchandise within the park area except Linder permit by the Director, and then only subject to such laws and regulations as may now or hereafter exist. (6) No person shall, except- cluly authorized peace officers in the course of their duties, drive, lead or keep a horse or other farm animal in any park area, except on such roads, trails or other areas designated for that purpose. No horse or such animal shall be hitched to any free or shrub in such manner that may cause damage to such tree or shrub. The only exception to this rule would be during a parade line-up or a special event, and only after obtaining written permission from The Director, (7) No person shall wash any clothing, or materials or other substances, or clean any fish in a park area or in a lake, stream or river, or in a park area. Park sinks, faucets and hydrants within the confines of parks or park restroorns shall not to be used for washing clothes of any type. (8) No person shall use park sinks, other than those provided in public resfroor-ns, for personal hygiene. Faucets, drinking fountains, hose outlets and hydrants shall not be used for this purpose. (9) No person shall clog picnic shelter sinks in a park area with food, debris, grease or any other substances (10) No person shall camp in a park area except by written approval of the Director. (11) The Director may restrict to designated zone areas certain activities, including but not limited to, swimming, picnicking, group picnicking, boating, water skiing, fishing, camping, group camping, hiking and horseback riding. ORT)MANCE No. 2o6o PAGE 2 WOODBURN ORDINANCE COMPILATION • (12) No person shall enter or remain in a park area anytime between the hours of 10:00 p.m. and 7:00 a.m. the following morning during April 1 through September, 30 of the calendar year, or between the hours of 7:00 p.m. and 7:00 a.m. the following morning during October I through March 31 of the calendar year, This section shall not applyto: (a) Persons attending an event for which a permit has been issued. b) Participants or spectators of athletic events in park areas lighted for These events; or (c) Persons attending events sponsored by the City. [Section 3(12) as amended by Ordinance 2083, passed May 26,1991] (13) No person shall have in their possession, any alcoholic beverages or intoxicating liquor, or consume such liquor while in a park area except that the use of alcoholic beverages may be permitted in Centennial Park in compliance with a Special Event Park Use Permit where the city has issued the permit and the premises have been licensed for the service of alcoholic beverages by the Oregon Liquor Control Commission. [Section 3(13) as amended by Ordinance 2083, passed May 26, 1992 and by Ordinance 2321, passed July 8, 2002.1 (14) Nothing in this ordinance shall in any manner restrict the authority of the City of Woodburn to enforce all State statutes and City Ordinances relating to the use and control of alcoholic beverages. (15) The Director, any Park employee, Code Enforcement officer, or member of the Woodburn Police Department is authorized to issue a civil infraction citation for a violation of this ordinance, (16) The Council, City Administrator or The Director shall have the authority to close a park area or a portion of a park area to the public at any time and without notice for any reasonable and necessary circumstance including, but not limited to, construction and maintenance in the park area and for the existence of a hazardous condition. Section 4. Fees, Fees may be charged for certain services and privileges, and for the use of designated areas, buildings or facilities. No person shall enter or use such areas, buildings, services or facilities or to be granted those privileges unless the appropriate fee or fees have been paid. Section 5. Rules of Conduct. The Community Services Department may adopt administrative rules for the conduct of persons participating in City Programs in the park areas, the Aquatic Center, or the Community Center. All persons participating in City Programs shall be registered. The Rules of Conduct shall be administered by the Director, or a park employee. [Section 5 as amended by Ordinance 2412, passed November 13, 2006.1 ORT)MANCE No. 2o6o 687 PAGE 3 WOODBURN ORDINANCE COMPILATION • Section G. Animals. (1) Persons owning, keeping or harboring a dog within a park area are responsible for the dog's behavior anid shall comply with the following regulations: (a) A dog shall be on a leash not more than (8) feet in length, or confined in a vehicle at all times, except dogs in off -leash dog areas designated by the City Administrator or the City Administrator's designee, (b) Any dog found by the Municipal Judge to be a dangerous dog pursuant to Ordinance 2434 (the Animal Control Ordinance) shall not be permitted, (c) A dog may not deposit solid waste matter on any improved park property unless the person owning, keeping, or harboring the dog immediately removes the solid waste, (2) The Director or a park employee may require a person in charge of any animal to undertake any measure, including the removal of an animal from the park area to prevent interference by the animal with the safety, comfort or well being of park, area visitors or resources. (3) No form animal, including, but not limited to, horses, cattle, sheep and goats is allowed in a park area except by permission of the Director, [Section 6 as amended by Ordinance 2472, passed September 27, 2010] Section 7. Glass Beverage Containers. Except by written authorization from the Director or designated park employee, no person shall possess a beverage container made of glass in any park area. Section 8. Additional Prohibited Activities. In addition to any other prohibitions in this ordinance, no person in a park area shall: (1) Set or use a public address system without the written permission of the Director, (2) Operate or use any noise producing device in a manner that disturbs other park visitors. (3) Use a metal detector without the written permission of the Director. (4) Play sports or engage in other recreational activities in areas designated by the Director as unavailable for those activities, (5) Over crowd persons or vehicles so that necessary access to emergency vehicles is unavailable. Vehicles improperly parked will be towed at owners expense. Section 9. Penalty, Any violation of this Ordinance constitutes a class 4 civil infraction and shall be dealt with according to the procedures established by Ordinance 1998. ORMNANCE No. 2o6o a =1 WOODBURN ORDINANCE COMPILATION • Section 9A. Enhanced Penalty for Violation of Special Park Use Permit. Notwiffisfanding Section 9 of this Ordinance, which provides that a viallation of the, park rules established by this Ordinance constitutes a class 4 civil infraction, any violation of the terms and conditions of a Special Event Park Use Permit by the permiftee shall constitute a class I civil infraction and shall be dealt with according to the procedures established by Ordinance 1998, the civil infraction ordinance. (Section 9A added by Ordinance 2321, passed July 8, 2002.) Section 9B. In addition to other measures provided for violation of this Ordinance, or any of the laws of the State of Oregon, any peace officer, as defined by ORS 133.005(3), as amended, or any City of Woodburn park or parks maintenance official or employee designated by the City Administrator, may exclude any person who violates any provision of this Ordinance, any City ordinance, any of the laws of the State of Oregon, or any rule or regulation duly made and issued by the Community Services Department or the City Council from any City park for a period of not more than 30 days. [Section 9B as amended by Ordinance 2412, passed November 13, 2006.] (1) No person shall enter or remain in a City park at any time that a Notice of Exclusion issued under this Ordinance excluding that person from that City park is in effect (2) An exclusion issued under the provisions of this Ordinance shall be for thirty (30) days. If the person to be excluded has been excluded from any park at any time, within two years before the date of the present exclusion, the exclusion shall be for ninety (90) days. If the person to be excluded has been excluded from one or more parks on two or more occasions within two years before the date of the present exclusion, the exclusion shall be for one -hundred eighty (180) days. (3) Before issuing a Notice of Exclusion under this Ordinance the issuing officer shall first give the person a warning and a reasonable opportunity to desist from the violation. A Notice of Exclusion shall not be 'issued if the person promptly complies with the warning and desists from the violation. No warning shall be required if the person is to be excluded for committing any act punishable as a felony, or involving controlled substances or alcoholic beverages, or which has resulted in injury to any person or damage to any property. Further, no warning shall be required if the person to be excluded has been warned or excluded from the park previously for engaging in the same unlawful conduct. (4) A Notice of Exclusion under this Ordinance shall specify the date the exclusion is to commence, the term of the exclusion, the City park that the person is to be excluded from, the provision of law that the person violated, and a brief description of the offending conduct. If shall be signed by the issuing party. The Notice of Exclusion shall provide information concerning the right to appeal the notice and to apply for a temporary waiver from the effects of the notice warning of consequences for failure to comply shall be prominently displayed or) the notice. ORMNANCE No. 2o6o PAGE 5 WOODBURN ORDINANCE COMPILATION (5) Notices of Exclusion shall take effect immediately except that if a timely appeal is filed under this Ordinance, the effectiveness of the exclusion shall be stayed pending the outcome of the appeal. If the exclusion is affirmed, the remaining period of the exclusion shall become effective immediately upon issuance of the Woodburn Municipal Court decision, unless the Court sets a later effective date. (6) A person receiving a Notice of Exclusion may appeal to the Woodburn Municipal Court to have the notice rescinded or the exclusion period shortened. In order to be timely, an appeal must be filed within five (5) days of receipt of the Notice of Exclusion. (a) The appeal need not be in any particular form, but should substantially comply wif In the following requirements: N Be in writing (ii) Identify the date, time, and place of the exclusion (iii) Identify the name and address of the appealing party (iv) Identify the official who issued the exclusion (v) Contain a concise statement as to why the Notice of Exclusion was issued in error (b) A copy of the appeal shall be served on the City Attorney. (c) An appeal hearing shall be conducted by the Woodburn Municipal Court and a decision on the appeal shall be made by the Court within ter) (10) days after the appeal is filed. (d) At the appeal hearing the City and any interested parties shall have the right to present evidence and witnesses and be heard, After due consideration of pertinent information and testimony the Court shall issue a written decision. The decision of the, Court shall be final, (7) At any time within the exclusion period, a person receiving a Notice of Exclusion may apply in writing to the City Administrator for a temporary waiver from the effects of the notice for good cause shown. In exercising discretion under this section, the City Administrator shall consider the seriousness of the violation for which the person has been excluded, the particular need of the person to be in the park during some or all of the period of exclusion, such as for work or to attend or participate in a particular event (without regard to the content of any speech associated with that event), and any other criterion the City Administrator determines to be relevant to the determination of whether or not to grant a waiver. The decision of the City Administrator to grant or deny, in whole or in part, a waiver under this section is committed to the discretion of the City Administrator, and is not subject to appeal orreview. (Section 9B added by Ordinance 2342, passed July 28, 2003; amended by Ordinance 2377, passed November 8, 2004.) ORMNANCE No. 2o6o 1 f WOODBURN ORDINANCE COMPILATION • Section 10. Severabillity. Each portion of this Ordinance shall be deemed severable from any other portion. The unconstitutionality or invalidity of any portion of this Ordinance shall not invalidate the remainder of the Ordinance. Hnql�-=r (1) Ordinance No. 1918 is hereby repealed. (2) Notwithstanding Subsection (1) of this Section, Ordinance No. 1918 shall remain valid and in force for the purpose of authorizing arrest, prosecution, conviction and punishment of a person who violated Ordinance No. 1918 prior to the effective date of this Ordinance. Section 12. [Emergency clause.] ORT)MANCE No. 2o6o a, PAGE 7 EXH8 of 12IP xff I tq ORDINANCE NO. 2577 AN ORDINANCE PROHIBITING CAMPING IN PUBLIC RIGHTS -OF -WAY; PROVIDING FOR ENFORCEMENT; AND DECLARING AN EMERGENCY THE CITY OF WOODBURN ORDAINS AS FOLLOWS: Section 1. Purpose. This Ordinance is adopted pursuant to the City's police powers as set forth in the Oregon Constitution and the Woodburn Charter for the following purposes: A. To protect public health and safety. B. To maintain and safeguard the use of Public Rights -of -Way, which the City holds in trust for the public C. To protect the constitutional rights of all individuals. D. To avoid the creation of public nuisances. Section 2. Findings.. The City makes the following findings: A. Camping on Public Rights -of -Way threatens the safety and welfare of all pedestrians, with the greatest impact on those pedestrians who are elderly or young children or who have physical and mental disabilities. B. Camping on Public Rights -of -Way is dangerous to the individuals who are camping and constitutes a public safety hazard. C. Camping on Public Rights -of -Way can be dangerous to drivers and constitutes a public safety hazard. D. Camping on Public Rights -of -Way can obstruct and delay public safety personnel responding to emergencies. E. The accumulation of trash, uncontained food and human waste related to camping in Public Rights -of -Way, is detrimental to safety and public health. Section 3. Camping on Public Property and Rights, -of -Way. It shall be unlawful for any person or persons to camp on Public Rights -of -Way within the City. I -M 1 0 - Hill A. "To Camp" means to set up, or remain in orr at, a Campsite for the purpose of establishing or maintaining a temporary place to live. Ordinance 2577 =1 EXH9 of 12IP xff I tq B. "Campsite" means any place where any bedding, sleeping bag, or other sleeping matter, or any stove or fire is placed, established, or maintained, whether or not such place incorporates the use of any tent, lean-to, shack, or any other structure or any vehicle or part thereof. ACampslite includes any place where there is a tent, or any structure or assembly of materials consisting of a fop or roof or any other upper covering and enclosed on one or more sides, that is of sufficient size for a person to fit underneath or inside. C. "Public Righfs-of-Way" means and includes, but is not limited to, the space in, upon, above, along, across, over or under the public streets, roads, highways, lanes, courts, ways, alleys, boulevards, bridges, trails, paths, sidewalks, bicycle lanes, public utility easements, and all other public ways or areas, including the subsurface under and air space over these areas, but does not include parks, parkland or other City property not generally open to the public for travel. Section 5. Enforcement. A. A violation of this Ordinance is declared a public nuisance under Ordinance 2338 (the Nuisance Ordinance). Due to the public health and safety concerns stated in the Ordinance Findings, the City Council directs the summary abatement of Campsites in Public Rights -of -Way, subject to applicable stale statutes. B. This Ordinance is cumulative to other City Ordinances and regulations and should be construed consistent with these other enactments. Section 6. [Emergency clause.] Passed by the Council and approved by the Mayor January 27, 2020. Ordinance 2,577 IBM =1 I EX10 of 12HIP xff I tq ORDINANCE NO. 2578 AN ORDINANCE, ENACTED IN COMPLIANCE WITH ORS 203.077, TO DEVELOP A POLICY FOR REMOVAL OF CAMPING SITES ON PUBLIC PROPERTY AND DECLARING AN EMERGENCY THE CITY OF WOODBURN ORDAINS AS FOLLOWS: Section 1. Unlawful Camping on Public Property. It is unlawful for any person to camp in or upon public property for more than seventy-two (72) hours after having been given a notice of unlawful camping as provided by this Ordinance. Any person found to be camping unlawfully on public property may be removed from the unlawful Camping Site pursuant to City ordinance and consistent with Oregon law. [Section I as amended by Ordinance No. 2600, passed March 28, 2022.1 ff-MR-17111Pjam- A. "To Camp" means to set up, or remain in or at, a Camping Site for the purpose of establishing or maintaining a temporary place to live, B. "Camping Site" means any place where any bedding, sleeping bag, or other sleeping matter, or any stove or fire is placed, established, or maintained, whether at- not such place incorporates the use of any tent, lean-to, shack, or any other structure or any vehicle or part thereof. A Camping Site includes any place where there is a tent, or any structure or assembly of materials consisting of a top or roof or any other upper covering and enclosed on one or more sides, that is of sufficient size for a person to fit underneath or inside. A, Prior to the removal of any individual and/or their Personal Property from an established Camping Site on public property, law enforcement officials shall post a Camping Site Removal Notice, written in English and Spanish, seventy-two (72) hours in advance of removal. 1 At the time the notice is, posted, law enforcement officials shall inform a local agency that delivers social services to homeless individuals where the notice has been posted. 2. This local agency may arrange for outreach workers to visit the Camping Site where a notice has been posted to assess the need for social service assistance in arranging shelter and other assistance. 3. All unclaimed Personal Property shall be given to law enforcement officials whether seventy-two (72) hour notice is required or not. The City shall develop a protocol for the custody, removal, storage, and destruction of the unclaimed Personal Property. 4. An Unclaimed Personal Property Notice shall be posted, written in English and Spanish, providing a phone number to call during the business hours of 8:00, AM to 4:00 PM, Monday through Friday, to arrange an appointment to pick up the unclaimed Personal &Z, EX11 �o���� Property. This notice shall be posted at all entrances to the Camping Site and made to be weather resistant. The unclaimed Personal Properly shall be stored for 30 days from the removal date in a facility located within the corporate boundary of the City of Woodburn and will be reasonably available to any individual claiming ownership. Personal property that remains unclaimed for 30 days will be disposed of and the notice removed. 5. "Personal Properly" means any item that is reasonably recognizable as belonging to a person and has apparent utility. Items that have no apparent utility or are in an unsanitary condition will be immediately discarded upon removal of the Camping Site. G. City officials shall photograph the Camping Site prior to the removal of property and provide a general description of items disposed of due to their lack, of apparent utility or unsanitary condition. 7. Weapons, drug paraphernalia and items that appear to be either stolen or evidence of a crime shall be turned over to the appropriate law enforcement officials. B. Following the removal of homeless individuals from a Camping Site on public property, the law enforcement officials, local agency officials and outreach workers may meet to assess the notice and removal policy, to discuss whether removals are occurring in a humane and just manner and to determine if any changes are needed in the policy. C.The seventy-two (72) hour Camping Site Removal Notice shall not apply: 1. When there are grounds for law enforcement officials to believe that illegal activities other than camping are occurring, 2. In the event of an exceptional emergency such as possible site contamination by hazardous materials or when there is immediate danger to human life or safety. DA person authorized to issue a citation, for Unlawful Camping on Public Property may not issue the citation if the citation would be issued within 200 feet of the notice described in this section and within two hours before or after the notice was posted. [Section 3 as amended by Ordinance No. 2600, passed March 28, 2022.1 Section 4. Enforcement. A. Unlawful Camping on Public Property in violation of this Ordinance constitutes a Class 3 Civil Infraction subject to forfeiture not to exceed $250. B. Recognizing the need for humane treatment of homeless individuals Unlawfully Camping on Public Property, the City Council, as an alternative to a Civil Infraction citation under section 4A, authorizes summary abatement of the unlawful Camping Sites pursuant to the procedures provided in this Ordinance. C.This Ordinance is cumulative to other City Ordinances and regulations and should be construed consistent with these other enactments. =I " EX12 of 12HIP xff I tq Section 5. [Emergency clause.] Passed by the Council and approved by the Mayor January 27, 2020. EXH1 �o���� Cify Cify Council Public Process Durafion of Public process Was an Ordinance Ado fed Whaf does fhe Ordinance do Locafion of Esfablished Camping Sife Aufhorized Camping Sife services and regulafions Porfland 1 month: Yes TIME: allows involuntarily homeless persons to camp between the hours of 8 pm and 8 am. After 8 am, the Clinton Triangle in Southeast Portland Site Services: (963,5067) May 31 - June 7, 2023 person must dismantle the campsite and all removal personal property until 8 pm. (1490 SE Gideon St). • Individual pods designed with ADA accessibility in mind (doorway ramps added as needed). Pods can also shelter two individuals who seek to be together. PLACE: The proposed code changes specify several places where camping would be always prohibited. • Some sites may be set up for RV residency Restrictions includethe pedestrian use zone, 250 feet from a school or childcare center, in the public right -of- • A small number of tent platforms for individuals who may not want to move into a pod right away way along the High Crash Corridor, and City Parks. • Meals: Average of one meal per day, plus snack (our experience reveals one meal is enough since not everyone eats the meal; there is typically enough food for those who seek 2 or 3 meals per day) MANNER: Prohibits the use of gas heaters in and around campsite, obstructing access to private properties or • Restrooms and showers, with some ADA-accessible restrooms business adjacent to the public right-of-way, alterations to the ground or infrastructure; environmental Laundry access damage; accumulation or leaving garbage, debris, unsanitary hazardous material, sewage, or drug • Community space for building connections and meeting with social workers paraphernalia. • Decompression areas • Pet areas ENFORCEMENT: If at any time, place, or manner restrictions are violated, the proposed code changes give the • Storage space for personal goods Portland Police Bureau the ability to issue citations, which they do not issue currently. First or second violation of • Access to public transit/transportation time, place, and manner restrictions, the person will receive a written warning. Third or subsequent violations • Electricity (i.e., for phone charging) have a criminal penalty of a fine of no more than $100 or imprisonment for a period not to exceed 30 days. • Wi-fi • Designated parking areas • Perimeter fencing • Regular trash collection and hazardous waste removal • Livability enhancements like planter boxes, artwork, etc. Service Provider: Urban Alchemy To support the extensive services at each site, Urban Alchemy (as of July 14) has hired more than 100 people locally. 85 are already active practitioners and 30 are being onboarded to staff the three Portland sites. At each location, Urban Alchemy and the City will provide: • 24/7 operations with 1 guest services staff for every 15 guests. • Single point of entry and exit for guests at the site with 24/7 check in/out procedures. • Daily access to care coordination managers who will help guest navigate the bureaucracy of social services (1 care coordination manager to every 20 guests). -Access to medical professionals. • Close coordination Multnomah County to use a Built For Zero client -centered public health approach to guide clients through the continuum of care. • Referral -based entry system through the City of Portland. Walk-ins will not be allowed. -Stay for an indefinite period of time. Though the intention is for an individual to use these sites temporarily before transitioning to other housing or care, there will be no specific time limit regarding length of stay. Key site rules: • Alcohol and drugs cannot be consumed in common areas/public spaces. • No cooking or fires are allowed. -No cooking or fires are allowed. • Each guest must agree to community guidelines that emphasize respect for their neighbor. Security: •No guns or illegal weapons; any other potential weapon (e.g. pocket knives) will be securely stored before a guest can access the site. • If an individual needs to be excluded from a site because a person is a clear / present danger to themselves or others, removal options will include the PPB Behavioral Health Unit and Portland Street Response. Perimeter Area: •24/7 hotline staffed by service provider for complaints or questions about the site or perimeter issues. • On -site service provider will monitor an area of approximately 1,000 ft. surrounding the site to engage and communicate with neighbors, engage immediately to new unsanctioned campsites, and report incidents of illegal activities (drug dealing, etc). • Light trash cleanup in the 1,000 ft. area and immediate reporting of large amounts of trash to the City's Impact Reduction Team or Metro RID. -Service provider will engage regularly with surrounding residents, clients, businesses, neighborhood associations, and Enhanced Service Districts. Parking: -Sites will be chosen with availability of public transit in mind. -Sites may include RV / car options. • Parking availability and rules will be aligned to reduce impact on the surrounding community. a, EXH2�o���� City City Council Public Process Duration of Public process Was an What does the Ordinance do Ordinance Adopted Location of Established Camping Site Authorized Camping Site services and regulations Eugene Work Session April 24, 2023 1 month: Yes TIME: Permitted overnight sleeping Dusk to Dawn Program between the hours of 4:30 pm and 7:30 am. In Dawn to Dawn Dawn to Dawn: Dawn to Dawn (formerly known as Dusk to Dawn) is a low -barrier, drop -in shelter (177,923) Ordinance 20689 Adopted April 24 - May 24, 2023 Ordinance determining the hors that the City Manager permits persons to sleep overnight at designated sites, the City 171 Highway 99 program that provides space where people can stay, keep their belongings, and receive connections May 24, 2023 20689 Manager shall consider, among other things, the seasonal sunset. to services. Shelter is provided in heated, multi -person tents. Managed by: St. Vincent dePaul Sign up begins at 2 p.m. every day at the Eugene Service Station at 450 Hwy 99N. The Service Station PLACE: City Manager shall recommend to the City Council proposed sites for the Dustk to Dawn program. can be reached at (541) 461-8688. Proposed site may not be located in a residential area or close to a school, and must be owned or leased by the City of Eugene, another governmental agency, a religious institution, a non-profit organization, or a Rules and Regulations: business if the business is located on property zoned commercial or industrial. The City Council must approve the site by motion and the City Manager must adopt an administrative rule governing use of the site. If, as an Administrative Order 53-1 7-03F addition to the permitted overnight sleeping program athorized by this subsection (11), daytime support • Property provider/site manager shall be resposible forproviding supervision during site operating services are available at or near the site, the Dusk to Dawn site may be referred as a Dawn to Dawn site. hours. No person shall camp in or upon the following publicly owned property: • Site will be occupied no earlier than 4:30 p.m. and no later than 7:30 a.m. in a 24 hour period. (a) Property that is primarily intended for and used by motor vehicles, including but not limited to, the portion of • Personal property will be stored in compliance with criteria st by the property provider/site manager the street between the curbs; and must be taken with guests when they vacate the site each day. (b) Publicly owned parking lots and on -street parking spaces; • One or more portable toilets with weekly cleaning,and weekly trash/recycling pick up. (c) Property that is intended to provide a buffer between lanes of vehicular traffic or between vehicular traffic • Keep the site and sorrounding property free from accumulation of trash or items left beind by guests. and pedestrians, including but not limited to traffic islands and parking strips, if there is not a minimum of 60 • Site manager shall maintain a roster of individuals who are authorized to be at the property. inches (5 feet) between the campsite and vehicular traffic; • No exceeding of the number of people permitted by the City Manager's written authorization. (d) Sidewalks, accessways, and shared -use paths when the minimum width established by the Americans with • Site manager shall ensure that guests comply with all provisions of these rules, the site agreement, Disabilities Act (ADA) or the Federal Highway Administration and provisions adopted by City Council. (FHWA) cannot be maintained. For purposes of this section, sidewalks must have a minimum clear width of 48 • All applicable provisions of federal, state, and local laws will be complied with, including the inches (4 feet), and accessways and shared -use paths must requirements of the fire code. have a minimum clear width of 120 inches (10 feet); (e) Property adjacent to a building if the campsite blocks access to the building's entrance, exit, access ramp, Dusk to Dawn - Guest Responsibilities: or stairs; (f) For the Willamette River and all other open waterways, property located within 100 feet of top of high bank; The following activities/items are prohibited from the property: and property within 5 feet of ditches, wetlands, and vegetative stormwater quality facilities. For purposes of this -Alcohol; illegal drugs section, "top of high bank" means the highest point at which the bank meets the grade of the surrounding • Weapons topography, characterized by an abrupt or noticeable change from a steeper grade to a less steep grade, • Illegal activity and "open waterway" means a natural or human -made creek, stream, pond, or open channel; and, • Open flames, unless approved by the Fire Marshal. (g) Property within 1000 feet of an educational facility. For purposes of this section, "educational facility" means • Loud music or other disruptive noise a public library or a building owned, leased or under the • Overnight visitors control of a public or private school system, college, university, or licensed daycare or preschool. • Physical violence, intimidating or threatening behavior or language while on or in the vicinity of the property; damage or harm to the property or property in the MANNER: Unless otherwise authorized in the code or by revocable permit, no person shall: surrounding area. (a) Cut or split wood on a street or sidewalk. • Behavior on or near the property that may negatively affect the peace and (b) Carryl, hau, deposit, or discard any rubbish, garbage, debris, human waste, or other refuse upon any street, enjoyment of the property and surrounding property for other overnight sleepers or sidewalk, accessway, or shared -use path exposed so as to be offensive to pedestrians. for neighbors. (c) Give a show, exhibition or performance on a street or sidewalk. • Children (d) Set up or operate a vehicle, stand or place for the display or sale of merchandise, or selll, vend, or display . Guests shall be selected by the property provider/site manager and may stay on the for sale an article in the streets or on the sidewalks or in doorways or stairways of business houses, or in any property until the property provider/site manager revokes that permission. If permission to remain other place where such activity causes congregation and congestion of people or vehicles on the streets or property on the is revoked, the guest(s) s must immediate) remove themselves and their property g () y p p y sidewalks. (e) Place or maintain gasoline pumps or similar devices for vending volatile oils on a street or alley except or risk citation for trespassing, having their vehicle towed, at the owner's expense, and their under a revocable permit from the city manager. property disposed of. • Guests shall deposit all garbage in waste receptacles provided by the property (f) Place personal property on a sidewalk, accessway, or shared -use path if the minimum width established by provider/site manager or transport it off site and dispose of it lawfully, and shall keep the area where the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) or the Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) is not maintained. For they are sleeping clean. purposes of this section, sidewalks must have a minimum clear width of 48 inches (4 feet), and accessways and -Guests shall use bathroom facilities provided by the property provider/site manager, or available to shared -use paths must have minimum clear width of 120 inches (10 feet). the public off -site. (g) Drain, or cause or permit to be drained, sewage, graywater, or the drainage from a cesspool, septic tank, • Guests must comply with any additional rules or regulations not covered here but recreational or camping vehicle waste holding tank or other contaminated source, upon any street, sidewalk, established by the property provider/site manager. accessway, or shared -use path, the associated stormwater drainage system, or adjacent wetlands. A violation of this section is deemed an immediate risk to public health and safety and, in addition to the issuance of a Dusk to Dawn - Closure of Site by the City Manager. citation for the violation, a recreational or camping vehicle is subject to immediate impoundment in The City Manager may close a site at any time upon determining that allowing camping at accordance with EC 5.693-5.980 and the administrative rules adopted pursuant thereto. a site would create or continue dangerous conditions or a threat to the public health, safety or welfare, or if the property provider/site manager fails to comply with these regulations or the provisions adopted by the City Council. 1 _* EXH3�o���� Cify Cify Council Public Process Durafion of Public process Was an Whaf does fhe Ordinance do Ordinance Ado fed Locafion of Esfablished Camping Sife Aufhorized Camping Sife services and regulafions Salem May 8: First Reading Less than a month Yes TIME: (177,487) May 22: Second Reading Ordinance 9- 23 PLACE: Camping Prohibited on Public Property. It is unlawful for any person to camp in or upon: (1) Any public property posted with a "No Camping" sign, (2) Any public right-of-way used for vehicular or bicycle transportation, (3) Within ten (10) feet of the intersection of a street and a driveway or a private pedestrian path, or within ten (10) feet of a building entry, (4) Any area designated as a park in the Salem Park System Master Plan, (5) The interior of any publicly owned building or structure, (6) Public property zoned single-family or multi -family residential or adjacent to those zones, (7) Within 600 feet of an authorized emergency shelter, day center, managed temporary village, or safe parking shelter location, (8) Within the area subject to a Permit of Entry issued by the City, The City Manager or designee, in the Manager's or designee's sole discretion, may designate a particular location on public property, or class of public property, where camping is prohibited, including: (1) High vehicular traffic areas, (2) Environmentally sensitive areas, (3) Any area that has become, or is at risk of becoming, a threat to public health or safety due to the chronic establishment of campsites, the proliferation of campsites within the area, or proximity to sensitive uses, such as pre-schools, K-12 and post -secondary schools, or social service providers. Areas or locations where a camping prohibition has been designated shall be posted with a "No Camping" sign. MANNER: Maintain a 36-inch pedestrian path within a public sidewalk, free of any obstruction. Gresham Part of City Council's Amended TIME: (111,621) Strategic Goal Policy 12-01 June 2023: Revised Clean- PLACE: up of unauthorized (1) No person shall camp on public property or public rights -of -way, other than an area approved by the city campsites on public for the permitted use and built for the purpose of campgrounds or overnight parks. property. MANNER: No person in charge of property shall permit camping on such property unless it is occupied and approved as a residential use and the property owner has given written permission to camp, and in no event for more than 72 hours in a 30-day period. Exceptions may be granted under emergency conditions as determined by the manager. ENFORCEMENT: "Persons experiencing homelessness" does not include a person camping on public property or on any public street or right-of-way who has been offered shelter in compliance with State law and City policy. The following provisions apply to persons experiencing homelessness: In accordance with ORS 195.500-530, the City Manager shall adopt an administrative rule developing a policy that recognizes the social nature of the problem of persons experiencing homelessness camping on public property and implement the policy as developed to ensure the most humane treatment for removal of persons experiencing homelessness from campsites on public property. The policy shall, among other things, comply with applicable federal and state law. The Manager shall review the policy annually to ensure compliance with applicable law and prominently post the policy on the City's website. A person experiencing homelessness shall not be subject to a fine or penalty as stated in section 7.10.1 65(4) unless that person has first been offered shelter in compliance with applicable law. EXH4�o���� Cify Cify Council Public Process Durafion of Public process Was an Whaf does fhe Ordinance do Ordinance Ado fed Locafion of Esfablished Camping Sife Aufhorized Camping Sife services and regulafions Hillsboro Advisory group met for 2.5 months: Yes TIME: Between the hours of 7 pm to 7 am. July 8-- The City of Hillsboro opened a Sites must be operated by: (107,299) three sessions: March 31 - June 20, 2023 Ordinance 64- temporary camping site at 699 SW The City of Hillsboro or other local government. March 31, April 14, and May 54 PLACE: Persons without shelter are permitted to camp on public ROW within the city or upon other city Wood street near Downtown Hillsboro OR 26, 2023 properties that are outdoors and open to the public. City manager may adopt administrative rules that can An organization with at least two years experience operating sanctioned campsites or emergency Survey to engage Hillsboro limit the actual ROW or portion thereof as well as which city properties may be used for camping. Managed by: Project Homeless shelters. Must be a local housing authority, religious corporation, or public benefit corporation community Sanctioned campsites established for camping by individuals and has received written approval from the City connect supporting homelessness. Ordinance updates manager. OR presented at two City A nonprofit corporation partnering with local government or an experienced organization as listed Council work sessions: May MANNER: Administrative rules may limit the manner in which camping may occur. Sanctioned campsites must above. 2 and May 16, 2023 comply with all applicable laws a regulations and any condition imposed on the operation of the campsite by https://www.hillsboro- Conditions the manager; must not create unreasonable risk to health or safety or constitute a threat to the public welfare; oregon.gov/Home/Components/Ne There can be no charge for use. no direct damage to the environment; no dumping of gray water; no open flames, recreational fires, burning ws/News/12729/1718 Must include sleeping areas, regular trash and recycling service, and restrooms. garbage and bonfires; no dumping of hazardous materials; no erecting permanent or temporary structure; no Must not create unreasonable risk to public health, safety, or welfare unauthorized connections or taps to electrical or other utilities; no camping within 10 feet from doorways to The City Manager may create reasonable rules for each campsite, such as: business entrances or driveways. Length of use Hours of operation Camping allowed in the ROW is subject to: camp materials may not obstruct any portion of any street, bike How many guests are permitted lane, or bike path intended for travel of vehicle, bicycle, pedestrian or other legal mode of travel; camp may Number of restrooms, trash, and recycling areas not be in any ROW in any location that does not have a curb or other physical barrier separating the camp or camp materials from the area intended for vehicular use; camp may not obstruct portion of sidewalk, multi -use Wood Sfreef Provisions: path, or pedestrian path in a manner that results in less than 36 inches of unobstructed area for passage or Investments from the City and other partners will make the site capable of hosting a maximum of 30 impairs any access required by the ADA; camp may not be attached to any public or private infrastructure; no campers, and the site will have the following facilities and services: coping on any portion of the ROW under or within a bridge. Camping within a vehicle must be parked in areas of the of the ROW where vehicles are permitted to be parked. No parking with or on a planter strip or other • Portable restrooms areas not intended for parking. No storing outside on the vehicle or the ROW; no obstruction of the sidewalk • Hand washing station multi -use path, or pedestrian path in a manner that results in less than 36 inches of unobstructed area for -Trash collection service passage or impairs any access required by the ADA; camp may not be attached to any public or private -Security fencing infrastructure; Vehicle camping must comply with all other applicable laws and regulations, including parking -30 designated tent sites and storage restrictions found in the city code or administrative rules. -Sleeping bags -Sleeping pads •24/7 supervision (from Project Homeless Connect) • Limited food and bottled water (from Project Homeless Connect) 300 EXH5�o���� Cify Cify Council Public Process Durafion of Public process Was an Whaf does fhe Ordinance do Ordinance Ado fed Locafion of Esfablished Camping Sife Aufhorized Camping Sife services and regulafions Bend Yes TIME: Camping may only occur for 24 hours at a time in any one location, after 24 hours in on location, the Currently no established site (103,254) camp and all associated camp materials mut be moved at least one block or 600 feet. PLACE: Camping is not allowed in any area zones Residential (RL, IRS, RM, RH) on the City of Bend Zoning Map in effect at that time; within the Waterway Overlay Zone, as determined by the City of Bend Zoning Map and Bend Development Code; any place where camp or camping materials create a physical impediment to emergency or nonemergency ingress, egress, or access to property, private or public, or on public sidewalks or other public ROW; on any vehicle or bicycle lane or roundabout within any public ROW; within 1,000 feet from any safe parking site or shelter approved under the Bend Development Code/ and or applicable provision of State law; on any street or public ROW the City has closed for construction, heavy vehicle use, or other use of the roadway that is incompatible with camping in the ROW, the closure of the street does not have to be for vehicle traffic to close a street to camping. MANNER: Camping, when and where allowed, is subject to the following: Camp or camp materials may not obstruct sidewalk accessibility or passage, clear vision, fire hydrants, City or other utility infrastructure, or otherwise interfere with the use of the ROW for vehicular, pedestrian, bicycle, or other passage. A camp or camping must be limited within a spatial footprint of 12 feet by 12 feet, or 144 square feet. No more than three camps may be set up per block. Individuals may not accumulate, discard, or leave behind garbage, debris ,unsanitary or hazardous materials, or other items of no apparent utility in public ROW, on City property, or on ay adjacent public or private property. Open flames, recreational fires, burning of garbage, bonfires, or other fires, flames, or heating deemed unsafe by Bend Fire and Rescue are prohibited. Types of cooking stoves and there devices for keeping warm are permitted, as allowed by adopted City policies. Dumping of gray water is prohibited. Unauthorized connections or taps to electrical or other utilities, or violations of building, fire, or other relevant codes or standards, are prohibited. Obstruction or attachment of camp materials or personal property to fire hydrants, utility poles or other utility or public infrastructure, fences, trees, vegetation, vehicles, or buildings is prohibited. Individuals may not built or erect structures. storage of personal property other than what is related to camping, sleeping, or keeping warm and dry. Digging, excavation, terracing of soil, alteration of ground or infrastructure, or damage to vegetation or trees is prohibited. Use of emergency power generators that result in a violation of Bend Code 5.50.020(A) is prohibited. All animals must be leashed or crated at all times. Vehicle camping: Bend Code 6.20 governs where and for how long individuals may legally park vehicles on the public ROW, these standards are applicable to al individuals including those who use vehicles for shelter and/or sleeping on public ROW. Vehicle must be legally parked in compliance with the Bend City Code and any applicable policies. No building or erecting of any structures connecting or attaching to vehicles is permitted, including tents that are not designed and manufactured to be attached to a vehicle. Individuals may not accumulate, discard, or leave behind garbage, debris ,unsanitary or hazardous materials, or other items of no apparent utility in public ROW, on City property, or on ay adjacent public or private property. Open flames, recreational fires, burning of garbage, bonfires, or other fires, flames, or heating deemed unsafe by Bend Fire and Rescue are prohibited. Types of cooking stoves and there devices for keeping warm are permitted, as allowed by adopted City policies. Dumping of gray water is prohibited. Storage of material outside vehicle is prohibited, other than what is incidental to activities such as short-term loading and unloading a vehicle. Vehicle must be operational or ready to be towed if designed to be towed, may not be discarded or left inoperable in public ROW or on City property. Use of emergency power generators that result in a violation of Bend Code 5.50.020(A) is prohibited. All animals must be leashed or crated at all times. ENFORCEMENT: After a camp has been in one place for 24 hours or more, the City may post notice at the location that the camp, and all associated camp materials, must be removed no more than 72 hours later and all personal property remaining will be removed. Vehicle camping: Violations will be in accordance with applicable State law and City ordinances and policies, including laws, ordinances, and policies governing towing and impounding vehicles. 301 EXH6�o���� Cify Cify Council Public Process Durafion of Public process Was an Whaf does fhe Ordinance do Ordinance Ado fed Locafion of Esfablished Camping Sife Aufhorized Camping Sife services and regulafions Beaverfon 01 /17/2023: Council work 4.5 months: yes TIME: A person without alternative shelter may camp between the hours of 9:00 p.m. and 7:30 a.m. After 7:30 (97,053) sessions; January 17 - June 6, 2023 Ordinance a.m. a person without alternative shelter must dismantle the campsite and remove all personal property from 03/07/2023: Council work 4841 the campsite. session; VEHICLE CAMPING: A safe parking program guest may camp in a vehicle in a safe parking site for a continuous 04/13 - 05/01 /2023: period as permitted by the regulations of the safe parking program. Community Survey; 05/16/2023: 1 st Public PLACE: A person without alternative shelter may camp in or upon the public right-of-way; provided, however, Hearing; that a person without alternative shelter may not camp in the following places at any time: 06/06/2023: 2nd Public 1. On city property, except that a safe parking program guest may camp in a vehicle at a city safe parking Hearing site. 2. Within 500 feet from a safe parking site, a shelter or a property where homeless services are provided. 3. Within 500 feet from a lot or parcel containing an elementary school, secondary school or a certified child care center. 4. Within 500 feet from a freeway egress or ingress. 5. Within 50 feet of an intersection. 6. Within 10 feet of a fire hydrant. MANNER: 1. A person without alternative shelter may not obstruct pedestrian or vehicular traffic along a public right-of- way or into private property and businesses adjacent to a public right-of-way. For purposes of this subsection, a person without alternative shelter is presumed to obstruct pedestrian traffic if a person reduces the path of travel to less than 36 inches. 2. A person without alternative shelter may not (a) start or maintain any fire for the purpose of burning any combustible material in or around a campsite; or (b) use a gas heater in or around a campsite. 3. A person without alternative shelter may not accumulate, discard or leave behind in or around a campsite (a) any rubbish, trash, garbage, debris or other refuse; (b) any unsanitary or hazardous materials; or (c) any animal or human urine or feces. 4. A person without alternative shelter may not camp within 150 feet of another campsite. 5. A person without alternative shelter may not erect, install, place, leave, or set up any type of fixture or structure of any material or materials in or around a campsite. For purposes of this subsection, a "fixture or structure of any material or materials" does not include a tent, tarpaulin or other similar item used for shelter that is readily portable. 6. A person without alternative shelter may not dig, excavate, terrace soil, alter the ground or infrastructure, cause environmental damage, or damage vegetation or trees in or around a campsite. Tigard Since January 2023 the City 5 months: Yes TIME: Camping is prohibited between 9 a.m. and 7 p.m. (55,762) engaged the Community January thru May 23, 2023 Ordinance 23- Homelessness Assessment 03 PLACE: Camping is prohibited in: and Response Team • Sensitive lands, such as wetlands, significant habitat areas, and undeveloped park land (CHART) . City parks In February and May the . City parking lots Committee for Community . Along SW Burnham Street, SW Main Street, SW Commercial Street and SW Tigard Street between SW Main Engagement (CCE) was Street and SW Tiedeman Street briefed and consulted on . Within 500 ft. of houseless services, schools, and freeway entrances/exits the ordinance . Within any vision clearance area around intersections, as indicated in grey in the images below The Chief's Advisory Panel has been consulted and MANNER: How campers may set up their campsites is regulated in several ways, including: gave feedback to staff on . Campsite may not obstruct travel the direction of the Time, . Campsite must be 10 ft. from driveways, building entrances/exits, fire hydrants, and other utility infrastructure Place, and Manner . Campers may not start or maintain a fire or use a gas heater ordinance . Campers may not dig, excavate, erect/install fixtures, or harm vegetation Staff held multiple 1-1 and . Campers may not accumulate, discard, or leave behind trash, hazardous materials, or feces group conversations with . Campsites are limited to 12x12 ft. and must be 20 ft. apart from one another neighboring jurisdictions about the status of each community's ordinance and how it can align with their respective ordinances. All feedback has been incorporated into the proposed draft ordinance. May 9, 2023: Staff presented background information, considerations, and recommendations to Council. May 23, 2023 1 st Legislative Public Hearing. 302 EXH7�o���� Cify Cify Council Durafion of Was an Whaf does fhe Ordinance do Locafion of Esfablished Aufhorized Camping Sife services and regulafions Public Process Public process Ordinance Camping Sife Ado fed Lake Oswego None None NO Resolution 16-24 A Resolution of the City Council of the City of Lake Oswego Amending the Park Rules (40,108) (09 /20/2016) : 17. Overnight Camping. Camping overnight in any Park Property is prohibited, except at places designated for such purposes by the Director. Keizer June 6, 2023: 1 st reading - 1 month Amending TIME: For those experiencing homelessness, in areas where camping is not prohibited, persons must relocate (38,704) ordinance did not pass Ordinance within 24 hours after arrival. unanimously and requires a 2020-812 second reading; PLACE: In express recognition of the need for those experiencing homelessness to19 sleep and rest and if they July 3, 2023: 2nd reading have nowhere else to go, camping is not prohibited in 20 public rights -of -way, except in the following right-of- way areas: (1) Vehicular and bicycle travel lanes and five (5) feet adjacent to such travel lanes. (2) Stormwater facilities. (3) Adjacent to any residential uses. (4) Within 100 feet of any school or daycare facility. (5) Within 100 feet of any church, except for on property that is accommodating camping or camping like activities under ORS 195.520. (6) Within ten (10) feet of the intersection of a street and driveway or a private pedestrian path, or within ten (10) feet of a building entry. (7) Within a five foot (5') clear pedestrian path on any public sidewalk. MANNER: Individuals may not build or erect structures, whether by using plywood, metal, wood materials, pallets, or other materials. Items such as tents and similar items used for shelter that are readily portable are not structures for purposes of this Section. The City Manager may adopt administrative rules or policies governing or guiding enforcement of this Ordinance, including but not limited to ensuring consistent and appropriate enforcement for various circumstances. Upon emergency declaration of the City Council, City Manager or Emergency Manager, other areas may be authorized for limited short-term camping. Upon finding it to be in the public interest, the City Manager or City Council may exempt a special event from compliance with this Section. The City Manager or City Council shall specify the period of time and location covered by the exemption, as well as other reasonable conditions. ENFORCEMENT: Violations of this Ordinance are infractions, and the violators may be cited under the Keizer Civil Infraction Ordinance. The minimum fine is $50. The presumptive fine is $100. The maximum fine is $150. In lieu of or in addition to a fine, the judge may impose other measures, consistent with ORS 153.008, that are reasonably calculated to aid the individual in not engaging in the conduct that led to the citation again in the future. Methods of enforcement for violations of this Ordinance are not exclusive and may consist of multiple enforcement mechanisms where legally authorized and appropriate. However, the intent of the city is to always resolve violations at the lowest possible level, and to engage to seek compliance and solve problems while maintaining the dignity of all involved. To that end, violations of this Ordinance should only result in citations when other means of achieving compliance have been unsuccessful, or are not practicable for the particular situation. McMinnville May 28, 2023 the Council Yes TIME: Camping allowed on most publicly owned property in McMinnville between the hours of 9:30 p.m. and (34,530) voted to amend Ordinance Ordinance 6:30 a.m. 8.36 5064 VEHICLE CAMPING: Sleeping in cars parked on most public property between the hours of 9:30 p.m. and 6:30 a.m. is allowed. PLACE: It is unlawful at all times for any person to establish or occupy a campsite on the following City property: 1. All park areas: 2. All public property located within the boundaries of the McMinnville Urban Renewal Area; 3. All publicly owned or maintained parkin lots; and 4. All public property located within an area zoned for Residential Use under MCC Chapter 17. MANNER: It is legal to use camp stoves and small cooking devices, as long as they are used in a safe manner and in conditions that do not place any person, property or structures in danger. It is against the law to store camp paraphernalia, such as tents, tarps, sleeping bags and other equipment, on the publicly owned property during the day (6:30 a.m. to 9:30 p.m.) It is against the law to camp on private property without the property owner's permission or as sanctioned under MMC 8.36.020 under Temporary Camping Program. Obstructing pedestrians or vehicle travel is against the law (ORS 166.025). This means that people may not: • Sit or lay in a manner that blocks passage of another person or vehicles or requires another person or driver to take evasive action to avoid contact. It is against the law to litter (MMC 8.16.168). All property should be treated with respect, regardless of the value of the property and, as a community, we have a right to keep the city beautiful be requiring citizens pick up after themselves. The City's parking code will continue to be enforced under MMC Chapter 10. 303 EXH8�o���� Cify Cify Council Public Process Durafion of Public process Was an Whaf does fhe Ordinance do Ordinance Ado fed Locafion of Esfablished Camping Sife Aufhorized Camping Sife services and regulafions Tualafin June] 2, 2023: City Council One month Yes TIME: A person without shelter may camp on outdoor City property as permitted by subsection (2) (a) only if the Grassy Parcel along Southwest (27,797) work session to discuss the Ordinance person complies with all of the following time restrictions. Tualatin Road adjacent to the police draft of the ordinance. 1475-23 • A person may only camp between the hours of 7pm and 7 am. After 7 am, a person without available shelter station. June 26, 2023: must dismantle the campsite and remove all personal property and camp materials from the campsite. Consideration of Ordinacne Prohibiting and Regulating PLACE: A person without available shelter may not camp in the following places at any time. camping in Tualatin • Within any City -owned or maintained parking lot. • Within 500 feet from a public or private elementary school, secondary school, or career school attended primarily by minors. • within 500 feet from an egress or ingress too a freeway. • Within 20 feet of a building, including but not limited to residences, commercial buildings and City buildings. • Within the Natural Resource Protection Overlay, Wetland Protected Areas, Natural Areas identified in the Parks and Recreation Master Plan, greenways, and landscaped areas on publicly owned land. • In the public right-of-way and railroad right-of-way. • within municipal grounds and Library Plaza. MANNER: A person without available shelter may camp on City property as permitted by subsection (2) (a) if the person complies with all of the following manner regulations. • A person may not accumulate, discard, or leave behind in or around a campsite any rubbish, trash, garbage, debris, or other refuse, unsanitary or hazardous materials, or any animal or human urine and feces. • Digging, excavating, terracing of soil or other alteration of City property, or causing environmental damage or damage to vegetation or trees is prohibited. • Obstruction or attachment of camp materials to public infrastructure or private property structures, including bridges or bridge infrastructure, fire hydrants, utility poles, streetlights, traffic signals, signs, fences, trees, vegetation, vehicles, or buildings is prohibited. • Erecting, installing, placing, leaving, or setting up any type of permanent or temporary fixture or structure of any material or materials in or around a campsite is prohibited. For purposes of this section, a "permanent or temporary fixture or structure" does not include a tent, tarpaulin, or other similar item used for shelter that is readily portable. • A campsite must be limited within a spatial footprint of 12 feet by 12 feet, or 144 square ft, and a campsite may not be within 10 feet of another campsite. Multiple persons may camp together in a single campsite, subject to the limitations of this subsection. • Unauthorized connections or taps to electrical or other utilities, or violations of building, fire, or other relevant codes or standards are prohibited. • Open flames, recreational fires, burning of garbage, and bonfires are prohibited except as specified in Chapter5-2-040. • Camping materials may not create a physical impairment to emergency ingress or egress or emergency response including within 10 feet of any fire hydrant, utility pole, or other utility, fire gate/bollards, or public infrastructure used for emergency response. 304 EXH9�o���� Cify Cify Council Public Process Durafion of Public process Was an Whaf does fhe Ordinance do Ordinance Ado fed Locafion of Esfablished Camping Sife Aufhorized Camping Sife services and regulafions Wesf Linn April 2023: Infomed the Two months: Yes TIME: "Overnight" camping means occurring anytime during the hours of closure or between the hours of 7:00 (26,931) community of the required April - June 20, 2023 Ordinance p.m. and 7:00 a.m. upcomiong changes 1744 through social media and PLACE: It is unlawful for any individual to camp at an established campsite, unless otherwise specifically newsletter campains. authorized by this section or City council. Any campsite may not create a physical impediment to emergency May 8, 2023: City Council or nonemergency access to City property or private property. Any campsite may not be set up on City work session, offering public property on a sidewalk that obstructs accessibility, passage, or otherwise interferes with the use of the sidewalk comment. for its designed and intended purpose. May 15, 2023: Proposed It is not unlawful for an individual to camp on City property overnight excluding parks unless there is a Code read at City Council designated camping area. meeting. MANNER: An established campsite may be authorized, notwithstanding subsection (5) of West Linn Municipal June 12, 2023: Present Code, when: proposed ordinance (a) the City Manager has declared an emergency. around removal of any (b) the City has issued an individual a parks permit or special event permit allowing camping in accordance reference to camping in with stated terms and conditions of the permit. the municipal code A campsite may not obstruct access to fire hydrants, utility poles, or public (5.115)with no regulation in infrastructure. place for camping. A campsite may not be located within 10 feet of building entrance, exit, driveway, loading dock, or established June 20, 2023: Adopted park trail. new Code. A campsite may not be located within 300 feet of any school or licensed, certified, or authorized childcare center. A campsite may not be located on or within 50 feet of a river or stream.Any campsite must be limited in size to 10 feet by 10 feet. Individuals may not accumulate, discard, or leave behind garbage, debris, unsanitary or hazardous materials, or other materials of no apparent utility on City property or in City right-of-way. Individuals at a campsite may not connect to electrical or other utilities and may not violate any building, fire, or other City codes and standards. Individuals at a campsite may use cooking stoves or other devices to keep warm and dry; however, open flames, recreational fires, burning of garbage, bonfires or other fires are strictly prohibited. Individuals may not dump gray water (i.e., wastewater from baths or sinks) or black water (i.e., sewage water) onto City property or any other facility, including storm drains, not intended for gray water or black water disposal. VEHICLE CAMPING: Individuals may use motor vehicles for shelter and to keep warm and dry on City right-of- way to the extent the use complies with the requirements in this section: Motor vehicles are in compliance with the parking regulations set forth in Chapter 6 of the code. Per Section 6.280, Motor vehicles may not be parked at any time upon the southwesterly right of way of Portland Avenue (Oregon State Highway Route 43) within the corporate limits of the City, from a point located at mile post 10.52 (directly opposite the intersection of Holmes Street and Highway 43) to mile post 1 1.12 (directly opposite the intersection of Holly Street and Highway 43). Motor vehicles must be operational, i.e., capable of being started and driven under their own power, or ready to be towed if designed to be towed, and may not be discarded or left inoperable in the City right-of-way. Individuals may not attach or connect any structures to the motor vehicle, unless such structures are designed for such purposes. Individuals may use cooking stoves or other devices to keep warm and dry; however, open flames, recreational fires, burning of garbage, bonfires or other fires in, on, or around motor vehicles are strictly prohibited. Individuals may not accumulate, discard, or leave behind garbage, debris, unsanitary or hazardous materials, or other materials of no apparent utility around motor vehicles. Individuals may not dump gray water (i.e., wastewater from baths or sinks) or black water (i.e., sewage water) onto City property or any other facility, including storm drains, not intended for gray water or black water disposal. 305 EX10�o���� Cify Cify Council Public Process Durafion of Public process Was an Whaf does fhe Ordinance do Ordinance Ado fed Locafion of Esfablished Camping Sife Aufhorized Camping Sife services and regulafions Wilsonville Extensive community outreach Yes TIME: Camping is not allowed in Wilsonville, except in the following designated locations, between 9 pm and 7 Wilsonville City Hall property located The City has identified where individuals who are involuntarily homeless may shelter for survival. (26,597) 6 City Council work sessions Ordinance am.: at 29799 SW Received input from the City's 879 Town Center Loop East, Wilsonville, Designated Area(s). It is prohibited at all times for any person to use City property or City rights -of -way DEI Committee, Library Board, Resolution PLACE: Vehicle camping: in designated spots at City Hall parking lot (29799 SW Town Ctr. Loop E.) Oregon to camp for survival, except at the following location(s). The City designates the following specific and Parks and Recreation 3058 Tent camping: in designated area across the street from City Hall parking lot. locations on the Wilsonville City Hall property located at 29799 SW Town Center Loop East, Wilsonville, Advisory Board In the event that the areas and Oregon for individuals who are involuntarily homeless to camp, pursuant to the time and manner February 23, 2023: City Council (1) Except as authorized pursuant to WC 10.770, at all times it is unlawful for any persons to camp or to spaces identified are at capacity and regulations outlined in WC 10.720 and WC 10.740. Work Session; establish, maintain, or occupy a campsite on City -owned property not identified as a Designated Area, an individual who is involuntarily March 6, 2023: City Council Work including, but not limited to: homeless needs a location to shelter Oufreach and Educafion Session; (a) All City parks and City parking lots within City parks. for survival, the City Manager may Resource Materials. The City will develop resource material(s), including, but not Mrch 20, 2023: City Council Work (b) All City parking lots, City structures, or other City property not designated for camping in the designate limited to, Washington County and Clackamas County resources for individuals Session; Administrative Rules, as provided in subsection 2 below. additional location(s) as may be who are involuntarily homeless and information of the City's camping for survival April 3, 2023: City Council Work (c) All City rights -of -way, including rights -of -way within and adjacent to areas zoned for residential uses and necessary pursuant to WC 10.770(2). regulations. The City will have these educational materials printed in English and Session; rights -of -way adjacent to public and private schools and child care facilities. Such temporary action by the City Spanish and available to employees, individuals who are involuntarily homeless, April 17, 2023: City Council Work (d) All City sidewalks. Manager must be considered for service providers, and community members at City facilities commonly utilized by Session; (e) All public transit shelters. ratification by the the public. The information will also be provided on the City's website. May 1, 2023: Public Hearing (f) All City property located in the SROZ. City Council at its next regularly (ordinance adopted on first (g) All City property located within 20 feet of a tree designated as a heritage tree in the City's Heritage Tree scheduled meeting. County Coordination. The City will coordinate with Clackamas County and hearing) program. Washington County regarding each County's response to and resources for May 15, 2023: Second Reading (h) The City property at the northeast corner of SW Barber Street and SW Kinsman Road (taxlot number individuals who are involuntarily homeless. City personnel will provide regular (Ordinance and Administrative 31 W 14B 00700). updates to the City Council and community of each County's resources and projects Rules adapted); Resolution 3058 (i) Stormwater treatment facilities, including, but not limited to swales, detention ponds, and drainage to address homelessness. adopted, establishes ways. administrative rules that define (j) On areas underneath City -owned rights -of -way or bridges that are not open to the public. Porta potties and sanitation are available at the camps. the time, place and manner (k) On railroad tracks or within 15 feet of railroad tracks. restrictions to be implemented (I) On any City property or City right-of-way that the City has closed to the public due to construction, locally by July 1, 2023. heavy vehicle or machinery use, or other City or City -sanctioned work that is incompatible with camping in the City right-of-way (2) Designated Area(s). Individuals who are involuntarily homeless may occupy a campsite within the time regulations provided in WC 10.720 and pursuant to the manner regulations in WC 10.740 in the Designated Area(s) identified in the Administrative Rules. For avoidance of doubt, camping is prohibited on all City -owned property and City rights -of -way not designated for camping in the Administrative Rules. MANNER: Camping by individuals who are involuntarily homeless, when and where allowed (see WC 10.720 and 10.730), is subject to all of the following: (1) Individuals, camp materials, camps, or personal property, including shopping carts, may not obstruct sidewalk accessibility or passage, clear vision, fire hydrants, City or other public utility infrastructure, or otherwise interfere with the use of the right-of-way for vehicular, pedestrian, bicycle, or other passage. (2) For campsites other than those contained within a vehicle, the campsite must be limited within a spatial footprint of 10 feet by 10 feet, or 100 square feet. For campsites including a vehicle, the campsite and camp materials must be self-contained within the vehicle. The intent of this section is to allow a person to sleep protected from the elements and maintain the essentials for sheltering, while still allowing others to use public spaces as designed and intended. (3) For campsites located in Designated Area(s), the campsite locations must comply with the spacing requirements identified in the Administrative Rules. (4) Open flames, recreational fires, burning of garbage, bonfires, or other fires, flames, or heating are prohibited. (5) Individuals may not accumulate, discard, or leave behind garbage, debris, unsanitary or hazardous materials, human or animal waste, or other items of no apparent utility in public rights -of -way, on City property, or on any adjacent public or private property. (6) Dumping of gray water (i.e., wastewater from baths, sinks, and the like) or black water (i.e., sewage) into any facilities or places not intended for gray water or black water disposal is prohibited. This includes but is not limited to storm drains, which are not intended for disposal of gray water or black water. (7) Unauthorized connections or taps to electrical or other utilities, or violations of building, fire, or other relevant codes or standards, are prohibited. (8) Obstruction or attachment of camp materials or personal property to fire hydrants, utility poles or other utility or public infrastructure, fences, trees, vegetation, vehicles, buildings, or structures is prohibited. 306 EX11 �o���� Cify Cify Council Public Process Durafion of Public process Was an Whaf does fhe Ordinance do Ordinance Ado fed Locafion of Esfablished Camping Sife Aufhorized Camping Sife services and regulafions (9) Storage of personal property such as vehicle tires, bicycles or associated components (except as needed for an individual's personal use), gasoline, generators, lumber, household furniture, extra propane tanks, combustible material, shopping carts, or other items or materials is prohibited, other than what is related to camping, sleeping, or keeping warm and dry. (10) Digging, excavation, terracing of soil, alteration of ground or infrastructure, or damage to vegetation or trees is prohibited. (11) All animals must be leashed, crated, or otherwise physically contained at all times. (12) Smoking, vaping, and/or the use or distribution of tobacco or cannabis products is prohibited in Designated Area(s). "Tobacco or cannabis products" includes, but is not limited to, any tobacco cigarette, cigar, pipe tobacco, smokeless tobacco, chewing tobacco, any part of the plant Cannabis family Cannabaceae, or any other form of tobacco or cannabis which may be used for smoking, chewing, inhalation, or other means of ingestion. This regulation does not prohibit the use of prescribed medication when used in accordance with the prescription instructions and when used in location(s) allowed under Oregon law. (13) Alcohol may not be consumed, used, or distributed in Designated Area(s). (14) Controlled substances, as defined in ORS 475.005, may not be consumed, used, manufactured, or distributed in Designated Area(s). (15) Vehicle Camping. Individuals who are involuntarily homeless may use vehicles for shelter and/or sleeping in Designated Area(s) under the following circumstances and subject to the conditions and restrictions provided in subsections (1) through (14) above: (a) The vehicle is legally parked in compliance with the Wilsonville Code. (b) Storage of material outside vehicles is prohibited, other than what is incidental to activities such as short- term (maximum 30 minutes) loading or unloading a vehicle. (c) Vehicles must be operational, i.e., capable of being started and driven under their own power, or ready to be towed if designed to be towed and may not be discarded or left inoperable in public rights -of -way or on City property. (d) Vehicles must be registered and insured, as required by the Oregon Vehicle Code. (e) No building or erecting of any structures connecting or attaching to vehicles is permitted, including tents that are not designed and manufactured to be attached to a vehicle. (f) Connections from vehicles to public or private stormwater, sewer, water, and electrical systems or to vehicles from public or private stormwater, sewer, water, and electrical systems are prohibited. 307 EX12�o���� Cify Cify Council Public Process Durafion of Public process Was an Whaf does fhe Ordinance do Ordinance Ado fed Locafion of Esfablished Camping Sife Aufhorized Camping Sife services and regulafions Ashland (21,607) No In order to enforce the Prohibited Camping code the City has a location for overnight use and use the Dusk to 1175 E Main Street, Ashland The City will provide a portable toilet, a clean-up station, pet waste bag stand and trash waste Dawn site. Ashland Police monitor the site with drive by patrols each evening. Behind the police station and city receptacles at the Dusk to Dawn site. Persons found not following the rules are subject to immediate expulsion. Failure to remove personal council chambers belongings by 7:30 a.m. constitutes a breach of the rules and expulsion from the Dusk to Dawn sleeping Overnight sleeping is allowed in this newly designated Dusk to Dawn site between the hours of TIME: 7 location. p.m. and 7:30 a.m., under the following conditions/rules: Guests must vacate the site by 7:30 a.m. and may not return until 7 p.m. each day MANNER: Sleeping space is limited to a 10-feet by 10-feet area allocation for each individual user or companion users of this site. The use of tents or similar temporary overnight cover is allowed within a sleeping space allocation. All camping gear and personal belongings must be contained in a sleeping space allocation and removed from the area by 7:30 a.m. each day. Any camping gear and/or personal belongings of value left on site after 7:30 a.m. will be removed and stored, campers will have 30 days to retrieve belongings. Items determined to pose a health or safety risk to the users of this site are subject to immediate removal and/or disposal. Children must be accompanied by a parent or guardian. Pets: Pets are allowed on -site and must be under their owners control at all time. Pets cannot be left unattended. If a pet is aggressive to other guests or pets, the guest and their pet are subject to immediate removal. Pet owners are required to pick-up after their pets and properly dispose of waste. All dogs six months of age or older must have received a rabies vaccine according to Oregon Health Authority guidelines, 333-019-0017. Upon request of law enforcement, the owner is obligated to provide proof of the rabies vaccine. Personal Behavior: Guests must treat other guests and members of the public with kindness, dignity, and respect Disrespectful, violent, disruptive, vulgar or combative behavior will not be tolerated, nor will racism or bullying. Campers must respect the allowable space of each camper. All guests must pick up after themselves and their pets and dispose of all refuse, including cigarette butts in the appropriate receptacles provided. Guests must adhere to a noise curfew from 10 p.m. to 7 a.m. Guests must adhere to any posted speed limits and traffic rules while on the property. Unauthorized and Illegal Activities - Unlawful behavior or noncompliance with rules for this site is immediate grounds for removal and future exclusion from access and use of this site, including for the following: No visitors are allowed on this site, only overnight guests. No unlawful weapons of any kind are allowed on this site. No cooking, campfires or open flames are allowed on this site. No illegal drug use, or legal recreational drug use including marijuana and/or alcohol use, is allowed on site. 308 Exhibit C 82nd OREGON LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY--2023 Regular Session Enrolled House Bill 3395 Sponsored by Representatives RAYFIELD, DEXTER, GOMBERG, Senator JAMA; Representatives ANDERSEN, NELSON, Senators ANDERSON, PATTERSON CHAPTER ................................................. AN ACT Relating to housing; creating new provisions; amending ORS 92.090, 94.550, 100.015, 100.022, 100.105, 100.110, 100.115, 197.303, 197.758, 197.830, 215.427, 227.178 and 458.650 and sections 3 and 4, chapter 639, Oregon Laws 2019, section 3, chapter 18, Oregon Laws 2021, sections 4 and 6, chapter 67, Oregon Laws 2021, and section 23, chapter 13, Oregon Laws 2023 (Enrolled House Bill 2001); repealing section 4, chapter 18, Oregon Laws 2021; and declaring an emergency. Be It Enacted by the People of the State of Oregon: RESIDENTIAL USE OF COMMERCIAL LANDS SECTION 1. Section 2 of this 2023 Act is added to and made a part of ORS 197.286 to 197.314. SECTION 2. (1) Notwithstanding an acknowledged comprehensive plan or land use regu- lations, within an urban growth boundary a local government shall allow, on lands zoned to allow only commercial uses and not industrial uses, the siting and development oh. (a) Residential structures subject to an affordable housing covenant as provided in ORS 456.270 to 456.295 making each unit affordable to a household with income less than or equal to 60 percent of the area median income as defined in ORS 456.270; or (b) Mixed use structures with ground floor commercial units and residential units subject to an affordable housing covenant as provided in ORS 456.270 to 456.295 making the proper- ties affordable to moderate income households, as defined in ORS 456.270. (2) The local government may only apply those approval standards, conditions and pro- cedures under ORS 197.307, that would be applicable to the residential zone of the local gov- ernment that is most comparable in density to the allowed commercial uses. (3) Development under this section does not: (a) Trigger any requirement that a local government consider or update an analysis as required by a statewide planning goal relating to economic development. (b) Apply on lands where the local government determines that: (A) The development on the property cannot be adequately served by water, sewer, storm water drainage or streets, or will not be adequately served at the time that development on the lot is complete; (B) The property contains a slope of 25 percent or greater; (C) The property is within a 100-year floodplain; or Enrolled House Bill 3395 (HB 3395-B) Page 1 709 Exhibit C (D) The development of the property is constrained by land use regulations based on statewide land use planning goals relating to: (i) Natural disasters and hazards; or (ii) Natural resources, including air, water, land or natural areas, but not including open spaces. (c) Apply on lands that are vacant or that were added to the urban growth boundary within the last 15 years. RESIDENTIAL APPROVAL PROCEDURES SECTION 3. ORS 215.427 is amended to read: 215.427. (1) Except as provided in subsections (3), (5) and (10) of this section, for land within an urban growth boundary and applications for mineral aggregate extraction, the governing body of a county or its designee shall take final action on an application for a permit, limited land use deci- sion or zone change, including resolution of all appeals under ORS 215.422, within 120 days after the application is deemed complete. The governing body of a county or its designee shall take final action on all other applications for a permit, limited land use decision or zone change, including resolution of all appeals under ORS 215.422, within 150 days after the application is deemed com- plete, except as provided in subsections (3), (5) and (10) of this section. (2) If an application for a permit, limited land use decision or zone change is incomplete, the governing body or its designee shall notify the applicant in writing of exactly what information is missing within 30 days of receipt of the application and allow the applicant to submit the missing information. The application shall be deemed complete for the purpose of subsection (1) of this sec- tion and ORS 197.311 upon receipt by the governing body or its designee of: (a) All of the missing information; (b) Some of the missing information and written notice from the applicant that no other infor- mation will be provided; or (c) Written notice from the applicant that none of the missing information will be provided. (3)(a) If the application was complete when first submitted or the applicant submits additional information, as described in subsection (2) of this section, within 180 days of the date the application was first submitted and the county has a comprehensive plan and land use regulations acknowledged under ORS 197.251, approval or denial of the application shall be based upon the standards and criteria that were applicable at the time the application was first submitted. (b) If the application is for industrial or traded sector development of a site identified under section 12, chapter 800, Oregon Laws 2003, and proposes an amendment to the comprehensive plan, approval or denial of the application must be based upon the standards and criteria that were ap- plicable at the time the application was first submitted, provided the application complies with paragraph (a) of this subsection. (4) On the 181st day after first being submitted, the application is void if the applicant has been notified of the missing information as required under subsection (2) of this section and has not submitted: (a) All of the missing information; (b) Some of the missing information and written notice that no other information will be pro- vided; or (c) Written notice that none of the missing information will be provided. (5) The period set in subsection (1) of this section or the 100-day period set in ORS 197.311 may be extended for a specified period of time at the written request of the applicant. The total of all extensions, except as provided in subsection (10) of this section for mediation, may not exceed 215 days. (6) The period set in subsection (1) of this section applies: (a) Only to decisions wholly within the authority and control of the governing body of the county; and Enrolled House Bill 3395 (HB 3395-B) Page 2 710 Exhibit C (b) Unless the parties have agreed to mediation as described in subsection (10) of this section or ORS 197.319 (2)(b). (7) Notwithstanding subsection (6) of this section, the period set in subsection (1) of this section and the 100-day period set in ORS 197.311 do not apply to: (a) A decision of the county making a change to an acknowledged comprehensive plan or a land use regulation that is submitted to the Director of the Department of Land Conservation and De- velopment under ORS 197.610[.1; or (b) A decision of a county involving an application for the development of residential structures within an urban growth boundary, where the county has tentatively approved the application and extends these periods by no more than seven days in order to assure the sufficiency of its final order. (8) Except when an applicant requests an extension under subsection (5) of this section, if the governing body of the county or its designee does not take final action on an application for a permit, limited land use decision or zone change within 120 days or 150 days, as applicable, after the application is deemed complete, the county shall refund to the applicant either the unexpended portion of any application fees or deposits previously paid or 50 percent of the total amount of such fees or deposits, whichever is greater. The applicant is not liable for additional governmental fees incurred subsequent to the payment of such fees or deposits. However, the applicant is responsible for the costs of providing sufficient additional information to address relevant issues identified in the consideration of the application. (9) A county may not compel an applicant to waive the period set in subsection (1) of this sec- tion or to waive the provisions of subsection (8) of this section or ORS 197.311 or 215.429 as a condition for taking any action on an application for a permit, limited land use decision or zone change except when such applications are filed concurrently and considered jointly with a plan amendment. (10) The periods set forth in subsections (1) and (5) of this section and ORS 197.311 may be ex- tended by up to 90 additional days, if the applicant and the county agree that a dispute concerning the application will be mediated. SECTION 4. ORS 227.178 is amended to read: 227.178. (1) Except as provided in subsections (3), (5) and (11) of this section, the governing body of a city or its designee shall take final action on an application for a permit, limited land use de- cision or zone change, including resolution of all appeals under ORS 227.180, within 120 days after the application is deemed complete. (2) If an application for a permit, limited land use decision or zone change is incomplete, the governing body or its designee shall notify the applicant in writing of exactly what information is missing within 30 days of receipt of the application and allow the applicant to submit the missing information. The application shall be deemed complete for the purpose of subsection (1) of this sec- tion or ORS 197.311 upon receipt by the governing body or its designee of: (a) All of the missing information; (b) Some of the missing information and written notice from the applicant that no other infor- mation will be provided; or (c) Written notice from the applicant that none of the missing information will be provided. (3)(a) If the application was complete when first submitted or the applicant submits the re- quested additional information within 180 days of the date the application was first submitted and the city has a comprehensive plan and land use regulations acknowledged under ORS 197.251, ap- proval or denial of the application shall be based upon the standards and criteria that were appli- cable at the time the application was first submitted. (b) If the application is for industrial or traded sector development of a site identified under section 12, chapter 800, Oregon Laws 2003, and proposes an amendment to the comprehensive plan, approval or denial of the application must be based upon the standards and criteria that were ap- plicable at the time the application was first submitted, provided the application complies with paragraph (a) of this subsection. Enrolled House Bill 3395 (HB 3395-B) Page 3 711 Exhibit C (4) On the 181st day after first being submitted, the application is void if the applicant has been notified of the missing information as required under subsection (2) of this section and has not submitted: (a) All of the missing information; (b) Some of the missing information and written notice that no other information will be pro- vided; or (c) Written notice that none of the missing information will be provided. (5) The 120-day period set in subsection (1) of this section or the 100-day period set in ORS 197.311 may be extended for a specified period of time at the written request of the applicant. The total of all extensions, except as provided in subsection (11) of this section for mediation, may not exceed 245 days. (6) The 120-day period set in subsection (1) of this section applies: (a) Only to decisions wholly within the authority and control of the governing body of the city; and (b) Unless the parties have agreed to mediation as described in subsection (11) of this section or ORS 197.319 (2)(b). (7) Notwithstanding subsection (6) of this section, the 120-day period set in subsection (1) of this section and the 100-day period set in ORS 197.311 do not apply to: (a) A decision of the city making a change to an acknowledged comprehensive plan or a land use regulation that is submitted to the Director of the Department of Land Conservation and De- velopment under ORS 197.610[.1; or (b) A decision of a city involving an application for the development of residential struc- tures within an urban growth boundary, where the city has tentatively approved the appli- cation and extends these periods by no more than seven days in order to assure the sufficiency of its final order. (8) Except when an applicant requests an extension under subsection (5) of this section, if the governing body of the city or its designee does not take final action on an application for a permit, limited land use decision or zone change within 120 days after the application is deemed complete, the city shall refund to the applicant, subject to the provisions of subsection (9) of this section, ei- ther the unexpended portion of any application fees or deposits previously paid or 50 percent of the total amount of such fees or deposits, whichever is greater. The applicant is not liable for additional governmental fees incurred subsequent to the payment of such fees or deposits. However, the ap- plicant is responsible for the costs of providing sufficient additional information to address relevant issues identified in the consideration of the application. (9)(a) To obtain a refund under subsection (8) of this section, the applicant may either: (A) Submit a written request for payment, either by mail or in person, to the city or its designee; or (B) Include the amount claimed in a mandamus petition filed under ORS 227.179. The court shall award an amount owed under this section in its final order on the petition. (b) Within seven calendar days of receiving a request for a refund, the city or its designee shall determine the amount of any refund owed. Payment, or notice that no payment is due, shall be made to the applicant within 30 calendar days of receiving the request. Any amount due and not paid within 30 calendar days of receipt of the request shall be subject to interest charges at the rate of one percent per month, or a portion thereof. (c) If payment due under paragraph (b) of this subsection is not paid within 120 days after the city or its designee receives the refund request, the applicant may file an action for recovery of the unpaid refund. In an action brought by a person under this paragraph, the court shall award to a prevailing applicant, in addition to the relief provided in this section, reasonable attorney fees and costs at trial and on appeal. If the city or its designee prevails, the court shall award reasonable attorney fees and costs at trial and on appeal if the court finds the petition to be frivolous. (10) A city may not compel an applicant to waive the 120-day period set in subsection (1) of this section or to waive the provisions of subsection (8) of this section or ORS 197.311 or 227.179 as a Enrolled House Bill 3395 (HB 3395-B) Page 4 712 Exhibit C condition for taking any action on an application for a permit, limited land use decision or zone change except when such applications are filed concurrently and considered jointly with a plan amendment. (11) The periods set forth in subsections (1) and (5) of this section and ORS 197.311 may be ex- tended by up to 90 additional days, if the applicant and the city agree that a dispute concerning the application will be mediated. SECTION 5. ORS 197.830 is amended to read: 197.830. (1) Review of land use decisions or limited land use decisions under ORS 197.830 to 197.845 shall be commenced by filing a notice of intent to appeal with the Land Use Board of Ap- peals. (2) Except as provided in ORS 197.620, a person may petition the board for review of a land use decision or limited land use decision if the person: (a) Filed a notice of intent to appeal the decision as provided in subsection (1) of this section; and (b) Appeared before the local government, special district or state agency orally or in writing. (3) If a local government makes a land use decision without providing a hearing, except as provided under ORS 215.416 (11) or 227.175 (10), or the local government makes a land use decision that is different from the proposal described in the notice of hearing to such a degree that the notice of the proposed action did not reasonably describe the local government's final actions, a person adversely affected by the decision may appeal the decision to the board under this section: (a) Within 21 days of actual notice where notice is required; or (b) Within 21 days of the date a person knew or should have known of the decision where no notice is required. (4) If a local government makes a land use decision without a hearing pursuant to ORS 215.416 (11) or 227.175 (10): (a) A person who was not provided notice of the decision as required under ORS 215.416 (11)(c) or 227.175 (10)(c) may appeal the decision to the board under this section within 21 days of receiving actual notice of the decision. (b) A person who is not entitled to notice under ORS 215.416 (11)(c) or 227.175 (10)(c) but who is adversely affected or aggrieved by the decision may appeal the decision to the board under this section within 21 days after the expiration of the period for filing a local appeal of the decision es- tablished by the local government under ORS 215.416 (11)(a) or 227.175 (10)(a). (c) A person who receives notice of a decision made without a hearing under ORS 215.416 (11) or 227.175 (10) may appeal the decision to the board under this section within 21 days of receiving actual notice of the nature of the decision, if the notice of the decision did not reasonably describe the nature of the decision. (d) Except as provided in paragraph (c) of this subsection, a person who receives notice of a decision made without a hearing under ORS 215.416 (11) or 227.175 (10) may not appeal the decision to the board under this section. (5) If a local government makes a limited land use decision which is different from the proposal described in the notice to such a degree that the notice of the proposed action did not reasonably describe the local government's final actions, a person adversely affected by the decision may appeal the decision to the board under this section: (a) Within 21 days of actual notice where notice is required; or (b) Within 21 days of the date a person knew or should have known of the decision where no notice is required. (6) The appeal periods described in subsections (3), (4) and (5) of this section: (a) May not exceed three years after the date of the decision, except as provided in paragraph (b) of this subsection. (b) May not exceed 10 years after the date of the decision if notice of a hearing or an adminis- trative decision made pursuant to ORS 197.195 or 197.797 is required but has not been provided. Enrolled House Bill 3395 (HB 3395-B) Page 5 713 Exhibit C (7)(a) Within 21 days after a notice of intent to appeal has been filed with the board under subsection (1) of this section, any person described in paragraph (b) of this subsection may intervene in and be made a party to the review proceeding by filing a motion to intervene and by paying a filing fee of $100. (b) Persons who may intervene in and be made a party to the review proceedings, as set forth in subsection (1) of this section, are: (A) The applicant who initiated the action before the local government, special district or state agency; or (B) Persons who appeared before the local government, special district or state agency, orally or in writing. (c) Failure to comply with the deadline or to pay the filing fee set forth in paragraph (a) of this subsection shall result in denial of a motion to intervene. (8) If a state agency whose order, rule, ruling, policy or other action is at issue is not a party to the proceeding, it may file a brief with the board as if it were a party. The brief shall be due on the same date the respondent's brief is due and shall be accompanied by a filing fee of $100. (9) A notice of intent to appeal a land use decision or limited land use decision shall be filed not later than 21 days after the date the decision sought to be reviewed becomes final. A notice of intent to appeal plan and land use regulation amendments processed pursuant to ORS 197.610 to 197.625 shall be filed not later than 21 days after notice of the decision sought to be reviewed is mailed or otherwise submitted to parties entitled to notice under ORS 197.615. Failure to include a statement identifying when, how and to whom notice was provided under ORS 197.615 does not render the notice defective. Copies of the notice of intent to appeal shall be served upon the local government, special district or state agency and the applicant of record, if any, in the local gov- ernment, special district or state agency proceeding. The notice shall be served and filed in the form and manner prescribed by rule of the board and shall be accompanied by a filing fee of $300. If a petition for review is not filed with the board as required in subsections (10) and (11) of this section, the board shall award the filing fee to the local government, special district or state agency. (10)(a) Within 21 days after service of the notice of intent to appeal, the local government, spe- cial district or state agency shall transmit to the board the original or a certified copy of the entire record of the proceeding under review. By stipulation of all parties to the review proceeding the record may be shortened. The board may require or permit subsequent corrections to the record; however, the board shall issue an order on a motion objecting to the record within 60 days of re- ceiving the motion. If the board denies a petitioner's objection to the record, the board may estab- lish a new deadline for the petition for review to be filed that may not be less than 14 days from the later of the original deadline for the brief or the date of denial of the petitioner's record ob- jection. (b) Within 10 days after service of a notice of intent to appeal, the board shall provide notice to the petitioner and the respondent of their option to enter into mediation pursuant to ORS 197.860. Any person moving to intervene shall be provided such notice within seven days after a motion to intervene is filed. The notice required by this paragraph shall be accompanied by a statement that mediation information or assistance may be obtained from the Department of Land Conservation and Development. (11) A petition for review of the land use decision or limited land use decision and supporting brief shall be filed with the board as required by the board under subsection (13) of this section. (12) The petition shall include a copy of the decision sought to be reviewed and shall state: (a) The facts that establish that the petitioner has standing. (b) The date of the decision. (c) The issues the petitioner seeks to have reviewed. (13)(a) The board shall adopt rules establishing deadlines for filing petitions and briefs and for oral argument. (b) The local government or state agency may withdraw its decision for purposes of re- consideration at any time: Enrolled House Bill 3395 (HB 3395-B) Page 6 714 Exhibit C (A) Subsequent to the filing of a notice of intent; and (B) Prior to: (i) The date set for filing the record[,]; or[,] (ii) On appeal of a decision under ORS 197.610 to 197.625 or relating to the development of a residential structure, [prior to] the filing of the respondent's brieft, the local government or state agency may withdraw its decision for purposes of reconsideration]. (c) If a local government or state agency withdraws an order for purposes of reconsideration, it shall, within such time as the board may allow, affirm, modify or reverse its decision. If the petitioner is dissatisfied with the local government or agency action after withdrawal for purposes of reconsideration, the petitioner may refile the notice of intent and the review shall proceed upon the revised order. An amended notice of intent is not required if the local government or state agency, on reconsideration, affirms the order or modifies the order with only minor changes. (14) The board shall issue a final order within 77 days after the date of transmittal of the record. If the order is not issued within 77 days the applicant may apply in Marion County or the circuit court of the county where the application was filed for a writ of mandamus to compel the board to issue a final order. (15) Upon entry of its final order, the board: (a) May, in its discretion, award costs to the prevailing party including the cost of preparation of the record if the prevailing party is the local government, special district or state agency whose decision is under review. (b) Shall award reasonable attorney fees and expenses to the prevailing party against any other party who the board finds presented a position or filed any motion without probable cause to believe the position or motion was well-founded in law or on factually supported information. (c) Shall award costs and attorney fees to a party as provided in ORS 197.843. (16) Orders issued under this section may be enforced in appropriate judicial proceedings. (17)(a) The board shall provide for the publication of its orders that are of general public in- terest in the form it deems best adapted for public convenience. The publications shall constitute the official reports of the board. (b) Any moneys collected or received from sales by the board shall be paid into the Board Publications Account established by ORS 197.832. (18) Except for any sums collected for publication of board opinions, all fees collected by the board under this section that are not awarded as costs shall be paid over to the State Treasurer to be credited to the General Fund. (19) The board shall track and report on its website: (a) The number of reviews commenced, as described in subsection (1) of this section, the number of reviews commenced for which a petition is filed under subsection (2) of this section and, in re- lation to each of those numbers, the rate at which the reviews result in a decision of the board to uphold, reverse or remand the land use decision or limited land use decision. The board shall track and report reviews under this paragraph in categories established by the board. (b) A list of petitioners, the number of reviews commenced and the rate at which the petitioner's reviews have resulted in decisions of the board to uphold, reverse or remand the land use decision or limited land use decision. (c) A list of respondents, the number of reviews involving each respondent and the rate at which reviews involving the respondent have resulted in decisions of the board to uphold, reverse or re- mand the land use decision or limited land use decision. Additionally, when a respondent is the local government that made the land use decision or limited land use decision, the board shall track whether the local government appears before the board. (d) A list of reviews, and a brief summary of the circumstances in each review, under which the board exercises its discretion to require a losing party to pay the attorney fees of the prevailing party. EMERGENCY SHELTER SITING Enrolled House Bill 3395 (HB 3395-B) Page 7 715 Exhibit C SECTION 6. Section 4, chapter 18, Oregon Laws 2021, as amended by section 3, chapter 47, Oregon Laws 2022, is repealed. SECTION 7. Section 3, chapter 18, Oregon Laws 2021, is amended to read: Sec. 3. (1) A local government shall approve an application for the development or use of land for an emergency shelter, as defined in [section 2 of this 2021 Act] ORS 197.782, on any property, notwithstanding this chapter or ORS chapter 195, [197,] 197A, 215 or 227 or any statewide [plan] land use planning goal, rule of the Land Conservation and Development Commission or local land use regulation, zoning ordinance, regional framework plan, functional plan or comprehensive plan, if the emergency shelter: (a) Includes sleeping and restroom facilities for clients; (b) Will comply with applicable building codes; (c) Is located inside an urban growth boundary or in an area zoned for rural residential use as defined in ORS 215.501; (d) Will not result in the development of a new building that is sited within an area designated under a statewide planning goal relating to natural disasters and hazards, including flood plains or mapped environmental health hazards, unless the development complies with regulations directly related to the hazard; (e) Has adequate transportation access to commercial and medical services; and (f) Will not pose any unreasonable risk to public health or safety. (2) An emergency shelter allowed under this section must be operated by: (a) A local government as defined in ORS 174.116; (b) An organization with at least two years' experience operating an emergency shelter using best practices that is: (A) A local housing authority as defined in ORS 456.375; (B) A religious corporation as defined in ORS 65.001; or (C) A public benefit corporation, as defined in ORS 65.001, whose charitable purpose includes the support of homeless individuals, that has been recognized as exempt from income tax under section 501(a) of the Internal Revenue Code [on or before January 1, 20181 for at least three years before the date of the application for a shelter; or (c) A nonprofit corporation partnering with any other entity described in this subsection. (3) An emergency shelter approved under this section: (a) May provide on -site for its clients and at no cost to the clients: (A) Showering or bathing; (B) Storage for personal property; (C) Laundry facilities; (D) Service of food prepared on -site or off -site; (E) Recreation areas for children and pets; (F) Case management services for housing, financial, vocational, educational or physical or be- havioral health care services; or (G) Any other services incidental to shelter. (b) May include youth shelters, winter or warming shelters, day shelters and family violence shelter homes as defined in ORS 409.290. (4) An emergency shelter approved under this section may also provide additional services not described in subsection (3) of this section to individuals who are transitioning from unsheltered homeless status. An organization providing services under this subsection may charge a fee of no more than $300 per month per client and only to clients who are financially able to pay the fee and who request the services. (5)(a) The approval or denial of an emergency shelter under this section may be made without a hearing. Whether or not a hearing is held, the approval or denial is not a land use decision and is subject to review only under ORS 34.010 to 34.100. (b) A reviewing court shall award attorney fees to: Enrolled House Bill 3395 (HB 3395-B) Page 8 716 Exhibit C (A) A local government, and any intervening applicant, that prevails on the appeal of a local government's approval; and (B) An applicant that prevails on an appeal of a local government's denial. (6) An application for an emergency shelter is not subject to approval under this section if, at the time of filing, the most recently completed point -in -time count, as reported to the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development under 24 C.F.R. part 578, in- dicated that the total sheltered and unsheltered homeless population was less than 0.18 per- cent of the state population, based on the latest estimate from the Portland State University Population Research Center. SINGLE EXIT MULTIFAMILY DWELLINGS SECTION 8. On or before October 1, 2025, the Department of Consumer and Business Services shall review and consider updates to the State of Oregon Structural Specialty Code through the Building Codes Structures Board established under ORS 455.132, to allow a res- idential occupancy to be served by a single exit, consistent with the following policies of this state: (1) The reduction, to the extent practicable, of costs and barriers to the construction of midsize multifamily dwellings, including those offering family -size housing with sprinklers on smaller lots, while maintaining safety, public health and the general welfare with respect to construction and occupancy. (2) Encouraging a variety of less expensive housing types that allow single -exit residen- tial buildings under certain circumstances consistent with other adopted building codes. (3) In adopting or considering updates to the building code under this section, the de- partment shall consider regional variation in firefighting capacity and equipment and may make amendments to the code contingent upon a certification by a local fire official that the municipality has sufficient firefighting capacity and equipment. PLANNED COMMUNITY ACT EXEMPTIONS SECTION 9. ORS 94.550 is amended to read: 94.550. As used in ORS 94.550 to 94.783: (1) "Assessment" means any charge imposed or levied by a homeowners association on or against an owner or lot pursuant to the provisions of the declaration or the bylaws of the planned community or provisions of ORS 94.550 to 94.783. (2) "Blanket encumbrance" means a trust deed or mortgage or any other lien or encumbrance, mechanic's lien or otherwise, securing or evidencing the payment of money and affecting more than one lot in a planned community, or an agreement affecting more than one lot by which the developer holds such planned community under an option, contract to sell or trust agreement. (3) "Class I planned community" means a planned community that: (a) Contains at least 13 lots or in which the declarant has reserved the right to increase the total number of lots beyond 12; and (b) Has an estimated annual assessment, including an amount required for reserves under ORS 94.595, exceeding $10,000 for all lots or $100 per lot based on: (A) For a planned community created on or after January 1, 2002, the initial estimated annual assessment, including a constructive assessment based on a subsidy of the association through a contribution of funds, goods or services by the declarant; or (B) For a planned community created before January 1, 2002, a reasonable estimate of the cost of fulfilling existing obligations imposed by the declaration, bylaws or other governing document as of January 1, 2002. (4) "Class II planned community" means a planned community that: (a) Is not a Class I planned community; Enrolled House Bill 3395 (HB 3395-B) Page 9 717 Exhibit C (b) Contains at least five lots; and (c) Has an estimated annual assessment exceeding $1,000 for all lots based on: (A) For a planned community created on or after January 1, 2002, the initial estimated annual assessment, including a constructive assessment based on a subsidy of the association through a contribution of funds, goods or services by the declarant; or (B) For a planned community created before January 1, 2002, a reasonable estimate of the cost of fulfilling existing obligations imposed by the declaration, bylaws or other governing document as of January 1, 2002. (5) "Class III planned community" means a planned community that is not a Class I or II planned community. (6) "Common expenses" means expenditures made by or financial liabilities incurred by the homeowners association and includes any allocations to the reserve account under ORS 94.595. (7) "Common property" means any real property or interest in real property within a planned community which is owned, held or leased by the homeowners association or owned as tenants in common by the lot owners, or designated in the declaration or the plat for transfer to the associ- ation. (8) "Condominium" means property submitted to the provisions of ORS chapter 100. (9) "Declarant" means any person who creates a planned community under ORS 94.550 to 94.783. (10) "Declarant control' means any special declarant right relating to administrative control of a homeowners association, including but not limited to: (a) The right of the declarant or person designated by the declarant to appoint or remove an officer or a member of the board of directors; (b) Any weighted vote or special voting right granted to a declarant or to units owned by the declarant so that the declarant will hold a majority of the voting rights in the association by virtue of such weighted vote or special voting right; and (c) The right of the declarant to exercise powers and responsibilities otherwise assigned by the declaration or bylaws or by the provisions of ORS 94.550 to 94.783 to the association, officers of the association or board of directors of the association. (11) "Declaration" means the instrument described in ORS 94.580 which establishes a planned community, and any amendments to the instrument. (12) "Electric vehicle charging station" or "charging station" means a facility designed to de- liver electrical current for the purpose of charging one or more electric motor vehicles. (13) "Electronic meeting" means a meeting that is conducted through telephone, teleconference, video conference, web conference or any other live electronic means where at least one participant is not physically present. (14) "Governing document" means articles of incorporation, bylaws, a declaration or a rule, regulation or resolution that was properly adopted by the homeowners association or any other in- strument or plat relating to common ownership or common maintenance of a portion of a planned community that is binding upon lots within the planned community. (15) "Governing entity" means an incorporated or unincorporated association, committee, person or any other entity that has authority under a governing document to maintain commonly main- tained property, to impose assessments on lots or to act on matters of common concern on behalf of lot owners within the planned community. (16) "Homeowners association" or "association" means the organization of owners of lots in a planned community, created under ORS 94.625, required by a governing document or formed under ORS 94.574. (17) "Majority" or "majority of votes" or "majority of owners" means more than 50 percent of the votes in the planned community. (18) "Mortgagee" means any person who is: (a) A mortgagee under a mortgage; (b) A beneficiary under a trust deed; or (c) The vendor under a land sale contract. Enrolled House Bill 3395 (HB 3395-B) Page 10 718 Exhibit C (19) "Owner" means the owner of any lot in a planned community, unless otherwise specified, but does not include a person holding only a security interest in a lot. (20) "Percent of owners" or "percentage of owners" means the owners representing the specified voting rights as determined under ORS 94.658. (21)(a) "Planned community" means any subdivision under ORS 92.010 to 92.192 that results in a pattern of ownership of real property and all the buildings, improvements and rights located on or belonging to the real property, in which the owners collectively are responsible for the mainte- nance, operation, insurance or other expenses relating to any property within the planned commu- nity, including common property, if any, or for the exterior maintenance of any property that is individually owned. (b) "Planned community" does not mean: (A) A condominium under ORS chapter 100; (B) A subdivision that is exclusively commercial or industrial; [or] (C) A timeshare plan under ORS 94.803 to 94.945[.]; or (D) A development established on or after January 1, 2024, in which each residential unit is either: (i) Subject to an affordability restriction, including an affordable housing covenant, as defined in ORS 456.270; or (ii) Owned by a public benefit or religious nonprofit corporation. (22) "Purchaser" means any person other than a declarant who, by means of a voluntary trans- fer, acquires a legal or equitable interest in a lot, other than as security for an obligation. (23) "Purchaser for resale" means any person who purchases from the declarant more than two lots for the purpose of resale whether or not the purchaser for resale makes improvements to the lots before reselling them. (24) "Recorded declaration" means an instrument recorded with the recording officer of the county in which the planned community is located that contains covenants, conditions and re- strictions that are binding upon lots in the planned community or that impose servitudes on the real property. (25) "Special declarant rights" means any rights, in addition to the rights of the declarant as a lot owner, reserved for the benefit of the declarant under the declaration or ORS 94.550 to 94.783, including but not limited to: (a) Constructing or completing construction of improvements in the planned community which are described in the declaration; (b) Expanding the planned community or withdrawing property from the planned community under ORS 94.580 (3) and (4); (c) Converting lots into common property; (d) Making the planned community subject to a master association under ORS 94.695; or (e) Exercising any right of declarant control reserved under ORS 94.600. (26) "Successor declarant" means the transferee of any special declarant right. (27) "Turn over" means the act of turning over administrative responsibility pursuant to ORS 94.609 and 94.616. (28) "Unit" means a building or portion of a building located upon a lot in a planned community and designated for separate occupancy or ownership, but does not include any building or portion of a building located on common property. (29) "Votes" means the votes allocated to lots in the declaration under ORS 94.580 (2). REGULATION OF CONDOMINIUMS SECTION 10. ORS 100.015 is amended to read: 100.015. The Real Estate Commissioner has the exclusive right to regulate the submission of property to the provisions of this chapter and may adopt such rules as are necessary for the administration of this chapter. Enrolled House Bill 3395 (HB 3395-B) Page 11 719 Exhibit C SECTION 11. ORS 100.022 is amended to read: 100.022. [(1)] Except as provided under ORS 100.015 or explicitly required or allowed under this chapter, a zoning, subdivision, building code or other [real property law,] regulation by a public body, agency rule or local ordinance or regulation may not [prohibit]: (1) Have the effect of prohibiting or restricting the condominium form of ownership; or (2) Impose any restriction or requirement upon a structure, property or development that is submitted or proposed to be submitted to the condominium form of ownership under this chapter that it would not impose upon a structure or development under a different form of ownership[.], including: (a) Any charge, tax or fee; (b) A review or approval process by any person of a declaration, bylaw, plat, articles of incorporation, regulation, resolution or any other document relating to the condominium or the submission of the property or development to the condominium form of ownership; (c) Any additional permitting requirements or conditions of approval of the property or development; or (d) Any other requirements. [(2) Except as set forth in this section, no provision of this chapter invalidates or modifies any provision of any zoning, subdivision, building code or other real property use law, ordinance or regu- lation.] [(3) Subsection (1) of This section does not prohibit any governmental approval required under this chapter.] SECTION 12. ORS 100.110 is amended to read: 100.110. (1)(a) Before a declaration, supplemental declaration or an amendment thereto may be recorded, it must be approved as provided in this section by the county assessor of the county in which the property is located and the Real Estate Commissioner. (b) Before a declaration, supplemental declaration or, if required under subsection (3) of this section, an amendment thereto may be recorded, it must be approved by the tax collector of the county in which the property is located. (c) A declaration, supplemental declaration or amendment thereto may not be approved unless the requirements of subsections (2) to (7) of this section are met. Approval must be evidenced by execution of the declaration or amendment or by a written approval attached thereto. (d) If the requirements of subsections (2) to (7) of this section are met, the commissioner, county assessor and tax collector, if applicable,[:] [(A)] shall approve the declaration, supplemental declaration or amendment[; and] [(B) May not impose additional requirements not specified in subsections (2) to (7) of this section]. (2) The county assessor of the county in which the property is located shall approve a declara- tion, supplemental declaration or amendment thereto if: (a) The name complies with ORS 100.105 (5) and (6); and (b) The plat complies with the requirements of ORS 100.115 or the plat amendment complies with ORS 100.116. (3) The tax collector of the county in which the property is located shall approve the declaration or supplemental declaration, or an amendment that adds property to the condominium, changes the boundary of a unit or creates an additional unit from all or parts of other units or from all or parts of other units and common elements for which a plat amendment is required under ORS 100.116, if: (a) All ad valorem taxes, special assessments, fees, or other charges required by law to be placed upon the tax roll for the affected units that have or will become a lien upon the property during the tax year have been paid; (b) Advance payment of ad valorem taxes, special assessments, fees or other charges for the affected units that are not on the tax roll and for which payment is required under paragraph (a) of this subsection has been made to the tax collector utilizing the procedures contained in ORS 92.095 and 311.370; and Enrolled House Bill 3395 (HB 3395-B) Page 12 720 Exhibit C (c) The additional taxes, penalty, and any interest attributable thereto, required because of dis- qualification of the affected units from any special assessment have been paid. (4) Subject to subsection (6) of this section, the commissioner shall approve the declaration or amendment thereto if: (a) The declaration or the amendment thereto complies with the requirements of ORS 100.105 and 100.135 and other provisions of this chapter; (b) The bylaws adopted under ORS 100.410 comply with the requirements of ORS 100.410 and 100.415 and other provisions of this chapter; (c) The plat complies with the requirements of ORS 100.115 or the plat amendment complies with ORS 100.116 and other provisions of this chapter; (d) The declaration is for a conversion condominium and the declarant has submitted: (A) An affidavit that the notice of conversion was given in accordance with ORS 100.305 and that the notice period has expired; (B) An affidavit that the notice of conversion was given in accordance with ORS 100.305 and copies of the written consent of any tenants as provided in ORS 100.305 (6) or a signed statement that no tenants were entitled to notice under ORS 100.305; or (C) Any applicable combination of the requirements of subparagraphs (A) and (B) of this para- graph; (e) A copy of the plat executed by the declarant and prepared in conformance with ORS 100.115 or plat amendment prepared in conformance with ORS 100.116 is submitted; (f) A certification of plat execution, on a form prescribed and furnished by the commissioner, is: (A) Executed by the declarant, the professional land surveyor who signed the surveyor's certif- icate on the plat, the attorney for the declarant, a representative of the title insurance company that issued the information required under ORS 100.640 (1)(e) or 100.668 (2)(d) or another person au- thorized by the declarant in writing to execute the certification; and (B) Submitted stating that the copy is a true copy of the plat signed by the declarant; and (g) A copy of a reserve study has been submitted, if a disclosure statement was issued under ORS 100.655 and the reserve study was not included pursuant to ORS 100.640 (1)(g). (5) The commissioner shall approve a supplemental declaration if: (a) The supplemental declaration complies with the requirements of ORS 100.120 and other provisions of this chapter; (b) The supplemental plat complies with the requirements of ORS 100.115; (c) The supplemental declaration is for a conversion condominium and the declarant has com- plied with the requirements of subsection (4)(d) of this section; and (d) A copy of the supplemental plat and a certification of plat execution described in subsection (4)(e) and (f) of this section have been submitted. (6) Approval by the commissioner is not required for an amendment to a declaration transferring the right of use of a limited common element pursuant to ORS 100.515 (5). (7) Before the commissioner approves the declaration, supplemental declaration or amendment thereto under this section: (a) The declarant or other person requesting approval shall pay to the commissioner a fee de- termined by the commissioner under ORS 100.670; and (b) For an amendment or supplemental declaration, the Condominium Information Report and the Annual Report described in ORS 100.260 must be designated current by the Real Estate Agency as provided in ORS 100.255 and the fee required under ORS 100.670 must be paid. (8) If the declaration, supplemental declaration or amendment thereto approved by the commis- sioner under subsection (4) or (5) of this section is not recorded in accordance with ORS 100.115 within one year from the date of approval by the commissioner, the approval automatically expires and the declaration, supplemental declaration or amendment thereto must be resubmitted for ap- proval in accordance with this section. The commissioner's approval must set forth the date on which the approval expires. SECTION 13. ORS 100.115 is amended to read: Enrolled House Bill 3395 (HB 3395-B) Page 13 721 Exhibit C 100.115. (1) A plat of the land described in the declaration or a supplemental plat described in a supplemental declaration, complying with ORS 92.050, 92.060 (1) and (2), 92.080 and 92.120, shall be recorded simultaneously with the declaration or supplemental declaration. The plat or supple- mental plat shall be titled in accordance with subsection (3) of this section and shall: (a) Show the location of: (A) All buildings and public roads. The location shall be referenced to a point on the boundary of the property; and (B) For a condominium containing units described in ORS 100.020 (3)(b)(C) or (D), the moorage space or floating structure. The location shall be referenced to a point on the boundary of the up- land property regardless of a change in the location resulting from a fluctuation in the water level or flow. (b) Show the designation, location, dimensions and area in square feet of each unit including: (A) For units in a building described in ORS 100.020 (3)(b)(A), the horizontal and vertical boundaries of each unit and the common elements to which each unit has access. The vertical boundaries shall be referenced to a known benchmark elevation or other reference point as ap- proved by the city or county surveyor; (B) For a space described in ORS 100.020 (3)(b)(B), the horizontal boundaries of each unit and the common elements to which each unit has access. If the space is located within a structure, the vertical boundaries also shall be shown and referenced to a known benchmark elevation or other reference point as approved by the city or county surveyor; (C) For a moorage space described in ORS 100.020 (3)(b)(C), the horizontal boundaries of each unit and the common elements to which each unit has access; and (D) For a floating structure described in ORS 100.020 (3)(b)(D), the horizontal and vertical boundaries of each unit and the common elements to which each unit has access. The vertical boundaries shall be referenced to an assumed elevation of an identified point on the floating struc- ture even though the assumed elevation may change with the fluctuation of the water level where the floating structure is moored. (c) Identify and show, to the extent feasible, the location and dimensions of all limited common elements described in the declaration. The plat may not include any statement indicating to which unit the use of any noncontiguous limited common element is reserved. (d) Include a statement, including signature and official seal, of a registered architect, registered professional land surveyor or registered professional engineer certifying that the plat fully and ac- curately depicts the boundaries of the units of the building and that construction of the units and buildings as depicted on the plat has been completed, except that the professional land surveyor who prepared the plat need not affix a seal to the statement. (e) Include a surveyor's certificate, complying with ORS 92.070, that includes information in the declaration in accordance with ORS 100.105 (1)(a) and a metes and bounds description or other de- scription approved by the city or county surveyor. M Include a statement by the declarant that the property and improvements described and de- picted on the plat are subject to the provisions of ORS 100.005 to 100.627. [(g) Include such signatures of approval as may be required by local ordinance or regulation.] [(h)] (g) Include any other information or data not inconsistent with the declaration that the declarant desires to include. WA (h) If the condominium is a flexible condominium, show the location and dimensions of all variable property identified in the declaration and label the variable property as "WITHDRAWABLE VARIABLE PROPERTY" or "NONWITHDRAWABLE VARIABLE PROPERTY," with a letter different from those designating a unit, building or other tract of vari- able property. If there is more than one tract, each tract shall be labeled in the same manner. (2) The supplemental plat required under ORS 100.150 (1) shall be recorded simultaneously with the supplemental declaration. The supplemental plat shall be titled in accordance with subsection (3) of this section and shall: Enrolled House Bill 3395 (HB 3395-B) Page 14 722 Exhibit C (a) Comply with ORS 92.050, 92.060 (1), (2) and (4), 92.080, 92.120 and subsection (3) of this sec- tion. (b) If any property is withdrawn: (A) Show the resulting perimeter boundaries of the condominium after the withdrawal; and (B) Show the information required under subsection [(1)(0] (1)(h) of this section as it relates to any remaining variable property. (c) If any property is reclassified, show the information required under subsection (1)(a) to (d) of this section. (d) Include a "Declarant's Statement" that the property described on the supplemental plat is reclassified or withdrawn from the condominium and that the condominium exists as described and depicted on the plat. (e) Include a surveyor's certificate complying with ORS 92.070. (3) The title of each supplemental plat described in ORS 100.120 shall include the complete name of the condominium, followed by the additional language specified in this subsection and the appro- priate reference to the stage being annexed or tract of variable property being reclassified. Each supplemental plat for a condominium recorded on or after January 1, 2002, shall be numbered se- quentially and shall: (a) If property is annexed under ORS 100.125, include the words "Supplemental Plat No. Annexation of Stage "; or (b) If property is reclassified under ORS 100.150, include the words "Supplemental Plat No. Reclassification of Variable Property, Tract " (4) Upon request of the county surveyor or assessor, the person offering a plat or supplemental plat for recording shall also file an exact copy, certified by the surveyor who made the plat to be an exact copy of the plat, with the county assessor and the county surveyor. The exact copy shall be made on suitable drafting material having the characteristics of strength, stability and transpar- ency required by the county surveyor. (5) Before a plat or a supplemental plat may be recorded, it must be approved by the city or county surveyor as provided in ORS 92.100. Before approving the plat as required by this section, the city or county surveyor shall: (a) Check the boundaries of the plat and units and take measurements and make computations necessary to determine that the plat complies with this section. (b) Determine that the name complies with ORS 100.105 (5) and (6). (c) Determine that the following are consistent: (A) The designation and area in square feet of each unit shown on the plat and the unit desig- nations and areas contained in the declaration in accordance with ORS 100.105 (1)(d); (B) Limited common elements identified on the plat and the information contained in the decla- ration in accordance with ORS 100.105 (1)(h); (C) The description of the property in the surveyor's certificate included on the plat and the description contained in the declaration in accordance with ORS 100.105 (1)(a); and (D) For a flexible condominium, the variable property depicted on the plat and the identification of the property contained in the declaration in accordance with ORS 100.105 (7)(c). (6) The person offering the plat or supplemental plat for approval shall: (a) Submit a copy of the proposed declaration and bylaws or applicable supplemental declaration at the time the plat is submitted; and (b) Submit the original or a copy of the executed declaration and bylaws or the applicable sup- plemental declaration approved by the commissioner if required by law prior to approval. (7) For performing the services described in subsection (5)(a) to (c) of this section, the city sur- veyor or county surveyor shall collect from the person offering the plat for approval a fee of $150 plus $25 per building. The governing body of a city or county may establish a higher fee by resol- ution or order. SECTION 14. ORS 100.105 is amended to read: 100.105. (1) A declaration must contain: Enrolled House Bill 3395 (HB 3395-B) Page 15 723 Exhibit C (a) A description of the property, including property on which a unit or a limited common ele- ment is located, whether held in fee simple, leasehold, easement or other interest or combination thereof, that is being submitted to the condominium form of ownership and that conforms to the description in the surveyor's certificate provided under ORS 100.115 (1). (b) Subject to subsection (11) of this section, a statement of the interest in the property being submitted to the condominium form of ownership, whether fee simple, leasehold, easement or other interest or combination thereof. (c) Subject to subsections (5) and (6) of this section, the name by which the property is known and a general description of each unit and the building or buildings, including the number of stories and basements of each building, the total number of units and the principal materials of which they are constructed. (d) The unit designation, a statement that the location of each unit is shown on the plat, a de- scription of the boundaries and area in square feet of each unit and any other data necessary for proper identification. The area of a unit must be the same as shown for that unit on the plat de- scribed in ORS 100.115 (1). (e) A notice in substantially the following form in at least 12-point type in all capitals or bold- face: NOTICE THE SQUARE FOOTAGE AREAS STATED IN THIS DECLARATION AND THE PLAT ARE BASED ON THE BOUNDARIES OF THE UNITS AS DESCRIBED IN THIS DECLARATION AND MAY VARY FROM THE AREA OF UNITS CALCULATED FOR OTHER PURPOSES. (f) A description of the general common elements. (g) An allocation to each unit of an undivided interest in the common elements in accordance with ORS 100.515 and the method used to establish the allocation. (h) The designation of any limited common elements including: (A) A general statement of the nature of the limited common element; (B) A statement of the unit to which the use of each limited common element is reserved, pro- vided the statement is not a reference to an assignment of use specified on the plat; and (C) The allocation of use of any limited common element appertaining to more than one unit. (i) The method of determining liability for common expenses and right to common profits in ac- cordance with ORS 100.530. 0) The voting rights allocated to each unit in accordance with ORS 100.525 or, in the case of condominium units committed as property in a timeshare plan defined in ORS 94.803, the voting rights allocated in the timeshare instrument. (k) A statement of the general nature of use, residential or otherwise, for which the building or buildings and each of the units is intended. (L) A statement that the designated agent to receive service of process in cases provided in ORS 100.550 (1) is named in the Condominium Information Report which will be filed with the Real Estate Agency in accordance with ORS 100.250 (1)(a). (m) The method of amending the declaration and the percentage of voting rights required to approve an amendment of the declaration in accordance with ORS 100.135. (n) A statement as to whether or not the association of unit owners pursuant to ORS 100.405 (5) and (8) has authority to grant leases, easements, rights of way, licenses and other similar inter- ests affecting the general and limited common elements of the condominium and consent to vacation of roadways within and adjacent to the condominium. Enrolled House Bill 3395 (HB 3395-B) Page 16 724 Exhibit C (o) If the condominium contains a floating structure described in ORS 100.020 (3), a statement regarding the authority of the board of directors of the association, subject to ORS 100.410, to temporarily relocate the floating structure without a majority vote of affected unit owners. (p) Any restrictions on alienation of units. Any such restrictions created by documents other than the declaration may be incorporated by reference in the declaration to the official records of the county in which the property is located. (q) Any other details regarding the property that the person executing the declaration considers desirable. However, if a provision required to be in the bylaws under ORS 100.415 is included in the declaration, the voting requirements for amending the bylaws also govern the amendment of the provision in the declaration. (2) In the event the declarant proposes to annex additional property to the condominium under ORS 100.125, the declaration also must contain a general description of the plan of development, including: (a) The maximum number of units to be included in the condominium. (b) The date after which any right to annex additional property will terminate. (c) A general description of the nature and proposed use of any additional common elements which declarant proposes to annex to the condominium, if such common elements might substan- tially increase the proportionate amount of the common expenses payable by existing unit owners. (d) A statement that the method used to establish the allocation of undivided interest in the common elements, the method used to determine liability for common expenses and right to common profits and the method used to allocate voting rights for each unit annexed is as stated in the dec- laration in accordance with subsection (1)(g), (i) and 0) of this section. (e) Such other information as the Real Estate Commissioner requires in order to carry out the purposes of this chapter. (3) Unless expressly prohibited by the declaration and subject to the requirements of ORS 100.135 (2) and subsections (9) and (10) of this section: (a) Not later than two years following the termination date specified in subsection (2)(b) of this section, the termination date may be extended for a period not exceeding five years. (b) Before the termination date specified in the declaration or supplemental declaration under subsection (7)(d) of this section, the termination date may be extended for a period not exceeding five years. (c) The general description under subsection (2)(c) of this section and the information included in the declaration or supplemental declaration in accordance with subsection (7)(c), (g) and (h) of this section may be changed by an amendment to the declaration or supplemental declaration and plat or supplemental plat. (4) The information included in the declaration or supplemental declaration in accordance with subsection (2)(a) and (d) of this section and subsection (7)(a), (b), (e), M and (k) of this section may not be changed unless all owners agree to the change and an amendment to the declaration or supplemental declaration and, if applicable, the plat or supplemental plat are recorded in accordance with this chapter. (5) The name of the property shall include the word "condominium" or "condominiums" or the words "a condominium." (6) A condominium may not bear a name which is the same as or deceptively similar to the name of any other, different condominium located in the same county. (7) If the condominium is a flexible condominium containing variable property, the declaration shall also contain a general description of the plan of development, including: (a) A statement that the rights provided for under ORS 100.150 (1) are being reserved. (b) A statement: (A) Of any limitations on rights reserved under ORS 100.150 (1), including whether the consent of any unit owner is required, and if so, a statement of the method by which the consent is ascer- tained; or (B) That there are no limitations on rights reserved under ORS 100.150 (1). Enrolled House Bill 3395 (HB 3395-B) Page 17 725 Exhibit C (c) A statement of the total number of tracts of variable property within the condominium, in- cluding: (A) A designation of each tract as withdrawable variable property or nonwithdrawable variable property; (B) Identification of each variable tract by a label in accordance with ORS 100.115 [(1)(0] (1)(h); (C) A statement of the method of labeling each tract depicted on the plat in accordance with ORS 100.115 [(1)(0] (1)(h); and (D) A statement of the total number of tracts of each type of variable property. (d) The termination date, which is the date after which any right reserved under ORS 100.150 (1) will terminate, and a statement of the circumstances, if any, that will terminate any right on or before the date specified. Subject to ORS 100.120, the termination date from the date of recording of the conveyance of the first unit in the condominium to a person other than the declarant may not exceed: (A) Twenty years, only if a condominium consists, or may consist if the condominium is a flexi- ble condominium, exclusively of units to be used for nonresidential purposes; or (B) Seven years. (e) The maximum number of units that may be created. (f) A statement that the method used to establish the allocations of undivided interest in the common elements, the method used to determine liability for common expenses and right to common profits and the method used to allocate voting rights as additional units are created is the same as stated in the declaration in accordance with subsection (1)(g), (i) and 0) of this section. (g) A general description of all existing improvements and the nature and proposed use of any improvements that may be made on variable property if the improvements might substantially in- crease the proportionate amount of the common expenses payable by existing unit owners. (h) A statement of whether or not the declarant reserves the right to create limited common elements within any variable property, and if so, a general description of the types that may be created. (i) A statement that the plat shows the location and dimensions of all withdrawable variable property that is labeled "WITHDRAWABLE VARIABLE PROPERTY." 0) A statement that if by the termination date all or a portion of the withdrawable variable property has not been withdrawn or reclassified, the withdrawable variable property is automat- ically withdrawn from the condominium as of the termination date. (k) A statement of the rights of the association under ORS 100.155 (2). (L) A statement of whether or not all or any portion of the variable property may not be with- drawn from the condominium and, if so, with respect to the nonwithdrawable variable property: (A) A statement that the plat shows the location and dimensions of all nonwithdrawable variable property that is labeled "NONWITHDRAWABLE VARIABLE PROPERTY." (B) A description of all improvements that may be made and a statement of the intended use of each improvement. (C) A statement that, if by the termination date all or a portion of the variable property desig- nated as "nonwithdrawable variable property" has not been reclassified, the property is automat- ically reclassified as of the termination date as a general common element of the condominium and any interest in the property held for security purposes is automatically extinguished by the classi- fication. (D) A statement of the rights of the association under ORS 100.155 (3). (m) A statement by the local governing body or appropriate department thereof that the with- drawal of any variable property designated as "withdrawable variable property" in the declaration in accordance with paragraph (L) of this subsection, will not violate any applicable planning or zoning regulation or ordinance. The statement may be attached as an exhibit to the declaration. (8) The plan of development for any variable property included in the declaration or any sup- plemental declaration of any stage in accordance with subsection (7) of this section is subject to any Enrolled House Bill 3395 (HB 3395-B) Page 18 726 Exhibit C plan of development included in the declaration in accordance with subsection (2) of this section, except that the time limitation specified in subsection (7)(d) of this section governs any right re- served under ORS 100.150 (1) with respect to any variable property. (9) The information included in the declaration in accordance with subsection (7)(j), (k) and (m) of this section may not be deleted by amendment. (10)(a) Approval by the unit owners is not required for a declarant to redesignate withdrawable variable property as "nonwithdrawable variable property" under ORS 100.150 (1) by supplemental declaration and supplemental plat, for any reason, including if the redesignation is required by the local governing body to comply with any planning or zoning regulation or ordinance. (b) If as a result of a redesignation under paragraph (a) of this subsection, the information re- quired to be included in the supplemental declaration under subsection (7)(L)(B) of this section is inconsistent with the information included in the declaration or supplemental declaration in ac- cordance with subsection (7)(g) of this section, an amendment to the declaration or supplemental declaration and plat or supplemental plat approved by at least 75 percent of owners is required. (11) The statement of an interest in property other than fee simple submitted to the condomin- ium form of ownership and any easements, rights or appurtenances belonging to property submitted to the condominium form of ownership, whether leasehold or fee simple, must include: (a) A reference to the recording index numbers and date of recording of the instrument creating the interest; or (b) A reference to the law, administrative rule, ordinance or regulation that creates the interest if the interest is created under law, administrative rule, ordinance or regulation and not recorded in the office of the recording officer of the county in which the property is located. SUBDIVIDING FOR DEVELOPMENT OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING SECTION 15. ORS 92.090 is amended to read: 92.090. (1) Subdivision plat names shall be subject to the approval of the county surveyor or, in the case where there is no county surveyor, the county assessor. No tentative subdivision plan or subdivision plat of a subdivision shall be approved which bears a name similar to or pronounced the same as the name of any other subdivision in the same county, unless the land platted is contiguous to and platted by the same party that platted the subdivision bearing that name or unless the party files and records the consent of the party that platted the contiguous subdivision bearing that name. All subdivision plats must continue the lot numbers and, if used, the block numbers of the subdivi- sion plat of the same name last filed. On or after January 1, 1992, any subdivision submitted for final approval shall not use block numbers or letters unless such subdivision is a continued phase of a previously recorded subdivision, bearing the same name, that has previously used block numbers or letters. (2) No tentative plan for a proposed subdivision and no tentative plan for a proposed partition shall be approved unless: (a) The streets and roads are laid out so as to conform to the plats of subdivisions and partitions already approved for adjoining property as to width, general direction and in all other respects un- less the city or county determines it is in the public interest to modify the street or road pattern. (b) Streets and roads held for private use are clearly indicated on the tentative plan and all reservations or restrictions relating to such private roads and streets are set forth thereon. (c) The tentative plan complies with the applicable zoning ordinances and regulations and the ordinances or regulations adopted under ORS 92.044 that are then in effect for the city or county within which the land described in the plan is situated. (3) No plat of a proposed subdivision or partition shall be approved unless: (a) Streets and roads for public use are dedicated without any reservation or restriction other than reversionary rights upon vacation of any such street or road and easements for public or pri- vate utilities. Enrolled House Bill 3395 (HB 3395-B) Page 19 727 Exhibit C (b) Streets and roads held for private use and indicated on the tentative plan of such subdivision or partition have been approved by the city or county. (c) The subdivision or partition plat complies with any applicable zoning ordinances and regu- lations and any ordinance or regulation adopted under ORS 92.044 that are then in effect for the city or county within which the land described in the subdivision or partition plat is situated. (d) The subdivision or partition plat is in substantial conformity with the provisions of the ten- tative plan for the subdivision or partition, as approved. (e) The subdivision or partition plat contains a donation to the public of all common improve- ments, including but not limited to streets, roads, parks, sewage disposal and water supply systems, the donation of which was made a condition of the approval of the tentative plan for the subdivision or partition. (f) Explanations of all common improvements required as conditions of approval of the tentative plan of the subdivision or partition have been recorded and referenced on the subdivision or parti- tion plat. (4) Subject to any standards and procedures adopted pursuant to ORS 92.044, no plat of a sub- division shall be approved by a city or county unless the city or county has received and accepted: (a) A certification by a city -owned domestic water supply system or by the owner of a privately owned domestic water supply system, subject to regulation by the Public Utility Commission of Oregon, that water will be available to the lot line of each and every lot depicted in the proposed subdivision plat; (b) A bond, irrevocable letter of credit, contract or other assurance by the subdivider to the city or county that a domestic water supply system will be installed by or on behalf of the subdivider to the lot line of each and every lot depicted in the proposed subdivision plat[; and the amount of any such bond, irrevocable letter of credit, contract or other assurance by the subdivider shall be] in an amount determined by a registered professional engineer, subject to any change in such amount as determined necessary by the city or county; or (c) [In lieu of paragraphs (a) and (b) of this subsection,] A statement that no domestic water supply facility will be provided to the purchaser of any lot depicted in the proposed subdivision plat, even though a domestic water supply source may exist. A copy of any such statement, signed by the subdivider and indorsed by the city or county, shall be filed by the subdivider with the Real Estate Commissioner and shall be included by the commissioner in any public report made for the subdi- vision under ORS 92.385. If the making of a public report has been waived or the subdivision is otherwise exempt under the Oregon Subdivision Control Law, the subdivider shall deliver a copy of the statement to each prospective purchaser of a lot in the subdivision at or prior to the signing by the purchaser of the first written agreement for the sale of the lot. The subdivider shall take a signed receipt from the purchaser upon delivery of such a statement, shall immediately send a copy of the receipt to the commissioner and shall keep any such receipt on file in this state, subject to inspection by the commissioner, for a period of three years after the date the receipt is taken. (5) Subject to any standards and procedures adopted pursuant to ORS 92.044, no plat of a sub- division shall be approved by a city or county unless the city or county has received and accepted: (a) A certification by a city -owned sewage disposal system or by the owner of a privately owned sewage disposal system that is subject to regulation by the Public Utility Commission of Oregon that a sewage disposal system will be available to the lot line of each and every lot depicted in the proposed subdivision plat; (b) A bond, irrevocable letter of credit, contract or other assurance by the subdivider to the city or county that a sewage disposal system will be installed by or on behalf of the subdivider to the lot line of each and every lot depicted on the proposed subdivision plat[; and the amount of such bond, irrevocable letter of credit, contract or other assurance shall be] in an amount determined by a registered professional engineer, subject to any change in such amount as the city or county considers necessary; or (c) [In lieu of paragraphs (a) and (b) of this subsection,] A statement that no sewage disposal facility will be provided to the purchaser of any lot depicted in the proposed subdivision plat, where Enrolled House Bill 3395 (HB 3395-B) Page 20 728 Exhibit C the Department of Environmental Quality has approved the proposed method or an alternative method of sewage disposal for the subdivision in its evaluation report described in ORS 454.755 (1)(b). A copy of any such statement, signed by the subdivider and indorsed by the city or county shall be filed by the subdivider with the Real Estate Commissioner and shall be included by the commissioner in the public report made for the subdivision under ORS 92.385. If the making of a public report has been waived or the subdivision is otherwise exempt under the Oregon Subdivision Control Law, the subdivider shall deliver a copy of the statement to each prospective purchaser of a lot in the subdivision at or prior to the signing by the purchaser of the first written agreement for the sale of the lot. The subdivider shall take a signed receipt from the purchaser upon delivery of such a statement, shall immediately send a copy of the receipt to the commissioner and shall keep any such receipt on file in this state, subject to inspection by the commissioner, for a period of three years after the date the receipt is taken. (6) A city or county shall accept as other assurance, as used in subsections (4)(b) and (5)(b) of this section, one or more award letters from public funding sources made to a sub- divider who is subdividing the property to develop affordable housing, that is or will be sub- ject to an affordability restriction as defined in ORS 456.250 or an affordable housing covenant as defined in ORS 456.270, if the awards total an amount greater than the project cost. [(6)] (7) Subject to any standards and procedures adopted pursuant to ORS 92.044, no plat of a subdivision or partition located within the boundaries of an irrigation district, drainage district, water control district, water improvement district or district improvement company shall be ap- proved by a city or county unless the city or county has received and accepted a certification from the district or company that the subdivision or partition is either entirely excluded from the district or company or is included within the district or company for purposes of receiving services and subjecting the subdivision or partition to the fees and other charges of the district or company. SINGLE ROOM OCCUPANCIES SECTION 16. Section 17 of this 2023 Act and ORS 197.758 are added to and made a part of ORS 197.286 to 197.314. SECTION 17. (1) As used in this section "single room occupancy" means a residential development with no fewer than four attached units that are independently rented and lockable and provide living and sleeping space for the exclusive use of an occupant, but re- quire that the occupant share sanitary or food preparation facilities with other units in the occupancy. (2) Within an urban growth boundary, each local government shall allow the development of a single room occupancy: (a) With up to six units on each lot or parcel zoned to allow for the development of a detached single-family dwelling, and (b) With the number of units consistent with the density standards of a lot or parcel zoned to allow for the development of residential dwellings with five or more units. SECTION 18. ORS 197.303, as amended by section 27, chapter 13, Oregon Laws 2023 (Enrolled House Bill 2001), is amended to read: 197.303. (1) As used in ORS 197.296 and this section, "needed housing" means all housing on land zoned for residential use or mixed residential and commercial use that is determined to meet the need shown for housing within an urban growth boundary at price ranges and rent levels that are affordable to households within the county with a variety of incomes, including but not limited to households with low incomes, very low incomes and extremely low incomes, as those terms are defined by the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development under 42 U.S.C. 1437a. "Needed housing" includes the following housing types: (a) Attached and detached single-family housing, middle housing types as described in ORS 197.758 and multiple family housing for both owner and renter occupancy; Enrolled House Bill 3395 (HB 3395-B) Page 21 729 Exhibit C (b) Government assisted housing; (c) Mobile home or manufactured dwelling parks as provided in ORS 197.475 to 197.490; (d) Manufactured homes on individual lots planned and zoned for single-family residential use that are in addition to lots within designated manufactured dwelling subdivisions; (e) Agriculture workforce housing; (f) Housing for individuals with a variety of disabilities related to mobility or communications that require accessibility features; (g) Housing for older persons, as defined in ORS 659A.421; [and] (h) Housing for college or university students, if relevant to the region[.]; and (i) Single room occupancies as defined in section 17 of this 2023 Act. (2) For the purpose of estimating housing needs, as described in ORS 197.296 (3)(b), Metro shall adopt findings and perform an analysis that estimates each of the following factors: (a) Projected needed housing units over the next 20 years; (b) Current housing underproduction; (c) Housing units needed for people experiencing homelessness; and (d) Housing units projected to be converted into vacation homes or second homes during the next 20 years. (3) At the time Metro performs the analysis under subsection (2) of this section, Metro shall allocate a housing need for each city within Metro. (4) In making an allocation under subsection (3) of this section, Metro shall consider: (a) The forecasted population growth under ORS 195.033 or 195.036; (b) The forecasted regional job growth; (c) An equitable statewide distribution of housing for income levels described in section 2 (4), chapter 13, Oregon Laws 2023 (Enrolled House Bill 2001) [of this 2023 Act]. (d) The estimates made under subsection (2) of this section; and (e) The purpose of the Oregon Housing Needs Analysis under section 1 (1), chapter 13, Oregon Laws 2023 (Enrolled House Bill 2001) [of this 2023 Act]. (5) Metro shall make the estimate described in subsection (2) of this section using a shorter time period than since the last review under ORS 197.296 (2)(a)(B) if Metro finds that the shorter time period will provide more accurate and reliable data related to housing need. The shorter time period may not be less than three years. (6) Metro shall use data from a wider geographic area or use a time period longer than the time period described in subsection (2) of this section if the analysis of a wider geographic area or the use of a longer time period will provide more accurate, complete and reliable data relating to trends affecting housing need than an analysis performed pursuant to subsection (2) of this section. Metro must clearly describe the geographic area, time frame and source of data used in an estimate per- formed under this subsection. (7) Subsection (1)(a) and (d) of this section does not apply to a city with a population of less than 2,500. (8) Metro may take an exception under ORS 197.732 to the definition of "needed housing" in subsection (1) of this section in the same manner that an exception may be taken under the goals. SECTION 18a. If House Bill 2889 becomes law, section 18 of this 2023 Act (amending ORS 197.303) is repealed and ORS 197.303, as amended by section 27, chapter 13, Oregon Laws 2023 (Enrolled House Bill 2001), and section 14, chapter _, Oregon Laws 2023 (Enrolled House Bill 2889), is amended to read: 197.303. (1) As used in ORS 197.296 and this section, "needed housing" means all housing on land zoned for residential use or mixed residential and commercial use that is determined to meet the need shown for housing within an urban growth boundary at price ranges and rent levels that are affordable to households within the county with a variety of incomes, including but not limited to households with low incomes, very low incomes and extremely low incomes, as those terms are defined by the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development under 42 U.S.C. 1437a. "Needed housing" includes the following housing types: Enrolled House Bill 3395 (HB 3395-B) Page 22 730 Exhibit C (a) Attached and detached single-family housing, middle housing types as described in ORS 197.758 and multiple family housing for both owner and renter occupancy; (b) Government assisted housing; (c) Mobile home or manufactured dwelling parks as provided in ORS 197.475 to 197.490; (d) Manufactured homes on individual lots planned and zoned for single-family residential use that are in addition to lots within designated manufactured dwelling subdivisions; [and] (e) Agriculture workforce housing[.]; and (f) Single room occupancies as defined in section 17 of this 2023 Act. (2) For the purpose of estimating housing needs, as described in ORS 197.296 (3)(b), Metro shall adopt findings and perform an analysis that estimates each of the following factors: (a) Projected needed housing units over the next 20 years; (b) Current housing underproduction; (c) Housing units needed for people experiencing homelessness; and (d) Housing units projected to be converted into vacation homes or second homes during the next 20 years. (3) Metro shall make the estimate described in subsection (2) of this section using a shorter time period than since the last review under ORS 197.296 (2)(a)(B) if Metro finds that the shorter time period will provide more accurate and reliable data related to housing need. The shorter time period may not be less than three years. (4) Metro shall use data from a wider geographic area or use a time period longer than the time period described in subsection (2) of this section if the analysis of a wider geographic area or the use of a longer time period will provide more accurate, complete and reliable data relating to trends affecting housing need than an analysis performed pursuant to subsection (2) of this section. Metro must clearly describe the geographic area, time frame and source of data used in an estimate per- formed under this subsection. (5) Subsection (1)(a) and (d) of this section does not apply to a city with a population of less than 2,500. (6) Metro may take an exception under ORS 197.732 to the definition of "needed housing" in subsection (1) of this section in the same manner that an exception may be taken under the goals. SECTION 19. Section 23, chapter 13, Oregon Laws 2023 (Enrolled House Bill 2001), is amended to read: Sec. 23. (1) As used in ORS 197.286 to 197.314, and except as provided in subsection (2) of this section: (a) "Needed housing" means housing by affordability level, as described in section 2 (4), chapter 13, Oregon Laws 2023 (Enrolled House Bill 2001) [of this 2023 Act], type, characteristics and lo- cation that is necessary to accommodate the city's allocated housing need over the 20-year planning period in effect when the city's housing capacity is determined. (b) "Needed housing" includes the following housing types: (A) Detached single-family housing, middle housing types as described in ORS 197.758 and multifamily housing that is owned or rented; (B) Government assisted housing; (C) Mobile home or manufactured dwelling parks as provided in ORS 197.475 to 197.490; (D) Manufactured homes on individual lots planned and zoned for single-family residential use that are in addition to lots within designated manufactured dwelling subdivisions; (E) Housing for agricultural workers; (F) Housing for individuals with a variety of disabilities, related to mobility or communications that require accessibility features; (G) Housing for older persons, as defined in ORS 659A.421; [and] (H) Housing for college or university students, if relevant to the region[.]; and (I) Single room occupancies as defined in section 17 of this 2023 Act. (2) Subsection (1)(b)(A) and (D) of this section does not apply to: (a) A city with a population of less than 2,500. Enrolled House Bill 3395 (HB 3395-B) Page 23 731 Exhibit C (b) A county with a population of less than 15,000. (3) At the time that a city is required to inventory its buildable lands under ORS 197.297 (1) or section 21 or 22, chapter 13, Oregon Laws 2023 (Enrolled House Bill 2001) [of this 2023 Act], the city shall determine its needed housing under this section. (4) In determining needed housing the city must demonstrate that the projected housing types, characteristics and locations are: (a) Attainable for the allocated housing need by income, including consideration of publicly supported housing; (b) Appropriately responsive to current and projected market trends; and (c) Responsive to the factors in ORS 197.290 (2)(b) to (d). SITING DUPLEXES SECTION 20. ORS 197.758 is amended to read: 197.758. (1) As used in this section: (a) "Cottage clusters" means groupings of no fewer than four detached housing units per acre with a footprint of less than 900 square feet each and that include a common courtyard. (b) "Middle housing" means: (A) Duplexes; (B) Triplexes; (C) Quadplexes; (D) Cottage clusters; and (E) Townhouses. (c) "Townhouses" means a dwelling unit constructed in a row of two or more attached units, where each dwelling unit is located on an individual lot or parcel and shares at least one common wall with an adjacent unit. (2) Except as provided in subsection (4) of this section, each city with a population of 25,000 or more and each county or city within a metropolitan service district shall allow the development of: (a) All middle housing types in areas zoned for residential use that allow for the development of detached single-family dwellings; and (b) A duplex on each lot or parcel zoned for residential use that allows for the development of detached single-family dwellings. (3) Except as provided in subsection (4) of this section, each city not within a metropolitan service district with a population of [more than 10,0001 2,500 or greater and less than 25,000 shall allow the development of a duplex on each lot or parcel zoned for residential use that allows for the development of detached single-family dwellings. Nothing in this subsection prohibits a local gov- ernment from allowing middle housing types in addition to duplexes. (4) This section does not apply to: (a) Cities with a population of 1,000 or fewer; (b) Lands not within an urban growth boundary; (c) Lands that are not incorporated and also lack sufficient urban services, as defined in ORS 195.065; (d) Lands that are not zoned for residential use, including lands zoned primarily for commercial, industrial, agricultural or public uses; or (e) Lands that are not incorporated and are zoned under an interim zoning designation that maintains the land's potential for planned urban development. (5) Local governments may regulate siting and design of middle housing required to be permitted under this section, provided that the regulations do not, individually or cumulatively, discourage the development of all middle housing types permitted in the area through unreasonable costs or delay. Local governments may regulate middle housing to comply with protective measures adopted pur- suant to statewide land use planning goals. (6) This section does not prohibit local governments from permitting: Enrolled House Bill 3395 (HB 3395-B) Page 24 732 Exhibit C (a) Single-family dwellings in areas zoned to allow for single-family dwellings; or (b) Middle housing in areas not required under this section. (7) A local government that amends its comprehensive plan or land use regulations re- lating to allowing additional middle housing is not required to consider whether the amend- ments significantly affect an existing or planned transportation facility. SECTION 21. Section 3, chapter 639, Oregon Laws 2019, is amended to read: Sec. 3. (1) Notwithstanding ORS 197.646, a local government shall adopt land use regulations or amend its comprehensive plan to implement [section 2 of this 2019 Act] ORS 197.758 no later than: (a) June 30, 2021, for each city subject to [section 2 (3) of this 2019 Act; or] ORS 197.758 (3) (2021 Edition); (b) June 30, 2022, for each local government subject to [section 2 (2) of this 2019 Act.] ORS 197.758 (2); or (c) June 30, 2025, for each city subject to ORS 197.758 (3), as amended by section 20 of this 2023 Act. (2) The Land Conservation and Development Commission, with the assistance of the Building Codes Division of the Department of Consumer and Business Services, shall develop a model middle housing ordinance no later than December 31, 2020. (3) A local government that has not acted within the time provided under subsection (1) of this section shall directly apply the model ordinance developed by the commission under subsection (2) of this section under ORS 197.646 (3) until the local government acts as described in subsection (1) of this section. (4) In adopting regulations or amending a comprehensive plan under this section, a local gov- ernment shall consider ways to increase the affordability of middle housing by considering ordi- nances and policies that include but are not limited to: (a) Waiving or deferring system development charges; (b) Adopting or amending criteria for property tax exemptions under ORS 307.515 to 307.523, 307.540 to 307.548 or 307.651 to 307.687 or property tax freezes under ORS 308.450 to 308.481; and (c) Assessing a construction tax under ORS 320.192 and 320.195. [(5) When a local government makes a legislative decision to amend its comprehensive plan or land use regulations to allow middle housing in areas zoned for residential use that allow for detached single-family dwellings, the local government is not required to consider whether the amendments sig- nificantly affect an existing or planned transportation facility.] SECTION 22. Section 4, chapter 639, Oregon Laws 2019, is amended to read: Sec. 4. (1) [Notwithstanding section 3 (1) or (3) of this 2019 Act,] The Department of Land Con- servation and Development may grant to a local government that is subject to [section 2 of this 2019 Act] ORS 197.758 an extension of the time allowed to adopt land use regulations or amend its comprehensive plan under section 3, chapter 639, Oregon Laws 2019 [of this 2019 Act]. (2) An extension under this section may be applied only to specific areas where the local gov- ernment has identified water, sewer, storm drainage or transportation services that are [either] sig- nificantly deficient [or are expected to be significantly deficient before December 31, 2023,1 and for which the local government has established a plan of actions that will remedy the deficiency in those services that is approved by the department. The extension may not extend beyond the date that the local government intends to correct the deficiency under the plan. (3) In areas where the extension under this section does not apply, the local government shall apply its own land use regulations consistent with section 3 (1), chapter 639, Oregon Laws 2019, [of this 2019 Act] or the model ordinance developed under section 3 (2), chapter 639, Oregon Laws 2019 [of this 2019 Act]. (4) A request for an extension by a local government must be filed with the department no later than: (a) December 31, 2020, for a city subject to [section 2 (3) of this 2019 Act.] ORS 197.758 (3) (2021 Edition). Enrolled House Bill 3395 (HB 3395-B) Page 25 733 Exhibit C (b) June 30, 2021, for a local government subject to [section 2 (2) of this 2019 Act.] ORS 197.758 (2). (c) June 30, 2024, for each city subject to ORS 197.758 (3), as amended by section 20 of this 2023 Act. (5) The department shall grant or deny a request for an extension under this section: (a) Within 90 days of receipt of a complete request from a city subject to [section 2 (3) of this 2019 Act.] ORS 197.758 (3). (b) Within 120 days of receipt of a complete request from a local government subject to [section 2 (2) of this 2019 Act.] ORS 197.758 (2). (6) The department shall adopt rules regarding the form and substance of a local government's application for an extension under this section. The department may include rules regarding: (a) Defining the affected areas; (b) Calculating deficiencies of water, sewer, storm drainage or transportation services; (c) Service deficiency levels required to qualify for the extension; (d) The components and timing of a remediation plan necessary to qualify for an extension; (e) Standards for evaluating applications; and (f) Establishing deadlines and components for the approval of a plan of action. SECTION 23. In addition to and not in lieu of any other appropriation, there is appro- priated to the Department of Land Conservation and Development, for the biennium begin- ning July 1, 2023, out of the General Fund, the amount of $1,250,000, to provide grants to local governments to assist them in amending their comprehensive plans as required under section 3 (1)(c), chapter 639, Oregon Laws 2019. REMOVING RECORDED DISCRIMINATORY PROVISIONS SECTION 24. Section 25 of this 2023 Act is added to and made a part of ORS chapter 93. SECTION 25. (1) Notwithstanding ORS 94.590, 94.625, 100.110, 100.135, 100.411 or 100.413 or any requirement of the declaration or bylaws, an amendment to the declaration or bylaws of a planned community or condominium is effective and may be made and recorded in the county clerk's office of a county in which any portion of the property is situated without the vote of the owners or the board members and without the prior approval of the Real Estate Commissioner, county assessor or any other person ih (a) The amendment is made to conform the declarations or bylaws to the requirements of ORS 93.270 (2); and (b) The amendment is signed by the president and secretary of the homeowners associ- ation. (2) The first page or cover sheet of an instrument amending the declaration or bylaws must comply with the recording requirements of ORS chapter 205 and must be in substan- tially the following form: AMENDMENT OF [DECLARATIONBYLAWS] TO COMPLY WITH ORS 93.270 (2). Pursuant to this section, the undersigned states: 1. The undersigned are the president and secretary for the [homeowners/condominium owners] association (name) in County. 2. This document amends the [declarationibylaws] of the association. 3. The [declaration wasibylaws were] first recorded under instrument number (or book and page number) Enrolled House Bill 3395 (HB 3395-B) recorded on Page 26 734 Exhibit C 4. The [declaration wasibylaws were] most recently amended or restated, if ever, under instrument number (or book and page number) recorded on 5. The undersigned have determined that the current [declarationsibylaws] of the [planned community/condominium], as last amended or revised, may fail to comply with ORS 93.270. The following amendments to the [declarationibylaws] remove provisions that are not allowed and are unenforceable under ORS 93.270 (2). No other changes to the document are being made except as may be necessary to correct scriveners' errors or to conform format and style. 6. Under this section, a vote of the association is not required. 7. The description of the real property in County affected by this document is: Dated this day of 20 . Name: President, (association name) Address: Phone No.: Dated this day of 20 . Name: Secretary, (association name) Address: Phone No.: STATE OF OREGON ) ss. County of ) The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this day of 20 by and Notary Public for Oregon My commission expires: (3) If an instrument recorded under this section affects a condominium, the condomin- ium association shall file a copy of the recorded instrument with the Real Estate Commis- sioner. SECTION 26. Section 4, chapter 67, Oregon Laws 2021, as amended by section 5b, chapter 367, Oregon Laws 2021, is amended to read: Sec. 4. (1) On or before December 31, [2022] 2024, each homeowners association of a planned community first established before September 1, 2021, shall review [each governing document currently binding on the planned community, or the lots or the lot owners within] the declaration and bylaws of the planned community and shall: Enrolled House Bill 3395 (HB 3395-B) Page 27 735 Exhibit C (a) Amend [or restate] each document as necessary to remove all restrictions against the use of the community or the lots not allowed under ORS 93.270 (2) as provided under section 25 of this 2023 Act; or (b) Execute and record a [declaration] certification that the homeowners association has re- viewed the [governing documents binding on] declaration and bylaws of the planned community and that the documents do not contain any restriction, rule or regulation against the use of the com- munity or the lots by a person or group of persons because of race, color, religion, sex, sexual ori- entation, gender identity, national origin, marital status, familial status, source of income, disability or the number of individuals, including family members, persons of close affinity or unrelated per- sons, who are simultaneously occupying a dwelling unit within occupancy limits. (2) [Notwithstanding ORS 94.590 or 94.625 or any requirement of the declaration or bylaws, an amendment to or a restatement of the declaration or bylaws under subsection (1)(a) of this section is effective and] A certification under subsection (1)(b) of this section: (a) May be recorded without the vote of the owners or the board members [if the amendment or restatement includes a certification signed by the president and secretary of the homeowners asso- ciation that the amended or restated declaration or bylaws does not change that document except as required under this section and as may be necessary to correct scriveners' errors or to conform format and style.]; and (b) Must be in substantially the following form: CERTIFICATION OF COMPLIANCE WITH ORS 93.270 (2). Pursuant to section 4, chapter 67, Oregon Laws 2021, the undersigned states: 1. The undersigned are the president and secretary for the homeowners association (name) in County. 2. The declaration was first recorded under instrument number (or book and page num- ber) recorded on . The declaration was most re- cently amended or restated, if ever, under instrument number recorded on 3. The bylaws were first recorded, if ever, under instrument number (or book and page number) recorded on . The bylaws were most re- cently amended or restated, if ever, under instrument number recorded on 4. The undersigned have determined that the current declarations and bylaws of the planned community, as last amended or revised, conform with ORS 93.270 (2) and that there are no provisions that would restrict the use of the community or the lots or units of the community because of race, color, religion, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity, national origin, marital status, familial status, source of income, disability or the number of individ- uals, including family members, persons of close affinity or unrelated persons, who are si- multaneously occupying a dwelling unit within occupancy limits. Any such provision that may inadvertently remain is void and unenforceable. 5. Under this section, a vote of the association is not required. 6. The description of the real property in County affected by this document is: Dated this day of 20 . Name: — President, Enrolled House Bill 3395 (HB 3395-B) (association name) Page 28 736 Exhibit C Dated this day of 20 . Name: Secretary, STATE OF OREGON (association name) ss. County of ) The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this day of 20 by and Notary Public for Oregon My commission expires: SECTION 27. Section 6, chapter 67, Oregon Laws 2021, as amended by section 5c, chapter 367, Oregon Laws 2021, is amended to read: Sec. 6. (1) On or before December 31, [2022] 2024, each association of a condominium first es- tablished before September 1, 2021, that includes units used for residential purposes shall review [each governing document currently binding on the condominium or the units or unit owners within] the declaration and bylaws of the condominium and shall: (a) Amend [or restate] each document as necessary to remove all restrictions against the use of the condominium or the units not allowed under ORS 93.270 (2) as provided under section 25 of this 2023 Act; or (b) Execute and record a [declaration] certification that the association has reviewed the [gov- erning documents binding on] declaration and bylaws of the condominium and that the documents do not contain any restriction, rule or regulation against the use of the condominium or the units by a person or group of persons because of race, color, religion, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity, national origin, marital status, familial status, source of income, disability or the number of individuals, including family members, persons of close affinity or unrelated persons, who are si- multaneously occupying a dwelling unit within occupancy limits. (2) [Notwithstanding ORS 100.110, 100.135, 100.413 or any requirement of the declaration or by- laws, an amendment to or a restatement of the declaration or bylaws under this section, upon sub- mission and approval of the Real Estate Commissioner under ORS 100.123, 100.125, 100.668 and 100.675, is effective and] A certification under subsection (1)(b) of this section: (a) May be recorded without the vote of the owners or the board members [if the amended or restated declaration or bylaws includes a certification signed by the president and secretary of the as- sociation that the amended or restated declaration or bylaws does not change that document except as required under this section and as may be necessary to correct scriveners' errors or to conform format and style.]; and (b) Must be in substantially the following form: CERTIFICATION OF COMPLIANCE WITH ORS 93.270 (2). Pursuant to section 6, chapter 67, Oregon Laws 2021, the undersigned states: 1. The undersigned are the president and secretary for the condominium owners associ- ation (name) in County. 2. The declaration was first recorded under instrument number (or book and page num- ber) recorded on . The declaration was most re- cently amended or restated, if ever, under instrument number recorded on Enrolled House Bill 3395 (HB 3395-B) Page 29 737 Exhibit C 3. The bylaws were first recorded, if ever, under instrument number (or book and page number) recorded on . The bylaws were most re- cently amended or restated, if ever, under instrument number recorded on 4. The undersigned have determined that the current declarations and bylaws of the condominium, as last amended or revised, conform with ORS 93.270 (2) and that there are no provisions that would restrict the use of the community or the lots or units of the com- munity because of race, color, religion, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity, national or- igin, marital status, familial status, source of income, disability or the number of individuals, including family members, persons of close affinity or unrelated persons, who are simul- taneously occupying a dwelling unit within occupancy limits. Any such provision that may inadvertently remain is void and unenforceable. 5. Under this section, a vote of the association is not required. 6. The description of the real property in County affected by this document is: Dated this day of Name: — President, Dated this Name: — Secretary, day of STATE OF OREGON 20 . (association name) 20 . (association name) ss. County of ) The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this day of 20 by and Notary Public for Oregon My commission expires: SECTION 28. (1) The amendments to sections 4 and 6, chapter 67, Oregon Laws 2021, by sections 26 and 27 of this 2023 Act are intended to extend the deadline for compliance with those sections and to clarify the process by which associations may comply with those sections. (2) Sections 4 and 6, chapter 67, Oregon Laws 2021, as amended by sections 26 and 27 of this 2023 Act, do not apply to a planned community or condominium that: (a) Was established on or after September 1, 2021; or (b) Complied with the requirements of section 4 or 6, chapter 67, Oregon Laws 2021, that were in effect before the effective date of this 2023 Act, notwithstanding the former deadline for compliance of December 31, 2022. AFFORDABLE HOUSING ON PUBLIC UTILITY LANDS SECTION 29. (1) As used in this section, "affordable housing" means affordable housing as defined in ORS 197.308 or publicly supported housing as defined in ORS 456.250. Enrolled House Bill 3395 (HB 3395-B) Page 30 738 Exhibit C (2)(a) To facilitate the development of affordable housing in this state, the Public Utility Commission may allow a public utility to sell, or to convey at below market price or as a gift, the public utility's interest in real property for the purpose of the real property being used for the development of affordable housing. (b) The instrument that conveys, or contracts to convey, the public utility's interest in the real property must include an affordable housing covenant as provided in ORS 456.270 to 456.295. (3) A public utility may not recover costs from customers for selling, or conveying at below market price or as a gift, the public utility's interest in real property under this sec- tion. HOUSING SUPPORT FOR LOW-INCOME COLLEGE STUDENTS SECTION 30. The Department of Human Services shall provide financial support to nonprofit organizations providing affordable housing support to low-income college students across this state in accordance with the department's self-sufficiency programs. SECTION 31. Section 30 of this 2023 Act is repealed on January 2, 2026. SECTION 32. In addition to and not in lieu of any other appropriation, there is appro- priated to the Department of Human Services, for the biennium beginning July 1, 2023, out of the General Fund, the amount of $4,000,000 to provide financial support to nonprofit or- ganizations under section 30 of this 2023 Act. SECTION 32a. Notwithstanding any other provision of law, the General Fund appropri- ation made to the Department of Human Services by section 1 (3), chapter _, Oregon Laws 2023 (Enrolled House Bill 5026), for the biennium beginning July 1, 2023, for self-sufficiency programs, is increased by $244,963 to administer financial support to nonprofit organizations pursuant to the provisions of section 30 of this 2023 Act. COMMUNITY HOUSING SUPPORTING AGRICULTURAL EMPLOYEES SECTION 33. Section 34 of this 2023 Act is added to and made a part of ORS 456.548 to 456.725. SECTION 34. (1) As used in this section, "community housing supporting agricultural employees" means a housing development that: (a) Is within an urban growth boundary; (b) Is within 20 miles of significant agricultural employment as identified by the Housing and Community Services Department; (c) Is promoted for residential use by agricultural employees and developed with amen- ities suitable for agricultural employees and their families; (d) Consists of a multifamily dwelling or a cluster of buildings, including manufactured, prefabricated or modular housing, housing produced through a three-dimensional printing process or other housing developed using innovative construction types; and (e)(A) Is subject to an affordable housing covenant requiring that the units are main- tained for a period of no less than 60 years as affordable to rent for low income households, as described in ORS 456.270 to 456.295; (B) Is operated as a consumer housing cooperative; or (C) Is operated under a model approved by the department designed to preserve affordability or control of the property by its residents. (2) The Housing and Community Services Department shall provide one or more grants to qualified housing sponsors for the purposes of developing community housing supporting agricultural employees. (3) In awarding grants under this section, the department shall prioritize applications: Enrolled House Bill 3395 (HB 3395-B) Page 31 739 Exhibit C (a) From a developer that is a nonprofit housing corporation that serves agricultural workers; (b) From a developer that is a nonprofit that promotes housing for agricultural employ- ees or other needs of agricultural employees, or from a developer that has entered into a partnership with a nonprofit housing corporation that serves agricultural workers for the purposes of developing the community housing; (c) Where other funding for the housing development has been dedicated or can be lev- eraged by the grant; (d) Where the housing development will be located close to significant agricultural em- ployment; or (e) Where the housing development will include or will be near specific characteristics or amenities designed to support or attract agricultural employees and their families. (4) Grants awarded under this section may be used for any project costs for the devel- opment or predevelopment of the community housing supporting agricultural employees. (5) A qualified housing sponsor receiving grants under this section shall agree to provide information to the department to report to an appropriate interim committee of the Legis- lative Assembly, in the manner provided in ORS 192.245, on the use of the grant on or before September 15, 2027. SECTION 35. Section 34 of this 2023 Act is repealed on January 2, 2028. SECTION 36. In addition to and not in lieu of any other appropriation, there is appro- priated to the Housing and Community Services Department, for the biennium beginning July 1, 2023, out of the General Fund, the amount of $10,000,000, to award and administer grants under section 34 of this 2023 Act. LOCAL GOVERNMENT HOUSING SUPPORT SECTION 37. (1) The Oregon Department of Administrative Services, in consultation with the Department of Land Conservation and Development and the Housing and Community Services Department, shall provide grants to councils of governments, as defined in ORS 294.900, and economic development districts to support housing and community development capacity within cities and counties in this state and within the nine federally recognized In- dian tribes in this state. (2) Councils of governments and economic development districts receiving grants under this section shall partner and consult with local governments, developers, financiers, the Department of Land Conservation and Development, the Housing and Community Services Department, other relevant state agencies and other interested public and private partners to enable local governments throughout the region to encourage community development and the development of infrastructure and needed housing, as defined in section 23, chapter 13, Oregon Laws 2023 (Enrolled House Bill 2001), by: (a) Bridging any information gaps; (b) Identifying and securing needed resources, including infrastructure and community facilities; (c) Connecting producers of needed housing with consumers of needed housing; and (d) Working with representatives of historically underrepresented groups to overcome community -specific barriers to obtaining housing. SECTION 38. Section 37 of this 2023 Act is repealed on January 2, 2034. SECTION 39. In addition to and not in lieu of any other appropriation, there is appro- priated to the Oregon Department of Administrative Services, for the biennium beginning July 1, 2023, out of the General Fund, the amount of $5,000,000, to provide grants under section 37 of this 2023 Act. AFFORDABLE HOMEOWNERSHIP REVOLVING LOAN FUND Enrolled House Bill 3395 (HB 3395-B) Page 32 740 Exhibit C SECTION 40. (1) The Housing and Community Services Department shall make a grant to the Network for Oregon Affordable Housing (NOAH) to establish a revolving loan fund that will allow a first-time home buyer who is purchasing a home, including a share of a cooperative or a condominium unit, in which the purchaser's equity will be limited, to es- tablish equity at a faster rate while making monthly payments similar to those described in subsection (3)(a)(A) of this subsection. The department may not make a grant under this section until NOAH has demonstrated that it has dedicated to a loan fund described in this section no less than $7,500,000 of additional private moneys. (2) Loans made from the loan fund must be used for the purchase of a dwelling that is subject to an affordability restriction, such as a restriction as described in ORS 456.270 to 456.295, that: (a) Has the effect of limiting the purchaser's ability to gain equity from the appreciation of the dwelling's value; and (b) Requires that the purchaser be a low income household as defined in ORS 456.270. (3) Loans made from the loan fund must: (a) Be made only to applicants that have met with an approved or certified housing counseling agency, as described in 24 C.F.R. 214 subpart B, and have a first-time home buyer program offered by the agency; (b) Have a term of 20 years or less; and (c) Have a fixed interest rate that is not more than the greater oh. (A) The rate that would allow monthly amortized principal and interest payments under the term of the loan to be the amount that would result from a 30-year fixed-rate amortized mortgage at the national current average rate as published by a reputable financial source; or (B) 0.5 percent. SECTION 41. Section 40 of this 2023 Act is repealed on January 2, 2026. SECTION 42. In addition to and not in lieu of any other appropriation, there is appro- priated to the Housing and Community Services Department, for the biennium beginning July 1, 2023, out of the General Fund, the amount of $7,500,000, to make a grant under sec- tion 40 of this 2023 Act. SECTION 43. On or before September 15, 2025, and on or before September 15, 2027, the Housing and Community Services Department shall provide a report to an appropriate in- terim committee of the Legislative Assembly, in the manner provided in ORS 192.245, on the use of the loan funds described in section 40 of this 2023 Act, as reported to the department by the Network for Oregon Affordable Housing (NOAH). AFFORDABLE HOUSING LOAN GUARANTEE FUND SECTION 44. Section 45 of this 2023 Act is added to and made a part of ORS chapter 458. SECTION 45. (1) The Housing and Community Services Department shall provide grants to one or more nonprofit corporations to develop a fund. (2) The moneys in the fund may be used only to guarantee the repayment of loans to fi- nance the construction of housing subject to an affordable housing covenant for low or moderate income households, as described in ORS 456.270 to 456.295 and as further defined by the Housing and Community Services Department by rule. (3) The term of a loan guaranteed under this section may not exceed five years. (4) The department and the state are not guarantors of any loan guaranteed by a nonprofit corporation under this section. (5) To be eligible for a grant under this section, a nonprofit corporation must: (a) Be exempt from income taxes under section 501(c)(3) or (4) of the Internal Revenue Code; and Enrolled House Bill 3395 (HB 3395-B) Page 33 741 Exhibit C (b) Demonstrate to the satisfaction of the department that the corporation is a commu- nity development financial institution that operates statewide to support investment in the construction of affordable housing. SECTION 46. Section 45 of this 2023 Act is repealed on January 2, 2026. SECTION 47. In addition to and not in lieu of any other appropriation, there is appro- priated to the Housing and Community Services Department, for the biennium beginning July 1, 2023, out of the General Fund, the amount of $20,000,000 to provide grants under section 45 of this 2023 Act. HOUSING AND COMMUNITY SERVICES DEPARTMENT ADMINISTRATION SECTION 47a. Notwithstanding any other provision of law, the General Fund appropri- ation made to the Housing and Community Services Department by section 1, chapter _, Oregon Laws 2023 (Enrolled Senate Bill 5511), for the biennium beginning July 1, 2023, is in- creased by $529,802, for purposes of administering sections 34, 37, 40, 43 and 45 of this 2023 Act. EMERGENCY HOUSING ASSISTANCE FOR COMPANION ANIMALS SECTION 48. ORS 458.650 is amended to read: 458.650. (1) The Housing and Community Services Department shall administer the Emergency Housing Account to assist homeless individuals and individuals who are at risk of becoming homeless, through means including the emergency housing assistance program and the state homeless assistance program. Notwithstanding subsection (3)(a) of this section, the state homeless assistance program shall serve individuals experiencing homelessness, especially unsheltered homelessness, without respect to income. (2) The Oregon Housing Stability Council shall develop a policy for the use of program funds with the advice of: (a) Persons who have experienced housing instability; (b) Tribes; (c) The Community Action Partnership of Oregon; (d) Continuums of care, as defined in 24 C.F.R. part 578; (e) Local governments; (f) Nonprofit organizations; (g) Homeless services providers; (h) Culturally specific organizations; (i) Housing providers; 0) Veterans' services organizations; and (k) Other entities identified by the department by rule. (3) The policy under subsection (2) of this section shall direct that program funds shall be used: (a) To provide to low and very low income individuals, including but not limited to individuals more than 65 years of age, persons with disabilities, agricultural workers and Native Americans: (A) Emergency shelters and attendant services; (B) Transitional housing services designed to assist individuals to make the transition from homelessness to permanent housing and economic independence; (C) Supportive housing services to enable individuals to continue living in their own homes or to provide in -home services for such individuals for whom suitable programs do not exist in their geographic area; (D) Programs that provide emergency payment of home payments, rents or utilities; [or] (E) Support for individuals with companion animals, as defined in ORS 401.977, that in- cludes: (i) Food for both companion animals and their owners; Enrolled House Bill 3395 (HB 3395-B) Page 34 742 Exhibit C (ii) Crates or kennels on -site or off -site that are easily accessible to the companion ani- mal owners; (iii) Basic veterinary services, including behavioral services; and (iv) Rules of conduct and responsibility regarding companion animals and their owners; or [(E)] (F) Some or all of the needs described in subparagraphs (A) to [(D)] (E) of this paragraph. (b) To align with federal strategies and resources that are available to prevent and end homelessness, including the requirement of providing culturally responsive services and using evidence -based and emerging practices effective in ending homelessness, including practices unique to rural communities. (4)(a) The council shall require as a condition of awarding a grant that the organization dem- onstrate to the satisfaction of the council that the organization: (A) Has the capacity to deliver any service proposed by the organization; (B) Is a culturally responsive organization or is engaged in a process to become a culturally responsive organization; (C) Engages with culturally specific organizations; and (D) Supports local homelessness system planning efforts. (b) Any funds granted under this section may not be used to replace existing funds. Funds granted under this section may be used to supplement existing funds. An organization may use funds to support existing programs or to establish new programs. (5) The department may expend funds from the account for: (a) The administration of the account as provided for in the legislatively approved budget, as that term is defined in ORS 291.002, for the department in support of directing a statewide policy on homelessness that ensures use of evidence -based and emerging practices, service equity in fund- ing and local planning processes. (b) The development of technical assistance and training resources for organizations developing and operating emergency shelters as defined in ORS 197.782 and transitional housing accommo- dations as described in ORS 197.746. (6) The department shall utilize outcome -oriented contracting processes and evidence -based and emerging practices for account program funds, including evidence -based and emerging practices for serving rural communities. (7) Twenty-five percent of moneys deposited in the account pursuant to ORS 294.187 are dedi- cated to the emergency housing assistance program for assistance to veterans who are homeless or at risk of becoming homeless. UNIT CAPTIONS SECTION 49. The unit captions used in this 2023 Act are provided only for the conven- ience of the reader and do not become part of the statutory law of this state or express any legislative intent in the enactment of this 2023 Act. OPERATIVE AND EFFECTIVE DATES SECTION 50. Sections 2, 17, 29 and 30 of this 2023 Act and the amendments to ORS 92.090, 94.550, 100.015, 100.022, 100.105, 100.110, 100.115, 197.303, 197.830, 215.427 and 227.178 and sec- tion 23, chapter 13, Oregon Laws 2023 (Enrolled House Bill 2001), by sections 3 to 5, 9 to 15, 18 and 19 of this 2023 Act become operative on January 1, 2024. SECTION 50a. If House Bill 2889 becomes law, section 50 of this 2023 Act is amended to read: Sec. 50. Sections 2, 17, 29 and 30 of this 2023 Act and the amendments to ORS 92.090, 94.550, 100.015, 100.022, 100.105, 100.110, 100.115, 197.303, 197.830, 215.427 and 227.178 and section 23, chapter 13, Oregon Laws 2023 (Enrolled House Bill 2001), by sections 3 to 5, 9 to 15, [181 18a and 19 of this 2023 Act become operative on January 1, 2024. Enrolled House Bill 3395 (HB 3395-B) Page 35 743 Exhibit C SECTION 51. This 2023 Act being necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health and safety, an emergency is declared to exist, and this 2023 Act takes effect on its passage. Passed by House June 14, 2023 Repassed by House June 25, 2023 .......................................................................... Timothy G. Sekerak, Chief Clerk of House .................................................................................. Dan Rayfield, Speaker of House Passed by Senate June 24, 2023 .................................................................................. Rob Wagner, President of Senate Enrolled House Bill 3395 (HB 3395-B) Received by Governor: ........................ M.,......................................................... 1 2023 Approved: ........................ M........................................................... 1 2023 .................................................................................. Tina Kotek, Governor Filed in Office of Secretary of State: ........................ M.,......................................................... 1 2023 .................................................................................. Secretary of State Page 36 744 Exhibit D �a ,,,,',,ii,,�'„' ,ems► , February 21, 2024 Mid -Willamette Community Action Agency c/o Sara Webb 2475 Center St NE Salem, OR 97301 RE: Approval for Mid -Willamette Valley Community Action Agency ("ARCHES") to operate an Emergency Shelter at 1560 Hardcastle Ave, Woodburn, OR (Tax Lot 051W08CD06700) Dear Ms. Webb: Staff approves the requested emergency shelter operation proposed to be located on the Church of Christ property located at 1560 Hardcastle Avenue; subject to the conditions of approval outlined below. Legislative Background: In 2020, the Oregon State Legislature adopted House Bill 4212 for the purpose of removing land use barriers that might otherwise prevent emergency shelters from locating on certain sites. HB 4212 was followed by the passage of HB 2006 in May 2021 continuing to allow local governments and certain non-profit organizations to develop emergency shelters in available buildings and/or on open sites without the need for any land use approvals (such as an application for a zone change or a conditional use permit) for the underlying property. Subsequently, these two house bills were followed by HB 3395, which memorialized the tenants of the previous bills and eliminated a sunset date that required applications to be submitted by a certain date. "Emergency Shelter" is defined as a use that provides shelter on a temporary basis for individuals and families who lack permanent housing. The proposed request meets this definition. Cities must approve a Super Siting application for an emergency shelter if the application complies with the approval criteria in the new state law which are outlined in the Findings below. This approval is not a land use decision and cannot be appealed by any party through the City land use Letter of Approval —1560 Hardcastle Ave — Emergency shelter Page 1 of 3 745 Exhibit D appeals process. It is also not appealable to the Oregon Land Use Board of Appeals (LUBA). It may only be appealed under the writ of review process provided under Oregon Revised Statutes (ORS) 34.010 to 34.100. Staff finds that the attached application materials submitted February 20, 2024 satisfactorily address the approval criteria listed in HB 3395 and must be APPROVED. Conditions are below. Conditions of Approval: 1. Conformance with Approved Application & Plans: All operations and site improvements shall be in substantial conformance with the approved application materials dated February 20, 2024. 2. Per the approved plans, overnight sleeping accommodations are limited to a maximum of 30 beds in two tents; 16 beds within the church building and five car camping parking spaces for families. All other non -approved sleeping tents/facilities on the property are to be removed. The statewide uniform building code and the federal Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), requires 36" access be maintained between all sleeping cots and any non - accessible egress to be 30 inches between cots or other sleeping locations. 4. Signage must be provided in each tent specifying "No Smoking/Vaping" to the satisfaction of the Woodburn Fire Marshal of the independent Woodburn Fire District. 5. The required fire truck turnaround in the southeast corner shall be clear of any encumbrances. It shall be a minimum of 60 feet X 20 feet and striped in red with a label, "No Parking Fire Lane", in white paint over the red stripes. This is a required turnaround for fire access. 6. The main entrance driveway shall be widened to a minimum width of 14 feet of compacted surface acceptable to the Woodburn Fire Marshal. 7. The applicant shall submit an annual Operations Permit to the Woodburn Fire District. 8. Prior to the start of operations of the overnight shelter, the applicant shall request an inspection and receive written approval from both the City Building Official and Woodburn Fire Marshal confirming that all applicable conditions of approval are satisfied. Final Decision a Ch r i s lKtrrr " V Community Development Director, City of Woodburn Letter of Approval —1560 Hardcastle Ave — Emergency shelter Page 2 of 3 Exhibit D CC: McKenzie Granum, City Attorney Bill Parks, Church of Christ Attachments: 1. Emergency Shelter Application (Feb. 20, 2024) 2. Letter of Agreement — Woodburn Church of Christ 3. Project Narrative (Feb. 20, 2024) 4. Site Plan (Feb. 20, 2024) Letter of Approval —1560 Hardcastle Ave — Emergency shelter Page 3 of 3 747 Exhibit D W D.BURN' cQmO lncorporetied,18,9 Section 1: Applicant Information RIE-CEIVED COMN1UNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT Emergency Shelter Siting Application HB 3395 (2023) Name of Applicant Organization: Mid -Willamette Community Action Agency Contact Mailing Address: 2475 Center St NE CitySalem State Oregon Phone Number: 503-585-6232 Email address: jimmy.jones@mwvcaa,org Anticipated opening date of shelter: ZIP 97301 Emergency Shelter Siting Application HB 3395 .... ...... ..... ... .. . ....... ....... .... .... Tt' a c an e ii, t .......... .......... 748 Exhibit D Applicant Organization Status: Mr/!E/V—D C1O1MMUNKYDEVELOPNIIENIT Local Government An organization with at least two years experience operating an emergency shelter using best practices that iaa: []Housing Authority []Re)igiouaCorponation nPublic Benefit Corporation (attach a copy of incorporation documents showing charitable purpose including support of homeless individuals and show tax exempt status) ��^ ' c_�,Non-pro�toorporationpartnehngvvdh: FILoco/Governmont �� ��"norgmnizetionw/that/eeetbwoyeoraexpehonoeopenaUnganemergennyohe|teruoing best practices and is either a) a housing authority b) a religious corporation c) public benefit corporation. (Attach documentation) Check the box if the applicant is the: Shelter Operator Title Holder Shelter Operator Name of Shelter Operator: Sara Webb Shelter Operator Contact(s): Shelter Operator Mailing Address: 2475 Center St NE Salem Or. 97301 Phone /Email address: sara.webb@mwvcaa.org Number ofyears' experience operating anemergency shelter: 10+ Property Owner Information Name: Church of Christ Bill Parks Address 15OUHardcaaUeAve. Woodburn Or. S7O71 Phona/EmnUaddmoo 749 Emergency Shelter Siting Application Vooma Exhibit D RECEIVED can; ,UN1TY DEVELDPMENI DEPARTNIENT Section II: Shelter Reauirements Is this new construction? ❑Yes 11No Do you have a pending building permit application? ❑ Permit Number(s): Oregon House Bill 3395 (2023) requires that emergency shelters meet ALL of the following criteria in order to operate: —Please provide a separate written response to each • The Emergency Shelter: o Includes sleeping and restroom facilities o Will comply with applicable building codes o Is located within the City's urban growth boundary o Will not result in a new building that is sited within an area designated under a statewide land use planning goal relating to natural disasters and hazards (e.g. flood plains or mapped environmental health hazards) unless the development complies with regulations directly related to the hazard o Has adequate transportation access to medical and commercial services o Will not pose any unreasonable risk to public health or safety The Emergency Shelter must be operated by: o A local government, or o A religious corporation, o A public benefit corporation whose charitable purpose includes the support of homeless individuals and that has been recognized as exempt from income tax under section 501(a) of the Internal Revenue Code on or before January 1, 2017, or o A nonprofit corporation partnering with any of those entities. ** For additional assistance with mapping, please contact the City of Woodburn Planning Department (503) 982-5246. Page 3 of 4 750 Emergency Shelter Siting Application HB 3395 t �� 'i n"� .0 ....1..... Exhibit D �FA 7 8 2026 C0�� UYDEVE0PW20T Section III: Documentation and Certification DEPAWNIEN-1 |nyour written narrative, please respond indetail tothe following: 1. How the applicants experience and plans for shelter operations demonstrate "best practices for operating enemergency mheKer." 2. Other services to be provided onsite, including number of people anticipated to be served, general site layout details, plans for sanitation, garbaQe, health and aohety, and description ofaccess tntransportation and services. 3. Any approval is contingent on issuance of a valid building permit, if required, and the facility meeting applicable building codes. 4. Agreeing to schedule a meeting with the Building Official and the Fire Marshall for a final inspection and/or consultation of the facility prior to occupancy of the emergency shelter. Please attach the following documents: 1. Adiagram ofthofaoUitvindicatinQsleeoingondroobnomareaoondoreaaforoUher services identified innarrative statement. Provide two copies ofofinadepartment access plan (see example be/ovv). The fire department access plan will show all buildings and structures on site, including temporary structures (tents). Show a minimum 20'fire truck access lane with a maximum of 150 feet hose lay length around all buildings and structures. Example offire department access plan: AVM���� � 2. A Site Plan showing the building location, access for emergency vehicles and clients, existing water and sewer connections, or intended locations if these systems are not 751 Exhibit D 3. Written correspondence from the Woodburn Fire District indicating that emergency vehicles can safely access the proposed site. The Fire District can be contacted at (503) 982-2360. 4. Written correspondence from the City of Woodburn Building Division that acknowledges that there has been a discussion and that it is reasonably likely that the proposed shelter(s) can meet building code after further discussion. Inquiries should be directed to the City of Woodburn Building Official at (503) 980-2430. 5. If the land is not owned by the applicant, written documentation from the property owner and/or the lease document that shows consent for the planned use. 6. A proposed capital and operations budget for the shelter, including descriptions of the funds that have been secured, applied for, and any needed funds not yet secured. Self -certification — I certify that: 12 1 will ensure compliance with applicable building codes, and provide copies of any applicable building permit approvals associated with this application. 2This facility will not pose unreasonable health and safety issues. 2 If required, I will provide an annual Operational Permit through the Woodburn Fire Department. OThis facility will be providing adequate access to emergency services and for residents to access commercial/medical services. ❑ The information provided in this application is accurate to the best of my knowledge. Sign here: Candida Ruggles Emergency Services Coordinator MVVVCAA Printed Name/ Position Title /Organization Name Date: Emergency Shelter Siting Application HB 3395 FEB 2 0 2024 COM,MUNI (Y DEVELCIPMIENI DEPAR':MENT 752 Exhibit D Woodburn Church of Christ Letter of Agreement On Friday, February 9, 2024 Woodburn Church of Christ (WCOC) agreed to lease the property located at 1560 Hardcastle in Woodburn, OR to Mid -Willamette Valley Community Action Agency (MWVCAA) effective February 15, 2024 at 9:00 AM. Lease payments of $6,000 will begin March 1, 2024 and continue each calendar month through September 2025. The undersigned parties agree that 1) this Letter of Agreement and 2) the attached Lease Agreement accurately summarize the entire understanding between them. Subject to the modifications set forth herein and any necessary, reasonable, mutually acceptable edits or minor proofreading changes made prior to full execution of the Lease Agreement on or before February 15, 2024, the terms and conditions set forth in the attached Lease Agreement will apply and be fully binding on both parties. • "MWVCANs contributions towards February payroll and operating expenses will serve as consideration for this agreement. No lease payment will be paid by MWVCAA for February 2024 • Sections 18 and 19 of the Lease Agreement will be amended to include a clear and specific breakdown of who is in charge of expenses related to repairs and maintenance. Specific exceptions will apply and other arrangements may be made upon request, but generally speaking, expenses that increase or enhance the long-term value of the property, including normal wear and tear, will be the responsibility of WCOC and day-to-day repairs related to operational matters and mishaps will be addressed by MWVCAA. With financial and logistical support from the City of Woodburn and with clear communication and in full cooperation with WCOC, MWVCAA agrees to plan, coordinate, and execute successful completion of the following capital improvements: o A security fence to secure and control access to the property o Driveway and parking lot repairs and improvements that meet fire code requirements Confirmation of MWVCANs openness and willingness to honor mutually -acceptable requests for space -sharing or off -hours usage of the building will be ratified A transition plan addendum including a schedule of anticipated program limitations and variances, anticipated shut -down dates, and move -in and move out timelines and procedures will be included. • References to 1540 Hardcastle will be removed from the Lease Agreement and lease payments will not be late until after the 10th day of the calendar month. 753 Exhibit D We affirm our clear understanding of this agreement and agree before God and one another to willingly abide by both the spirit and the letter of this agreement For Mid -Willamette Valley Community Action Agency: Ji ,,y-Jones, Executive Director For Woodburn Church of Christ (Landlord): 1 r Curt Jones, Specia Projects Director IPM Carisa Rangel GoUso Carisa Rangel Gottuso, Financial Committee Rose drian, Financial Committee 12 February 2024 Date 12 February 2024 Date 2/1224L������� Date 12th February, 2024 Date 754 Exhibit D R E: 0 E(V�D DEPARIMENT Mid -Willamette Valley Community Action Agency ARCHES Project ("ARCHES")submits this Emergency Shelter Super Siting application, as allowed under HB 3395, to request approval to expand the existing emergency sheltering program and day center services currently offered by Ray of Hope to unhoused individuals. The Ray of Hope program is located at 1560 Hardcastle Ave; Woodburn, OR 97071, and is owned and operated by the Church of Christ and Neighbors Serving Neighbors. Application approval would grant ARCHES permanent use of the site and church facilities to operate the current emergency shelter program and provide additional sheltering options and supportive services to assist individuals who are transitioning from an unsheltered or unhoused status, as per the terms of HB 4212. Project Introduction In 2023, ARCHES partnered with Ray of Hope to support their sheltering program and to devise a service delivery framework that expands current operations, Presently, Ray of Hope offers emergency sheltering with limited access to case management services. On average, the program serves approximately 30 unhoused individuals from the Woodburn community. 0 The Emergency Shelter Site Plan: u There will be 4,992 hours of operations in a year. Monday through Saturday 7pm to 9am Sunday 7pm to 7am. Total hours of operation are subject to change depending onprogram needs. o Two heated military tents will be staged outside the church facility nightly and will sleep a maximum of3Oindividuals on mats/cots. An additional S parking spaces will be designated for families with children to sleep safely in their vehicles. Two sets of restrooms for women and men are available for use inside the church facility. o During extreme weather conditions, when temperatures reach 32 degrees and below, sheltering operations will be moved inside the church facility. During the day, warming can accommodate 43 standing individuals and, in the evening, up to 16 individual sleeping spots based onthe current interior floor plan. When temperatures reach 100 degrees and above, likewise, operations will be moved inside the church facility. o We will comply with applicable building codes, including the posting of exit signs on both ends ofeach tent along with two fire extinguishers. Signagewill include "No Smoking/Vapino"inside and outside ofthe tents and postings where Snnokina/VapinQand Dog Run areas are permitted. 755 Exhibit D V The proposed staffing plan includes: one Program Manager; two full-time Shift Leads and tmxo-part-tinneShift Leads; three full-time Site Assistants, three part-time Site Assistants, and three on -call Site Assistants; and one part-time Case Manager. > Each shift will assign 2Site Assistance/Site Assistant Leads toperform safety checks throughout their shift, in 20-nninute intervals that will include: walking the perimeter, checking that only the nightly registered clients are onsite and inapproved areas, and standing fire watch over the sheltering site. > Staff will have access tophones inside and outside, aswell as, begiven a radio to communicate with other staff members. o Clients will have access totransportation fornnedioa|andcnrnnnerda|senvicesvia the Woodburn Transit System (VVST)that operates Mon. -Fri. OarntoG pnn, Sat.S am to 5 pm, and Sun. 9 am to 3 pm. The transit system is provided, free of charge, throughout the City ofWoodburn. o The sheltering program will implement policies and procedures to mitigate risks to public health and safety. Trained staff will review the program rules and mutual respect expectations with each client to create a safe and heathy community, respectful of each other, staff, and broader neighborhood. Additionally, clients must agree tocomply toparticipate inthe program. Also, staff will closely monitor clients to deter illegal activity and ensure clients are not loitering in the surrounding neighborhoods. ° The Emergency Shelter must be operated by a nonprofit corporation partnering with any other entities in the subsection: o Mid -Willamette Valley Community Action Agency ARCHES Project is a nonprofit organization that has advocated for low-income people and strived to reduce poverty since 1967. �l�����iV�[\ w The EnnergencyShelter vvi//provide on -site and atnocost: ^^c-`~^-'"^-�� o Showering and bathing facilities FED 2 R 7D o Personal property storage while sleeping onsite o Laundry CUMMUN|TYDEVEL0PNENT o Food services DER4RTMFNl o Recreation areas for pets o Case management services, orany other services incidental tothe shelter o Collaborate with partners for medical and dental van * The Emergency Shelter may include: o House|essindividua|s 756 Exhibit D RECE-ME-D �-� � O YO76 ' �" � « uv�. o Houseless families with children in a vehicle DEVELOPPYIENT Mid -Willamette Valley Community Action Agency's experience offering low -barrier sheltering Solutions using a variety of models, positions us to provide a sheltering program that will meet the unique needs of Woodburn residents who are experiencing unsheltered homelessness. Since 3O17,The ARCHES Project hasoperotedtheSa!em Warming Network, which provides low barrier shelter beds to unhoused individuals typically between November 1and March 31, when temperatures reach SZ degrees or below. |n3O20,The ARCHES Project openeditsfirstZ4/7,year-roundfadUtyca|/ed Tanner Project, which provides 36 transitional shelter beds to male and female veterans. Tanner Project was the catalyst for our long-term shelter movement, preceding the purchase of two Salem hotels, becoming the selected provider to operate the City ofSalem's 75 bed navigation center, and receiving state funding to open a shelter specific for families with young children. To date, The ARCHES Project nnaintainsaninventoryof261year-noundshelterbeds,capab|eof providing 95,265 bed nights annually with preference given to military veterans, individuals being discharged from the hospital, elderly, and families with young children. At these shelters, guests have routine access to trauma informed services which include housing focused case management, referrals to community partners and resource navigation, healthcare connections, benefits attainment/maintenance, employment services, mental health and recovery programs, and hygiene supplies. The frequency atwhich these services are accessed are client -led, however, they are available to residents throughout the duration of their stay. Since the fall of 2020, The ARCHES Project has provided shelter and service navigation to 462 unique individuals at Tanner Project, the ARCHES Inn, and Navigation Center. Other Services tobeprovided on- ite, including number of people anticipated tobeserved. general site layout detaOa, plan for san�ation,garbage, health and safety, anddeucription of access totransportation and services. I. Mid -Willamette Valley Community Action Agency will operate a3O'bedovernight low - barrier mnanagedshelteratChurchof[hhst|ocatedat1S60Hardcast|eAve. Woodburn, Oregon, 97071. Open from 7 pm to 9 am Monday through Saturday and Sunday 7 pm to 7 am, this co-ed, pet friendly shelter will promote utilization bybeing void of background and sobriety requirements. During their stay, guests will beprovided with an evening meal, morning snack, and be encouraged to utilize the on -site laundry and shower facilities. Additionally, they will have routine access to trauma -informed services which include, navigation tohousing, medical, mental health, and substance use disorder treatment, employment services, and benefit attainment. For community referrals within Woodburn, our staff will educate shelter guests on how to effectively utilize the city's free public transportation. Should our staff need to refer someone to a community partner or resource outside of Woodburn, we will provide them with a day- ttachiment 757 Exhibit D pass to utilize the Cherriots Regional service which operates routes connecting Woodburn to Salem. MWVCAA takes seriously our obligation to provide sanitary shelter solutions to ensure the health and safety of all guests. To accomplish this, a standard commercial dumpster will be on - site with garbage pick-up scheduled at least twice a week or more frequently if demand dictates. Additionally, MWVCAA has adopted a robust cleaning regiment across all of our shelters, which includes regularly wiping down touch surfaces, sweeping, moping, and sanitizing showers after each guest. RECEIVED FFR 2 0 20 CO INIUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT 758 Exhibit D Emergency I Bath 11'-0. I I— Ln Lq Bath room Hardcastle Ave. Woodburn OR Main Entrance Access Church Building D Tent Shelter Cots Storage Containers F7 Restroom/ Showers L L un ry d a K � tchen Parking Spots Electrical Box 00 � Ol Imp X 20' 4----� FEB 2 0 202LI C01MNIUNITY DEVELOP'14'' DEPARTMENT 759 .... ...... ..... ... .. . ....... ....... .... .... ........ �i �.. Ag4,-.44 fun.- WWODBURN In �or�arn reA 188� February 26, 2024 TO: Honorable Mayor and City Council FROM: Jim Row, Assistant City Administrator Jesse Cuomo, Community Services Director SUBJECT: Community Center Polling Results and Project Scope Determination RECOMMENDATION: Receive a report on the results of the Community Center Likely Voter Survey and the recommendation from the Community Center Advisory Committee (CAC) and affirm the City's intent to place a bond measure on the ballot in November 2024 that would fund the fully scoped version of the Woodburn Community Center Project. BACKGROUND/DISCUSSION: The City hired Patinkin Research Strategies to conduct a survey of registered voters about their opinions of a potential November 2024 bond measure that would fund the Woodburn Community Center Project. The telephone survey was conducted from January 22-25, 2024 and included 400 likely voters in the City, which resulted in a 4.9% margin of error at the 95% level of confidence. Bi- lingual surveyors were utilized and 33 of the interviews were conducted in Spanish. The survey results were presented to the City Council earlier this evening. A presentation on the results of the survey were also presented to the CAC on February 20, 2024. Following the presentation and a comprehensive discussion, the CAC members in attendance voted unanimously to recommend that the City Council place a bond measure on the ballot in November 2024 that would fund the fully scoped version of the community center project. As confirmed during a presentation to the City Council on June 26, 2023, the full version of the community center project includes the "base Plan" plus the four alternates that comprise a warm water recreation/ therapy pool, 2nd gymnasium, elevated walking/ running track and partner / multi -purpose suite. This version of the project would result in a facility that is 80,000 sq. ft. in size, almost quadrupling the size of the existing Aquatic Center. Agenda Item Review: City Administrator x_ City Attorney _x Finance 760 Honorable Mayor and City Council February 26, 2024 Page 2 FINANCIAL IMPACT: The full version of the project is estimated to cost $60 million, assuming a fall 2025 construction start date. Given the fact that the City has secured a $15 million Oregon Lottery Bond Grant and has agreed to commit up to another $5 million in Urban Renewal funding toward the project, it is estimated that a $40 million bond measure would be required to complete the project's funding package. A bond measure of that size is anticipated to cost the average homeowner in Woodburn approximately $15/ month in additional property taxes. 761 WWODBURN Ig �e� Item Inc orpornreA 1889 February 26, 2024 To: Honorable Mayor and City Council through City Administrator From: Chris Kerr, Community Development Director c 'r Heidi Hinshaw, Associate Planner Subject: Council Briefing of Planning Commission approval of a Variance application for AWARE Food Bank at 152 Arthur St (VAR 23-08) RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends no action be taken on this item and provides this summary pursuant to „a'N.aa:�l�va_eim 1 � y llaa rrieroll (ra.: iiroa.: roe. e WII::.:��,: Section 4.02.02. The Council may call up this item if desired and, by majority vote, initiate a review of this Commission decision. BACKGROUND: On February 8, 2024, the Planning Commission unanimously approved a sign variance request for the AWARE Food Bank allowing existing canopy -mounted signage to remain. There was no testimony in opposition. The appeal period has ended, and there was no appeal. The subject property, 152 Arthur Street, is within the Downtown Development and Conservation (DDC) zoning district. It was originally developed in 1910 with a commercial building. Marion -Polk Food Share Inc. purchased the property in 2012 for the AWARE Foodbank. A fire significantly damaged the building on August 18, 2021, and it was demolished in August 2022. City staff reviewed and approved a land use application package on October 13, 2022 to redevelop the site into the AWARE Foodbank (DR 22-10 & PLA 22-06). Through this variance application, the applicant requested to keep the signage that has already been installed which does not meet current WDO requirements per Table 3.10.10D: "Awning/Marquee Signs" are "Deemed wall signs" and "Shall not extend above or below the awning or marquee." However, Marion/Polk Food Share (MPFS) believes the current placement of the address Agenda Item Review: City Administrator _x_ City Attorney _x 762 Honorable Mayor and City Council February 26, 2024 (Briefing of Commission Approval VAR 23-08 AWARE Food Bank) Page 2 and facility name signage improves pedestrian and traffic safety by identifying the facility in a more prominent, visible manner by being placed upon the awnings and closer to the right-of-way. Additionally, due to the architectural requirements of window size, shape and awning depth, the potential locations for signage was limited. The existing signs meet all other standard requirements for wall signs within the DDC including size, ratio of sign area to fagade, colors, and materials. Front fagade of food bank with Sign # 1 Front fagade of food bank with Sign # 2 Page 2 of 2 763 „4 WbODBURN Incorporat—1 1889 February 21, 2024 TO: City Council FROM: Frank Lonergan, Mayor SUBJECT: City Council Appointment The following appointment is made, subject to the approval of the Council. Please forward any adverse comments to me prior to the Council meeting on Monday, February 26, 2024. No reply is required if you approve of my decision. City Councilor - Ward III • Jennifer Cantu 764